


Konstantin Kisin critiques Tucker Carlson’s and Jacob Rees-Mogg’s WWII discussion, arguing Carlson’s “why did Britain fight?” framing is ideological “utopianism” and moral simplification, and that “woke right” and “woke left” share similar methods (victimhood, black-and-white thinking). He claims Churchill shouldn’t be treated as a WWII villain and argues Britain’s war aims were justified against Nazi exterminationist tyranny.
Konstantin Kisin is the host/author. The “guests” discussed are Tucker Carlson (American podcaster) and Jacob Rees-Mogg (British politician/broadcaster).
Carlson isn’t a secret Nazi; he’s “ideologically captured.” Moral perfection is childish because it ignores proportionality in stopping mass slaughter. Rees-Mogg’s “we’d be speaking German” line is reframed by Carlson as a shallow “why is your country screwed” argument.
Oswald Mosley internment (May 1940; released 1943); Hitler’s aims for European hegemony; Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact; Operation Barbarossa; WWII civilian mass murder; Churchill rhetoric vs “tearing down statues.”
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
The host discusses Tucker Carlson's views on World War II and critiques his arguments.
“Based on excerpts, I prepared myself for something genuinely dark.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On TRIGGERnometry, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00Konstantin Kisin: I want to talk about something that men collectively pretend isn't an issue and collectively know absolutely it is. Uncomfortable underwear. Sheath sorted it. Sheath.com. The dual pouch system separates and supports everything properly. So you're not making constant adjustments or dealing with chafing that by 3pm has become genuinely distracted. Trusted by fighters, athletes and veterans who don't have patience for gear that doesn't hold up. Speaking of veterans, Sheath was founded by Robert Patton, who developed it during his second tour. That's not a marketing angle. That's just the actual story.
0:36Konstantin Kisin: And 10 ,000 five-star reviews from men who tried them and didn't go back suggest the product delivers on the idea. 100 % money-back guarantee on the first pair. There is no downside scenario here. Sheath.com, code Trigonometry for 20 % off. Try them once and the underwear you own right now will feel like a punishment by comparison. That's 20 % discount code again. It's Trigonometry at Sheath.com. Never go full Tucker.
1:09For days now, my timeline has been full of clips from the allegedly blockbuster showdown between American podcaster Tucker Carlson and British politician and broadcaster Jacob Rees-Mogg, in which they clashed on the subject of the Second World War. Based on excerpts, I prepared myself for something genuinely dark. One clip in which Carlson claims he has no idea why Britain fought World War II was particularly worrying. This, I thought, is the moment. Tucker has finally gone all the way. He's crossed the Rubicon, set up a tent on the other side and started selling merch with my struggle on it. And so, despite wanting to watch the entire thing less than a remake of Downfall directed by Daryl Cooper, I force myself to.
1:52Sadly, far from being disgusting and outrageous, it's mostly just disappointing. As he correctly says in the discussion, Carlson isn't a secret Nazi. He's just ideologically captured and not very bright. A typical podcaster, in other words. As regular viewers will know, I've talked extensively about what I call the woke right. This is a term that has caused much consternation because to many people, wokeness is definitionally a pathology of the far left. To be woke is to be extremely left-wing. I take a different view. To me, wokeness is a pathology of human beings that is reflected not in the views people hold, but in the behavior its adherents feel entitled to engage in.
2:31Most people have been implicitly taught to think of the political spectrum as aligned with communism on the far left and fascism on the far right. Horseshoe theory, on the other hand, sees these far ends of the spectrum bending towards each other and meeting as they reach for the same methods. We saw this in the 1930s when the hostility to an act of destruction of democracy, suppression of criticism, scapegoating and extermination of outgroups, socialist economics, militarism and so on were prevalent both in the communist world and in the fascist countries of Europe and beyond. The horseshoe theory of wokeness is no different.
