


The episode discusses two issues: (1) online sadistic groups targeting vulnerable children in the UK, and (2) Manchester City’s defiant response after being found guilty of years of Premier League financial rule-breaking, including misleading accounts and disguised funding.
Rob Harris, Sky News sports correspondent (interviewed City’s chief executive). Adele Robinson, Sky News correspondent (also promotes her documentary “The Calm” about online sadistic and deadly communities).
City’s response insists they are innocent and the independent commission got it wrong; possible penalties include expulsion from the Premier League, points deductions, director unsuitability, and even criminal investigations.
Alleged sham sponsorships inflating income by about £830m–£900m; Etihad Airways deals; UEFA financial fair play context; Aguero’s 2012 title moment; De Bruyne; City spending ~£1.2bn on players (2009–2018); 2024 signings Enzo Fernandez (£125m) and Elliot Anderson (£116m).
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Learn about the alarming rise of online sadistic groups targeting children in the UK.
“Online sadistic groups are targeting vulnerable children.”
Discussion of Manchester City being found guilty of financial rule-breaking and their defiant response.
“Manchester City have been found guilty of years of financial rule-breaking.”
Exploration of the potential consequences for Manchester City, including possible sanctions.
“Now that's our sports correspondent Rob Harris, trying and failing to get answers from Manchester City's chief executive.”
An explanation of financial fair play regulations and their implications for clubs.
“There's the potential the independent football regulator deems directors unsuitable to continue in their roles.”
Examination of the questionable sponsorship deals Manchester City engaged in.
“Well, to that, we need to go back to the global financial crisis of 2008.”
Discussion of how Manchester City's financial strategies translate into competitive advantages on the pitch.
“The commission puts it over£830 million of wrongly recorded sponsorship income.”
Insight into the financial evidence that Manchester City claims supports their innocence.
“what in the hundred plus offences that they've been found guilty of are they actually disputing?”
Contextualization of when Manchester City first came under scrutiny regarding their finances.
“and related parties in terms of transactions.”
Exploration of how Manchester City's management and players have reacted to ongoing financial scrutiny.
“Now, this is all out in the open in the sense it's in the accounts.”
Explore how Man City is managing their legal challenges and the emotional responses from rival clubs.
“Now, Sissi have never in any way told me not to repeat it, not issued a denial in any way, just not addressed it in any way at all.”
Discuss the possible penalties Man City could face and the broader implications for fans and the club.
“You can find The Calm on the Sky News app, website and YouTube channel.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On This Is Why, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00Online sadistic groups are targeting vulnerable children. The sheer amount of potential victims is astounding. It's a very real threat and it is here in the UK. It will always shock me. A young boy could commit such awful offences. Some of the content has been the worst I've ever seen. Parents need to be aware of what can happen on these sites. Find The Calm on Sky News YouTube.
0:42Manchester City have been found guilty of years of financial rule-breaking. Their response is to come out fighting, and this is why.
0:55online sadistic groups are targeting vulnerable children the sheer amount of potential victims is astounding it's a very real threat and it is here in the uk it will always shock me a young boy could commit such awful offenses some of the content has been the worst i've ever seen Parents need to be aware of what can happen on these sites Find the com on Sky News YouTube
1:32There are probably people you'd rather not bump into when your football club has been found guilty of years of financial rule-breaking Fairly high on that list, a reporter with a microphone Sky News, the Premier League confirms you cheated for nearly a decade Do you apologise to football fans? I have nothing to say, thank you. Are you destroying football? Thank you. Do you not have a message for football? Thank you. Now that's our sports correspondent Rob Harris, trying and failing to get answers from Manchester City's chief executive. But don't worry, the club has plenty to say in its statements.
2:03They insist they're innocent, say the independent commission got it wrong and promised to keep fighting. The findings concern misleading accounts and disguised funding over nearly a decade. The possible consequences include getting booted from the Premier League. City's response is defiant. The punishment is undecided. Rob's reporting suggests this fight could have years left to run. Rob, explain this to me. Usually, if an individual, an institution is found guilty of more than 100 offences, they come out, they hold their hands up, they express a degree of contrition for what they've done. Compare and contrast, Manchester City, they're acting as if they've done nothing wrong.
