

The episode argues that social media is being flooded with AI “influencers” made by reskinning real videos, which can eclipse human creators, enable scams, and blur what’s real. It also examines misinformation claims that Ukraine’s bombing of Yandex data centers reduced Russian bot activity, concluding the viral interpretation is largely wrong. It closes with a separate rage-bait/casino story about Jack Doherty.
No named guests appear in the transcript; the hosts include Matt and Pablo Torre (mentioned as a Pulitzer-winning journalist who investigated the earlier “robot bird” story).
AI influencer reskins are mass-producible and hard to hold accountable; they often funnel viewers to OnlyFans and crypto/meme-coin schemes; “bot takedown” narratives confuse web-crawling bots with disinformation accounts.
“Jean Phil” and other “funny haircut” AI characters (tens of millions of views); Brett Olson’s joke/outfit copied; “tectonic guy” dance reskinned by multiple AI characters; Yandex data-center bombing and Cloudflare graphs misread; Jean Phil meme coin; Higgspad; Jack Doherty’s Shuffle.com gag-order deal.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Discussion of Kelly Clarkson's experience at a Brooklyn store and the subsequent social media fallout.
“So then, Art of Play, the rad, quote-unquote, shop in Brooklyn, respond on Instagram.”
Exploration of the emergence of AI influencers and their impact on social media.
Analysis of how AI reskins are taking over original content and the implications for creators.
“So Instagram and TikTok have been flooded with these AI influencer reskins of real human videos.”
Discussion on the monetization strategies of AI influencers and the absurdity of the phenomenon.
“That's become easier to do thanks to this platform Higgsfield, who has this program Higgsfield, Genjutsu.”
Explore the emergence of AI influencers linked to meme coins and their impact on social media.
“Oh, you can sign up to this or be a part of this.”
Discussing misinformation, bot activity, and the evolving landscape of online trust.
“So that was a story about how the dead internet theory is kind of real and happening.”
Explore how inauthentic social media networks operate and evolve.
“Since then, we have seen a massive evolution in how inauthentic networks of accounts operate, you can't build up a following like you could before.”
Discuss the viral spread of misinformation and the impact of social media silos.
“I mean, there was an analysis that said over the weekend there was a 19.3 % fall in AFD mentions.”
Analyze the psychological aspects of narratives in politics and social media.
“I think this is where we've got to a slightly dangerous point in terms of the fragmentation of social media and the way that people now inhabit some of these silos like Blue Sky.”
Understand the responsibility of social media platforms in controlling misinformation.
“stuff, because it literally just takes like, you know, a little, little bit of effort to influence these general views on social media.”
Learn about Jack Doherty's amusing brand deal that resulted in a gag order.
“Lots of people on the Internet hate him.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On Top Comment, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK.
0:30goals, or appetite for investing, Schwab has everything you need all in one place. Visit schwab.com to learn more. Imagine buying a toy for your kid, but it doesn't come with batteries. That sucks. But honestly, it's even worse when you buy business software. You end up with fragmented, disconnected systems that cost a fortune and don't talk to each other. Odoo completely changes that. Odoo comes fully complete, with all your business apps perfectly integrated and working together seamlessly. it's everything your business needs in one place saving you time headaches and serious money stop paying for missing pieces go to odoo.com that's odoo.com to learn more okay we're going to begin this episode with a little bit of role play oh you can play kelly clark i don't know how to do a kelly clarkson impression i can't you don't you're american you can just read it out okay all right fine okay enter stage right kelly clarkson okay so kelly clarkson three days ago tweets just drove all the way to brooklyn to check out this store i thought looked really rad and had a few things in mind to buy and literally was looked at as if i couldn't afford it and was told he could find something comparable for me wow dude you're an idiot and just lost a huge sale but y 'all should go check out art of play in brooklyn if you enjoy being treated like Julia Roberts' character in Pretty Woman, for sure, check it out.
1:59Thumbs down. Dripping with sarcasm. So then, Art of Play, the rad, quote-unquote, shop in Brooklyn, respond on Instagram. Yesterday, Kelly Clarkson visited us in Brooklyn and inquired about buying Molly, a one-of-a-kind singing and dancing bird automaton who plays an important role in the magic shows that we host here. Molly is permanently attached to the wall and isn't for sale. However, comma, onto the next slide. By the way, this is like a, it's sort of like a screen grab of a Word doc. It's quite long. Basically, they go on to say, the negative experience Kelly described on Twitter would resonate with anyone who has ever felt judged in a shop.
2:38But at our play, whether someone comes in to make a purchase or look around for a while, they're equally welcome. We greet everyone who walks in the door. Invitation to pick things up and play. Blah, blah, blah. Imagine our surprise when there's a local business. We're attacked by 8 million people who've never visited our store. And then they've basically detailed the amount of, since then, abuse that they've received. I really enjoy the end of the statement, though. As a talented popular singer once said, what doesn't kill you makes you stronger. But sorry, since then, people have pointed out, using photographic evidence, that Molly, the one-of-a-kind singing and dancing bird automaton, which Kelly Clarkson clearly was very keen to buy that it did have a price tag of$15 ,000 and you can see that in a photo in this shop.
3:30At which point they then clarify an additional detail about the visit to the Curiosity Shop. We explain that while Molly is permanently in touch with the wall and serves as a de facto mascot for our shop a nearly identical automaton is owned by the creator of the machines who would be willing to part with Molly's twin for$15 ,000 and they explained this to Kelly Clarkson at the time. Right. I'm really interested by what you can do with an automaton bird. The crazy thing is that Kelly Clarkson went into a store and was like, I need this singing and dancing bird automaton. I need it. For$15 ,000, don't care, I need it.
4:04And the store was like, well, it's not quite for sale. So then she tweeted a follow-up, okay, cool. So you're not only rude, you're also a liar. I think, look, brass tacks here. initially you see Kelly Clarkson's post and you're like wow that sounds really entitled like why would you post that but the more I hear from this shop it does sound like there was a singing dancing bird automaton for sale there now obviously this has taken on a bit of a life of its own and it's become subject to a classic dose of sleuth disease yeah because everyone's like well we need to get to the bottom of this and why it's happened and everyone includes a Pulitzer winning journalist Pablo Torre who's like, fine, I'll look into it.
4:44And people are like analyzing the CCTV. Like, it's just, it's all got a bit out of control, really. For me, it begs the question, like, I've never understood why people leave negative reviews on things, unless it was like, really, really, really horrendous. Like you turned up in a hotel and like there wasn't a bed or something. I just don't really understand that. But maybe I'm just not rage bait enough. Well, it's also a little tone deaf, because I mean, over half of US Americans can't afford like basic life necessities and she's getting angry because she wasn't sold a$15 ,000 toy bird. If I'm honest I think that the internet is broadly coming down on the side of the shop but also does anyone actually care?
5:21I just love the idea of Kelly Clarkson being like you think I can afford this singing this robot bird because I can I can afford the shit out of that robot bird. okay this episode is not actually about automated birds but it is about fake things i mean all of social media is in a way especially with the increasing number of bots present on social media is essentially a singing and dancing automaton or is it or is it on today's episode we're going to talk about the evolution of ai influences and how social media has been flooded with these re-skinned AI influencer versions of humans' content. And we're going to be talking about misinformation, about misinformation, this story of some AI data centers that got bombed in Russia and whether that actually means that a load of bot networks have been taken down, have disappeared or not.
6:16Spoiler, it doesn't.
6:24matt for the past few weeks very regularly you've been posting on our group chat saying guys is anyone seeing these weird ai influencers with the strange hair yeah i've been begging begging someone to talk to me about these funny haircut ai influencer people and here we are And finally, now that it gets some mainstream attention, you all seem to think it's a story. So here we are. So Instagram and TikTok have been flooded with these AI influencer reskins of real human videos. One of the earlier ones that people were seeing was the Takeoff and Quavo hotel lobby video.
7:23Now we're increasingly seeing these funny haircut guys, the first of which is Jean Phil. Jean Phil with the, people will know him from his triangular hairdo. Yeah, he has. Blonde, and he's often wearing a suit, right? Yeah, he's wearing a suit. He has a very strange sort of metabolism. Clearly his body is very, it's odd. He has a blonde bob and a curled mustache and he's often shadow boxing in these videos. Whoever's running this page is an absolute genius. And I'm not talking about Jean Phil because that Jean Phil isn't even real because this whole page is an AI character that again is not real.
7:59Distinguir le vrai du faux va devenir vraiment impossible sur les réseaux sociaux. Lui c 'est Jean Phil. Petite coupe sympa, costume en pied de poule, il se balade dans Paris, il boxe dans l 'air. Who are these people that keep coming up on my TikTok page with bobs above their ears? Blonde ones, ginger ones, brown-haired ones. Someone please tell me if they're real or not, because what the heck? And that was kind of the first big funny haircut AI guy. Some analysis has suggested he got around 75 million views on Instagram alone. So this stuff gets popular very fast. then a whole litany of other ai influencer characters popped up including is it brigitte macarron these people clearly are just doing the most basic google searches to figure out like what a french sounding name is and then there's there was archibald brown who kind of presented himself itself as a um british kind of counterpart rival to jean phil when he was like hunting for him and also doing shadow boxing and the difference right compared to like we've spoken about ai influencers before especially the ones you know the ones that are almost like influencers on steroids they are extra beautiful they've often been women sort of in different scenarios say like a kind of MAGA influencer or just one that's sort of promoting a certain aesthetic or style the reason this feels different and like an evolution from that is not only is it absurd like it's not beautiful it's weird but also although you know i know you do find jean philip particularly chic matt does have a crush on john philip i'm more of an archibald guy but the difference crucially is that these ai influences have sort of become like entities in and of themselves and other people can copy their likeness almost like we've become clippers for the ai influences like we make the content for them?
9:52We are the vessel by which they exist or put them into existing videos like you say? Well we as humans are becoming like less and less important on social media because all of these AI influencers are what is now called a reskin which means that they are taking a video that a human has made and using advanced tracking motion tracking and reskinning to put an AI AI person's face and body over the top of that video. So it looks like this AI character was in the original video. That's become easier to do thanks to this platform Higgsfield, who has this program Higgsfield, Genjutsu. Now Genjutsu literally translates as illusionary techniques.
10:35This program has led to Jean Phil and all these other influences, but it's also led to people's kind of hard work essentially being eclipsed by a cast of random AI characters re-skinning their videos. So for example, the comedian Brett Olson found that there was an AI influencer who copied his joke, his outfit, you know, his movements on stage. I stole my joke and my outfit. Here's the setup. Do you know every billionaire? Every single one has said AI is coming. It's coming for your jobs there's nothing you can do about it and your taxes are gonna fund the whole thing here's my setup do you know every billionaire every single one has said ai is coming it's coming for your jobs there's nothing you can do about it and your taxes are gonna fund the whole thing pretty good got a that's right here's the punch lines half the country hears all that and blames immigrants from south of the border instead.
11:36And half the country is like, goddamn, fucking Mexicans. And then if you went to this AI influencers profile, it kind of linked back to her, her, it's AI only fans page, which if you don't know about AI only fans, that, I mean, that is now a big thing on social media. And we've seen this happen before, feuds between influencers or people taking aim at other creators saying, hang on a second, you are ripping off my content. You're telling my story like it's your story. You're copying a trend I've come up with and you're not crediting me, all that kinds of stuff. And on the whole, that person who'd done the copying would be cancelled maybe slightly too far, but at least sort of shamed or trolled.
12:16You can't really shame or troll an AI influencer. You can't really hold them accountable because they're not real. No, and also they can be mass produced with the click of a button. So you can have one person releases a video, say they've spent a year perfecting a dance routine. For example, the tectonic guy. There was a guy who revived the tectonic dance and he did it at a rave and it was incredible.
12:45Now that video is being replaced by lots of different AI characters with exact motion tracking on his dance video. and he this the original dancer is relegated to this tiny voice somewhere in the comments being like by the way this was originally me but that's drowned out now because that dance that he spent a year perfecting is now just the basis for like a whole genre of ai characters to do that dance so he is just kind of the initial meat layer in a new world of social media that is now the ai influencers world this is kind of the thing we were worried about with ai right that it kind of will eclipse human creation in this case because you can have a hundred ai influencers reskinning on the same video that original video is going to get way fewer views than the you know collective millions of views that this new cast of aviders who are you reskinning are going to get so what's the point of humans anymore basically and also what's the point of these ai influencers That's so depressing.
13:49That's true. What is the point of these AI influencers? Well, we know that some of them are being, like you mentioned about them, directing people back to say their OnlyFans account. We've seen a lot of these AI influencers connected to cryptocurrency schemes, people using them as a kind of absurd way of pulling people into, oh, click through and click on this link. Oh, you can sign up to this or be a part of this. Right, exactly. With the rise of Jean Phil, there was the Jean Phil meme coin, which I think at one point skyrocketed to around 12 million USD in total trading value. The creator of that coin, he made, I think, about 100 grand just off of the transaction fees on Pump.Fund, Pump.Fund being the platform where you can mint meme coins.
14:33Now that process becomes streamlined. So a new platform has arisen, which isn't connected to Higgsfield, but calls itself Higgspad, which basically allows you to kind of create an AI influencer, automatically link it to a meme coin, and then you just reap in the money as that AI influencer grows. I think that it's important to talk about the absurdity here and the sort of how people are trying to sort of out AI each other. We become accustomed to seeing bizarre AI edits. If you want to grab people's attention, you have got to come up with the weirdest possible character or the strangest sort of scenario so that people will actually stop scrolling and be like, oh, what is this?
15:13And I think that's the direction that generative AI has taken us in to the point where like your feed is like like being in some sort of like strange fever dream compared to what it used to be like. I mean, ultimately, this comes down to kind of a couple of things. First of all, it's kind of an extension of the dead internet theory, which was this idea that increasingly the internet is just bots, right? In some way, TikTok has paved the way for this because the whole platform is predicated on people using sound and image from other creators to kind of do it themselves, right? But that's, you still have the humans doing that.
15:47now there's very little to stop you as an original human creator having your original creation just become fodder for like an industrial scale ai influencer operation it's very difficult to do a copyright claim instagram as a platform it deprioritizes stuff that is ai but doesn't label itself as ai but these influencers they are labeled as ai but they're not really pretending other people's content right yeah and that and i i think when we talk about the impact here like most people would see jean phil or whoever and realize that he's not a real person that this is an ai generated influence so there will obviously be some people who genuinely think this is a real person are like who's this strange character but actually like most people know it's ai but they kind of well either you find it irritating and annoying and you're like oh i don't want this on my feed or you just don't care right you just become so desensitized to this sort of thing that you're like oh well this is just what my feed is like now like i i remember that there was that period of time where generative ai started to take over my social media feed and i'd be like oh like it was always those things where people would be sort of like cutting up like a cat or something there was quite a gulf between the authentic quote-unquote content human content and then the ai generated content whereas i think this reskinning means that that gulf feels feels less than it did before because there are elements of the content that feels like the stuff you're used to seeing but then obviously it's got these AI implanted elements and so it's less sort of egregious or maybe we are just used to it and that's why I'm just kind of like oh well this is what the internet is like now you don't know whether anything is real yeah and if you're not used to it like you better get used to it because it's a sheer numbers game like humans we have our hands tied behind our backs in this content war because we can't mass produce content like they can isn't there an issue though for the social media companies because something that various people who work at the companies have said to me before is that while ai generated content is a bit of a sort of quick hit think like the cheating ai for fruits in that for a short period of time it gets a lot of engagement and traction over time that kind of content is a bit of a turnoff because we actually don't really like things that we know to be entirely fake like we sort of want to we prefer things that feel like they are human in some way and so if your feed becomes entirely overwhelmed with this sort of content you might spend less time on it which is not good for the companies because they can't sell ads and make money and all of that sort of stuff you could see a world where some of the platforms are like actually we're going to start down ranking and deprioritizing this stuff long term like youtube for example no one wants to watch a half in our YouTube video at the moment of an AI influencer.
18:29You're absolutely right. But then the question is, can they stop it? And this is the issue around everything with AI is it can have extreme effects on different aspects of society and different aspects of the internet before we figure out how to stop it. And we sometimes will never be able to stop it. What it all comes down to in terms of any potential that humans do have to kind of fight back against this, if you want to say it described in those terms, what we briefly mentioned at the beginning of this segment is the IP question. So we currently live in what's basically kind of two-tier IP situation around AI.
19:05These individual creators will have basically no way to pursue a claim against AI influencers who are using their content. On the other hand, you have big companies like Sony who are suing Anthropic, who are suing like multiple LLMs for using their library of music and other content in order to, you know, create AI content. But the big companies can make these allegations. The big companies can do these lawsuits, but individual creators cannot. I think we often think of the social media companies and the AI companies as sort of kindred spirits, right? They're kind of the same thing, but focusing on a different area.
19:41But actually, you could see how in this situation, it benefits the AI companies to, if you're going to get a little bit conspiratorial here and or sort of look at what the motive of all this stuff could be. Like it would benefit these AI companies to create these kinds of influences and to encourage other users to reskin authentic content because it's good for their tool that they're essentially marketing. But that might actually be bad overall for the social media companies who don't want to host tons and tons of this content and or obviously for the creators like you mentioned. Currently, the trend on social media appears to be kind of nonsensical, crazy looking AI influencer characters, because those seem to do the best on social media.
20:22I mean, what if the trend moves towards Higgs field genjutsu being used to create realistic influencers again? And there are lots of those as well. The trend could switch and then, because people don't like the kind of novelty, crazy mustache people, then they start making more realistic ones. And then we kind of get to this point where we've chatted about this on Top Comment quite a few times. Does that accelerate the backlash against influencers in general? Probably. because then authenticity becomes this sort of premium product as in actual authenticity. Kind of this idea that like AI art will be like easy, accessible art and the real content becomes prestige.
21:02Yeah, there's definitely a big question that gets to the heart of like AI art, which is why is it that we as humans prefer art to be made by a human, right? The AI music is now getting to the stage where it's pretty good but the fact that we know that there isn't like a real human being a real like taylor swift who's like gone through a breakup and is therefore writing a song about something that actually happened to her matters to our emotional reaction to that song the one thing that ai can never really do or at least we haven't yet seen it we'll do is to create something out of its own willpower right there always has to be a human telling it what to do because it's not motivated by desire like the same way we are and then having that desire blocked by the reality of living in the universe which leads to suffering which leads to art right it doesn't have any of that anyway all this is to say that we now live in a world where you can with incredible ease make anyone do or say anything in a video online
22:32We'll be right back. Start planning your getaway today at applevacations.com or contact your travel advisor. Apple Vacations, where your story starts. Discover a spectacular island destination with crystal blue seas, endless sunshine, and the cool Bahamian breeze. Baja Mar, located in Nassau, Bahamas, offers your choice of three luxury hotels, over 45 fine dining and nightlife venues, Jean Batiste's all-new Jazz Club, the Caribbean's most luxurious casino and one-of-a-kind experiences for the entire family, like our 15-acre tropical water park, wildlife sanctuary, world-class golf course, and so much more.
23:11Visit Bahamar.com today. So that was a story about how the dead internet theory is kind of real and happening. But then now we're going to talk about a story where people kind of see dead internet theory where it isn't because we're so obsessed with that narrative of the internet is now bots. Yes. This is like sort of some misinfo about misinfo. It's a very like meta misinfo story. In lots of ways, though, it connects to the same thing as these AI influencers, which is that people just no longer trust anything they see online and believe everything must be fake or distorted or not as it appears.
23:50So this story starts with Ukraine bombing some data centers belonging to Yandex, which is like the big internet provider. It's like the Google of Russia. Their search engine has a 72 % market share in Russia. Yeah, exactly. It's massive. They're also Yandex taxis. There's all sorts of things. Yandex kind of does everything. When I lived in Russia, I was like very well acquainted with Yandex. Right, right. These data centers get bombed. This is obviously in retaliation against Russia invading and attacking Ukraine. And we're seeing an increasing number of attacks from Ukraine sort of targeting Russia.
24:28And off the back of this, President Zelensky then makes these comments, the president of Ukraine, saying we've kind of got the bots, right? Because we've knocked out these data centers, it's going to be the case that you're going to see less sort of bot activity from or we've disrupted some of the disinformation, misinformation warfare coming from Russia. Now, Russia obviously is very well known for its information warfare tactics and the way that it uses inauthentic accounts or has used inauthentic accounts over a number of years. Often when we say Russia, inverted commas, we mean sort of groups affiliated with or supportive of President Putin who have networks of accounts and generate content that is disruptive and polarizing.
25:16I mean, this dates all the way back to 2016 when there are various allegations of foreign interference around democratic events like the US election. There have been comments this week from the Prime Minister, Andy Burnham, here in the UK trying to kind of point the finger at Russia around the Brexit referendum. The thing is, is that the situation has very much evolved since then. And so what we want to do here is actually try and figure out what is true in terms of how much this targeting of data centers has actually affected bot activity, quote unquote, and how much of it is actually just people sort of wanting to believe that they can control something that they have not very much control over.
25:52Exactly, because there were a number of graphs that went viral stemming from this original post by Cloudflare, this huge U.S. software company, which pointed to a massive drop in activity, bot activity from Yandex. However, there was a misunderstanding between how the public understood these graphs and what, you know, Cloudflare initially meant, which was that they were referring to a different kind of bot than what people see as a bot. It's not that it's fake data. It's that it's been completely misinterpreted by people who are posting about it. And that was being shared by hugely influential accounts, hugely credible accounts too.
26:36When we think of bots, most people tend to think of like a fake account on Twitter posting fake news or boosting other people's fake news. But the majority of bots are things like web crawlers and indexers, which, you know, without going into too much detail, because it might bore a lot of our listeners, like search engines like Yandex rely on web crawler bots and indexer bots, which scan and download data from websites and put it into essentially a data set that is then indexed so that when you use the search engine it uses that data set to find web pages based on your search terms etc so a lot of bot activity is things like yandex bot or google bot when cloudflare basically reported this reduction in bot traffic it was the web crawlers and the indexer bots that they were reporting and not like random bot accounts on twitter posting disinformation yeah and and i think that when people are talking about bots here they are thinking of the bots of a decade ago which was a period of time, quite a short period of time, to be honest, where it was possible to create inauthentic accounts, to make them look like real people, and to deliberately sow division.
27:47And what we saw during 2016, there is an ongoing debate about to what extent this actually impacted democratic events, voting, public opinion, what have you. But what we do know is these fake accounts did exist. Since then, we have seen a massive evolution in how inauthentic networks of accounts operate, you can't build up a following like you could before. And actually, what we've often seen more recently is that these kinds of inauthentic networks either use real influencers as their vectors, like they'll find polarizing accounts that exist and you just hop on those narratives. It's not very difficult.
28:23By liking or replying? Yeah, liking, replying, sharing similar talking points. And if you want to go a step further, you message those accounts and you say, hey, could you share this? Hey, could you share that? And that's not to say that it's not the case that it could be that some of the inauthentic accounts have been knocked out or aren't working but the idea that kind of en masse yeah that's happening just doesn't make sense also because so many of these accounts and inauthentic networks are not run from even inside russia there are so many inauthentic networks i think the gru is going to let their entire bot project be defined by like three data centers of course not they've you know and a lot of them are based in southeast asia a lot of them are based in the middle east and this is where it's this is important right This like initial viral story claimed that there was a 90 % reduction in traffic, internet traffic mentioning alternative for Deutschland, the AFD party.
29:12That's just straight up incredibly not true. I mean, there was an analysis that said over the weekend there was a 19.3 % fall in AFD mentions. But if you look at other German parties like CDU, the Greens, SPD, they all had similar or greater falls in traffic, too, because it was like your typical weekend lull in people talking about political parties. Because I guess some people still do have lives and their entire life isn't just getting angry on the Internet. But the fact that this story has gone so viral, politicians and expert commentators are still retweeting it. I mean, it just shows you that there is such a gulf of understanding between commentators and politicians and how this tech actually works.
29:53It is true that this attack did take down the cloud systems, the storage systems, the Yandex servers. It did take down a lot of the servers necessary for, for example, Yandex's LLMs. So things like translation would have been much harder coming from Russia, automatic translation. So maybe if there were bot accounts that relied on Yandex's other products, like their server systems, maybe it would have been more difficult for them to operate. But we absolutely do not have the data to demonstrate that at this stage. But as ever, when people decide that they want to believe something, and it's something that is going incredibly viral within their own echo chamber, they are so easily convinced of it.
30:34And I think some of this derives from other examples we've seen of cases where there have been internet blackouts, say in Iran, and certain political pages have disappeared afterwards, like pages connected to the Scottish National Party and people applying that same logic, but to a situation where it's not quite so clear cut as just saying, oh, look, a bunch of websites have disappeared. I think this is where we've got to a slightly dangerous point in terms of the fragmentation of social media and the way that people now inhabit some of these silos like Blue Sky. So we've seen some people deciding to leave, and this was several years ago now, but people decided that they wanted to leave Twitter when it became X and it was bought by Elon Musk.
31:11And they went to places like Blue Sky. Now, Blue Sky, therefore, is largely populated by people who are more left-leaning politically. If you hop over onto Blue Sky, you have a very different experience to when you're an X. mainly because of the political talking points but also because everyone kind of seems to agree with each other and I think there's a certain enjoyment that people derive from that because it's like great everyone agrees with me and we can build up these theories and we can all kind of like relish in and enjoy the same thing a bit like when you use a chatbot and it kind of like agrees with and validates everything you say and that feels nice and good but it's there that you've seen loads and loads of people sharing this stuff because they sort of want it to be true like haha look we've got rid of the bot networks we're going to win like it's this sort of battle just doesn't work like that see i'm i'm of two minds about this because on the one hand you're totally right i mean psychologically a lot of people want that big bad wolf story this simple narrative especially for example democrats in the u.s when trump won or people who were against brexit when brexit happened it's very psychologically it's difficult for those people to accept that a huge number of your fellow country men and women want this thing that this terrible thing that you hate to happen.
32:24So it's very easy to say it was all Russia, right? But on the other hand, all of these elections and the Brexit referendum are operating on tiny margins. And it only takes a little bit of influence to switch an election. So I do think that we do also underestimate how vulnerable our democratic processes are to this stuff, because it literally just takes like, you know, a little, little bit of effort to influence these general views on social media. But again, as is always the case here, the problem is the platforms. If the platforms fix the algorithms or the platforms fix the recommendation systems, then this wouldn't happen.
33:02You couldn't game it. Yeah, exactly. And one of the kind of unfounded theories that's been going around about these data centers and getting rid of the bot networks, quote unquote, and everything else, is, oh, look, Ukraine have done this on purpose so that they can somehow stop the spread of polarizing, divisive, misleading content before the midterm elections in the US. I mean, obviously we have classic October surprise, et cetera, in the US and something happens and it could impact the election. See Hunter Biden episode that we did of top comment. But on the whole, most of these narratives are seeded over a much longer period of time.
33:36So even if you did knock out, like say in theory, this was true, like you knocked out a whole set of bot accounts that could somehow change the narrative around the midterms, they would have already started doing that. They already started doing that two years ago. Like they already started doing that six years ago, seven years ago. So like the damage would have been done. The damage would have been done anyways. And that's what's so effective about misinformation is that you spin and sell and amplify narratives that real people will buy into, that they are vulnerable to. And then they take it upon themselves to spread those ideas.
34:06And you don't really need to do anything anymore.
34:11OK, so this next story is really funny. Only if you know who Jack Doherty is. Lots of people on the Internet hate him. Yeah, I mean, he's kind of like a manosphere adjacent e-pimp, tiny, tiny man child who is like kind of famous for being, I think it's fair to say for like being obnoxious on social media. So a lot of his videos will be like him provoking someone into a fight and then his security like dealing with that person. He's sort of rage bait personified. He's rage bait personified, exactly. And he's been paid by, well, he thought he was agreeing to a brand deal with this casino called Shuffle.com and then came to realize that actually it was essentially a gag order, right?
34:54They were like, don't post. Yeah, so this is so funny. So he thought this was like a promotion deal. He'd be promoting their stuff. But in the fine print, it actually said you are not allowed to post on social media anymore. So the reason we haven't been hearing from this annoying guy is because this casino basically trolled him into signing an agreement that makes it illegal for him to post on social media, which I think we need to be doing a lot more of this. But the CEO of Shuffle, this guy called Noah Dummett, basically posted on X saying it's money well spent to get this motherfucker off the internet.
35:29Yeah. But also, I guess, great publicity stunt for them. Because if you haven't heard of Shuffle.com, you have now. Just to give you an example of how annoying Jack Doherty is, a lot of his content would be very clearly staged situations where he was getting into a quote-unquote fight, including with the Island Boys. Do you remember the Island Boys? Island Boys. I knew you just needed to sing that. But there's a video where he's at the Island Boys' house and he gets punched in the face or something. By the way, small tangent, the Island Boys now do gay incest porn on OnlyFans. Anyway, thank you for listening for today's episode.
36:09If there is someone you would like to pay to not exist on social media, maybe they're popping up on your feed too much and you want us to get to the bottom of what's going on, get in touch. It's all the usual contact details. You can send us a WhatsApp, plus 44-330-123-9480. You can email topcomment at bbc.co.uk. Maybe you even want to make us into AI influence. No, I'm joking. Don't do that. Talking about Five Guys, when you go to Five Guys, are you ordering a milkshake or are you no milkshake until after the burger? No milkshake until after the burger. No way. No fucking way. This chick's crazy.
36:45Technology is changing our lives at a rapid pace. But how might it be impacting what we value? I'm Ros Atkins and in a new series I'm exploring how tech is shifting our ideas of worth in friendship, culture, finance and work. I'll look back at technological revolutions of the past as well as looking forward to a world centred around AI to test whether what really matters to us is changing. From BBC Radio 4, that's The Value Crisis with me, Ros Atkins. Listen now on BBC Sounds.
37:49Global Story on bbc.com or wherever you get your pods.
From shadowboxing Parisians to chihuahuas fronting rap videos, the acceleration in generative AI capability is now impossible to miss on our feeds. On this episode, Matt and Marianna explain how new software allows users to 'reskin' video content to make anyone say or do literally anything they like. They discuss the resulting shift from realism to absurdism online, the existential threat to any type of IP ownership, and why independent creators inevitably suffer the most.
Also this week, after Ukraine hit several Yandex data centres inside Russia, viral posts began circulating suggesting there had been a noticeable reduction in social media activity by Russian bots. This narrative was fuelled by multiple high-profile accounts, and even echoed by President Zelensky - only it wasn't true. After experts debunked the claims, Top Comment dissects why this 'misinfo on misinfo' was able to flourish, from circumstantial evidence to Bluesky echo-chambers.
Plus - Kelly Clarkson is in hot water after leaving a bad review, and the YouTube prankster who was tricked into an online gag order.
Top Comment is hosted by Marianna Spring and Matt Shea. The series producer is Laurie Kalus. The assistant producer is Sophie Millward. The social producer was Richard Kenny. The technical producer was Stephen Bailey. The editor is Justine Lang. The senior news editor is Sam Bonham.
If you want to get in touch about something that's popped up on your feed, our email address is [email protected] or you can send us a WhatsApp on +44 330 123 9480.