1. Podcasts
  2. Accidental Tech Podcast
  3. 712: Mildly Technologically Traumatized
Accidental Tech Podcast

8 Oct 2026 · 2h 17m · 45 chapters

Episode artwork

712: Mildly Technologically Traumatized

In short

The episode is about (1) first-hand reactions to Waymo driverless taxis—how “limited” deployment still feels remarkably normal—and (2) a deep dive into hacking/automating a BMW app with Home Assistant using iPhone remote-control/KVM hardware, plus broader discussion of using AI coding tools, and tech support/router/audio/ISP updates.

Guests

No explicit named guests appear in the transcript. The main speakers include multiple hosts (John, Marco, Casey) and a recurring “Marco” participant; others are referenced only as commenters/sources (e.g., Claude, Chaos Tian, Elijah Yap, Adiko, Roland LeBron, Miles).

Key claims

  • Waymo rides: in supported areas, the car drives “like a human,” including handling a difficult left turn without excessive conservatism; the app experience is smooth and pricing is similar to Uber/Lyft.
  • Waymo vs Tesla: Waymo’s sensor suite (including LiDAR) and safety record make the hosts more comfortable than Tesla, which they say they don’t trust based on past incident handling.
  • BMW/Home Assistant: direct MITM isn’t feasible due to an attestation service (“Approve”) that likely issues short-lived tokens and verifies app integrity.
  • Remote control solution: using a GLINet Comet Q (Pi KVM-based) to control an iPhone directly avoids iPhone Mirroring timeouts and enables automated lock/unlock to prevent OLED burn-in.

Notable examples

  • Waymo pickup/dropoff doesn’t enter a hotel driveway loop; it picks up across the street.
  • High-fidelity macOS screen sharing blanks the local screen and audio warns “this mac is being controlled.”
  • Verizon ending CableCARD support leads to canceling TV and reducing bill from ~$250 to ~$100/month.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

0:45

First Experience with Waymo

A host shares their first ride in a Waymo, describing the experience and insights.

“It would only pick me up like outside, like across the street.”
3:56

Comparison with Tesla and Safety Concerns

A discussion on comparing Waymo's self-driving technology with Tesla's, focusing on safety and technology.

“But if for no other reason, I feel more comfortable in Waymo because it has a broader array of sensors.”
6:06

Follow-Up on BMW Hacking

One host discusses their attempts to integrate their BMW with smart home systems and the challenges faced.

“I have some follow-up to start the show.”
12:22

Innovative Solutions with AI and KVM

Exploration of using AI and KVM technology to enhance their interaction with devices.

“Number one, I wanted to try, well, could I like tickle the iPhone mirroring app and just have it like refresh itself every couple of minutes to try to prevent that timeout?”
14:01

Exploring the Comet Q's Functionality

Learn how the Comet Q works with an iPhone to manage remote access and control.

“And so it said, why don't I just do that?”
15:40

Discussion on AI Implementation

Discover thoughts on AI coding tools and their role in enhancing software development.

“But I think Claude and I have gotten there.”
17:16

The Value of Human Direction in AI

Understand why human direction is crucial to effective AI output in coding.

“but they did a really nice job around it.”
17:41

The Role of Ideas in Software Development

Explore the importance of human creativity in generating valuable software ideas.

“Plus these would have made it so much easier to set them up.”
25:00

Embracing AI and Its Impact on Software

Learn about the benefits of using AI in software creation and addressing criticisms.

“to keep those people on board i'm sure i've already lost them so sorry um and i don't i don't mean to be, you know, flipping about this.”
26:28

AirPower Desk Video Discussion

Delve into the AirPower desk video and its verification through audience feedback.

“And there was some doubt, I think, from certainly John and me that maybe this was AI.”
Show all 45 chapters
28:00

Exploring High Bandwidth Memory Videos

Learn about a unique tech video on high bandwidth memory and its production methods.

“But it definitely is a slightly different style.”
29:18

User Feedback on Ubiquiti vs. Eero

Hear contrasting user experiences with Ubiquiti and Eero Wi-Fi systems.

“We got some feedback with regard to Ubiquiti home Wi-Fi versus Eero.”
32:24

Navigating Consumer Product Issues

Discuss the challenges of dealing with tech products and user expectations.

“But one theory that seems plausible to me is that because there are a lot of things to fiddle, sometimes people will go fiddle with things that they shouldn't be fiddling with, and that causes a problem.”
35:19

AirPods Audio Settings Clarified

Explore the intricacies of AirPods' audio settings for better user experience.

“All right, continuing on as we try to speed run the rest of this because I can tell John is very upset with me.”
37:05

Verizon's Cable Card Support Cut

Understand the implications of Verizon dropping support for cable cards.

“Yeah, well, so for reasons that listeners directives know, I've been spending a lot of time on phone with customer support, and that continues.”
41:23

Cost-Saving Changes with Verizon

Discover how to save on monthly bills by adjusting your Verizon services.

42:00

Exploring Five Gigabit Internet Options

Discussion about upgrading home network equipment for faster internet speeds.

“One, they have to come into your house and change the equipment.”
44:34

The Reality of Internet Speed Limitations

Reflections on whether faster internet is necessary given current usage patterns.

“I feel like I mostly agree with you, but the one thing that consistently, consistently maxes out my downstream bandwidth, downloading a new Xcode.”
46:24

TiVo's Commercial Skipping Controversy

Discussion about TiVo charging for the feature to skip commercials.

“So speaking of TiVo, they're getting a little desperate, John.”
50:06

Insights on M6 and A20 Chip Details

Detailed analysis of the M6 and A20 chip specifications and implications.

“about the M6 and A20, and I could take a stab at this, but I think it's probably best served for John.”
56:01

Analyzing M6 GPU and Core Architecture

Discussion on the core structure and capabilities of the M6 chip, comparing it to previous models.

“And I didn't realize this when we were talking about it.”
58:59

Rumors of Upcoming MacBook Pro Redesign

Exploration of rumors regarding the new OLED touchscreen MacBook Pros and their design implications.

“and how much bigger the large cores are than anything else.”
1:04:49

Concerns Over Battery Life and Performance

A deep dive into the potential trade-offs between MacBook weight reduction and battery performance.

“But are they going to also make the cooling worse?”
1:10:03

Apple's Laptop Design Choices

Discussing the balance between design and performance in Apple's laptops.

“So even though my peak is still 15 watts, I'm at 15 watts for five seconds instead of 10.”
1:14:51

Apple's Smart Home Device Rumors

Exploring rumors about Apple's new smart home devices in partnership with LG.

“The products developed with LG will include a smart deadbolt lock, indoor security camera, outdoor security camera, and floodlight camera.”
1:18:08

Concerns About Smart Home Partnerships

Critiquing Apple's approach to smart home products and partnerships with LG and Belkin.

1:20:55

Future of HomeKit and Apple's Role

Debating the potential success of HomeKit and Apple's commitment to smart home products.

1:24:01

Apple's Outsourcing and Product Quality Concerns

Discussion on Apple's outsourcing practices for hardware and their implications.

1:25:11

Upcoming Microsoft Surface Device Announcement

Speculation on Microsoft's new Surface device and its naming conventions.

1:25:51

Apple's Vague Developer Post on User Privacy

Analysis of a recent Apple post concerning user data privacy and access.

“segment, but we really need to talk about it before it becomes stale and before we forget about it.”
1:27:08

Concerns Over Full Disk Access and User Security

Discussion on the complications of full disk access for apps and potential user risks.

“So the adjective I would use to describe this post is ominous.”
1:30:56

The Difficulties of Granting Permissions on macOS

Exploration of the challenges users face when managing app permissions on macOS.

“Like, and to be clear what full disk access does, if you're a sandbox Mac app, you can't just read any file in the file system.”
1:34:41

The Future of AI Agents and User Data Privacy

Examining the implications of AI agents having access to user data and potential solutions.

1:38:03

Navigating macOS Security Dialogues

Discussion on the challenges of macOS security prompts and their impact on automation.

1:41:18

MDM Experience and Community Feedback

Insights into managing MDM setups and the responses received from the community.

“Out of the box, it is almost impossible.”
1:43:56

The Complexity of MDM Solutions

Exploring the intricacies and challenges of using MDM products for macOS automation.

1:47:17

Future of macOS and AI Integration

Speculation on how Apple might adapt macOS security for better AI integration.

“And no, I don't mean turning off system integrity protection, like more granular controls where you can say what it can and can't do and that it wouldn't bother you after you made those decisions.”
1:52:00

Concert Venue Experience

Learn about the unique seating arrangement and view at a favorite concert venue.

“So we did that and then hung out at the house for a little bit and then went downtown to go to the concert.”
1:54:31

Review of the Phish Concert

Hear detailed impressions of the Phish concert experience, including set lists and song lengths.

“It's really an incredible place to watch a show because not only if you're old like we are, not only can you sit down if you'd like, but there's that rail right there that you can lean on.”
2:00:04

Ear Protection at Concerts

Discover the benefits of using earplugs at concerts for better hearing protection.

“I think it was the best one I've seen since the Sphere shows that I saw two years ago.”
2:02:14

Concert Earplugs Comparison

Compare different types of concert earplugs and their effectiveness during live shows.

“But it did feel pretty nice not to have, you know, ringing ears and not to feel like I'm in a fish tank afterwards.”
2:06:00

Concert Sound Experience

Discussion about the AirPods Pro 2's sound quality compared to earplugs.

“and guitars more than everything else which makes it honestly a little hard to enjoy a concert because that's the part that really gets you going.”
2:07:55

3D Printed iPhone Duo Model

Sharing experiences and insights about a 3D printed model of the iPhone Duo.

“For you, I mean, you need it for multiple reasons.”
2:10:05

Physical Feel of the iPhone Duo

Discussion on the dimensions, usability, and feel of the iPhone Duo model.

“the reason I'm bringing this up is because now I've been able to like hold this thing and fiddle with it.”
2:14:29

Bagel Shop Breakfast Review

Reviewing a breakfast experience at a local bagel shop and discussing bagel quality.

“It feels really weird in a bunch of ways.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On Accidental Tech Podcast, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00Marco Arment: Have either of you ridden in a driverless car yet? No. Nope. I had the opportunity to ride my first Waymo. Oh, interesting. How was that? It was really... So it's exactly what everyone says. It was really weird for like the first few minutes. And then I got bored and looked at my phone. And it was just a taxi. And then on the way home, I'm like, let's book another one. And I booked another one in homes. I'm like, well, as long as Waymo is available, I know like mathematically it's probably safer for me to take a Waymo than a human driven car. So I literally immediately was converted. So one thing to know, like I was staying in a hotel and the Waymo would not come into the hotel's little like loop driveway thing.

0:46John Siracusa: Oh, interesting.

0:47Marco Arment: It would only pick me up like outside, like across the street. So I and I'm sure there's probably some reason maybe maybe Waymo doesn't go into private property. I don't know. Um, cause I was thinking like, even, even like where it should pull over to drop you off or pick you up, that is itself a very difficult problem. And I was thinking like, wow, everything about this is a very difficult problem. Like, you know, you get past the entire self-driving thing, which is not a small thing. And then you're like, oh, but where do you park? Like, even that is a difficult problem. Um, but it was really nice.

1:20Marco Arment: Like it pulled up and you know, it, the, the app is fine. like it's it's a modern decently seemingly well-made app price-wise i i compared like you know comparing the waymo to an uber or a lyft at the same time you know the prices jump around a lot but they were all within the same ballpark of each other so it wasn't it wasn't significantly cheaper or significantly more expensive and waymos are everywhere like there are tons of them and you just don't really like you stop noticing after a while even like like you know like we had We had rented our own car, and so we were also driving that around.

1:57Marco Arment: But when you're a driver on the road surrounded by Waymo's, it was fine. And being a passenger in a Waymo was fine. It was unbelievable. Because I know, I have said on this show years ago that I think it's going to be a very long time before we have fully self-driving cars on all roads, the way that we think. Waymo is not that. It is not on all roads. everywhere. You can't have Waymo pick you up anywhere and it can't drive you anywhere. But in the places it operates, it seems remarkably good. That's super cool. I was worried. There was one time during the Waymo ride where it had to make what seemed like a fairly difficult left turn into pretty moderate volumes of traffic that I was like, how conservative?

2:51Marco Arment: Is it going to be really conservative and be sitting here forever and nope it just did it like basically the same way humans would do it you know it wasn't aggressive it wasn't overly like weirdly conservative it just did it at a safe time and it was fine and that's how the entire ride was like the reason it was so easy for me to stop paying attention to the fact that it was a waymo was that it just drove like a human. And I know if you compare to Tesla self-driving, I haven't followed that recently. I've heard Tesla self-driving has gotten very good, but it's not Waymo good. By the sheer numbers of it all, it's not Waymo good.

3:33Marco Arment: And frankly, I don't trust Tesla and the way they have handled safety and problem incidents and stuff before. I don't trust them to be as safe as Waymo.

3:43John Siracusa: Can I jump in here? I don't really disagree, but I don't, to be fair, I don't really know what I'm talking about. I just want to get ahead of all the feedback. I have understood, and actually Marco and I talked either earlier today or yesterday, and we'll talk more about that in the post or in the after show, but I have heard, Marco's heard, we have heard, all three of us have heard, that Tesla self-driving is truly incredible these days. I get that. We understand that. We hear you. You don't need to write us. But if for no other reason, I feel more comfortable in Waymo because it has a broader array of sensors.

4:19Like it has LiDAR. It has all of these things. And I'm not saying Marco's right or wrong about which is safer, but I will agree with you, Marco, that I certainly handle the bad times that Waymo has gone through a lot better than I trust the bad times that Tesla has gone through.

4:32Marco Arment: Yeah, because Waymo's safety record is shockingly good. And even, I'm sure Tesla, compared to person miles for human drivers, they're probably better than human drivers per mile driven. But there's obviously some degree of irrationality in the same way that people are afraid of flying but not afraid of driving to the airport at the same way, despite the math showing they probably should be more afraid of driving to the airport. similarly like i think people are more afraid about self-driving cars than they are by human drivers in in a way that is mathematically you know not supportive of the data but yeah the way it just was so remarkably normal and like it was a regular good driver i couldn't believe it it to people who live in cities that are served by them all the time this they're you probably done this years ago and you probably you're probably like yeah what else is new and literally i took two of them and now I'm like yeah what else that's all it took but if Waymo was available in New York I would take it all the time and certainly anywhere that I'm going that is anywhere that I'm going where it would make sense to have an Uber drive me there if Waymo serves that area I'm going to use Waymo instead it's that good

5:52John Siracusa: that's super cool John no thoughts I'm surprised

5:57Casey Liss: not for me I don't like to just be clear I don't like taking human-driven Ubers or Lyfts either. So I'm an equal opportunity hater of other people driving. All right. I have some follow-up to start the show. I have been hacking on my BMW, or really my BMW's app. The short short of this is, I think we covered this in the post-show from last show. I forget exactly when it was. It's been a minute. But I really would like to, for no good reason, to be completely honest, have information about my BMW and home assistant. This is so if I want to, and I don't currently have this particular desire, but I want to know I can.

6:31If I want to say, oh, if it's less than 40 degrees and over 70 degrees when I know I'm going to leave the house in the morning, go ahead and precondition the car. You know, if it's not in a pretty decent temperature range, go ahead and precondition the car. And I do this for Erin's car because she has a much more reliable schedule for leaving the house. But I want to be able to do stuff like that or, you know, be able to know if the car is charging or whatnot. And, you know, maybe I can put a light on the status board in the kitchen, whether or not the BMW is charging, all these sorts of things, right?

7:03I want to be able to do that. Do I need to? No, but I want to. So there were a bunch of suggestions after last week's show, many of which were very, very good. First of all, a couple of people asked about my theory about certificate pinning and a couple other things. And I had Claude decompile a copy of the IPA that I extracted with – oh, shoot, I can't remember the name of the app. Like iMazing or something? Yeah, iMazing, I believe it was. So I was able to copy the app off of one of my phones. and I had Claude go through and try to decompile it and just figure out in a broad sense, can you extract useful API information from here?

