


Violent nationwide protests in France and how similar youth unrest is spreading across Europe, driven by cost-of-living pressures, youth unemployment fears, and political uncertainty ahead of next May’s leadership change.
Catherine Gileadie, a French journalist living in Paris who witnessed the weekend violence and describes police tear gas/bombs and chaotic street conditions.
The protests’ scale surprised even French authorities; police were “overwhelmed” and not in control. Discontent mixes education demands (students), unions, and earlier “Gilets Jaunes” grievances. The unrest may boost far-right and radical-left narratives, though it could also be counterproductive.
Arrests (2,400+), ransacked shops (2,000+), looting/razed public buildings; protests in Albania, Italy, Spain, Portugal, and youth unemployment concerns in the UK.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Overview of the protests in France, including arrests and President Macron's response.
“Individual circumstances may vary for prescription only.”
Catherine Gileadie describes her firsthand experience of the protests in Paris.
“For more, I'm joined by the French journalist Catherine Gileadie, who lives in Paris and witnessed the violence over the weekend.”
Discussion on the unprecedented scale of the protests and the police's response.
“So confusion, chaos, sadness, some people injured.”
Exploration of the different groups involved in the protests and their motivations.
“It started in recent weeks with students about education.”
Analysis of the political climate in France and across Europe in relation to protests.
“So, yes, it's a very difficult moment, but it's also the end of a regime.”
Speculation on the future of Europe and the potential impacts of the protests.
“So yes, this is not just a French problem.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On This Is Why, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:01Sky News, the full story first.
0:12The violence and disorder in France will have other European leaders worried, and this is why.
0:35finger sticks. Learn more at freestyllibre.us. Finger sticks are required if your glucose alarms or readings do not match symptoms or when you see check blood glucose symbol for the first 12 hours. The views expressed should not be used for medical diagnosis or treatment as a substitute for professional medical advice. Individual circumstances may vary for prescription only. Safety info found at freestyllibre.us.
1:03Hey everyone, I'm Gareth Barlow More than 2 ,400 people have been arrested across France following violent nationwide protests On Sunday night, President Macron addressed the nation saying nothing justified the unbridled violence Public buildings have been razed to the ground and looting is widespread. France isn't the only country where the young, in particular, are protesting. Students in Albania, Italy, Spain, Portugal have all also clashed with police. And even in the UK, the Prime Minister, Andy Burnham, has called the high rates of youth unemployment an economic catastrophe and moral failure.
1:39So what's caused the huge disconnect between the state and young people across the continent? For more, I'm joined by the French journalist Catherine Gileadie, who lives in Paris and witnessed the violence over the weekend. Tell me first of all, how would you describe the weekend? Unusual. And like everything that is unexpected, because it is unexpected in its scale. And the fact that the police wasn't able to bring things back to normal for a while. I was there. I was in Paris until late in the evening. and I had seen some unrest before. I had seen some looters and people who want to destroy things.
2:21And I have seen many peaceful demonstrations and peaceful demonstrators who were from the beginning of the demonstration. It was painful. It was a painful moment for many reasons. Take us onto the streets, if you will. If we were on the streets of Paris over the weekend, as you were, what did it smell like? What did it sound like? What did it feel like? What was the mood on the street? Because the images are remarkable. What was it like to be amongst it? Well, you're a journalist and you're a TV journalist, so you know the power of images. And I have seen how the foreign press has covered it. And also in the French press, I have seen the images that wonderful photographers took and very impressive images.
3:05There were some impressive moments, some unusual moments. And you're right. I mean, And it didn't smell good from 12 o 'clock to midnight. The police had thrown so many bombs, tear gas, that it was difficult to breathe easily in Paris, even in the underground. And indeed, it was noisy. It was noisy. So confusion, chaos, sadness, some people injured. It's a complex moment in France, not only in France, actually, but yeah, it's a complex moment. You described it as unexpected. And from an outside perspective, I feel as though I've talked about protests in France, the student-led protests about school funding and shortfalls in teaching numbers for weeks now.
3:54What was the element about the weekend that was new, that was unexpected, that took what's happened in previous weeks and took it a step further? But you could also add that France is well known for its demonstrations. The French have a way to negotiate that is first going to the fight. And then we negotiate. You will never see a strike in France that has been called off because the negotiations were satisfying for everyone before the actual demonstrations and the fight. So, yes, France is known for that. What is new and what surprised us all is the scale of it. This is the surprise. and the fact the police and they are admitting it today, the Minister of the Interior has admitted it today and the French president has also had this sentence in his very short address yesterday saying the police did what they could.
4:45They admit that they were totally overwhelmed and that they were not in control. It's the first time I hear that in my generation, I think I have to say. It's the first time that we get to that result when 2 ,000 shops have been ransacked, where the streets of Paris, some of them are quite impressive. And again, beware of images. Most of the streets in Paris are okay. We are not at war. I'm saying it like that because as every French person, I've received messages from my friends saying, are you okay? Yes, I am okay. No worries. And we are okay. And it's impressive. But again, I'm waiting to know who are the people who have been arrested.
5:28We have only figures. We don't know. Who are they? The president said the ultra left. Who's the ultra left? I guess depending on where one stands on the spectrum dictates to some degree what you consider to be far and ultra left. It's subjective to some degree. I'm just thinking about the makeup of people. There will be that percentage who are just rioters, looters, criminals, idiots that just see an opportunity, seize it and run to the Apple store, grab the phones and chuck them on the Internet. But there are also groups with what they see as legitimate concerns. It started in recent weeks with students about education.
6:06They were then joined by unions and the Gilets Jaunes that kind of gripped France for the best part of a year in 2018. And so if you look at people that would say they have legitimate concerns, that grouping has got bigger and therefore surely the concerns have got larger. And the question surely on the lips of many French people and many analysts will now be, well, if the presidency and the ruling class were struggling to sort out schools, are they going to be able to deal with this newer, even bigger list of demands? We are in a moment in France where there is a scare and there is a scare in the younger population with quite a big majority of them coming from foreign families that the far right will rule our country.
6:54And we are in this context where the discontent, the social discontent, economical discontent is added to this uncertainty of how our country will be ruled from next May, actually. Every time they voice their demand, they come into universities or other schools to say, come, come with us. They always end with the Marseillaise, which is very unusual, the French anthem. They say we are French and they have a French flag with them. This is also very new. You have people that are French politicians don't dare say they are black or from Arabic families. But Trump says it. And there are people who say, I am French, you know, and I'm afraid that next year there will be a far right leader who doesn't want me to be here, even though I'm French.
7:48I've been French for three generations. And so this is the context. So, yes, it's a very difficult moment, but it's also the end of a regime. You know, it's the end of Emmanuel Macron. He's only here for six months. He cannot be reelected. Nobody really believes he's in charge anymore. There'll be some observers who say they understand the concerns of some of the protesters regarding the change of politics in France. But some observers will also say, well, look, going out onto the streets and protesting and rioting and looting and setting fire to stuff, surely that feeds into the hands of people like Jordan Bardello or Marine Le Pen or the far right.
8:26And actually, these kind of protests could be counterproductive, if anything, inflammatory. What do you make of those arguments? Yes, you could definitely argue that the far right will benefit from the disorder. And the right, as well as the far right, but also the left, has asked for more order. Yes and no. The electorate of the far right doesn't really need demonstrations like this to say, you know, we were right, we are right, we should vote for Marine Le Pen. And it can also be argued that for the radical left, Jean-Luc Mélenchon, who's very popular with the students and the younger generation, it has actually made the far left quite popular as well, saying they're the only one to listen to us.
9:14It's also, I guess, important to think of the fact that France isn't in isolation at the moment, is it? In terms of dissent, especially amongst its populace regarding kind of cost of living, Spain, Pedro Sánchez having to call an early election because of protests there about housing prices, in Milan over the course of the weekend protests, in Portugal, Albania. It's not unique to France. Yes, yes, of course. Of course, France is not the only one. Sometimes we hear that France is an inspiration for some of those movements. Indeed, there is a difficulty in our Western societies in terms of how the wealth is being redistributed.
9:53So yes, this is not just a French problem. Indeed, it's a Western problem. And we are part of Europe as well. And even though Britain is out of the European Union, it does concern Britain as well. The protests are unique to France, the cost of living pressures, the challenges of employment, young people feeling as though they've got a difficult future. isn't unique to France. The questions over what the future looks like politically isn't unique to France. Look at Germany, the rise of alternative for Deutschland, AFD, and the challenges that the main centrist parties of old are having in kind of engaging their populations and keeping them on side.
10:29It goes across borders as well. What do you think France, what do you think Europe looks like on the other side of this? Because there has to be another side. At some point, there will be a future and it will look different. What does that future look like? Since the world has deeply changed after the fall of the Berlin Wall, I know that was a while ago, but still in a life like mine, it was, you know, I was an adult already. The world has become more complex and more chaotic. And, you know, I have children and I have no idea what the world will be for them. So that's in 10 years, you know, 15 years, 20 years.
11:09We were talking about the French parliament so divided. And why aren't people voting more is also because they don't see those ruling doing the effort to work together. You know, we haven't talked about the United States, but we can see there that definitely what is ruling, not all the Americans, far from that, But what is ruling is the strength. So do we just have to be the strongest? Are we going to work together? I think this is what I heard from the younger generation. Let's work together and stop just being enemies on a bipolar world. Let's hope this generation will remain like this. And maybe they will change the world.
11:55But for the moment, yes, it doesn't look good. If I may, you mentioned that you have children. What do they make of all of this? I mean, my children are 20 and 24. So they're not in high school anymore. They're studying. They haven't demonstrated, actually. But they definitely support their friends who have done that. And they criticize the police. I mean, the image of the police in the younger generation is just so terrible. But at the same time, they also see and condemn those who just came there in Paris, in Marseille, and in the world to destroy and to loot. And I really hope that these demonstrations, asking for better studying conditions, better standard of living, will bring people also to think, OK, let's see what we can do together and not one against the other.
12:48That's all for today. Email us at y at skype.uk to tell us your thoughts. I'll be back again tomorrow.
12:59Thank you.
Violent clashes, burning buildings, widespread looting and thousands of arrests. Even for France, the scale of the current protests across the country is extreme.
What started off as student demonstrations, highlighting issues like a lack of staff and equipment in schools, has grown into a much bigger movement – which the government admits it’s struggling to contain.
But France isn’t the only country where the young are protesting. Students in Albania, Italy, Spain and Portugal have also clashed with authorities.
So, what’s caused such a huge disconnect between the state and young people across the continent?
Gareth Barlow speaks to French journalist Catherine Guilyardi, who lives in Paris and witnessed the violence over the weekend.
Have you got a question for the podcast? Email us: [email protected]