

Election Day “surprises” and late-cycle politics/polling, plus legal updates on Supreme Court oral argument, Alaska’s ballot/candidate eligibility fight involving “other Dan Sullivan,” California’s non-citizen voter-roll case, and DOJ/FBI perjury charges.
No external guests. Hosts are Sarah Isgur (former Republican campaign operative; worked on Romney 2008/2012, Carly Fiorina, RNC/NRSC) and David French (legal/political commentator; co-host of Advisory Opinions).
Hina Hosa vs. Greg Abbott polling; Zell Miller/ Lieberman cross-party endorsements; Planis/Marsh/None of the Above name-deception precedents; ranked-choice voting thought experiment in Alaska.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Hosts discuss upcoming live shows and their comedic setting at comedy clubs.
“James piece about the recruitment of the other Dan Sullivan, what that means criminally and electionally for Alaska, as well as updates on the California 20 ,000 non-citizens on the voter rolls lawsuit.”
Sarah shares a humorous encounter with a fan, discussing recognition in public.
“Like when you're out in the world, like if somebody recognizes you, why they do it?”
Hosts share their Halloween experiences and creative costumes.
“I regret to say I did not, I was not much of a participant in Halloween this year because I'd gotten the, and I urge everyone to do this.”
Sarah discusses polling trends and their implications on upcoming elections.
“part of Democrats and a lot of hope on the part of Republicans that all of the polling right now is off because it is very difficult to get white rural voters to participate in polls.”
Explore the dynamics of political campaigns in Texas, highlighting key candidates.
“Your first work for campaigns was in Texas.”
Discuss the reliability of polling averages and specific Texas race predictions.
“Hina Hossa is a pretty traditional Democrat.”
Analyze the impact of endorsements in Michigan's political landscape and specific cases.
“That would be a poll that's really, really far off for the New York Times.”
Discuss the courage it takes to make principled political decisions and the backlash that follows.
“But as far as like moving the needle materially, and for those who don't know, Haley Stevens lost by, I believe, less than a point to Abdul Al-Sayed in Michigan.”
Examine the moral obligations of politicians and voters amid partisan politics.
“but she knew what she was doing and she did it anyway.”
Reflect on the moral implications of compromising values for political gain.
“And I remember there were several people came up to me and they said, because people dogpiled on me like you wouldn't believe for saying that Plattner should go.”
Discussion on the importance of character in politics and moral analysis.
“or whatever else happens to be on your ballot.”
Overview of the upcoming Supreme Court case involving religious discrimination.
“First up, on Tuesday, the justices will hear argument in St.”
Update on the legal proceedings surrounding the Alaska election case.
“I just don't know that we're going to get to that more interesting case.”
Discussion about the implications of the New York Times' pre-election reporting.
“because once the Alaska Supreme Court spoke on this matter about his eligibility without any clear federal hook here, that's it.”
Examination of strategies to confuse voters by using candidates with similar names.
“by the way, said, my view is if Democrats don't want the New York Times reporting their involvement in schemes to defraud the voters of Alaska, they could easily avoid this by refusing to do that sort of thing.”
Discusses the Alaska Supreme Court's decision regarding Daniel Sullivan's candidacy and potential legal implications.
“The Alaska Supreme Court, when they decided this case, David, remember you and I both said, if we were on the Alaska Supreme Court, if there were a legal ability to remove Daniel Sullivan, we would have done so.”
Explores possible legal violations related to campaign conduct and voter manipulation.
“So you would no longer be asking for the same redress, which is to remove Dan Sullivan from the ballot.”
Analyzes the current situation in California regarding alleged non-citizens on voter rolls and the court's stance.
“segregate out 20 ,000 ballots of people who they believe are unlawfully on California's voter rolls because they are not citizens, a district court said, nah dog to that one.”
Discussion on the procedural arguments in election-related legal cases.
“The district court set a hearing for October 27th, and you went straight to us before the district court hearing.”
Update on the legal issues surrounding the planned shutdown of a golf course.
“So if you remember where we left off on this, Judge Reyes enjoined the administration from doing anything with the golf course.”
Discussion on the implications of credibility for the Department of Justice.
“on the end of our last episode, that continues.”
A reminder of the significance of voting and the integrity of the election process.
“It is a day to be proud to be an American and to tell your children how unique it is in the course of human history that we get to pick our leaders.”
Preview of future discussions on legal cases affecting government actions on homelessness.
“And David, for our next episode, we have that oral argument in the St.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On Advisory Opinions, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00You ready? I was born ready.
0:18Sarah Isgur: Welcome to Advisory Opinions. I'm Sarah Isgur. That's David French. And we are bringing you a special election day episode where David will ask Grifter Sarah questions and Grifter Sarah will do her best to be a little less grifty than usual. Maybe, maybe just more operative than Grifter. And then don't worry, we will return to a legal podcast, albeit an election-ish legal podcast, where we will talk more about Alaska and what the new revelations from that New York Times James piece about the recruitment of the other Dan Sullivan, what that means criminally and electionally for Alaska, as well as updates on the California 20 ,000 non-citizens on the voter rolls lawsuit.
1:05Sarah Isgur: The golf course continues to be the most unhinged thing I've ever read. And those FBI agents that were charged with perjury. So much to talk about. And what is the best thing to hand out for Halloween? We have the answer. Let's go. David, some housekeeping before we get started. First up, we have two live advisory opinions shows in Texas, Austin and then Houston, December 5th and 6th. You can go on the website, scotusblog.com and go to AO to find stuff, or you can just go to sarahisger.com to find the links to buy tickets. Should be some fun shows, David. As we noted last time, for reasons totally unclear to us, they booked us at comedy clubs and nothing says comedy like a Supreme Court update during the lame duck, you know?
1:58Well, you know, Sarah, how I think I listen to our podcast more than you listen to our podcast.
2:03Sarah Isgur: If you've ever listened to it, you listen to it more than I do. So I listen to probably one out of every three just to, you know, like I like to know how it flows and how it's going, you know, and all of that. How is it going? I love our podcast. We have a great podcast, Sarah. I just have to tell you this podcast is really, really good. Yeah. But I was listening to the last one we did when you first advertised it. And I said something like how the comedy clubs are a natural home because this is like a humor. And it sounded so lame and nerdy the way I said that, but I, you know, I am who I am, Sarah.
2:42It just, it is what it is.
2:45Sarah Isgur: I had kind of an amazingly funny moment. I was at a playground with my kids in DC and I was wearing my SCOTUS blog hat and this guy walks by and he says, I love SCOTUS blog. And I said, thanks. And our kids end up sort of playing for a second. And so then I'm like, so are you a lawyer or just a nerd. And he said, Oh, I'm not a lawyer, just a nerd. I'm just like really into advisory opinions with Sarah Isger and David French. And that's when I realized he wasn't saying, Oh, I like SCOTUS blog to me. He was just saying I like SCOTUS blog to a fellow SCOTUS blog nerd. And then I was like, Hi, I'm Sarah.
3:23Sarah Isgur: He like squealed and his parents were there with him. And he asked for a selfie. And David, it is my absolute first celebrity moment. It was really wild. And it was really nice. That is so fun. I will tell you this. It is an interesting thing. Like when you're out in the world, like if somebody recognizes you, why they do it? Like what is it that makes them, is it they saw you on TV or they, you know, read you at the New York Times or they done this or that. But for me, I don't know if you've ever, for me, sometimes no one will recognize me until I speak. And so one time I was flying to Miami for our National Constitution Center event.
4:06And there was a woman sitting next to me. And when she sat next to me, I was reading a book. And I just kind of looked and smiled and nodded, sort of, you know, greeting her. But then went back to my book and we said nothing the whole flight. And then when she got up, she was kind of struggling with her bag. And I said, can I help you with your bag? and she said, wait a minute. Have I been sitting next to the co-host of Advisory Opinions this whole flight? It's like, yeah. And it was just the voice. It's hilarious.
4:34Sarah Isgur: Okay, well, more housekeeping. If you are a student, be it high school, college, grad school, homeschooled, doesn't matter. You can get a full year of dispatch membership for free thanks to the generosity of our members who have donated to our student sponsorship program. This is actually pretty exciting. So basically, people donated just to give students free membership to the dispatch. So if you are a student, we've got a lot of free memberships to give out. And if you're not a student, but you've got one in your life, send them the link. Okay, so basically you can go to thedispatch.com slash student dash sponsorships, plural, and fill out the short form.
5:16Sarah Isgur: You don't need a credit card. Nothing renews automatically. Our team will get you set up. teachers, you can sign up a whole class there too. So this is for the dispatch. And I think it sounds like a really cool thing. Okay, David, that is the housekeeping. Although I do have some Halloween updates. Halloween went really well. We had an army ranger and a bluey. Oh, love it. Yeah. I was a pickle and Scott was in a shark onesie. So really full family participation. We didn't do a theme. It just felt very good. You know, very easy, low key. I will note that Sheldon Gilbert, the president of the Federalist Society, was that guy this Halloween.
6:03Sarah Isgur: No, he didn't hand out raisins or floss like your local dentist. He handed out pocket constitutions for Halloween. I mean, if you wrap a Snickers around a pocket constitution, there's nothing better. I mean, like, yeah. Absolutely. Absolutely. I regret to say I did not, I was not much of a participant in Halloween this year because I'd gotten the, and I urge everyone to do this. Sarah, when you get to be a certain age, you should get this shingles vaccine. But I will tell you the second dose of the shingles vaccine knocks you on your butt for like 24 hours. And so I was sort of like in the flu-like state.
6:46Yeah. So I missed going around Hyde Park in Chicago with a princess, a tiger, and a tiny little hungry, hungry caterpillar.
6:56Sarah Isgur: Oh. But they did come by before they went. And my sister who's visiting went with them. And she packed her own costume, a piece of toast with jelly on it. I actually love that. Yes. It's fantastic. I do. I think the winner for all of my friends, the parents went as graham crackers, just cardboard with like lines drawn on it, you know? The dog went as fire. The oldest daughter went as Hershey's chocolate. The youngest daughter went as marshmallows. And they were s'mores. That's fantastic. I love that. All right, let's get into it. We are recording this the day before the election. This will come out the day of the election.
7:41And a lot of you guys, longtime advisory opinions listeners know this, but maybe some of the more recent ones don't really realize it. And because you come to this podcast with us talking about the law, we talk almost exclusively about the law. But Sarah had a whole career in politics. She managed a presidential campaign. She was in Senate campaigns. House campaigns too, Sarah?
8:06Sarah Isgur: I did pieces of a bunch of local and House and stuff campaigns, like when I did OPPO stuff. And I did a stint at the Republican National Committee, the National Republican Senatorial Committee. Romney in 08 and 12, Carly Fiorina. She's, put it this way, she's a veteran of the political wars. She has the thousand yard stare. So it is, and we have a character for those who've not listened until recently called Grifter Sarah. When she comes out of her legal world, reenters her political world and offers us her political expertise. So I thought that we would give advisory opinions. We'd zig a little bit from our normal content.
8:47It's a shame that you're listening every two days a week to somebody who's a really knows her stuff in politics. And you never get that because that's not this podcast. But we're going to give you a little taste of that because I thought we would start by interviewing Grifter Sarah for a little bit. So I'm going to ask Sarah burning questions that I have for her. And hopefully, you know, you'll have some of the same questions. So I want to start. So, Sarah, you remember 2012 probably with much of a seared memory as I remember 2012. And we both remember 2016 and 2020 and 2024. And every cycle, we have had the polls argument.
9:29I remember the polls are supposed to be skewed in 2012 against Republicans. They turned out not to be. In 2016, 2020, and 2024, Trump outperformed polls. in 2018 and in 2022, the polls seem to be more or less correct. There's a lot of angst on the part of Democrats and a lot of hope on the part of Republicans that all of the polling right now is off because it is very difficult to get white rural voters to participate in polls. That is, you have to make many, many more calls, whereas progressive college educated Democrats are delighted to talk to pollsters. They cannot wait to talk to pollsters and tell them what they think of Donald Trump.
10:18As you're looking at the sort of avalanche of polls that are coming in at this very last minute, and they all seem to be saying one thing, but both the Post and the Times added a caveat that we're having trouble getting our sample right. How do you view that? Like with all polling, I look at trends, not bottom line.
10:40Sarah Isgur: So I was on the dispatch podcast last week and I was saying that I felt like the races were tightening and I was like, this is a vibe sense, um, you know, spidey stuff going off. And they were kind of like, yeah, but like, why? And I was like, I'm having a really hard time articulating why. Um, I don't know why I was, uh, since then I've sort of thought of some reasons, but the polling actually is now bearing me out. The race is tightening a little bit. So the New York times, for instance, showed Hina Hossa who's running against Greg Abbott in Texas. I'm going to get this slightly wrong, but like up three points last week.
11:15Sarah Isgur: And then she's up one point this week. That would still show Hina Hossa winning. I don't care about, I don't think it tells me whether Hina Hossa is going to beat Greg Abbott. I think that's very unlikely because the fundamentals often overcome a poll that's within the margin. But the trend tells me that some of that partisan coming homeness is happening a lot closer to election day than I'm used to it happening. It normally happens, you know, in Labor Day. And yes, we saw some of that, but not to the extent that I thought we would. But we seem to be seeing it right now. So look at the trend of the polls, not the bottom line of the polls.
11:52Sarah Isgur: And again, when you're talking about kind of a wave election, which all midterms tend to be wave-ish. And I feel like we say that a lot and don't define it. So a wave election is actually probably we would be better calling it a tide election. It is how high the tide is. If it's an eight point tide, that's going to swamp anyone who's in a Republican plus four district. Right. Because it's eight points. The Democrats are outperforming, you know, the general ocean or something. The polling is really bad at telling us how high the tide is, I guess. And it's been bad because for all the reasons you said, David, it's not there is a partisan valence to it, but it's also just really hard to get people to answer their cell phones right now.
12:39Sarah Isgur: Yeah, of course. I do not. I do not. Me neither. Yeah. And people have fewer and fewer landlines and online polling isn't as reliable. And so, yes, it is getting harder and harder to build any sample. But this is why the trend thing is helpful. The polling groups that are actually good at what they do, they may have trouble building their sample, but they're gonna build the same sample every time. And so the trend that they find, if Hina Hosa is performing less well this week than she was last week, should be really reliable, all things considered. So that's my answer on the polling. And it's really unhelpful for people who wanna know who's gonna win.
13:21Right. You know, people ask me that all the time and I don't have the same political background that you do, but I'm telling them I could be totally wrong about this. And this could be, you know, when this airs on Tuesday morning and you hear it 12 hours, you know, you look at the results 12 hours later, I'm having trouble believing it. So when I look at Tallarico 50, Paxton 43, the final New York Times Siena poll, I'm like, what? What? Because I was just down in Texas. I took a look at this race and I can tell you the Democrats I talked to are not 50, 43 confident, Sarah. So when you look at that, you're in Texas right now.
14:00You got your start in Texas. Your first work for campaigns was in Texas. You've worked with Senator Cruz.
14:08Sarah Isgur: So this is another thing that the New York Times poll, let's just use that poll for right now. But again, polling averages tend to be more reliable, things like that, but to pick out one set of numbers. I mentioned the Abbott-Hina Hossa numbers because that is going to be such a traditional race this cycle. Both are perfectly fine candidates. There's no scandal. There's no real huge name ID bump from some news story. Hina Hossa is a pretty traditional Democrat. Abbott is a pretty traditional Republican. So I like using that as my baseline polling model this time around and because I know Texas.
14:42Sarah Isgur: Okay, so not only am I looking at Hina Hossa's numbers moving down, even though the New York Times has her up still, again, I think Abbott's gonna pull out that race because there's fundamentals in the state and ground game and all of that. But the other trend you have to see is it's the same sample they're using for Abbott Hina Hossa that they're using for Paxton Tallarico. So again, use that tied example. In order for Paxton to win, Abbott has to win by like six points. That would be a poll that's really, really far off for the New York Times. You know, when we talk about the polls being off in 2016, we're still talking about a little over one point, usually under two points for the most egregiously wrong polls.
15:30Sarah Isgur: The New York Times being off by six, quite unlikely. And again, intra-poll, you can compare and trend from poll to previous poll of the same company you can compare. You just can't use the baseline in my view. So I was just on MSNOW, that's what they call MSNBC now, and I was asked about Haley Stevens. Yeah. And I had two thoughts about this. Thought number one that I shared was, I honestly don't think it's going to make that big of a difference in the race. It might make a difference on the margins, But as far as like moving the needle materially, and for those who don't know, Haley Stevens lost by, I believe, less than a point to Abdul Al-Sayed in Michigan.
16:16And Sayed is probably the left most Democratic nominee who's running a serious race for Senate. And Haley Stevens barely lost. At the very last minute, she endorses the Republican opponent. And it was, you know, all anybody was talking about in the political world yesterday. day. And so I had two thoughts. One, I don't know that these, my primary opponent endorsing me or not, it's really that big a deal with actual regular voters. But I also said, look, Abdul al-Sayed is probably the leftmost major candidate running. He said after there was an attempted massacre of Jewish preschool students, will hurt people hurt people.
17:01Now he condemned it. He condemned the attack, but then he was trying to explain why these things happen and said, use that phrase, hurt people, hurt people. Because the person who attempted the massacre, his family had been killed by the IDF in an Israeli airstrike. It doesn't understand. I don't quite understand how being mad at the IDF means you should massacre American kids. But that was that was the the Al-Sayed, which he later apologized for. but it was a reprehensible thing to say, just reprehensible in the moment. And I said on MSNBC, look, if you narrow the tent by selecting somebody who's more ideologically extreme, guess what?
17:44You narrow the tent and some people will leave it. Some people will leave. And that's my impression of what happened in Michigan. So let's talk Michigan. Do you think, Was I wrong on MSNBC when I said, hey, I don't think that the battle between Al-Sayed and Haley will make that big a difference because this was really a referendum on Trump? Was I wrong about that? And what is your thought about her endorsing the Republican?
18:14Sarah Isgur: Endorsements matter in low name ID races. The Michigan Senate race is not a low name ID race. but here we mean like endorsements you know like traditional endorsements like a newspaper or another political figure in a normal course of events with a planned endorsement what we saw from Haley Stevens was clearly not a planned endorsement and I think there's two ways of interpreting her endorsement one is on principle and I want to spend a minute on this one because I think it's really easy with partisan brain from both sides, I guess, to talk about the principle of the thing. Having someone from one party endorse someone from another party used to be really normal.
19:04Sarah Isgur: Zell Miller endorsed George W. Bush in 2004. Joe Lieberman endorsed John McCain in 2008. On and on and on, we can go about this. Lieberman was almost the running mate. Yeah, right. Yeah. But obviously this feels different. And I am hard pressed, David, to think of another example of an endorsement where someone knowingly ends their career in doing it. Haley Stevens will never again run for office in the Democratic Party. It's something that she had obviously built her career around for the last 20 plus years. And she decided to throw all of that away to tell her fellow Michiganders not to vote for the guy from her party.
