1. Podcasts
  2. This Is Why
  3. Why now? Burnham’s Brexit backtrack explained
This Is Why

15 Oct 2026 · 18m · 8 chapters

Episode artwork

Why now? Burnham’s Brexit backtrack explained

In short

Andy Burnham reopens debate on the UK’s relationship with the EU, asking “why now?” without committing to rejoining. The episode weighs what Brexit lost (market access) versus what it gained (political autonomy, no freedom of movement), and outlines EU options short of full re-entry (customs union, single-market alignment, or full rejoin).

Key claims

Brexit’s economic hit is estimated around 4–8% of GDP and is diffuse (higher costs, less investment, reduced competitiveness). Labour members are largely pro-EU (over 70%), but Burnham’s rhetoric may not equal policy change (“all options are open”).

Notable examples

EU “pick and mix” is rejected; single-market means rule-taking and no vote; made-in-Europe protectionism could affect car exports.

Guests

Anand Menon, director of the think tank UK in a Changing Europe, previously discussed associate membership for Canada.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

0:45

Andy Burnham's Brexit Position

Discussion on Andy Burnham's call for a closer relationship with the EU.

“I thought we'd reached an understanding.”
3:54

Reasons for Reconsidering EU Ties

Analysis of economic and political reasons for a closer relationship with the EU.

“So is this then, Anand, more than just a change in the language, a change in the rhetoric and the tone?”
7:49

Public Opinion on Brexit

Exploration of public sentiment regarding Brexit and potential rejoining the EU.

“is the debate within the parliamentary Labour Party about what they put in their next manifesto.”
11:46

The Complexities of Single Market Membership

Discussion on the implications of rejoining the single market and its challenges.

“where we were seeing people on the vote leave side of the argument or the leave side of the argument, I should say, arguing that post-leaving the European Union, we could still remain within the single market.”
14:02

The Impact of Brexit on Public Perception

Explore how public understanding of Brexit's economic impact is challenged.

“You remember her speech outside Downing Street in July 2016, when she said she was going to think about the just about managing and the injustices of modern capitalism.”
14:40

Understanding Brexit's Economic Effects

Learn about the diffuse and significant economic impacts of Brexit.

“One of the really interesting things is how hard it is to make that public argument linking Brexit and the economy.”
15:42

The Changing Political Landscape

Examine the evolving factors influencing UK-EU relations post-Brexit.

“All those things have a real economic impact on the country.”
16:58

Calls for Leadership Amidst Uncertainty

Discuss the need for clear leadership and direction regarding Brexit.

“You've got the European Union changing in real time.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On This Is Why, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:01Sky News, the full story first.

0:12Do you remember getting Brexit done? Well, apparently the warranty's expired and Andy Burnham wants another look at our relationship with Europe. This is why.

0:40So there it is. The UK has left the European Union. 47 years of history brought to an end. I thought we'd reached an understanding. You wouldn't ask me to explain the difference between the single market and the customs union again, and I wouldn't ruin your afternoon by doing it. Well, Andy Burnham has rather inconsiderately intervened. I personally believe we need to get closer because we have not had a good decade. We've had a decade of low growth, too much division. I'm the seventh prime minister in 10 years. That's the decade since Brexit. We have to make the next decade ahead of us much better than the last.

1:22So, Europe. And here we go again. The prime minister wants us to reconsider our relationship with the EU. He hasn't announced that we're rejoining, but he has reopened a conversation that consumed years of British politics and quite possibly several of your friendships. The interesting bit is why he thinks now is the moment. Annand Menon is director of the think tank UK in a changing Europe. Annand, you're becoming a regular on this podcast. I mean, the last time you were here, we were discussing the potential associate membership for Canada. Now it's Britain's turn. Have you been surprised by the way in which Andy Burnham is talking about a refreshed, closer relationship with the European Union?

2:05I mean, certainly when you think back to Starmer, he never spoke in quite these terms, did he? No, Keir Starmer was very, very guarded in what he said on the EU. They put down those red lines in the manifesto around a customs union, single market, freedom and movement. And Andy Burnham has sort of, you know, played fast and loose with this issue in his rhetoric, particularly at party conference. Am I surprised? Only slightly in the sense that one of the things that was clear to in the sort of dog days of Starmer was that a lot of his backbench MPs were starting to think that Europe was an area where they needed to go quicker, where they needed to be more ambitious.

2:44And I think broadly speaking, there were three clumps of reasons why this thinking was emerging. The first was economic. I think there was a growing realisation that if Rachel Reeves was going to go around saying Brexit has cost the economy 8%, having a set of very limited negotiations with the EU that would gain less than 1 % over 10 years wasn't big enough. The second thing was the world. So the combination of Donald Trump, meaning we're going to have to work more closely with the Europeans on security anyway, and that means working more closely with the European Union, and the fact that our major partners are becoming more protectionist.

3:19So we have this made-in-Europe scheme that the European Union is putting out that is going to have a massive impact on our car exports. Again, a reason for being closer to the European Union. And finally, there's the politics. And I think there's been a growing realisation in Labour ranks that what's happened to the party since the election in 2024 is they've lost votes to their left, to the Greens, to the nationalists in Scotland, to Plaid in Wales, all parties that are far more positive about Europe than the Labour Party is. And there's a realisation, I think, that if the Labour Party starts to be a bit more aggressive in its language on Europe, you can win some of those voters back.

3:56So is this then, Anand, more than just a change in the language, a change in the rhetoric and the tone? This is a change in policy? Well, that we just don't know. Andy Burnham is very good at sounding like he's saying a lot without saying very much. I think he did that masterfully at party conferences, that all those Labour members, and Labour members are massively pro-European, remember? The last poll I saw, over 70 % of Labour members want to rejoin the European Union. So members leave the room where he gave his conference speech with that warm glow that Andy is going to deliver. If you go back and read what he said, he didn't commit to anything at all.

4:36All he said was, and I think either in the speech or in his interviews the next day, was that all options are open. We need to have a serious think about our relationship with Europe and decide which option is best for us. I mean, on the surface, Keir Starmer could almost have said that. Do you know, Anna, chatting with the team this morning, you know, about this podcast, about my discussion with you, you know, I was reminded it's been quite some time since Brexit was everywhere, on everyone's lips, on every front page, and was a topic of discussion in pubs up and down the land. So it might have...

5:07The good old days, we call them. The good old days. That's one way of describing them. But I think maybe before we get too much further, in the broadest possible sense, what was lost, what was gained by our exiting the European Union? Well, what was lost essentially was market access. What was gained was political autonomy. So outside the European Union, the UK gets to regulate how many Europeans come in, who's eligible for visas and things like that. So there's no more freedom of movement. We get to make our own trade deals. We get to make our own regulations. And it's worth saying in areas like tech, some bits of financial services, if you talk to the industries, they're very happy that we're out and they think that our regulations are attracting investment that we wouldn't get if we were abiding by EU rules.

5:50The cost? The cost is more expensive, more burdensome, more administratively complicated trade with what remains our largest trading partner. And there is no doubt now, because we have the data to accompany the forecast that we had in 2016, that that has had a significant negative impact on our economy. OK, so when Andy Burnham says closer ties, acknowledging your point that he hasn't gone any further than that in terms of the detail, what are the options on the table short of rejoining itself? Well, the first thing to be said is we need to wait and see whether Andy Burnham shares the delusions of virtually all of his predecessors in the post of prime minister, which is to believe that he has that unique ability to make the European Union give us a special deal.

6:37I mean, so every British prime minister, back to it including Theresa May, thought that somehow they could persuade the EU to give us a bit more market access in the areas we wanted it. And every single time the EU has said no, the EU has said we'll make an exception for the area like agriculture that we're negotiating now. But you're absolutely not going to be able to take a pick and mix approach to our single markets. So the options from the EU side are we stay where we are. We sign a customs union that gets rid of a bit of customs paperwork at the cost of all the trade deals we've signed around the world, because we'll have to align with the trade deals that the EU has signed.

7:09We can join the single markets. So we align all our economic regulations with those of the EU. but that makes us a rule taker across the board. So Brussels sets the rules that govern our economy. We have freedom of movement. We'll have to pay into the budget. We don't get a vote. Or you can go full fat, if you like, and say, actually, you know what, we might as well just join. So those are broadly the options that the British government has to choose from. So, Anand, would an early election, of which there has been much speculation of late, would an early election help or hinder him in gaining those closer ties?

7:41It's difficult, isn't it? because it kind of depends what Labour go into the next election saying. And I think that is the crucial issue. That is the debate to watch over the next two or three years, is the debate within the parliamentary Labour Party about what they put in their next manifesto. There are lots of Labour MPs out there who are saying we should have rejoined in the manifesto. We heard Emily Thornberry say recently, chair of the Foreign Affairs Select Committee, we should stick it in the manifesto, then we don't need a referendum. There are other Labour MPs that say we should put in the manifesto that we're going to have a referendum about rejoining.

8:10what that manifesto says will be absolutely fundamental to the future of this debate and indeed to the future of the country i mean the one thing i would say following labour's conference in liverpool is the next labour manifesto is going to be like war and peace because everything every big decision seems to have been pushed back to then so social care next manifesto electoral reform next manifesto triple law next manifesto brexit next manifesto that's going to be a chunky document if he really delivers on what he said in Liverpool. Let me try and put the argument from the other side. I mean, we both know, I mean, we've seen a bit of growth recently here in the UK and indeed across Europe, but the European Union does have its own economic problems.

8:49I mean, some would argue, but look, why should we be tying ourselves more closely to the European Union rather than looking, you know, to faster growing markets elsewhere? I mean, to which my short answer would we look at a map. Yes, it might well be the case that all the growth is in Asia at the moment. But the problem is we're not. And, you know, one of the few rules of economics, I'm not an economist, so I tend to be like sniffy about economists. But one of the rules of economics that I think has clearly shown that it holds is that trade volumes are very, very closely related to distance. So you trade more with countries that are nearest you.

9:26And the European Union might not be growing very fast at all. And it certainly isn't growing fast compared to, say, India. But the European Union is our biggest trading partner. So actually, our trade relationship with the European Union is significantly more important than our trade relation with India because we trade more with them. So that's why I always get slightly frustrated with this argument where it's like, well, the European Union isn't doing very well. Unless we can change our geography, in a sense, that doesn't change the fundamental issue, which is that if you can increase trade with the people you trade most with, that's going to have more of an impact than if you sign a trade deal with a country you don't trade much with.

10:02Where do we know that the public are in terms of their view of closer ties with the European Union? Because, of course, that doesn't necessarily mean full out-and-out rejoining of the institution, the EU. I think what we know is that a significant chunk of the public, a big majority of the public, now think that Brexit was the wrong decision, not the right decision. You'll get majorities, if asked by pollsters, saying that they would vote to rejoin. I think those figures are soft in the sense that, firstly, they don't bear in mind what happens to public opinion if you say, what do you think about joining if it means we pay significantly more as a membership fee than we paid last time?

10:41What do you think about joining if, and it's an if, the EU insists that you must sign up to joining the euro when you're ready? So I think when the conditions are introduced that those numbers change. The other thing we don't know is how the public will react to doing this all again. My experience in focus groups quite often is if you mentioned Brexit, half the participants stick their fingers in their ears and hide under the table because they never want to hear the word again. Right. So it remains to be seen behind all the noise of the sort of aficionados that you hear all the time or the podcasters who have really strong feelings about this, whether the great British public are ready to have this conversation again and whether they will thank a prime minister who makes them have this conversation again.

11:42I'm old enough to remember a point in the pre-referendum Brexit debate where we were seeing people on the vote leave side of the argument or the leave side of the argument, I should say, arguing that post-leaving the European Union, we could still remain within the single market. I mean, at the moment, what would be the bars, the issues towards the UK just simply going straight back into the single market itself? Well, if we wanted to go back into the single market, the EU would be open to negotiating it, and I'm sure it might well be possible. There is an absolute paradox around this, though, isn't there?

12:16Because those Leave campaigners went round with banners that said, take back control, OK? And there is no option that implies less control than being in the single market, because you are subjecting yourself to the rules made by the European Union, which will apply automatically to your economy. And that's across the board. That's the European Union regulating financial services, the European Union being in charge of the regulations that govern the city without us having a vote. Now, there will be an economic benefit to that, OK, because most of the economic loss from Brexit comes from us being outside the single market.

12:54But actually, I wonder about that option simply because given the centrality of that idea of control, I'm not convinced how appealing the single market membership itself might prove to be. I mean, we should also not forget the fact that a lot of the sentiment surrounding that leave vote was to do with the fact that there were parts of the United Kingdom that were neglected, not looked after. There was a disconnect between significant parts of the country and where the power rests in that country. This is for me, and this is a purely personal view, the ultimate tragedy of Brexit, right? You're absolutely right.

13:34There are a lot of people back in 2016 voted for Brexit because they thought the politics and the economics of this country simply weren't working for them. And let me say in brackets there, which should warn us of the fact that Brexit isn't a silver bullet. Our economy was misfiring even before we left the European Union. So there are problems separate to being outside the European Union that we need to think about. So we have this referendum in which everyone thinks to themselves, oh my God, there's large chunks of the country who really don't like the status quo. Theresa May got it. You remember her speech outside Downing Street in July 2016, when she said she was going to think about the just about managing and the injustices of modern capitalism.

14:11Boris Johnson got it. He talked about levelling up and, you know, bringing wealth to parts of the country that haven't seen it for decades. But the tragedy of Brexit is that even though it changed our debate and made everyone realise the problem, nothing has been done about it. But does that not suggest that if Andy Burnham could come up with a policy portfolio which addressed that, that actually far from, you know, leavers looking down their nose at anything to do with a closer tie with the European Union, there might actually be a chunk of the leave vote that Burnham could pick up? One of the really interesting things is how hard it is to make that public argument linking Brexit and the economy.

14:47I was in a focus group about six months ago and Brexit came up and someone was talking about the impact of Brexit. And one lady said, don't be so ridiculous. We left the European Union 10 years ago. It's obviously not that that's affecting our economy now. Now, she was wrong. OK, she was wrong in the sense that, A, we only left the European Union five years ago. and B, it is impacting on our economy and it will always impact on our economy because those trade barriers are there for good. But it spoke to the fact, I think, that it's quite hard. The economic impact of Brexit is big but diffuse, which means even though it's significant, and the estimates range from 4 % to 8 % of GDP, and any of those numbers is huge, whichever one you pay, it's diffuse in the sense that you don't suddenly get a deduction from your pay packet saying Brexit cost.

15:32It's just that there's less trade. There's less availability of stuff in the shops. Things might be more expensive. There's less investment in this country because of Brexit. Our industries are less competitive because they're less vulnerable to competition from European competitors than they were under Brexit. All those things matter. All those things have a real economic impact on the country. None of those things are very easy for your average punter to discern in day-to-day life. And I think that's the challenge facing those who want to make an economic argument for join, is if you like joining those dots.

16:07Anand, when next we speak, and undoubtedly we will, what would tell you that Britain really is changing course, that Annie Burnham does have a clear idea of what he might like to happen? I suppose there is a European summit coming up on the 20th November that might steer things a bit. Yeah, the summit will deal with the sort of residue of Keir Starmer's renegotiations. So the negotiation on agriculture, on emissions trading, on youth mobility. So, I mean, a precursor to anything happening with the European Union is they have to agree on those issues, come up with a deal, get them over the line and have a successful summit.

16:38I think then it's up to Andy Burnham to explain to us what he means by this national conversation. Bear in mind, all the parts in this story are moving. So the world is changing. You know, you have war going on in the Gulf. You've got President Trump doing whatever it is President Trump happens to be doing today. You've got tariffs. You've got uncertainty. You've got the European Union putting up even more trade barriers against us. You've got the European Union changing in real time. Everything's changing at once. OK, this isn't simply a debate about what we choose to do with the European Union.

17:09in that sense and what we need from the prime minister i suppose certainly ahead of the next election is a degree of clarity about what he thinks our destination is i don't think he can forever prevaricate and say obviously the british people will decide ultimately we need a bit of leadership we need a bit of clarity and i i would hope that by the time of the summit if we get those negotiations over the line that will be the time that he chooses to clarify some of this for us and it's always lovely to see you thanks for joining us all the best and that's your lot for today but topics such as this always tend to get you talking send your feedback directly to me the email is why at sky.uk we'll read some of them out on the podcast tomorrow till then take care

From the publisher

Remember when Brexit meant Brexit? Well, a decade on from the referendum to leave the European Union, Andy Burnham thinks now is the right time to reopen the debate.

The new prime minister is calling for a fresh look at our relationship with EU ahead of a summit in November. Is this just an attempt to boost economic growth with a better trade deal or is there more to it?

What does Burnham really want? And would the public swallow the prospect of a 'rejoin' referendum?

Niall Paterson is joined by the director of the UK in a Changing Europe think tank, Anand Menon.

Have you got a question for Niall? Email us: [email protected]

More from This Is Why

All episodes