7:42And the answer is yes. And it was bad news because what Claude discovered is the app uses something called Approve, spelled A-P-P-R-O-O-V. And I'll put a link in the show notes. And what this is, is an attestation service. So basically, I don't know much more than the following, but my understanding is there's some sort of communication between the app and I guess the approved servers to verify this is an honest to goodness app on an honest to goodness phone that's not being tampered with and blah, blah, blah. And then I think it gives like a short lived access token or something along those lines.

8:14All this to say, I can't just like man in the middle of this thing short of doing some, maybe some wonkiness with like a, with an Android phone where you have a little more access to this sort of thing. Uh, but it seemed like it was not likely that this was going to work because there's some attestation that I would never be able to fake. A lot of people said, hey, you talked about how you do the high fidelity, I forget what it's actually called, screen sharing in macOS. Have you tried low fidelity? And what I didn't remember when I was speaking about this last week is that the high fidelity screen sharing, I think actually makes a virtual display when you do it rather than just re-emitting the regular display or something.

8:52There's some way that virtual displays are

8:53Casey Liss: involved i encountered that now that all my machines are up on 27 and i'm using um screen sharing the other downside i mean one of the downsides you're about to talk about about the high performance virtual display thing uh disconnect but the other downside is you can no longer like go and sit in front of the computer that is being controlled like that one they're within two feet of each other sometimes i'm going back and forth right if you go over to the computer that is being shared with high performance screen sharing it just has a black screen and if you try to press a button or something have you experienced this oh yeah i believe that's right if you are using high fidelity screen sharing like you said the physical hardware is blackened or blanked or whatever while you're doing the screen but you don't know the next thing that happens marco have you seen this um i don't think so this is i think this is the first time that i've seen a mac do this maybe in a long time i'm sure there's some precedent for it but if you sit down in front of you like oh the screen's black smack the space bar or whatever like try to touch id on it or something you know like just i basically say hey wake up like the first time it happened i just thought the screensaver had come out or something it talks to you it speaks out loud and says this mac is being controlled by screen sharing if you want to end the screen sharing session hit the escape key what and the awesome thing is that it says that over its audio output but the computer you're screen sharing from also says the audio because you know you can hear the audio of the computer screen sharing and when they're within two feet of each other it's like stereo slightly delayed really weird so yeah that that's it because i can't show anything on the screen it can't put up a dialogue you know what i mean so it it's it's like the thing when it says you know picking the marco surely has seen this one if you leave it on the like pick your language uh too long

10:33Marco Arment: on the setup process it talks to you the it starts telling you about voiceover yeah exactly voiceover

10:37Casey Liss: is the bubble i'm sure you've heard it before uh but yeah so yeah that high performance one is high performance but it's weird yeah it is weird for sure uh but people theorized hey maybe if you go to the low fidelity one, maybe that'll work. And what ended up happening was if I were to configure everything the way you're not supposed to with like leaving the screen on forever, blah, blah, blah. It did work, but it seemed that after a couple of minutes, iPhone mirroring timed out and locked itself, which was a bummer. I also did try using an HDMI dongle. I don't recall if I said that last week.

11:07That didn't make a difference. A few people have suggested an OBD2 dongle. This is a dongle that you plug into your car, but that's read only. And I'd rather be able to affect the car, like I was saying. A few people reached out and talked about, well, what about BMW's car data? And I think it's BMW's car data. And there's also a third-party service with a similar name, Smart Car, I think. The car data service is also read-only and not offered in the US. So now I know how all you EU folks feel. And again, read-only. Then I forget, forgive me, I'm going to butcher the name here, but Chaos Tian from Mastodon, you know them from a bunch of very interesting work that they've done with reverse engineering and things like that.

11:49At least I'm pretty sure that's right. I hope I'm not lying. Anyway, they pointed out, and they were not the only one, but they were the one I remembered pointing out, hey, what you could do is you could use automations to intercept a push notification and then use, like use shortcuts, I should say, to intercept a push notification and then have the phone do whatever you want it to do using the My BMW app's intents and shortcut actions or whatever. I didn't try this, but I know it should have worked or it should work, which is a really great solution. I didn't try because there are a couple of other things I wanted to try.

12:22Number one, I wanted to try, well, could I like tickle the iPhone mirroring app and just have it like refresh itself every couple of minutes to try to prevent that timeout? But as it turns out, Marco was in town literally this morning, yesterday into today. So we hugged it out like 10 hours ago. But anyways, and Marco brought a couple of gifts. One of the things he brought is a 3D printed trinket, which we don't have in the show notes, but we should talk about at some point. But the other gift he brought is a GLINet Comet Q, which is the one that works with DisplayPort or whatever it is, capable iPhones.

12:59And the iPhone that I was using for these sorts of things was an iPhone 15, I believe, that I was previously using as a webcam. So I hooked the Comet Q up to the iPhone, did all the instructions you need to do to get like mouse and keyboard support working. And then I set Claude off and say, hey, instead of using iPhone mirroring, could we use this? And I sent a screenshot of Safari using their basically web-based VNC in order to affect the, you'll read and affect the phone. And I said, hey, and it doesn't have to be Safari. It can be Chrome or Firefox if those APIs are better. And this is one of those times that even as someone who has very mixed emotions about AI, I was blown away because it basically churned for a few minutes and said, in so many words, why are we even f***ing around with a browser?

13:50Why don't we just go directly to the KVM hardware and see if it has an API? Oh, okay, let's see. And it dug. It does. And it turns out that the Comet Q is like a rebranded Pi VPN.

14:05Marco Arment: Yes. Or Pi KVM. Thank you, Pi KVM. Thank you. And so it said, why don't I just do that? And I said, yeah, why don't you just do that? So now I spent the afternoon after I dropped Marco off at the airport saying, okay, let's see if that can work. And it does. And then I thought to myself, wait a second, this iPhone 15, I think is OLED. I forget where the transition was. I don't like the idea that this thing is going to be on even if dimmed because I am begging for burn-in, right? so I said to it, well, hey, can I give you this iPhone's passcode, and can you make the KVM lock it when it's done doing a refresh, and then unlock it when it needs to do a refresh, and it said, yeah, fam, I got you, and now it's doing that, so this is hot off the presses like 10 minutes ago, but I think I've got it, I think I've got it, so I use the Comet Q, which just lives attached to the phone, then the Comet Q, so the Comet Q is going into the iPhone's USB-C port.

15:05Comet Q is plugged into power, and it passes the power onto the iPhone, and my Mac Mini will, every minute or two, wake up the phone, unlock it, check it and see what the state of the world is, and then re-lock it. Or, if I'd like to lock my car, start climatization, whatever, whatever, it will unlock the phone, it will do whatever it needs to do, and re-lock it. And I turned off the always-on display, so the display is completely blank. this is very early news. I'm reserving the right to change my mind on this, but I think I've got it. And it was all thanks to Marco giving me the comic cue. So thank you, Marco.

15:39Thank you, everyone, for your suggestions. But I think Claude and I have gotten there. And let me tell you, I'm not asking you to love AI. I'm not asking you to think this is the coolest thing in the world. I don't think I think it's the coolest thing in the world, but it's really freaking cool that I was able to make this work. And I was in the same way that Lex Friedman has talked about, I'll try to remember to put his post in the show notes, was talking about how he's kind of an author. I think that was the word he used. I might be misrepresenting him. But he was saying, I do a lot of, almost all my games and apps and whatnot are LLM coded, but says Lex, I'm the author.

16:13I'm the producer, if you will. I'm the one who's directing them. And if you don't have me, these apps would be trash. And this app is trash because I don't care. I just needed to get stuff into MQTT so Home Assistant can read it. But the point is, I was able to direct Claude to do exactly what I wanted it to do. And in some cases, like saying, stop messing about with the browser, you idiot. Just go direct to the source. It was even better than what I could have come up with. So I'm not asking you to love AI. I'm not asking you to think it's the greatest thing. I'm not saying it's the greatest thing, but damned if it isn't really freaking cool.

16:44Marco Arment: Oh my God. Okay. I have so much to say. All right. So first... Yes. Sorry. Carry on. First, so the GLINet Comic Q. GLINet actually sent me a Comic Q and one of the other PoE ones as freebies. So thank you for that.

16:55John Siracusa: Yeah, they sent me a couple of these sorts of devices as well.

16:58Marco Arment: And what happened was, I had one Comic-Q and one The Power Over Ethernet one.

17:03John Siracusa: Which is great, by the way. I really love that one a lot.

17:05Marco Arment: And the Comic-Q, I'm like, this is so amazing. And you said it was a rebranded Pi KVM. It's more like in the way that macOS is rebranded Unix. It's like it is based on Pi KVM, but they did a really nice job around it. Yeah, yeah, yeah. That's fair. And it's a very, it's like a much more, you know, polished finished product than any of the Pi KVM stuff out there, of course. You know, what you'd expect. So anyway, I love the Comet Q so much. I plugged it into my data center hardware and I'm like, oh my God, I want one of these on every one of my Mac Mini locations. Like right now I keep Mac Minis in three different locations.

17:38Marco Arment: Like I want one of these, at least one in each location. Plus these would have made it so much easier to set them up. So I want one that I can like bounce around to. so i go and of course they're backordered because like when they first launched earlier i think like august they launched um they were backordered forever i'm like oh god so i'm like i really want another one let me see what ebay is doing i go on ebay and they're selling you know their retail price is like 140 bucks or so they're on ebay for like 170 175 and i'm like oh i do i really could use one more at least so i can like move it around my servers like let me get one more on eBay and I'm bidding and I bid all the way up.

18:15Marco Arment: And at the last minute, somebody sniped my bid for like 175. I'm like, oh, geez. The next day, they're in stock at Amazon for regular price. So I ordered five. I'm just like, just go. I want so many of these. And as it turns out, I don't quite need five. That's why I gave one to Casey. But I will mention they are at this moment still in stock on Amazon, actually on sale for only$119. And if you are a nerd who needs a KVM of any kind, like a remote KVM, because the other thing too, is like all the Comet series of KVMs, they are themselves able to run tailscale clients. So you're able to connect it to your tailnet and then you can from anywhere log into this KVM and you know, whatever the machine that it's controlling is which is very useful because the kvm itself is a tail scale node so once you're in like the tail scale ecosystem if you manage any computer remotely especially if you're doing like you know like a mac mini in a closet kind of situation or you know or somebody else's house or a data center something like this can be awesome to save your butt if something breaks screen sharing or if you don't want to leave screen sharing open for maybe mac os security hole reasons um you can you cannot you can just not even have screen sharing enabled and just use this as the kvm um you know obviously you do your own security research and stuff but like it's such a fun little product um so i can strongly recommend like if you're nerdy enough to listen to our show the odds that you are nerdy enough to want one of these i think is pretty are pretty high so i would i would snag one while you can um anyway so yeah thank you to glin for sending the original freebie and i bought five more and gave one to casey all right um now you were you just were disclaiming your your ai coding work and i know look i'm i'm gonna piss off everybody first the tesla people now they're i'm sure they're all they're already writing in um and now everyone else who doesn't like tesla you know they tend to hate ai um so now i'm gonna piss them off sorry about that um i'll do my best but you know you you said that you know like like Like Lex was saying that like, you know, like being the director of the AI is where the value is now.

20:27Marco Arment: And the more I use AI coding tools, the more I see like it is obviously not the same thing as like, you know, compare it like making it making an analogy to assembly language versus higher level languages. It's it's not quite that it's it's a it's a larger and more profound jump than that. But the reality is that AI generally is not very good at figuring out what to do on its own. It is, however, very good at executing on your ideas. And it's also not very good at doing a lot of polished, nice behaviors. It's not very good at coming up with thoughtful features. It's not very clever. It's not very good at making nice designs.

21:14Marco Arment: and these are all things that you as the human can be responsible for making and and directing and coming up with what ai is really good at is kind of the worst parts of programming to a lot of people like oh i have to i have to build this stupid form and i have to debug this really tricky thing like it's really great at that uh and that's the parts that we kind of suck at it's really bad at the parts that we are good at of like hey what if i had an app that did this like the idea parts And as like, first of all, as good idea people, but also as experienced programmers, we bring skill to using AI that the average person does not have.

21:58Marco Arment: And that skill is still valuable. And I don't think we need to be sorry about using AI. I think using AI is helping us deliver great software. but we are the ones still coming up with the ideas figuring out what's even good to do and then figuring out all the things to ask it to do everything to ask for and then when it gives you the results we are the ones that are like this button should not be here and this is hey this feature kind of sucks why don't you move it into this kind of navigation or why this should really be redesigned to you know fit this other pattern here like we are the ones who know what to ask it to do.

22:31Marco Arment: And if you look at the AI assisted coding output, like as a product, what you or I are able to have AI make with us is so much better than what a random person who has no experience developing software is able to make, because we know what to ask it to do. And we know what kind of standards to hold it to people who were like, oh, it's useless. Like anybody could make that It's almost like in the abstract art world, somebody can make abstract art and a casual observer can look at some painting of some really cool looking circles and be like, well, I could have done that. That sold for$20 ,000. I could have done that.

23:18Marco Arment: It's like, yeah, but you didn't do that. And the person who did that, their artistic contribution was not that they were the first people to ever think of putting circles on paper. They put those circles on paper in that way. They had that idea to do it at that time with those details and those methods and with that kind of story around it and that kind of marketing. And all of that, those are all really important parts of app development and product making. There's a lot of people out there who just keep one-starring everything I make. Like, oh, he said he made it with AI, so it's useless. How dare he charge money?

23:53Marco Arment: And these people, look, I'm probably going to be dealing with people for the rest of my career. We all will. But the reality is what people want is good products that are thoughtfully made, that work well, and that solve their problems or delight them in some way. It doesn't matter who's writing the code. Whether it's some AI model churning out the actual code behind that doesn't matter at all to the customers. all that matters is do we do do we make something good and does it work for them or make them happy or both and if ai helps us do that better that's great for everybody i honestly i am past the point of apologizing for using ai i don't think any of us should really be apologizing anymore if it helps us achieve those goals and i know that's going to be a little unpopular but the the goals speak for themselves because what almost all those people also want is for us to fix bugs in our software or to not ship them in the first place or to work on their pet features or like they want us to have the skill and bandwidth that ai gives us uh and but they just you know they're uncomfortable with with you know some of the realities of that and and i think look there's only so much we can do to keep those people on board i'm sure i've already lost them so sorry um and i don't i don't mean to be, you know, flipping about this.

25:10Marco Arment: I mean this really seriously that like the skill of making software is now involving using AI agents to help you. And that results in more better software. So that's great. And I don't think we need to be apologizing for that.

25:29John Siracusa: I mean, I hear you. And certainly it's been a real help for me in call sheet. And I think that, you know, in talking to my peers and talking to Marco over the last 24 hours and talking to like Underscore and talking to other people, it sure seems like not all of my peers, but a lot of my peers are actually further along in their AI journey than I am. And I am a couple of two to four months behind them. But I can tell you that a lot of great stuff has been delivered in CallSheet that would not have been just straight up would not have happened were it not for Claude and Claude Code. So, and they are actually a lot of things we've talked about in this segment are former and potentially future sponsors.

