

The episode argues that recent U.S. politics and elections can be understood through free-speech dynamics—how fear, censorship, and intimidation shape voting, and how First Amendment protections (including Citizens United) affect campaign information and outcomes.
Sarah Isgur and David French (hosts). They speak live at FIRE’s Soapbox 2026 in Philadelphia. No additional guests are named in the transcript.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Discussion on the significance of the First Amendment.
“and go through it again across from Independence Hall.”
Exploring the effectiveness of a controversial political ad.
“So one item on this side of my thesis that they them add that was so effective as one of the closing arguments for the 2024 presidential election.”
Examining the government's role in social media censorship.
“got quite a bit of attention was pretty jaw-dropping.”
Analyzing how fear affects voting decisions and political participation.
“C-E-G, two years of advisory opinions podcast.”
Discussing the dichotomy between human nature and American values on free speech.
“So human nature is free speech for me and not for thee.”
Evaluating the consequences of the Supreme Court's Calais decision on representation.
“Sometimes human nature wins, that McCarthyite, that Woodrow Wilson, the cancel culture we saw in Woke 1.0, MAGA cancel culture.”
Explore how free speech serves as a defense against authoritarianism, referencing historical figures like Frederick Douglass.
“and then you enforce compliance in part by suppressing dissent, which is an old school authoritarian playbook.”
Discuss the persistence of division in American politics and how it can lead to significant changes in governance.
“We can't even, you know, elect new people because of gerrymandering or whatever else.”
Analyze the effects of campaign spending on election outcomes and the implications of the Citizens United ruling.
“Democrats have a real option here to show how they can govern a state that offers that or to say, you know what?”
Explore the nuances of political speech and its protections under the First Amendment.
“That has always been incredibly unconvincing to me.”
Discuss how financial contributions influence election outcomes and voter perceptions.
“Now, as you said, it's not the case that money is irrelevant, especially in the low name ID election.”
Examine upcoming legal challenges regarding social media regulations and free speech implications.
“Okay, David, we have a few minutes left and two important things to get to.”
Analyze a school incident involving Confederate flags and the limits of political expression in educational settings.
“It is one side saying, we have won this debate and I'm not going to have any more debate about it because I'm going to hold on to my win.”
Explore how the heckler's veto impacts free speech in schools.
“And my argument has always been no, because if you're rooting the disruption in the response to the speech and not in the nature of the disruptive nature of the speech itself, you're creating a heckler's veto on campus.”
Discussion on the implications of fighting words and harassment laws.
“And now we will open it up for questions.”
Explore the complexities of gerrymandering and its bipartisan implications.
“saying like, yeah, so let's like amend some stuff.”
Address listener concerns about money in politics and electoral reform.
“and then we're going to answer them so that we don't run out of time?”
Discuss potential reforms to the Electoral College and their implications.
“and Harvard Law professor who has helped do this.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On Advisory Opinions, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00Sarah Isgur: Welcome to Advisory Opinions. I'm Sarah Isgur, that's David French, and we are live at FIRE's Soapbox 2026.
0:27Sarah Isgur: David, the theme is First Amendment. Damn it, still revolutionary. Yes. Oh, get it? Yes, in Philly, still revolutionary. I mean, this is just catnip for me. We were driving in yesterday and drove past the Museum of the American Revolution and I wanted to immediately jump out and go through it again across from Independence Hall. It's like my happy place. But I do wanna just one critique the crowd for just a second. So our please clap moments, I'm beginning to mentally rate them. and that was fine, but nobody's as good as SMU Law School in Dallas. I just want to say that. Wow, SMU is really dining off that for a year now.
1:07Sarah Isgur: It's for a long time. Okay, so I wanted to start with a provocative thesis for you. Okay, here's my thesis. the last six years of our politics and elections can be explained looking through the lens of free speech. So one item on this side of my thesis that they them add that was so effective as one of the closing arguments for the 2024 presidential election. We talked about this a little at the time, there were those who saw that as an ad about transgender participation in sports, transgender rights in general. I'm not denying that that was sort of the front face of the ad, but actually what I think made the ad so effective was the free speech part of the ad.
2:03Sarah Isgur: It was this idea that you were being, you know, forced to put pronouns in your signature block or, you know, forced to speak in a way through social stigmatization, et cetera, and that that's why the they-them ad had such a resonance with voters. Okay, let me give other examples. The Murthy v. Missouri Supreme Court case, right? This was about the Biden administration's social media censorship. It was decided on standing, but the record that came out and got quite a bit of attention was pretty jaw-dropping. An administration basically threatening social media companies that they didn't take down speech that the administration didn't agree with.
2:51Sarah Isgur: The Department of Homeland Security created the Disinformation Governance Board to coordinate efforts against online disinformation. That one had some rings of 1984 to it. And then, of course, this was nothing new, but it certainly hit some sort of air pocket after October 7th, but campus speech. And this idea of shutting down speech you don't like through violence, through heckling, and even through potentially assault, encampments, locking people in libraries, et cetera. Then, of course, Donald Trump wins re-election. And you have, I mean, I don't know that I need to list all of the free speech threats from the last two years.
3:37We've got only 40 more minutes before questions. So, yeah.
3:42Sarah Isgur: Okay, so can I grandfather those in? Because they're fresher in the mind. C-E-G, two years of advisory opinions podcast. Yes. Yes, okay. And then you have this midterm election. Okay, so is our politics defined more by free speech? Like, that's not going to be in one of the polling questions on what's the issue that's most important to you, etc. But is it a vibe? Is it this sense that the American people are like, you know, F me, no F you? Yeah, so I wanna be super clear about this. Obviously, things like affordability, corruption, like the top issues really do matter more to the average person walking into the voting booth.
4:25But I do think there is a class of Americans and I think the vibe or the aura, whatever Gen Z term you wanna apply to this, then does extend around the country. and it goes something like this. It is, if I am afraid to say something because of a movement, a leader, a person, as a general matter, if I'm entering a phase where I'm very afraid to speak, I'm gonna be super happy to vote against the person who made me afraid to speak. And I'll tell you an interesting sort of anecdote to support this. And also, I know that the plural of anecdote is not data, but this is just an interesting anecdote.
5:08I went down to Texas to report on the Paxton-Talerico rates.
