1. Podcasts
  2. TRIGGERnometry
  3. Owen Jones vs. TRIGGERnometry
TRIGGERnometry

10 Oct 2026 · 1h 53m · 37 chapters

Episode artwork

Owen Jones vs. TRIGGERnometry

In short

Debate between Owen Jones and Triggernometry host about neoliberalism’s effects in Britain and the US, and how it links to militarism abroad, immigration politics, and the failure of alternative models like “petro-socialism” in Venezuela. They argue over whether early-1980s recessions were caused by neoliberal policies that allegedly began later, and whether rolling back the state (plus union-busting and financialization) explains long-run stagnation and inequality.

Guests

Owen Jones, author known for writing on neoliberalism; argues neoliberalism means privatization of state assets, tax cuts for the wealthy, curtailing organized labor, marketization, and financialization (rewarding finance/asset markets over productive industry). He also discusses militarism/imperialism and their destabilizing effects. The other guest is the Triggernometry host (the interviewer), who challenges Jones with economic timeline disputes and questions about policy causality.

Key claims by Owen Jones

Neoliberalism delivered less growth and worse distribution than the 1970s; privatization and union weakening contributed to wage stagnation and insecurity; financialization shifted investment away from production; recessions and deindustrialization were “lasting catastrophic damage,” followed by asset-price booms; wars and state failures destabilized populations that were then scapegoated.

Notable examples

1970s oil shocks (1973, Iranian revolution/1979); UK Thatcher/Reagan era; Sheffield deindustrialization; UK right-to-buy leading to later private-rent extraction; Big Bang financial deregulation (1986); Venezuela under Chávez (poverty reduction then collapse tied to oil dependence and later sanctions).

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

0:00

Understanding Economic Disagreements

A discussion on differing views about market mechanics and policies.

“I think the real disagreement here is I don't think you understand how the market works.”
1:50

Defining Neoliberalism

Owen Jones explains the concept and implications of neoliberalism.

“Really enjoyed the book And one of the things you talk about a lot is neoliberalism.”
2:58

Critique of Neoliberal Policies

A detailed critique of neoliberal policies and their socioeconomic effects.

“and it's financialization okay kind of gist i guess right okay and so what are your issues with that let's just pick this apart so um what it's done in practice is less growth which is less equitably distributed.”
6:36

The Impact of Neoliberalism on Society

Discussion on how neoliberalism has shaped economic growth and societal structures.

“And you do a fairly good summation, actually.”
10:50

The Intersection of Neoliberalism and Militarism

Exploration of how neoliberalism and military ventures intersect and affect society.

“So if you've got the Cold War ending during the 60s, for example, then get you down social democracies dominant at the time.”
14:00

Economic Policies and Recession Analysis

Exploration of the impact of Thatcher and Reagan's economic policies on recessions.

“But what happens is you get, in the 80s, in the early 80s, you get that rapid deindustrialisation which takes place.”
17:03

Privatization and Its Effects

Discussion on the privatization process and its implications for the economy.

“So what happens, privatisation is a process which begins in the first term because what they do with these state-owned firms is they prepare them for privatisation.”
20:06

Consequences of Deregulation and Economic Recovery

Analysis of the consequences of deregulation and the uneven economic recovery.

“What you're talking about is removing state subsidies.”
28:00

Debating Economic Models: South Korea vs. Venezuela

Explore the contrasting economic policies of South Korea and Venezuela and their implications.

“So South Korea was an example that I looked at in the book.”
30:10

The Venezuelan Experience: A Deep Dive

Analyze the historical context and outcomes of Venezuela's economic policies under Chavez.

“But that is why, if you look at the policy of the early...”
Show all 37 chapters
42:25

Debate on the Effectiveness of Socialism

Discussion on the long-term consequences and realities of socialism in various countries.

“They have a very short-term vision because it's like saying, you know, well, you know, in the 1930s, the Soviet Union really did great.”
46:12

The Role of Oil in Venezuelan Economics

Analysis of how oil dependency affected Venezuela's economy and social programs.

“Well, because what you're doing is you're basically saying, you know, all of these governments and regimes are all in the same bracket.”
51:11

Comparing Political Systems

Exploring the spectrum of political systems and their impact on governance.

“I mean, when you say, you know, I'm saying Petro, it doesn't matter.”
55:46

Impact of Immigration on Economy

Examination of immigration's effects on wage stagnation and public sentiment.

“To come closer to home, we spent a lot of time talking about this fairly abstract thing.”
56:00

Debating Immigration's Economic Impact

Explore the economic implications of immigration and public perceptions around it.

“And the reason people are upset about mass immigration and illegal immigration, we can bundle them together for this purpose.”
1:04:50

Complexities of Immigration and Crime

Discuss the nuanced relationship between immigration and crime rates.

“You're absolutely right that migrants are people like anyone else.”
1:10:02

Debate on Statistics and Crime

A discussion on the impact of immigrant backgrounds on crime statistics.

“They're not immigrants, they're British.”
1:10:56

Evidence from European Studies

Presentation of studies from Finland and other countries linking immigration to crime rates.

“And I said there are studies that show this, and we argued, you tried to bring up British-Pakistanis, and I made the point, well, I'm talking about immigrants because British-Pakistanis are British, blah, blah, blah.”
1:11:56

Cultural Values and Offence Rates

Discussion on cultural differences and their potential impact on crime rates.

“do you accept that this is I'm reading out here this is from Venice AI all these studies that you asked for do you accept this?”
1:13:12

Assimilation and Community Integration

Exploring the assimilation of immigrant populations and the implications for society.

“The figures that I'm talking here, so for example, it says...”
1:14:24

Historical Context of Foreign Policy

Discussion on the historical role of Western intervention in Afghanistan and its consequences.

“We have a large settled Pakistani population, but we also have large numbers of people arriving from Pakistan.”
1:16:08

Responsibility and Refugee Policy

Debate on the moral responsibility toward Afghan refugees and the criteria for selection.

“because I think it is absolutely key, is this country helped destroy Afghanistan.”
1:17:38

Public Stance on Military Interventions

Discussion on the importance of voicing opinions against military interventions.

“but my view on it was always it would have been better to go in and take out Osama bin Laden and al-Qaeda with special forces.”
1:18:34

Arguments for a More Selective Immigration Policy

Presenting the case for a selective approach to immigration based on crime statistics.

“Look, I encourage people to use social media as part of activism.”
1:19:42

Screening and Immigration Processes

Exploring the practicalities of screening immigrants and their implications.

“My actions on this is, I opposed it when I became a public figure, and I've always said so.”
1:21:40

Dialogue on Refugee Arrivals

Discussion on the complexities of refugee arrivals and legal asylum processes.

“I know what you're saying, but I'm saying what does that mean in practice?”
1:24:01

The Impact of Refugee Arrivals

Discussion on Afghan refugees and their reasons for coming to Britain.

“What we did is we closed down safe and legal routes.”
1:25:23

Debate on Immigration Numbers

Exploration of historical immigration numbers and current trends.

“which would then reduce the number of people arriving by small boats.”
1:26:40

The Consequences of War

Debate on the repercussions of military interventions in Afghanistan and Iraq.

“And don't you think that that is a far better explanation of why people are upset about immigration than your argument?”
1:27:55

Responsibility for Refugee Crisis

Discussion on the moral responsibility for refugees resulting from conflict.

“Do you understand what per capita means?”
1:29:05

Evaluating Immigration Arguments

Analysis of arguments regarding immigration and who should bear the burden.

“and the vast majority of them stayed either internally displaced or in their poorer neighbouring countries.”
1:30:00

Legal and Safe Routes for Refugees

Discussion on the need for legal and safe immigration routes.

“The tiny percentage of Afghan refugees and Iraqi refugees come here.”
1:31:30

Economic Considerations in Immigration

Debating the economic implications of immigration policies and public services.

“Open safe and legal routes, and then you reduce them.”
1:34:22

Public Opinion on Immigration

Exploration of public sentiment regarding various aspects of immigration.

“Yeah, but she was the Home Secretary at the time.”
1:36:14

Proposed Changes to Immigration Policy

Discussion on suggestions for improving immigration policy and regulations.

“people, by large margins, say they don't want to remove those migrants.”
1:38:01

Debate on Immigration and Benefits

Explore the contentious debate on immigration policies and the implications for foreign nationals in terms of benefits and employment.

“I would also reduce the number of people, in fact, not reduce, I would just say there shouldn't be any benefits for foreign nationals in this country.”
1:49:19

Mental Health and Stigma

Discuss the stigma surrounding male mental health and the societal pressures that contribute to it.

“And, you know, I interviewed straight men who were homophobically bullied throughout their childhood, beaten up, attacked and all the rest of it, in a way that I wasn't as a gay man.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On TRIGGERnometry, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:01Francis Foster: I think the real disagreement here is I don't think you understand how the market works. So how could those things that happened in 1984 and 85 cause a recession in 1980? It says these policies helped plunge Britain and the US into dire recession in the early 80s. But the policies happened five years later. No, that's not true. Deregulation begins immediately. People feel they're competing for scarce resources. is, immigration has actually, without immigration, our economies would be poorer. My policy is that we're much more selective about who we let into this country. Do you understand the word selective?

0:36No, I know what you're saying. I know what you're saying, but it doesn't, I'm saying what does that mean in practice? I'm trying to tell you. Tell me. It's funny talking about economic insanity and problematic, it's one of the most insane economic ideas I've ever heard. Well, the market.

0:49Francis Foster: Are you interviewing me here? Well, it feels like I am now, yeah. Yeah, well, maybe you should stop. Are you too popular? Is life too easy? Then head over to our merch store and change your life forever by telling the world you watch Trigonometry. You'll be able to buy hoodies, t-shirts, caps, stickers, posters and of course the world famous Trigonometry mug. Go to shop.triggerpod.co.uk. That's shop.triggerpod.co.uk and become part of the show. Owen Jones, welcome to Trigonometry. Here I am in the heart of the beast. Beautiful studio It's a really beautiful studio by the way Of course Thank you very much We open with a compliment Who says people who disagree can't Can't disagree Let's keep it up Looking very dapper You also not as dapper but still presentable I'm in a brown shirt so keep him with the character He said it But anyway It's so good to have you on Thank you very much for coming on Really enjoyed the book And one of the things you talk about a lot is neoliberalism.

1:56And I think it's really important before we delve into all the issues. Could you just define what you mean by it? Because it's a word we hear all the time. I don't think a lot of people know what it means. No, yeah, that's totally fair enough. I think neoliberalism is it's privatization of state assets. It's slashing taxes on those with assets and with wealth. It's curtailing organized labor. It's promoting marketization. it's in practice it's financialization it's about rewarding assets and finance over the productive economy it means an economy which is geared towards finance I mean 80 % of finance is recirculated through finance insurance and real estate rather than going to the productive economy so it's the financialization of everything everything becomes a financial product companies don't invest anymore in the way they should in their own company it goes to share buybacks it goes to share dividends um so yeah i think it's marketization privatization and it's financialization okay kind of gist i guess right okay and so what are your issues with that let's just pick this apart so um what it's done in practice is less growth which is less equitably distributed.

3:13So the average growth in the 1970s was almost the same as it was in the 1980s. The 1970s is portrayed as Britain is in a catastrophic meltdown. It's a sick man of Europe. It's stagflational, the rest of it. And no question, Britain and the West were in a bit of a mess in the 70s, mainly because of the oil shop of the early 70s. A bit of deja vu, because we're kind of going through that again, because of conflicts in the Middle East, It's 1973 onwards, you get the Arab states imposing an oil embargo. And later as well, with the Iranian revolution, you get another oil shock. So you get massive inflation, but it's also caused by the Vietnam War because the Americans didn't print money, or sorry, they did print money.

3:58They didn't raise taxes to pay for the war, they printed money. So you get this inflationary wage, the international financial framework, Bretton Woods, collapses under Richard Nixon. So the West is in this mess in the 1970s because of that. But Thatcher and Reagan spun a story. This is because of the state. It's because of the unions. But what you get in the 80s is the same amount of growth in Aboriginal Britain. In the 90s, the growth is less. In the noughties, it's lower. In the tens, it's about the same. And in the 20s, again, it's very weak growth. So what you've had since that tourism is 80s, the same growth as the 70s, less equity distributed.

4:39Every decade after that, it's lower growth than the 1970s. You get the privatisation of utilities, shit in our water. Railways, which are obviously a rip-off, inefficient mess, which are subsidised by the public, even though they're privatised. You get a housing crisis. Four in ten of the homes flogged off by right to buy are now rented out by private landlords charging twice the rent. You get, because of the smashing of the unions, you get stagnating wages. Even before the crash, they were stagnating for millions of workers. But the average British worker now, their wages are pretty similar to what they were in 2008.

5:20You've got the financial crisis, which was all about, that was what financialisation led to. So we've ended up with an economic model, which is, again, it's all about assets rather than productive industry. It's about complex financial products rather than making things. And which is why even the likes of Donald Trump talk about that legacy. They talk about de-industrialization. They don't talk about the reasons why. But we've ended up with an economic model, which works very well for a certain elite. But for actually for millions of workers in America, again, wages in America have been stagnant for decades.

5:56And for British workers and for workers across the Western world, this is an economic model which has led to insecurity, stagnation, a public realm which is underfunded and crumbling. So I think neoliberalism has obviously failed. I don't even see what the defence is, because by definition, if you look back to even the 60s, when you have high tax public ownership and strong trade unions, that's the decade with the highest growth that Britain has. And it's more equitably distributed. You get sustained rises in living standards of constantly improving public services. But that's all gone. We do have stagnation and decline.

6:34That's economic stagnation and decline. Social progress has come to an end. technology improves you get more advanced phones we've got ai but in terms of how people's people's lived experience it's it's insecurity and stagnation except for the people at the top i don't know what's the i don't know what the defense of the economic model is i don't see

6:52Francis Foster: just any the stats speak for themselves i think well and this is the central uh thesis of your book that neoliberalism at home as you call it all of the things that you described plus adventurism or militarism or imperialism whatever you might want to call it abroad these two things combined are the reason where the West is. And you do a fairly good summation, actually. I'd say 90%. There's 10 % where we can talk about later, perhaps. But 90%, you do a very good summation of the kind of mainstream alternative arguments for the position the West finds itself in today. And the kind of central right-wing arguments, you explain what they are, faithfully, actually, which is to your credit.

7:37Francis Foster: And then you explain what you've just explained. And so the central thesis is neoliberalism at home, the way you've described it, combined with militarism abroad, let's say. Is that a fair summation? Exactly. So they collide together. So you get this economic model, which just factually speaking, doesn't deliver the growth it did. And it's less equitably distributed. And it's going to all these financial products and the financial sector rather than making things. At the same time, we've had military adventurism. I mean, how many wars is the West supposed to suffer a strategic defeat in before Western elites face a reckoning?

8:16There was the war in Afghanistan, which was a two-decade-long occupation, following, as I detail in the book, the West arming and supporting...

8:24Francis Foster: Oh, so, do you mind if we just stick with the neoliberalism part? I have more questions about that. OK, as long as we come to military adventurism... We may, depending on how much time we have. Oh, come on. No, I'm not... The reason it's not interesting to me personally is we actually agree on that completely. We were both completely opposed to the law. Okay, but the way they fuse, though, the way they fuse... Sure. Because obviously Iraq, Afghanistan, Libya, and now Iran are all absolute catastrophes which have disgraced... And we disagree with all those wars, so that's why it's not that interesting to talk about.

8:49Francis Foster: Fair enough. But the reason they collide with the economic model, in part, is you get destabilisation and population movements as a result. I mean, Libya's a really striking example. That's a failed state. It's collapsed into catastrophe. And what that meant, a population movement arriving in Europe, seven years after the financial crash in particular, where you get stagnating wages and that insecurity I spoke about. And then you get this population movement who are then scapegoated for the economic model. And the way Muslims are portrayed, I think, is very important. important. We will get to this part.

9:32We will definitely get to it.

9:33Francis Foster: Do you mind if we just stick just for the economics? But the reason that's then the problem... I get the argument you're making. I think everybody watching will understand what you're saying. And we will talk about this. The problem with the economic model though is because after the crash, you get a great reverse. Because with the end of the Cold War, the West goes, we've won... This is where I want to get to. Yeah, exactly. We've won this... Do you mind if we just... But with the economic model, people feel, sorry, they feel they're competing for scarce resources. I understand. Because there's no growth.

9:58Francis Foster: I get it. And then when the far right, as I would describe it, say it's because of migrants that you're struggling, people feel if there's no alternative, then they feel they're competing. I totally get it. I promise you we will get to all this. The only reason I was interjecting is I want to talk about the neoliberalism part first. We will definitely talk about mass immigration and all of that in a second. So the central thesis, the one thing that I missed out in my summation of your central thesis is that you say the reason that people thought neoliberalism was a great economic vision and economic set of policies was that it was dominant and supreme at the time the Cold War ended.

10:35Francis Foster: And so you've basically got a victory. I'm using your inverted commas, let's say, for the purposes of this. The West wins the Cold War with neoliberalism, therefore neoliberalism good. Fair summation? Yes. So if you've got the Cold War ending during the 60s, for example, then get you down social democracies dominant at the time. So that form of capitalism would be the one that would be seen as triumphant. And in the introduction, I just want to bring this quote up because it's kind of, it sums up your point of view. And this is what I wanted to talk about. So you say, the Soviet Union's demise came at the very high point of what is variously known as Thatcherism, Reaganism or neoliberalism.

11:12Francis Foster: The selling off of state assets, slashing taxes on big business, the wealthy and the wealthy deregulation, subordinating the real economy to financial institutions and hobbling organized labor. all the stuff we talked about. And you say such policies helped plunge Britain and the US into dire recession in the 1980s. But later in the 1990s, the economies were booming. So in the late 1980s, in the early 1990s, you get another recession. Because you get now, because of this, you get these endemic big recessions which caused massive de-industrialization. But the first recessions that these policies caused were in the early 80s.

11:46Early 80s, so exactly. So I went back to Sheffield, where I was born, and that's a city that was devastated. You get industries that just disappear immediately. So entire communities have their hearts ripped out. These are places where people have, you know, they're often male-dominated. Their father, their grandfather, their great-grandfathers worked there. Entire communities based around them, they just disappear overnight. And you get this, I mean, many of those communities never recovered. You get, you know, and this was done deliberately because what Thatcherism did is hike up interest rates to a very high level.

12:22but also fritted away North Sea oil, in our case, rather than Norway, which invested in a sovereign wealth fund. And what it did is it made our exports very, very uncompetitive artificially, which then just wiped out industries which could no longer compete.

12:38Francis Foster: Okay, so the reason I bring this up is this is the first point in the book where I was like, maybe I'm misunderstanding this. So I went, we used Venisei to fact check stuff. So I went and looked at it. And this way it didn't make sense to me because the privatizations that you talk about, the BT and other British companies, they were sold in 1984. The recession was in 1980. The deregulation of the city, when you talk about financialization, the Big Bang deregulation, that was 1986. Yeah, but... Hold on. So the tax cuts, they... Sorry, I don't understand the criticism, sorry. You need to spell it out.

13:11Yeah, great.

13:11Francis Foster: You've just got to let me make the point. So deregulation of the financial services, 1986. The tax cuts happened at the very beginning of the downturn by the time of... 1981. 1981, exactly. So two years in... Recession started in 1980. And the showdown with the miners that Thatcher had happened in mid-90s. 1984 and 1985. Right. So how could those things that happened in 1984 and 1985 cause a recession in 1980? Well, firstly... Which is what you say. It says these policies helped plunge Britain and the US into dire recession in the early 80s. But the policies happened five years later. No, that's not true.

13:49Obviously, the fact that's like monetarism, which is what you get from the early 80s onwards, is, you know, as I said, what they did is they make British exports less competitive. But what happens is you get, in the 80s, in the early 80s, you get that rapid deindustrialisation which takes place. And then what that does is suck growth permanently out of the economy. So you get this artificial boom in the late 80s, which then ends in a crash. It ends in the early 90s.

14:16Francis Foster: Oh, and I'm talking about, you say that these policies, so I just want to read this quote back. Yes, so in the 90s, what they... So you say selling off of state assets, that's privatisation, right? Yes, selling... Slashing taxes, deregulation, and financial reform, right? These things you say, and hobbling organised labour. Yeah, hobbling organised labour. You say these things caused a recession in Britain and the US in the early 80s, but all of these things happened later. They happened after the recession. Well, firstly, deregulation begins immediately. So in 1980, for example, you get, that's when, for example, right to buy, they start announcing privatisation then.

14:52And you get the removal of import controls and so on. So you suddenly allow, at the time when monetarism is being introduced in Britain, you suddenly get the ability to, so capital can leave and inflows and outflows at the same time. when they're hiking interest rates and...

15:16Francis Foster: Well, they're hiking interest rates to deal with the inflationary pressures of the oil shocks, but I'm not trying... No, not because of the oil shocks. Okay, but let's park that for a second. Owen, I'm not trying to catch you in a quote that you've kind of got wrong or whatever. The reason I'm picking this bit out specifically is it challenges the entire thread of your argument. Hold on, but let me explain my argument before you challenge it. I really welcome you pushing back on this. I'm just trying to stress, as we do with everybody. Yeah, of course. Trying to stress test your argument. So your central thesis, as we established, is Thatcher and Reagan come in.

15:49Francis Foster: They do privatization. They break up trade unions. They do all the stuff that you mentioned. And that causes the economic stagnation and problems that we have. Which then we have permanently. Right. Because in the night, what they do is they introduce this boom and bust. Oh, you've got to let me finish my question. Yeah, of course. Yeah, sure. Sorry. So you say all these things cause a recession. But what I'm saying to you is the things you say caused the recession happened five years after the recession you say it caused. No, that's not true. Privatization does begin in the first term of the 1980s.

16:18So when was BT privatized?

16:20Francis Foster: BT was... 84. 84, 85. And all of these other big companies that were privatized, they only really got going in 84, but the recession happened three years before that. So is it possible that your argument sort of breaks down on that basis? because what the counter argument to your argument is, you have these two oil shocks, 73 and 79. And the reason that Thatcher, and this is kind of the established narrative, let me lay it out, you can then argue with it, is that the reason that we had a recession in 1980 was not because of neoliberalism, but because a decision was made, we either choose inflation or unemployment.

16:56Francis Foster: Hold on, let me just finish the argument and then you can answer it. And we either choose inflation or we choose unemployment. and a decision was made to hike interest rates to prevent inflation from spiralling. So what happens, privatisation is a process which begins in the first term because what they do with these state-owned firms is they prepare them for privatisation. So what they do is they remove the state subsidies from those state-owned industries. And the removal of that, which is part of preparing for the privatisation, which they did, of mining, for example. So mining is a really striking example.

17:29You get the beginning of the privatisation, which takes place in the first term of Thatcher's government. What that means is market discipline is imposed on British coal. Now, is British coal privatised in the first term of the Thatcher government? No. But is the state subsidies removed from these state-owned industries in preparation for privatisation? Yes. Does that then cause, in part, because what happened in the early 80s, and this is part of the deregulation I talk about, is state subsidies are removed from various industries on the basis of the states, this was their argument at the time, was picking winners and losers.

18:10So their view, the argument of thatcherism was, we are going to remove this state intervention, this state support, in preparation for privatisation. We're going to impose market discipline. And that happened at the very moment they'd hiked interest rates and allowed the outflow and inflow of capital without state intervention. So that is deregulation and that is the policy of privatisation because it's the beginning. It's the removal of state support. Is that deregulation? Yes, of course it is. Of course that's deregulation. What are you talking about? The people who watch this show have generally done more thinking about how governments operate the most.

18:46But there's a difference between understanding the problem and having actually built insulation against it. That's the world Mikhail Thorup operates in. He's been living as an expat for over 25 years, visiting more than 110 countries and calling nine of them home. He founded expat money nearly a decade ago to help others do the same. When he helped someone build an international Plan B, the knowledge he brings is entirely first hand. Every recommendation comes from something he has already done himself. Expat Money works specifically with freedom minded families and investors who want to reduce their exposure on any one government or any one system.

19:23Second residencies, second citizenships, offshore banking, international real estate, legal structures that spread your life across borders. Mikkel has put together a free report called Plan B Residencies and Instant Citizenships. It covers five routes to a second passport, including one that almost never gets discussed. How a foreign residency functions as genuine political insurance, which countries actually make sense depending on what you're trying to protect and what it realistically costs. Go to expatmoney.com slash trigger or click the link in the description of this episode to download the report.

19:58There's no charge, no catch. That's expatmoney.com slash trigger.

20:04Francis Foster: No, deregulation is when you remove regulations. What you're talking about is removing state subsidies. Well, it's the withdrawal of the state. That's what I'm talking about. What Thatcherism does is roll back the frontiers of the state. That begins in the, as soon as she comes to power, it comes to power with the imposition of market discipline, as she would describe it, on state industries, which she regards and argues are bloated and inefficient, and therefore state support needs to be withdrawn. And it happened at the very worst moment possible because interest rates had been hyped to such a high degree, and North Sea oil was also discovered, which also then made those exports uncompetitive.

20:43Did she privatise all those industries, including mining? Mining came significantly later, actually. No, but she imposed those policies of withdrawing the state from the economy at that time. And that is what caused the massive recession. So of course, I stand by what I said. Privatization is a process. But what the state did, I mean, you can see this with the railways. What Thatcherism did is starve the railways of resources. And then the argument was, well, the railways aren't properly, they look at them, they're disintegrating the state ownership and they need private investment and so on. But it's wrong to look at privatization as this happened in, for example, on this particular day without looking at how she removed the state's support for those industries in preparation for privatisation.

21:27It's a process, of course it is.

21:28Francis Foster: The same is true in the United States, where the recession was in 1981 and 1982. And again, all of the things that you talk about, breaking up unions and all that happened in 1986. That's false. That's false. Sorry, that's completely false. When is the first bus stop between Ronald Reagan and the organised labour movement? It's not about the first bus stop. No, no, no. When they actually... did the labour busting in 1986. That's not true in America. What's the big turning point with the labour movement? You must know this. Tell us. It's the air traffic controllers. Okay. 1981, immediately. But that doesn't cause a recession, right?

22:04No, what it does, what that did is unleash a massive spate of union busting all across the United States of America. And what that did is remove the organising, the power of organised labour to sustain the living standards of workers. But that doesn't cause a recession. That sucks demand out the economy. Of course, that's what happens. But at the same time, I mean, under Reaganism, again, you get the withdrawal of... They didn't have the same levels of state interventionism that the social democratic consensus existed in America. And yet they also had a recession. Wouldn't that be more likely because by the old fight?

22:42No, because what they did is they immediately introduced cuts to public expenses. I mean, sorry, the other point, which was completely missing here, is the cuts. Because this is what I was talking about. It's the withdrawal of the states. That's what we're talking about. So what Thatcher does in the early 80s, as soon as he comes to power, is impose sweeping cuts, not just on the subsidies I'm talking about, but on state, from state investment. Ronald Reagan does the exact same thing. That sucks demand out the economy. And that's that rolling back of the states, which is what they all did. And they did it on the basis of the let the market let rip and that will raise prosperity.

23:17But the cutting of state expenditure under Reagan and Thatcher during a recession, unlike the Keynesian argument is you invest at this time because then it's counter-cyclical and so on. What they both did is they were ideologically committed to rolling back the state. And that is what made those recessions in America and Britain so profound. And they did it at the time where they disciplined organized labor, which is what obviously Reagan did, reducing the bargaining power of unions in order to raise the wages of the workers. So, of course, yes. I mean, everyone knows Reaganism and Thatcherism at the beginning rolled back the states.

23:58I'm not disputing that. No one questioned that then caused a huge recession.

24:03Francis Foster: The argument was... The recessions lasted about a year. There was a double-dip recession in the US. And in the UK, it lasted from, I think, Q1 in 1980 to Q2 in 1981. So they weren't that long. They were about a year long. And what's interesting to me would be, how do you explain the rapid recovery you see after that? Well, I mean, just firstly on that, what they all did is inflict lasting catastrophic damage. Possessions do, sure. No, but that's not fair or reasonable. Actually, I'm kind of surprised at the argument, given the way Trumpism has particularly postured in defence of the Rust Belt communities, for example.

24:40Because in all of these cases, you get a rapid fall, particularly in Britain. And Britain is the worst case where you get deindustrialisation in a really rapid scale. And those communities then never actually recover.

24:55Francis Foster: Sure. And then you get a boom, which is, because as I've said, in the 1980s, the average growth is the same as the 1970s. Yeah. But what you get is a... The way to explain that is because you get a boom and bust. And what the boom does is it's based partly on the inflation of asset prices. You get the... and of big finance. You obviously don't get the big bang for several years in Britain, but that is such a misnomer in terms of how people think of financialisation. I mean, financialisation actually started in the early 70s under the Ted Heath government when they basically liberalised cheap credit.

25:36But in the early 80s, after the abolition of exchange controls, that obviously has a huge impact in the financialisation of the British economy. So you get a boom which becomes about inflating asset prices and big finance. and obviously some people do very well out of that and some people did very well, not least in the South East. But at the same time, industry was falling apart in the North. You get then an economic recovery which is extremely weighted and it's weighted in favour of people who are affluent and you do get, for example, people, I mean, you know, short-term sugar rushes, people, for example, right to buy.

26:20Did some people, working class people, benefit from that? Yes. The question is what happens to their children and their grandchildren when four in ten of the properties rented out to right to buy are now rented out by private landlords charging twice the rent. So the issue is you get, you know, when you get growth and no one questions you, you've got growth. And, for example, you've got a boom. You get an actual boom in the late 80s in particular. That boom actually helps build the economic model, which I would argue is one that delivers overall less improvements to living standards and wages.

26:53And that's what happens. I mean, you get a boom in the 80s, which cements the financial sector as the epicentre of the British economy. And then in the 90s and the noughties, wages in America and Britain stagnate. And the only way that's compensated for, where people don't feel they're actually getting poorer, is because of cheap credit. But what happens then with the financial crash? So, yes. I mean, you could say, did Reaganism and Thatcherism, by rolling back the state and withdrawing the state from the economy, which is what happened immediately, which was my point, did that cause a recession?

27:28Yes. Did their policies also cause a sugar rush, which causes a big boom in the late 80s, which benefits some sections of society at the expense of others? Yes. Does that build an economic model? But, oh, and that's true of everything. Is that an economic model then, which overall produces less rises in living standards?

27:47Francis Foster: I understand what you're saying, but that's true of any policy. Policy of subsidising industry to the tune that Britain was subsidising industry. It also benefits some section of society at the expense of others. So all policies create these trade-offs, right? Yes, but... So South Korea was an example that I looked at in the book. Because South Korea is cited by Thatcher and Reagan as a vindication of capitalism. Now, that's because you could go, well, there's North Korea, a self-declared communist state, and then there's South Korea, a capitalist state. South Korea, North Korea originally is more industrialized and better off than South Korea.

28:25South Korea then leapfogs it and does much better. Hey, presto, that shows capitalism is innately superior to communism. Now, Stalinism doesn't work. The Stalinist undemocratic command economy doesn't work. It can industrialise a country quite quickly, often at great cost. See, we do agree on some things. There we go. But can we believe... No, obviously a tanking. But can it deal with a complex consumer economy? It absolutely cannot do that. No. And you need... I mean, that's one reason. Without democracy, how can you allocate resources properly? Full stop. If you just have bureaucrats controlling everything from the centre, you can't do that.

29:00But South Korea is, you know, if people advocated for the policy South Korea has in this country, they would be called not just communists, they'd be called extreme communists. Because in South Korea, the whole policy was based on the nationalization of the entire financial sector, pretty much, as well as the commanding heights of the economy. And the point there that winners and losers is what they did is they strategically invested the money in the industries that they wanted to grow and they wanted to expand. I'm in favour of that. And that's... But that... Ah, but you see what Thatcher... Then you can't support Thatcherism.

29:33Francis Foster: I don't support Thatcherism. I'm just asking you questions about your book. No, oh, fair enough. But I'll try to work out... But that's my job. But yeah, true. Sorry, I didn't know... Politically, I thought you would have supported Thatcher. But the problem is... But Thatcher... Thatcher went in the opposite direction. That's the problem. But Owen, this is very black and white. It's like, I support some things Thatcher did without supporting all of it. What I'm saying is my view has always been that the government borrowing money to invest in the right things that I think are the right things.

29:58Francis Foster: is perfectly valid and a reasonable thing to do at certain points in the economic cycle. So this is not a black and white conversation, but in this conversation, I'm really interested in stress testing the arguments that you're making. That's it. OK, so... So let's leave that there. No, but on South Korea... You made your point. No, you're right. Fair enough, though. But that is why, if you look at the policy of the early... Well, I think we should invest way more money in nuclear energy, for example, in this country, and should make it way easier to build nuclear power plants. It's a good example.

30:24But you want an industrial active policy, fair enough. But the point is, it's what Thatcher's and regularism did, is abdicate responsibility to the market. You let the market... You made a point. But South Korea, which they venerated, did the exact opposite. And actually, if you look at all those sorts of economies in Asia, that's what they did. And they didn't have the... You know, we pursued economic policies, which led to decline, an economic model which doesn't deliver rising living standards, improve public services and improve security. That ended in the 80s. So we're talking about alternatives.

30:53One of the countries that you thought really worked at the time was Venezuela. You said it was an inspiration to the world, showed that there was an alternative. And somebody, and everybody would know this on the show, they can drink. My mother's from Venezuela. I saw in real time what happened when Venezuela literally descended into, basically, let's be honest about it, a form of hell. 78 % poverty, 38 % extreme poverty. That means you effectively can't eat. 75 % of Venezuelans lost 19 pounds on average. and obviously the poorest lost a lot more. Inflation, 10 ,000%, and then it just skyrocketed.

31:28Caracas was the murder capital of the world, the kidnapped capital of the world. I mean, it doesn't give me any pleasure to say this. It's a failed state, isn't it? No, I know that that's a completely reasonable point. And, you know, when I wrote about that in 2012, that wasn't the case. What happened under Chavez from 1998 to 2012 was poverty objectively fell very, very deeply. you did get public investment in public services and so on. I went there in 2012. I went and, you know, and, you know, there was certainly the big issue that came up in 2012 when I went there was the question of violent crime.

32:05I would argue that that wasn't specific to Chavez. I mean, Venezuela in the 1980s also had very high levels of violent crime. And equally, I would note in the 1980s, under what I would term neoliberal administration in Venezuela, you had as well, you had hyperinflation in the 1980s. Not to the same extent. Not to the same extent, but it was really high. It was very high inflation. And the reason I think, you know, because, you know, there were other examples in Latin America which didn't end up in that catastrophe, which pursued like Bolivia, for example, which again reduced poverty to a large, to a huge degree, expanded public services, which didn't end up like Venezuela.

32:45And the big mistake of Venezuela, which I should have obviously thought of at the time and definitely was something that I guess I've learned from, is they made fossil fuels, they made oil their absolute centrepiece. 98 % of our economy was dependent on it, you're correct. And what, you know, that was a disastrous policy, as we saw. I do think US sanctions have obviously played a role. That's obviously throttled the economy. So I wouldn't, you know, that is a contributing factor. It was basically a siege on Venezuela. But nonetheless, the model, the kind of petro-socialist model is not a model which works.

33:28And that is a model we can see from 2013, 2014, just collapse. And you can see it collapsing. US sanctions did obviously play their role but in 2012 Venezuela wasn't, I mean as I said violent crime was definitely a big problem, I don't think that was specific to that period but poverty had objectively collapsed in Venezuela. And it was also civil rights abuses, let's be fair Chavez was an authoritarian regime I had family members who were I'll tell you a story, one of my family members was literally, he was the president of the Bank of Venezuela, he had a meeting with Chavez 2004, 2005 Chavez demanded he hand over the gold reserves to him My relative refused He went on Hola Presidente Which was the show where he took over all of the TV channels Said the words Diego Luis Fuera And put him under house arrest until he handed over the gold reserves My cousins were journalists I mean they were pretty much told from 2005 onwards If you criticise the government You were going to be in very serious trouble I think what I'd push back there I mean, obviously I'm not denying the experiences that your family had there at all, and I don't know the specifics and so on, is I met the opposition while I was there, and I spoke to the opposition, and they were obviously very denunciatory of Chavez and opposed him, but when I asked them specifically as a dictator, they said, no, but it's our job to stop him creating a dictatorship, and they spoke to what they regarded as his demagogic tendencies.

34:55And all the way through that period, the Venezuelan media was not just bitterly overwhelmingly opposed to Chavez, but kind of beyond parody opposed. And what happened in the early... But to be fair... Just quickly, in the early 2000s, there was a Pinochet-style coup against... Chavez led a coup before that. Yeah, well, I'm not a coup guy, and obviously, you know, he should... But this was an attempt to overthrow a democratically elected government, which no one questioned Chávez won those elections in the noughties. No one claims that he didn't win those elections. There was a coup which overthrew him.

35:34And a lot of governments after a coup against them would actually probably end up doing a far more authoritarian crackdown than that government ended up doing, actually. I mean, you know, my parents took in, as I read in the book, Chilean refugees who fled Augusto Pinochet's regime, who was obviously put in power partly by the West. to overthrow a democratically socialist government. And I would know in Venezuela, in the 80s, you had a Western-backed government which massacred, in the late 80s, hundreds, if not more people. No, but it was like Tiananmen Square. So I would argue, we can talk definitely Maduro and what happened then, which I'm not going to defend.

36:15But actually, the human rights abuses in Venezuela, and I'm not denying that there weren't examples, but you had a coup against them. The media was... You could literally... But that's their right, Owen. If it happened in the United States... And look, there are many people on the American right who said what the press have done against President Donald Trump is disgraceful, disgusting. If Trump had done that, I would... And the crackdown, shutting down 32 media outlets... I don't support shutting down any media outlets, but OK, let's just do a hypothetical here, shall we? Let's do a hypothetical.

36:51Donald Trump is overthrown in a coup And the entire American media incite the coup, support the coup How did the Venezuela media incite the coup? Because they supported it The vast majority of the media outlets supported that coup You know that, come on, you know that I mean, I read, I saw, look, they were literally broadcasting And inciting people to come and join the coup I mean, it was, and did they all get arrested afterwards? No In America, if CNN and MSNBC and all the rest of it literally called for people to overthrow the government and succeeded in a military coup or whatever against Donald Trump, what would happen to those media outlets afterwards?

37:28Just genuinely, what would happen? What would happen? There would be a risk. But that didn't happen in Venezuela, actually. So you're saying he was not an authoritarian then? I don't think Chavez was a dictator. No, I think he was a democratically elected... Owen, come on. There was a very famous case in 2009. I mean, I met the opposition. They didn't think he was a dictator.

37:48Francis Foster: So when I literally live there, perhaps you can talk a little bit about it. So in 2009, it's a very famous case. You can look this up. Chavez put a Venezuelan dissident in prison. It went to the Supreme Court. The judge let this person go. Chavez, on national TV, called her a bandita. The UN published a report on this and said it was completely egregious. And we can bring it up on Venezia. She then let him go. She was then put in prison. Chavez said he wanted her to go to prison for 30 years. She went to prison in the end for one year in one of the most notorious prisons in Venezuela. I honestly don't know the circumstance of that.

38:27All I'd say is I just do not think in Britain or anywhere else that if you'd had a coup against an elected government, that I would argue the government that was then restored. You don't think Chavez was a dictator. No, but hold on. It's fine. No, but I don't think you argue actually he was a dictator. I think you'd argue he was a thwart. I think he was a dictator. So you don't think he won those elections? I think he won the first election fair and square.

38:51Francis Foster: Just like Vladimir Putin won the first election. No, no, no. I was in 20... You can still be a dictator after winning an election. I was there in 2012, and I went round from polling station to polling station. And every polling station had an observer from the opposition and from the government to look over the process. They had a double lock on voting, where people voted on paper and then voted electronically. and then those different votes were then separately checked to make sure that there wasn't any disparities. No one's arguing with you that he won the first election. What we're arguing about is whether he then became a dictator after that.

39:28That was 2012. That's just before he died. And at the time, the Venezuelan media was largely opposed to him. So it's not the same as Russia where you have media outlets which almost... You don't get dissident media in Russia. It doesn't exist. No, yeah, it does. It does.

39:42Francis Foster: They just have to say we're a foreign agent. That's the way it works in Russia. Dissident journalists, dissident media outlets are... Owen, I'm Russian. I know about Russian media. You do not have mass media in Russia. No, not mass media. Okay, but that's what we're talking about. In Venezuela, you have mass media, including TV channels, which were very against and opposed to Chavez in 2012. Does that change? Yes. And obviously, Venezuela descends into outright authoritarianism, which I would not in any way deny under Maduro. There's no question about that whatsoever. But did... was... you know, if you go to a government...

40:13If you go to a country at the time, which I did, and you see media outlets largely opposed to the president, you meet opposition leaders who are obviously very angry and denunciatory about the government. Most of the things at the time they were talking about was a violent disorder, I would just know, who themselves said, we don't regard him as a dictator. They did seem as demagogic. They said that. I totally accept all that kind of stuff. In the context where you had a coup d 'etat to overthrow him and install a Pinochet-style dictatorship of the sort that the Americans in the West backed in Latin America, which slaughtered thousands of people.

40:50Do I, I mean, again, I just, you know, I don't see that as a dictatorship. The economic model at the time did reduce poverty, but it wasn't sustainable because it was based on oil. I'm glad you said that. But that's what I accept.

41:03Francis Foster: Let's talk about this. If you own gold, you probably bought it for the same reason I did, because you looked at what central banks are doing to currencies and decided you wanted something they can't print. Good reasoning. But here's the thing nobody talks about after you make that decision. Your gold is just sitting there. It's not doing anything. You're paying to store it, you're paying to insure it, and in the meantime, it earns precisely nothing. Until now. What you're about to hear is not a normal gold advert. Today's sponsor is Monetary Metals. They've figured out something that once you hear it, seems obvious, but almost nobody in the gold world is doing it.

41:40Francis Foster: Monetary Metals connects gold owners with productive businesses, refiners, jewelers, companies that actually need physical gold to operate. Those businesses lease your gold and pay you a yield, not in dollars, not in pounds, in gold. So instead of your gold sitting in a vault costing you money, it's out in the real economy doing something useful and you're earning more ounces of gold for it. Up to 4 % annual yield paid in gold. If you already own gold, this is the logical next step. Visit monetary-metals.com slash trigonometry or click the link in the description. See how your gold can stop costing you money and start earning you more gold.

42:21Francis Foster: That's monetary-metals.com slash trigonometry. Well, it's not just petrosocialism. I mean, there are people who've experienced socialism like myself and Francis too, who would argue that very often what tends to happen, particularly with Western leftists who see socialism as the answer and as the alternative, as you said, Venezuela was at the time. They have a very short-term vision because it's like saying, you know, well, you know, in the 1930s, the Soviet Union really did great. And there were lots of people in the West, by the way, at the time who were saying it's wonderful to look at the re-industrialization, look at the order, look at this, look at the grand buildings that were being built, etc.

42:58Francis Foster: And they look at a very short-term picture. They draw conclusions from it because it fits their priors and they don't think about the long-term consequences. And if you speak to people in many countries which have gone through these experiments, what they would say is the reason socialism doesn't work. You mentioned earlier that you thought, you know, you need democracy even in a communist country because otherwise you've got bureaucrats making... I don't support any of those Stalinists, sorry. No, no, not Stalinists. But they wouldn't be, well, they wouldn't be... No, I wasn't saying I'm saying you support Stalinism.

43:27Francis Foster: I'm making a point about the structure of society. You were saying you need democracy because otherwise you've got bureaucrats doing everything. It's not democracy that prevents bureaucrats from doing everything. It's the market that prevents bureaucrats from doing everything. Even if you elect bureaucrats, they still end up running the country. What then happens is, this is a structural argument about these types of societies not working. We saw this in the Soviet Union. is when instead of having the market being the power that decides, that makes these decisions, when you have people with this much power, money doesn't matter as much as the power does.

44:03Francis Foster: And then you get a very corrupt society, which is exactly what Venezuela became. And what all of these societies eventually become, where people will use bribes and influence, etc., to make these decisions instead of the market making them through financial points. And so you end up with a very corrupt society, which is why these societies eventually break down. Just on that, because, I mean, firstly in Venezuela, I mean, Venezuela in 2012, the de Hugo Chavez had a smaller state sector than Britain has now. Are you saying he wasn't a socialist? Well, I mean, what he did is use, actually, the proceeds from oil revenues to invest in social services and in poverty reduction.

44:43You did get nationalisation in oil. Did he do widespread nationalisation?

44:47Francis Foster: But I'm asking you, are you saying he was not a socialist? Because you supported him and you said he's an inspiration. I'm calling it, well, I mean, you know, I said it's a form of petro-socialism. I mean, I'm a democratic socialist and I believe in, you know, am I arguing for, you know, the abolition of all market relations? No, I'm not arguing that. I've never argued for that. But in terms of Venezuela, did you have a government, which was a progressive government? It doesn't matter what label you put to it. It was a government that in that period, I thought was using oil revenues to benefit people who were struggling in a way that I thought improved their lives, which it did, until it all fell apart.

45:23But that's what I'm saying, is these societies fall apart, and you're only looking at the short-term picture because you like the ideas. No, I'm not, because it didn't fall apart in the other Latin American countries. It didn't fall apart in Bolivia. It didn't fall apart in Ecuador. I mean, Ecuador, then, you end up with a right-wing government, partly because a member of the ruling party, when he was elected, then shifted dramatically off to the right. But actually in Ecuador, in Bolivia, in these other Latin American countries where you had left-wing governments, none of these left-wing governments abolished capitalism.

45:54None of them did that. But they did, you know, this was called the Pink Revolution at the time. It was called the Red Revolution at the time. But what they did is they were all different sorts of governments, but they used progressive policies to improve people's lives. Venezuela was the one that fell apart. Bolivia didn't fall apart. Ecuador didn't fall apart. So I don't accept that premise. And also we can't...

46:16Francis Foster: Which premise? Well, because what you're doing is you're basically saying, you know, all of these governments and regimes are all in the same bracket. I didn't say anything about those regimes. No, you said Venezuela and the Soviet bloc, but Venezuela did not introduce a Soviet-style system at all. No one claims that. The vast majority of the country was privately run. What I'm asking is, do you not think that... France, is it fair to say that Venezuela became incredibly corrupt? Yes. That's what I'm asking. these systems create the incentives for corruption which is what you saw yeah but then again so again this is where i think it's quite interesting i was like when i went to venezuela you could it just it was like it was a very capitalist society in lots of ways it was like adverts everywhere shops everywhere they also seized private property you have to accept that they seized private property from the state sector was smaller than it is now i mean as in britain So it wasn't a state-run society.

47:08South Korea, which I've noted, South Korea nationalised all their banks. They nationalised the top tiers of their economy. South Korea didn't... You know what this experience is like? It's like boxing jellos, the Americans would say. But I don't accept... I'm asking you... What am I supposed to say when it's a case of I don't accept the argument that you're making? Because factually, Venezuela didn't become a state-run society.

47:29Francis Foster: A society that has an authoritarian dictatorship. You don't agree. It's an authoritarian system in which people seize private property and under popular demagoguery take from the rich and give to the masses. Is that a socialist society? You clearly thought it was a good society. I didn't think it was a socialist society. I thought it was a progressive government, which was reducing policy. And just to clarify, Chavez in multiple speeches identified that as socialism. Yeah, but Chavez was really quite a complex political character because when he came to power, he called his policies the third way and said he was emulating Tony Blair.

48:07I mean, he went on all sorts of fascinating political journeys, obviously. And obviously they called it 21st century socialism. In practice, did any of those Latin American countries enact mass nationalisation of the economy? None of them did, including Venezuela. That just did not happen at all. They did seize private property. The vast majority of Venezuela remained in private hands. No one can dispute that. That's factually what happened. After World War II, when Britain nationalised the railways and a fifth of the industrial economy, do you regard that as... But they didn't seize it. No, I don't support seizures.

48:43I support pop-up ownership. But that's what they did in Venezuela. Well, again, they didn't largely because they didn't...

48:48Francis Foster: No, no, they did. They just didn't seize everything. They didn't seize the vast majority of the economy. That's exactly what I just said. They didn't seize the vast majority. I support nationalisation, which means you transfer assets from the private sector into the public sector. Just pause. We've got into this argumentative back and forth, so we can't actually talk about this stuff. What Francis is saying is, and what I'm saying is, there's a massive difference between nationalisation as in, I am the government, I will give you money for this thing that you own, and now it comes into private property.

49:19Francis Foster: Andy Burnham, for example, has talked about nationalising potentially water and rail, etc. I don't imagine he will do it by taking it against the will of its current owners. He'll have to pay for it. Yeah, I mean, that's what I advocate. But what happened in Venezuela, which you supported at the time, was people were seizing property without paying anyone a thing. Again, I mean, list what you're talking about. Which aspects of the economy are you talking about? Francis would have to tell you what was seized or we can look it up. So it's farmlands, potentially. What percentage of the farmland was seized?

49:53That I do not know. Why does that matter? Well, I mean, I just, I don't know about that.

49:56Francis Foster: If 100 farms were seized, which is not a lot by the scale of the country, is that okay? I guess the question... So you didn't know... The issue is... No, I didn't know about the farmland. I don't know about the farmland. That's fine, you didn't know. So I'd be interested to know what, because I'd have to know what the context is and all the rest of it. I just don't know about agricultural policy in Venezuela and the Chavez. At the time, what I thought was a big success was the massive reduction of poverty by using oil revenues to invest in social programs. That did succeed. It didn't succeed, obviously, when you could bet in the house on oil.

50:25Francis Foster: What did you learn from getting that one wrong? That I think, just because a model which you can see is working in terms of reducing poverty for, at the time, 15 years, that's how long it reduced poverty for, that you should look under the bonnet. Well, how is it working? And I think, you know, just using, in this case, fossil fuels in order to, you know, to bet the house on that, to invest in your social programs is not a good idea. And that's what Ecuador and Bolivia didn't do because they didn't depend on oil. Oil, you know, that is something which obviously I think all of us who thought Venezuela was working in that sense should have thought about.

51:11I mean, when you say, you know, I'm saying Petro, it doesn't matter.

51:15Francis Foster: So you think if Venezuela didn't have oil, it would have been fine? Well, they would have had to do something else, which is what Ecuador and Bolivia did. So you wouldn't have had what you've had? Well, again, you can just compare the neighbouring countries. But that's why I don't support, obviously, the Soviet system. I don't support that at all. No one's accusing you of that. I would have been locked up. No one's accusing you of that. Well, no, because you started talking about that then. You brought that in while I was talking about Venezuela. And I don't think they're comparable because one is an overwhelmingly privately run economy in which state intervention is actually less than it is in Britain.

51:46Francis Foster: Do you accept that there's a spectrum of political systems? Like at one end you have fascism, at the other end you have communism? Let's say, I mean, I personally think it's a bit of a circle, but it doesn't really matter. Right. So would Venezuela be towards the communist side or towards the fascist side? I mean... Probably towards the communist side. Can we agree on that? Well, I mean, you could say we're closer to communism in Britain than we are to fascism We are, but it doesn't matter. I don't know how helpful that is. Their taxes on the rich were lower than ours, for example. They didn't hike taxes on the rich either.

52:18Communism is not just about taxes on the rich. But what made it communist then? Seizure of private property on authoritarian government. So if they hadn't, I don't know what farmland or how much of that farmland we're talking about. The rhetoric of Hugo Chavez about taking... I think there's rhetoric and substance. You're making the pro-Donald Trump argument there. That's interesting. Well that's Well that is true Because Trump Trump 1.0 And Trump 2.0 Are very different Politically But Trump rhetoric And Trump practice Is also different No I don't I mean The big problem I would argue With Venezuela Actually Is One of the big problems Is they did reduce poverty But they didn't actually Redistribute wealth Particularly There wasn't some Redistribution of wealth They didn't hike taxes They were also highly corrupt Well there's no question That you got I mean I don't think that's specifics to Venezuela, by the way.

53:07Lots of poorer countries have endemic corruption in them. And I don't think, you know, I mean, we could look across various poorer countries. Poorer countries and corruption, that often goes together. And it particular happens when you have, you know, a big, for example, rich resource that's susceptible to corruption. But Venezuela, you know, I think looking back, you know, I think just saying, well, they're reducing poverty to a large degree, which they did, therefore that this is a successful model. First, you can't export it because it's oil dependent. And secondly, they didn't actually change Venezuelan society.

53:40They didn't redistribute the wealth. You still got the big oligarchs in Venezuela. They didn't. That's what always happens in socialist societies. That's the point.

53:47Francis Foster: That's the point. The people at the top always seize a lot of the wealth and keep it for themselves. Yeah, but under a Stalinist system... No, not under Stalinist. Well, under a Soviet system, whatever you want to call it. No, no, no. No, I don't. In societies that have this level of disparity between the power of different people at the top. Venezuela always had that. That's the problem. Latin America is full of very unequal societies. That's not caused by Hugo Chavez. He came to power because Venezuela was such an unequal society. And kept it exactly the same. He didn't. Well, yes, I agree. Just like the communists did in Russia, just like they do in every country that they take over.

54:23Francis Foster: Are you saying the people at the top of the Chinese Communist Party aren't the super rich? No, I'm not disputing that. But that's obviously, I mean... Are you saying the people are the top of the North Korean Communist Party? This is what I don't understand at all. Sorry, hold on a minute. Hold on. Let's pause this. In those countries, what they did is they expropriated the rich, the bourgeoisie, if you like, the capitalist class, and the major landlords. They confiscated. They did. I mean, you've got expropriation on a large scale. Those people then didn't become the top of the Communist Party.

54:54These are different people altogether. In Venezuela, he came to power. He didn't challenge the existing oligarchs. What he did is use oil revenues to put into social programs which reduce poverty. That's not true. There's no... I don't see what the comparison is because he didn't hike taxes on the rich and he didn't engage in mass nationalization of the economy. There is actually no comparison. Did it work in the end? Absolutely not. Should they have bet the house on fossil fuels? Clearly not. But there isn't actually a parallel because they had... They didn't hike the taxes and they didn't engage in mass nationalisation.

55:26And they ended up with lower taxes and less state intervention in the economy than we have in this country.

55:31Francis Foster: So they weren't socialist enough. Well, but they weren't. Obviously, they were less state interventionists than we are. That's just a fact. So Venezuela and Hugo Chavez was more right wing. No, did they have a lower state section at all? You made your point. Let's move on. To come closer to home, we spent a lot of time talking about this fairly abstract thing. I fear no one's watching at this point. Well, let's talk about Europe and the UK and the argument you started to make at the beginning about the fact that effectively we've got these two decades now of stagnation, which you do after the financial crisis in 2008.

56:09Francis Foster: And the reason people are upset about mass immigration and illegal immigration, we can bundle them together for this purpose. people are upset about both because their wages are stagnating. Not just. That gives it the intensity. That gives it the intensity or more intensity? I think the reason you get such an intense anger and fury, in my opinion, is people feel they're competing for scarce resources. Factually speaking, if you look at Britain, Germany, people don't think in terms of studies and statistics. We've gone through that. But immigration has actually, without immigration, our economies would be poorer.

56:51I mean, with, I mean. Our GDP would be smaller, yes. Well, no. Our GDP per capita would be higher. Our tax revenues. Yeah, that's. Our tax revenues would be lower. Yeah. Because, and also migrants on average tend to be younger. So what, that means they're less dependent on public services. Yeah. So they are net, overall, tend to be net contributors to the exchequer. Well, right now they are.

57:12Francis Foster: 20 years from now when they get older and need health care and pupil places and schools and all of that. What was the argument there, given our birth rates collapsing? I mean, without them, we'd be in an even worse situation. I'll tell you what the argument is. We'd have a smaller working population and we'd have a bigger aging population. I'll tell you what the argument is. So the argument is that people make, which is accurate, when you bring bodies in, you increase your GDP, and some of them will work, therefore you increase your tax revenues, right? But if you divide your GDP or your tax revenues by the number of people who are now in the country and include the cost of all the infrastructure that you then have to build, when you do it on a per capita basis, our per capita GDP, despite these massive waves of immigration that we've had, is flatlined.

58:00Francis Foster: Which is what you mean when you say people's living standards are flatlined. Firstly, obviously, you can't divide GDP per capita because that's not how much money we all have. We don't live in a society where GDP has been equally distributed amongst the public. That's not what happened. But what is just factually true is we would have less tax revenues in Britain and in Germany. And we'd have a smaller working age population and a bigger ageing population. That's the problem. Okay, but let's make this really simple for people, okay? Let's say you have a cake and the cake has 10 pieces. Okay? And there's 10 people.

58:38Francis Foster: So each person gets one piece of the cake and they're all the same size. Hold on. Hold on. Just let me finish the argument and then we'll talk about what you disagree with. There's 10 cake, 10 pieces, 10 people. You've now added two more people, one of whom has brought in a piece of cake. So you've got 11 pieces. You've got a bigger GDP. You've got more tax revenue, but there's now 12 people that you have to spread the cake over. No, I know, but this is a zero-sum fallacy. It's just bad. It's just very bad. It's a very popular policy on the left, yeah. No, it's a really bad, it's just really bad economics.

59:09Because? Because migrants expand the cake beyond their own needs. So what you mean, you end up, because of migration, people who are less dependent on public services, they're less likely to use their health services, for example, and what they do is they create economic output. They bring tax revenues, but they also increase economic activity. So what they do is they expand the economy in a way that means other people become better off as a consequence because there's more taxes going into... They are spending more in terms of the exchequer than they are receiving from the state.

59:52Francis Foster: But in order for that to be true, they would have to earn more than the average British person in income and pay more tax than the average person. Well, I mean, study after study shows. It's just, I mean, this is just arguing over facts. But it's just basic logic. But every, every, if there's 10 pieces of cake. If studies show that their net contributes to the executive... Oh, and hold on a second. Just let's use basic logic instead of studies, because there are studies that show otherwise too. But it doesn't show that, by the way, because they're less dependent on the state in terms of what they receive.

1:00:18Well, they are right now, right. But what do you mean? I don't understand what you mean by that.

1:00:21Francis Foster: Okay, I'm an immigrant to this country. Yes. Okay, 20 years ago, I was making less than the average person in this country, but I was also consuming less than the average person in NHS services and whatever. I am now in my mid-40s. I have two children. I am now probably going to use all of the services that the state has to pay for more. I've remained an immigrant. And if I wasn't earning more than the average person, I would now be a net drain. And my children would be, and their children would be, and this carries on, right? So my basic argument is very simple. When you have a large wave of low skill, badly paid immigration, which is what we've had.

1:00:57Francis Foster: By the way, under the Tories, just the same as we did under Labour. That reduces your GDP per capita instead of increasing it, which is exactly what the statistics show. No, it doesn't. Our GDP... Every study shows that economic growth. Hold on, hold on. Every study shows that economic growth. May I finish my point? You've had plenty of time to talk, have you not? We are sixth in GDP, and people say we're the sixth largest economy in the world. We're 29th, or 27th, depending on how you measure it, in GDP per capita. But it's a bad statistic. It's a bad statistic. Despite the wave of immigration that we've had, we are not seeing people getting prosperous in the way that you described.

1:01:34I know, you're absolutely right. No, but that's because of the economic model. What the evidence, what the research shows over and over again, and I cite the evidence, I cite the studies into this, is that we have had weak economic growth, which we agree on, but without immigration, it would be even weaker. That's the problem. So no one is saying immigration has solved the problem of the economic model. I wouldn't. Why would I be a socialist? I would go, well, we don't need to get rid of the economic model. We'll just have mass immigration. That will solve the problem. Who's arguing that? No one's arguing this.

1:02:01Well, you want both. I just, I believe that immigration has enriched this country factually, economically and socially compared to what it would have done. But these two things. But also, what would happen with the care sector? What would happen to the care sector? Hold on.

1:02:14Francis Foster: Hold on. So this is where it's actually really important to have the discussion because you say immigration has enriched this country. I agree. Immigration has also damaged this country. These two things can be true at the same time, and I'll explain why. Not all immigrants are the same. Some immigrants contribute more. Some immigrants contribute less. Some immigrants are conducive to the cohesion of society, and they start businesses and they create jobs, and some immigrants commit crime, right? Immigration is a word, but what it hides underneath it is millions of people who have different behavioural patterns, different cultural attitudes, different ways of being, different rates of committing certain crimes.

1:02:49Francis Foster: Some of them are way more likely to sexual assault women and others less so, right? So when you talk about immigration has enriched this country, that includes people who've come here and opened a restaurant that we all go to and enjoy and have a chat in, and also people who commit grooming gangs offenses, right? So when you talk about immigration, it's not a catch-all. You could be more selective about it, which is what I believe, in this selective immigration system where you get the best of the world and you don't get the worst of the world. And we've had pretty much the reverse. Here's something I've noticed about how people actually behave.

1:03:22When you ring a business and nobody answers, you don't leave a message and you don't try again tomorrow. You ring the next one on the list. Your customers do exactly the same to you. They aren't loyal to you. They're loyal to whoever picks up. Today's episode is brought to you by Quo, spelled Q-U-O. The business phone system built so you will never miss a call. What Quo actually does is straightforward. Every call, text and voicemail lands in one place. So whoever on your team looks at it can see the full exchange and pick it up from there instead of starting cold. Several years into running trigonometry, I've learned that most operational problems aren't solved by hiring more people.

1:04:01They're solved by better systems. This is why Quo stands out to me. It's simple enough to set up in minutes and doesn't require anyone on the team to become an IT person overnight. And when nobody on your team is free to pick up, an AI agent takes a call, answers the obvious questions and can book someone in immediately. The league doesn't sit overnight going cold, which is usually when you lose a business. There's a reason Quo is the number one rated business phone system on G2 with over 90 ,000 businesses relying on it. Money's on the line. Always say hello with Quo. Try Quo for free plus 20 % off your first six months when you go to quo.com slash trig.

1:04:44That's Q-U-O dot com slash trig. You're absolutely right that migrants are people like anyone else. There was a whole breadth of experiences, of attitudes and all the rest. Factually speaking, we would have been in a far worse state because entire sectors of the economy would have collapsed. The NHS would have collapsed. The care service would collapse. A whole swathes of industry wouldn't exist. And we would have a smaller working age population supporting an increasingly ageing population. In a 10-year period between 2014 and 2024, the number of people over the age of 65 increased by 1.5 million.

1:05:32Our birth rate at the same time is collapsing, partly because the government, under our economic order, People cannot afford childcare and they can't afford the cost of kids because of a housing crisis and how expensive childcare is. So just factly speaking, if you end up with a low birth rate and an expanding ageing population and you don't deal with that, you end up in a massive crisis. You can see a demographic crisis in the places like Japan where they haven't had mass immigration and their economy has now been stagnant for about 30 to 40 years. So we can see that experiment in real time. In terms of migrants, you know, I mean, in terms of criminal offences, the percentage overall of migrants who commit offences is roughly the same.

1:06:15It's proportionate to the British population. Hold on.

1:06:17Francis Foster: But again, you're pooling people together in order to do this. So, yes, it's true. If you take Swedes and you take Russians and you take Ukrainians and you take people from the Indian subcontinent and you take people from Eritrea and you take people of Somalia and then you average all of them out. Yes, you will get the same rate of offending average as the British public. But that is not true when you drill down into the statistics. People from parts of the world where women are treated as second-class citizens, where, like in Afghanistan, they're effectively not allowed to go outside without a chaperone.

1:06:46Francis Foster: People from those parts of the world... So people fleeing the Taliban? Hold on, hold on. People from those parts of the world, we know this in the same studies that you talk about, and if the government allowed us to look into this and measure these things properly, we would see even more so. People from these parts of the world commit sexual offences, for example, at a way higher rate than the average British person. Way higher rate. And so the average British person might be saying, why are we bringing them in? I think, I mean, Afghanistan's quite an interesting example. I've met Afghan refugees.

1:07:15Francis Foster: You like studies. So talk about the stats that I'm giving you. People from certain parts of the world commit sexual offences at a much higher rate than the average British person. Why would we bring them here? Well, I mean, in terms of Afghanistan, for example, because, I mean, firstly, as I've said, overall, there is no disparity. I mean, you said it's about averaging out. Yes, it is. You said it's about averaging out. I'm saying people from parts of the world... No, I'll give you an example. No, okay. I'll give you an example. I'll give you an example. No, I think it's a really good example.

1:07:39Take, because this comes up in terms of the grooming scandals and so on, because you mentioned that. You mentioned that. What is the rate of child sex offences amongst Pakistani British men? Tell me. What percentage? No, what percentage? Owen, can you just come back to the...

1:07:56Francis Foster: No, I am. I am. No, but that's... No, you're not. Yes, I am. Yes, I am. No, you're not. You're saying people... You brought up grooming gangs, which I mentioned half an hour ago. Just come back to the question. I am, though. Owen, could you just come... I'm giving an example. I'm giving an example. Owen, everyone watching can see that you're dodging. No, I'm not dodging. Just come back... Do you think Pakistan is an example? Is it... No. Is Pakistan one of those places? Can you come back to... Is Pakistan one of those places? Owen, just come back to the argument I made. I am. People commit sexual offences at different rates, depending on where they come from.

1:08:22Francis Foster: Is Pakistan an example of a place you regard as a place... I don't have the stat that you're asking. Okay, I don't... You don't need to answer the stat. You answer this question instead, please. Do you regard Pakistan as a country in the world where there were problematic attitudes towards women. Do you? I think... Do you? Yeah, I think Pakistan is a place where there's a need for struggle, obviously, like lots of countries against misogyny and so on. But I'm asking... So it's a place where people treat women badly? Is it? The role of women in Pakistan is... Well, I mean, they've had a female leader, unlike the United States of America.

1:08:56Is there a huge problem of misogyny in Pakistan? Yes, I'm not denying that. Okay, so we agree then. So what's your point? Because if you look at sex offences committed by British Pakistani men, they are completely... I'm not talking about British Pakistani men. I'm talking about immigrants. Okay, talking Pakistani full stop. People of Pakistani origin. These are British people. People of Pakistani origin. Do you agree that they're British? Yes, but I'm saying... So maybe different. No, this includes people who were born here or who have moved here. That's not who I'm talking about. Who are you talking about?

1:09:21This is ridiculous. Immigrants. We were talking about immigrants.

1:09:23Francis Foster: So you consider British Pakistani immigrants? No, you're saying that people from other parts of the world, when they come here, some commit sexual offences more than others because of where they're from. And then you brought up British-Pakistanis who are British and therefore not immigrants. The statistics include people who were born in Pakistan and are migrants and people who are born in this country who are British. I'm talking about immigrants. I'm talking about first-generation immigrants who are not British. People who are quote-unquote fresh off the boat from Somalia and Eritrea commit sexual offences at a higher rate than the British population.

1:09:55But that would mean, in the case, for example, of those who are of Pakistani heritage in this country, that would mean they would have had an outsized impact on those offences. They're not immigrants, they're British. No, the statistics include people born in Pakistan. Not the statistics. Which statistics then? Which ones are you talking about? You're talking about such small sample sizes, you can't talk about them, you can't extrapolate them. Which ones?

1:10:18Francis Foster: There are studies from all over Europe where you are actually allowed to measure this. We can bring them up on the screen for people watching, which show... You shouldn't do that because you need to bring the studies to me. You can't just say... Okay, no worries. Dean, could you get my phone, please? We'll get Vanessa to show us this. So, Owen, we took a little break to look this up. I just want to remind you where we pause this, okay? I made the very simple argument, which is people from certain countries around the world, particularly countries where treatment of women is not what we would all like it to be, are more likely to commit sexual offences.

1:10:48Francis Foster: And I think a lot of people are reasonably going to ask in that situation, why would we not be more selective about... Is that a fair summation of where we parted? Yeah, yes, that's fine, yeah. Cool. And I said there are studies that show this, and we argued, you tried to bring up British-Pakistanis, and I made the point, well, I'm talking about immigrants because British-Pakistanis are British, blah, blah, blah. So here are the studies from Europe that I'm talking about. Finland, there was a study in 2017-2018 that found that foreign-born offenders represented 27.2 % of suspects versus 7 % of the population.

1:11:21Francis Foster: So there's several times more likely than native Finns to commit that offense. In particular, Iraqi men are 12.8 times more likely to be suspected of a sexual offence. And for specifically, I think it's 1.31 per thousand people versus 0.08 for Finnish men. These studies are replicated in Germany, in Sweden and in Europe. And by the way, we're not allowed, the government does not collect these statistics deliberately in this country. And many people would argue that's to conceal the reality to, quote, protect community cohesion. so if do you accept that this is I'm reading out here this is from Venice AI all these studies that you asked for do you accept this?

1:12:04I don't know those particular figures but I will take the figures that you just said.

1:12:07Francis Foster: So we can accept them for a second okay cool so hold on so if it's the case that foreign born people from certain parts of the world are way way more likely to commit and we all I think agree is bad wouldn't we be reasonable to be more selective about allowing people from that part of the world to come here? So the problem is it's not controlling for age in particular? No, these studies do control for age. And it reduces some of the effect. I've got... Hold on, hold on. Okay, because I'm looking here. So it says, for example... It reduces some of the effect. Germany is a really striking example, for example, because it dramatically reduces it.

1:12:44Francis Foster: But it's still significantly different to the native population. That's... I mean, for example, a 2026 peer-reviewed study It looked at all 33 countries from 2008 to 23, obviously 2015 being the big population movement, and it found there was no statistically significant relationship between immigration inflows and recorded sexual crime. But that's not what I'm talking about. But you are, because we're talking about the increase in... No, you're backing your own point. But I'm not, because you're talking... I've got to be able to answer it. The figures that I'm talking here, so for example, it says...

1:13:14Francis Foster: I accept what you said and let me answer it. But we're talking here particularly about places with higher levels of immigration. No, no, you just said immigration doesn't seem to increase the number of sexual offences. That matches your earlier statement that overall immigrants don't commit sexual crimes at a high rate. It was looking at asylum specifically as well. Well, fine, but that still doesn't change the argument. My argument is not all immigration is the same, and the evidence clearly bears that out. Now, you say, if you include the fact that these people are younger. Young men. Young men.

1:13:43Yeah, because that's what...

1:13:45Francis Foster: And those are the groups that are more likely to commit sexual offences. Then it's not as skewed. It's still skewed, but it's not as skewed. But that's the same argument you made about the NHS. You say these people are great to have because they're young. And I'm saying, yeah, but they're young also means they commit a higher rate. So wouldn't we be more selective? And particularly the point I'm trying to get you to accept is that not all people from all parts of the world are the same. They have different cultural values. And some of those cultural values we might not want here. Well, again, I mean, what you're arguing there is about partly about assimilation.

1:14:14No, it's not No, it's not about simulation With all due respect, it is Because again, I don't know why we keep dismissing Not least because it keeps coming up In this whole discussion Which is the main discussion we've had in this country About this whole issue Which is about the issue of grooming gangs I'm not talking about grooming gangs We're talking about sex offences We're talking about those who commit sex offences We've accepted, all of us That in Pakistan the position of women is significantly worse than it is in this country. We have a large settled Pakistani population, but we also have large numbers of people arriving from Pakistan.

1:14:54The evidence shows that they are not more likely to commit sex offences than the overall population. And we've had, obviously, an assimilation of, despite people claiming that Muslims are not assimilated in this country. I know you said they're not assimilated in this country. I said they're not assimilated. You said basically, I looked up, you said about British Muslims not being assimilated. When did I say that? I can look it up if you want.

1:15:18Francis Foster: You can if you want. The one stat I've always, whenever I've talked about this that I've always given is I've said that, I quoted The Guardian, which I imagine you're a fan of, which said that more Muslims have joined ISIS and al-Nusra than have joined the British army. Right. So I don't think that's evidence of assimilation. But a large number of Muslims are very well assimilated in this country, a large number are not. I think that part, we have a huge Pakistani population of British Pakistani origin, and we have large migrant flows from Pakistan to Britain, that you don't have, despite what we said about within Pakistan, in terms of problems that women face, that women don't face problems in this country, you don't see that.

1:15:58And that is to do, obviously, with the fact that you obviously can bring people in from different parts of the world, and people can assimilate. The point you make about Afghanistan, I just really have to just make this point because I think it is absolutely key, is this country helped destroy Afghanistan. We funded the jihadis, the majahadeen, in the 1980s. I don't know if you support that or not. Do you support the West's support of jihadis in the 80s in Afghanistan?

1:16:23Francis Foster: I was about... No, but do you? No, come on. I say that I oppose it. Look, I'm a geriatric millennial. I don't know how old you are. Yeah, I'm similar age. Okay, we don't need to play around. We don't need to piss around there. Come on. You either support it or you don't, in hindsight. I think the West should not... Do I, in hindsight, support the West giving money to the Madji Houdini? No. Good, we agree. But we agree. Well, no, that's not... Because lots of people still defend that. They defend that on the basis of bringing down the Soviet Union and all the rest. So that, I mean, that is not...

1:16:52I don't know. I've never seen you comment on this. So what's your argument? We helped destroy Afghanistan, therefore we have to accept their rapists. And then... We committed heinous war crimes in Afghanistan. Do you know what we did to Afghanistan? Do you know about the war crimes we committed? I do. Right. So we have to bring in the rapists now. No, because the vast majority of Afghan refugees are not rapists. No, they're not. And what we have, in my view, is an obligation to people in countries we've helped, in my opinion, destroy. And if you don't want to bring in refugees from those countries, then you should have loudly marched and opposed...

1:17:25Did you march against the war in Afghanistan? I marched against the war in Iraq. Afghanistan was a bit... Well, I'm talking about Afghanistan. Did you support the war in Afghanistan? Do you think we should have gone in at the time? Look, I was young. Did you support going into Afghanistan?

1:17:36Francis Foster: I didn't have a strong opinion at the time because I was very young, but my view on it was always it would have been better to go in and take out Osama bin Laden and al-Qaeda with special forces. So did you vocally oppose the occupation when it was happening at any point? I was probably, what, 16 at the time? No, you weren't. It ended in 2021. Did you oppose the occupation? Oh, yeah, yeah. I think I pretty much said it. I said one time I appeared on GB News. It was a catastrophic mistake. Well, we didn't. No, no, I'm not saying after it happened. I'm saying during the occupation, what did you do to oppose it?

1:18:06What did you say about it? I was against it. No, can you cite an example of you publicly? Did you protest about it? Did you write articles denouncing it? Did you do videos about the West occupation of Afghanistan? Did you do any of those things?

1:18:19Francis Foster: Owen, I became a public figure about six years ago. It doesn't... Well, six years ago... In that time, I've said it was a mistake. Since I became a public figure, I became a... and you could have used your position to speak out about this. You could have protested. You could have protested. You could have... Look, I encourage people to use social media as part of activism. There wasn't social media when the war in Afghanistan started. There was social media in 2021. There was social media in 2020. There was social media in 2019. Don't be silly. You're being ridiculous. And I've always said I opposed what happened in Afghanistan.

1:18:49So did you post... Did you use whatever limited position you have in British society? Did you post opposing... Did you say anything opposing it? It's ridiculous. It isn't. It's absolutely ridiculous.

1:18:59Francis Foster: Do you think everyone in this country who opposed the invasion of Afghanistan has tweeted about it? No, but I think that if you're someone who's vocally now speaking out about taking refugees in from Afghanistan, then you should, in my opinion, have taken a position against what we did to that country. Hold on. And we committed heinous atrocities against people. We shot innocent people. What war crimes did we commit? No, no, we're not going to play this game. It's not a game. It's not a game. Just stop. We helped... Owen, you're just talking over me now. You've got to stop. You're talking over me.

1:19:32Francis Foster: I am not. We helped wreck Afghanistan. I accept that. We've got to take responsibility. I agree with you. So take responsibility. I am taking responsibility. So what I'm saying to you is, I can only take responsibility for my actions. My actions on this is, I opposed it when I became a public figure, and I've always said so. However, I do not... Look that up. Owen, just stop talking. However, I do not think we should not take any refugees from Afghanistan. I've never said so. So what's the argument? I have never said so. What's the argument? I said very clearly in language, and people can come back and watch it, we should be more selective about accepting people from certain parts of the world where we clearly see, as we do in the studies, which you challenged, right?

1:20:10Francis Foster: We see clearly in the studies that people from certain countries, hold on, hold on, from Iraq, for example, in the study that I quoted you, are 13 times more likely to commit sexual offences in that study. Should we not be a little bit more selective before letting people in from that part of the world? Again, we really... Look, as I spoke about in that book, as I spoke about in that book, I went to Iraq, I went to Baghdad, and when people found out I was British, they said to me, you destroyed this country. Our forces in that country include the Americans predominantly, but also the British. I'm afraid to say...

1:20:44You're dodging the argument. No, I'm not. I'm not at all. I'm saying we have a responsibility. You're saying we should be more... Selective. Selective. Yeah, but what do you mean by selective? I can tell you. If you're interested, I can tell you. How are you screening for people who are potentially rapists or not? I don't understand your argument here. What's your argument?

1:20:59Francis Foster: Well, one of the arguments is you might be more careful about who you're in. That means you do extra checks. That means that you don't let in people with certain criminal convictions, which we currently do. That means that we don't... How do you do that? How do you do what? Sorry, I'm really... I'm interested in what you're arguing. If you are right... Because you don't disagree, as far as I can tell. I'm trying to work out the disagreement, actually. If you let me talk, you'll find it out. You're dragging this out. You support Afghan refugees and people from Iraq. No, I don't. So you don't support any of them coming in?

1:21:27Francis Foster: No, that's not what I said. Well, then what are we disagreeing on? What we're disagreeing on is instead of listening, you keep interrupting me and talking over me. Tell me what your policy is. My policy is that we're much more selective about who we let into this country. Do you understand the word selective? No, I know what you're saying. I know what you're saying, but I'm saying what does that mean in practice? I'm trying to tell you. Tell me. So first and foremost, I think anyone who comes into this country illegally, that is on a small boat, on a lorry, etc., is to me immediately far more suspect than anybody else.

1:21:56Francis Foster: What's your evidence for that? I'm telling you my opinion. My evidence... No, but I'm not interested in opinions. I thought we were doing empirical practice. You've got to let me explain what I'm saying. Why is an Afghan... Oh, and this is just degenerated and you interrupting me. No, it's just you doing... You asked me to explain. I'm trying to explain. So just be quiet for a moment and I'll explain. Calm down, though. Chill out. If you are coming into this country by the first act that you do is you violate the laws of this country, right? You are coming in here deliberately to avoid our immigration system because you can apply for asylum, right?

1:22:26Francis Foster: I have friends from all over the world who've come here by applying for asylum. If you don't do that and you come here on a small boat or you come here on a lorry by breaking the laws of this country, it's clear to me that you should be subjected to a far higher standard of scrutiny because you are, in my opinion, far more likely to be doing so in order to get around the immigration system, which would never have let you in in the first place. Before we just talk about applying for asylum, look, am I allowed to ask or is it just convenient? Of course. I've heard. So is your argument, first of all, there, that your argument isn't even a blanket rejection of people who arrive on boats?

1:22:58Francis Foster: It is a blanket rejection of people who arrive on boats. So is that Afghan... So anyone who's... If they were an Afghan woman, for example, would you reject them? I'm saying... Would you? Would you? Honestly, I'm not trying to trick you. I just want to work out what you're policy. Fine. I would definitely not reject an Afghan woman who applied for asylum and is entitled to asylum. No, no, if she arrived on a small boat. How are Afghans supposed to apply to asylum? What we should do is create refugee processing centres in the region. Here we go. Great. Look, it sounds to me... When you let me finish, we find out that we actually agree more, but you keep interrupting and misrepresenting.

1:23:34I'm not trying to misrepresent it. Because originally what you were saying is we need to do extra checks. I said we need to be selected. We'll just ring up the Afghan police and ask if they've got in trouble with the authorities. I don't think that's going to work, obviously. Obviously, the problem we've got is we shut down safe and legal routes. That's why you've got a massive increase in people arriving by small boats. In the early 2000s, the rate of people arriving in this country as asylum seekers is not actually that different at its peak from the level of today, for example. But they weren't arriving on small boats.

1:24:01What we did is we closed down safe and legal routes. So when I met Afghan refugees, I don't know if you've met these people who arrived on these boats. Have you ever spoke to an Afghan refugee?

1:24:10Francis Foster: The guy who runs the taxi company that I use all the time in my local city is an Afghan refugee. Who arrived on a small boat, I'm asking. I don't think he arrived on a small boat, which is why I... But have you spoke to any... Okay, fair enough. I went to Calais in 2015 and I spoke to people who were there. The reason they're arriving, they're moving to Britain, they speak English, almost all of them. I mean, they spoke English very fluently. They don't speak French. People from the Democratic Republic of Congo stay in France because they speak French. That, you know, is a fairly straightforward explanation for that one.

1:24:42And, you know, in one case, I met a 15-year-old boy whose father had been murdered by the Taliban. In another case, I met someone who'd lived in Britain for... He came here as a kid and then he was deported from the country because he was classed as an illegal migrant. And he went back to Afghanistan and then he was jailed by the Taliban. And then he fled and then he... Sorry, he wasn't jailed by the Taliban. He was captured and tortured by the Taliban, I believe, at the time, because this was before the Taliban took over the whole of Afghanistan than they took over parts of Afghanistan, not the big cities.

1:25:18These were, you know, we destabilised a country. We both agree, as far as I can tell, that we need safe and legal routes, which would then reduce the number of people arriving by small boats. I don't really know what the disagreement is.

1:25:31Francis Foster: I can explain to you what the disagreement is. I believe those numbers should be far smaller than they are. So an example, just for people understanding the context of this, when I came to Britain in 1995, 96 actually is probably more accurate, There was about 55 ,000 people coming here legally every year. Legally. Sorry, say again. 1996, total net immigration into Britain was about 55 ,000. We now have hundreds of thousands of people coming legally, and we also have tens of thousands, maybe more than 55 ,000 a year, coming illegally. Yeah, it's a very small proportion of overall immigration, but yeah, that's true.

1:26:08Overall levels of immigration have massively increased, yeah. My view is we have society, we wouldn't be able to afford public services, they wouldn't function, our economy would collapse, we wouldn't support our aging population if they didn't. But not with that.

1:26:19Francis Foster: I'm having flashbacks to Jimmy the Giant here. Fair enough. 55 ,000 people a year were coming totally legally when I came 30 years ago, right? Now that's the number of people who come here legally. Now you can say it's a small proportion of the total immigration, but that's only because overall immigration has shut up. And the point I'm making to you is we now have more people coming illegally than were coming legally 30 years ago. And don't you think that that is a far better explanation of why people are upset about immigration than your argument? I think we shut down legal and safe routes, which had consequences, and we then helped destabilize the Middle East and also Central Asia.

1:27:00We shouldn't have done what we did in Afghanistan. We shouldn't have invaded Iraq and slaughtered huge numbers of people. I agree. And if we hadn't have done that, then we wouldn't have large numbers. And Libya, where huge numbers of people... I mean, without Libya, people wouldn't even be passing... That route is obviously absolutely central to people crossing the Mediterranean. My view is, you know, if you break it, you own it. And you shouldn't go around launching wars which slaughter hundreds of thousands of people more. I mean, in Iraq alone, the excess death toll is about 400 ,000. That was back in 2013.

1:27:34you shouldn't commit terrible crimes, destabilise entire countries, and then when people from those countries arrive, then demonise them. I'm not demonising anyone. When have I demonised anyone? We're talking, basically, what we're saying is that all Afghan men should be seen as potential rapists. That's not what I said. You are, because that's the de facto logical argument. Do you understand what per capita means? That's the de facto argument. I said we should be more selective. I think, well, look, I believe we should have safe and legal routes and that those safe and legal routes should judge cases based on their merits.

1:28:09So I don't disagree with you on that. I don't see what the disagreement is in that sense. I don't think a lot of your supporters would support opening safe and legal routes. The reason we had safe and legal routes for Ukraine, for Hong Kong, for the vast majority of the world, those were all gone. You can't apply for asylum in the vast majority of the world to Britain. You just cannot do that. So people should just break our law and come here. The only way you can do that is, it's not breaking the law. Well, it's not, you know, it's... They're breaking into our country. You don't have to claim asylum under international law in the first country you end up.

1:28:39But they are breaking our laws. They're crossing our borders without our consent. We shouldn't have broken international law and invaded Iraq then, should we? We should have far break it. We literally broke into... So that entitles them to break into our country. We broke into Afghanistan. We broke into Iraq. I agree, and I was against that. And we slaughtered... Well, not very vocally, but I saw some things, but we slaughtered huge numbers of people. We destabilised those countries. and what I find so offensive about what you're saying is millions of people were displaced because of those wars and the vast majority of them stayed either internally displaced or in their poorer neighbouring countries.

1:29:11Your argument in practice is the countries surrounding the nations, we destabilised, they should bear the brunt. They're the ones who should carry the burden on what we did. Why? Why should Pakistan, which opposed the war in Iraq, and, for example, well, sorry, Pakistan is Afghanistan. Why should Pakistan, why should that be the place where millions of Afghan refugees, although the Pakistani regime has been driving them back to Afghanistan, why should they take in millions of Afghan refugees when we're the ones who invaded and occupied Afghanistan? Why, in the case of Iraq, why should its neighbouring countries take in all those refugees when they didn't invade Iraq?

1:29:49Why? Your argument is, we did the displacing, you accept that, But you're saying it's the poorest, the poorer countries surrounding those nations, which do take almost the vast majority. The tiny percentage of Afghan refugees and Iraqi refugees come here. There were millions of Afghan refugees, although were in Iran and Afghanistan, sorry, in Pakistan. There were millions of Iraqi refugees which fled into the neighboring countries. A tiny, tiny percentage, a tiny percentage came to this country. and you think that's a huge outrage and they're breaking into this country. But they are.

1:30:28Francis Foster: Well, again, we shouldn't have broken into their countries. I'll just let you talk uninterrupted for a very long time. I am perfectly happy for us to accept Afghan translators and other people who helped coalition forces and there will be other people who are at particular risk, et cetera, et cetera, particularly if they're carefully vetted. But what I'm saying to you is just because the West did this or did that does not entitle people to break into our country against, Owen, against the will of the people of this country. Offer them safe illegal reads then? The people of this country have...

1:30:59Francis Foster: You believe in democracy, I think, right? The people... Hold on. See, the moment I say anything, you begin interrupting. The people of this country have voted over and over and over and over to reduce immigration and to get illegal immigration to zero. Why is it right to allow... You clearly support these people breaking into our country. Who are you to overrule the wishes of the British people? I've said that I support safe and legal routes. I don't want people across the challenge. Dangerous for them, for a start. I don't want that. So they shouldn't be coming? Open safe and legal routes, and then you reduce them.

1:31:32I'm happy to open a refugee processing centre.

1:31:34Francis Foster: The problem is it wouldn't let in 90 % of the people who are coming. Well, I don't know where you're plucking those statistics from. Most of the people who are breaking into this country are not coming from war zones. Why was it under the... They're economic migrants. Most of them are economic migrants. Well, we've already gone through, actually, the numbers of people arriving from... Afghanistan and Iraq are two of the great sources of people arriving in this country. I don't think they're economic migrants. I don't think anyone would say that's a reasonable way of describing... I said the majority of the people who are breaking into this country are economic migrants.

1:32:04Francis Foster: Most of them are not... They're mostly coming from places, actually, of places which have huge conflict or dictatorships, some of which supported by the West, I would know. What about Sueta, when you saw tens of thousands of people breaking into Spanish territory in North Africa. Are they fleeing Moroccan that we overthrew? No, they're just economic migrants. They want to come to Europe because it's a better quality of life. No one is arguing that you should... Well, I'm not, because I think the caricature you're making is that we should abolish borders. In the world in which we live, we have abolished borders.

1:32:33You can't do it. Well, we haven't, because otherwise, as I've noted, you wouldn't have the vast majority of the world's refugee population in the poorest or poorer countries. Because they can't get here. They're not willing to pay people smugglers tens of thousands of euros to get here. Well, I mean, yes, they tend to be better off people who end up coming here, actually. Yes, you're right. And actually, you know, the issue is that the vast majority of refugees fleeing our wars end up in other countries which didn't cause the wars. You've made that point. Fine. No, I know, but that's why I think it's an absurdity.

1:33:06You made the point. Your view is we should just trash these countries and then we shouldn't... That's not my point. My point is we should never have trashed these countries. We should have shoulder the responsibility.

1:33:15Francis Foster: No, that's not my point. My point is we should... It is in practice. My point? Oh, well, in the same way I could say your point is that people should be allowed to break into our country. No, I've said safe and legal routes would stop that from happening. I don't want people crossing the channel. It's really dangerous for them for a start, as I've said. But when people arrive here, I think their case has to be judged on a case-by-case basis. And I'd note, under a Conservative government... Why are you pointing me? I'm not a Conservative. No, no, no, no. But, ah, no, this is the point I was going to make.

1:33:38A Conservative government which wanted to reduce immigration. It did. Why didn't they? What happened? Why was there a massive gap? I'm asking.

1:33:46Francis Foster: Oh, the same economic argument you made earlier. I mean, we've had senior conservative politicians like Sola Bram, and she was in the studio last week, making this very same point. The reason the last conservative government refused to cut mass immigration is they didn't want to have to accept that total GDP would fall. No, they knew the economic consequence would be severe. They wanted to reduce immigration. That became the whole thing. They knew that because we measure economic activity with GDP and not GDP per capita, I'm telling you what they said. Can I finish telling you what they said? They knew those economic sectors and those public services would collapse without them.

1:34:22Francis Foster: Can I just tell you what they told us? Is that OK? Who are you talking about? Soella Bravman. Oh, God. She was the Home Secretary. Yeah, I know. She's now a reform politician. Yeah, but she was the Home Secretary at the time. We had Liz Truss on the show. We've had Boris Johnson on the show. We've had all these people on the show and we've asked them all these questions. So I'm telling you what they said. Is that okay? Can I do that? That's totally fine. But these are all self-serving comments by them. Well, you said, what did they tell you? I'm trying to tell you, right? What they all said was, the reason that you can't cut mass immigration is that the Treasury doesn't want you to because then the headline economic figure of GDP goes down and then people get upset because the media will be able to say, you tank the economy.

1:35:02Can I say why I think they didn't? Oh, so you didn't want to know why they said it? You just wanted to express it. You know, I studied history and what we were always told to do is not to take a source at face value. You look at the context and their purpose and particularly self-justification by historical figures. You don't just accept what they say. We accept the headline polling figure that most people in this country want immigration to do. We accept that. Yeah. Yeah. What happens when you start polling people about the main chunks of immigration? What happens? I don't know what you're talking about.

1:35:39The main subsets of immigration, for example, foreign students. That is a massive subset of who pay£40 billion a year into this country. You poll people about foreign students. They go, do you want to get rid of them? No, I don't want to get rid of them. Then you keep going. You go, what about people from Ukraine and Hong Kong? No, no, no. That's again, we've already got here, by the way, that is a vast chunk of people arriving in this country already.

1:36:03Francis Foster: Yeah. And then you start asking people about... like healthcare workers, nurses. When you poll people about the actual subsets of immigration, people, by large margins, say they don't want to remove those migrants. But you end up with a vast majority of immigration. And that's the problem. I can tell you exactly the immigration I'd want to reduce. It's very simple. It's a tiny proportion of immigration. Whatever you say will be a tiny proportion of immigration. It's not a tiny... Well, Owen, you've got to understand, you know, a lot of people from your position trying to paint the opposition to immigration in this country as an extreme position and an extreme view.

1:36:39I haven't said that.

1:36:40Francis Foster: You haven't said that here, but I think you have said that in the past. No, no, I just... I haven't. I object to the scapegoating of migrants' problems they don't cause. I object to that. So do I. So do I. OK, well... And I've said so repeatedly. I just have a video out last week saying immigration debate has become too white and white. The problem is if the Conservative government had massively reduced the number of foreign students, then they would have lost tens of billions... They would have lost billions of pounds. I can tell you the sensible immigration that should be reduced. First of all, yes, it's true that a lot of those foreign students are paying high university fees.

1:37:13Francis Foster: A lot of them were not going to legitimate universities. And the evidence is very clear on this. There were all sorts of fake schemes to get people into this country under fake student visas who were not actually studying. The same thing is true with some key workers. We've seen restaurants in parts of the country which have had 30 people come in under sort of key worker views, all of this stuff. But really, it's very simple. The way I would reduce it, I would stop all illegal immigration because it's illegal. People shouldn't be coming. You're talking about tiny percentage. Let me just finish.

1:37:41Francis Foster: Well, it's more people than what came here when I came here a year. That's quite a lot. Okay, fair enough. Can I just finish? I know, but I thought it was an interview. Can I just... Well, an interview requires that you listen to me and I listen to you. I am, I am. I have listened to you for a long time and I'm just trying to make one point and you interrupt. So I would reduce fake students. I would reduce the number of people who are coming here illegally to zero because they shouldn't be coming. I would also reduce the number of people, in fact, not reduce, I would just say there shouldn't be any benefits for foreign nationals in this country.

1:38:12Francis Foster: There's no reason. Let me finish, and you can argue with it if you want. So anyone in this country, when I came to this country and I was a student, I had a stamp in my visa which said no recourse to public funds. That should be the case. If you can't support yourself in this country, you shouldn't be here. It's just difficult. It's just such an important point you raised. They're not that long. Okay, keep going because that's really... Go for it, go on. And at the same time, I would make sure that people who come here who are net contributors, i.e. they're paying more in tax than they're taking, if they are compatible, et cetera, et cetera, we take those people.

1:38:46Francis Foster: So that would be a pretty sensible immigration policy in my view that wouldn't reduce the good students and all the rest. So you're going to take tax credits off all those care workers and drive them all into poverty? Is that what you're going to do? No. Why? You're taking away all benefits from foreign nationals? Yes. So you're now going to... If you're a foreign national in this country, unless you're part of a very specific sectoral programme where we accept this... Okay. Yeah. Sorry, no, well, I'd be fascinated to know what you mean by that. So foreign national... So people who work in the care sector have very, very low wages.

1:39:16Yes. Most benefits in this, you know, it's not unemployment benefits that make up the working age bill. It's, for example, tax credits, which cost vast sums of money, where the government steps in because the gap between people's income and their ability to live is too big because they're not paid enough. The care sector depends on foreign nationals.

1:39:37Francis Foster: So it does at the moment. Yeah. Well, it does depend on it at the moment. Fair enough. Until we suddenly have this massive army of British born care workers, which we have a million young people who are not employed and not training. And they could be doing those low pay jobs and getting valuable life experience. That's a separate discussion. It is a separate discussion because it hasn't happened yet. I'm I'm saying, would you strip away tax credits and all other in-work benefits for care workers who literally, the whole country, what, in an already underfunded, understaffed care sector? If you're a foreign national, I'm not saying you do it all overnight, but a phased-in policy, absolutely.

1:40:16So then they will all leave the country and then we won't have any care workers. That's correct. Well, who's going to look after all those elderly people now then? Who's going to look after? No, tell me.

1:40:24Francis Foster: I'm about to, if you let me say it. Okay. So what I'm saying is, first of all, of course, like with every sector of the economy, you have certain carve outs for certain groups that you are OK with. But on the broad sweep of things, I'm perfectly fine. So are we saying care workers? Can I finish for God's sake? Do care workers keep their benefits or not? I'm asking. Are you interviewing me here? Well, it feels like I am now. Yeah. Yeah. Well, maybe you should stop. Well, it's just because of these long, long discursive talks. I don't know. I'm just asking. It doesn't. I'm saying. I got about a sentence in for my answer.

1:40:53Francis Foster: OK. I'm perfectly happy to have a policy that foreign nationals in this country do not have access to the benefit system. There may be some temporary carve-outs for certain industries where that transition will take some time. But in a country in which we have a million young people who are neither in employment nor in education, the idea that we can't find, you know, people make this argument about the hospitality sector. Oh, it's completely dependent on foreign labor. It is. It is. You can't go into a restaurant in this country without encountering someone who's foreign. However, those jobs when I first came here were being done by British people.

1:41:30Francis Foster: And yes, they've all now been replaced by people from other countries who are happy to work in worse conditions for less money. It's true. But the moment you prevent the system from topping up the wages of those foreign people who are here, British people will do those jobs. And the prices, by the way, will go up and so will working conditions. Is your genuine argument, I just really want to absorb what you're saying here. Yeah. Are you saying that you're going to take away in-work benefits from migrant workers in the care service, hospitality, retail, which will leave, there's no question, them unable to live and pay their rent and look after their kids?

1:42:08They will, the vast majority of them, almost certainly leave the country.

1:42:10Francis Foster: That's the purpose of the policy, yeah. And then you're saying that all of a sudden, now all these sectors with millions, in some case, if you top them together, of migrant low-paid workers who are propping up these sectors, which are often... We are propping them up. The government's propping them up. No, we're subsidising them because their wages are too large. That's what propping up means. We're subsidising the bosses who aren't paying them properly. But all of a sudden you're saying these sectors will suddenly, there'll be all these people in this country to just start looking after elderly people, keeping hospitality running.

1:42:44They will just, all of that will happen and those industries won't just collapse. Are you serious? If you do it overnight. It's madness.

1:42:50Francis Foster: Owen, just hold on. You're misrepresenting the argument. I'm saying you do it overnight. I said phased in policy. How long? How long a period? Because you're betting the house on all these sectors being able to get care workers, retail workers, hospitality workers to fill in what you're saying will be, I mean, we're talking potentially millions of people. Migrant workers, I don't know how many in work benefits. Do you know what's that? I think the real disagreement here is I don't think you understand how the market works, which is maybe why the basis of your entire worldview. Do you know how the market works?

1:43:22Francis Foster: If there's a shortage of labor in a particular sector, particularly a low skilled sector like hospitality, it's not I've been away. It's not that hard. Let's be honest. Right. What happens is if you can't find enough staff, what do you do? Why are they understaffed? Can I just finish this argument? Yeah. What happens is when there's not enough staff for a particular job, what do you do as an employer? You put the wages up so that you attract more people. And when that is the case, you make it a more appealing job for people to do. So is your genuine argument, because at the moment the care service used to accept as understaffed, we don't have enough care workers, even though we have, obviously.

1:43:56So your argument is that what will happen is when these foreign care workers at the moment, literally, including I'm sure people watching, looking after their elderly parents and grandparents and doing an incredibly difficult, arduous job for very little wages, they will now be made literally unwelcome in the country because they won't be able to live. They won't be unwelcome. They will be unwelcome because you can't afford... If you take away people on that low pay, if you take away in-work benefits, not least when they have families, they won't be able to afford to live here, then you're arguing that there will be a massive hike in wages and there will be this army of British-born people who will start doing care work, retail, and hospitality, including in companies with very little profit margins if we're going to be brutally honest about it.

1:44:42Is that honestly your view? That's going to happen. And these sectors aren't just going to collapse.

1:44:46Francis Foster: Well, if you do it overnight, they'll collapse. But if you do it over time, of course that will happen. This is, I think, it's funny talking about economic insanity and problematic. It's one of the most insane economic ideas I've ever heard. Well, the market. The market. If the market worked, then you wouldn't. Oh, and we run a small business. I'm telling you my experience as a business owner. Why is the care service on to staff then? Because the wages are too low. That's why. If you paid me... So why aren't they increasing the wages now in order to attack more care workers? Why hasn't that happened?

1:45:16Francis Foster: Oh, for a very simple reason. Because you are getting the government to give poor people from the third world money to come and fill those jobs. That's why. So why aren't we getting enough to do it then? Why isn't the... Because the wages are still too low. Yeah, but I'm asking, if clearly immigration is not filling, We have all these industries where you still have vacancies. So why hasn't they then they increase the wages to increase the number of people working based on the fact that they aren't getting people from these poor countries to fill these vacancies? They're getting lots and lots of people from poor countries.

1:45:47Francis Foster: It's understaffed. Yes, because there's such a massive opposition to immigration. You can't bring in people who are going to work for five quid an hour. So then they should improve the wages, but they're not. But they haven't done that. They won't. As long as you have cheap foreign labor, they will never improve the wage. You're saying if there are vacancies, the market will adjust for that by improving wages. I'm saying that is not happening because there are vacancies and they're not improving the wages. Because there's massive downward pressure on wages by having millions of people from foreign labour.

1:46:14But then that's not enough to deal with the staffing problem. OK, we can leave it there. But all I'm saying is you would crash the economy in a most devastating fashion. You are not obviously going to get people to suddenly fill all these... So British people can't do those jobs?

1:46:30Francis Foster: I'm saying... That million people, million young people who are not in educational training, they can't serve a plate of food? It depends on, I mean, it depends on the circumstances of the young person. Because they've got too much ADHD or anxiety or whatever? Well, some of them actually are people who are disabled, yes. Some of them are, but not all of them are. But also, it's not a static population. This is the problem as well. You don't seem to offer this. One million is not, these are people who are. They're going in and out, of course. They're going in and out of often low-paid. So let's get them more jobs that are better paid.

1:46:55They're often in low-paid, insecure jobs or zero-hour contracts. Which is what I don't want. Fine. You want to build a socialist state, like Conrad. But the fact is they're in insecure work, which is often transient, which is that that's the nature of the service sector, the hospitality sector and all the rest of it. So if there were more jobs for them in those sectors

1:47:11Francis Foster: and the wages were higher, they'd be better. Well, no, because you're reducing, firstly, the demand in the economy because there will be less people paying in the economy. That's what you'll do. You'll withdraw from the economy demand by huge numbers of people leaving the country. Yeah, but you said yourself they need subsidies just to be able to live. Yes, their wages are too low. So we are paying them. The government's paying these people. That's then circulated in their local communities. So you want to take from British people, give to foreigners so they spend money here. That's what you want.

1:47:38I'm saying those sectors would collapse. That's what those subsidies do. Those subsidies are for British people. And it doesn't matter where you're from if you're in these low-paid jobs. Most in-work benefits are going to British people. And it's because wages are too low. I want to increase wages, which is why I support a strong trade union movement. and that's why I want collective bargaining. This is what you should support. You should support collective bargaining in the care sector. The point about care sector, about care bargaining, sorry, the point about collective bargaining is it enables workers to use their collective power to improve their wages on the basis the market will not do that.

1:48:15That's why it exists. And in a place like Finland, you mentioned Finland before, they have collective bargaining and they have higher wages and so on. But what you're arguing in practice would be, it would literally mean millions of people potentially, a vast number of people would leave sexes dependent on migrant workers without some huge army of people waiting to fill those jobs. And you'd suck demand out of the economy. Let me say the final thing, and then we'll move on,

1:48:38Francis Foster: because we've got to let you go soon. What I'm saying is, over time, I would like to replace people who come into this country who can't even earn enough money to pay enough tax to be net contributors with British people doing those jobs. You don't agree? I know, but can I... You don't agree? I think that's perfectly possible. That's our disagreement. Just quickly, lastly, though, you do accept, because there's lots of costs to that, one of them is that the working age population will shrink relative to pensioners. You must accept that. It will reduce, yes. Do you not see that imposes really quite steep costs at the same time that you've just collapsed all these industries?

1:49:14I haven't collapsed any industries. You have, but do you not see that you have... Which industries have I collapsed? What are you talking about? Retail, hospitality Huge numbers of Huge I mean you have Low paid cleaners I mean you suddenly get We're going back around You've said your piece You get a smaller Working age population And that imposes costs Because you have An ageing population Sure Okay fair enough Owen thank you so much For coming on the show Final question is always the same What's the one thing We're not talking about That we really should be Male suicide Biggest killer of men Under 50 is suicide and suicide for anyone who's been touched by it is just like a nuclear bomb going off in people's lives and even though the rate of depression and mental distress is higher amongst women, the suicide rate is much higher amongst men and that's often to do with it being seen as unmanly to talk about people's feelings and problems and there's a stigma attached to it.

1:50:11One thing I've written about before which I don't think might sound a bit surprising is homophobia against straight men because most straight men get homophobic theories at some point if they're seen as not manly enough, not aggressive enough, not getting into fights, not talking about women in a degrading way. And, you know, I interviewed straight men who were homophobically bullied throughout their childhood, beaten up, attacked and all the rest of it, in a way that I wasn't as a gay man. But that has a wider impact because homophobia is used, I think, to enforce gender norms. And one of the ways straight men suffer is talking about feelings and problems is seen as unmanly and gay.

1:50:48So I just, for me, it's about the stigma there and it's about mental health and it's about making sure that men who need help and need support get it and feel able to get support. So Owen, thank you so much for coming on the show. You know, to fact, to have someone on from a different point of view, having discussions, it's been really, really heartening. Thank you so much. Yeah, bless you. Thanks for coming on, mate. Cheers, cheers, cheers. And your book is out now, Owen Jones, The Fall of the West. And, well, we got into such a... How They Really Lost It. How They Really Lost It. And we got into such a conversation that we don't have time for Substack.

1:51:20But we'll see you again next time.

1:51:37Francis Foster: Ryan Reynolds here from Mint Mobile. The message for everyone paying big wireless way too much. Please, for the love of everything good in this world, stop. With Mint, you can get premium wireless for just$15 a month. Of course, if you enjoy overpaying, no judgments, but that's weird. Okay, one judgment. Anyway, give it a try at mintmobile.com slash switch. Upfront payment of$45 for three-month plan, equivalent to$15 per month required. Intro rate first three months only, then full price plan options available. Taxes and fees extra. See full terms at mintmobile.com.

From the publisher

Triggernometry is proudly independent. Thanks to the sponsors below for making that possible:

- Expat Money: download the report to understand offshore banking, second passports, asset protection and international businesshttps://expatmoney.com/trigger

- Earn a yield on gold https://monetary-metals.com/triggernometry/

- QUO: Business Phone System for Startups. Try QUO for free, PLUS get 20% off your first 6 months when you go to https://quo.com/TRIG

- Venice gives you the best AI models in one place. Private. Unrestricted. No lectures. Get 20% off your first month: https://venice.ai/triggernometry/owen-jones/2026-10-10

https://stat.fi/til/rpk/2018/13/rpk_2018_13_2019-05-16_tie_001_en.html

Join our exclusive TRIGGERnometry community on Substack! https://triggernometry.substack.com/

OR Support TRIGGERnometry Here:
Bitcoin: bc1qm6vvhduc6s3rvy8u76sllmrfpynfv94qw8p8d5

Shop Merch here - https://shop.triggerpod.co.uk/

Advertise on Triggernometry: https://trigger-brands.com | or enquire at [email protected]

Find TRIGGERnometry on Social Media:

https://twitter.com/triggerpod
https://www.facebook.com/triggerpod/
https://www.instagram.com/triggerpod/

About TRIGGERnometry:

Stand-up comedians Konstantin Kisin (@konstantinkisin) and Francis Foster (@francisjfoster) make sense of politics, economics, free speech, AI, drug policy and WW3 with the help of presidential advisors, renowned economists, award-winning journalists, controversial writers, leading scientists and notorious comedians.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

More from TRIGGERnometry

All episodes