Is a little alcohol bad for you?

0:00Support for this show comes from Odoo. Running a business is hard enough, so why make it harder with a dozen different apps that don't talk to each other? Introducing Odoo. It's the only business software you'll ever need. It's an all-in-one, fully integrated platform that makes your work easier. CRM, accounting, inventory, e-commerce, and more. And the best part? Odoo replaces multiple expensive platforms for a fraction of the cost. That's why over thousands of businesses have made the switch. So why not you? Try Odoo for free at odoo.com. That's O-D-O-O dot com.

0:41Support for the show comes from Injun. Running a small business means every dollar has to work hard. But if your team is still booking travel the old way, it's costing you more than you think. Enjin is the fastest growing travel and spend platform in the country, built specifically for businesses like yours. Book a trip in as little as two and a half minutes. Earn up to 10 % back on hotels. And in 2025, Enjin customers saved more than$300 million on travel, with zero booking fees, no contracts, and no BS. More than 1 ,000 businesses join Enjin every month. Join them and get$500 when your business signs up and starts traveling at engine.com slash Vox.

1:27Dylan Scott, senior correspondent and senior good pal of mine. Bird Pinkerton, pal of mine and co-host of Unexplainable. You have a mystery for me, I believe, about alcohol. I do. So if you're anything like me, you know, I think we both grew up in the 90s. You have heard some very mixed messages about what drinking moderate amounts of alcohol can do for your health. Just in time for the weekend, a new warning about the dangers of alcohol and cancer. It feels like every week you read the news and there's a new study about alcohol. And it's saying the exact opposite of the study you were reading about last week.

2:11Several studies have shown moderate drinking may be good for your overall health, but... No amount of alcohol is good for your health. Less drinking means less risk. So I decided, like, I want to get to the bottom of this for myself and for our audience. Like, I want to actually understand what to think about the health effects of drinking moderate amounts of alcohol.

2:38okay and so what what did you find like what are the health effects of drinking moderate amounts of alcohol well this is unexplainable so i found it was unexplainable but in a way that i think is really interesting and revealing because this story of alcohol's health effects and our imperfect attempts to measure it is, I think, the story of how it's really, really hard to isolate and pin down the health effects of all kinds of things that we really would want answers about, these things that we interact with and consume all of the time. Okay, let's go.

3:39you know i think to start we should establish that the science is pretty settled when it comes to heavy drinking alcohol is bad for you it has neurological effects it causes liver disease and we've known that for hundreds and hundreds of years. How much is too much though, I guess? Or like what is a lot of alcohol? This was one of the things that surprised me when I looked into this and I think it would surprise a lot of people, which is that what normal people think is a lot of drinking and what scientists and doctors think is a lot of drinking, there's a pretty big gap there. But looking at the scientific definition, for some people, the limit is two drinks per day.

4:28Anything above that is heavy drinking. And for other people, it can be just one drink per day. And anything above that is heavy drinking. And like, you know, a drink can be a pretty small amount. Even one can of beer, if it has really high alcohol content, can be more than one drink. And so if you're drinking more than that limit each day, the researchers that I talked to were in agreement that that's going to be a problem. There are heart risks. There are cancer risks. It's damaging your liver and you would do better to drink less. But what if you are drinking like just a glass of wine every two days or whatever?

5:07I mean, this is where things get contentious. This is where all of the argument is. So let's start with sort of the pro-alcohol side. And we can start with a researcher who has made the case that maybe some small amount of alcohol might actually be good-ish for you. My name is Ken Mokomal. I'm a primary care physician at Beth Israel Decus Medical Center. I do think it's worth pointing out that Ken has been in the news in the past, and he has faced some criticism from his peers about his research allegedly being influenced by the alcohol industry. Like, back in 2018, he was leading a study on alcohol's health effects for the NIH, and that study got shut down because the NIH found some suggestion that there was bias in the study's design.

6:01But, you know, even with that history, I thought it was really helpful to talk to Ken and to get his perspective on the research. And I also thought it was interesting, like, he's staked out this position, but he doesn't really seem to have a personal investment in drinking alcohol. Although a sizable part of my research career has been related to alcohol, we hardly drank at all in my house. My dad was a chemical engineer, and if he happened to open a beer, it was like, you know, a major event in the house. In fact, I continued hardly to drink at all. But even so, part of the reason he wanted to study alcohol is that, as he said, he's actually a primary care doctor.

6:39So he's not like just a cardiologist by training who's only worried about your heart. He's not only a liver doctor or a kidney doctor. He's worried about the whole person. And for him, alcohol was a really good fit because alcohol touches on so many aspects of people's lives. You know, decades ago, as he was starting to think about this, he developed this question about whether some amount of alcohol might be helpful. This was right around the time that in kind of clinical medicine more generally, when I was going through training at that time, we were moving into the idea that when people had heart attacks, that one of the ways that we could either treat them or prevent them was to use things like giving people baby aspirin.

7:24Right. And that eventually turned into like, you know, lore all over the world. Aspirin is a blood thinner, and heart attacks happen basically because the flow of blood to the heart is blocked in some way, and so thinning out the blood might help. And indeed, the New England Journal had published this sort of small paper in the early 1980s showing that aspirin prolongs how long it takes somebody to clot their blood, and if you give them aspirin plus alcohol, it was markedly longer than even just with aspirin alone. So I'll be honest, I'm thinking to myself, well, if that's true, and we're spending all this time trying to give people aspirin and stuff, why aren't we washing down that aspirin with a little bit of alcohol?

8:09If that data from the early 1980s was right, and we're seeing that alcohol has a little bit of blood thinning effect, and we're looking for additional blood thinners, it seems like the natural next thing to do. And his boss actually didn't totally shoot this idea down. And, you know, Ken told me, like, there are better blood thinning options than alcohol. So the idea wasn't, like, let's, you know, give everybody who's having a heart attack a shot of whiskey. But, you know, he was still interested, like, could naturally thinning your blood this way, you know, prevent heart attacks just over the long term?

8:45and could there be other positive impacts that alcohol might have on your health somehow? So if you're like having a glass a day, is your blood just like a little bit thinner and maybe that prevents heart attacks? This more like kind of long-term, small-dose exposure, prophylactic approach. Yes, that's what he was curious about. And he, you know, went down this long rabbit hole for many years after that, looking for some answers. He was mostly looking at these big data sets, these things that are called cohort studies or large population-based studies. More or less, the idea is quite simple, right?

9:25We're going to take lots of people. We're going to ask them some universal standard questions, including things like, how often do you drink alcohol? When you drink, how much do you have? What's the most that you have? And then using that information, we're going to then sort people into bins and then wait and see what happens. Now, these are not experiments. I want to emphasize that because that's going to then come back to haunt us a little bit. These are not situations where I ask you to drink a certain amount or ask you not to drink a certain amount and manipulate it the way that, say, I would do with mice in a laboratory.

10:03These are just, you chose to drink or you didn't chose to drink, and I'm going to follow along and see what happens. And in our case, they involved anywhere from, you know, a few thousand to tens of thousands of people, followed for anywhere from three or five years to 25 years. And so, you know, Ken's looking at these studies where people have reported their alcohol consumption, and then he's looking at data that shows their health outcomes, and he's going through the numbers and he found a slight link in small doses to some potential health benefits from drinking alcohol. To the extent that there's sort of a simple message that I could offer, it's that where we see, well, I'll call, quote, benefits of alcohol.

10:53These are not proven. It's definitely causal. But to the extent that we see any, it's predominantly for things like diabetes and heart disease. So he's saying that there may be a slight benefit, a slight positive health effect for your heart from low-level drinking. If there's any benefit, there's benefits from drinking small amounts frequently. And in fact, binge drinking, for the most part, obliterates any of the benefits that you see from frequent drinking. He doesn't sound super sure about this, though, or like confident. Like, when he says, if there's any benefit, he's not making like a particularly definitive statement.

11:37No, he's not. And I mean, this is what I found the most interesting after digging into this. Ken actually spent a lot of our time in our conversation talking less about like the specific data he found and what it showed. and more about, like, the problems with the data itself. This is not high-quality evidence in the same way that you would want, say, to have a new drug approved. It's just not.

12:12What's wrong with the evidence? That is after the break.

12:23This is advertiser content from IBM. Cold take. When it comes to quantum computing, if you need a million qubits to calculate anything, it sounds like you need a quantum computer the size of a football field. So why are we even trying? My name is Olivia Lanes. I am the global lead for content and education at IBM Quantum. So you will not need a quantum computer the size of a football field. The quantum chip is really, you know, the size of a stamp. So the chip itself is never going to be the size of a football field. What could be a very large footprint is all of the infrastructure that goes around cooling it, housing the chip, and controlling it.

13:09IBM has really been, I think, the biggest pioneer in terms of making this technology accessible. IBM has deployed, at this point, over 90 quantum computers worldwide. So if we talk about scaling, I will just say we have a plan. We have what it takes, engineering and science-wise, to make these computers work and to build them up to the scale that we know they will be useful. If you would like to learn more, you can do so at ibm.com slash quantum. Support for the show comes from Injun. Running a small business means every dollar has to work hard. But if your team is still booking travel the old way, it's costing you more than you think.

13:55Injun is the fastest growing travel and spend platform in the country, built specifically for businesses like yours. Book a trip in as little as two and a half minutes. Earn up to 10 % back on hotels. And in 2025, Injun customers saved more than$300 million on travel. With zero booking fees, no contracts, and no BS. More than 1 ,000 businesses join Engine every month. Join them and get$500 when your business signs up and starts traveling at engine.com slash Vox. Support for this show comes from Odoo. Running a business is hard enough. So why make it harder with a dozen different apps that don't talk to each other?

14:38Introducing Odoo. It's the only business software you'll ever need. It's an all-in-one, fully integrated platform that makes your work easier. CRM, accounting, inventory, e-commerce, and more. And the best part? Odoo replaces multiple expensive platforms for a fraction of the cost. That's why over thousands of businesses have made the switch. So why not you? Try Odoo for free at odoo.com. That's O-D-O-O dot com.

15:14alcohol withdrawals that's great so dylan scott before the break uh you basically told me that our our data on alcohol is bad um why why is that well it might be most helpful to start with like what would high quality data even look like and in an ideal world what you would do is set up a randomized control trial. Like you'd have two groups of people and one group would drink and the other group wouldn't drink and you would follow them both over time and you'd track what happened with their health. And at the end of this trial, you would be able to measure what the health effects of alcohol actually were.

16:03And that is the gold standard that we use for approving pharmaceutical drugs, for example. I can see why it would be pretty impossible to get like a thousand people or whatever into a randomized control trial and basically be like, you have to drink two bottles of IPA every day for the rest of time. And, you know, you can't drink any alcohol, but you have to drink two bottles of orange juice or something like that's not that's not realistic in the world we live in. No, no, exactly. So instead, we have the setup we were describing before the break. We have these observational studies that just ask people about their real lives, you know, how much alcohol they drink.

16:50And, you know, we try to follow them over the course of their lives just as they unfold naturally, try to deduce some health effects from that observational data. But that kind of study, it has some pretty big problems. And I'll just try to do a thumbnail sketch about what most of the evidence is about and what its problems are, and you can edit it out of your thing if you want to. This is Tim Namy. He is the director of the University of Victoria's Canadian Institute for Substance Use Research. He has been doing research since the 1990s, and at first glance, it would seem that he fundamentally disagrees with our first researcher, Ken.

17:35Like, Ken is out here saying, there's a possibility that a small amount of alcohol might be good for your health. And Tim thinks the opposite. The science is very consistent for 40 years that, like, when it comes to alcohol, that less is better. He is basically saying there is no amount of alcohol that is good for you. It's not that people shouldn't enjoy alcohol or shouldn't drink alcohol. It's just that there are many things in life that we do that come with some risks. And it's okay, right? But it's just like, I guess, as a scientist and a public health person, I like to call BS when I think there's been a bit of BS.

18:17And I think we've seen over the past 20 years that that kind of health halo around particularly wine and particularly so-called moderate drinking has kind of fallen away. At no level of consumption was there a significant protective effect. But when we talked to Tim and he was explaining to me why he doesn't think that glass of red wine has any kind of health halo, I realized that he was actually saying a lot of the same things that I was hearing from Ken. because, you know, as it turns out, they're both looking at the same kind of data, and they both agree on this key central point. I think the evidence base is pretty crappy.

19:01In fact, you know, a lot of Tim's argument for why he's calling BS on the idea that a small amount of alcohol could have some health benefits is because of his frustration with the data sets that we're drawing on. Like, he says that, for one thing, a lot of studies out there aren't asking questions that are specific enough. Most of what informs our information about the relationship between alcohol and, say, heart disease is based on what we call big cohort studies. These are studies that are designed to ultimately study heart disease, cancer, but they weren't really designed with alcohol in mind.

19:40Why is that important? It's important because typically they're only asking people at one point, like at the beginning of the study, for example, like, okay, how many days a week you drink and how much you drink on the days you drink. And then from that, they calculate an average consumption. We know there's a big health difference between one drink every night versus having seven drinks in a week and they were all consumed within two hours on Saturday night. But, you know, depending on the way the researchers phrase their questions or just the information they choose to collect, in theory, both of those could be recorded as I had seven drinks this week.

20:20And that imprecision makes it hard in general to interpret some of the data we have on alcohol and its health effects. That does seem like fixable though, right? In the design of either future studies or current studies. I mean, sure. You know, we could design a perfect survey question to ask about people's alcohol use. But even if we did, there are other things that are not so easily fixed, like the lack of randomness in studies like this. Because, you know, when you're not randomizing things truly, like when you're just having people report how much they're drinking and then letting them go about their lives, there are a lot of ways that the cultural context in which they live could affect the data that you're getting.

21:11You know, we could go back, I think, to like the idea that moderate drinkers are seeing some positive health effects to their drinking. As Tim pointed out, you know, moderate drinkers actually tend to fit a certain profile and they share other things in common. The problem is the so-called moderate drinkers, especially in developed countries, tend to be very socially advantaged. These people also have higher education, they have higher incomes, their children smile at them, they go to the gym, they drive BMWs. I mean, this is a big problem, right? So basically, Tim's argument here is that maybe it's not that little bit of alcohol consumption that's good for you.

21:53It's that the people who tend to have lots of other healthy things going for them in their lives tend to be the ones who are drinking only a little bit. And that might kind of bump up the numbers, you know, showing positive health effects from their drinking. So it makes it appear like, oh, moderate drinking, you know, gives you straight teeth and it gives you a good job and it gives you a BMW. But in fact, it's the BMW and the nice job that lets you buy a nice bottle of wine.

22:23And on the flip side, you know, he said we also need to be really careful about how we think about and study non-drinkers. Those people are actually in many cases not never drinkers, but are in fact former drinkers. Former drinkers we know are very unhealthy. They tend to be unhealthy. And it may be because they drank a lot or had bad effects of alcohol and they stopped drinking. But what we know about former drinkers is for a variety of reasons, they tend to not do well. Some folks might not be drinkers at the time of the study, but they might have been heavy drinkers before the study even started.

23:00But at the time of the study, when the researchers are collecting all this data, they would report that they actually don't drink. So this could really influence the results that this study ultimately reports. And I've seen other studies have pointed out that some of the people who are really, really heavy drinkers, they die at such a young age that they don't end up getting included in these studies. And so all of these things are the problems with observational studies and relying on observational data to draw firm conclusions about the health effects of different things. Unless you're controlling for all of this stuff, it becomes really hard to isolate for the specific health effects of alcohol.

23:44But like, my understanding is that you can find ways to correct data for stuff like this, right? Like if you ask people who joined your study, did you or have you had a problem with alcohol? Can't you kind of control for all those factors, I guess, or like weight the study accordingly? I mean, you can certainly try. And Tim Namy is a co-author on a recent really big meta-analysis of all the prior research of cardiovascular effects from alcohol use. And that's exactly what they were trying to do. They were trying to slice and dice this data to account for all kinds of different things, gender and age and race and even this abstainer bias that they were cognizant of.

24:33But, you know, there's an art to doing that kind of work. You know, different people could choose to weigh different variables to different degrees. And that's what leads to some of these differences of opinion that we've seen between different scientists. Is there any hope of getting better data? I don't know. I personally would like to have better data on this thing that's pretty ubiquitous in modern society. Yes, I agree. And there are researchers who are trying to use things like genetics to improve the data we have. You know, they're studying people who have a genetic tendency to drink or not to drink and looking at their health outcomes.

25:18And then we've got other researchers who are trying to set up studies to measure the specific biological mechanisms that might explain some of the benefits or negative consequences that we're seeing. And so, you know, I think that would make people feel more confident, at least, that like, okay, it's actually the alcohol that's doing something here. And it's not just that, you know, these people happen to have certain drinking patterns or their health outcomes are actually being determined by, you know, having a BMW or their kid is smiling at them, whatever it may be. But, you know, overall, I mean, I thought, look, I thought Ken made a compelling point that even though this is hard, even though the answers may not be perfect, we could and should try to do better.

26:07At least for me, the fact that something is hard is not a reason not to do it, especially when something is important as this, right? A lot of people drink alcohol. Over half Americans are drinking alcohol. How is it that we don't know exactly what the hell this stuff does if half of Americans are doing it? And the fact that it's hard is a cop-out answer, I think, for not having good information. Were you surprised by this at the end that we don't have better answers? You know, it honestly, it simultaneously did and did not surprise me. You know, I've reported on health for a long time, reported a lot on how people's behavior affects their health.

26:47And this is a recurring theme that, you know, understanding how people's behavior affects their well-being is really difficult. with caffeine or chocolate or sugar, you know, these substances that we're consuming all the time and we want to understand what they're doing to our bodies, we've run into this problem again and again, where it's really hard to set up a proper randomized trial that would really give us the answers that we want. And so instead, we're left with this imperfect observational data that leaves us a little bit uncertain about exactly what conclusions we should be drawing with it.

27:24what should people do in the face of this imperfect data? Should they start drinking? Should they stop drinking entirely? I think the most important thing is that people just be aware of the facts that we've been covering on this episode. Because as we've said, you know, the researchers who we talked to were all in agreement that once you're drinking heavily, according to the scientific definitions, you're inviting some pretty serious health risks. And I don't think anybody would say, you know, you should start drinking because it's going to be good for your health. But I don't think anybody we talked to would say, like, absolutely everyone, you know, we need to go back to prohibition.