

The episode discusses how social media outrage around the “Cornell 7” (a reopened US case involving alleged gang rape at Cornell University) became a call to action, while also examining how online “sleuthing” can turn toxic and lead to misinformation/doxxing. It then contrasts this with a viral backlash against a COVID-conscious lesbian bar in Massachusetts, arguing it shows “woke 1.0” backlash and algorithm-driven outrage.
Two hosts (Matt and Tristan are referenced; Matt is the co-host). They discuss neighborhood WhatsApp culture and social media activism; no external guests are named.
Online attention may have contributed to the district attorney reopening the criminal case; the civil suit alleges Cornell mishandled accountability. The episode warns that screenshot-based sleuthing can misidentify people and spread unrelated/false “evidence.”
A fraternity Snapchat screenshot about “free pussy” and claims that no one intervened; Florence Pugh’s Instagram content triggering censorship filters; the Last Ditch Bar mask-policy reversal and Zoom mediation conflict; “Vinny Jr” body-double conspiracy.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Exploration of neighborhood WhatsApp groups and their role in community vigilance.
“And actually she seems to have played a part in foiling this potential terror attack via WhatsApp.”
An in-depth conversation about the Cornell 7 rape case and its social media implications.
“Matt, my feed has been absolutely overwhelmed with posts about what some people are calling the Cornell 7.”
Explore the complexities of using social media for accountability in sensitive cases.
“And I think the argument of a lot of these people who are doing the sleuthing would be like, yes, the reason we're holding these people accountable is because we think there's been a failure by any authority to do so.”
The need for change in how justice is served in sexual assault cases.
“who are genuinely shocked about this case, I think has played a significant role in it now being reopened and looked at in a different light, in a different way.”
Discuss the effects of social media activism on individual cases and broader issues.
“These monsters must all be brought to justice and see nothing but the inside of a prison cell for their heinous crimes against this woman.”
Analyze the nuances of consent and the legal challenges surrounding rape allegations.
“This is the systemic injustice that people are angry about.”
Examining the importance of statements and legal definitions of consent.
“I can say with 100 % confidence I was raped.”
Investigate Cornell University's response to the allegations and accountability measures.
“and we don't deny that it's morally wrong or disgusting or offensive, but their case centred on whether what had happened had been consensual or not consensual.”
Investigate Cornell University's response to the allegations and accountability measures.
“their suggestion is you didn't just have to write an essay.”
Discuss the viral story of a COVID-conscious bar and the cultural implications.
“Last week, a COVID-conscious lesbian bar in Western Massachusetts went insanely viral on social media.”
Explore the backlash against a Massachusetts bar relaxing its mask policy.
“The place where this bar exists, Greenfield, Massachusetts, has not had any confirmed COVID cases for months.”
Delve into the public apology made by the bar and the ensuing chaos.
“buckle up because this is genuinely the story of the year.”
Analyze the tensions during the community Zoom meeting and its implications.
“But it's been stressful for these people for a while because the bar wasn't doing well because you're allowed to pay what you want.”
Discuss the internal conflicts within the left regarding woke culture.
“You bitches in Bushwick and Brooklyn think you're running the woke Olympics?”
Examine the backlash against extreme woke culture and its effects.
“And this is the ultimate example of that, which is, I think, why it is being ridiculed both on the left and the right.”
Learn about the impact of algorithms on political discussions and beliefs.
“I think as well it's a product of algorithms and engagement being a result of arguments and rage.”
Investigate the recent conspiracy theories surrounding footballer Vinny Jr.
“But actually in lots of ways, woke has become its own rabbit hole where you become so immersed in it, it actually becomes almost impossible to interact with anyone who's outside that rabbit hole.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On Top Comment, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK.
0:30Listen to Choiceology at schwab.com slash podcast or wherever you listen. If you are currently overpaying on software to run your business, remember this number, 10 ,000. That's the number of new businesses that join Odoo per month. Join Odoo today at odoo.com. That's O-D-O-O dot com. OK, Neighbourhood Chats have been making headlines this week for perhaps an unexpected reason, which is a woman, a farmer, posted on her neighborhood chat when she saw some people in balaclavas and vans and all sorts of stuff close to where she lives in the Cotswolds. And actually she seems to have played a part in foiling this potential terror attack via WhatsApp.
1:16Yeah, because most of the time, as anyone who's been in a neighborhood WhatsApp knows, when someone posts there's a bunch of sketchy people in the neighborhood, it's because they're like being a Karen and it's just like people wearing a hoodie. But in this case, she maybe was right and they may have actually been terrorists. It's like the sort of sleuth vigilantism that finds its way into neighbourhood chats, which can be useful, right? They can also be an absolute cesspit for like random stuff, gossip, toxicity. I mean, you have a particularly lively one, don't you? I do. I have some stories from my own neighbourhood WhatsApp.
