


23 Oct 2026 · 12m · 6 chapters

Sally Rooney has withdrawn her novels from UK shops after her support for Palestine Action, which the UK government banned as a terrorist organisation under the Terrorism Act. The episode weighs whether she should be allowed to sell books while donating proceeds, and whether the ban should stand.
Helen Brown, journalist who writes about culture for The Telegraph.
Brown is a culture journalist and discusses Rooney’s politics, writing style, and public controversy.
Faber can’t pay Rooney if she donates profits to Palestine Action because providing money/property to a proscribed group could be a crime. Rooney frames her actions as solidarity and says public figures should accept consequences.
Rooney’s novels Normal People and Conversations with Friends; her refusal to translate recent books into Hebrew without an Israeli publisher supporting a cultural boycott; mention of Palestine Action vandalism and a member attacking a policewoman with a sledgehammer.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Discussion on Sally Rooney's decision to withdraw her books from sale in the UK and its implications.
“But the next generation may have to work a little bit harder to read her books after she withdrew them from sale in the UK.”
An overview of Sally Rooney's background, her writing style, and her cultural significance.
“Sally Rooney is a 35-year-old Marxist feminist Irish novelist.”
Exploration of the political implications of Rooney's withdrawal and the reasons behind it.
“But we didn't have the weight of all these political judgments.”
Analysis of public perception regarding Sally Rooney's principled decision and its consequences.
“Britain's 2000 Terrorism Act makes it a crime for a person to provide money or other property to an organisation if they know it has reasonable cause to suspect that it may be used for the purpose of terrorism.”
Discussion on how Sally Rooney views celebrity culture and its impact on her work.
“It is also interesting, however, a lot of people are saying, oh, Sally Rooney's come out for freedom of speech, you know, you should be allowed to do right, say anything.”
Information on how readers can access Sally Rooney's books following the withdrawal.
“hold her up as a, you know, a champion for their cause.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On This Is Why, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:03Sky News. The full story first.
0:15Fans of Sally Rooney have been rushing to buy her books before they disappear from the shelves. And this is why.
0:32Sally Rooney's novels have been flying off the shelves, but it's not because she has a new book out. The Irish author, celebrated for novels including Normal People and Conversations with Friends, has been described as one of the most important writers of her generation. But the next generation may have to work a little bit harder to read her books after she withdrew them from sale in the UK. It's all because of her support for Palestine Action, which the UK government banned as a terrorist organisation last year. Support for the group can land followers up to 14 years in prison. A big problem for Rooney, who said last year that she would use proceeds from her novels and their BBC adaptations to support Palestine Action.
1:22Sally Rooney: Writers and other public figures in the wealthy global north are now increasingly speaking out against genocide and even joining protest campaigns and formal boycotts. As one such figure myself, I know that I'm often asked questions about the price I have had to pay for trying to show solidarity with Palestine. So should Rooney be able to sell her books in the UK? Well, the answer is a resounding yes if you ask more than 150 writers, celebrities and public figures who signed an open letter to the government. I'm Mari Arora and there is a lot to discuss in this story. So thankfully, I'm joined by journalist Helen Brown, who writes about culture for The Telegraph.
2:04Helen, thank you so much for joining us today to bring us up to speed on this really interesting and complicated story. Can you just start us off with the basics? Who is Sally Rooney? Sally Rooney is a 35-year-old Marxist feminist Irish novelist. you will, yeah, she is not, as my next door neighbour thought, the wife of the footballer, Wayne Rooney. This is an Irish novelist and she is best known for the novels Conversations with Friends and Normal People, which you might well have seen on the BBC. Yeah, okay. So she's been writing for quite some time. She's considered to be really one of the kind of biggest writers of her generation.
2:45Is that fair to say? That's really fair to say. And she is and has always been a political novelist. So while millennials might see her novels, especially Normal People and Conversations with Friends, as love stories, what she does really well, I think, is look at the lives of the individual, literally the normal people, in the context of the wider socio-political world. And I think she brings to bear that anxiety that her generation feel about trying to operate their very unique, you know, their jobs, their friendships, their romances, in the context of the wider world, which the internet is sort of pounding at their doors the whole time.
3:23They feel that their every minute decision has these wider impacts. A lot of people, a lot of critics find her prose can be a little bit blank. You know, there's not a lot of florid description. I quite like the starkness of it. And I think sometimes it can create a space around the words and feelings of her characters that can give them space to move, but also I think reminds you of the weight that a lot of young people feel is on all of these decisions. You know, I mean, I've got teenage children and they, you know, they're constantly like, am I allowed to listen to Sabrina Carpenter anymore?
3:58Who's been cancelled? What can I do? You know, I think when I was growing up, we felt a lot more free. You know, you put a record on, you weren't going to get cancelled by your peer group. You know, they might have said that's a terrible record and that's really uncool. But we didn't have the weight of all these political judgments. So I think Sally Rooney is very good at describing the challenges of operating as a young person today. And the economic difficulties, these are people who can't get a deposit for a flat together and are being hammered by boomers for having their avocado on toast. So Sally Rooney is a bestselling novelist.
4:29Give us a flavour of how many books she's actually sold. Sally Rooney has sold millions of copies of her novels around the world. I think the stripped nature of the prose makes them identifiable to anyone in almost any country. Although they are set in Ireland, they relate to any individual. However, Sally Rooney really doesn't like the fame that comes with them. There's kind of a sideswipe at Lana Del Rey in her most recent novel, Intermet. And she's openly characterised modern celebrity culture as a poisonous condition and a form of hell. an invasive system that does not truly work for anybody.
