


A Guardian “Today in Focus” episode analyzing why Texas could be a major problem for Donald Trump in the midterm elections, focusing on the Texas Senate race between Democrat James Tallarico and Republican Ken Paxton, plus broader issues like cost of living, immigration/ICE, and the political impact of Trump’s unpopularity.
David Smith, The Guardian’s Washington Bureau Chief (reported from Texas, interviewed voters and campaign events).
Texas is shifting demographically (Latinos now over 40%; cities like Austin are more diverse/tech-driven), making it a battleground. Tallarico could win a statewide Senate seat for Democrats since 1988. Paxton is portrayed as uniquely vulnerable due to corruption scandals and Trump’s endorsement. Trump’s stolen-election stance and low approval (about 32–33%) may hurt Republicans.
Tallarico’s “God is non-binary” controversy; Paxton’s “$1,000 Montblanc pen” theft story; Tallarico’s flu absence and viral Ohio mental-health rumors; a mother in Abilene affected by nearby data-center lights; Latino voter “buyer’s remorse” tied to ICE overreach and economic strain.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Discussion on Texas's political landscape and Trump's influence.
“Big in size, big in attitude, big on old-fashioned American values.”
Explains the significance of midterm elections and their impact.
“Why Texas is spelling trouble for Trump.”
Explores the changing demographics and their effects on politics.
“Democrats really fancy their chances and Democrats win in Texas.”
Profiles Democratic candidate James Tallarico and his appeal.
“I think it's also important because Texas is such an amalgam of different demographic groups.”
Discusses Tallarico's progressive stance and controversies.
“I was struck just walking down the street how many driverless taxis, Waymos and others were floating around.”
Investigates Ken Paxton's background and controversies.
“For years, Republicans have tried to take over religion and say this is our territory and Democrats are just secular and godless, liberal and so on.”
Analyzes Paxton's weaknesses and Trump's role in his candidacy.
“I think another important point about Ken Paxton is that he has Donald Trump's blessing.”
Discussing the vulnerability of Ken Paxton and its implications for Republicans.
“But Ken Paxton is way weaker, way more vulnerable.”
Exploring Trump's endorsement of Paxton and its potential consequences.
“On the subject of Trump he is reportedly very close to Paxton.”
Overview of James Tallarico's campaign events and strategies against Paxton.
“Beat the most corrupt politician in Texas and take back our state.”
Discussion on the influence of wealthy donors like Elon Musk in Texas politics.
“Vance, who's making homophobic quips suggesting that Tallarico is gay.”
Examining voter concerns, particularly related to the economy and immigration.
“Listen to The Flipside on your favorite platform.”
Explore the implications of Trump's election strategy and potential outcomes if he loses.
“And there are lots of other interesting races too.”
Discover the new podcast series exploring interactions between AI and humans.
“A desperate man turns to his chatbot for help.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On Today in Focus, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00This is The Guardian.
0:08Today, has even Texas turned on Trump?
0:30ShipStation connects Shopify, Amazon, TikTok Shop, and over 200 more marketplaces with one platform that does it all. You can manage orders, sync inventory, track returns, all automatically. Everything your operation needs, all in one place. Upgrade your shipping operations to stress-proof your biggest sales days and capture every bit of potential revenue. Go to ShipStation.com and use code AUDIO and get 30 days free.
0:57Everything's big in Texas. It's practically the state slogan. Big in size, big in attitude, big on old-fashioned American values. Texas has given us barbecue culture, cowboys, and two presidents called George Bush. It's been red for decades. If Republicans lose here, it's a big, big deal. And yet this week, Trump has had to make his fifth campaign visit crisscrossing the state, rallying his base for the midterms. On election night, Texas is going to prove that America does not belong to those who hate it. America belongs to those who love it. And pushing hard for his guy, Ken Paxton, in the way only he knows how.
1:43This guy is considered by many to be the best or among the best few, but he's the greatest in the history of Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton.
1:59But they're flagging. What was supposed to be a comfortable win for Republicans has now become the most closely watched race of the elections.
2:11On The Guardian, I'm Noshi Nekbal. Today in Focus. Why Texas is spelling trouble for Trump.
2:21David Smith, welcome back to Today in Focus. Great to be here. Thank you. You're the Guardian's Washington Bureau Chief. So forgive me, this question is probably below your pay grade. But let's just bear with me. Let's get to the basics. What are the midterms and why do they matter? The midterm elections happen every four years, and they are called midterms because they are halfway through a presidential term. And the elections decide control of the US Congress. Every seat in the House of Representatives is up for grabs, and then about a third of the Senate seats as well. And this will matter for various reasons, including Congress can be a check on the power of the president.
3:03And what we've seen historically often is that presidents do badly during midterms. There's often an anti-incumbent sentiment. In addition to all of that, there are lots of elections for state governors who are influential figures and often themselves go on to run for president one day. David, you do get out of DC, of course. And recently you went to Texas, you know, the home of honky-tonk, cowboys, everything being supersized. If the Democrats win there, they'll have a very good chance of taking control of the Senate. Well, Texas has arguably become the biggest battleground state in the country.
3:39Normally, it's a safe Republican territory, but not this time. Democrats really fancy their chances and Democrats win in Texas. That would be a huge symbolic blow to Donald Trump. If a state that's as conservative and Republican as Texas goes against him, that will tell us a lot about public sentiment. I went to the state capital, Austin, because that's the home of James Tallarico, who is Democrats' big hope here, running for the U.S. Senate and actually narrowly ahead in most polls at the moment. At the end of July, look at that. It was Tallarico plus three. August, Tallarico plus three. September, Tallarico plus three.
4:23October, Tallarico plus three. People on the ground, they're enthusiastic for Tallarico and saying if he wins, this will be an electoral earthquake. It'll be the first time Democrats have got a senator elected in Texas since 1988. And the first time Democrats have won any statewide office since 1994. There is a tremendous amount at stake here, given that Texas is the second biggest state by landmass, second biggest state by population. hugely important for future elections, including for the presidency. It's such a big prize in the electoral college. If a Democrat won Texas in a presidential election, it would be very hard for Republicans to overcome that.
5:05I think it's also important because Texas is such an amalgam of different demographic groups. It's a place to watch in terms of national trends as Texas goes, so goes the nation. David, talk to me about the mood because Austin's something of an outlier, I think. I mean, I've spent an inordinate amount of time in Texas. I was counting up the trips before this episode and it's something like two dozen from when my sister lived there, you know, from the era of Bush through to Obama, Trump, Biden back again. As you say, it's a very red place, very Christian, very conservative. What did it feel like on the ground when you were there?
5:43Well, yeah, I remember Rick Perry, himself a Texan politician, describing many of these states as they're like blueberries in tomato soup, by which he meant the cities like Austin and Dallas and Houston and so on, often are very democratic. They often have Democrats as mayors. These are the liberal progressive hubs. But then when you travel 50 miles in any direction, you're surrounded by the Sea of Red and the Republican heartlands in the rural areas. But the demographics of Texas are shifting. Latinos are the fastest growing group now making up more than 40 % of the population and crucial for any politician there.
6:27As with the rest of the country, white Christians are in decline. And in cities such as Austin, which I visited, you can see Texas becoming younger and more diverse. It felt quite buzzy and metropolitan. And the other thing that's happening around Austin, it is becoming a major tech hub. I was struck just walking down the street how many driverless taxis, Waymos and others were floating around. And near Austin, Elon Musk has set up home and his big companies like SpaceX are there. These tech billionaires found what they thought was a refuge. It's very low tax, very low regulation. One person compared it to the modern Wild West.
7:11And so the current debates around tech and data centers are very front and center in Austin and Texas generally.
7:26What is it about Talariko? What makes him interesting? What is his appeal? Well, he's young. He's 37. He's a fresh face on the democratic scene. He's religious. Whilst I was a state representative, he went to study at the Austin Presbyterian Seminary, which I visited, learned that as part of that course, you know, he'd be learning Hebrew and ancient Greek and no doubt honing his public speaking skills. He was a rising star for quite a number of years in the Texas House of Representatives. You can't offer thoughts and prayers on Monday and then debate a bill to loosen gun regulations on Tuesday.
8:10Well, of course, Republicans have a majority. So there were moments when he had to learn how to work with Republicans. And often I spoke to Wendy Davis, former Texas politician who now runs a political action committee. And she remembered the first time she met James Tallarico at a fundraiser and how he made an instant impression. The Republican members of the statehouse had taken a call on him, baby gov. And I think everyone assumed that at some point he would run for governor because even they could see how uniquely talented he was. But other moments where he was standing up for public education in particular as a former middle school teacher himself.
8:54I interviewed Edward Garcia, former principal of the middle school where James Tallarico was a teacher. He remembered Tallarico putting up posters of civil rights leaders. And he enlarged Rosa Parks, Martin Luther King, Gandhi, put together these leaders. And he had a theme of freedom and just working hard to gain what you have. So he's young, religious, pretty progressive, which, as I understand it, has not exactly been a straightforward mix for him. Yeah, he's been getting into one or two controversies. When he talks about progressive issues, there's one now famous remark where he described God as non-binary.
9:40God is both masculine and feminine and everything in between. God is non-binary. I mean. And Republicans are panning him over that one. He has said that God is, and I quote, non-binary, whatever the hell that means. Which now he's been forced to backtrack slightly on or at least say, you know, I was being provocative with that statement. But what it means is that God can't be defined by human categories. So I think one interesting theme is here is the religious left. For years, Republicans have tried to take over religion and say this is our territory and Democrats are just secular and godless, liberal and so on.
10:26And we've seen the rise of several Democratic politicians saying, no, actually, there is a way to be on the left and still talk about God and church and religion. My faith teaches me to love my neighbor as myself. Tallarico combines that with a certain economic populism. populism. But the billionaires who own the social media algorithms, who own the cable news networks, who own the politicians fighting on our screens, they want us at each other's throats. I think to his supporters, he has a certain earnestness. For people who can't say, what do you mind describing your t-shirt here? My t-shirt, it says, I'm a Talafrico.
11:13Talarico, refreshing for Texas. As an authenticity, I think. He's a straight-up honest guy. I mean, politicians are going to do what they do, but what the other guy is doing is just crooks. He's seen as a breath of fresh air.
11:35And in the red corner, there's Ken Paxton, who won the Republican primary to become the party's candidate. Until now, I guess he's sort of been known, I might be making this up, as Teflon Ken. You know, nothing seems to stick. He's sailed through scandal after scandal in his political career. David, can you tell us the top things we need to know about Ken Paxton? Yeah, Ken Paxton, the state attorney general who's 63 years old. James Tallarico has described him as the most corrupt politician in Texas history. Quite a claim. Quite. And he does have a very checkered record. This is a man who was impeached by the Texas State House, by indeed his own party.
12:18It was over a scandal involving access to influential people and alleged bribery. ...that he allegedly had a burner phone used in alias for Uber trips and made payments to a man previously convicted of fraud. Yeah, just some of the new evidence we pull from thousands of times... There's an entire separate case against Ken Paxton over securities fraud. On top of that, Paxton claims to be a very religious man, but had a very public and messy divorce. His ex-wife said that was on biblical grounds. And that following, quote, recent discoveries, she does not believe that her marriage honors God. And certainly voters I interviewed in Texas, often they would praise Tallarico, but they would quickly pivot and also say they just feel Paxton is toxic and tarnished and Texas needs to do better.
13:11And what do you think of Ken Paxton, Republican? Do I have to comment? I can't believe he's still in office after he was impeached. He's the slimeball. I think another important point about Ken Paxton is that he has Donald Trump's blessing. And that is partly why he's here in the first place. There were, of course, primary elections in Texas before we got here. And on the Republican side, it was with the incumbent Senator John Cornyn challenged by Paxton. And Trump threw his weight behind Paxton, who's been a staunch ally. And, for example, backing Trump's claims that the 2020 election was stolen.
13:48That might prove to be Donald Trump's biggest mistake of this election cycle. Every expert commentator, pundit that I speak to says, if John Cornyn was the Republican nominee here, we wouldn't even be having this conversation. He'd be on a glide path. He would cruise to victory. But Ken Paxton is way weaker, way more vulnerable. That might be what brings Republicans down. That said, if John Cornyn was here, then I wouldn't get to ask you about Ken Paxton stealing a$1 ,000 pen. I mean, I know you've done cash for access, big political scandals. But David, can you tell us about the pen? My recollection is Ken Paxton was at a courthouse in Texas.
14:27And there was, you know, your metal detectors and conveyor belt as usual. And as we all know, we take our watches off and put things in the little tray. Somewhere during that process, Ken Paxton spotted that someone else had left a very expensive pen. $1 ,000 Montblanc pen, worth saying. Indeed. don't we all use those and instead of handing it in he he coolly pockaged it for himself which is really as as ever in the Trump era a very sort of on the nose metaphor for who Ken Paxton is at least so his critics would say. Vote for James Tallarico. He won't steal your pen. On the subject of Trump he is reportedly very close to Paxton.
15:10I mean I say this but I will quote what the president said about him when he was endorsing him. He may not dress right. You might not like the way he dresses. And I say this, it's so insulting to him, but I might as well say it. He may not talk exactly perfectly. You might not love his television interviews. And he may not be the best looking guy I've ever seen. You might not like the way he looks. You might not love his look. And, you know, we should say that Paxton had a severe eye injury when he was 12 and required several rounds of surgery as a result. And yet, anyway, this is Trump's full-throated endorsement of him.
15:40As you said, Trump also held this unusual midterm convention over the summer in Dallas, which is the beating heart of Texas. David, is that relationship, given Trump's current unpopularity, is it doing Paxton any favours? Not much, I don't think. It is extraordinary when even an endorsement comes with those caveats. You'd hate to be Trump's enemy, but I think the endorsement helps in the primary race. It may actually be a turnoff. It might actually be hurting Ken Paxton because Trump is toxic. And you see that in opinion polls. Ken Paxton, the Republican candidate in the closely watched Texas Senate race, can be heard complaining President Trump's recent midterm convention in Dallas hurt Republican campaigns, including his own.
16:33When we did that in the convention, the Trump members, everybody came to God. I think of all US presidents in history, Trump is the second most unpopular after Harry Truman going into midterms. His approval rating is down to 32, 33 percent. Some Republican candidates actively want Trump to stay away from their district or state because they think he will hurt them more than help.
17:05So, David, you were at a couple of Tallarico events. What has his campaign looked like? One morning, I went to a community centre in Austin. There were people queuing up to vote, and as you can imagine, a buzz of excitement when the word came, James Tallarico is coming to vote here. A couple of black limousines drove up, journalists ran after him.
17:35Tallarico emerged, gave a polite greeting. And then he had to stand in the queue along with everyone else, waiting for his turn to vote. Then he emerged and stood at a microphone. Thank you, guys. Thank you all for being here. Talked to reporters about the David and Goliath struggle that his campaign has, but his belief that people power is going to do it over big money in this election. Beat the most corrupt politician in Texas and take back our state. So thank you all for being here. I appreciate it. He's framed this election as being about the wealthy who own everything versus the rest of society.
18:16That is a very current theme in American politics right now, especially in Texas with these big tech companies. is Tallarico and many other Democrats are coming down quite hard on data centers and saying there needs to be much closer scrutiny, much tighter regulation, stopping this issue where data centers just sprout up in a community. I met a mother in Abilene who built her dream home with her husband within a data center and popped up across the street. Now her little boy wakes up in the middle of the night and thinks it's dead because the lights shine through his bedroom window. So David, one thing Talaweko has been particularly strong on is his opposition to the donations of one particular Texas resident, namely Elon Musk, who to all intents and purposes is funding the Paxton campaign.
19:10David, what is going on there? And how do you go up against the richest, arguably most obnoxious man in the world? So the rally I went to, he did take off the gloves as well and was notable just how much he concentrated on the tech elites, including Elon Musk, who is a significant figure in Texas. He basically said, this election is about whether you want a senator who serves you or who serves their billionaire megadomers. And Ted Baxton has the ultimate megadomber. Elon Musk is trying to buy this. Even though in many ways the stars have aligned for Democrats in this campaign, they still face a huge uphill struggle.
19:55Republicans are bringing in voter suppression efforts, closing polling places, making people travel further. And then there is this absolute deluge of cash, including$158 million from Elon Musk alone. And people I spoke to there really felt that this is existential for the current tech elite. These tech entrepreneurs really, really fear this. And right now, maybe having meetings behind closed doors, how do we stop James Tallarico? And a lot of that Musk money pouring into the Republican campaign has been spent on attack ads. James Tallarico is weird. Very weird. There are many more than two biological sexes.
20:38In fact, there are six. And you've got Vice President J.D. Vance, who's making homophobic quips suggesting that Tallarico is gay. Before we get started, I love you too, sir. In a totally platonic way, to be clear. I'm the vice president, not James Tallarico. And it does all seem quite desperate. And then, you know, they had this thing where Tallarico got up out of the flu and that seemed to be a gift to their campaign. David, can you tell us what happened there? Yeah, I mean, they did have this issue at the end of September, I think. Tallarico came down with flu. He attended a virtual event, said, sorry, I can't be there in person.
21:19I don't want to spread this around. And then he disappeared off the campaign trail. I think it was for about nine days. Which isn't heard of really at this point in the campaign. It certainly was unusual. Yes. And his campaign certainly could be criticised for leaving a vacuum there, sort of failing to explain where he was and what he was doing. And of course, nature abhors a vacuum. Politics loves to fill a vacuum with speculation and rumour and gossip. And of course, Republicans seized on this. Where is James Tallarico? Donald Trump at a rally in Texas had a go at it, suggesting without evidence that James Tallarico is vegan.
22:00And he tried to eat meat for political reasons to show his manliness and fallen very ill because of it. Throwing up all over the place. But that's what happened. He ate it and then he was seen running backstage to a room and throwing up all over the place. He doesn't like meat. And then someone online, you know, upped the ante by suggesting, no, actually, I've got evidence. Tallarico has checked into a mental health facility in Ohio. And of course, the way the internet works, that was everywhere within hours. Why did he totally evaporate for 12 days? I don't buy any of it. And in the situation in Ohio, we've got to have the Ohio, the center has got to turn over the woman that gave the recording.
22:47We need to hear from her. Why would she say that? Now, she might - And then was thoroughly debunked by this institution who said, no, Tallarico has never been here. Tallarico himself said, I've never actually been to Ohio in my life. Wow. And on and on it goes. Indeed.
23:08And David, not to take this out of the toxic, snide arena of politics and bring it down to the concerns of voters, but when you were talking to people there, what issues were coming up? Our cost of living is number one, I think, in Texas and across the country. People are sick of the high petrol prices, and the Iran war has been a crucial factor in that. They just talk about the difficulty of making ends meet for farmers in Texas and other parts of the country. It's really the cost of diesel and fertilizer has been very painful. You know, these elections are usually about the economy and this one probably no different.
23:55So in preparing for this episode, I actually read that the Trump administration had had a massive reduction in border crossings from Mexico into Texas. It's been a huge success in those terms. Has that not helped Republicans in Texas or is the wider conversation around immigration and specifically around ICE, is that now actually harming them? It certainly was a high concern for Texans, you know, being a border state and often it's legal immigrants who are the most concerned about it and Latinos living in that region. And I think that helps explain why we saw a very significant shift in the 2024 presidential election with many Latino voters, especially in the Rio Grande Valley near the border, actually shifting from the Democrats to the Republicans and supporting Donald Trump.
24:49And what we've now seeing, according to opinion polls, at least, is some buyer's remorse on their part and many of them potentially shifting back. And I think for two reasons, one, based around immigration, as you say, they feel that ICE, the Immigration Customs and Enforcement, has overreached and been overzealous. And people in their families or people they know have been rounded up off the streets, sent to detention, potentially deported. That has gone down very badly with many Latino communities in Texas and elsewhere. And then the second reason is, again, the economy and cost of living. There are many Latino small businessmen and women who really felt that Trump could be good for them.
25:41Economically, their businesses may be struggling now more than ever due to the Iran war and due to tariffs, especially. So many of them, I think, now regret supporting Trump and they're ready to come back to the democratic fold.
25:58Coming up, can we finally, finally start thinking about a time post-Trump?
26:32Transcription by CastingWords Side podcast from Barclays Investment Bank. Hear two research analysts in a lively debate and get insights from every angle to further inform your view. Listen to The Flipside on your favorite platform. 500 orders a month was manageable. 5 ,000 is madness. Embrace intelligent order fulfillment with ShipStation, the only platform combining order management, warehouse workflows, inventory, returns, and analytics in one place. What used to take five separate tools, ShipStation does in one. Automate fulfillment and rate shopping to ship up to 15 times more with up to 90 % savings.
27:11Go to ShipStation.com and use code AUDIO to try ShipStation free for 60 days.
27:22David, what other races should we be keeping an eye on next week when the results start coming in? I will certainly be watching Michigan. Could be the first Muslim senator in history, could be. Exactly, yes. And also figure of the left aggressive in Abdul Al-Sayed. And I think Democrats everywhere are watching that as a potential test case, given that Michigan is a swing state. If Abdul Al-Sayed wins, then that is a green light for progressives and democratic socialists to run for president in 2028. And the stock of Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez goes up as a viable contender. And there are lots of other interesting races too.
28:03Recently, I was in Kansas, of all places, for a Trump campaign rally. No Democrat has won a Senate seat there for 94 years when Herbert Hoover was president. And so that's one to watch on election night. If that one falls to the Democrats, then you really know that Donald Trump is in big trouble. Speaking of which, David, Trump has consistently told voters to act like he is on the ballot. But now I want you to pretend I'm on the ballot because if you go out... Which is an interesting strategy given how unpopular he is. But it doesn't look great for him, does it? And the prospect of Trump being humiliated seems a scary one because who knows what he'll do or where he'll bomb if he's upset enough.
28:48And in your view, what would it mean for his presidency and the rest of the world if he ends up losing heavily on Tuesday? Yeah, it will be a major blow to Donald Trump's presidency. This will be the first really major national verdict of the voters on how is his second term going. And it could be quite scathing. The opinion polls suggest he's going to do very badly and that actually his claim, imagine that I'm on the ballot is actually going to backfire horribly. I mean, Democrats are saying, yes, bring that on. The more Trump is there, the more people will vote against him. So on a technical level, it'll mean Congress has more muscle to impose checks and balances on Trump.
29:34I can expect Democrats to launch various investigations into the Trump corruption, the origins of the Iran war, hold committee hearings, try and subpoena White House officials, maybe members of Trump's family. Democrats all debate, should they impeach Donald Trump for a third time? However, I'm not sure Donald Trump will go quietly, and I'm not sure he'll welcome the fact that I think the day after the midterms, we will immediately be into a conversation about the 2028 presidential election, which by the Constitution excludes him. He's not the kind of guy to willingly take a backseat and say, OK, now I'm going to anoint a successor.
30:16And certainly there are those who believe the two years remaining could be the most treacherous of all. Donald Trump is like a wounded animal. He'll feel power slipping away. He'll be more tempted than ever to lash out, to still dominate the headlines, to still make it all about him. And there may be nothing more dangerous than a reckless Donald Trump who feels he has nothing to lose. That's a terrifying prospect. David, thank you so much for your time. Great to be here. Thank you. That was David Smith, Washington Bureau Chief for The Guardian. My thanks to him. You can follow all of our election coverage, including the live blog at theguardian.com.
30:55And just before we go, if you enjoy this episode, maybe you'd consider leaving us a review. We love to hear what you think of the show and it helps other people find us. If you'd prefer to correspond with us in private, there's also an email address just for you. And it is tiff.questions at theguardian.com. Send us a question, a suggestion for an episode or, you know, ideas on who you'd like to hear from next. And that's it for today. This episode was produced by Ivor Manley and Hannah Aydan. It was presented by me, Noshi Nikbal. Sound design is by Ross Burns and the executive producer is Sammy Kent.
31:32We'll be back in your feeds this afternoon with the latest.
31:37This is The Guardian.
31:48Hey, I'm running out to drop off a stack of letters and packages. Need anything shipped while I'm gone? Save the gas. Stamps.com lets you print postage and schedule pickups right from your desk. Sync your contacts into the address book, get detailed accounting insights, and get notified the moment your certified mail is delivered. All from my desk? All from your desk. Join the 4 million businesses using Stamps.com right now with code podcast and get your free welcome gift. Stamps.com code podcast. Taxes and fees apply. I could see that I was transitioning from being a functioning alcoholic to a non-functioning alcoholic.
32:24A desperate man turns to his chatbot for help. Can it convince him to change? This interaction probably did push me to thinking I have to quit. Black Box, The Chatbots, a new series from The Guardian Investigates about the strange things happening between AI and us. Search for Black Box wherever you get your podcasts.