

The Netflix documentary series Trainwreck, Episode “Trainwreck | Part 1,” focusing on two calamities: Mayor of Mayhem (Toronto’s Rob Ford scandal) and Poop Cruise (the 2013 Carnival Triumph disaster).
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Discussion on the nature of chaos explored in Netflix's 'Trainwreck' series.
“Like when a disabled cruise ship was set adrift for days with no power and overflowing toilets.”
Interview with Cheyenne Brown about the film focusing on Rob Ford's rise.
“I think Rob really kind of rose through the ranks as sort of an ordinary person who happened to be in politics.”
Exploration of Rob Ford's persona and the initial public perception of him.
“And so there's a scene within the film where I wanted to look at the different faces of Toronto at his launch night.”
Discussion on Rob Ford's denial of substance abuse allegations and its implications.
“That's the impression that I got whilst I was making the film.”
Analyzing Rob Ford's confrontations with the media and public support dynamics.
“I do not use crack cocaine, nor am I an addict of crack cocaine.”
A detailed look at Rob Ford's scandals and how they affected his political career.
“particularly the Toronto Star, I think as an individual going up against an establishment is quite a brave move.”
Explore the paradox of Rob Ford as a politician and a celebrity amidst scandal.
“But Rob Ford really refused to take that path.”
Discuss how Ford's cancer diagnosis changed public sentiment and legacy discussions.
“How did Rob Ford's public image change after his cancer diagnosis?”
Reflect on how society's understanding of mental health has evolved since Ford's era.
“Also, it's fair to say he did good things for people in the city, but it's also fair to say he was quite divisive.”
Delve into the events and interviews surrounding the infamous Carnival Triumph cruise.
“James, welcome to You Can't Make This Up.”
Investigate the fire incident that led to chaos on the cruise ship and passenger reactions.
“You have like a day on the onshore in Cozumel and you get to go off the boat.”
Explore how the cruise staff attempted to keep morale up during a crisis.
“But yeah, I think generally speaking, she was always trying to put a positive spin on it.”
Discover how Larry's experience on the cruise impacted him and his daughter.
“don't kind of make me feel like, hey, the lifeboats are on their way.”
Hear about Devin's struggle to impress his future in-laws on the cruise.
“You know, it's not the experience that he wanted.”
Learn about the unexpected rescue attempts and the significance of Wi-Fi access.
“Like, I don't really need to know what's going on with your bowels, you know, future mother-in-law.”
Examine the chaotic conditions on the ship as the situation worsened.
“So you never get a situation now in the modern world where you've got 4 ,000 people cut off from any communication.”
Understand how CNN covered the incident and its implications for news media.
“So yeah, it becomes an absolute nightmare, in my opinion.”
Discover the reforms made in the cruise industry in response to the disaster.
“It was the biggest story in America for those days at the time.”
Reflect on how this experience might affect people's decisions about cruising.
“Well, as you said, and as we see, Triumph is now sailing with a new name.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On You Can’t Make This Up, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00Rebecca Lavoie: I'm Rebecca Lavoie, and this is You Can't Make This Up.
0:15Rebecca Lavoie: You Can't Make This Up is the podcast where we uncover the true stories behind your favorite Netflix documentaries and films. On today's episode, we take a closer look at the Netflix documentary series Trainwreck. It's like something that came out of a nightmare movie. The snowball has started to roll, and there's no stopping it. My God, it's chaos. Today, we're talking to directors Cheyenne Brown and James Ross. Sometimes, little things can spin out of control, creating memorable disasters. They can be media storms, schemes gone awry, or business plans gone wrong. Like when a disabled cruise ship was set adrift for days with no power and overflowing toilets.
0:55Rebecca Lavoie: I'm telling you, it got bad fast. I would never expect having to poop in a red bag. Oh no. Oh no. Or when the city of Toronto was stunned when its populist mayor resisted calls for his resignation, even though a video showed him smoking crack with gang members. I do not use crack cocaine, nor am I an addict of crack cocaine. Holy shit. Holy shit. Holy crap. I just cannot believe what the mayor of Toronto just said on live television. Netflix as a train wreck takes viewers inside a series of calamities, some large, some small, and tries to bring reason to chaos. This season covers the scandal surrounding Toronto's Rob Ford in Mayor of Mayhem and embarks on the 2013 sewage-filled voyage in Poop Cruise.
1:41Rebecca Lavoie: We'll hear from the people who lived through each fiasco where anything that could have gone wrong did.