19:50Sarah Isgur: Mind you, in the meantime, he raises$1.2 million off of her endorsement of the other guy. Right. So she endorses Mike Rogers and El Syed raises$1.2 million in the four hours after. she, I assume, is no longer able to sleep in her home right now because of the amount of death threats that I'm quite confident that she would have gotten. So from a purely principled standpoint, I am hard-pressed to think of something that takes more courage than that, frankly. Again, you can disagree with why she did it or all of the other stuff, but she knew what she was doing and she did it anyway. I had a friend who mentioned having lunch with someone who was a Democrat, a prominent Democrat, and that person is Jewish and also thinks El-Sayed is a threat to the Jewish community, anti-Semitic, all of these things.
20:43Sarah Isgur: but he's not going to speak out about that because of, you know, all of the normal concerns for his career, for his family, for all the stuff. That is a perfectly normal thing that people are doing this day and age is keeping their mouth shut. And so I just think if you could just step back from whatever partisan side you approach this and say, wow, someone actually said the thing they believe, regardless of the consequences, we should clap for that because that is a unusual and brave thing to do right now. I actually said something along those lines. I said, we've been asking for politicians to be independent of partisanship for 10 years now and somebody does it.
21:24And then, you know, they get very upset about it. And this is something that a number of Republicans have done. Yeah.
21:31Sarah Isgur: Let me give an example though of a small one. Cassidy Hutchison, right? Now, she wasn't throwing away a 20 year career, but she was a young woman with no foundation of, support and friends and money and all of that. Exactly. And she was asked a question. She was asked to tell the truth and she told the truth. Now, I don't know if she fully appreciated the consequences of what that would mean. Obviously, the Trump administration has tried to indict her and failed for perjury. But there's an example of someone who, again, did something pretty brave. If you can sort of take off the partisanship of the whole thing, we ask people to tell the truth and to speak up.
22:11Sarah Isgur: And then we scream at them, hurl insults at them, send death threats to them when they do it in a way that hurts our team. And you're right, David, there are many Republican examples of that. And we heard so many times that Democrats, if Trump were in their party, they would stand up and do the same thing. And between Plattner and El Sayed, I just haven't seen a lot of it. Well, at least Plattner stepped down. So I do give credit for, Plattner was forced out after the most awful, the most awful allegations. Plattner stepped down. I'm grateful that he stepped down. I'm glad that there was some hygiene there.
22:51The El-Sayed situation. Also, there's an interesting thing going on here. You have a situation in Alaska, which we will get to, which we condemned last week when we talked about like the difference between the dirty tricks and illegality, gamesmanship and illegality. And we condemned the gamesmanship, but then talked about the law. We didn't even know how bad the gamesmanship was when we condemned the gamesmanship before. Now we learned it's really bad. And then also there's another aspect of the El-Sayed situation. There was an ad put out. And this came from an outside group, an outside individual.
23:30It was gross and anti-Semitic. It was gross. It was basically like, I can't afford my groceries because the Israelis are killing Palestinians. And I mean, that was the ad. Like this was the ad. And it didn't come from El Syed. But you know what the easiest thing in the world to do? And this is what people have been begging Republicans to do for years is to condemn plainly bad things. If something is a bad thing, just say it's a bad thing. But they won't do it. Why won't they do it? Because they're worried about the base, the fringe, etc.
24:08Sarah Isgur: Let me just mention, by the way, a historical example of that again to make it far enough back that maybe people sort of can let go of some of the partisanship. When George W. Bush condemned Trent Lott for celebrating Strom Thurmond and saying the country would be better today if Strom Thurmond had been elected president, George W. Bush just condemned it. I don't mean he said don't vote for Trent Lott. He didn't say that. He just said that was a bad thing and I don't agree with it. That's all. Mitt Romney in 2012 campaign. I don't, I remember this very well. There was a extremely hateful Christian talk radio person that Romney condemned.
24:47And it made a bunch of the parts of the Christian right go nuts that Romney, but Romney did it. And it was the right thing to do. Why is it on me if I'm a Michigan voter? Why is it on me to swallow the fact that a guy won't clearly condemn an anti-Semitic ad? Why is that on me? Why is that my moral obligation to swallow that versus his moral obligation to clearly condemn that which is reprehensible? And why is it my obligation, if I'm a voter in Alaska, to swallow the dirty trick from Mary Peltola versus condemning or, and if she did it, I'll just freaking apologize, apologize for it. But, you know, this is the legal part of Alaska after the break, by the way.
25:32Sarah Isgur: So don't worry. Yes. So don't. So again and again, you have a situation where partisanship totally messes up with the moral equation because the moral equation is a truly dreadful thing happened. And the proper response to the dreadful thing is to say that's dreadful and I condemn it. The proper response is not to say you have to swallow the dreadful thing to support me. No, no. No, that's how we end up with Trump, guys. That's how we end up with Trump. That's what I wrote after Plattner. And I remember there were several people came up to me and they said, because people dogpiled on me like you wouldn't believe for saying that Plattner should go.
26:13And then after all the other revelations, I remember somebody came up to me and they said, David, how did you know more was coming? And I said, I don't know about your life experience, but in mine, when somebody has had a SS tattoo for 20 plus years, they're generally not a good human being. And you can just set your watch by that. and we just do this weird thing in partisan politics where you take something where you would never tolerate it in any other context of life. And you go, well, no, it's not only my obligation to tolerate it in politics, but to vote for it, to vote for the people who do it.
26:53I don't get it, I will never get it.
26:55Sarah Isgur: Well, guys, it's been a long time, too long since I quoted from A Man for All Seasons. You guys know, if you've been listening for a while, Well, I think all answers are in A Man for All Seasons. It's sort of like what the godfather is to men. A Man for All Seasons is to me. And this has been passed down to me by former Deputy Attorney General Rod Rosenstein, who gave me his signed copy of A Man for All Seasons. Sorry, that makes it sound like it was signed by the playwright. I mean, Rod signed it. So it profit a man nothing to sell his soul for the whole world. But for the Senate majority? in a branch that doesn't do anything?
27:38Sarah Isgur: I don't care how you vote tomorrow. I just want you to vote. And I want you to vote for the candidate you actually think would be good, right? A good person, someone, a representative. You know, you will not be there in the room for all the different decisions that they will make as a U.S. senator or a governor or a House member or whatever else happens to be on your ballot. I think character matters extra in a representative government. I completely agree. And do not let anyone bully you into swallowing things that you find reprehensible for the quote, greater good. The ends don't justify the means.
28:23Wait, yes. Yes, the ends don't. I always get that backwards. Means ends. The ends don't justify the means. And if you wonder if that's a valid moral analysis, just think about what the last 10 years of American politics have been about and have been like. And do you want more of that?
28:41Sarah Isgur: When we get back, we return to Becoming a Legal Podcast. And we have a lot to go through and we're gonna just snappity snap right through it, okay? Yes. A court deadline has a way of focusing everyone's attention. There's a document to finish, a client waiting for an answer, and a clock that doesn't care what else is happening. But if you run a small law firm, the deadline on the case isn't the only one that matters. Payday still comes around. A good system lets the team stay focused on the clients without treating every payroll or HR detail like an emergency. That's where Gusto comes in. Gusto is online payroll and benefit software built for small businesses.
29:18Sarah Isgur: It's all-in-one, remote-friendly, and incredibly easy to use, so you can pay, hire, onboard, and support your team from anywhere. Gusto helps simplify payroll with an automatic tax filing and unlimited payroll runs for one monthly price without hidden fees and surprises. Try Gusto today at gusto.com slash advisory and get three months free when you run your first payroll. That's three months of free payroll at gusto.com slash advisory. One more time, gusto.com slash advisory. All right, David, First up, on Tuesday, the justices will hear argument in St. Mary Catholic Parish versus Roy. This is that religious discrimination challenge brought by Catholic preschools in dot dot dot Colorado over the state's requirement that all schools participating in its universal preschool program must admit everyone, including LGBTQ children and children with LGBTQ parents.
30:19Sarah Isgur: We talked about this in our term preview. The day has come. So we will absolutely break down that oral argument after it happens. Very excited to see exactly how this breaks down because as we talked about in our term preview, look, A, once they've taken a case, 70 % chance that Colorado loses. Also, it's Colorado. So 100 % chance that Colorado loses? Like Colorado cannot win these cases going all the way back to Masterpiece Cake Shop, the animus that they have shown religion in the state, they just can't stop doing it. And so they keep losing these cases. 303, Creative, I mean, the list goes on.
31:05The conversion therapy case. Yes, Chiles. Yeah, so I feel like this is one of those cases that is like a branching two forks. And it's one fork in the road. And it just depends on which fork do you go down. If one fork in the road says, we say that every preschool or every school that's getting these funds has to be open to all, but we've allowed those schools that we like to have exclusive policies.
31:34Sarah Isgur: And for instance, to be clear, the St. Mary Catholic parish side has argued, and they have one of the Colorado folks testifying to this, that they would allow schools to discriminate on the basis of race, for instance, which is banned by the statute, if it were a school of children of color, or to have an only LGBTQ children's school, which would be discriminating on the basis of sexual orientation. It's sort of like a version of viewpoint discrimination. But these are the ones we like. Yeah. Yeah. And so if those are the facts, if the Supreme Court says, OK, I'm convinced that what's actually happening here is that Colorado has on paper an all comers policy, but in reality engages in sort of like you said, the analogy would be viewpoint discrimination and allowing people to discriminate when they like the discrimination.
32:24This case might be 8-1, 7-2. I mean, that's Masterpiece Cake Shop. Masterpiece Cake Shop was Colorado walked in and said, we're enforcing a non-discrimination policy in an even-handed way. And the evidence was they had not. They had allowed other kinds of discrimination that they liked. So that's why Masterpiece Cake Shop was 7-2, but it was also a narrow precedent because it was rooted in viewpoint discrimination.
32:46Sarah Isgur: And Child's was 8-1, same thing. Exactly. That was the conversion therapy case. But if it is the other branch, which is we're unconvinced by this person's testimony that they would have allowed it, that what we're dealing with is on its face an all comers policy that is rooted in to get the funding. You just have to be open to students from all over the state and without without any discrimination. That's a more interesting case to me, Sarah. I think it's a closer case. I think it's a more interesting case. I just don't know that we're going to get to that more interesting case. All right. More to come on that one.
33:27Sarah Isgur: David, let's do some revisitation. We've said this before, that this is an appellate podcast. And generally speaking, a federal appellate podcast, because we don't like doing facts. And it's really hard when there's fast moving cases. And we're talking about TROs. Things can change in like an hour. But we've tried to cover some of these cases for you that are either the Trump infrastructure cases like the golf course or the Alaska election case with Dan Sullivan, the Dan Sullivans. And not surprisingly, David, things changed massively right after we taped that podcast. So let's start with Alaska.
34:06Sarah Isgur: Since we last talked about how the Trump administration filed a case to basically stop certification of the election, unless incumbent Dan Sullivan won, One, two important things have happened. One, a federal court threw out that lawsuit. Understandably so, the federal court was like, I don't even know what you want me to do. There's no redressability here because we won't know why people voted for the other Dan Sullivan. So like, what are you even talking about? Like, what is your lawsuit actually asking me to do? I don't know. Therefore, I'm throwing out your lawsuit. David, not a surprising outcome.
34:47Sarah Isgur: for that piece of this. No, not surprising at all. I think it's the right legal outcome. It's the outcome we predicted because once the Alaska Supreme Court spoke on this matter about his eligibility without any clear federal hook here, that's it. And then of course the request for relief was so speculative. And yeah, I mean, I think that was plainly the correct outcome, but comma, dot, dot, dot. But comma, dot, dot, dot. We also got a fascinating story from the New York Times outlining exactly how other Dan Sullivan got on the ballot. David, that story broke as we were finishing our recording.
35:31Sarah Isgur: And I basically we hadn't read it. We just seen the headline. And it said basically the Democrats were involved with getting other Dan Sullivan on the ballot. And I was like, duh, I'm sorry. Was anyone confused about this? But the story delivered so much more. And just side note, David, for all the media criticism that I do, that everyone does, especially in the run to an election, I've just also been on the other side of this. Days before an election, publishing a story where you are describing a crime, which we'll get to in a second, that could affect the outcome of the election, that goes through so many legal reviews.
36:12Sarah Isgur: And the easiest thing that the New York Times could have done to protect themselves is not publish that story until after the election or at all. And they didn't. They published it a week before the election. So just that's this is a podcast about doing brave things at a time when we don't have a lot of people wanting to do brave things. That actually was a brave thing to do. OK, can I just say something really fast? There was a volcanic negative reaction to The Times publishing volcanic and a news story that affects the outcome of an election. This is like the Purcell principle, right? Don't publish something that's going to change, potentially change the outcome of an election.
36:52Sarah Isgur: But what do you do when it's the truth? I love what a guy on Twitter named Dylan Esper, who's a good follow, by the way, said, my view is if Democrats don't want the New York Times reporting their involvement in schemes to defraud the voters of Alaska, they could easily avoid this by refusing to do that sort of thing. Okay. The story in short outlines involvement by members of Mary Peltola's team, her Senate campaign team, and the Democratic Senate campaign committee to recruit, pay for, encourage someone named Dan Sullivan to run against in the race Dan Sullivan, including finding someone who used an alias to travel around the state of Alaska and meet with these potential candidates.
37:45Sarah Isgur: David, let's just start with the grossness before we get to the legal factor. I don't think anyone sees this and thinks it's not gross. There's this one moment that they describe where they're watching a focus group grapple with the two Dan Sullivans, and basically they're enjoying, and obviously it's the point, to confuse these voters. and they say something really dumb, by the way. Like I talk about this a lot on this podcast. First rule of criming, don't text about your criming. But they said something like, we've got a scheme for you. Like the point was to confuse the voters. It is gross. It is also worth noting, David, these are not the first people, the geniuses to come up with the idea of trying to confuse voters.
38:29Sarah Isgur: The more common way that you as a voter have interacted with, this is third party recruitment. So the Democrats like to recruit libertarians to run on the libertarian ticket. And the Republicans like to recruit Green Party candidates to run on the Green Party ticket, just to add names to the ballot and to peel off some of those base voters. Once you have both on the ballot, it tends to cancel each other out. But it's sort of this like race to the bottom of annoyingness. And that's been going on for many, many decades, long predating me, you know, getting into this line of business. However, David, there has also been efforts to recruit people with the same name.
39:11Sarah Isgur: That is not some genius novel idea either. There's a couple problems with it, though. One, in a normal sort of first past the post system with a primary and a general election and voting, it doesn't do you a lot of good. Like, are people going to be so confused that they accidentally, that person wins the primary who has the same name? No. And so once the primary is over, it doesn't do you any good. You would basically need to find someone to run as the Green Party candidate with the same name. And that becomes really hard to do. This is a bug of ranked choice voting. It encourages this type of behavior, which is why we haven't seen a ton of it and super public, you know, high level ones until right now, because Alaska is sort of the largest, in terms of space, of course, jurisdiction to experiment with ranked choice voting.
40:04It rewards it because the many candidates,
40:08Sarah Isgur: regardless of your party, end up on the final ballot. So as long as you can recruit someone same name, it actually becomes a feature, not a bug to have the same name, unlike in the primary system. That being said, David, there are still legal precedents about what to do when you have candidates with the same name. Let me read you a couple of them because they were in the Alaska Supreme Court's decision to say that the other Dan Sullivan could be on the ballot. Okay. In Planis versus Planis, a candidate for state representative was disqualified from the ballot where his name mirrored the name of an existing and well-known candidate.
40:42Sarah Isgur: The District Court of Appeal of Florida, Third District held it was lawful to disqualify a would-be candidate where the candidate designated a name on his ballot application that had not been adopted by him and under which he had not transacted private and official business. There, the court held that the appellant had not acted in the, quote, good faith and honest purpose required of candidates. And then in state v. Marsh, a potential candidate intended to list his name on the ballot as Fred Johnson. Another potential candidate who had previously filed was named Fred H. Johnson. As a result, the Nebraska Supreme Court held that the Secretary of State was justified in removing the potential candidate because his true name was Arthur Fred Johnson.
41:22Sarah Isgur: Arthur F. Johnson or A. Fred Johnson, rather than his listed ballot name of Fred Johnson. The court found that such a tactic would be a, quote, patent fraud as, quote, electors are entitled to have their identification of candidates unobscured by trickery or fraud, end quote. This also happened in None of the Above versus Hardy, where the guy tried to change his name to None of the Above. We can guess how that one went over. The court said he had, quote, no hope of being a serious candidate. His sole purpose was to arouse interest in the adoption of a None of the Above option by the legislature.
41:58Sarah Isgur: As a result, he violated the statute, which required his name to not be deceptive. The Alaska Supreme Court, when they decided this case, David, remember you and I both said, if we were on the Alaska Supreme Court, if there were a legal ability to remove Daniel Sullivan, we would have done so. The Alaska Supreme Court said, look, the Constitution lays out the requirements to be a candidate. Daniel Sullivan meets all those requirements. And then the Alaska statute says, you know, you have to get whatever signatures to be on the ballot. And he did that. Therefore, we have no ability to kick him off because his name happens to be the same as an incumbent.
42:34Sarah Isgur: The incumbent doesn't get like to own the name Dan Sullivan. So they basically said that it was different than these other cases because it really was his name, Daniel Sullivan. And he really goes by Daniel Sullivan in his real life, et cetera, et cetera. And of course, Daniel Sullivan said he was a conservative. He was running for bona fide reasons. He had told the court all of these things. Given that, David, the question is, did the New York Times report a crime? I would like to offer you some possibilities for that. I'm very curious about that because I have some thoughts on it as well. One, the obvious one, which is perjury.
43:10Sarah Isgur: Did Daniel Sullivan commit perjury? Maybe, depending what else those text messages show. But they do show text messages between Daniel Sullivan and this guy who used a false identity to talk to Daniel Sullivan, who knew what the purpose of running was, and it was to help Mary Peltola's campaign. So did he commit perjury? I'd want to see a whole lot of the actual transcript and what he said. Two, did the guy who was using a false identity commit fraud under Alaska state law? Maybe. Three, did they violate any campaign finance laws? That's always an easy one to trip over and these people did not come off like geniuses in their emails and text messages.
43:55Sarah Isgur: So I'm guessing they did. But again, I would need to spend more time with it. But David, here's my big one that I want to offer you. Okay. 18 U.S.C. 241. Conspiracy against civil rights. This is a big stick to use. So if two or more persons conspire to injure, oppress, threaten, or intimidate any person in any state in the free exercise or enjoyment of any right or privilege secured to him by the Constitution or laws of the United States. You've committed a crime and you can go to jail for a long time, not more than 10 years in prison. David, that's a really hard case to prove most of the time.
44:40Sarah Isgur: But again, because these morons put everything in text and email, they appear to have basically said that they were committing this crime. Yeah. So if you, if a long time advisory opinions listeners, when you hear the phrase 18 USC section 241, now I'm not going to hold you to remembering code sections, but there might be a way in which you go, that sounds weirdly familiar. What about 18 U.S.C. Section 241? Well, that is one of the statutes used to prosecute Donald Trump after the January 6th election. Now, why would that statute have been used to prosecute Donald Trump? The answer is really interesting because the way that 18 U.S.C.
45:32Section 241, and you can go back to cases from like the 1930s on this, is it basically says, OK, it's not just about did you threaten somebody physically? Did you, you know, obviously, if you threaten somebody, vote for me or I'm going to don't vote or I'm going to beat the crap out of you or something along the lines. But it also involves schemes to do things like expand the number of votes count, constrict the number of votes counted. In any way, it's a conspiracy to sort of to to mess with the ability to count and rely and rely on the outcome of an election. Now, I think it's probably a tougher lift to get there on 18 U.S.C.
46:17Section 241 in this circumstance than it was when, say, Trump says, I need 10 ,000 more votes or whatever the number was, because that actually falls right in line with some case law, which is very interesting. But 18 U.S.C. Section 241 is actually a statute that is really, I don't know, you know, the word flexible. It's got more flexibility than you think. And that flexibility is something that was wielded, I thought, very properly against Trump. I think you could take the case against Trump and make a very effective argument that it matched precedent involving 18 USC Section 241 pretty well.
47:05It was a very close match to actual precedent on 18 USC Section 241, which is why I never bought the law fair argument around January 6th. but it is a broad statute. And it is one that I think that is, that folks should be thinking about. And also this duty of candor to the Alaska Supreme Court. Now, none of this, none of this will mean that the Trump administration lawsuit has merit. I don't believe that it has merit, but I do think that if I were in Alaska, if I were a Democrat in Alaska who participated in this, if I'm the Alaska Supreme Court, I'm angry that essentially I was sold a case on false pretenses.
47:46Did it involve behavior that was perjury or contempt? To TBD, don't know. We're not gonna opine on that. But it certainly raised both my eyebrows, Sarah.
47:57Sarah Isgur: Yeah, and if you're wondering like what can happen, you can ask the Alaska Supreme Court on top of moving for sanctions, bringing perjury charges and all that. You can ask the Alaska Supreme Court to reopen the case. Now, obviously this will then happen after the election. So you would no longer be asking for the same redress, which is to remove Dan Sullivan from the ballot. And that is a problem with the reopening argument. But this whole thing is a mess. And frankly, like one side has pretty dirty hands. I want to be clear, Democratic Senate candidate Mary Peltola said she was not aware. And there is nothing in the New York Times piece that directly shows that she was aware.
48:37Sarah Isgur: But when some of these people start getting arrested, It will be interesting to see whether they say she was aware or not. And that, again, changes, I think, how this proceeds. I had a brain meltdown the other day in thinking about this and its connection with ranked choice voting. Because my actual first thought was ranked choice voting makes this less impactful. But then I thought about it. There is one circumstance where it doesn't, where ranked choice voting makes it actually more impactful. And that is this scenario. If you look at the polling in Alaska, it's very close, very close. So let's suppose ranked choice, I believe there's four actual candidates on the ballot, but we'll just do a thought experiment with three.
49:22The way ranked choice voting matters or works is after you count the votes in the first round, if somebody exceeds 50%, the election's over, you won, you're done. If nobody gets 50%, the person who was last, they're dropped away and you take a look at who their voters voted for because you've ranked and you're going to allocate votes based on their number two vote will go to whoever they voted for. Number two will become like a number one vote for the person they voted number two. So think of it like this. Imagine and again, the polling here is super close. Imagine at the end of the polling or at the end of the first ballot, it's 49 % Dan Sullivan incumbent, 48 % Mary Paltola challenger, and 2 % Dan Sullivan fake.
50:14Okay. Assuming the 2 % were confused voters, Dan Sullivan, the real, should win right there. At that point, it would be a very logical. Now, I know a lot of listeners are saying, no, no, no, no, no. Some of those 2 % are going to be banked as protest votes. Just bear with me for a minute. In a race that's very close, all of a sudden, if you have this intentional confusion, you now literally don't know if 50.1 % of people arrived at the polls wanting to vote for the incumbent. And then you go to the number two. And it could be that some of those 2%, thinking they were voting for the incumbent Republican, put the Democrat number two.
50:55They just put the Democrat at number two. Then all of a sudden she could become number one on the strength of that confusion. And so when I was first thinking through it, I don't know why I had like this brain lock that I could, I didn't think through that very tight scenario on first round, but that's why it's so matters. And again, I go back to the Dylan Esper thing. If you're really mad about this being reported and talked about on the eve of a very important election, you know who to be mad at. And it ain't us.
51:31Sarah Isgur: And it ain't us. David, when we get back, we've got updates on that California 20 ,000 non-citizens registered to vote case on the golf course case. Of course, that'll never die. And the FBI agents who were charged by the Department of Justice. We'll be right back. When our first was about a year old, I thought it'd be really funny to put him in a large shopping bag. The picture we got is of a very confused little baby looking really adorable in this huge bag, and it's those little moments that tend to disappear into a camera roll, even when they're the ones we most want to remember. Aura frames can bring those everyday photos out of your phone and into your home, where the whole family can actually enjoy them.
52:13Sarah Isgur: Aura frames can bring those everyday photos out of your phone and into your home. The little moments in life are worth remembering. You can do that with Aura Frames. Aura is the number one digital frame loved by millions of families, and their Black Friday Cyber Monday deal is the best of the year. For a limited time, visit AuraFrames.com and get up to$50 off select frames, plus an additional$5 off your order with the promo code ADVISORY. That's A-U-R-A-Frames.com promo code ADVISORY. Support the show by mentioning us at checkout. Terms and conditions apply. Okay, David, this case out of California where the Department of Justice asked California to segregate out 20 ,000 ballots of people who they believe are unlawfully on California's voter rolls because they are not citizens, a district court said, nah dog to that one.
53:10Sarah Isgur: We have the night Circuit, two to one with Boumette dissenting, agreeing with the district court and saying California doesn't have to do anything. In the meantime, though, we have third party groups jumping in to say, and this gets a little bit confusing, I guess, David, right? There's, let's call it, you know, compare it to hearsay. There's the truth of the matter asserted. That's asking California to set aside these 20 ,000 ballots before they get mixed in. but there's also sending California the letter to set aside the 20 ,000 ballots okay so the third party groups are saying that sending the letter itself is a form of voter intimidation meant to threaten the election officials meant to intimidate voters from trying to vote in the first place and that the letter itself was unlawful in order to get standing judge bozberg ordered the department of Justice to turn over the list of 20 ,000 people to one of these third party groups.
54:10Sarah Isgur: So right, the state of California has the 20 ,000 list. But this like random other group was like, we want the list too. And DOJ was like, no, they're just going to use it to like attack us. And Judge Boesberg said, give them the list, they may only use it to establish their standing, as in they can go through the list and find out if any of their members are on the list. And that would give them standing to bring this lawsuit potentially. Okay. Well, not surprising what happens next. We have a lot of headlines that say things like over 40 % of names on DOJ list of alleged non-citizens are not on California's voter rolls.
54:49Sarah Isgur: And so now the justice department is asking for sanctions against the third party group because clearly they didn't just use the list to establish their standing. So this whole thing, David, has snowballed off into some other corner of the universe. But for the absolute update, we're still at the same place we were. California does not need to segregate out those ballots. David, did you get a chance to read the Judge Bumate dissent on that? You know, we had talked about this and the credibility problem. This, you know, this had been brought during the Bush administration, and they said there were 20 ,000 non-citizens on the voter rolls.
55:26Sarah Isgur: I think we'd all assumed that there were 20 ,000 non-citizens on the voter rolls, but we don't assume that anymore. And that's a problem for the Department of Justice today and moving forward. But I felt like the majority versus the dissent of the Ninth Circuit decision on this was actually kind of that argument. Do you take DOJ at face value or not? Yeah. Yeah. I felt like that. So there are really sort of two things going on at once. The one which I thought where the per curiam opinion was quite strong was basically like, wait a minute, you've brought this to us prematurely, that we're not supposed to be looking at this right now.
55:59You filed something with the court, a district court, and you said, you need to rule before November 3rd. The district court set a hearing for October 27th, and you went straight to us before the district court hearing. That's not proper. You gave them, you asked the district court to rule by a certain date. They set a hearing before that date, And then you went ahead and appealed to us saying essentially that by setting it at that date, that was a constructive denial of our TRO motion. And so I thought that that was actually a quite procedurally sound argument. And then as far as the rest of it went, I'm right there with you.
56:38This was a classic example of I just flat out don't think the majority of the Ninth Circuit believes the Trump administration, period. that they just don't believe that they're literally genuinely 20 ,000 non-citizens on the ballot. And I think that's hovering in the background of all of this. It's like, no, this is not a thing you're doing here. You're playing a game and we're not going to play your game. And that's the strong sense you get from the majority and the Ninth Circuit. and they really hammer it home on the timing issue because they were talking about, well, this was an issue on your radar screen going all the way back to July.
57:22And then you don't file until October. And then you give the district court a deadline of November 3rd, and then you go up to us way before the deadline you gave the district court. And so what are we doing here? And I think there is a sense that you're playing games with us and we're not going to do it. And I think that Judge Bumate is treating this much more like, no, this is legitimate. This is not a game. They're not playing games. It's almost like, what if this was a normal administration? How would you rule kind of dissent? And I think that you hit the nail on the head on the tension there.
58:00Sarah Isgur: All right. Next up for updates, golf course. So if you remember where we left off on this, Judge Reyes enjoined the administration from doing anything with the golf course. And she said, look, the president keeps saying there's a plan to shut down the golf course on November 15th. And you guys keep coming in here and telling me not to believe the president and to believe you instead. And I'm just done with it. Nobody can do anything. I believe there is a plan. And, um, and I don't find what all of you have told me to be credible. So David, then since we taped that podcast, the National Park Service now confirms that it will shut down the golf course on November 15th.
58:43Sarah Isgur: I, I don't, I don't, I'm sort of out of words for this. So right before, you know, a show cause hearing basically, and it can quasi contempt hearing, at least it looks like to me, they're now saying they are shutting the golf course down, despite having told her that there were no plans to shut the golf course down. So they're going to have to say the plan arose after the hearing with her, despite the president saying there was a plan the whole time. This is careening off a hill. Also, David, speaking of careening, those two FBI agents that were charged with lying before Congress, a judge dropped those charges and said there is no other way to describe this indictment other than as weaponization.
59:35Sarah Isgur: So just to like putting a nice little dot on the end of our last episode, that continues. And just to connect to what we just said, if you're like, how dare you treat this Department of Justice different from other previous Departments of Justice? This is why, this is why we live in a world in which the reputations of lawyers are known and the reputations of institutions are known and you're granted degrees of discretion and trust or not on the basis of those reputations. This is how the law, the legal system works at a level and in real life in a way that an awful lot of people don't understand.
1:00:15And when you blow up your credibility, you blow up your credibility. And there are consequences for that. And the Trump administration is seeing that now again and again and again.
1:00:28Sarah Isgur: All right, David. So tomorrow is election day. It is a day to be proud to be an American and to tell your children how unique it is in the course of human history that we get to pick our leaders. So, you know, despite all of the nonsense and the feeling of shenanigans, there is nothing new about shenanigans in American politics. And yet it is still this glorious both duty and privilege that we have. So enjoy it out there. Go vote. And vote with confidence because as we have gone through a million times, it is very hard in this big decentralized country that we have to mess with it all. It is very difficult.
1:01:15Your vote is not going to be wasted. So vote with confidence.
1:01:20Sarah Isgur: And David, for our next episode, we have that oral argument in the St. Mary's case and the other Boumete dissent. I really, really, really, really, really want to talk about it. It is about what a city can do to remove homeless encampments where disease is breaking out, rat-borne disease. It is an unreal set of facts here. And I feel like it illuminates this larger thing about the sort of heckler's veto that we have caused in government as we have tied down every government action with so much red tape from Congress, red tape from courts and everything in between. Maybe part of the reason why we're all so frustrated is because nothing ever seems to happen, including clearing homeless encampments.
1:02:13It would seem all that and more
1:02:15Sarah Isgur: on the next advisory opinion.
1:02:25Oh Oh Oh
David French interviews “Grifter Sarah” Isgur as the midterm elections conclude, before they dive into new revelations in the Alaska Senate race and discuss an update in the California noncitizen voters lawsuit.
The Agenda:
–It’s not a wave, it’s a tide
–Does Haley Stevens’ endorsement matter?
–St. Mary Catholic Parish v. Roy
–The Dan Sullivans of Alaska
–California noncitizen voting lawsuit
–Trump’s golf course update
Show Notes:
–We’re hiring! Apply here.
–Come see us in Austin! Or come see us in Houston!
–Student sponsorship sign-ups
–New York Times/Siena poll
Advisory Opinions is a production of The Dispatch, a digital media company covering politics, policy, and culture from a non-partisan, conservative perspective. To access all of The Dispatch’s offerings—including access to all of our articles, members-only newsletters, and bonus podcast episodes—click here. If you’d like to remove all ads from your podcast experience, consider becoming a premium Dispatch member by clicking here.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices