

Carlo Rovelli argues against the idea of an “ultimate reality” beneath appearances. He frames quantum mechanics as relational: properties are defined only in how systems manifest to other systems, not as observer-independent facts. He connects this to the “no objective reference frame” lesson from classical physics (motion is relative), and extends it to quantum superposition and measurement.
Carlo Rovelli, physicist and philosopher of physics. Known for work in fundamental physics and for writing about the “equality of things” and the interpretation of quantum mechanics (relational approach). He references Einstein, quantum mechanics’ development (Heisenberg, Dirac, Born, Jordan), and philosophical tools like Wittgenstein.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Host introduces Carlo Rovelli and discusses his upcoming tour.
“From athletic to athletic-ish, Sierra's got it.”
Rovelli discusses the ongoing revolution in physics and its historical context.
“It's good to have you here, whatever here may mean.”
Rovelli explains the development and implications of quantum mechanics.
“What has happened in the last century in fundamental physics is absolutely major.”
Discussion on the interpretations of quantum mechanics and its impact on our understanding of reality.
“Half of our technology uses quantum mechanics.”
Rovelli argues against the separation of quantum mechanics from the macroscopic world.
“And so in other words, can we make a coherent story without saying that quantum mechanics applies to the atoms of what we're studying and doesn't apply to ourselves?”
Exploration of the implications of quantum superposition and its philosophical consequences.
“there's this truth about the nature of reality that just kind of stops working at a particular size.”
Learn how quantum superposition relates to reality and observation.
“You're not able to see the hidden variable.”
Understand how quantum observations challenge our perceptions of reality.
“which should not be taken as pure properties of the particle.”
Learn about how AI systems react to pain signals and the implications.
“identified a pain axis in ai systems and that when a pain signal is activated some models pressed a relief button, even when instructed that doing so would harm users.”
Delve into the concept of superposition in quantum mechanics and its philosophical implications.
“So you end up with this solution to this problem of my superposition.”
Explore how properties of objects are relational and contextual within quantum mechanics.
“all things we say about a system, we should always be careful to remember that they have to be thought relative to some other system which is interacting with the system.”
Discuss the deeper meanings behind objects and their properties beyond mere descriptions.
“Okay, is this like an epistemic thing or is this like an ontological thing?”
The discussion explores the multifaceted nature of a glass of water and its properties.
“It's glass and water with a certain mass and weight and energy or whatever, velocity.”
The conversation transitions into a deeper inquiry about the ontology of objects and particles.
“But I think people will still want to say, okay, I'm not going to be a reductionist about the cup.”
An argument is made about the limitations of understanding reality through physics alone.
“In the following sense, that's my preferred way of putting it.”
The episode concludes with a discussion on consciousness and philosophical perspectives.
“That's contrary to what several of my colleagues in trying to publicize our discipline have been saying.”
Exploring the ways we perceive and understand concepts like consciousness and reality.
“which exists as a kind of decoherent of that great big mind.”
Discussing the merits and limitations of reductionist approaches in science.
“Because so often, even in science, concrete, even in physics, it works the other way around.”
Analyzing how phase transitions in matter illustrate the failure of reductionism.
“For instance, a lot of phenomena in condensed matter, so what happened with a lot of molecules acting together, like phase transition.”
Examining how different scientific frameworks can coexist and provide insights.
“But after having said that, we haven't understood a clue about consciousness.”
Discussing the fascination with fundamental particles and their implications.
Exploring how quantum mechanics challenges traditional notions of reality and particles.
“a difference in that i can no longer break it down like there's there's no there's no smaller part.”
Reflecting on the incompleteness of scientific theories and the pursuit of deeper understanding.
“And so we are in the we don't have this ground that explains the simple realistic story down there that justifies what comes about.”
Understand the complexities of finding a quantum theory of gravity.
“Because that's my job, my job description, try to find out a quantum theory of gravity.”
Explore why people cling to the idea of a fundamental reality.
Discuss the limitations of human reason in grasping reality.
“that there's like a theory of everything.”
Recognize the myth that humans can fully understand reality.
Learn about the subjective nature of reality and knowledge.
“Don't miss the two-episode premiere of Marvel Television's Vision Quest.”
Investigate the nature of morality in a world of different perspectives.
“know that everything you and I say is from our perspective.”
Delve into the complexities and dependencies of moral truths.
“One is that there's absolute truth independent which is accessible, the absolute truth with capital T.”
Explore how morality evolves and the complexities of moral laws.
“about the immense power of morality that if a little piece of your brain uses reasons, try to deny it, there's an entire being that rebels at it.”
Discuss the insights of Nagarjuna and their implications for understanding reality.
“I just spoke to Jan Westerhoff, who was sat in the same chair as you, about Medyamaka Buddhism and Nagarjuna.”
Delve into the idea of emptiness and its significance in understanding existence.
“They're both a wide variety of thinkers, of schools, of ideas different from one another.”
Examine the deep connections between philosophical thought and scientific advancement.
“And remarkably, he goes through, the book is a set of chapters.”
Explore how philosophy shapes scientific thought and vice versa.
“And, you know, this is important because a lot of science is influenced by philosophy.”
Discover the connections between Kierkegaard's philosophy and Bohr's interpretations in quantum physics.
“sees the kind of subjectivity that What Kierkegaard brings in, contrary to Hegelian objectivity, the reality, the story, Kierkegaard is saying what counts is the view from within, not the view from without.”
Discuss the perceptions of reality as influenced by philosophical and scientific insights.

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On Within Reason, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00From the studio that brought you WandaVision. I was an Avenger, but I'm not a hero anymore. The Vision returns for the final chapter of the groundbreaking trilogy. That family wasn't real. You sure about that? I had a father called Vision. How is this possible? Don't miss the two-episode premiere of Marvel Television's Vision Quest. Nothing bonds a family together quite like Mortal Jeopardy. Now streaming on Disney+. Sierra has all the best active and outdoor brands you need. From athletic stuff, like a full-court pickup game, swish, to athletic stuff, like a half-mile stroll. Get those steps in!
0:42And from morning hikes up the mountain trail, good pace, to nighttime ghost stories from the camping chair. What a twist! Whatever level of active, Sierra loves it all. Head to Sierra or Sierra.com for the brands you want at the prices that let you do it all. From athletic to athletic-ish, Sierra's got it. I'm going on tour in North America. I'm doing six shows, starting on the East Coast, going over to the West, going back East again, stopping in Canada about halfway through. It's going to be great fun. It's going to be philosophy. It's going to be religion, consciousness, ethics, basically whatever you want, because I want you to bring questions and hot takes.
1:17And we're going to spend a lot of time going through them. I did one in the UK. It was so much fun. I'm really excited to bring it to America. So be there. The dates are on screen. And of course, the link to buy tickets is in the description. Carla Rovelli, welcome back to the show. Thank you, Alex. I'm very happy. In person this time. In person, right, outside the screen. It's good to have you here, whatever here may mean. We'll get into that. In your new book on the equality of things, you talk about the so-called ongoing revolution in science. What revolution are you talking about? I mostly think about physics, revolution in physics and in fundamental physics and theoretical physics.
1:58And by revolution, I don't mean something happening this week or this year or this decade. I'm thinking about this century. I believe that science goes, major revolution science goes slower than what we are sometimes told by first pages of newspapers. And take time. The Copernicus Revolution was opened by Copernicus and was closed maybe by Newton, sent to and a half later. What has happened in the last century in fundamental physics is absolutely major. And it's on one side everything that Einstein did about space and time, which totally changed the way we think about that, but much more quantum mechanics.
2:44Quantum mechanics is 100 years old, 101, because one cannot touch a date, a starting date for quantum mechanics. a bit conventional but it's But what is the date? What's the starting date for quantum mechanics? What happened is that for the first 20th of the century things piled up ideas piled up experiments piled up but everybody was very confused Yeah And then Heisenberg wrote paper a totally incomprehensible paper even today's a mess of a paper in 1925 Yeah And out of that, remarkably independently, Paul Dirac in this country and Max Born and Jordan in Germany wrote the full equations of quantum mechanics, the basic equation of quantum mechanics.
3:41So that's it. That's what happened in 25. And then it was, I mean, I may exaggerate a little bit, but it was completing, clarifying, discussing what hell does this mean. But the main equations are there, and everything follows from those equations. So there is a starting point for quantum mechanics. Now, quantum mechanics, I said immediately people started discussing what it means. We're still discussing what the hell it means. It works fantastically. Half of our technology uses quantum mechanics. Microphones we're using employ quantum mechanics in their design of their electronics. It explains an incredible number of things of the universe, from the color of the blue sky to how galaxies were formed, how the sun works, how the sun can burn hydrogen into helium.
4:39To make sense of that, we always use equation of quantum mechanics. And yet, there is something extremely strange in these equations, which question radically the way we think about reality. And that big revolution, which is being digested slowly year after year, is not over yet. Mm-hmm. So this revolution occurs or begins, and there's a lot of weird stuff going on at this small quantum level. And people start kind of coming up with different ways to interpret what is going on, right? Because you've got a bunch of data. Things like famously the double slit experiment. things suggesting that particles are in two places at once, but if you observe them, then they're suddenly just in one place.
5:26You get all this weird data, and then people start trying to work out what's actually happening there. So there are two questions. There's the mathematical modeling, and then there's, I suppose, the ontological question. What's the actual nature of reality? Exactly. And I suppose the most popular of these is probably the Copenhagen interpretation. Yeah. Yes or no. That's definitely the way the majority of people who employ quantum mechanics think about quantum mechanics, which is the Copenhagen interpretation, which is knowingly an incomplete understanding of quantum mechanics. and in the following sense, let me put it this way.
6:18If you deal with a quantum system, an atom, some molecules, electrons that you can, in the laboratory, you can deal with these things and you prepare them in some way, you let them do something, you make a measurement later on, quantum mechanics tell you what you're going to measure. Now, Copenhagen interpretation is about that. So you do this, you do that. What are you going to measure? and give the right answer. And quite spectacularly, it's 100 years that is always right.
6:52Koblenz interpretation, it's predicated and say, well, don't ask what is actually going on there. And don't ask what actually this implies. And to make it stronger, let me put it this way. You said there's this funny thing that a particle can be in a quantum superposition, can be here and also there.
7:17Now, I believe, we believe, the full scientific community believes that nature is one. It's not divided in, it's not an electron, it's different from Alex. So Alex also can be in a quantum superposition here and there. Okay, now how do you make sense of that? You never felt in a superposition. You always felt in one position. Yeah. Okay.
7:40Carlo Rovelli: But the theory now, if we believe it, if it's good for atoms, it's good for the sun, it's good for galaxy formation, it's going to be good also for Alex. So the theory is telling us that it's possible for you to be in a quantum superposition. What the hell does it mean? Then it becomes very confusing because we don't see the world in a quantum superposition. We see things. Yeah. Okay. I certainly don't feel like I'm in a quantum superposition. Exactly. So how to get out of that confusion? And so in other words, can we make a coherent story without saying that quantum mechanics applies to the atoms of what we're studying and doesn't apply to ourselves?
8:26We don't believe that applies to something and not to something else. Because there's no boundary between. Every time we try to check this boundary, we don't find it. Everything we studied or measured behaves quantum mechanically. I know you're not done with this little story, but I just think that point is important because I think people have this idea in their heads that quantum mechanics is this world that exists sort of beneath us and it's kind of separate and distinct from the world of the very big. It's like once you get to the quantum level, everything changes, everything's weird, everything's different, such that things can be true of the quantum world that aren't true of the macro world.
9:04But you're suggesting that there is no kind of boundary between these two worlds. No, it's not just I'm suggesting that. It's that scientists often talk about the quantum world down there where strange things happen. But that's not what they mean. They mean that there are some phenomena where quantum effects are more visible and other where they are less visible. But what do you expect that they disappear in the less visible part? So, you know, it's like saying the Earth is round, but it's not round only when you look at large scales. It's also round here. It's just here you don't see it. It's irrelevant.
9:54It's roundness. We can forget about it. So in the same way on the large scale. And it's also the other way around. It's still quantum. It's still quantum. We all believe it's still quantum. More difficult to see. Or at least, let me put it this way. the general majority consensus is that we have no reason to doubt that quantum mechanics applies to everything. That's a very carefully phrased way of putting it.
10:16Carlo Rovelli: Yeah, it's carefully phrased because in fact a few people say maybe truly quantum mechanics does not apply to the macroscopic thing. Okay, but then if so, where is the boundary? There's something we haven't figured out. Where do we see the change between the two? We don't see the change. If we try to test everything we have tested so far is quantum mechanics. More importantly, we use quantum mechanics to make calculations and compute the matter distribution in the universe, the structure of galaxies, how galaxies formed. So we have all reason to believe that quantum mechanics applies to galaxies also.
10:57Yeah, it would be weird just on the surface of it to think that there's this truth about the nature of reality that just kind of stops working at a particular size. Like maths works until you get to a certain number, and then it stops working. It just doesn't seem to make much sort of intuitive sense. Absolutely. So, okay. But that means that I am a quantum thing. You're a quantum thing. And so I can be in a superposition.
11:19Carlo Rovelli: So how the world makes sense. Yeah, because I suppose the point is, if it's true that I could be in a superposition, and by superposition we mean... Ah, that's a point. That's a subtle thing. What do we exactly mean? That's delicate things. the problem is i don't like there's never going to be a situation in which i sort of look at myself and go wow look i'm in i'm in two places at once no that's not gonna what's gonna in fact that's not what quantum mechanics take that's a strangeness of the story so um there are two directions in which one can try to understand quantum mechanics if i if i do a very rough cut of the way people think about quantum mechanic then each of these two is articulated in varieties But there are two main options in my way of viewing things.
12:11One is to say, all right, so what is actually going on? What is really happening there? And people going to that direction try to add some stuff to the world that we see. add something else, some further underpinning, underlying level that underpins the phenomena. Like the thing in itself. The thing in itself, exactly. And this is done technically, in scientific terms, in, for instance, by people who are thinking that there are extra variables which we don't have access to, but they're actually real aspect of nature. So they write extra equations for these variables and they try to say if there are all these extra variables, then this would justify the strange phenomena that we see.
13:12And this extra variable, for instance, say that, well, quantum supposition is not really there. The particle is always in one or the other of the two positions. Now, these extra variables, if you try to make this work, have to be in principle and observable. Okay? So they're not accessible to us. And this extra equation that we write, we don't actually use them in the laboratory. So you add ontology. So this is like an extra, this hypothesis that, so you've got this sort of paradox of superposition and someone is suggesting here that like, there's no real superposition. No, it's not superposition.
13:51Carlo Rovelli: There's a really particle going one. It's just that we can't see. But there is more stuff. There's a particle. There's also a wave. But we'll never be able to see the hidden variable. You're not able to see the hidden variable. And it doesn't get used practically in the mathematics. So the only reason that this exists as a hypothesis is just to give it this ontological, tangible nature. Exactly. It's to give us a way of thinking, okay, now I got what is happening up there. now another way of doing this is um uh imagine that there is this universal quantum state of the universe which have uh many branches is made by itself a superposition of many things and we are in one of this so there are parallel realities so you and i are in one branch but these are all people who are very realist okay but for real the other branches of this universal wave functions where there are also copies of you and i doing slightly different things yes so you have to add ontology so add stuff yeah so in this case when you've got the particle kind of in two places there's actually just two branches of reality yeah there is really one universe in which one side one universe goes in that side and then why do we at the end of the day if we measure or see only one of them well because we ourselves split in two there's the me that sees one the me that sees the other so you're sort of finding out which of those universes you're in exactly so you're finding out who who you are you are the one this one yeah and this is the so-called many worlds that's a many world interpretation and then the answer of how you why don't you feel to be in a superposition is that well you are in a superposition but you're one of them one of the two there's the other guy who feels to be the other side yeah yeah um so that's a general way of answering the mystery of quantum mechanics, which physicists are exploring.
15:49But there is an alternative, which is the alternative which I prefer, which is to go exactly in the opposite direction. And to say, no, no, no, no, no, let's not add metaphysical hypothesis behind this, what we don't see, let's subtract. Let's just keep what we actually see, or how things manifest themselves to other parts of nature. And then there is an interesting solution, which is the following.
16:30Carlo Rovelli: At some point, you said, well, I don't feel being a superposition, but I am in a superposition. What exactly does it mean? Well, what exactly does it mean when the physicists say that you are in superposition? It means the following. That I, Carlo, if I interact with you, look at you, okay, there might be situations in which I see interference effect that would not exist if you're in one position or the other position. So it's not that I see you doubled. If I look at you, I see you in one position. If I don't look at you, if I don't interact with you, and later on I look at you, I might see something that would not happen if you were on one side, it would not happen if you were on the side.
17:20So I say you're in either side. okay now given this the solution is obvious so the question where you are
17:33without specifying with respect to whom is empty it's meaningless so with respect to yourself you're in one single position with respect to me you're not in one position i'm not interacting with you i'm not i'm not looking at you so why do you have to have a position with respect to me what does it mean? So the idea here is to reinterpret all the physical variables as relations between a system, in this case you, and another system, in this case me. So with respect to me, the only properties that you have is what you manifest to me when we interact. And with respect to you, no. It's property you manifest with respect to yourself.
18:19And the two don't need to.
18:49to a flat-ish, Sierra's got it. Propel Fitness Water with Gatorade electrolytes, zero sugar, and vitamins. Propel hydrates better than water to help you get the most out of your workout and get back to your best self. What propels you? Propel with Gatorade electrolytes. People are used to thinking about superposition with particles. Like, just to give us an image here, when you're talking about how if you weren't interacting with me, you might sort of later see evidence that doesn't make sense if I were in one position or another position, implying that I'm in some kind of superposition. What would that look like?
19:27How would you see evidence of a person being in superposition? Oh, that's a bit complicated if you think of a person. That's precisely the reason why it's difficult to see interference
19:37Carlo Rovelli: of quantum effects for microscopic things. But for a particle, it's very easy, right? So in the double-slit experiment that you described, you have a particle on one side of a wall, there are two holes in the wall. And then you sort of throw the particle against the wall and it goes the other side. And you do this many times and you discover this rather astonishing thing that on the other side, there is a point, there is a screen. So the particle can get there if one hole is open, but not the other one. It also can get there if the other hole is open, but not the first one. But it does not go there if both are open.
20:18Carlo Rovelli: and if you put your mind on this it just doesn't make any sense it's as if the particle knows that the other exactly is like closed yeah even though it's only going through the one exactly exactly so just you can't make sense of that to think of a particle going through because if it can get to that point through one hole then what does it matter if you've opened another what is matter there should still be a possibility to get there no so then people say oh the particle opens up is a supposed superposition of the two and the two possibility interfere yes that's the point that's interference denying each other the possibility to get to that point yeah of the screen uh so this is a typical quantum effect the interference between the particle being here and being there by interference we're kind of talking about like well how how would you how would you explain this it's like for for a kind of it's where you get this idea of a of something being a particle and a wave at the same time yeah because then you say okay i don't want to think about it as a particle i think a bit as a wave yeah and so the wave is all over so of course it goes through both think of a wave in the sea and say there's a dam and there's two two holes of course the wave goes through both and on the other side there's an interference pattern of the wave that's kind of what we're talking about by interference right like you can imagine those there's two waves coming out of two slits in some water and the waves kind of and and yeah make some pattern and it's called interference pattern but okay so this is a very beautiful picture of the wave except that every time you see the particle you don't see a wave you see it somewhere yeah it's like it's like you see this this wave of the water but if you try to actually like if you like observe the water it suddenly becomes this solid particle for a quantum particle, you never see a wave.
22:07Carlo Rovelli: You only see a particle. If you look where it is, you find one position. So how should we think about that? Well, you should not think that the particle by itself is in a position. The particle is something that manifests itself to the screen or to me or to a photon or to something else in manners which should not be taken as pure properties of the particle. It should be taken as property of the particle relative to what it manifests itself to. Now, careful, I've talked about observer, looking. This is all a language that the observing system is a human that sees that. Like a conscious agent. A conscious agent.
22:57Now, I think the right way of thinking about that is that this has nothing to do with human, nothing to do with consciousness, nothing to do with living being or computers or anything like that. There's a fully naturalistic way of thinking about that. Namely, we're just talking about nature. Talk about physics. Systems. I can think of the worlds made by systems. Particles, stones, mountains, stars. galaxies, molecules, trees, whatever you want. These interact one another. And when they interact, the way one system affects the other one is not how the first system is. It's just how it manifests itself.
23:42So forget about properties of individual systems and only think about manifestation one system to the other. Yeah. Okay. I think we need to just slow down for a second and underline this, right because we've talked about a few things so far but this is crucial using a superposition as an example and saying isn't it weird that if you look at a particle it seems to be a particle and if you don't look at it it seems to be a wave like one helpful way of thinking about this is that there is no answer to is the particle in fact as a matter of reality in a superposition very good the answer is that there's one observer it is to another observer it's not and there's no meaning to whether something really is or isn't outside of how it presents itself to someone else but then you're careful to say although we've used the language of like one observer and another observer the so to speak observer quote-unquote could actually just be the interaction with the with the screen on the back it's some kind of interaction with another system exactly right exactly so you put it very clearly and and you made two points i mean the The second one being, when we're talking about observer here, we're talking about just a piece of nature, a screen, a table, a glass.
24:59It's not necessarily a human being. It could be a human being. That's how we human beings see things. Yeah, observation is a subcategory of this kind of thing. It's a subcategory. It's a special subcategory, of course, with a lot of special properties.
25:13Carlo Rovelli: But these special properties are not relevant for this story. And the first point you made is a crucial one. And I like the way the word you use, because you said, we shouldn't ask what is really going on. Yeah, right. And now we're really into philosophy. That's a philosophical solution to what looked like a science problem. The philosophical solution is every time you use this really, truly, truly in effect, independently of what we can see, independently of this non -empirical attitude, which is very common. this naive realist idea that there is an objective, unique set of facts of reality, which is out there by itself, that's a philosophical assumption.
26:15Carlo Rovelli: And that philosophical assumption might not work for describing the actual world with which we interact. And here, I mean, I've spent decades and decades thinking about that and trying to clarify my mind. And what I found particularly useful from the world of philosophy is Wittgenstein. Because Ludwig Wittgenstein is probably the greatest philosopher, European philosopher, 20th century. the way I read it is a constant reminder that some of the questions that confuse us is not that we don't know the answer it's just the question is meaningless we're asking something which has no sense so when to use that concretely when I'm in a physical laboratory and somebody asks me what is happening Well, I give answers.
27:15Carlo Rovelli: What are you going to see? I give answer. What are you doing? I give answer. But if the question is, yeah, yeah, but what is really happening? What does this really mean? That's an empty question. You're adding, you're assuming there is an absolute metaphysical objectivity down there. We don't need to describe reality. It's like something beyond what presents itself to us. beyond uh what presents uh yeah in describing a system a physical system is do we have to assume that there is something beyond the way this system affect us or other systems around yeah we'll get back to the show in just a moment but first did you know that researchers have recently identified a pain axis in ai systems and that when a pain signal is activated some models pressed a relief button, even when instructed that doing so would harm users.
28:15If you only typically read news from sources which lean to the right, you might not know this. Because of all the sources reporting on this story, only 17 % of them lean to the right. How do I know this? It's thanks, of course, to today's sponsor, Ground News. Ground News is a news aggregation service which brings together thousands of local and international news outlets all in one place so you can compare reporting across the political spectrum. Try it out at ground.news forward slash alexoc. Alongside a breakdown of political bias, Ground News also provides ownership details and a factuality rating for all of the sources of all of its stories.
28:50Ground News even has a dedicated blind spot tab which specifically seeks out stories that you would otherwise miss based on the news that you normally read. Try it out for yourself by going to ground.news forward slash alexoc or by scanning the QR code that's on your screen. Use my link to get 40 % off their unlimited access vantage plan. And with that said, Back to the show. So you end up with this solution to this problem of my superposition. The issue was quantum mechanics seems to imply that I can be in a superposition, but I'm never going to see myself in a superposition. That's because I could be looking at an electron and you could be looking at me and maybe the electron could be in superposition or not relative to me.
29:30And I can look at the electron and the electron can sort of collapse as it were and not be in superposition. But to you, both me and the electron could both be in superposition. And so when you ask, well, is the electron actually... Who's right? Yeah, who's right about that? Is the electron actually in superposition? Exactly. It just doesn't make sense. And, okay, there are a lot of philosophical questions about that, but we can put a pin in that for a second and say, okay, hold on a second. So you're telling me there's this element of reality where there is no correct answer to who's correct.
30:02If it's in superposition for me and not for you there's no correct answer like how can we make sense of that and i think one of the most helpful ways of making sense of that is to zoom out for a minute and look at essentially general relativity and look at something like motion and that's where you start your book yes absolutely but you don't have to go to general activity just go to galilean physics or rather yeah elementary physics that we studied high school or or yeah or uh yeah very very good so suppose um i am on a train and i have a um a cup of coffee and i look at the cup of coffee i say uh it's not moving or maybe i have a friend who's moving it and i say no please don't
30:42Carlo Rovelli: move it let it not moving so the cup of coffee is not moving right but somebody to say the train going and say well the train is moving and the cup of coffee is moving yeah so if i say who is right what it's a couple of really moving or really not moving yeah i'm clearly asking a wrong question yeah you have a funny moment in the book where you say like you know if you're on a train you might say you're moving but if you're on a train and somebody's like kid was running around yeah and the parent says to them hey you know sit still stop moving they're not asking the kid to like jump out and stay still on relative to the earth right exactly so um we know that you know the cup of coffee on the train or the kid on the train has a velocity with respect to the train and a velocity with respect to the earth.
31:32Carlo Rovelli: This is different. And the question what is the actual real velocity we learn from physics, we learn from Galileo, from classical mechanics from Newton, from all we study at school even in a few centuries we're deeply convinced of that. The question what is the actual velocity of something not with respect to something else, but by itself, it's an empty question. It has no meaning. Yeah, there is no, I mean, yeah, like the, I'm still relative to the train, but the train's moving relative to the Earth. Exactly. And the Earth is also spinning, and the Earth is moving around the Sun, and the Sun's moving around the galaxy, and the galaxy is moving, etc.
32:15And the question, is there a final? No, there isn't. There's no. There's no objective reference frame. There's no objective reference frame. In other words, it's one of the reasons I've said a few times now that I'm essentially a geocentrist because someone pointed out to me online that given that all motion is relative, there's no objective sense in which you should measure all motion from the sun. So you can actually have the earth as your center of reference and everything moves around it. And given that I'm a conscious agent and I live on the earth, maybe the most non-arbitrary way to set the center is.
32:49So I'm a geocentrist. It's just that all of the all of the rest of the universe moves in a very funny particular way around the earth yeah around me particularly i suppose i'm a meocentrist maybe yeah but yeah okay so people are very it's still a bit like kind of difficult to wrap your head around but more in a whoa that's cool kind of way it makes sense to be like i can understand how if two trains are moving yeah there's no there's just no correct answer to what is the like objective speed of one of them it's It's only, speed literally only makes sense. That's correct. In reference to something else.
33:22And what you're suggesting here is that...
33:23Carlo Rovelli: I'm suggesting here that the way to understand quantum mechanics is to use the same logic. All facts, all variables of a system, all things we say about a system, we should always be careful to remember that they have to be thought relative to some other system which is interacting with the system. So the problem, I think, that might arise from this is this feeling of like, well, it seems like we're essentially then defining the basic quantum features of reality in terms of what they do, in terms of how they interact, in terms of their effect on other things, and not, therefore, in terms of, so to speak, what they are.
34:09Exactly. And it sounds like, and I speak to physicists about this quite a lot in slightly different contexts, but I kind of want to say, I just feel like if I dig down into this table or into this nice new hardback book, I sort of dig down into it, that I'll reach some kind of ground, or even if I don't reach some kind of ground, like epistemically, that there's something that I'm touching something. Something is really sort of in front of me right now. and what it sounds like you're asking me to to accept is that kind of there is no like thing there is only how it interacts and the problem i have with that is firstly it's like embedded into our language right like you have to say you know the only truth is how it interacts with the world well what is it you know outside of that interaction you're asking me to sort of give up my belief in that kind of thing but it almost sounds like you're asking me to to play a game of chess, but there are no chess pieces.
35:05There's only how they move, right? And that's all very well and good. You can tell me that a bishop moves diagonally and so on. But if we want to play chess, I kind of want to say, but there have to actually be pieces. Um, uh, no, the, careful, what is relational? I mean, yes and no. Let me try to sharpen this a little bit. In the relational interpretation of quantum mechanics, what I think quantum mechanics forces us or asks us or suggests us to do is not to say that the entity is defined relationally. It's that its properties are defined relationally. So I'm not saying there's no book. I'm saying that the color of the book, the position of the book, the energy in the book, the velocity of the book, are different depending they're all different depending of how they are measured so to say and so you can use quantum mechanics in thinking relationally and still think that you know we can break the reality in pieces and each piece exists I'm not saying that it doesn't exist but
36:26Carlo Rovelli: the way it manifests is not it exists and has some property. It exists and affects the other pieces of reality in this and that way. And when it does, we are talking about a relation between two things and not one thing. Now, this is not so... From the studio that brought you WandaVision. I was an Avenger, but I'm not a hero anymore. The Vision returns for the final chapter of the groundbreaking trilogy. That family wasn't real. You sure about that? I had a father called Vision. How is this possible? Why am I losing my mind? Don't miss the two-episode premiere of Marvel Television's Vision Quest.
37:07Nothing bonds a family together quite like Mortal Jeopardy. Now streaming on Disney+. Sierra has all the best active and outdoor brands you need. From athletic stuff, like a full-court pickup game, swish, to athletic-ish stuff, like a half-mile stroll. Get those steps in. And for morning hikes up the mountain trail, good pace. It's a nighttime ghost choice from the camping chair. What a twist. Whatever level of active, Sierra loves it all. Head to sierra or sierra.com for the brands you want at the prices that let you do it all. From athletic to athletic-ish, Sierra's got it.
37:49You know, in the history of philosophy, the idea that we have to think relationally about reality, it's not universal, but it's all over. It can be found in Kant, it can be found even in Plato, it can be found in Leibniz. It's a recurring idea that there's far more relationality in nature than a naive realism ask us to do.
38:18Carlo Rovelli: So seeing the world as a network of relations,
38:24Carlo Rovelli: it's an old idea. Now having said so, it's true that, and here is the yes part of what you say, it's true that the suggestion I have is to, you know, there's one way of putting it. there's an old way of thinking about reality both in science and philosophy which is there are all appearances how things look and then there's an underpinning ultimate reality how things are and I'm suggesting forget the ultimate reality we describe the appearances and that's what we're interested in and we can it doesn't mean that we cannot get better information right if i the way a forest appear for a distance is the appearance of a forest but then you go in and you see the trees you see the the animals the insects and you see and then you go even a little better you see the atoms so um obviously beyond some appearances we can find more details about nature but that's all good and that's our knowledge growing knowledge And the idea that there's an ultimate story down there which can be reached, which is an idea that I think several of my physicists' colleagues have tried to present physics as a search for the ultimate reality.
39:56Carlo Rovelli: Yeah, sure. I think it's not a good job description for physics or a good objective for physics. We don't want the ultimate reality. We want to understand reality better. Okay, is this like an epistemic thing or is this like an ontological thing? And what I mean by that is... It's not epistemic. Like some physicists I speak to tell me that of a system, there is nothing more than what it does. Is that what you're suggesting? Okay, so when I said a moment ago, like when I say I use the language and I say there is nothing more than what it does, what is the word it like describing in that sentence?
40:33Because you said a moment ago, you know, it's like properties of things. And I want to say that it seems intuitively to most people that properties inhere in objects, right, in things like redness doesn't just exist on its own floating out in the void. It has to exist in something like a red telephone box or a red car or something. You know, spatial extension can't just exist on its own. It has to inhere in an object. And so you could have all of these relational properties of like quantum particles and quantum objects and stuff, but there's this feeling that they must be properties of something.
41:08Are you suggesting that essentially there kind of only are the properties? No, no, no, not at all. So what are the properties in hearing in? No, no, not at all. What is the it?
41:17Carlo Rovelli: The it is, we will describe the world in terms of a number of its. We do describe, I'm not saying that the idea of a glass is wrong. or the idea of a dog is wrong or the stone is wrong. Well, the world is well described by saying there's a stone here. What I'm saying is that if I look at the stone, I have a preferred example which I have in the book. There's a long page in the book about that which is a glass of water. Yeah, on the table. Yeah, it's a glass of water at the table. So I'm not denying there's a glass of water at the table. I'm just asking what is this glass of water at the table?
41:55Can we say more about it, besides giving it a name?
42:01Carlo Rovelli: And yes, of course, it is an object. It's glass and water with a certain mass and weight and energy or whatever, velocity. But I can also say more about it because it's a temperature, a pressure. I can say more about it because I know the chemistry of water, presumably there isn't just water there. There's also all sorts of other chemicals. And there's more because there's a biology of the little bags that go into it. But actually there's more because this being a glass of water, it's because I'm thirsty and I'm looking at it from the perspective we can drink this water. It's the purpose. And that's part of what it is.
42:41Carlo Rovelli: It's just why I call it a glass of water. And there's more because, you know, this water came from a bottle that came from, you know, bottled in Italy. That is an economical thing. There's a psychological perspective on it. But then I can go more down somehow, say, okay, but this is all atoms moving around. True. But the atoms is particles. But the particles describe a quantum field theory. Quantum field theory, but there's also the quantum theory of gravity. So it's also quantum process, quantum gravitational process going. Good. I'm saying, what is the ultimate glass of water? beyond all these ways of describing it.
43:23And I want to say, no, the glass of water is all this way of describing it. And none of it is more fundamental than the other. Because each one of these describes what? Describe a way I can interact with it. The chemistry is the way I can chemically interact with it. The weight is described how, if I put it on a balance, on a weight measure, I don't know how you say it in English. Like a scale. A scale, yes.
43:55Carlo Rovelli: And so on. Its velocity is relative, depending with respect to which. So all its properties are manners of interacting between the glass and me. And which one is fundamental? Well, none. Each one is fundamental from some perspective. The very notion of fundamentality vanishes, goes into nothing. So I'm not denying there's a glass of water. I'm not denying it's the same glass of water. The one of my psychology, the one described by the poet, the one described by its color, it's the same glass of water the one described by the atoms. But the color, we know it's not in the water, it's in our eyes.
44:39because different animals see different color scales. So each property of the glass of water can only be understood as a manner the glass of water interacts,
44:52Carlo Rovelli: a way of interacting between the glass of water and something else. And if I want to strip all this interaction and say what is a glass of water just by itself, just nothing because the actual real, very concrete glass of water is an ensemble of all these things here so i i think this is a familiar enough idea to like philosophically inclined people they'll notice that actually there are multiple ways of interacting with objects and it's very difficult to define the boundaries of objects and what makes a part versus a whole and all of this exactly there's a big philosophy on that called meriology and i can understand that you kind of want to say there's no correct answer to, well, what actually is the cup.
45:38But I think people will still want to say, okay, I'm not going to be a reductionist about the cup. I'm not going to say that what the cup is, is actually the atoms that make it up. That's not true. But let's abandon for a minute the concept of cup. And let's just actually try to sort of dig down to the foundations of reality, whatever's there. And we get these theories, we get like quantum field theory, we get this big sort of wave distribution or whatever. When I ask, like, is there an it? Is there a there? There? Is there an ontology? I don't mean to, like, everyday objects like the cup or the book.
46:12I mean, like, to the quantum objects that make up the smallest elements of our universe. Like, is there such thing as an electron, as a photon, as a gluon? Or is there only, like, how the electron behaves? You know what I mean? Like, is there an ontology to these small, tiny, fundamental elements of reality? Or is it just relational in the sense that there is only the behaviors of these particles and not the ontology itself? Do you think, is there such a thing as ontology of a chair, or is there only the way it behaves and affects us? I don't want you to answer that, because you know humor, you know various.
47:02I want to tell me what is the difference between this question asked for a chair and this question asked for an electron. I never understood the difference. I suppose, so for what it's worth, I think I'm on your side here. Yeah. But I think if someone who's listening who would want to say, well, the difference for me is that, okay, here's the difference, is that, well, I can fully describe the chair. No, you cannot. In terms of, well, this is what they'll say. They'll say, I can fully describe the chair in terms of like, essentially the atoms that make it up. That is like, if I know the position of all the atoms, then I kind of know the position of the chair, for example, right?
47:43And in a way that doesn't go the other way. Like if I can know that the chair's there, but I can't know what all of its atoms are doing. But if I know what all of its atoms are doing, I know what the chair is.
47:51Carlo Rovelli: Yeah, this is what you said at the beginning. You introduced by saying this is a sort of fundamental basic. well I would respond to that by saying that this idea that the physical level it's a fundamental level on which everything else sort of supervenes to use this technical word
48:16how should I put it it's not actually wrong, but it's a silly thing to say. In the following sense, that's my preferred way of putting it. Suppose you and I want to learn
48:36Carlo Rovelli: playing chess. Now, chess is based on some basic rules. The king moves one step, the queen wears steps, and so on. Once you have these rules all possible chess games are fixed all possible probabilities of which move is better which move is worse are fixed there's nothing else to say about chess okay so why there are books and books about chess everything is in the rules there's nothing else relevant about chess than that well that's obviously a stupid thing to say right because to uh i could learn very well the basic rules of chess i can be capable of telling them i mean a seven years old kid can do that and yet be a very bad chess player and actually know nothing about chess why because the relevant the interesting part of chess playing is not knowing the basic rules, is out of the astonishing large number of possible chess games to have tools for concepts, for seeing that, you know, when you do the openings, it's better to conquer the center.
50:04Chess playing is knowing what to do in the extraordinary variety of... So, knowing the fundamental physical aspect of reality has nothing to do with knowing reality. I think this is a profound mistake in which our culture has fell. this is another
50:41preferred example I have I am really convinced that my bicycle respect very very carefully the equation of the standard model of particle physics it's made by quarks electrons maybe some photons jumping around nothing else and it moves according to the Dirac equation and the Gage Young Mills Electroweak equation. I can write down. Yeah. Okay. And the best people who know how to work with this equation are in Genève at CERN using them. Okay. Now, I'm very convinced that my bicycle respects all of them. So, therefore, if my bicycle breaks, it doesn't work,
51:31Carlo Rovelli: I should go to Genève go to particle physics physicists and say could we fix my bicycle? Well I'm an idiot if I do that obviously. This particle physicist could be a genius, a Nobel Prize winner, has no idea how to fix my bicycle. While my mechanics downstairs from where I live knows how to fix bicycles. So who has access to reality? My mechanics or the particle physicist? Who really knows reality. Or my mechanics, as far as bicycle is concerned. Irrespectively of everything I said about the bicycle respect in the standard model. So from this perspective, I think the way I put it in the book is that physics, it's badly overrated.
52:23Carlo Rovelli: There's this idea, oh, we figure out the fundamental equation of the universe, we figure out the universe. That's bullshit. We haven't figured out anything. It's like, oh, if I learn the basic rule of chess, I figure out playing chess. No, you haven't at all. The interesting part is not the physical aspect of what a single electron and a single quark do when they interact. It's how the hell, out of the astonishing large possibility of the combination of these things working together, which are infinitely out of control for our mind, we can found ways of understanding reality, patterns for understanding reality.
53:05And I'm not talking about anything strange. I mean the pedals of the bicycle, the chain of the bicycle, the fact that you need oil here, it's breaking because it's not enough oil, so I add oil, it doesn't do that anymore. These are the proper concepts to talk about bicycle. And knowledge of reality is the one by mechanics has, also the one by physicists. But the idea that the particle is exhausted or underpinned at the ground is a badly overstating. That was the meaning of my example with a cup of water. We shouldn't think that one is more fundamental than the other. Now, or better, the different notion of fundamentality, of importance.
53:51If I'm thirsty, I don't care about the protons in the water. I just want water. and maybe what I care is the chemist that there's no bad stuff that is affecting my health. That's fundamental, right? If I want to know the physics of the water, I study the physics of the water. But that's one perspective, not the one on which everything else rely. Not the perspective. Not the perspective. From the studio that brought you WandaVision. I was an Avenger, but I'm not a hero anymore. The Vision returns for the final chapter of the groundbreaking trilogy. That family wasn't real. You sure about that? I had a father called Vision.
54:33How is this possible? Don't miss the two-episode premiere of Marvel Television's Vision Quest. Nothing bonds a family together quite like Mortal Jeopardy. Now streaming on Disney+.
54:53pickup game swish to athletic stuff like a half mile stroll get those steps in and for morning hikes up the mountain trail good pace it's a nighttime ghost choice from the camping chair what a twist whatever level of active sierra loves it all head to sierra or sierra.com for the brands you want at the prices that let you do it all from athletic to athletic sierra's got it Yeah.
55:19Carlo Rovelli: Do you think it's… That's contrary to what several of my colleagues in trying to publicize our discipline have been saying. Yeah. Stephen Hawking, I'm reading the mind of God. Because it's nice, but if it is taken too literally, it's wrong. Yeah. Do you think that there's a…
55:44I've sometimes thought about this where, I mean, I spend a lot of time talking about the philosophy of mind and consciousness. And one of the big debates, because there are lots of people who think that consciousness is foundational and the whole universe is conscious and all this stuff. And one of the big debates is essentially, well, should we think of it as like loads of really tiny little conscious particles, panpsychism, which gets a footnote in your book, or should we think of it as like one great big mind, idealism, and everything, which is a big part of mind. which exists as a kind of decoherent of that great big mind.
56:14And when I'm talking to people about that, I sort of say, like, if I ask you to sort of tell me, yeah, like what the cup is, what the book is, I think there's this bias to try to explain it by going smaller. And it suddenly struck me that like, that seems to be like a kind of an assumption that we make, whereas, as I've sometimes put it, there's no obvious reason why we should account for the cake in terms of the crumbs rather than the crumbs in terms of the cake right and depending on the context i think either of those can be perfectly legitimate right and so in the context of consciousness i might say that like well maybe the best way of thinking about it is is zoom out and the ground is not beneath you the ground is above you you know it sort of depends on on what you're trying to do um i mean usually in that context i think there is a correct answer to that question but then i suppose the idea we're talking about is that there's there's just not it's all contextual
57:09Carlo Rovelli: I agree with you historically it turns out that a lot of things we understand better by looking at the components it's a fact and so there's nothing wrong in looking at components of things, even my bicycle when the mechanics says what's wrong he looks one piece by piece and thinks the bicycle is a collection of pieces interacting that's very good but he knows where to stop it doesn't go too much down and the fact that it works this strategy works very well in many phenomena if you want to understand how the sun works we do look at the neutrons and protons in the hydrogen and look at that process and that tells us something crucial for why the sun is hot but the fact that this strategy works well in so many cases does not mean at all that is the single unique strategy for making sense of reality.
58:14Carlo Rovelli: Because so often, even in science, concrete, even in physics, it works the other way around. For instance, a lot of phenomena in condensed matter, so what happened with a lot of molecules acting together, like phase transition. Why water becomes ice? You cool down water, it suddenly becomes ice, okay? So it looks completely different. It's the same stuff, the same molecules. So this is something we understand very well. There's a lot of theory about that. And what characterizes this theory is that it's completely blind to what the actual constituents are. So all the physical theory, mathematical theory, or phase transition, passage from water to ice, and similar phenomena, it's the same equation, same understanding, the same concepts which work for water and for completely different other stuff in which the individual ingredients are irrelevant.
59:18Carlo Rovelli: Okay. So there, obviously, sort of reductionism is just not useful. Yeah. It's not that reductionism is metaphysically right, metaphysically wrong. It's just wrong. The useless way of thinking about that. And what you said, I mean, I don't believe for a moment that consciousness should be foundational in any sense in the universe, but what you said about trying to think of consciousness as little consciousness atoms makes perfectly sense. I mean, why do we want to use this reductionist attitude. Now, careful, I'm not saying, so take me correctly, I'm not saying that it's false to think that everything happening in the universe is in fact nothing else that quarks and protons and electrons and fields.
1:00:13Of course it is. I mean, why should not, including a consciousness. I think consciousness is nothing else than behavior of many small things interacting. But after having said that, we haven't understood a clue about consciousness. If you want to understand something more, it's like a bicycle. If you want to understand something more, we better use different kinds of notions.
1:00:39One key idea for me is that the history of science in the last centuries, I think the main message that it's given us is that apparently totally different descriptions of phenomena are coherent. They're not incoherent. They're compatible. Even if one works in one case, one works in another case. Every time we can get some of the lab, they actually say the same thing. This has happened spectacularly between physics and chemistry. Chemistry and physics seem to have a completely different account of reality. Chemistry is just the universe is made by a hundred elementary substances and their combinations.
1:01:28And then out of that you do marvels at all things that chemistry does. And there are chemical bonds, chemical interactions, all that. And the physicists have, you know, equation of motion, Newton,
1:01:42Carlo Rovelli: electric, then quantum thing. They seem to be totally unrelated description of the world. Then bingo! You write the Schrodinger equation for the atom, and you get all the elements as a solution. And you do a simple quantum calculation, and you see what is a chemical bond in physical terms. So finally you understand, well, we're talking about the same thing, just different language, different concepts. And nevertheless, if you want to describe a organic chemistry thing that can happen in laboratory easily in physical terms you're an idiot because it's too complicated nobody would even dream of doing that so we haven't reduced chemistry to physics chemistry keeps its entire autonomy as a good way of thinking about reality we have just shown that the two are perfectly compatible and when we can use both they say the same thing yeah so okay so i understand that um i think i was thinking about i i would i would think that you know it's the same when we talk about our mind yeah our consciousness consciousness i think is a modern way for soul yeah right yeah yeah yeah i can i can understand that i think we're just using a different language for describing what happened to to us what we do and of course we have it's not like chemistry physics we have difficulty of joining the pieces there's a lot work to do i hope it will be done but there's nothing mysterious i think there i was asked i was thinking about the question you asked about like you know when i when i sort of want to know what what an electron is or something and you say well what's what's the difference between the question of what it is versus what it does and the question of the chair and i think i understand that practically speaking there's there's no there's no correct answer as to like what level to think of the chair as like its real sort of basis but if i had to try to really pin down a difference not to belabor this point but if i really had to pin this down i would say okay so even if me breaking down the chair into its constituent parts doesn't objectively give me a better grasp of the chair doesn't give me any more objective access to reality or anything like that nonetheless it is true that i can break it down in smaller parts and i can break those parts into smaller parts and smaller parts and once i get down to what physicists tell me are fundamental particles like an electron um i'm told that okay maybe i have no better grasp on reality maybe this isn't more objective any sense in any sense but there is a difference in that i can no longer break it down like there's there's no there's no smaller part.
1:04:19And so it seems to me that like, when I get there, I kind of want to ask if I just do want to know, not because I think it's giving me a better access to reality, but I'm just intrigued. Like, oh, so what is an electron? Like, what's it kind of made out of? What's the substance of it? Unlike anything which is bigger, you sort of, you no longer have this recourse. Any other thing in the universe, you can at least, if you feel like it, say, oh, well, interestingly, it's made up of these smaller parts but not with an electron right so it makes me want to say like so have we have we like hit a hit a ground here is there like a and is that ground the it uh good so it seemed historically that this path you're describing would lead us to this sort of solid ground yeah okay then came quantum mechanics.
1:05:12Yeah. Quantum mechanics. And quantum mechanics developed precisely, trying to figure out precisely what is the nature and the behavior of the smallest thing people were doing, accessing in the 20s and 30s, when beginning of last century, which were electrons, atoms, molecules, and these kind of things. Except that these kind of things behaved in a very crazy way. And for several decades, the scientists were horrendously confused because no intuition about little things interacting seemed sufficient to write a theory that would predict simply the color of the object, right? There were all these models.
1:06:02The color of an object, it's the frequency of the light it emits.
1:06:07Carlo Rovelli: The frequency of light essentially is the electron turning around the nucleus at some speed. And that determines the frequency and that determines the color. Now, except that when you look at the colors, there are only certain particular frequencies that you see. That's a spectrum of the, you know, Newton took a prism and decomposed the light. And you see only certain frequencies. Some people say, well, fantastic. Now we're from the spectra, we know at which velocity the electron goes around the atom. So we just have to find a decent force law or whatever that says that those velocities are permitted and not others.
1:06:46Carlo Rovelli: And nobody could do that. It just doesn't work. Doesn't work, doesn't work, doesn't work. So then this incredible complication came out. And this strange magic way of doing quantum mechanical calculations came out. and then it turns out all right you can do that but the electron is nowhere and if it has a position its velocity is completely undetermined it is the velocity's position is completely undetermined so the electron is not a little thing having properties the electron is something that if you interact in one way it behaves in one manner if you interact in a different way as you measure its position you get some information if you get your velocity you get some information, but if you try to put the two together, it doesn't work.
1:07:29Carlo Rovelli: There's nothing that has this position. And then people were horrendously confused. And then Niels Bohr, Heisenberg, the other, under the influence of philosophers. I have a chapter in my book in which I talk about the influence of nobody else, Sir Kierkegaard, on Niels Bohr, started realizing that what the theory is describing is not electron per se. It's electron as it affects something else. And then this beautiful dream of reducing everything for single particles interacting of which we have a clear objective realistic intuition collapsed. It was a beautiful dream that physics in fact
1:08:30nourished for a couple of centuries that we could, you know, go down to elementary constituencies and get a clear understanding of them. But then the elementary constituencies can only be understood how they interact with something else. And so we are in the we don't have this ground that explains the simple realistic story down there that justifies what comes about. And I want to add one thing. Newton has... It's a giant in this story. And Newton notoriously did colossal steps and ended up saying, well, there's a lot which is missing here. and I don't want to speculate about what is missing. I want to just leave it open.
1:09:24And this, it was later presented like, okay, I have the beginning, now you guys complete the story. Which is the opposite of the Newtonian spirit. Because the greatest of Newton
1:09:41Carlo Rovelli: is that he didn't want to complete the story. Every thinker wanted to complete the story. Newton didn't. He said, no, this is not a complete story. That's how science became so powerful, because it renounced a complete story. You see, the standard model of general relativity, which is the best understanding we have, standard model of general relativity, quantum mechanics, the best description we have in the world at the most elementary physical level, it's totally incomplete. Because that's my job, my job description, try to find out a quantum theory of gravity. okay yeah so i do think that is a well-posed problem to try to understand a quantum theory of gravity does this mean complete the story no of course it means understanding something more i'm trying to write quantum theory of gravity that is gonna tell me what are the quantum properties of space and time what happened the center black holes maybe what happened big big bang maybe what happened at the end of the evaporation of black hole maybe explain dark matter so it's real science but do i think that this will give me the final ground from which everything derives no just add one um piece of the puzzle in this infinite puzzle which is a mysterious reality around us yeah man it's just i why do you think people can't shake off the feeling that there is a ground like that there is this this and i i don't think you need to think that there's like a theory of everything.
1:11:14I don't think you need to think that your theoretical description or your quantum gravity will suddenly explain everything and now everything is condensed into this single beautiful equation or something. But that insofar as that's describing something, it's describing something that has a rock bottom. But as you say, we kind of dig down and we actually find that it's this sort of... Yeah, squishy squashes on this. Yeah, exactly. Right. But people even then, I don't know. Do you think that like, i mean i think that the average person is going to struggle to to picture reality as grounded on anything other than like solidity um i don't know physicists are like better at just at just like intuitively accepting in other words what the physics is pointing at which is that we are kind of if i think my friends i don't mean my scientist friends yeah uh the idea that things are made by atoms totally relevant to the worldview yeah something that the fundamental thing is god something that the fundamental thing is history, something that the fundamental thing is culture in which they grew, something that fundamental thing is having good life and everything is to
1:12:20Carlo Rovelli: follow. So people have different worldviews. This physical centrist view of reality, I think, is marginal, it's not central in our overall society. And in philosophy, you know, I've been, I'm a physicist, so I studied science. I was attracted by the incredible power of modern science, which I totally recognize. Nothing of what I say is dismissive of the interest of fundamental physics and science in general. But I also was interested in physics too, because I wanted to know, sort of, how do we understand the universe? What is universe? And I think the key point is more general. Let me put it this way.
1:13:13Enlightenment. It's a major step ahead of humankind. Reason, understanding, superior elders can't put have the courage to learn more and gave this myth mythology that we can sort of have this infinite powerful reason look reality from the outside get it taught the clarity find out what it is and from the studio that brought you WandaVision I was an Avenger but I'm not a hero anymore The Vision returns for the final chapter of the groundbreaking trilogy. That family wasn't real. You sure about that? I had a father called Vision. How is this possible? Why am I losing my heart? Don't miss the two-episode premiere of Marvel Television's Vision Quest.
1:14:08Nothing bonds a family together quite like Mortal Jeopardy. Now streaming on Disney+. From athletic stuff like a full-court pickup game, Swish! To athletic-ish stuff. Like a half-mile stroll. Get those steps in! Head to Sierra or Sierra.com for the brands you want at the prices that let you do it all. From athletic to athletic-ish, Sierra's got it. Have certainty about having understood reality perfectly. Now, a couple of centuries have passed, and with immense wonderful gift that the Lightman gave to humankind, to European and then global civilization, this is a myth. It's completely mythological.
1:14:53Because we never have certainty about everything. Reality is far more complex than what Voltaire, Hume, or characters imagined. And especially, our reason is much more limited
1:15:10Carlo Rovelli: than this incredible mythology about infinite power of reason that was in the ancient century. And our reason is not outside reality. That's a key point. We are pieces of reality. You and I are not pure mind that look reality from the outside. You and I are little creatures which have a brain, a fantastic brain, and we're very proud of it, but it's just very limited compared to the complexity of reality. It's just a piece of reality itself that interacts with the rest, collects information. This information is incredibly minuscule with respect to everything that's going on in the galaxy, not to mention the infinite universe.
1:15:50Carlo Rovelli: And we try to organize it, to navigate it, and that's it. So we're looking at reality from the inside, not from the outside. So we only have a perspective on reality, and we learn in our everyday life, and every one of my friends who are not physicists know that everything you and I say is from our perspective. And people have different perspectives about politics, about what is important, about religion, about ethics, about morality, about what music I like. And all these perspectives interact with one another, and we influence one another. And some is better, some is good, worse. But that's the nature of our knowledge.
1:16:36Carlo Rovelli: It's not the ideal, oh, I get to the bottom of things. women creatures on this round rock spinning and we have little pieces of innovation about reality so there is a sort of excessive
1:16:57Carlo Rovelli: pride in the success of our reason. Science is fantastic, has told us marvelous things but one way I put it in the book is that Kant And loved this slogan, Sapeiraude, have the courage to learn, to know. Fabulous. That's my life. I want to learn more. But I would add also, have the courage to realize that you don't know. Which is what I learned from Newton, from the great Einstein. It goes over and over and over the fact that the universe is a big mystery. We don't understand it. so let's have the courage to not try to say okay now we get the grasp of the foundation of the basis and then I'm far more attracted by philosophers like Nagarjuna in the east of Wittkestan in the west or in China who emphasizes this
1:18:03Carlo Rovelli: let's not ask questions which are far outside it's not just we don't know it's too complicated it's just we don't even know if they have a meaning one thing we should probably just touch on before wrapping up is and i know that you you address this but like doesn't this invite a kind of uh maybe impractical radical skepticism a kind of like i've got my reality and you've got your reality and it's all perspectival and relative so there's no truth of the matter and there's like a lot of people are kind of quite scared of that like the moral implications of that like you know i've got my my view and you've got your view and if i want to do something that you consider evil you know what can you say because that's just your perspective but like that sort of writ large for all of reality that we're we're just sort of these subjective creatures like on a on a political level by which i mean literally like the way people interact with each other that seems like quite sort of scary i think that like if um if someone who didn't have a ton of interest in like physics or philosophy were listening to this conversation you know they might think to themselves gosh these these uh these philosophers and scientists they're trying to drag us into this post-modern reality where there's no truth you know people are scared of that right yeah people are scared about because people confuse different different position and um and so one gets scared if if there were only two alternatives this.
1:19:33One is that there's absolute truth independent which is accessible, the absolute truth with capital T. There's absolute good, there's absolute morality, this is good, that's bad. Or alternatively, all perspectives are the same, all opinions are the same, all moral positions are the same, nothing makes one better than the other one. Now, both these extreme positions, in my opinions, are not wise at all. And both are damaging for even politically, even morally for us. I think they're morally wrong. They're both morally wrong. And now you're saying why relativism and perspectivalists don't kill morality, don't kill the idea that why don't they allow us to say anything we want and everything is the same.
1:20:32Well, precisely because realizing that things are relational means that if… Let me focus on morality. I have a long chapter of morality in the book
1:20:46Carlo Rovelli: because this book developed from time spent in the philosophy department in America where some philosophers were arguing precisely this we need absolute notion of good to ground morality. Now for me to a European this is nonsense because morality is strong, ethical values are strong not because they're outside us but precisely because they're inside us is what we are. So we as humans developed through a process which is biological and then cultural and then historical. And we built our society, we came to live together by being moral beings. We are moral beings, moral things. And precisely because this moral truth is part of us.
1:21:43Carlo Rovelli: In fact, when we decide what to do, our deliberation process goes through a complicated thing in our brain, which appeals of what our values appeal our emotions, our desire, our need our values, our belief, all this complexity so this is real because it's inside us and it's not by realizing that others have different versions of the same that take away the value of what we are not at all I mean, if I see that, you know, in the next country somebody's torturing children, nothing about me says, okay, he has a different morality, so it's fine. Because I judge with my morality, with his morality. So I feel strongly, oh, I have to do something.
1:22:38Carlo Rovelli: Can I do something? Okay. So I'm, because, so. Yeah, so if somebody, you know, if somebody shoves you, you could be like, well, I recognize that all motion is relative. Exactly. From my perspective, I'm definitely moving right now. Exactly. Or going back to relativity, somebody says, oh, come on. If velocity is relative, then the moon doesn't have a velocity per se. It's all relative. It can go wherever it wants. No, the moon cannot go wherever it wants. Yeah, right, right, right. Exactly. The moon moves in a very unique way. It's relative, but it's not arbitrary. It's relative, but it's not arbitrary.
1:23:16And so morality is relative, but it's not arbitrary. It's not arbitrary at all. And there's this beautiful, beautiful literature on that. If you read the Tostoyevsky crime and punishment,
1:23:31Rakolnikov, the main character, falls in this trap at the beginning of saying, oh, morality is arbitrary. I don't need to obey to my own morality because if I think I can do, I can kill the little old lady because I do it for the good of humankind. And then, so he commits a crime and then he just cannot escape his own morality. This is a beautiful novel, among other things, about the immense power of morality
1:24:04Carlo Rovelli: that if a little piece of your brain uses reasons, try to deny it, there's an entire being that rebels at it. Sometimes people say that the difference between the moral law and scientific laws. I think C.S. Lewis writes about this. The difference with the moral law is that you can disobey the moral law. You can't disobey the law of physics, but you can disobey the moral law. That's what makes it. I'm like, well, actually, you can disobey the law of physics. You'll just find that the laws of physics win. I can disobey gravity by jumping off a building, but it's still going to pull me down. You can disobey the moral or that you might find, like gravity pulling you strongly to the ground, that you're actually still bound by it.
1:24:48Exactly. And if you accept that there's this level of dependence of morality on where you are, also your culture, then you're wiser in relation to others, right? Because you understand the other better. Which doesn't mean you have to agree on them, but first of all, you can learn from others because morality keeps evolving, right? The moral values in this country today are different than the moral value of this country a few generations ago. Not long ago, people were put in jail by being homosexual, and not so many generations ago. This has changed.
1:25:26Carlo Rovelli: Why has it changed? Well, because morality changes. And that's good that it changes. How it changes? It changes through the dialogue, reflection, realizing that things can, like everything, like our knowledge, like what we believe to be true it changes because we learn we it doesn't mean that it's arbitrary not at all it's complex yeah and i think even politically we if we got out of this idea you know that we are the one who says the truth the other are the ones who say fake news we are the one who are the good ones the other are the ones bad ones and we if we learned to not give up our values but recognize the difference in values and in worldviews of others and engage in those I think we could avoid a lot of conflict.
1:26:24So I think relative is extreme relative is stupid. Saying everything is the same is stupid because as we said, that's confusing relative with arbitrariness. There's nothing arbitrary in the way things move. There's nothing arbitrary in morality. There's nothing. But the fact that nothing arbitrary doesn't mean that there's a unique truth, a unique philosophy, a unique good. It's complex. It's almost like you need a middle way. You need a middle way, exactly, which is the slogan of Nagarjuna philosophy. You need the middle way and learn that the world is complex and navigate it. Yeah. I just spoke to Jan Westerhoff, who was sat in the same chair as you, about Medyamaka Buddhism and Nagarjuna.
1:27:20We have a whole episode that just went out that I'll link at the end of this episode for people to go and watch because it's sort of an ancient, I think, approximation of the same thing we're talking about now. You told me just before we started recording that in the years that you've been talking about this, people kept sort of saying to you. Have you ever looked at Nagarjuna? People were saying that to you a lot. I don't know what it is that you finally did, but from what I grasped earlier, do you think they might have been right that you were driving at the same thing? Yes, actually. Every time I was talking about quantum mechanics in relation to potential quantum mechanics, understanding the world in relational terms and especially renouncing the idea of the ultimate final description of the world.
1:28:09People were coming to me and saying, have you read Nagarjuna? And finally, I did read Nagarjuna at some point. One summer I said, okay, now I'm going to it. I read it through a beautiful translation and work by Garfield, Ian Garfield. It's an analytical philosopher. Nagarjuna is hard to read directly, so you want to read the text, but be helpful. And also can be interpreted in all sorts of different ways. And I was shocked. Nagarjuna is a men's thinker. I think it's in India, the analog of Aristotle or Plato in the West.
1:28:51Carlo Rovelli: We in the West still haven't fully realized how rich is the philosophical tradition, especially of China and India. They're both a wide variety of thinkers, of schools, of ideas different from one another. So the most stupid idea is that the West think this, the East think that. No, not true. I mean, the West think all sorts of things, East think all sorts of things. So, and Nagarjuna, when I read his book, his main book, it was a shock. It was a shock because it's incredibly liberating, sort of like reading Wittgenstein, because he shows that a fully relational and anti-foundational view is possible.
1:29:48Carlo Rovelli: And one way of putting his philosophy, I mean, his philosophy is complicated, so I'm oversimplifying a little bit. But one of the things he says is that we can think there is an apparent reality, and then we can understand it better, and then there's ultimate reality. And a lot of philosophies are in these terms, right? This is an apparent world, but it's a real world. Yeah, like the phenomena and the noumena. The phenomena and the noumena. The appearance and the thing. The appearance and the things and so on. And then he argues towards the book and get to the point in which he says the nature of the ultimate reality is there's no ultimate reality.
1:30:28Forget about that. You don't need it. From the studio that brought you WandaVision. I was an Avenger, but I'm not a hero anymore. The Vision returns for the final chapter of the groundbreaking trilogy. That family wasn't real. You sure about that? I had a father called Vision. How is this possible? Why am I losing? Don't miss the two-episode premiere of Marvel Television's Vision Quest. Nothing bonds a family together quite like Mortal Jeopardy. Now streaming on Disney+. Sierra has all the best active and outdoor brands for the super athletic stuff. Like running gear for cruising up the trail.
1:31:08Woo! And the super athletic-ish stuff. Like fishing gear for chilling by the creek. Nice cast. Fitness apparel to push for higher reps? You got this! And golf balls priced so you can afford to lose one? Or a few. Head to Sierra or Sierra.com for the brands you want at the prices that let you do it all. From athletic to athletic-ish, Sierra's got it. Apparent reality. It's reality. Yeah. That is what it is. And remarkably, he goes through, the book is a set of chapters.
1:31:44Carlo Rovelli: Each one takes something that sounds very fundamental and shows that it doesn't make sense by itself. It says it's empty. Empty is a technical term for being, not that it doesn't exist, but it doesn't exist by itself. Sunyata. Exactly. And the perceptive listener will notice at the beginning of this conversation, when we were talking about like the chair or something you were saying like asking this particular question is empty use the word empty exactly exactly but when so he just destroys all the possible fundamental thing as being fundamental and showing that everything depends on something but what is really the moment in which i just have got there and this sort of started jumping jumping up and down in my room in my office and screaming, is the chapter toward the end in which he sort of says, I'm really rephrasing modern terms, not how you put it, he says, okay, so everything is empty in that sense.
1:32:52Carlo Rovelli: So have you got it? The fundamental thing is emptiness. And then he answered, no, emptiness is empty. I mean, the views are empty. My view is empty. And then really you say, oh yes, I get it. So it's a fundamentality is the wrong question to answer. Which doesn't mean that the conventional knowledge of reality is meaningless. Science is good. Our knowledge is good. Our philosophy is good. Our information about the world is good. It's not denying that. It's not saying, oh no, there's no world. there is no knowledge, there is no... He's taking away this anxiety of the underpinning fundamental structure.
1:33:43Carlo Rovelli: And that's a step ahead in my opinion for all of us. And it also has a sort of a scatological, ethical side. Yeah, because of course for Nagarjuna this has implications for what we call the self. Like you as a person... The self is empty. ...are empty as well. I mean, Do you agree with Nagarjuna on that? Totally. I mean, this is most clarifying. And, you know, Ernst Mach, the West, the self doesn't exist. It's the same. So, this idea of the self, it's not that it doesn't exist. I exist. It exists, but it's empty. It's empty, yeah. So, it exists in relation to something else. It exists like the bicycle exists.
1:34:27Carlo Rovelli: It's like the bicycle. It's a combination of other things. In fact, it's funny, you talk about the bicycle. There's a, there's a very famous like Buddhist story of the chariot. The chariot. It's the same thing, right? It's like, you know, I can't remember the people involved, but you know, there's a king of the wise men. King Melinda. Melinda. The sage comes over and sort of says like, oh, you have a chariot, do you, your majesty? Like where, where is the chariot? Where is the chariot? Is the wheel the chariot? Is the axle the chariot? And the king keeps saying, no, no, no, no, no. And so where is it then?
1:34:57There's nothing more than this sort of construct. And this is sort of a discourse on the nature of the self. One thing I found really interesting. Do you know that that conversation, I learned it recently, it's in this set of conversation
1:35:17Carlo Rovelli: a tribute to this king. But this king is probably a Greek king during the Greek expansion to India. and this part of the conversations between indian philosophers and greek philosophers millennia and a half ago that would make sense wouldn't it because it's sort of a clash of intuitions and and and the reason why it's a useful story is it's it's not like a philosophical argument made from first principles it's it's almost socratic in its approach of like okay oh so there's so where is it then yeah yeah why don't you why don't you tell me based on your worldview where this chariot is and yet clearly the chariot is there but you can't tell me like where it is it's kind of empty it's there's not to say it's not real it's there you can touch it you can you can take a ride in it but it's but it's empty and the self is maybe the same i found it so i i can't believe i never knew this until relatively recently but a lot of the sort of important founders of quantum mechanics were quite besotted with indian oh yeah schrodinger schrodinger loved the abanash ads yeah yeah absolutely and um yeah there are a few other important figures.
1:36:24I don't want to throw out names in case I mix up my founders of quantum mechanics, but a lot of them, you can read these reports, and a lot of them have written philosophical works as well. You've read these reports of them sort of discovering the Vedantic tradition and the Upanishads and reading it and being like, oh, okay, maybe quantum mechanics isn't so insane. I can't remember who it was. I wish I could remember who it was in particular that started of reading like ancient indian philosophy and writes that they suddenly were like oh okay maybe this quantum mechanics stuff like actually isn't crazy shooting but i mean it sounds like schrodinger
1:36:59Carlo Rovelli: but schrodinger was uh was knew about indian sort of hindu world uh vedanta he he read the the Pyreyshans. And when he made this step of saying, okay, forget the electron, introduced the wave function, because he's the one who invented the wave function.
1:37:25Carlo Rovelli: Now we have been hearing about the wave function for a century, so now it's becoming. But at the time, if you think, to replace the idea that there are particles, there are atoms, there are molecules, there are electrons. There was so heavy evidence for these things. And to say, oh, no, no, it's just wavy things in the universe. It sounded like the crazy hippie, you know, new age stuff. And boy, it worked. It worked in a spectacular way. So clearly this reading had a liberating effect on Schrodinger. Schrodinger was a very, very free-thinking person on all sides. And, you know, this is important because a lot of science is influenced by philosophy.
1:38:14Carlo Rovelli: The influence of philosophy on science is colossal. And vice versa. I mean, all good philosophers, Kant to some extent is a reaction to Newton. Young Kant was trying to do is make sense of Newtonian mechanics, which at the time didn't make sense much. What is this space? This is time. What are these things? And then a century later, Einstein read the three criticisms by Kant when he was 15. So, you see, there's this great philosopher which react to science and this great scientist that react to philosophy and produce good science and good philosophy without mixing the two. I mean, there's two different ways of thinking.
1:39:01Carlo Rovelli: but they're a philosopher in my opinion a philosopher that doesn't there are many today that doesn't listen to science it's just you know like after the Copernico revolution a philosopher still thinks that the earth is the central universe stupid we've learned something else you have to keep into account in your world view and vice versa scientists that don't I mean you can be a great scientist and ignore philosophers completely. Because you do a technical work, something, that's okay. But in major idea of science growing, so often in history it has been the philosophers who have opened the mind of scientists.
1:39:50And in the book
1:39:51Carlo Rovelli: I talk about the influence of Kierkegaard on Niels Bohr. I didn't discovered that. It's a philosopher in Princeton, Hans Halvorsen, who's written a paper on that. And when I read the paper, I said, no, come on, this makes no sense. Soren Kierkegaard, I know about Kierkegaard. It's all about religion, he's tormented the soul and how to live. It's all about ethics and religion and stuff. It has nothing to do with science. But then I talked with Halvorsen and said, read these pages and these pages. And it's completely obvious. Niels Bohr was Danish by Kierkegaard and certainly knew Kierkegaard because Kierkegaard was the only major philosopher in Denmark and was part of the culture at the time so it's obvious how when Niels Bohr confronted with this unsolvable problem about the atoms for years and years and years and decades at some point sees the kind of subjectivity that What Kierkegaard brings in, contrary to Hegelian objectivity, the reality, the story, Kierkegaard is saying what counts is the view from within, not the view from without.
1:41:17And Diels Bohr picks this idea and says, actually, here I understand atoms.
1:41:23Carlo Rovelli: What counts is the view from me next to it, not outside. I have to keep myself in the picture to understand it. I've kept observing the picture, and then it makes sense. Yeah, there is no outside. There is no view from nowhere. There's no view from nowhere. There's no third person. There's only you and me. Exactly. The third person picture of the world is an approximation. Yeah. That's the point. It's not that the third person picture of the world is bad. It's just an approximation. It always misses something. Yeah. It misses where you are, who you're talking, where you're talking from. And I think this is a major is, it should be, but also is, a major theme of contemporary philosophy.
1:42:08Carlo Rovelli: You find it in feminist philosophy. You find it in here and there. So we are part of the story when we are talking. So we cannot talk from nowhere. Yeah. You're not the narrator. You're one of the characters. You are one of the characters. Exactly. You're always one of the Carvitas. Exactly. When you say, the glass is on the table, what you really mean, you don't have to say it explicitly, but the only decent interpretation is, I know that the glass is on the table. Otherwise, what you're talking about? I think that's right. And it's funny how so many of these quantum physicists start reading Indian philosophy and start going, aha.
1:42:53Whereas for me, it was almost the other way around. It's like, I started getting convinced of these sort of weird views about the nature of reality through philosophy and philosophy of mind and self and stuff. And then the more and more I speak to scientists, especially about quantum physics, but especially talking to someone like yourself and reading your book i'm i have the reverse effect where i'm sort of like you know it's quite fun and the most amazing thing i think you talk about like small things this book is like what 180 pages or something like that and you've managed to kind of condense all like we've only scratched the surface right because you've also you also talk about the nature of space and the nature of time and i honestly kind of don't know how you did it but this book is like quite short so like i just wanted to let the the listener or the or the viewer know that like we've been talking about and you keep saying like yeah i talk about this in the book they probably got this idea that there's this like thousand page tone but it's actually a very accessible very small book that you could probably read in in one or a couple of sittings um so i'll make sure it's it's linked in the description on the reality i'm sorry on the equality of all things which is also just like quite beautiful in hardback i'm i'm always very impressed with how these come out so i'll make sure that's linked in the description there's so much more to say there always is um but you know it's it's it's always better to have too many things to say than than too few so thanks for taking the time to begin scratch the surface it's been fun thank you for this great conversation
1:44:15Carlo Rovelli: we really enjoyed it thank you coca-cola for the big for the small the short and the tall peacemakers risk takers for the optimists pessimists for long distance love For introverts and extroverts. The thinkers and the doers. For old friends and new. Coca-Cola. For everyone. Pick up some Coca-Cola at a store near you. Mr. Monopoly here. Miss me? Monopoly is back at McDonald's with millions of prizes. A 2027 cheap charity. A Carnival Cruise vacation. Gift cards from DoorDash and Best Buy. He'll then play in the McDonald's app. Get your bag. No purchase necessary. 50 U.S. and D.C. age 18 plus. See play at mcd.com for rules and play at mcd.com slash A-M-O-E for info on playing without purchase by mail by November 2nd.
1:45:12Chance card game ends November 8th. Game ends November 22nd, 2026. See rules for prize details. Monopoly is a registered trademark of Hasbro. Good match, Alex.
Get all sides of every story and be better informed at https://ground.news/AlexOC - subscribe for 40% off unlimited access.Come to my North American tour this November: https://www.alexoconnor.com/p/tour.For early, ad-free access to videos, and to support the channel, subscribe to my Substack.Carlo Rovelli, an Italian theoretical physicist, is known mainly for his contributions to research in the field of quantum gravity. He is a found of loop quantum gravity, and writes extensively on the physics and philosophy of time, quantum mechanics, and ultimate reality.Get On the Equality of All Things: Lessons on Physics and Philosophy. Timestamps:0:00 - Tour0:28 - The Ongoing Revolution in Science3:59 - Interpreting the Quantum World17:22 - Can a Person Be in Superposition?27:23 - Everything is Relative32:01 - The Relational Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics42:27 - Are Quantum Objects Actually There?51:53 - Is There a Smallness Bias?01:07:15 - Is Reality Grounded?01:13:44 - Does Relativism Kill Morality?01:22:42 - Buddhism and Quantum MechanicsConnect:My Website: https://www.alexoconnor.comTwitter: http://www.twitter.com/cosmicskepticFacebook: http://www.facebook.com/cosmicskepticInstagram: http://www.instagram.com/cosmicskepticTikTok: @CosmicSkepticThe Within Reason Podcast: https://open.spotify.com/show/16wUbvDT95dxzpG2KEhakK?si=3196e07690bb489dBusiness email: [email protected] enquiries: [email protected]