5:12Sarah Isgur: When? And this was about a month before. Okay. And you didn't call? You were moving. You were moving. And so I was down, but I wasn't in Houston. I was in Austin and Beaumont anyway. Beaumont's like an hour away, but okay, sure. We'll work this out later. But the... Ouch. The fascinating thing was I talked to person after person who identified as Republican or conservative evangelical. And it was absolutely beyond crystal clear to me that they were either not voting for Paxton under no circumstances, or they were going to actually flip and vote for the Democrat instead of Paxton. And these were people who were like leaders of evangelical organizations, board members of evangelical organizations.
6:00These were people who had been working in Texas politics for years, and they all had the same thing in common, which was don't put it on the record. Don't tell anybody this is what I'm doing. I don't. It will be terrible for me. It will be terrible for my organization if anyone knows that I am voting for a Democrat or I'm not voting Republican. and that atmosphere of fear and that atmosphere of intimidation is it creates a false consensus because if you've created a sense of fear and intimidation, very few people are going to disagree with you and so you're going to start to think, well, maybe I'm more popular than I really am but it really also creates a rage.
6:43You are very happy to go into a safe place in the safety of the voting booth and do something about it and I've heard this time.
6:51Sarah Isgur: This reminds me, by the way, of the scene in Mean Girls where she asks who here has been victimized by Regina George. And like, it takes a second, but then everyone raises their hand. Yeah. Yeah, like no one wants to speak out against Regina George, but if they can all kind of do it secretly and together, then everyone takes down Regina George. And you saw it in 2024. If you look at some of the jurisdictions that moved most red, even though they stayed blue, even though they stayed blue, some of the jurisdictions that moved red the most were some of the bluest jurisdictions in the US, the places where the echo chamber was there in vengeful force.
7:28And I think what we're dealing with right now is a pendulum swing, human nature versus American nature. Okay, and here's what I mean. Human nature is free speech for me and not for thee. That's human nature. The founders knew when they were designing this country, they really had to inculcate virtue because a lot of what they were creating here was not something that we were naturally prone to, protection of other people's liberty, et cetera. So human nature is free speech for me and not for thee. But 250 years in, free speech has been embedded so much as part of the American nature that it's almost like we who live here have a little extra competing voice in our head that is like, oh, my impulse, my vengeful impulse, my desire to censor, whatever, this might backfire because it's landing on a culture that's been trained for 250 years that we should not be like this.
8:25And this is kind of a story going back and forth in American life. Sometimes human nature wins, that McCarthyite, that Woodrow Wilson, the cancel culture we saw in Woke 1.0, MAGA cancel culture. And then that American nature starts to reassert itself. And it says, nope, not here. Maybe somewhere else, not here. And so I think that's an interesting, very interesting thesis.
8:50Sarah Isgur: So another part of this in my mind, I mean, one of the things that I really have enjoyed from Tuesday was, and I think I'd mentioned this to you, the data digital teams on these campaigns have become really sophisticated. Like, they know, you know, everything about you when you're walking into the voting booth. And so they know on election day whether you have voted and they've got you—the score can depend some model for our purposes. They model you on a 100-point score. Your likelihood of how strong you are is whatever. So all the modeling in Texas basically showed that Abbott was going to win, you know, by like 4 p.m.
9:30Sarah Isgur: on election day by about two and a half points. because that's how many high Republicans had walked in on election day, but they voted for the other guy. And this is, well, it turned out to be a woman, but this is where free speech is inextricable from voting rights as well. And I just felt like the American people really had the last laugh here. And you look at all of those gerrymandered seats. So Republicans lost four of the five seats in Texas that they had specifically drawn because they thought they could lower the margin and therefore, you know, crack and pack Democratic voters. And then they lost two of their own seats that they hadn't even messed with.
10:23Sarah Isgur: So like, cool beans there. And maybe this brings us a little to Calais. So this is the Supreme Court's decision on the Voting Rights Act that was decided at the end of last term. And there was a lot of hand-wringing. Now, we've talked about the legal side of Calais, but now let's talk about the consequential side of Calais. So if Mississippi elects the Democrat, and that's super tight, but he is up right now. And he's favored based on what's hanging out there. Right. I think he's up 43 votes. I think he's now exceeded four-digit lead. He might be up 1 ,000 votes at this point. All right, fair enough.
11:01That landslide, mandate.
11:03Sarah Isgur: Yes. All right, so let's look at the Senate because the Senate isn't affected by gerrymandering, just like the governors aren't affected by gerrymandering. That's more of the, like, culture of America willingness to elect black leaders from both parties. So the U.S. Senate, if he wins, would have seven black senators, all-time high, obviously, and then five Black governors were elected Tuesday. That's more than double the number ever elected in U.S. history from three to seven. Before this election, no two elected Black governors had served at the same time in January 5. Okay, so that is a change in American culture that really Chief Justice Roberts and others had talked about during the oral argument that they were kind of mocked for.
11:52Sarah Isgur: Like, you know, sort of how dare you say American culture has changed. So that's maybe something on their side. On the House side, so this is where gerrymandering, where Calais itself matters, where we have mid-cycle redistricting in a bunch of these states. On the one hand, it looks like we will have two fewer Black representatives in Congress. On the other hand, it's a little hard to say that that has anything to do with Calais. New seats won by Black members, six, including two in North Carolina, where they did mid-cycle redistricting. Two other members held their seats despite having mid-cycle redistricting in Alabama and then a third one in North Carolina.
12:31Sarah Isgur: And of course, one of the Black members of Congress just became governor of Florida. So Calais, David, did Calais matter? You know, I think Calais mattered in an interesting way. And that is that if you look at the statistics regarding Black turnout as a percentage of total turnout in all of the Southern states, really, that were impacted by Calais, there was a material increase in black turnout as a percentage of total turnout. And this really circles back to free speech because in many ways, whatever legal scenario, whatever legal environment you create, if you have enough communication about it and you have enough ability to broadcast it, critique it, get outraged by it, do something about it, it really is interesting how much mass mobilization can swamp legal technicalities, so to speak.