1:58Rebecca Lavoie: A bit later on the show, we'll be talking to Poop Cruise director James Ross. But right now, it's Mayor of Mayhem director Cheyenne Brown. Cheyenne, welcome to You Can Make This Up. Thank you for having me. This film is part of Netflix's Trainwreck series, and it looks at former Toronto mayor Rob Ford. Can you start by telling us who the Fords of Toronto are? So Rob Ford was the son of Doug Ford Sr. And Rob Ford was the mayor of Toronto. So the film is essentially the rise of his popularity to getting elected and what happened in the years following him being elected mayor. It seems like Rob may not have been the Ford sibling with the most political aptitude.
2:42Rebecca Lavoie: Is that right? I mean, I think he had a really interesting take on politics and he saw politics from the research that I've done and watching a lot of interviews with him, he kind of went in a different, less traditional way of being a man of the people rather than being a quote-unquote established politician who went to a certain college or had a certain education. I think Rob really kind of rose through the ranks as sort of an ordinary person who happened to be in politics. Fair to call him a populist, do you think? I think he is divisive. And, you know, a populist is somebody who's able to be divisive and also very popular.
3:23So I guess in that sense, you are able to call him that. But I think Rob Ford is so complex that he's more than just a populist, if you see where I'm coming from.
3:33Rebecca Lavoie: Absolutely. Ford was a center-right politician in a generally more liberal city. So what were the factors that led to his rise in government? Um, his, oh, his rise. So that's a really good question, because I think it can start in so many different places. And where we start with, you know, Rob Ford's popularity beginning in the film is during the garbage strike, which angered millions of people across the city. And so by starting in that particular moment, you understand that this is real issues that real Torontonians are dealing with. And so we really set the scene as, you know, Rob Ford is kind of coming through the realms within this crisis moment in the city.
4:15Rebecca Lavoie: Ford was pretty much written off as a mayoral candidate. So what did the voters see that the pundits missed and what were some of the strategies he used to get elected? So I think some of his strategies was to really dig into different elements of society. It wasn't just one person who was going on or one group of people. it was everyone in the city. And so there's a scene within the film where I wanted to look at the different faces of Toronto at his launch night. And there was so many different types of people from different nationalities, races, ages, genders. And I think that was a really clever tactic that I'm not even sure that he knew he was doing.
4:57But I think just by being this customer service mayor, he was able to be incredibly relatable. And I think people had their own personal stories of Rob Ford helped my cat out of the tree or Rob Ford helped, you know, me sort out my refrigerator. Rob Ford gives his business card out to almost everybody he meets. And he says, if you have any problems, call me. A colleague of mine tells me a story about her dad had a tree in his backyard and the tree was dying. My friend's father called Rob Ford. He came to the house. He looked at the tree and he mediated sort of a solution. So he got things done on the ground.
5:39Being a personable politician was a strategy that I don't know if he necessarily thought was that was going to make him mayor. But I think that's just something that he wanted to do his ward. And then that sort of spread across the city.
5:51Rebecca Lavoie: It's interesting because he was remembered for his scandals, but it sounds like you're describing Ford as someone who truly saw himself as a public servant in a sense. Is that the case? I think so. I think so. And this is very much, you know, I'm talking about when the scandals weren't so much on the front page of the news constantly. Whilst he was a councillor, there was many controversial moments. There were moments where he said things about bike cyclists and swimming with sharks or, you know, there was a comment about AIDS, people of AIDS. And those were moments which were quite big news in Toronto in the local news circuit.
6:28However, I think once he's elected, you're able to really track the scandals and the headlines and the controversy. But in those initial years, it's really this public servant, civil servant. I'm here to serve you. I'm not here as a career politician. That's the impression that I got whilst I was making the film.
6:48Rebecca Lavoie: Did Rob Ford have a reputation for alcohol misuse or substance misuse at this time before he was elected mayor? So before he was elected mayor, Rob Ford would often be seen on Twitter at local sort of off licenses buying like small bottles called Mickey's. And so a lot of people would hear and see Rob around the city and take photographs. That was the early ages of Twitter where it was about locations and where people were. And that's kind of how it operated. Very different to where we are today with X. And so there was an understanding, sort of like a hidden, quite an open secret that he would drink after hours after work.
7:31And then there were rumours that he was drunk and, you know, taking drugs in bars. But it was all kind of rumors circling around City Hall where nothing had ever been, you know, there wasn't any concrete evidence at this time.
7:46Rebecca Lavoie: So it was revealed there was a video of Rob Ford smoking crack cocaine. What was his response to the scandal? So even casting our minds back into the earlier scandals that Rob Ford had even before the video, a sort of playbook that he would make would be deny, deny, deny, get found out and then admits, you know, that you've caught me. And I think this is in the initial stages when the Toronto Star report on the Gawker article. Rob Ford and the Fords, they deny it. I do not use crack cocaine, nor am I an addict of crack cocaine. As for a video, I cannot comment on a video that I have never seen or does not exist.
8:33It is most unfortunate that I have been judged by the media without any evidence. And it takes a while for it all to come out. And it's because you might distrust the media at this point because there's been a lot of coverage of Rob Ford. It's a similar situation of him denying, denying because the Toronto Star didn't have any, didn't have a video. So it couldn't include screen grabs of the video. But it's only later on down the line when the police chief on a separate investigation, they have a raid and they recover a tape. And on that tape is reported.
9:12Rebecca Lavoie: In your film, it shows people being really surprised at the time of his denouncement of the media as untrustworthy. Can you talk a little bit about that? Because some people might not realize that hasn't always been the case. Yeah, I mean, we were getting news in a very different way back then in, you know, 2012, 2013. and so a lot of people who were his supporters just didn't believe it was true and they believed what he was saying, you know. And I think when he was going up against the media, particularly the Toronto Star, I think as an individual going up against an establishment is quite a brave move.
9:48And so I think that got a lot of support and I think that, yeah, he got a lot of support from people in the city who were like, maybe they are lying, Maybe they are going up against him. And so that narrative of other media always telling the truth, you know, you can really see it playing out on a city level. But to make comparisons with today and fake news, it's on such a widespread. But, you know, you've got AI, deep fakes. There's so many different forms of communication now. But back then, it was social media was still quite a new sort of form of communication. him.
10:25Rebecca Lavoie: The conventional wisdom was that he should step aside. So I think a logical question is, why didn't he step aside? I think he didn't step aside because, again, what we were talking about earlier is that he believed he was a civil servant and a public servant. I think he really believed that he was in that position because he was elected there and he was. It's a democracy. He was voted into public office. So he refused to step down because at that point, there wasn't any hard evidence. And I said, Rob, they say they have a video of you smoking crack cocaine. And he told me, don't worry, buddy, there's no video.
11:06And that was not the answer I wanted to hear. Because to me, that suggested that there could have been a video. And he felt that the police chief, Bill Blair at the time, wasn't in support of his mailship.
11:22Rebecca Lavoie: Again, though, the gaffes didn't stop there. Can you talk about some of the subsequent scandals involving Rob Ford? So one of the big scandals that we delve into in the film, there's a moment in which Rob Ford is accused of acting inappropriately with a colleague. and there's a scene within the film where he's asked about it and there's quite a controversial, he says something quite outrageous. You don't have to repeat it. To the media. I won't repeat it. Oh, and the last thing was Olivia Gondek. It says that I wanted to eat her. I've never said that. I'm happily married. I've got more than enough to eat at home.
12:03Thank you very much. And so that was a huge scandal. Everybody thought, you know, journalists and reporters and photographers just couldn't believe that he said what he said. And so that caused another scandal. But then when the video is uncovered, that causes another scandal. And then he's caught in another video with a pipe in his hand. And then that causes another scandal. But then he then goes to rehab after. So there's a quote in the film of a reporter called Dave Ryder who just said, you know, scandal flew off Rob Ford like sweat off a runner. And I think it was just one thing after another, after another, after another.
12:41There's also another scene where he runs over and accidentally pushes over a female counsellor who says she's a bit discombobulated afterwards. So there's a lot that goes into it.
12:53Rebecca Lavoie: That live television moment where he said that thing that I'm not asking you to repeat, did it change the way that reporters covered him going forward? Because we saw the reactions. They didn't know what to do because he was on live TV at the time. I think they reporters just knew he was unpredictable. And I think that was a moment of him being unpredictable. I know we're up live right now, but I don't know if we can. Mayor Ford speaking as Mayor Ford does very plainly. As he said in council yesterday, he effed up. And now using language that I don't think we can broadcast that on TV, but we just broadcast that on TV.
13:34They would be very truthful with this. And I think this is a fair statement to make is they knew there were scandals of him when he was a councillor. And when he was elected, I think there was a understanding that things were going to get a little bit more interesting in Toronto. And I guess they were right.
13:54Rebecca Lavoie: A lot of public figures have a scandal and then step aside, or they have a scandal, they deny it. And then when the second scandal comes out, then they step aside. But Rob Ford really refused to take that path. Was it his refusal that helped drive some of this scandal energy even more than his transgressions? I mean, yeah, that's a really interesting point, because I do think it's, he just didn't give up. He was a fighter. And you see all throughout the archive, you know, when he is pretty much mobbed daily by the media and by reporters, he refuses to give up. And I think that there's an element of, I've been put in this position by the public.
14:35I'm not going to stand down. And I think he was living by a different rule book to a lot of other politicians. And I think it makes you question, what do you expect of your elected officials? Do you hold them into high esteem or do they get away with it? Why do some politicians get away with other scandals and other politicians are, you know, their careers are over? So those were the questions that I had as I was making the film.
15:05Rebecca Lavoie: What do you think of this idea? You know, could Rob Ford have been early proof that a politician can't be shamed out of office if they don't have any shame, if they're shameless? Yeah, I think so. But I think what Rob Ford really represents is this idea of a politician being a celebrity. So if you're seeing your politician as a celebrity, do you see the politician as a politician or is it a celebrity? A politician and a celebrity, they operate on two different rules. celebrities can have scandals and bounce back from it. Politicians in the Rob Ford world now can have scandals and bounce back from it.
15:41But typically, politicians struggle with that bounce back and they find another role, job or go into a different career. But I think Rob was onto something with that celebrity politician because it blurs the line of what you expect.
15:55Rebecca Lavoie: Celebrities will often speak about their demons after they've been in a scandal. Did Ford ever do that? Did he ever open up to the public and talk about what may have driven his behavior? I don't think it opened up to the public, but I think going to rehab sent a message that there was a greater thing happening in his life and he was struggling with that addiction. In so much of sitting down and having an honest conversation, talking about the troubles in his life, I don't think that happened. But in terms of going to rehab and admitting that he's got a problem, that was definitely a part of him, you know, telling everyone that I've messed up and I'm struggling with this thing and I'm going away.
16:38I'm going to get myself sorted. I'm going to get myself cleaned up and, you know, push on forward. But I don't think that conversation ever happened publicly.
16:48Rebecca Lavoie: How did Rob Ford's public image change after his cancer diagnosis? I think people are a lot more sensitive and less tough on him, you know, and I think that is the right approach. You know, this is a man who has just been diagnosed with an aggressive cancer. And it's quite sad because you see his decline in health, you know, in real time. and I think if you have experienced that or seen that personally, I think you have to approach it differently because he was no longer that person sort of fighting the media or the Toronto Star on a public space. He was essentially a man who was sort of dying in front of the eyes of millions and so the media really took a different turn in how they were reporting him and plus he took a step back.
17:37Like his brother went in his place instead to run for a second term.
17:42Rebecca Lavoie: As you show, a lot of the legacy of Rob Ford is wrapped up in late night comedians point of view of him and in jokes that have him as a punchline. But in the end, do you think his story is a comedy or is it more of a tragedy? Oh, it's definitely a tragedy because, you know, one of my contributors, Tom Baer, says this, that he didn't get his final act. His life was cut short, you know, and you question like, what if, you know, what if? he didn't get cancer and he was able to run again, what would have happened to the city? Would it become more divisive? Would there still have been a progressive mayor that was elected again?
18:19But I don't think that there's much that's comedic about it. Because I think with the scandals, it's a man that's struggling with addiction at the heart of it. And it's somebody who's struggling with it on a public platform as a politician. So a lot of people did say it's like a Shakespearean tragedy. and that's really how I see it.
18:41Rebecca Lavoie: At the end of the film, you ask many of the participants what Rob Ford's legacy is and they give widely varying responses. He was dishonest. Selfless. Smart. Outspoken. Unpredictable. Exploitative. You know, all of us have a Rob, you know, somewhere in our life. And I think in the long run, history will think of him as a man who had an illness, who, despite that, accomplished some things that had never been accomplished before. What do you think Rob Ford's legacy is? It's so interesting, isn't it? Because some people said it depends on who you speak to. But I guess my thoughts on Rob and his legacy is that he's a complex man and he's a complex person like all of us.
19:25He can be many things. He's not one-dimensional. He's not just a politician who was controversial. Also, it's fair to say he did good things for people in the city, but it's also fair to say he was quite divisive. He was a family man. He was a good friend to people. You know, he was a father. He was so many different things. And I think that is something that I just learned as politicians, you are an elected official, so you open yourself up to more criticism. But fundamentally, you're a human being. And so just sort of treating people with a different level of, you know, understanding. And something that really was brought to life as I was making this is the conversations around mental health are so different now than they were then.
20:12Would the same thing happen now if we firstly, there wouldn't be somebody selling the video for$100 ,000? It would just be on the Internet straight away. Would we respect his privacy? you know, would we say, okay, there's something deeper going on here. Are we going to put this person on Jimmy Kimmel? Or are we going to tell jokes about somebody who's struggling with addiction? It's just made me think about how much society has evolved, you know, in the last 10 to 15 years.
20:42Rebecca Lavoie: The film is Trainwreck, Mayor of Mayhem. Cheyenne Brown, thank you so much for telling me all about it. Thank you. you.
20:54Rebecca Lavoie: And I'm joined now by director James Ross. James, welcome to You Can't Make This Up. Thank you very much for having me along. So I just asked Cheyenne about her doc, whether it was a comedy or a tragedy. What category would you put poop cruise in? It's probably edging more towards comedy than tragedy. I'm not saying it was a nice experience for anybody on board, but, you know, no one died. They all got home safe. And I think in hindsight now looking at it, you know, through a lens today, it seems like kind of a comedy experience. And the passengers on board certainly kind of reveled in the retelling of the story of what happened.
21:32Rebecca Lavoie: There were thousands of passengers and crew aboard the Carnival Triumph. How did you go about finding and casting people to interview for this? I'd have to put credit to Lucy in Georgia. They were really leading on the casting. And, you know, there's tons and tons of hours of YouTube footage of this up on YouTube. And that was a kind of way of starting who had good footage. But really what we were looking for was bright, articulate people, but especially people who had kind of more invested on this cruise than your average holidaymaker, vacationer. So this cruise really meant a lot. So when it goes wrong, you know, the stakes are even higher.
22:11So, yeah, they were characters who kind of really stood out for us and, you know, told the story brilliantly. And it was a pleasure interviewing them. You know, we really had fun doing those chats.
22:21Rebecca Lavoie: Can you talk about all that video from aboard the ship? Because I'm assuming there was also video that wasn't just of toilets, right? How much was there? I mean, there's tons. There's tons and tons and tons. You know, people go on holiday and they they they take video and they take photos. And half the footage is like everyone having a great time. You know, they're doing shots at the bar and they're dancing to Pitbull. And, you know, everybody's like on this wonderful vacation, having a great time. And then I think what was really interesting in kind of telling the story is how incrementally things change.
22:51You know, at first it goes wrong and are we OK? And then it gets worse and it gets worse and it gets worse and it gets worse. And as we kind of go through that footage, you'd be in the edit and all of a sudden, you know, we'd get another load of few hours of material come through. And then you'd be like, oh, is this going to be the good stuff or is this going to be the bad stuff? And you'd look at it like, oh, my God, what the hell? You can't unsee it, right? You never quite knew what you were going to get. Yeah. Really, yeah.
23:18Rebecca Lavoie: So can you remind me, what was the original itinerary for this cruise in February of 2013? I think it was supposed to be a four or five day cruise, you know, nice vacation, set sail out of Galveston. It was kind of February. So, you know, it's a little escape. Everyone goes on board. You go down to Cozumel. You have like a day on the onshore in Cozumel and you get to go off the boat. And then I think it's one day back to Galveston. And up until everything happened with the fire, they were all having a great time. It goes from being this kind of perfect little mini vacation to being the very antithesis of that.
23:54Rebecca Lavoie: So the problem did begin with this fire in the engine room. What do we know about what happened? So what we know, and we know very detailed amounts of what happened because there was a kind of inquest afterwards. So there was a kind of fuel leak. I think there was kind of fuel coming out one of these engines and it landed on like a hot spot and it caught fire and the fire was kind of contained, but it had burnt through these electrical cables, which basically meant that there was no power on board the ship. So the kind of emergency power kicks in, but all the lights have gone, all the air conditioning's gone, you know, the coffee machine doesn't work.
24:33And at first, you know, those are the things you think of. But then somebody realizes that actually all the toilets on a cruise ship require electricity to kind of power the flush. So the toilets aren't working. And I think at first they thought, you know, like the engineering guys, they'll go in, they'll fix this, they'll do something with the wires and, you know, within a few hours we'll be underway again. So the solution to the kind of immediate problem was a short-term solution. It was kind of like, well, what do we do in this kind situation. So Jen, who's the wonderful cruise director, who was kind of right there at the forefront of the decision making process, decided that, you know, we in the shower and poop in red bags.
25:13That's the way to go with this scenario.
25:16Rebecca Lavoie: So how did people respond to that when they first found out that there was this plan to poop in red bags and then just leave them in the hallway? I mean, the most amazing thing is that there's a recording of the announcement being made. So someone's like holding their phone up and they're pointing it at this, you know, speaker because everyone wanted to know what's happening. You know, like their ship had just been on fire. People were panicking. You know, once everything calms down, I think the last thing you're expecting is suddenly this lovely kind of British accent to come on and say. So folks, you do need to do a number one, everybody.
25:52You can do it in the shower. and if you do need to do a number two what we're going to do is we're going to deliver some red bags to all of the bathrooms on board and if you do need to do a number two we ask that you please do it in the red bag and drop it off in the bins in the corridors so i think everybody's just in shock and you can hear people kind of in the background like giggling like it almost sounds like a joke like you want me to what like what on earth is going on like it's just the not the first thing you'd be thinking of that's going to be the most immediate pressing problem. It was.
26:28So I think a lot of people's first reaction was like, no way, no way am I going to poop in a red bag? Like, what are you talking about? Like, this is insane. I'm on vacation here. Like, don't tell me to do that. You'd like to think that people are compliant and, you know, like if someone in authority tells you to do something, no matter how ridiculous it is, you know, we'll go ahead and do it. But the reality is that people do their own thing. You know, they don't want to follow the rules. And I mean, if you were told to poop in a red bag, I think probably most sensible people would be like, no, no, that's not for me.
27:00No, I'm not going to do that, I'm afraid.
27:03Rebecca Lavoie: So one of the voices we hear from is Jen, the cruise director. And it seems like the passengers really responded to her. Everybody said really nice things about her. She had this pleasant voice, even when she was breaking bad news. Was she trying to keep folks in the loop or was she trying to like the keep calm and carry on thing? Is that what she was trying to do? I probably think it's a bit of both. I mean, there's a kind of communication chain as well. Like she's doing what she can on board and making the decisions that, you know, need to be made on board. But there's also, you know, Stephen's the guy with the satellite phone and he's communicating back on land with Carnival head office.
27:40So there's a kind of chain of communication because at some point they're told to do things that the crew on board are like, I don't really think this is a good idea. But hey, head office, they want to, you know, open the bar or whatever it is. So they've got to do it. So I think Jen was in a really, really difficult position. Like she's trying to make the best of a bad situation. You know, she's calling the shots where she can, but she's also having to, you know, take direction from above. But yeah, I think generally speaking, she was always trying to put a positive spin on it. We've had power cuts before and engineers go and do whatever they do to turn it back on.
28:15So I just thought once the engine room cools down, they'll go in, they'll turn everything back on. And then we'll be back to normal in an hour or so. She was trying to be chipper and up. And, you know, there's this announcement she does the second day after the phone. She's like, good morning, everybody. I hope you've had a great night. And I think a lot of people were like, piss off, Jen. Like we're sleeping on deck here. It stinks of urine. And I get why she's trying to like make the best of it and keep people's spirits up. Because, hey, you know, this is this is a cruise and cruises are supposed to be fun.
28:48But I think at some point people were like, can you just like tell me how it is? Like, tell me how bad it is. Tell me the truth here. Because people don't like being not lied to. I think that's a bit strong, but kind of being given a glossed over version of the truth when really, if it's going to be five days before we're home, just tell me that. Right. And I'll deal with it. don't kind of make me feel like, hey, the lifeboats are on their way. And then they don't turn up for another six hours.
29:11Rebecca Lavoie: Yeah. You talk to these people more than a decade after the poop cruise incident. I want to ask about Larry, you know, more than 10 years on, how does he feel about having taken his daughter on this cruise? So you'd think that over 10 years later, a guy like Larry, he's in control of himself. He's a kind of, you know, upstanding Texan guy, that he'd have moved on in his life. But it was incredible how little it took in terms of talking to him for all of those feelings to, like, really come back. Like, he found it a very emotional thing speaking about this. From the start, I had it all planned out for it to be great.
29:50But then it turns so bad that it's like, this is not what I wanted.
29:57that I failed. Don't look at me because then I'll look at you. It was just a bad situation and nothing you could do about it. He loves his daughter very much and I think that was a difficult time for him. And so kind of taking him back to that time and remembering, you know, what it was like for him being on that boat, he was crying quite a lot in that interview, you know, because I think he really loves, you know, Rebecca and he wanted to be the kind of great dad who took her on this thing. And, you know, as he says in the film, this is not what I wanted. You know, it's not the experience that he wanted.
30:30But I think what's kind of true for all of our characters, all of our passengers is that it may not have been what they expected it to be, but actually they all take something kind of very powerful from that experience. You know, like in the end, Larry and Rebecca have this incredible experience that they went through together. The kind of adversity of that actually really bonded them. And they knew that like, daddy and daughter could get through anything together. And that was really beautiful. So I'm sure they wouldn't have wished that to have happened. But once they got put in that situation, they came through it.
31:03You know what I mean? And there was something really beautiful about that, that I was really kind of always keen to tell what people are like under adversity.
31:09Rebecca Lavoie: What about Devin? Because it seems like he was really trying to impress his future father-in-law. And one of the ways that he tried to impress him was by not pooping for three days. Did that work? I don't know if not pooping was how Devin chose to impress him. I think Devin, yeah, certainly went on that cruise. You know, he was about to get married and it's like meet the parents. You know, he wanted to make a good impression. So, I mean, he says, you know, like at one point, I think they found a toilet and they're like, hey, you know, or like, do you need a red bag? Like you want to be the nice guy in the situation, but also TMI.
31:45TMI. Like, I don't really need to know what's going on with your bowels, you know, future mother-in-law. Once I found one toilet that worked, it certainly was a relief and also a little bit awkward with my soon-to-be in-laws. Hey, you probably have to do a number two. I found a working bathroom. Here it is. Hope you're feeling OK. Did you use a red bag yet? It's a really weird conversation to have. I think he just made the decision like, no, I'm going to hold it. But of course, this was the thing, like when it was first announced that, you know, you're going to have to go in a red bag, everybody thought, well, look, OK, we're going to get rescued in a few hours.
32:21So I only need to hold this a few hours.
32:23Rebecca Lavoie: I mean, I don't even have to go. Right. Exactly. Yeah. But then a few hours became a day. And you think, well, maybe I can make a day. And then and then a day became like two days. And then at some point, this kind of ticking time bomb is going to have to go off. And everyone's getting more and more and more desperate on the ship. So that's when, you know, those who decided to hold off from that kind of fateful decision ended up having to face the reality that at some point, you know, everybody's got to go. You're making it worse. Yeah. Nature's going to call and you're going to have to answer, as Kaylin says.
33:01Rebecca Lavoie: At one point, another cruise ship comes alongside, and it seems like the only thing they can offer is first waving passengers, Wi-Fi, and then they take off. They're like, smell you later, and they take off. Why couldn't that ship rescue the people on the Triumph? Yeah, I mean, I think that was the expectation that everybody had on board the ship. When they saw this boat coming across the horizon towards us, it was like, hooray, we're being rescued. But these ships are like skyscrapers, and they're floating around in the middle of the Gulf of Mexico, the danger of trying to bring two boats next to each other and get people across is just like a non-starter.
33:38And you see they've got this little kind of boat that moves between them. And, you know, like they get some like water and some watermelons, more red bags, you know, nappies for babies, you know, things like important items that they need because they're running out of supplies. But to have 4 ,000 people shuckling back and forward on that little boat would have taken forever. And also, I would hazard that the passengers who've arrived on that cruise ship, who are on a perfectly good cruise ship, who are on holiday, probably don't want 4 ,000 stinky Carnival Triumph passengers invading their boat.
34:12Where are they going to sleep? They don't have enough cabins. They don't have enough food. So they had to sit it out. But yeah, there was this expectation like, hooray, we're being rescued because there's other boats coming along. But the great thing that happened, it was this kind of weird consequence was that everybody realized they could steal Wi-Fi reception from this other boat. So you never get a situation now in the modern world where you've got 4 ,000 people cut off from any communication. They couldn't ring home. They couldn't speak to their families. They couldn't send a text or anything.
34:43Then all of a sudden, this window of communication to the outside world briefly opens up. And that's when this story that's happening on board the boat, but nobody else really knows about it, all of a sudden kind of escapes and gets off the boat and then becomes this, you know, global story in the media and CNN and everybody pick up on it. And, you know, the snowball starts to roll.
35:05Rebecca Lavoie: There is a literal tipping point. And that's when the tugboats finally catch up to the triumph and the pull causes the ship to, you know, tilt. What happened when that happened? Yeah. I mean, I think the weather turns as well. There's a kind of a number of factors and i think as well like everybody's been weeing in the shower so i don't know the sewage system or the drainage system at least has been just you know the level of year has been rising and rising and rising and rising so at that point when the boat starts to move everything just kind of sloshes out and i mean that was some of the most insane footage that we saw everything overflowed into the floor and just kept overflowing raw sewage water that is slippery you would be walking down the hallway and all of a sudden squish squish squish squish and you know what you're standing in uh we were in excrement all of a sudden you've got these stairwells that are kind of and then people are walking and they've got like squidgy carpets and you can hear the kind of squelchiness as they walk down these stairwells and you can see little puddles and rivers of urine and you know in some of the restaurants, there's like kind of standing water and there's buckets out trying to catch stuff.
36:20And people talk about it running down the walls because you've got floors stacked on floors, stacked on floors, stacked on floors. So yeah, it becomes an absolute nightmare, in my opinion. It really hits the fan, so to speak.
36:34Rebecca Lavoie: You show us in the documentary, sort of the decision-making process of the team at CNN, for example, to begin to cover this as a real story. Do you think their coverage met the moment, the coverage that you saw for this documentary? Well, I think it was a very smart decision. Jeff Zucker had recently taken over CNN. You know, they weren't doing so well in the ratings. He needed to kind of make a mark in the mainstream media landscape. You had all this stuff happening like the Pope had just died. You had Obama doing a State of the Union address. You had North Korea firing missiles. And he said, this poop cruise story, this is the story.
37:17This is what people want to see. This is kind of human interest. Let's go all in on this story. It was like wall-to-wall coverage. Let's take a closer look inside this giant ship. Lots and lots of people in a little space here. We would talk to maritime lawyers, infectious disease people. E. coli, salmonella, shigella. These are all... I might have even talked to a psychologist or someone to help us understand what it would have been like for these people to be in such an ordeal. And I think at the time there was a lot of criticism. It was kind of shocking that he did it. But that was the beginning maybe of a kind of movement from the news kind of moving into an entertainment space.
37:52So whether you like it or not, it was a very shrewd decision. And I think he read the room in terms of what people are interested in, like what viewers want. And I think, you know, 13 years later, the fact that we're making this film now shows testament to that people are still interested in people in these extraordinary circumstances like this. So I think it was a very shrewd and astute realization of something's going on here and people want to know about it. And we need to throw all of our resources at this story, cover it morning, noon and night. And who cares what the critics say? Like, people want to know about this.
38:28And they did. It was the biggest story in America for those days at the time.
38:32Rebecca Lavoie: There are indications that the crisis on this ship was not unforeseeable. Have there been any reforms made because of the situation? Yeah, there was a huge amount of reforms, I think, that came from this. The ship itself was taken back to port. It had a kind of multi-million dollar refit. The Carnival Cruises also looked at this fuel line issue, which had been cropping up with a number of their vessels previously. we have a lawyer in the documentary Frank Spagnoletti who'd noticed that there'd been multiple cases of fires occurring on board or fires that had been put out so there was an issue there and luckily because of this event on the Carnival Triumph no one died I mean it wasn't a great experience but no one died and it did lead to them addressing this issue and likewise the film ends with this realisation that your rights as a cruise passenger at that time, you essentially had none.
39:28You know, once you bought the ticket, you kind of gave away all of your rights to safe passage, sanitary conditions, all these kind of things. And since then, I think they've resolved those issues that I think were present previously. So yes, it did lead to change. And that's an important thing.
39:46Rebecca Lavoie: Well, as you said, and as we see, Triumph is now sailing with a new name. When viewers finished watching this, what do you think they might be weighing before they book their next cruise? Well, I mean, I really hope anyone who goes on a cruise doesn't have this experience. I hope they don't. Things have moved on. I hope it doesn't put people off, but I can imagine there may be quite a few people who may think twice about going on a cruise. I've never been on a cruise. It's not something that I've ever really fancied doing. And I think it's fair to say I I don't have a cruise booked now, but it's really popular.
40:23I mean, people love it. People go on cruises. There was a lot of people who booked immediately to go on that same cruise straight the year after because it was such a kind of crazy experience for them. I mean, people are mad. That's kind of one thing I learned about, you know, making this film. Like, people do all kinds of crazy things.
40:42Rebecca Lavoie: Well, the film is called Trainwreck Poop Cruise. James Ross, thank you so much for telling me about it. Well, thank you so much for asking. and I hope audiences enjoy it. That's it for this week's episode. Thanks again to Cheyenne Brown and James Ross. Dig deeper into all your favorite Netflix documentaries and films at Tadoom.com. There, you can read much more on each of the catastrophes covered in this season of Trainwreck. For more of my takes, check out my other podcast, Crime Writers On. Each week on that show, we break down the latest in true crime documentaries, TV shows, podcasts, and pop culture.
41:15Rebecca Lavoie: If you like You Can't Make This Up, please rate and review this show and share it with your friends. Find us on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and wherever else you get your podcasts. And make sure to follow the show to stay tuned for all new episodes. You Can't Make This Up is a co-production of Netflix and Partners in Crime Media. I'm Rebecca Lavoie. Thanks so much for listening.
41:48Thank you.
Netflix’s Trainwreck takes viewers inside a series of calamities - some large, some small - and tries to bring reason to chaos. This season covers the scandal surrounding Toronto’s Rob Ford in Mayor of Mayhem, and embarks on the 2013 sewage-filled voyage in Poop Cruise. We hear from the people who lived through each fiasco where anything that could have gone wrong…did.
In this episode of You Can't Make This Up, host Rebecca Lavoie interviews Shianne Brown and James Ross.
SPOILER ALERT! If you haven't watched Trainwreck yet, make sure to add it to your watch-list before listening on.
Dig deeper into all of your favorite Netflix documentaries and films at Tudum.com. There you can read much more on each of the catastrophes covered in this season of Trainwreck.
Listen to more from Netflix Podcasts.