
The hosts discuss Siri AI reliability (what works vs. fails), then pivot to Apple hardware/software updates: the new ProLED XDR MacBook Pro (including touchscreen toggles and accessibility), complaints about rounded display corners affecting UI layout, and the iPhone Duo (retail personalization delays, scarcity, and “crack gate” reports of inner-display failures). They also cover ATP store/merch deadlines, Fineliner (a graffiti-style profile export and text input ideas), and sponsored tools (Granola meeting notes).
No named guests appear in the transcript; it’s primarily the show’s hosts (e.g., “John,” “Marco,” “Nick,” “Mike,” “Allison”) plus references to external people (John Gruber, Guy Rambeau, Keith Huss, Jeff, Andy Anako, Luke Miani, Donald Decodes, Terrence O’Brien, Curious Haggy).
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Exploration of Siri AI's performance changes with software updates.
“like setting a timer is a great example that up until 27.2 was awful it was just abysmal you know set a timer for two minutes and wait 10, 15 seconds.”
Hosts share specific instances of Siri's capabilities and limitations.
“when I was going to spend a couple of days in Manhattan and I said, what's the weather like between now and Wednesday morning in Manhattan and what are the highs and lows mainly in that range?”
Discussion on the need for Apple to enhance Siri's functionality and reliability.
“The one time you ever wanted those data detectors and they're not there.”
Detailed discussion about ATP merchandise offerings and sales urgency.
“John, how would you like to handle this?”
Discussion on enhancing text input on iPhones without pencil support.
“It's very nice to take notes on Fineliner on an iPad if you have a pencil because it's easy to take precise handwritten notes.”
Update on the Fineliner app's reception and user suggestions for improvement.
“this was so cool like i love the actual graffiti look i love all these ridiculous characters and the weird way you had to make certain things especially like the f and the t like it i love this so much.”
Discussion on choosing the right developer account structure for app management.
“Out of curiosity, I don't mean for this to sound like a gotcha, so if it does, I apologize.”
Discussion about the new MacBook Pro features and trade-in offers.
“And Allison writes, I got super excited when I heard you say that the 14-inch ProLED MacBook Pro is two-tenths of an inch thinner, but it's two-hundredths of an inch thinner.”
Exploration of touchscreen features on MacBook Pros and useful accessories.
“But I would say, if you are thinking about upgrading and going through this process, check Apple's trading values.”
Discussion on keyboard dust covers and their effectiveness.
“With regard to keyboard marks on the screen, Keith Huss writes, this, and we'll link it, microfiber keyboard dust cover has totally saved me from oily keyboard impressions on my 2026 MacBook Pro.”
In-depth analysis of the design flaws related to rounded screen corners on MacBook Pro.
“Yeah, I wish I had known about this last episode because it would have really colored my comments on the new MacBook Pro with ProLED XDR display.”
Exploring the personalization feature of iPhone Duo and retail experiences.
“Honestly, why do they have to round them so much that it matters?”
Discussion on Apple's supply chain issues and customer experiences during the iPhone Duo launch.
“I feel like we talked about this at least in passing last episode, but the iPhone duo will welcome you if you purchase it from an Apple store.”
Investigation into reports of display issues with the iPhone Duo and Apple's response.
“That, you know, that might be different and better than for now.”
Learn about the durability concerns of the iPhone Duo, including potential flaws and manufacturing issues.
“Okay, so first of all, all of these problems are exacerbated by the shortages because these stores can't keep a lot of spare stock.”
Exploration of the iPhone Duo's battery and Face ID features.
“The iPhone Duo lists two batteries in the battery health thing in settings.”
Discussion on Phil Schiller's departure and future Apple leadership.
Discussion on the potential direction of Apple's App Store under CEO John Ternus.
“The umbrella topic that we're talking about here is what kind of CEO will John Ternus be?”
Exploration of plans for product development and organizational changes at Apple under Ternus.
“John Ternus is moving to accelerate product development, broaden Apple's range of devices and create a leaner organization with a greater focus on engineering.”
The discussion revolves around Apple's team structure, the role of middle managers, and the company's approach to product releases and innovation.
“I don't know what the state of that is inside Apple.”
Insights into Ternus' leadership style, his focus on design, and the organizational changes he's implementing at Apple.
“This is from a different post in the beginning of October.”
Exploring the need for a stronger focus on software as Apple transitions to a new CEO.
“And hardware is great and continues to be great.”
Discussing Tim Cook's role and compensation as he steps back but remains influential.
“more from early september from german as part of the transition cook is moving out of his office in Section 7 of Apple Park and handing the space over to the new CEO.”
Addressing worries over recent hardware design choices and their implications for Apple.
“And apparently you also get paid$45 million in stock.”
Discussion on the leadership changes at Apple, focusing on the potential of new CEO Ternus compared to Tim Cook.
“And so it was at least worth discussion.”
Discussion on the leadership changes at Apple, focusing on the potential of new CEO Ternus compared to Tim Cook.
“Jennifer News said senior vice president, Deirdre O 'Brien, senior vice president.”
Discussion on using the Duo phone as a primary device and its camera capabilities.
“However, I think there are definitely going to be times, for example, I don't know if I go to a concert sometime this month, just pulling that one right out of my bottom.”
Insights into the frustrations with app optimizations on the Duo phone.
“And I don't have a calendar in front of me, and I know that you have travel coming up roughly in that time frame.”
Advice on committing time to the Duo phone for a comprehensive experience.
“I currently am still completely enamored with it and amused by it, but I could make the argument either way.”
Detailed frustrations regarding the camera functionality and user interface of the Duo phone.
“the i forget what they call it but the lock the two apps together thing where you tap on the dividing line between the two of them but let me tell you on the occasions i do want to go to up Oh, is it amazing.”
Discussion about the psychological barriers and benefits of using a folding phone.
“Maybe what I need to do is just grab the screen with my mitts, you know, and just not be so precious about it.”
Concluding thoughts on the value of the Duo phone and the need for updates.
“You're deciding probably with two hands to open the phone.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On Accidental Tech Podcast, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00Casey Liss: How has Siri AI been working for you? Like s***, why do you ask? The first question should be, are you using Siri AI? And I think my answer is like, not really. So far, I have not asked it to do anything that I didn't ask my phone to do before Siri AI. So basically, I'm using the same functionality as I used to, but now it's just a little bit slower and ask me more follow-up questions. But that's a little bit on me, because I should be realizing it can do more than that now and asking it more, and I haven't been.
0:29John Siracusa: yeah i mean all i'm obviously i was snarking a second ago but i kind of mean it um i feel like in what what are we on 27.2 in 27.2 the stuff that used to be local and then seemingly wasn't local like setting a timer is a great example that up until 27.2 was awful it was just abysmal you know set a timer for two minutes and wait 10, 15 seconds. Sure. Timer set for, you know, two minutes for it or one minute and 40 seconds or whatever, because at least it was smart enough to offset itself, but it was real bad.
1:05Marco Arment: At least it wasn't like, did you say set a timer or bet a limer? That's baffling.
1:11Casey Liss: Those responses baffle.
1:12John Siracusa: They're so, it's so far off. Yep. No, that is very true. Um, but no, that got better with 27 too. But in general, I feel like early on, and I'm not the only person who said this, but early on, I felt like, yeah, this is way better. I'm loving this. It's working so much better, blah, blah, blah. And then it got like real bad. And I think, and maybe this is me just making this up, but I feel like, um, it was around the time that everyone else got access to it, that suddenly things got real crummy. Um, and then eventually it seems to have gotten a little bit better now, but it's not been all roses and pansies.
1:50John Siracusa: Now, it's also worth noting, I was not on the beta. I don't think I ever ran a beta. And if I did, it was at the, or no, I think I ran, I didn't run anything until the release candidate. And that was obviously way at the end of the cycle. So a lot of people had really positive things to say during the beta cycle. And I can't speak to that one way or the other.
2:07Marco Arment: I have had the same types of experience of the Siri AI that I've always had with Siri, which is sometimes it's really useful and a lot of times it fails. And the failure rate is high enough now that I'm just, I'm like, I hesitate to ask it anything anymore. So here we are again. Here's some examples of things I've asked it recently that have worked and not worked. I asked it sometime the other day when I was going to spend a couple of days in Manhattan and I said, what's the weather like between now and Wednesday morning in Manhattan and what are the highs and lows mainly in that range? and it gave me a nice clear weather report answer that was great i asked it you know recently i asked what time is sunrise and it nailed it perfect although it did say i said what time is sunrise at night and it said today sunrise was at 7 0 5 a.m it's like okay i mean it's gonna be close enough tomorrow but that's still okay whatever i said does blue bottle have a larger owning company and it said yes and it gave me the company name and everything okay okay those are good two of the best were what kind of recycling is tonight?
3:09Marco Arment: Because here we have recycling in alternating weeks. One week is like cardboard and the other week is like bottles and cans. And I have them in my calendar. And it figured out and it said, tonight is cardboard recycling. Perfect. Those are great. I add, there was something that John Gruber gave me the address of a million years ago and I couldn't remember what it was. And I said, John Gruber told me the address of so-and-so. What is it? And it dug through my messages with John Gruber and sure enough, there was the message. That's great. Yeah. But I also asked it. There was a Adam had a friend who was over and she said something really funny.
3:40Marco Arment: I wrote it down in Fineliner and Fineliner indexes all of its stuff with Siri. And I can check. I had like a debug log to see like what did my copy of the app index so I can make sure it's there. And I asked what was so and so's quote in Fineliner. No chance. Didn't it search for a while. Couldn't look anywhere. It said I couldn't find a quote from so and so in Fineliner. I checked your messages, emails and notes, but nothing came up. which means sounds like it wasn't indexing okay whatever i was walking in the city and there's a there's a long elevated park called the high line it's like an elevator rail platform that's been converted and there's the best there's certain there's it's like because it's an elevated platform there's like staircases every few blocks and i asked where is the northernmost entrance to the high line and it thought for a while and it gave me the address of the high line like the main middle of it whatever it was like not even close now that i then proceeded to go ask an AI app this exact same question where is one of the most interested highline it got it immediately and told me exactly where it was like where the staircase was on this street in this street perfect so I know AI can do this it just didn't do it I also uh at some point recently uh asked give me directions to little island which is another thing over there in Manhattan it just spun for a while and then just didn't do anything I'm like uh um okay like do I ask again so I tried asking again.
4:59Marco Arment: It's like just spun for a while and it said getting directions to Little Island and it got me driving directions. Now I am walking. I had been walking at that point for many blocks. I am clearly walking. I said, no, no, no. I said, give me walking directions. And it's getting walking directions to Little Island and then just didn't respond ever again. Okay. Yesterday I was on the train platform here in the suburbs and there was something going on that I thought, you know what? I should probably call the police about this.
5:31John Siracusa: Oh, that's not good.
5:32Marco Arment: It was getting, it was not, it didn't seem like an emergency. So I thought, I don't want to dial 911. So I pulled up Sierra and I said, call the Suffolk County Police. And I thought for a while and it said, here's the number for the Suffolk County Police. I can't call it for you. Okay. Now it was showing the number in that little blob up top, the live activity area blob. So I'm like, all right, can I just tap the number, please? And I tap it and it shows a menu inside the blob that is clipped by the blob and tapping the phone number in the menu does not call it. Cool.
6:07Casey Liss: The one time you ever wanted those data detectors and they're not there. Like where it makes every single number anywhere in any Apple OS thinks it's a phone number.
6:15Marco Arment: Yeah. Like it just like if this was, you know, a more urgent thing. I thought asking Siri for the number for a local police department would be faster than trying to search the web for it and find it that way. Nope. Sure. Why do I keep doing this? If any of the major AI apps, you know, Claude sponsored this episode, disclaimer. But if Claude or Gemini or ChatGPT, if any of them failed as often as Siri does, we would never use it again. but we tolerate this level of failure from siri i i don't entirely know why um but i i just i wish apple would hold themselves to even higher standards for siri because while siri ai can do amazing things and sometimes does amazing things the failure rate is still so high on dumb stuff that should work i hope they don't think this is good enough i hope they i hope that the high ups at apple even though they say how amazing this is i hope they know it still sucks a lot of the time and that they're working to fix it because it's not good enough.
7:24John Siracusa: This is your final warning for all of 2026. This is it. This is that moment. If you're driving, use a signal because you're a grownup and then pull over and go to atp.fm slash store. If you're walking, check your blind spots and then move to the side of the sidewalk and then go to atp.fm slash store. And now is the moment to go ahead and place your orders for Americans. We hope, but do not guarantee that they should be here in time for Christmas for Europeans. Uh, all bets are off. I'm so sorry. But anyways, um, we have a bunch of stuff on offer, John, I will let you decide if you want to go through a quick nickel tour or if you just want to speed run this, but for real, for real, the store closes this upcoming Sunday with this, this is being recorded it on a Wednesday.
8:16John Siracusa: You probably won't hear it until Thursday or Friday. It is going to be all done on Sunday. Don't be that person. It happens about 15 times every sale in a, ha ha, guess what I almost did, but I didn't weigh, but don't be the actual person, which happens at least once every sale. Oh no. Oh no. It was me this time. I'm the one that forgot. ATP.fm slash store. John, how would you like to handle this? Do you want a speed runner? Do you want to take us on a quick
8:45Casey Liss: final tour first i want to say that the sale ends november 8th hopefully you're hearing this episode before november 8th or even if it is november 8th i think we have until midnight so get out there and buy the stuff um uh i just want to have a couple of updates first enough people ordered the a18 pro shirt that it will be printed barely but still so good you know kudos to all the a18 pro people second uh the response to the atp pride and trans pride shirts has been amazing they're far and away our best sellers obviously we don't have the final numbers but like after the sale ends we'll tally everything up and then we'll announce on the show how much money is being donated to both of these two charities trans lifeline and transgender law center but i just want to give kudos to everybody all of our listeners who are overwhelmingly buying these two shirts which is great not sure uh when and what the upcoming like if we do this again we might put like the our you know our pride logos on a different uh piece of thing maybe we'll embroider on something or whatever but like don't think oh they're just going to have these shirts all the time if you want an atp pride or atp trans pride thing t-shirt long sleeve shirt tank top pullover hoodie sweatshirt get it now because like any of our products i mean we get we get emails like this all the time all throughout the entire year hey could you bring back the whatever shirt not always like you know when are you going to sell this thing again we might in a couple years or we might never sell it again so don't just assume because you see something for sale now that it'll be for sale later get it now if you want it uh and that includes the uh the zip hoodie uh that now comes in multiple colors so if you if you just never wanted a black hoodie or you're sick of black hoodies try one of the colors it's not many colors but there are colors other than black and then also the polo like the polo is selling pretty briskly too but again this may be the last time we ever sell a polo because it's so damn expensive we're making zero money on it so it's not there's no charity with atp polo it's just very expensive so do not wait um luckily atp gift memberships are available all year round so you can save them as a last minute gift the night before Christmas, you can, you know, say, oh no, I don't know how to get this nerd in my life or someone doesn't know what to get me.
10:43Casey Liss: So you can always do that. But for the merch, November 8th, do not wait.
10:48John Siracusa: Yeah. And to be clear, we, we aren't saying, John is not trying to like bring upon artificial scarcity. We really and truly do not know what will go, what will happen in the future with regards to pride, trans or really any of these products. And so the safe bet is to just go ahead and order. And generally speaking, we try to do different stuff each sale with the exception of the like bog standard ATP shirt. Um, generally we try to try to mix things up. So if it may end up that we'll do pride and trans pride forever, it may end up that this is a one and done. We genuinely do not know sitting here.