3:07The ideology which is parodied as gay race communism is different from the post-liberal right, but the methodology is similar. Identitarian victimhood, a belief in the fundamental immorality and irredeemability of their political opponents and a general black and white thinking about everything, including war, history, and politics. The woke left's approach to history is simple. Imagine a perfect world. Now look at people who lived 200 years ago and notice that they were not living in it. Conclude that they were monsters. Tear down the statues. And what about the woke rights approach? Imagine a perfect world.
3:42Now look at the people who were making impossible decisions before and during World War II and noticed that both the process and the outcome were not perfect either. Conclude that they too were monsters and invert the moral order. This is how you get to that Churchill was the greatest villain of World War II rhetoric and what is that if not the metaphorical tearing down of his statue? Killing innocent people is always wrong, Tucker emotes. And of course, in a utopian vacuum, we'd all agree with him because it's superficially true and important. Proportionality, discrimination, the whole apparatus of just war theory exists precisely because we take it seriously.
4:18But as a moral position about the Second World War, it's not profound, it's childish. The Second World War was a mass slaughter of civilians. That was its defining characteristic. The Axis powers murdered civilians on an industrial scale as policy, continuously, until the moment they were physically prevented from continuing. Six million Jews, millions of Slavs, and that's just Hitler's Germany. Japan had been in Manchuria since 1931 and at full-scale war with China since 1937. By the time Hitler invaded Poland, millions of Chinese civilians were already dead, with much of the killing done in close quarters and by hand, beheaded with swords, burnt or buried alive, or used for bayonet practice.
5:00So the actual question, the one any serious person has to answer, is not, is killing innocents wrong? It's this. Given the mass killing of innocents already happening at vast scale, every single day, are you willing to use force to stop it, knowing that doing so will kill enemy combatants and civilians too, but in far smaller numbers? When moral perfection is the standard, Carlson's whataboutism almost works. In fact, it seems to work on millions of people who want simple explanations for complex problems. Look over here, says Tucker. Britain locked up political opponents and their wives during the war.
5:37How undemocratic. To disrupt the framing of Churchill good and art is bad, Britain did X less than perfect thing is close to compelling. Less so when you know the facts. The person he's talking about is Oswald Mosley, the leader of the British Union of Fascists. Mosley was interned in May 1940 with the invasion expected within weeks. He had married Diana Mitford at Goebbels House with Hitler as a guest. Diana had met Hitler repeatedly and was lobbying for a pro-Nazi radio station in Britain. He was released in 1943 on health grounds despite a public outcry and lived on until his death in 1980.
6:15Such tyranny! Next, Carlson explains that Hitler never wanted war with Britain. After all, he said so. And if you can't trust Adolf Hitler, who can you trust? Seriously though, ask yourself, is this a coherent position for someone who's built a career on being suspicious of powerful elites? Would Tucker accept this line of argument regarding Joe Biden or Anthony Fauci or even Donald Trump? By the way, we know exactly what Hitler wanted. He wanted Germany to become a hegemonic power in Europe, an aspiration which had been the organizing principle of British foreign policy for 400 years to prevent.
6:51If you're a fan of logical consistency, by the way, you'll know that Carlson advances the argument that Russia was provoked into invading Ukraine in 2022 because great powers will always concern themselves with what happens on their borders. Yet Britain, a great power in 1939, was supposed to look absentmindedly on as Hitler gobbled up all of Europe? Besides, as the Soviet Union found out, even an alliance with Hitler didn't mean he would not turn on you the moment he felt it was to his advantage. After signing the Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact with Stalin in 1939 and invading Poland together, Hitler launched Operation Barbarossa less than two years later invading the Soviet Union and butchering its citizens.
7:32Which brings us to the exchange everyone has clipped. When asked why Britain fought World War II, Reece Mogg replies that we'd all be speaking German. Tucker says, who cares? We'd all be speaking German is English shorthand and has been for 80 years, but we would be living under an exterminationist tyranny. British people do have an aversion to foreign languages, but World War II was not about a phobia of really long nouns. This is the point at which Carlson deploys his favorite trick of invoking Britain's current problems as being a direct consequence of the victory, which he puts in air quotes.
8:04If you want that war, why is your country so screwed? Is effectively his question. This is another bout of utopianism, of course, because as with the woke left, he deliberately avoids the actual choice which faced Britain in the 1930s. We were not choosing between fighting the war and the land of peace, milk and honey. Even if we accept that the current state of Britain, which I agree is depressing, is a consequence of fighting a war nearly a century ago, a tenuous claim at best, that does not mean that a Hitlerian empire stretching from Kalei to Vladivostok was a better alternative. Tucker's rhetorical posture is easy to adopt but hard to disguise.
8:39He almost succeeds in making his why is your country screwed argument sound like a far-reaching, all-encompassing, philosophical query. Like he's exploding the bounds of our tunnel vision. In reality, he's just moving the goalposts. Somehow Churchill is expected to not only answer for his conduct in World War II, but every absurd and short-sighted policy decision that came since, including those made decades after his death by people who hate everything he stood for, all of this is just incredibly low-quality, motivated reasoning about history, which we've seen before from the Imran X. Kendi's and Robin DeAngelis of the world.
9:17Indeed, it's not an accident that Churchill has been the target of far-left attacks for decades. He represents as much of a threat to their worldview as he does the Carlsons, and for the same reason. Britain was right to fight the Nazis. It did so honorably, and its victory is one of the great achievements of Western civilization. If you enjoyed these videos, remember to go to constantinkissen.com and read them as articles days, weeks, sometimes months ahead of time. Head on over to www.constantinkissen.com and subscribe today.
9:55recent years. That being the case, I'm keen to protect my family in case things continue to get worse. That's why I'm making sure to keep a portion of my savings in gold. The reason the price of everything continues to go up is that governments keep printing money. When they do, inflation is inevitable. What does inflation mean? It's just a fancy word for the value of your money being diluted over time. This is what's happened to the value of the dollar in our lifetimes. Gold is a great way to preserve the fruits of your hard work, while the value of your dollars, pounds, and euros is continually being eroded.
10:28My gold dealer, The Pure Gold Company, works across the world providing excellent service and competitive prices. I recently bought some of these Victoria Sovereigns. The good thing about these coins is that unlike many investments, they're exempt from capital gains tax. The Pure Gold Company keep my coins in a vault for me, but they can also deliver them to your home. Go to thepuregoldcompany.co.uk forward slash Constantine dash Kissen to protect your wealth today.
Triggernometry is proudly independent. Thanks to the sponsors below for making that possible:
- We use Ground News to escape the echo chamber and stay fully informed. Go to https://ground.news/triggernometry to save 40% on the Ground News unlimited access Vantage plan
Konstantin X / Twitter - https://x.com/KonstantinKisin
Konstantin Substack - https://substack.com/@konstantinkisin
Join our exclusive TRIGGERnometry community on Substack! https://triggernometry.substack.com/
OR Support TRIGGERnometry Here:
Bitcoin: bc1qm6vvhduc6s3rvy8u76sllmrfpynfv94qw8p8d5
Shop Merch here - https://shop.triggerpod.co.uk/
Advertise on Triggernometry: https://trigger-brands.com | or enquire at [email protected]
Find TRIGGERnometry on Social Media:
https://twitter.com/triggerpod
https://www.facebook.com/triggerpod/
https://www.instagram.com/triggerpod/
About TRIGGERnometry:
Stand-up comedians Konstantin Kisin (@konstantinkisin) and Francis Foster (@francisjfoster) make sense of politics, economics, free speech, AI, drug policy and WW3 with the help of presidential advisors, renowned economists, award-winning journalists, controversial writers, leading scientists and notorious comedians.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices