


A man (William Chapman, 23) died after entering a tiger enclosure at Yorkshire Wildlife Park; the episode uses the tragedy and viral footage (including Donald Trump sharing it and posting an AI wrestling video) to ask why zoos keep big cats and how that can support conservation.
Professor Amy Dickman, Director of Oxford University’s Wildlife Conservation Research Unit; leads field work on lions via Lion Landscapes in Kenya and Tanzania.
Tigers in captivity may be less wary of people than wild tigers, making enclosure breaches especially dangerous; online “cuddling/wrestling” videos and AI distort perceptions and encourage harmful interactions. Zoos’ strongest role is “ambassadorship” that converts attendance into funding for wild conservation, partnering with field projects.
Lion Landscapes community risk-reduction/incentive programs; London Zoo lion enclosure anecdote; emphasis on welfare monitoring (e.g., pacing/mental distress) and veterinary care.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Professor Dickman discusses tiger behavior and safety in zoo environments.
“I think zoos in general offer that opportunity for people to really go and appreciate the breadth of biodiversity that is out there, how amazing wildlife really is.”
A conversation about the importance of zoos in wildlife conservation efforts.
“And I suppose that rather neatly brings us onto the kind of the broader question.”
Discussion on whether zoos still hold value in the digital age of wildlife viewing.
“I think if anything they could potentially have a more important role because what you pick up on your phone now, you don't know if it's true or not.”
Professor Dickman shares her passion for big cats and the importance of conservation efforts.
“That can help if you watch great documentaries, David Asmer, etc.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On This Is Why, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:02Sky News, the full story first.
0:12A man's died in a tiger enclosure. Donald Trump has posted an AI video of himself wrestling a tiger. But behind those headlines is a question worth asking. Why do we keep big cats in zoos? And this is one.
0:42On Saturday, 23-year-old William Chapman was killed after entering the tiger enclosure at Yorkshire Wildlife Park. His family are grieving, and now they're having to contend with footage of the attack circulating online. Donald Trump shared that footage, then posted an AI-generated video showing himself wrestling a tiger and giving it a hug. The family has asked people to stop sharing distressing content. Today, we're going to take a step back from that and ask something quite fundamental. Why do we keep big cats in zoos? For me, it was big cats. I think zoos in general offer that opportunity for people to really go and appreciate the breadth of biodiversity that is out there, how amazing wildlife really is.
1:25Joining us today, Professor Amy Dickman, Director of Oxford University's Wildlife Conservation Research Unit. Amy, just to tap into your kind of professional expertise here, when we look at what is known about what took place at the zoo in Yorkshire, what can we infer about the tiger's behaviour? We know that tigers are highly dangerous apex predators. So, you know, if any zoo visitor knows that they are extremely dangerous, you don't want to have that interaction with them at all. and there is no human interaction with animals that are that dangerous in a zoo. They're not used to people entering their enclosure.
1:59Anything that enters their enclosure is intentionally there for them to interact with. So that's the whole reason that zoos are so careful and so professional about having all the barriers in place, the signage, trying to make sure there is no way that people could accidentally get into those enclosures because, as we saw with the tiger and this really tragic event, it ends extremely badly. Would you describe that as the behaviour of a wild animal, of a wild tiger? Well, ironically, if you were out in the wild with tigers, tigers would be much more used to having people around them. They would be much more used to navigating landscapes where there are people.
2:34And they're probably scared of them and they're wary and they know where they can retreat to. So it's actually quite different. If we're out in the field, I work mainly with lions, but if you're out there and lions are in the area, you're obviously very careful. you're obviously professional about what you do, but actually the risk is probably lower in those situations. And if you go into a zoo enclosure, because the only time they would interact with things in their enclosure is if they're meant to interact with them. So they probably don't have the same level of fear of human noises, human voices, they're more used to people being around.
3:04So actually, ironically, it can be a much more dangerous experience than a wild tiger or a wild lion out there in India and Africa or wherever. It seems utterly counterintuitive to someone like me who doesn't work in the area because this was a tiger that was born and raised in captivity you presume around human beings I would have thought this would have been a rather more domesticated big cat but actually the opposite seems to be the case. Absolutely and I think this is really dangerous and we see it a lot online in particular with all these sort of videos if you go online you see lots of things about people cuddling lions and tigers and wrestling with them and AI of course has made that so much worse and this perception that these animals can and should be interacted with in that way is is we don't know to be clear at all that this had any impact in this particular instance but the general idea that interaction with big cats is something that is aspirational sometimes is i think is extremely damaging is something that we should remember these are wild animals even raised in captivity even used to people they deserve the ultimate respect and it is why zoos spend so much time and money on trying to make sure that these tragic events do not happen.
4:10And I suppose that rather neatly brings us onto the kind of the broader question. If these remain wild animals, and very clearly they are, what then is the case for keeping them in zoos? What for you is the strongest argument for the presence of big cats in British zoos? I think the strongest argument is that they are ambassadors for their wild cousins, and they really do engage them. There is something so primal and so inspirational about seeing a big cat up close, you know, personally actually looking it in the eye and recognizing that in the eye of that cat, you are much less than a human in the normal way you're used to being.
4:44There is something that puts you back in that place of being something less than this amazing predator in front of you. And I remember being a kid going to zoos. I always dragged my family to the zoo to go and stare at the big cats. I was passionate about big cats and it was looking and interacting from afar with those cats that really just made me realize how incredible wildlife is. For me, it was big cats, but I think zoos in general offer that opportunity for people to really go and appreciate the breadth of biodiversity that is out there, how amazing wildlife really is. And I think that ambassadorship for wild species is their central kind of role for most people.
5:20And obviously what they need to do as well is make sure that they convert that interest, that attendance into actual gains for wild conservation. So zoos should and do provide significant revenue and for wild conservation, making sure that the presence of those wild animals in captivity is actually benefiting wild animals out in the wild. Your point about feeling less is well taken. I've just remembered being at London Zoo at the lion enclosure with my then two-year-old, the big glass, thick glass wall, sitting the other side, just inches away from my boy, this lion just looking disdainfully at the pair of us.
5:54But of course, your work has largely been field-based. I wonder, having spent all that time in the wild with these creatures, whether perhaps your view of the utility of zoos might have moderated a bit, seeing them in their natural habitat, comparing them to an enclosure, which is a fraction of a single percent of their territory in the wild. Absolutely. And while that is absolutely true, that it's a relatively small size, of course, compared to a home range. But the only reason they have such big home ranges in the wild is because they need to go and get all the resources, the food they need, the mates they need, etc.
6:28Of course, that isn't the case in captivity. And if anything, my view on zoos and their relationship to conservation has actually strengthened by running a field project. So I've recognised how important zoos are at being long-term partners for field projects. The project I run, Lion Landscapes, it's really, really important to have those relationships with zoos because they give money year after year after year. They engage millions of people that we could never reach and saying to them, look at this project that's out there in the back of nowhere in Kenya and Tanzania. You know, people will never be able to come probably and see what we do, but the zoos can bring that project to millions of people around the world and raise money so that we can then go and do the work that we need to do with local communities to give those wild cats a better future.
7:10How can we judge whether or not a big cat is happy in the enclosure, that the environment that they are being provided with adequately represents what they would have in the wild? Well, I think those are two different things. Whether it adequately represents what they have in the wild and whether they're happy are probably two different things. Because actually what they have in the wild is often not the best life in terms, I'm not saying they all need to be in captivity at all, but the idea that they have this utopian life in the wild is just not true. You know, they get into fights. They are often very battered and injured in multiple different ways.
7:44They suffer disease, obviously. So the life of a wild big cat is not amazing. It's fantastic for what it is. And it's something that is so, so valuable. But it's very, very different from the life of a big cat in a zoo where they have veterinary care. They have welfare standards. They have, you know, obviously daily, multiple times a day, people interacting with them, making sure that they are physically in good health, that they're not, you know, showing kind of behaviors like pacing. or things that might indicate mental distress. So I think every zookeeper that I know is extremely invested in the care and the welfare of their animals.
8:17And you know those animals, you know if there's a day when it just doesn't seem right, when it seems under the weather, just as you would if you interact with an animal every day at home. In the work that you do, and you've mentioned already, you've closely worked with zoos on a number of occasions. What beyond the money do they do for you? I mean, if money is needed to conserve big cats. And the best way to do that is through funding projects like the one that you run. Shouldn't we just be funding projects like the one you run rather than chucking money at zoos? It's going to be wonderful of everyone.
8:50I'm fully supportive, by the way, of everyone sending money to the project. But it's very hard for us to get awareness of these field projects. There are amazing field projects all over the world that have no way, no pathway in front of millions of people around the world. I think zoos can give that conduit where they can say, look at the partnerships that we work with. You may never have heard of tree kangaroos or rare orchids or all sorts of amazing biodiversity that's out there. If you see it in the zoo and you recognize how amazing it is, and then you realize there's a pathway, even through just being at the zoo that day, that you're actually helping that species out in the wild.
9:25That's quite a powerful way for making people feel that they have some agency of actually tackling the huge biodiversity crisis that we have. It's certainly not the only way. It absolutely can't be the only way. There is much more that needs to happen. But I think zoos can and do play a very significant role in advancing wild species conservation as well. It's an argument often made, and particularly by people who would wish to see zoos in this country, if not closed entirely, then at least scaled back considerably, that, you know, out there, there is plenty of opportunity to see up close and personal wild big cats behaving in their natural environment, displaying natural behaviours, simply by picking up your phone and going to YouTube in this 21st century where there is so much digital information available and available to be consumed in so many different formats, do zoos really have the utility that they had when they first came along?
10:18I think if anything they could potentially have a more important role because what you pick up on your phone now, you don't know if it's true or not. And more and more, as we touched on before, the sorts of things you see on your phone are either actively misleading or fake or have a message that is not necessarily true. So I think zoos take that quite seriously of what's the real educational value what are the stories that you should be telling about these cats it's not about interacting with them it's not about you know some fake ai video of of some crazy interaction out there it's about recognizing these are amazing animals that have their own intrinsic value their amazing value and their place in an ecosystem that they are here in a captive situation which i totally understand people may feel when they look at it they feel you know god i wish it was out there in the wild the best way of keeping wild animals out in the wild is to open up conservation to as many people as we can.
11:09And that is where I think we don't necessarily just do it through a screen. That can help if you watch great documentaries, David Asmer, etc. But there is a still thinker place for that personal interaction and that recognition of real well curated, professionally done stories about the reality of big cat conservation and wider biodiversity conservation. Look, tell me just a little bit about the work that you yourself do, Amy, obviously working with lions. On a daily basis, are you petrified? No, not at all. Partly because we have an amazing team and partly most of what we do when we work out with lion conservation in East Africa is working with people because the lions know how to be lions.
11:45The lions are doing what they do out there. Most of the threats to them are because they pose a really significant risk to people and to their livestock. So we work with people through lion landscapes to actually think, how can we work with those communities to reduce the risks and to make sure that people see this wildlife as an asset so how can you do incentive programs so they see that wildlife has a real value and actually is a route to them having improved things like healthcare education veterinary medicine and switching that kind of recognition that these things can have real tangible value in a way that has often been lacking and what is it about big cats that you very clearly love so dearly i can't quite explain it all i can say is i've always been passionate about big cats.
12:26It's always been just a fascination. I think that I remember standing at a zoo and looking into the eyes of a lion and just being so captivated by it. And I think that has stayed with me my whole life. I've gone into big cat conservation because I want those animals to be there in the wild, doing what they're meant to be doing and critically benefiting the people who live alongside them. So that has been a real driver for me. It's something we work on with many, many partners. Zoos are one of them, but I think it takes all of us to understand more about the value of these animals and how we can get engaged in their constellation.
12:58Well, Amy, it's been lovely to chat to you. Thanks so much for the time. Thank you. And that's your lot for today, but do remember to get in touch with your thoughts. And we are also in the market once again for your suggestions for a future episode of This Is Why. It can be a person in the news. It could be an event. It could be pretty much anything. Just email me, why at sky.uk. We're back tomorrow.
13:26Thank you.
Donald Trump decided to mark the death of a man mauled by a tiger in a Yorkshire zoo by posting an AI-generated video of himself wrestling with a tiger.
The killing of 23-year-old William Chapman has offered a stark reminder of just how dangerous zoo animals can be when things go wrong.
So, has the social media obsession with animal videos desensitised us to the threat from wildlife?
It has also renewed the debate over whether we should be keeping animals like that in captivity in the first place. Just how safe are the UK’s zoos and why do we even have them?
Niall Paterson is joined by Amy Dickman, professor of Wildlife Conservation at Oxford University.