11:24John Siracusa: So if there's a question, like John said, the other thing we get constantly other than, Oh my gosh, it was me this time is, Hey, could you bring back just like john said and maybe but maybe not uh one thing i can say though is our policy has
11:37Casey Liss: always been um for the for the shirts for the m chips we basically only do them once oh that's true yep so like we have the on-demand shirts that we have like m1 through you know whatever like on-demand shirts that are just not as printed as well but the good printed versions of any of like the chip shirts we do them once so there's never going to be another m5 ultra shirt or m5 of Alter Interposer shirts because those aren't, they're not, it's a non-on-demand version. It just comes out when the things come out. So those, I mean, we could obviously change the policy, but we've been consistent since the M1.
12:09Casey Liss: We sell the shirt, the good versions of the shirts when the chip is new and pretty much never again. Yep.
12:15John Siracusa: But yeah, so I don't want you to be cross with us if we do end up doing more Pride or Trans Pride shirts in the future. Cross?
12:21Casey Liss: Are you British? Yeah. This talks to Mike on a podcast too much.
12:25John Siracusa: I know. It's the bog standard a minute ago, which I absolutely think of as a British system. I don't know what's happening over here. But anyway, all we're saying is now is the time. You have until this coming Sunday, November 8th at midnight ATP time. So please, please, please, ATP.fm/. All right. Let's talk about this sweet new app that is sweeping the nation, Fineliner. Nick Foster writes, in honor of ATP bringing back their best shirt, the Palm Graffiti shirt and Marco's new app, please enjoy this Fineliner profile where every letter is in graffiti. We will have a link in the show notes, which in turn has a picture in it.
13:01John Siracusa: This is incredible. I love it. And Nick was even kind enough to include, I don't know how you want me to phrase this, Marco, but like a downloadable pack so you can use this yourself.
13:12Marco Arment: Yeah, this is incredible. Yeah, so that's what Nick included was the profile export. There it is. Thank you. Because everything in FileLiner is just a database. And so I kind of gave it its own, quote, document format for exports, which is just a SQLite database. And one of the things you can export besides individual notebooks is your profile, which includes the avatar, icons, and font. So that is the part that Nick exported here, which is great. And I loved this so much. This was not a good thing for me to see when I had like an hour to kill afterwards because I'm like, hmm, this gives me some ideas.
13:55Marco Arment: Now, I had already – Fineliner, as I mentioned, it's a note-taking app, and I'm not going to spoil too much about it. But the idea is I was trying to figure out like on the lead up to launch, how do I make this useful on an iPhone that does not have pencil support, which is most iPhones except the Duo. So, you know, it's on the iPad. It's very nice to take notes on Fineliner on an iPad if you have a pencil because it's easy to take precise handwritten notes. On iPhones, it's harder to make that useful. And so I added a text tool for iPhones that gives them a full-blown text box. You could just type into it.
14:33Marco Arment: If you happen to have your own custom font established in the app, it will use that. It's wonderful. It will reflow the text around stuff if you drag stuff in and out of the text, etc. But I was thinking, like, are there better ways to input text on devices when you don't have a pencil with you or if you're on a device that doesn't support the pencil? and one of the things I thought of was wouldn't it be funny to put like a graffiti area on the bottom just to have you know obviously not that wouldn't be the only way to input text but that would be like a fun mode and to and to kind of like test out like how would that feel today I actually booted up like I found one of those pom os emulator websites that you're like you know because now nice everyone's making these amazing emulators of old computing and game hardware that you can just run in your browser and so i found one of those and booted up pomls and like let me see like how is graffiti today and like i have only the fondest memories for all of this yeah but wow is it slow to answer text it's horrendous like it would it would be it's so much worse than using an on-screen keyboard on a modern touch device like it there would be no reason for me to ever actually do it besides maybe like a fun april fool's gag um i'm not sure if that's my style but it was it was really fun to play with an old palm you know i virtualized like a palm 5x which is my favorite one ever and it was it was so fun to see it and as i as i when i bought one on ebay a couple years ago to play around with like they are really fun to play with for a brief lifetime but it is kind of like okay this was wonderful in the 90s slash early 2000s when this came out but it's it's not what you want to use now when you have other options but this was so cool like i love the actual graffiti look i love all these ridiculous characters and the weird way you had to make certain things especially like the f and the t like it i love this so much.
16:36John Siracusa: Yep, this is really, really well done.
16:37Casey Liss: Whatever holding company currently owns the rights to graffiti would probably find you and sue you anyway.
16:43Marco Arment: Well, I mean, they're so fun, they're okay with our shirts, don't tell them. But it's a lot of fun. Don't tell BMW or Apple either.
16:51Casey Liss: Yeah, but speaking of shirts, the graffiti shirt, I think this is the second time we've ever sold it and it probably won't be back for years. So if you want one, get it.
16:57Marco Arment: Yeah. But also, I will just give a quick update on Fineliner while we are on the topic. It's going very well so far. Thank you to everybody for all the very kind words and a lot of, you know, getting a lot of replies on social media, getting a lot of nice emails. It seems to be, it's not like exploding in popularity yet. It's having, you know, a relatively like casual start, I would say. It's not like, you know, it's not setting the world on fire yet, but I'm kind of, what I'm hoping for is organic growth and spreading. And so, hey, if you like it, spread it. Thank you. And for everyone else, just thank you.
17:34Marco Arment: I I appreciate you using it, and it's going very well so far.
17:38John Siracusa: I have a question for you. Out of curiosity, I don't mean for this to sound like a gotcha, so if it does, I apologize. Why are you using Overcast as the business account and not setting up a bespoke business account for each of your apps? The reason I ask this is because last I remember thinking about this, which admittedly was years ago, it was very, very difficult to unravel an Apple developer account such that you could sell just one of the apps within the account. And the rule of thumb, many years ago, was to make an account per app. So this way, if you ever sold the app, you would just sell the entire account, and that was that.
18:11John Siracusa: So I'm just curious, why Overcast Radio LLC and not something else?
18:16Marco Arment: The main reason why, so first of all, what you were just saying about the difficulty of transferring apps, that has gotten more capable and easier over time. I'm sure there are still pains in the butt about it or limitations about it, But it used to be like if you ever touched iCloud, you'd never be able to transfer an app ever. Oh, yeah. I forgot about that. I don't think that's true anymore. I could be wrong. I don't think so. But at this point, I realized like no one's coming around buying my apps. These are my apps. They're going to stay in my app. And if somebody wants to give me$100 million for an app, we'll cross that bridge when we get to it.
18:52Marco Arment: I don't think it's going to happen personally. But anyway, so the reason I – it was kind of part of my year of efficiency theme this year. That as I was preparing to launch Unforgetful, I faced the same dilemma. Do I launch it under Overcast Radio LLC with my Overcast developer account? Do I start a new LLC with a new developer account? What do I do there? And as part of the year of efficiency, I went through the process of having the LLC take an S election on the taxes, which everyone seemed to think I was allowed to do given the conditions of it. And it added some complexity. I have a payroll provider that I pay myself through now and stuff.
19:37Marco Arment: So there's some complexity, but it saves a lot in taxable income. And so the question arose, like, okay, when Unforgetful was going to launch, should that just be part of that same entity to take advantage of that and all of the other kind of established infrastructure I have around Overcast Radio LLC being an entity with a developer account that makes apps? and I decided to just do it because the advantages of setting it up separately were reasonably small and unlikely and the advantages of rolling it all in turns out to be huge because I've done it the other way. I've had, you know, like I used to have my full city account that had its own apps on it.
20:15Marco Arment: Like that was like my Fire Island driving app. I had it over there. It was just kind of a pain to have everything be separate and when it's on one developer account and one LLC, so much stuff just becomes simpler, easier, more efficient things like you know i only have to have one app figures account then that covers all the apps you know i only have to like when i have relationships set up with like you know invoicing systems for hosting providers or like i you know i hired uh you know designers and stuff like i already have everything set up for that and the bank accounts are set up and the credit card is set up and everything's already set up the hosting accounts are set up the domain registration, like everything is all set up for that.
20:56Marco Arment: And it just made it a lot easier to just have it combined into one. So Overcast Radio LLC, while it is not the best name for an entity that contains these three completely unrelated apps, it does make a lot of sense, logistically speaking, and tax wise and legally and financially and everything else. And no one cares what the company name is anyway.
21:17John Siracusa: We are sponsored this week by Granola. Let me tell you something. It is long documented on the show that my memory is trash. And this has pretty much always been the case. As I get ever older, it gets ever worse. That's just the way of the world. And if you're in a situation like me where you have anything less than photographic memory, then you might want to have really robust notes for your work meetings. And if you want that, then it'd be great to have some sort of tool on your side to help you take those notes. Well, Granola is an AI-powered notepad that makes your meeting notes useful. It captures what happens in your meetings and turns it into clean, structured notes with decisions and action items pulled out and made easy to find.
21:58John Siracusa: Let me build on that a little bit. Structured notes, you say, Casey? Why, yes. This looks a whole heck of a lot like Markdown to me, and that's what we like to see. So I did a call with Syracuse a couple of months ago to try this out, and it genuinely went really well. Granola took some really robust notes. Not too much, just the right amount. It's very Goldilocks, and I mean that in a complimentary way. And what's great is for each of the line items that you see, you can drill in and get a transcript summary. And then it will also pull out poll quotes of exactly who said what with speaker attribution, who said what in the exact words they use that led them to the summary that then led them to the line item.
22:38John Siracusa: It's really, really well done. And it's really great if you're like me and you want to be present in the moment and not worry about taking notes, but also not lose track of action items after the fact. It really did work spectacularly well, and I was really, really pleased with it. So once you try it on a first meeting, it is hard to go without. You can try Granola totally free. Head to granola.ai.atp. That's G-R-A-N-O-L-A.ai.atp. All caps on the ATP. I'm not sure if it matters, but let's play it safe. To get your time back, go to granola.ai slash ATP and try it on your next call. Thank you to Granola for sponsoring the show.
23:21John Siracusa: All right, let's talk MacBook Pro with ProLED XDR display. And Allison writes, I got super excited when I heard you say that the 14-inch ProLED MacBook Pro is two-tenths of an inch thinner, but it's two-hundredths of an inch thinner. And John, you added in our internal show notes, the 14 inch is a half millimeter thinner and the 16 inch is 0.8 millimeters thinner. So there you go. Our bad.
23:48Casey Liss: Yeah, I just wrote the wrong number in the notes last time. I guess I missed the zero and I just read the wrong number. So my bad. It is not as much thinner as you would hope. But it is actually half a pound lighter.
23:58Marco Arment: Oh, by the way, regarding the ProLED XDR MacBook Pro, what a long name. I don't understand. Why didn't they just, I know they wanted a separate name because they still have the other ones and that's fine why didn't they just call it the MacBook Pro XDR yeah yeah anyway ProLED Marco I know I'll get used to it
24:20Casey Liss: don't forget about display what do you mean XDR I don't know what that means you have to tell me it's display
24:24Marco Arment: anyway but I actually cancelled and reordered it because again year of efficiency two things that helped a lot number one New York has a sales tax exemption for computers that you buy if they're primarily used to make software available for sale. And I qualify for that. So I got tax free on that. And then also after, you know, when John, you asked me during the show last week, oh, what am I doing with the old one? And I said, oh, I'll probably, you know, trade it in or sell it, whatever. Well, after the show, I typed in this show number into Apple's trade-in thing and it offered like$3 ,600. And I was like, whoa that's more than i expected um but it had a had like a glitch in the form it wouldn't give me a gift card it said like you know that much trade-in or null gift card okay take the null take the null yeah what is that apply to any price and it becomes null who knows better than nan true anyway so uh i was like oh but if i if i reorder it it lets me apply it to the current order.
25:30Marco Arment: And I checked prices on eBay for the same configuration. And obviously, you don't look at listing prices. You look at sold items. And the sold items prices were like$3 ,100 to$3 ,900. And Apple offered$3 ,650. I'll take it. So we'll see how that turns out. I haven't gotten the machine yet. So I haven't sent this one back yet. And they haven't accepted the trade-in and whatever else. But I would say, if you are thinking about upgrading and going through this process, check Apple's trading values. It was a very pleasant surprise how high that was.
26:06John Siracusa: Moving right along, a friend of the show, Guy Rambeau, points out with a screenshot that touchscreen MacBook Pros have a toggle to completely disable the touchscreen. In the same Cardner chat that I bring up many times, one of the three of us in there is, well, two of us are the same age. One of them is a few years younger than myself. and the other one, well, at least younger in body, but very much old in spirit. And he was whining and moaning about, oh, I don't want this, I don't want this, it better be able to be turned off. Well, if you are old in spirit, if not in body, and you want to turn off your touchscreen, I have great news for you, as Guy pointed out.
26:43John Siracusa: There is, I think, an accessibility option in touch called Ignore Touch Gestures, with the subtitle Ignores Gestures when using touch displays in Sidecar, and there is an on-off toggle right there. Additionally, John, you made another discovery.
26:58Casey Liss: I saw a couple of people report on this, that apparently you can set it up so that pinch to zoom acts like control mouse wheel or like a control two finger swipe. Like in other words, pinching anywhere on the screen will do the zoom thing for accessibility, which is nice, as opposed to like zooming within like the preview app or whatever. So for people who do want to touch that screen, that might be more convenient than the control two finger swipe or whatever you've been doing.
27:22John Siracusa: Yeah, I use that all the time when I don't have contacts in, and it is very helpful. And I could see pinch to zoom or pinch to full screen zoom, whatever you want to call it, being really helpful. Coming back to Guy Rambo, the glowing Apple logo on the new MacBook Pro models is controllable by software. It has a 25 hertz PWM frequency and per device calibration. Core brightness, which is the name of the framework, I guess, implements automatic brightness and controls the relationship between display and logo brightness. One interesting tidbit, the brightness of the logo is adjusted differently depending on the enclosure color.
27:54Nice.
27:55Casey Liss: So that bodes well for being able to control that using whatever private APIs that he's discovered. All right.
28:00John Siracusa: With regard to keyboard marks on the screen, Keith Huss writes, this, and we'll link it, microfiber keyboard dust cover has totally saved me from oily keyboard impressions on my 2026 MacBook Pro. It's a correctly sized, super thin microfiber cloth that you just close up in your laptop over the keyboard. They also offer size for the 14-inch MacBook Pro. And it's something like$2 on AliExpress. So not bad.
28:22Casey Liss: I always get paranoid about putting anything inside the clamshell of a laptop and closing it because there's so low tolerances. I'm afraid it's going to crack something or do something weird, but apparently Keith has had good luck with it.
28:34Marco Arment: Yeah, I've seen people use these for years. I've never been tempted to use one, but I ordered one when I saw the message. I'm like, no. Because the imprints are pretty rough on my 14-inch nanotexture, and that's what I ordered, another 14-inch with nanotexture. I'm like, okay, I think the time has come for me to try this method.
28:53John Siracusa: All right. There is some dissension in the ranks. John, I can introduce this if you'd like, but I feel like it might be best if you take us through this.
29:01Casey Liss: Yeah, I wish I had known about this last episode because it would have really colored my comments on the new MacBook Pro with ProLED XDR display. But, yeah. So Jeff writes, on the new MacBook Pro ProLED, the bottom corners of the screen are rounded. app kit prefers to keep your window corners concentric with the display instead of clipping them for content inside the window you can use apis like ns view layout region uivue layout region geometry proxy container corner insets and corner container corner offset to easily constrain your layout against the changing radius and there is a video linked we will link the jeff's post and the video i would encourage both of you to look at the video if you have not but and while i explain what's going on here so what jeff is saying is that um the screen the physical screen on the pro led macbook pros have rounded corners on the top and the bottom time was when apple made screens that were rectangular and then they started rounding the top corners on the laptops and that was not great but there was some precedent because back from the original macintosh on the original macdose had a nine inch crt and it was rectangular okay um but the menu bar had black pixels in the upper left and upper right corners that made the menu bar look like it had rounded top corners it didn't the screen was just not drawing those it was a monochrome display right so it was a white menu bar and they just didn't light up those pixels if you played a full screen game or whatever of course it would use those pixels but when the menu bar was visible it rounded them and that's kind of what apple was doing with rounding the corners of the display although the radius was much bigger in the modern age but apple wasn't just not drawing the pixels there they would either not include those pixels in the screen or cover them with parts of the bezel or whatever so you could never put a pixel in the corner of the screen because there was no corner they rounded the top and bottom corners and i didn't like that but you know the menu bar is up there anyway and guys so if you if you play full screen video you're going to miss the corners it's annoying but whatever now they rounded the bottom corners now they've gone too far too far it's so terrible again the physical screen does not have pixels like you can't see them if they're there they're covered maybe they're not there entirely they've rounded the top and bottom corners of the screen on the pro lid laptops and it's not a small corner radius it's pretty big you have to watch this video because the problem is let's say you have a window that has like they show like a sidebar with like a filter at the bottom of the sidebar where you can type things in to filter the sidebar or something and you know there's a corner radius on the window because mac os 27 windows do have a rounded corner but that corner radius is not as big as the physical corner radius on the screen so if you take that window and move it down to the lower left corner it's like uh-oh we're about to clip your ui because some part of your ui now is going to be hidden in the pixels that we refuse to sell you in the corner of your screen and they're like oh don't worry we've updated app kit and ui kit and all these other things so that your app can detect when that's happening and squirm the damn controls away from the corner and also make the corner radius of the window bigger as it approaches the corner so it can nestle into the corner and shove the text field over also that ui isn't clipped or they could just make a rectangular screen to show rectangular content on their rectangular laptops this is so incredibly dumb it just it boggles my mind someone thought this was a good idea and then someone said but but but what about when people they're not going to be able to see stuff there what if they have it like oh don't worry i've got a solution the solution was not this is a terrible idea we should never do this like no we can make the framework provide api so the ui will squirm out of the way and the corners of the window will get rounder but only one of the corners i think i don't know maybe there's all i can't tell the corner rounder and the text field will move out of the way someone should have stopped this and raised their hand and say what what are we doing here like what is the purpose of screen what why do screens exist what what what are they there for are they there to show us the content that's on our computer are they there to look cute and which has higher priority so incredibly dumb obviously you can connect an external display who knows maybe their external displays are going to have tennis ball size rounded corners and anytime you bring ui up near it'll morph the sides of the windows so everything squishes over so they can have big round corners on their six thousand dollar protus play xdrs if they ever make another one i am incredibly angry about this this is so dumb and is also yet another reason for me to hate laptops and i will link again in the show notes we'll link again in the show notes to uh uh martin vichari's uh post about rymar's servas's post about rounded corners and how bad they are and how they steal space and are stupid.
33:52Casey Liss: It's like, at what cost rounded corners? And the cost is incredibly high all throughout the UI, not just the corners, everywhere it's high, but like, oh, but I just like it, it's cuter. And they were too rounded in Tahoe. Now they're less in Golden Gate, so I'm okay with it. But now they're coming for the screen. Please just read these articles. If you think rounded corners aren't a big deal, who cares? It's just an aesthetic thing. It's not. It physically reduces the space. You have to see content on your screen, in every window, in every toolbar, in every sidebar, and now in the entire screen.
34:19Casey Liss: I'm very angry about this.
34:21John Siracusa: I had no idea.
34:24Casey Liss: So dumb. So dumb.
34:26Marco Arment: Honestly, why do they have to round them so much that it matters? The simple solution here is just have the standard window corner radius be small enough that it could fit a small thing in the corner. But like, no, when you're laying out content in a window, you're never putting controls or text labels at the very, very first pixel, like a near any edge. You're always spacing it in by at least five to 20 pixels or points.
34:58Casey Liss: You could in like a CAD app that has like a bar along the bottom with lots of things. You could put it in a totally lower left corner. But I will point out. But nobody would do that. You would always set it in by at least like five or 10 points, at least. like again some apps really want to use every inch of the screen especially like really technical apps that don't care how they look like a cat app or a 3d app with a million text fields everywhere but i will point out these are remember these are the oled macbook pros one of the strengths is oled is that you can turn off pixels and they're totally black so guess what just make the screen have all the pixels and if you want rounded corners fine don't light up those pixels but oh if you have a problem the solution is oh for the in this instance we have to light up the pixels because you shove the window in the corner.
35:36Casey Liss: Like what? You can have your cake and eat it too. You won't even be able to tell that the pixels are there because you just turn them off, right? There's no reason to physically not include those pixels on this incredibly expensive display. Do what the original Mac did. Include the pixels. Just don't light them up and it will be invisible because it's black. So dumb.
35:56John Siracusa: All right. Before John completely finishes crashing out, let's move on to the iPhone Duo. I feel like we talked about this at least in passing last episode, but the iPhone duo will welcome you if you purchase it from an Apple store. And I think only in the U S and we had talked about, I'd seen a couple of reports of this full buy online. I did order one from an Apple store, picked it up in an Apple store. I was the first person I'm pretty sure to pick it up in my Apple store. This did not happen for me. I'd seen, and I don't have a source for this, but I'd seen somebody say that they were asked if they wanted it, wanted this personalization to happen.
36:29John Siracusa: And they had to wait like five minutes for, you know, magic to happen with that toast thing, whatever it's called that magical box. that they've come up with. But anyways, Luke Miani's video has an example of this, and we'll put a link in the show notes, a timestamp link in the show notes, so you can see this, but sure enough, in cursive, it says while it's opened, hello, Luke. And I kind of wish that this had happened for me just because I think it's fun, but apparently not 100 % execute. They don't execute 100 % of the time.
36:59Casey Liss: Yeah, I think it is that little toaster or pizza oven where you put it in or whatever. You would think like, oh, they'll just put it on a server somewhere and you know they don't need to put it in a pizza oven they'll just give you the box and when you open it up it'll connect to the server and find out who you are but that's at this point when you just open it up it doesn't even have a network connection so we can't look it up on this this is like literally the first thing that you see before it connects to wi-fi before it connects to cellular before anything just took it out of the box so it has to be some kind of thing that they you know use their little we can reprogram your device while it's in the box and they just you know put in your name or whatever it's cool yeah i think it's it's
37:33Marco Arment: a fun little tweak i have not seen it on um either of the two duos i've unboxed um but i also get the impression that apple retail is you know struggling to keep up i'd say with the with the realities of the duo launch like it's been a lot for them because of course like you know the stock is you know very very small volume people are very highly demanding and people are still lining up outside Apple stores every single day trying to get duos, mostly because there's a huge market for resale. But also, I was in the city yesterday and I saw two duos in use by real people in the wild, which is now tied for how many times I've seen the iPhone Air used by real people in the wild.
38:21Marco Arment: But real people are also, it isn't all just being resold. Real people are actually using it for themselves also. And there's just no supply. So I've heard from the retail people that like, you know, basically everyone, you know, we mentioned last week that I was using, I mentioned I was using one of those like stock tracking sites to alert me when they came in stock. Well, everyone's doing that. And people are using AI agents to like buy them for them as quickly as possible when they do come in, like the moment they come in stock. So like one, I found, I learned the answer to, I mentioned last episode that when I tried to pick up, when I picked up the two terabyte model that I, the only one I could get, I asked if I could change the payment method to my business credit card.
39:04Marco Arment: See, also year of efficiency. And I was told then that they couldn't. Well, I found out from some birdies why they couldn't. So the way their system would work, it's already paid for when you go to pick it up. And so they would have to process it as a return and then have me rebuy it. But the moment it's scanned in as a return, it goes back into available inventory for the store and then someone else could grab it online. And they would because they have AI bots running and monitoring websites and everything. And so they would not have a way to guarantee that they could resell the same one back to me a moment later because somebody else would probably grab it in the meantime.
39:44Marco Arment: So that's the reality of what like the kind of conditions and like speeds and everything that Apple retail is dealing with right now. So I'm guessing like once this all calms down, which could be weeks or months away, then I'm guessing they're going to have more time to like apply these customizations and things like that. That, you know, that might be different and better than for now. I wouldn't expect this to be a common occurrence.
40:09John Siracusa: Donald Decodes is apparently a YouTube channel and they have a good explanation behind the nanotexture layer on the iPhone Duo. We'll put a link to that in the show notes.
40:19Casey Liss: yeah they did a really good job of like explaining slowly and very carefully why does this layer exist how is this particular one designed and how does it do the job that it does and how is it different than other things really good video highly recommend yep it was very good uh then
40:33John Siracusa: we have to bring up i think we again made passing mention of this last episode now we need to really properly dig in uh crack gate or whatever you'd like to call it uh andy anako on the 24th of october this is the day after release if i'm not mistaken right check out the newly minted iphone duo subreddit it's filled with posts from happy day one owners as well as ones from people whose screens broke almost instantly these busted duos are all broken in the same way vertically along the crease with a thick horizontal bar about two-fifths of the way up on the right hand side does doesn't this consistency imply an underlying design or manufacturing defect yes jp yes it does jpeters at the verge two days later on the 26th here's apple's full statement from apple's alex alex kirschner the response to iphone duo from early users has been incredibly positive and we're seeing exciting things from developers who are rapidly updating their apps to take advantage of its unique form factor we are aware of an issue impacting some impacting the inner display on a small number of iphone duo units if users experience issues with their iphone duo display they should
41:30Casey Liss: contact apple care for a replacement the statement was fine and like you know this type of thing like i know people are mad they're like oh there's a problem and apple's not doing it's like they're gonna like if your thing breaks on the day you buy it apple's just gonna replace it for free like Like, if they start doing this right after all your AppleCare runs out, then that's a big thing and we need to make a big stink. But right now, I feel like it's just, it's a bummer and it's sucky and Apple's going to have to eat the cost of it or whatever. But as an owner, it's mostly just like, oh, I got unlucky and I got one of the bad ones.
42:01Casey Liss: But you're going to get a new phone.
42:03Marco Arment: Well, see, the problem. Okay, so first of all, all of these problems are exacerbated by the shortages because these stores can't keep a lot of spare stock. because they have no stock. So, yeah, obviously, if this happens to your phone, Apple's going to take care of you, but you still have to either return it by mail or go to the store and wait for a new one. And if you go to the store, they might not have one that day or that week to give you.
42:34Casey Liss: Yeah, no, it is a bummer. I'm not saying it's not a bad thing that happens to you, but all these stories, people bring out the pitch for us and they're like, Apple knows about this and is denying it and is refusing to repair it. It's like none of that is happening. It's a bummer, and it's bad. bad that like apple's first phone has problem it doesn't surprise me though like honestly it's a very difficult complicated fragile thing and apple's gonna screw it up on their first time
42:54Marco Arment: out yeah and here's the thing i don't think the evidence that we have so far shows that it is an inherent flaw to the design it looks like you know based on people who have figured out there's like there's one part inside the hinge that seems like it has a weak point and cracks at a certain point, but that seems like it could either be easily tweaked halfway through the build of this product or something, or it seemed like it was just literally like a bad run of that part that has a weakness in it from a bad manufacturing run or something. Because it's not happening to every duo. You know, the reviewers that put them in bending machines thousands of times, it never happened to them.
43:33Marco Arment: So obviously, it isn't happening to all of them. That being said, it is obviously a significant issue. But again, what does that mean? It doesn't mean 5 % of them fail. That's a lot in terms of absolute numbers. But does it mean the one that you personally have will fail in this way? Probably not. But that is still a big issue for Apple. And they do have to and will be dealing with it. And when they say a small number, that is PR speak. That is standard procedure. You always say it's a small number. That doesn't mean it's a small number. but it again probably anecdotally is probably at least a reasonably small percentage so this is a bigger problem than they are saying in all likelihood but it is not the biggest problem in the world and it does seem like it is not a guarantee that every duo will break this way but we will see and again all these problems are exacerbated by the short supply once the supply gets better.
44:32Marco Arment: Maybe they can, you know, maybe they iron out some of the manufacturing issues that might be causing this flaw to happen. Maybe, you know, obviously repairs and replacements would get easier to do and faster to do. So that will, that will, that will kind of heal all wounds, like as volume goes up. I would expect this is probably going to be widespread enough that I bet it gets one of those extended warranty coverage things they do, where like they'll just cover it for free past AppleCare for a couple of years. Like it seems like it's that scale of problem. So again, not every unit, but it's certainly a lot of them.
45:09Marco Arment: So, you know, stay tuned for that. Like in one year from now when all of their stock AppleCare plans expire, I bet this issue still gets fixed for free.
45:18Casey Liss: Yeah, we'll see if it ends up being a manufacturing defect or design defect or whatever. But that's the thing to worry about. Not happening anything that happens like on the first batch that they made on like day one or whatever. like you figure they'll address that it's the problem is a year from now if screens are breaking like this a year from now now you have a serious problem now you need one of those programs now there's a class action lawsuit like that's where things get serious but day one the first one's off the assembly line um it doesn't surprise me that there's a problem and yeah apple's never going to tell you what the percentage is they're not going to tell you like that so that's all
45:46Marco Arment: you'll find that out in the class action lawsuit but uh but like i get like i guarantee you it's higher it's higher than they're trying to make us think but it's lower than it being the end of the world but i i do think this will end with that outcome i think it will have a class action lawsuit i think it will have an extended service bulletin or whatever those are called like i think those things will happen but for for a given iphone duo owner we don't know like what how likely is it that your phone will break in this way at some point that is it doesn't seem like
46:15Casey Liss: it's super high right now well there's some complications that we'll get to in a second but first for the one person who did try to figure out what the problem was or has a theory anyway
46:22John Siracusa: Right. So Terrence O 'Brien at The Verge writes, YouTuber Curious Haggy was able to reproduce the cracked screen during some durability testing of the iPhone Duo. We'll put a link to that YouTube video in the show notes.
46:34Casey Liss: And that's the one where it's like, like, uh, this is where they're all breaking. The line is on the same plot to the place of mine broke in the same way. I opened it up. I looked underneath the part where that line was and lo and behold, a piece of the hinge cracked and it just was free flowing and loose. It must've cracked and flung itself up against the back of the screen, which hits it in exactly that spot. And it's like, okay, I believe that's how their phone broke because there's literally a broken piece of metal right under the part of the screen that broke a, that metal shouldn't be broken and b smoking gun it's right it's right underneath the the place where the screen got damaged but does that mean that's how they all have broken because i haven't seen the other ones opened up so it's a good theory uh but there's more to it now we get to our friend uh i don't know what this person's name is is his name actually jerry i don't know i i believe there
47:20John Siracusa: was a recent video where he said his name isn't actually jerry and jerry was like a relative like
47:25Casey Liss: his grandfather or something like that mkbhd uh referred to him by name i don't remember what it was though maybe it was zach or something anyway so this is uh jerry rig everything and there's a
47:35John Siracusa: timestamp link in the uh show notes but uh quote unquote jerry uh peeled off the uh the matte layer on top of the screen and shows he has two duos side by side one with the covering and one without and you can see the difference i understand people who are worked up about how muted the colors are on the inner screen and so on and so forth. But for me, as someone who does use this phone outdoors, including in strong sunlight, that and I'm not as discerning as like, I don't know with John Syracuse, for example, I don't mind the matte screen. And in fact, I think I prefer having this because it's so much more useful outdoors in sunlight.
48:17John Siracusa: So for my personal taste, I vastly prefer the way it is, the way it looks with the matte layer on top. But I absolutely concede and concede and can see that the color reproduction is definitely better without that matte layer on top
48:33Casey Liss: of it yeah there's a different different background behind these two so it kind of messes it up but yeah like if you like the the shiny one you could in theory take off the matte thing but keep in mind that the matte thing isn't just doing light diffusion it's also literally protecting the screen it's another layer of protection so it serves that function as well so i would not recommend this and also i think this is the same video or maybe it was one of the other reviews that explained like you can't put this you know apple and apple replaces this they have to do it with like you know fraction of a fraction of a millimeter precision because of the way that like when you fold it the the layers slide past each other slightly and it's it's it's not the type of thing where you can say ah this is close enough because you literally fold it in half so please don't try this at home but that's that's this whole challenge i rig everything he destroys
49:14Marco Arment: phones like that's that's the that's the deal yeah that's a task best left to youtubers not us
49:19John Siracusa: yes all right uh also from that video do not get sand in your duo uh jerry rig everything puts a pile of sand on the duo and it would no longer close or open all the way due to sand getting in the hinge uh there i feel like there was another video that we that you linked right below it in the notes okay there you go thank you uh where this is also spoken about sorry i watched a lot of youtube videos this morning that john had come up with um so they all kind of blurred of dust like on paper the duo should be able to keep it out given the ip67 rating 68 68 thank you uh but in reality it seems perhaps a little less cut and dry so that's that's the thing with the
50:01Casey Liss: rating so the the second video is from i fix it i fix it did like the fine neon dust we'll have timestamp links to both the jerry rig everything sand and the i fix it neon dust uh and jerry rig it's just destroying stuff and seeing how it works and then i fix it would like opened it up and just a forensic of like it's like very brightly colored dust you can see where it went and not where it didn't go and here's the deal according to i fix it uh their examination of it it seems like and this is a real kind of like loophole that apple should address at some point that the rating ip68 or whatever it is is about water and dust ingress into the part where the computer lives not the hinge because the dust didn't get into the place where the soc is the place where the ram is the place where you know dust and water didn't get into those areas but it a hundred percent got into the hinge that's why i was so shocked when they get this rating because like how are they sealing the hinge because the the the screen like floats over this empty chasm i'm like oh maybe there's just like a sealed area below where the like where the screen loops into there so it doesn't you know like maybe they sealed that up nope that's where the hinge lives sand can 100 % get in there and when it does get in there say goodbye to your hinge like the phone wouldn't even close anymore because the sand was in there crunching and crunching away and this is part of the thing of like lots of people put lots of grit in the hinge and then they would try to open it and it's like it won't even open all the way it won't even go flat and they'll just like i'm gonna force it because i'm a youtuber i'm gonna force it and they force it and you know what happens the hinge breaks and pokes the screen so now a year from now when someone says look i I have the line on my screen.
51:39Casey Liss: It's just like those day one people. Their thing broke when they took it out of the box. I have the same thing. It's obviously a manufacturing defect. Is it? Or did you get one piece of sand under that part of the hinge and then force it open? And that one piece of sand caused that little thing to snap. I'm not saying the people whose things broke out of the box. That's a manufacturing defect or something or a design flaw. But a year later, if you get sand and grit into your hinge and you force it open and then your hinge cracks and then it hits your screen and breaks it in the same place. that i feel like is not really you know this it's not the same problem as the other thing like apple should still replace it under apple care if you still have it or whatever but like it's not a well i know the class action loss it works out is it a design flaw that because this is true of all the folding phones basically if you get sand in the hinge it's game over so do not take your iphone duo to the beach just don't do it like it doesn't take a lot of sand to render this inoperable and it's not like you can open it up and just i'll just blow it out like a Nintendo cartridge and it will be fine.
52:35Casey Liss: No. Like, it's a very delicate piece of machinery. And although they sealed up the two halves, the two halves are waterproof and dustproof. The hinge is not part of the two halves and it is absolutely not dustproof. So do not get fine particulates anywhere near that hinge. You will be sad. Yeah. And I think, like, and look, I'm not saying that
52:57Marco Arment: Apple should design this to tolerate YouTubers pouring sand into it. They're obviously doing a significant stress test but i think this is worth thinking about like you know are you the kind of person that has to frequently clean a bunch of dust out of the port from the bottom of your phone
53:10Casey Liss: is there sand in the pocket of your jacket where you put your phone right or or just like like how
53:14Marco Arment: often do you have to like clean dust from around your phone from your pocket or whatever storage situation you have are you frequently having to like you know clean under under the case ridges that you of your case or whatever like again putting stuff out of the port pulling stuff out of the speaker holes. Like if you operate your phone in conditions or store your phone in conditions where you're going to have a lot of lint and dust and sand possibly like, yeah, the Duo and any foldable is probably not a great choice for you, or at least you should probably get Apple care for the duration of the time that you're going to have it.
53:45Marco Arment: But it looks like, you know, look, Apple has done an admirable job sealing it up from the elements reasonably, but you have to still keep in mind it is still a folding phone in the same way that like even if they do a really great job you know if they do like a macbook pro and they try to seal it up from any kind of you know small ingresses it's like it's still a laptop laptops inherently have a bunch of entry points and are inherently very sensitive to certain types of things like dust and liquids where your phone is more easily sealed up well a foldable phone is going to be less inherently sealable and inherently water and dust proof than a regular slab phone that's always going to be the case because it has this incredibly intricate moving hinge that is constantly being open and closed throughout usage of the phone i think they could seal a laptop because i think
54:38Casey Liss: the laptop's hinge is sealable but the way the screen folds into a little empty area on phones currently no one has come up with a way to either see because you have two choices you can seal that which apple has chose not to do or try to do or you can make the mechanism tolerate you know tolerate dust coming into it like some way to like get the dust out and let it like make all the gaps big enough that everything falls through it and doesn't get caught within it uh and with current screen technology sealing it seems to be impossible but laptops could be sealed if apple really wanted to because i think that the hinge on laptops is the type of thing like you know it's it's not there's no like oled screen looping itself in and filling a cavity and like a double-edged hinge like the hinge inside this is so complicated look at the hinge on a macbook pro it's simple and there's you could easily make that so no dust can get in there and even if something does get in there it's not going to break anything so like but yeah no one no one has any idea how to do with folding and apple's a big achievement here is hey the two halves of the phone are sealed nothing's going to get in there but my folding phone is useless to me if i can't fold it or unfold it because the hinge is hosed.
55:43John Siracusa: Yep. Right. So just to recap, like JerryRigEverything's video and then iFixit also puts some extremely fine dust in a baggie and shakes the duo in a baggie and shakes it all up and it's also... And then they opened
55:57Casey Liss: it up and found, say, where did that dust go? And the answer is it all went in the hinge. Yeah, of course. And not in the other parts. Like they opened up the other halves and like it didn't get in here, but it did get in the hinge.
56:09Marco Arment: We are sponsored this episode by I've been using Claude a lot more recently. And look, there's only so much I can say in a two-minute ad read. Let me just tell you some things I've been doing with it more recently. So first, I had it build me a financial dashboard. I had it build a connector using some third-party secure services to log into my stuff, download reports, and build me a financial and tax dashboard for my businesses and my personal stuff. So that's amazing. I also have it now monitoring feedback channels for my apps so that it is now, as much as it can, finding feedback and bug reports, and then combing through Xcode Organizer and combing through emails and stuff, trying to figure out, are problems being reported?
56:46Marco Arment: What are some new problems? Is there anything it can quickly go in and fix or make tests for so we can both do it together? It's been amazing. I do so much with Claude now, and it just blows me away how capable it is the more I ask it to do. Claude is the AI for problem solvers. It's the collaborator that understands your entire workflow and thinks with you, not for you. Whether you're debugging code at midnight, building a financial model, or strategizing your next business move, I've done all these things, to a lot of extent you're thinking to tackle the problems that matter. Really, I'm just so impressed with how much it's able to do with relatively little specific guidance for me.
57:24Marco Arment: Obviously, I tell tweaks I want to make here and there are the things it makes, but for the most part, boring stuff like, hey, this user's reporting a CloudKit bug. See if You can figure it out. A few minutes later, it's like, all right, I figured it out. Here it is. You want to pull a request? It's incredible. I've had such good luck having Claude handle work I don't want to do or find bugs I would never have found on my own or analyze data to find patterns and correlations I would never have seen in my own. So it's just amazing. Discover what's possible. Try Claude at Claude.ai slash ATP. That's Claude.ai slash ATP.
58:00Marco Arment: and check out Claude Pro, which includes access to all the features that I mentioned in this ad read. Claude.ai slash ATP. Thank you so much to Claude for sponsoring our show.
58:14John Siracusa: Basic Apple guy writes something that I did not notice, but I find fascinating. The iPhone Duo lists two batteries in the battery health thing in settings. I'm looking at mine right now. and yeah, they look identical, same maximum capacity, same cycle count, same manufacture date, same first use. But sure enough, there's battery one and battery two.
58:37Casey Liss: And they're two different sizes. They don't show that on the screen, but they are two very differently sized batteries.
58:41John Siracusa: Steven Robles points out something that I've discovered probably since we last recorded, but I'm glad that I think John put this in the show notes because I would have forgotten to bring it up. iPhone mirroring absolutely works on the Duo, but just the outer screen. And as far as Steven and I can tell, there's no way to open it, if you will, to the inner screen, which is fine, but a bummer. And I hope that gets better over time. Sam Shepard writes, they wrote directly to us, I believe, but I'd seen this floating around in a couple of places and it is brilliant and I've tried it and it works. Sam Shepard is unlocking the iPhone Duo with kind of his like index finger first or zero with the first knuckle area.
59:24John Siracusa: It's very hard to paint a word picture about this, but imagine If you're looking at your palm and you're going from the place where your index finger meets your palm to the first hinge, the first knuckle, that's what Sam registered with Face ID and I've since done as well. And it's not foolproof, but it works pretty well. And Sam has a really good and very short video on Mastodon where he talks about what he's done and shows a demonstration of it. This gets my, to use a Merlinism, official okie-dokie. This was a great idea and it's working pretty well for me.
59:53Casey Liss: I think this is lowering your security because there's just not as many lines and swirls on that part of your finger. There's some, but not enough that I feel like that. I think that's drastically reducing the security. It's like when people register like their dog's nose or their cat's paw on Touch ID when it first came out. Like you can do it, but I don't necessarily recommend this. And I put Sam Shepard's thing in here because I think he was the very first person I saw do this before all the other later articles. I want to give credit where credit is due. and there's a picture in his post and you can see you know how he i i circled it in red in our show notes but you'll see it i think it's like a video it's you just grab the phone around there and you push that pad of your finger against touch id and it unlocks but go look at that pad on your finger right now and then look at your fingertip and compare the complexity and number of ridges and swirls i feel like this is a secure downgrade well you might be right i think apple
1:00:43Marco Arment: giving us like a little bit of security downgrade opting in like i it's a tricky question like should they allow us to have lower security on our devices it's a like you can get me to answer that question both ways depending on what day you ask me right it's a tough decision you know one thing you could potentially argue is like well wouldn't this phone be better and maybe something also like an iPad non-pro, like an iPad mini, wouldn't these be better with some kind of camera-based Face ID option that you could say, all right, well, for basic unlocking, let me just use the front camera if you don't have Face ID hardware and just try to recognize me and maybe don't let me make purchases that way or access sensitive data like unlocking a password app or your secure notes.
1:01:34Marco Arment: I think as the iPhone line goes on, if they continue to have the duo and it continues to succeed, which seems likely. And they're always going to have the challenge of where to put Face ID hardware in this. Like, do you put only one on the outside? Do you put two entire sets of it, one on the outside and one on the inside, so it can work the same way in both? I think that, and, you know, that's obviously a physical space problem. It's a looking through the screen problem, and it's a cost problem. So there's multiple large problems to try to do that. so there's going to be I think persistent demand in the iPhone ecosystem for some alternative to Touch ID but where Face ID in its full form can't or won't reasonably fit so I think they will probably be pushed by market demand to address this problem in some way maybe that way is kind of what they're doing with HomeView remember HomeView?
1:02:28Marco Arment: they have this camera based facial recognition and it does provide like a lower level of security that gives you access to some things but doesn't give you access to everything without a higher level that's an added
1:02:40Casey Liss: level of complexity where is my phone completely unlocked or partially unlocked i really don't think they're going to do that i think apple's current solution is uh apple watch unlock which they love because it makes you buy another apple device and they're like we already have a solution to this it's called unlock with your apple watch and it's very secure yeah but a lot of iphone
1:02:55Marco Arment: owners don't also own apple watches and then they use touch id and then they trained it on their cat's nose and lower their security right or well and also but you can also make an argument that like when when all these mechanisms inevitably fail which look both both touch id and face id fail all the time and require you to enter your passcode all the time what happens people have low security passcodes it's like they they eventually give up make their passcode 1212 and that's like you look around at what like what do regular people do it's that it is the phone equivalent of sticking a post-it note with your computer password that your network admins made you you know made you set on the monitor or under the keyboard tray or something because you know like security can only be so inconvenient or complicated before people will just route around it so if the system is so cumbersome and annoying and limited that people are just having to enter their passcode 20 times a day and having the passcode possibly be simpler to make easier and that just increases the odds of other people guessing or shoulder surfing it that's not actually serving security so it is it's a very tricky question but i think you know obviously the easier you can make good security the better and these things are always in tension but i do think the the answer here is probably going to be they probably need some kind of visual camera based face id alternative for people who choose it but i think if they did that i think they'd
1:04:22Casey Liss: make it unlock it fully like they don't make if you make your code one one one one they unlock the phone fully man like that's that's you that's there is no like lower security mode where it's like okay you have a garbage passcode so you're not really unlocking everything you can't purchase with it your pass your icloud keychain is unlocked nope if you make that your passcode it will unlock everything just like it has always done so i think they that's their way of kind of leading up to the user it's like if you want to make one one one one your passcode uh good luck out there yeah but
1:04:50Marco Arment: But that's not an amazing outcome for anybody. Like if what you need to do to make your phone convenient for you to use is to make your passcode 1111 because either Touch ID is too slow or fails all the time or you're trying to use Face ID in challenging situations such as outdoors, that's not actually serving anybody's security. and it that that that just becomes security theater at that point it's like oh great i'll jump through all these hoops you know that apple's making me jump through you know because i haven't entered my code and then like okay well my code's 1111 because i have to enter it five
1:05:24Casey Liss: times a day and it's really annoying i know but like the camera based ones it's a real problem like that's why they make the home view so incredibly limited because someone can just print a picture of you from the internet and hold up in front of the phone and that's that's they don't want to go that far like the real question is like what's the threat model if someone steals my phone can they unlock it well if they shoulder shift the code i'm screwed even if my code is
1:05:41Marco Arment: really complicated so that's bad well but look look at android phones and most android phones do camera based face id and it's not like look it used to be really bad no one's stealing those that's true but it used to be really bad when they first did it but like it is more secure now than it used to be and it's less secure than touch id i feel like maybe but again like maybe for a lot of people that would be fine it's certainly better than one one one one yeah i think apple just needs
1:06:07Casey Liss: to make the face ID hardware smaller and cheaper like they and put it in Macs for crying out loud like so that's that's the path they're traveling hopefully this will be a transient problem where it's like remember when face ID couldn't fit in our devices and now it's so thin it's in everything
1:06:18John Siracusa: that's where we need to go one last piece of iPhone duo and actually just follow up in general reachability is coming to the duo in 27.3 as per Julie Clover at Mac rumors reachability can be enabled in settings accessibility touch reachability it is on by default after updating to the iOS 27.3 beta. When the iPhone Duo is closed, a short swipe left on the left edge or a short swipe right on the right edge will shift the outer display's content left or right. And there's a couple of images in that article.