26:05John Siracusa: Tailscale, I think it's coming up next week. Claude is sponsored in the past and I think is sponsoring the future. GLI net has sent us free stuff and never asked for anything. It's just, it ended up that we legitimately like it. So, I mean, consider that when you listen to this segment, but genuinely there's a lot of great stuff that I've shipped specifically because of Claude and I'm struggling. I'm finding it harder to feel sorry for that. you know i don't know john any thoughts before we move on i do not okay john is like walking away

26:39Marco Arment: slowly at the homer in the bushes like just i'm out no i'm not i don't disagree with anything if i disagreed i would have something to say but you know i'm more or less on the same page i mean if and when i eventually ship the app that i'm working on now i'll have more to say about it then but uh this might be a while all right last week we talked about an air power desk video that

26:59John Siracusa: It was very, very cool. And there was some doubt, I think, from certainly John and me that maybe this was AI. We didn't think it was, but maybe. And Elijah Yap writes in, in episode 711, John mentioned the Chinese YouTuber HTX Studio and his AirPower-inspired desk. And Elijah also provided, or I think it was Elijah, provided a long-form link to the, I think we had had one of those YouTube shorts in the show notes. I found the real link. Oh, thank you. All right. One John Syracuse found the real link. Anyways, Elijah continues, I confirm he's real and not AI. He even interviewed Tim Cook in 2021.

27:27John Siracusa: And we'll put a link to that in the show notes. Additionally, Adiko writes, the air power table is real. The video is actually four years old. It originally debuted on Bilibili, I think, which is apparently Chinese YouTube. HTX recently started posting their Bilibili videos translated to English. The original video has 40 million views. We'll put a link in the show notes to that. And John also found another video. Can you tell us about this one, please?

27:50Casey Liss: Yeah, I mean, so I'm looking at this channel now. And by the way, Elijah sent a picture of himself. with the person from the video so he was firsthand real person and then you know i'm pretty sure tim cook was talking to a real person too anyway and that was from 2021 so pre-ai-ish um but yeah i was looking other everyone's been sending like here's their latest video on the channel and similar to i when i watched this video i didn't know the story about that other video being four years old but um that makes sense with the air power reference as well but similar to the other video it's like they they make these videos for chinese language youtube and then hdx studio like other people might even make them but an hdx studio takes them and says hey we'll translate them to english right and so and narrate them and do all that stuff so at the beginning of this video we're going to like in the show notes they say this video is by such and such and we're translating it to english anyway this is a video about uh high bandwidth memory um and seeing the style of like i watch a lot of like science technology explainer videos on youtube the the style of this video definitely seems different than the ones i normally watch i'm not i you know I don't know enough to say this is a Chinese style tech video because it's one video I've seen.

28:57Casey Liss: I have no idea. Right. But it definitely is a slightly different style. And the production value is very high and it looks really cool. And I think they do a good job of explaining it. And so I'm putting it in the notes just to say, hey, if you want to know about high bandwidth memory, you've heard us talking about it a lot and you know about it because of the rampocalypse. And that's where all the all the manufacturers are making high bandwidth memory for AI things. what is that memory and how is it different than the regular memory that we have in our computers and also some of the technology behind fabrication i know we talked a while back about the asml machines and how they produce the light source they use for masking chips and how insane that process is this process isn't as ridiculous but it does give you an appreciation for what goes into something as simple as making a memory chip and sticking it on a big gpu in a data set somewhere and why those things cost$300 ,000 each, right?

29:49Casey Liss: How could it cost that much money? That doesn't make any sense. They're hard to manufacture. So anyway, check out the video. The link will be in the notes. Yep, very good stuff.

29:56John Siracusa: We got some feedback with regard to Ubiquiti home Wi-Fi versus Eero. We talked about this in episode 710's Overtime with regard to Ubiquiti's new Wi-Fi thinger. Anyways, Roland LeBron writes, I got the Ubiquiti home Wi-Fi thing right when it was announced. I was looking at converting my home to Ubiquiti gear for a while, but I couldn't figure out what to get from their website. So this was perfect for me. It's a good starting point in the Ubiquiti system. I've been adding various PoE switches in the house since, and it's glorious. Installation was easier than my old TP-Link mesh setup. And yeah, I mean, it's been really great for me, especially once I've solved my Sonos issues, which we talked about in the past, but short, short version, I turned off SonosNet and everything got great.

30:34John Siracusa: However, in contrast to that, Miles writes, I switched from Eero to Ubiquiti and I miss Eero greatly. So much constant tweaking and fiddling is necessary, and it doesn't feel as solid, even with an all-wired backhaul. I also got the travel router everyone loves, and it conks out constantly. I don't know if I'm unlucky or people just like the amount of control and info they give you and let the fragility and fickleness slide. I understand to a point what Miles is saying. That has not been my experience. So I traveled last week to the podcast-a-thon, which, oh, by the way, I meant to put this in the show notes.

31:00John Siracusa: Thank you to everyone who donated. I don't have the numbers in front of me because I completely forgot to put it in the show notes, but it was something to the effect of like$756 ,000 for the year or for the campaign. we're like just so short it's so close to 5.6 million lifetime I believe and I really really really want to thank all of the ATP listeners who have even considered donating it's very kind of you and I really appreciate it anyways when I was in Memphis I used both my UTR and UTR LR which we'll talk about in a pre-show in 10 weeks when I finally get there and they all worked great so I'm not saying Miles is wrong I'm not saying that's not what their experience was but for me it's been great And I haven't heard any other crummy experiences.

31:40John Siracusa: Certainly, Ubiquiti is way more fiddly, but I don't actively fiddle with things unless I desire to. I wouldn't say I'm doing maintenance or anything like that.

31:50Marco Arment: Yeah, I think Ubiquiti gives you a lot of fiddling that you can do, but you don't need to. You used to need to. It used to be a lot harder to set up a Ubiquiti system. It was much harder to know what to buy. It was much harder to set it up because it was much less polished. now it's really like the app is super easy it's really well done like yeah i mean i wouldn't like you know send a router to totally non-technical people to set up but honestly i don't think i do that for any brand of router um it's just ubiquity stuff is really good now and it's way nicer to use

32:25Casey Liss: than it used to be i put these two in there there were a couple other feedbacks on both sides of this just to show that the same product can get such different reactions from people and i mean And I'm not, since I don't have personal experience with this, I can't say who's closer to being right. But one theory that seems plausible to me is that because there are a lot of things to fiddle, sometimes people will go fiddle with things that they shouldn't be fiddling with, and that causes a problem. And then future fiddling to fix the fiddling. You know what I mean? Like enough rope to hang yourself kind of thing where, I mean, I'm not sure if that's what's going on or whether things really are flaky.

32:57Casey Liss: I mean, things like the travel route, there's not much to fiddle with anyway. So I don't understand why that would be flaky. But anyway, I do hear both sides of this and people people say, I mean, these are totally, totally opposite experiences. And of course, you two are both in favor as well. But I still hold up Casey's situation as an example of a sort of a miles type of thing. Are you like, oh, I turned off Sonos then it was fine. But here's the thing. You didn't have to turn off Sonos then when you had a hero. Why? Like, is your work is your working around the crappiness, whereas you could be just sticking to the straight and narrow.

33:27Casey Liss: Like, I don't know the answer to those questions, but I do know that the two first people I knew who dealt with Ubiquiti, one had this weird experience where it wasn't as good as Zero in a way that really mattered to them until they figured out a workaround. And that doesn't fill me with confidence. But, you know, anyway, I'm not in the market for one, but I will still definitely keep my eye on this because I like the tech specs and I, you know, I don't mind a little bit of fiddling. So I will consider this for four years from now when I replace my Wi-Fi setup again.

33:53John Siracusa: Yeah, if I recall correctly, shoot, I can't remember the acronym. I believe it starts with an S, but basically there's some sort of thing that lets you kind of cross between networks and assign priorities to different network nodes where you, uh, yeah, right. Uh, Eero was way more forgiving and Sonos's implementation was straight up incorrect. And Eero would roll with it. I think in part because it just didn't really care about that sort of thing because it wasn't, it wasn't, um, not smart enough, but I can't think of a better turn of phrase, but it wasn't smart enough to care about these sorts of things.

34:24John Siracusa: whereas Ubiquity does care about those sorts of things. And because Sonos' implementation was unequivocally wrong, it caused problems. And so what ended up happening was when I told the Sonos to stop trying to make your own faux network within the actual network, everything worked great. And so I understand why Sonos was acting the way it was. I'm sad that it took them this long to finally do the switch or provide a switch to turn off SonosNet. but once they did, it's been bulletproof ever since. But I hear what you're saying, John.

34:56Casey Liss: Yeah, like there's something a consumer thing of like some product is doing something wrong, but you've just got to deal with it. Like, because you're a consumer product and people are going to complain that some of this crap doesn't work, so fix it. And Yubikuti is more of like, well, they're the ones that are wrong. Why don't they just fix their stuff? You know what I mean?

35:08John Siracusa: Yeah, they're the no-talent ass clown.

35:10Casey Liss: Why should I change? He's the one who's saying that. Yeah, there it is. That's a different mindset. But, you know, who knows? Maybe Yubikuti is coming over to the other side and they're going to start doing weird workarounds for broken consumer products too. Yeah, you never know.

35:21John Siracusa: All right, continuing on as we try to speed run the rest of this because I can tell John is very upset with me. One AirPod versus two AirPod audio settings. We've been talking about this with regards to some funky noises when you go mono. Is that right, John? Remind me what the situation was here.

35:36Casey Liss: Yeah, like when you only had one AirPod and it was in transparency mode and my finger would touch the microphone or make a fuzzy noise. We talked about this last week and it seemed like I had solved my problem, but then everyone was writing in saying, hey, I did the thing that you said where there's like one AirPod mode and two AirPod mode, but it turns out in one AirPod mode, I have very limited options. Well, there's a setting for that too, and I forgot to mention it.

35:57John Siracusa: Alright, so if you go into settings, accessibility, AirPods, and then choose your AirPods, there's a noise control section, and within that section, there is noise cancellation with one AirPod on or off.

36:09Casey Liss: Yeah, and if you don't turn, it's off by default, and if you don't turn it on, you don't even get the option to do noise canceling with one airpod the only options you get are off and transparency which is another reason people thought oh one airpod is always transparency it's not that's just the default and it is a fairly constrained default because your only other choice is off but if you turn on this accessibility option then you have all the options yeah i had no idea that like i knew

36:32Marco Arment: that it was by default it would always go transparency like when you took one of your one of your butt out and i knew that there was an option to turn that off but i did not know that detail that like well if you want this other behavior like yeah it's it's kind of a mess yeah

36:43Casey Liss: And of course, this is spread in like seven different places and they're not explained anywhere or whatever, but just that's what this podcast is for. So just so you know, it seems to me from what I've been able to tell, there are in fact two different settings. There's the one AirPod setting, the two AirPod setting, and then the one AirPod setting is artificially constrained by having an extra option and accessibility that you have to turn on to get more options there.

37:01John Siracusa: Fun. All right. John, you have done the unthinkable and you've beaten me to it. And I am in my own head. I'm playing taps as we speak. What have you done?

37:12Casey Liss: Yeah. Yeah, well, so for reasons that listeners directives know, I've been spending a lot of time on phone with customer support, and that continues. And I guess I just kind of get, you know, you know when you're like cleaning, you're like, well, I'm cleaning, I might as well clean all the things. If I'm going to be stuck on the phone listening to hold music and dealing with customer support, shouldn't I also do the thing where I call Verizon and deal with my cable card discontinuation? Like November 5th is the cutoff date, isn't it, I think? I don't remember off. Anyway, to catch everyone up, Verizon is my ISP and they are dropping support for cable card, which is how my TiVo gets its television signal.

37:47Casey Liss: They're dropping support because the law that required them to support it lapsed and was not renewed. And so they don't have to support it anymore. And so they're not. So they basically said, hey, we were forced to give you this cable card and you enjoyed a decade or two of amazing third party products that made our TV product better. But that time is over. Your cable card will no longer be supported. If you want to keep getting television from us, you're finally going to have to let us put a stupid box in your house which is essentially just a much worse uh you know tcpip based video streaming box uh branded by verizon and i don't want to do that so my plan was all right i'll just you know before november 5th i'll call them up and i'll try to get rid of my tv service i tried on the website before that you know can i just see if i if i drop down to like the cheapest tv service they have or something and it kept telling me my bill would go up and not down so i'm like i'm gonna have to call but you know you don't want to call verizon so my plan was to wait sometime between when they gave us the november 5th date and the date itself somewhere in the middle because i didn't want to be doing it on november 4th when everyone else is scrambling and they're all messed up and i didn't want to do it when they sent the email to everybody so here we are kind of in the middle i called them a nice person uh at verizon after penetrating their various systems to get to a human being um told me uh that i could save money by not having tv uh you know because that's what i asked i can you just get rid of the tv am i allowed to do that i said yeah sure um because they noted some that i had some ancient plan and they noted i had been a customer forever and stuff like that i'm like yeah i know um they said what everyone else what the email said and what everyone else who has done this said which is normally we want your uh equipment back don't even bother just keep the cable cards they're yours we don't even want them recycle them do whatever you want we you can't even return them to us we don't want them back so thanks for that that's how much they hate the cable that's that's right what are they going to do with them though it's useless it's just recycling um uh yeah so they uh and i'll at first i said is there there's not a way that i could have like a really cheap tv plan without having any verizon equipment in my house and they said no there's that's not a thing that you can do anymore so i'm like all right fine just kill the tv entirely we used to call that cutting the cord which never made a lot of sense and has made increasingly less sense as time has gone on because obviously no cords are being severed although it is funny when i first moved into this house the people who owned this house before me had a rcn internet i don't even know if they still exist or somebody bought them but they had rcn cable based internet and they had canceled that service apparently and i know this because outside the house where the rcn coaxial cables came in they were literally cut like cut ends of the cable were sticking up i saw where they had cut them like wow someone really did cut the cord but anyway uh the fiber optic cable that comes into my house that uh is currently where was providing television telephone and internet has not been cut thankfully and still exists only now it just provides internet and telephone and yes i still have a quote-unquote landline telephone don't add me as they say it's fine i I have a cool number.

40:54Casey Liss: I want to keep it. That's, you know,

40:57Marco Arment: you can transfer those. Yeah. Everyone's like, you can transfer that to a voiceover IP, but honestly,

41:01Casey Liss: the voiceover IP things weren't any cheaper than what Verizon is giving. You know, like I could transfer one and it would be a big hassle and it would cost me the same amount per month. So I looked into it. I didn't, didn't see a lot of savings there. Anyway. So yeah, now I have no more TV and my bill was reduced. My monthly bill will, or will be reduced once the new monthly bill comes from 250 per month to,

41:23John Siracusa: drum roll 100 per month not bad pretty good yeah pretty pretty good and they also said and by the way uh we have a new five gigabits fios option oh and i said how much more per month is that and they said it's ten dollars more per month thank you john oh i'm so mad at you right now you know they're they're doing to the credit of the person who i talked to verizon they did not try to convince me not to cancel my tv service they didn't try to do anything but they did try I did try one upsell and I was receptive to that potential upsell of the 10, you know,

41:56Casey Liss: try to sell this person more and faster internet access. But here's the thing, two things. One, they have to come into your house and change the equipment. I'm like, really? I just got the equipment changed for the one gigabit upgrade. It didn't seem that long ago. This, this equipment can't handle five. They said, yeah, we need to go in and change the little box with probably an even smaller box. And two, I can't use five gigabyte ethernet. All my whole home network is one gigabit. i don't have any switches i don't even have 2.5 gig switches i have everything is one gigabit in my house so i just tuck that one into my back pocket so casey i do not actually have five gigabit per second in fios for both of those reasons one it's required someone to come to house and change equipment but two i would need to change all my switches uh and it's not that many like i maybe have three switches that i would have to upgrade i could probably leave like the the tv entertainment center as a one gigabit switch because who cares but the computer room and the Synology and like, you know, I might need to fish out all the cable.

42:51I don't know if the cable can handle five gigabits. I don't remember if it's Cat6 or Cat5e. But yeah, I'm not.

42:58Marco Arment: Before everybody writes in, we know Cat5e can do faster over shorter distances. Go ahead.

43:02Casey Liss: Well, it's a pretty long distance. I'm 100 feet. It's a long, like, and it's not coiled up somewhere. It's 100, legit 100 feet because of course the fiber optic cable comes into my house at the far opposite corner of where I'm sitting right now. So there is significant amount of routing through the basement to get to where I am. So anyway, the main barrier is like, I haven't really found any even 2.5 gig or five gig switches that are inexpensive and not hot and don't have fans and are reliable and blah, blah, blah. So I'm just going to let this sit for a while. But it's good to know that if and when I decide that one gigabit internet is not fast enough for me, this is out there waiting for me.

43:40Casey Liss: And I'm excited about that.

43:42John Siracusa: I'm very jealous that the five gig is there. I looked like a month or two ago, and we couldn't even get two gig internet here so i am jealous but i can tell you that my ubiquity equipment a small small amount of it is 10 gig capable so i have 10 gigabit but uh not internet but intranet between my computer and my synology and that's it and i think i have one more port available that can go more than uh one gigabit i believe i have to figure over time that the the

44:10Casey Liss: you know that type of speed will come down in price to more consumer things that we use you know chips will be fab done a better process someday you know the things won't be as hot they won't need as many fans or ideally any fans and just like gigabit switches used to be expensive way back in the day and now they're just commodity junk you can find anywhere that'll happen with 2.5 gig and 5 gig and 10 gig eventually so maybe i will upgrade eventually i'm just keeping that

44:33Marco Arment: one in my back pocket for now yeah it's funny like i honestly i cannot think of any reason why i would need faster than gigabit like i don't i don't want to like bill gates myself here like i don't think i need that for anything i wouldn't say ever but like i i'm never limited by my gigabit

44:52Casey Liss: speed however it's always the server on the other end that's the problem right you weren't i'm it's it's very difficult to max out my connection during normal work you really need to do some sort of like peer-to-peer bit torrent or steam download or something to really actually saturate my gigabit and it's not you know so if i had a faster connection it would just be even harder for me to find things on the other on the wider internet that can fill that pipe yeah but however

45:16Marco Arment: of course i want it like there's there's no reason ten dollars a month yeah if i if i had the routers i would have immediately upgraded right i would like i would definitely pay the ten dollars a month and just start like you know buying hundreds of dollars worth of new switches

45:29Casey Liss: to like upgrade that's the second part that i'm a little wary about right yeah like i would

45:33Marco Arment: definitely like that would definitely trigger like an upgrade of all the switch infrastructure of it. And I really don't need it. And that's a thing. But, boy, would that be cool.

45:43John Siracusa: I feel like I mostly agree with you, but the one thing that consistently, consistently maxes out my downstream bandwidth, downloading a new Xcode. Every time.

45:54Casey Liss: Oh, yeah. I don't have great luck with Apple's stupid Akamai CDN whatever thing they're using. I don't get the best speeds from them. You know what this means, Casey? We need this for our work.

46:04John Siracusa: We need it for our work. That's exactly right.

46:06Casey Liss: Unlike the other consumer products that you can buy, you can't just actually choose to have five gigabit FIOTs. You got to wish for Verizon or some other ISP to offer it in your area.

46:15John Siracusa: Yeah. The only other choice we have around here is Comcast, and it's never going to be that fast, or at least not symmetric anyway. Sorry. That's all right. All right. So speaking of TiVo, they're getting a little desperate, John. I wonder why. You got an interesting email recently. Can you tell me about this?

46:30Casey Liss: Yeah. I'm not going to read the whole email, but it was kind of coincident with me deciding to make this call. they sent out an email to all their existing customer or their remaining customers let's say and said hey you know that feature where you can skip commercials by hitting a button uh we're going to charge money for that now which is hilarious like the whole you know not to rewind all of dvr history but like replay tv came out and let you skip commercials and they got sued out of existence and tiwo was like we don't let you skip commercials we just let you skip forward 30 seconds it just so happens that most commercials come in multiples of 30 seconds so hit the buttons as many times as you want right um eventually late late in the life of tivo tivo said you know what let's just give them a button to skip commercials we know what the commercials are let's just let's just give them a button and so they made one button on their remote skip all the commercials so what used to be knowing how many times you had to hit 30 seconds skip and often was also like enter the secret code to enable 30 seconds skip anyway um they just gave you one button on their remote that would skip all the commercials and that was pretty cool and yeah now that they're taking their remaining customers to say hey do you happen to live somewhere they can still use TiVo, maybe using TiVo over the air because they can use over the air as well.

47:33Casey Liss: So if you're using TiVo with an antenna, but you still have commercials, we know where the commercials are and we were giving you a button to skip them, but now we're going to charge you a fee. So instead of you watching commercials and like people making money by showing you ads, we're going to charge you money to skip those commercials. And if TiVo was in any way relevant in the world, they would be sued out of existence, but no one cares about them anymore. So they'll probably get away with this right before they die. We are sponsored this week by coax. So imagine you're a child of the 80s and 90s, like, I don't know, me, and you really reflect fondly, at least in part, about going through the TV guide, the cable guide that was on the TV.

48:14For children, you would go to a particular channel and it would scroll through the list of all the things that were on all the other channels. And almost all the time, what ended up happening was 99 % of it was trash and there were like one or two good options. Well, imagine that, but what if all of the options were good options? Because all of the options come from your own media. That's kind of what Coax does. So Coax is a zero-config, zero-hassle way to watch your home media server, like Plex or Jellyfin or Envy, like it's streaming into your house over good old-fashioned Coaxial cable, hence the name.

48:45So this is really clever. And what's really great about Coax is sometimes you sit down, you know you want to watch something, but you're not really sure what. And you've got effectively infinite choices, be that because of a streaming service, or particularly if you're like me, because of all the stuff you've amassed at home. Well, Coax, to a degree, removes the element of choice because it's pulling from your own library, but it also adds a tiny bit of time pressure because it effectively treats these things as though they are on right now. So that means that you can browse and watch all kind of in one, and it's really, really clever.

49:18Additionally, Coax has a custom-built video engine for handling direct playback of MKV files, and despite that, the App Store bundle is under 60 megs. And it supports all four major platforms, macOS, iOS, tvOS, of course, and even Vision OS. That's how you know that we ain't messing around here. So it is really, really clever and really, really fun. And if you're interested, and you should be, you should go to coaxtheapp.com, C-O-A-X-T-H-E-A-P-P.com, and check out coax, again, C-O-A-X-T-H-E-A-P-P.com. Check it out and give it a whirl. It is zero config, zero setup. You can go from, hey, that sounds interesting, to, wow, I'm using it in just a few minutes.

49:59We thank Coax the app for sponsoring the show.

50:05John Siracusa: All right, so we have a bunch of details about the M6 and A20, and I could take a stab at this, but I think it's probably best served for John. Why don't you just take us through this, please?

50:14Casey Liss: Yeah, this is from the High Yield and Semi-Analyce YouTube channels, and YouTube does this weird thing where you're like okay what channel is this from so i can put it in the notes and it shows it as being attributed to both like they have like some kind of collaboration feature so i don't even know which like which channel is the primary channel for this but i'm just telling you what it says we'll put a link in the show it's obviously we'll also include timestamp links to the sections we're going to talk about but suffice it to say i think one of these channels is the place that like gets the chips and cuts them open right and the other channel is someone who gives like commentary and analysis and i'm not sure which is which but anyway they got the chips and cut them open which is what we always want to do is like let's see what the heck is in there and obviously once they do that they're using informed and i'm going to say speculation but educated guesses about what everything is and some things are very sure but this is definitely this this is definitely that and other parts of the chip they say in the video is like we don't know what this is and we're not going to guess so there is a large amount of unlabeled area but it's probably this stuff but anyway here are some tidbits i've pulled the highlights that i thought were interesting from this video again with timestamp links so the first bit is that the m6 uses the same super cores as the a20 pro and also the same e-course as the a20 pro with only small changes likely due to chipped area optimizations rather than core differences according to the video so that answers the question we kept speculating about and has changed over time it used to be that the m chips would have the like the big the you know they weren't called super cores then but the big the power cores from the previous phone chip and then when the new phone chip comes out it would be one core generation ahead of the m chips but since then the scheduling of everything having to do with silicon from apple has just been all over the map and right now the m6 and the a20 pro are in sync they've got the same super cores and the same e-cores question and again we'll put a link in the show notes to a stamp stamp you know that because they look exactly the same when you cut the chips open and you look at them like there's a very sort of telltale path you can just eyeball and go yeah that's the same i see that's the same core um so there's that answer second the a20 pros e cores have eight megabytes of l2 cache and they go through this in the video trying to label the cache levels as l1 l2 l3 l4 it's difficult because apple keeps adding layers and other like this is l2p versus regular l2 because they don't want to go like l5 there's a lot of cache on these chips So anyway, the A20 Pro cores have eight megabytes of L2 cache.

52:40Casey Liss: And that is the L2 cache in the phone chip and the Pro phone chip has been on quite a journey. The A18 Pro, four megabytes. The A19 Pro, six megabytes. The A20 Pro, eight megabytes. That is not a normal progression for the amount of cache in it. Let me just tell you, because cache on chip takes space and it costs a lot of money because it takes space and it's not the same as the RAM in the RAM chips or whatever. So Apple has apparently found that giving more cache to the e-cores in particular is beneficial and it has doubled in only a couple of years.

53:11Marco Arment: Yeah, well, it makes a huge difference to performance usually. That's why it's a big deal when chips increase the caches because it usually helps performance substantially. And it's a way that Apple will often use it to give a chip generation a boost where the core itself didn't get that much better like in kind of non-cacheable or non-cached workloads. but they like and oftentimes it is like during a process shrink like this where like oh we have more real estate to spend now because the process shrink we can throw more cash at it and that makes the speed difference even better for most workloads yeah and the tricky bit with cash is it's like

53:49Casey Liss: i mean apple has less of this problem other people you're like how much is the right amount of cash for what level cash for what course for blah blah like what is the right amount and so that's why you end up with something like 18 with four they're like you know i i didn't look up what the 17 was but then they go to a19 and be like we think the e cores can benefit from more cash so they go to a19 and they go to six and like what they're looking for is like okay we don't we can't just say like oh just give it as much as it wants because every every tiny little square millimeter on that chip is so precious and so expensive any millimeter used for cash is not used for something else so you really want to spend it wisely you don't want to give like the e cores this huge amount of cash and like turns out they use like one eighth of it it's just a waste of space a a waste of power it's a waste of everything so you're cautious like let's go from four to six but then they said actually six wasn't even enough we should give them more like and they're determining from real world use like how much of that cash are they using how much does it benefit and you know with simulations and stuff like that but also like what are real workloads that are running on our phone chips do they actually benefit from more cash does it make them faster does it make them more power efficient like whatever does it produce less heat because they have to go with dram last often and so they've decided from the a18 to the a20 that the e-cores need double the amount of uh cache and in comparison if you look at the shared s slash p core l2 cache that has stayed at 16 megabytes that entire time so the e-core has got went from four to six to eight and the s and p cores 16 that seems to be the right amount uh yeah and it's obviously it's more right but the right amount for them so keep an eye on the caches lets you know where apple feels like they've been underperforming in the past and where it's worth spending diary area on in the future and speaking of memory let's go on to uh memory bandwidth i forget if this was in the specs when we looked it up but i don't recall it being there but just in case it wasn't uh when we were looking at the chips when apple released the products like on their on their web pages but uh what they say from looking at the chips is that the 16 gigabyte m6 has the same memory bandwidth as the m5 which is 154.6 gigabits gigabytes per second only the 24 gigabyte and 32 gigabyte m6 have the increased memory bandwidth lengths to the faster 1066 10667 megabits d ram and they have 170.7 gigabytes per second and so if we didn't say that before it's worth knowing your ram speed depends on how much ram you get your mac with if it doesn't matter to you it doesn't matter but if you're doing like ai workloads and you actually are bandwidth limited um i mean i don't know if you'd try to do an ai workload with 16 gigabytes of ram but who knows maybe using a small model but keep in mind the 24 gigabyte and 32 gigabyte m6 have faster memory bandwidth than the 16 because they just use faster ram chips that's just choice that apple made um moving on to the gpu uh the core counts for the base no suffix m chips the m1 had eight cores the m2 m3 m4 m5 had 10 cores and the m6 has increased the core count for the first time in four years going to 12 so that's another situation advanced m1 had eight and they just said 10 cores is enough for anybody for the whole rest of the time m6 says you know what it's a shrink we think maybe more cores would be worthwhile especially now that they have this ai neural accelerator or whatever things in them so that's worth noting as well um we've finally moved beyond 10 cores in the gpu And speaking of cores, the M6 chip is the first M chip to come with all three kinds of cores.

57:09It's got S, P, and E. And I didn't realize this when we were talking about it. Oh, I didn't either. Right, because it's a stupid naming. You're like, what the hell? But anyway, the M5 only has S and E cores. They're renamed S and E cores. The M5 Pro Max and Ultra only have S and P cores. And remember, P is the medium now. So we've got the one that has really big and little. That's the M5. and then the pro max and ultra have really big and medium they don't have any of the e cores but the m6 traded two of its s cores for four p cores so they traded two big cores for four mediums

57:42Casey Liss: and they share that they share the same cluster with the s cores and most of the cache so if you look if you look at the chip layout like the what used to be like the power core cluster like the big cores they have their own set aside bunch of cache that is only shared by however many s cores there are and when they trade when the m6 traded out s for p cores those p cores share that same cache with the s cores like so they're in these little like clusters the e cores have their own cluster and they've got their own cache that we just talked about and then of course there's the system level cache that's above that above that there's lots of levels of caching in these chips but you can see physically speaking like and you know why they made that trade right because yes you drop two of the biggest cores but in exchange you get four of the medium cores and apparently that trade off on the m6 has been beneficial for the workloads that chip sees as evidenced by marco doing his benchmarks and other people benchmarks and ships so but yeah it's the only one with all three sizes because it's got the biggest ones a bunch of mediums and a bunch of littles as well and it'll be interesting to see for like the future generations the m7 and so on do they keep this thing where like the pro max and ultra only have big and medium and the littles are only for the no suffix one or do they mix it up on all of them um yeah we'll put time style links to a bunch of uh essentially frames from the video that show all these different cores and you can see what they look like.

58:58Casey Liss: You can see the actual relative sizes of a small, medium, and large core and how much bigger the large cores are than anything else. And then you can see for yourself that the cores are the same because they look like little maps of a city, and when the maps match, it's the same core.

59:12John Siracusa: There is a rumored October event. It is the 7th of October as we sit here recording, and there is a rumor that there was going to be an event, I think on the 13th, something like that. We don't plan to do a full preview or anything like that this episode, but there were a couple of tidbits we wanted to talk about. So on the 4th of October, Gurman posted, I'm told the new OLED touchscreen MacBook Pros are lighter, significantly lighter. Apple's re-engineered the machine's interior, miniaturizing parts and rearranging components to make the computer much easier to carry. The current 16-inch MacBook Pro weighs as much as 4.8 pounds compared with the 3.3 pounds for the 15-inch MacBook Air.

59:48John Siracusa: So any meaningful reduction would be immediately noticeable.

59:52Casey Liss: Are you scared? This is not new information. I believe when the OLED touchscreen MacBook Pros were first rumored, I think more than a year ago, maybe two years ago, it was like this is going to be a new case design and also the case is going to be thinner and lighter. But this is like late breaking and I didn't add these italics. German put these italics in there. Significantly lighter, which I have to say as I mean, I'm not really as a MacBook Pro fan. I'm not a laptop fan, but as someone who cares about pro-level Macs, anytime I see something about the pro-level laptops getting thinner and lighter, I worry.

1:00:28Casey Liss: Yep. Me too. That's an interesting point. That's your desktop.

1:00:32Marco Arment: Yeah. And their track record is not amazing in this area because last time they made the MacBook Pros thinner and lighter, that was the wonderful 2016 generation that we all hated and it made them significantly worse as MacBook Pros. And when they finally redesigned them in the M generation to be better, they made them a little bit thicker and heavier. And that allowed them to give them a better keyboard, all the ports we needed, great battery life, and great cooling. So what I'm wondering here is, this is kind of what is at stake here. So to make them significantly lighter, you don't need to change the keyboard for that.

1:01:11Marco Arment: So that's probably, at least for that reason, the keyboard is safe. You hope. Right. You do need to change the keyboard to make it super thin, but maybe they don't. Maybe let's hope that's not on the table right now. Okay. Weight comes mostly from the metal and the battery. Now, maybe if they have different ways to design the frame, to save weight, sure. But wouldn't they have done that already if it was that easy? That's kind of what I think. I'm a little worried about it coming from that. I think the most likely answer is that it comes from making less battery in there. And that is not something that I want.

1:01:52Marco Arment: So I – But you shouldn't care that much about it if you're using it on your desk all the time.

1:01:55Casey Liss: It's plugged in.

1:01:56Marco Arment: That one, yeah. But the one that I like travel with, my wonderful little M4 14-inch, I worry about that. Like the 14-inch one is where I'm concerned about the battery life. The 16-inch, I'm – because I use it plugged in most of the time and because it has great battery life, it'll probably be okay um you know if apple had to thin it down a little bit um and maybe cut the battery by like i don't know 10 i'd be willing to give that up but probably not more than that because you know the other thing is what they used to do with um with their thinning efforts to the laptops back when battery life was you know pretty pretty rough a lot of the time is they would figure out some benchmark and they would say okay the laptop when doing this benchmark now it has you know 27 hours battery life or whatever so we have excess battery that we can get rid of and all we need is quote all day battery life the definition of which shifts around constantly but what they do is like they'll optimize the battery life for that benchmark and they'll say okay well if you're doing this you know web mix workflow whatever your laptop only needs to last eight hours or 12 hours so we have too much we can shed it but what happened in the past was the power consumption of the chips in the laptop had a pretty big range between relatively idle and when it's working at full blast and when it was working at full blast you would get nowhere near the battery life they would claim because they were optimizing for that idle time and as the chips got more efficient at being idle i know that's a weird thing to say but like as as chip design has gone on we've gotten much better over time at reducing the idle power usage or like the low power usage and we have that you know with the e cores and everything we see a lot of that the problem is a lot of things would a lot of things that people did all the time with pro machines like developing software editing video like you know things that push the machine a lot of that you like that's what pro people buy their pro consumer computers for, and whatever benchmark Apple tested the battery on, it would be nowhere near reflective of that kind of use.

1:04:09Marco Arment: And that kind of use, you'd get like two hours, and whereas the mixed web, you might get 12 hours or whatever. Most of that problem was a long time ago. Chips now are different. Computers now are different. But I do worry a little bit. If they are going to save significant weight, they almost certainly have to do it by cutting the battery life, or at least by cutting the battery capacity i should say but in do we really want that is that a really good trade-off for for people on the pro like it makes total sense on the lower end stuff on the air or if they're gonna have like you know if they're gonna like have like a kind of a mid level where they currently have the 14 inch with the m4 like do they cut that down a little bit who knows but like i excuse me the m5 or nagas soon the m6 but i really worry if they cut this are they cutting into the battery life significantly of actual pro workflows on their pro hardware and if they don't cut the battery life are they cutting into the cooling because what's also heavy are things like heat pipes and heat sinks those are also heavy and the the better the cooling, usually it comes from either larger heat sinks with more fins and stuff and or different materials like copper that are, I think copper is heavier than aluminum.

1:05:29Marco Arment: I could be wrong. But are they going to also make the cooling worse? Am I going to hear the fan more on my pro desktop laptop that I'm using here as it's under a load? Because when it was new, I never heard the fan at all. Now that it's, I guess, three years old, I'm starting to hear the fan. Sometimes I'm sure it's filled with dust but like these are are these gonna are they going to be able to do this in a way that doesn't compromise factors that are really important to a pro machine and i i'm a little skeptical of that i'm more than a little skeptical that like i'm a little

1:06:04John Siracusa: scared of what this means you know i think i'm with you almost all the way there but the thing that I keep wondering, and maybe I'm too optimistic, but if these new computers come with the two nanometer chips with a process shrink or what have you, if these new chips are considerably more efficient, then maybe the net change is nothing. And you can make a strong argument. I could make a strong argument. Well, then let's have more battery life. Instead of removing battery, let's have more battery life. And I'm not here to say that that's wrong. And And I honestly don't know if I would prefer lighter or more battery life.

1:06:44John Siracusa: I think for me, I'd actually prefer lighter because I'm so infrequently in a position where I need a lot of battery life. But that's not the same tradeoff everyone else would make.

1:06:51Marco Arment: Well, but also like – but like I think what you – like you said that like if they shrink the process, that makes the chips save power. It does at idle. But what usually happens is whatever the total full blast wattage that they engineer the chips and the thermal envelopes around them for, usually that thermal ceiling stays the same. Having the smaller process saves them on idle power, and it usually allows them to just cram more in there. As we were saying earlier, more cash, more cores. They can maybe ramp the clock speeds up a little bit. Like whatever it is, they the top of the power budget, they usually keep in the same range for a given computer family because it's designed around the thermals and the enclosure and everything else.

1:07:40Marco Arment: So that's what I worry. Like at idle, they might say, oh, look, we have all this excess battery because we measured in this web, you know, this like web and AI usage benchmark that's using like non-local models. So they're basically web browsers. Yeah, it's getting great, great battery life. OK, great. But what if we push it? Is it still getting great battery life if we push it? And if we actually do the things that Apple demonstrates their machines doing in their marketing videos, that's the question.

1:08:04John Siracusa: No, that's totally fair. The other thing I'm thinking about is, you know, as John has had us just comparing, like, you know, phone chips with Mac chips, we haven't or Apple hasn't explored the thermocouple thing. What's it called? I can't remember the darn name of the thing. Vapor chamber. Thank you. We haven't explored that in laptops, have we? Because we have fans. But would that help? I don't know. And would that reduce power usage? Will reduce thermals, reduce power usage, reduce battery draw? I don't know. I'm not a hardware engineer, and now that's obvious. But maybe that would be helpful.

1:08:36John Siracusa: I'm not sure.

1:08:37Casey Liss: I don't know if they can scale up like that. Maybe they should put a thermal pad on the MacBook Air first. They're so behind and not behind, but they're so not particularly caring about thermals on some of their consumer laptops. But I do think that Intel and Johnny Ive really screwed us all up on this front because we just have this past trauma of the MacBooks that Marco just mentioned, like the 2016 models. And it's just, you know, that whole era of taking the ports off the computers and making them thin and coinciding with Intel being crappy. And it was just bad all around. And I think this is making all of us understandably worried about what is otherwise just the normal progression of laptop advancement.

1:09:18Casey Liss: I mean, if you just look at the history of the laptop period from like the PowerBook 100 series up till today, it is that exact tension that Markov was just talking about, which is like, oh, so you've got something that takes less power. Are you going to use that and spend it on increasing your battery life? Are you going to spend some of it on making the thing thinner and lighter? And it's always a tradeoff. Like if you just spent it on battery life, we'd have laptops the last seven days and they'd be as thick as the PowerBook 100. No one would want them. Right. Because they're just no one wants to carry.

1:09:46Casey Liss: it always cracks me up whenever i see these in my attic and just pick one of them up i'm like holy cow these things are big you don't remember how big they were compared to today's until you see one of them you're like is this a joke like just you know they were so and i'm not talking about the 16 pound mac portable which i also have in my attic i'm not even talking about that i'm talking about the thin and light power books which were a revelation they're so huge right so we always spend some of our technological dividend on making them thinner and we balance that with how much more battery life that we want and the same thing is true of shrinks you know we do how much do you spend on increasing the clock speed like what we have we have we can dissipate 15 watts why should we ever not dissipate 15 watts let's just crank up the clock speed so that yeah it's lower power when it's idle but why don't we crank up the clock so it is the same power usage as the other one and the chip will be faster and it will get more work done and sometimes thanks to race to sleep that can actually even save you power because you're like well i'm done with the job sooner.

1:10:40So even though my peak is still 15 watts, I'm at 15 watts for five seconds instead of 10. So actually does save battery life. And how do we want to spend that dividend? And we just have so little faith now in Apple ever wanting to go in the other direction.

1:10:53Casey Liss: We're like Apple, you are not allowed to spend the dividend on making it thinner and lighter because the last time you did that you way overspent on thin and light and gave us a laptop that was out of balance. um so i'm not particularly opposed you know i'm not saying laptop progress must stop and they can never get any thinner and lighter and all future gains must be spent on battery life but that's not a tenable position we're just worried that apple will make the wrong choice because they very recently did and it sucked for a long time given how long it takes apple to rev these like we've been on this um case design since they basically quote unquote fixed the laptops right since they ditched the old one put the ports back on made them a little bit thicker and heavier and so it makes sense that like after many many years of using this design which people generally like uh that maybe we are at the point where we can make a new case that is thinner and lighter because that's part of where the lightness comes in it's like some people are trying to saying batteries aren't that heavy what happens when you make the case smaller is there's less room for battery so even if you're like save money on the case or save weight on the case make less case once you make less case there's less room in the case for battery and then you lose battery there too as well so you know i'm not sure what they're going to do here now casey's point about two nanometer remember that the rumor is and i've seen nothing contradicting this the plain old no suffix m6 is it and so if any of these oled touchscreen macbooks are going to have any chip in them that is quote unquote better than the plain old no suffix m6 it's going to be an m5 pro and m5 max and they're not two nanometer so don't look to those chips to save you anything because they don't get a shrink they're the same chips we've had which is fine but like there's not really a two nanometer dividend to spend in that case uh it could be that only the plain no suffix m6 macbook pro will be the one that is significantly thinner and lighter because it's got the two nanometer chip and it is the low-end macbook pro it is you know again i know this is not what you use marco is your 14 inch and no suffix m chip yep it's the

1:12:51Marco Arment: regular m4 and and for that purpose i've actually been very happy with it it is a little slower to build uh you know than than my my big one is but like it was a lot less expensive and it uh has very good battery life and that like and i do actually use the battery life of my laptop so i that's why i'm a little nervous like about them possibly shrinking it down um because this is you know i i love the balance of this machine currently if it could get lighter yeah that'd be nice but again these but when these things are in contention i'd rather keep the battery than

1:13:27Casey Liss: then make it a little bit lighter yeah so well it on the plain m6 one i mean it has the potential market advantage of the fact that apple is uh not rumored to roll out the m6 based macbook air anytime soon but also what does it differentiates an m6 based macbook air from m6 no suffix m6 6 macbook pro well in this case oled and touchscreen oled is another potential power savings especially if you've got a lot of black pixels on your screen i guess and you know i don't know what the power difference is with the tandem oleds versus an lcd so maybe it's a wash but that is another potential thing out there uh and obviously the touchscreen that's another feature that is going to differentiate presumably the plain no suffix m6 macbook oled macbook pro from and an m6 macbook air at some point in the future um remains to be seen if the redesign does actually make a thinner chassis for the m5 pro and max models maybe it will have a thinner chassis and these will be crappy ones because that chassis is made for the next four years and it will come into its own when the m7 pro and max come out because they will be on two nanometer a lot of open questions here but yeah just you know with a late breaking german rumor like again we're not going through every product they're going to announce next by next episode they will in theory have announced all these and we'll be talking about the actual product so there's no point but with him re-emphasizing the significantly lighter thing it is it is something to watch for because we're all traumatized that's what it comes that's what it comes down to mildly

1:14:51John Siracusa: technologically traumatized additionally on the 6th of october so this was yesterday as we record two days after the other report german writes apple's upcoming push into smart home devices will include a doorbell thermostat and other accessories developed through an unusual partnership with lg electronics inc the products will be part of an ecosystem of devices that work with Apple's new smart home hub, as well as an upgraded HomePod mini and fresh TV set-top box. Please, Apple, please, new Apple TVs. The products developed with LG will include a smart deadbolt lock, indoor security camera, outdoor security camera, and floodlight camera.

1:15:24John Siracusa: Though the two companies work together to develop the accessories, the products will carry the LG brand. LG is handling manufacturing and product support.

1:15:31Casey Liss: So this is another late-breaking, very late-breaking rumor of like home stuff that's going to be announced. Again, we're not going through all the products but it's all the stuff that you just remember for months and months but this wasn't in the the rumors right up until now because they're not really apple products i mean apple does this with a bunch of things they they partner with belkin to make a bunch of stuff that they don't want to make they shuffle a lot of stuff off to beats i think they do stuff with logitech as well um you know there's there's always lots of rumors about how much of this product that is not apple branded was actually designed to buy apple um a lot of people writing about the story i said hey remember when apple part went with lg to make a 5k display back when they didn't make any displays i hope apple wasn't particularly involved with that product because it wasn't a great product it wasn't particularly reliable and it had a lot of problems and it was ugly and the stand sucked although apple is really great at making sucky sands so maybe they did have a hand in it and other products yeah other products like you look at the belkins one it's like oh this is you know again the rumors are this belkin product is literally apple designed this product but they just don't want to deal with it so they say belkin it's your thing you brand it you support it you manufacture it we just gave you the design go and we'll put you in our store these lg products i'm not getting particularly excited about because it's just like another one of those partnership deals but it really does make it seem like apple you know apple always wants to encourage home kit stuff and but they're pushing to the home with the home pod with the screen and blah blah we'll talk about that next week but it's presuming they announce it it's like well we want a whole ecosystem of home kit devices and there are a bunch of third parties that make home kit devices but it's like apple does feel some responsibility especially with the supposedly new home kit architecture so like we want like good devices and all the important product categories but we don't want them so much that we want to make them it's kind of like them with the wi-fi hubs like well yeah presumably mac users need to have wi-fi in their home but we don't care enough to actually make it so you're on your own and here it's like well i hear people like smart locks and you know yeah smoke detectors and thermostats but we don't care enough about that to even bother how we can barely get ourselves to make smart speakers but we do want them to exist and we want to show them on stage so who's willing to partner with us to do this and as a couple of commenters pointed out kind of like home wi-fi stuff it's like apple some of these devices are the type of thing where maybe people would want to buy from a brand with the that they trust and believe and especially when it comes to privacy like a lock you know or like a security camera and the fact that they chose lg which is currently going through a scandal where their tvs are listening to you even when they're turned off um maybe not great from a privacy's perspective but like that's that's the problem with apple i mean we have this topic keeps getting pushed down and it will surely not be probably not be next week because it'll be an event video but maybe the week after that the whole uh push by new management slash turnus to change the way apple um releases products and how many products they release and how often and so on and so forth there's just kind of like this really old tired looking elephant in the room which is like why doesn't apple make wi-fi things everybody needs wi-fi and it's so annoying picking from third-party products people were sad when they gave up printers although apple really was just rebranding other people's printers then but yeah home security cameras locks if ever there was a product where apple's privacy focus design and reputation would be a marketing advantage for those products that would be those would be great candidates and it seems clear that apple wants to make sure that they have good products in those categories available but again they don't care enough to do it themselves so they're outsourcing it so i'm currently left wondering based on this rumor and by the way there's fcc diagrams you can see what these things look like they just they don't look like apple products they look like lg products i'm wondering if any of this will be mentioned at all in any significant way in the presentation or whether it will just be a slide and say and lots of third party you know manufacturers are making products as well like i can't imagine apple actually featuring these it's not like they feature the the belkin products they just mention oh and also these are available if you want a thing that does this you can buy this in our store and it's made by milk and that seems more likely than anything else but the story just made me sad about all the products that apple has decided are important enough to have but not important enough for them to make and do a good job on and maybe i shouldn't be complaining because if we look at casey what quote unquote good job they're doing on streaming boxes and uh smart speakers all those categories apple sometimes takes a little bit longer than we would like to make significant updates to them so maybe i'm wishing for them to come and do the same thing to these products and maybe to be better in the hands of lg but from a privacy perspective probably not well and and their track record in

1:20:14Marco Arment: this area is really mediocre. You know, they have, as you mentioned, like, you know, they've done those with Belkin and LG before. And those products have usually been pretty mediocre. And it is Apple kind of like half-assing an initiative. Like, yeah, we want all these smart home devices. Well, we're not going to like make an ecosystem that actually attracts people to make these products on their own. And also, we're not going to make our own versions. so we will co-develop or whatever it is with LG or Belkin or whatever but then what you get at the end is products that neither company really gives that much of a crap about and it shows I've had many of these products, I've bought the random Belkin things in the past, I had the LG Ultrafine monitors that are now somewhere in Casey's house and I've had and I've had the LG HomeKit cameras, I think I had four of them they all sucked and broke after reasonably short times and this is exactly what we're doing again it sounds like like why it's all gonna work this time because it's the new home kit it's so much better than the old one that's the thing like the entire path of home kit so far has been like apple kind of half-assing stuff that they occasionally care about for two seconds to put it in some you know event video and then they never touch it for you know months or years after that and the products all kind of suck or don't really ever pan out or only work briefly but like or like the ecosystem itself doesn't pan out and all the things that are promised like no one ever makes them or one company makes them and then stops making them like it this is how this is this has gone for years why would this time be any different it sounds like they're they're basically running the same playbook so like what why would it work

1:22:07Casey Liss: this time when it hasn't worked before there's a couple things in favor of it now is first being that siri is no longer embarrassingly terrible it is it is merely slightly behind the competition but like that i mean that's the whole reason the the home pod but the screen whatever they end up calling it has been delayed as long as it has because the rumors are this hardware has been done forever but the software wasn't but now siri is here and you can talk to it in a more sane manner although recently today i set two reminders on my phone with voice and both times it asked me what app do you want to use cool it had never asked me that before i've been using the phone since the lunch day infuriating anyway um in theory there's a software story here that makes it so that the products like we'll see we'll see when they present the whatever their smart home hub thing is how they presented it is it presented like a weird off to the side hobby like apple tv is it presented like a new big thing but the fact that they have a voice assistant that could conceivably power a non sucky product of that type does mean that there are some things that are different now does that help at all with smart locks and cameras no not at all it's totally unrelated but it does mean that maybe apple will be more interested in home kit now that they have like more of the pieces to provide a successful solution i mean the home pods are still a problem there's still a rumor they're going to make another big home pod and maybe they're going to make a new mini but those are so small and underpowered and can't do any crii stuff anyway so maybe they're it's going to be a while before they get dragged into it but this new thing is like here's our new approach this presumably has the smarts to run cria ai in a reasonable way it is much more capable it has a screen on it and it potentially could be the hub for your home to talk to these other devices which are admittedly lesser and maybe just featured on a slide somewhere um but yeah like the actual products themselves like it all depends on how good the home kit standard is and all that other stuff we'll see how it goes but it's kind of like you know when they outsource to belkin for like um like a dongle fine like it's literally the same dongle that apple would sell it's just got it like a belkin stamp on it somewhere and the color of the plastic is different like i don't think anyone cares too much about that it's when they do it for things like monitors where you're like apple we would kind of prefer that you make a good one of these instead of something where the usbc port flakes out after two years and the things burn in and stuff like that and not again not that apple's track record is stellar but like and of course they would charge a jillion dollars for it but i'm not i'm not jazzed by a bunch of lg uh home kit products but i am actually interested in the i don't even i haven't even kept up with the rumors what they're going to call us i keep calling it home pop of the screen have you heard rumors of what the supposed name is or is that still no no everyone's just guessing like home pad or whatever but it's just there's people's guesses oh god i hope it's not oh and speaking of names uh microsoft announced the um surface pro no surface microsoft surface ultra today ish um like the next line of laptops and they're using ultra in the thing and people like well that means that the macbooks won't be called ultra i mean maybe but maybe apple doesn't care so just keep that in mind apple absolutely would not care in that case like it is funny if they are called ultra it is funny that that microsoft is preempting them by like a week with its own ultra it's not like other companies aren't also doing pro and max and ultra like yeah apple and for for good or for ill apple sets these stupid trends and people follow them and then you know apple even rumors of what apple might name their things causes trends and they're like we're going to beat them to the punch and call our computers ultra even though apple already called its watch ultra but then didn't call its folding phone ultra we don't know what's going on ultra all the things just to be safe yeah anyway tune in next week we'll find out what they actually announced and if lge is featured at all anywhere All right.

1:25:50So I apologize that we're probably going to end on a maybe not stupendously happy segment, but we really need to talk about it before it becomes stale and before we forget about it.

1:26:00John Siracusa: So sometime in the last week, I forget exactly when it was, Apple put up a fairly vague post on their developer website. And I would like to read to you the entirety of that post, because it's not that long. It reads as follows. We give developers powerful APIs to build incredible capabilities into their apps for Apple products, backed by a set of controls designed to protect users' private data. Full disk access largely sidesteps these controls in order to allow backup apps to function properly on the Mac. Some developers are using full disk access in ways that could put users at risk, exposing everything on their systems, including files, mail, messages, and even browsing history, without users' full knowledge and understanding.

1:26:41John Siracusa: For communication apps, this could also compromise the privacy of the people users are communicating with. Going forward, we will introduce additional controls to ensure that users who genuinely wish to grant an app this extraordinary level of access can only do so with explicit user action. Addressing this is critical. As AI agents become increasingly capable and autonomous, the risks associated with this level of access will grow substantially. We are committed to ensuring users clearly understand these risks before granting such access so they can make informed decisions about their own data and privacy.

1:27:10John Siracusa: Thus ends their entire post.

1:27:12Casey Liss: So the adjective I would use to describe this post is ominous. Yes. Like, I don't really understand what possessed them to do this other than as a PR move, because it's clear that they're not ready to tell us what they're going to do, but they're like, we're going to do something.

1:27:28Marco Arment: I mean, you know, it is obviously, I think it is spurred on by the AI agents that, you know, like meta released theirs. I know there was an article where the guy said it read his messages, although that's kind of disputed.

1:27:40Casey Liss: um i don't think it's disputed that he read his messages just disputed what his story is but yeah right like there's a there's a press there's a public relations angle to this which is there's been a series of stories recently from people using macs with ai agents and being surprised that the ai agents were able to access things on their macs that they thought they shouldn't have been able to access even though from a technical perspective i'm sure they could and so they make this announcement which is like basically saying we know about this and we're going to do something about it or we're not ready to tell you what we're going to do about it but again based on past experience mac users and developers are worried the most recent precedent that is cited in a lot of the stories about this is what they did to screen recording or screen um i don't forget what it was really called but the thing where it lets uh mac apps see other pixels on the screen um and i think it was in was it in sequoia or something they changed that to make it more onerous whereas before you could grant something screen recording permissions like say let's say you have an app that takes screenshots for you it's kind of important for your screenshot app to be able to see the screen to make pictures of it because it's a screenshot app uh and it used to be you'd get the app you'd install it you'd run it and it'd be like hey i need screen recording permission because i'm a screenshot app and you'd be like okay fine and then apple said but we don't like that because lots of apps can trick people into giving it screen recording permissions and people won't realize that they did it and then from that point on forever and ever and ever that app can see every pixel on their screen and that's a security problem so what we're going to do is if a user grants an app screen recording permission we're going to say okay fine but then like next week we'll go hey hey you gave that up screen recording permission you sure about that you sure you want to keep doing that and the user will say yes and then we'll say all right we'll ask you about it again anytime you restart your computer or once a week whichever comes first and from the perspective of a user who bought a screen a screenshotting app and just wants to use it multiply that by however many apps that need this permission you're constantly being barraged with hey we know you gave this thing screen recording version but are you sure are you sure you want to give a screen stop asking me yes yes the app needs to have it i want it to have it it's okay.

1:29:53The flip side of this is what your phone does something similar, which is like, I don't know if you know this, but the whatever app has been has precise tracking on your location, and you've given it that and it's been doing that for six months, and it's ran in the background for 20 hours. Are you sure you want to keep doing this? For whatever reason, I find it slightly less onerous on the phone. But on the Mac, there's just too many apps that need too many permissions, that if the policy is we can't ask you once, because we ask you once, like they'll social engineer you into saying yes and you'll forget and so we need to say i know you said yes but maybe you didn't really think about it so here's another dialogue for you to not mindlessly click okay on and read it again and if you just mindlessly clicked okay on this one don't worry about it because in a week or 24 hours or whatever the hell we decide we're going to ask you again and that is maddening to mac users who're just like let me just use my computer let me just use it but on the other hand it probably saves some people from social engineering and security things So that's the bind Apple is in here, at least the bind that it seems to think it's in, which is we have full disk access.

1:30:55It is one of the hardest permissions to give already. Like, and to be clear what full disk access does, if you're a sandbox Mac app, you can't just read any file in the file system. You can read your own files only, but you cannot read any other files. You know, like, how does any app work then that doesn't have full disk access? Are you telling me text that it needs full disk access because I can open a text file for my desktop? No, what they did was fairly cleverly, I think, made it so that sandbox Mac apps can't read anything except for their own stuff unless the user does something that makes Mac OS think that the user is saying it's OK.

1:31:33So, for example, if you go file open and text edit and you open a file, that is you as a user giving the app permission to read that file. and so you don't again the app doesn't need full disk access it gets targeted access just to the file that you picked if you drag a file onto the text edit icon in the dock that also grants text edit permission to read the file that you dragged on because user action caused that to happen in that way you can have applications that seem like well surely this has full disk access but they don't example is my app hyperspace which reclaims disk space requiring you remove files that's gotta have full disk access nope i've never needed it i don't the app doesn't need it and doesn't even benefit from it because that what hyperspace asks you to do is say what do you want to scan and then it shows you an open dialog box or lets you drag a folder onto the window or drag a folder onto the doc icon all of those actions give hyperspace permission to read the thing that you told it to read it still has no ability to read anything else doesn't need it because there's always a user initiated action so you're like why would anybody want full disk access well obviously backup programs do but sometimes there is no user initiated action

1:32:47Casey Liss: sometimes like for example if you're if you're going to make like a finder replacement there's no user initiated action to let you like just it needs to read the whole hard drive because it's a file browser so it's like a screenshot app screenshots have to have screen recording permission and a file browser you kind of need to have unless every time it launches you say show up an open dialogue box and tell it to pick the top level of your hard drive which would be ridiculous right um so let's say you do need full disk access it's so hard to do first of all you can't just pop up a dialogue like all the apple's versions you can't pop a dialogue that says do you want to give us that full disk access no that doesn't exist we all know if you're a mac user what you have to do the app that has to put up written instructions or like try to orchestrate some other windows and say you have to go into system settings you have to find where this thing is you have to add us we can't do it we can't show you a dialogue we can't ask you a yes no question you have to do this outside of our app and then come back here the second thing is mac apps can't even tell whether they've got full disk access there's not even a way for them to check i'm assuming this is so they can't nag you because like every time you launch it you can't say hey i don't have full disk access you can do heuristics like let me just try to read a random file and if i can't do it assume i don't have full disk access but like the apis are what i assume is intentionally sparse and they're going to make this harder harder how like that they'll have to like put a drop of blood into system settings before they'll let them enable full disk access like how could this be harder and the only thing i can think of is they'll do with the screen recording which yeah you can grant it but we're going to nag the user about it forever and we're just going to say you know this you know super duper still has full disk access uh and it's had it for six months you sure you want it to continue having it it's like stop asking me stop like i just wish there was a big off button on this type of thing so we don't know what they're gonna do so it's not worth worrying about what they're you know what any specifics but everything i can think of sounds worse and before we get into the the ai bot based things or whatever one other tangent here that i haven't heard anyone talk about it i don't quite understand why so i want to make definitely make the point here um full disk access and like giving us some you know the muse facebook ai agent full disk access and then it reads your messages from your messages database and says like oh i noticed you were talking with whatever and you're all freaked out or whatever because you didn't realize you gave it full disk access like that's that's part of the pr disaster that we're dealing with here right and everyone's just like well it's just like you know if it's a mac and you get it full disk access like that's that's what's going to happen like i'm you know debating about that control and how hard or easy it should be but there's still one other issue here which is why is that data unencrypted at rest on your mac good question and that's mostly just a legacy of these things these these programs and apps exist for a long time so to define some terms um encrypted at rest means when it's sitting in a file on your disk is that file just have your messages in it like in text that you can read or is that file itself encrypted setting aside like disk encryption because like when you're logged into your account and your and your disk is unlocked even though your disk is technically encrypted that's for like when if someone takes your computer and like unplugs it from the wall and runs away with it uh the bits on the disk are encrypted so that unless they can decrypt the disk to boot from it or log in with it they can't get those bits right set that aside once they are logged in on your computer and the disk is unlocked and the operating system is booted and they're in your account then there are files on the disk which may or may not be encrypted if you look inside those files are your messages just there and readable or is that file itself filled with essentially gibberish because it's encrypted you want the data to be encrypted at rest which means the file even if i give you my messages database you can't read it because it's all encrypted and who can read it the messages app can read it by getting keychain entries that only belong to the messages app that no other app can see and there's no permission for that there's no permission i believe for let me see keychain entries that belong to other apps that would be bad like only the messages app can read the encrypted at rest messages database file from the disk that would be a safer way to store messages on people's macs apple same goes for every other unencrypted at rest database file that's probably less balanced a sqlite file somewhere on the mac put the they should be encrypted at rest they should be in a little encrypted disk images or like whatever whatever solution they want to do for this if that stuff was encrypted at rest an ai agent with full disk access would have the privilege of reading a gibberish file that it cannot decrypt and then it would have to find a way to find a security flaw to get the keychain access to decrypt or whatever so i'm not saying it's a it's a solution but like that might be better than making full disk access harder for everybody to use harder for developers to deal with harder for users to deal with and yes harder for ai agents to deal with but like what if they just couldn't get at the messages and then maybe have more granular permissions where you can grant people not full disk access, but access to my mail, but not my messages or my messages, but not my mail or whatever.

1:37:45Many solutions exist here and

1:37:47Casey Liss: most of them have nothing to do with annoying users even more when they want to have one or more Mac apps that can read the entire disk.

1:37:54John Siracusa: You know, the good news is based on past history, we know that Apple's going to handle this real easy way by adding another 300 friggin dialogues for us to clear and and approve and blah blah blah yeah i mean that's the that's the you know it goes unsaid but we should mention it again dialogue fatigue the more of these dialogues you put up the more people just go yes okay yes yes whatever yeah yeah go go leave me alone go it is self-defeating because you're like what will make it secure we just need a few more more a few more dialogues bro just a few more right and it's counterproductive and and this is a known anti pattern of security it's like you know like i on when you hear it you're like well it does make sense if i if i gave it full disk access like i do want it to remind me next week it's like but yeah but once you have decided no that screenshot app it's fine i want it to keep it forever you have no mechanism to make that happen you're gonna get bugged about like it's the second you go from oh i'm glad this reminded me to please stop reminding me it's just a forever please stop reminding me you know so they definitely need better controls of this um

1:38:53Casey Liss: and on the ai agent front like what if i want to dedicate a mac mini to an ai agent and have it do stuff for me or whatever uh it's a huge headache uh because the security system on mac os is made for human beings every part of it like when i mentioned before like oh when the user drags a thing onto a thing that like you know that gives it permission or like it tells the user go to system settings then click on security and privacy then click on accessibility except it's been renamed in uh mac os 27 it's called something else now and then find the app and if it's not there hit the plus button and then go the open state dialog box and find the app and drag it all that stuff that's for humans to do so much so that a lot of the dialogues you see for example again if you're using a mac app and you see a dollar that comes up and says hey app such and such wants to access files on your desktop is that okay have you seen that dialogue before there's no way to grant that permission preemptively except by trying to do a thing that requires it and then it throws up a dialogue and you as the user have to say okay and by the way those dialogues are not visible to ai agents running on the system they're only visible to humans that they like they're they're masks from the like accessibility structure of things in such a way that the ai agents can't see and click those like it's basically it's preventing an ai agent from acting like a person and being like i'm just going to grant myself everything and go through system settings and grant and grant and grant some of not all but some of the things that appear on the screen that you have to say okay to cannot be seen and therefore cannot be acted upon by ai agents which means that if you want to run like a headless mac mini that's doing stuff very often that headless mac mini will not be able to progress because there's something up on the screen that it can't see that requires you to connect through screen sharing and click on it does this sound familiar marco a little bit this gets into the second thing which is like what if you're managing a bunch of headless mac mini servers now you're like the ai agent and you're like what why is this computer not doing stuff oh what was your thing it wanted you to to uh click okay that to say that yes you've upgraded to mac os 27 like software update complete like that it was that like and and granted ai agent could see that and click through it um but like this this is all part of the same thing which is the needs to run a mac without a person in front of it in specific scenarios where you want that to work mac os is very hostile to that.

1:41:18It doesn't lend itself to that easily. Out of the box, it is almost impossible. There's lots of blockers where it's like you as the human need to click through a bunch of crap that you don't care about. And imagine if you have like something running headless that needs full disk access. Imagine if that thing throws up a dialogue that AI agents can't see every seven days that you have to click OK to. You'd have to have like some automation that goes through all your Mac and Mades and say, yes, I know this app has full disk access. Yes, it's fine every seven days and if you if you miss it the app is blocked until you go through and click the dialogue and that is very much like mdm of like how do i set up all these computers

1:41:52Casey Liss: and have them install the os or whatever and i know this is probably better for follow up or whatever but i wanted to wonder if mark i wanted to make any comments on the various bits of advice uh slash snark from the people who are mdm experts uh have been sending his way based on his experience with MDM?

1:42:09Marco Arment: No, I mean, not really. I think what I've mostly seen is people saying, A, why didn't I join the giant, I think it's a Reddit community, like the Mac admins, there's a giant community of people. Why didn't I join that and post there? And I have no good answer, except I didn't feel like going through all of that when AI could just tell me answers that I needed. And the second most common feedback was, oh, and by the way, and just a little bit more on that. I don't have an amazing history of posting to a new community and getting helpful responses. Sorry, internet, you have a bad track record in that area.

1:42:49Marco Arment: So that's another reason why the idea didn't even cross my mind to go join some giant community and post a newbie question because historically the internet and its communities have not been kind in that kind of situation. So yeah, sorry. But then also, it was a lot of like, well, why don't you use a real MDM? Because all the things you complained about, the real MDMs can do it. Okay, not helpful. When it's like, why don't you use something different as opposed to like, well, I was using Apple's built in business thing because it's built in and my needs are pretty small, and it's free. And all of the other ones that maybe have like a little bit more intricate settings and everything, those cost a lot of money.

1:43:30Marco Arment: And that wasn't worth it for this use case so that's why but the the responses i got some of them were very nice in tone and and very helpful um many of them were not so okay it kind of reinforces that that first point um so that's that's all yeah so i saw because they sent most of the feedback just the

1:43:49Casey Liss: atp feedback i saw it as well and i think like part of the part of the frustration is like oh macs are not made for automation or whatever and they're like oh i automate macs all day you're just using the wrong automation uh it doesn't necessarily negate the point that macs aren't designed for automation because i do feel like like the good products that do this are incredibly complex i having been subject to these products when i worked my jobby jobs because they were all running on my mac uh various different brands of them some of which are even uh sponsored atp in the past some of them do amazing things but i always feel for those companies because the amount of support they get from apple at doing those amazing things always seems to be limited like they're kind of on their own or apple's like well yeah i know you've got some needs and you want to make an mdm and we'll provide you a way to do it but like yeah put in feature requests we'll see what we can do and they're like we're gonna find some heroic way to work around your broken ass stuff like that's what these mdm companies have to do like they are really just battling against an os and a vendor that wants to support them but not that much and then sometimes there'll be a major new version of mac os that will have some horrendous bug that totally breaks their ability to automate some part that's essential and they have to figure out how to do it because their customers want to upgrade eventually to the new version of mac os for a variety of reasons and the mdm vendor is like you can't upgrade yes because apple broke x y and z and we have to figure out a way to hack around i mean i mean that's just part of working on any platform but they're in a very difficult situation because the things they're doing like when you have to work around like oh there's a layout bug and some new control like there's lots of options that we have but when you have to work around something like oh i no longer have access to this value that i need to unlock this thing to set this feature it's very difficult to figure out a way to do that it's not just a matter of oh i just got to make a custom control it's like i'm stuck i have no way to do this like just like super duper with like when apple breaks stuff having to do with it's it's one piece of software that's allowed to make bootable systems now when they break that super duper has no recourse they just have to like beg and plead with apple or try to do something heroic so i do feel for these companies but yeah like those products are complicated and extremely powerful and it takes heroic efforts to make them and as you pointed out last time we talked about this marco expensive often much more expensive than the free apple thing that you're using and yeah you get what you pay for but like they're made for companies where paying a couple bucks per computer per month uh is not that big a deal compared to the other expenses but for a single person operation with no employees and a significant number of macs that they have to manage it does start to add up especially if you need none of the features except for like please set up this mac with mac os so i don't have to in a non-automated way like it's amazing that it's possible and these products are great and powerful and i think a lot of a lot of people heard when marco was complaining about this was like you can't automate macs which if your job is moderating macs you're like well what the hell of course you can automate macs but i think what marco was saying was i can't automate max right now with this free product and you know and again it's not like oh i just made a dummy mistake i should have i should have picked this one of these commercial products it was much more expensive right and so if apple supported this better first of all it would be better for people like marco but second of all it would be better for these big companies too because they i'm sure they wish that they had better vendor support from apple as well i'm sure they wish apple gave them more capabilities and broke fewer things and generally uh you know cater to their needs more like like every developer thinks right um so yeah like and maybe this is you know it feels so long ago that we were talking about the uh the the ai ram dividend you remember those days remember that it's a phrase doesn't make any sense anymore right to refresh everyone's memory apple added rams to their macs and uh you know they do that periodically anyway but it was long overdue and everyone's like they're adding this because you can't run uh apple intelligence with uh with too little ram so they put more ram on all their phones and all their ipads and all their macs and yay it's the the apple intelligence ram dividend that was short-lived now we have now we have uh ai doing the opposite and making ram really expensive uh but in a similar vein there are certain parts of the software ecosystem including involving apple where people were like there's a thing i've always wanted and the vendor apple whoever was never doing it but now all of a sudden ai agents want it and the vendor did it immediately to empower the agents to do the thing and sometimes it's the thing like i don't care if ai agents use this whether it's like a new api or a new service or a new whatever i'm just glad they added it because now i get to use it and i am wondering if apple eventually gets a clue in this area that the fact that ai agents are stymied by apple stupid security may cause apple to rethink its approach and that will benefit not just ai agents but actual humans who are also annoyed by the lack of options um and we don't have time to go into more of them but like imagine if you had control over how your mac behaved and how granular this stuff was and if you could say stop reminding me and stuff like that like it's not a consumer facing feature but kind of like the uh mdm stuff the ability to do this the ability to say you are a headless mac running AI agents and I'm going to turn off all the controls.

1:49:07Casey Liss: And no, I don't mean turning off system integrity protection, like more granular controls where you can say what it can and can't do and that it wouldn't bother you after you made those decisions. That would be amazing. So watch for that in three to five years.

1:49:19Marco Arment: All right. Thank you to our sponsor this episode, Coax. And thanks to our members who support us directly. You can join us at atp.fm slash join. One of the many perks of membership is ATP Overtime, our weekly bonus topic. This week on Overtime, we're going to be talking about AppZapper 3000, the new app, and the delicious generation that it references. Join to listen, atv.fm slash join. Thanks, everybody, and we'll talk to you next week. Now the show is over. They didn't even mean to begin. Because it was accidental. Accidental. Oh, it was accidental. Accidental. John didn't do any research. Marco and Casey wouldn't let him.

1:50:01Cause it was accidental It was accidental And you can find the show notes at ATP.FM And if you're into Mastodon You can follow them At C-A-S-E-Y-L-I-S-S So that's Casey Liss M-A-R-C-O-A-R-M-N-T Marco Armin S-I-R-A-C-U-S-A Syracuse. It's accidental. Accidental. They didn't mean to. Accidental. Accidental. Tech podcast. So long.

1:50:46Marco Arment: So as Casey breezed by earlier, I woke up in Virginia this afternoon. Or this morning, rather. This morning. No, no, no, no. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah, so I forced Casey to go to another concert. This time, it was a fish concert.

1:51:05John Siracusa: It was indeed. You know, my recollection, which we have long since established, is garbage. But I feel like I said to you at some point, hey, you know, fish is coming. You know, haha, maybe we should go. Haha. And then I think either I caught you at the wrong time or you forgot about it or whatever that ended up happening. And then like a few weeks later, you said, wait a second. Did you know fish is coming to Richmond? And I said, yes, yes, I did. And then next thing I knew, in a good, friendly way, not in a nasty, jerky way, you basically said, hey, guess what? We're going. I'm flying in. So that's what we did.

1:51:37John Siracusa: So, Marco, you flew down. What was it? Yesterday morning arrived. Yesterday early afternoon. We went to a different barbecue spot in town, as we are wont to do. We went to a place called Q Barbecue, which is my second favorite barbecue joint in town. I don't know if you have things you'd like to share about that. I'm happy to hear it. Otherwise, I'll just plow forward.

1:51:56Marco Arment: It was good. It was a big pile of meat. That's exactly what I wanted. Exactly right.

1:52:01John Siracusa: So we did that and then hung out at the house for a little bit and then went downtown to go to the concert. We got a couple of ciders at a, not a brewery, but a place, a beer purveyor downtown. A bar. A bar. Well, they specialize in beer, but yes. This is Capital Ale House for locals. Anyways, so we got some very tasty ciders while we were there and then went to the show. This was at the same location that the Goose show was, at least for my family, infamous Goose show last year. And we were, what, like literally two seats right of where we were for the Goose concert? Is that right?

1:52:41Marco Arment: Yeah, and this is part of why I insisted on going to this because this venue, this is the Allions. Allions.

1:52:48John Siracusa: I don't know how to pronounce it properly.

1:52:49Marco Arment: know how you say it the the travel insurance people as it turns out uh travel insurance you know one of life's extended warranties is very profitable so they can build stadiums amphitheaters rather there we go so they they the way it's arranged is there's like the general admission pit in front of you and then right behind the pit is the first row of like regular seats but it's elevated up above the pit such that if you have one of those seats your feet are like near the pit people's backs or shoulders who were standing there so you are sitting like almost a full person above the pit so that if you have that front row of seats not only do you have a perfectly clear view because you're like a whole person above everyone there you could even sit down and have a perfectly clear view and you are a great distance away from the stage so that you're not like right on top of them but you're close enough still that you can still enjoy like the whole light show and you're still close enough to see everybody, it is, I think it might be my favorite concert venue that I've ever been to.

1:53:51Marco Arment: Because if you can get that front row, it's just the best seats you'll ever have. And that's what we had for Goose. And because I found those seats on StubHub to get for this FISH show, I was like, oh my God, we have to go. Because look at these seats. I found them again.

1:54:07John Siracusa: Yeah, and when Marco said a minute ago, a great distance, what he meant by that was an excellent distance, not a large distance. And so, yeah, I was looking as I was watching the show last night. I feel like when we were standing, we were approximately, vertically speaking, eye to eye with the band. You know, maybe they were a little bit above us, maybe a little bit above them, but roughly eye to eye. And like Marco said, above the entire pit. It's really an incredible place to watch a show because not only if you're old like we are, not only can you sit down if you'd like, but there's that rail right there that you can lean on.

1:54:40John Siracusa: And so you can kind of put a lot of your weight on your, on your hands instead of on your feet for three straight hours. Um, it was, so my review of fish was, is basically as follows. It's pretty good.

1:54:52Marco Arment: Hey, all right. I'll take it. I don't think that this is something I would seek doing. Like if fish was here and Marco was not like, Hey, guess what? We're going. I don't think I would go. But if Marco said to me, Hey, fish is here and we're going, I would say, okay, sounds good.

1:55:08John Siracusa: So it was good. But there was the first set, it was the same situation as Goose, which really, I should say Goose is the same situation as Fish, where there was a set, a set break of like 20, 30 minutes, another set, and then an astonishingly short encore break. It was like 60 seconds, I think probably because they were bumping up against curfew, and then like a 10, 15-minute encore, and then that was that. And the first set I thought was pretty good. the second set opened with a song whose name I've heard 10 times in the last 12 hours and they've already lost. Life Saving Gun. Thank you. Life Saving Gun.

1:55:44Is that right? Yep. Okay. Life Saving Gun. That song went for like 41 minutes. We'll put the set list in the show notes. I am not opposed to a long song. In fact, some of my favorite goose tracks or performances, I should say, are 30-ish minutes. That one kind of lost me for a little bit, if I'm honest. But But the funny thing is, you know, I asked Marco on the way, well, obviously Marco asked me what I thought, and I asked him on the way out, and I would like to hear your expanded version, but the short, short version of what Marco said on the way out of the concert was, that was really, really good.

1:56:16And by pure circumstance, as we were almost at the car, I heard my name shouted at me, which was fairly unusual. And it's dark, and my eyes are tired and dry, and I couldn't see who the heck was shouting at me. Happy shouting, not angry shouting. I couldn't see who was shouting at me. And as it turns out, as I realized who it was that was looking at me and gesturing or whatever, I walked a few paces that way. And I realized it's my friends, Matt and Jade, who I hadn't seen in years and I knew were really into fish. Well, I bring all this up to say, you know, we introduced Marco and blah, blah, blah.

1:56:49And I knew that the two of them could speak the language. And Marco obviously could speak the language. And within seconds, what I heard was, wah, wah, wah, wah, wah, wah, wah, wah, wah, wah, wah. But it was the effusive version of that because they were all like, oh, oh, my God, did you see this? And what about that? It was it was adorable. And I very much enjoyed being a fly on the wall when that was happening. But what did you think of the show?

1:57:12Marco Arment: I do think, you know, as you mentioned, the 41 minute long life saving gun before the show, Casey was asking me, like, you know, kind of what to expect. And I was telling him, I'm like, well, you already know what Goose is like live. Goose is basically following Fish's format for their shows very closely. So, yeah, you have the first set, 20-minute break, second set, brief break, encore. And he's like, are the songs really long? And I'm like, well, it's generally similar to Goose songs. Most songs, maybe you get 10 minutes out of them. Some of them are a little shorter. Some of them go a little longer.

1:57:45Marco Arment: Some of them, they will occasionally, maybe once per tour, they'll expand one out into like a half hour. well literally like you know two hours after i tell him that we get we get the 41 minute song this is the longest song i've ever seen them play live like i haven't gone to that many shows but it's it's definitely the longest one i've seen live and i'm like but and by the time they you know bring it back around at the end of whatever that was um and they start you know playing like the you know the main riff of life saving gun again to end it I was like oh yeah we're still in that like they have I like forgot where we were basically like in you know after that long and I'm like and I kept looking over at Casey I'm like because you know the first set the first half of the show it was much more like high energy jams like just really going at like very everything very melodic and I had told him I'm like you know kind of like the way I describe fish versus goose I mean they're not their actual musical style is more different than you might think.

1:58:50Marco Arment: But the way I kind of describe them in short is, you know, fish, like the highs are higher and the lows are lower. They go a lot more directions. It can get a lot more experimental in a way. And Goose, you know, as Goose develops and gets more experience and gets more, you know, just kind of develops their sound, like they are getting more experimental than they were. But Goose is generally like, it stays closer to the rails. You know, you can, it maybe doesn't stay on the rails but you can you can still see the train as you walk away fish like has gone you know to the next town over and then we'll find their way back to the train tracks um like they they really go a much further direction but um this was like the in this the middle of this 41 minute song and kind of the surrounding you know bits they really went off the deep end in a few ways and i kept looking over at casey like is he still having an okay time Is he still awake?

1:59:47Marco Arment: Yeah, like this is the more challenging part of the show maybe for him. And then they brought it back and kind of went back on the rails for the rest of the show. But I would say, from my point of view as a Phish fan, I was very happy with this show. I think it was the best one I've seen since the Sphere shows that I saw two years ago. I really enjoyed this show. It was very, very good. And I told him, like, listen, like, as we were coming out, I'm like, this is a very good representation. It's not like if he had a terrible time, I wouldn't be like, well, this was a bad show. Try it again. Like, no, this was a good show.

2:00:24Marco Arment: And this was a good representation of a fish show. And so if you like this, you like fish. If you don't like this, you don't like fish. And it sounds like you liked it okay.

2:00:36John Siracusa: Yeah, I think I liked it okay is reasonable. Again, I would not bristle if you said, you know, let's do it again. I would probably even be enthusiastic. But that being said, I don't foresee myself saying, you know, let me put on some fish right now. Or, you know, where's fish coming nearby? Maybe I'll go without Marco. And I don't mean that in a turdy way. It was good. It was enjoyable. As I've said to Marco and some local friends of mine as well, like I'm a pretty big sucker for almost any kind of live music. So almost anything I'm going to end up saying, you know, that was pretty good. And I think this was an example of that.

2:01:14A couple of other quick notes that are one is related, one is not. I brought with me, and I can't remember the last time I've done this, and I don't know what possessed me to do it, but I brought with me foam, what do you call them? Earplugs. For the first time in years when I've gone to a concert, because as it turns out, I've been to more concerts recently than I have in a while. and I didn't wear them for the first or use them or whatever for the first song and for the most part I didn't find it to be that uncomfortable but there are definitely moments that I was like woof and then I think it was after the first song I put them in and you know what was weird about the experience was that at the end of the show my ears didn't hurt they weren't ringing and I felt pretty good imagine that so I got to potentially introduce this thought technology into future shows yeah it's nice having

2:02:01Marco Arment: hearing protection during concerts It turns out the fidelity was not near as good with them in, of course. And these were not like bespoke concert ear plugs or anything like that. They were just crappy foam ear plugs. I don't even know what the provenance of them was. But it did feel pretty nice not to have, you know, ringing ears and not to feel like I'm in a fish tank afterwards. But wildly unrelated to that, very, very briefly, Marco brought two gifts to me when he came down, which is wholly unnecessary, but very kind of him. Marco brought the aforementioned KVM but Marco also brought something else.

2:02:35Marco, would you like to tell me what you brought me?

2:02:37Marco Arment: I will, but first of all let me just say one more time I have tried so many concert earplugs. And in fact, since our last recording, I've actually been to two concerts. We also went as a family to go see Weezer last week.

2:02:49Casey Liss: I forgot about that. Yeah, yeah. I've seen Weezer live. You know where?

2:02:52Marco Arment: At WWDC. At WWDC, yeah. Yeah, they played the Beer Bash. That was so sad. The WWDC Beer Bash is a terrible gig for bands because you're playing through the backs of a bunch of nerds who are trying to talk. There were some Weezer fans who were into it, though. Yeah, but I was shocked how good of a show Weezer put on because I saw them many, many years ago, like right after college. I've always been a huge Weezer fan. Well, in the 90s, I was a huge Weezer fan. I haven't honestly kept up with them recently, but I was shocked how good of a show they put on because they used to be a much lower energy concert performing band.

2:03:24Marco Arment: And their concerts, I don't think, were very good in the past years. but they have grown and expanded and they put on a really good show and i and as an old weezer nerd i was incredibly pleased with some of the songs i heard that they played most of pinkerton some of the blue album a bunch of the new stuff some of which i knew some of which i didn't um and even like they played long time sunshine which is a b-side from a million years ago that i never thought i would see live like it was a great show great set great performance so i highly recommend Weezer. Anyway, so in these two concerts in a week, I got some new like audiophile earplugs to try out again.

2:04:03Marco Arment: And I had a bunch of extras for my family in case they wanted them and stuff. And I have once again come back to the best concert earplugs by far are the AirPods Pro in transparency mode, but with loud sound reduction enabled. I've said this before in the show a while ago the the settings and defaults have changed over time by default when i got the airpods pro threes loud sound reduction was was off and they have to you have to jump through a weird part of the accessibility settings to turn it on like it shows up as a table row in certain areas of the settings but tapping it does nothing and it's just like it's like it's like mac os permissions like you just have to know to go somewhere else to go turn it on like i don't know why you can't just turn it on and off there, but that is by far the best concert earplugs, both in fidelity of what you're hearing and honestly, to me, in comfort.

2:04:55Marco Arment: However, there is a difference between the AirPods 3 and 2 that I think is pretty important. The AirPods Pro 2 is the better concert earplug for most people because it doesn't actually seal as well. And I think the way it is reducing loud sounds might be a little bit simpler. Let me just quickly go over this. I swear this won't take too long. So what loud sound reduction appears to be doing is what I would, in my limited understanding, call a multiband compressor. When something loud is detected above a certain threshold, if it doesn't want to pass it through in transparency mode to your ears at that same loudness, which should hurt your ears, it basically ducks down the volume seemingly of just those frequencies that it's detecting are peaking past the limit.

2:05:44Marco Arment: now at a concert those frequencies are usually the lead instrument the lead guitar and the vocals with the airpods pro 3 it seems to be doing a more surgical job of that filter and so at a concert with the airpods pro 3 in this mode the reduced loud sounds feature seems to cut out the vocals and guitars more than everything else which makes it honestly a little hard to enjoy a concert because that's the part that really gets you going. What you want, what I want, is for any kind of tweak or setting or mode that in that case where it's ducking a loud sound, duck everything, duck the entire volume of everything equally.

2:06:28Marco Arment: That would be so much better for a concert. And the reason the AirPods Pro 2 are better, in my opinion, first of all, I do think they're more comfortable still, But also, they don't seal as well as the threes. And maybe that or a combination of like that and maybe the fact that they're doing simpler or less processing on like the loud sound filter. For whatever reason, the Pro 2s let more of the guitar and vocals more evenly through. It's still not doing like a totally dumb sound reduction like what I want, but it's closer to that. so I have found in even like an A-B testing them both like I'll do like you know half the concert with one hat and switch to the other it's very clear to me the AirPod Pros are still better than all the best earplugs out there and I have I have like the Minuendo ones that are they're like almost the same price as the AirPod Pros highly recommended I have the Sennheiser ones I have all like the the loop and the Eros and all the different ones that are recommended by like Wirecutter and all the NPR tests and everything none of them sound like anything good at all The menu windows come the closest, but they cost almost as much as AirPod Pros 2 and are still not the same audible quality.

2:07:40Marco Arment: But AirPod Pros, definitely still the best. But I wish Apple would give me a mode or a tweak to that loud sound reduction that would reduce all sounds equally and not just try to notch out the filter that is triggering it. Okay. What I brought Casey. The other gift I brought Casey. Oh, yeah. I forgot about that.

2:07:59John Siracusa: We were in a 41-minute sidebar.

2:08:01Marco Arment: Yes. going back to the to the to the melody here i also brought casey a 3d printed model of the iphone duo um i i made one like when that one floated around the internet maybe three or four months ago i printed that one out and we talked about it and playing with it well since the introduction video of the iphone duo and the release of like its actual specs people have made better models of it that more accurately represent its actual dimensions the actual screen size and shape and everything else so i printed out one for myself and i'm like this is actually really useful as a developer because i you know as i'm working on my duo adaptations for my apps i'm like i kind of want to see like how big is it like does it how does it feel in the hand what can you reach i print one out for myself and i'm like oh i'm going to see casey tomorrow i'll make one for him too so i print one out for him too and that's that is the second thing i brought him and i gotta tell

2:08:49John Siracusa: you this thing is well first of all as as a trinket as a 3d printed trinket extremely cool very great fidget device, which means I'm screwed when my actual phone gets here because I'm going to want to fidget with it constantly.

2:09:03Marco Arment: Get the AppleCare. Yeah, exactly. For you, I mean, you need it for multiple reasons. You're going to drop it on the first day, but... Don't even get me started.

2:09:10John Siracusa: No, this thing, the Fidelity, I'll ask you to link the, if you can find it, if you can link the... Yeah, the model. The model, thank you. Link it in the show notes. But the Fidelity of this model is incredibly impressive. like it has a protruded like lock button it has what you could if you squint you could say is a usbc port and actually i just plugged in a usbc cable into the faux usbc port it fits perfectly

2:09:39Casey Liss: come to think of it um that's awesome is it taking a charge it is not taking a charge um it has the

2:09:45John Siracusa: volume buttons on the top it has grills on the top and the bottom like it has the camera uh plateau and the flash and whatever. Oh, I get instead of microphone. I forget what else is back there. But anyways, it is a astonishingly good facsimile of, of the real thing. It has the Apple logo, which is in set a little bit. But the point, the reason I'm bringing this up is because now I've been able to like hold this thing and fiddle with it. And I feel like it's, I feel like this is the right form factor from what I can tell. But in, in so far as like the book style and approximately this size and blah, blah, blah.

2:10:21John Siracusa: because it's a fair bit wider than what I'm used to. Maybe not a fair bit. That's a bit of an exaggeration. It's like 10 to 15 % wider than my current phone, I'd say. And granted, this doesn't have like real bezels on it. So maybe I'm not seeing the screen for what it actually is, but it feels like reachability is not perfect. Like I would have thought something that's quite a bit squatter would make the far upper left corner more reachable. and I wouldn't say it's that different than the phone I have now. But the interior display, well, first, the outside display is a touch bigger than I thought it would be, actually.

2:11:01John Siracusa: And the inside one, I feel like, is a touch smaller than what I expected. I think that's a Casey issue. I don't think that Apple's misled us. I don't think that the marketing is bad or wrong or anything like that. I think it's just my mental model of it was a little askew. But the inside does feel like it will be a two-handed device, first of all. But secondly, this feels like it's a really good compromise. The big problem I have with this is Marco, when he handed it to me after a couple of minutes, said, put it in your pocket. And I didn't pick up what you were putting down at first. But I put it in my pocket.

2:11:34John Siracusa: I was like, oh, yeah, it feels good. Now, granted, as you pointed out, this is considerably lighter than the real thing will be. But in terms of physical shape and size, it felt pretty good in the pocket. but then you blew my mind with the next thing you said told you to sit down yeah sit down before

2:11:47Marco Arment: you drop it so if you put it in a left pocket which is where i've always kept my phone um the corners the sharp you know it has two soft corners and two sharp corners and the two sharp corners as long as you put your phone screen in like because you're not a monster of course um the two sharp corners then are your front corners of the phone it's gonna rip your jeans like and if you remember like remember like back in the day you would have like the iphone 4 shaped imprint in your jeans pocket like where it wore away the edges and you could always tell like oh those were the pants that i i bought those pants during the iphone 4 generation and then you know you your your later pants that were more recent you could say oh the the phone imprint on these is a little bit bigger that must have been from the iphone 6 generation you know like you could tell you could age your pants based on what shape and size the phone imprint in the pocket was well the duo is going to have its version of that for sure because not only is it thick and a very noticeably different shape but it has like two significantly pointier corners than the other two corners so i think this is for me like it actually feels really weird in the pocket as a result i think it looks really weird and i think if i'm going to spend any time with the duo as my daily driver for multiple reasons you know i think i'm gonna have to switch to a right side phone person like change the change the pocket it's in, change the hand I use to operate it, because it is so much a right-handed phone device that I think there's multiple things that are going to drive that conversion.

2:13:17John Siracusa: Yeah, I think you're probably right. And I feel for lefties, I'm sure that's going to be frustrating. Now, I think if this was a left-hand device, I'm sure I could make it work. I do use my phone in my left hand. Probably, I would say I'm like 60-40 would be my guess with my dominant hand, my right hand being 60. Maybe it's more than maybe 70, 30. I don't know. But I think I could handle it. But yes, I agree with you. This is definitely a right-handed device, you know, for better or worse. Yeah.

2:13:45Marco Arment: But it is, honestly, like it's very, it's very useful to handle this model. You know, obviously the real one is, it might be a little bit different, but this is, this is damn close.

2:13:55John Siracusa: Yeah. Yeah.

2:13:56Marco Arment: It allows you to feel the form factor. It allows you to see the screen and, you know, like really a tricky size for reachability. But I do think based on the reports of everyone who has used phones of this dimension, like the Samsung ripoff of this, like everyone loves it when they actually use it. And that's probably what I've heard about foldables generally is like once people use foldables, they tend to love them, but it is, you know, a big expense and, you know, it's not for everybody. But like, I think this feels, I'm excited about it. It feels really good. It feels really weird in a bunch of ways.

2:14:33Marco Arment: But I think it's going to be, I think people are going to like it. And I think, I think I do want to give it a shot as a daily driver, even if it means changing the entire way that I've ever held my phone.

2:14:44John Siracusa: yeah yeah i totally hear that no but uh all all told oh i forgot one important thing that we did this morning uh marco slept in i was very jealous i had family that i was you know helping get off to school whatever uh but eventually we had a late breakfast together and we went to uh probably my preferred of the two local bagel places i really like this is not the one that was award-winning that we spoke about i don't know three or four months ago uh but we went to cupertino's uh which is closer to my side of town, don't be creepy, and had some breakfast. And Marco seemed to think, in the same way that I thought fish was not a waste, pretty decent.

2:15:23John Siracusa: I feel like the report I got from you was not a waste, pretty decent.

2:15:27Marco Arment: Yeah. This is like, as we were going to the bagel place, we were kind of joking about how much John would hate anything that was out of Long Island. Correct.

2:15:37Casey Liss: You don't realize, I'm here in Massachusetts where the bagel situation is grim. So I can't imagine it will be worse. Yeah.

2:15:44Marco Arment: But I would say that it was better than I expected. However, that bagel was not baked today. Even Brugger's gets that part right. I know. I'm a bagel expert and I can tell you. And Brugger's and Panera, like the kind of Midwest bagel chains, they can be really good. And I used to work at Brugger's in high school. Like I've had a lot of Brugger's. I think Brueger's makes New York style bagels pretty much. And when they're fresh, they're great. And I have no problem with those bagels. And I don't think you need to be in New York to make New York bagels. It's not like you need the water or anything like that.

2:16:22Marco Arment: Those are mostly disproven. You just need to make it the New York style and with New York quality standards. And this place, they mostly got it. But even in New York, there's occasionally a bagel place that does not bake fresh every morning. And if you go there early in the morning enough, you'll get a bagel from yesterday. And they won't tell you, but you can tell. It's obvious when you get a bagel from yesterday.

2:16:45Casey Liss: It should be against the law.

2:16:47Marco Arment: It should. You're right. And that's what this was. It was not fresh.

2:16:50John Siracusa: I think it was fresh, but I can't prove that by any stretch.

2:16:54Marco Arment: It was not. I 100 % guarantee you that bagel was not baked today. But if it was, it would have been really good. And so this is the kind of place where if you happen to show up after they've baked a whole bunch of bagels and you get a fresh one, I bet it's pretty good. But that's not what I got.

2:17:09John Siracusa: Can't win them all, but you know what? I still consider it a victory that you weren't like, ugh. I'll go with that.

From the publisher

Sponsored by:

  • Coax: Channel-surf your home media server

Become a member for ATP Overtime, ad-free episodes, member specials, and our early-release, unedited “bootleg” feed!

More from Accidental Tech Podcast

All episodes