
The hosts recap a day in New York centered on eating a “bigger pizza,” then pivot into ATP merch/store updates and a long tech news follow-up segment focused on Apple’s HomeView (a HomePod-based display), Apple TV (price history, microphones, AV1 decoding, and missing audio pass-through), and the iPhone Duo (replaceable cover layer; hands-on impressions from an Apple “Creator Showcase”).
No external guests. The episode is hosted by the ATP hosts (notably John Syracuse and Marco, with Casey mentioned as visiting New York). Other named contributors are commenters/writers and reviewers, not in-studio guests.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
The hosts share a story about their pizza choice during lunch in New York.
“So I am past the stage, I think all three of us, well, probably Marco and me more than John, but I'm past the stage where I need to broadcast every ounce of my life to Instagram and whatnot.”
Discussion about new merchandise items that support LGBTQ charities.
“Okay, well, so the theme for this year is John's disappointed that Apple doesn't put out better chips.”
Detailed discussion about various new shirts and products available in the store.
“and if I were you, I probably wouldn't believe us, but hand to God, this is God's honest truth.”
Exploration of HomeView pricing, competition, and market comparisons.
“And there's been a lot of, like, snarking and chuckling and also theorizing about, hey, when was this thing, this hardware built?”
Analysis of the design reasoning behind HomeView's wall mount pricing.
“and we had some interesting thoughts genuinely interesting thoughts about um wall mounts and pricing and whatnot.”
Discussion on practical issues with installing HomeView in kitchen designs.
“And so it's not something that you get that, you know, every couple of years you have to reevaluate your needs.”
Consideration of developer challenges with HomeView's screen dimensions.
“And we were actually told specifically that they can't put an outlet on the side of the island anymore.”
Explore the history and changes in the pricing of Apple TV models.
“We had some discussion with regard to the price history.”
Discuss the implications of AV1 hardware decoding in the latest Apple TV.
“There's some new far-field microphones in the Apple TV box itself.”
Delve into the audio pass-through feature and why it matters to users.
“Now, will this get sent to the Apple TV?”
Learn about the replaceable cover layer of the iPhone Duo and its benefits.
“couple of times, but it didn't explain what it was.”
Hear firsthand experiences from the iPhone Duo showcase event in Manhattan.
“It isn't like an$8 Amazon screen protector.”
Share initial thoughts on the iPhone Duo's design and weight.
“the device from a hardware perspective is extremely cool.”
The discussion revolves around the weight of the iPhone Duo compared to similar models and its perceptual effects.
Hosts discuss the operational design of the iPhone Duo's hinge and how weight perception affects usability.
“somewhat close to what we expect to be an event where we're going to have lighter laptops announced.”
A deep dive into concerns about the screen crease of the iPhone Duo and its overall display quality.
“my personal opinion, all of us, including me, fretting about the crease was misplaced angst and agita and nervousness.”
Discussion on the noticeable features of the iPhone Duo's camera and how it affects the user experience.
“The anti-glare mat, whatever they're calling it thing on the inside was great.”
Exploring the nanotexture finish of the iPhone Duo and its implications for maintaining cleanliness.
Hosts share their impressions of the iPhone Duo's software and specific apps that stood out.
“With regard to software, again, I barely played with any of this stuff.”
Discussion comparing the iPhone Duo to the Vision Pro regarding usability and functionality.
“And I did not once lock or unlock a phone.”
Hosts express their excitement about Apple's innovation with the iPhone Duo despite its high price.
“every couple of times I put it on in a year.”
Discussion on the trade-offs that define the iPhone Duo’s design, contrasting it with previous products.
“But it's so great to have Apple kind of, moonshot is a bit dramatic, but doing a moonshot or taking a moonshot.”
Discussion about the iPhone Duo, its features, trade-offs, and user experience.
“But man, it is so cool and fun to see Apple shooting their shot again.”
Comparison of the iPhone Duo with Vision Pro, exploring user perceptions and potential applications.
“The thing is, the way I use a phone, I don't think this is going to be the right phone for me.”
Exploration of potential use cases for the iPhone Duo and its future in the market.
“In the same way that like when we went from the regular sized, you know, like the mid-sized iPhone, when they added the Plus and the Max phones.”
Explore the advantages of using larger screens for productivity tasks.
“For almost any kind of document-based workflow, almost any kind of productivity work, a big screen is always better for that.”
Learn about the pre-order experience and strategies for securing devices.
“I was like, I have no idea what you're talking about.”
Hear personal stories about the difficulties faced during the ordering process.
“It was 30 seconds, maybe, before I was done.”
Discuss the failures in Apple's ordering system and their impact on customers.
“Now, the Apple Store business reps are the nicest people.”
Discussion on the rise of Chinese YouTube tech reviewers and their impressive production quality.
“I've watched the ones that John has linked, and I put all these links in the show notes.”
In-depth conversation about the quality and characteristics of folding phone screens.
“A lot of people, like Joanna Stern most primarily, but a lot of the other channels as well, wanted to make a robot bend and close and open the thing over and over again, right?”
Discussion on the new phone's design features and peculiarities.
Reviewers' insights on the hinge mechanism and battery life of the phone.
Exploring user experiences and challenges with the phone's usability.
Contrasting different reviewers' opinions and their implications for users.
“I think you covered pretty much everything.”
Discussion on the need for long-term reviews and software support for the device.
“And then, yeah, we've already got rumors about, well, maybe Face ID will be in the iPhone Duo 2.”
Discussion on Apple's challenges with software support for third-party apps.
“And then when the year is over, apps will have updated, third-party apps will have updated for the Duo.”
Exploration of demand versus supply issues faced by Apple with the Duo's launch.
“so that their apps would be optimized earlier.”
Excitement around the rumored release of a new iPad mini and its potential features.
“And that's very interesting because we just got finished talking about how the iPhone Duo is basically a substantially better iPad mini.”
Brief discussion on an upcoming Intel event and expected products.
“No, it still has Touchdown ID probably, but still, that would be amazing.”
Discussion on the development process of a new note-taking app for iPhone Duo.
“One of the many perks of membership is ATP Overtime, our weekly bonus topic.”
Sharing experiences with a new app developed by Marco and its unique onboarding.
“But it could be out when this episode's published, for all I know.”
Learn about the whimsical onboarding process of a new app and its impact on user engagement.
“And so then at lunch, I think maybe I was giving you puppy dog eyes accidentally because I don't remember begging to see it or anything like that.”
Discover how artwork and handwriting can become part of an app's interface, enhancing personalization.
“People are going to have to either pause the show or skip over this portion.”
Dive into the technical aspects of the app, including vector graphics and dark mode functionalities.
Explore the role of AI in shader design and unique features of the app.
“And it took, to be clear, AI wrote the first version of the shader.”
Understand the app's pricing model and the free features available.
“Unforgetful is a very narrowly targeted app.”
Discuss the expected user experience and who should try the app.
“I don't know if I'm going to stick with that long-term, but I think it might.”
Hear reflections on the evolution of app development from niche to mainstream.
“You know, a second ago, you said, these are the apps I want to make.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On Accidental Tech Podcast, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00Marco Arment: I had a really great day yesterday. As did I, coincidentally. Casey was visiting New York. We met up. We'll talk about wine a little bit. And then I got to eat half of a pizza for lunch.
0:14John Siracusa: We're going to have to post. It's funny you bring this up. I almost started like posting pictures from yesterday and I thought, you know what, let's see how we handle it on the show. So I am past the stage, I think all three of us, well, probably Marco and me more than John, but I'm past the stage where I need to broadcast every ounce of my life to Instagram and whatnot. And I do enjoy posting things that are unique and different. But I thought, you know what, let me keep this one close to the vest and see what we get into on the show. And so I will put a link in the show notes to Marco and I at John's a bleaker before we absolutely destroyed an entire pizza.
0:53John Siracusa: And the funny thing about this was we got to John's after some shenanigans in the morning, which we'll talk about. And by the way, when your phone is used to navigating by car, you need to tell it to navigate by foot when you're in New York City. Because I was navigating before Marco and I had to walk from somewhere to John's. And I think we took the most circuitous route possible. We might have walked through Brooklyn at some point or another to get to John's. But in any case, eventually, when we were almost there, I realized, oh, these were driving directions. Whoops. But no, we got there and we were having a happy debate over should we get the smaller or the larger of the two size pizzas.
1:33John Siracusa: There was no debate.
1:35Marco Arment: Just always get the bigger pizza. Nobody ever is like, we have way too much pizza. No,$2 more to get a bigger pizza. Of course, get the bigger pizza for$2 more.
1:48John Siracusa: And that's what we did. And we polished off the entire pizza. And I had no regrets. Now, I didn't eat dinner that night because I was still full. But no regrets. It was great. It was a really lovely time.
1:59Marco Arment: We had a little bit of time to kill before we parted ways afterwards. And we were dragging after eating an entire half pizza each. No amount of coffee could have kept us very awake after that.
2:16John Siracusa: We have important administrivia to take care of. It is time. Now, let's suppose you're walking in the streets of Manhattan. Perhaps you are, I don't know, walking in a circuitous route because you forget that you need to toggle over to walking directions. And you hear my voice. You hear these dulcet tones say to you, the ATP Holiday Store is back, baby. And if you want to, you should pull over, not block the sidewalk, and go to atp.fm slash store, and you will see some genuinely fantastic work pretty much entirely done by John Syracuse. So John, take it away if you please. What do we have on store or in the store this time?
2:59Casey Liss: Okay, well, so the theme for this year is John's disappointed that Apple doesn't put out better chips. So we have a bunch of logo shirts, including a leftover logo shirt that we should have made last sale, but we didn't. So anyway, to start, our first two shirts are shirts that we've been talking about for a long time but haven't done. If you're familiar with our logo, our show logo, you might be looking at it now in your podcast player. It's a combination of the BMW M logo and the rainbow six colored Apple logo and the initials of our show, ATP Accidental Tech Podcast, all in one logo. It's a great logo, okay?
3:36Casey Liss: And it does, you know, the stripes, the BMW M-ish stripes, there's six of them because it's the same colors in the same order as they are on the old style rainbow apple logo and we've often talked about our logo and said and also if you wear that shirt and someone mistakenly thinks that's supposed to be like a like a pride flag logo that's great too another meaning to throw into the thing because we support that it's great it's a happy accident but we always have the idea why don't we actually make atp shirts with the pride colors in it because the pride pride flag colors are actually different and in a different order than the apple logo colors which are different than the bmw m colors and so on and so forth so we have done that this year we have a shirt called atp pride and it uses i always forget the name i link to it i have to look it up again like the traditional pride flag uh with what does it get red orange yellow green blue and purple is the order and i tried to copy the colors exactly and those replace the apple six colors logo okay and we have a second shirt called atp trans pride which uses the trans pride logo which has fewer colors but then i just repeated i think they repeated in the flag too it's like blue pink white pink blue uh it's actually a different uh number of stripes than the other one but we made it work and i think both these shirts look great so now your atp logo shirt won't be mistaken for a pride flag it literally is choose the regular pride flag i forget what again i forget what the name it is but it's like one of the older ones and the trans pride flag um and the i think they come in multiple colors mostly neutral colors because they have like rainbow logos on them but i really like the Trans Pride one that comes with like a light bluish or even the dark bluish shirt.
5:13Casey Liss: And it seems to go well with the light blue and pink and white logos in there. And of course, it's not just t shirts, it's long sleeve shirts and sweatshirts and pullover hoodies and all the things with those logos on it. So those two shirts, ATP Pride and ATP Trans Pride. And for these two shirts, we are donating 100 % of the profits from the sales of these two shirts to LGBTQ charities. So I've chosen two charities for this one. It was very difficult for me to choose charities. I don't know a lot about this. And I'm looking at like charity navigator and trying to find good things or whatever.
5:42Casey Liss: Here's what I came up with. If I've picked terrible charities, tell me and we'll change them. But if it's just like you prefer a different charity, maybe next time, you know, again, let us know. Maybe next time we'll pick a different one. But here's what I picked for this one. Pick two charities. Again, 100 % of the profits from both these shirts going to these charities. First one is Trans Lifeline. I'm reading from their website, but how they describe themselves. self. Trans Lifeline is a grassroots hotline and micro grants nonprofit organization offering direct emotional and financial support to trans people in crisis for trans for the trans community by the trans community.
6:13Casey Liss: So this is like targeted on the ground. If you are, you know, in crisis, call this number, they will help you and they will give you money. And it's like, you know, real kind of grassroots stuff. The second one is Transgender Law Center. Again, reading from their website. They are the largest, the largest trans specific trans led organization in the United States. Their advocacy and precedent setting litigation victories in areas including employment, prison conditions, education, immigration, and healthcare protect, protect and advance the rights of transgender and gender nonconforming people across the country.
6:45Casey Liss: So my, my thinking behind picking these two is one, it's like a really, you know, direct on the ground, helping individual people thing. And to the bigger picture fighting against the terrible laws that are happening in our country to try to take away rights from trans people. And you may be thinking, why are they two trans charities? What happens to just generic LGBTQ charities? Let me tell you, I had such a problem trying to find a non-problematic generic LGBTQ charity that wasn't like involved in some kind of scandal or other thing or whatever. So again, maybe I'll try again next time. But for now, I picked those two and I figured it's reasonable because right now in our country anyway, trans people are the ones getting it the worst.
7:24Casey Liss: Everyone's getting it bad. Like, you know, marginalized people are not having a good time in America, period. But trans people are just really like they're the subject of half of the political ads. And they're like such a tiny fraction of the population. It's brutal. So anyway, that's what we're doing with those. Oh, and by the way, I said we're donating 100 percent of our profits from these shirts. Also, Cotton Bureau is kicking in two dollars for each shirt sale as well. So nice. I didn't know that. That's great. So there you go. We're not making a cent on those. They are entirely a charity thing.
7:54Casey Liss: And I think the shirts look great. please buy them if you can.
7:57John Siracusa: Yeah, for what it's worth, John has genuinely done a really good job with both of these. And we've said this in the past, and if I were you, I probably wouldn't believe us, but hand to God, this is God's honest truth. We really don't make a lot from merch. We really, really don't. The costs for us are quite a bit higher than you think. I am fully aware that the cost for you is quite a bit higher than you would want. Honestly, it's quite a bit higher than we would want. But like John said, for the small amount that we would have earned off of these two shirts. We will be giving 100 % of that, plus the$2 from Cotton Bureau.
8:31John Siracusa: Thank you, fine folks at Cotton Bureau. We will donate that, and we will follow up about it at a later date.
8:35Casey Liss: More on terrible profit margins as we go to later products. But yeah, like, again, if you just want to donate to these charities directly, it will give them way more money than buying a shirt. But the shirts are cool. And for the shirts, like, you know, I don't know how many, like, influencers we have listening. Steven Robles, if you're listening to the show, I know he wears, like, one of our M5 shirts or whatever. I would encourage people to buy one of these shirts and you think, oh, are you telling them they can put it on so they can virtue signal and say how wonderful they are? No. The reason you're wearing this is to let more people in the world know that you are essentially a safe person.
9:09Casey Liss: Other people don't know what it means, don't care, whatever. It's a logo. Is that about tennis? Is that about BMW? No one knows or cares. But the people who do know and care will see this shirt on you and hopefully understand that you are a safe person. And I think that's important. And also you know just being seen right people don't know what it is like if you i that's why i encourage like youtubers to wear because i just wanted to be out there in the world and for someone to come upon it and say hey there's someone who recognizes my humanity boy it's such a low bar so it sounds terrible when i say that but anyway yep there you go those two products all right so the next one is a shirt that i should have made last sale and i didn't that's on me my bad uh we do shirts for like the m chips because it was like can you believe apple made chips starting with m and we have this bmw m based logo now we can combine them together uh that was a happy accident uh but then uh with the macbook neo they put an a chip in a mac and all these shirts are like mac chips right because i love macs uh they put an a chip in the mac and hey our podcast begins with a so we are making finally an a18 pro shirt because we've had things with the m chips with the pro thing and we had atp shirt with an a and now we have an a18 pro shirt we should have had it when the macbook neo can't we did have macbook neo shirts you know we had like the ones that were colored like the neos those are really cool but we forgot to make an a18 pro shirt now we have one finally uh the uh the mistake has been corrected uh as for actual new chip shirts apple did come out with new chips they're not great but they exist m5 ultra and m5 ultra interposer shirts are here i remember how excited it was about the original interposer shirt but now my description of it is that apple just can't stop sticking max chips together maybe a little bit snarky but we've always had that shirt of like the two maxes like one is rotated and connected to the other one right max max anyway so we do have m5 ultra and m5 ultra interposer shirts we always like to bring back one shirt from the past that we've sold in past sales and this time we're doing the atp graffiti shirt which I think we only sold one other time and is actually one of my favorite shirts.
11:13Casey Liss: My kids have a couple of these. I love it when they wear them. They seem to wear them a lot. Maybe it's because it's not that recognizable. But anyway, it's the ATP logo, but drawn in palms, graffiti, like the palm handheld, their graffiti handwriting recognition. Like they would have a little guide telling you how to do it. Like start with your pencil here and draw like this. So we're doing the ATP graffiti shirt again. And again, it's not just search. It's long sleeve sweatshirts, all of that other stuff. Then of course we have the ATP logo shirt. We have the atp zip hoodie and the zip hoodie has expanded for the first time this year so it's a good year to buy a zip hoodie but you've always sold and it's a very nice like soft black zip hoodie with an embroidered atp logo uh on like the left chest and my kids have these and they use them all the time they're great uh and it's black because this is the rainbow logo it kind of clashes with some stuff well this time we have first of all two new weights one or two new weights if we have a medium weight and a heavy weight i think the medium weight might be the same as normal weight but anyway we definitely have a new heavyweight weight of this so you can get a thicker one if you want it and you can get it in like grayish bluish white it's like apple products it's like they're not really strong colors because the really strong colors would clash with the with the atp logo this has got so many colors in it right but you can get a white one and you can get a gray and like kind of like a coral greenish blue and a bunch of the point is you can get atp zip hoodies in different colors in different weights now so please check out that product now finally the bad news the atp polo the cost the cost to us the cost of that polo blank shirt before we put our embroidered logo on it has gone up astronomically just i don't even know if we're ever going to sell this again but i figured because we just we found out of this late breaking it's like uh-oh the price got so first of all the price to you is going up by a lot too but also i cut the profit margins down to basically zero on this shirt and this may be the last time we sell it because it cost so much money just for the blank shirt before we even put a logo on it before there's any kind of profit so um our profits on the atp polo shirt if you buy it with the member discount are measured in cents per shirt since and the only reason to that is because i didn't want to have a a dollar amount that was like fractional i wanted to have an integer number of dollars and i didn't want to lose money in every shirt so if you ever wanted an atp polo shirt you should probably buy it now and give us the you know handful of uh nickels and dimes that we're going to make on each one because we may never sell it again because the price is just so high it is our fanciest shirt as the description says it is very nice i have a couple of them but boy i don't know what happened with their price structure but it has gone maybe they use ram in the shirts or something it's gone up by a lot uh so yeah get your polos while you still can this may be the last time they're ever sold and finally we have the atp hat which is just a baseball hat with the embroidered atp logo all right sorry i took so long those are the shirts that's the store store will be open for three weeks if you are an atp member remember to go to log into atp.fm go to your member page and get your atp member discount code that will give you 15 off everything in the store if you're not a member just become a member get the discount and then cancel it's really no
14:10John Siracusa: no no no no no no no you do this every time no you do not have to cancel i mean you can cancel you can you can also not cancel we encourage you well marco and i two-thirds of atp encourage you
14:21Casey Liss: to not cancel people do it all the time it's we see it happen we get a bunch of membership bumps people buy from the store and then they cancel which is fine like get the discount it's good also gift memberships that's also on the atp.fm store page if you want to ask for a gift membership so you don't have to pay for your own membership you want to ask for it for the holidays you can do that here is a link that you can copy and give people and say here click this link and buy it for me you can buy a gift membership from somebody else another nerdy person in your life you think might be want to be an atp member that's linked from this page as well atp store again you'll hear about this two more times and the store will be gone and casey will yell at you that's exactly
14:56John Siracusa: right yep so again i will say this briefly every single time somebody reaches out and says oh no oh no i'm the one i did it this time it really happens every time like casey does this whole
15:11Marco Arment: spiel because and it sounds like it's a joke and it's not it actually really happens every time
15:17Casey Liss: people do write in and joke to us about it but then there's the legitimate people who are like Like, I know, haha, funny, but it actually happened.
15:23John Siracusa: Yep. So be not that person. I almost said be that person. Don't be that person. And instead, go to ATP.fm. Thank you to John for sponsoring the show. All right. Let's start with some follow-up. We need to talk about the home view. And there's been a lot of, like, snarking and chuckling and also theorizing about, hey, when was this thing, this hardware built? and according to mark german uh finished units have been sitting boxed up in warehouses for the better part of a year waiting for software to catch up whoopsie doopsies yeah love love that
16:00Casey Liss: concrete info although when we get the hardware presumably there's usually like some way to tell from like the serial number or something to know but yeah that's that's gotta hurt i mean it makes
16:09Marco Arment: sense like when you look at the hardware like it is basically like regular apple you know as i as i kind of described as like you know the apple stock colors of aluminum it's like yeah it's it's an aluminum, you know, bezel screen on top of a HomePod subwoofer. Like, that's... Yeah, they could have made that years ago and apparently they did. And yeah, the hard part was the software and Siri. So that... This is, you know, a little bit interesting, but really not very surprising at all.
16:39John Siracusa: Paul Hearing writes, I was surprised at how expensive HomeView is. It's almost four times the cost of an Amazon Echo Show 8, which lists for$149, but is almost always on sale somewhere for around$80.
16:50Casey Liss: I couldn't believe those prices, so I looked up some prices. And we will link to what I looked up. Again, Amazon changes prices all the time, so maybe by the time you follow these links, the prices will be different, but this is what I looked up.
16:59John Siracusa: Or it could be that because you're the person following these links, maybe it'll change the price for you. But what John found was the Echo Show 5 was$100, Echo Show 8$200, Echo Show 11$250, Echo Show 15$350. John, do you know enough about these to give me the two-second overview on what the differences are?
17:18Casey Liss: I mean, I think the numbers are basically just screen size. So in that case, like with a five inch screen, the Echo Show 5 is closer. But like it really just shows the range that Amazon Echo Echo Show is their Amazon Echo thing with a screen on it. They have four models that span from 100 to 350. And so Apple still is kind of they're at the high end of that range, but they're in the range. They're in the mix. Now, granted, you're going to say, OK, well, well, Amazon's$350 one has a 15 inch screen and Apple's$300 one has like a five inch screen or a six inch screen. mean that's not close well i still think it is a pretty reasonably priced product again maybe because they did build them a year ago back when all the components cost less but we'll see if the price suddenly increases if they actually sell through all the home views that they made which is uh not a sure thing given how long it took them to try to sell through the big home pods
18:08John Siracusa: and we had some interesting thoughts genuinely interesting thoughts about um wall mounts and pricing and whatnot. So MVK writes, my theory is that if the wall mount was priced less than the tabletop version, people would buy it to save money, but never mounted. The majority of units in the wild in that scenario would be flat on tables or stood up with janky, cheap hardware and never hung. So including a bass speaker for quote unquote free ensures the majority of them that get sold will actually look good in homes. I can't decide, I waffle back and forth if I think this is 100 % right or 100 % wrong.
18:39Casey Liss: I don't think Apple cares how it looks in your home because no one's, you know, someone comes over and see that they'll think it's junky. But like, man, people do all sorts of stuff with Apple hardware as it is. But it's an interesting theory. I mean, we'll get one more theory and then I'll give my what I think is the more obvious answer. But anyway.
18:54Marco Arment: Yeah, I think this is more of a justification than a reason. I think it's like it's a post hoc. Like, well, we want to capture as much money as possible from professional installers and high end builds. Well, this is also a reason that this might be a decent idea.
19:08John Siracusa: so ben o matic writes if the wall mounted model was even 50 less amazon would explode with cheap base units with speakers with a mount and a usbc connector my guess is that apple doesn't want to incentivize a market that'll result in lots of cheap off-brand versions of the product on
19:22Casey Liss: countertops and in social media feeds i think that amazon's still going to have tons of mounts for these things because remember the ones that apple commissioned from like schneider home or whatever are insanely expensive so you're still going to see all that stuff but yeah there's lots of theories about how if they made them a different price everyone would buy the one without a base but i'm not sure about that because i think people like the speaker i mean the speaker part of it and if they know they're getting one with it's it's so clearly doesn't have any place for a big speaker in it anyway like i think they're just the same price because that's just an apple thing to do right i mean it's it's kind of amazing that uh that's not true of some apple products like they for for a lot of the past you know monitors with and without the like you complained about didn't the visa mount was the same price as the one without it but then apple adjusted it it's rare when Apple does actually make that kind of adjustment.
20:08Casey Liss: Usually it's just this is the price of the product and you can get the wall mount or not. And yeah, the cost to us is different, but we don't pass that on to you. And that's just the Apple way.
20:15John Siracusa: All right. Jan or Jan probably, Wedekind writes, Wedekind, I'm so sorry. Just pick one of those and hopefully it worked right. The best thing about the HomeView is the dozen Chinese copies that will drop very soon, probably with OLED and a Linux variant so we can tinker with Home Assistant. To be clear, this is not my pseudonym. I did not write this, but I agree with the sentiment.
20:37Casey Liss: Yeah, it's interesting. Like that's the one of the effects that Apple has is regardless of what whether or not what Apple has done is a good idea. Is it a good idea to have a little R2D2 with it with an arm and a screen on it? Doesn't matter if it's a good idea. If Apple does it, people will copy it because it looks like Apple. And so you hope the thing that Apple does turns out to be a good idea so that the copies are good products. But very often the copies are just like Apple in all of the good and bad ways. And if Apple does something stupid, then you have a million stupid copies. Remains to be seen if the HomePod form factor, the Home, I did it again.
21:12Casey Liss: The HomeView form factor is in fact the right size and shape for that. But either way, they will be copies.
21:18John Siracusa: Jimmy writes, quote, who's going to have a hole in their kitchen island to snake a USB-C cable down? quote me and jimmy provided a very helpful image where there is one of those like desk grommets is that the word i'm looking for uh that has a what appears to be an ipad uh on a mount coming uh being powered by power that runs through the grommet and one of the is that the 12 south dingus that you can charge like the travel dingus something like that anyway the we'll put a link in the show notes of the picture uh but yeah sure enough in a grommet through the kitchen table
21:50Casey Liss: well yeah so it looks like there's like marble or some kind of stone in one half and then wood on the other and thankfully they put the hole in the wood half right now that being said like i assume
21:59Marco Arment: this was kind of a dig at john gruber's review where he pointed out like no one ever has a hole in their kitchen island for this we said that on the show i thought we said it as well yeah everybody said it everybody yeah and i think like it is true that most most kitchen islands don't have holes in middle of them and one of the biggest reasons why i mean besides the fact that you know people tend not to have new kitchen islands installed that often. And so it's not something that you get that, you know, every couple of years you have to reevaluate your needs. But also you do have to worry about like, what if liquids spill and pour into that?
22:34Marco Arment: What are they pouring into? And is it going to damage anything? Are you going to be able to clean it? Is it going to be a problem? And so, yeah, most of the time, people don't design things this way. So it is a valid complaint of like, how are you going to plug this thing in? But I also think like most people are not going to have the home view in the middle of an island. It's kind of a weird position. They're going to have it like, you know, when you look at where do people put Amazon Echoes and stuff, they put them like against the wall. First of all, they put them where the outlets are, but they put them like in the corner or on the part of the island that touches the wall or whatever.
23:07Marco Arment: It's not something that people, despite the weird Apple commercial, like are going to be swiveling around all the time. Like I think mostly it goes like in a corner or against a wall.
23:17Casey Liss: As I alluded to last time, I think it is currently against code in at least some states in the US to have outlets on the side of Kitchen Islands that used to be allowed. And I think they changed it. I might be wrong about that. But there's a bunch of electrical issues. Let's just say electrical issues related to Kitchen Islands and where they get power. And like you said, what's going on underneath the Kitchen Island?
23:37Marco Arment: Yeah, I believe it was explained to me when we did a kitchen renovation a few years ago. And we were actually told specifically that they can't put an outlet on the side of the island anymore. Because apparently the rationale that this electrician said was that people can like, if you walk by it and you accidentally pull something, like if you hit the outlet and you pull something off the counter that's electrically powered, that can be bad. And typically the codes are designed to avoid hazards like that.
24:04John Siracusa: All right. We have a couple more notes with regard to the HomePod. Now I did it. HomeView. Derek Martin writes, I was surprised to see that the HomeView screen doesn't have identical dimensions to the Duo screen. because they're so close and it could save developers time and money. I'm with you on, it seems like it would have been similar, but I don't really think it's going to save developers much time because there really is no third-party story for this.
24:28Casey Liss: Yeah, it's not an app platform. Like CarPlay already adapts to a bunch of different sizes and shapes. So I get the idea, like if it was 1.4 by one instead of one by one, but I think it being square definitely is the design they were going for with the little cute factor.
24:41Marco Arment: Yeah, but also like the, so much of the UI is widgets and things that are basically widgets in new contexts. And the developer story for this, I mean, first of all, the reason I laughed is that Apple does not care to save developers time and money, ever. That's also true. That is the last thing. Apple will prioritize, what's the coolest version of this product we can make? Period. And developers, do what you got to do. Like, that's it. But anyway, the main developer story here is widgets. and there is a small square category of widget the same one on your iphone if you do like you know the smallest widget size it's like it's you know two by two square icons that size is what's shown in standby mode and developers like that's the only thing we can really do and it seems to be using that same kind of system and so they just they just blow that size up and show it at large at larger you know pixel densities you know render but it's still that that class of widget being shown here.
25:44Marco Arment: Those widgets are square. And so Apple can very easily tile, you know, a two by two grid of them and do whatever they want over there. So I think there's a lot of things they're taking advantage of with like, you know, doing a square screen for a bunch of square widgets that are both theirs and third party. And as for the CarPlay API side of things, CarPlay screens have never been fixed resolutions and sizes. They've always varied and been kind of like, you know, a general, class of interaction that like, well, you can expect to have approximately this minimum size, but it can also be massive or it can be different shapes and have different capabilities.
26:18Marco Arment: And CarPlay itself is fairly adaptive to different sizes. So in this particular case of the HomeView, these concerns were not that significant.
26:29John Siracusa: Finally, from Rick Allen, will Marco be adding CarPlay support to Unforgetful so it will show up and work on the HomeView?
26:36Marco Arment: reading this in the show notes earlier is the first time I've ever considered this I don't know if Apple would let a reminders app apply for the CarPlay entitlement and get it not everyone can actually make CarPlay apps reminder look out for that pothole yeah right so you have to apply for the special CarPlay entitlement and then you have to agree to a bunch of conditions things like you're not going to wedge a game into it So people would be distracted while driving, like by playing your taxi adventure, like through CarPlay or whatever. Like you have to like agree to certain terms that you're going to be, you know, reasonably safe and not try to get around restrictions and stuff like that.
27:16Marco Arment: But Apple is, I believe, human reviewing all of those. I think they at least used to be. And I think they still are. So I don't think they would let that in. But if they did, not a bad idea. We are sponsored by ZocDoc. ZocDoc helps you find doctors and book appointments easily. This is really great. For me personally, I've moved a few times in my life. And, you know, every time I got to find a new doctor. More recently, I've had to change health insurance a lot as I was, you know, independently employed and buying off the marketplace. And a lot of times you got to change doctors when your insurance changes.
27:49Marco Arment: And it's just so hard to find doctors, especially when you need some kind of specialty. Like, oh, now I have to find an allergist or whatever. It's such a pain. And then, you know, you got to sign up for somebody's portal and book some appointment through something. You can't call anybody anymore. It's just, it's something that it's easy to put off. And ZocDoc helps solve this problem. ZocDoc lets you easily find and compare local doctors who are in network for whatever your insurance is. They have more than 150 ,000 providers within 200 specialties across all 50 U.S. states. And every doctor has reviews from real patients on ZocDoc.
28:27Marco Arment: They have detailed profiles, so you can help choose the right one for you. Once you choose, you can see actual appointment openings that those doctors have, and you can instantly book a visit with a click. It's so fast to get appointments, often within just one to three days. You can even sometimes score same-day appointments with doctors, so you don't have to wait months to find somebody who's available. It's wonderful. And ZocDoc is, of course, free to use. Your health matters, and taking care of yourself shouldn't be complicated. Ready to be seen? head to ZocDoc.com slash ATP to get started and check that appointment off your to-do list.
29:04Marco Arment: That's ZocDoc spelled Z-O-C-D-O-C dot com. ZocDoc.com slash ATP. Thank you so much to ZocDoc for sponsoring our show.
29:18John Siracusa: All right, let's talk Apple TV. We had some discussion with regard to the price history. John, can you tell me about this YouTube link, please?
29:27Casey Liss: Yeah, I had a recollection of this, but didn't remember the details. So I looked it up afterwards. And here we are in the Apple event in March 2015. I forget what kind of event it was, but I don't think it was like a major one. At that event, Apple lowered the price of the Apple TV from$99 to$69. I had totally forgotten that it was that low. I was going to guess that they had lowered it to$99. No, they lowered it to$69. So that$69 in March 2015 is equivalent to$100 today, roughly. So still pretty cheap. And this was the third generation Apple TV, basically the one before the Apple TV HD was introduced in September of 2015.
30:05Casey Liss: So it was kind of the end of life of the non, the pre HD Apple TV, but it was still that same black puck. I think it was a different, you know, it was like flatter and squatter or whatever. But anyway, just to give you an idea of how far we've come for Apple TV prices. Again, I'm not counting like the weird other one that ran like macOS 10.4 variant or whatever. I'm talking about the little black puck thingy. You could get it for$69 in 2015. Glenn Feishman made a chart of all of them, including inflation adjusted numbers and the actual price adjustments and absolute values. And it's fascinating to look at, although a little bit confusing, but we will link it in the show notes.
30:42Marco Arment: And John, just as a reminder, what's the price of the current Apple TV remote by itself?
30:47Casey Liss: It's not$69, but it's close.
30:49Marco Arment: It's$59.
30:52Casey Liss: $59 for the remote.
30:54John Siracusa: All right. Microphones. There's some new far-field microphones in the Apple TV box itself. And Jason writes, have fun trying to get the new Apple TV to answer any of your questions without the four HomePods nearby hijacking the Siri request with a grimacing emoji.
31:08Casey Liss: That's the picture they show. They always show like, oh, you're Apple TV and the four HomePods. Good luck talking to the little black box.
31:15John Siracusa: That is true. However, if you're a learned individual, you don't have any HomePods in your house and you don't have to worry about this. Yeah.
31:23Casey Liss: And to be clear, according to Apple, and a lot of the time this works, Apple's devices will coordinate with each other so that they don't all answer. They will figure out who's supposed to answer. They will pick the quote unquote best one and that one will answer. That's how it's supposed to work. Sometimes it does work that way. But if you have a lot of Apple devices, you know it doesn't always work that way. For example, if you say, hey, dingus, to your phone that's on the desk in front of you and you hear a HomePod three rooms away answer, you know that this system remains imperfect.
31:57John Siracusa: Indeed, it does. All right. With regard to AV1, which the following is via Michael Barnes, among others, the new Apple TV has AV1 hardware decoding thanks to A18SOC. SoC. Here's a feature comparison of the second, third, and fourth gen Apple TV models from Reddit. That's Ribbit and Reddit put together. Anyway, from Reddit. All right, so then with that in mind, we can look at the announcement dates for the last few generations of Apple TV, starting from the oldest, April 20th of 2021, then April 18th of 2022, a scant 546 days later. then after that october 13th of 2026 1456 days later my word that's the thing that stood out
32:43Casey Liss: to me on this chart the chart was basically saying who you know which things have av1 hardware recording or whatever but also had the release dates and it's like boy yeah those are stretching out a lot aren't they really not great uh it's also worth noting that youtube and netflix both
32:56John Siracusa: desire to and do encode things in AV1. Now, will this get sent to the Apple TV? Who knows? But that is what they use, or they at least vend that to other devices.
33:06Casey Liss: Yeah, that's what people are excited about AV1 because it's like, hey, better picture quality with the same bandwidth or sometimes better picture quality with even lower bandwidth. It's a better codec, yada, yada. So that's why people, that's why you might care that your Apple EV has AV1. But it only matters if either you're using some app like Infuse or something that can, you know, read av1 files and decode it on the hardware or if big services like youtube netflix and other streamers actually start somehow detecting that you have av1 hardware decoding and start sending you an av1 encoded stream that it looks better than the previous streams but who knows if they'll even do that that's kind of up to apple to coordinate with them and it's debatable whether anyone would even know but eventually i don't know let's say 20 years from now they'll all have av1 encoding and then uh you know streaming services can all switch to it
33:54John Siracusa: All right, John, there are a lot of very, very grumpy nerds that Apple did not include the thing that they must include in the new Apple TV. How could they not, John Syracuse? And Andrew Haglund was one of the people who was curious about what does this even mean? So Andrew writes, what do you mean when you say that the new Apple TV does not have audio pass-through? And I will add as a corollary, why do we care? so i thought you were going to jump in there but you didn't and that's fine uh i will move right along and tell you that caleb dennison uh has a youtube short i think it's whatever it is it's a short youtube video uh where caleb explains and caleb says the apple tv 4k has always taken a bitstream audio signal from streaming services or your personal media collection and converted it into a signal that is ready to be amplified by your receiver or a tv or a soundbar the problem is that when Apple does the conversion, it's stripping out a bunch of information from the audio signal, which prevents your receiver or soundbar from having certain kinds of control over it.
34:57John Siracusa: It can affect receiver and soundbar dialogue normalization features, so bringing up the volume of dialogue and only dialogue, for example, or how channel levels can be adjusted. And a lot of users report that Apple's audio output doesn't sound as dynamic, punchy, or interesting as the output from other streaming devices. Audio pass-through, or lossless audio pass-through, allows the signal to go straight through the Apple TV 4K to your soundbar or receiver where you have more control and sometimes get better sound.
35:24Casey Liss: And that's why AV nerds are upset about it continuing to not be there because they probably have a fancy receiver or at the very least some kind of soundbar or some other equipment that they bought because of its features, because of the control it gives them over the sound or whatever. Regular people who are just connecting their Apple TV to the TV and don't have any external speakers don't care about this. But yeah, the audiovisual nerds are like, come on, give us pass-through because they don't want the Apple TV doing this role. They have other equipment that they want to use for that purpose that they bought for that purpose.
35:53Casey Liss: It should just be a software change. It should be a thing they can roll out anytime they want. But yeah, they're annoyed that it doesn't exist. I mentioned it last episode a couple of times, but it didn't explain what it was. And Caleb Dennison is one of my favorite TV reviewer people who recently went independent after quite a struggle. So check out his channel.
36:10John Siracusa: Finally, for follow up, Apple says the iPhone Duo has a replaceable cover layer, as they call it above the display. Joe Rosignol at MacRumors writes, in a recent interview with content creator Angelica Ciliani-Fendi, Apple's vice president of hardware engineering, Kate Bergeron, revealed that the iPhone Duo's nanotexture cover layer above the inner display can be removed and replaced. Quote, it's actually replaceable, which is a really nice thing for the customer that you can peel off that layer and get a new one, said Bergeron. To be clear, Kate Bergeron is not saying that one of us will peel this off.
36:42John Siracusa: No, no, no. You do not want to do that. that's very bad so continuing from uh joe from the u.s customers who purchase apple care plus coverage for the iphone duo can get the cover layer replaced for 19 according to apple's website the cost to replace the cover layer without coverage has yet to be disclosed or at least at the time of writing of that yeah i think it's 50 bucks yeah i was gonna say i thought we had seen a price since then anyways the cover layer helps to hide the crease in the middle of the foldable inner display bergeron and said apple did a quote significant amount of engineering work quote to ensure that this layer remains in good condition for as long as possible but customers will have the option to replace it if it wears down or the crease becomes more visible over time
37:18Casey Liss: it's kind of amazing this wasn't mentioned in the keynote but when we're talking about it before especially when the rumors about using it with the stylus came out it's like all right so it's a matte surface and it's bending and you can use it with a stylus what is going to happen in terms of wear and tear on that surface because it can't be a piece of glass like on the nanotexture ipad because it bends and it is like it's a very thin piece of glass you know what i mean you know what i mean it can't be like a rigid piece of glass that doesn't bend and so what is this going to be like in terms of durability and the answer is that it's just a wear item it's like brake pads right you you you know it you use it and if it starts getting scuffed or messed up you can replace it and relatively cheaply again if you apple care plus you have apple care plus twenty dollars can you think of any repair to any apple product even with apple care plus that costs twenty dollars that's pretty cheap and without apple care plus i believe i believe it is 50 bucks um of course if you have to replace the entire screen that's a thousand bucks so yeah uh it's good that it has a wear layer on top but it but keep in mind that because it has a wear layer that probably means that layer will in fact wear wear that being said though like the the reviewers
38:25Marco Arment: like some some of the reviewers have tested the durability of that layer and it seems pretty good like it's not obviously it's not invincible nothing is but it seems like from the test so far that it is seemingly better than people think. It isn't just like a piece of plastic. Like it seems like it's actually...
38:42Casey Liss: I mean, it is a piece of plastic. It's just a good piece of plastic.
38:44Marco Arment: Well, yeah. It isn't like an$8 Amazon screen protector. It actually seems like it's pretty sturdy. All right.
38:51John Siracusa: So Marco, what were you doing yesterday out of curiosity?
38:55Marco Arment: I was at an iPhone Duo. I believe it was called a Creator Showcase. Was that what?
39:00John Siracusa: Yeah, I believe that's right.
39:01Marco Arment: It was an event that Apple put on in Manhattan where they invited a bunch of people from the press and a bunch of developers. And the developers, it was kind of like a mini keynote situation where it's like, you know, these developers have been, you know, we brought them in from various companies, you know, people like Netflix, MLB, The New York Times, you know, high profile or in a few cases, some indie developers. And they've had a few weeks with Duo units to develop and make really cool versions of their apps on them. And then so they invited members of the press to come basically walk around and handle the iPhone duo ahead of time of the official release tomorrow and play with these fun apps that these companies had made and have representatives from the companies give little tours and show off their apps.
39:52Marco Arment: Basically, I think Apple used the word showcase. I think the showcase is a perfect word for it. It was like a demo event where we got to walk around. Casey and I got to actually handle the iPhone Duo and use it in this somewhat limited way, but still, we got to actually hold it and see it. So that was really cool. And of course, as I mentioned earlier, Casey and I got to see each other, which was also really nice. Not at a jam band concert this time.
40:19John Siracusa: Although next time it will be again. Yeah, we'll make up for it really quickly.
40:22Marco Arment: Don't worry. But it was really fun. It was a really cool event, and we got to handle the Duo, and that was also really fun.
40:29John Siracusa: Yeah. So I have a ton of thoughts, all of which are extremely poorly considered because while we did go around to all these stations to kind of try all these different apps and whatnot, we weren't being monitored in the sense that we could do whatever we wanted with these phones within reason. But at least for the two of us, I'm pretty sure I can speak for Marco in saying that we didn't want to just sit there and go screwing around with other people's apps as somebody's trying to engage with us about their particular app. So we got to play with the duo some. I folded and unfolded it a zillion times.
41:05John Siracusa: I got to have a look at it. The reactions I'm having today are based on what happened yesterday morning. and tomorrow morning in less than 12 hours, in theory, I will have my iPhone, oh, spoiler alert, but I will have my iPhone Duo in my hands. So now I'm jumping ahead and John's very angry at me, my bad. But suffice to say, these thoughts are poorly considered and I am reserving the right to completely change my mind. But with that said, the device from a hardware perspective is extremely cool. It is extremely, extremely cool. It's heavy, but not in an off-putting way, or at least I didn't think so.
41:48John Siracusa: And Marco, please interrupt me if you have thoughts. Oh, I have lots of thoughts.
41:51Marco Arment: Don't worry. You get through yours first. Don't worry.
41:54John Siracusa: I won't forget. It was heavy, but not in a burdensome way. It felt like sturdy, for lack of a better word.
42:02Casey Liss: On the topic of weight, by the way, and I know if we get to the other iPhone doer reviews, we'll have this, but I was surprised a couple of them pulled out the actual weight in grams of the iphone duo which i hadn't really compared to the other phones it's not actually that much more than the uh iphone pro max or maybe it was slightly less i forget let's look it up but it's within the ballpark of the pro of the the pro max which surprised me because i just assumed it would be so much heavier than their pro max but yeah as with anything with the perception of weight if you make a very small thing that weighs the same amount as a very large thing the large thing feels lighter and that's definitely an
42:37Marco Arment: effect there yeah well and also like you know it is heavier than the max it's like 250 something grams grams of and the max is um some and the pro the pro is like 220 something and the max is kind of somewhere in the middle um but those kind of weight differences you know going from like 220 something 250 something that matters a lot like especially in perceptual feel um and for something that you're holding in your hands and it's bouncing around in your pockets like that those differences matter a lot you know like we're we are as we'll talk about later we are somewhat close to what we expect to be an event where we're going to have lighter laptops announced.
43:13Marco Arment: And if laptops shrink by 10 or 15 % in weight, that's very noticeable. It matters. It matters a lot. Yeah.
43:22John Siracusa: So the weight, I didn't find bad. The hinge, the operation of the hinge, using the hinge, absolutely, and reviewers have clocked this as well, absolutely a two-handed thing. I don't suspect that that's something that people will be able to do with one hand or at least not easily. But don't hear what I'm not saying. It's not hard to use the hinge. It's just calibrated, for lack of a better word, that you're going to need two hands to do it.
43:50Casey Liss: Weight update. iPhone Duo 254 grams. iPhone 18 Pro Max 249. It is a 5 gram difference.
44:01Marco Arment: Oh, that's really not much. And then what's the regular sized Pro? 211. Oh, yeah. See, that's a substantial.
44:08Casey Liss: The thing is, the Pro Max does always feel heavy, but it's entirely about how big is it in a length and width. You know what I mean? It's just perception. Perception is reality when it comes to, does this feel heavy or not?
44:23John Siracusa: The hinge was great. the crease on the inside display. It is there, but in my personal opinion, all of us, including me, fretting about the crease was misplaced angst and agita and nervousness. I think the crease is a nothing burger. Now, will it be worse in a year? Maybe, but the video reviewers seem to say otherwise. We'll get there.
44:49Casey Liss: No, absolutely.
44:50John Siracusa: It'll be worse in a year.
44:51Casey Liss: Absolutely it will.
44:52John Siracusa: Okay, that's fair. But will it be way worse? Will it be noticeably worse? Yes. I'm not so convinced. Maybe.
44:59Casey Liss: Yes, it will be noticeably worse. All right, we'll see. We'll get to the reviews. I've watched a lot of reviews about this, and that seemed very, the very common consensus and inclusion. Now, will it be bothersome? No, probably not. That's what I'm driving at.
45:11John Siracusa: Yeah, yeah.
45:12Casey Liss: It's not like, oh, I can't use this, because, like, first of all, folding phones have existed for years and years, and people use them with horrendous creases in them. It's fine. Like, it's not, it doesn't stop you from using the phone, especially if you arrange the images on it and don't put things in the crease, which we know Apple doesn't put things in the crease, right? It'll be fine. But speaking of wear items, the screen itself is a wear item with respect to the crease.
45:34Marco Arment: Yeah, but it's also going to be a lot like your phone's battery life, where it's not going to change overnight. It's going to be a gradual shift towards less good over the course of the years that you own this phone.
45:48Casey Liss: Well, I think it's also kind of like driving a new car off the lot, where the depreciation happens in a really big chunk the second you drive it off the lot and then gradually after that a lot of the reviewers have shown that when you take it out of the box it's amazing it's perfect if you open and close it 20 times noticeable decrease and then it's a gradual slope from there really i that's interesting i i yeah i can't confirm nor deny but i i what i i mean i watched
46:15John Siracusa: all the videos that you linked and we will link in the show notes and what i got from that was yeah you might notice it and i'm sure john would notice it but you know captain super sense over here but for a regular person i i really don't think it'll be much but you know what we don't need to continue to bicker about this because we'll know in a year um the thing or the the displays the outer display the fidelity of the outer display was great the fidelity of the inner display probably even better i'm now maybe numerically in like um if you look at the specs Maybe I'm wrong about that, but it looked wonderful.
46:48John Siracusa: I thought they both looked great. The anti-glare mat, whatever they're calling it thing on the inside was great. However, the thing that put me off the most about the iPhone Duo, and I'm not sure if it's the particular apps I was looking at, if it was this impeccable lighting in this Apple space that we were in, which was gorgeous, by the way, just absurdly pretty. But nevertheless, I don't know what it was. And Marco, when I finally shut up and give you a chance to talk, I'm curious what your two cents are. But the not hole punch, but the FaceTime camera that's on the big display, the one that's under the display, the not hole, but hole for that was very, very visually loud to me.
47:33John Siracusa: Astonishingly so. I think I'm overblowing it a bit and I'll admit that, but I was expecting to barely be able to see it. And oh baby, I saw it. Conversely, I was expecting to be able to see the crease. If you look just right, you can see it. And if you're running your finger across the center of the screen laterally, you can feel it. But otherwise, to me, the crease was 100 % a nothing burger. But the camera on the big display, that was so noticeable that I found it
48:02Casey Liss: very off-putting and you know why that was noticeable because there's no matte there among other things that's right then the nanotexture matte stuff stops at the camera so like there's nothing they can do about it there because basically like they've intentionally made a surface texture difference they have to do it because the the camera can't see through the wavy plastic right right it would be all distorted so like in any lighting condition in any situation it's like you can tell matte versus shiny and the camera hole is shiny and the rest of the screen is
48:31John Siracusa: that and there's nothing you can do about that yeah and i mean i i'm sure over time i would get used to it i if you were to go back to when we first got the notched phones i bet you i was whining and moaning about how noticeable the notch was and now well now they're they're holes rather
48:46Casey Liss: than not just you get what i'm driving at now they're trying to put content like there was never any content behind the notch because it's not screen but now i'm putting content there but like yeah i i do wonder if they'll revisit that but it seems like it's kind of an intractable problem because you can't distort the light that goes to the uh the camera sure but what i'm
49:03John Siracusa: wondering is over time will i just stop seeing it oh yeah probably i mean like you can get the
49:09Casey Liss: same experience just by looking at all the reviews like when you first see it you'll see it in the reviews too but then eventually you'll stop paying attention to it like it yeah i mean maybe it'll be like you'll you'll constantly think something is on that part of the screen and try to wipe it off but eventually you get used to it and speaking of that and speaking of the nanotexture um that's one of the things a lot of reviews talk about is like all nanotextures um how much does it hold on to finger grease essentially and how hard is it to get off and yeah it's just easier to get grease off a glossy surface it's not impossible it's just it's just like any other nanotexture on any other apple device especially the nanotexture touch devices like the ipads and maybe the upcoming uh macbook pros would touch it in a week or so um it's going to take a little bit more effort fingerprints may show up more and it takes a little bit more effort to dig that finger grease out of the grooves?
49:55John Siracusa: With regard to software, again, I barely played with any of this stuff. I had like a couple of minutes with each of these different stations. Without question, there were pieces of software that Marco and I tried that were better than others. A couple of examples of ones that I thought were really, really great. The Netflix app is extraordinary. It's extremely well done. All of the press that it's getting, all the hype that it's getting to my eyes 100 earned now to be fair the one of the developed really the developer of all these updates is a is a friend of mine so i am biased but i genuinely believe that it is just incredible the work that he and they have done um i also thought fantastical while more subtle was really well handled and it was great to meet is it michael is that right yeah it was great to meet him i'd never met him before um and so it was good to see that those were my personal favorites with regard to using the phone.
50:54John Siracusa: Again, I only had a couple of minutes with it and I wasn't doing too much with iOS proper. It was mostly just, you know, working or messing with these apps, but having messed with it a bunch in the simulator made it feel reasonably natural, but I didn't get enough time with it that I can really pass any strong judgment as to whether or not I would get used to it. And I did not once lock or unlock a phone. And I suspect that all the whining and moaning that all these reviewers are doing about not having face ID, I bet you I will be leading that charge next week after having spent a little bit of time with my phone.
51:33John Siracusa: So all in all, my impression, I think I could summarize is this, and I'm really excited to hear what Marco has to say, because honestly, we actually didn't talk too much about this when we were together. My impression, especially having digested it a little bit as I was digesting my half a pizza, is that if you think about the Vision Pro, right, and just hear me out here, if you think about the Vision Pro, it's extraordinary hardware, and honestly, it's extraordinary software. But even though we thought it would be super useful and, you know, you could do good things with it. Did we think that?
52:14John Siracusa: Well, I feel like there was a window of time where at least I thought it. And despite all that, I don't think the Vision Pro ended up being that way, right? Like the Vision Pro was compromised and that was okay because you saw what they were going for, but it wasn't particularly useful. And I say that as someone who still enjoys the Vision Pro every couple of times I put it on in a year. But anyway, so the Vision Pro, compromised, not that useful. The iPhone Duo, by contrast, is compromised for sure. But not only is it useful, and I think having the inner display is useful, and I think being able to go two up on the inner display, it's very intuitive and useful.
53:05John Siracusa: so yes it's compromised but unlike the vision pro it's useful like potentially really freaking useful and so the thought of having something that useful and just different maybe for the sake of being different which i would normally poop all over but in this case i think i we are all so thirsty and i feel like all three of us maybe marco more than anyone have been banging this drum for a while, but it's so fun to have something different and fun again. And actually, there's something we're going to talk about in the post-show tonight that I think really, really relates to this because I saw something yesterday, something unrelated yesterday, that is really, really fun.
53:49John Siracusa: And it's cool to have fun back. We are not the only ones saying this. I know Jason Snell has been saying this a lot, for example, but having this thing that is not only fun, but useful. Compromised, perhaps, but nevertheless is interesting and fun and different and exciting. Now, I'm conveniently slipping under the rug that it's$2 ,000. I'm slipping under the rug that you can't get your hands on one of these. Half the price of the Vision Pro with any accessories. Right. I'm sweeping under the rug that nobody can get their hands on these, which we'll talk about later. Vision Pro didn't have that problem.
54:29Marco Arment: Yeah, right.
54:30John Siracusa: But it's so great to have Apple kind of, moonshot is a bit dramatic, but doing a moonshot or taking a moonshot. And I'm so here for it. And would I recommend the phone to an average consumer? I don't know. At$2 ,000, probably not. But the good and bad news is I feel like I need it for both of my jobs. And so I'm going to be getting one. And will I keep it? Probably. Will I keep it as my carry phone? I don't know. Tomorrow we're going to a football game and I hope to bring this with me as my phone. And let me tell you, I don't take that many pictures of what's going on in the field, but it ain't going to be fun at 2X.
55:10John Siracusa: You can just set it up on the
55:11Casey Liss: car ride over?
55:12John Siracusa: Yeah, right. Preference acknowledged. No, I'm actually, as we speak, I'm using an Apple Thunderbolt cable directly plugged into my Mac, doing a backup of my iPhone 17 Pro to my Mac. So hopefully I can do that, a restore from that tomorrow.
55:27Marco Arment: Hope you aren't on the 27.2 beta on that phone. No, I am not. Good. Because I don't think you'd be able to install it onto the 27.1 iPhone Duo.
55:36John Siracusa: No, I'm not. But yeah, that's a good point. But yeah, so I am super excited for this. I'm not convinced I'm going to like it or love it. There's a lot in the reviews, which maybe one day Marco and I will stop talking. We can get to the reviews. But there's a lot in the reviews that scares. Well, scares is dramatic, but scares me. And I'm worried about Touch ID. or excuse me, I'm worried about touch ID slash lack of face ID. I'm worried about the lack of the 4X camera. But man, it is so cool and fun to see Apple shooting their shot again. I think I'm done now. I will come up with something more to say in a second.
56:11John Siracusa: But Marco, take it away. What are your impressions?
56:13Marco Arment: I liked the comparison to the Vision Pro and I'll tell you where I think it's different. Using the word compromised was a very good word for the Vision Pro. the iPhone Duo from what I can tell so far I wouldn't say it's a compromise I would say it's a trade off a compromise kind of suggests like there was no good version of this possible so here's like here's something we had to like you know the less good version that we had to ship because we couldn't ship a better one the iPhone Duo from what I can tell so far is not a compromised product. It's just a product that takes some much more opinionated trade-offs to get some extremes than the other phones do.
57:05Marco Arment: You know, with the iPhone Duo, if that product is right for you, what you want is the absolute biggest screen that you can fit in your pocket somehow. And literally everything else about it has had to be adjusted to achieve that trade-off. It's not necessarily a compromise. It's just like, this is the trade-off. It's like, well, if you want the biggest screen in your pocket possible, it's probably going to be a little bit heavy or it has to be thick because you have to fold it in half or whatever. And then it's like, okay, well, if you have a folding in half screen, you need a screen on the outside also so you can use it while it's closed.
57:41Marco Arment: So then you need another screen. Now you need more battery, you need more cost, you need more components, you need more complexity. Okay, like that all follows from that. But if what you want fundamentally is, I want to carry in a pocketable size the largest screen I possibly can, then this is a product for you. The Vision Pro, I never thought like this is a product with an audience that absolutely must buy it. The Duo, the audience that must buy it is obvious. It definitely exists. It is not even that small. It's not that big, but it's not no one. It's not like, oh well somebody in some enterprise might use this like no i know a lot of people regular people who will want this and who would you know if they can if the if the price if they can swing the price like who would absolutely love this so what they've made in the duo as far as i can tell so far anyway i haven't lived with this phone i've played with this phone so i have not used it as my own i have not set up touch id i have not set up my you know my my apps my apple id my iCloud like none of those so it's hard to really say you know more than what the reviewers are saying or even the same because we the reviewers have all been able to live with it for like you know five or seven days or whatever um we have not i did put one in my pocket i kind of looked around like i'm whistling but i did put one in my pocket to see like how does this feel in the pocket it's freaking heavy that's how it feels um it did not feel as clunky as i expected it to feel in a pocket in terms of size, but boy, is it heavy.
59:17Marco Arment: But again, the trade-offs you're making here are you want the absolute biggest screen possible. And when you see that big screen, it's fantastic. Now, the trade-offs to get there, these are some really weird new things to get used to. One thing I noticed, the very first thing I noticed when I first picked one up, besides the fact that it's heavy is that the outside screen and the inside screen look totally different from each other. And not just because of the size and obviously one's half of the other. Because they have such radically different surface treatments and trims around them, the outer, this will kind of sound like a mullet joke, the outer screen is all Phil Schiller and the inner screen is all John Ternus.
1:00:12Marco Arment: The outer screen, it's the Schiller era aesthetic. Everything is like shiny. And like, so, you know, the very, you know, the glass screen, the glossy glass finish on the screen. Around it, you see the high polished titanium edge. You know, it's very similar to the iPhone Air. If you've seen an iPhone Air outside of a case or, you know, the older Pro phones where they had the polished stainless steel band like in the early teens in the Pro phone era. it's that look it looks high polish high fingerprint but high high polish glossy shiny fancy and then you open it up and the inside is this beautiful matte screen surrounded by a very thin unnoticeable you know matte black bezel it's a completely different look and whenever I was switching between those two screens, I would notice like literally every time I'd close it, I'd be like, oh, the outside screen is so shiny.
1:01:16Marco Arment: And then you open it up, it's like, this screen is so nice and usable. Like it was these two contrasts in one product. And that's kind of a microcosm of the whole product. Like the experience of using the outer screen is pretty weird. And I found it pretty unpleasant. Like if you read John Gruber's review, he really hated the experience using the outer screen. And I think I agree with most of that. I really did not like using the outer screen much at all. But again, it's a tradeoff. To get the inner screen to be as amazing as it is requires the outer screen to be kind of crappy in terms of usability.
1:01:59And they have achieved that. The thing is, the way I use a phone, I don't think this is going to be the right phone for me.
1:02:08Marco Arment: The way I use a phone is, first of all, a lot of one-handed, on-the-go, walking around kind of use. And it's just not going to be good for that. I think it's going to be hard for a lot of, look, I'll just say men, a lot of people who don't carry their phone in bags, who are used to carrying their phone just in a pants pocket. I think they're not going to necessarily understand the appeal of this phone to people who do carry bags. People who carry bags and who carry their phone in bags usually, the in-pocket size matters a lot less. The weight has a little more tolerance because it's in a bag. 20, 30 grams in a bag don't really matter that much compared to in a pocket.
1:02:54Marco Arment: and a lot of times it's a two-handed operation to get the phone out anyway and so to have a second step where you're like unfolding it to get this amazing interior screen no big deal it's not adding that much to the to the total action being taken there whereas if you're having your phone just in your pants pocket all day long that it's the outside screen is going to be more important and the clunkiness of the unfolding is going to be relatively more of a burden to you. So I can see this having very different opinions based on who's talking about it, who's using it. It's not for me, I don't think.
1:03:33Marco Arment: But it is really, really cool. And every time I looked at that screen, the inside screen, even the outside screen, as I said, the outside screen is beautiful. I just don't like using apps on it. especially when you bring the keyboard up, it really takes up a lot of the screen. However, I did notice that typing on that keyboard was very pleasant because it's wide. So you do get a lot more like key size in the same way. Like if you if you're like usually like a regular sized phone person and you try out a max for a little while. One of the things you notice when going to a bigger screen iPhone is, oh, the typing is nicer once you get used to it because you have more space.
1:04:15Marco Arment: Maybe it's less error prone. You have that with this. Going to the Duo from a Pro phone, the keyboard feels very spacious on the outside screen. And one challenge is, kind of as I expected, I think, during the Duo announcement, the problem is you can have the keyboard on three different sized screens, basically. You know, outside screen, inside portrait, and inside landscape. Technically four if you add also the like half split view, but no one's... And tent. And don't forget tent. Oh, God. But like, you... Okay, let me just get out of the way first. I don't see any reason why anybody would ever hold the phone in like book view where it's slightly bent, but you're holding it in landscape.
1:04:55Marco Arment: Like that's not going to be a thing anybody does. So don't worry about that. Just the way you use this phone is either closed, open portrait or open landscape. All the other things are going to be like a fun gimmick here and there occasionally, but no one's going to do it for that much time on a regular basis. But portrait, landscape and front are all three very different keyboard sizes. So for me, I was like, I got used to typing on the front one just enough. And then when I open it up to either of the inside ones, they're totally different sizes.
1:05:25Casey Liss: And don't forget the split variants of the inside ones too.
1:05:27Marco Arment: Right. That's only if you bend it. I think you can toggle split and non-split with a key on the keyboard. Of course you can. So yeah, everything about it is weird. But the whole time I was using it, I'll be honest. When I was using the Vision Pro, the very first few times I was using the Vision Pro, it all just felt like friction to me. Everything about the Vision Pro was like, oh, God, this is a compromise or this is not good. This is like Division Pro. Everything was like, maybe someday this might be good for someone, but not me and not today. The duo is like, oh, no, I don't think it's right for me, but it's really cool.
1:06:05Marco Arment: I really like it. And it's already right for a lot of people today, exactly as it is with all of its shortcomings and tradeoffs. so i was i really enjoyed using the duo i am i am getting one we'll get to that in a minute but i i don't think i'm gonna live with it as my daily carry phone for the whole year and beyond um i don't think so but i could look because i haven't used it myself as my phone yet i can't really know that. But it is really, really nice at what it tries to do. Is it perfect? No, of course not. But it's really nice today for what it is today. Not some promise of the future, not a bunch of content snacks saying this is what someday this might become.
1:06:53Marco Arment: No, it's really great today. You can't get one, of course, but that's a bit of a problem. But it's very cool. And that inside screen is so gorgeous and so nice to use. And so honestly, the inside is also so nice to hold. Because again, like what John said earlier about the weight discussion, the phone feels like a brick in your pocket. But when you open it up and you're handling it like a little iPad, it feels weightless. Yeah, it gets lighter when you open it. That is honestly the perception because you're holding a much thinner thing. And so you're like, oh, well, yeah, like per square foot here, like per visible square foot of this thing, this weighs very little.
1:07:38Marco Arment: It is a remarkable feeling to hold it and to use it in the open state. And even though there's all these different tradeoffs and shortcomings and the apps are still going to be spotty for a while, there's going to be lots of bugs. I found bugs already. Even in the demo phones, there were bugs in certain apps, a lot of animation bugs, rotation bugs, like all sorts of weird stuff. But again, this is all like really, there's a lot going on in this software. There's a lot of things have changed, a lot of new stuff, a lot of unfinished stuff. But it is something great today. I think it is going to be a hit.
1:08:16And I think it's going to be a very polarizing reaction from people.
1:08:21Marco Arment: In the same way that like when we went from the regular sized, you know, like the mid-sized iPhone, when they added the Plus and the Max phones. those were polar those are polarizing too because a lot of people were like oh my god i want the biggest screen i can possibly get this is amazing a lot of other people were like why would anybody want their phone to be that giant it's ridiculous well the iphone duo takes that a huge leap in that same direction of like okay well now we're going to add way more screen space with way more trade offs. And a lot of people are going to be like, that's the stupidest thing ever.
1:08:59Marco Arment: Or how could they flub detail X that I care about or whatever. But then a lot of other people are going to be like, yes, I need that. I want that. I want the biggest screen I can get. And it's going to depend a lot on how you use your phone, how you carry your phone, what's important to you. You know, some of the most impressive, I think maybe the most impressive demo that we saw was there was a team there from the Instagram edits app. What was really nice about edits was like they, you know, they kind of, they were describing how like when you're editing a video, you know, you have like the, you know, the preview on one half and like, you know, the timeline stuff and the controls and, you know, different parts of it.
1:09:38Marco Arment: And that's the kind of thing, like you can see like if that's something that you do, if you edit video with one of these tools, this is a game changer. Like if you're like a video person, a content creator, you're doing this kind of stuff on your iPhone, you're going to want this for all of that because it's like it makes your your main like iphone thing that you do all the time a lot better um or you know if you if you if you fly a lot and you want to just like have this thing up on a tray table and like helping to you know amuse you on the on the plane or show some video or something i can see that being amazing too um there's so many use cases i mean just even if you just like edit spreadsheets or documents on your phone a lot.
1:10:19Marco Arment: If you use your phone as your main computer or as your most commonly used computer, which most of us honestly do, I can see this being amazing because what is better than having a ton of screen space for that kind of use? For almost any kind of document-based workflow, almost any kind of productivity work, a big screen is always better for that. So I think, again, it's going to be a hit. It's not going to be the most popular iPhone by a mile. um for lots of reasons even if they could make enough of them it wouldn't be the most popular iphone um but i think it's going to be a hit and i think they have done something really great here it's not perfect version 2 will be a lot better probably like whether that's you know whether it's like next year or that's more of like an s thing and then maybe it may be two years from now yeah it probably really needs face id and it probably needs better cooling and boy it could really use better cameras um and maybe they can do some of those things maybe they can't but it's right now the version for sale right now while not perfect is great
1:11:24Casey Liss: john any questions uh no i'm probably gonna go check it out when it arrives in stores tomorrow but uh before then all i did was watch reviews but before we get to that we should talk about
1:11:34John Siracusa: your pre-orders yeah so um the pre-orders were for us at 8 a.m uh last friday and uh day or two before then, I got a text from our friend Jelly, who said, hey, you know, our monthly FaceTime, you see what's going on then? I was like, I have no idea what you're talking about. And then I looked at my calendar. Oh, oh, we were supposed to get on the call at 8am. And so Jelly was like, what do you want to do, bud? So I said, how about we get on the phone a little bit early? And when when the time comes, you know, we'll pause for a second and take care of it. So, uh, as jelly was talking, I was listening, but I was doing the force refresh dance on the app store.
1:12:19John Siracusa: Uh, I've heard people tell me that's actually not helpful. I don't know if that's true or not. I never like force quit apps other than this. Um, but that's what I did. Um, my pro tip, which I shouldn't share because I should keep it for myself. But my pro tip is I have always, always had a better experience using my iPhone on cellular. I don't know if that's a Richmond, Virginia thing. I don't know if that's a Fios thing. I don't know what it is, but, um, I can tell you that for me being on cellular on my phone for like dub dub tickets way back when for phones, it's all, that's always the best I've ever done.
1:12:58John Siracusa: And so I was doing the force refresh dance or, and, or force, force quit dance. and I had done the pre-pre-order, you know, the night before or what have you. And, um, and I was able to, I think it was eight Oh one. I got in, I said, yes, I'll take it. Uh, do you want to do pickup? Uh, sure. Yes. Uh, when immediately, you know, 8 AM on Friday. And by some miracle, I was able to lock it in and get it through. I was, once I saw that it let me in. It was 30 seconds, maybe, before I was done. And so I have 8 a.m. pickup tomorrow as I record this. White, which I don't think I've ever done a white phone before, but I don't know, maybe having Marco's stupid 3D print has like incepted me into wanting white.
1:13:44Marco Arment: Well, you saw both of them yesterday.
1:13:46John Siracusa: Yeah, I didn't take that close of a look at it, to be honest. And honestly, I think I would have been happy with either. But I don't know, something about this, I was thinking about this actually because I knew one of you would ask me. I think because it's so different than anything else I've had, I kind of wanted it to be a different color too, which maybe that's silly, but that's what I thought.
1:14:02Marco Arment: Honestly, I think the white is obviously the better looking version. I think it's way better looking than the navy. The navy is not bad looking, but the white is great looking. I would agree with that. The contrast, this is a phone that looks really good with contrast and the white really accentuates what it is the contrast between it like it's just you see it when you see like the two halves you see the white half against it like it just yeah the white looks fantastic yeah uh so that's what i did uh
1:14:34John Siracusa: 512 uh 512 gigabytes and again day one delivery um our friend tyler or at least marco my friend tyler um who is our occasional concert companion amongst other things uh he also did the same thing and he had, as he was checking out, he was telling me, as he was checking out, it kept saying, no, actually you can't do a pickup because that slot is filled. And so he told me that basically what he did was he tried like 8, 8.15, 8.30 or whatever. I forget the delineations, but you know what I'm saying. And then he failed a couple of times. I was like, ah, screw it, noon or something like that, you know, in order to like give himself a little more buffer.
1:15:11John Siracusa: And so he's going to be there a couple hours ever, a few hours after me. But yeah, I was able to luck out. So then I finished my FaceTime call with Jelly, and this was right at the beginning of the call, so I wasn't off the call for another hour, hour and a half. And then I came up for air, if you will, and started looking at the internet, and oh, people were not happy. People were not happy. And I was blissfully ignorant about it for like 60 to 90 minutes. I would love to hear John's story and then Marco's, please.
1:15:42Casey Liss: My story? What is my story? I'm not ordering one of these phones.
1:15:45John Siracusa: I know. I'm just I'm just messing with you. Marco, how did it turn out?
1:15:47Casey Liss: Although I did see people complaining about it. It's happened to me. It's just, I don't know what it is, the CDN, luck of the draw. When do you get let into the Apple store? And for an in-demand product, being let in 60 seconds later can mean a lot.
1:16:00John Siracusa: Yeah, it really can. And that's the other thing, actually, that reminds me. Some people were saying, oh, it was 8.05. It was 8.07 or something like that for me, or for these other people. And for me, I'm almost sure it was 8.01. And I don't know. I just got lucky with the caches, I guess. But anyway, Marco, how did it turn out?
1:16:15Marco Arment: Less well. I'm sorry. So there is a new program that we heard about from the Apple Store business reps. Don't even get me started. I believe it's called Get Ready, the same thing that you can do in advance on your phone, but it's like the business rep version of this. Now, the Apple Store business reps are the nicest people. I've dealt with them over the years through various stores around New York. Like I've dealt with them for a long time. They are the nicest people. They do whatever they can for you. The thing is they can't do that much for you sometimes. And in the same way that like, you know, when I was talking about how when I was doing the MDM stuff and, you know, for all my server setups, you could tell like the MDM and like business admin side, like the IT side of Apple, you can tell they don't really get the resources they need from like the other departments.
1:17:10Marco Arment: and that's kind of why a lot of the Apple business stuff is more difficult than it needs to be or more limited than it needs to be because it seems like the rest of the company just doesn't give them what they need. That's how the business reps are too. It's very clear to me that over the years, the business reps have lost their abilities to do things very well for people in a lot of cases. They don't have a lot of tools at their disposal and they don't have a lot of resources at their disposal. Um, so I submitted the order for the business rep because what we were told at first was if you submit it through the business rep, it will automatically be submitted right when the store opens at minute zero and your order will be, you know, right there, right, right up front.
1:17:57Marco Arment: Now I got a phone call from my business rep a few days beforehand saying, Hey, I'm, I've heard some rumblings. I don't think you should count on this because it's because supply is going to be so constrained just in case you should probably try to place an order yourself at opening time also and we'll submit both and you know if we got a council one we cancel one no problem okay great so that's what i did because i had the business one i was like well let me and my you know tiff has decided she wants one too and so i'm like and she had she hasn't had an upgrade in a couple years like all right that's that's perfectly reasonable so i i set up tiff's order first in my phone like as my get ready one on my App Store version on my phone.
1:18:40Marco Arment: And then I configured mine to be a short time after that that I could just go in and fill out a couple more things, do it again, and go. So I was there right at minute zero with TIFF's order ready to go. The App Store app did not open on time. Of course. It didn't open until five minutes later. And I had Safari open on my desktop. I had Chrome open on my desktop. And I had the Apple Store app on my phone, refreshing all of them. The pages on Safari and Chrome on the desktop eventually switch to a kind of concert like, you know, stay on this page and we'll let you in. And, you know, when you're slotting the queue opens up.
1:19:17Marco Arment: Guess what? Those never let me in. That literally never occurred. If I would have trusted that page and just stayed there until it let me in, I would not have gotten an iPhone duo ever. Fortunately, I didn't trust those pages because you never trust those pages. They work on Ticketmaster, maybe. They do not work on Apple. So I got in, kept refreshing the app. About five minutes later, I got in through the app on my phone.
1:19:43John Siracusa: So this is roughly what time?
1:19:44Marco Arment: 8.05.
1:19:45John Siracusa: Oh, okay. Okay.
1:19:47Marco Arment: Got in, submitted TIF's order real fast, and even then, five minutes in, which was as soon, it was within seconds of the store being available and actually open to me. It was already delayed to the second week of November, I believe. First or second week of November. Okay. So that's already like a two week delay. I quickly go back and I submit mine. Mine's a monthly. Then eventually about 92 minutes after the store opens, I get the confirmation from the business rep channel. And that one has a date of January 26th from other people who I've asked in different reports online. As far as I can tell, that might be true of every business order for the iPhone duo that they all might've gone in.
1:20:31Marco Arment: I don't blame the business reps for this. It's, whatever system they were submitting through, it just didn't put in the orders. And it seems like all of them are like... I haven't heard of anybody getting a Duo through a business rep earlier than January. So the way this order went, I have to say I was mad. At least the business rep had the foresight to call me and warn me like, hey, don't count on this order. But okay, so Apple has this business system that just didn't work. Like flat out didn't work too bad. Literally the thing it promised, you'll be there right at the beginning, was just false.
1:21:11Marco Arment: Like it just failed completely to do the, like it's like you had one job, you didn't do it. Okay. Secondly, the app never opens on time for my area, whatever that means. And I've been in different areas and it seems like it's always kind of random. I'm sure it's various CDN propagations and things like that, But the internet has solved this problem. Ticketmaster doesn't have this problem. Only Apple has this problem. This is a solvable and solved problem. I did everything right in two different ways and still got screwed by their system because it didn't behave the way it advertises that it will behave.
1:21:52Marco Arment: I know this is a very privileged position that I'm trying to order multiple foldable phones, trying to get any of them here so I can do my job. but every part of this rollout has been in a way that makes it more difficult for developers to do our jobs we literally did everything right we were there and the system wasn't ready it didn't let us in but it let some people in because literally as soon as the system opened dates had slipped two weeks and a bunch of people did get first day orders so it wasn't that the store didn't open for anybody until 805. The store didn't open for me until 805. And that kind of thing, like, again, I know this sounds whiny, but it's just that kind of thing, random failures to random people who are doing the right thing and doing exactly what you asked them to do, is incredibly frustrating because the system ultimately, from our point of view, is unfair.
1:22:49Marco Arment: I am perfectly fine to wait in a line. I'm an American and I'm a New Yorker and we are good at those things we are good at waiting in lines we're not we're not british they they really mastered it but we're close but here it's like the apple store there is no line it's just chaos and it's random and that's just really frustrating because we do everything right and we still just randomly lose not because we were behind in line but because the line just broke for us and the solution was too bad. I know, I recognize it's a tough situation, but there are so many ways that they could handle it better.
1:23:29Marco Arment: Like, and number one would just be make their system actually fair. Like, make it actually open the same time for everyone and make those cues work. That would make it feel, even though it would still be difficult and, you know, sometimes you'd still have bad luck, at least it would feel fair. Whereas this system just feels unfair.
1:23:50John Siracusa: We are sponsored this week by Quince. So it's definitely getting chilly here in Richmond, and that means it's a great time to figure out, hmm, maybe I should refresh my wardrobe a little bit and add something new, change things out, or whatever the case may be. And let me tell you, if you are in that mood, if it is the time of year where you should think about these sorts of things, and I bet it is for you, you should check out Quince. What's great about Quince is Quince focuses on high-quality wardrobe staples made with premium materials, like 100 % Mongolian cashmere, organic cotton, and merino wool.
1:24:21John Siracusa: Their styles are timeless, versatile, and designed to become the dependable pieces you reach for day after day. And what my favorite thing about Quince is, is that everything at Quince is priced usually like 50 % to 80 % less than similar brands. Quince works directly with ethical factories to cut out the middle people, so you're paying for high-quality, not brand markup. Now, Quince just recently was kind enough to send us a little bit of money to spend. And another great thing about Quince is that it's not just for dudes. They have men's and women's stuff. They have baby and kid stuff. They actually branch out into all sorts of things, including stuff for your house, stuff to travel with, and so on.
1:24:57John Siracusa: So you should really check it out. But regardless, we ordered a few things from Michaela, including an organic cotton long sleeve fit and flare pocket dress. Actually, we did basically the same dress in two styles. One of them has these adorable little kitty cat heads on it. The other one is like nothing but like a fall colored flowers and stuff. And again, they have pockets. They are really adorable. And Michaela is super duper excited. So find your next fall favorites at Quince. Download the Quince app for app exclusive offers or go to quince.com. Get free shipping on your order and 365 day returns.
1:25:33John Siracusa: Quince is now available in Canada and the UK as well. And when Quince asks you where you heard about them, you can let them know that it was the Accidental Tech Podcast. It's the best way to support the show. So go to quince.com, Q-U-I-N-C-E.com and check it out. Thank you to Quince for supporting the show.
1:25:52John Siracusa: Let's talk about duo reviews. I've watched the ones that John has linked, and I put all these links in the show notes. John, do you want to give us a nickel tour about what you found interesting about each of these?
1:26:02Casey Liss: Yeah, I have a meta topic after watching all these reviews. I picked out some of the better reviews that I saw. This is not all the ones that I read or watched, but this is some interesting ones. And I came away with an interesting notion that I was talking about a little bit on past episodes, and that is that this is the season where I discover Chinese YouTube. Apparently. We talked about HTX Studio last time and a couple episodes ago, this big YouTube channel that is now doing English language stuff. And in this one, I found another one that the channel name is like Tim Pan, but I think it might also be from a company called MediaStorm, another YouTube channel.
1:26:44Casey Liss: And I looked at their channel and they like had 72 ,000 subscribers. But then I went to their Chinese channel and they have a million. So again, it seems like, you know, Chinese YouTube channel or Chinese video content creators coming over and doing English language versions for English speaking audience when they're already just massive in China. And I bring this up because MKBHD, which I think I also had the season where I discovered to mkbhd many years ago it's like who is this person i've never heard of this person anyway we've heard of him now um he has been uh you know i think he's like one of the biggest if not the biggest english language you know just american youtuber who talks about tech stuff and reviews phones and things like that and you know even coming in as late as we did to his fame we all got to see him kind of travel a little bit of the journey from like independent content creator to someone who's got a media empire and is running a company and gets invited to all the apple events and interviews tim cook and has fancy cameras and stuff like that and part of the journey has been like um watching the things that marquez gets excited about like getting the fancy red digital cameras and a robot arm so you can swoop the camera down and around the new iphone or samsung phone or whatever and make these cool intros with motion graphics i just remember how excited he was like every time they'd come up with a new video of just like the intro sort of like you know intro graphic animation and cool camera shots and everything that would lead into his video about whatever product he's talking about.
1:28:12Casey Liss: And so that's the context I'm coming from as someone who watches, you know, the biggest, you know, America, US based tech YouTube video content channels, which is for me is a very straight line continuation of me watching computer chronicles on PBS after school and everything like I've always just been craved video content for tech. and now there's tons more of it so it's great then enter these chinese youtube things we already talked about hdx studio and like to like their thing about hbm uh memory um and i figured what their other video oh the weird table thing and everything we didn't know if it was real if it was ai and i was saying the production value on the on their hbm video was amazing the tim pan media storm video same deal and i'm watching these videos and i'm like my jaw is like on the floor i'm like they have what look like extremely expensive fancy well-done motion graphics yeah everywhere oh yeah yeah like top-notch production like like marquez is like i'm excited about this new intro i made with my hojillion dollar robot arm and camera and it's like how about you do that for every shot at first i was watching and i'm like are they ai generating these because this looks like it's so expensive like i could not believe how well done it was it was it like it was clever it was like it wasn't just like flash for the sake of flash like the on-screen graphics would help explain and emphasize the point and there was just so much of it and i'm just seeing dollars raining from the sky and there was this point this point in the tim pan uh iphone duo review where he was talking about like uh you know when i forget what it was like some other new phone came out and um and the people at his company here's what the breakdown was of like did they want the new phone or whatever maybe it was the air like not a lot of people wanted the air and then he compared but like this year when we had like getting company phones for everybody how many people wanted the the duo and it was a huge percentage like that wanted the duo but they didn't just give percentages and a little of course motion graphic you know 3d rendered chart they have they gave hard numbers and the hard numbers were 140 people wanted the duo 18 wanted the 17 one of the 18 pro and 41 one of the pro max that's 198 people and so i was like okay wait a second is the company that makes this youtube video made up of 200 people is that why it looks like this like i don't quite understand the economics or whatever but here i'm here to say
1:30:38Marco Arment: maybe that's not all they do like maybe maybe it's a company it's like yeah maybe it's like a
1:30:42Casey Liss: production company yeah like maybe it's just a totally different company they do this on the side maybe he's just doing this independent he has a day job but all i'm saying is these you know chinese youtube channels that are you know making english language versions for english speaking audiences are amazing like just phenomenally like so much money is on the screen i think the videos are well done i think they cover lots of points that other people don't they do extensive testing of everything every time they need to test something it's like but of course we know somebody who has a an x-ray machine and we know somebody who has this device and we know somebody has that or whatever that just so much good information so much motion graphics well executed is is blowing my mind how good the chinese youtubers are i don't understand the economics i don't understand if each of these people also the mkbhd equivalent of china which of course is multiplied by the vast population that's there all i'm saying is please check out these videos and i will say that the the presentation style of a chinese youtuber presenting to an american audience it's different than an american style i mean for cultural reasons it's just like the style is different i i like it i think it's great but like i think a lot of the people who watch marquez eventually come to know him as a personality and can relate to him because he's just like someone you would know whereas this is a more kind of more professional more at a distance presentation and again i don't know if i can't say like i said last time i can't say this is the style of chinese tech youtube i have no idea i've watched two channels like so don't take this with a grain of salt but i'm here to say that these channels were these reviews were extremely impressive because i watched all the normal american ones well like the joanna stern nailer patel diverge i read gruber's article like and you know marquez thing right but like man htx studio and tim pan from media storm whatever the hell that is i don't even understand if it's like if that's the person or if that's the company i don't understand any of this but the reviews were really good sorry for this huge preamble but this is this is the thing that you guys were playing with phones and i was just like my eyes are just falling out of my skull watching these these uh chinese youtube things and the thing is i don't think they're ai like i read the only reason i said that is because i was like surely they don't have enough money to pay for this to be done by humans but i think it might be like like wow i don't understand it anyway uh In the reviews, there's tons of good information, some of which we've already covered.
1:33:06Casey Liss: A lot of people, like Joanna Stern most primarily, but a lot of the other channels as well, wanted to make a robot bend and close and open the thing over and over again, right? Because that's the thing you do, right? I've got one. I got a review unit. I can't destroy it because it's not mine. It's an Apple review unit. But I'm okay with making a robot rig that opens and closes it thousands of times. And then I'll see what it does. So Joanna's the rig, which looked a little shaky. But anyway, Joanna's rig opened and closed it 32 ,000 times. and i think it was uh it was either htech studio or tim pan from media storm did a thing where they of course like laser 3d scanned it at like a microscopic level to show how wavy it is at the crease and compared it to other foldable phones and they did the iphone duo when it came out of the box and scanned it and you could see how wavy it was and then they open closed it a bunch of and they scanned it again and it was way worse like just dramatically again right i don't i wouldn't say way worse way like in absolute in percentage value of deflection it was way worse like 200 300 percent now it wasn't or did we watch the same videos like 200 to 300 percent uh worse than it was when it was out of the box okay that is not the that is not what i remember but maybe i'll get you a screenshot later but here's the thing to your point casey before you get defensive which is too late we're talking like we're talking like microns so when you go from one micron to three microns it's still basically imperceptible right okay okay that makes me feel better but percentage wise like when it comes out of the box it will never be that flat again and it immediately like the car driving off the light a lot gets way way worse and it will get worse over time but it's the deflections are very small now it's always been very small on other folding phones as well but they had made the poor choices to have glossy screens and even a couple of microns of deflection on a glossy screen shows up a ton yeah which of course is why apple has the matte screen which is why no matter how bad that crease gets it will probably be fine for the entire life of the phone because the diffuse you know the the wear layer on top makes it so you don't see that telltale specular highlight of the crease you know what i mean uh and so none of them came away saying oh this is going to be really bad or whatever but they also basically came away saying that apple screen is one of the best folding phone screens but the the thing that makes it better than the competitors is their their smart decision to put matte on top of it and everyone thinks that every other phone is going to do that as well because it does hide the grease extremely well now my take on matte screens has evolved a lot over the years we talked about on this very show back in the day where when apple was making like matte like their 30 inch apple 30 inch apple cinema display with a matte thing on it and then like pc laptops are coming up with glossy screens we're all gross.
1:35:50Casey Liss: I saw a glossy screen laptop and CompUSA and it was disgusting. I can't believe people even like those screens. Those were plastic glossy screens and they looked awful because any one or two micron deflection in that plastic makes weird specular highlights. It makes everything look wavy and everything always look like it was wet and greasy and just like it didn't look nice. Then Apple made glossy screens with glass in front of them. And I was like, oh, I actually like that. Glossy versus matte, you know the trade-offs. If it's glossy, you get deep, rich blacks and better sharpness overall. But if there's any light reflecting in it, you're going to see that light exactly in the monitor.
1:36:26Casey Liss: Hell, you might even see your own face, like Samus in Metroid Prime, reflected in the monitor because it's so glossy. So, you know, so that's the trade-off. In a dark room, a glossy television or a glossy monitor will always look the best because you have no reflections and no light sources. Everything is as sharp as it can possibly be because the light is not being deflected by any wavy type of layer the blacks are completely black that's what you want in out out in the real world where you have uncontrolled lighting like with a laptop or a phone where you're walking around you can't control where you are where the lights are going matte really helps there but i will say in most of the reviews that they were showing the matte screen again this is probably worse on camera than it is in real life like any matte surface if you're coming at it on an angle and the light hits it at the right angle it whites out the whole damn screen you know because that's what matte does it diffuses light and on an angle a glossy screen if you're lucky enough not to have a direct reflection in the middle of your image making it impossible to see it can you can still get like blacks or whatever but the contrast gets annihilated at various angles with a matte screen and that's a trade-off and that's the right trade-off for a folding phone both because of the crease and also because unlike even in a laptop you really have an uncontrolled lighting condition because you're holding it in your hand like at least with a laptop in a cafe even if you have a glossy screen you can kind of like bend it and position yourself with the table so that it's not so bad but when you're holding a phone who knows where the lights are coming from as you walk down the street and are jostling around or whatever so mad is the way to go there but be aware that there are definitely trade-offs related to the madness um another fun thing i saw in a review was one of them did like a the little thing where you put like a little magnet sheet on on the back of it the magsafe ring on the back of the uh duo has a little i think it's a little weird magnet in the center of the circle and nobody knows what that's for i figured they'll discover it eventually once they start cracking the thing open or maybe it's not a magnet or whatever but i don't think the other phones have that so that's a little bit mysterious also the magnet's a little bit weaker on the uh the duo than there's another phones probably because it's thinner um i don't see what other tidbits were in there what do you what tidbits do you remember from the reviews that you want i mean certainly like so first of all i love
1:38:40Marco Arment: these channels that had they had like you know cat scanners and x-rays ultra because they can't
1:38:46Casey Liss: break it open because it's it's apple's review units right once they apple get their own phones
1:38:50Marco Arment: they'll be you know yeah yeah apple apple prohibits them from disassembling it so they're like okay
1:38:54Casey Liss: we'll just x-ray our way and and open and close it 32 000 times right okay with that and by the way on that on that topic when uh when joanna stern did open and close it 32 000 times no measurable or perceptual difference in the hinge yeah like the hinge seems like a remarkably
1:39:11Marco Arment: engineered part of this like it and i liked how i forget but one of the chinese youtubers um broke down like the different parts of the hinge from having cat scanned it in a 3d rendered graphic yeah it is amazing like it like this is like you know the production quality of apple's videos and they like you know zoom around they're virtually rendered and they make the product they couldn't even open this one yeah it's like it's incredible how it works with like you know different springs and cams to get like the different parts of the motion like wow um yeah so that anyway going back to the the less impressive stuff um yeah the magnet strength wasn't as strong um in particular the thermals of the iphone duo seem not amazing it everyone dlt it's got the hot side and the cold
1:39:54John Siracusa: side yeah well you know everyone has a great that's a great reference but i feel like that was consistent ish i feel the same with battery life i feel like more than half of the reviewers said the battery life was trash but not everyone did i thought most of the reviewers said the battery
1:40:11Marco Arment: life was better than expected yeah most of them it seems like the battery life is actually pretty decent um but the the like thermal throttling is a thing not as bad as the iphone air but not nearly
1:40:23Casey Liss: as good as the iphone pro yeah so on the battery life thing it's tricky because i don't think most of the reviewers even maybe even the chinese ones have really standardized across all of them to decide what is a representative test of a folding phone because you have to decide how much is it with screen open how much is it with screen closed because obviously with screen open you're lighting up a lot more pixels and that can really affect battery life most of the reviewers who lived with the phone said battery life was fine like and i think it's because when you're living with the phone like you just physically can't have it open all the time like it's like you're gonna spend some portion of the time with its clothes especially if you're putting it into a bag or whatever um we'll see if that degrades over time but that's the battery life up from the reviews i was pleasantly surprised that most of them thought it was pretty good now if you do a test where you put it on a stand and you'll have it open the whole time yeah it's gonna do worse with the giant screen open but well we'll see how that fares like it's so hard to tell because it's like okay when you have this phone how often are you going to use it yeah unfolded and you could have wildly different battery life just based on how much time you spend with the big screen lit up versus the small screen or god forbid both screens and as a as a i keep calling her i justine has what's what i don't even know her last name is anyway it's aric i think something like that as i justine pointed out when she reviews these things she's like we can't really give you a fair battery assessment because when we make these videos we have the things on and running like at full blast like with the cameras running like all the time so it's not it's not representative if you're not a content creator making a review of the phone like your usage won't be the same as hers but she did say that during that it still seemed pretty good all things considered and the heat issue most of the people did benchmarks and tons of these channels do great benchmarks said that like if you're just testing the cpu it matches the speed in most benchmarks of the 18 pro and the 18 pro max but the second you test anything having to do with the gpu thermal throttling gets you on the duo which makes some sense because it's like the gpu does tend to produce more heat it's just physically bigger on the on the soc than the other stuff and plus obviously the cpu is also running when the gpu is running so for non-gaming non-gpu related things it seems like Like it's not thermal throttling that badly, but it is for the, and to your point, Margaret, I think that is actually better than the air because I think the air thermal throttles like no matter what part of the chip you use.
1:42:48Casey Liss: Yeah. Whereas this one manages not to. And yeah, the hot side and cold side is because the SOC is on one side and that's the hot side and that's fine. Like it's kind of a shame they didn't magic some way to spread the heat from the hot side to the cold side, but the hinge is kind of in the way and that's kind of an important complicated part. So yeah, the vapor changer is entirely on the hot side and it is very small vapor chamber, not nearly as big as the one on the 18 pro again from the x-rays. So I think they did as good a job as you could imagine with, uh, the, the physical aspect of this.
1:43:23Casey Liss: Uh, but yeah, and on the rest of the reviews, I mean, I think I get to the, to the credit of the Chinese YouTube channels. They also went into all this stuff. They did everything. They did the tech specs. They did the benchmarking. And they also did like the day-to-day life things. But some of our more familiar reviewers did an even better job of this, which is like talking about what it's like to live with. Because they know because they've had it for like a week and a half or whatever. How hard is it to find the buttons? How annoying is it not to have FaceTime? All the different weird orientations.
1:43:50Casey Liss: The case situation, which is really weird. Like Apple's case requires sticky adhesive to stay on because there's no way for it to actually grip the thing without literal sticky adhesive. you have to like peel off this little thing and then stick the the apple's case to it very strange times in in the case world i know lots of third-party cases have been like that sometimes for past phones but really weird for an apple case to do that just the physical reality of living with it of a short squat phone that's hard to reach uh and the lack of face id and not knowing where the touch id button is and having the volume buttons be in a weird place and having to get accustomed to like rotating it to what you think is the upside down position because that's the actually the better way to hold it where your fingers aren't blocking the camera uh even though it looks like it should be the other way based on where the opening in the case is just lots of weird stuff like that and depending on the reviewer they were either like like kind of like you are marco it's like well this is a trade-off and here are the trades-offs versus a more like gruber's approach which is like this is not a good phone for the way i use phones and so i don't like it uh, waking me up when they have face ID.
1:44:55Yeah.
1:44:55John Siracusa: I think you covered pretty much everything. Um, obviously you and I got slightly different vibes from this, but I've had a very busy couple of days. And so maybe, uh, maybe you're right and I'm wrong. Uh, but anyways, um, no, I think you covered it all pretty well. And I think that's a pretty good executive summary. I mean, obviously I'm going, I'm going to live with mine for at the bare minimum, you know, 13 days I sitting here now, I don't plan to return it. And I presume I will keep it as a device for, you know, app development but i'm genuinely curious if i'm going to switch back to my 17 pro or what i'm
1:45:28Casey Liss: going to end up doing but we'll see yeah when i when i was watching these videos i was thinking about youtube and i'm like based on these videos it seems like a guaranteed slam dunk that like casey's going to return his phone and marco is not going to use it as his main phone but coming hearing the impression you guys had actually touching and using the phone maybe that's not true like it just it seems like the reviewers are crankier than normal about this phone and i guess maybe it's just because like after like 20 something or you know almost 20 years of like iphones being fairly straightforward rectangles that the foldable phone has just thrown them all for a loop and because they're not they they're not as interested in the thing they get for trading off that other stuff it to them it's just like well i see all the things that i'm losing and the thing that i gain is not that important to me so i'm gonna ding this phone it's almost it was kind of like glad that tech reviewers have essentially not fallen into the same trap as game reviewers used to remember when game reviewers used to give like numeric scores from one to ten they still kind of do remember that like the metacritic score like what is the metacritic score for this game they find all the one ten reviews from all the big gaming websites back when there used to be a lot of big gaming websites and they would average them and say here's the metacritic score it's a 7.2 out of 10 um i do wonder what the duo would have gotten out of 10 from these from these reviews because boy there was a lot of people who were upset about how awkward and weird it was to use just day to day even if they did rave about the big inner screen and the matte screen and all the stuff they loved about it they just couldn't help saying but yeah like it's it's making it not fun for me to use a phone anymore like i can't use it it doesn't work my hands don't know how to work it like nila tried to spin it into like it's fun to come up with new moves to do with your phone like like i don't know like rubik's cube type of moves like it's kind of fun to come up with new physical moves but still he was kind of like but it would be better if i could just use it and not have to do all those gymnastics so that's that's that's like a week and a half of use so i'm you know i think i think this is a great like like they do in car reviews they should have a long-term test where yeah here's your review but we're going to keep it and drive it for 40 000 miles and see what we think about it then i would watch for that in a couple of months for like the revisiting the iphone duo after living with it who abandoned it who lived with it and found that they really love the advantages they get despite the disadvantages.
1:47:48Casey Liss: And then, yeah, we've already got rumors about, well, maybe Face ID will be in the iPhone Duo 2. We'll cover that in a future show.
1:47:54Marco Arment: Yeah, and to be clear, that's not rumored. It's just hoped for. No, there was a new rumor.
1:48:01John Siracusa: Oh, really?
1:48:02Marco Arment: German has already got his iPhone Duo 2 rumors, and one of them is Face ID. Of course. yeah and I think you know the themes for almost all the reviews like they all pretty much agree on the broad themes so you know watch them if you want if you need help with your buying decision watch them and see if see what appeals to you and what doesn't the summary of it's basically a folded in half iPad mini in your pocket I think is a pretty good summary how does that sound to you are you somebody who loves the iPad already? Have you carried around an iPad mini a lot before? Or have you wanted to? Have you ever used an iPad mini?
1:48:41Marco Arment: Does that sound good to you? Does that sound amazing enough to you to give up things like face ID, easy one-handed operation, the best cameras? Maybe not, but maybe. I think for me, I've never been that much of an iPad power user. or even many times that much of an iPad user, period. So it's a bit of a, you know, I'm not super excited about the iPad-ness of it. But in another way, like, and I think Gruber covered this well, it seems almost like a reset of the idea of an iPad. It's like, what if the iPad never existed and we just made phones bigger today for the first time? and in many ways i think it gets things more right than the ipad especially in the area of multitasking i've been working on an ipad a lot these last couple weeks we'll get to shortly ipad multitasking still doesn't make any sense to me and like at least now i know how to undo what i do usually but like i am accidentally invoking ipad multitasking all the time it gets in my way constantly.
1:49:56Marco Arment: It almost never is doing what I want it to do. When I played with the duos, I figured it out instantly. And it was totally fine. It was rock solid. My fingers kind of already knew it just because it's based on the swipe up home indicator thing. Without ever having been taught it, I just instantly figured it out. And it just did what it felt like it should do. Yeah, it's more limited than iPad multitasking. You can only have two apps. Like you can't do arbitrary Windows and everything. But actually, I think that's fine. And I think for almost everyone who uses iPads, that's a better idea than the kind of baby Mac that they've implemented on iPads now.
1:50:40Casey Liss: well i mean so the thing i would have added to grubber's uh section where he was talking about that is uh the big advantage that that software stack has on the duo is the thing bends in half and because the phone bends in half when you say well there's a left half and a right half it's like well duh physically speaking there is a left half and a right half it's not a manufactured thing of software if you bought a 13 inch ipad and they only let you split the screen 50 percent and it didn't bend in half, you'd be like, what the hell? Does it have this giant screen? You're telling me I can only have two things side by side.
1:51:14Casey Liss: Why can't I have a third? Why can't I have slide over? Why can't I have a little windows, blah, blah, blah. So yeah, it is a more, it is a more limited constrained problem space and it is constrained for a reason that everybody can see it bends in half. Now, not to discredit them, they did an amazing job with that multitasking. Like the way it works is great and is a great fit for the hardware. And arguably the iPad did not do a great job of fitting their hardware, but you can't use the same solution for a 13 inch iPad as you can for the Duo. So I wouldn't say, let's just bring this over to the iPad.
1:51:41Casey Liss: I'm not saying the iPad is perfect or even good, but it's a different problem area. So I think the Duo team knocked it out of the park. And that's the final topic on this quickly. On software, a lot of people were asking, we were talking about the developer story. We were like, Apple doesn't care. What does Apple care if apps aren't ready? They'll just put the thing out. It'll be a year. And then when the year is over, apps will have updated, third-party apps will have updated for the Duo. And Apple's fine with it. This first year doesn't count. What does Apple even care? These reviews are why I care.
1:52:09Casey Liss: they care every single review dinged not just third-party apps but apple itself for buggy weird ass things like joanna stern said like i couldn't send the message because the keyboard was covering the send key it rotated into a weird position and things were odd every review totally slammed the fact that if you have a non-updated app it looks like garbage on the duo every review said this this is why apple cares they don't want reviewers to send spend a whole section telling you about your apps are going to suck on the duo and again it's day zero like it's it's even some of them did say in the week and a half i was reviewing this my third-party apps were slowly rolling out in the store and things got better so that's fine this is not the story that apple wants to see for their new device they want it to all be all superlatives and nothing bad and every review slammed the hard the software support and we all understand why it's there and yes it will get better as third-party apps come out and most reviews said that but man does apple not want that section of their interview.
1:53:05Casey Liss: Man, do they not want a section of review where you show on video an iPhone-sized rectangle in the center of that gigantic, beautiful inner screen? Every review did that. And every time I saw it, I'm like, oh, someone at Apple is gritting their teeth right now. Because that is not how they want this product to be shown. But it is the current reality of this product.
1:53:23John Siracusa: And also, I really don't want to do this whole dance again, because I'm pretty sure we already talked about this. But if Apple wanted this story to be better, Apple could have made this story better. They could have disclosed this internally earlier so that their apps would be optimized earlier. They could have done more labs in more places.
1:53:47Casey Liss: They could ship it two months later and miss the holiday season?
1:53:50John Siracusa: They could ship it later.
1:53:51Casey Liss: Yeah, when there's more stock maybe for everybody.
1:53:53John Siracusa: I 100 % understand, well, to the best anyone can from outside, how and why they landed where they did. but if the software story isn't great because third-party devs order it at 8 0 5 in the morning and don't get it for a month and a half that's or a month or two weeks or whatever it doesn't really matter that's apple's choice that's apple's fault and if they want third-party developers to do what they can to make their apps better on this device then they they ship 27.1 beta or whatever it was for Xcode, you know, Xcode for 27.1, they ship that immediately. If they want us to make good apps, they don't take away all the system apps in the simulator.
1:54:38John Siracusa: They leave them as stuff for us to look at, to crib. This is all self-owns with regards to software, with regards to software. It's all self-owns.
1:54:47Casey Liss: And on the hardware front, by the way, that's the thing that none of us know right now, and maybe some will be able to reverse out of the next earnings call. But the question is um when you have to attribute the current uh you know february now february ship date how much of it is because demand was high and how much of it is because they're having trouble building these obviously both of those factors are in fact because i think demand was high and also there have just been endless stories about they're having difficulty manufacturing this so what are the ratios like is there any world in which they could have had enough supply or is this that like how what it comes down to is how many how many duos do you think they sold Obviously, they sold everyone they could make.
1:55:24Casey Liss: How many could they make? And this is just a question that currently only Apple knows. It doesn't matter. Practically speaking, you just can't get one until February. And it clearly is a very popular product. And as Marco pointed out, they did not have this problem with the Vision Pro, which was also a complicated, difficult product to manufacture. So clearly, demand is very high for this. But it also seems to me that their supply is lower than usual for a launch of a phone because Apple usually doesn't miss demand predictions this badly unless they literally can't make any more phones and with the duo i believe that's probably the case yeah but i mean
1:55:57John Siracusa: i'm super excited i really really am i think even if i decide you know not my carry device just not for me even if that's the conclusion i come to i think this is such a fun and interesting and kind of wild device and i'm so glad that apple is shooting their shot like i said earlier yeah
1:56:16Marco Arment: And also, we are on the verge of potentially, according to the rumors, having a new iPad mini be released. And that's very interesting because we just got finished talking about how the iPhone Duo is basically a substantially better iPad mini. And having now held the Duo and used the Duo, I'm like, I wish the mini was more like this. and you kind of think like could it be the ipad mini is not gonna be too grand though no but but like could the ipad mini be significantly thinner lighter smaller and have almost the same size screen as it does now with an oled screen it's coming with yeah with oled like it's like that's actually i'm i'm very interested all of a sudden like imagine if it has nanotexture oh my i did think about that like a a thinner lighter nanotexture oled ipad mini and face id someone
1:57:13Casey Liss: in the chat room said, let's not get crazy.
1:57:15Marco Arment: No, it still has Touchdown ID probably, but still, that would be amazing. I would love that. Fingers crossed for next week, I guess, but that sure would be cool.
1:57:26Casey Liss: Yeah, speaking of that, we should squeeze that in before we go.
1:57:29John Siracusa: Yeah, so as we record, it's Thursday, October, what is the time? 22nd, and there has been announced a Pro Intel event on the 28th of October. If we didn't have so many other things to talk about tonight, we would definitely cover this more. I apologize. We don't have more time for it. But suffice to say, that is happening, I believe, Wednesday the 28th. So hypothetically, we will be talking about it that night, or at least recording that night. And we will post whenever Marco gets to it. But we know it's a thing. I'm sorry, we didn't have a chance to talk about it. But we are not invited and we will cover it from afar.
1:58:06Casey Liss: Yeah. And quickly, the rumored devices are the touchscreen 14 and 16 inch macbook pro with oled displays um the new ipad mini with an oled uh new iMac with an m6 uh 14 inch macbook pro models with the m6 chip uh yeah that's there's a bunch of rumor products that this is not a surprise event we all expect it to be coming that's what we're looking forward to will be a little bit of a scramble uh we'll also get to find out whether they call these things the ultras everyone is saying is because the event tagline says pro and tell that they're not going to be called ultras but they're not going to spoil the name of it in the invitation So we'll see you next week.
1:58:40Marco Arment: All right. Thanks to our sponsors this episode, ZocDoc and Quince. And thanks to our members who support us directly. You can join us at ATP.fm slash join. One of the many perks of membership is ATP Overtime, our weekly bonus topic. By the way, you also get a discount on those merch things we mentioned earlier from the ATP store if you're a member. But ATP Overtime is our weekly bonus topic. This week on Overtime, we're going to be talking about the people holding up the internet. Join on to listen at ATP.fm slash join. Thanks, everybody, and we'll talk to you next week.
1:59:38Casey Liss: .fm And if you're into Mastodon
1:59:42Marco Arment: You can follow them At C-A-S-E-Y-L-I-S-S So that's Casey Liss M-A-R-C-O-A-R-M-E-N-T Marco Arment S-I-R-A-C USA Syracuse It's accidental Accidental They didn't mean to Accidental
2:00:13Marco Arment: As we are speaking here, let me click on this button, click on this button, and boom, submitted to the App Store. I love a live either release or submission. Love it. That's a release, right? Well, no, submitting to the App Store is not a release.
2:00:30Casey Liss: Oh, I thought you had a pending developer release.
2:00:32Marco Arment: Oh, no, I wish.
2:00:34Casey Liss: Well, submitting to the App Store means nothing. You could be waiting a week.
2:00:37Marco Arment: Waiting for review. To nobody's surprise, when the iPhone Duo was announced and when they announced Apple Pencil support, I had to do it. I just had to. So I've just submitted to the App Store. Remarkable. It's not called that.
2:00:58Casey Liss: But it should have been.
2:00:59Marco Arment: No. All right. So we talked on a member special, what, maybe a year ago or maybe following the theme of John's talk me out of it for an app idea that he had once. I said maybe talk me into it or talk me out of it for an app idea that I had. I want an iPad, an Apple Pencil version of note taking in the style of a remarkable e-ink tablet. this was you know after i had done like my journey through remarkables and super notes and i had i had decided i really liked the remarkable tablet um but of course because i'm me i wanted my own version i wanted to i wanted custom stuff because i wanted ultimately i wanted some features that remarkable i thought would never add but they still haven't um that especially some stuff from super note that i really liked um in some of the organizational features that Super Note had, but I didn't like other parts of Super Note.
2:02:00Marco Arment: So it was a whole thing. And ultimately, these were devices that I still, to this day, don't regularly carry around because they're just, you know, they're these big iPad sized note taking devices. And I don't always have that with me. But when Apple said pencil support for the Duo, I was like, that's interesting. When I was thinking about making this app. I actually wrote a prototype, Apple Pencil note-taking ink engine. I didn't want to use Pencil Kit because Pencil Kit has a bunch of automatic behaviors that are very difficult or impossible to disable. And I found myself hacking around it so much, trying to just customize it and disable certain built-in things so I could do my own things.
2:02:44Marco Arment: At some point, it was like, I'm just going to write my own. So this was all, I ended up writing my own ink engine. And I loved how it wrote. I think it writes better than anything else on the iPad that is not PencilKit. And in some ways, I think it's better than PencilKit. I was very, very happy with this ink engine. But an ink engine is not an app. There's a lot of other stuff that goes around an app that you need to make to make it compelling. And I was like, you know, I don't use my iPad very much. I probably shouldn't make an iPad app. When I got the Duo development SDK, I, at first, you know, first thing I did was fix Unforgettable for the Duo.
2:03:21Marco Arment: because it was the easiest. And that kind of got me going. And I did Overcast with the momentum that I had from that. It was great. And those updates are in the store. And it's wonderful. I'm very happy with how those turned out. I think Overcast will need some more substantial, you know, redesign work at some point. But again, I have to be very careful how I do that. And that's going to be a bigger job with a lot more like iteration and testing and betas and stuff like that. And that's not something that was going to happen in a few weeks. But then I thought, hmm, I wonder, this seems like a good opportunity.
2:03:57I don't use an iPad that often, but if I had an iPhone Duo, it would be in my pocket all the time.
2:04:04Marco Arment: And when I made the 3D model of it, I printed the 3D model, and I was like, hmm, this is really close in size to a Field Notes notebook. And people carry those in their pockets and little pens all the time. Lots of people do that. So I wonder if I could make this app into kind of like a Field Notes style, like a notebook app for the iPhone Duo. Wouldn't that be fun? I have a few weeks before it comes out. Let's see if I can do it. and I think I did it. The app is called Fineliner. It is named after the type of pen that it represents. It is submitted to the App Store. I expect, because it is an app for iPhone Duo, I expect it to go through probably somewhat quickly.
2:04:53Marco Arment: I would guess that probably by the end of the weekend, it's probably in the App Store. But again, I could be wrong. Who knows? It's the first submission. So I don't know. If it gets rejected, that could add to things. You know how it goes. But it could be out when this episode's published, for all I know. If it comes out in the next 18 hours, maybe. Who knows?
2:05:17John Siracusa: So at one point, Marco had stepped away when we were at the iPhone creator showcase and whipped out his computer for some reason. And I was like, what is going on? And he was talking to, I thought, an Apple person. And I was very confused. And I was done with the conversation I was having and I go walk toward, you know, Marco and whoever the Apple person was. And in a not mean way, Marco goes, no, no, no, no, no, no. You don't know what this is. It was the very polite, very kind, you need to buzz off. This is not for you, which he's talking to Apple people. Fair enough. I don't know what's going on.
2:05:54John Siracusa: But at some point, I think you had said to me something along the lines of, I've got something new and you don't know about it and I'm going to save it for the show. Yes. Or something along those lines. And so then at lunch, I think maybe I was giving you puppy dog eyes accidentally because I don't remember begging to see it or anything like that. But one way or another, you said, all right, here, let me show you what I've got. Marco hands me his iPad mini, hands me a pencil. I personally don't want to spoil the onboarding of this app. Maybe Marco will spoil it. That's up to him. But the onboarding of this app is unlike any other app I've seen.
2:06:33John Siracusa: And it took me a minute, probably longer than it should have, but that's not Marco's fault. That's my fault. It took me a minute to understand what was happening. Let's just say, I thought I was doing a tutorial and then I realized, oh, oh, this is so much more than that. And all I will say, and I'd like to hear John's two cents as well. All I will say is, in the same vein, as we were talking about, you know what? Even if the Duo sucks, it's fun. It's fun and different and dare I say whimsical. I don't know if Fineliner will have a place in my life or not. I really, truly don't. But I'll be darned if the onboarding alone isn't fun and whimsical and different.
2:07:21John Siracusa: And I think even if you have no interest in owning an iPhone Duo, if you are into Apple stuff, if you listen to this show and if you have someone in your life that has one or an Apple store near enough that it's not burdensome to go, you need to go and play with the Duo for a little bit. It's worth a little bit of your time to just mess around with it. Similarly, even if you don't feel like you need a note-taking app for your Duo or for your iPad or what have you, you need to try the onboarding experience of this app because it is so cool and so fun and so like anything else. so unlike, excuse me, anything else I've ever seen.
2:08:00John Siracusa: And it's one of those things where the second you see it, you get very angry that it was not you that came up with the idea. So again, I would like to hear John's perspective because, you know, while Marco and I were at lunch at John's of Bleeker, you know, that's when I saw it and I whizzed through it only to realize I made a grievous mistake. I should have really taken my time and let that sink in. But Mr. Syracuse, what was your impression? And if you'll permit it, I would love it if you could be vague about the specifics of what we're talking about.
2:08:28Casey Liss: No, I'm going to spoil it. People are going to have to either pause the show or skip over this portion. Be like, I can't talk about it without spoiling it.
2:08:34John Siracusa: Oh, John, come on. You can do it.
2:08:36Casey Liss: You can do it. People, look, we do this all the time in Rectifs. If you don't want to be spoiled on Marco's app, pause the program now, go download it from the App Store and try it yourself and then come back to the show. The show will be here when you need it.
2:08:46Marco Arment: I would say don't look past the first screenshot either.
2:08:49John Siracusa: Right. Well, fine. I would genuinely recommend, truly, in the same way, I would say pull over and go to atp.fm slash store. Pause the show. Pause the show and go check it out. Truly, it will be so much more fun for you if you go in cold.
2:09:06Casey Liss: We'll put a link to the app in the show notes. Whenever the app comes out, we will put it in the show. Hopefully it won't come out a month from now, but we will put a link in these show notes. I mean, I can put a link in now. It just won't work. Yeah, yeah, I guess. Yeah, we can just, yeah, give Casey the URL and he'll put it in. You can just click on it and have it not go anywhere. All right. So I got this app because Marco posted it to a Slack that we're in the test flight link to it and i immediately installed it and i could tell what it was from like the little preview and the icon or whatever like oh he made remarkable isn't that nice and i launched the app and i immediately knew exactly what he was doing when i saw that thing and you know what i look for next i looked immediately to say did he also include a button that says i don't want to do this just skip through to the rest of it and true to form like steve jobs not putting arrow keys on the original macintosh keyboard there is no such button at least until later through the onboarding process sure there is you just didn't scroll down i i i i looked for it on the initial screen it is there eventually but i didn't see it on the very first screen that you see um and yeah so what he has you do it's a it's a pen and ink you know whatever like use apple pencil to to you know you launch a notebook by the way can i just slap you right
2:10:22Marco Arment: here for a moment please for the love of god don't try this on a regular iphone please
2:10:30Casey Liss: you're like christopher nolan asking people not to watch his movies on the back of an airplane
2:10:33Marco Arment: it's using trying to use a like a a drawing note-taking app on an iphone with your finger is terrible i and i have bought every stylus that you can buy to try to test is there anything that is good for the iPhone. No, there is not. The iPhone Duo, yes. And any iPad, yes. Please test this with an Apple Pencil or some equivalent stylus that uses the Apple Pencil APIs on an iPad. Please. Anyway, go on.
2:11:05Casey Liss: Yeah. So it says, hey, draw yourself. And it even says, look, you can put two dots for eyes and a smile. You know how to draw yourself, draw yourself. And so you're like, all right i mean the reason i knew this is what it was going to be was because my brain did the math and it's like why is this app asking me to draw myself it's not teaching me how to draw with a pencil everybody knows how the pencil works you put it on the screen and it draws it's not it's a familiar device or whatever it's clearly going to use what i draw for something and what is it going to use it for well it's probably going to make it some part of the ui and so you draw yourself and then the next screen has you drawing a back button an undo arrow and like if you didn't get it on the first screen you get it on the second screen you're like oh i'm drawing the ui for the app i'm going to use this ui is going to have buttons like again like procreator whatever that little undo arrow the the left chevron that takes you back in the navigation stack uh the pen tool the eraser tool i'm going to draw them but you know you can just trace over the helpful vague like gray outlines that marco provides or you can draw whatever the hell you want because nothing's stopping you from drawing anything you want these little things you are drawing the user interface on during the onboarding at a certain point it says do you want to keep drawing these things you just want to get to the app and there's like a draw it for me later thing and you can import and export these and i don't know if there's any kind of cloud sharing or whatever but the point is you are essentially personalizing your app in the same way you would personalize a paper notebook by you writing the date and your handwriting at the top or whatever system you have for like you know putting titles on pages or bullet journaling or i don't know all this but i do know that when you open up your own notebook your handwriting is all over that it's not just the content that has your handwriting it's everything it's the metadata it's the structure it's whatever and so using this app after you have drawn the ui when you're using it you see essentially your artwork your handwriting your self-drawn face is the account button thing or whatever that's the interface to this application with a few exceptions and some screenshots i'm going to send marco that i think needs some more work but anyway that's that's the the the conceit of this thing and it is adorable and it is whimsical and people are going to love it and it is going to be like there's no way not to you know again you spoil it in the first screenshot everything every review is going to start with this because how can you not it's an incredibly good idea but also setting aside like oh give me the idea for onboarding or whatever just the experience of using the app where you're constantly seeing essentially your work and i know it's like well i drew a less than sign how is that my work you'll be surprised how much you could recognize your own scribbles because you're used to seeing your own scribbles right like you it makes it feel more like home for yourself even if you're not good at drawing even if you just trace them like i felt like i i could look especially since i didn't draw all of them because i just wanted to get to the app the ones that i didn't draw were clearly not drawn by me now it's granted they're probably neater than what i would have drawn as well but like you could see like my personality not my personality so it's it's a very clever long-term idea to give the app a feeling that an app with a standard ui is not going to have
2:14:16Marco Arment: thank you very much i'm you you got it like you absolutely got it um i i'm really curious to see the picture you drew yourself please share that um oh i was just rushing through it because i
2:14:27Casey Liss: knew it was going i was like i gotta see this i gotta see this this is the screens that you need to do something about i don't know what's going on here but it's wacky wait the screen oh i just put it in slack oh you're doing it on a phone for god's sake i mean it runs on a phone so you have to make the screen look like something and that's nothing oh geez yeah all right the
2:14:45Marco Arment: setting screen doesn't look good on a phone well no one nobody should be using this like people
2:14:49Casey Liss: are gonna run this on a phone there's my face isn't it great that you could have done better than that i was rushing through it he got the test flight like an hour before the show do it on an iPad for God's sake. I do have an iPad and a pencil. I know. I'll just don't. And I will say that I'm not really in the market for this kind of app, but I will definitely try it on my iPad to give it a fair shot.
2:15:09Marco Arment: I even like when I was making the screenshots, I only put one screenshot for the regular iPhone because the problem is you can't in the app store. You can't omit it. Yeah. So you can't ship to the app store an app that is only available for iPads and iPhone Duos. If you include the iPhone Duo, it has to work on every iPhone. And so you cannot rule them out. You cannot say, like, you know, don't even let people install it on a regular iPhone. So I had to ship it on the iPhone, and it's bad. Anyway, yeah, so the idea that I had, like, when I use Remarkable, I kind of built this whole system of, like, I made this custom PDF with, like, tappable regions because I was trying to simulate links between different sections.
2:15:56Marco Arment: so I can kind of have my own little UI in my notes. And links are a feature of the Super Notebooks. That's like one of the key features that Remarkable seems like they will never add. But I loved my ability to kind of make my own little custom UI with my own crappily drawn icons on my Remarkable. And so that's what I've made the app to replicate. It was like, what if I did a good version of that for iOS devices? and that's what it is. It is a note taking app. You can doodle or draw but it's not really intended for illustration. I'm not doing realistic brush and ink simulations. Everything works like a fineliner pen.
2:16:42Marco Arment: It's just like you have fixed width markers basically. That's it. There's no pressure sensitivity, no tilt sensitivity. You are drawing a very like digital looking art style um but it's all backed by solid tech so first of all of course everything is cloud synced it's all on iCloud everything you know john you you asked if your
2:17:06Casey Liss: stuff's synced yes of course it syncs i was thinking is there iCloud based artwork sharing
2:17:11Marco Arment: with other users uh you can collaborate on notebooks you can invite people to your notebook
2:17:15Casey Liss: you can work on them together i meant the glyphs for the controls like undo redo like can you share sets of those with other people i know there's like an import and export but i was wondering if there was like a cloud-based marketplace i probably not because then you just have people drawing penises that's yeah i'm not going to do that that's always the user-generated drawing content uh destination very rapid very rapid destination within three microseconds the entire ui is filled with penises yeah and by the way i just posted my ui in the uh that's pretty good casey said that's better than what he did i drew those with my finger on my phone it's still better
2:17:47Marco Arment: than what i did to be fair on the phone i do make the canvases a lot larger just to make it just to give you a fighting chance um but that's still that john that's pretty good for a phone i will give you that um you you have always been the best artist of the three of us as i do try to
2:17:59Casey Liss: trace my finger of his little eyes just if you're afraid of this you're like i can't draw ui why you was selling me an app it doesn't have a ui like i swear to you you can just simply trace over the outlines he gave you with a pencil and it will look fine and it will still have your personality so don't worry don't like oh i can't buy that app because i'm not a good artist you do not need to
2:18:15Marco Arment: be a good artist to make this ui and think i'm not a good artist like and that's so i i kind of like when the drawings are a little bit sheet like i think it looks fun that way to have something
2:18:27Casey Liss: that's just like a little sheet yeah people make uis intentionally looking like like good designers make uis intentionally looking that way so it looks handmade and handwritten but now this is
2:18:36Marco Arment: the real thing you're making it yourself yeah exactly um and i had fun with making this entirely like the entire ui is custom there's no stock component anywhere in this there's no liquid glass. There's no like system bars or anything. There's no system sheets. There's no. It's like
2:18:52Casey Liss: a game in that way. Like no, no OS UI.
2:18:55Marco Arment: Yeah. Like it, it looks like a UI made of pen and paper. And also, uh, because, so because it's very, you know, everything again, very digital, um, it's all vector based. You can zoom in all the way. Everything stays sharp. You can scale and rotate things. Everything is fine. You can export as SVG or PDF. In addition to images, everything is vector it also has dark mode the entire app including your notes flips to dark mode because the colors are semantic colors so there's like you know like the the black pen just becomes nearly white in dark mode and so and you know all the colors have dark mode variants on them so that you can actually like you know switch to that and have dark mode notes so like It's a very fun hybrid of the analog world and the digital world.
2:19:46Marco Arment: I have a fun page turn animation that I stole from iBooks. When I was bragging weeks ago about how I had AI make me a metal shader, that's what that was for, to try to get that right. And it took, to be clear, AI wrote the first version of the shader. But wow, did it need a lot of tweaking and a lot of behavioral and appearance changes to be good. This is the design is not AI's forte, let's say. But writing metal shaders, it's pretty good at and I'm pretty bad at. So that worked out well. But the entire app is it's meant to be fun. But also, I think the tech behind it is also good. so I have the organizational features that that I wanted I have custom headings custom links to whatever you want you can use you headings and links great organizational features the headings show up in your handwriting wherever possible I try to show things in your handwriting John didn't mention but there's also you you don't have to do this but if you take the time to draw every letter you can also have a custom font in the app and have all the text in the app show up in your handwriting by making a custom font and you can even export that font as a ttf and you and you can use it on your mac you can't use it on the ipad for technical reasons but it's just fun and on the iphone duo i do a lot of fun things with like the closing and opening simulation and stuff like that check it out um if it's for you awesome if it's not for you cool i that's fine it's not going to be for everybody.
2:21:27Marco Arment: And I'm kind of making this like, this is the kind of app I make. Same thing with Unforgetful. Unforgetful is a very narrowly targeted app. It's very opinionated, and it's either really for you or really not for you. Fineliner is the same kind of thing. Fineliner is a very specific kind of app, and it's either going to land well with you or it's not. I think there's a lot of little fun and delight and power in there. If you don't take handwritten notes, this might not get you to start. If you just want something to doodle some stuff in, go for it. The app is mostly free. So I'm doing a bit of business model experimentation here too.
2:22:11Marco Arment: Almost all the features in it are free. The only thing that charges money is it starts out with three pen widths and three colors of ink. and you can buy, oh, and three page templates, blank and then lines and wider lined. And you can buy additional colors, pen widths and templates. Most of them come in a deluxe pack that you can get for, I think it's 12 bucks to start. And those are one-time purchases. There's no subscriptions in this app. I'm kind of taking a gamble with that. I don't know if that's going to work. I don't know if I'm going to stick with that long-term, but I think it might. And so I'm going to give it a shot.
2:22:55Marco Arment: But all that is to say, like, you can use the app for free. And there's like unlimited notebooks, unlimited pages. Use all the tools in the app, like all the headings and links and all that stuff. That's all free. Like all of that. The only thing you're paying for is if you want different colors, page backgrounds and pen widths. That's it. So give it a shot. See if it works for you. If not, it's at least fun to play around with for a little while.
2:23:17John Siracusa: Yes, very much so. So you absolutely, if you have an iPad in your life and an Apple Pencil or an iPhone Duo with the appropriate Apple Pencil for that, you absolutely need to try this. It's not going to cost anything but your time. If you only have an iPhone, like, you know, when John was trying to just run through it quick before we recorded, I still think it's worth your time to try. But yeah, it's not going to be the world's best experience. You know, a second ago, you said, these are the apps I want to make. And it's funny, my gut reaction, maybe nobody else will see it the way I do. But I view myself as having made a bunch of silly toy apps and then finally getting into something real with CallSheet.
2:23:55John Siracusa: And so you could say I had a bunch of silly toy apps and then I finally got my own Overcast. And now you've had your own Overcast and you're moving into silly toy apps. And so we're on the opposite journey. Or at least that's the way it looks to me anyway.
2:24:09Casey Liss: I just wrote my announcement blog post for our new app, which is not coming out anytime soon. But anyway, I'm pre-writing the – there's like you're pre-writing the obituary for people. the opposite anyway right i'm pre-writing the announcement post for my thing and i basically repeated what i said back when i talked about it earlier like that i've i've gone you see you you had the two different directions if you were going from like toy apps to like mass market and markets going from mass market to like niche apps and what i said last time we talked about this is i started out making these super niche apps that nobody wants and then i tried to get mainstream with hyperspace but then i'm back on my bs and i'm making niche apps again so i've gone in a u-shape start out making obscure stuff that nobody cares about made one app that's kind of potentially has somewhat brought up you not really because hyperspace is still super nerdy but whatever i tried and it's like nope i gotta i have to go back to these stupid apps nobody wants so
2:24:55John Siracusa: more on that in a future episode everyone so go check it out there's a link in the show notes to where the app will be but we'll see if it's actually there when you click it so best of luck
2:25:06Marco Arment: thank you very much Beep, beep, beep.
Sponsored by:
Become a member for ATP Overtime, ad-free episodes, member specials, and our early-release, unedited “bootleg” feed!