1:52I also, we put out a call for other people's neighborhood WhatsApp stories and got some pretty funny ones. I mean, look, the most recent thing to happen on my neighborhood WhatsApp was basically a few people had spotted Bill Nighy in the area, the actor. And someone said like, oh, maybe he lives around here. And someone else said, I don't think he would live around here. Like implying that, you know, he probably lives in a nicer area. And then someone else was like, why couldn't Bill Nighy live around here? Our neighborhood's perfectly good enough for Bill Nighy. And that just led to like a huge debate.
2:24But there's something about the nature of these groups, right, which is like they're so personal and small. And like people who would traditionally lurk on social media, which is the majority of people, actually do probably get involved. Because often people are asking questions that are like pertinent to your life about like the bins or something that's going on. But it also means that the strength of feeling can be quite hard. Oh, for sure. I mean, look, a lot of it is, especially on mine, seems to be people asking for like very, it kind of annoys me how obscure these requests are right like someone the other day said hi is anyone here a registered aromatherapist with a materia aromatica account please and i'm like what no my days of being a registered aromatherapist with a materia aromatica account you're actually trying to be a clown but more on that later oh yeah true when i put the call someone said that their neighbor to whatsapp someone was selling caniston duo yeah cream for thrush right exactly which is a thrush cream like from their public account you're basically saying your entire neighborhood i have thrush which is fine but it's like they're selling it they want money for it um i also had one where someone lost a parrot and the chanel me parrot just flew away on me gone chanel she's an african guy named chanel the parrot's name was georgina actually and people were like out there trying to catch this parrot i was watching it just laughing massive because i'm like guys it's a bird if you lose a bird it's lost like that bird's free now you know like but people were like oh i found some feathers i'm like shaking some nuts outside the tree and people doing like hashtag come home georgina and stuff in my old block of flats there was someone who was seemingly stealing packages but like who didn't live in the block of flats and would come in and take the packages and a few of the neighbors like gathered together to basically get the ring doorbell footage and like hunt down the person and uh they returned the packages oh wow so true So we're not even sure if they were like, it was like the traitor was in the group, right?
4:17Maybe. Or someone who knew the person stealing the packages. One person said that there's a person on their group chat called Gwen, who's constantly on a voice call with the entire group chat and doesn't realize it. Another person is continuously trying to organize, quote, boys nights, and no one ever responds. And he doesn't stop messaging, is now resorted to saying, is anyone coming? And yeah, recently a fox was found dead, a baby fox in my neighborhood. and people immediately jumped to these conclusions. But someone was like, oh, I bet it was poisoned. Then someone else was like, people who poison foxes are like the scum of the earth.
4:51They should be arrested and hanged. Then someone said, oh, I've seen meth on our road before. And someone was like, do you think that's what killed them? And she said, yes. I think this is the key takeaway from neighborhood chats, which is because they are smaller than posting on actual social media, I'm sure none of these people would actually post this stuff like in the comments on Instagram or on X or on TikTok. But because it's like a safe space of like, 40 people or however many people it is, it almost is like it doesn't count. And because they're not your actual friends or family necessarily, it almost also feels like it doesn't count.
5:22But because it's people that live near you, it can also be such a vector for misinformation because you ultimately possibly trust them because you have more in common with them than a rando on the internet. But why do people feel okay with getting into fights with someone who lives in proximity to them? That's what I'll never understand. I don't know. Neighbour beef is a tale as old as time, right? Yeah. Now, Matt, a different type of community feud that we're going to be talking about on this episode of Top Comment is this lesbian COVID-conscious mask bar in Massachusetts. Yes, and how the hilarious backlash to this bar changing their mask policy for one night essentially shows us that we may be witnessing the death of Woke 1.0 on social media.
6:02And we're going to be talking about how social media outrage over what people are calling the Cornell 7 and these allegations of gang rape at a university in the US have contributed to the reopening of the case. We're going to talk about social media activism and how it can be a force for good, but also the toxicity that can come with some of the sleuthing that accompanies it.
6:29Matt, my feed has been absolutely overwhelmed with posts about what some people are calling the Cornell 7. Now, at this point, we're talking about a case that is being reopened, but at the time that we're recording, there haven't been any criminal charges. And it all relates to this alleged rape, gang rape of a woman at Cornell University in 2024. There's been a huge swell of social media outrage, all sorts of people kind of pouring over the new details that have been made available. And that is because there was this civil case that was filed against Cornell University and also against the individuals who she accuses of being involved in this alleged rape.
7:12And this happened on the 16th of September. So she's anonymous. She's a Jane Doe. She's not been named in the filing. But it was covered pretty extensively by the student newspaper who actually decided to publish the names of the men that she is accusing of being involved in this. And the kind of central point of the case is that she feels not only that they are guilty of wrongdoing, but also the university didn't protect her, didn't act accordingly after she was drugged and raped, she alleges, at this frat house. I'm waking up so filled with rage, so much anger. The more and more I read the details of the Cornell 7 and Jane Doe, the more my blood just boils.
7:53I am deeply, deeply disgusted with the way that the university has handled everything with what's going on with the woman that came forward and talked about her being S8. It's like, unescapable. Rape is everywhere. And it is horrific. And it's like, not processable. So it's a really like, it's worth saying from the get go, this is a quite distressing story, really. And that's one of the reasons why it's provoked such a reaction online. A lot of the outrage online centers around the fact that the civil case alleges two of these men only were expelled while the rest were offered the chance to mitigate their punishment by writing essays, which is what was first reported and picked up on by a lot of celebrities and people like AOC and Florence Pugh.
8:38Yeah, and we'll get into the response from Cornell University and what they say about all of that. But I mean, the way that I actually first heard about this story was the post that Florence Pugh did on Instagram. And it really caught my attention because it had one of those labels on it, which is essentially like this could be explicit or graphic content. So you can click to see it, but you don't automatically see it. Often content about Gaza, for example, or about war zones has those labels on it. But when I clicked through, I realized it was actually several paragraphs that she'd written expressing her distress and outrage about hearing about the case.
9:11But because the word gang rape was used, it seems like that automatic filter was applied. And the defense from the companies is always to say, you know, like words like this, topics like this can be really triggering for people. But in this case, and Florence Pugh kind of highlighted this, it made her feel like she was being censored and actually stifling a discussion where lots of women felt genuinely shocked and appalled at the allegations that were being made. And this was part of something systemic, right? Like it's about this case, but it's about this wider feeling around sexual assault and rape allegations on college campuses and how they're handled.
9:45And, you know, on platforms like TikTok, things get automatically banned. Sometimes your account can be banned if you say the word rape. People get around it by saying grape, which kind of almost seems to trivialize it. They'll use the emoji. Now, Now, whatever the intent may be behind this, effectively, it's hard to see it as anything other than censorship. And in a world where rape in the US, just as it is here, has a vanishingly unlikely chance of ever leading to a charge, let alone a conviction, the vast, vast, vast majority of rapes don't lead to any sort of further action, where there's a long history of universities brushing this stuff under the rug.
10:22The last thing that people want is for social media to censor discussion of this endemic issue. Yeah, and what we're gonna chat about here and try and unpick is how the social media outrage has actually contributed to some of the real-world action and steps that are being taken to reopen and look at this case. Let's kind of get into some of the information that's come to light that has been particularly shocking for people. So one of the central bits of evidence which is in this lawsuit is a screenshot of what appears to be a fraternity Snapchat group. And it's a screen grab, the woman alleges, from the night where this incident that she's describing took place.
11:02When I first saw it, I was like, whoa. It's someone posting saying that there's free pussy upstairs in this frat house, essentially. You know, the inference being, you can go and have sex with this person. And by the way, that is the most, I think, a lot of people pointed out shocking part of this, including in her civil suit, because it's after that message is sent by one of the accused at around 1.42am, allegedly, that the room in which this alleged rape was initially happening began to fill up with other men. And some people have said, including the defendant's lawyers, and including people who have analyzed her original statement, that the initial encounter, the first threesome that she was having, was consensual according to her initial statement.
11:46But it was the later stuff that happened when men entered the room where it became non-consensual. And this is the reason why the Snapchat, I think, has triggered such a discussion on social media about men calling out other men's behavior, calling out vulgar, misogynistic, abusive language, because the Snapchat group is more than the people accused, right? There's like 50 people in that group. And so, so many of the videos that I'm seeing on TikTok and Instagram that have been popping up are people talking about those who are accused, calling them the Cornell 7. There are different views about naming a group of alleged offenders in this way and whether that's helpful or unhelpful.
12:23But a lot of the discussion is focusing also on not just the seven, but then the 50 members of this chat, and that real fear that there was an action taken, that they didn't do anything to try and stop or interrupt or intervene. Seven hours.
12:44Seven boys.
12:50How did not a single one of them speak up in seven hours do you know what you can do in seven hours do you know how much they did in seven hours and who knows how many others in that group chat that were aware of what was going on and were completely complicit and said absolutely nothing just let it happen now while there is of course genuine understandable outrage and i think it's triggered a really important conversation about the bystander effect and where men need to step in and call this stuff out and like why was that an acceptable thing to do in that environment which I think speaks to why people have been so frustrated and angry because this isn't just one incident right it's this feeling that these kinds of attitudes messages this kind of behavior has been normalized on college campuses and nothing has changed really because there have been so many incidents like this over over many years but it's also the area where we start to get into that kind of where the outrage tips into in some cases slightly problematic sleuthing and people saying well right let's name and shame every single person who was in the snapchat group or who was part of the fraternity and that's not to say that those people aren't accountable for not calling it out or not doing anything but we also don't actually know like was someone asleep or ill or did they raise something afterwards it's quite hard when you just have one screen grab to know the full context surrounding it which certainly doesn't mitigate the really strong feelings of upset and outrage, but I think shows where we start to get into this murkier territory of like, is it okay when people are being held to account on social media?
14:23And I think the argument of a lot of these people who are doing the sleuthing would be like, yes, the reason we're holding these people accountable is because we think there's been a failure by any authority to do so. Yeah, and this is such a complicated issue, right? Because as you say, some of the men in that chat would have been asleep, right? Do they all deserve to be doxxed as people have been arguing for the Cornell 7 themselves, whose faces and names have been released, who's in many places their workplace has been notified. There's calls for people to do that to the rest of the people of this group.
14:51Is that fair? Probably not. But the shock that not one man appeared to call it out on that group is still completely valid. The fact that no one did is the shocking thing. I think maybe a lot of it does come from a place of good intent, right, or a place of wanting to seek justice. The problem is that when individuals and sleuths, as we talk about quite a lot on Top Comment, get involved in this justice process, and while they might be highlighting legitimate faults or problems with that system that have failed to hold individuals accountable, they also can get it wrong, right? So there's one guy who I've been messaging because he actually had to come out and post on TikTok.
15:27He'd been wrongly identified as one of the Cornell Seven because he shares the name of one of those people. But he is not involved at all. And he wrote, I'm Indonesian. I'm not the person who's been named, essentially. I've been receiving a significant number of messages, comments and tags because of this name confusion. To be absolutely clear, I have no connection whatsoever to Cornell University, to the fraternity or to the individuals involved in that case. It's like that's when it can go wrong, right? And so you've got someone who is just like not connected at all, but does share a name, which is always possible, experiencing this.
15:58And he himself is kind of doesn't actually want to speak about it publicly because he knows it. He doesn't want to make it be about him, essentially. And also we're seeing people trying to identify her. There have been people actually trying to post on TikTok saying like, I am Jane Doe, to sort of muddy the water of making it harder to find the name of the woman making these allegations. But it's the danger of when this is taken into social media's hands and the Internet's hands, the risk, perhaps. Right, and on top of that, if you look up the Cornell 7 on TikTok right now, I would say most of the top things that come up contain unrelated footage and kind of really horrible soundtrack that sound like it's someone being raped that is not from this case, but is presented in a very legitimate news style as though it is the footage of this case.
16:44And understandably, the responses are pure outrage. When you take that on top of the fact that there are people being attacked and doxed who are not connected to this. There is an argument that the social media coverage of this case does more harm than good, especially when we need to wait for the civil case to run its course. The district attorney has reopened the criminal case. There will be a grand jury hearing, and then we will have more facts. But we're not waiting for that, right? We're just going straight in on social media, and that's the issue. Now, the counter-argument is, did the district attorney reopen the criminal case because of the online outrage that the release of the civil case caused.
17:23And arguably, yes, right? Like the amount of attention, the strength of feeling, the groundswell of mainly women, but also men, who are genuinely shocked about this case, I think has played a significant role in it now being reopened and looked at in a different light, in a different way. First of all, I'm so glad that so many of us are speaking up, speaking our minds and holding people accountable, as we fucking should, because it's about time we had some change. These monsters must all be brought to justice and see nothing but the inside of a prison cell for their heinous crimes against this woman.
17:54Two years later, and this is finally getting attention. The fact that Jang Do has to relive the worst night of her entire life two years later. Why the actual hell did it take this long to bring this to someone's attention? Like when we think about how social media activism works, think back to the Me Too movement. It can be such a powerful force for triggering a wider discussion about something that people are experiencing. in the case of Me Too, you know, sexual abuse, harassment, abuse of power, misogyny, and it can be incredibly effective. And I'm sure and I hope that there are women who see some of the outrage at this case and who have had similar experiences or are in an environment like that, who think, no, this is not okay.
18:32And I'm really happy that other people think it's not okay too. And I think the thing with this type of social media activism is it becomes about so much more than the individual case and allegations. And that's actually the bit where it gets a bit messy because people are then projecting all sorts of things onto a single case, which has its own intricacies and nuance and complexities, no matter how shocking the allegations are. But often what they're projecting is really real, which is either their own experiences or other instances or allegations of this sort of thing, and the feeling that this is really systemic, that no one is doing enough, basically, to protect women who find themselves in situations where they are not able to consent or where they then end up, as is here, alleging rape.
19:11Especially because perhaps the primary nuance here is that, sadly, she has a very low chance, statistically, of ever seeing any of her accused, if they did do this alleged crime, see any jail time. And most women like her, it's the same scenario. This is what's so infuriating. This is the systemic injustice that people are angry about. To the point where some people, and look, academics who study rape and crime have a huge issue with this term. But some people say that rape has been effectively decriminalized in the UK and in the US due to the insanely low conviction rate. But people don't like saying that because we don't want to give the impression that it's not illegal, because we don't want people to think they can get away with it.
19:52But the statistics do show that you are almost certainly going to get away with it. And so much of the social media conversation and content focuses on this, right? Which is like how difficult it can be in the hours, days, weeks after the alleged rape or assault has taken place. and how even your perspective on it can shift or alter or, you know, it's an incredibly difficult thing to process. So we're now seeing more evidence emerge, come out. So CBS in the US have seen some of the transcripts relating to the initial report that the victim made and then also have published additional text messages reportedly exchanged between one of the defendants and the alleged victim.
20:31And this includes a message basically where this person is apologising and then the reply from the alleged victim says, none of the sexual stuff was illegal, and goes on to sort of say the initial sexual encounter with this person and another man she didn't have a problem with. And they even discuss sort of meeting up again. But I think these things can unfold in a way that is often, yeah, just quite complex, not so straightforward as, the morning after you say, what happened, I think was illegal, and I need to go and speak to prosecutors. So what's interesting is if you look on a platform like TikTok, the overwhelming majority of people are outraged by this and say this definitely happened.
21:09You get a platform like X, a lot of people pointed to the fact that with that first encounter with like the first two men, it is potentially going to be difficult for them to be found guilty, given what she said in this initial statement. Cornell 7 Jane Doe just got exposed. Newly released text messages between her and one of the men she later accused show huge contradictions. Just because you regret a decision that you made while you were in college, while you were intoxicated, while you were looking to have a little fun, does not mean years later when you see a financial gain that you can then claim SA.
21:41This is actually the opposite of empowering towards women. In this particular case, there's literally no evidence other than the revised testimony of this woman in a civil suit that the men did anything illegal under New York law. There's lots of evidence that they're scumbags. There is no evidence of actual rape other than what she's saying now two years later. It's very easy to get wrapped up in the hoopla and the witch hunt. That whole Me Too movement really did a doozy. It's just women don't always tell the truth. Now, what you just said is absolutely right. I've covered so many rape cases and in almost all of them, as is well documented by academics, a woman will tend to try and normalize the experience by maybe saying to the person or to her friends, that it was consensual.
22:26And only later, after, you know, really thinking through the process and healing and kind of coming to terms with it, will realize that what happened was actually rape. So her new civil suit, she absolutely can now say that that initial encounter was rape. It was not consensual. You know, just because she said in the statement, that doesn't affect that. But the other thing that's been less reported is CBS News also obtained a quote from her interview with campus police before the statement was provided to the district attorney, in which she says, in reference to the encounters that happened later in the night, and this is the exact quote, I can say with 100 % confidence I was raped.
23:05Now, this happened just like three or more weeks after the alleged incident, right? And she said, I can say with 100 % confidence I was raped. The biggest question, in my opinion, for Cornell University right now, is why, according to the district attorney, the summarized statement that he received that his office received did not include that quote. And it's interesting looking at the response from Matthew Van Houten, who's the Tompkins County District Attorney. I was reading through some comments he'd given in an interview. And in these comments, he says, we don't deny the account that she gave of what happened, and we don't deny that it's morally wrong or disgusting or offensive, but their case centred on whether what had happened had been consensual or not consensual.
23:46And he's trying to make the point that the Snapchat message, which has triggered so much of the anger online, he says from a kind of legal perspective, wasn't key to their case originally because it doesn't tell them whether she could consent or not consent. And that's ultimately the basis on which they would build a case of rape. And you would be totally valid to say, well, hang on a second, that just doesn't feel like a system that is very effective or that represents women and how are all these things fine and OK? You would also be totally justified in saying, well, even if it didn't meet the legal threshold, why did Cornell University not try and address the cultural issue here?
24:21Because the fact that someone thought it was okay to post that on a Snapchat group with that many people does indicate to some extent that there was an issue in terms of attitude and behavior. Cornell's response to the criticism of how they handled accountability for the students involved, their response has been to say that the matter was referred to a panel of trained faculty and staff that issued, quote, a range of sanctions, which included expulsions and suspensions from Cornell. E.g. their suggestion is you didn't just have to write an essay. That might have been something that people did alongside other punishments.
24:52So they dispute Jane Doe's allegation that they didn't adequately sort of look into the perpetrators, essentially.
25:03Investing with Schwab is like spending a Saturday at a great farmer's market. You can fill your reusable tote with a bit of everything. Maybe you go for some free-range, self-directed investing. Or perhaps you pick up a few farm-fresh trades while you peruse. You can even get help from a dedicated advisor. That's full-service wealth management. Mix, match, and change your mind whenever you want. Because at Schwab, you can invest your way. No matter your goals or appetite for investing, Schwab has everything you need all in one place. Visit schwab.com to learn more. Fall into paradise with Apple Vacations.
25:36Book from September 25th through October 22nd and save up to 55 % on vacations to Mexico, the Caribbean, Hawaii, Central America, and top domestic destinations. Whether you're dreaming of a beach escape with the family or relaxing getaway for two, now's the perfect time to plan some time together. Travel through September 30th, 2027. Start planning your getaway today at applevacations.com or contact your travel advisor. Apple Vacations, where your story starts.
26:09Last week, a COVID-conscious lesbian bar in Western Massachusetts went insanely viral on social media. And it was in a story that a lot of people think that it was first reported by the Boston Globe, but it was actually first reported by the podcast Blocked and Reported. And then the Boston Globe did their piece. And this is one of the funnier stories of my life. By the way, can I say, when I first saw this, It's like that thing where you haven't watched a TV series for like three series, and then suddenly you start the next series, and you're like, what? Like, what is going on? Like, honestly, I went on X that day.
26:45I remember going on it and being like, why is everyone talking about lesbians wearing COVID masks in a bar in America? I was like, how? Like, what has happened? So, okay, so one thing that I think, especially for a UK audience, that's really important to clarify, is that among these kind of hyper-woke, far-left identity-based communities that exist across the US, it's very common to act as though the pandemic is still very much alive and that it is still just as deadly and that to disagree with that, to not wear a mask, for example, is somehow eugenicist or like, you know, ableist to people who are immunocompromised and so forth.
27:23And that's very common. Like there are like grocery stores in Brooklyn today where they have like mask on Wednesdays and stuff like that. You don't get that in the UK. Well, yeah. And doesn't that derive from that during the pandemic here in the UK? most of the rules were set for everyone in every part of the country. And so you didn't really have a choice. Whereas in America, it became like a personal decision for a lot of people. Like, do you take the pandemic seriously or not? And that became a political dividing line. And so wearing a mask was like a symbol of, I don't like Donald Trump, or a symbol of like, I'm on the left.
27:55Exactly. Now, why are we saying this? Because this COVID-conscious lesbian bar in Western Massachusetts was not mask optional. It was mask mandatory. The place where this bar exists, Greenfield, Massachusetts, has not had any confirmed COVID cases for months. But, you know, they still have this mask mandate. But anyway, this bar is called Last Ditch Bar. They announced on social media, they said, It is with love. We inform our immunocompromised disabled divas. We will be opening Saturday nights as mask optional. which led to a firestorm of people claiming that they were eugenicists and ableists for relaxing their mask policy during what they see as a deadly ongoing pandemic.
28:35One person said, I hope your venue gets firebombed for robbing my fellow immunocompromised people of their Saturday plans just to scrape extra revenue from ableists. This person, by the way, is the same person that's gone viral for wearing what they refer to as a hijab-inspired secular accessorization. Essentially, it's a white person in a hijab. and also for putting masks on her babies, which is very dangerous according to several health organizations. I mean, this is sort of like woke on steroids, right? It's like where people have gone so far down their kind of rabbit hole of like what they perceive to be sort of right and fair and morally good.
29:08And that they're actually then almost becoming offensive. If you guys haven't heard of the drama surrounding the COVID-conscious lesbian bar in Massachusetts, buckle up because this is genuinely the story of the year. If we were doing the woke Olympics, this story would take the gold medal because it's a reminder these looney tunes walk amongst us. I need to get all my lesbians together and we need to do a Socratic seminar about this lesbian bar in Western Massachusetts article. I need people to be writing with their fucking muji pens about this shit. And obviously there's an argument to be made right like if you are immunocompromised it is it's great to be able to go somewhere where you don't have to worry so much about getting unwell or everything else.
29:48I think the thing that's quite hard to understand is like This is a very small community. How many immunocompromised lesbians are in this community, right? Like, are people driving all the way across the country? Well, hundreds, apparently. I mean, like, the thing is, yeah, it looks like a Portlandia sketch, this whole thing, right? But a lot of people will be attracted to this community for that reason. And I guess that as well, with the point we're making about the kind of symbolism of the mask and everything else, it's like, you know that you will probably agree with these people on lots of, like, political viewpoints, say.
30:15It's almost like a shorthand for, are you woker than woke? Come on down. So, in order to try and defuse the situation, the COVID-conscious lesbian bar issues an apology, but the apology doesn't provide alt text for the visually impaired. So they are further trashed by the hyper-woke residents of Greenfield, Massachusetts, for being ableist, essentially, in their response. So they hold a kind of public Zoom meeting with mediators to try and placate the community who are furious. And that's when things just all go to complete shit for them. Now, by the time this community Zoom meeting comes around, two of the people who run this bar have actually left.
30:59One of whom, who goes by it, its pronouns, had enrolled in clown school. And they cited various reasons, including stress over the situation. I mean, the bar hadn't been doing well for a while because... So, stress from the bar or stress from the clown school? Clown school to get over the stress from the bar. Got it. You know what it's like. I'm sure we've all thought we need to enroll in clown school to get over job stress. But it's been stressful for these people for a while because the bar wasn't doing well because you're allowed to pay what you want. And a lot of people couldn't afford the cover charge, but they let them in anyway.
31:30So they lost a lot of money. So things were already not going well. So when the Zoom meeting comes around, this person called So Noir, who identifies as a gender expansive lesbian, but uses he, him pronouns. They were just super aggressive to the last person left, who was on the call, who ran the bar. One of the things this person said was that one of the mediators in this Zoom call, by virtue of being a licensed therapist, could have them hospitalized against their will, which in So Noir's telling was, quote, wildly unsafe. And so then, you know, after hours go by, they say to So Noir, like, oh, would you like to come to another meeting because we feel like maybe we have failed you.
32:09in this one, this person responds, there's a lot of emotional and physical labor that goes into this. So for you as a white person that asked me to stay for another meeting for free is incredibly disingenuous and racist. I'm not doing that. So it's like, I want to complain at you and call you racist for taking the mask policy out of your lesbian COVID conscious power. But then I don't want to actually participate in the process of trying to resolve that. And asking me to do so as racist. And it's just such a, like, Gordian knot of wokeness that you can't untangle it. You kind of just need to cut it off.
32:39But this is why this particular case has captured social media, right? Because it has become the, like, the sort of pinnacle of woke extreme. Western Massachusetts? You bitches in Bushwick and Brooklyn think you're running the woke Olympics? You're not. As a brown woman who went to college in Western Massachusetts, the shit these white people are throwing tantrums over is insane. I would genuinely meet like a bisexual woman from Connecticut from a wealthy family with loving parents and they would go on for half an hour in class about how oppressed they were because they grew up with asthma. I once had someone tell me at my college that they did not believe in the institution of hygiene and that asking them to wear deodorant was a form of oppression.
33:36this person was white. What's different about this story is it's not the right making fun of the left and the woke people, it's actually the left. Fighting within the left. I don't know if that would have happened, you know, a few years ago. I think you wouldn't have seen people like Hasan Piker and stuff making fun of this event years ago, which shows you that maybe what AOC famously said, which is that woke 1.0 was crazy. It's true. Maybe it's true. But also it's, aside from the kind of whether that's true or not point, it's that people who are chronically online and very good at being online, like Hasan Paikha, various other streamers, people on the left, have realized that everything around Woke 1.0 is very unpopular on social media, right?
34:17It's kind of like anything you say could get you in trouble. You might get cancelled, you might this or that. But beyond, I think, what the majority of people would see as actually problematic or offensive things, it's sort of like the same as the backlash against cancel culture. It's just being like, whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa, hang on a second. Like, this just feels like it's not really making sense anymore. And this is the ultimate example of that, which is, I think, why it is being ridiculed both on the left and the right. It reminds me a lot of, do you remember, this story went viral for similar reasons, the new Democratic Party convention in Canada that happened in March 2026, when they were trialing a new form of, like, privilege-based conversation contribution, where they had colour-coded cards for this political party meeting, based on, like, race, gender, class, etc., that defined like when and how much you could contribute to the conversation, and it just derailed into just complete and utter procedural nonsense to the point where they couldn't even have a conversation and were misgendering each other and so forth.
35:15And it went viral because it was like, this is such a mess. Like, what are we actually solving here? Like, what is this accomplishing? And I think that's one of the reasons why you're having people like AOC and Mamdani and Hasan Piker, to a degree, distanced themselves from some of the woke 1.0 stuff. And when you look back on it, it's when woke turned from being politically aware of your status and the struggles of other people, to being more of like policing the speech of in groups and out groups according to like, an indistinct code online. It became something where it's like, either you're in or you're out, you're woke or you're not.
35:56And if you're not, we're gonna cancel you. And also it stops, and this is, I think, the reason why there's been such backlash against it. But it then stops people being able to talk about stuff that would actually be valuable for them to understand, to engage with, to analyze. But when people are so terrified of like, saying slightly the wrong thing or not quite understanding, it actually sort of reduces, I'd say, general public understanding of these issues and makes them so thorny and complicated to even touch that people just don't, they don't get even the attention they deserve sometimes. Like real examples of discrimination, which then you feel like you can't even talk about because it will lead to some kind of cancellation.
36:29I think as well it's a product of algorithms and engagement being a result of arguments and rage. And a lot of these people built up their following by essentially constantly being in arguments with everyone. Like, disagree with everyone and you're gonna get more. And that's not necessarily the main reason, right? But I think that the engagement you get makes you think that your point is valid. And so you keep going, keep going, keep going, until you're now arguing about things like the lesbian Covid bar. Exactly. It's like this kind of toxic cancel culture, you know, woke cult that makes people on the left tend to gain more traction on social media.
37:03On the right, it's more of like a kind of toxic shock culture that gains the more traction. But in either case, it's disrupting the real conversation, and it leads to crazy policy choices. And I think that a lot of the people on parties on the left in the US and the UK are now starting to move away from that. It's not just Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez removing her pronouns from her Twitter profile. It's things like, let's actually think about this whole defund the police situation, right? Or let's think about whether we want to use Title IX investigations to remove someone from a university job because of something they said or an opinion they had being felt to be racist or so forth by some members of the student group.
37:42I mean, I do think this is something that even though they're saying Woke 1.0 is over, I don't think it really is for a lot of people online. But this is all the danger of algorithmic silos, which is where you end up being taken by your algorithm to a place where what you consider to be sort of normal, quote unquote, is very different from what someone else considers to be normal. You know, a lot of the people we're talking about here have fallen down the rabbit hole, which we usually use to describe people who are getting really deep into unfounded conspiracy theories like suggesting stuff as hoaxes that never happened, or even people falling into say the manosphere or other toxic communities online.
38:17But actually in lots of ways, woke has become its own rabbit hole where you become so immersed in it, it actually becomes almost impossible to interact with anyone who's outside that rabbit hole. And I think that's why COVID lesbian mask bar is such a kind of astounding example of it, because you're like, wow, how do any of these people think this is just sort of normal?
38:41Okay, Matt, the idea that someone has been killed and replaced, the body double conspiracy theory, is a tale as old as the internet or before that. But there is a new victim of this conspiracy theory. And it is Vinny Jr., who is a very famous footballer and plays for Real Madrid. So why do people think this? Well, one, because people are crazy, but also because he had plastic surgery on his chin. Also straight after the World Cup, right? So people had seen loads of images of him and then all of a sudden he looked completely different. And I think that because he was very visible during the World Cup, he plays for Brazil.
39:13I think that that probably contributed to a lot of the conspiracy content. Yes, and now people are suggesting he was killed and this is a body double being used to fulfil endorsement deals. Yeah, and loads of people are like zooming in on his legs. I mean, obviously with footballers, there's loads of footage of them playing, so it's quite easy to sleuth all over them. So legs change, guys. Well, they do. And also, like footballers famously do have like plastic surgery and stuff like that. So instead of going for the easy option here, as ever, the internet is going for the unbelievable option for which there is no evidence at all.
39:44That he has been replaced by a body double. I mean, pretty much every recent US president has also been accused of this. Yeah, like every world leader, so many celebrities. Remember Avril Lavigne? Avril Lavigne, yes. There's like endless conspiracy theories about this kind of stuff. And it should be said as well that Vinnie Jr. has been the subject of all kinds of abuse on social media, especially racist abuse in Spain where he plays. And some of this conspiracy content is really absurd, but some of it also has that sort of like abusive undertone or overtone. Exactly. And look, football fandom has increasingly been entering an age of kind of conspiratorial paranoia, which is only going to be furthered by all of the Man City stuff.
40:21I mean, the conspiracy theories about FIFA president Gianfantino, that he had a body double. Remember that he was like. Maybe you're going to spread conspiracy theories about the Premier League so that Man City can be let off the charges. Look, I'll say one thing on Man City. Look, it's really, really bad. right but at the time that the Sistine Chapel was painted the Catholic Church was widely accused of corruption and that doesn't make it any less beautiful over a decade of the best football in history. If you post that on football Twitter I think you would go more viral than you've ever got in your life.
40:53It's true like you would yes it comes at a cost but we witnessed the apogee of tactical football. And on that note if you know what really happened to Vinnie Jr. Or if you're the real Vinnie jr. Yeah, well, Vinny, come on. Or if you want to tell us about what's going on in your group chats, anything else that's popping up in your feed, we will investigate. Get in touch. Plus 44 330 123 9 4 8 0 on WhatsApp and top comment at bbc.co.uk on email. Matt just turns up in like a full clown outfit. I'm this close to enrolling in clown school, by the way, if you keep interrupting me.
41:32Is Facebook dying? I'm Tristan Redmond, host of the Global Story podcast from the BBC. More than 15 years after The Social Network, a new movie on the inner workings of Facebook hit cinemas in October. The journalist who's reporting inspired the film tells us why Facebook stopped being cool and whether Meta, its parent company, can reinvent itself. For more, listen to The Global Story on bbc.com or wherever you get your pods.
An alleged case of gang rape at a Cornell frat house has caused widespread outrage after new details emerged in a civil suit brought by the purported victim. Evidence including a Snapchat screenshot advertising a "free" sexual encounter has seen anger online directed not only towards those men accused of being involved, but others who apparently failed to step in. As a criminal investigation is reopened, Marianna and Matt explain how this case has taken over social media, from scathing critiques of campus culture and opaque accountability measures, to doxxing, misidentification and censorship. The university's leadership has denied its response was inadequate.
Also this week, we discuss arguably the most viral story of the year - the fallout at a covid-conscious lesbian bar in western Massachusetts. After the struggling Last Ditch decided to suspend their mask mandate on Saturday nights, they were met with a torrent of abuse calling them ableist and even eugenicist. Top Comment takes you through the chaotic conversations which followed, and we consider whether AOC spoke too soon when she famously closed the book on Woke 1.0 identity politics.
Plus - what RAF Fairford tells us about neighbourhood WhatsApp groups, and how Vini Jr became the latest celeb to find himself at the centre of a body-double conspiracy.
Top Comment is hosted by Marianna Spring and Matt Shea. The series producer is Laurie Kalus. The assistant producer is Sophie Millward. The technical producer was Mike Regaard. The editor is Justine Lang. The senior news editor is Sam Bonham.
If you want to get in touch about something that's popped up on your feed, our email address is [email protected] or you can send us a WhatsApp on +44 330 123 9480.