2:45They've got a lot to lose if they were to admit guilt. They insist that there is still irrefutable evidence to defend their position and the fact they are innocent, but the consequences for this are serious. There's the potential the independent football regulator deems directors unsuitable to continue in their roles. The extreme version is that Sheikh Mansour is deemed no longer suitable to be the owner and they have to sell up. And we've seen it in a different situation in recent years when Roman Abramovich was sanctioned by the government. He was forced to sell Chelsea following the full-scale invasion of Ukraine by Russia over his ties to Vladimir Putin.
3:19So it's not without precedent in different circumstances. And then there's potential for criminal investigations too. OK, so let's just explain exactly why I find the response from Man City so striking. in the simplest possible terms, what is it that they have been found guilty of? And who by? Well, they've been found to have artificially inflated the income coming into the club with sham contracts by the tune of£900 million. All intended to show they've got more money coming into the club so they can spend it on players. Players who've delivered so much success, particularly in this period, three Premier League titles, stockpiling the squad with talent that has gone on to win other trophies too, like the Champions League for the first time in the club's history, which will confuse a lot of people.
4:07Why do you need to artificially inflate income when you've got one of the wealthiest owners in the world? He owns the club. He's got billions in the bank. It's his thing. Why can't he just chuck money at it? Well, to that, we need to go back to the global financial crisis of 2008. The year Sheikh Mansour bought the club, actually, he was also involved in a bailout of Barclays Bank as well. But UEFA, as the governing body, was concerned about the potential for clubs to go out of business, to be spending beyond their means, and to address debt. Actually, it was prompted by, in part, concerns about Manchester United's high debt following the Glazers takeover, but it ended up focusing on limiting losses.
4:45So, even if you had a wealthy owner, you could only spend what was legitimately coming into the club. It's called financial fair play, and then some also interpreted it as being trying to ensure a level playing field. So, you've got competitive balance. So, we'd already seen Robin Abramovich and all the money he'd put into Chelsea and how they'd started to dominate. So it was addressing multiple things in a way. Liquidity of clubs, ensuring that even if an owner walked away, you wouldn't be in financial jeopardy. Also to ensure that one team can't just race ahead of the other. So just walk us through the process.
5:15Where was the money coming from? Where did City say the money was supposed to be coming from? Can you give us an example? Well, in 2009, we saw the first big sponsor of the Sheik Mansour era and it came from Abu Dhabi. Etihad Airways. Kind of coincidence, though. And they got the naming rights, the stadium, and they went to the training ground, got on the shirts as well. Now, big questions over the deal. And you have to think to where City were in 2009. They'd only won the league twice in their entire history. They hadn't won it since 1968. They'd been in the third tier at the turn of the century.
5:50So not a big global appeal in terms of fan base compared to Manchester United, for instance. Not that track record or success. so you'd weigh things up in a way and this term has been used in football by the authorities fair market value what would you expect Etihad to pay if they didn't have that relationship already in Abu Dhabi so not focused on that and gradually they also built up more sponsors from Abu Dhabi as well lots of different companies travel related banking communications and people want it oh that's amazing to manage to screw all these big new sponsorship deals all happen to be from the same place as the ownership.
6:27OK, so the figures are varying on this. The commission puts it over£830 million of wrongly recorded sponsorship income. Premier League taking combined revenue and all the rest of it together puts it above£900 million. OK, this is going to sound like a really daft question, but how does that turn into a competitive advantage on a football pitch? Well, it's about signing players. And if you look at the period in question, 2009 10 season to 27 2018 well they spent about 1.2 billion pounds on players and you look at how much so a lot of the cash coming in to spend on players is accused of being sham and the word sham contracts is throughout the Premier League verdict give me some names that I might recognise well in that period signed Sergio Aguero who won the title in 2012 one of the most dramatic moments I was there at the Etihad Stadium final seconds of the season was this against QPR?
7:21It was. So Manchester United's game at Sunderland had just finished. City were still drawing at that point against QPR. It wasn't enough to win the title. Then suddenly Sergio Aguero with the United players on the pitch at Sunderland, waiting to celebrate, discover that Aguero scores this dramatic moment in stoppage time. And you've got Martin Tyler's commentary. Aguero! I swear you'll never see anything like this ever again. It was one of the most sensational finishes to a season, but Aguero, one of those players who joined, Kevin De Bruyne as well, one of the star playmakers of all time as well.
8:01So, you know, these are significant players. And also, City would often make the point that they hadn't broken the world transfer record, but they're able to get talented players in each position, loads of options of depth. OK, so when City say that they haven't done anything wrong, what in the hundred plus offences that they've been found guilty of are they actually disputing? Well, they've never told us what their irrefutable evidence is and their priority would always be... Well, that's why it's irrefutable, because no one's had the chance to refute it. Yeah, and their focus would always be on fighting the football authorities, presenting it there, not having to give it us in public.
8:37But at the heart of this case is, effectively, City are receiving money from the sponsor. It shows in the books that the sponsor is paying them, But actually in Abu Dhabi, the ultimate parent company of Citi is repaying that sponsor. There's also a schema and image rights. So players are very marketable. Citi sell them off to a company. So that's sort of banking the marketability of your players. You get cash coming in. But then that company was actually being paid by Abu Dhabi United Group, Sheikh Mansour's company. Sheikh Mansour, vice president now of the United Arab Emirates. just showing how far-reaching the club is in terms of this being about more than a football enterprise, but also they always say City, it's a private investment of Shein Mansoor, but so connected with the state.
9:25These allegations have been round for donkey's years. In fact, one of the reasons I was particularly pleased to see your name on the list this morning as guest on the podcast is you've been following this for donkey's years yourself. When did you first start hearing that there might be something amiss? Well, it was within years of the takeover. Once we're seeing these sponsorships gather, but there's nothing you can fully establish at this point. And, you know, there's a reticence around for people to really challenge often in football, you see. But then a particular moment came and the Manchester City accounts dropped for the 2012-2013 season.
10:02This was the first season it really starts to become notable because they would be assessed by UEFA for compliance with financial fair play. So before then, you could basically just spend what you wanted to. Now, I started to go through the accounts and I spotted something about intellectual property and related parties in terms of transactions. And I discovered there was£47 million that they generated by selling intellectual property. And without it, and this relates to the image rights, which I've just mentioned, they would have made even bigger losses. Also in this, there was£22.5 million received from related parties, which included selling the right to use City's name to New York City FC, which didn't yet exist.
10:45It was the team they were launching in Major League Soccer. And I remember sort of asking about it. I said, well, is the money relatable? I think someone within the club said, it's about selling the right to use the name within the same group. Because once they'd bought City, they also started this umbrella of clubs. But within that network, you would then sell the right to use City's name to another part of the group. And that formed part eventually of a UEFA case as well in 2014, which led to a settlement for breaching financial fair play because their losses were too great. Now, this is all out in the open in the sense it's in the accounts.
11:14You could see it there. But it was all about how they were trying to comply with the rules. Whilst acknowledging that there were others, of course, asking similar questions. I think if we're trying to work out exactly why it has taken so long for these allegations to be looked at properly by the governing body, I think we can go back to 2019. You were speaking to Pep Guardiola directly about this. Just to remind us of that incident, because I think the way in which he responded speaks to the way in which Man City have responded to this since the very beginning until the last time we've quizzed them about it.
11:47Yeah, the key context around this, the Football League documents, which we get into how they were brought into the public domain by a Portuguese hacker, they showed that when Roberto Mancini was City manager a few years earlier, he had two contracts one with manchester city another allegedly with one of shake mansour's teams in the uae and he was receiving allegedly as much if not more as a consultant advisor for that team in the uae we don't know what he was doing it earned in that money so questions about if in some way it was inflating his city income i've had the chance to answer mancini about that by the way and he didn't want to say anything but in light of that we come to 2019 and we don't get the chance let's say we when is the moment to ask managers about this well that week in 2019 UEFA had just started to bring its case against City so suddenly that information from a few months earlier was even more relevant so I also wanted to know Petr Guardiola do you also have another contract as well a sort of consultancy now there's nothing wrong with that you can have that.
12:56You just have to sort of inform in terms of compliance with financial fair play and your own obligations on payments. And he did not react well to it. Mancini was discovered to have had separate payments from Abu Dhabi while he was manager. Have you ever had separate payments from Abu Dhabi while he was manager? Do you know the question that you're asking to me? Do you know the question asking me if I receive money for another situation right now today? Do you believe, honestly, do you think I deserve to make this kind of question happen Roberto I don't know the day one that travel about the I've received money for in other situations just down the front please are you accusing me to receive money no I'd ask the question sometime again but it's only relevant because it came up again this week that's why that's why I said it's important to pass the mic please Rob I was going to say you did ask the question immediately after they just won the cup final didn't you your timing was immaculate and actually and we're often discussing it as journalists as well we've got this case hanging over them can you treat it as normal success while there is this cloud and actually given the fact they had just won the fa cup we i think have to contextualize it against the backdrop of what is a huge ua for case against them and they'd won the premier league at brighton about a week earlier and i didn't raise it then but i'm mentioning in my reporting the fact this case is hanging over so shouldn't we actually ask since we're mentioning it, the fact that there is this ongoing sort of question mark against all this success.
14:25Now, Sissi have never in any way told me not to repeat it, not issued a denial in any way, just not addressed it in any way at all. Another really curious aspect of this, and I think it goes to the way in which Man City are handling this, is they reportedly knew the Commission's findings, your 100 plus guilty verdicts, all the way back in July. And then they went off and they spent, what, more than 400 million quid during the transfer window, as if they do not care. And it's interesting whether rival clubs should have known necessarily, because this is players being signed from their rivals, and that's using that financial advantage.
15:01And often in these sorts of cases, you do get the chance, the parties involved, to be able to see verdicts, if there's anything heavily disputed in terms of factual elements of it. But yes, breaking their own transfer record twice in the summer transfer window, So signing particularly Enzo Fernandes from Chelsea for£125 million. Also Elliot Anderson as well from Nottingham Forest for£116 million. What has been the response? I mean, you've been amongst some of the biggest names actually in European football this week, the decision makers. When you have been speaking to them, what has been the kind of emotional response?
15:45shock, anger, a sense that this was inevitably going to come. Yeah, there's always been that sense speaking in and around clubs, the fact that they want to be on this level playing field, they want to be ensuring if they're going to abide by the rules, everyone is, and the fact that City have this huge financial advantage and the alleged manoeuvres to flout them, and there has been that concern, it's why clubs are looking at suing them to claim for compensation, which you can do in the Premier League. We've got a case involving Burnley against Everton at the moment, over Everton's breach of the financial rules on a far, far lesser scale as well, but how they might have missed out as a result being relegated.
16:23And that's what we're seeing now down the line. Clubs are looking at, well, if City hadn't had this financial advantage to be able to sign these players, well, in that year, might we have won the title? Might we have qualified for the Champions League instead as well? So they might have earned tens of millions of pounds in priesman alone, let alone the commercial advantages as having had those trophies or being in Champions League.
16:53I'm Adele Robinson, a correspondent for Sky News, and I wanted to give you a recommendation for when you finish this podcast. I've made a documentary for YouTube called The Calm, Online, Sadistic and Deadly. It takes a look inside one of the darkest corners of the internet and the disturbing community that exists there, exploring how young people can be drawn into it and the devastating consequences that can follow. It's a story that's difficult to hear, but one I think is really important to understand. You can find The Calm on the Sky News app, website and YouTube channel.
17:29So what are the potential penalties, potential punishments? I mean, look, I'm obviously, with a Scottish accent, when hearing about this story, went straight in my mind to Rangers. different governing body, different set of circumstances, I know, but the crime was so egregious that they got sent down all the way to the very bottom end of Scottish football. Doesn't what Man City has been accused of and found to have been guilty of, doesn't that demand a similarly massive nuclear winter-style response? Well, ultimately, City could be expelled from the Premier League. The clubs would have to vote for it.
18:05It requires three-quarters of the 20 to approve it. Would they do that, though, given the cash count that Man City is? It's interesting, actually, whether they would look at self-interest completely. Would it be an advantage of them not being there, losing that financial power to sign players, or would it reduce the marketability of the league? Because City have Erling Haaland, one of the great players in the world at the moment. If he was to leave the Premier League, is that damaging overall for the Premier League? It's good for the Premier League to have some of the best players in the world.
18:34Points deductions could come their way. some talk of staggered points deduction so deducting them points up every year for several years so it impedes their ability to say qualify for the Champions League which also means there's less money coming into the club so they can't comply with the financial rules which are currently profit and sustainability and it creates all sorts of issues down the line but they're going to have to assess this at a commission this will be extensive there's also the appeal process as well which needs to be over by Christmas the city will be trying to find faults they call it unsafe in terms of the way they've been found guilty.
19:08You say that it has to be over by Christmas. Weren't you speaking to City's chief executive this week? Or, well, other people were speaking to City's chief executive this week. He gave you a bit of a swerve, but apparently he was saying, what, this could take years? Well, I was told in a private meeting of the executive board of the European Football Club's body on Monday, he brought it up himself, Aaron Soriano, the chief executive, and he said it's gone on since 2018. It could go on for some time to come. and indication it could be years still with the attempt to go to the high court. They'd already been using the courts to try and get this whole thing thrown out to stop the Premier League investigating.
19:46In 2019, they went to the Court of Arbitration for Sport to try to block UEFA even investigating them. They actually added something to their case at CAS. It hadn't been known they were going to CAS until I discovered it in June 2019 and reported it. So they added to their case against UEFA, how did I discover the fact they were even going to the court of arbitration for sports? So it just shows the level actually of legal might they'll put at this. But look, we're talking in abstract terms about punishing Man City for what has been done. And actually, ultimately, you're not going to be punishing the billionaire owners.
20:23They've still got their palaces. You're not going to be punishing the footballers, at least in the medium to long term, you know, because they will still be earning plenty of money wherever they end up. It's the fans, isn't it? No matter what the sanctions are, and you've got to hope that they are going to be significant, ultimately the people who will pay the price are those who have devoted their lives to following this club. And the many staff members at City as well. Of course, of course. Because many in jobs that don't pay anything like the salaries of Erling Haaland and all the stars who will be concerned about what will happen to them if the club was to be booted out of the Premier League.
21:00But then there are the fans as well who have put their faith in Sheikh Mansour to give a broad sweep assessment. Some very critical of us for applying our scrutinising reporting, not wanting to see their club undermined. They talk of it being a cartel of clubs, the established elite who are out to get them. But these fans, they don't get to change clubs. It's the clubs many have been born into. They've supported all their lives. So to expect them to abandon the team just because of issues of the ownership. Rob, we will see what happens with Man City, certainly. Thanks very much indeed Great to join you And that's your lot for today But do get in touch with your thoughts Particularly if you are a Man City fan At what do you make of your club's response What do you think will happen next Do let me know why at sky.uk Is the email We're back tomorrow
21:54Online sadistic groups Are targeting vulnerable children The sheer amount of potential victims is astounding. It's a very real threat, and it is here in the UK. It will always shock me. A young boy could commit such awful offences. Some of the content has been the worst I've ever seen. Parents need to be aware of what can happen on these sites. Find The Calm on Sky News YouTube.
Guilty. The damning verdict in favour of the Premier League against one of its most successful clubs – Manchester City.
The case concerned more than a hundred charges – from disguised funding to misleading accounts – with possible consequences ranging from points deductions to expulsion from the Premier League.
But rather than backing down, the club has come out fighting – insisting an independent commission got it wrong and vowing to appeal.
With City standing firm and the punishment still undecided, there could be a long way to go before the final whistle.
Niall Paterson is joined by Sky’s sports correspondent Rob Harris, who has been following the case and putting questions to the club’s most senior figures for more than a decade.
Have you got a question for Niall? Email us: [email protected]