13:24I mean, that's a little bit much to call that a legal technicality. It is consequential. But it is very interesting to me how much the mobilization of individuals can fully swamp legal reform and legal change. And it also, I think, shows why, to a large degree, I don't think the Trump administration, when it launched a free speech crackdown, was acting in a way, I think it was short-sighted. I think it ultimately ended up foolish, but I think there was a method to the madness. And I think the method to the madness is you enact and create legal change and then you enforce compliance in part by suppressing dissent, which is an old school authoritarian playbook.
14:10And so if you're constantly threading ABC or CBS or NBC for not covering things the way you want them covered, you begin to realize how much free speech is the backdrop or is the firewall against sort of the mass injustice, which brings us back to this has always been the case. You know, we're not in Boston right now. We're in Philly. But, you know, I always, when you have a situation where there is threatened injustice, threatened authoritarianism, I always go back to Frederick Douglass, a plea for free speech in Boston in 1860. And Frederick Douglass articulated the free speech principle that I think is the principle that is the canary in the coal mine, which is if you are worried if someone is going to be authoritarian, if you're worried about authoritarianism, you don't really have to read a bunch of think pieces.
15:07You don't really have to read a bunch of like political scientists sort of comparing 19 or 2025 America to 1929 Italy, you have to ask, are people being censored? Because Frederick Douglass said that a free speech was the first, it is the dread of tyrants and it is the first thing that they seek to suppress because free speech is the unique dread of tyrants. So any movement that builds, if one of the first parts of their agenda is the suppression of speech, every last alarm bell should be going off. And this was part of, you know, back in my pre-journalism life, I was FIRE's president. And, you know, one of the things that you would see in campus after campus was they would lead with a speech code.
16:00They would lead with a speech code. And that should have been the sign that the alarm bell's ringing that something is broken in higher education. Because if you lead with the speech code, that is the person, that is the instrument of the tyrant. And the free speech is the dread of the tyrant. And the suppression of speech is the first sign of the tyrant. And so to circle back to the conversation at the very start, I think there's a lot to the thesis, a lot to the thesis. It's the leading edge indicator.
16:36Sarah Isgur: So, okay, a couple ways to go here. One, if the people are so good at having their voices heard, you know, for the last 26 years where American politics, again, sort of this historical anomaly, had been so closely divided between the two parties, I think that's part of what gave rise to the feeling of helplessness, of how can we get Congress to do their job? We can't even, you know, elect new people because of gerrymandering or whatever else. We can't possibly ratify an amendment to the Constitution. We are so divided 50-50. If that's just not true, it turns out the American people can speak very loudly when they want to.
17:17Sarah Isgur: Can we break some of these other stalemates, legally speaking, that are putting so much pressure on other parts of the political system and in particular the judiciary? So having written a book about American division that might just have been blown up by this election, I've got some thoughts about this. Because when I wrote my book in 2020 about the persistent American division and its threat to the very unity of the United States, I went back and you were able to see that there were periods of very close division for a very long time in different periods of American life. and they were always going to end, that the stalemate was always gonna end.
18:00But the question was how and under what circumstances. So one of the first stalemates ended in the Civil War. That was the worst possible way, the way we want to avoid to end stalemates. But virtually in every other circumstance, the stalemate ended when one party finally overreached so much or failed so completely that the American people just said, done. All y 'all got to go. I mean, this is what happened in Texas. We were talking before the podcast about how crazy it is that every single statewide election went to the Democrats. And there isn't even a button, as you were saying, in Texas polling machines where you can just press single ticket Democrat and all the lights light up.
18:46Sarah Isgur: No, you had to go through 140 pages. is doop, doop, doop. It took a really long time. My six-year-old was very frustrated. I mean, so what we had was a bunch of people doing like that prank you see in movies where somebody goes into an elevator and it's maybe 100 floors and they just go, and they just did that for the Democrats, right? And so yes, at the moment, it does appear that the log jam has broken. Well, let me put it this way. For the first time in 26 years, it is quite possible that the logjam has broken, that there are things that the Democrats could do between now and 2028 to actually break the logjam.
19:25Now there are things that they could do to make the pendulum swing back. Right. Many of them may be related to free speech, actually.
19:31Sarah Isgur: Indeed. And so this is, we're at one of those moments, but I've got a question for you. By the way, wait, fun fact, just to note this on the free speech side, you know, Ken Paxton lost for all the reasons. just too many to name. But don't forget that also the reason he got impeached in part was because of what he did to the whistleblowers, the people who spoke out to say factually and accurately what they had seen him do while in office. He then retaliated against them, fired them. They ended up having to be paid out of Texas taxpayer dollars. So again, you can't separate that out from the actual merits of the corruption as well.
20:16Sarah Isgur: But it's all part of this idea that I think people rejected. It's not just affordability. It's the corruption that goes with it. It's not just the corruption. It's that if you're corrupt, you have to prevent people from talking about your corruption. And that whole ball was nicely nestled in into Texas. Okay, so can I flip around and ask you a question now? Yeah. Okay, here's my question. We just had a race in Texas. we're sticking with the Texas theme because honestly, guys, I don't know if you agree with this. I think the Senate victory was actually, for Democrats, was actually less consequential over time.
20:52Sarah Isgur: You're saying Democrats winning control of the U.S. Senate. Democrats winning control of the U.S. Senate was less consequential over, will be deemed less consequential over time than Democrats sweeping in Texas. I think that's true very briefly because Senate control, while there is a Republican in the White House, is really just about confirming judges. Not going to be that big a deal. In that sense, the House having a higher majority where they're not held hostage could actually be a big deal because of subpoenas and investigations. Fine. But if we're just looking at the Senate, that's really a judicial question.
21:29Sarah Isgur: Yeah, I mean, it matters, but not a huge amount. There weren't that many judges left. In Texas, this is going to be so important of whether the pendulum swings back or whether the logjam is broken because so many businesses have moved to Texas. So many people have moved to Texas because of what Texas was offering in terms of a business and economic climate. Democrats have a real option here to show how they can govern a state that offers that or to say, you know what? I'm going to lose reelection in four years anyway. So the only thing I really need to care about is my national profile. And what I need to do is make a lot of headlines so that I can run for president or whatever, because I'm not going to win re-election no matter what.