1:06:48Casey Liss: Is this the first time reachability has gone left to right instead of top to bottom?
1:06:51Marco Arment: I believe so. I mean, the Duo has a lot of things where the first time something is on the left to right instead of the top or bottom.
1:06:59John Siracusa: We are sponsored this week by Tailscale. Let me throw a hypothetical at you. Suppose you're the kind of person that would listen to a podcast called the Accidental Tech Podcast. And suppose you have a bunch of devices, not necessarily servers, just devices. And maybe you have some like phones or tablets or what have you. You have a laptop or maybe a machine at home. Maybe you have some sort of device at your parents' house, like a Raspberry Pi. Maybe, I don't know, you have a fleet of 40 plus Mac minis co-located somewhere. Weirder things can happen. Am I right? Well, what if you wanted all of those devices to be able to talk to each other without having to worry about where they are?
1:07:35John Siracusa: Not geographically, not in terms of network topology. They can just always talk to each other no matter what. Well, that's what Tailscale does. Tailscale is freaking magic. You remember when things used to just work? Well, Tailscale just works. And what it is, it's a modern, secure, zero-trust connectivity platform. And it provides It's an easy and fast way to securely connect from and to any device or service anywhere. It is truly incredible. My entire computing life pretty much runs on tail scale. I use it to connect to a Synology at my folks house and not have to port forward anything because it's all protected in my tail net.
1:08:12John Siracusa: I use it to connect to my Linode instance, a DigitalOcean instance. I could stand up a Linode node in Australia if I wanted to and connect to it lickety split. It is truly incredible. And the great thing is Tailscale's personal plan will be free forever for up to six users and unlimited devices. No credit card is required. They'll never ask you for one. And you can go to Tailscale.com slash Accidental Tech to get started. And additionally, if you'd like to bring Tailscale to work, use code Accidental Tech, all one word, for three free months of any paid plan. Thousands of companies like Microsoft, NVIDIA, and The New York Times have already made the switch.
1:08:49John Siracusa: You owe it to yourself to check out Tailscale. Again, T-A-I-L-S-C-A-L-E.com slash A-C-C-I-D-E-N-T-A-L-T-E-C-H. Tailscale.com slash Accidental Tech to get started. Thank you to Tailscale for sponsoring the show.
1:09:06John Siracusa: All right, let's talk topics. And we probably only have one kind of interrelated topic for tonight. And that is, we're going to start with Phil Schiller's long exit. And kind of some rumors about Ternus' plans for Apple. This is from early September, and Mark Gurman writes, Phil Schiller's exit is notable. The veteran executive ran the App Store and Apple Events. The App Store portion alone generates an estimated$30 billion a year. Schiller is 66 years old and clearly wanted to have some semblance of retirement. But there's a bit more to the story, I'm told. Tarnas and Services Chief Eddie Q want to make even more money from the App Store and figure out ways to raise margins and squeeze additional recurring revenue from the platform.
1:09:48John Siracusa: Schiller, on the other hand, seems to believe that such moves will only further irk developers and governments. While there was no internal blow up or anything like that, it's something he wanted no part of. Let the record show that Phil Schiller is the only active Apple executive to come on the show and is clearly the best one of them all.
1:10:06Casey Liss: Obviously. Well, so here's the thing. The umbrella topic that we're talking about here is what kind of CEO will John Ternus be? This was, I think, from like not before he took over, but like right when he did or whatever. And it's it's German. So his sources are usually real. But on the other hand, it is kind of like rumors from inside the company, you know, who someone who claims to know the mind of Phil Schiller. It's like it's supposedly this is a thing that Ternus and Andy Q want and supposedly part of Schiller doesn't want it. And he's leaving and you connect the dots and it's like, well, he doesn't want any part of that.
1:10:39Casey Liss: And it's just it's, you know, there are many logical leaps leading to this story of like, you know, Ternus and Q want to do this thing and Schiller because he's a good person doesn't. And so he's leaving. And I'm not sure I buy that story. But as one of the first sort of inside scoop story from someone who normally has, you know, actual real inside scoops from Apple. Having it say, hey, your new CEO that you're all excited about, you know, one of the things that he wants to do. squeeze more money out of the app store talk about the thing you do not want to hear you're like no no no john that's not you're supposed to we're you're new and you're supposed to fix things this is worse this is taking a bad thing and making it where i'm eddie q like whatever we just like yeah isn't he adorable he wants money from services he loves services and goes to basketball games or whatever but you're the new ceo and we didn't like what tim cook was doing to the app store and you come in and the first rumor we read about you is yeah the app store we can squeeze more out of that we need we need additional recurring revenue from the platform it's like i hope i mean the schiller thing is a sideshow i don't i think she'll retire because he's he's old and wants to retire like and maybe he does or doesn't disagree with this but he presided over the app store during lots of things that we disagreed with and who knows what happens there so i'm putting schiller entirely aside and i'm saying i mostly discount the idea that he's leaving because he disagrees with what turnus wants to do with the app store i feel like that is not why he's leaving but who knows but i desperately want this rumor about what turnus wants to do to the app store to be not true i'm willing to believe eddie q wants that i want turnus to say no no eddie let's not squeeze the developers even more because they already hate us
1:12:22John Siracusa: yep we'll see i don't love the sign the sound of this but we'll see if it's actually true and this
1:12:28Casey Liss: was september i haven't heard anything about it since and if anything german occasionally gets wrong it's like oh hearsay from inside the company who knows who the sources are and what agendas they have like this is not like there's a new product coming in here it respects and we'll know whether it's true this is like interpersonal drama and the thoughts and the minds of executives they're never going to say out loud but i'm keeping an eye on this does turn to start turning the screws on the app store or turning them tighter because the screws are already there and they're screwed in pretty tight already so i'm i'm watching this i think the only thing that i would you know maybe
1:13:00Marco Arment: be a little optimistic about here is mark german has really good sources for facts and much spottier
1:13:11Casey Liss: sources for reasons and stories and interpersonal drama yeah and and look and it's that stuff's hard
1:13:18Marco Arment: to validate even for us after the fact like we like when he says oh this product's going to be really this is going to have a touch screen blah blah blah like we can validate that after the fact is oh yeah he was right look german called that you know two years ago whatever it's much harder for us to know oh yeah german called the fact that this executive fought with that executive or whatever like that's that's hard for us to know and so it's hard to check this but historically speaking that kind of stuff seems like it is either never verifiable or turns out to seemingly not be true more often than his predictions about facts although in this one what we'll do is just
1:13:51Casey Liss: watch what Apple does. Do they turn, do they squeeze more money out of the App Store? Is that a turnist policy? We're not going to know it today. We're not going to know at the time the rumor comes out in September, but it's a thing we can watch.
1:14:00Marco Arment: Yeah. The other thing is like, Phil Schiller has been the head of the App Store for most of this time, including all of the really worst of the screw turning years. Like, all those years under Tim Cook that the App Store was like basically going around, like scrounging around for everyone's business model saying, hey, you guys you just launched your new startup and you're not using an app purchase. You got to give us money or you're out. That was all with Phil Schiller presiding over the App Store. Now, Phil Schiller wasn't and still isn't the CEO. So there's people above him who can overrule him.
1:14:36Marco Arment: And we saw in some of those court documents that came out that that seems to have happened at some point for certain decisions around this. But we don't know how, like, if Phil is no longer doing this, are things going to get only worse or might things get better because might some of the things that we not this is a lot of mixed verb tenses here might some of the things that we didn't like have been phil's call and maybe somebody else can change those and finally my i think my final version of this that is a little optimistic is like john turnus is new to this role he we don't know that much about him yet but so far we like what we see and i think even though like even though i don't think i agree with tim cook on a lot of a lot of the actions he took towards the end especially it was obvious that tim cook is a pretty smart person who does things in a very considered way and tim cook chose john turnus and it seems like a lot of people who we tend to think are pretty smart people who we agree with a lot seem to support John Ternus.
1:15:43Marco Arment: So the people who all work around him seem to think widely that he's a pretty good leader, a pretty good person and pretty capable for this role. So what that shows me is even if he's going into this with an idea like trying to squeeze the app store that we don't think is right, that tells all of that context suggests to me he can change his mind. like he we've all had ideas that we change our mind about look I'm an expert in this like I think we can give these people more of the benefit of the doubt that they can learn they can try things they can change their mind or fail or change course over time until and unless they show us that they can't or won't and some people do show us that some people show us that oh wow the decisions they continue to make in this area continued to be terrible, like Tim Cook's engagement with Donald Trump.
1:16:41Marco Arment: I think that was horrendous and is horrendous. And he never got better at that and still probably still hasn't. So I kind of stopped, you know, hoping for that there. But John Ternus is in many ways, many of these issues, a clean slate. We don't know how he's going to decide. So even if he said at some point, let's squeeze my money out of the app store, maybe in a year, he won't think that anymore we don't know yet um and i'm willing because he is new and seemingly pretty good in a lot of areas i'm willing to give him the benefit of the doubt that like this probably isn't the be-all end-all if it even is true which itself is a pretty big question mark this is one of the
1:17:23Casey Liss: downsides in the uh very smooth transition that they are all so happy and uh you know they're always apple exactly is always saying how proud they are of their beautiful transition from tim cook to you know obviously because obviously again the transition of steve jobs dying was not ideal and not on their time scale and you know it's just a tragedy right and so now it's like well now we don't have somebody dying we can actually plan for this let's do it well but part of that plan and part of the plan of like not spooking wall street and whatever like you know making it smooth and everything is that uh it doesn't allow the new incoming ceo to do what new incoming ceos do in companies that are in trouble because apple's not in trouble right but But if you have a company that's in trouble and you do a CEO transition, always, always, not just privately, but also publicly, the new CEO comes in and says, look, here's what I'm going to do differently.
1:18:13Casey Liss: Here's what I here's my vision for Acme Corporation. They have to because like that's their job. It's like, well, the whole point is you want a new person to come in. What is your vision for this company? We're kicking out the old one for whatever reason, probably because the company's in trouble. Tell me it happens all the time with car companies because they're always perpetually in trouble, especially American ones. It's like, what's your new vision for, you know, General Motors or whatever? And they come in and they present their vision. Ternus is absolutely not doing that because when you're taking over for Apple and Apple is not in trouble, Ternus feels like his job is to not rock the boat.
1:18:46Casey Liss: Everything's fine. It's exactly what Tim Cook had to do, which is like Steve Jobs is gone, but everything's going to be fine. No big changes. Tim Cook didn't come in and say, I have a bold new vision for Apple and it's to make cars like he didn't say that. It wouldn't have been a good thing to say. and turnus did not come in and outline his vision and we're so used to seeing that when there's a change in leadership not just in companies that are in trouble but like in any kind of like big leadership change like presumably the new leader is there for a reason but apple's idea is like no there's just there's just the institution of apple and a steward who guides the ship and there's no difference of opinion or difference of strategy it's just a smooth thing that you know don't worry about who that person is behind the curtain it's somebody is there in charge but it's just apple you know just sailing along and that's not reality but that's the face they try to give so with a rumor like this we can't compare it to remember turnus's bold new speech on day one where he said his vision for apple no there was no such thing he said the same word salad that tim cook has been saying for his entire career which is like oh apple's great and we're wonderful and it's a great company and i love it and i love technology it's like okay so in the complete absence of knowing what turnus's vision for apple is unless it happens to be exactly the same as the vision that tim cook has been articulating all we have are these terrible rumors and like i hope to god this one is not true in any way shape or form i i'm not out here hoping that he like thinks it and changes his mind i'm hoping he never thought it because boy what a wrong-headed thing to think like what of all the things this if you had to pick what is the worst possible uh strategy turnus could pursue when taking over apple i would say squeeze the app squeeze more profit And the App Store would be really high on the list.
1:20:26Casey Liss: So I'm just crossing my fingers that this is just BS.
1:20:29John Siracusa: Sure hope so. I don't know. I don't love it. But man, the services money is sweet if you ask Apple.
1:20:35Casey Liss: I mean, services, like, oh, yeah. By all means, squeeze more money out of services? Just the App Store. I didn't know. It's like, well, that's all services is. It's games and the apps. I get it. But just, like, go. If you love services revenue, there are lots of places to get services revenue. I'm not against services. I'm like, you know, do our services better and get more people to pay for them. And like, I get it. But the app store specifically, that's just like poking a wound.
1:20:59John Siracusa: All right, then continuing on, let's talk about a different post from later in September, also from Gurman. John Ternus is moving to accelerate product development, broaden Apple's range of devices and create a leaner organization with a greater focus on engineering. The early ideas under consideration include relying less on traditional spring and fall product release schedules and eliminating some middle management positions to reduce the layers separating engineers from senior executives. Ternus has indicated that Apple must introduce products more quickly and become more experimental to remain competitive in the artificial intelligence era.
1:21:34John Siracusa: There are cost-cutting efforts in motion. Ternus is also seeking new sources of revenue and ways to generate more money from existing products, especially as growth in the company's services business slows. turnus has advocated for a leaner organization for years while leading hardware engineering he told employees during an all-hands meeting that apple should hire fewer people ask more of its existing engineers and reduce organizational bloat during a presentation he showed a slide charting annual headcount growth and argued that the company should be accomplishing more with fewer employees turnus services at edq and chief financial officer kevin perek are also looking for ways for new ways to bolster revenue as growth in apple services business decelerates and its app store economics come under pressure.
1:22:15John Siracusa: They have discussed launching new services and extracting more revenue from existing products and offerings. Meanwhile, the cost-cutting will continue for the company's upcoming swath of holiday parties. Some teams have been told they won't be allowed to bring plus ones for the first time in years. Oh, no.
1:22:28Casey Liss: Trouble in paradise. Not the plus one. All right, so this is a mixed bag, okay? So this is my summary of this one in the notes is, more products, faster, leaner. So a couple things. The leaner thing. if turnus was to give a public facing you know i'm a new ceo and here's my vision for apple this would be the type of thing you might include i think our organization has too much bloat we need to be leaner like we were back in the old days when we were making you know great products there's too much too many people you know just too many layers right that is very often a problem in organizations and apple historically has uh tried not to be that but any company over time like you build up layers of management between things and it just makes it harder to like steer the ship and usually the best products are done by small teams that are close to the but there's not like 17 layers of management between you and the ceo like that's not a form of success so that's a very cliche kind of like i'm going to come in and clean house and we'll be a leaner organization but here's the problem with that apple's reputation for decades now has been the company that already puts like three people on a team that other companies who put 300 on like that's their whole thing is like oh you know again twitter had like 500 engineers working on like the search box and apple has like three people working on like this gargantuan new effort right watch os yeah like just there's but you know but like you joke about because watch os doesn't seem like it's a lot of development a lot of their big projects have been very small teams like that's their whole thing and maybe it feels like apple has drifted away from that but i look at this idea and i'm like okay so if there's too many like middle managers and people who aren't contributing by all means trim that but like to make the team smaller have the teams actually grown to the point where it's a problem or is it like back in the old days you know we had two people who made the entire g4 cube right i don't i i'm a little bit suspicious of this one because i feel like yeah again i'm i'm not that i have anything against middle managers but if you have too many of them if there's like you know you have four people doing the actual work and then 17 managers before you get to the ceo that's not a good org chart so that should be changed.
