1. Podcasts
  2. Accidental Tech Podcast
  3. 715: Diner Lobster
Accidental Tech Podcast

29 Oct 2026 · 2h 40m · 57 chapters

In short

The hosts discuss the iPhone “Duo” (Apple’s foldable), including their buying experiences, day-to-day usability, and software/hardware tradeoffs. They also do ATP store holiday admin: Pride/trans charity shirts, other merchandise, sale best/worst sellers, and deadlines. No formal external guests appear in the episode; it’s primarily the hosts plus references to people they mention (e.g., Adam on Mastodon, Aaron, Stephen Hackett, Neely Patel, Gruber).

Guest backgrounds

No podcast guests are present in the transcript. The “guests” are the hosts themselves (John, Marco, Casey). They are not described with formal bios in the transcript, except Casey’s background as an iOS developer.

Key claims

  1. Buying the Duo was frustrating due to stock/holding rules; business reps can pull stock aside, but personal card checkout can’t be changed to business.
  2. The Duo is not a one-handed phone; it’s awkward/heavy/bulky when closed, and reachability is worse side-to-side.
  3. The crease is less noticeable than expected; the internal matte display is a standout.
  4. Touch ID is “fine” and surprisingly fast (especially with Apple Watch unlock).
  5. Multitasking is intuitive, but limited; live activities and some app gestures (Slack) feel rough.
  6. Cameras are a major disappointment, especially in low light vs a standard iPhone 17 Pro.

Notable examples

  • Casey’s watch transfer nightmare: apps/system apps re-download after restore; “rest finger to open” behavior.
  • Pencil: cheaper styluses (e.g., “Meta pen”) don’t work; Apple Pencil USB-C does, but the phone rocks so writing on a table is hard.
  • UI nits: emoji keyboard shortcut muscle memory breaks; Slack workspace switching changed.
  • Camera comparison at a flag football practice: Duo photo worse than iPhone 17 Pro (Erin’s).

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

0:10

iPhone Duo Acquisition

Discussion about Marco's experience procuring an iPhone Duo and the challenges faced.

“There's some rumbling in the streets that you might have been able to come up with a toy for yourself.”
7:52

iPhone Duo Impressions

Marco shares his thoughts on the iPhone Duo after initial use and its design challenges.

“And by the way, don't forget if you're an ATP member, or go to your member page, get the code for 15 % off.”
14:01

First Impressions of Disruptive Tech

Explores the mixed feelings about adopting new technology despite its flaws.

“That's what this is going to be like for a lot of people.”
14:52

Hands-On Experience with the Device

Discussion on the hardware and software impressions of a new device.

“I've tried them out in the Apple store for a little while just to see what they're like.”
15:58

Initial Setup Challenges and Insights

Shares experiences and frustrations about transferring data to a new phone.

“I think I was the first person to walk out with one.”
17:01

The Dreaded Phone Transfer Process

Unpacks the complexities and common issues encountered during phone upgrades.

“First of all, I nominally do this sort of thing for a living twice over.”
20:45

One-Handed Usability Challenges

Discusses the usability of the device with one hand and design limitations.

“But here I am again doing this slightly delayed September tradition of Apple, for the love of Christ, can we please put a little bit of effort into this?”
22:35

Weight Perception of the Device

Comparative thoughts on the weight and bulkiness of the device versus expectations.

“But I did for a little while carry a Max phone, or for a year I carried a Max phone.”
23:38

Touch ID vs. Face ID Experience

Comparative analysis of Touch ID and Face ID and their usability in the new device.

“That when it's open, and I had this written down, literally what I wrote down in my notes yesterday, the day before, is the following.”
26:08

Crease Experience and Overall Satisfaction

Evaluates the visibility and impact of the device's crease on user experience.

“But if that same button does touch ID, if that unlocked the phone, you'd be like, I can never see my notifications on the lock screen because as soon as I touch that damn button, it unlocks the whole phone.”
Show all 57 chapters
28:01

User Experience with the Device

Discussion on the crease and screen quality of the device.

“Basically what rest does is it does a swipe up on your behalf.”
29:47

Apple Pencil Compatibility

Exploring the compatibility of the Apple Pencil with the device and its functionality.

“Yeah, I was super impressed with that screen, just every aspect of it, including how well they handled the crease.”
31:47

Ergonomics and Usability Issues

Challenges faced due to the device's design and user interface quirks.

“The other thing is, if you're going to use the pencil with it, you really want to be opening it up and using it in portrait orientation, using it in landscape.”
35:02

Live Activities and Notifications

Discussion of live activities feature and user experience in real-time usage.

“The thing that might be driving me the most bananas about this phone, and I'm being a little bit hyperbolic here and a little bit dramatic, but I also kind of mean it.”
37:36

Camera Features and Selfies

Analysis of camera performance and the awkwardness of taking selfies with the device.

“in Slack, they have updated Slack for the Duo, which is great.”
39:06

Final Thoughts on Device Functionality

Concluding remarks on usability, camera quality, and potential improvements.

“Because toolbars and everything is smaller on the outer display, the Safari share arrow is now buried within the puzzle piece thing on the left-hand side of the address bar.”
42:01

Reviewing the Duo Phone Experience

Discussion on the features and usability of the Duo phone, including multitasking and camera performance.

“That is one of the things that I was expecting to be unhappy about, and I am indeed unhappy about.”
45:04

Comparing the Duo with High-End Phones

Exploration of the Duo phone's pricing and its comparison to high-end models like Marco's phone.

“I'm not trying to subtweet, if you will.”
46:21

Discussion on AppleCare and Device Protection

Insights into AppleCare pricing, family plans, and the practicality of device protection.

“AppleCare is like$20 a month on this phone and you are no longer allowed to pre-buy an entire year of AppleCare, which would save you some money.”
49:55

New iPad Mini Features and Updates

In-depth discussion about the features of the new iPad Mini, including the A20 Pro chip and acoustic display.

“We are roughly an hour in and we got a lot of crap left to talk about.”
56:00

Revisiting the iPad Mini

The hosts discuss their experiences and opinions on the iPad Mini's functionality and design improvements.

“And then when the keyboard cases came out, I learned that it's so much nicer entering text with a keyboard than any other way.”
1:03:34

M6 iMac Overview

An in-depth look at the new M6 iMac models, including specs, pricing, and features.

1:09:14

MacBook Pro Updates

The hosts provide updates on the MacBook Pro with M6 chip, discussing specs and pricing.

“But now we get to the good stuff and we're going to stop our speed run.”
1:10:01

Initial Reactions to New MacBook Pro

Hosts discuss their first impressions of the new MacBook Pro announcement.

“Anyway, so at one, when I was at lunch, that's when all this dropped.”
1:12:03

Excitement Over the Return of the Apple Logo

The hosts express their joy at the return of the classic glowing Apple logo.

“This is the old manniest old man thing to be excited about, but I'm so excited for this.”
1:14:40

Analysis of Product Improvements

Discussion on the improvements in the new MacBook Pro without significant drawbacks.

“As far as anyone can tell, I think the keyboard seems the same.”
1:17:09

OLED Display Technology Explained

Hosts delve into the details and implications of the new OLED technology in the MacBook Pro.

“You know, he's, he's very new to the job.”
1:19:15

Concerns About Burn-In and Touch Features

Discussion on burn-in protection and limitations of the touchscreen features on the new MacBook Pro.

“These MacBook Ultra rumors had our heads spinning with all the things that it could be and all our hopes and fears.”
1:24:01

Displays and Burn-in Protection

Exploration of screen technologies and Apple's burn-in protection strategies.

1:25:19

Dynamic Island vs. Notch

Discussion on the new dynamic island feature compared to traditional notches.

1:26:43

Touchscreen Integration in Macs

An examination of how Apple is integrating touchscreen features into MacBook Pros.

1:33:32

MacOS Adjustments for Touch Support

Overview of how MacOS is being adjusted to accommodate touch inputs without disrupting user experience.

“And while MacBook Pro hinges are pretty solid, yes, you can make it wobble pretty easily with some firm taps on the top of the screen.”
1:36:05

Expanding Touch Controls

Insights into how Apple is enhancing touch control functionality while retaining visual consistency.

1:38:03

Touch-Friendly Controls in macOS

Learn about how macOS has made controls more touch-friendly for users.

“The actual touch target for the letter E is much bigger.”
1:41:42

Changing Expectations for Touch Screens

Explore the evolving expectations of users regarding touch screens in laptops.

1:44:01

Hardware Changes: Size and Weight

Discuss the recent hardware changes in MacBook models, focusing on size and weight.

“They did little adjustments here and there, but for the most part, macOS will still look and work the same way as it did before when everyone's not touching it.”
1:45:47

Battery and Cooling Innovations

Understand the implications of battery capacity and cooling innovations in new MacBooks.

“Going from 3.5 to 3.0, you will feel that.”
1:48:26

Design Continuity in MacBook Pro

Examine the design features of the latest MacBook Pro and their relationship to previous models.

1:50:16

Pricing and Configuration Options

Analyze the pricing structure and configuration options available for new MacBook models.

1:52:00

MacBook Pro Storage and Pricing Details

Discussion on the storage options and pricing of the new MacBook Pro models.

“Maybe they just turn those off and just shoot it at the sides.”
1:55:35

Upgrading Considerations for MacBook Pro

Exploring personal considerations and financial implications of upgrading the MacBook Pro.

“So I priced out 14-inch space black nanotexture M5 Max with no binning because I want 64 gigs of RAM, which is what I currently have.”
1:59:15

Debate on Timing and Need for Upgrade

A discussion on whether it's the right time to upgrade given the current market conditions.

“There are also some tax differences for business expenses there that might be relevant.”
2:06:05

The Dilemma of Upgrading Computers

Discussion on whether to upgrade to newer computer models amidst concerns over pricing and specs.

2:08:12

Navigating Dual Computer Usage

Exploration of the challenges and benefits of using multiple laptops for development.

“So what I've been doing a lot recently, the number of times that I am a away from home has gone up in the last couple of years.”
2:12:36

The Need for a Single Powerful Laptop

Rationale for transitioning back to a single, high-powered laptop to enhance efficiency and workflow.

“I mean, John would never buy a laptop, but that's closer to what I would do.”
2:16:30

Plans for Laptop Transition

Details about the decision to sell old laptops and upgrade to a new high-end MacBook.

“Silver, 14-inch with the glowing Apple logo.”
2:19:41

Discussion on App Availability Issues

Conversation about the misleading error messages related to app availability in different regions.

“but apparently you're not making it available in the UK and I'm very angry about it.”
2:20:00

Fineliner: App Release Update

Learn about the launch of the Fineliner app and the misleading error message from Apple.

“It should say, hey, this app isn't even on the App Store.”
2:21:00

Development Journey of Fineliner

Discover the challenges and joys in creating Fineliner, including its features and user feedback.

“Anyway, that is now behind us and I'm happy to say Fineliner is out.”
2:24:40

Fineliner's Unique Features

Explore the various features of Fineliner that enhance user experience and functionality.

“There are plenty of people who are like, I couldn't wait.”
2:27:39

Tech and Fun: Balancing Delight in Fineliner

Understand how Fineliner combines technical excellence with fun design elements.

“Everything about this app is nerd compatible.”
2:30:34

The Game-Like Experience of Fineliner

Learn about the playful, game-like elements in Fineliner's interface and business model.

“There's a lot of depth to it that you will eventually maybe find.”
2:34:04

Proud of Fineliner's Design and Features

The speaker discusses their pride in the design of their app Fineliner and its custom UI features.

“But I feel almost like it is a bit of a game, certainly in the business model.”
2:36:07

Goals for User Reach Over Profit

The speaker emphasizes their goal of maximizing user reach over immediate financial gain from the app.

“I honestly, if I don't make that much money from this, but a ton of people use it, I consider that a win.”
2:36:46

Future Plans for Seasonal Content

Discussion on the potential for seasonal packs and templates to enhance Fineliner's offerings.

“Well, it's a shame because I had a quick advice for you.”
2:37:45

Monitoring Launch Success and User Feedback

The speaker plans to track user feedback and sales data post-launch to measure success.

“But, but yeah, like I think there's a lot of potential here for future fun stuff to be added, future purchases of different ink packs and color schemes and templates and stuff like that.”
2:38:42

Positive Launch Reception

The conversation highlights the positive initial reception of Fineliner and excitement for future use.

“No, I'm very glad that it's gone well, and I'm very excited for you.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On Accidental Tech Podcast, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00Do we have a pre-show or do we want to just jump into the administrative? I know we don't typically do that. We always have a preview. Whatever pre-show we have, it has to be short.

0:09Marco Arment: All right. I think that was just it. No, come on. Well done, John. Well done. Hey, Marco, I hear there's some rumors. There's some rumbling in the streets that you might have been able to come up with a toy for yourself. That sounds really disturbing. oh come now behave no that's you're not making it better um it's are you talking about a duo yes oh yeah i i okay i didn't know what he was talking about either golly y 'all y 'all dirty gracious wow every listener is gonna okay all right all right all right anyway moving on uh did you did you procure an iphone duo is that the toy that you've procured procured i do have an iPhone duo.

0:58I'm mad about it, but I do have. Do you want to expand on that or do you want to save it for later?

1:03Marco Arment: Ever since Saturday morning, you know, when it said when the Apple said like, check back on this day for in-store pickup. I've had one of those stock checking sites that like pulls it every few seconds and eventually like, you know, something will pop up and it'll alert me and it makes, you know, all my devices make sound and everything's, you know, blinking and sirens are going off in case the garage door is closing and like all these different things happened. Then, of course, I rushed to the computer and go, go, go. I have everything preset and then, oh, it's gone. Oh, God. And then that happened all weekend.

1:34Marco Arment: So all Saturday, all Sunday, like that was just every, every, you know, couple hours, one would pop up in stock somewhere in the New York metro area. I had a very wide search radius that covered 12 different Apple stores. It would get to the cart and it would, you know, try it and then, oh, it's gone. Like, after living like that for, you know, 48 hours and continual failures, I finally got one, except it had to be the two terabyte model. Oh, no. For, after tax,$3 ,400. Oh, my word. There was a time that I would look at a$3 ,500 laptop and be like, woof, that's expensive. Oh. Oh, and by the way, the business reps.

2:18Marco Arment: so the business rep i was dealing with is very nice um but kept saying you know i'm gonna see if i can you know hold something aside or figure out something for you you know and and of course like the every day the answer was nope sorry nope sorry nope sorry um meanwhile i go to pick up this phone and it's a business expense because this is literally all of what i do but you know in order to get the fastest checkout possible i just put it on my personal card so the first thing I asked is like, hey, as I'm picking it up, can I put this on a business card? Nope. Can't change it. Of course. And then the person I was picking it up was like, oh, you're buying it for a business.

2:54Marco Arment: Why didn't you just have the business reps hold it for you? And of course, I, you know, unloaded the entire story on this poor woman who was just trying to check me out. And she was like, oh, well, here, the business reps here have been pulling stock aside for their customers since launch. What? Uh-huh. What? To hear again another way that this entire process has been like tilted and a little unfair and a little irregular, it just irritated me so much. I'm so frustrated. I'm frustrated. And this doesn't even affect me. And I'm frustrated. All right. We have some administrative to take care of.

3:32First of all, let me remind you that the ATP store is open for the holidays. I will do my normal spiel in a moment. But John, can you give us the nickel tour real quick? Oh, sure. The products that we've got. So we've got our two pride T-shirts that are pride and trans pride variations of our logo, where all of our profits are going to charity for those shirts to Trans Lifeline and the Transgender Law Center. So you should check those out. We've got our A18 Pro shirt for the chip that we forgot from the MacBook Neo, which we sold shirts for last sale. And then, of course, we've got the M5 Ultra and the N5 Ultra Interposer shirts.

4:06We brought back the Palm Graffiti shirt as well. And then we've got our usual stuff. Also, don't forget that if you have a zip hoodie and you always want one that's not black, now you can get ones that aren't black. They come in white and gray and bluish and so on and so forth. And finally, the ATP Polo, which we're basically selling for cost because the cost of it has gone up so much. And this may be the last time we sell them. So if you want an ATP Polo, get it back. And the one thing I want to say about the sale, question for you two, hopefully you have not looked at the sale pages. What do you think our best-selling products are and what do you think our worst-selling product is?

4:36for best selling, I would guess it's actually the Pride and or Trans shirts because we got notifications almost instantly that we had pre-ordered enough that they will get printed. Printed is probably not the word I'm looking for, but you know what I mean, which I was very, very excited by. That was, I think, the first two products that we crossed that threshold, which made me very happy. Worst selling product, probably the polo because it's a fortune and nobody likes them but me. that's not literally true people write me all the time and say they like them but compared to the other things i think nobody likes them but me and the polo is also a jillion dollars that's what i'm saying and it's again we apologize we wish it wasn't but unfortunately that is the case what

5:19Marco Arment: do you think marco because we're not selling a short sleeve version of the regular atp logo that normally that's almost always the top seller so yes we are what do you mean we're not selling a short sleeve version of us yes we are we are selling that where oh oh i was just okay i was looking at slash store i thought it was only the long sleeve one because that's that's the graphic being displayed there they were graph the pictures change watch oh okay all right well it's just your first time dining with a smart coat yeah i was going so okay that's probably number one but i think casey's probably right for this time i think i'm guessing the atp pride the rainbow version i'm guessing that is number one and i'm guessing last place is the a18 pro my second guess for last place is graffiti all right so our top sellers are in fact the pride shirts they've been close to neck and neck although i do think the regular pride one is out ahead now so that's a good guess because those are the you know the most special shirts and people want to support charity and by the way as many people noted you can just click the links in the store page and donate directly to the charities they get way more money if you just don't hit directly to them than buying a shirt of course you don't get a shirt then but just saying if you want to donate you can just donate directly um the worst seller by far by an astronomical amount by so much that i think the shirt may not get printed although we'll see a18 pro nobody likes it nobody likes it they don't like an a chip and even though it's got the a in our logo and everything a18 pro the macbook neo was so three months ago whenever the hell it was uh we have currently sold six and one of those is me why did you buy one i buy one of every shirt yeah or not every shirt but like anytime there's a new design you'll get one same so i'll probably be in for one as well yeah but anyway a18 18 Pro, unloved, very unloved.

7:02People are liking the polo because they're trying to get it. Graffiti's doing pretty well. Yeah, 18 Pro. So anyway, just like I said with the gray MacBook Neo shirt, if you want an 18 Pro shirt, go get like six of your friends to buy one. Otherwise, it's not getting printed. If you are listening to this and you think to yourself, man, I would love to have some ATP merchandise for the holidays to either gift myself or gift someone else. What you need to do is, if you're in the car, turn on your blinker because you're not a jerk. and pull over to the side of the road. If you're walking, scoot yourself to the side of the roadway or sidewalk that you're on.

7:37Go to atp.fm slash store and go and take care of it now. Don't be the person that says, oh my goodness, I missed it. I can't believe I'm that person, but this time I'm that person. Don't be that person. You're better than that. atp.fm slash store. Sale ends November 8th. November 8th. Do not wait until November 7th. Do not wait until November 8th. And by the way, don't forget if you're an ATP member, or go to your member page, get the code for 15 % off. If you want to become a member, you should do so and get 15 % off. All right. The other bit of administrivia, we have a new member special. So, hey, if you are interested in joining as a member, you can do that at atp.fm slash join.

8:15And not only will you get a little bit of a discount on the merchandise, but you'll also get this member special. And John, do you get other member specials or only the new ones? You get all the member specials all the way back in time. All the way back in time. So this member special is ATP Insider Time Management, which was the classic Casey episode where I didn't come up with the idea. A listener did. But I said at the beginning, because I'm an idiot and I never learned from my mistakes. Oh, we don't really have that much to say about this, do we? And I think this might have been one of the longest ones we've done so far.

8:46So we're bad at time management. That's fine. Yeah, it turns out. So if you're interested in that, ATP.fm slash join. Check out ATP Insider Time Management. Turns out there's more there than we thought. And I believe that was our 47th member special. So there's a big back catalog. Was it really? Yeah. Holy jamoys. I would have guessed half that. Great. Well, Q &A was our 46, and I think the Q &A was the previous one. So, yeah. Wow. Today I learned. All right. Let's do some topics. And obviously, there's a bunch of new things that we need to talk about. There's also some fun things from Marco in the after show.

9:17There's a little teaser for you. But we have something important to talk about, which is Marco and I have gotten iPhone duos. Obviously, we just talked about that to a degree a little bit ago.

9:27Marco Arment: Asterisk. Well, kind of, sort of. But Marco and I have iPhone duos, and we have some things to say. Marco, would you like me to start? Would you like to start? Or how do you want to handle this? I'll start because mine is going to probably be shorter. I actually just decided to set it up as a test phone only. To be honest, my initial impression of it is not that I want to use it as my personal phone. I will see if that changes throughout the year because there are things about it. So, and I'm sorry if I step on what you were going to say about any of this stuff, Casey. That's fine. What I thought was going to be an issue with it is an issue with it.

10:04Marco Arment: It is heavy. touch id sucks it really does want to be used right-handed when it's closed it is weird that you have basically three different sized software keyboards that you have to learn to type on although i do enjoy the additional space of the the front screen keyboard because it's so wide but also it is a very very difficult phone to use one-handed and the kind of lifestyle i have first of all i keep it in a pocket as i mentioned last episode i think if you keep it in a bag it's substantially more compelling but if you keep it in a pocket it's going to feel more burdensome because it's just so much heavier unless you are already a Pro Max user in which case go ahead because that's about the same weight but if you were just a regular Pro user it's going to feel really heavy to you.

10:49Marco Arment: One handed use if you just want to like quickly take it out of a pocket do something and put it back in that is really not what this phone is made for this phone will fight you on that and you're carrying around a big brick for that privilege. I'm definitely afraid I'm going to drop it but also I don't want to put a case on it because that would make it even bigger and bulkier. That being said, I did get to play with the Apple folio case, the one with the kickstand and the front cover on the screen. It felt very nice. And I saw somebody online who just cut it on its spine. So it was only the back half, which that's, you know,$130 thing to cut.

11:26Marco Arment: But that honestly looked pretty good. And I think would actually improve the grips potentially without too much bulk and the kickstand would be useful. so if I carried a duo I think I would probably try that but ultimately it feels like I'm going to drop it I don't I think the ergonomics of it are all wrong for me and that's not to say it's wrong for everybody but I think it's all wrong for me that being said I also am tempted to try it because it is fun it reminds me in many ways of the very first MacBook Air which everyone rags on because it was really slow and it did overheat and the SSD was stupidly priced and slower.

12:07Marco Arment: But I had that first MacBook Air and I loved it, even though at times I hated it. And I think it might also evoke similar feelings as the 12-inch MacBook. That was a computer that was very frustrating in a lot of ways, but also people did love it in other ways. And I think what the Duo is doing, it's putting a lot of novelty and fun into the iPhone, which has gotten pretty boring. And not to say that that's bad, but the iPhone is just a very mature product. You know, the regular, you know, slab phone. It's a very mature product. It doesn't change that frequently or in very big ways. We've had the same thing forever.

12:44Marco Arment: It very much feels like a foundation of our technology lives. It just never changes. This changes it in a big way. People are doing fun stuff. People are having fun with it. So I think if you look at it rationally, almost no one should buy this thing but sometimes you can do things for irrational reasons sometimes you can buy something because it's fun and sometimes being on the cutting edge of something has a lot of sharp edges and downside and i think this is one of those times that this phone if you want to live with this phone as your phone there's going to be days where you regret that choice it's also so different and new and exciting and fun that i think many people will choose to take that trade-off.

13:30Marco Arment: And I don't know that I will, but I am honestly tempted just for the fun alone. But boy, is it heavy and awkward and lots of other challenges. Writing with a pencil on the table is useless because the whole thing rocks so much. The camera box. There's a lot of things that I thought would be great about it that aren't, but there's other stuff about it that I didn't even know or realize, but that ends up being kind of cool. So it's fun to play with. I don't, again, I don't think it's going to be for me, but I think that having just a year of disrupted fun, just like that first MacBook Air, even though we all knew its shortcomings, a lot of us still bought it and used it and liked it a lot of the time.

14:21Marco Arment: That's what this is going to be like for a lot of people. and it's not that you are denying the shortcomings or blind to them no we we see the shortcomings we accept them and we use it anyway that's what this kind of feeling is i think that's really largely going to happen with the duo it's already happening um but for a lot of people including again probably me for a lot of us we're like you know what i my phone is not a place where i want to have that level of disruption and that and the fun's probably not worth it for me um but i'm glad it's there for the people who decide differently on that.

14:54I'll give you my quick take too. I've tried them out in the Apple store for a little while just to see what they're like. It's an impressive piece of hardware. I would take one for free in a second if anyone wants to send me one. It's really cool looking. It's fun to play with. I could definitely find a use for the screen. I think that the both screens look really good, both the glossy one on the outside and the matte one on the inside and it's nice being able to compare the two different approaches in an apple store the matte screen does amazing of course the sun is not in the apple store so there's that but in even in the apple store with all its point light sources and everything looks really good uh the i love as i said in the last program i love the what they did with the very constrained environment for for two-part multitasking if you've got a phone that splits in half it just naturally the interface flows right out of the fact that the phone bends in the middle.

15:45I think if I had one, it would be more of like an around the house phone. And when I left the house, I wouldn't want to take that with me for all the reasons Marco mentioned. But I came away very impressed with the hardware and thought the software was pretty good too. All right. I got thoughts. I picked up mine at 8am at Short Pump. I think I was the first person to walk out with one. There was a very long line for walk-ins. I would guess at least 50 people, maybe upwards of 100. I'm terrible at estimating crowds, though, so take that with a grain of salt. I was the third person in line. The first person I overheard being told, I'm sorry, your pickup appointment isn't until January 25 or whatever, and I felt very bad for them.

16:26But then there was one person in front of me and me, and I'm pretty sure I happened to walk out with mine first. And so I've been using it since then. And I think my executive summary is something I said to my friend Adam on Mastodon, and his reply, I think, was also very helpful. My executive summary is, and this is what I said, this device is mostly me being annoyed by things I didn't expect and not annoyed by the things I did expect. To which Adam replied, I'm serious when I say I haven't had this much fun in a long time. I think that's the summary. So let's talk about it. First of all, I nominally do this sort of thing for a living twice over.

17:07I am an iOS developer, and I flat my gums about Apple stuff for a living. I have yet to figure out the right f***ing way to transfer phones, and it's a Casey problem. I think it's a Casey problem. No, that's an Apple problem. Oh, my word. So this year, what I thought I would do, because the last several years, I did a phone-to-phone transfer, and I've tried all sorts of cockabamy schemes in order to have Ethernet connections between them, where I get like a USB-C like pass-through Ethernet thing so I can power them and have Ethernet. I've tried that. I've tried like using a Thunderbolt 5 cable, maybe it was 4, but you get the point, like a really, really nice, like 100 plus dollar Thunderbolt cable.

17:45I've tried that. I haven't done iCloud backup because I don't like that because then you get this like phone that you can nominally use, but then you can't do anything with it for like two hours, which arguably is what I ended up doing anyway. We'll get there. But I probably should try iCloud backup the next time I do this, but I don't typically care for that. So this time what I did was is I did a backup the night before to my computer and restored the day of. And I just want to point out that every time we tell our phone transfer stories, whatever method we didn't use, everyone writes in and says you should have used method you didn't use because I used it and it works for me.

18:21And a very popular one is, hey, you guys used to do iTunes backup and then you stop. You should never stop. You should definitely do that. So you're taking a tour of all the things. eventually you'll do an iCloud backup, although Marco's done iCloud backup too. I think we have, we have had iCloud backup represented in our cycle. Here's the problem. Like no matter which one we do, if it screws up, that's our experience. And even though people say you should have used other method next year, we'll use other method. And then people will say we should have used the method we use the previous year.

18:47So it's just, all I'm saying is this should be much more reliable. Concur. Um, what I did was I did a backup and then I did a restore in that for the most part went really well. The problem I ran into is because I'm out of shape when it comes to this dance and I didn't do the backup immediately before the restore. And that's what I should have done. Let me tell you why. What I should have done is unpaired my watch and then done the backup. And so then when I restore the backup, I repair the watch. I didn't do that. And holy feep, That was a complete goddamn nightmare. Getting my watch to go from one phone to the other ended up being I had to unpair it from the old phone, repair it to the new one.

19:30And then when I did that, what I ended up seeing after I did a restore, which is what should have happened, and everything looked like it should have been good. But then I start, you know, it says your watch is restored. You're good to go. But then I go to use the watch and every app, including every system app, except like settings and a couple, maybe one or two others, every single app, including the system apps, is trying to download again, which I assumed meant something was screwed up. I later found out, nope, that's just how Apple Watch Restore works these days. I had no idea. So again, some of this is on me for sure.

20:06I get that. But it's just bad, Apple. It's just bad. I want to have one phone turn in to the other phone. I don't want to have to read you 800 freaking prompts about location services and this and that and this and that. No. One of these ways, one of these ways should be, I would like my new toy to look like my old toy. Please and thank you. That's all you need to know. That is everything you need to know.

20:35Marco Arment: Which is probably a pretty common need. Right? Like, doesn't everyone face this whenever they upgrade their phone? Yeah, it's just so. And I know everyone says this every year. And here I am again. And now it's October, not September. But here I am again doing this slightly delayed September tradition of Apple, for the love of Christ, can we please put a little bit of effort into this? Please, please, can we put some effort into this? Real-time follow-up. I just got a text from Aaron. What are you yelling about? I am not kidding. Oh, my word. Anyway, so once the watch transfer was done, then that was mostly a decent time after that.

21:13So let's talk about it. I'm going to hit this kind of all. It's going to be a little scattershot, and I apologize about that. But I did take a bunch of notes. I want to go through them. First of all, this is not a one-handed device. It just isn't. I'm a devout pop socket person, which I've actually mostly stopped doing on this phone. Because why? Because it's a two-handed phone. you say to yourself, oh, but Casey, the outer, the closed version is so wee and so little and so squats. And all of those things are true, except it's really freaking wide. And reachability top to bottom is wonderful now.

21:47It's what I've wanted for years, but reachability side to side now sucks. So you're really stuck with this being a two handed device, no matter how you slice it. So if you, as Neely Patel said, you can try different moves. And one of the things I did when I was in the Apple store. I said, can I open and close this with one hand? And the answer is, I can, but it's really hard. Yeah, it's not something you'd want to like rely on. Like, I'm just saying it's like a move. You got to like learn a move. It is, it can be done. Don't say it can't be done, but boy, is it hard. To be clear, I'm not talking about opening and closing, which I don't think I've tried doing it one handed yet.

22:20I'm just talking about using it, just using the device one handed. Yeah, I know what you mean. I thought the reachability wasn't that bad from the way I hold the phone with my right hand, but it's certainly worse than like a quote-unquote regular phone well it's it's worse laterally but it's much better vertically yeah so i meant later like the first i was trying like can i reach can i reach upper left corner upper right corner holding it right and i can reach i have a pretty long thumb but like and also the way i grip the phone but it is harder yeah so uh the reachability problem is different but it's still a problem uh i for me this is just my personal opinion i am not trying to negate anyone else's especially marco's opinion i don't find it to be that egregiously heavy.

22:58It's not light. I'm not saying it's light. You've had a Max phone before, right? I have, but not in a couple of years. But that is a very fair point. But I did for a little while carry a Max phone, or for a year I carried a Max phone. But that was like two or three years ago now. And to reiterate, the Duo is five grams heavier than the current Max phone. Yeah. So when it's closed, I wouldn't say it's light. I'm not trying to say it's light when it's closed. But I don't feel like it's egregiously heavy. Like many others other than Marco have also said marco is not standing alone in this in fact i think i'm the one by myself in this particular opinion no i didn't think it was that i expected it to be heavier honestly and now i've never had a max phone and i think it is bulky and i wouldn't want it in my pocket but weight wise and they had it in the apple store they had it set up right next to the max they had a display with it right next to the max so i could pick up both of them and go can i feel five grams the answer is no i couldn't and i didn't think it was egregiously heavy but again i wouldn't want to put

23:49Marco Arment: it in a pocket i mean for whatever it's worth i've had i've like handed this test phone to a couple of other people in the last couple days, it's the first thing everyone says. Well, you got to hand it to them open. Well, he's less that way. That's true. Because the Max is always open. I mean, you hope it's always open. That's true. No, that is really true. That when it's open, and I had this written down, literally what I wrote down in my notes yesterday, the day before, is the following. When open, it's impossibly light. I understand conceptually that is literally impossible. but the way the weight is distributed, it feels impossibly light.

24:26And as someone who has handled but never owned an iPhone air, impossibly thin. I love the feel of this when it's open. It's fine closed for me, but I love it when it's open. Um, I realized around the time that I got the device that if you're curious what it's like when it's open, it is almost exactly the same size as an Apple Magic trackpad when open. So that gives you a rough idea of about how big it is.

24:54I was of the opinion that I was going to frigging hate Touch ID. I was primed and ready to be furious about it. I prefer Face ID, but Touch ID is fine. Now, most of the reason for that, to be fair, is because watch unlock. I have used it in the past. I guess maybe I never turned it for more recent phones. I don't know what my deal is, or maybe it's different in this phone or with this iOS release. I don't know. But it's like astonishingly fast now. It used to be that it would wait until Face ID timed out, and then it would finally be like, oh, yes, I can unlock your phone now. But now, I don't know what it is.

25:36Maybe they're not waiting for a finger. Maybe they know that there's no finger touching, so they don't even bother. I'm not sure what the story is. but with if you're wearing an apple watch and i totally understand not everyone is going to wear an apple watch or maybe you don't want to wear it all the time totally get that but for me i basically always have an apple watch on and it is astonishingly fast to unlock is it perfect no would face id be better yes would i prefer face id absolutely but this was one of those things that i was primed and ready to be furious about it's really fine the other aspect of that that i think we forgot to mentioned last time is they do this thing with the touch setting aside watch so you have no apple watch they do this thing with the the touch id button on the side of the duo where um even if you touch id it and unfortunately i couldn't test this in the apple store because they have touch id like disabled on the phones for reasons that make sense when you think about it um it first uh like pauses to let you see your notifications because it's kind of hard to like what if i just want to see my like on your regular phone you can just tap the side button and see your notifications as a lock screen without unlocking your phone.

26:38But if that same button does touch ID, if that unlocked the phone, you'd be like, I can never see my notifications on the lock screen because as soon as I touch that damn button, it unlocks the whole phone. So by default, when you touch the button, it will be like, okay, here's your lock screen. Keep your finger on that button and now we'll unlock. I could not test. I know they have a setting for this. What is it like? Hold to unlock. Well, what it says on the screen is rest to open. I'm not sure what the setting is, but that's what it says on screen. Right. again i couldn't i couldn't test that in the apple store because they have touch id uh locked but if you have one of these phones know that they're that's why it does that it's an intentional choice because otherwise you there would be no way for you to see your notifications on the lock screen and casey can you tell me does that setting make it not do that and just unlock immediately uh i don't i gotta find it first um i mean i guess you're always unlocking with the watch so you're not you're not noticing i mean not always and also you can always hit that that button with a finger that is not registered for touch id obviously but like oh yeah that's my understanding that's why that preference exists.

27:38Because some people are registering all five of their fingers. Yeah, I'm trying to find... Oh, rest finger to open is the name of the setting. And it's on by default, I think. Which is within Touch ID and passcode. So I just turned it off. So now I've locked my phone and I've sat and rested my finger. Oh no, I have to press the button. You have to keep your watch away from it. Oh yeah, that's true. No, I mean, it doesn't seem that different. It just doesn't automatically unlock itself. So it doesn't... Basically what rest does is it does a swipe up on your behalf. Yeah, exactly. Is effectively what it does.

28:06Um, so yeah, so, uh, yeah, not having face ID again, I can't stress enough. 100 % I would prefer it if I stick with the duo for next year. And if there's a duo too, and it has face ID, I will be overjoyed. But this was one of those things that I was expected to be expecting to be furious about. It's a nothing burger. It's fine. Speaking of nothing burgers, the crease, nothing burger. Like I feel it sometimes, but not always. I see it occasionally, but not always. generally speaking, I really don't notice it. I really, really don't. And I don't think I'm being like super duper. I can't think of the word I'm looking for, but like, I'm not grading on a curve here.

28:46I really don't think so. I was expected to be like, that this, I'm going to notice this all the time. It's going to be really annoying. And I do notice it, but I don't find it to be nearly as annoying as I expected. And I don't notice it nearly as much as I expected. Yeah. The matte surface really does an amazing job. Again, maybe Apple store lighting is more beneficial than being in the sun but it's really it does a good job because those ones in the apple store are getting an open and close a lot more than normal ones so even though they're quote-unquote brand new they're not really like a lot of i open and close it 100 times myself right so they're getting a lot of opening and closing and i expected that the matte surface would hide it you know reasonably you can still see it but whatever hide it well enough but i thought oh i'll be able to feel it really well they did a good job of making it so you can't feel it that much yes you can feel it you can you could With your eyes closed, you can find where it is, but I expected it to be way worse feel-wise just because there has to be like a gap there for it to go into.

29:38But they shore up that gap in a way that hopefully doesn't puncture your screen from the back more on that next week in a very beneficial way. Yeah, I was super impressed with that screen, just every aspect of it, including how well they handled the crease. Yeah, and I really like the internal matte screen. I genuinely am not sure if I would want it on the outside. I probably would because using this thing in sunlight would be even better than it already is with a matte screen. I think I would probably want matte everywhere, but I can tell you for sure, I'm loving it on the internal screen. It just looks different in a pleasing way to my eye.

30:17It's fuzzier than a nanotexture on the iPad. It's a little bit fuzzier than that, but I think it works well on this particular device. It is, I found it less blurry than I thought it was going to be. but again good thing about being an apple store side by side with it with a with a nanotexture ipad you're like oh i see the nanotexture ipad is a little bit more uh i don't know like refined and less less hazy um but you know that's because it's a much thicker piece of glass

30:44Marco Arment: also the inside screen feels fantastic with the apple pencil like that texture oh interesting oh man does it feel good um i also by the way i did some testing um all over amazon there are cheaper apple pencil compatible styluses um the biggest brand seems to be this brand called meta pen and i've i've gotten i've gotten a couple of them over the years for ipads um as far as i can figure out they do not seem to be compatible the only stylus i've gotten to work with the duo is the apple pencil usbc all those like you know meta pens and stuff it's you can get them to work on almost any other iPad.

31:23Marco Arment: And they don't have any kind of like pairing, you just like bring it near it and it works. So it's probably using whatever mechanism the Logitech Crayon uses. And that mechanism does not appear to exist or be enabled for the Duo. So for whatever it's worth, if you were out there hoping to get a cheaper stylus for your$2 ,000 phone, it's not going to happen, at least not yet. So if you want some kind of pencil, you got to get the actual Apple Pencil usbc that being said the alponsal usbc is pretty good and uh the only my only um slight complaint about it is that when you first pick it up if you haven't been using it for a while it doesn't work immediately it has to like wake up and connect i guess so if you pick it up real fast and start drawing on the on the duo the first few strokes might not actually register yet um which is a little annoying but i you know i understand why it has that some kind of standby thing but otherwise using the using the apple pencil on both duo screens it's really it works it works great with that one massive exception of the duo completely rocking on a table so much that you cannot write with it on on a surface and no matter what case you get i don't think it's going to make a big enough difference to that i'm sure people have cases that'll even that out but without a case yeah well it would have to be pretty thick to even it out i don't put little extra pegs to make up for the camera bump i'm sure but then it would be ridiculous in a pocket like i anyway i know if your plan ridiculous in a pocket with any case on it yeah if your plan is to like use the duo to take notes like a lot uh you better like holding your notebooks when you're taking or putting it on your leg or something something squishier yeah like but even then like yeah if it's on if it's on like you know your leg or a bed or something like you can do that but it's rough.

33:07Marco Arment: The other thing is, if you're going to use the pencil with it, you really want to be opening it up and using it in portrait orientation, using it in landscape. With the hinge, it's kind of a little bit weird. I think the ergonomics of note-taking on it are much better handheld in portrait. And if you want any other situation than handheld and portrait, you want an iPad mini. Coming back to the matte screen, again, love it, love it, love it. however one of the things that i did not expect to be annoyed by and i'm getting over but was very it put me off a lot at first um is the camera on the inside screen on the on the bigger screen the the camera that is under the display i find that to be fairly glaring i'm getting to get to the point that i can ignore it but i find that oftentimes particularly in dark mode it's pretty obvious where it is.

34:02Additionally, even in light mode, if you can't see the circle that is the camera, the text that is under, or I guess over the camera, I should say, is fuzzier than all the text around it. And so I'll think, oh God, what happened? Oh, right, right, right. Oh no, what happened to my screen? Oh, right, my bad. So that's a little bit frustrating. Would I have preferred a hole punch camera? Maybe. Like it is nice to have nothing, like no no clearly visible and well when things are great it's nice to have nothing that you can see as being a camera but then in in more circumstances than i expected the inner can or the the opened camera is the the front facing camera the one that's under the screen i find that i see that far more than i expected and it's a little bit annoying yeah they could have done hole punch in the upper right corner like so many other android foldables do and then they could have done the apple thing and just turn that circle into the dynamic island and sort of rejiggered their whole UI around that, but they didn't.

34:59Yep. Let's see. The thing that might be driving me the most bananas about this phone, and I'm being a little bit hyperbolic here and a little bit dramatic, but I also kind of mean it. If you happen to have a standard iPhone in your hands, you can follow along with me as long as you can do so safely. If you go to, let's say, send a text message, and you start to type a message, it doesn't matter what the message is, it doesn't matter who it's to. I'm looking at my comically tall 17 Pro, hilariously tall 17 Pro. It actually seems misproportioned to my eyes now because I've been trained by the Duo.

35:40Anyways, if you look at the 17 Pro or equivalent keyboard, in the bottom left-hand corner, for me anyway, the way I have it configured, the bottom left-hand corner is a little emoji icon, and above that is the 1, 2, 3 to change your keyboard. On the Duo, the bottom left-hand corner is 1, 2, 3 with a little baby emoji one next to it, and then next to that is the space bar. As someone who has been known to use an emoji from time to time, and by that I mean freaking always, I keep hitting the friggin' 1, 2, 3 button when I mean to get an emoji, because I've gotten years of muscle memory for go to the bottom left of the screen.

36:17And the bottom of the screen is now the one, two, three button. I'm sure I can retrain myself. This is a silly thing to fuss about, but it is driving me freaking crazy that every time I go to send to an emoji, I'm actually changing the keyboard. And then I got to remind myself how the heck to send an emoji again. It's driving me batty. Live activities. I like what they're going for. And what they do is in the upper right hand, well, sorry, live activities with the closed Duo. In the upper right is the hole punch camera. Below that is time. And if you have a focus mode icon, well, I guess a focus mode icon, if applicable, then time.

36:51Then you have that like combined battery Wi-Fi cell widget, which I also really like. But if you have a live activity, it obviously is going to go into the hole punch, so to speak. And what it does is it shimmies everything on the right-hand side of the screen down. When you're on the home screen, that's fine. But when you're on the lock screen, or excuse me, when you're on apps, it's not great. And I think some of that is that the software isn't 100 % like the iOS software is 100 % locked in on this. But live activities, especially if you're trying to do more than one, it's a bit rough out there.

37:21And I don't love that because I do love live activities. I like it for sports scores. I like it for timers. I like it for like a delivery or something like that. I use live activities relatively often and it's rough out there. Don't love that. Another nitpicky thing in Slack, they have updated Slack for the Duo, which is great. However, the gesture to go for the left to right swipe gesture that brings you back, no longer brings you back to your list of workspaces. It used to be that if you kept swiping left far enough, you could get to your different workspaces. So the relay Slack, the incomparable Slack, you know, all these different Slacks I'm a part of.

37:59Well, now I absolutely have to hit the button in the upper left-hand corner to get to a different slack and it's driving me freaking baddie. Selfies, they are better and worse. Fidelity, very good. Really like having the ability to use the outer main camera in order to take a selfie. That being said, you look like a moron because you look like you're trying to take a selfie with an iPad mini. You look dumb. You really, really do. The way they handle this is when you open the camera app, if the phone is open, if you flip the phone over on the outer display, the smaller of the displays, it says slide to show camera.

38:35And then you can do that. And then you see the camera. I like that affordance. I think it works well. That being said, you look like a moron. I'm doing it now. And I'm the only person in this room. And I look like an idiot. Also not a great work. Maybe I just haven't figured it out. Not a great way to ergonomically try to take a picture because you've got this giant slab in your hands and you're trying to figure out the right way to take a picture. And if you're trying to do it one handed, because, you know, you're trying to do the, like, hold the thing out at a distance so you can get everyone in the shot dance.

39:03Not great, Bob. Not great. Toolbar buttons. Because toolbars and everything is smaller on the outer display, the Safari share arrow is now buried within the puzzle piece thing on the left-hand side of the address bar. I don't think that was the case on the 17 Pro. I don't remember. I'm trying to find where it was. But it was not there in the 17 Pro. And let me tell you, It is very, oh yeah, because that's what it is. There's a second row of icons. There's back and forward, there's share row, bookmarks, and tabs. That row is not there in the Duo's outer screen. Instead, you've got just the address bar with the left-hand side as the puzzle piece that has everything in it, the everything bucket.

39:51The right-hand side is reload. And in the toolbar, which again is the right gutter of the phone, you have new tab and the tabs button. I get why they did that. I freaking hate it. The shero is buried and it's driving me batty. Getting close to done. I was on a FaceTime call with Stephen Hackett. We were talking about when he comes to visit and what we're going to do to my house in order to destroy it as per the perk, the goal on the podcast-a-thon or the campaign. And there was a point in time that I needed to show him something, but I needed two hands because I was measuring something and I wanted him to see me measuring something.

40:30And you know what was pretty great? I could put the phone in laptop mode, sit it somewhere safe, John, and have it just looking at me. Now, granted, I can't see Steven, but he can see me just fine. And I didn't need to jerry-rig some sort of apparatus in order to stand the thing upright. I just put it in laptop mode. It was great. You should have put it in open book mode. You know what I mean? Yeah, I guess I could have, but that would have been less stable. Because then you would have a better view of the screens. You could see more of the screens. I probably could have. You're right. But the stability of that would have been questionable.

41:03Additionally, at one point, we were looking at the Unify app. Like in the context of FaceTime, I shared my screen, and it took two or three tries to get this to work. But we were looking at the FaceTime app, and on the left-hand – or excuse me, on the Unify app, and the left-hand side – this is with the device open. The left-hand side was the Unify app. Right-hand side was Steven's face. It was great. Loved it. Also, Gruber covered this. I will probably forget to put the link in the show notes, but Gruber was saying that it's really crummy that closing the device doesn't lock it because your natural inkling, if you're an old man anyway, having had flip phones when you were younger, your inclination is when you close the device, it should lock and then you can put it in your pocket.

41:42That's not what it does. When you close the device, it just switches to the outer screen again. This was kind of driving me batty and Gruber complained about this a little bit. and then uh steven roblez came in came up with a shortcut because apparently there is a shortcut trigger for when the device is opened or when it's closed and steven came up with a very very straightforward shortcut that says when the device is closed lock it then he improved it to say if when the device is closed lock it if it is on the home screen but if it's not on the home screen just carry on works works great it's really really good i'll try to remember to put a link in the show notes again no promises like it's a document right now see it perfect all right yes i will endeavor to remember to transfer them to the show notes that people can see uh the cameras yeah they kind of suck and right now it doesn't bother me too much because i haven't taken that many pictures but let me tell you we were at a football practice earlier tonight a flag football practice earlier tonight and it was getting dark and i took a photo with my camera and took a photo with erin 17 pro and hers was way better this is 17 pro mind you not 18 pro uh hers was way better so i'm not happy about that.

42:47That is one of the things that I was expecting to be unhappy about, and I am indeed unhappy about. Final two items, super fast. Tent mode. This is where you open it like, you know, 30 degrees or whatever and sit it on the desk. I do this occasionally because it's kind of fun to have like a picture display going while I'm working. That's kind of neat. Laptop mode, I think I've used once, and that was in the aforementioned call with Stephen on FaceTime. All in all, I really like this phone. I think I'm going to stick with it for the year. I'm unsure what I'm going to do in the future. But let me tell you, it is pretty darn nice to be a passenger princess or whatever and not having to worry about bringing an iPad with you because it's already with you.

43:27It's pretty darn nice if you want to do two things at once. Like at one point, Erin had been asked to substitute a couple of times and I was watching her fumbling about fumbling about just in the sense that it's burdensome, not because she doesn't know what she's doing. She knows exactly what to do, but she's fumbling about flipping between calendar, text messages, calendar, text messages, trying to figure out from this teacher that asked for her help, what days and what are we doing those days? Is it reasonable for her to sub, et cetera? You know what I could have done in the duo? Could have opened it up, put text messages on one side, calendar on the other, boom, done, easy peasy.

44:00I really agree with what everyone says that the multitasking on this is limited, but that is beautiful. I love the way they handled multitasking on this. It's really, really intuitive. Works really great. I really, really like this phone a lot. It is with compromises. In the same way, I think it was Marco said earlier, the original MacBook, the one-port MacBook, was a machine that was defined by compromises. And you can make that argument for this phone as well. But golly, did I love that MacBook. And golly, right now anyway, I really love this Duo a lot. I really, really like it a lot. I can't tell you if I'm going to stick with it, and I'm very excited for future Casey a little less than a year from now to share his thoughts.

44:42But today's Casey, I really, really like this phone a lot. I'm really surprised how much I like it. I'm surprised how little I'm put off by some of the things I thought would be deal breakers. The only thing that I think is really remaining a deal breaker to me is the cameras. And 99 % of the time, I'll have Erin with me anyway, so I can just grab her phone. This is a really impressive phone. I'm not trying to imply that Marco's wrong by any stretch of the imagination not at all also this thing's hilariously expensive especially if you were coerced to buy what did you say a one terabyte one or two terabytes two terabytes the joke I made about Marco's phone earlier is it's like the diner lobster from the famous SNL sketch and from real life in diners where you'll see lobster on a diner's menu and they just assume no one's ever going to order it but they always keep one around just in case that's the phone that Marco got every Apple store gets one of those just in case someone comes in And it's like, someone came in and asked for it.

45:33Do you believe that? We sold it to him. Amazing. Amazing. So, yeah. So, I am not trying to imply. I'm not trying to say. I'm not trying to subtweet, if you will. I'm not saying that Marco is wrong. And in fact, I could make the argument that I myself could make the argument that Marco is right. But for me today, I'm just having a lot of fun with this thing. That's what Adam said. You know, I'm having a lot of fun. And it is so wild what they've done to iOS. In a good way, mostly. what they've done to iOS to make all this work. I'm really, really digging it. I just want to congratulate Casey for not breaking it in the first couple of days of owning it.

46:09Yes! So let's keep those fingers crossed. You have no case, right? No case. However, I did notice, I really don't want to belabor this. If we want to come back to this another episode, that's fine. But very briefly, I noticed that AppleCare, which has been my case recently. Yes, I know it's not really a case. Just go with it. AppleCare is like$20 a month on this phone and you are no longer allowed to pre-buy an entire year of AppleCare, which would save you some money. And I looked at it and I did the thing that maybe I shouldn't, but I took the fall and I did AppleCare Family. So this is on it.

46:41Like 15 devices are on AppleCare Family and it is also very expensive. It's$50 a month. But like the entire family is covered. And given that we are starting to get to the point that children are going to have phones soon, it seemed like it was worth it. And again, given that this alone would have been$20, I figured, geez, why not? And I got a bunch of refunds. Like I had just re-upped on the 17 Pros for a year, an additional year for each of them. And I got a refund for almost all of that. I got some Apple store gift, Apple gift cards for a couple other things that I'd gotten AppleCare on. Cause I have, I'm not, it wasn't exclusively phones, but it was mostly phones.

47:15But now like Vision Pro is on this MacBook Pro. I'm pretty sure it's on it. Studio display, I believe is on it or that might be too old now. I forget, but you get my point. A bunch of stuff is on this. And I'm actually feeling pretty good about it now. Because now, some stuff that wouldn't have been on it, like, I did have it on Erin's phone for this year. But generally speaking, she doesn't have AppleCare. And she has broken a couple of phones in the past. Not catastrophically like me, but enough that it's been annoying. So I'm really, so far I'm happy with it, despite the obscene cost. And so, no case, no pop socket, generally speaking.

47:47But I haven't dropped it yet. We are sponsored this week by Granola. So if you're the kind of person that has a lot of meetings, which is probably almost everyone listening to me right now, then you might find that concentrating on what your coworkers are saying while also taking notes can be a bit burdensome and a little tough. Additionally, oftentimes you're in the midst of having a conversation and an action item or some other to-do will fall out of that conversation. And then it will fall out of your memory if you're anything like me. and that's no good. So what can you do about that? Well, Granola is an AI-powered notepad that makes your meeting notes useful.

48:24It captures what happens in your meetings and turns it into clean, structured notes with decisions and action items pulled out and made easy to find. And the best part, Granola integrates seamlessly with how you already work. No setup, no configuration, no friction. So I did a meeting with John to talk about ATP member special ideas. It was like a month, month and a half ago. And Granola listened and took notes on it. And it's really, really great. And not only does it call out the action items and whatnot, but it also will justify the decisions it made. So if you click on any line item that it comes up with, it shows a transcript summary.

48:58And then we'll call out the actual words that were said in order to get to that summary. And so it's really, really useful. So for example, there was a line item title, ATP Insider Show Q &A transcript summary. They landed on this after discussing the member special driven by one listener's question about ATP lore and deciding it was narrower than a general host Q &A. and then it has an actual quote from John and then it continues with the summary. Then they explicitly workshopped the title and agreed to simpler framing fit because the episode would cover mostly show history, but not only that.

49:26And again, more quotes after that. It works really, really well. And if you're like me and super forgetful, it can really save your bacon. So once you try it on a first meeting, it's hard to go without. You can try it totally free. Head to granola.ai.atp. That's G-R-A-N-O-L-A.ai.atp to get your time back. Go to granola.ai slash ATP and try it on your next call. Thank you to Granola for sponsoring the show.

49:54Here's the deal, listeners. We are roughly an hour in and we got a lot of crap left to talk about. So the three of us are going to endeavor to try to be very quick about the stuff. Yeah, buckle up. We're going to try to speed run it. We're going to try to be quick about the stuff that leads up to the MacBook Pros. And then we're going to let the MacBook Pro air out a bit. or at least that's the theory. Again, as always, laugh as you look at how long these chapters are and laugh at this sweet summer child that doesn't know what the future brings. All right, so John, let's start and let's try to do this chronologically.

50:25And we'll start with this past Monday, which is the iPad Mini. Yeah, Apple releasing things on a series of days instead of one big event. Sure, why not? It gives you more time to make notes. The previous iPad Mini was A17 Pro. This one is an A20 Pro, which is a nice update. It's about the same size, a little bit less heavy. it's like 38 grams less to 34 grams less depending on if you get cellular uh this kind of like we're going to see this in a lot of products that we talk about today we say it's about the same size we're talking sub-millimeter differences in length width height or maybe one or two millimeters really weird that like they didn't make them exactly the same size but they're almost exactly the same size storage is the same as the old model 128 256 512 um the a20 is an a20 but you get dinged some cores if you get like again tied to random stuff it's tied to storage so if you get 120 and 256 gig storage you get your downwind efficiency core and you get one fewer neural engine so only one of the two neural engines works like the a20 pro is two neural engines but you just get one if you don't get the 512 gig model if you get the 512 gig you get all the cores working which is a bummer but whatever just be aware um the big story is that it's an oled screen and it's 8.5 inch instead of the old one was 8.3 they call it super retina xdr because they love long names for screens that will also come up later 1200 nits peak hdr the previous one didn't have hdr at all and it's 600 nits sdr which is up 100 nits from what it used to be 25 or 24 thinner bezels and every time i make the bezels thinner on the ipad i'm like so is this just like impossible for me to pick up now like i know they have the touch rejection or whatever but wow they're they were already so small anyway it's a 23 16 by 15 12 uh 326 ppi the ppi is the same as the old model but it is 50 pixels wider and uh 24 pixels higher okay sure apple um it does have nanotexture available so i know marco and many others are super excited by that it is an option on the 256 and 512 only i think which is weird yes market segmentation no promotion 60 hertz only and apparently it supports extended display mode when connected to an external display if you have ipad os 27.2 and apparently this does not work on the old minis even with ipad os 27.2 which is a bummer it's got the n1 chip which gives you wi-fi 7 bluetooth 6 and thread radio c2 for cellular um so it's got all the latest apple chips uh 12 megapixel center stage landscape camera which means it's on the long side now instead of the short side um it has an acoustic display instead of normal speakers yeah this was fascinating yeah uh this is what apple says specially designed woofers are paired through the display to produce punchier bass and more volume in addition custom tweeters are now hidden between the glass and aluminum enclosure for clear highs the acoustic display also features a sealed enclosure that helps ipad mini achieve its ip67 rating so the idea is they vibrate the screen that is the screen is your speaker and this is very uh well established technology in the tv world i think my tv and has but it's been it's been in tvs for years and years where i don't know why they do it in tvs but they do like i guess to try to make the sound feel like it's coming from the screen and not from like especially a flat screen like where are you going to put speakers if you have them front facing it's weird and they all the tv makers want to have like no bezel type things where it just looks like a screen so where do you put the speakers now they're firing backwards they're firing upwards i've got it why don't we just make the screen shake and then some tvs went so far as to try to find like the person's mouth on the screen and make the sound come out of it you know anyway shaking the screen is a well-established technology, but I will tell you that shaking the screen is not an ideal speaker.

54:01There's a reason real speakers are not made of a gigantic piece of glass, 65 inches wide, right? So I think it's a good idea for an iPad though, but I do wonder how it's going to sound. In my experience with televisions, it doesn't sound good. I don't know if it sounds better or worse than crappy TV speakers, but it sure doesn't sound as good as any kind of real speaker that's facing you but for an ipad mini that probably had crappy speakers already maybe it actually is better and especially if they put like more drivers into it and again sealing it up so there's like fewer places for stuff to go in i didn't look up what ip67 is i think the six is the dust and the seven is like splash resistance or something but not dunking i thought it was the other way around i'm not confident that that's right anyway the whole idea of like where are the holes we've got the usbc port which i think is already pretty well sealed but the speakers are always a problem because you got to make them like the apple watch where you have like there has to be a hole for the speaker to work and when water fills it we have a feature that pukes the water back out you know uh the screen using the screen as a speaker basically solves that and i think the ipad mini screen is big enough perhaps to get decent bass out of it whereas the watch screen probably isn't so anyway uh still no face id in case you're wondering this is not a tiny ipad pro even though it has an oled screen it remains an ipad mini segmented into that place again no promotion no face id even though i feel like it could fit uh midnight and starlight colors all the prices are up 100 bucks nano texture is also 100 bucks and cellular is 150 extra pre-order is october 28th in stores november 6th and also finally they have a new smart folio case um actually i didn't put a link to that in there so i don't know what it looks like but yeah they love the tech woven stuff there's a tech woven case for the ipad mini marco are you excited about this are you going to get one?

55:43Marco Arment: I have already ordered one because the pre-order was earlier today. I think this is going to be really fun. So I've gone back and forth with lots of, you know, iPad logistics over the years. At first, I tried to use it as, you know, a tablet. And then when the keyboard cases came out, I learned that it's so much nicer entering text with a keyboard than any other way. and that really killed my love for the iPad mini because while keyboard cases do exist for the iPad mini they're so much more cramped than the full-size iPad ones that they're they're pretty hard to use also Apple makes the best keyboard cases for iPads and they don't even make one for the mini because it would be way too small so you're stuck with like third-party ones that don't work as well and just aren't as well made honestly and so the external keyboard situation is pretty dire for the mini.

56:38Marco Arment: And so I kind of fell out of the mini for a while. But the problem with the big iPads is that ever since they went to the Magic Keyboard, especially an iPad Pro with a keyboard is just really heavy and bulky. And at that point, you're so close to a MacBook that you might as well just get a MacBook. And so that's what I've been doing. And so I really haven't used the big iPads much at all for in recent years. But then I started working on Fineliner, which is a pencil based drawing app and it works really well on the iPad mini and the iPad mini happens to be a really good size for what I want out of a note-taking device it's great and so I started using my iPad mini again and I've just been so happy using it and what they've done here with this new one is they have not pushed the iPad mini into being more of a laptop replacement They've made it much better at being what it already was.

57:39Marco Arment: So to be a laptop replacement, you need keyboard input. You just need a keyboard. Simple as that. On-screen keyboards are nothing compared to a keyboard case. But what this is pushing into is both small pencil use and also consumption. That's what many iPads, maybe even most iPads, are used for is watching video and reading stuff and browsing the web and stuff like that. And I think for that, if you're not like having to type a lot of text, this is a great device. Now, the new iPad mini is only one gram heavier than the iPhone Duo. And the screen is significantly larger. It's in the same ballpark, but it's larger.

58:23Marco Arment: And I think if what you want is roughly that size class device to use, you know, always open, You can't fold it, obviously. Or as our friend joked in Slack, you can fold it once. I was going to say, if you have this thing in your house, the fear is you're going to pick it up one day and try to fold it. Yeah. But as that device, as mostly a content consumption or very light productivity device or like note taking or something with the pencil, for that, it's awesome. And look at what they are doing with this. they made it substantially lighter, a little thinner, and water-resistant. And with Nanotexture, they're competing with Kindles.

59:09Marco Arment: That's what that is. That's why they're doing that. Kindles are great with glare because they're e-ink. So that's what Nanotexture is for in this context. And Kindles are water-resistant. That's what that's for in this context. And so what this does is it takes a device that already, it doesn't do everything the iPad Pro does, but it kind of goes in places the iPad Pro doesn't go. And they've taken it and moved it further that way. It is way smaller and way lighter than the other iPads now. It has water resistance, which none of the other iPads do. And it is going to be much easier to hold in your hand for a long time.

59:49Marco Arment: And by the way, nanotexture is way more affordable on this than on the iPad Pro. Because the iPad Pro, I believe this is still the case, doesn't it still require the one terabyte configuration? I mean, this one does require the not lowest config for nanotexture. Yeah, but you can get it with 256 for 800 bucks. It's a very different price point for nanotexture on an iPad. And I also will point out that if you're comparing pricing this, I just said they were all$100 more than they used to be. That means$120 to$700,$256 is$800, and$512 is$1 ,000, and then plus$100 for nanotexture. But that still means you can get two OLED iPad minis with nanotexture, tape them together, and it costs as much as a Duo.

1:00:31Marco Arment: That's the thing. So the value of the Duo is it's always with you. It's always in your pocket, weighing it down and pulling your pants down, but it's always in your pocket. but if what you want is a phone is like the best phone and the best tablet in that approximate size class i think what you want is an iphone pro and the new ipad mini which the combination of which costs as much as the iphone duo so but but then of course it is two separate devices which has its pluses and minuses i think mostly minuses don't discount the two ipad minis taped together it's the ultimate duo just don't fold them together too hard you'll crack the glass yeah but anyway so i did i did order one of these um what they've done is they've pushed the mini more pro but not all like i do wish i think everyone wishes they would have gone a little further because the mini has not been particularly inexpensive for most of its life like you would think a lot of times apple like the smallest product is the cheapest one and so they sell a whole bunch of them to people who just want the cheapest one or kids or whatever else The iPad mini, for most of its life, has not been that.

1:01:37Marco Arment: So the people who are using it are choosing it for other reasons. Over the last couple generations, they've tried to do little things, upgrading it in minor ways here and there. People mostly have complained about the screen quality not being very good. There was that tearing issue on the one two generations ago. They've made it OLED now. Awesome. And that's probably responsible for some of the significant weight and thickness savings. Awesome. They didn't go 60 hertz, or they didn't go 120 hertz. Why? Market segmentation. But they're pushing it into pro territory and all these other ways. That's why it has no face ID.

1:02:10I'm sure they could find room for face ID in there, but they don't want to.

1:02:12Marco Arment: What they have done is make it almost an iPad Pro, but small, like an iPad Pro Mini. And I will add that if you get the big one of these, 512 nanotexture cellular, that's like$1 ,200. That's a$1 ,200 iPad Mini. Yeah, but the iPad Pro is like starting in that range. I know, I'm just saying, it does creep into the iPad Pro range, but they didn't make this a tiny iPad Pro. They intentionally are not doing that. It's also not as cheap as a Kindle, I will say, but it's still staking out that, like, I'm not a pro, I just have some, whatever pro stuff has trickled down to me. And also for the chip, A20 Pro, that's a current-gen chip, whereas the Mini usually gets a chip that's been out for, like, a half a year or something.

1:02:54That's the thing.

1:02:55Marco Arment: So, like, between the OLED and the faster chip and the nanotexture option, like, they really are bringing a lot of proness to it. they just didn't go further now i don't blame them for you know for it not being an m5 chip like that's fine because this is a much smaller device that would probably not fit the power envelope and they might not update this for two years too sure but to to push the ipad mini into being even better of an ipad mini i think that's a very good choice and i'm honestly i'm looking forward to this significantly i think i'm going to end up using it a lot because of my new fineliner business and just because i'm getting into this you know as like a pen tablet i think it's gonna be awesome all right m6 imac john take us through it all right so there's two versions just like there was with the m4 imac and i think the one before it and the two versions are two thunderbolt ports and four thunderbolt ports which is a very straightforward way to describe the differences between these computers to be clear it is the same form factor that it has been in the past the colorful very flat uh imacs um all it's available in all the same colors and every model is available in all the colors i couldn't tell archive.org was failing me if this is new i seem to recall that at one point maybe the two thunderbolt ports model you could only get in two colors or something at least the very cheapest uh configuration of it it was only like it was like the the more boring set of colors and but it was still it wasn't like only you know silver it was it just it was like four colors versus seven or whatever i think they're all available in all colors but it was hard to tell maybe i was fooled by the configurator anyway um the two thunderbolt port ones gets a binned m6 because this is the m6 imac and the binned one is down one performance core and down one efficiency core uh and down two gpu cores and then the four thunderbolt ports gets an unbinned m6 which is nice uh ram you get 16 or 24 for 200 bucks more on and on the four thunderbolt ports one you have the 32 gig option and that also bumps up the ssd to 512 so it's basically a 400 ram upgrade plus a 200 ssd upgrade apple loves doing this because it makes my eyes cross when i try to figure out the pricing and specs and these things but they tie features together and so when you change one it changes another it's very confusing for storage the two thunderbolt ports one has 256 512 and one terabyte and the four thunderbolt ports one has two terabytes and the upgrades are 200 to go to 512 500 to go to one terabyte and a thousand to go to two terabytes nanotexture is extra 200 bucks it is a 24 inch screen uh it was a one extra 100 bucks to operate the ipad mini and uh i think the uh iMac is more than two mac mini screens but whatever don't try to do the math it's significantly more than two mac mini screens uh for wireless i think it has got the new n1 chip because it's got wi-fi 7 and bluetooth 6 that used to be 6e and bluetooth 5.3 ethernet was one gigabits when you when you got it but now for the two thunderbolt port model at a 30 extra you can get the little like power cord ethernet adapter because there's no room and the thickness of the device for ethernet that's the same as it's always been but the difference is for that 30 bucks you get 2.5 gigabit ethernet and the four thunderbolt port one comes with the ethernet thing at no additional cost so look at that an imac with 2.5 gigabit per second ethernet very impressive um for input the magic mouse is no cost and the magic trap pad is an additional 50 bucks keyboard with touch id is the same as it was this really annoys me if you get the two thunderbolt port one you get for free magic keyboard with lock key which is their way of saying you don't get a keyboard with touch id not because the mac doesn't support it you just don't get one if you buy the two thunderbolt port mac and you want a keyboard with touch id that's 80 bucks extra and the only choice you have i think in the configurator is magic keyboard with touch id and numeric keypad so if you want a small keyboard with touch id your only choice is to get the four thunderbolt port model because then you get the magic keyboard with touch id at no additional cost or the extended version of that for 30 extra and the reason this is all weird with the iMac like can i just get it with no keyboard and buy my thing separate apparently not but also remember every single thing in the iMac is color matched and i think it was the case that apple wouldn't sell you the color match parts but i think you can get them now but anyway it's an annoying situation come on it's the m6 model you can't put touch id everywhere i'm not even asking for face id anymore that's how beaten down i am just put give touch id so sad um the price for two thunderbolt port starts at 1500 and before starts at 1700 pre-order narrow now available in stores november 6th looks like a basic straightforward part swap for the iMac to keep it up to date and the m6 is pretty good i give this computer mostly a thumbs up cool all right wednesday today as we sit and record oh no i'm skipping one i'm skipping one shoot sorry tuesday still we got the m6 macbook pro this is a the base model macbook pro and there's a new one yeah i mean this is very much like the imac where they took an existing computer and pulled out its you know soc and put in a new one it's got the m6 uh with all cores working on all the models which is nice but if you get the one with 16 gigs of ram you get slower ram uh again it's like i think we talked about which computer i forget some other computer we talked about recently apple did the same thing if you get 16 gigs of ram you get 153 gigabytes per second memory bandwidth if you get 24 or 32 gigs of ram you get 170 gigabytes of per second of memory bandwidth and why they use slower ram chips in the 16 gig model awesome all right you gotta save money somewhere and that's how they're doing it uh your ram choices are 16 24 and 32 uh if you're upgrading from 16 it's plus 200 for the 24 and plus 400 for the 32 storage is one two and four terabytes going to two costs you a 500 extra going to four costs you 1500 extra the screen is the same as the old m4 macbook pro it's a thousand nits uh sdr 1300 hdr uh pro motion nanotexture is 150 extra 70 watt charger to no cost 96 watt charger for 20 bucks extra and get nickel and dime for everything here unchanged size and weight essentially prices start at two grand pre-order now in stores november 6th a nice update uh with the m6 and it is the only as we'll soon the only MacBook Pro with an M6 in it.

1:09:13Yeah. All right. So that's a thing. But now we get to the good stuff and we're going to stop our speed run. I think we did okay. Look at us.

1:09:20Marco Arment: I think look at us. I think I'm very proud of us. Yeah. All right. So now we're going to be here for another six hours talking about the MacBook Pro OLED. This happened earlier today. If you'll permit me a two-minute digression, at 10 o 'clock this morning, I'm sitting there refreshing Apple.com and refreshing the Apple YouTube site or whatever. I keep refreshing, keep refreshing 10, 10.05, 10.10, 10.15. I'm not doing this like literally every second, like an iPhone. And I look at the live blogs, man. Well, hold on. I'm not doing this like an iPhone order, but I'm doing this every like minute or two to see what's going on at like 10.15.

1:09:51I'm like, why have they not put anything up? It was Pacific time. It's Pacific time. Way to go. Way to go, Casey. Good work. Just what are we even doing here? I knew it was in LA. What am I even doing? Anyway, so at one, when I was at lunch, that's when all this dropped. And yeah, there's a press, a newsroom article we'll link in the show notes. There's a like two minute product intro. There's also a one minute like commercial. John, take us through. What do we got here? Yeah. So what is this book that everyone thinks they're referencing? I'm not familiar enough to the book to know, but the longer commercial says if you give a Mac an OLED, is that if you give a mouse some cheese or something.

1:10:34Cookie? are you familiar with that give a mouse a cookie that one yeah give out what is that is that a kid's book i don't know i've just heard that phrase you're asking the wrong person all right anyway uh people are saying that references that uh the the ads are a little bit weird but let's start with the name of this product uh it is not macbook ultra it is not macbook studio uh it as as the the invitation said pro intel and uh you know they said we're here to talk to you about new macbook pros and they sure did the press release calls it this macbook pro with all caps pr o l e d xdr display so macbook pro with proled xdr display elsewhere on apple.com they say macbook pro proled xdr display or in the pop-up menu on the competitor they say macbook pro 14 inch proled xdr display parentheses m5 max woof all right sony oh so yes do you get it it's a macbook pro and it's got an oled pro oled proled i don't think proled is a nice phrase i also don't like to see it all caps also keep in mind that proled in all caps comes after the word pro so it's macbook pro proled but they didn't stop there xdr gotta keep going display awful awful product name it's not awful capitalization very silly proled sounds a little bit like prolapse I don't like it.

1:12:00Wow. Wow. Gracious, John. Don't like it. All right. Anyway, let's get to the good news. The light up Apple logo is back. Oh, my God. I'm so happy. That is the best part. This is, we are three old men. Totally get that. This is the old manniest old man thing to be excited about, but I'm so excited for this.

1:12:19Marco Arment: No, because when Turner's posted that teaser with like the bat signal kind of style of like projecting it, I was thinking, oh, my God, is the light up Apple going to be back? because like oh i'm so happy because here's the thing there is no purpose that it serves it is just there for delight and that is something that apple used to do a lot and they really didn't do it much past about about exactly 10 years ago when they launched when they removed the light up apple logo in 2016 yes when when they launched the the touch bar generation of macbook pros that had the butterfly keyboard and removed all the ports and everything that they removed they like stripped away all of these little delights i am happy to see this back for a lot of reasons but number one i think it shows kind of just as a it it probably doesn't matter in a big way if you look at it objectively but what it shows is apple's current leadership likes computers again and likes apple's computers again and that you know what the kind of like the the big like dark night of the soul that we all went through for from 2016 to about 2020 was like it seemed like apple hated the mac themselves and we we were like but we we love the mac why don't you love the mac it's kind of scary if the people making the mac don't seem to love the mac that much and and it was that kind of like super like extreme minimalism johnny ivan tim cook stripping everything away kind of like we hate computers don't you hate computers let's make them as minimal as possible and but but no we don't hate computers we love computers and you're the only company that makes the computers that we love so we kind of need you to love them and what what's amazing about this update you know we went into this kind of showing our damage from that from that period saying like oh they the rumors are they gonna make them lighter are they gonna cut the batteries down like are they gonna and And I was worried too, are they going to take away any other ports?

1:14:18Marco Arment: Are we still using the SD card slot enough that we can still keep it, please? I was worried, what are they going to take away? What is it going to cost us? Because their updates during that time period, it was always like, all right, we took one step forward and three steps back. We made it better in this one way, but worse in the other ways that matter to you. And what's amazing about this update is that as far as we can tell so far, they didn't take anything away they just made it better that is amazing it seems so we you know the battery capacities are exactly the same in watt hours it's on the spec pages they didn't shrink the batteries at all well we don't know if they shrunk them but they have the same power well yeah they didn't shrink the battery capacity at all like it isn't there they aren't just playing tricks with like oh it's 24 hours now and it was 24 before nope there's no benchmark tricks like that the literal watt hour capacity of the batteries is the same.

1:15:18Marco Arment: All of the ports are still there. As far as anyone can tell, I think the keyboard seems the same. It seems like they didn't make any parts of it worse. They just got gains. Well, except the price, but they got gains from converting the panel to OLED, and that seems like a lot of the weight gain or the weight loss was from losing some of the backlighting components and all that stuff. If that's true, and so far it seems to be, It's just better. That's exactly what a product update needs to be. It's just better. And for, I would say, probably their most important product for most diehard Apple fans, that's really important.

1:16:01Most important product for their pro users. Trying to characterize it as weird because it's not their best-selling Mac. It's not their most important product. That's the iPhone. But it's their most important high-end product, I guess. most important high-end Mac lots of adjectives get put in here but the MacBook Pro is kind of the standard bearer for the entire Mac platform at this point because most people buy laptops this is the top laptop and even though it didn't get a new name and just got this stupid suffix this is the top of the MacBook Pro line as evidence by the price which we'll get to

1:16:29Marco Arment: yeah but this I'm just I'm so I'm so happy to see this like again like it does show our damage like how much we were honestly gaslit for a few years there to whatever degree that a computer can do that to a fan group but um it was it was a rough time being a fan of these computers for like four years and they've just been getting better and better and better since then and again like the rumors came around they were going to read us on the macbook pro and we all were like uh-oh you know getting a little nervous no this shows turnus has his head on right like and i i think this this bodes very well for the turnus era in hardware we don't know how he's going to handle a lot of other stuff yet.

1:17:09Marco Arment: You know, he's, he's very new to the job. We'll see how, you know, things like policy decisions, like, look, it remains to be seen. But I think this is showing, like, the hardware is in a really good place and is, and just keeps getting better in all the right ways. I'm so happy to see that. And to bring back the logo, the glowing logo on the lid, it's like, oh, finally, fun. And like a little bit of whimsy and a little bit of respect to what we used to love about this like you know enjoying apple's past like celebrating things that people love about their computers that's all here and i'm so here for it keep in mind that the laptops got fixed when tim cook was still ceo whenever that was 2021 or whatever when they finally fixed the laptops and gave it the good keyboard and put the ports back on and this lap this these models these pro-led things were started several years ago so this is all under tim cook these projects are happening so the turnaround had already happened now granted turnus was in charge of hardware that whole time so it's fair to treat it to him as well but the battle had already been won so in some ways it was a little bit again maybe like irrationally worried for us to think oh maybe they're going to screw them up it's like well what has changed inside apple that would cause them to screw up something given that these computers were started three years ago and the answer is nothing and so here we have them they're normal i will say for the light of apple logo someone somewhere inside apple slightly gave into the urge to make the logo bigger as they say because i do feel like the apple on the back of the thing is a little bit bigger than it should be it's fine it's fine it's just a little bit too big maybe they'll fix the next one um and unlike i don't know how actually this works because i don't think i was watching teardowns when it happened but people are saying that back in the day when they had the glowing apple logo the backlight the either led or cold cathode whatever backlight of the then lcd displays is what you were seeing through the the apple logo i don't actually know if that's true but i'm pretty sure it's not true with oled which means that the light up apple logo has its own lights yes which means they could do an rgb stripe color one someday i don't think they will they probably never will but third parties will maybe crack that sucker up and figure out a way to do it but anyway um they everyone who has gone to the event has said and shown that it dims with the monitor so if you if you dim the display down with the brightness keys the thing on the back dims as well i would imagine it has to be independently controllable somehow because they're not those two things aren't actually connected it's all just software keeping them in sync.

1:19:33And I do wonder if like in like a dark classroom or something, it would be convenient to be able to like, you know, cut the light on your external thing, but maybe it doesn't make a difference, but I'm sure some will figure it out. Down to some bad news. These MacBook Ultra rumors had our heads spinning with all the things that it could be and all our hopes and fears. And one of our hopes was cellular. Nope. Nope. You would think given how astonishingly expensive these are, which we'll get to, you would think that maybe they could find a way to throw some cellular in there nope all right well you know look look this didn't take something away we never had it we still don't there you go and still no face id obviously all right let's get to the screen let's talk about the screen tandem oled which is what apple's been doing for their oleds and all their things it's 14 inch uh and the 14 inch well the 14 inch screen is 22 pixels wider than the non-oled version um according to apple's animation on their own website when they like zoom in on like the pixels of the display they show the sub-pixel arrangement um and i heard some people saying i've never seen a sub-pixel arrangement like that uh they're on every single led monitor and television it's this is the classic uh oled arrangement of a rgb but it's like a red rec a green rectangle on top of a red square and to the right of that a taller blue rectangle it is not what the current fashion in oled displays is which is rgb stripe where they do a red green and a blue stripe just like they are in leds um rgb stripe oleds do exist many manufacturers sell them in very many different shapes and sizes on big monitors small monitors phones blah blah blah this doesn't have one it's not as big a deal on the mac because mac os many many years ago stopped doing sub pixel anti-aliasing which is where they use the r the g and the b sub pixels as a way to make jaggy lines by using individual sub pixels the mac hasn't done that in years and doesn't but if you're using an os that does do that like windows if you don't have an rgb stripe subpixel layout and you try to look at text they get weird color fringing on them i don't think it will be noticeable on this have you noticed it on your phone because guess what your phone doesn't have an rgb stripe screen either and hasn't in the entire oled era so just fyi this is not an rgb stripe oled rgb i still think rgb stripe oleds are nicer if only because like of the i think this is what they call the pixel aperture ratio like how much of each pixel is light up and how much is not if you look at the sub pixel thing on apple's page you'll see boy a lot of that pixel is just black space with rgb stripe if you can shrink it then you get a red green and a blue stripe pretty close to each other so most of the pixel is light up and that helps with brightness and power use and all sorts of other stuff so anyway it's an amazing screen but be aware it is not rgb stripe um apple says that the touch center is built directly into the display panel not layered on top of it reducing latency so users feel like they're touching the content itself blah blah blah anyway i think that's pretty much standard one of their ads the short version or maybe it's a long one one of their videos says burn-in protection and then it's never mentioned again and i can't find anything on apple's website what do you mean burn-in protection there's lots of different kinds of burn-in protection there's pixel cycling where they they provision extra pixels on the display not pixel cycling like pixel shifting where they provision extra pixels and then move the display around a few pixels at a time so that it's not in the same exact place there's you know static logo detection where they there's all stuff from the tv industry none of these things can really help in the end because if you have some element that's on your screen and it's very bright and it doesn't move shifting it around is just going to smear the burning edges which is better than a sharp burning edge but it's still burning uh and reminder how burning on oled is because the pixels have organic material in them that wears out the more you use it and the more you use it meaning how bright are you driving these pixels in whatever these sub pixels in whatever color so that's just the nature of oled over time they wear out they have uh compensation cycles that they run where they try to figure out how much the pixels have worn out and try to under drive the pixel other pixels around them so it continues to maintain an even display again this is nothing new our phones have had oled forever our ipads have had oled for a pretty long time now a mac has oled granted a mac has a different environment than your phone your phone is uh you know even with the always-on display that's kind of dim and you're trying it on and off and putting it away same thing with ipads a mac could be on all the time maybe it's bringing back the the uh purpose of screensavers uh back in the day with crts you know there was like a reason for it and now with oleds maybe there's a reason for screensaver we saw just pretty images just to get changing pixels on your screen but um maybe for next week i would love to learn more about what apple is doing for burn-in protection because they did mention it oh here's another no uh it does have a touchscreen we'll get to that in a second we didn't mention it before sorry because we just assume you all know the rumors anyway no apple pencil support so you can touch the screen but you can't poke it

1:24:30Marco Arment: that's look having having experimented a lot with the apple pencil with the iphone duo with like it not being good on a surface you're not gonna like flip your laptop up on its screen so that it's against the desk they'd have to have the screen like bend around backwards you know like other things yeah like original tablet pieces the convertible type tablet pieces did that um yeah that's you don't want that yeah so anyway just that's why no touch screen doesn't mean pencil no pencil support it's it's promotion 120 hertz a thousand that sustained two thousand nits max which is really nice uh and the uh they'll do a thousand it sustained so they'll do a thousand nits in sdr for like outdoors and 2000 peak uh nanotexture is 150 bucks extra um the non-nanotexture has what apple says is a state-of-the-art anti-reflective coating i don't know if that means just the same anti-reflective coating they've always had on the screen but they made a little bit of hay about how their anti-reflective coating is better and supposedly better for touching the screen as well it's also got all the apple's color calibration stuff uh with their color apple color matching function 2026 that we talked about in the past episode um it supports gen lock so you can synchronize the with uh well here's i'll read apple's thing because i don't honestly i don't know what gen lock is with support for gen lock macbook pro with pro xdr display synchronizes the display's refresh rate with the camera's capture to minimize ghosting tearing and other visual artifacts so you go it's syncing with the camera so you what you're seeing on the screen is uh in sync with what the camera is seeing in its sensor uh and finally for the screen it has a dynamic island instead of a notch which we talked about at length about how this would manifest itself um i still think it's a little weird but software wise apple is doing what you would expect so now that it's a dynamic island but not a notch everything expands from that area i don't know if it does this in the notch ones you guys can tell me but do they do the same thing with like when you do uh siri does it pop out of the notch or does it just go in the middle of your screen it just pops up in the middle of the screen yeah well with this one everything comes out of the new dynamic island so if you have like a live activity thing if you're someone sending you airdrop and it says accept decline on my mac i see the accept decline thing in the upper right corner as a notification but on this thing it grows out of the dynamic island top center of your screen the dynamic island is very small it is like it's not a circle but it's like a very very small it's almost like two circles connected by straight lines when the two circles are touching each other it is very small but because there's a dynamic island and not a notch it does not go to the top of the screen so there's a bunch of light up pixels above the dynamic island that's what makes it an island i think that's a little silly because what am i what benefit am i getting from that if it was up to me i would say could you move that dynamic island up so it touches the top of the screen and becomes a notch so i get more pixels below it because that's what's more important to me is the pixels below it and in one of apple screenshots they show the dynamic island first of all their screenshots they show it with the i forget if this is the default but they show it with the not visible menu bar like where the menu bar has no background whatsoever right because that's how they want you to think of the display like oh the menu bar it's barely even there it's just words floating on nothing and then the dynamic island is between the words they show like this is some 3d program that has so many menus that they span through the dynamic island so it's like volume mo graph character the next menu title is animate but it doesn't fit between the character menu title and the dynamic island so there's a bunch of blank space then there's the dynamic island then it says animate simulate tracker these are all menu you know menu bar menu title names and then i look at the dynamic island and i'm like is that dynamic island lower than the bottom of where the menu bar background would be because if you move that dynamic island up so it touched the top of the screen you could make the menu bar narrower and get back some pixels i don't know i just i'm bothered by i'm bothered by this thing taking up space on my screen vertical space to be clear not horizontal space vertical space i'm because again like the whole point of this is like well if it wasn't there we'd have to have the camera in the bezel and you would lose those things anyway it's like it's all a bonus i get it but moving it down from the top of the screen is not a win for me so i'm not i mean i don't even use laptops so i'm not a particular fan of this i do love how tiny it is it's very very tiny width wise it's much tinier than the notch we're getting there but i don't like those light of pixels above it sorry yeah well i mean i'm sure it won't bother most people touch support now we're getting to it so it is it's a touch screen okay so a bunch of people have uh input on this and they really for in the little presentation that they gave which apparently was not very long it was not live screamed but a lot of people in the audience have shown segments on it so i feel like i've watched the entire thing turn this came out and said we got new macbook pros they have touch they have apple logo here they go and go into the room and take a look at them right it was longer than that but it was not much longer so here's steven levy at wired quoting john turnus talking about touch stuff because of course everyone's going you said you're never gonna do touch the mac you said touch isn't good on the mac blah blah anyway so here here's uh turnus uh explaining it the mac is first and foremost an indirect input device built around the trackpad and keyboard but i think there's times when it's comfortable and handy to have touch we need to get to a point where adding touch didn't make the product lesser in any way it didn't make it heavier it didn't make it thicker that came together with the oled screen the best display we've ever put in a mac all these things and oh yeah it has touch as well so turnus's explanation and this is very clear both in what turnus says and whatever all the other c-level executives are saying also in the developer videos that we're going to talk about in a little bit.

1:30:05Every piece of Apple messaging in the same. The Mac is for keyboard and mouse, trackpad, whatever. That's the Mac interface. But it also has touch now. And that is reflected in the software they provide as well. Because that's the question all the people are asking. You said we would never do touch. Touch sucks on the Mac. It's uncomfortable. You shouldn't do whatever. And what they're trying to say is we wanted to do it in a way that didn't compromise the thing at all and it's not going to become a touch device it's just not it's a mac you use a keyboard you use a trackpad it's got a pointer it's indirect input which again greats because the mac was the original direct input but anyway uh in the modern day in the age of touch screens the mac has indirect input and it still does and they're not changing that and they keep emphasizing it um more from jaws uh greg jazwack uh justifying the but you you said Apple would never do this.

1:30:55He says, most pros own an iPad and almost every pro owns a phone, an iPhone. So this is something they're natural with. There's a generation of young creators and young people using our MacBook Pros that expect to touch. Well, I think they expect to touch because every other laptop in the world has touch. Also true. Right, like, and they're right, you know, because these people grew up on iPhones, they expect to touch it and everything expects to have a touchscreen. But that's the reality. We talked about this many, many times on this show before these were even like any kind of a concrete rumor that it just makes sense for apple to add touch because we all see people just stab at the screen with their finger and are kind of surprised when it and disappointed when it doesn't work and does that mean the mac is going to become a touch interface no but it just means every once in a while it's a convenient thing to do and for a limited amount of things it's actually better than using a mouse or a trackpad in some ways and they even got johnny serugian because remember he's not just the chip guy anymore he's the new john turnus he's the hardware guy uh so suruji says mac touch also involves custom silicon of course and a re-architected thermal system to prevent the display from feeling hot when people pinch stretch and swipe on it i haven't used enough touchscreen laptops to know if the screen getting warm is a problem but i suppose no it's a problem with the the way that macbook

1:32:13Marco Arment: pros have vented their heat has basically been they suck air in through those slots on like under the palm rests and they blow it out through the hinge. So I don't think it's necessarily a problem with other laptops as much as it would be a problem with Apple's previous thermal design if they didn't change it. I think they still do the same. They say it involves custom silicon, but they don't elaborate. So I'm not sure what the custom silicon is. And then re-architected thermal system would be what you're saying, Marco. Maybe they're sending the hot air out somewhere else. Or I don't know. But we'll see when they tear these things down.

1:32:41Marco Arment: I wonder if maybe because the screen is so bright, I wonder if maybe they somehow have like slots in it so that the the main fans of the laptop can shoot some air through the screen too no let's do that so what they do in the tv world um uh tv is a tv manufacturer will buy oled panels from the one or two makers that make whatever oled panel they need but then what the tv makers will do to differentiate their tv set from other people who use the exact same panel is they will all have some kind of innovative whatever some kind of proprietary material they slap on the back of the oled to dissipate heat we have a special honeycomb graphite layer we have a special heat spreading copper whatever like everyone's got something that they stick on the back of the oled to pull heat away from the oled and i'm assuming that's what they mean that they also bought an oled screen from lg or samsung or whoever the hell makes this and then they stuck their own proprietary heat sucking thing to the back of it um that's that's got to be it but we'll see with the teardowns um this is steven levy uh continuing here suruji contends that the current touchstream laptops suffer from wobble when fingers make contact to the with the display to minimize this effect apple has redesigned the hinge on the macbook pro to stabilize it so i'm very interested to see a teardown of like comparison of the hinge on the oled macbook pro to the non-oled one but that's that's a claim right from suruji that uh the other laptop wobble and ours i guess wobbles less because as you said marco it's not like you're gonna you know if you push your finger on the top of a laptop display it's going over like it's just it's just well also that's also how you adjust it like it can't be too hard to push because that's how you operate it yeah and opening and everything we'll see like they they've always had the variable effort where it's like it's easy in the beginning but not too easy it is a delicate balance apple has done pretty well with hinges setting aside the uh the duo screen thing which we will talk about in the next episode people don't worry um but that's the claim we'll definitely have to check that out uh now here is an article from wired with uh terrence o 'brien and and antonio gd benedetto oh no not wired the verge sorry um they say apple is adjusting mac os to handle touch by magnifying some controls when you poke at them like the red yellow and green traffic light buttons in the top left corner of windows to close minimize and maximize an app similarly tapping to open a drop down menu magnifies it, giving you a bigger target.

1:35:06And while MacBook Pro hinges are pretty solid, yes, you can make it wobble pretty easily with some firm taps on the top of the screen. So there's two things. One is commenting on the wobble. Yes, you can still make it wobble. They don't comment on whether it's better or worse than it was before. And then the adjustments to macOS. They posted this before Apple started posting its own videos, one of which we'll link, which is designed for touch on Mac. And they go through and explain this video pretty succinctly. here's what we're doing and their answer is everything looks the same nothing looks different everything measures the same your apps aren't going to break the mac is a keyboard and indirect input device but we added touch support and that's the message and it is very clear and it is refreshing as a mac developer that they haven't like made a giant fisher price version of mac os or they haven't broken the layout in every single one of our apps but they have done a tremendous amount of work behind the scenes to make mac os touch capable without changing any of that stuff and i don't envy them because so much stuff especially in like app kit which is a framework dating back to i think the late 80s early 90s when it was uh you know the next step open step days that's where all this came from um that those when they were making that uh ui toolkit they didn't have a notion of multi-touch on desktop computers it's like you have one pointer and you can click it somewhere and you can click it on a single control at a time and then you move it and you have dragging and it's like what do you mean multiple points on the display that are being quote-unquote clicked at the same time what do you mean multiple things are dragging we have to track all of them like that breaks everything it breaks everything having to do with anything so to begin with how they're handling this first they had to map all the gestures of like what does it mean to tap what does it mean to double tap and they had to map that to stuff so like you know a click with uh they say trackpad but i'm gonna say mouse clicking with the mouse is tapping on the screen double clicking is the same as double tapping drag or flick with two fingers is the same as drag or flick with one finger there's a guy on a trackpad you know when you do two fingers on a trackpad it's scrolling that's one finger on the screen because so you don't have to take two fingers on the screen to like scroll safari window it's just like on an ipad pinches the same in both places context menu is tap with two fingers on a trackpad but on the screen you tap and hold uh and then drag is click and drag on a trackpad and on the touch screen it is tap hold and drag and they demo this when you tap and hold the context menu appears but just ignore that and start to drag so they've kind of overloaded that one gesture which is tap and hold but they're basically out of gestures they didn't want to make you do two fingers or whatever and there's other stuff built into mac os like three finger swiping on the screen to go back and forth on apps three finger swiping up on the screen to do like expose and all that stuff it's what you expect the next clever thing they've done is what they call expanding controls and i'm encompassing two things in that they just talked about one but one way of expanding controls is they just made the touch areas of controls bigger without making the controls bigger kind of like like the letter e on the keyboard is it's the same size visually but when they think the next letter of the word is going to be E.

1:38:13The actual touch target for the letter E is much bigger. They do that with all the controls and all their framework. So like they show like a save button that looks the same size as it always been. But guess what? The touch area extends beyond the bounds of the save button. Same thing with, you know, check boxes and pop-up menus or whatever. The thing on the screen is the same size, but the part that you can touch with your fat finger is much bigger. And they claim the bigger area is coincidentally exactly the old 44 points on the original iPhone size that they always said like a minimum touch target of 40 never mind they violate this all the time but they they're saying that it's uh whatever it is on max screen it's 36 points and that is equivalent to 44 points on the with the old ios guidelines so bully for them for making a matchup exactly now as for the controls that actually visually expand we talked about this rumor a while ago and it is much more tame than i thought it was going to be um so some examples from the video if you pull down a menu from the menu bar with a mouse or a trackpad it looks normal but if you tap that menu with your finger every item in the menu is spaced out more it's not double the spacing it's maybe like 20 more space in between them but it just makes it easier to tap the item you want or to drag down to the item you want with your finger and they show it side by side basically your menus get taller i suppose this could break some people's layout because you i never expected that menu to go off the end of the screen but the menuing system will handle that and just having a scroll but that's one way of expanding controls another one this is one near and dear to my heart currently working on an app that has about 50 of these controls in it the stepper control where you have a text field and then like an up and a down arrow and you can make the number in the text field go up and down that may be the smallest standard control in mac os because the stepper is the same height as the text field but the stepper has an up like little chevron and a down thing.

1:40:06So it's half the height of a text field. That's how big the buttons are. It's fine to hit them with a trackpad or a mouse because you got a little pointer and it's very accurate and you have pixel precision with it. But try hitting the up or down stepper with your finger. That's really hard. So the way they do it is if you touch that little stepper, the little stepper control expands to be like four times the height and twice the width it was before with big, fat, friendly, touch-friendly buttons. So you touch it once and it's like, and it zooms out into this big capsule of touch-size controls.

1:40:38So then you can go tap, tap, tap, up, up, down. You can drag between them. That's very clever. Sliders, they do the same thing. Sliders are fine to control with your finger, but what if the slider is really short? And when you put your finger on it, you can't even see where it is in the slider anymore because maybe the slider is only twice the width of your finger. Now, when you tap a slider, it zooms out to be this big, giant slider floating above your UI, and then you can use it more easily and then the final example that gave was a control that i haven't seen in ages but it's the little like circular volume dial control that is about the same again about the same height as a text field and you can like rotate it uh you tap that sucker and it becomes i don't know 10 times the height with it with a little uh touch thumb that you can scroll around with so again this only happens when you touch it with your finger when you use it with mouse it's the same as it always does when you touch it with your finger some bigger thing appears that first touch doesn't count towards using the control it just makes the bigger control appear and then you use it with your finger and that's basically it that's what they've done to mac os to make it more touch friendly setting aside all the other stuff of like of course you can pinch and zoom in maps and you could swipe to scroll and you know all the things that you would expect to work everywhere if you're using an ipad app or a iphone app in the iphone simulator now you can just touch it on your screen i know it's i know you keep your things up in clamshell mode but that might actually be useful to actually touch your you know simulator thing instead of using the weird like uh virtual circular fingers or holding an option or whatever the heck you do these days whatever the kids these days do their option keys i don't know do you guys you do stuff in the you have to use your apps in the simulator you're not always using it on device right correct all the time yeah yeah well i don't know but if you have you have your uh desktop laptop in clamshell mode you're not gonna be able to take advantage of this so you should open the display up and now you can touch it you can touch it in the simulator oh yeah one of the other things they showed in lots of the software demos this is not a sort of os level framework thing although it kind of is they showed like i don't know what app this is let's pretend it's logic but some app that has like a on-screen representation of the level sliders that you would see like physical level sliders in like a music studio and you can just move four of them at once put four fingers on the screen grab them go them up or you know like it's something you can't do with the mouse because the mouse you click one of the virtual sliders but in you always see them in like the you know 70s music studio you got your hands on the sliders and they're moving multiple sliders at the same time go ahead of course they show an on-screen piano keyboard now you can play piano with multiple fingers on your screen couldn't do that before the mouse cursor so yeah all the normal stuff that you would think would work does work and how practical is that how many people are going to be adjusting the the faders with multiple fingers on the screen of their laptop i don't know but it's a thing you can do now because it is a multi-touch screen honestly i think this is a

1:43:19Marco Arment: great way to have done it. And we've been saying for years, like they probably do need to add touch screens to their laptops because everything else is a touch screen in everyone's lives. Young people expect every screen to be a touch screen. Many people touch their laptops now because they are accustomed to touching everything else in their lives of all ages. And we've talked about, I pinch and zoom paper magazines sometimes. Yeah, exactly. We've all done that. You just built it into your brain at this point. We've all done it at least once. And so I think enough people expect screens to be touchable and to respond to things like pinching and scrolling that if you have a major computing device that doesn't have touchscreen input now, it feels broken to a lot of people.

1:43:57Marco Arment: So they had to do it. And I'm glad they didn't basically turn macOS into iPadOS to do it. They did little adjustments here and there, but for the most part, macOS will still look and work the same way as it did before when everyone's not touching it. That is exactly the right amount of accommodation that I think it deserves. And so, again, I think they did a really nice job so far. I mean, we haven't used it yet, so we'll see what it's like in use. I don't personally plan to touch my screen almost ever. One thing I will be curious to see is, with the new screen, they've raised on the whole laptop, there's a whole new screen stack in there.

1:44:41Marco Arment: Will it be better, and maybe this is part of the consideration for making it touchable and maintaining that long-term, will it be better at resisting the keyboard imprint problem on the screen and if you do get the keyboard imprint will it be more easily cleanable because why do you think it would be better because if they are making a screen that's designed to be touched maybe they've made it a little more cleanable that's what I'm hoping for yeah I don't know about that again you know it's kind of you know I know it's I know it's a bit of a stretch a bit of a wishlist item there but since it will now be even dirtier for many people because they will be touching it regularly that would be nice to have maybe all the fingerprints will hide the key cat you know because you see it now because the key the key grease is makes little like squares right so maybe there'll be so many fingerprints that'll just be like it'll blend in anyway i don't plan on touching my screen but i'm glad that it's there getting back to the hardware finally uh it comes in space black and silver no new colors uh the soc uh i saw a grouper because grouper is obviously not keeping up too much with the rumors or doesn't believe them anyway um it's like people are saying that there's not going to be an m6 uh max or pro that seems weird it's like yeah that's the rumor and guess what it's true you get an m5 pro and m5 max with binned and non-binned varieties that i believe are essentially the same binning and non-binning for the um as the non-oled version because these are chips that have already been in macbook pros um with all the same price adjustments and everything that go with them which is annoying um size and weight here's where we get some interesting stuff because as mark already alluded like the rumors about this we're worried like oh no they said those last late big rumor you talked about where german said it's going to be considerably lighter oh no are they going to take out battery are they going to make it too thin they're going to remove ports so here's the size difference 14 inch is almost exactly the same size but not quite um the biggest difference is that it is 0.2 inches thinner but it is 0.07 inches less wide and 0.16 inches less deep so it is smaller everywhere but mostly where you're going to notice that it is thinner but here's the real stat that wins one half a pound lighter both the m5 pro and the m5 max version are one half a pound lighter so in a thing that used to be three and a half pounds now it's three that is good weight savings yeah you will notice that like when you pick it up you will notice that because Because that brings it almost to the weight of the MacBook Air, which is 2.7.

1:47:09Marco Arment: And this is a 3.0. Going from 3.5 to 3.0, you will feel that. And it will feel a lot like the MacBook Air. And like I said, it's a little bit thinner, too, and a little bit smaller all around. The 16-inch, same deal, although not as big a difference. It's 0.03 inches thinner, 0.01 inches less wide, 0.15 inches less deep, 0.7 pounds lighter. Holy cow. went from 4.7 pounds to 4 pounds that's um again amazing three almost three quarters of a pound yeah a top tier laptop um and these these go to these go to the respective 0.1 pounds when you put the m5 max chip in them i don't know what the 0.1 pounds i guess maybe heat heat sink i bet yeah because because the way they built the max studio for a while is like the ultra had a copper heat sink yeah yeah the standard chip had like you know probably an aluminum heat sink or something and then the big one had a copper one they're probably doing something like that i think it's still that way yeah that's my guess i mean i you know the actual you don't think the m5 max weighs more yeah i mean it does weigh more 0.001 grams more you're right the chip definitely does weigh more but it's not enough to matter uh but yes it's probably like a larger heatsink or something and that's great it's amazing that they didn't emphasize this more because like they lost weight they didn't lose a lot of size they they lost a little bit of thickness but somehow somewhere they lost weight and as marco said before and as we'll get to it they didn't remove battery capacity it's exactly the same but i think it's probably exactly the same batteries like it maybe it's we'll find out it's like is it literally the same battery that's in the existing m5 pro and m5 max no the um the 14 inch gained like 0.1 watt hours or something so like it's like a slightly different spec but i that's the thing i i'm looking forward to the teardowns of this because you know a lot of times i fix it will like you know weigh the different components or whatever i really want to know like where the weight savings come from it can't all be backlights for the screen like there has to be something else they took out the lead weights that were in there before to make it feel expensive yeah right all right so looking at this picture wise having just i made a point to go look at these in the apple store because i don't have one of these and i just want to look at them again so when the new ones came out i would have a comparison and styling wise even though the people who are there in person say oh it's a lot like the old model but it may be a little bit more tapered or whatever but this looks so much like the existing uh macbook pro case obviously it's not the same case because every dimension is different if only fractionally especially the thickness but like i said it has all the same ports it seems to have exactly the same strategy for cooling like with those long slits along the size that the macbook air doesn't have but the pros do have you know for cooling well the slit on my 14 inch is each side is one long slit this one they're divided in two yeah i wonder if they did that because like the nut that because if you make a really long open slit you can pinch it together in the middle right yeah it could be for structural rigidity or maybe it's two different channels maybe maybe one's an exhaust i don't know like who knows i i do i do find that slit to be slightly uncomfortable when handling these it's a little bit sharp edge maybe they've helped that a little bit but anyway if you were to look at this from a side um acoustic related because like you know they have a bunch of new speakers and stuff in there i wonder if that's part of the speaker design too but it really does look like the current model so it is not a radically new reimagining of what it looks like it's basically flat-sided round you know like all the same kind of practical no nonsense make a rectilinear container with pleasing edges where you can fit all the components like we said all the same ports you got i think it's the same ports in the same order yeah same ports in the same places and thank god they didn't mess up the ports didn't lose anything oh you didn't get we didn't get a better sd card slot but like whatever this is you know this is a weird thing because again this is a computer that they're releasing with the m5 pro and m5 max many months after the macbook pro already got the m5 pro and m5 max so it's not the new m6 anything it's not you know like the m6 one is a newer thing with two neural engines and blah blah blah but this is the the pro and the max anyway it's it's a little bit of a weird model presumably things will be right again with the m7 when you know these things go to the back of the back so anyway yeah as we said batteries are the same capacity within 0.1 watts hours or whatever uh no change for the ports magsafe 3 is the same mag safe that yours has right uh i don't even i think so yeah i don't know i think it's the same um obviously thunderbolt 5 all that other stuff from the other things uh ram their ram continues to be torturous if you get the m5 pro with the the binned one uh you can get 24 or 48 at an additional 600 but if you get the unbinned one you can get 24 48 with an extra 600 or 64 with extra thousand m5 max if you want the 30 core gpu you can only get 36 gigs of ram if you want the 40 core gpu which is the totally unbinded one you can get 48 64 at 400 additional bucks or 128 at additional 2 000 bucks same thing with storage they have to mess up the configurator m5 pro gets one two or four terabytes with two and four being 500 and 1500 extra m5 max you can get starts at two which is nice two four eight and 16 to go to two to four is a thousand to go to two to eight is three thousand and go to two to sixteen is seven thousand additional dollars for the ssd space but wait the options will get worse on later computers but yep seven thousand dollar upgrade to your ssd to go from two terabytes to 16 terabytes but this is the first time 16 has been offered in an apple laptop so that's good yeah but if you want to spend seven thousand dollars if you want to spend multiples of the price of your computer to expand your storage you can do it um the wireless stuff is all the same as the non-oled versions right wi-fi seven bluetooth six all the other stuff you expect yeah um they made a little bit of hay about the sound apple says high fidelity six speaker sound system with force canceling woofers and they say an all-new woofer design that provides 50 deeper bass and all new tweeters that shape sound dispersion for remarkable clarity and for the first time dedicated audio tuning for closed lid use delivers exceptional sound quality when the macbook pro is connected to an external display so users can enjoy a premium audio experience however they work what does that mean i am really curious like because yeah like i i never even thought they would try so my my best guess here uh is that when the lid is closed maybe they don't use the speakers that point directly against the screen in that configuration like the ones that are aligned with the keyboard.

1:53:38Marco Arment: Maybe they just turn those off and just shoot it at the sides. My first question is, does this mean that they're saying that they drive the speakers on the MacBook Pro differently when it's closed? Yes. Or does it mean that when your MacBook Pro is closed and attached to your next-door monitor, they change the audio leaving your MacBook Pro and going to the monitor? No. That's not how I took it. It's all about what's on the device. So you think they're saying we change how we drive the speakers in your MacBook Pro when it's closed. Correct. That's how I took it. That's how I would take it. I mean, I guess the only other, I guess, yeah, they wouldn't like use the laptop as the woofer or something.

1:54:14Marco Arment: That would make sense. Because I imagine they do processing on the laptop to be like, hey, when we're driving our weird little speakers inside the laptop, do this. Absolutely. Yeah, they definitely do. But when we're driving, when we're sending the audio signal out to the monitor, do something different. Almost certainly. I don't think it's necessarily, well, I guess it's implicitly about the monitor. i think it's whether or not the damn thing is closed but i guess it won't be closed unless you have a monitor nearby so i guess yeah it's weird because they say when it is connected to an external display but you could have the lid open when it's connected i don't know they don't explain we'll find out but anyway they're doing some audio stuff uh camera the only difference they had in their compare thing was advanced video stabilization which i don't know what they mean and why is that not in the other models because they literally have the same soc so i don't know what that is um the charger they bifurcate bad if you get the m5 pro you get 70 watt for free and 96 watt for 20 bucks extra the m5 max has 96 watt for free i'm gonna go out on a limb here and suggest that your 2800 laptop should come with the right charger no matter what options you have right yeah yeah i know it's just 20 bucks extra you gotta you gotta nickel and dime you uh external displays uh they're it's the same as they were on the other ones but just to remind that if you have an m5 pro you can drive up to three external displays over a single cable if you have m5 max you can do four external displays and the m5 max has display port 2.1 the m5 pro does not in general the m5 max has more display hardware and more gpu so it can do more displays if that's what you care about uh prices 400 extra bucks uh for uh in addition to the price of the non-oled so the m5 pro version starts at 2900 for that you get 24 gigs of ram one terabyte ssd and the stupid 70 watt power adapter the m5 max version starts at 4 500 bucks for that you get 36 gigs of ram 2 terabyte ssd and the good power adapter and if you max this sucker out with an m5 max 128 gigs of ram 16 terabyte ssd and nanotexture it will be 14 249 half of which is that ssd just bananas so i genuinely don't know what i'm going to do about this but i had told myself a year or two ago before ram pricing became lol uh i told myself that i was going to upgrade once the touch the touchscreen happened not because i necessarily want a touchscreen um i think the point about using it with a simulator is very valid but generally speaking the most i would ever probably do with the touchscreen i think is scroll from time to time but anyway i i priced one out to basically replace my existing m3 max macbook pro which i don't have any particular problems with but it's you know, three-ish years old now, and I feel like it's roughly time.

1:56:51So I priced out 14-inch space black nanotexture M5 Max with no binning because I want 64 gigs of RAM, which is what I currently have. I want 8 terabytes of storage, which is what I currently have, and I'm getting astonishingly close to filling because I really like having all my photos and some other stuff all the time. If I don't trade anything in, the total price to buy is$8 ,649, which is astonishingly expensive. Just ridiculously expensive. So then I asked myself, well, if I do this, should I lease it? Which I generally... No, please, please, let me stop you. Okay, yeah, yeah. You connect your laptop to three giant monitors.

1:57:40You never even look at the screen. The only difference between this one and then the existing M5 Macs and M5 Pro MacBook Pros is the screen. The screen means nothing to you. If you want to get a new laptop, get the non-OLED one, say 400 bucks. went 400 on top of 8600 like at that point yeah well that's because of your eight eight terabyte ssd it's really gonna kill you it is and i mean and yes i know people are gonna write me like you really need the eight terabyte ssd no i don't suppose i need it but i apparently you do if you're filling it well that's the other thing but i could make i could make moves so i don't need it but i should tell you some of my sob story about that in a future episode yes please i would I tried to save money on mine to do four terabyte and it's, it's a juggling act, but anyway, continue.

1:58:23Right. That's what I'm saying. And so I don't particularly want to downgrade, but I don't know if I want to spend 8650 on a new machine. And then I'm looking at leasing because I figure, you know, unlike a car, which we actually did lease Aaron's car and I hate that we did. It's just leasing is not my cup of tea. I'm not saying it's again, like the duo conversation. I'm not saying it's wrong for everyone. I just don't like it. But I thought to myself, well, I mean, I upgrade a computer every two to three to four years, so it may make sense in this context, especially with this pricing being absolutely bananas.

1:58:56But a lease is$183 a month, which is also astonishing. So I computed it, what is it, 183, so it's actually 182 and change, but$183 times 36 months is$6 ,588 or thereabouts.

1:59:15Marco Arment: There are also some tax differences for business expenses there that might be relevant. But agreed, that is obviously a lot of... But look, you're talking about a$10 ,000 purchase. But this is such the wrong time to buy. Because this is a weird generation where the latest and greatest MacBook Pros have the same exact SOCs as the ones that have already been out. it the big selling point of this one is it's lighter which you don't mostly care about and it's got a display and it's got a touch a touch display and an oled display and again you're looking at your three big 5k's you're not looking at the touch display it's like do not spend$200 a month or$8 ,000 up front and granted like you're like well i have an m3 so it is a big deal for me but like wait like of all the years to buy a new macbook pro unless you were dying for touch or unless you're like i use this screen all the time and oled's going to make a big difference in my life this is not the time to spend that much money now if you were getting a base model you're like all right well 2900 bucks and i'm gonna get a 14 inch it's fine like that's more reasonable and that lease would be more reasonable because you crave the 8 terabyte ssd and because you need 64 gigs of ram and because we're in ramageddon it just blows everything all out of proportion and like if you're gonna spend that wad of cash get the latest and greatest soc get something with an m7 get something with an m8 or something i definitely think you should wait no no no i i mostly agree with you i take a couple of minor issue with a couple things you said like for example i do care about the quality of the screen even though you're right most of the time i'm not looking at it but one day a week you're not yeah i mean again you're not wrong uh but that being said the the thing that i'm worried about is do i really think ramageddon is going to get better in the next year or two because i really give it three years well but that's the thing in three years i'm 100 going to be replacing this computer so don't you want to live like me a little bit and just be desperate for a new computer no sure don't as much as i love you no absolutely not don't see but that's what happened to me i was desperate at exactly the wrong time and casey you're not desperate at exactly the wrong time which is now yeah i mean i guess you're right i just am i am i screwing future casey because is what did we say the eight terabyte ssd is where was that it's three thousand dollars is it going to be four in 2027 or five or seven although by the way i'm pricing i didn't get to the second part of the pricing which is the 16 inch you're like oh that one starts at 3400 you know specs are the same 24 gigs one terabyte and the max starts at uh 4800 but then you go to the maxed out version of the 16 inch and the maxed out version of the 16 inch is 14 549 and because you probably didn't memorize the number i said before you're like wait isn't that the same price as the 14 inch once you get up to the maxed out price the price of like the 16 inch screen versus the 14 inch like that just becomes noise if you don't remember the maxed out 14 the maxed out 14 inch was 14 ,249 and the 16 inch is 14 ,549 practically the same price it's like when you buy a car you're like oh what's 200 bucks for floor mats because you're buying a 30 ,000 car right it's all the 16 terabyte ssd in the ram that's what you're paying for and some other stuff that comes with it yeah the the macbook pro like ever like the last generation macbook pro was always priced that way we're like the it was like all the same pricing basically but the 16 inch was a few hundred bucks more at every single tier but also like And once you get into 15 grand, a few hundred bucks becomes line noise.

2:02:31Marco Arment: Yeah. But also, I mean, look, I'm not going to say these are amazing prices. They're not. I think if Apple adds a high-end option, like a 16 terabyte disk that literally didn't exist before, and everyone's like, it's now$15 ,000. It's like, yeah, but no one's going to buy that. It's now. Says Mr. Dino Lobster. I know. You're going to go and you're like, oh, look, I needed a 16-inch MacBook Pro, and the only one they had came with a 16 terabyte ssd so i bought it for 15 grand i'm gonna return in 14 days i i mean yeah but like i need a laptop now i i do but i'll get to that but imagine going home to your wife and say i needed a laptop so i bought one for 15 grand but don't worry i'm gonna return this is the only one they have um no but that's i i feel like people are like they they raised the price to 15 000 like that's not that's kind of disingenuous like okay they added an option that almost no one's going to buy and that's higher but when you look at like you know what the where the pricing is now yeah compared to where it was 10 years ago it's a lot of money but like the m3 max that i have now like that was like seven thousand dollars when i bought it three three ish whatever it was years ago that that was and to replace it with the same specs now it's about i think it's about eight or ten thousand dollars so it's more but yeah but that's the environment we're living in like they didn't make the thing out of solid gold just to you know jack the price up like yeah no i'm not saying it's egregiously expensive i'm just saying like this is this is like apple is enjoying a grace period in which all the price increases we say well yeah that makes sense because we know their costs are increasing and we know they're just passing it on to us right and they're gonna make their margin but they were already before like what i'm saying is like the increased prices now it's just a a ramageddon inflated version of what they've been doing since the beginning of time and so yes these are expensive computers they've always been expensive computers and what you if you compare this you know try to price out like a pc workstation laptop for that has anywhere near these specs like you're not going to get stuff that's that much cheaper if it matches the spec for spec and if you don't need these specs great apple offers laptops from $600 up.

2:04:46And also these very same laptops without an OLED screen for less money.

2:04:49Marco Arment: Right, exactly. So like these are the top of the line and if you need or want it, that's what the top of the line costs. And speaking of top of the line, just going to throw this one in there. When the Mac Studio came out, they said, and you know, you can get it with up to 512 gigs of RAM, but actually 512 gigs of RAM isn't available now. It'll be coming in October. Well, it's here. And if you go to the Mac Studio configurator and you upgrade the RAM from 96 gigs, which is the minimum on the spec where you can go up to 512. You go from 96 gigs to 512 gigs. That option, I think this is the champ for the highest price option that you can click in a configurator to say, hmm, I'm going to go from 96 gigs of RAM to 512 gigs of RAM.

2:05:30That will be an additional$15 ,500 for that change in RAM. That's a car. It's a car, for goodness sake. Just one option, just changing the RAM. That's not the price of the computer. and that is ramageddon for you in a nutshell so there we are and by the way the maxed out mac studio is now 29 800 um yeah that's a hell of a lot of ram but just fyi that that is how much it costs if hey if you need to do local ai and you want to gang together four of these things it still might be cheaper than one of those 50 000 nvidia things but i'm not sure no i think this looks really good on the whole um i don't think i disagree with you john that because there's nothing actively like broken about my current computer i don't know that it's the right time to upgrade the only thing that worries me is i i genuinely worry that ram pricing is going to get worse and ssd pricing is going to get worse not better and if that's the case i should buy now but yeah i mean it really it really depends on like here's the thing having just gone to a essentially a downgrade in specs i have less ram and a smaller ssd because prices right having just done that the convenience of an m3 with the ram and the ssd you want versus an m5 without the ram and ssd you want i would stick with the m3 in a heartbeat just because like the day-to-day convenience of having all the ram and all the space you need versus having that all of a sudden to be thinking you have to worry about and to be clear i haven't needed to worry about ram but i have had to worry about disk space that inconvenience doesn't make it feel like a fancy a new computer and to be clear i cheaped out on my m5 max max studio as much as i possibly could for to try to make it so like yeah okay it's not as maxed out as my whole computer but this is a time you have a computer and i didn't spend that much for it you know what i mean like that's that was my goal um so if you're looking at this and you're like oh it's so expensive maybe i should get the lower spec one like that i feel like that would be a downgrade for you for sure because you've got you've got a system now that does everything you need has the capacities that you want uh that is fine for your purposes and downgrading from that especially in disk space because it's like there's no there's no getting around right it would just it would just feel worse for you and on the other hand you try to match those specs as you said it's now you're paying eight grand to go for an m3 max to an m5 max like that's basically what you're paying for and yes it has a nice screen and blah blah blah and stuff like that you're basically paying for like to be fractionally faster at a bunch of stuff that probably doesn't matter in the grand scheme of things so i definitely think you should skip these things just skip them entirely and even if it turns out ssd prices go up because they probably will um you probably shouldn't buy next year either you should probably buy an m8 like i think because look look at it this way what is it about your current system that is currently bothering you are things too slow and you're twiddling your thumbs and and getting distracted because compiles are taking too long how much faster would they be with an m5 how much faster would they be with an m7 or m8 like is that going to make a difference in your life and the OLED screen.

2:08:28Would you even notice? I would. I would. I take your point, though. I would notice, but I take your point. And yeah. Marco should get one, though. I'm sure Marco already ordered one. Marco did. There it is. What did you buy? All right. Oh, God.

2:08:45Marco Arment: They're nice laptops, Casey. It's very nice. So what I've been doing a lot recently, the number of times that I am a away from home has gone up in the last couple of years. I'm bouncing back and forth a lot more between the beach. I'm doing a lot more stuff going back and forth with the city. Oh, you got two of them. And the other thing that's changed massively in the last six months is I'm doing a huge amount more agentic software development. So what I've had is desktop laptop and laptop laptop. desktop laptop is the m3 max all decked out i've used it as a desktop it stays at my house most of the time if i you know go to the beach for the summer i'll bring it um but you know for the most part like i'm traveling with the smaller one when i'm just going somewhere for a day or or a weekend or something i'm bringing a smaller one and i've liked having two different computers in a lot of ways because like you know like i you know run the beta on the small one but not the big one and stuff like that like i would i would treat them differently but one thing that's getting increasingly high of a pain in the butt is trying to coordinate clawed code between the two and trying to coordinate any kind of AI project and operation between the two because these things just don't share well and also because like when I first got the travel one, the M4, the base model M4 14 inch, I wasn't writing that much code like on the train and on the ferry but when I would But I'm like, well, there's only so fast I can type and I'm not going to be held back that much by the build speed of this.

2:10:24Marco Arment: Well, that is very different now because now when you're doing a lot of agentic work, you are being held back by the build speed a lot. You're being held back by simulator speed a lot. And the simulators have gotten so slow. I have been waiting on my laptop so much these last few months as I've done more agentic coding, which it was the opposite of what I would expect. But that's how it is. Because in the background, Claude's cranking away, testing out different things, building test suites, running test suites, trying different techniques, trying different things. It's working my computer's butt off on my behalf.

2:10:59Marco Arment: And it could be doing three different things at once in different projects. And those are all just slamming the processor cores with background Swift compile processes, background simulator launches, all sorts of stuff like that. So my plan has been I really should probably upgrade that laptop with this generation and get it like a Pro or Max chip and a bit more RAM so I can do all that stuff a lot better. And then next year with the M7 generation, upgrade my desktop laptop all the way with the 8 terabytes and the 128 gigs of RAM and stuff like that. But I think that is actually the wrong move.

2:11:38Marco Arment: I think the move for me is to go back to one computer because of all of this agentic stuff happening. I think I need to go back to one laptop that is super powerful. This is the way. And, you know, and look, this stuff is changing a lot. So it's possible in six months I might say that's no longer the right move. I don't know. Probably not, but who knows. But it is getting increasingly obvious to me that the best way for my current computing needs to continue is to have one really awesome 14-inch MacBook Pro. I did, like for the last couple of days, I've been carrying around the 16-inch trying to use it as just my laptop laptop.

2:12:22Marco Arment: And I really don't like the 16-inch for that purpose. It doesn't fit as well in small seats on trains and ferries and planes and stuff like that. it is and I really missed my nanotexture display that I have on the 14 inch even though it has a keyboard imprint in it and so I figured okay what I really what is best for me really is to upgrade the main laptop and retire the travel laptop and just have it be one awesome 14 inch and I could wait for the m7 generation to do that that's probably if I was john that's more that's closer to what I would do. I mean, John would never buy a laptop, but that's closer to what I would do.

2:13:05Marco Arment: But I'm not John. I'm me. And so, of course, I ordered one. So I basically maxed it out in every way except the disk. It was a lot of money. And this is the main way I make all my money. So I think it's worth it. It's a business expense in every possible way. And it will literally allow me to work better and faster almost every day. And I think having it just be one computer again, it's not going to be better in every way, but I think it's going to allow a lot of efficiencies in a lot of my workflows and a lot of other stuff. So I'm going to keep the 14 inches that I have now as a backup just in case if I need another Mac, maybe install betas on it still.

2:13:49Marco Arment: But for the most part, it's probably going to become a transcription worker machine in my house and uh and i'm i'm gonna upgrade so i ordered the again the 14 inch mostly maxed out except for the the ssd and uh we'll see when it gets here are you gonna trade in the 16 inch sell it or someone in your house gonna use it where is that going i haven't looked yet to see like you know what you know what is the right move for that i i'll see what apple will give me for it but i don't know i mean it's you know usually when things are like very well optioned usually trade-ins are not very well priced for you.

2:14:23Marco Arment: Usually, like, a direct sale is better. I don't think I have any immediate family needs for it, so I think selling it is probably the right move. I don't want to take it. I don't know if he cares yet about having his own Mac laptop. He's still, you know, PC gaming. I think he's a little young to care about that, but we'll see. Anyway, so that's the plan. High-end 14-inch replacing both of my current computers, and the M3 Max is probably going to be sold. I get what you're saying about, like, trade tables and stuff, and it taking up my room but it's it's like three quarters of a pound lighter than the old 16 inch so would that make a difference or is it really just a little bit length and the width it's really about this like the screen lid size like you can't open it all the way when you have like a like a small seat and especially a bigger screen you're getting you're getting xcode on the 14 inch screen you're okay with that well here's the other thing i'm using xcode directly a lot less because a lot of the times i'm having claude fix the bug and i'm just reviewing it like in tower to see what did you do and I see oh all right yeah you did it the way I would have done it or better great check done like so I'm actually not spending as much time maxing out the screen space like what I've been doing recently I like I've I went to the beach this past weekend as like a little work retreat um to get all the stuff out and I like I didn't spend almost any time in my office I was like upstairs looking out the window with the 14 inch on the kitchen countertop and i just loved working that way and that's i realized that i've been using the 14 inch more than my big computer just because it allows me to work in other places and i've never been you you've heard me on the show for a decade i've never been the kind of person who didn't want to do everything possible in my office at my desk with the biggest monitor with the full keyboard with the mouse everything like that.

2:16:09Marco Arment: But honestly, AI work has changed that pretty significantly. And I'm more loving the ability to just be wherever I want to be. I can work better in coffee shops. I can work better at different parts of my house. I can work better while I'm traveling. So my needs have significantly changed and my usage has significantly changed. So that's great. And look, I've traveled with a 14 inch for a long time now so when i do actually dive in and use xcode it's not impossible i can also you know i've edited our podcast on a 14 inch again like you know logic is pretty cramped compared to a 32 inch monitor but it's fine i i make it work it's fine so for me the the ergonomics of using the 14 inch like in cramped spaces where i often am are are better overall than the 16 for my actual needs.

2:17:02What color did you get?

2:17:04Marco Arment: Silver, of course. Silver, 14-inch with the glowing Apple logo. It's going to be awesome. The thing I noticed, again, being in the Apple store and looking at all this stuff, I don't think it had occurred to me, or maybe I had forgotten, that they put black under the keyboard. Even if you get the silver one, they have essentially black, whatever, anodization or pink. Yeah, they've been doing that for a while. I kind of like the better one is silver. I do too, but they started doing that when they revamped it for the M generation. I accept that. Because I recognize that when it's all silver underneath it, like it was with the old, the old, old MacBook Pros, that does.

2:17:36Marco Arment: It still is with the Air. It does look old in a way. No, I like it better. But. It almost makes me, like, because at least with the black one, it matches because it's black everywhere. But, like, the silver one, it's, like, this big black hole. Anyway, it doesn't matter. I don't care. I'm not a laptop person. I was just struck by it. Especially, again, at the Apple store where it's sitting right next to the laptops that don't do that. Yeah. You know, the current. The Neo doesn't do it. The Air doesn't do it. I think those are the only ones. I think all the Pros do it. All right. Did we make it?

2:18:03I think so. I think we did. I mean, we skipped, well, maybe for next week or maybe some other time. We didn't talk about the Creator Studio update, and we may talk about it in a future episode or may not, because there is some stuff there.

2:18:14Marco Arment: All right. Thank you to our sponsor this week, Granola. And thanks to our members who support us directly. You can join us at atp.fm slash join. One of the many perks of membership is ATP Overtime, our weekly bonus topic. This week on Overtime, we'll be talking about, is Apple reentering the server market? we're going to be talking about that you can join to listen atp.fm slash join thank you everybody and we'll talk to you next week now the show is over they didn't even mean to begin because it was accidental oh it was accidental john didn't do any research marco and casey wouldn't let him Cause it was accidental Accidental It was accidental Accidental And you can find the show notes at ATP.FM And if you're into Mastodon You can follow them At C-A-S-E-Y-L-I-S-S So that's K-C-L-I-S-S M-A-R-C-O-A-R-M-N-T Marco Armin S-I-R-A-C USA Syracuse It's accidental Accidental They didn't mean to Accidental Accidental Tech podcast so long Hey Margo, I really wanted to try your app but apparently you're not making it available in the UK and I'm very angry about it.

2:19:47Also, I live in Norway and I really wanted to try your app but it's not available in Norway and I don't understand why. We should have gotten ahead of this. I feel bad it was a group effort but we should have it Are you ever going to make the app available in Germany Marco? So yeah

2:20:00Marco Arment: So what happened was last week's show I said in the after show I said like oh it hasn't so we talked about my new app Fineliner we're going to talk about it again in a minute but what I said was like it's still a review it's not out yet it'll come out sometime soon we'll put the link in the show notes when it comes out when you click a link to the app store to an app that's not released yet the error message that shows from apple is something like this this app is not available in your region or something like that yep um which is true yes it's true what it actually meant is this app is not yet available in any region but that's not you know apple's message kind of is misleading and unhelpful so the actual situation was the app was not approved until today so anyway and it's not again the people who sent this message it's not your fault it's apple's fault for their stupid error message.

2:20:50It should say, hey, this app isn't even on the App Store. It's not available in your country. So incredibly misleading. It is not the fault of the listeners. It's entirely the fault of Apple. Very frustrating.

2:21:01Marco Arment: Yes. Anyway, that is now behind us and I'm happy to say Fineliner is out. It's on the App Store now. It's free. Go get it. I have had so much fun developing this app. We gave a brief overview of it last episode, I will just reiterate, it is a really fun notebook app for iPad, iPhone Duo, and even a little bit regular iPhones. In the meantime, I actually did add like a text tool to make it more useful on regular iPhones than it was last week. I have had so much fun making Fineliner and the initial reaction so far from people are so strong. This means a lot to me for a lot of reasons. You know, Overcast has been my only major app for such a long time.

2:21:52Marco Arment: When I launched Unforgetful this summer, that was a very like personal app for me because it was about like, you know, my struggles with ADHD and trying to help other people like me. And that meant a lot to me as well. But Unforgetful is a very small app. And I wouldn't describe it as fun. It's very utilitarian, but it's also, it's a very, very specific app. It's like if you, if your brain works a lot like mine, and if you want your task list to be basically exactly what I want out of my task list, this app could be for you. But if you, it was a very narrow focus of like very high value to a very small group.

2:22:31Marco Arment: That's Unforgetful. And also Unforgetful is also basically done. it's a very simple app again by design i don't want to bloat it up with a bunch of additional features that would make it less effective and so there's not that much more to do besides regular maintenance over time fixing a few bugs here and there as they crop up you know adapting to new screen sizes i you know i adapted it to the duo you know like that kind of stuff but i don't think i need to really add a lot of features to unforgettable i think it's it's effectively maybe not feature complete technically but it's close to feature complete And Fineliner, I almost didn't release this app because I thought, eh, who's going to want it?

2:23:11Marco Arment: I wasn't sure what it was going to be. But then I started working on it inspired by the iPhone Duo. Number one, I realized I actually like it a lot on the iPad Mini, as I discussed earlier. And the iPad Mini is such the perfect device for Fineliner. but also i realize like this the more i've developed it i keep having more and more ideas for fun or interesting or useful features and when i do them i smile and when i see the results when i try the results i have had so much fun making this up and i've had the most ridiculous ideas and then I try to do them and most of them work. And I'm like, oh my god.

2:23:56Marco Arment: And I like, the delight that people are reporting to me that they have trying this app for the first time. I had that delight when I tried it myself for the first time. Sometimes you don't get that when you made it because you've seen how the sausage is made or you're too close to it to really appreciate it or whatever else. That's not how I feel about this app. It's so fun and so delightful that I am having that same experience as I use it myself. And I don't want to spoil much about the app if you haven't tried it yet. No, no, no. I think at this point, since John insisted on spoiling it last episode.

2:24:35I have a spoiler warning. I have not spoiled. Technically, I have not spoiled a single person. Everyone has said, hey, I stopped when you told me to stop, and I didn't get spoiled. Not everyone. There are plenty of people who are like, I couldn't wait. I just rammed through it. Well, I mean, they were fairly warned. If they spoiled themselves, they spoiled themselves. But I gave them ample warning. Everyone else who didn't want to be spoiled stopped the program, just like I said, and then they waited patiently for it to be released in Brazil. In any case, my point, the reason I bring this up, other than to fuss at John, is to say at this point, I think we can assume everyone is spoiled whether or not they've tried to do it.

2:25:07I was going to say no sense in spoiling because we already talked about the spoiler part. Now we can be spoiler free. So now our roles are reversed. I'm saying don't spoil it. Oh, all right. Well, I mean, I'm also happy to be spoiler free. Yeah, just go check it out. It's free. like you know it's literally a free app just go download it it's not free and then like it makes you pay immediately like it's free free free free free there is a thing to pay for in it but you can use the app for almost all of its functionality for entirely for free yeah i'll tell you like so

2:25:29Marco Arment: no ads it's a it's like a notebook app so you know you're drawing and stuff and what you pay for is additional pen colors additional page templates and uh additional pen widths there's that you get But not additional pages, right? Unlimited pages, unlimited notebooks, unlimited text recognition, all that stuff. That's all unlimited. No ads. No ads, and nothing is subscription-based. It is all, most of the features are totally free, and then the handful that I charge for, they're one-time purchases, they're family-shared, they're between$10 and$12. So it's just really, what I'm trying to do here is, in addition to just having a lot of delight in this app, And look, the other two of my apps are subscription priced.

2:26:16Marco Arment: That is what makes sense for them. But no one is delighted when they see a subscription. What I'm going for here is delight. And also functionality, but I'll get to that. But I'm going for number one, delight. When people see this, I've had it out in testing around a lot of different people and different groups of friends, occasionally strangers or other developers who see it over my shoulder or something. When people see it, they are delighted by it. And that means the world to me. It makes me so happy. So that was what I was going for with this entire app, was a delight. So I wanted to extend the whole thing from the visual appearance to the business model and also to some of the tech details.

2:27:06Marco Arment: Fineliner is a very playful looking app, but it's also serious tech under there. It is a very nerdy implementation of a very delightful app. Everything, all of what you're drawing with is all vectors. Everything you can export to SVG and PDF, even like, you know, if you can export, it has like its own native document format to like transfer the documents between different devices if you need to for some reason. They're just SQLite files. You can look at them. It doesn't matter. Do whatever you want with them. I don't care. Everything about this app is nerd compatible. There are no analytics. There's no accounts.

2:27:45Marco Arment: There's no logins. The sync is just iCloud sync. So it just syncs automatically with iCloud. That's all it needs to be. There's no tracking. There's no creepiness. And it performs well. It has the tech that you need. like you know it handles stuff you know sync conflicts and merging and all that stuff that's all handled for you don't have to deal with that i've had people fill the entire page with strokes so it's kind of like performance test like the stress test the engine and then i like you know take an eraser and take stripes through it or take a segment out and chunk it out and pull it out i made a whole text engine between last episode in this episode that is in 1.0 that's why that's what made it more useful on the iPhone.

2:28:27Marco Arment: The text, it is vector shapes, but it remains editable unless you really mess with it. But you can like drag text out of a text block. You can select it and move it out. The rest of the text will reflow around it. And you can drag in near the text, a drawing, say a graph or whatever. The text will reflow around that drawing. You can strike out through the text and it will erase that word and collapse the rest around it. There's so many features in here that are like technical fun. There's a lot of the app that you can, I will say you can customize. And you can export some of those customizations in ways that you might find useful.

2:29:05Marco Arment: You will see later. If you are into note taking and you want to use it for note taking, it indexes everything you write. Of course, it recognizes text. It also recognizes what you draw. If you draw a picture of a hamburger and you search the word hamburger, your picture will show up in the search results. there's all this tech underneath it. Because what I also want to do, not only am I delighting people, I think, and I hope, and I know, I'm not going to stand back myself. I know, they're telling me. Not only am I delighting people with the visual interface, but I also want to delight nerds when they go to do something nerdy and they find something like that.

2:29:40Marco Arment: Like when you go to edit text and it just edits or it reflows. If you're typing text with the default textbook, if you don't resize it, it aligns with the lines on the page. Of course, why wouldn't? If you have a line template on the page, why wouldn't your text align? If you select wide lines, it aligns with the wide lines. Whatever lines you select, it aligns with those. If you're typing into a text box and you hit the end of a page, it just turns the page and starts on the next page. Transparently, it just does it. What I'm trying to do here is make something that scales with your technical needs while still being this fun, delightful, app that is just super fun to use and makes people smile.

2:30:24Marco Arment: It is playful. It is a little bit retro. And it's super fun on the iPhone Duo, although it's even better, I think, on the iPad. Check it out. There's a lot of depth to it that you will eventually maybe find. But check it out. I think it's a lot of fun. If you want technology to be fun again, I think you will enjoy this. And I think that ultimately, I'm so inspired in part by the iPhone duo in large part because by that as i was saying earlier even though the duo you know i'm not sure if it's going to ever really be right for me but it is really fun and again with the macbook pro they re-added the the apple logo the glowing apple logo that's just fun that they that doesn't serve any technical purpose it's just fun we've been in an era of tech in for a while that fun has been pretty hard to come by in a lot of what especially what big tech was doing and i feel like right now we're kind of breaking out of that.

2:31:21Marco Arment: Fun does typically go in cycles, and we've been in a low fun cycle for a while, and I think now we're breaking out and we're having fun again. The Duo inspired that for me, and I'm having so much fun with Fineliner. I think it's the right time for it. And fun, you know, there's a lot of apps that I think if you use it on the Duo, stuff like the cassette player app and the toaster and the mini computers, These are apps that you'll download and you'll have fun with them for two seconds. And then you'll be like, all right, well, I'm done. Fineliner is not that. Fineliner, you will have that fun. But it's also really useful as a note-taking and doodling app.

2:32:04Marco Arment: And so if what you want is to have fun with notebooks or just to have a really good reason to have an Apple Pencil, give it a shot. It's so much fun. And it's also a pretty good note-taking app. And for all the fun you're having here, it is, I suppose, fitting that your business model is essentially the current video game business model, which is you sell cosmetics. yeah well honestly like so before you get it honestly like part of what i'm going for here is more of a game feel like it's like what if you know so it's it's very much inspired by the way i you know kind of stumbled through school was i tried to have fun with everything like i was doodling all over my notebooks and and by the way i can't draw and with fineliner that doesn't matter.

2:32:52Marco Arment: You'll see the aesthetic of the app is such that if you can't draw, it's almost better. But also, it doesn't require you to be good at drawing. It embraces our crappiness in drawing. I cannot draw for crap, and it's fine. Even the icon. I hired our friends at Parakeet to make an icon, and they made a great icon. But I ended up not using it because it was a very polished icon. And I made this crappy stand-in one. I had a page open in Fineliner that was like brainstorming different icon concepts. And this was the second one I drew. And I drew a bunch of other stuff and I had the icon from Parakeet and I was showing other people and they were like, oh, I like that one better.

2:33:37Marco Arment: And they kept pointing to this one. And I must have shown the app to 10 different people. Every one of them said they liked this icon the best. like what am I doing fretting over this why don't I just ship my draft like literally I did not draw this to be the icon I drew it as a concept of what someone else with more talent might make as an icon and then I shipped it that's kind of the ethos of fineliner it is very much like hey let's let's just kind of do a fun imperfect job it's it's it embraces imperfection in a way that is very fun But I feel almost like it is a bit of a game, certainly in the business model.

2:34:16Marco Arment: And you're right, it is basically selling cosmetics. Although there will be some functionality upgrades coming down the road as well. I'll spoil, I'm adding a widgets feature. And that's going to also be a purchase. Because that's a pretty narrow feature, but it'll be fun. But I'm kind of treating it really like a game. One thing you'll notice in Fineliner is I use as little stock system UI as possible. The entire UI is custom. Almost everywhere across the app, you're seeing custom UI. Even like I made my own dialogues and sheets and popovers. They're all custom because it fits the aesthetic. And when you see Fineliner running on a device, especially if you see it on an iPhone Duo, it looks striking.

2:35:01Marco Arment: it looks so cool like i i love the way it looks on the iphone duo so much it's it really is like striking and i love that like it it makes me feel first of all it makes me feel very proud of my work because i have always said i'm not really a designer this makes me feel like i'm a designer i'm not a very traditional designer but this app is my design and i think it has a great design i think this has an actual chance of getting me an ada for the first time ever and i'm and i'll tell you right now i'm going for it i am aiming for that ada this year i i really i don't know if i can get one but i'm i'm gonna push for that i'm gonna do whatever i can to get this app to be that caliber to maybe win an ada because i think it actually has a chance and i feel really proud of this design and i just that's never that's never happened before i've never been this proud of a design um so i'm very happy about that but we will uh we'll see how it goes i as of this speaking, I have zero sales data because it's been out for less than a day.

2:36:02Marco Arment: And I don't have any analytics on it. So I have no real-time insight into how many times it's been downloaded, what people are using it on, how many times things have been purchased. I have no idea. But my goal here is reach. I honestly, if I don't make that much money from this, but a ton of people use it, I consider that a win. That's what I'm going for. I want as many people as possible to see Fineliner and have fun with it and enjoy it. And if I happen to also make money from it, great. Look, the reality is I don't think that many people are going to be encouraged to buy my internet purchases.

2:36:38Marco Arment: But I just want as many people as possible to see this app and to use it. And for other people to see it running on their phones and iPads and for people around them to say, hey, what's that? That's what I want here. So here's hoping. Well, it's a shame because I had a quick advice for you. How to make money on cosmetics but i guess you don't want to make money so i'll just keep those suggestions oh i'd like to also make money but that's just not the primary goal you're selling cosmetics you have to have like holiday notebook covers of course i'm gonna yeah that's the idea here making sure that you're picking up the easy stuff there just like there are so many things in your app that lend themselves to seasonal cosmetics to you know just like anyway yeah yeah absolutely so that that is definitely like on the like part of the concept when i designed when i decided to do this business model was, yeah, of course, I'm going to have like seasonal packs and stuff like that.

2:37:27Marco Arment: Like that's, that's definitely, you know, and there's, look, it's a notebook app. I can also have different packs for things like different, you know, different types of templates that you can have, you know, not just like, you know, lines and grids and dots, but you know, if certain types of planners and stuff like that, like until those people come after you, if someone's going to find you and sue you, so be careful. Oh, thank you. Yeah. So I'll, I'll keep an eye on that. But, but yeah, like I think there's a lot of potential here for future fun stuff to be added, future purchases of different ink packs and color schemes and templates and stuff like that.

2:37:58Marco Arment: But ultimately, I think what I would expect to happen here in the best case, the way I see this mostly succeeding is just a huge amount of free users and then some tiny percentage of them buy the special pens or whatever. And as long as that gives it enough money to survive, which it doesn't take that much because I'm not running servers for it. it should be, I think it should be sustainable. So we'll see. Again, I, I, as of, as of right now, I have no sales data and even tomorrow, I mean, it's tomorrow it will have been out for half a day. So I, that's not much data either. So we'll see how it goes.

2:38:37Marco Arment: You know, I'll report back over time if it's going, you know, amazingly or terribly or, you know, within expectations. But in my mind, it's already a success for my goals, which is I wanted to make something really fun that made me smile and is making other people smile and it's achieving that in spades well i'm really really pleased for you it seems like the launch has gone really well from all the chatter i've seen uh there have been a bunch of people who've said i waited like casey said it was worth it you know just saying john is not always right folks i gave a spoiler warning as you could hear it if you wanted to i wasn't saying people should be spoiled i saying i wanted the people i didn't want to leave it a secret so the people who wanted to know what it was about could just listen to the show.

2:39:17Just giving me the option. I'm very happy. Spoilers are additive, Casey. Oh, I see how it is. No, I'm very glad that it's gone well, and I'm very excited for you. And once I can take a breath, because this week has been just relentless, I am really excited to sit down with my iPad Pro and really properly give it a shot.

From the publisher

Sponsored by:

  • Granola: The AI notepad for back-to-back meetings

Become a member for ATP Overtime, ad-free episodes, member specials, and our early-release, unedited “bootleg” feed!

More from Accidental Tech Podcast

All episodes