22:14Sarah Isgur: I think that would be a huge mistake. Huge. Not just for that Democrat, but for the Democratic Party, which, again, will not have broken the logjam. So, like, one of the first things that Governor-elect Hinojosa at least has said she's going to do is end school choice in Texas. I think that would be a huge mistake for Democrats. Now, it doesn't mean you can't change it or make it more, fair isn't the right word, better for the public schools to change the school choice program. But if you just get rid of it, that will be a signal, a bad signal in terms of logjam versus pendulum. But here's my real question to you.
22:53Elon Musk comes in in the last few weeks and spends$200,$300,$400,$500 million. I think there's a chart that showed that Elon Musk, since he entered the political scene, has now spent more money total to try to influence American politics than George Soros has spent over the entire course of his life.
23:11Sarah Isgur: So this cycle was$474 million total with$168 million in Texas. So my question, and I want to just repeat, every statewide race, including state Supreme Court justice, including the new business court that was, I mean, every one of them went Democratic. That's half a billion dollars flushed down the toilet. What does this do to the argument over Citizens United? Yes, I love this. Yeah. Okay. So since 2018, money has no longer been a predictor of who will win U.S. Senate races. In fact, in 2018, it was a reverse predictor. the person who had less money to spend was slightly more likely to win, but mostly it just was zero predictor at all.
24:01Sarah Isgur: And this time, I would like to say that, again, it was like reverse. Like the voters saw that this side was trying to buy their vote and rejected it. But I actually think it just didn't matter, if that makes sense. Like you can run all the ads you want, but at the end of the day, people are actually pretty smart. and maybe what we need to do is go back and look at the pre-times, I don't know, call it pre-2000 when we thought that television ads were so, so effective. What if that's when we were wrong? You know, what if we had some correlation versus causation there that we could go back and really pull apart now that we've seen this era?
24:42Sarah Isgur: But regardless, the idea that Citizens United has somehow corrupted our politics, I don't think it's just blown up because of Elon Musk, although, my God, it's going to be my talking point moving forward. But it's also, I think, you know, Citizens United was one of many very speech-protective cases that this court has done. Like, even if you disagree with Citizens United or you hate super PACs or whatever, it was a pro-First Amendment case protecting the First Amendment rights of, you know, People who wanted to put out a documentary criticizing a federal candidate for elected office within 90 days of a general election.
25:23Sarah Isgur: The government said, no, you can't have that speech within 90 days of a general election at all. Not allowed. No speech. And the Supreme Court said, yes, you can. So it's a speech protective case. And if it doesn't matter, then my God, shouldn't we have the speech protection? And you think about the ads, this cycle that we talked about the most, right? This is the ad in Ohio that Vivek Ramaswamy outside group ran. So Citizens United is what allowed that ad. It probably destroyed Ohio. For the GOP. For the GOP. And then, of course, the Michigan ad, which also an outside group also would have been likely banned by Citizens United.
26:11Sarah Isgur: And in that sense, Senator-elect Al-Sayed won, but he won by so much less than, I mean, James Tallarico in the red state of Texas. Yeah. And so again, it's funny. The idea that like the money buys politics, the money wins elections, the ads always help. In the two biggest ads of the cycle, the ads, I mean, I guess you could question it, but I would offer to unquestionably hurt the candidates and provided information to voters, even though they were from outside groups, that again, more speech is better. More speech provides more information. The fact that those candidates wouldn't condemn those ads, wouldn't walk away from those ads, like more speech gave us really important information, I think about those people and voters responded to it.
26:57You know, there's always been two arguments against Citizens United. One I have found so supremely unconvincing from the get-go. And then the other one would raise the eyebrow a tiny bit. Okay. So the one that was so unconvincing from the get-go to me was that Citizens Unite, money is not speech. That in other words, that what we're -
27:18Sarah Isgur: That's by the way, the title of my next panel that I'm moderating is money speech. David has decided. Okay. Well, we've decided, we both decided this and to use your own, to use one of your own analogies, right back at you. As imagine if you said, okay, well, we're going to protect gun rights, but nobody can spend more than$5 on a gun. Do you have gun rights? No, absolutely not. So if you highly regulate money, if you highly regulate the use of money to advance constitutional rights, you are regulating the right. I mean, to me, there's very little question about that. And so the idea that if you're a private corporation and you want to spend money to influence a political cause, that that is not a speech issue.
28:05That has always been incredibly unconvincing to me. And especially, you know, I always like to raise the exact context. This was about, can we market a documentary about a political figure right before that political figure's election? And if we know anything about the original purpose, meaning, understanding of the First Amendment, it's political speech. This thing was supposed to protect political speech. So the principled arguments, sort of the legalistic argument against it, I've always found it just not convincing at all. The smarter critics of it will say what we need is a, they'll acknowledge that and they'll say, but the effects of this are so profoundly bad that we need to amend the constitution to limit the application of the First Amendment to cash in political campaigns.
28:56And I think that this last 10 years in my mind refutes the pragmatic argument. The one that says that, well, even if the First Amendment does cover it as written, as understood currently, that on the law, that Citizens United was correct, the law just is going to create terrible outcomes in the real world. And so we need to change the law. And I think that from now on, one of my first talking points is going to be money buys elections like Elon Musk's half a billion dollars bought. Blue Texas. Now, as you said, it's not the case that money is irrelevant, especially in the low name ID election.
29:37Sarah Isgur: Right, although again, so generally speaking, once you hit a certain threshold, that's where we saw the money not mattering. So statewide races where they had plenty of money for ads, name ID was quite high. The money just didn't matter after you hit a certain amount of name ID. But in local races, mayors' races, congressional races, money could still make a difference because people actually just didn't know who the candidates were. And so the money was for voter education, basically. Any negative information was going to be the first information they heard. And so therefore, running some ad against your opponent would actually be really helpful that you wouldn't otherwise have money for.
30:13Sarah Isgur: Except, boy, Elon Musk spending all that money in Texas, again, actually kind of disproves that as well because he was spending money in a lot of those down-ballot races too. And it didn't, it again had the opposite. It might've just alerted the voters on the down ballot races to a new person to vote against. Yeah, yeah. Like they're, you know, I was saying this earlier today on the dispatch podcast that normally we're so used to these elections where they're close, where one ad like the they, them ad, could that have made a difference? Or was this messaging in this rural district important? or this one issue really changed it.
