1. Podcasts
  2. This Is Why
  3. Why Russia targeting civilians shows peace talks won’t work
This Is Why

10 Nov 2026 · 17m · 9 chapters

Episode artwork

Why Russia targeting civilians shows peace talks won’t work

In short

The episode argues Russia’s deliberate attacks on civilians and civilian infrastructure in Ukraine make peace talks unlikely to work, and contrasts this with Ukraine’s claimed rule-of-law approach.

Guests

Rob Clark, a military analyst who also works with Sky News Defence Insider on Russian casualties and battlefield analysis.

Key claims

UN investigators say Russian forces either knew civilians were gathering for aid or failed to check, including drone attacks on civilians in Kherson and a state policy depriving Ukrainians of electricity and essential services. Clark says strikes show patterns like “double tap” attacks and “drone safaris” with no military purpose.

Notable examples

EU-funded humanitarian aid point in Komosuvika (Zaporizhia) hit by two strikes; Kherson drone killing a boy on a bicycle; siege-like pressure on Eleshky with “zero military purpose.”

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

0:58

Humanitarian Aid Attack in Ukraine

Discussion of the bombing of a humanitarian aid distribution center in Komyshevaka.

“Imagine you need somewhere to get help, somewhere to shelter, somewhere you can feel, even briefly, just a little safer.”
1:50

Military Strategy and Civilian Targets

Analysis of the implications of Russia's military strategy targeting civilians.

“What does attacking civilian life achieve that fighting an army doesn't?”
4:00

Impact of Energy Infrastructure Attacks

Exploration of the legality and implications of targeting energy infrastructure in Ukraine.

“of the fact that the Russians are illegally targeting civilians as part of their strategy.”
6:46

Psychological Warfare in Targeting Civilians

Examination of Russia's tactics to instill fear and chaos in Ukraine.

“So we have that, the background noise that is created by targeting energy infrastructure.”
9:08

Legitimacy of Siege Tactics

Discussion on the legitimacy and military purpose behind siege tactics used by Russia.

“It's absolutely insane to think that they're going to be honest actors.”
11:36

Russian and Ukrainian Casualties

Overview of casualty rates and military actions from both sides of the conflict.

“People don't show up to vote, so I'm asking them to pretend I'm on the ballot.”
14:01

Understanding Ukrainian Military Targets

Explore the rationale behind Ukraine's military strikes inside Russia, focusing on their strategic implications.

“Now, again, I have to keep saying there's a difference here between the Russians and Ukrainians.”
15:07

Cyber Warfare Against Russian Finance

Learn about Ukraine's cyber strategies targeting the Russian banking system and its implications for the war effort.

“and you have a serious impact on the Russian military front.”
16:13

Civilian Targeting and Ethical Warfare

Discuss the complexities of civilian targeting in warfare and the ethical distinctions between Ukraine and Russia's actions.

“It's transforming the government debt directly into cash for military procurements.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On This Is Why, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:02Sky News. The full story first.

0:11You don't have to be a soldier to be a target in Russia's war on Ukraine. And this is why.

0:22Find politics hard to make sense of? A little bit depressing? Or just bloody boring? Well, it needn't be. I'm Beth Rigby, Sky News' political editor and one of the hosts of Electoral Dysfunction, the politics podcast that cuts through the BS and has a bit of fun on the way. And I've enlisted a crack team of political juggernauts to help me out. There's me, Harriet Harman. Me, Jess Phillips. And me, Ruth Davidson. So join us. Search for Electoral Dysfunction wherever you get your podcasts.

0:58Imagine you need somewhere to get help, somewhere to shelter, somewhere you can feel, even briefly, just a little safer. In Komyshevaka, in Ukraine's Zaporizhia region, a former school was being used to distribute humanitarian aid. Last Monday, whilst that was happening, it was hit by Russian bombs. Dozens of people were killed. Russia says it was targeting military units in the area. But the United Nations assessment is that Russian forces either knew civilians were gathering for aid or failed to take the most basic steps to find out. UN investigators have also found Russian drone operators are deliberately attacking civilians in Kherson.

1:40And they have identified a Russian state policy of depriving Ukrainians of electricity and other essential services just to make them suffer. Today, we're asking why. What does attacking civilian life achieve that fighting an army doesn't? And when Ukraine's operations harm Russian civilians, what do the same rules require of Kiev? Military analyst Rob Clark is back on the podcast. Rob, let's start with one of the more egregious examples, at least to my eyes, of what at first glance appears to be Russians targeting civilians that has taken place in this war. and it took place in Zaporizhia. A school was being used to distribute humanitarian aid.

2:22What do we know about what happened? Basically what we know, the very small town called Komosuvika, no really larger than the village, and it's on the absolute front lines of the Zaporizhia region. It's around 70 % of the Zaporizhia region is under Russian occupation and Komosuvika, this tiny village, is right on that front line. It's about 20 kilometres from Russian positions. the situation on the ground the the school it used to be a school and it was basically repurposed around a year ago as a eu funded humanitarian aid point which had a shelter underneath as well like like an air shelter and it was targeted by what appears to be a double tap russian strike so it was first targeted and then in the immediate aftermath where people were sort of trying to collect themselves and work out what happened.

3:12Several minutes later, a second series barrage of strikes took place, inflicting many more casualties than the first. Now, when we talk about this action, the idea of a double tap strike has a lot of familiarity and continuity with Russian sort of current tactics. You know, just in the Zaporizhia region alone, two or three similar attacks were recorded and verified in September and October. So there's a pattern emerging where in these frontline towns that are on the border of the Russian-occupied areas. They're in that region where the Russians can basically drop these glide bombs still within Russian-occupied territory to avoid themselves coming under attack.

3:52And they're now very, very accurate. So the speculation is going to be an accident. I very much think it wasn't an accident at all. So in your mind, this is as clear an example as we could get then, really, of the fact that the Russians are illegally targeting civilians as part of their strategy. Yes, very much so. The Russians are very aware, well aware of the sort of the ground, of the area, who comes in, who comes out, positions, civilian settlements, for example. There's no fixed military positions around the town of Komatsubaka. It is entirely civilian. And like I said, it's the fact that this is an advertised and well-known, not only a distribution point, but a European Union-funded one as well.

4:32They even have, well, they had, sorry, the EU flag on the building itself. So it couldn't have been more obvious. Okay. We have also seen the Russians at various points during this conflict, during this war, targeting energy and water infrastructure, particularly in and around the capital. What is the legality of that when it comes to a war? Yeah. So just for a bit of context, it's around 80 % of all of Ukraine's energy infrastructure is currently damaged. It's been attacked and targeted in some form of disrepair and disuse. 80%, which is huge. In terms of the legality, I had very similar questions regarding the war in Iran when the Americans were striking and the Israelis were striking energy infrastructure in Iran.

5:14And it's the idea of dual use, a dual use purpose. If it can be comprehensively argued and sustained, that whatever you are targeting for a military purpose, whether it's civilian infrastructure or obviously military infrastructure, but if it serves a military use, then it can be classified as a legitimate military target. And the example in Iran, which is similar to Ukraine, it's not just energy, but for example, things like roads and important rail infrastructure. Now, for example, with roads and rail infrastructure and transport, if you can make the claim that they're being used for military purposes, then it's valid.

5:44You have to take some mitigation for civilians. But the energy is a separate matter because whilst energy obviously supplies and supports a military campaign, it's a part of civilian infrastructure which civilians are entirely dependent upon. So when that is removed, the civilians no longer have access to that facility. So it's an incredibly tricky position. I think precisely because the amount of energy infrastructure that is targeted inside Ukraine doesn't serve the Ukrainian military because it's so far away from the front lines, from Ukrainian military units. Like you said, the majority of this is happening in and around the capital, Kyiv.

6:19The same can't be said on the other side. If you look at it from the other perspective with Russia, The majority of the energy infrastructure that's targeted inside Russia by Ukraine is to support the Russian financial system and the export market. So the oil fineries, for example, is a separate dilemma there for the Ukrainians and the Russians. And I think the ability for the Russians to strike the energy from infrastructure in Ukraine is almost entirely designed to cause havoc, terror and misery in the Ukrainian population. There's no other real tangible metric. So we have that, the background noise that is created by targeting energy infrastructure.

6:53We have the attack on a building in a village in Zaporizhia where they knew that civilians were going to be. We've also had examples, according to UN investigators at least, of Russian drone operators directly targeting civilians in Kersen as well. Yeah, this is the so-called human safari zones and the drone safaris. Obviously, it's quite a grim sort of moniker. There's a lot of recorded evidence now by multiple agencies. It's not just the Ukrainians. It's independent verifiers like the United Nations. And Kherson, because it's so close to the Russian front line and obviously was occupied earlier on in the war, they have these operators inside Russia basically targeting civilians at will and seemingly for fun.

7:35I mean, I think a lot of people have seen footage recently over, I think it was about two months ago, of a young boy on a push bike cycling down a country path targeted by a first-person view drone who was killed. Clearly no military purpose whatsoever. And it's a blatant war crime. And, you know, this needs to be called out for what it is. Sorry, this probably sounds like a really daft question. What is it that Russia is trying to achieve in terms of its war priorities when it comes to targeting civilians? So there's several things happening. I think targeting civilian infrastructure can be argued by the Russians to serve a military purpose.

8:11It's up to them as the attackers to argue how that serves a military purpose. So the onus and responsibility is on that. And it's for them to make. If they can argue legitimately that an energy infrastructure site was supporting the Ukrainian military, then that's one thing. Even though the caveat, they are still the aggressors in this war. It is not a fair war. It is not a war of choice by Ukraine. It is a war of survival. That's for the Russians to try and make an argument. And that will be heavily debated if they ever did, which they don't ever seem to really do. When it comes to targeting civilians more deliberately.

8:41It's the ability for the Russians to create basically fear and panic in the Ukrainian population. It's the idea of not only do they want to erase the Ukrainian nation as a separate entity, it's the idea of just absolutely creating chaos and sowing division. All of this in their minds would help put political pressure on the Zelensky government to try and form some form of, you know, peace or settled agreement, which is favourable on Russia's side, not Ukraine's. But in all honesty, and I think even the Russians are beginning to know this, all this does is push the Ukrainians even harder and harder away from any sort of idea of peace with the Russians, purely because if a regime and a government can be as bloody and as callous as the Putin regime, in what instance, in what world does anybody really think that they're going to be legitimate peace actors in some form of settled negotiation down the line?

9:30It's for the birds. It's absolutely insane to think that they're going to be honest actors. We focused on the Russian-occupied town of Eleshky a lot recently, a place that, to my eyes, looked essentially as if it was under siege. There was precious little aid getting out. Certainly people couldn't move out. When I think of siege, I think of medieval times and trebuchets and all the rest of it. In war, in the 21st century, is laying siege to a town in this fashion actually something that the Russians are entitled to do? No, absolutely not. Alekshki served zero military purpose or zero military function.

10:05So you could make an argument for a siege if it was like the local administrative region or Kiev, for example, like the head of government, as barbaric as that would be. But it serves no military purpose. And as a military analyst, my first instinct is to not necessarily look at the humanitarian aspect, it's to look at the military aspect. Does it serve a military purpose? What military gain or advantage would be held by a particular action, no matter how barbaric? And quite often with the Russian choices, there seems to be no decisive military victory or win that can be achieved by loss of their actions.

10:38And the siege of Velesky is a clear example of that. And again, it comes back to we have to remember who we're dealing with. We're not dealing with an honest actor. We're not dealing with a rational Western democratic system of government. Russia, you know, are probably the most dishonest actor when it comes to things like international treaties. You know, what they say, what they mean are two very different things.

11:21U.S. Fingers sticks are required if your glucose alarms or readings do not match symptoms or when you see check blood glucose symbol for the first 12 hours. The views expressed should not be used for medical diagnosis or treatment as a substitute for professional medical advice. Individual circumstances may vary. For prescription only. Safety info found at FreestyleLibre.us. People don't show up to vote, so I'm asking them to pretend I'm on the ballot. I'm thrilled he's saying that. His approval ratings are in the toilet. America's midterms matter to all of us. Voters will decide who controls Congress.

11:50Trump's Republicans or the Democrats. The people are not being heard. They'll have the power to shape what he can and can't do. We've been travelling the country speaking to the very people who will decide what happens next. Trump 100. Wherever you get your podcasts.

12:13Rob, you work an awful lot with our chums over on the Defence Insider app and one of the bits of work you've been doing most recently has been on Russian casualties. Where are we with that? Because the numbers that I have seen have been all over the shop. Yeah, sure. So the casualties keep seeming to, well, not only increase exponentially, but also every month, every quarter, there seems to be a new grim milestone for the Russians themselves. So October was the largest month for Russian casualties. It's around 50 ,000, 54 ,000 just for the month of October. Dear Lord, that's a huge amount. Yeah, and again, just for context, because it is a large number for context.

12:48That's the same amount that the British lost on the first day of the Battle of the Somme, which is the bloodiest day in British military history. And equally, it's not far off the total casualty rate for the Americans in Vietnam. And that's just in one month. So it shows the level of resources that the Russians are willing to throw at this, which again shows no sign that they're going to just throw their hands up any time soon and go, yeah, you know what? We're going to walk away from the Donbass. You know, we were wrong. You were right. Nobody goes through that amount of pain and expenditure to walk away with nothing.

13:20But again, that shows the scale of political appetite that the Russians are willing to expend in this war. And that alone is terrifying enough because it shows that they're just not going to stop. Rob, if you listen to the Kremlin these days and to take them at face value, you would believe that the Ukrainians are not just as bad as the Russians. In fact, they are far worse. We've talked about Russian targeting of energy infrastructure inside Ukraine. What about the Ukrainians doing the same to the Russians? There was a big hit on the refinery near St. Petersburg. Yeah, there was. And in the last sort of year to 18 months, it's really been a focus of the Ukrainian sort of war effort to target inside Russia to bring the war to the Russian population.

14:01Now, again, I have to keep saying there's a difference here between the Russians and Ukrainians. It's become quite a well-known line now. If Russia stops fighting, there's no war. If Ukraine stops fighting, there's no Ukraine. So Ukraine are, by virtue of the defenders, almost entitled to act in their own national self-interest, which is their self-survival. But even with the Ukrainian strikes inside Russia, for example, you mentioned the refinery this week. We talked about military distinction and military proportionality. Does it serve a military goal? And that refinery just outside St. Petersburg, I think it's the country's second biggest refinery by output.

14:35And the second largest use of that refined product goes to a nearby airport, which serves military purposes. It basically deploys a lot of troops. It's like a troop staging area. So, again, you can make the argument there. And I think broadly, from what I've seen, the majority of Ukrainian strikes inside Russia do try to target either dual use military infrastructure, like airports that host Russian military movements, but then also the oil infrastructure, which is used to basically finance the Russian war machine. You remove that from the Kremlin's ability to withdraw money and you have a serious impact on the Russian military front.

15:13So therefore, it's an entirely legitimate means of targeting. What about the more recent innovations when it comes to warfare? And I'm thinking in particular of cyber. The Ukrainians have targeted, with a degree of effectiveness, Russian banking and communications. Again, I can almost see if they'd gone after, you know, kind of the Russian equivalent of the MOD in terms of a cyber attack, but going after Russian banking, how does that fit in? It's really interesting, actually. The Russian banking system is quite unlike any other banking system in the world, save maybe the Chinese and the Iranians for very similar reasons.

15:47So, for example, the Russian finance ministry, they issue domestic government bonds. Now, this is to raise trillions of dollars for the war effort because basically public buyers are scarce. So state controlled banks are forced to buy these loans. And this is a form of monetary mechanics to basically keep the cycle going. The Russian central bank provides this liquidity to commercial banks against these securities as collateral. And this loop basically functions as a hidden ruble printing press. It's transforming the government debt directly into cash for military procurements. So it's absolutely right that these institutions should be coming under increasing cyber attack, basically to try and halt the funding of the war economy against Ukraine.

16:31I think it's perfectly legitimate. it. Okay then, Rob, dip your toe in online in any of the commentary around the Ukraine war, and you will have people accusing the Russians very clearly of targeting civilians. On the other hand, you do have those in the Kremlin and elsewhere suggesting that at times, Ukraine has done exactly the same thing, if perhaps not to the same extent. Where do you fall down on that argument? Ukraine is fighting for national survival, and therefore it has every legitimate means at its state disposal to defend against an aggressor, which basically wants to capitulate the regime in Kiev.

17:06Now, there will be lines in that. Ukraine are still governed by the rule of law, the international law of armed conflict, so civilian proportionality, military distinction, things like this. And largely, by and large, they are sticking to those intrinsic rules of engagement. With Russia, it's an entirely separate system. They are using their entire state apparatus to basically not just destroy Ukraine and destroy the idea of a Ukrainian nation, but to do it in the most barbaric way possible. And I think where there are instances, and there are, of the Ukrainians falling short, as isolated as they are, it is inevitable given the nature of humans in war, but also increasingly the ability to hold those to account where they do fall short, and they do and they are held to account, is entirely separate to how the Russians operate inside Ukraine.

18:00And not just operate inside Ukraine, how they operate domestically. The Russians are, you know, very, very bad axes to their own people. We've known that for decades. That's not like a new revelation. And how they act inside Russia is exactly how they act outside Russia, inside Ukraine. So I think it's a very important distinction to be made. Rob, it's always good to see you. Thanks for your time. Pleasure. Thank you. That's a lot for this episode, but there is plenty more military analysis from Rob and his colleagues over on our new app, the Sky News Defence Insider. And you can currently get a three-month free trial for new users.

18:36All the details are in the notes attached to the show. This is why he's back again tomorrow.

18:48Find politics hard to make sense of? A little bit depressing? Or just bloody boring? Well, it needn't be. I'm Beth Rigby, Sky News' political editor and one of the hosts of Electoral Dysfunction, the politics podcast that cuts through the BS and has a bit of fun on the way. And I've enlisted a crack team of political juggernauts to help me out. There's me, Harriet Harman. Me, Jess Phillips. And me, Ruth Davidson. So join us. Search for Electoral Dysfunction wherever you get your podcasts.

From the publisher

Even as delegates gathered in Abu Dhabi for renewed negotiations between Russia and Ukraine, Moscow’s missiles continued to hit key Ukrainian energy infrastructure.

Of course, the response from Russia is that retaliatory strikes on oil and gas sites amount to the same thing.

But the United Nations has identified a growing number of Russian attacks on civilian targets that have little or no military justification.

Niall Paterson is joined by Sky’s defence analyst Robert Clark, who argues Moscow’s continued action shows they have little appetite to stop the fighting.

There is more exclusive military analysis and content on the new Sky News Defence Insider app.

Sky News Defence Insider is a subscription app designed for audiences seeking deeper insight into defence, security and global affairs. New users can get a three-month free trial.

Download and subscribe here.

Paid subscription required for full access. UK only. 18+. T&Cs apply.

More from This Is Why

All episodes