1:24:34Casey Liss: I don't know what the state of that is inside Apple. But the team sizes, everything I have heard from inside Apple is the team sizes are not out of control. If anything, everybody feels like they're under resourced, that there's not enough people on their team doing what they're being asked to do. So I, I can put this one kind of in the middle of like, it sounds like a reasonable thing that a CEO might want to do. It's not ridiculous. But I worry that, again, of all the things that Apple needs smaller teams on implementing projects is maybe not it. And then And the second part of this is more products faster.
1:25:05And this is a complicated one because, I mean, we're just coming off of so many products
1:25:13Casey Liss: have been announced just in September and October. Like this show has just been slammed. This is the most Apple, new Apple products I think we've seen released in the shortest period of time in the entire history we have done this show. But every single one of these products was planned and scheduled and executed before our turn is with CEO. You know what I mean? especially the home view which is like a year old right um but on the other hand he was in charge of hardware that whole time so is this attributable to turn this is certainly not attributable to turn this is new uh ideas as ceo but maybe he's taking his ideas from when he was head of hardware and saying you know what i did when i was head of hardware we're doing that but more that is plausible but it is so it's hard for me to say like oh he's already doing it more products faster i'm like well he wasn't ceo for those but he was the head of hardware so i don't know but like it seems like you would say he's already delivered on more products faster because god we have so many products and they're coming out faster than we could even cover them on this podcast is that a good thing for apple it's certainly different like this whole thing about like i don't just want to do it in spring and fall it takes us too long to make products that i mostly agree with because i mean there's been i've been listening to uh it's about to say 20 max for 20 20 20 but um a design in california uh jason's now in my curly's podcast that i was on uh as a guest on one of their series talking about how long it was i mean obviously the story is like you know the ipod was conceived and shipped within a single calendar year but lots of products back in those days of like the early 2000s apple uh with the exception of macOS 10 um were conceived implemented executed and shipped on incredibly short timelines whereas now we're like there's a german rumor of a device that's going to ship in 2029 and maybe it'll slip to 2030 and it's just such a long wait we wait years and years from the first rumors of the product that eventually it does come out exactly as it was rumored four years ago it's like really it took you four years to produce that whereas the old apple would have done that in a year a year and a half so i do think there's something to that of like let's not not every product needs to be this multi-year slog where we just iterate on it forever like get stuff out try things be more experimental ship more stuff don't feel beholden to these specific schedules.
1:27:25Casey Liss: But on the flip side of that, can you imagine if Apple released products at the rate it has released them in September or October? If it just did this all year long, year after year, it would just be buried in products.
1:27:36Marco Arment: But at the same time, I think there is a lot of room for them to speed that up. As you mentioned, we've seen a lot of cases where you see some story come out where like, oh yeah, a good example of this would be like, if some camera AirPods thing comes out Or Metaglasses, like we were all saying a couple years ago, like, wow, they should really get on that. It seems like it's kind of a growing market. And it's like, oh, yeah, there were rumors like, oh, yeah, they'll have that in two years from now. What? It really takes them that long to make that kind of product?
1:28:06Casey Liss: And then it doesn't ship and it's delayed for another two years. And we're like, that's the worst. They actually ship. You're like, that rumor was true. It was four years ago. It just took them four years to put it out.
1:28:16Marco Arment: But it is, you know, I recognize it is a very difficult problem because, first of all, they have high standards and they don't want to ship crap. And we like them for that. But also, when they do ship a product, they need to make it usually in much higher volumes than a lot of the other manufacturers do.
1:28:32Casey Liss: Not the home products. They should do that.
1:28:34Marco Arment: Well, that's true. But and the other thing is, like, you know, if they if we are telling them they need to release things faster, that does strain things like the software quality, which we don't want that either. But we are also in an era now where the pace of technological iteration is pretty fast right now in the industry. A lot of that's AI driven. A lot of it's not. But things are getting quickly better, faster from everybody. And competition is getting better quickly. And, of course, AI itself. We can't ignore that. That's a huge part of it. like ai you know both models and you know products and features built around those models are getting better very quickly and this is a pace that apple is not accustomed to and has not been able to meet for many many many years so they do need to speed that kind of stuff up and it is going to be hard and it is going to be messy and it is going to be imperfect but just in order to keep leading and being competitive in the industry that they're in, they do have to get a lot faster.
1:29:44Marco Arment: And honestly, they do need to get a little bit less careful with the types of products and product risks they're willing to take. I'm not saying make a bunch of spy glasses for everybody, but I am saying like, try more things. Tim Cook's Apple was pretty conservative and that served them well in a number of ways you know that's very good financially it's very good for like the stock price you know you can be pretty it's pretty predictable um very efficient with inventory and stuff like that but they didn't take a lot of like new swings under cook and the ones they did were sometimes really weird like the car or the vision pro i mean they took two big ones the
1:30:26Casey Liss: vision pro and the car were tim cook's two big swings one of them shipped one of them didn't um and there's lots of small ones where tim cook took a lot of small swings of like we're going to invest in a company that makes quartz crystals or micro led displays and a lot of those are just like fizzled out or whatever but they were it was not the type of thing of like i've got an idea for a product let's just ship it and try it because as you pointed out like that's not hasn't been apple's mo and also apple always always somehow convinces themselves and they're mostly right most of the time that like look if we make anything we have to make millions of them and so we it's harder for them to like let's just try it and see if people like it because if they do and you didn't plan to manufacture 20 million of them you're screwed especially in the current like environment with like parts and everything so you know maybe this is not timing is not great to be more daring with the things that they ship because when you're apple like that's what people you know ding apple for all this like oh look at this this android manufacturer a framework laptop why can they do it and apple can't it's like they're gonna sell 100 000 of those apple's gonna to sell 100 000 a day so like it just becomes impossible to you know it's a whole different equation of like we have to pre-buy all these parts we have to manufacture them we have to forecast demand we have to make sure where they were right it's it's harder for them it's harder for a big company to do that it's one of the disadvantages of being a big company but we'll see like the home view is arguably that the the rumored robotic home view is arguably that like there's lots of products that may actually ship that are weird and may be duds um and you know in in this recent rash of products it's been pretty straightforward it's like oh the new a new laptop a new max like the home view is the weirdest one and that one was done a year ago um so i'm not sure what will come with this but like the things i like about it the most are don't be beholden to the strict release schedule that always has to be spring and fall when it's when it's done ship it uh you know if you have an idea put it out there and maybe like just green lighting things within the company um and being a little bit more daring about that and not like i think tim cook's problem was you know he had a little bit of the everyone was asking him his entire career as ceo when's the next big thing when's the next big thing and so he felt the need to try to make the next big thing and it definitely wasn't the car but that you know that was a big thing wasn't the next big thing um and then uh the vision pro which was a big thing turned out not to be the next big thing but he's always like we have to make these big bets and then the times when he didn't where it's like we'll just make some kind of weird wireless earbed whatever that wireless earbud turned out to be a huge business and he just side-doored it like no one even thought like oh this is the next big thing but honestly it kind of was the next big thing airpods changed the world a lot more than the apple car and the vision pro did but like no one was paying attention to that one.
1:33:20Casey Liss: So I'm hoping Ternus is thinking we need to do more things like the AirPods. You know, not a big product. No one's going to put it on the cover of Time Magazine, but actually if it's successful, it'll be life-changing for a lot of people.
1:33:34John Siracusa: All right. This is from a different post in the beginning of October. Also, German. This is quite a bit for me to read, so buckle up. During early conversations about taking the CEO role, Ternus questioned whether he was up to the challenge. I'm not you, Ternus told Cook. You do so many amazing things. Cook, in his characteristically deadpan tone, replied, I know you're not me. His point was that Ternus needed to be himself. Aside, how do you hear this? How do you hear this? Presumably this conversation was just the two of them. How does Gurman know that this to be true?
1:34:07Casey Liss: It's obviously retold Game of Telephone, but can't you totally hear Tim Cook doing his like... Tim Cook has his... not his inside voice, but he has... Tim Cook has the voice that he talks to the public with, and then he has the voice that we hear tales of him talking internally in the company with. And I know you're not me. I see him saying with a totally unsmiling face in his internal company voice.
1:34:26John Siracusa: Oh, yeah. In recounting the story to employees, I guess there it is, Ternus describes it as a turning point. What Cook said, what Cook said that, quote, has really resonated and stuck with me, quote, is that he spent his time as CEO where he added, quote, the most value for Apple, Ternus said, and I need to spend my time where I can add the most value for Apple. That idea, he said, has given Ternus the freedom to approach the role differently. There will be differences in where we spend our time, but the mission, the goals, are the same. Ternus is largely leaving the company's financial operations to Chief Financial Officer Kevin Parekh and its supply chain to Chief Operating Officer Sibit Khan.
1:35:04John Siracusa: Instead, Ternus is spending considerable time with Chief Hardware Officer Johnny Shrugy and Hardware Engineering Leader tom marib remaining deeply involved in product engineering but i'm told he is also devoting substantial attention to another area that has long lacked a single overarching leader design turnus already had some involvement involvement with the design studio as apple's head of hardware engineering given the close coordination required between the two functions since becoming ceo however he has immersed himself in the industrial design and human human interface teams several people familiar with the department said he works hands-on in the studio several times a week, sometimes visiting multiple times in a single day.
1:35:41John Siracusa: One of Turnus' first priorities was to restore the design studio standing within the company. The group had lost numerous employees to Ive's firm, Love From, as well as OpenAI's hardware team and other companies. That contributed to its diminished influence and credibility within Apple. The departures forced the company to promote junior designers and hire extensively from the outside to replenish the team's ranks. Many people inside and close to the company believed it should recruit an outside chief design officer to oversee the entire organization, but I'm told no such search is underway. Apple instead made a significant effort during the launch of the iPhone Duo to portray Molly Anderson and Dye's successor, Steve LeMay, as its design leaders.
1:36:15John Siracusa: Ternus posed with Anderson in the new phone, while Anderson and LeMay helped introduce the device in a joint video.
1:36:21Casey Liss: So at the time this was written, we hadn't yet had Ternus' first earning call, but on the first earning call, you saw an embodiment of the first part of the thing you just read, which is, you know, Tim Cook was basically saying, look, I spent my time on these particular things because that's my skill set. You should spend your time on the things that fit your skill set. And so Tim Cook was the operations guy and he would talk about operations stuff on the earnings calls and he knew it backwards and forwards. Like this was his area of expertise is what he did as a job before he was CEO. And so there he was on the calls and he would talk about all this stuff.
1:36:54Casey Liss: Ternus on the earning call brought on his CFO and a COO and just deferred to them and they answered all those questions because that's not his deal that's not his area gruber was pointing out in his site that when jobs was ceo he didn't even show up for most of the earning calls because it's like that's not my deal talk to the cfo they'll explain stuff he just showed up when he felt like he had something to say maybe turnus feels like he needs to be there again like the oh there's no ceo it's just apple gliding along smoothly tim cook was all the earnings calls i'll be on all the earnings calls but honestly he doesn't really need to he has to be on this one because this is his first one obviously you got to show up or whatever like i get that like if if he's just going to defer to the cfo and coo to answer all the questions anyway after he's after his like hey welcome i'm the new ceo whatever like maybe after the first year or so he can just not show up for them because that's you know that's not his strength that's not he's not going to be in there like saying i let me tell you how you should manage your inventory or write contracts with suppliers that's not his thing right so the the uh you know with turnus retelling again who knows when he's this is third hand like turnus says that he talked to cook and said this and we heard what turnus said from an employee who told german who you know again game of telephone but he's basically explaining um i you know i'm not going to be tim in terms of where i spend my time but i'll spend my time in other areas and the second part of this story is german says guess where he's spending his time he loves the design studio just like steve jobs used to go down there and play with stuff he's down there all the time and that makes sense because he was the hardware head of hardware and i'm sure like i said he was working with them on designs of the hardware all the time and that's where he's choosing to spend his time and when i read this i'm like all right you know like maybe that is one of his strengths it's part of his area of expertise he probably has a good relationship with johnny surugi he's trying to rebuild the design team that makes sense these are all again if he was to give a speech about the his vision for apple he would be saying i'm going to rebuild the stature of the design team because we've had a lot of people hired away to love from an open like it's all true we know it's true he's not making that speech we just hear about it through rumors but that seems like a very sensible thing to do but when i look at this whole big paragraph i'm like all right you know like this makes sense but i think of i immediately think of something that marco already mentioned because it's probably already in his mind and what i think about is hey john you know there's another part of products that Apple sells that is really in need of some attention.
1:39:13Casey Liss: And it's called software. I know he was the head of hardware. And hardware is great and continues to be great. And he should work with the industrial design team and work on new great hardware. Great. Thumbs up. It's your strength. You've already been doing a good job at it. Go where your strength is. But every single one of those hardware products has software on it. And the software needs some help. In many different ways, The software interface, the software reliability, just the things that the software does, choices about the software. And I get that's maybe not his strength, but one of the things that I would expect from the fictional never to be given speech about my vision for Apple as the new CEO would be, what is your vision for hardware software integration and where the software should go?
1:39:59Casey Liss: Not that software is out to sea or in a terrible situation, but most of the things these days I have complaints about Apple about are about software. and it reminds me of when Johnny Ive was put in charge of everything and he was at the time considered to be great at hardware although he got worse at that when his worst instincts kicked in but he didn't know a damn thing about software and made some dumb decisions and I didn't like it when he was in charge of software Alan Dye terrible decisions made bad software Dye's gone Ive is gone new hardware guy comes in it's I've never even seen him mention software I'm not sure if he knows his products run software.
1:40:36Casey Liss: It's so important to the experience. He just assumes that we'll automatically be there and someone else will worry about it. But like, that is a key thing. And, you know, everyone loves Steve LeMay. And, you know, we don't know anything about him other than what he's done. It seems like he's improved macOS. So thumbs up on that. But like, LeMay kind of the software one and Molly Anderson's kind of the hardware one. I don't know how they're splitting up the duties there or whatever. But I would love to see something about how Turnus recognizes that software is an important part of Apple products and that it's in a bad spot right now and needs help.
1:41:06Casey Liss: And, you know, an acknowledgement like, do you know what's wrong with Apple software now? Do you know how software is making the hardware look bad? Like Marco just gone talking about Siri AI and all that stuff. Like you have incredibly capable hardware, incredible hardware devices that are let down by substandard software. Do you just think, oh, the software is there and it's fine and I can give the talking points on it and say some, you know, thing about how wonderful it is and how much better it is and how, you know, he's saying all this stuff about siri but it's like but no man it's just not it's not good like i don't expect him to know like the intricacies of like good user interface design and what's wrong with mac os and the stupid rounded corners and all that other stuff or whatever but like even just something as simple as your most important product and your headlining features siri ai it's not good enough and that should be a fire under your butt and i don't see a single thing about it in any of these stories it's like i'm going to concentrate on design no no turn this sign is going okay concentrate on software well maybe design is going okay because he
1:42:01Marco Arment: has been present in it though like i the thing is you know when you're the ceo of apple you can't just focus on any of these things it's like yes he i think it is good that he is involving himself in design so far that seems to be pretty successful for the product and also he does also need to care about software a lot like that i don't think i don't think we can make him like say oh you know you shouldn't focus on design because you should be focusing on software no he should be focusing
1:42:25Casey Liss: on both i just want to see him go where the fire is you know what i mean like you know steady as she goes on the things that are going well but like again you know this is just one story so we don't know but like like if you're saying what's my vision for apple you wouldn't spend a lot of time talking about the things that are already going well you'd be like i'm going to continue doing that stuff because it's great but here's what like again if the new ceo comes in here's where the problem is the old ceo we kicked him out because we had a problem with x and now i'm going to come in and i'm going to fix it let's say you're a car maker and your cars are unreliable you're like reliability is job number one you're not saying you're not going to make you know cool sports cars or you're not going to make the corvette anymore it's like corvette's going great but like reliability is a problem a new ceo comes in i'm going to make our cars more reliable right because that's where the problem is it's not like he's going to personally do it i don't expect him to personally design the software but he's like i'm going to rebuild the industrial design team and i'm going to do this like because he's he's got he's directing the company his vision for the company should be like don't squeeze more out of the app store make developers happier and fix the software but instead it's like i just i just really want to get more into industrial design like again maybe this is maybe i'm missing it and this is really just a story about he's going to spend his time but i really want to see him say i recognize where i see the fire i see where the fire is and i'm going to direct the company to put water in that direction while i go over here and play with the industrial design team that's fine all right and then finally uh this is yet
1:43:48John Siracusa: more from early september from german as part of the transition cook is moving out of his office in Section 7 of Apple Park and handing the space over to the new CEO. That means Tarnas is moving into the executive suite for the first time. Before being named CEO, he worked alongside the hardware engineering organization in an office away from Apple's center of power. Software chief Craig Federighi, another longtime holdout from the executive wing, remains with his team elsewhere at Apple Park. Tim Cook is getting a new office at Apple's campus, but the biggest indicator that Cook will remain heavily involved is his giant new pay package, which has raised eyebrows among Apple leaders.
1:44:20John Siracusa: For the next year, Cook will get a base salary of$2 million. That's down from the$3 million he had as CEO, a salary that Ternus now receives. But the$2 million is still twice the typical base salary of senior vice presidents and members of the C-suite. In terms of restricted stock units for 2027, Ternus was given a target of$55 million on top of the salary and unspecified bonus, while Cook gets$45 million. These numbers will fluctuate based on how Apple's share price performs, but Ternus' compensation likely won't be far off from Cook's pay in recent years as CEO. Cook's new package, though, is highly unusual for a chairman.
1:44:51John Siracusa: Art Levinson, who was non-executive chairman before Cook took the executive version of the role, was paid less than$560 ,000 by the company last year. Man, he got played.
1:45:01Marco Arment: Yeah, but see, here's the thing. If Tim Cook is still having to deal with Donald Trump and Xi Jinping, it's worth it. Keep Ternus and the rest of the company isolated as much as possible from all of these awful world leaders that Tim Cook has to deal with.
1:45:20Casey Liss: fine it's worth the money well so i do feel like this is kind of a again a situation that we didn't experience with steve jobs because he died but like if you are the ceo of apple for a long period of time and apple is successful during those times you attain a certain level of celebrity certainly steve jobs had tremendous level obviously of celebrity but even tim cook the boring old guy he was tim apple for so long that he has a certain amount of cachet as just as a minor celebrity in his own right and and practically speaking he has knowledge and experience having run apple all these years so if he's not literally leaving the company which he is not and you want to keep him around you can't be like okay now that you're not ceo anymore you're gonna get paid by senior your vice president you're like i'm tim freaking cook if you want me to stay at the company you're gonna pay me like tim freaking cook especially as mark especially if i have to do the same bs i was doing before and deal with all the politicians and stuff because you know that's the thing that you know whatever whatever like he's been doing it and he's you know apparently not going to make turnus do it and turnus is probably ill-suited to it and whatever like it's terrible and we all hate it but like if he's going to be there doing that if you want to keep him around you have to pay him like this now with turned us moving to like the big ceo suite thing like it's interesting that both he and federighi were like you know we're men of the people we don't go in our fancy offices i i hang out with the rank and file people and stuff like that and you might think that's like an act or whatever but like a lot of a lot of ceos do this like i don't have a big uh executive suite i'm down there in the cubicles alongside with the workers but i my read on federighi is that's just the kind of person he is like it's not an act you know like you don't do this oh you've been doing this act for 20 years like it's not an act that's who he is as a person he wants to be down there with the rank and file people getting things done nerding out doing all the stuff he is to still the big big wig executive and everything but he wants to do that and turnus apparently was like that too he wanted to be with the hardware team so i do wonder if turnus is like uh i gotta move into the fancy ceo suite because it's expected of me because i'm the ceo of the one of the biggest companies in the world like i can't be in a cubicle with the team or they don't have cubicles whatever they open the weird open seating they have i have to be in the ceo thing but then tim cook gets his own little minor ceo wing because they're like i'm i'm not leaving they they gave me a big pay package and i'm still here to ride this sucker out presumably until trump is gone or who knows maybe even after that and this whole thing does make me think about what is the what is the dynamic and the relationship in there i think it's probably healthy based on turnus's retelling of that story of like look tim cook doesn't want to do this you know he left of his own accord i want to force tim cook out he decided when he wanted to leave he left on his own terms presumably he is doing what he has decided he's going to do and he wants to hand it over to turn he wants turn to be successful he doesn't want to do everything he's like turn to you do what you have to do you're not me play to your strengths i'll be over here in my supporting role until i feel like not doing it anymore and in the meantime i don't imagine tim cook you know coming to meetings and putting his oar in and being like oh you know what about this what about this what about that like no he shouldn't even be in the room he's not getting like to the extent that they discuss it'll be like you know um counseling or like do you have any advice for me or what do you think of that but i picture i'm picturing it mostly as a one-on-one thing um i really hope that's the case because you can't be a new ceo again i said this all this at the time transition you can't be the new ceo with the old ceo like breathing down your neck like looking over your shoulder like you're trying to do your work tim cook is behind you going oh what do you think about dotting that i what about crossing that t it's like tim could you go back to your wing like i'm trying to be ceo like i don't think that's happening but it is interesting that that like that that's the that's the situation they're in where they essentially end up they mint celebrity ceos if you are a successful ceo of apple you will attain celebrity you will attain knowledge and power and if you don't fully 100 leave or die if you stay at the company now you're like this celebrity in residence for however long you feel like being that.
1:49:31Casey Liss: And apparently you also get paid$45 million in stock. Nice gig. If you can get it, I guess.
1:49:36John Siracusa: Uh, I mean, I don't know. I, I'm, I remain, I remain hopeful about having turn us at the helm. I think there's certainly plenty of things to worry about. Um, we would be at least slightly remiss to not mention the absolutely astonishing, uh, election results from yesterday as we record this. And here again, I remain hopeful. There's a lot of work to be done with regard to the absolutely ridiculous government that we currently have. But hopefully this is a positive sign and things will happen. Similarly, I feel like we have every reason to be hopeful right now with regard to Ternus and his approach to running Apple.
1:50:14John Siracusa: And hopefully it will continue to get better and better. But there's a lot of work to be done. And we'll see if Ternus and everyone else at Apple does it. But I don't know. I think there's a lot we could be pessimistic about in both cases, but I am currently and personally really, really, really hopeful and enthusiastic in both with regard to fixing our absolutely broken government and fixing a occasionally broken Apple.
1:50:39Casey Liss: i was a little bit more hopeful before i learned about the lower rounded corners on the new macbook pros because oh my gosh john because that was turnus like he was head of hardware when that product was designed and implemented and this is exactly the blind spot that i'm afraid he has which is that he doesn't know what good you know design is when it comes to like the operation of not just like as a physical object and a beautiful piece of sculpture and like the circuitry and everything but just that like that you should never do this this is a bad dumb decision like the same way all the bad dumb decisions in tahoe like like alan dye had to go or in my opinion is that he just made bad decisions and made bad software this is a bad hardware decision and it was done under his watch and like he should know that's bad he should know it's bad he should fix it but it's like it's not like someone else's thing he he that he owns that he was head of hardware when that product was designed and implemented no one else was forcing him to make those damn rounded corners at the bottom he did it himself i know i'm attaching way too much to that but it's exactly what my fear is it's exactly what my fear is is like this is the exact blind spot and and the reason it annoys me so much is this has historically been a traditional strength of apple that they know what good design is and and we talk you know it's the reason he's ceo is because they do so well with the hardware as hardware objects and as implementations like low power socs with amazing you know performance incredible reliability every year they make a really good iphone and they ship millions and millions of them and they're good products year after year it's like it's amazing right but there's more to the products than the hardware and this is this is my main concern and at this point we have nothing to go on except for bad decisions that were made under when tim cook was ceo i'm not going to blame tim cook for the rounded corners and mostly blaming turnus but uh but now we have things to watch because like i said at the top of this we do not get and never will get that speech of turnus's bold new vision for apple all we can do is just watch what the company does over the next several years and then back solve but I thought this set of rumors about what supposedly people are thinking inside Apple was all we get.
1:52:37Casey Liss: And so it was at least worth discussion. And I'm sure we will revisit this after Ternus' first full year or maybe his second full year. I'm willing to give him a lot of runway to figure it out and to transition and to fully take on this new stuff and maybe to wait for Tim Cook to leave in a couple of years. But I do think he has his work cut out for him.
1:52:55Marco Arment: I think I am encouraged because it seems like he is engaging with products already within the company so much more than Tim Cook did. And, you know, I should be thankful for that.
1:53:08Casey Liss: Yes. Like Tim Cook didn't engage at that level.
1:53:11Marco Arment: Well, that's true. Because when he did engage, it was terrible. But and look, Tim Cook, I think for much of Tim Cook's reign, I guess, he was what the company needed. Like he was really good at stabilizing things and scaling things and making everything just flow better and work better and way more profitable. And he was very good at a lot of that stuff. I think what the company needs now after a pretty long time of that is a product engaged person, like a product engaged leader. And from everything we've seen so far, Ternus is very engaged with the products. Like Tim Cook, I don't know if he ever used a computer, but Ternus obviously loves technology in a way that Tim Cook, I don't know that we ever saw that from him.
1:54:00Marco Arment: You know, I think Tim Cook liked optimizing the systems around him and doing his work and doing a good job of the things he cared about. It just doesn't seem like computers were something he really cared that much about. Whereas Ternus, that's very clearly not the case. Ternus very clearly loves computers, loves Apple's products, loves phones. Like he he's really into that stuff. And I think he's you know, he's in the same way that Tim Cook had downsides. So will turn us. But for this era of Apple, I think what they really need is a product CEO. And it does look like they finally have that again.
1:54:35Casey Liss: when you say that though i think product ceo and i think hardware product ceo because i wonder if when i see him visiting products i wonder if the screens are turned on at all and like the the thing this german article gets into this is like for the stuff that he is not good at like the tim cook stuff he's got the coo he's got the cfo those people were there under tim cook like i feel like that's covered like those people were surely guiding those departments even when tim cook was ceo and so i have confidence that they know what they're doing and can continue apple's uh you know, historical strength in their supply chain management operations and manufacturing millions of things.
1:55:11Casey Liss: But on the topic of design, which was touched on, there is a leadership void there that is being filled by LeMay and Molly Anderson. So I see like there's some hope there. But on the software topic, leadership hasn't changed. Federighi is still there. And whatever problems existed under Tim Cook, Ternus isn't addressing it, doesn't have the skill set, and isn't changing anything about it. So I don't have confidence that that is going to get any better, even though he's the new CEO. Like, that's why I keep pulling, calling out the gap, because like, I'm not worried about operations because Ternus is in operations.
1:55:44Casey Liss: I'm not worried about hardware because Ternus isn't in charge of hardware anymore. Like, and I'm less worried about design because I feel like there's already been a little bit of a turnaround there with the new leadership. And I'm not saying this is all Federighi's fault. Maybe it's the case that Federighi was being told to do things with priorities that, you know, tied his hands behind his back and made him ship things before they were ready or whatever. Like, but this is the thing I'm going to be watching. Maybe I'm more, now that I've talked about this, maybe I'm more worried about this than the App Store thing.
1:56:11Casey Liss: Because honestly, like, we're all being squeezed so much in the App Store already, like, how much worse can it get? But the software can definitely get a lot worse. So I'm watching that.
1:56:19Marco Arment: I think it is not inconspicuous how... And Craig Federighi has not been promoted to a higher title. Where can you go from where he is?
1:56:30Casey Liss: He's the head of all software. He's not going to be CEO, so that's it. He's at the ceiling.
1:56:34Marco Arment: He wasn't made chief anything, though. There's now like a chief of hardware. There's no chief of software. Well, the chief of hardware is a keep Surugi at Apple title. Sure. I don't. It's hard to say there's any kind of confidence. But I just, if you kind of read the tea leaves a little bit, I think the Craig Federighi era is near its end. I don't know how soon, but I'd be shocked if he was still in his role in four years.
1:57:06John Siracusa: I don't agree with that at all. Somebody remind us. Somebody take that. Somebody put it in a reminder.
1:57:10Casey Liss: Why don't you write it down the counter because I'm not willing to bet on that. But here's the thing about Federighi. His strengths have, he's never been the user interface guy. like he's a software guy in the sense of like the nitty-gritty parts of software and my impression is that to the extent that he has failed at low-level software stuff it has been mostly forces outside his own control in terms of when things have to be shipped and you know bad decisions made like you know the whole ai thing can't pin on him because tim cook hired the what's his name from uh google and tasked him with doing this stuff and took it all away from federigi and said we've hired a google guy and he's gonna do it all and don't you worry about that and federi had to come in and clean up the mess later and so i don't blame him for that like i know a lot of people blame federi for things but i never picture him as like oh i know what user interfaces should look like and the problem is who has had that job when i've had it it was bad because he was bad at software and then die had it and it was bad because he was bad at software and now lame's got it and maybe that's the solution but it's just like i don't you know when steve jobs was there he was it basically he you know and he made bad decisions too but at least he had good taste and we have like i don't know what the gap is like there's never been a celebrity named c-level executive who we can say that person is responsible for the past few decades of apple software being good because honestly of the past few decades apple software has not been hot it's not been that good right the the heyday of how great it was and how you know and and to be fair the software and the duo was amazing so talent still exists for doing that like you know again within the constraints of the hardware which is a whole other thing but like i don't think anyone says hey could you think of a better way to design the software that is on the duo given that you can't change the physical form factor i think they knocked it out of the park so talent still exists for that but there's not there's not a c-level executive name or like point to that person and say they're why apple software is amazing because it's not amazing and there is no person for that and i just hope i mean maybe it'll be steve lemay someday or whatever but like it's not federighi it's not turnus and it definitely wasn't I've.
1:59:08John Siracusa: I mean, just looking at apple.com slash leadership, the very top tier is Ternus CEO, Eddie Q, senior vice president, Craig Federighi, senior vice president, Jaws, senior vice president. Yeah. Jennifer News said senior vice president, Deirdre O 'Brien, senior vice president. The only chiefs are CFO, COO, and Surugi does have hardware officer, but I concur with John on this. That was, we've got to give him, throw him a bone. Otherwise he's going to bounce. And I don't think Federici is in need of that kind of a, I don't know what word I'm looking for,
1:59:44Casey Liss: but he wants to have his desk with everybody else. Yeah. I agree. He can't be promoted unless he becomes CEO and that didn't happen. So this is it for him.
1:59:51John Siracusa: I couldn't agree more. And I don't think he's upset by that personally. Like I have no, I have no way of knowing, but the vibe I get, especially, you know, talking to the handful of people I know in Apple and in software at Apple, i don't get the vibe that he is like clawing his way into chief software you know uh chief software officer or what have you like i i really think from everything i can tell he's pretty content
2:00:13Casey Liss: where he is yeah he's such a nerd's nerd and he's not like he has he doesn't have the delusions of grandeur that he has the greater vision for apple user interface across all its products like that's not his thing at all and so and it needs to be somebody's thing but it's never been his and we can blame him for like unreliability of the software that's shipped and stuff like that and bugs that don't get fixed but i don't blame him for like i don't blame him for tahoe man like it's not on him i mean we don't know from the outside it's hard to know who's responsible we just know the products they ship blah blah blah but yeah it's maybe my impression of him is wrong who knows maybe they're i know we the reason he brings up is there are a lot of federighi uh detractors out there and they all write to us and say why don't you say how bad federighi is and for me it's because I don't actually think he's bad he's just narrowly focused and limited and I think he knows that he's narrowly focused and limited and I don't think it's his job to make sure Apple's user interface is good across the whole company
2:01:11Marco Arment: Alright, thank you to our sponsors this episode Claude, Tailscale and Granola and thanks to our members who support us directly you can join us at atv.fm slash join one of the many perks of membership is ATP overtime our weekly bonus topic by the way we also get discounts on merchandise as members so you if you go to atp.fm store you really want to do that like now anyway uh this week on overtime we'll be talking about some fun fan-made tools for atp and our listeners uh join to listen atp.fm join thank you everybody so much and we'll talk to you next week
2:01:49Casey Liss: Now the show is over
2:01:51Marco Arment: They didn't even mean to begin Cause it was accidental Oh it was accidental John didn't do any research Marco and Casey wouldn't let him Cause it was accidental Oh it was accidental
2:02:10Casey Liss: And you can find the show notes at atp.fm And if you're into Mastodon You can follow them
2:02:20Marco Arment: At C-A-S-E-Y-L-I-S-S So that's Casey Liss M-A-R-C-O-A-R-M And T-Marco Arment S-I-R-A-C-U-S-A Syracuse It's accidental Accidental They didn't mean to Accidental Accidental tech podcast so long
2:02:49John Siracusa: marco you have two iphone duos now yeah i have a quad now i just i put them next to each other
2:02:55Marco Arment: uh no it's the it's the iphone ultra um i i was able to snag a right-sized one i got the 256 uh today so i have returned the two terabyte monster um and i have finally moved into it as my phone. I didn't want to do that with the other one because I'm like, I really want to return this while I still can if I can save$1 ,200. Oh, gravy. $1 ,400 after tax, I think. But anyway, so I finally moved into it as my phone. I only have a few hours of using it as my phone so far. I think I might hate it, but I want to give it some time. How are you with yours so far after a little more time, Casey?
2:03:45John Siracusa: I think everything I said last week sticks. I wouldn't say I've had really many epiphanies other than I would like to reiterate that I was devastated to lose Face ID. And it's been fine. Like, I would still prefer Face ID, but it's been fine. Well, it's been fine with Apple Watch Unlock. It's been even good with Apple Watch Unlock. With just Touch ID, it's been fine. but I always have an Apple watch on so it's not really been an issue. The one thing that is really starting to drive me nuts not enough that I plan to switch back to my 17 Pro as my daily driver but it's driving me nuts the cameras.
2:04:24John Siracusa: The cameras are legitimately not great and I don't understand how anyone survived with an iPhone Air. I really don't and I miss Also fair also true. I desperately miss the 8X Like I was at Declan's football practice this, this evening and I would have loved to have been able to zoom more than two X would have been great, but I can't. Um, I really, really, really am having fun with this though. I really enjoy it. I do not feel the outer screen is a complete waste. Like so many people seem to, um, I have been flipping back and forth between in and out, but I will, but I would say easily half, maybe as much as three quarters.
2:05:05John Siracusa: My use of the phone is on the outer screen. so far I really like it I was listening to I want to say it was connected where Mike and Steven were talking about using their duos and how they felt it was extremely conspicuous and they were like I'm putting words in their mouth but the takeaway I had was that they were like uncomfortable or embarrassed to use it particularly in like open mode and I do not care I don't care at all like I was way more nervous about using AirPods when they were brand new than I am using this. Like I do not care. And nobody seems to very much care either. I don't know if that's because I don't live in a big metropolitan area or, or maybe people, the people I'm around all know I'm a freaking dork, but it's one way or another.
2:05:50John Siracusa: Um, I, I haven't had any of the issues with that with regard to like embarrassment or anything like that. Or maybe I'm just getting older and more comfortable in my old, in my own skin, who knows? Um, but in any case, I plan to stick with this as my daily driver. However, I think there are definitely going to be times, for example, I don't know if I go to a concert sometime this month, just pulling that one right out of my bottom. Uh, there's going to be times that I will probably dual wield and I will probably bring both the duo for the camera for, excuse me, for the phone bits. And because that's the only one with like a cellular connection, but I, my current thinking is I will also bring my 17 pro for the purposes of using the camera.
2:06:30John Siracusa: I don't plan to do that, generally speaking, but in this case, where I won't have Erin next to me, where I can just steal her phone, that is probably going to be my plan.
2:06:40Marco Arment: Yeah, I think, I mean, again, just trying it for a little bit. I think I really don't like Touch ID, and I think I really don't like the way it dynamics, like the pocket dynamics of it. Oh, interesting.
2:06:57John Siracusa: That doesn't bother me at all.
2:06:58Marco Arment: I so far I'm kind of hating the pocket dynamics, but we will see. I want to try to live with it for at least a few days before before I give up. I mean, I'm keeping it regardless because it is a very important test device for me now. I do also I would feel that embarrassment factor like like I don't think I'm going to want to open it up for a little while in public until, you know, give it like a few weeks so that most people have already seen them around. you know like that's going to be a short-lived problem but it is in the short term like in the very short term i think it is going to affect me a little bit um but i think ultimately i i don't i don't think i'm going to stick with it but i am very glad to be trying it the other thing is like the app situation really is still as bad as everyone says like i you know as i was setting up apps on the new phone today i'm like installing like you know like the app for my car and you know of the app for like my like the the train app for the long island river and stuff like that and like it's none of those apps are updated no they all show in like the the little you know floating black box in the middle of the screen like it's going to be a while before those things are
2:08:06John Siracusa: updated but that's that's only really bad when you're on the inner screen right when you're on the outer screen it's mostly fine um and the other thing i would say to go back just a half step my ask of you which i have no leverage and so you can completely ignore me and that's perfectly reasonable, but my ask of you is, I would say give it at least a week, preferably two weeks, of being your carry phone. And I don't have a calendar in front of me, and I know that you have travel coming up roughly in that time frame. So I wouldn't fault you if you didn't want to use this while you travel, although I would also argue it might be the perfect time to bring it, but that's neither here nor there.
2:08:43John Siracusa: But I would say give it at least one full week, and preferably two full weeks so you can really properly live with it for a while and see what you think more than just a few days. Because I think if you get through a whole week, my understanding of your weeks is that by and large, they're fairly repeatable, fairly understandable. That's not the word I'm looking for, but you know what I'm driving at, right? Like if you go through a full week, I think you'll probably get 80 % of your final answer. But I would argue, give it a second week. Basically, treat yourself as having your own two-week return policy.
2:09:16John Siracusa: obviously you're not literally returning it but you know before you return to the 17 or 18 or whatever you would be going back to i would encourage two weeks and i beg of you one week just to see what a full week with this thing is like and then again after a week but at most two weeks i think you're absolutely going to know one way the other and if the answer is screw this that's totally reasonable i could make an argument why the iphone duo is a piece of crap and nobody should buy it. I currently am still completely enamored with it and amused by it, but I could make the argument either way.
2:09:48Marco Arment: The very, very first day is probably the most uncomfortable time because it's so different. And I haven't really had a chance yet to love what it brings me. Like, I haven't found anything that's like, oh my god, I love this on the inside screen, with the exception of, like, you know, running Fineliner. And I have thought also, like, you know, Fineliner, I have high hopes for this app, and I'm very proud of it and I'm very happy about it. It is not amazing on regular iPhones. It really is an iPad and Duo app, ideally. I have thought I really probably should spend a lot of time with the Duo just so I can really live the fineliner lifestyle for a while and see how much can I lean into that and how does that make the app better and everything.
2:10:38John Siracusa: Like I said, I think I think a week would probably be enough, but I think it would be better if you gave it two weeks. And even if you stop after a week, I would encourage you to occasionally use this, even as an accessory iPhone, in cases where it could really shine. For example, going to like one of your town meetings with the extracurriculars you do over at the beach or bringing it, I don't know, traveling somewhere. Maybe you don't have it as the phone that has cellular potentially. And maybe you just like use the hotspot, but you treat it, you imagine it as your only phone or something along those lines.
2:11:16John Siracusa: I think that might be informative because, you know, in the case of like a town meeting or what have you, you could use, you know, Fineliner. You could use it for all these things. another thing that i found with the duo that i don't do often enough but i'm trying to train myself similar to our siri conversation is going to up with two different apps it's not the sort of thing that i would do all the time and i haven't yet found an occasion where i want to do the i forget what they call it but the lock the two apps together thing where you tap on the dividing line between the two of them but let me tell you on the occasions i do want to go to up Oh, is it amazing.
2:11:52John Siracusa: It's so nice. It's so incredibly nice. Now, admittedly, I'm talking about five, maybe 10 % of my usage of the phone. But golly, is that wonderful when I do that? So yeah, so much of this phone I'm still completely in love with and really enamored by. But absolutely, without a shadow of doubt, everything relating to taking pictures kind of sucks. I hate that when you're using the inner screen as a viewfinder, it's opposite what you would expect. And I think Gruber in particular has been talking about this.
2:12:22Marco Arment: Yeah, the orientation is because the camera is sideways.
2:12:25John Siracusa: Right. So if you're holding the device in landscape and you're using the camera, the image that you take with the camera is portrait. And from a technical perspective, I understand this, but I hate it. I absolutely hate it. And then if you want to take a landscape photograph or video, you have to rotate the device to portrait. Additionally, while I totally get the idea behind using the device when it's open in order to take a selfie, which I do not irregularly with like family and friends, like say we're going out to a meal or something. I've done this with you a handful of times, for goodness sake.
2:13:04John Siracusa: Recently even.
2:13:05Marco Arment: With pizza. Exactly. The big pizza. Always get the bigger pizza.
2:13:08John Siracusa: Always get the bigger pizza. Um, when I do this, like, first of all, the, the slide to switch displays thing, I feel like it works sometimes like annoyingly infrequently, maybe that's user error. I don't know, but to switch from the like inner display to the outer display is the viewfinder. I find it very rarely works the way it works the first time. And then secondly, when you have the phone in, um, opened up and you're trying to look at the rear camera to get a nice selfie. I mean, I'm trying to do this stupid viewfinder as we're talking and it's freaking impossible. It keeps like acknowledging it with haptics and then just not doing anything.
2:13:47John Siracusa: Very frustrating. But anyways, when you have this giant slab open, I have yet to crack the code on the right way to hold my hands to not only not drop the giant slab, but perhaps even more importantly, take the damn picture. And again, maybe this is user error. Maybe what I need to do is just grab the screen with my mitts, you know, and just not be so precious about it. But it's incredibly frustrating. So here it is, arguably, this is the best possible way for me to take a selfie. And to actually do so is very, very challenging. And so everything camera related on this phone is driving me up a wall.
2:14:26John Siracusa: And that is a big deal. I'm not trying to like fluff that off or like, I'm not trying to minimize that. But other than that, which admittedly, again, big deal. Other than that, though, it is an incredible device that I absolutely adore, and I'm really, really liking it. And I think, unquestionably, I think I'm going to stick with it for this year. The question that I haven't answered and I won't answer for another 11 months is, what do I do next year? Assuming there is a Duo 2, what do I do next year? I really and truly, I'm not sure. Sitting here now, I think I'd probably stick with the folding phone, but I have no idea.
2:15:02John Siracusa: Ask me again in a year.
2:15:03Casey Liss: On the camera thing, like you mentioned that, like you understand why it is that way. Unfortunately, with the camera hardware that ship with that thing, you have no choice but to be annoying in one of the two things because either the camera looks wrong when it's closed or the camera looks wrong when it's open because obviously when it's closed and you hold it in your hand, the camera is in one place and then you open it up and you rotate it. So the solution is square sensor and you crop it right but they didn't do that they have a rectangular sensor and they use the entire rectangular sensor and they need to use the entire rectangular sensor because already the phone the camera is not that good or not as good as the 18 pro camera so you definitely don't want to crop out of that but that's the only solution with this design with these cameras in this position and the phone that folds this way the only way you can make the camera not quote unquote look wrong in one either folded or unfolded mode is to have a square sensor and crop it in a different rectangle each time.
2:16:00Casey Liss: And so maybe in the future, like thinking of you like next year, am I going to use the new folding phone? If they have a bigger sensor that's big enough to be square and they can crop it, all of a sudden that annoyance goes away and presumably the camera is also better. If it has face ID, that would also make you happy. Like these are the things that people are going to be measuring with the, you know, the Duo 2. What have they improved? Not just it's a new SoC, but like did they put a square sensor on the camera? Are the cameras better? Does it have face ID? and marco with your embarrassment of opening the thing i would say that like definitely at least use the phone until you get over that because like what the hell is the sense of having a holding phone if you're never going to open it up then you're just torturing yourself by having a weird small thick phone that you never open like that's the whole sale and on that front though i don't think it's a slam dunk that will make you like it more because what i think about as someone who hasn't carried one of these is i always think about like setting aside the embarrassment which i think you need to get over just to give it a fair shot um like there is some i don't know it's it's like a a tiny i don't know how big some kind of hurdle that you have to overcome to decide is it worth me opening the phone how long like it signals a longer investment in usage because it's not so fast that you can do it like a like a star tack Motorola, you know, it's not so fast that there's no cost to it.
2:17:20Casey Liss: You're deciding probably with two hands to open the phone. And the idea is I'm going to use it for some amount of time that it's worth me opening it and then closing it again. And lots of things we do with our phones are like, oh, quick peek, ba-doop, you know, like there's lots of these short interactions where it may be that you feel like, oh, I don't want to bother opening it. And I feel like when you open a folding phone, you're not committing to but you're predicting that the thing you want to do with your phone is worth the opening and closing time for the advantages that you get with the bigger screen and that i think once you get over the you know i don't want to open it that is the determiner of whether you find the phone valuable is like if every interaction you have you just feel like oh i opened it and i closed it and i and while it was open i did something but honestly there was more overhead in the opening and closing than there was value in the half a second that i looked at the bigger screen right and that's going to make you open it less and then if it does sort of degenerate down to like now i'm just using a fat squat phone that i never open not because i'm embarrassed to open it but because i don't want to pay the cost of opening and closing unless i'm settling in to read a long article on the train or something that i feel like is the thing i would be looking for as i was using this is like how how does the return on investment work out in terms of is it worth you know so you signed everything's a seinfeld thing is this sponge worthy yeah right is this is this interaction open the phone worthy and obviously if the things if the apps haven't been updated on the phone hell no it's not worth it why would i open it up just so i could see the the the phone slightly bigger with black giant black spaces around it or whatever but that i'll be interested to hear your updates on that obviously casey feels like he's already getting enough value out of it that he's you know it's it's worth opening lots of things in his life are sponge worthy but marco still up for grabs no young people don't even get this is an ancient cultural references that are actually kind of lewd but anyway google it kids
Sponsored by:
Become a member for ATP Overtime, ad-free episodes, member specials, and our early-release, unedited “bootleg” feed!