1. Podcasts
  2. This Is Why
  3. Why France’s school protests are a problem for president Macron
This Is Why

7 Oct 2026 · 22m · 9 chapters

Episode artwork

Why France’s school protests are a problem for president Macron

In short

France’s school protests over deteriorating conditions, teacher shortages, overcrowding, and exam disruptions have spread nationwide and become a political challenge for President Emmanuel Macron ahead of spring elections, with police using tear gas and stun grenades.

Guests

Ruby Selimensky, a 17-year-old student in Lyon, describes her school’s flooding and collapsing ceiling, large class sizes, absent teachers, chaotic timetables, and tear-gassing during blockades. Richard Engel, NBC’s chief foreign correspondent and co-host of The World, reports on protest growth and injuries.

Key claims

900 schools are closed or blockaded; about 250,000 people protest nationwide (50,000+ in Paris). Injuries include a student losing a hand and another with broken teeth from flash grenades. Movement is expanding beyond students to unions, parents, and teachers, with political blame aimed at left-wing Mélenchon and far-right opportunism.

Notable examples

Lyon “blocus” barricades shutting a school; tear gas used on students and even a school field trip of seven-year-olds; police chasing protesters after a headmaster called them.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

0:39

Historical Overview of Protests

Exploring historical precedents for protests in France and current grievances.

“the gilets jaunes, the yellow jacket fume demonstrations.”
1:25

Student Grievances and Conditions

Students describe the dire conditions in their schools and the reasons for protests.

“But first, let's hear from Ruby Selimensky, a 17-year-old student in Lyon.”
2:26

Ruby's Experience on the Ground

Ruby Selimensky shares her firsthand experience of the protests and police response.

“it's hard to concentrate and they just continue making our exams harder.”
4:25

Student Perspective on Government Response

Discussion on the political response to the protests from students' views.

“I have not been going to school for the past week.”
8:22

Parents and Broader Support for Protests

Ruby discusses parental support and the growing involvement of various groups in the protests.

“Yeah, I mean, my mum is happy that I'm doing this.”
10:10

Richard Engel on the Expanding Movement

Richard Engel provides an overview of the broader implications of the protests and their political significance.

“Richard Engel is NBC's chief foreign correspondent, also co-host, along with Yalda Hakim, of our sister podcast, The World.”
14:00

Protests Against Macron: A Political Analysis

Explore the dynamics of the protests against President Macron and their implications.

“And another group of labor unions are also joining this demonstration, and it's morphing into a movement against Emmanuel Macron.”
16:40

Economic Struggles and Protest Demands

Discuss the economic challenges facing France and the protesters' demands for better education funding.

“So what can President Macron do, if anything?”
20:00

Protest Movements and the Role of Youth

Analyze the role of youth in the current protests and their demands for change in France.

“I mean, how can these protests be brought to an end?”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On This Is Why, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:01Sky News, the full story first.

0:10better classrooms more teachers hardly revolutionary demands but in france they've sparked protests that are spreading well beyond the school gates and this is why

0:38The French Revolution, the student protests of 1968, the gilets jaunes, the yellow jacket fume demonstrations. France has quite the history of taking its disagreements onto the streets. And you might hope today's pupils would learn all about that, sitting in a decent classroom with a teacher in front of them. For some, that's precisely the problem. My school, I have flooding going on. The school ceiling, it's collapsing. The government does not want to give money to a school. What began as protests about schools has brought parents, teachers and unions onto the streets. A sometimes heavy-handed police response is added to the anger.

1:16And the far left and far right are making competing arguments about what France needs ahead of crucial presidential elections. Richard Engel, co-host of our sister podcast The World, is in Paris. I'll be speaking to him shortly. But first, let's hear from Ruby Selimensky, a 17-year-old student in Lyon. Ruby, just walk me through the reasons behind these protests. These protests, which started very small, but which are now practically all across the country. Yep, so they started in the Persian suburbs, as you know, and they got national interest from other high schools, including mine. I'm part of a pretty privileged high school, but we did want to show our support for these underprivileged high schools, especially in the Parisian suburbs where they experienced a lot of police violence.

2:06I know in my high school, in my class with 35 students, in others, they could be going up until 40 students per class. There's also quite a big shortage of teachers. I've had classes where the teacher was absent for a couple of weeks, a couple of months even. Then also the timetables, they're pretty crazy. I mean, I start every day at eight. Some schools, they finish at 6.30. Also, exam conditions are horrible. I had an aura once. It was 37 degrees in the room. it's hard to concentrate and they just continue making our exams harder. And Ruby, you describe yourself as going to a pretty privileged school.

2:51Yeah. And these are the conditions. Yes. So how bad has it gotten for those that you've already mentioned, those in the kind of the Parisian suburbs? I know that some of the buildings, they can be pretty run down with the lack of chairs, a lack of desks, even my school. I have flooding going on the school ceiling. it's collapsing and the government does not want to give money to our school because there's so many other struggling schools that need the money or they just don't have it. There's often times at school where I just there's water on the floor and there's lack of access in the gymnasium and things like that because we can't use it.

3:28What effect has this had on your education? It is quite hard. It's kind of weird because before the protests it's your everyday life so you don't necessarily realize the things that are going on. And it's only now that you kind of think of the conditions we have. For me, it's my everyday life to get up at 6.30, be at school at 8, have class until 5.30, get home, do work, do my extracurriculars and go to bed quite late because I have a lot of things to do. And it's become a ritual that becomes the norm. And then when you realise that shouldn't be the norm. It creates a switch. So some pretty awful conditions in your own school, even worse conditions further afield.

4:11You've been out on those protests. Just tell me exactly how those have gone. Students in my school organised what they call a blocus, which is where they put barricades in front of the door to stop entry. And that blocus was very successful. They managed to close down the school. I have not been going to school for the past week. School has been just completely closed. I've participated nearly every day to other blocus or any other protests that's been happening. And I have been witness to quite brutal conditions coming from the police. Tell me about the police response. We have seen snapshots of it, largely from in and around Paris.

4:52what's been your experience last week after my school's blue kus i went to another high school that was also doing a blue kus where it wasn't as successful and their own headmaster called the police on us we were immediately tear gassed as as they arrived with no warning and chased away from the school we weren't in front of the school anymore and they continued chasing us i was with a group of both girls and boys and they were calling girls names calling the equivalent of a slut to them one of them was hit in the hip there was another one of the boys that was tackled to the ground then hit on repeatedly and then arrested blindfolded and taken into a police car I've been witness to many other things I mean during protests I've been tear gassed repeatedly at one point during a protest we were going through a tunnel where there was a tram stop they gassed both sides of the tunnel and a class of seven-year-olds were there on a school field trip seven-year-olds yeah and they were tear gassed too and one of my friends was in the tram with them with these children putting teardrops in their eyes as they were crying I'm just trying to understand why the police on arriving at a demonstration outside a school would immediately deploy tear gas.

6:20I'm not doubting your account, Ruby, at all, but was this truly a peaceful protest? In most cases, it is. So when I was at the other high school and when the headmaster called the police on us, we were blocking the doors to the school. There was barricades being used and the headmaster, we then had a conversation with him after we came back to the school to talk to him. He said that to him that was posing a threat to his students, but he did call the police on his own students. So it's really hard to figure out the levels to this. But there are obviously students that are there not for the same reasons as us, that they want to create violence and they're burning the bins.

7:06I think it just really depends. But from what I've seen, we are just 17 year olds. There are children as young as 14 getting their hands blown off that are just peacefully protesting and we're getting sent tear gas. and it's pretty scary. Do you think the politicians are listening to you? Well, personally, I was invited by the mayor of Lyon to talk to him with 20 other students. The mayor can't do anything about the situation because high schools, the administration is done by what we call the region and it's not the mayor that can do anything, but he was there to listen to us. But in terms of government officials, the interior minister is reacting pretty awfully.

7:48he's giving practically no restrictions to the police. Only yesterday, he banned what they call a grenade d 'assourdissement. I think, I don't remember. Yeah, exactly. Stun grenades. But, you know, all the tear gas is still in action. I think Emmanuel Macron spoke on it and was just saying that there shouldn't be violence from the kids and not touching base on the police violence. And I think just overall, I don't feel listened to. I don't feel represented by the government and how they're responding with it. How do your parents feel, Ruby, about you taking part? Because one of the striking things over the past couple of days is me seeing parents coming out, protesting alongside their children, partly, I would imagine, to try and keep an eye on them because of the dangers to them, but also quite clearly in solidarity.

8:40Yeah, I mean, my mum is happy that I'm doing this. she is proud of me she thinks it's great that I'm meeting with the mayor and you know having proper conversations and obviously not being violent yesterday there was actually a huge peaceful protest in the whole of France where I think hundreds and thousands of people were there not just students including parents I do feel really supported by my family and you know it's just great to know that in terms of family I feel heard what happens next do you think Ruby I mean quite clearly, despite being tear gassed, despite witnessing the violence, doesn't strike me that you are prepared to stop protesting just yet.

9:22No, we're definitely not ready to stop. I think what needs to be recognised is the police violence and the conditions and schools that needs to change. Now it's not just a high school problem, it's a national problem. There's public servants that are coming to the protest, students from universities. It's not just us anymore that's in the fight. No one's happy anymore. They realise this is unfair and that we're not going to just stop. I mean, yesterday the education minister was saying how he wants to close the schools. That's not how he's going to just stop us and shut us up, basically.

10:07Okay, so that is the view from the student body. But what's been happening with these broadening protests? Richard Engel is NBC's chief foreign correspondent, also co-host, along with Yalda Hakim, of our sister podcast, The World. Richard, it is fantastic to have you on the podcast. It's been a while. I've been listening to yours for quite some time. So good to actually meet you. Oh, thank you very much. Pleasure's the same. Richard, you've been out and about. You've been in the heart of it. Just give me a flavour of what you have seen these protests are becoming. So they're growing. It started out strictly as a movement by high school students, and it spread.

10:43People online heard about this. Other students joined in, and it was no longer just one school. It suddenly became dozens of schools and dozens more schools, and the police moved in. There was a couple of quite serious injuries, and now it has expanded well beyond just a few schools. There are 900 schools that are currently closed by the government or blockaded by students. There were, according to the government's own numbers, about a quarter of a million people on the streets all across the country, about more than 50 ,000 of them just in Paris. And they've been joined now by the country's biggest labor union, by a working group and parents and some teachers.

11:32So it's a bigger movement now than just students. And it's set to expand even further in about 10 days when more unions are joining into this protest movement. I mean, Richard, this will not be the first set of student protests that you have covered. But this growth, this swelling in the numbers, the violence that you yourself have witnessed, what does that put you in mind of that you have previously reported on? It's rough. People got hurt. There have been at least two serious injuries, one where a young man had his hand blown off by a police stun grenade. It seems that a lot of French media reports that he picked it up, this explosive flash bomb that the police have been using to frighten people and disperse the crowds.

12:19And it blew up in his hand like a big firework and took his hand off. And another student, also a young man, was hit in the face by one of these flying flash grenades, and it broke most of his teeth. So also quite a serious injury. But other than that, it was a lot of pushing and shoving, lots of arrests, lots of, I think you can call them detentions, because generally these people are being arrested, but they're not going to court and they're not going to face long prison terms. They're released after 24, 48 hours. So it's more of an effort to get them off the streets, frighten them a little bit and slow the momentum down.

12:57So it looks violent because there's fire and there's noise and there's these stun grenades and there's huge numbers. But compared to other uprisings that I've seen in Turkey or places like that, it didn't resort to armed conflict, which makes all the difference. But for how much longer do you think that that might last, Richard? I mean, is this genuinely still a protest about, you know, the quality of education in French state schools or is it metastasizing into something broader? It's changing into something broader. The French people would say not metastasizing, which implies that it's a cancer.

13:37They think what's happening here is an expansion of a positive movement. it, they would say, and I spoke to many of the demonstrators of all ages, it is certainly changing. And it's going to change significantly on the 17th because groups like the gilets jun, the yellow vests, and some of those guys are quite rough. You know, some of those guys are, will take the violence even to a higher level than we've been seeing with the students. They've done that in the past. And another group of labor unions are also joining this demonstration, and it's morphing into a movement against Emmanuel Macron.

14:16So president of France, he's already served two terms. Each one is five years, so he's been in power for almost 10 years. French elections are this spring. And this is also now a movement against him. And Macron and his allies say this is no longer just some organic student protest. This has become an organized movement and that these students and others are being manipulated as we enter a period of political jockeying. And they point in particular to one candidate, Mélenchon, and he's an old rival of, well, of the establishment, but particularly of Macron. And he's aligned himself with the students and the unions and the youth in general.

15:02Even though he's 75, he's surrounded himself with a group of very, very young advisors and cadres. So the powers that be are blaming the elections and blaming this particular left wing candidate for mobilizing the streets. If we see the powers of the left of French politics kind of lining up behind these protests, what about, you know, that aspect of the French political spectrum? I suppose you could call the hard right, you know, the national rally. I mean, a party that really is in the political ascendancy at the moment, one we've covered on this podcast a number of times. I mean, where are they?

15:35What is their position on what is going on in Paris's, on France's streets? Well, they think this is awful. This is abomination. And they think it's chaos. And the students, not just the students, but the student led demonstrators out on the streets were specifically chanting against bad schools, against Macron, and also against the far right, against the Front National, the party of Marine Le Pen and before that her father. and they have been actively denouncing those parties. This was a rejection of those far-right movements. So it's the political drama that is facing all of Europe also playing out on the streets where you have the far-right in ascendancy, left-wing groups that are more youth-oriented saying we can't accept this and now they've been joined by organized labor.

16:41So what can President Macron do, if anything? I mean, the French economy is tanking, debt up to their eyeballs, the bond market telling them you are not spending any more money. And ultimately, what these protests want, surely, is more money to be spent on education. What can he do? Well, that's exactly the argument that the government is making, saying, well, listen, we don't have any money. And that's what the argument they've been making for years. A couple of years ago, I was in Paris again for the demonstrations. They were actually, I would say, a little bit more violent than these ones about pension reform.

17:14And they wanted to raise the retirement age from 62 to 64, which across world standards is still relatively low. And Macron kept saying, we don't have the money for this. We don't have the cash. We need people to work those extra two, three years, whatever the job, however the categories broke down. It was a very long and complicated pension reform bill. And the people didn't buy it then and they're not buying it now. Richard, we clearly both know that there are presidential elections looming for France. Who stands to benefit more from the anger that is being displayed on the streets? It's a great question.

17:55The left wing is certainly trying to capitalize on this. And there's the politician I mentioned, this sort of stalwart of the left, Mélenchon. And he's been accused by Macron of organizing all of this. And by the way, he's not exactly denying it either. I think the difference is with the campaign now, the students are asking for something new. They're asking for more money, better conditions and not as many students in the classroom, better ratios to teachers. They're asking for something productive and positive that doesn't exist. In the past, the French protesters have been out to prevent losing something because there is a feeling in this country that the good life that French were able to enjoy of a secure job and a pension and you could retire at a certain age and know that you were going to be able to have a life that you could be proud of in your golden age.

18:50They feel that all those things are being stripped away and stripped away and stripped away. And this movement wants to not just defend what they're losing, but put more things back, better schools, be proactive. So they could benefit from the general dissatisfaction on the streets. But there is also anger that the far right is capitalizing. And you're seeing that in the UK. You're seeing that all over Europe because there is the cultural impact when you have huge numbers of people from non-traditional British or French culture coming in. And there are homeless, lots of homeless on the streets.

19:33Paris is a beautiful city. But if I walk around, as I did last night, about one in the morning, Place de République, it's rough. You know, there were dozens of homeless sleeping on the ground or sleeping in tents, entire families sleeping in tents. There are real problems as well in this country. And Marine Le Pen and others have been able to capitalize on that and say, France doesn't look like France anymore. Let's make France great again in a very kind of Trumpian way. So, Richard, where does this go next? I mean, how can these protests be brought to an end? Even if Emmanuel Macron had the money to do everything that those student protesters wanted, it would take time to put into place.

20:12So where do we go from here? Well, a promise to do it would probably work. The protesters say there's money out there, that if they can raise in a matter of hours hundreds of millions of dollars for rebuilding the iconic cathedral of Notre Dame, why can't they open up the wallets and make it so that the schools aren't falling apart and not overcrowded? And there are people who agree with that sentiment. There were parents and teachers. So you would think the teachers would be the last ones to go out and stand in solidarity. I spoke to several young teachers who were out there and saying, yes, the conditions are terrible.

20:51And they're saying they haven't been paid. I spoke to a teacher who hasn't been paid for the last month and a half. So there are real issues. And if Macron chooses to engage with them, that then you could probably see the movement scaling back. But I keep looking at this date, October 17th, when it's supposed to be bigger, more people involved. I wouldn't say only student led, although I think they will be used as the vanguard in all of this. And it's a bit of a send off party. That's the way they're thinking of it for Emmanuel Macron and starts the election season off in earnest. So unless he does something really quick, I think in 10 days, they're going to be scenes like this, if not bigger across France again.

21:37Richard, been an absolute pleasure chatting to you, thanks for your time My pleasure And that's your lot for today, but do remember to get in touch We always want to hear your thoughts on what you've just heard Yesterday's episode, well that was on an apparent death from plague Yep, the thing that caused the Black Death In a scientist working at a lab in Russia Debbie O 'Brien emails in Do you know if there are any unreported deaths? Well, no Debbie, because they're unreported But we are keeping eyes out for any new detail And Peter Greenaway says this Very strange this happened in Russia Makes you think Were they thinking to drop something on Ukraine to weaken them?

22:13Surely not I have to say Peter I'd be with the surely not end of the spectrum The email address is why at sky.uk We're back tomorrow

From the publisher

Imagine being tear-gassed and targeted with stun grenades – all for complaining about timetables, absent teachers and crumbling classrooms.

That’s the experience of thousands of French students, whose initial demonstrations over high school conditions have evolved into a wider national protest across 40 towns and cities.

Parents, teachers and a sympathetic public have all joined pupils on the barricades. But far-right groups have accused those on the left of politicising the movement.

And while the use of stun grenades has now been banned, the response from the police and government has been heavy-handed and heavily criticised – just months before a general election.

Niall Paterson is joined by NBC News chief foreign correspondent and co-host of The World podcast, Richard Engel – and Ruby Celemenski, a 17-year-old student in Lyon who has witnessed the police response first-hand.

More from This Is Why

All episodes