5:11Okay, so let's focus on what's in the news now. What has changed? She's agreed with the publishing house, Faber, to withdraw her books from sale here in the UK. So what has actually happened for her to make that decision? Well, it's interesting why she's done it now. She hasn't published a novel since 2024's Intermezzo. So she's not currently on a big kind of push campaign to sell a novel. What she does want to do, I think, is to highlight the situation of Palestine Action. She is a big supporter of the protest group Palestine Action. And she is making a protest alongside Faber and Faber with that organisation's designation as a terrorist group by the British government.
6:01Britain's 2000 Terrorism Act makes it a crime for a person to provide money or other property to an organisation if they know it has reasonable cause to suspect that it may be used for the purpose of terrorism. So in other words, the publisher would be on the hook, that's Faber and Faber, they'd be on the hook, along with Sally Rooney. If she's donating her profits to Palestine Action, they can't be paying her. So they have pulled all of her novels off the shelves. What both are doing here is challenging whether or not Palestine Action should be designated as a terrorist group. And I think, as we know, it is an organisation which includes an awful lot of people from those who have committed acts of vandalism.
6:43And in one shocking case, one member of Palestine Action took a sledgehammer to a policewoman. So there is physical violence to a human being and there's also been damage to property. but also Palestine action does include a lot of, as we've seen, you know, elderly pensioners, marching vicars, people basically just committing a bit of civil disobedience. Okay, let's delve a little bit more into what Sally Rooney has said about Palestine action. Earlier this year, Sally Rooney said, writers and other public figures in the wealthy global north are now increasingly speaking out against genocide and even joining protest campaigns and formal boycotts as one such figure myself.
7:23I know that I'm often asked questions about the price I have had to pay for trying to sow solidarity with Palestine. So what she's arguing is that actually public figures like herself basically need to stand up and be heard, even if there may be consequences. Financial for her, of course, is the most obvious one when we're talking about these book sales, for instance, right? Yes, exactly. So she was donating money to Palestine Action. And I think what a lot of people would say is, look, you know, it would be a very different situation if Sally Rooney were giving her money to a terrorist group like Hamas.
7:57She's not. She's giving money to the protest group Palestine Action. It is also interesting, however, a lot of people are saying, oh, Sally Rooney's come out for freedom of speech, you know, you should be allowed to do right, say anything. That's not her position. And in fact, historically, she has refused to allow her most recent books to be translated into Hebrew until she found an Israeli publisher that would support the cultural boycott of Israel. You say, for instance, that it's not the same as funding Hamas, but arguably they are both terrorist organisations proscribed by the UK government.
8:30Whether people might see them as very different or not, they are technically, legally both terrorist organisations, right? Yes, exactly. And I think what Sally Rooney is trying to do is highlight maybe the difference between the two groups, and she's put herself on the hook to do that. Now, her books have been flying off the shelves ever since this announcement came about. Do you think the decision was made purely on principle? Absolutely. It's a pure principle. This would be a very different situation if she had a new book to sell and there were millions of copies sitting in warehouses. There aren't at the moment.
9:05But yeah, I think even Sally Rooney's harshest critics would say she is the woman who absolutely believes in the causes that she's standing up for. I think she really has very little time for money and celebrity anyway. So yeah, this is clearly a principled stand and she clearly wants to draw attention to the government's designation of Palestine action as a terrorist group. If we're looking at the impression that this gives publicly, who do you think comes out best? because some people would argue actually Sally Rooney is being made into perhaps a victim here where she's just wanting to sell her books and she's being forced to kind of take them off the shelves.
9:46Other people would argue she knows exactly what she's doing and she knows that organisation is a banned terrorist organisation. What do you think the public feels on this? I doubt she's going to change anyone's mind re where they stand on Gaza. I think there is nothing cynical in it from Sally Rooney's perspective. I think in general, you know, the people who back her and support Palestine Action are, you know, going to continue to hold her up as a, you know, a champion for their cause. I think her critics will remain her critics. I think for the people who are a little bit stuck in the middle, I think, I think, yes, she has provided a useful reminder that Palestine Action is prescribed a terrorist group.
10:29And what she wants to do is just to be having this debate. Should these people be qualified as a terrorist group? And she has brought that conversation back into the mainstream, which was her clear intention here. Now, there's always that famous phrase, isn't there? All publicity is good publicity. Do you think this applies here? I would say that Sally Rooney is attempting to get publicity for her cause rather than for herself. I genuinely don't think she enjoys that attention for herself, but that she is mobilising her power for that cause. Possibly even those who didn't previously read her books and support her causes will now be tempted to pick one off the shelves while they are still available.
11:12OK, speaking of books being still available, if she were to bring out another book, how would UK readers be able to read it? Will they have to fly abroad to try and find a copy? Are we talking about trying to find them on the black market? I mean, what's next here? So as far as I'm aware, while they're not on shelves, I think you can still buy them on Amazon anyway. So I don't think there's any huge problem. I think there's also quite a lot available that you can actually read directly online. She's just highlighted her cause and she's got us having this conversation, which was what she wanted.
11:45Helen Brown, thank you so much for your time. Pleasure. that's all for today email us at y at sky.uk to tell us your thoughts and we'll be back next week
There's been a rush to buy Sally Rooney's books after she said she can no longer sell them in the UK.
Rooney, known for best-selling novels Normal People and Conversations with Friends, said the decision was made with her publisher over her support for the banned group Palestine Action
A month after the group was proscribed by the UK government as a terrorist organisation, Rooney said she would donate the earnings from her UK work to them.
The Irish author, seen as one of the most important writers of her generation, has been backed by hundreds of writers and public figures who have signed an open letter to the government.
Mhari Aurora speaks to Helen Brown, who writes about culture for the Telegraph, about what is behind Rooney's decision.