30:55And if we tweak this issue, it goes back to your curling analogy on politics that if the stone goes and the stone's gonna go and the sweepers have some ability to move the stone, speed it up, slow it down, whatever, but the stone's still generally gonna go where the stone is. When elections are really close, that sweeping really matters. When they're not close, you were looking at this And I was thinking, why are we talking about inflation, corruption, free speech, Iran war? It's all of it. It's all of it. And it snowballs. And it snowballed, exactly. And so in that context, I think this was an election where, as you were saying, because voters were so disgusted at a degree that I, going into it, did not see.
31:43I mean, I thought there was anger. I thought there was discontent. I did not see this coming. And if anyone in here predicted every statewide race in Texas would go to the Democrats, I'd love to meet you. Because there's a lot of questions I have about future basketball games. There's a lot to talk about.
32:02Sarah Isgur: A court deadline has a way of focusing everyone's attention. There's a document to finish, a client waiting for an answer, and a clock that doesn't care what else is happening. But if you run a small law firm, the deadline on the case isn't the only one that matters. Payday still comes around. A good system lets the team stay focused on the clients without treating every payroll or HR detail like an emergency. That's where Gusto comes in. Gusto is online payroll and benefits software built for small businesses. It's all-in-one, remote-friendly, and incredibly easy to use, so you can pay, hire, onboard, and support your team from anywhere.
32:37Sarah Isgur: Gusto helps simplify payroll with an automatic tax filing and unlimited payroll runs for one monthly price, without hidden fees and surprises. Try Gusto today at gusto.com slash advisory and get three months free when you run your first payroll. That's three months of free payroll at gusto.com slash advisory. One more time, gusto.com slash advisory. Okay, David, we have a few minutes left and two important things to get to. One is this question from a high school teacher that I think you guys are going to be into. Oh, you're going to like this. But before we get to that, the legal issues on free speech that are going to dominate the next two years prediction.
33:23Free speech issue number one to dominate the next two years, regulation of social media. I think that is an area where you're going to see a lot of bipartisan buy-in. You just had an 11th Circuit case that was upholding Florida's ban on social media for, was it 14 and under? I can't remember exactly.
33:41Sarah Isgur: It was, yeah, 13, 14, and then 15 up, I think. Or maybe it's 14, 15. Yeah, no, sorry. It's 14, 15, and then 16 and up. Yes, but they didn't say no Facebook. Correct. What they said was no infinite scroll, no sort of, all the characteristics of social media were banned. Social media wasn't banned, and the 11th Circuit upheld it. Without your parents' permission. Yes, without your parents' permission. And the 11th Circuit upheld it. And I do think that the regulation of social media and the regulation of artificial intelligence and the content of artificial intelligence is going to be the next frontier because we have a lot of bipartisan buy-in on social media bad, AI bad, do something government.
34:28it. And whenever you have that very, very strong impulse this bad, you do something about it. That's when your free speech alerts should be going off. And so I think the next big consequential free speech fight is going to be over the extent to which social media can be regulated, particularly with regards to children.
34:53Sarah Isgur: This sounds pretty bad for free speech though. Yes. It has the potential, I think, to be very bad. I believe it does have the potential to be very bad, especially as you begin to get into a panic. So, you know, we have - It's sort of interesting, like most free speech restrictions, when I think about them, are to try to maintain power, right? It is one side saying, we have won this debate and I'm not going to have any more debate about it because I'm going to hold on to my win. Or I literally been elected. I mean, and this is the John Adams version, right? I've been elected and I don't want you to criticize me because I'd like to stay in power.
35:29Sarah Isgur: The social media fight is different than that. It does not seem to be, to me, viewpoint or even content-based. I think it's both. I think that whatever faction does not control social media is very panicked about power in social media. So I do think that that is, because the incredible reach and power of all of these privately held social media companies for a lot of people, it feels like government censorship almost, if they're blocked, if they're deplatformed, if they're demonetized, whatever you want to talk about. It has that feel because you're dealing with large, immense multinational companies.
36:11It feels like government censorship without being it. So then people will try to appeal to the government to do something about that. And that becomes very much a power issue. But it's also, and I think this is the area in which the free speech issue is going to become particularly dangerous. It's also being deemed a public health issue. And remember, we had a lot of free speech issues around COVID. Why? Because of the public health argument. And so if we begin to have the public health argument on platforms that are nothing if not speech, their speech, that's what they are, that's where I can see some real issues.
36:49But I'm very interested in sort of the way in which Florida did it. The way in which Florida did it was not, as I said, by banning Facebook, not by banning memes, not by banning like influencer photographs where the person is turned into Brooke Shields when they're really, quite frankly, not. You know, all of that. It's none of that. Brooke Shields is your go-to there? Yeah, sorry. I'm my, I'm, forgive me, Sarah.
37:16Sarah Isgur: 1985 called it, wanted to pin up girls back. You know how old I am, but anyway. Literally no updated reference for 40 years. That's impressive. I mean, you know, there's a few. Can you name a current actress? Is Brookshild not a current actress? Nope. Oh, okay. Maybe not, who knows? But the - I'll give you a hint. She's in an ad about sports betting.
37:49Every now and then my deficiencies are exposed in a live podcast. But if you're concerned about, so it's taking the approach of we're not gonna ban the content. We're not gonna ban any viewpoint, but we're gonna ban the way in which the content, or we're gonna limit and regulate the way in which the content is presented. Again, back to the infinite scroll, the likes, all of this stuff. That is going to be a very interesting, and I think it's going to be a free speech issue that a lot of us in the, and I'm just going to go ahead and make some assumptions that there's a we here in the free speech community at a FIRE conference.
38:25Let me just go ahead and make that assumption. A lot of us might have some differences on the margins and on the edges of this one. I think it's going to be very interesting.
38:34Sarah Isgur: Okay, time for the question from the high school teacher. I'm a high school math teacher, and I have a question about an incident that happened at my school two years ago. Our school is very diverse, both politically and culturally. You will see a few kids wearing MAGA hats, but you also saw vote for Kamala Buttons. Normally, no one cares, and the school historically hasn't prevented students from political expression. This is like the best law school hypothetical. But it's not a high vote. Is this real? It's real. During the 2024 campaign, two students at lunch walked around with a large Confederate flag advocating white replacement theory ideology.
39:10Sarah Isgur: It was overt and was crystal clear that they were advocating for white nationalism, but they didn't use any offensive words or even hint at violence. As you would expect, this blew up and became the talk of the school and the town. The school suspended the students for five days. They also referred them for expulsion. The expulsion ended up being moot because the two students decided to switch to homeschool because they were worried they would constantly get assaulted. I have it on good authority that an administrator told one of the student's mothers that they would do their best, but there is just no way they will be able to keep their son safe.
39:46Sarah Isgur: My question is, was the school legally in the right? Is there a limit to how offensive a sincerely held view can be where a school could engage in legitimate viewpoint discrimination? That's a great question. Okay. So I would say the only way the school, because we've talked about this and the substantial disruption prong of Pinker, Pinker Tinker. Gosh. Okay. Which explain just a little bit more what that is. So essentially in Tinker v. Des Moines School District, a young kid comes in during the Vietnam War, and he has a black armband on to protest the Vietnam War. And he was faced discipline for that because, you know, it was going to make other students upset.
40:31It was a political statement that would make other students upset. And the Supreme Court, in the very famous words, said, you don't abandon your rights at the schoolhouse gate. Neither teachers nor students abandon their rights at the schoolhouse gate. And that you're going to have an opportunity to speak as a student in a public school, but you cannot create, your speech cannot create substantial material disruption to the educational environment. Because the obvious purpose is, if you're in a math class, it is math. And if the speech means you can't be teaching math, but then that raises a question, what is the disruption you're talking about?
41:04So is it the inherent disruption of the speech? In other words, rather than wearing a black armband, I think if I walked into the math class and I had a megaphone and I started chanting, you know, no blood for oil or whatever. I'm using dated references.
41:17Sarah Isgur: Again, what? I'm so sorry. At least we've made it into the century, I guess. Yeah, I mean, I'm gradually approaching 2026, Sarah. Okay. So you're screaming and yelling about, you know, no blood for oil, stick with me. Okay. Then, yes, that's obviously a disruption because I am drowning people out. I'm preventing the teacher from speaking. easy call. What if I walk in and it's the black armband and there is a kid in there whose father was killed in action six months before and they attack the student who wore the black armband. Is that a substantial, there's obviously a disruption, but is that a substantial disruption that would lead to censorship?
42:03And my argument has always been no, because if you're rooting the disruption in the response to the speech and not in the nature of the disruptive nature of the speech itself, you're creating a heckler's veto on campus. And you're also then unlearning liberty to use the fire fearless leader, Greg's previous, one of his previous books. You're teaching the kids to unlearn liberty by teaching them that, yeah, if they're angry enough, if they're mad enough, if they're violent enough in the worst, they can stop the speech that they don't like. So my answer to this is actually pretty simple. That is a protected shirt unless, and the only way it is not, is if it would meet the test for Title VI racial harassment.
42:47If it met the test of severity and pervasiveness that deprives the student of the ability to receive the benefit of the educational program, if that is a Title VI violation, properly understood. Totally separate. Okay. So my view would be, no, you have to, as the government, say, look, you can't assault somebody for a T-shirt. Sorry, you cannot do that. No matter what their T-shirt says, you cannot assault them for their T-shirt, period. You can debate them for their T-shirt. You can hate them for their T-shirt. You cannot assault them for their T-shirt. And if you do assault them for their T-shirt, that's not a substantial disruption that will merit censorship.
43:32Sarah Isgur: Okay, so you have described the First Amendment as you would like it to be. I'm not sure you have described the First Amendment as the Supreme Court currently sees it. So let me start from the extreme side of this, which is where the school started, which is suspending and moving to expel students because of speech that was not violent and not disruptive, again, according to how this was described. To the extent someone knows the rest of this story and it turns out whatever, like, I don't know. I'm going by - Yeah, we're just going by the email. That's right. We're going by this hypothetical slash real story as it was presented.
44:11Sarah Isgur: There is no question that the school has no ability to suspend or expel a student for their speech. That, very easy under current, former, any First Amendment jurisprudence I am possibly aware of, even if you weakened it down, you know, and diluted it with all of the, you know, chicken stock. Where I think you might be wishful side versus current reality side is whether the school can say, put away the Confederate flag, we're in math class. Like, I'm sorry, sir, this is a Wendy's. Yeah. And that that's based on the substantial disruption that it will cause in the classroom where you have worn something, you know, you knew it was going to cause a disruption.
44:58Sarah Isgur: I don't think that's necessarily necessary to the analysis, but there's not much question that that's why they did it and what they did. And so if it is causing, if your shirt is causing a disruption in class, maybe it's because it has that certain actress who was in the sports ad, and maybe it's just a picture of her holding the footballs, that would also cause a substantial disruption in math class. I think the math teacher can ask you to take both t-shirts off. But my actual response to that is that that school is on the superhighway to school uniforms. Because this is the way they cut the Gordian knot is they essentially say, okay, look, this is why we can't have nice things.
45:41Because you walked into the room with the Confederate flag shirt on and you put us in this impossible box. That was evil. That was bad. But it was speech. Well, guess what? But I mean, this goes back to the college dorm door, the college flags out of the college windows at public universities where somebody unfurls that Confederate flag. And then the next thing you know, it's like no flags for anybody. No t-shirts for anybody. And that's the way they cut that knot.
46:10Sarah Isgur: Nothing's wrong with, sorry, someone said, what's wrong with uniforms? Nothing, but we're not having uniforms because you think it's necessarily good for the students. You're having uniforms because we can't have speech because students can't control themselves. I'm not saying anything. As a parent of three kids, when you're thinking school uniforms make pre-shopping, school shopping, so easy, like it's the best, you know? And so there's a lot of reasons for school uniforms, but this is what I'm saying is there are ways to deal with these issues that don't involve viewpoint discrimination. So, but my version of this though, which I think is different than yours, is that the substantial disruption doesn't have to be caused by the student.
46:53Sarah Isgur: That the student, by wearing the shirt, if they cause a substantial disruption in the classroom because of a heckler's veto, like, I don't love this, right? But yes, it is that the other students get a heckler's veto. If they are all disrupted because now they feel like they need to tell you why your shirt is offensive to them and that you are morally reprehensible, we are not learning calculus. And that the school can step up and say, you know what? we are not having this conversation right now. We're not interested in this conversation right now. So we are going to censor your speech during curricular time.
47:26Sarah Isgur: Now, could they do that at lunch? Like, could they say you have to take the t-shirt off, but then at lunch you can put it back on because that's your time? Maybe, although this gets into some details. Again, I'm not sure a school has to do that because while you don't shed your First Amendment rights at the schoolhouse door, they are limited because, again, you are in school and the school is able to run their school without just everyone running around, you know, pew, pew, random thought. If there are four SCOTUS justices listening to this current podcast, I'm begging you to take this issue. Not this necessarily, this case, but this is crying out for resolution.
48:01We had a case involving, there were only two genders, T-shirt out of the First Circuit that I really wanted the Supreme Court to take because that was a heckler's veto. I worried about a heckler's veto type speech suppression.
48:14Sarah Isgur: When our first was about a year old, I thought it'd be really funny to put him in a large shopping bag. The picture we got is of a very confused little baby looking really adorable in this huge bag, and it's those little moments that tend to disappear into a camera roll, even when they're the ones we most want to remember. Aura Frames can bring those everyday photos out of your phone and into your home, where the whole family can actually enjoy them. Aura Frames can bring those everyday photos out of your phone and into your home. The little moments in life are worth remembering. You can do that with Aura Frames.
48:47Sarah Isgur: Aura is the number one digital frame loved by millions of families, and their Black Friday Cyber Monday deal is the best of the year. For a limited time, visit AuraFrames.com and get up to$50 off select frames, plus an additional$5 off your order with the promo code ADVISORY. That's A-U-R-A frames dot com promo code advisory. Support the show by mentioning us at checkout. Terms and conditions apply. And now we will open it up for questions. Please wait for the microphone to come to you so that we can get it on the podcast. I'm Michael Myers, president of the New York Civil Rights Coalition. My question to David is the question of fighting words.
49:33and free speech by people who use ***, for example, towards a person. Are there no exceptions to free speech? I thought the courts said fighting words are an exception and people have a right to deny people the free speech and call them a ***. I think, I will honestly say, I think Fighting Words has been, and this might be, this would be a fun law review article, actually. Wait, did I just say fun law review article? I think Fighting Words has essentially been subsumed by the harassment analysis. So the fighting words doctrine arose before Title VI, Title VII, Title IX. And it talks about something that is very, very real, and that is very extremely provocative, individually directed speech.
50:35That that is something that, you know, pre-civil rights era, this was how the law accommodated the sort of very, the reality that human beings, when encountering extreme verbal, personally directed verbal aggression, that there are consequences that come from that, that that is not the sort of this, if you're talking about the purpose of the First Amendment, the meaning of the First Amendment, this kind of extremely provocative, individually directed speech. And the reason why I tie that to harassment is I think that one of the best ways to understand the difference between free speech and harassment came from a mutual friend of, I think, a bunch of people in this room, Eugene Volokh.
51:21And he talked about one-to-many speech and one-to-one speech. So that if you are, and to use an analogy, I'm going to get modern. Okay, so let's imagine you're in the quad of the campus and you say, stop the genocide in Gaza. And you're saying, or Palestine, from the river to the sea, Palestine shall be free or globalize the Intifada, which are both arguably calls for violence, that that, even though they're calls for violence, that they are going to be absolutely, totally protected. But if you take an individual Jewish student and you follow them around campus going from the river to the sea, from a river to the sea, you're using the same words, but instead of one-to-many, it is a one-to-one interaction that is designed to provoke, enrage, et cetera.
52:13And that's when you're gonna start to get into the Title VI arena. And so I do think that the fighting words concept is dead. You just don't find, there haven't been many cases about this at all. I think it has been replaced by an anti-harassment regime that is just a separate test entirely.
52:32Sarah Isgur: Okay, shorter answers. Sorry. But that was a big question. I've enjoyed you guys for years. You have a great chemistry. I'm curious. What's something each of you has learned from the other? Could be just general about interactions, but a legal something could be fun too. Too many to list. Gosh. I learn stuff from you all the time. It's actually deeply frustrating sometimes because I think I'll know what you're going to say and then you say something like different and smarter and I'm like, damn it, that's why David's like so important. I'm gonna say I've probably learned more about politics from Sarah, like just keeping it like in the professional world that we live in.
53:14Like I've probably learned more about politics from Sarah than anybody I've known, honestly. I will tell you that the curling analogy that she uses has like dominated my mind for so long. And it's so funny because I used it to begin a times piece. And one of your friends was reading it and they're like, that's Sarah Isger. And then she looked up and saw it was by me and knew that I was gonna, and I did attribute it to you very, very clearly. But I mean, that's just one example. But I would say, you know, I have learned so much. And then I think on the personal side, Sarah is a big hearted human being who is a wonderful friend to people.
53:57And I think one of the things that's just wonderful about like...
54:02Sarah Isgur: I'm trying to see when I can cut this off. This is... But anyway, those are two things. I just cut it off. Sorry. For some reason, that question just, I went back to... I was driving on GW Parkway next to my favorite willow trees, the Potomac River and like the Washington Monument, the Lincoln Memorial. And I picked up the phone and I called you about an ethical question. that I had a fundamental life question. And we didn't even know each other that well yet. We'd only been on the podcast six months maybe by that point that I was calling you. And I remember thinking like, this is someone who I'm gonna like for the rest of our lives.
54:41Sarah Isgur: Isn't that kind of weird? Yeah. Like we will be. Okay, next question. Enough bushy stuff. Also a long time. Ayo listener, although I'm still annoyed at David for making me subscribe to the New York Times. I'm so sorry. But thank you. Both of you have spoken about and written about constitutional amendments that you'd like to see at least considered. Do you think the midterms will open the Overton window for a discussion of any of your proposals? I think the only thing we lack is sort of the imagination to get something in the bloodstream a little. I actually think, for instance, the pardon amendment that we've talked about, where a president would need to have the advice and consent of the Senate before a pardon becomes effective, would be very easy for this Congress to pass on a bipartisan basis.
55:33Sarah Isgur: I think it would get ratified by all the states needed in pretty quick order. Yeah. But it just doesn't have a lot of attention and no one's thinking about it. that being said, maybe when President Trump leaves office and issues a lot of pardons, that would lead more people to talk about it. But I think it's only a lack of sort of imagination and attention at this point, because I think people are hungry right now, given that they just saw that their vote mattered on Tuesday, that there's going to be people saying like, yeah, so let's like amend some stuff. Let's like get in there and like do things.
56:09Sarah Isgur: Ending partisan gerrymandering is an easy one that doesn't even need an amendment, for instance. I will be curious, Democrats bragged about how they had, bragged, that's maybe pejorative, but like Democrats had said that they had tried to ban partisan gerrymandering and it was blocked by Republicans, but it was not a standalone bill. It was this whole, you know - HR1 monster. Yeah, which they knew Republicans couldn't agree to. If they did it as a standalone bill, I think Republicans would be very on board. Tell your Indiana thing. Oh, Indiana. So this is amazing. So Indiana, remember, they were trying to gerrymander to essentially eliminate Democratic representation from the state.
56:47And a few Republican senators, state senators, blocked the gerrymander. And then all but maybe one lost their primary. Had that gerrymander taken place, Indiana would be bright blue. That it was not, it was a dummymander, to use the term. My Times colleague, Jamel Bowie, uses that. And you saw this in North Carolina, North Carolina.
57:10Sarah Isgur: North Carolina. I mean, but also Texas tried to push back on this. It is a shame that they gave into it, but plenty of people in Texas knew this was a mistake. So, which is all to say, I think you could have bipartisan support in Congress for that too, because plenty of members realize that there's this partisan fever that takes hold that causes these dummy manders. Well, and I think of it like this. I completely agree with Sarah about the pardon power, and I would love to see a concerted effort at that. I I would love it. And I think it's the perfect, perfect first amendment to try to push to reopen the amendment process.
57:42And I would look at it like this. Think of it as this wave one of the new democratic majority is going to be all centered around holding the Trump administration accountable. It's gonna be centered around like setting forth a legislative agenda that they could run on in 2028. But there's gonna be a wave two. And wave two, I think it'd be important for those of us who speak into the public square to say, make some systemic changes that both sides can agree on to end, to help get us past this period of stagnation. And the pardon power is one. Partisan gerrymandering is another one. I think there's a lot that could be done you could get some bipartisan buy-in on.
58:19Sarah Isgur: Okay, can we get two more questions asked and then we're going to answer them so that we don't run out of time? Actually, no, three. Let's do three questions. We're going to spend a minute on each one. Another longtime listener. Appreciate you guys so much. Um, you have spoken to the influence of money on election outcomes or lack thereof, right? That money doesn't necessarily buy an outcome in election. But I think what a lot of people are concerned about is the influence after the lawmaker is elected, a sort of quid pro quo. And I'm curious about your thoughts on Maine's solution to money in politics, not limiting how much money super PACs can spend on campaigns, but how much individuals can donate.
59:01Sarah Isgur: two super PACs and whether you think that could withstand constitutional scrutiny. Okay, two more questions. Thank you. So as you were breaking down the t-shirts, all I could think of was the ghost of Justice Black. And this is the same person, remember, from this morning that Nico was talking about, the free speech absolutist, the greatest civil libertarian ever, in Tinker, saying, what are we even doing here, to quote David French? So is that evidence of Tinker's unworkability ultimately? Are we working on a false premise? Okay, good, good. Loving these. Last one. I'm going to go such a different direction that you may not want to answer it.
59:48Sarah Isgur: So I'm from Georgia and we had the exact same result as Texas. I'm not convinced that Georgia is blue, just like I'm not convinced that Texas is blue. I believe that Trump and the war and his conduct was the unifying thing in this election. He said he'd vote like I'm on the ballot, and I think people did. And so I want to go to two years from now when things are back in play and to an issue that has been a big one in the past, and that's the Electoral College. We're just talking about that. What we can do about the Electoral College. I pitched something to Pete Buttigieg a couple of years ago of trying to have a statewide effort to have all 50 states go to proportional voting for the Electoral College because we only have a handful right now that do that, which would come close.
1:00:42Sarah Isgur: But I don't know that that would be doable or what other things would be doable, but I'd like to ask you. Okay, we have less than a minute. Answer to the first question. We have a panel right after this that is going to go so into the weeds on this with Professor Lawrence Lessig, who is actually one of the attorneys and Harvard Law professor who has helped do this. So I feel like we're going to spend literally an hour on this starting in five minutes. So I'm holding that question. You do tinker. So on tinker, is it unworkable? I think tinker is unworkable so long as you have the heckler's veto.
1:01:16I think that makes it unworkable. If it is rooted around the nature of the expression as literally disrupting the class, I think it's unworkable. framework.
1:01:25Sarah Isgur: Okay, great. Last thing on the Electoral College. We're going to run on time. Punctuality is a sign of respect. Okay, on the Electoral College, there's this interstate compact where if you get to 270 states that would represent 270 electoral votes, that they would go to the national popular vote. I think that's a huge mistake just politically. And I think that Democrats think that would help them yesterday. I don't know that they think that today. And so I don't think it'll happen because anytime you do that, some state will then break away when all of a sudden it doesn't help them. So that's a bad idea.
1:02:03Sarah Isgur: The idea of going to a proportional vote, I'm wildly in favor of the Nebraska-Main system, where, yes, you have your two Senate votes from the Electoral College. That goes to whoever wins the state. but your congressional votes in the Electoral College are split up by the proportion of how the state went. I see no downside to that. I love that one. And I also love expand the house. Which would be the same. Expand the house. Very similar effect. Very similar effect. States would then be represented in the Electoral College at a far more nuanced level, basically. Okay. Thank you guys so, so much.
1:02:40Sarah Isgur: And thank you, fire.
1:02:50We'll be right back.
Sarah Isgur and David French analyze the last three election cycles as influenced by free speech issues, from Donald Trump’s “they/them” ad as an effective closing argument in 2024 to contentious campus speech and protests and the Trump administration’s threats to social media companies. The two also discuss the next free speech fight in the last two years of the Trump administration.
The Agenda:
–Free speech highlights from the last few years
–Talarico and Texas
– The consequential side of Callais
–The next free speech fight
–A math teacher’s legal question
–Audience Q&A
Show Notes:
–We’re hiring! Apply here.
–Come see us in Austin! Or come see us in Houston!
–Murthy v. Missouri
–Divided We Fall
–Tinker v. Des Moines Independent Community School District
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices