

Whether viral social-media “relationship tests” and pop-psych labels (e.g., bird test, orange peel test, attachment styles, “love languages,” red/green flags) are helping people spot real problems or instead fueling anxiety, misdiagnosis, and relationship breakdowns; plus how social media now shapes culture and fame.
No named guests in the transcript; it’s a BBC “Top Comment”-style discussion with two hosts. One referenced expert is Christine Redmond (UCLouvain researcher) and another is Frankie's Therapy (MA drama psychotherapy; EMDR therapist).
Viral relationship advice often turns normal dating uncertainty into clinical-sounding diagnoses; comment sections can “collectively diagnose” from little info; algorithms make content feel personally relevant; quizzes can function as sales funnels.
“Bird test” (curiosity as love), “orange peel test” (partner effort), love languages traced to Gary Chapman (not scientific), TikTok “NarcTalk” overuse of “narcissist,” and GTA 6 as satire with in-game social feeds.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Discussion on the bird test as a relationship indicator from social media.
“You want me to ask you some questions about it?”
Exploration of how social media influences relationship dynamics and advice.
“It's a bit like, it would depend in what context you brought it up.”
Analysis of social media as a cultural force affecting fame and relevance.
“sharing their tips and tricks and hints about relationships, some of which could be useful, but some of which also could be quite harmful.”
Critique of the concept of love languages and popular relationship theories.
“This idea that like, oh, some people's love language is acts of service for others.”
Discussion on the validity and impact of relationship advice found online.
“Can I tell you what the history of love language is?”
Learn how TikTok shapes relationship perceptions through content and commentary.
“Not to deny the experiences of people who have been ghosted.”
Discover how social media algorithms influence our understanding of relationships.
“NarcTalk, which is a sector of TikTok, of people who are obsessed with diagnosing other people as narcissists.”
Explore the nuances of attachment theory and its misinterpretation on social media.
“And yet more than half of the creators on TikTok talking about ADHD are using that to sell products like fidget spinners or courses for ADHD, people who have ADHD.”
Understand the importance of credible sources in psychological advice online.
“on social media I talk about trauma bond attachment and what healthy relationships actually look like and I think that social media can be amazing at providing psychoeducation in an easily relatable way.”
Identify the challenges of seeking relationship advice in today's social media landscape.
“If you go to BBC Action Line, there is lots of support there for help with mental health or other relationship issues.”
Explore how social media influences modern gaming and cultural icons like James Bond.
“I look here from looking from the outside.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On Top Comment, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK.
0:30goals, or appetite for investing. Schwab has everything you need all in one place. Visit schwab.com to learn more. Fall and comfort foods go hand in hand. Grandma's mac and cheese, soup and grilled cheese. But how do you create those cozy moments while still maintaining your health goals? Hero Bread can help. Hero Bread's soft, fluffy, flavorful sliced breads, bagels, tortillas, and Hero noodles have only 0 to 5 grams net carbs and up to 19 grams of protein per serving. So go ahead, enjoy some cheesy mac and cheese. Enjoy that stacked sandwich with Hero Bread for lunch or start your day with a fully loaded bagel.
1:11Because with Hero Bread, there's none of the stiff baked goods you expect from Better For You brands. And right now, Hero Bread is offering 10 % off your order. Go to Hero.co and use code IHEART at checkout. That's H-E-R-O dot C-O, code IHEART. All figures per serving of Hero Bread. See nutrition facts on Hero.co for sodium and sugar content.
1:38I saw a bird today. You want me to ask you some questions about it? What type of bird? Oh, you know about that? Yeah, wasn't I there when we spoke about that? maybe you were very quick to the draw on that uh but if you hadn't been what do you think your reaction would have been if i said i saw a bird today be honest why are you telling me that yeah i thought so i thought so which is a red flag for the future of our relationship and this podcast according to social media if you don't know what i was talking about the bird test is a so-called bid for a connection that's gone viral on TikTok as a way to test if your partner is actually curious about your life and whether they really love you.
2:20It's a bit like, it would depend in what context you brought it up. So if someone was like, how was your day today? And you were like, oh, I was at work and I was doing this and oh, I saw a bird. If you said it like that, then you'd be like, oh, what kind of bird? What would you say? If anyone said I saw a bird today in almost any context, I would say exactly what you just said. Like, why the hell are you telling me that like what but to some people on tiktok that is a red flag that means that your partner doesn't love you because they're not curious isn't it also like if you live in a circumstance by which talking about a bird would be normal or abnormal like maybe in america or something where this bird thing oh yeah in america it's totally it's like i saw a bird today i'm like oh my god honey what was it and like i don't know it's true isn't it like i don't know i just felt like for example if you and your partner are both bird watchers yeah then you're on a bird watching trip together yeah then but then the conversation will be like i saw a bird today and then it's like did you log it in the bird watching book like why are you telling me hurry up write it down another thing that people are doing is the orange peel test um ask i actually don't know that one ask your partner to peel an orange for you so the idea is you're asking them to do something which you could easily do yourself and if they don't do it like i guess they don't love you you know whatever.
3:32But these tests, much like all of the relationship advice that social media is awash with, are largely complete bollocks dressed up as science. And so we're going to get into that today. Yeah, because all of this is part of this kind of wider trend where creators are increasingly sharing their tips and tricks and hints about relationships, some of which could be useful, but some of which also could be quite harmful. And when our algorithms and our feeds and our chatbots become relationship therapists. What impact is that going to have on all of us and our relationships? Speaking of relationships, GTA 6 comes out this week.
4:10And that means that for the next like 72 hours, a large portion of the entire planet are going to be living vicariously through the relationship of the characters Lucia and Jason, who are the stars of the new, what's arguably the biggest release in gaming history. But what a lot of people don't know is that GTA 6 is itself a kind of satire of 2020 social media culture. There are real working social media feeds within the game of GTA 6. Now, when you think about that, when you think about the fact that we've just had arguably the most famous actor cast as Bond at the time of casting in a franchise that's now owned by a tech company.
4:54The fact that mainstream comedy is now basically taking their comedians directly from TikTok and Instagram. The fact that Hollywood studios are now scanning YouTube for the directors of their next big hit. It's difficult to conclude anything other than social media is now the defining kind of cultural force. And it basically decides who gets famous and who's culturally relevant and the old powers that be are playing catch up it's essentially social media's world and we're all living in it or another way of looking at it is like social media is one of those you know cordyceps funguses that infects our brains and like makes us climb to the top of a branch and then sprouts over our head and then infects all the other ants and then they get infected and they do the same thing okay so with the relationship thing yes like these days having a conversation with your partner can basically descend into a a therapy speak back and forth about gaslighting what personality type you are diagnosing them as narcissistic love languages attachment theory and like i think taking love languages as an example of why a lot of this stuff is untrue is a good place to start because love languages went so viral, right?
6:10This idea that like, oh, some people's love language is acts of service for others. And some is touch. Yeah, for some it's touch. For some it's like words of affection, right? Now I was looking at - Is it words of affirmation? Yeah, sorry, words of affirmation. I was looking at the history of this. You haven't been consuming enough of this concept. Well, my love language isn't like research. That's more your love language. Is it? My love language is chatting. That's definitely my love language. but but on this i think loads of these words have come into the sort of public consciousness in a way that they know like people just weren't using like attachments that are love language um stuff about kind of personality disorders or different forms of abuse they weren't talking about these things in the way that they are now and i think that is massively down to the amount of this content that exists on social media and how once you consume as we know just a little bit of it.
7:00You are bombarded with it. Welcome to cupping season. I'm glad that you made it out of summer alive, but this is where the big dogs play. It's not about the bird. It's about being seen. If you come across a man who does any of the following things that I'm about to list off, keep him. He is a walking green flag. What's up divas? These are signs you should break up with your boyfriend. Hey, I'm a boyfriend hater till I die. If you chase it, it's going to run. And if you grip it, it's going to slip out of your fingers. And if you put it way up on a pedestal, guess what? You can't freaking reach it.
7:30This is the same thing that happens in relationships, and I'm about to make it all make sense. The question that we're going to try and answer here is, is this just the new astrology where it's like a kind of innocuous, fun way to like mythologize yourself and your psychology and whatever and your relationship? Or is there something a little bit more sinister? Are people trying to market you a label that they can then use to sell products to you? Like, you know, could these like pop psychology theories that are being spread by creators on TikTok actually be damaging to relationships? Or flip side of that, could it be that more people are able to recognize emotionally abusive and manipulative behaviors and actually maybe that's no bad thing too?
8:07Like what does this kind of content empower us and trigger an important conversation? Or actually, can it be quite corrosive and toxic in and of itself when you're trying to point out toxicity? Can I tell you what the history of love language is? I think it's the perfect starting point for how ridiculous this stuff is. And I researched it, especially for you. So research is your love language. It is. So basically love languages, it turns out, was developed by this guy called Dr. Gary Chapman. And it's just based on like his experience with his own wife. He's like not a scientist and there's no actual research here.
8:43And basically he initially neglected household chores like washing dishes, vacuuming or cleaning the bathroom, assuming his wife should handle them and expressing his love primarily through words of affirmation. When his wife expressed feeling unloved, he came up with this love language thing and basically concluded her love language was acts of service. Whereas my meaning like helping around the house and doing stuff and mind is like words of affirmation. How dodgy does that sound? You basically come up with a philosophical framework to justify you're not doing chores. Also, my love language is words of affirmation.
9:20That's so much easier than acts of service, right? Yes, very true. But 50 million people have taken this online test. Although not for some people. I think there are some people who the idea of any words of affirmation would send them running a mile. We just don't happen to be those kinds of people. The truth is, it's basically all pseudoscience. There's no basis for any of this stuff. but 50 million people have taken the online test about their their love love language videos with the hashtag of half a billion views on tiktok and it means nothing let's do a little quiz do you know these things do you know what cuffing season is yes it's like around wintertime people need a relationship apparently right yeah exactly that yeah so i think that's stupid yeah red and green flags i think most people know that that's become very widely used but but that's so confusing because they're always changing right like yeah like and also different people's perception of a green or a red flag will vary you know it depends on who they are and where they're from and their own relationship history and where but yeah i mean red flag is broadly something that is seen as harmful and right green flag is a positive thing about someone yeah bread crumbing i haven't heard is that like when you like lead like you like lead someone on so they're they're yeah it's like you're sort of not that great to them and then you're a little bit nice to them so that they are available for sex yeah kind of like you're not committing to it so it's like benching them it's sort of like yeah like half benching them it's sort of like that like half haunting their house you'll you'll kind of you know you'll keep someone interested and hooked but not but you'll never actually properly commit to them so you'll keep asking them questions say but you won't actually try and meet up or yeah that kind of thing right right right um zombying yeah evolution of ghosting basically when someone who has been ghosting you then just like reappears right okay So actually that's haunted housing.
11:06Okay, okay. Benching is already also here, but you already got there. Keeping someone as an option. And then, see, the things that I've seen loads on my social media feeds are just all these like, everything is called a theory, right? Even when you're like, is it a theory? So like red string theory. So this is this idea that everyone is tied to their soulmate through a kind of series of different coincidences or opportune moments. and um so it's basically saying that like you you end up with the right person in the end sort of by all these weird or often it'll be things like someone will post about how they were accidentally pictured on like a family holiday at disneyland and their then then to be husband was just like in the background on the lawn yeah i've seen viral stories yeah and then it'll be like and then we got married and we're like whoa but then there's also this whole man's first love love theory thing which is like men basically only just like the first person they love and everyone else's doesn't really hang on those two theories contradict each other because if well exactly if i only love the first love then but i actually loved some random like kindergartner that was in my family photo from 50 30 years ago well exactly it doesn't make sense and then and you know another one that i've seen loads of is the taxicab theory this is this theory that men like men decide to enter relationships because they feel in the right place to do so rather than if it's the right person, right?
12:29So it's kind of that theory that someone can go out with someone for like 10 years and then they break up and then they go out with someone else immediately because they just happen to be in the kind of right headspace where they want to marry someone. Oh, is this the idea that every man has a light that comes on? So if the light comes on, then you get in the cab. But you could be like the most perfect person ever, but if their light's not on, then they're just not interested. Right, okay. And that doesn't apply to women? Well, I was just about to say this, that a lot of the content is, although there are quite a lot of male, there are still male creators, a lot of the content is created by women and about women's experience of men.
13:01And that's not to say that there's not really valid stuff raised because there definitely is. I think there's something about, and this is probably a product of like decades, if not centuries of women feeling like, you know, particularly when women didn't have all of the kind of rights and autonomy that they have now, the women weren't able to talk about these things and share these things amongst themselves. And so now that they are, it's almost like on overdrive. Yeah. I mean, look, one of the kind of harsh realities of the modern dating world is that just because you have slept with someone or went on a couple of dates with someone, that person doesn't actually owe you anything.
13:35Other than like good communication, right? Like being clear about like what they want from it. But it's this idea that like, if I love this person, they have to love me. Exactly. And I do think that a lot of these terms and a lot of the more sinister terms that we're going to get into sometimes become misapplied when it's just like this person doesn't love, they don't like you, they're not into you. So you can come up with like, let's define the behavior as ghosting or they're anxious avoidant or they have a different love language or they're a narcissist or whatever. And it's just like, it didn't work out.
14:06That's what happened. It didn't work out here. Not to deny the experiences of people who have been ghosted. But they don't happen on the scale at which these videos and content would suggest, right? They kind of suggest that every relationship exhibits almost all of these things. There's this study that was done this year, actually, by Christine Redmond. So she's a researcher at University College Louvain, which is in Brussels. And she analysed 31 TikTok relationship advice videos. Here she is with her results. I found two broad kinds of language. There was clinical or clinical sounding terms such as attachment styles and nervous system regulation, which can make advice sound authoritative.
14:46Then there was everyday therapeutic language. Know your worth, show up, the bare minimum and do the work. That's less clinical, but it still creates standards for what a good partner and a good relationship should look like. A common pattern was identify a relation problem, explain it through psychological label and turn it into a task of individual self-work. Someone not replying might become avoidant. Feeling distressed about that might become anxious attachment. And the answer is to heal, regulate yourself or decide whether you've done enough work. the comments were really important too audiences are not passively receiving advice they're adding to it they're validating it and they're applying labels to other people in fact in my own sample narcissist appeared in comments rather than in the creator videos this suggests the comment section can become a kind of collective diagnosis room supportive at times but also a space where complex people and relationships can be pathologized from very little information.
15:57There was also a gender divide in this small sample. Non-qualified creators were more likely to use essentialist claims about men and women, for example, that men are simple or that women should adapt their communication to make the relationship work. A lot of the advice eventually asks, does this person meet your needs and should you leave or stay in the relationship? So The Atlantic interviewed a bunch of relationship therapists about this and they said that it's basically become impossible to do relationship therapy now because couples are coming in with all of this therapy speak. They've already diagnosed their partner as most commonly a narcissist, even though that's an incredibly rare personality disorder, right?
16:38Every ex is now a narcissist according to NarcTalk, which is a sector of TikTok, of people who are obsessed with diagnosing other people as narcissists. But they also diagnose their partners with everything from borderline personality disorder to ADHD, et cetera. And that's what's difficult, right? It's a lot of the things we're talking about here. There's two different buckets. You've got the sorts of behaviors that manifest in most relationships. And perhaps it's kind of valuable to hear from different people about their experiences of that and how they deal with it. Like, you know, when they're having an argument, like what are their good tactics for just like cooling off or like, you know, we take 20 minutes and then we come back or, you know, all that kind of stuff.
17:12Like it seems quite basic, but might be quite useful to people and then there's this that yeah there's this use of terms that are actually like clinical terms that are you know you require a proper diagnosis to know whether you've got a personality disorder or um specific narcissistic traits or even sort of like you know people are accused of being like sociopaths or psychopaths it's like all of those things require like proper clinical assessment not just watching a video on your social media feed and then being like oh this kind of reminds me of you and the second element of this is the algorithmic impact which is that because you're being recommended this stuff, particularly I think when, and I found this, when you get recommended something and you actually haven't looked it up, right?
17:49Like you haven't searched for it, you haven't been interested in it and you suddenly get it served to you. You're like, what is it about how I've been browsing on my feed or what I've been looking up or what I've been typing in in other browsers that has sent this my way, which then sort of makes you feel like it's more accurate that you're like, oh, well, there must be a reason I've been sent this. It's like that whole idea that, you know, people's social media feeds figured out that they, like their sexuality before they did kind of thing like you know figured out that they they might be a lesbian because of the content they were viewing and then they got push videos it's it's that kind of concept but with relationships so i've seen quite a few comments where people are like oh i hadn't even considered what was happening to me before was this but now this has been served to me i sort of think oh it must have been pushed to me for a reason and that's the problem with algorithms is that like algorithms are like automated recommendation systems based on engagement and based on the engagement of other users like us but we're human beings and when we get served something up it feels like it's meant for us like it was sent to us but it wasn't not in the traditional way of you know sitting down with a clinician or a psychotherapist or whoever and having a conversation and them saying oh i think what you're describing might be this it's not the same as that but it kind of feels like that i mean let's we should probably quickly talk about attachment theory because that is like the the in vogue relationship advice that everyone's talking about now right now it isn't pseudoscience it's like it's not astrology that it is a real thing but it is highly unlikely that you are using it correctly when you're talking about you or your partner's relationship because you've listened to a few podcasts and seen it on social media or whatever right it's also not as straightforward as just like you are this very clear-cut attachment style like all sorts of people might have different relationships with people in their lives and behave differently in those relationships so you might lean one way or another but it's not as clear-cut as it's made out right yeah and i and i think it'd be especially skeptical if any of these creators or advertisements or anything come with a quiz right because the quiz is sometimes they're ads sometimes they're ads as well i've noticed this stuff coming up like you'll have three creators and then you'll have a sponsor post that's like do this quiz and it'll tell you about yeah attachment style trauma all those sorts of things and the quizzes are often a sales funnel i mean we talked about this when we did our episode on adhd i mean studies have shown that like fewer than 50 percent of the things said about adhd on social media in the most popular videos are true.
20:00And yet more than half of the creators on TikTok talking about ADHD are using that to sell products like fidget spinners or courses for ADHD, people who have ADHD. It's similar to this kind of thing, right? The quiz funnels you and makes you feel as though it's a personalized experience. It's giving you a label and that label is then sold to you and then further products are sold to you down the line. Just on the attachment style content that pops up. I think one of the things that can be especially harmful or toxic about that content is it's often, it's not just framed as a kind of, this is how anxious attachment works or this is how it's usually in a sort of like self-help way.
20:38And it's usually in a like, here's what you can do to quote unquote fix or heal your own attachment issues or your partner's attachment issues. And so it's often like in this situation, if your partner does this, you should do this and in this situation obviously none of that knows any of the context of your own relationship but because it's quite didactic and it's quite like self-helpy and it feels like oh okay like it's really easy to see how that translates into real behavior and maybe in some cases that might not be that bad it might actually be useful and encourages people to sort of reflect on their own reactions but you can also imagine situations where people do actually sort of react according to what their feed is telling them and it it doesn't work and it's actually really unhelpful and even can you know result in the breakdown of a relationship because they're not really responding to the evidence in front of them they're doing what the content on their feed is telling them to do yeah but even the guy who wrote the book attached co-wrote co-authored it which started this craze has like expressed that he's like concerned about yeah and that's a book right so it's like got layers to it and citations and it's written by someone who's an expert and that gets us into something else important which is how much of this content is being made by people who do have a background in psychology or counselling or therapy or psychiatry even and how much of it is being made by people who have been a little bit infected by what we often call the sleuth disease and are talking about this stuff but don't they and they might be well intentioned right like they might be really interested in it or even have had their own personal experiences that have informed their interests but ultimately they don't have any qualifications and we see this around lots of examples of medical misinformation that i've looked into too now one of the creators who is is qualified to talk about this stuff and defends posting this kind of content is someone called Frankie's Therapy she's on Instagram um she has an MA in drama psychotherapy and she's an EMDR psychotherapist so EMDR is a form of trauma therapy and she has nearly half a million followers and this was what she had to say on social media I talk about trauma bond attachment and what healthy relationships actually look like and I think that social media can be amazing at providing psychoeducation in an easily relatable way.
22:46So I actually think it can be amazing when someone shares their personal experience online as I think this can really help other people feel less alone and as a therapist we're really limited in what we share about ourselves. However I think there's huge responsibility when it comes to psychological advice. So my main concern is for the person watching that they may start labelling everyone they date or recognise something in themselves and feel ashamed as though that makes them a bad person or incapable of having a healthy relationship. I think relationships are really complicated and I think often the advice that's being given from people who've not studied can really miss the great areas there and often patterns are villainized when they shouldn't be villainized so you know but ultimately it's not her videos about trauma bonding that are probably viewed by the largest number of people it'll be the people who have seen her videos come with their own interpretation and made their own video about their own experience and then that's what of them is pushing.
23:57This is also coming at a time, right, where we're living through what many have called a relationship recession. Like there is a decline in people coupling up in relationships, getting married, and that is leading to a decline in birth rates as well, which, you know, is leading to all sorts of wild and worrying political movements based around that decline in the birth rate. But that means that there is a large pool of relationship anxiety upon which these creators can draw from but i also wonder if these creators are contributing to that relationship anxiety like half of the reddit stories that you'll read about infidelity are so clearly fake and either written by ai chatbots and have such a like very clear villain and and and victim like character arcs that it's just so clearly written for engagement and i think that basically you shouldn't be looking to the internet for for relationship advice ever i think it's a counter saying that and I was looking at some of the videos about particularly about sort of harmful behaviors and emotionally abusive behaviors and in the context of domestic violence and emotional abuse I don't think it's a bad thing that people are aware of like stuff that's really not okay and I think that if you are in a relationship where and I think this is this is why like you can see why people turn to social media feeds because there's something about relationships that is so incredibly private and yet and talking to anyone in your life about it feels like you You know, you might be even suggesting that you're going to break up with someone.
25:22You don't want to verbalise those things because you don't want someone to think badly of that person or what have you. So you can so see why people turn to social media for advice. And I do think that there's something about, you know, for a very long time, it was very hard for people to kind of pull together their experiences and actually say, like, this kind of behaviour is not OK, it's unhealthy, it's toxic. That doesn't necessarily mean the person is a narcissist or that they're abusive. But for whatever reason, the situation isn't OK. I don't think it's a bad thing if people are aware of and empowered.
25:50The problem is, is that a lot of the sources of this information aren't necessarily credible. And I think that if you're listening to this and you've been seeing loads of this stuff on your social media feed and you are actually really worried about some of the behaviours you're experiencing in a relationship. If you go to BBC Action Line, there is lots of support there for help with mental health or other relationship issues.
26:14GTA 6 comes out this week which means that for the next like 72 hours slash a week large portions of the planet will be like living vicariously through the characters of GTA. I've actually never played the GTA games. I was just about to say do you do, because I, as you might imagine oh no, was it you that said actually I could imagine you playing GTA someone said that to me the other day. Really? I can't. You'd be surprised if people are coming out of the woodwork and being like i can't wait to play the gta game i'm like what you played i feel like i did like nintendogs and cooking mama and the gta really passed me by definitely the sims um yeah i know what my msn name was for like the longest time sim crazy oh wow you really were a sims super fan basically yeah i've played lots of like random games like cooking krabby patties with spongebob but i haven't played gta before neither have i but i feel like but let's talk about it exactly i mean it's been reported that an estimated 83 000 days have been booked off in the uk by employees to play this game uh in america some analysts have said that it's costing the u.s economy a billion dollars just people taking time off to play this game um it is like the biggest seems to be the biggest release in that i can ever remember in the history of gaming i mean for ages we had the meme of like we got x before gta 6 yeah it's definitely permeated my social media feeds in a way that i'd not yeah really seen before like i'd always thought of it as like you're either into gta and you go off and do that and consume that content or you're not and you don't get it whereas it's become a bit of a sort of like moment right online yeah absolutely which i'm sure deliberately so well i mean it seems earned it's a bit like barbenheimer where it's like those films yes it was a meme but like that's not just a marking gimmick like those were the two biggest releases of that year and they both were incredible films so like this and this game their views it's like i don't think a game has ever gotten this much universal acclaim before it's so immersive that like you're as you play the characters if you like eat lots of fatty foods your character gradually becomes fat if you like work out they gain muscles if you like go out all night on a bender then you you look tired a person doesn't really appeal to me like i don't like i have a real life i like i don't want to be like i don't know like changing nappies like in a game as well like it seems too immersive i feel like a game should be in gta probably it's so immersive i don't know if you have a baby with the but like but a lot with the characters but a lot of that count as cheating i don't know we let's ask tiktok well that's so that so that your bbc did slightly get um made fun of for posting an article i love when you say it like i am bbc You are though.
28:55You kind of are. You work here for a second. Where are you sitting? Yeah, I come here. I'm a freelancer. I look here from looking from the outside. I look here from in. Just kidding. Please give me more jobs, BBC. I love you. But in this case, the article was kind of funny because it was like, it was like asking young people whether like cheating in the game was acceptable. And it or like having a relationship in GTA is cheating. And it's like, of course, it's not like no one thinks that right. It's like reading a book about another couple is not cheating. But a lot of people don't realize that the company that makes GTA is British, right?
29:32And the game itself is kind of a British satire of American culture. And this one in particular is a satire of 2020 social media-driven culture. and you know it's based in a kind of um satirical it's based in a satirical version of florida and miami which have you been to miami recently i don't know if i've ever been to miami miami is the like the silicon valley like random bits of florida miami is literally like everyone in miami's like statistically miami has more top influencers per capita than any other like u.s metropolitan Halton area. And if you go there, if you like walk down Miami beach, literally everyone is either TikToking, everyone has an only fans, like it's the social media capital of the world.
30:18And that is of course why the developers who, by the way, in the making of this game, they were like hanging out in Miami to get inspiration. That's why this game is based there. And it is, they have like all the Florida man people in the game. So like, and you know, all the viral social media stories about crazy things happening in Florida, those are real things happen in the game there are real working social media feeds in the game your character has a phone that they can like take out in the game and scroll through social media so they basically accepted social media as like an element of the gameplay in a way exactly feels quite new yeah it feels like like i mean it it does feel like we are finally reaching this kind of point in our cultural history where I think the old powers that be in media and culture, the gaming studios, the Hollywood studios, like the television, et cetera, are now essentially playing catch up to social media.
31:17And I think you can kind of read into the James Bond casting thing in this way too, because first of all, this is the first time that the new Bond has been announced this time on instagram right in the past it was always some big real life event it was daniel craig on a speedboat down the thames or it was pierce brosnan you know and it was like through the traditional yeah exactly it was like it was like covered by the media and it felt like whereas this was this was instagram first right it was instagram first and i you have to remember right like real first real first and you know jeff bezos says he was heavily involved in this casting right amazon now own the franchise.
31:56And I think there is something that I don't want to extrapolate too much, but I think there is something you can say about a culture from this moment, because it's, if you look at like SNL UK and SNL US, it used to be that those shows were like how comedians were found and brought into the public light. But now they've just cast Instagram and TikTok comedians who are already famous on their own. And we've heard actors reporting that casting agents and execs are asking for like a total follower count of the cast of a TV show or a movie before they approve the cast. So we are kind of living in a world where you have to become famous on social media first and then like the industry gives you the step of approval.
32:41Yeah. And you sort of end up in this cycle where ultimately it's the social media platforms and the way that their algorithms work and the way that they're designed that are shaping cultural moments which is so the other way around to what we were used to before what i would say on james bond which i think is interesting too is that robert patterson is someone who is sort of recognized or known for his ability to court if not just sort of cruise through fandoms like phantoms are like a bit nuts at times i mean this in an affectionate way like they can be brilliant and they can absolutely make a franchise they can also come with quite toxic elements and someone like Robert Pattinson well Robert Pattinson himself has been he obviously did Twilight that's you've got a a large proportion of millennials who were totally consumed with that content and it was one of the kind of really early fandoms obviously he was also popped up in Harry Potter right like huge fandom not the same as the main actors in Harry Potter but nonetheless like was Cedric what was it Cedric Diggory yeah Cedric Diggory and then he's done Batman yeah he's Batman and James Bond and James Bond I mean there's all these jokes now about like he's every job right like yeah maybe he's gonna present top comment next week who knows yeah or he's gonna be a little bit like a little bit like it actually i think i think he's a bit pale of an you but that's maybe i'm thinking of him in his vampire sort of era yeah i mean look but anyway basically it feels like the choice although i'm sure like a lot of it was based around his ability oh he's clearly gonna be amazing at the role clearly but also these other things you imagine would have factored into the decision making which is like look he's someone who is a look like a bit of a cult hero in certain circles online, that is a very useful thing.
34:20And whether he has social media or not doesn't matter. People take to him well as a sort of figure and a character. In fact, him not having a social media profile almost makes it even better for them. So yeah, basically social media is shaping James Bond in the same way that it's shaping GTA. Exactly. I mean, when you take all of that, the fact that Hollywood is now looking to YouTube for its new directors, The fact that mainstream comedy is finding its talent from social media directly. The fact that this bond was announced on Instagram. And the fact that the biggest release in arguably gaming history, GTA 6, is itself a satire of social media in which there are real in-game social media feeds that you can access in the game on a phone your character has.
35:08I think it's difficult to conclude anything other than we have now passed the point in our cultural history where social media is defining who becomes famous, who becomes culturally relevant, and the old powers that be, the film studios, etc., the gaming studios, everything, are playing catch up. They are looking at social media for what to do. the thing that strikes me actually about everything we've talked about in this episode is that i spend a lot of time investigating people who believe really outlandish conspiracy theories that go beyond real examples of abuse of power etc and that focus on this idea that like shadowy forces are shaping the world around us and like they're they're dictating everything and deciding how it all works and that you need to turn to your social media feed as the way of escaping those shadowy forces when actually what we're talking about is how the social media feeds are the shadowy forces.
36:01Like the algorithms and the way that social media sites are designed and what they favour or don't favour and what they reward and don't reward. That is invisibly, on and off quite visibly, shaping the world around us. And it's that that you should be worried about way more than the kind of invented cabal. And what we investigate on Top Comment every week is how social media feeds are shaping and impacting all of our lives. So if there's something that you've spotted that you want us to look into that is affecting you, please do send us a message or a voice note on WhatsApp plus 44 330 123 9480 or you can email top comment at bbc.co.uk.
36:40Bye.
36:57everyone's talking about ai but to understand where it's going you need to understand where it came from what can the luddites teach us about technology replacing human work Can humanity learn from the nuclear age before creating something else it can't control? The future of AI didn't begin with ChatGPT. It began centuries ago. This is the global backstory Superintelligence. Five special episodes exploring the history behind the biggest story of our future. Listen to the global story wherever you get your BBC podcasts.
The internet is full of other people’s relationships. But how much of the advice out there is actually reliable? What are people being told online, and what impact is it having on their real-life relationships? In this episode of Top Comment, Marianna and Matt iron out what Cuffing season and Breadcrumbing mean, so you don't have to. They discuss how more psychological and clinical terms such as Attachment Theory and Narcissist are being simplified and used incorrectly, at times to sell products. And they hear from researchers and creators on how the algorithmic effect can lead you down a rabbit hole of labelling yourself and others.
Plus, in case you hadn't noticed, Grand Theft Auto V1 is out. What do GTA 6, James Bond and SNL have in common? After more than a decade of development and many months of hype, the Scottish video game is a satire of American social media culture, with its fictional take on Miami, the influencer capital of the world. The next James Bond was announced on Instagram, rather than at a traditional press event. Meanwhile, Hollywood and mainstream comedy are increasingly turning to social media to find their next stars. Does all this mark the moment when social media has taken control of popular culture?
Top Comment is hosted by Marianna Spring and Matt Shea. Made by Emma Close and Sophie Milward. The editor is Justine Lang. The senior news editor is Sam Bonham. If you want to get in touch about something that's popped up on your feed, our email address is [email protected] or you can send us a WhatsApp on +44 330 123 9480.