1. Podcasts
  2. Top Comment
  3. Frances Haugen: exposing Facebook five years on
Top Comment

9 Oct 2026 · 44m · 26 chapters

Episode artwork

Frances Haugen: exposing Facebook five years on

In short

Discussion of Frances Haugen’s 2021 Facebook whistleblowing, the film The Social Reckoning, and whether accountability has improved five years later. Haugen argues Meta’s systems are “content agnostic” but can knowingly choose not to fix algorithmic bias toward anger/divisiveness for engagement; she says incentives and Mark Zuckerberg’s insulated decision-making drive continued harm. She highlights uneven safety investment (e.g., 11% of users spoke English but over half the safety budget went to English), and how Facebook became “the internet” in places with limited alternatives, worsening misinformation and conflict. Notable examples include Myanmar and Ethiopia information operations. She also cites litigation: school-district class actions and large damages estimates, plus ongoing individual suits.

Guests

Frances Haugen (data scientist/software engineer; Facebook whistleblower who provided ~20,000 pages of documents to the Wall Street Journal in 2021). Other referenced figures: Jeff Horowitz (WSJ journalist), Brandon Silverman (ex-CrowdTangle), Sarah Wynne Williams (former Facebook employee; memoir Careless People), Daniel (Kenyan content moderator), and Mark Zuckerberg (Meta CEO).

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

0:30

Discussing 'The Social Reckoning'

Overview of the film about Frances Haugen and Facebook's impact.

“Listen to Choiceology at schwab.com slash podcast or wherever you listen.”
1:10

Discussing 'The Social Reckoning'

Overview of the film about Frances Haugen and Facebook's impact.

“we want to connect people all around the world.”
2:08

Whistleblowing Context

Importance of discussing the evolution of social media accountability.

“Clue, it feels that it's perhaps got even more insane since then.”
2:44

Introducing Frances Haugen

Frances Haugen shares her background and experiences as a whistleblower.

“Like, it's a strange time for this film to come out because it kind of tells the story of the whistleblowing and it's sort of like, and then the Wicked Witch of the West died.”
3:21

The Fear of Whistleblowing

Frances describes the anxiety and risks she faced while gathering evidence.

“But back in 2021, I brought forward about 20 ,000 pages of Facebook documents.”
4:25

Meta's Content Choices

Frances discusses Meta's algorithm and its impacts on society.

“And you can see my reflection and a scattering of them.”
6:12

Mark Zuckerberg's Leadership

Insights into Mark Zuckerberg's influence and decisions at Meta.

“That kind of engagement arms race, essentially, between the companies.”
8:06

Shifting Public Opinion

Frances discusses how public perception of social media companies has changed.

“We are going to ask about that film more in a moment.”
11:44

Impact on Youth and Society

Exploration of how social media affects children's behavior and societal norms.

“Is it technology and societal choices and future outlook?”
14:00

The Scale of Facebook's Global Impact

Learn about the extensive reach of Facebook and its implications for safety and regulation.

“So the core complaint I brought forward five years ago was that Facebook claimed they really, really cared about keeping all their users safe.”
Show all 26 chapters
14:58

Consequences of Whistleblowing

Understand the harsh repercussions faced by whistleblowers in tech.

“where the internet was still maturing at a much faster rate than it is in, say, the UK and the United States, and telling people, like, if you use our products, we'll pay for your data.”
17:27

The Case of Sarah Wynne-Williams

Explore the legal challenges faced by former Facebook employees.

“I never intended to be a public whistleblower.”
20:00

Meta's PR Strategy and Public Perception

Examine Meta's public relations efforts in response to criticism.

“So it really is a unique level of persecution that she has experienced.”
22:46

Litigation Impacting Social Media Companies

Learn about ongoing lawsuits and their implications for social media firms.

“But the reality is there's still like two, three big chunks of litigation that are not resolved.”
24:25

The Release of 'The Social Reckoning'

Discover insights about the movie adaptation of Frances Haugen's experience.

“the Aaron Sorkin film about your story that's out this week.”
26:31

The Evolution of Tech Whistleblowing

Analyze the changing landscape of whistleblowing in the tech industry.

“is that you can see the stuff sort of inside or the experiences inside companies that are otherwise very difficult to see within and to penetrate.”
28:03

The Evolution of Whistleblowing in Tech

Learn how the landscape of whistleblowing in tech has changed since Frances Haugen's revelations about Facebook.

“Like we didn't have a normalization of dissent or the idea that you need to dissent.”
29:33

The Need for Independent Oversight in AI

Explore the importance of independent auditors in AI development and the need for accountability.

“One of the things I'm very, very heartened by is just a couple weeks ago, Dario Amadei, the Anthropic CEO, came forward and said, hey, we need independent external auditors embedded inside of frontier AI companies.”
31:06

Future Generations and Social Media

Discuss the potential long-term impacts of social media on younger generations and the need for intervention.

“Like where do you think we'll get to in 10 years time, 20 years time in terms of what that accountability could look like?”
33:09

Frances Haugen's Parenting Choices

Understand Frances Haugen's perspective on raising children in a digital age and the privilege involved.

“Would you let your kids use social media, Frances?”
34:24

Depiction of Whistleblowers in Film

Learn about the portrayal of whistleblowers in media and the challenges in accurately depicting their experiences.

“Because because being a whistleblower, I think, actually is like two or three phases.”
36:19

Depiction of Whistleblowers in Film

Learn about the portrayal of whistleblowers in media and the challenges in accurately depicting their experiences.

“is like spending a Saturday at a great farmer's market.”
36:51

Reflections on Social Media's Impact

Examine the ongoing effects of social media on society post-Haugen's whistleblowing and recent developments.

“Since chatting to Haugen, you and I both saw the film, Mariana, last night at the press screening.”
42:00

Impact of Whistleblowing on Social Media Perception

Discusses how Frances Haugen's whistleblowing has changed public perception of social media companies.

“Very much so now, perhaps even more so than it was before.”
43:20

Meta's Response to Allegations

Explores Meta's defense regarding allegations from Haugen and the actions taken against critics.

“You know, you see the immense degree of internal and external processes that Meta has in place to prevent negative press, to prevent what they're actually doing, getting out to the public.”
44:39

Invitation for Listener Engagement

Encourages listeners to reach out with social media topics for investigation.

“Now Matt, there are winners and losers to social media contributing to the world going to shit and we happen to maybe be the winners.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On Top Comment, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK.

0:30Listen to Choiceology at schwab.com slash podcast or wherever you listen.

1:00It's everything your business needs in one place, saving you time, headaches, and serious money. Stop paying for missing pieces. Go to odoo.com. That's O-D-O-O dot com to learn more.

1:15You've woken up in the metaverse. You don't have any legs. We are a corkboard. Is that kind of good? We are the town square. Senator, we are more of a town square. we want to connect people all around the world. We're aware of the problem and we're working on it. We are aware of that. Okay, that was our addition to be Mark Zuckerberg because Matt and I have bitten and watched The Social Reckoning, which is the new Aaron Sorgan film that's out all about social media, whistleblowing, and simply Facebook. It dramatizes the story of the Facebook whistleblower Frances Haugen and her relationship with the Wall Street Journal journalist.

1:56Jeff Horowitz. Jeff Horvitz. And in it, Jeremy Strong plays a much better Mark Zuckerberg than we just did. And obviously, top comment is for investigating social media, not film reviews. But the reason that we want to talk about this one is because it provokes quite an important discussion about how much the world has evolved since Francis Haugen blew the whistle on Facebook and released all these documents called the Facebook files through the Wall Street Journal. Clue, it feels that it's perhaps got even more insane since then. And basically that the social media companies have almost become more defensive in their attempts to avoid accountability, although there's lots of litigation and regulation.

2:36Right. So we actually interviewed the real whistleblower, Francis Haugen, before he went to go see his film. So we're going to play that interview in a bit and then discuss the film. But yeah, you're right. Like, it's a strange time for this film to come out because it kind of tells the story of the whistleblowing and it's sort of like, and then the Wicked Witch of the West died. But in reality, after the events depicted in this film, things got a lot worse. So we're going to discuss that and also how the real story potentially differs from what's depicted in the film.

3:10Frances, could you start by telling me who you are? Hi, my name is Frances Haugen and I am a data scientist. I'm a software engineer, but I'm most frequently known as the Facebook whistleblower, though there are many Facebook whistleblowers. But back in 2021, I brought forward about 20 ,000 pages of Facebook documents. And it led to things like a lot of the pressure around passing the DSA in Europe and the recent AG lawsuits in the United States. I remember at the time when the information that you had gathered was released. I remember being added to that consortium of journalists and looking at that content.

3:46A blast from the past. Yeah, well, exactly. And one of the things that has always stayed with me, actually, was so Francis took pictures of loads of different internal documents, particularly around issues like misinformation, the safety of teenagers and kids and the impact on them and all sorts of other things as well around human trafficking, issues in other bits of the world where there was a feeling that perhaps less effort was going into moderating content and protecting communities. And I remember, Francis, in the pictures, you could see your reflection sometimes. Oh, yeah. There's apparently an artist who did an exposition where they just put up the frames that had, like, my reflection in them.

4:22They got a hold of them somehow. And so it's, like, all, like, random frames of Facebook things. And you can see my reflection and a scattering of them. What was going through your head when you were taking those pictures at the time? It was an incredibly scary period of time. Less because, like, I thought something was going to happen to me. Like, just for context, like, until Sarah Wynne Williams was sued by Facebook. Facebook had never gone after another Facebook whistleblower. It's not like I feared like legal repercussions, but every day I was dealing with subjects inside of Facebook where like people's lives were on the line.

4:52And it was very clear to me at the time that if I got caught before I was done, no one else was going to get to finish. Because it was very clear that Facebook would close all the doors as soon as they knew that they had that vulnerability. And after I came forward, they did shut down lots and lots of their internal access to information. So it wasn't like an unfounded fear. But every single day was just like this looming anxiety of like, is today the day that I get caught? I think a lot of the things that you've leaked and discussed come down to kind of one fundamental question. Do you think that meta pushes content knowingly and intentionally that makes people angry, that harms society for profit?

5:31I would say they may think of their systems as being, quote, content agnostic. So content agnostic means we don't have like a list of topics where we're like, these are the topics we prefer. They would say, we just show people what they like. But if you get told that your algorithm has a bias towards encouraging content that is emotionally evocative, and the shortest path to a click is anger, or a shortest path to a click is divisiveness, things that alienate people. If you get told, hey, you have a bias in your algorithm and you choose not to fix it, at some point it becomes a knowing choice.

6:03So I don't think they ever set out to intentionally make things worse. But when they were told they had options to make things better, they chose not to take them. One of the things that I found speaking to insiders from within all of the major social media companies since you decided to become a whistleblower is how much they highlight what you've discussed there. That kind of engagement arms race, essentially, between the companies. And there's one insider I spoke to who was someone who used to run CrowdTangle, who worked at Facebook, Brandon Silverman, who you probably know. And he said something to me in a recent investigation I did that there was this calcifying of defensiveness within Meta more broadly, Facebook and Instagram, about the way that they could be inflaming the problem rather than fixing it.

6:51How do you feel the situation has evolved, changed or not since you came out and spoke about this? So there is a movie coming out called The Social Reckoning, which is like a dramatization of a lot of my experiences around whistleblowing. But it's as much about Mark Zuckerberg and like what is his experience of leading the company. And one of the things that I felt like rang really true is, you know, I think most people are not aware of how much inside of Facebook all decisions flow back to Mark. That because he has the majority of voting shares, like in terms of being a shareholder, he has the majority of the votes.

7:24His opinion is the only one that matters. And I think one of the things that has really gone worse since I came forward is I think Mark had a sense of, you know, you're damned if you do, you're damned if you don't. As of like maybe 2020, you know, around the 2020 election, I would say even today, it's even more so where, you know, it is not clear to me that he has integrated the feedback that he's received from me, from others over the last five years. and especially as we see them begin to dabble in AI and these like augmented reality glasses, it doesn't seem any of the old lessons have been learned.

7:59And so unless we change the circumstances and the incentives around these companies, we're going to continue to see the same kinds of bad behavior. Thank you for bringing up The Social Reckoning. We are going to ask about that film more in a moment. But just on Mark Zuckerberg, you've recently said that he is not evil. You know, he's someone who's apologized on a number of occasions. Can you just give us a little bit of an insight into him as a character? Like, what do you think is going on inside his head? How morally culpable do you think he feels about all of this? You know, I think Mark Zuckerberg is such a fascinating human being from the perspective of there have been very, very, very humans in all of human history with as much power as Mark Zuckerberg, who have been as insulated from consequences as Mark Zuckerberg.

8:42Like, most of the powerful CEOs in the world, they are constantly in an evaluation loop, right? Like their jobs are not guaranteed forever. If they make mistakes, they can be removed. They have to engage with both the public and, say, their shareholders, their employees. The way humans learn, the way we mature and become like fully realized adults is by dealing with consequences. Like there's been a whole bunch of research on how do people evolve as like moral agents. And it comes down to facing consequences. And it's not even like, oh, you got arrested, you got a DUI. No, it's like, did you see the pain that you caused that person you cared about?

9:16And the challenge with Mark is that he has been the CEO of Facebook since he was 19 years old. You know, if the first Social Network movie was about, like, what is the experience of, like, a perhaps too powerful 25-year-old, you know, what happens when someone has another 15 years to continue down that path? And, you know, we know from reporting from The Wall Street Journal, from The New York Times, that Mark has chosen to begin living a life that is incredibly isolated. So he's bought all of his neighbors' houses in Palo Alto and kind of merged them into a single compound. We know from that reporting that his kids go to like a one-room schoolhouse for their pod on that compound.

9:52So they don't go to school and interact with the public. You know, he has a compound in Hawaii that has hundreds of acres and tunnels and bunkers. We have to ask the question, like, what kind of experience of the world causes someone to turn that inward, like compels them to? And part of that is the series of choices he has made has angered the public to an extent where, you know, even at the height of Doge, you know, right after the Trump election, Elon Musk is running through the U.S. government, cutting things, firing people. You know, even at the height of Doge, Elon Musk had substantially better popularity numbers than Mark Zuckerberg.

10:26And so I think he's a fascinating character. And unfortunately, we all live with the consequences of the choices that he's made. I mean, that is quite a biting criticism because if I'm reading you correctly, you're sort of saying that he hasn't matured and grown up into adulthood, that he's sort of an eternal child in a way. And it does make me think about his recent wardrobe change. Have you seen the gold chains? You know, like what's the latest flavor of Mark this week, right? I always worry, Frances, that Matt might turn up at our interviews with some gold chains on. You never know. Yeah, that's sort of – What level of curls does he have this week?

11:02Is he a show beach boy this week? He does look better, though, I think. He looks better. Well, he's tried to rebrand right. And I think this actually leads to another important question to ask you, Francis, which is you mentioned that the popularity or rather lack of popularity when it comes to Mark Zuckerberg and Facebook, Instagram, Meta more generally. Do you feel like there's been a shift in public opinion around the social media companies since you first came out and shared the information that you did? Because I find in terms of people getting in touch with me, there seems to be widespread concern about these companies in a way that didn't exist even back in 2018, 2019.

11:43The tech clash. Yeah, I would say I think one of the phenomenons that we are only kind of beginning to understand the scope of and we are going to be wrestling with for a while to come is there is very clearly a generational wave happening in terms of the impact of we don't know if it's just technology. Is it technology and societal choices? Is it technology and societal choices and future outlook? There's some kind of generational change where kids are showing up for school substantially less prepared. They're having trouble sitting in class. We're seeing higher rates of violence in the classroom, in other places in society for young people.

12:16For example, a lot of malls in the United States no longer let people be in the mall by themselves under the age of like 16, which is very, very foreign. You know, when I was a 12-year-old, 13-year-old, you could go hang out at the mall with your friends. I can't do that anymore in a lot of places in the United States because the 12 - and 13-year-olds behave too badly. I think there is a real perception that we have to be examining what is a digital childhood and how does that shape and affect what kind of person you become. And, you know, if we go back five years, you know, just six weeks before the first Wall Street Journal story on the Facebook files came out, the U.S.

12:49Senate sent Facebook a letter and said, hey, we want to see any research you have regarding the well-being of kids. And Facebook felt invincible enough that they sent back a letter that was like a complete non-response. There is no generally accepted amount of time that is considered the safe amount of time for a child to use social media, which is not a response to show us your research. Right. And today, you know, that we live in enough different of a world five years later that we have a legally mandated cap of two hours a day for Instagram, at least in the United States, for kids under the age of 16.

13:24You know, you're not allowed to send notifications to kids during a school day because we now have consensus, or at least 47 U.S. states have consensus that when you send notifications to kids during a school day, it impacts their ability to focus in school. You can't send them notifications late at night. I think there is a greater willingness to say, hey, these systems are really intimately intrusive in our lives. Do we want to have that for our most vulnerable members of our society? And that is a real change that has happened since I came forward. One of the things that I think really struck me about your initial whistleblowing was, I think you said you were at the time referring to vaccine misinformation.

13:59And you said something like, in the English speaking world, attempts to clamp down on these posts are barely there, but in the rest of the world, they're almost non-existent. And I think where the alleged harms that you referred to become kind of dizzying in their scale is when you remember that this is a global company that actually is everywhere in every country on almost every child's phone and every adult's phone too. So the core complaint I brought forward five years ago was that Facebook claimed they really, really cared about keeping all their users safe. Yet, even though only 11 % of users spoke English, over half of the safety budget went towards English speakers.

14:35Wow. And that's because, you know, Meta's an American company. They're afraid of having people have bad experiences in the U.S. and push for regulation. At the time, there was only a handful of languages, like maybe 20 or 30 languages that had any safety systems. You know, there's thousands of languages in the world. Most of those languages had no safety systems. And the place where this gets dangerous is, and this is the thing that did change in the wake of my whistleblowing, for years and years and years, Facebook was going into countries where the internet was still maturing at a much faster rate than it is in, say, the UK and the United States, and telling people, like, if you use our products, we'll pay for your data.

15:12If you use anything else on the web, you're going to pay for it yourself. And in many, many, many corners of the world, Facebook basically became the internet. You know, when you don't have your own website, you use a Facebook page because, you know, everyone uses Facebook. Maybe even in a lot of cases, like newspapers wouldn't have their own page. They would just have a Facebook group that they controlled so they could push it out to subscribers. That version of the internet where you are completely dependent on Facebook, right, where the network effects mean it's very, very hard for people to disengage.

15:42that's where it gets really really profoundly dangerous and we've seen this play out with with incredibly bad consequences in places like Myanmar where the government of Myanmar literally sent their own military officers to Russia to learn how to run information operations against their own people or places like Ethiopia where you saw expats you know people who had left the country actively running information operations on people back in Ethiopia inflaming the the civil were there. At the time, Frances, you said that you weren't so scared about repercussions from Facebook itself, but rather some of the other consequences.

16:19Since you decided to blow the whistle on the company, other people who have done similar, although in different contexts, have faced quite harsh restrictions, backlash, consequences. Why do you think there's been that change? So the two that jump out the most for me are one, a man named Daniel. Daniel is a content moderator out of Kenya who sued on behalf of the content moderators who were experiencing severe mental health issues. Imagine every day looking at graphic violence from these platforms as like your primary job. They alleged human trafficking because a lot of those people were brought in from places like South Africa on contracts that were very punishing if they tried to leave.

16:59And people like Sarah Wynne Williams, who was a relatively early employee at Facebook, who wrote a memoir detailing her interactions with Mark Zuckerberg and Sheryl Sandberg. And I think in both those cases, part of why they faced such ruinous consequences. So in the case of Sarah Wynne Williams, I think the legal penalties at this point have accumulated up to like hundreds of millions of dollars, which is like clearly more than she'll ever be able to pay. They're very, very, very afraid that anyone will ever confirm the allegations. So in my case, like I brought out a huge amount of documentation.

17:29I never intended to be a public whistleblower. Like, that was a decision that happened very, very, very late in the game in my whistleblowing journey. And so I always designed the disclosures such that, you know, they could stand on their own. Like, I was very methodical about how they're organized, you know, what topics, that kind of thing. And in their cases, like, you know, a lot of the allegations that are being made are ones where either they'd be incredibly disruptive to the industry, right? Like, the role of these human moderators is one of these things that most people who sit just looking at their phone, you never realize that there are people basically in factories forced to look at the worst of the internet every day.

18:08That's kind of like one of the dirty secrets of the internet. They don't want those people to organize. They don't want them to be raising these experiences because people would ask a lot of questions. And the meta glasses just shows like an even more intimate level because we now know that these glasses are sending photos back to these same moderators. And so we want people to even more not imagine that there could be a human on the other end. And on Sarah Wynne-Williams, Frances, the response from Meta to her allegations that she makes in her book, it's been very different to the approach they had to you.

18:39They've been much harsher in terms of not wanting her to speak out. What do you make of that? Why do you think that Facebook has taken the approach it has to her? So I think in the case of Sarah Wynne-Williams, you know, she had very, very close access to both Mark and Cheryl. and they need to make sure that no one else ever comes forward and validates the issues that she raised. So because, you know, she wasn't carrying an audio recorder around and recording her conversations with these people, she wasn't hacking the video surveillance system and taking back film clips. It really is her word versus theirs.

19:13But if you had even one other person come forward and confirm the experiences that she had, it would be incredibly damning both to Sheryl and Mark's brands. I believe she was like one of the first foreign policy kind of advisors to Facebook. So she was brought in around the time period when Arab Spring happened. And she was got to see a very fascinating window of time. Her memoir, Careless People, I think is a really, really good piece of reading to understand like, how did we end up with the internet that we ended up with? Just because a very small number of people made a lot of very important decisions that have shaped how politics and other things have played out.

19:47And today, the gag order extends so far that when she is invited to panels, she's not allowed to say anything once she gets there. Or even her physical presence is being alleged to be validation for the concerns raised by other people against the company. So it really is a unique level of persecution that she has experienced. I mean, they're not doing themselves any favors, it seems, in their effort to not look like an evil company. I mean, saying you are not allowed to sit down silently at this event. I mean, what do you think about their strategy in the wake of you and Wynne Williams and all these other whistleblowers and all this tech clash that we're experiencing?

20:26Do you think that they're handling it well from a PR perspective? So it's interesting. There's a scene in the movie where the communications coach is trying to get Mark to exhibit communication that at least appears empathetic. You know, and they tell them, you know, you should acknowledge what people feel, you know, explain why they felt the way they felt and like say what you found in order to address these issues. And a great example of how like very clearly the message has just not gone through to at least mark is in the case of the recent augmented reality glasses. If your listeners have been following along, there is a concern around violating other people's privacy.

21:01There's a small fraction of users, though still a meaningfully large number of them, who have been doing things like running YouTube channels where they go up to women and put them into embarrassing situations because the women don't realize that they're being videotaped. Or people taking them into intimate environments like locker rooms or other places where people would, like you would notice if someone had their phone out and it was filming you. And in the recent product update, Mark got up there and announced like there's not going to be one kind of glasses, there's going to be two kinds of glasses.

21:29There's now going to be a version of these glasses that does not have a camera. And I watched an interview with him where a journalist kind of teed up a softball for him where they said, you know, we noticed there's no camera in one of your models now. Like, that's awesome. Like, did you hear the concerns that people didn't want to spy on their friends and neighbors? And he's like, oh, no, no, no, no. It's just it's so much cheaper to not put a camera in them. Like, there's always going to be people who want the cheapest version. And like when you don't put a camera in, the glasses look like normal glasses and it's like wow like it's quite possible that no one has told him i feel so bad for his handlers and his pr managers yeah it's just wild but it feels quite kind of emperor's emperor's new clothes almost like that idea that yes people are are not telling him that information or for whatever reason he's not not internalizing yeah not internalizing it and i've often felt that when i'm right of replying all of the major social media companies to be honest they'll respond to with a statement that is just completely contradicts what you've just revealed to them or put to them that can make you feel like almost like you're being gaslit a bit, like you're going a bit mad.

22:31I wonder just on that point about the perception of the social media companies, what do you think about the litigation ongoing in the US and the impact that that's having on the perception of the companies? So one of the things I'm always trying to remind people of is that it may feel like we reached the end of the race with like the big 47 state settlement with Instagram. But the reality is there's still like two, three big chunks of litigation that are not resolved. So for context, there's a giant class action litigation involving school districts. So schools are alleging that they had to spend substantially more on physical security, like security guards, on tutors, on mental health professionals, because of choices that Instagram made intentionally around their product.

23:15So this is things like Meta ran a variety of experiments to help kids experience less anxiety because of the platform or interrupt them less at school, and then chose not to actually launch those experiments because of very, very small impacts on their business. So, you know, 1 % fewer minutes spent, not even necessarily money, basic business metrics. And that lawsuit, experts have estimated, may reach north of$200 billion,$300 billion. Like, it's a big, big lawsuit. We still have all the individual kids and family lawsuits that have just started being to move through the court system. So the first one of those verdicts happened in Los Angeles a few months ago.

23:51And so it's one of these things where I think we are going to see a very, very interesting next few years. And remember, every time one of these settlements happens, it cements further in the public's mind that this is not the opinion of a whistleblower. This is not the opinion of some academic somewhere. This is a group of everyday people sat down on a jury and were presented with internal documents from these companies and came out and said, no, you're responsible. And that's a very different kind of assignment of blame than having me come up here and say, I have concerns. So, okay, you've mentioned it twice already.

24:24Let's talk about the movie, The Social Reckoning, the Aaron Sorkin film about your story that's out this week. Do you feel like the film captures kind of the core of what it is that you spoke out about? You know, one of the things I'm most grateful about the movie is it's going to sound weird for maybe people sitting on the other side of the pond, but in the United States, even though maybe only 10 % of the documents I brought out involved kids, the public perception often and why I do interviews today is the primary reason I came forward was because of the well-being of children. The issues around Facebook's differential impact outside the United States, their lack of protections for people who don't speak English, even things like societal violence, right?

25:05Like the fact that Facebook did not fix the algorithm when they found out changes were causing more polarization. That has faded into history up until now. And one of the things I'm extremely excited about the movie is the movie does a really good job of synthesizing down at least three memoirs. So I know two of them. I'm pretty sure on the third one. It's like a thousand nonfiction pages. They have successfully synthesized that down to about a two-hour movie. And one of the things that I think they did really, really well is for the parts that they present, which is the core of my original complaint, right?

25:38These things around like the algorithm is impacting our lives in very intimate ways and we are not being told the truth about it. I think they do an incredibly good job of both depicting how did Jeff and I get to a point where we could make that case to the public? Because remember, when I came to Jeff, I had some things that I knew for sure. And there were other things that I didn't know the why of, like how do all these little wires connect to each other? And the movie does an incredibly good job of kind of capturing the excitement of discovery, of like figuring out how the murder mystery, like all like, you know, the clues fit together.

26:09But it also shows very vividly the societal consequences. And I'm not going to spoil, I don't want to spoil the ending, but helping connect these kind of abstract issues around things like code to our everyday lives. The film focuses a lot on the experience of whistleblowing. And I think one of the things that's always helpful, actually, when you see these experiences brought to life via fiction or via art, I guess, is that you can see the stuff sort of inside or the experiences inside companies that are otherwise very difficult to see within and to penetrate. And I say that as a journalist who would quite like to do that a lot of the time.

26:48What do you think about the evolution of the tech whistleblower? Because we've seen loads of new whistleblowers, especially in the realm of AI, you know, people just posting on X, like, I'm really worried about this, which feels worlds away from you, you know, diligently gathering together all of these photos of documents where you could see your face in them. What do you make of the people blowing the whistle on the AI companies and how that has changed and evolved in the past five years? So one of the things I often find myself having to provide context on, especially when I talk to young adults.

27:21So I sometimes go to high schools, I sometimes go to colleges. There is a lot of concern about the future. Like people feel like a sense of doom, you know, like how can we have hope for the future? And one of the things that I often try to remind them of is that, you know, AI and nuclear weapons are often drawn as like analogs to each other. Like they're both things that can have the power to end the world. But if you went back in time to like 1960, which was like right before we got going on things like the Tusban Treaty, there wasn't yet a culture of dissent. You know, there were so few people protesting against nuclear weapons that the police felt it was valid to do things like beat Dorothy Day, who was like a Catholic worker, on like the steps of City Hall in New York to the point where she had broken bones, right?

28:05Like we didn't have a normalization of dissent or the idea that you need to dissent. And the thing that I find so exciting about watching the AI whistleblower today versus like what I went through five years ago was I had to come forward with that many documents because Facebook had spent or the tech in general had spent decades telling us that there was nothing dangerous here. The Internet is for looking at pictures of cats. Really, that's the classic line. It's for pictures of your cousin's breakfast. It's not something that could shape our politics could shape how the course of our society.

28:35And what's exciting for me about seeing, one, many, many more whistleblowers, two, seeing more men. So before me, a much larger fraction of all tech whistleblowers were women. Now there are a lot more men who are speaking out. And I think part of that is that we have normalized this idea that tech people have a responsibility to be kind of like the last line of defense until we can get in place a larger, more systemic version of societal oversight. But lastly, I think people understand now that as our economy shifts from being like a physical one where like, you know, we can all take this phone apart, right?

29:10People do. You can watch YouTube videos of people taking my iPhone apart. We can't go home and take apart ChatGPT. We can't go home and take apart Claude. We have to have those employees inside the company speak out if something is wrong. And so I'm very grateful to see kind of this diversification of whistleblowing and that people clearly feel it's urgent enough that they need to come forward. So how do we solve all these issues? Oh, just that's easy. One of the things I'm very, very heartened by is just a couple weeks ago, Dario Amadei, the Anthropic CEO, came forward and said, hey, we need independent external auditors embedded inside of frontier AI companies.

29:48And they need to have full access to data, like they need to have employee level access to data so that when we say something about what's going on, someone who is not an employee can independently confirm whether or not that is true. And for context, like five years ago when I appeared before the Senate, because we're actually like five years almost to the day now, you know, that was one of the core things that I asked the Senate for. And the reason why like just even some of these very minimal interventions are so essential, like the first step to us having something more robust is people need to remember that when we went forward in the United States and regulated the car companies, there were probably 100 ,000 automotive engineers in the world between Europe, United States, Japan, various places.

30:29You would get a PhD in automotive engineering from a number of different universities. You cannot today get a PhD in frontier AI models. You can't get a master's degree in AI model frontier policy. Like we are inventing a lot of this on the fly. And the more people that can be exposed to the actual reality of what we are building, the better perspectives we will have, insights we will have on how to govern them more holistically. So the first step is access and transparency because that helps people stay honest, motivates them to do the right thing. And then we need to continue to have these discussions to figure out what's the robust long-term path forward.

31:05There's often discussion about litigation versus regulation and what ultimately will bring about accountability for the social media companies. Something I've heard recently as well, speaking to lawyers who are considering cases being brought in other places, not just the US, against the social media companies, is this idea that there's a generation of young people aged right now between, say, 15 and 25 who could in the future essentially kind of ask for almost something akin to reparations from the social media companies. Like where do you think we'll get to in 10 years time, 20 years time in terms of what that accountability could look like?

31:40I think you're not extending the age range down far enough. You know, when we look at eight and nine year olds today, something like a third of seven to nine year olds had social media accounts just a couple of years ago. Right. So one of the things that we don't know how it's going to play out is like how effectively we're actually going to keep, you know, some of these younger kids off of these platforms. But the kids who are showing up for, say, seventh grade, they're 13 years old. They're already showing up with the results of years and years of exposure to systems like YouTube, Instagram, TikTok.

32:10And I think we are going to be facing some very, very hard societal conversations about what happens to a 22-year-old who has been online for six to eight hours a day, basically since they could operate a phone. And we are going to have to figure out what does it mean to rehabilitate people so they can actually connect in person. Because one of the things that we are starting to see more and more of is young adults and teenagers having relationships with AIs. Right? Like if you're someone who has been, you largely had an online childhood, you may be very deep in games, it might be much, much easier for you to connect with a virtual person than a real person.

32:50Are we going to lose a generation or a large chunk of a generation to people who don't have kind of the scaffolding of skills that allows them to connect face to face? I think right now we are right on course that we are going to have to confront this and we should start having conversations now about how to either intervene earlier or what do we owe each other? Given that these people in many ways were like sacrificed to our laissez-faire oversight of these tech companies. Would you let your kids use social media, Frances? So I have a two-year-old and currently she thinks Bluey is a thing that magically appears on planes.

33:28That's the only place that she gets tablets or like laptops. We took her to the Plantarium at the Natural History Museum in New York recently and she did not engage. She was like, I don't understand the concept of moving things that are not humans. So we're going to try to keep her off screens as long as possible. And we have gone to quite great lengths to make sure that she has. And this is a great example of privilege, right? We have the awareness that we need to build an in-person life for her. We have the time. We have the motivation to make sure she has little kids that she plays with. We go to that effort to make sure that's there.

33:59But not all kids have access to that. And I hope part of the money that comes through for the settlements goes into investing in more kids having the option to be able to connect in person with other children. Because that's what we need to have a really robust future. Very quickly, how do you see in Enora and what do you feel like being played by Mikey Madison in this film? I think Mikey does an amazing job of capturing like how emotionally intense the experience was of being a whistleblower. Right. Because because being a whistleblower, I think, actually is like two or three phases. There's like the period of time before you realize you will have to blow the whistle.

34:37And that period of time is incredibly discouraging because most whistleblowers are really conscientious people who like their companies. You know, like they're not these disgruntled employees like they come forward instead of just walking away because they want to see change. She did a very good job of the kind of expressing how lonely that experience is. And she did an amazing job of documenting, you know, it's not a linear path. And I loved getting to revisit that time that I worked with Jeff, like finally figuring out how the puzzle pieces fit together. So I'm very grateful that she played me and I thought she did a great job.

35:07Yeah, I'm looking forward to as journalists who investigate social media, seeing how they depict Jeff and like what. yeah how much that matches up with the slightly unglamorous yeah well so i i i need i need i feel like i need to do a teeny tiny psa which is do it um jeff is incredibly incredibly incredibly good with tech and one of the things about this is you gotta remember it's an adaption and one of the most important kind of devices you need if you're going to have a lot of exposition you're going to tell a lot of kind of background is you have to have an audience inside the movie for that.

35:40And so my way of rooting for my team member, right, because like Jeff is like a long term collaborator. I really believe in him is remember he won a Pulitzer for this reporting. So he is smart and very competent. So just remember that as you want. So I'm guessing he is not portrayed as Seth in the film. You have to keep asking the really obvious question. Well, I'm glad we're backing that journalists are smart. I think we all support that. That's a message. Top comment can get a point. Well, thank you so much, Francis, for chatting to us. It was so interesting. And I hope you enjoy the film being out.

36:11Thank you for inviting me. It was great to be here.

36:18Investing with Schwab is like spending a Saturday at a great farmer's market. You can fill your reusable tote with a bit of everything. Maybe you go for some free-range, self-directed investing. Or perhaps you pick up a few farm-fresh trades while you peruse. You can even get help from a dedicated advisor. That's full service wealth management. Mix, match and change your mind whenever you want. Because at Schwab, you can invest your way. No matter your goals or appetite for investing, Schwab has everything you need all in one place. Visit schwab.com to learn more. Since chatting to Haugen, you and I both saw the film, Mariana, last night at the press screening.

36:56and I can, I think we all see what she meant about having to like counter the portrayal of Jeffrey Horowitz as dumb because that is indeed how he is portrayed in the film. Yeah, as journalists who investigate - They did him kind of dirty. They did a bit. And as journalists who investigate social media, I'd like everyone listening to Top Comment to know that it's not always quite like that. I mean, that's the problem though. When you're watching a film that's about something that you actually do yourself, like for example, cultivate relationships with whistleblowers inside the social media companies.

37:27There were so many moments where, I've said to Matt already and was saying, even when we were watching, like, you'd give longer for a right of reply than that. Or like, you know, the way that you'd cultivate the relationship with that source. They're quite an interesting portrayal, both of them. The way they interact with each other is sort of like, I mean, they invented in the film that she goes to his apartment in a kind of sexy outfit to make it look like it's a date to cover up for the fact. I don't know if that actually happened. It didn't. It didn't happen. I mean, look, it's a tough gig to turn what is essentially kind of a procedural and probably quite boring discussion with whistleblowers for social media companies into an exciting Hollywood tense drama.

38:12And that's why they have to invent things like that. And I think we all understand that. But I think that where the film was better and more engaging was when we were with Jeremy Strong's Mark Zuckerberg in the boardroom meetings and in his kind of media training. That's when it felt like you were watching a really good episode of Succession and it felt like we were really inside the machine dealing with this impending crisis. and they, you know, quite bitingly portray Mark Zuckerberg as sacrificing civic health for tiny, tiny percentages of engagement. They tread quite an interesting line between how much of this is willingly causing polarization and harm by trying to increase engagement, essentially, and how much of it is sort of careless, that it's a byproduct of just optimizing on engagement and therefore you're driving polarization and making stuff worse in the world.

39:06Some of that is boiled down in a way that perhaps oversimplifies how it works. Like my impression, certainly from speaking to insiders in the companies, is not that the people at the top of any of the big companies are evil, quote unquote, but rather that they are almost like programmed to focus on optimization and the success of the company and they disregard the impact that that could have. I mean, it is essentially, I think you could make the case It's an activist film, and it is driven by the desire to make a political point more so than to tell a story. And I think that one of the difficulties with people who care about these issues around social media is that the harm caused by social media is invisible.

39:48It's technologically complex. It completely changes the world that we live in in terrifying new ways. But we don't really understand it or see it. And it all comes down to this central notion of meta new. according to the Facebook files, that disinformation and anger inducing polarizing content led to more engagement. And they ignored, it seems according to the Facebook files and in this film, that Mark Zuckerberg himself ignored the recommendations of their own internal civic integrity team who were saying you can decrease the harm to our society by 38 % if you make this one change but mark zuckerberg chose not to do that that's where it feels like succession when you're in the boardroom and mark zuckerberg's like nope you know what percentage of engagement will we lose and they're like one percent and then he's like no that's too much yeah you know that that was interesting that bit so the film itself covers that period of time from about sort of 2019 up to kind of 2021 essentially obviously that's like five years ago and so much has happened in the social media world since then and i think you know towards the end of the film not not any spoilers because obviously everyone knows that haugen does like blow the whistle that did actually happen yeah when they're kind of celebrating the success of that it's this slightly bittersweet moment because you're like well actually since then i would say that i remember thinking at the time when when haugen blew the whistle it felt like this real pivotal moment and it kind of wasn't in fact if anything everything ended up going in the opposite direction Elon Musk bought X there was this engagement arms race that really heated up between all of the social media companies as they tried to compete with TikTok especially and and all kind of dabbled in short form video and reels and TikTok and what have you and numerous insiders whistleblowers I've spoken to from the social media companies were basically like the companies themselves decided well we're kind of no in here so let's just keep optimizing on engagement at all costs let's increase borderline content let's give people what they want quote unquote and we've seen so many examples of rioting violence um uh harm brought to individuals and to society that's connected to social media that you and i have both investigated and exposed multiple times since then and so while it feels like the moment haugen blew the whistle did i think change some of the public perception of the companies and the attitude towards the companies actually yeah if we're honest like social media feels like it's fucking up the world.

42:20Yeah. Very much so now, perhaps even more so than it was before. Exactly. I mean, I completely agree. I mean, look, the counter argument is that the huge civil litigations that we're seeing now against Meta arguably were rooted in the Facebook files and this initial whistleblowing, which is a real result. But you're right. I mean, after Trump got back into power, we saw a new side of Zuckerberg. He rolled back a lot of the moderation systems that they had put in place. And, you know, we're now living through that world now. So it's a weird time for this film to come out, a film that kind of ends in this moral moment where Zuckerberg chooses to shut down Trump's account around January 6th.

43:02And it almost feels like Francis Haugen has kind of won, if you will, because that is not what's happened. Yeah, and ultimately all of this raises the question of what does it take for there to be change within the social media companies? And we're not saying that as activists, we're investigative journalists but all of the evidence I've seen feels like the companies are becoming less transparent and less willing to change and more defensive and closed off and I think an example of that is Sarah Wynne Williams was at the press screening that we went to of the film in the panel afterwards and she's not allowed to speak right so she was sitting on the stage afterwards on this panel silent because otherwise they'll sue her for loads and loads of money and one person in the crowd at one point shouted we hear you Sarah but at that film does portray that a bit.

43:46You know, you see the immense degree of internal and external processes that Meta has in place to prevent negative press, to prevent what they're actually doing, getting out to the public. And now they're suing a woman for sitting on a panel silently, who has written a book about them. So it's like, you guys got to be a little bit conscious of your evil company image. Now, Meta, which owns Facebook and Instagram have repeatedly countered the allegations made by Francis Haugen and also actually allegations that they are trying to stop Sarah Wynne-Williams speaking. They argue that these various testimonies are not a fair representation of the entirety of their social media company and the work that they're doing because obviously these individual people work in specific teams.

44:33And as I know from lots of insiders of the companies, they can be quite siloed in terms of what people see and don't see. and so that's the defence that they usually give when it comes to these sorts of things. Now Matt, there are winners and losers to social media contributing to the world going to shit and we happen to maybe be the winners. Why? Because we get to talk about it every week. Yeah, we do. And if you want to get in touch with us about what is popping up on your social media feeds and you'd like us to investigate, to look into it, it's the usual contact details. You can WhatsApp us, plus 44 330 123 9480 and you can email topcomment at bbc.co.uk.

45:09Stay optimistic out there. The path to a great future for everyone is putting superpowers in everyone's hands to accomplish more than we ever could before. We're going to do that together. I can't wait to see how you use all of this to improve your lives and shape the future. Have a good night. Part of why I blew the whistle was I didn't want to lay in bed in 20 years. Having seen another million people die, I know that I could have done something when I had a chance. This week on The Interface, we're talking to Frances Haugen, the Facebook whistleblower who leaked the documents that changed how the world saw social media.

45:42And now she is the subject of Erin Sorkin's latest movie, The Social Reckoning. So join me, Thomas Germain. And me, Jess Maddox, for The Interface. Listen on BBC.com or wherever you get your podcasts.

From the publisher

As The Social Reckoning hits cinemas, the whistleblower who inspired the movie joins Top Comment to discuss what's changed since she leaked tens of thousands of internal Facebook documents in 2021. Considered by many to be the primary catalyst for much of the legislation and litigation currently targeting social media giants, Frances Haugen's revelations have nonetheless been followed by an apparent acceleration by those same companies in pursuit of maximum engagement. On this episode, Frances talks about tech accountability in the age of AI, the increasingly punitive measures being taken against others who decide to speak out, and what she really thinks of Mark Zuckerberg. Meta has consistently disputed Frances Haugen's characterisation of its policy, culture and safety procedures.

Plus - fresh from attending the press screening, Matt and Marianna give their thoughts on the film.

Top Comment is hosted by Marianna Spring and Matt Shea. The series producer is Laurie Kalus. The assistant producer is Sophie Millward. The technical producers were Ben Andrews and Dafydd Evans. The editor is Justine Lang. The senior news editor is Sam Bonham.

If you want to get in touch about something that's popped up on your feed, our email address is [email protected] or you can send us a WhatsApp on +44 330 123 9480.

More from Top Comment

All episodes