

The episode debates whether “lame duck” senators should confirm judges after an election, using a Texas blue-slip dispute as the hook. Topic: Senate advice-and-consent ethics in lame-duck periods; blue-slip prerogatives; Supreme Court cert denials; First Amendment compelled speech and firearms “sensitive places”; a Fourth Circuit leak case; and a listener proposal to remove/alter the presidential veto.
Sarah Isgur and David French (hosts). No other guests are interviewed.
Senators should generally “do your job” and serve out their term, but may consider clear democratic mandates in extreme cases; independence is fine only if exercised wisely. Blue slips are defended as a good-faith deference mechanism, especially for minority/White House opposition, but criticized when used for personal/political aggrandizement. Justice Thomas’s “sensitive places” approach demands close historical analogues; Gorsuch/Thomas/Alito are portrayed as speech-protective in a CME compelled-bias case.
Cruz vs. Cornyn over Elliot Geyser (Assistant AG, OLC) and a missing blue slip; Bozeman blocking Eighth Circuit nominee Lee Rudofsky; Maryland “Sensitive Places” firearms cert denial; California CME implicit-bias compelled speech (Shurtleff discussion); LinkedIn metadata order in a classified-leak case (Judge Wilkinson); listener idea to remove the presidential veto or make it overrideable by simple majority.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Discussion on the lengthy process involved in judicial nominations.
“Now, this has to do with a nominee coming out of the Northern District of Texas.”
A detailed account of the conflict between Senators Cruz and Cornyn regarding judicial nominations.
“The original nominee for the seat, Aaron Neely Cox, sits in limbo for a very, very long time, eventually takes the chief legal officer position at Walmart.”
Cornyn's strong accusation towards Cruz highlights the tension in the Senate.
“the floor of the Senate on Wednesday afternoon.”
Exploration of whether senators should act on nominations after a significant election.
“reporters in the press gallery can hear it i don't find you credible i'm mad at you That's Cornyn.”
Discussion on representative democracy and the responsibilities of elected officials.
“And I don't think there's an easy, simple answer to this.”
Examination of the Senate's constitutional role in confirming judicial nominees and state representation.
“And the next folks will do that as well.”
Discussion on the balance of power between Congress and the President regarding judicial nominations.
“And wisely, in the context of Judge Rudofsky, I think it's not been wise at all.”
Explore the intricate relationship between the presidency and the Senate in judicial nominations, including the blue slip process.
“The power to declare war, the power to raise and collect imports and duties, you know, commerce clause, general welfare, right?”
Discuss the implications of Donald Trump's lame duck status on judicial nominations and the impact of recent withdrawals.
“The president has nominated someone for that Eighth Circuit seat.”
Analyze the Supreme Court's decision regarding firearm regulations in sensitive places and the implications for First Amendment rights.
“All right, David, first up, the Supreme Court denied cert in the Maryland Sensitive Places case.”
A deep dive into the nuances of legal citations and their implications.
“There's like close to a dozen citations in this string site, but Blackstone is first.”
Discussion on a recent dissent related to compelled speech and First Amendment rights.
“All right, David, I want to get to this other descent from the denial of certiorari.”
Analysis of a case involving government requests for journalist metadata.
“Judge Harvey Wilkinson, the one, the only, has another barn burner out.”
Explore the complexities of government leak investigations and the balancing of First Amendment rights with governmental interests.
“I suppose, if you were going to investigate a leak investigation, went to LinkedIn and was like, yeah, we'd like to see that reporter's metadata on LinkedIn for the last 18 months.”
Discuss the implications of overbroad subpoenas and the difficulties in drawing the line in legal investigations.
“I was I was thinking into my veins, as the kids would say.”
Debate listener suggestions on altering presidential powers and improving congressional effectiveness.
“All right, David, I want to leave you with a email from a listener with an idea.”
Examine how state governance structures may provide insights into federal governance and constitutional amendments.
“In some ways, some of these states maybe function better.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On Advisory Opinions, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00You ready? I was born ready.
0:18Sarah Isgur: Welcome to Advisory Opinions. I'm Sarah Isgur and that's David French and we are going to have a beautiful podcast today, David. Gorgeous. Just gorgeous. Gorgeous. A little confirmation hearings. You know, what's constitutional? What's moral? What's ethical? What does representative government really mean? And then we've got cert denials from the Supreme Court and statements and dissents from denial of cert. A little Wilkinson First Amendment national security, the audacity of the American experiment. And a proposal from a listener about the veto power that I think you're going to be super into.
0:58All this and more on Advisory Opinions.
1:04Okay, David, I want to start with this story coming from my home state, Texas,
1:13Sarah Isgur: Senator Cruz versus Senator Cornyn. Now, this has to do with a nominee coming out of the Northern District of Texas. And by way of background, and I don't think anyone wants to spend that much time on the details here, but let's back up. The last thing that's going to happen for a nominee is the confirmation vote on the floor of the Senate. That's your advice and consent. That's in the Constitution. Everything before that, though, is going to be really in the weeds. So the thing before that is you get voted out of committee. The thing before that is the committee hearing. The thing before that is going to include like getting brought up to the committee, a blue slip in the case of a district court nominee.
1:54Sarah Isgur: In order to even get to that point, you're talking about an FBI background check, your FJQs, that's your Senate Judiciary questionnaire, your financial disclosure report. It takes a long time, right? There is a long runway to get to this point. So when the election happens, the Northern District of Texas seat has been, it's been a journey, David. The original nominee for the seat, Aaron Neely Cox, sits in limbo for a very, very long time, eventually takes the chief legal officer position at Walmart. Then we go through a whole series of things. Anyway, election day happens, and we don't have a nominee.
2:33Sarah Isgur: And all of a sudden, we don't have someone who has all of that runway taken care of. So Senator Cruz has an idea. What about Elliot Geyser? Now, Elliot Geyser is the former Solicitor General of Ohio, not Texas. But he's the Assistant Attorney General for the Office of Legal Counsel, which means he had an FBI background check 15 months ago. And so instead of doing the 10-year FBI background check and the 10-year financial disclosure and all that. He just needs the 15-month update. It's like the booster shot, if you will. Much faster to do. So they just go nuts, all-nighters everywhere to turn around his paperwork.
3:24Sarah Isgur: Fast forward to Wednesday, when the Senate Judiciary Committee has its last hearing of the year. Elliot Geyser is not brought up. Why? Because Senator Cornyn does not turn in his blue slip, and that's a no-go. That's the end. Home state senators have to turn in the blue slip for judicial district court nominees. We've gotten rid of the blue slip for the circuit courts. Obviously, there is nothing for the Supreme Court. So, David, we now have reporting from the floor of the Senate on Wednesday afternoon. Basically, they are screaming so loudly at each other that it is heard to the point of being quoted in the press gallery.
4:06So this is Cruz and Cornyn, the two senators themselves.
4:10Sarah Isgur: Right. So remember, Cruz suggests the Solicitor General of Ohio. And Cornyn's like, dude, we have a committee. It's called F-Check, where they interview people. They recommend people to us. We recommend people to the White House. That's what sets off this whole series of things. And obviously, this Ohio dude didn't do it. Okay, quotes. and david i just love the italics in this to let us know where the emphasis was okay this is cornyn yelling at cruz wait do we need to like get in somebody and have one of our advisory opinions plays honestly we kind of do and remember this is loud enough that the reporters in the press gallery can hear it i don't find you credible i'm mad at you That's Cornyn.
5:02Sarah Isgur: That's Cornyn to Cruz. Then it's garbled. They can't quite hear what the lead up to this is. But, you know, something, something, I'm super mad, quote, for ending my career. Now, what's interesting about this is, of course, your head's immediately going to Donald Trump. Donald Trump, at a very pivotal moment in this primary, well, in the runoff, endorses Ken Paxton. when we all thought he was going to endorse John Cornyn. And in fact, there was some reporting that he was going to endorse John Cornyn and changes his mind. But David, this forgets actually a very important moment in Senate history, which is when Ted Cruz wins election in 2012, remember he's like the Tea Party guy, right?
5:47Sarah Isgur: He reads green eggs and ham on the floor to stop Obamacare and that whole thing that made him very popular with the Tea Party, very unpopular with his colleagues. Well, do Senate terms in six, right? So like John Cornyn, 2026, he's up, which means 2020, which means also 2014. That's two years after the junior senator from Texas is elected. Ted Cruz did not endorse John Cornyn in 2014. And there's a lot of people who believe that that's when John Cornyn sort of street cred with the conservative base fell apart, et cetera, etc. And it was this like inappropriate move for a junior senator. So the quote for ending my career very plausibly could refer to either one.
6:35Sarah Isgur: And then Cruz says something back to him and Cornyn says, oh, that's bullshit. Okay. So David, I raise all this because it's one of those like old school DC moments for sure. But also it raises questions about what is appropriate in a lame duck session. The American people just eviscerated the Republican Party. So should Republican senators be voting to confirm judges when the American people have just said, we don't want you doing anything? On the flip side, the people who elected these guys to office, John Cornyn in 2020, for for instance, they didn't elect him for five years and 10 months. They elected him for a six-year term.
7:20Sarah Isgur: So shouldn't he finish out his term? What is the right way to think about the advice and consent role constitutionally, morally, ethically? Yeah, I think it's a really good question. Very good. And I don't think there's an easy, simple answer to this. So this is my best stab at thinking it through in the moment, which is, I would say you do your job, you serve out your term as you. In other words, as the person you were elected, you were elected to be. So if I'm elected to be John Cornyn and I, one of John things that John Cornyn does is he does, he goes by the regular rules of order on blue slips and judicial, you know, judicial nominations, et cetera, then be John Cornett.
8:09But that goes to kind of my theory of representative democracy is that you're not electing issue bot 9 ,000 who just spits out whatever you want him, that he's essentially your marionette, your puppet. Because the reality is you're electing somebody who's going to be involved in an incredible array of issues, 90 % of which you've never thought about. He's going to encounter new issues that were not on your brain and mind at all when you were voting. And so you really are electing a person, a human to stand in for you. And that's their job until their job is over. So that's my view of representative democracy, which also helps explain why I'm so keen on higher character, because you're putting trust in this person to make judgment calls.
8:57So I said, do your job, but what's the but? But I think there are circumstances where it is abundantly clear, say, for example, that there's a vote against the war, you know, a vote against a particular policy. It's very clear. It's very abundantly clear. Should you, in your capacity of being John Cornyn or being Sarah Isger until your term is up, not take that into account at all? That feels like a bridge too far to me. But when we're talking about things like district court nominations, et cetera, that's just the nuts and bolts of governing. Keep doing it until your job is done. And the next folks will do that as well.
9:39And just I just but it's a great question. Okay.
9:43Sarah Isgur: Let me add another dimension to this. Yes. Elliot Geiser is the assistant attorney general for the office of legal counsel in the Department of Justice. He was the former solicitor general of Ohio. John Cornyn's whole beef is like, this guy's not from Texas. Mind you, his wife, who is just the most incredible human, is very much from Texas, from Dallas. Her whole family's in Dallas. They had talked about moving back to Texas after this job regardless. They got married in Austin, I think. He clerked for Judge Edith Jones. Yes, my judge on the Fifth Circuit. So he has Texas ties, but he is not licensed to practice in the state of Texas.
10:20Sarah Isgur: He has not practiced in the state of Texas. So, you know, the ties are weak, but they're there. The other part of this is Senate prerogative. The Senate has a constitutional role in the advice and consent process. And we saw this, of course, most recently with the Eighth Circuit nominee. The White House nominates District Judge Lee Rudofsky to the Eighth Circuit, and Senator Bozeman blocks him. Why? As the Wall Street Journal said, quite pithily, I think, sounds personal, period. That was the whole sentence. Got to appreciate good writing when you see it. But the idea that Senator Bozeman's trying to sell and that now Senator Cornyn's trying to sell is, I'm a senator.
11:07Sarah Isgur: I look out for my state. I don't care what the White House wants. I don't care what the White House pick is. It's my pick. This is my prerogative, and this is a legislative function. So David set aside the lame duck thing. How much, I mean, how much, despite me talking about us talking about impeachment, oversight, appropriations, all of the ways in which the legislature can check the presidency, how much is this an appropriate way to check the presidency? I'm not going to confirm your nominee because I want my dude. Yeah. So I'm a believer in, I mean, Sarah, how many times have we said to Congress, do your job?
11:51It's just a consistent theme of advisory opinions. It's probably said more times than you've mocked my age. And that's saying something. That is saying, that's a high bar. We cannot be hypocritical about this. Congress, do your job. And I like the concept of senators exercising independence, but it's always got to be subject to the Spider-Man principle, which is with great power comes great responsibility. So yes, yes, exercise independence. Do it wisely. And wisely, in the context of Judge Rudofsky, I think it's not been wise at all. If you look at the person that he wanted, this is a person who, as Josh Blackman reported in the Volokh conspiracy, made some highly improper comments to law students out there in public, highly improper, about his communications to the White House regarding the circuit court seat.
12:51Really unusual stuff that demonstrates terrible judgment. And so that person is your dude? I think you flunked the Spider-Man rule here because Lee Rudofsky is an incredibly respected jurist. He is somebody who has respect of peers outside, who is a conservative jurist of the highest quality, highest integrity person, and also just really has the respect of people who are inside and outside of the quote unquote tribe of conservative jurists. And so just to say no to that because of my dude. Yeah, I like that you have senatorial independence and you feel free to exercise it against the White House.
13:37Now do it intelligently. Don't do it foolishly.
13:41Sarah Isgur: David, I don't know if I have a rant that's about to pour out of my mouth, but let's see what's about to happen. Sarah, I'm here for it. I'm here for it. I'm just not sure. So Congress has all sorts, they're Article I. Yeah. Their powers, while limited, are also listed and they are big. The power to declare war, the power to raise and collect imports and duties, you know, commerce clause, general welfare, right? These are huge powers that also check the president. And again, then there's the impeachment power, an enormous power to check the president. You know what doesn't strike me as a power to check the president at all?
14:27Sarah Isgur: A thing that actually originates with the president in Article 2, which is the power to nominate judges. I get that the Senate has an advice and consent power, and they should exercise it with good judgment across the board, especially with cabinet members for what it's worth. And yes, with judges who have life tenure, I do want them to exercise judgment. But the original power to nominate, I guess, weirdly, this is like the one time I'll ever say this, like ever, that probably is an executive power. And there probably should be some deference to the executive about that. Is that is this crazy?
15:04Sarah Isgur: Am I saying this? No, I mean, it's not crazy. But let me give you the counterposition here that the Senate, as part of the advice and consent power, is saying, look, presidents, we know a lot more about the human beings who inhabit our state, the law, the legal community in our state, the people who are going to know and understand and serve our state the best. This is that famous phrase, the difference between a lawyer and a judge. A judge knows the senator. Exactly. I haven't heard that. I love that. You haven't? I've never heard that. Yeah, that's fantastic. So in other words, you're saying, look, you're a person who has to nominate hundreds, if not thousands of people.
15:46As part of our advice and consent, we're telling you, you should defer to the senators who are from that state. Now, obviously, Trump doesn't have to pull the, I mean, he could submit it anyway, and the Senate might knock it down because of the lack of blue slips. So, you know, so I don't think it is actually.
16:09Sarah Isgur: But like, the blue slips aren't in the Constitution. Are we pro blue slip? I think I am. I'm soft pro blue slip. but they could go away tomorrow. But I'm more cautious about this than I used to be after I was soft eliminating judicial filibuster. And now I don't like where we are. Look, let me tell you the real plus sides of the blue slip and it's for the minority party senators. And by minority party, I don't necessarily mean in the Senate. I mean, as opposed to the White House. And so that is important to me. But of course, is that even being honored? Right. Has it turned into just the power of the White House Party senators to return a blue slip?
16:54Sarah Isgur: Then I don't know that that's a Senate prerogative so much as a party prerogative. Yeah. Yeah. I don't like that. I mean, that's not the blue slip. To the extent there would be a blue slip utopia, that would not be it. Yeah. I don't think it's an easy call. But I do think on balance, if you're saying we are people operating in good faith, trying to present to the White House the best possible person to serve in a capacity that has a disproportionate impact on my state and my constituents, all other things being equal, is that a good practice to defer to those individuals? I tend to think so. But not 100 % of the time.
17:35There might be compelling reasons why you wouldn't defer, and I could think of some compelling reasons not to defer in this case with Judge Rudofsky.
17:43Sarah Isgur: I guess where I'm falling, I'm pro-Blue Slip asterisk. If they were using their appropriation power, if they were standing together as senators to do that, and then they just happen to also do it for Blue Slips, I think I'd be like, hell yeah, Article 1, baby. LFG. But that's not what's happening. The only time they're standing together is— Every now and then, Sarah, you say things that make you think you've played World of Warcraft and you're just not telling the truth about it. I have never—I don't even know what it is, to be honest. Is that what you guys call wow? Like, is that the— Wow is—well, I would call it wow, but—so I was trying to say World of Warcraft so you would know.
18:26But looking for group. Yeah.
18:29Sarah Isgur: Yeah. But you know what I mean? Like here we have in the Rudolfsky example, for instance, Bozeman wants to block Rudolfsky. Cotton, his fellow state senator, stands in solidarity. Okay, I think there's reasons to do that, right? Cotton wants to be, you know, Senate leadership someday. He needs his home state senator to do that. Fair enough. And then Cornyn and Tillis stand in solidarity with Bozeman and Cotton as like a, you know, this is the Senate, hear us roar. Okay. Again, I would just find that to be a lot more credible if they did it on any appropriations thing ever. Well, and especially, Sarah, when retaining the blue slip power really does help me help make you big man on campus individually and personally, sort of in your legal community of your state.
19:17So it, you know, there really is a kind of, um, personal aggrandizement element to it. Um, that, you know, it's just another group of people who are sort of incentivized to cater to you personally. Now, obviously that's a, that's a temptation across a number of fronts. You know, Again, one of the reasons why character is so important is you want people to be, if not immune, nobody's totally immune, aware and combating that impulse in themselves. But yeah, I mean, not doing the rest of your job, but hanging on to these personal prerogatives isn't a great look. But again, I guess all other things being equal, I'm Chesterton fencing on this one right now.
20:01Sarah Isgur: Okay, fair enough. Well, the blue slip for circuit nominees went away in 2017 in the 115th Congress. The only blue slip we have left is for district court nominees. What's interesting, David, about this, and I had said this before the midterms, was when will Donald Trump be a lame duck president? We're going to know what the judicial nominees first. And my God, did that come truer and faster than I could have ever imagined. In quick succession now, the Trump administration has lost two of their nominees. First, they had to pull the Rodofsky nomination in deference to the senators from Arkansas to the Eighth Circuit.
20:43Sarah Isgur: And then on Wednesday, they had put forward the Elliott Geyser nomination for the Northern District of Texas, never got blue slipped, never got a hearing, never going to happen. And that means that that seat is going to stay open through into the next Congress, where the blue slip process will continue once again. The president has nominated someone for that Eighth Circuit seat. Unclear whether Supreme Court Justice Cody Highland will make it through to confirmation before the new Congress comes in. He had his hearing on Wednesday. No real fireworks. But, you know, we'll see. Just one quick thing.
21:22I'm very glad you clarified that that the blue slip wasn't an Eighth Circuit issue. That nomination was pulled because of senatorial disapproval, not formally because of the blue slip. And I feel like I kind of might have mangled that a couple of times.
21:35Sarah Isgur: I don't think you did. I just wanted to clarify. There was a blue slip for circuit nominees up until quite recently. So I was just pushing back on your Chesterton's fence point. We already took down several pieces of wood from that fence, like big pieces. Yeah, totally true. Okay, when we get back, the Supreme Court has denied cert on what I think is this, I mean, really obvious First Amendment issue. But somehow I find myself looking around at who my allies are, and it's the conservative honey badgers. It's Gorsuch, Thomas, and Alito? As my First Amendment champions? Has the world turned upside down?
22:17We'll be right back. All right, David, first up, the Supreme Court denied cert in the Maryland Sensitive Places case. These are a number of Maryland statutes that ban carrying firearms in public demonstrations, on mass transit, places of amusement, health care facilities, locations that sell alcohol for on-site consumption, and state parks and forest land. So they denied certainness. There is a statement respecting the denial of cert from Justice Thomas. He's not dissenting from the denial of cert. He says, I agree with the court's decision not to grant certiorari because each Maryland statute implicates a distinct historical tradition of firearm regulation.
23:01The breadth of petitioners challenge would complicate our review. In an appropriate and more narrowly focused case, however, we should consider the scope of the state's authority to ban firearms in sensitive places. And he basically notes that in terms of his view of the, you know, text history and tradition, and let's go with history here. He notes in Bruin, we observed that early American legislature sometimes prohibited weapons in, quote, legislative assemblies, polling places, and courthouses. And so, David, we're back to my, you know, vertical level of generality problem. Yeah. OK, so they did ban guns in sensitive places.
23:47Do we need then to look at whether the sensitive places are similar to one another? Or do we just say, like, they clearly thought they had the power to ban guns in some places that they deemed sensitive. And now this legislature can decide what it thinks are sensitive places. Justice Thomas thinks that the places themselves need to be analogous. I will go out on a limb and say that that that will involve a lot of judicial judgment. Yes, Sarah, it's we're in this text history and tradition thing again, where we're looking at early American legislative enactments as if they're judicial interpretations of the Constitution, which is conceptually flawed right from the very beginning.
24:29But I'm beating the deadest horse possible when I talk about that, because we just talked about it recently at UVA. But the question here is going to be, again, using this rubric, obviously remember from Rahimi that Thomas is much more along the lines of exact match. So he's going to be looking at what are the precise matches for those historical examples for a sensitive place, whereas the Rahimi majority isn't going to be looking at the exact match. It's gonna be taking an approach more like you said, Sarah, there can be bans on sensitive places. So what are sensitive places? Well, they're not only the examples from the post-colonial period, but those are typical, representative, instructive.
25:22So how similar is a legislature to a sports arena? How similar is an airport? How similar, you know, so you're going to be walking through the subway platforms, you know, you're going to be walking through a lot of different things and sort of trying to figure out if there's a similar characteristic to other sensitive places. And we're going to just get to intermediate scrutiny. It's just going to be judgment all the way down. It's going to be, okay, in my judgment, this is similar. This is not similar. And here's why. And look, I don't blame anybody for intermediate scrutiny, but just like, can we just say that's what it is?
25:58Can we can we stop pretending that we're getting something precise from this historical record? Because we're just not. Now, Clarence Thomas is thinking he's getting something quite precise from it, which begins to look very, very much like strict scrutiny. But then can we just say that? Because this plumbing the historical record through non-interpretative bodies to determine what the current system of regulation should be, it just keeps striking me as hopeless. But at the same time, I think it's quite obvious that you can overdefine sensitive places to such an extent that essentially carrying a weapon outside the home is a kind of a nullity, a near practical impossibility.
26:49And for people who are under actual real threats in their lives, that can be fatally dangerous. And so, you know, there's obviously going to be a regime that could be way too broad of sensitive place restrictions. That's really way too broad that you're essentially shoehorning a gun ban through the sensitive places loophole. So, you know, there's obviously judgment that has to take place here. But to say there's judgment that has to take place here, I think should be divorced from, well, let's parse the, you know, 18th century Kentucky legislature's conclusions. Well, David, and just to follow up on that conversation we had on the last episode about dangerous and unusual places.
27:32Sarah Isgur: Yeah. You know, there's been this follow on conversation that the New York Times piece screwed this up that, of course, Scalia did not make a typo. So I just wanted to revisit that very briefly. Here's the line from Heller. We think that limitation is fairly supported by the historical tradition of prohibiting the carrying of, quote, dangerous and unusual weapons, end quote, C, Blackstone, Wilson, Dunlap, Humphreys, Stephen, Russell, Wharton. There's like close to a dozen citations in this string site, but Blackstone is first. Some of those citations use dangerous and unusual. Some of them use dangerous or unusual.
28:18And the pushback in The New York Times has been, what does C mean in legal citations? I will say that I would think that C means check this out for support of what I'm saying, which is different than a quote followed by just a citation, which would mean this is where the quote is from. Mm hmm. So I actually, on the one hand, don't think that Scalia had a typo or miscited Blackstone at all. That being said, it doesn't matter the overall conversation of whether it's dangerous and unusual, dangerous or unusual or dangerously unusual, because it is still the case that he said dangerous and unusual and that that has been cited by other courts.
29:05And we should, you know, talk about that. But in terms of whether he made a mistake in the Heller opinion with the citation, I believe no, that the C means that is not where the quote is from. It's, hey, check this out. It supports my quotation. So, OK, let me ask you this question. OK. Because we might have a slight AO disagreement here. OK. When I was practicing, if I had a dangerous and unusual and I put C after it, I would not include dangerous or unusual quotations after that. So if you're including, let's just make this easy, 10 citations. All the ones that or would not be in that list. It would only be the ones that had and.
29:47That's interesting. Even if you believe that they're being used interchangeably, that the term regardless means unusually dangerous. And so the or and and is not relevant. It's in quotes. OK. It's in quotes. So like if I'm writing a brief and I would be interested, you know, to hear some article three listeners over a cup of coffee talk about this. if you have quotes and then C and what is in the C is not what's in the quotes. I think you got a problem. I think you got a problem. Yeah. I'd be interested in other other people's thoughts on that. Because what does C because I would have more grace if it was C-E-G.
30:24OK. But if it's C but even C-E-G, I wouldn't do it if it's in quotes. OK, let me tell you what I would have done, David. OK. I would have had dangerous and unusual citation. for where that quote is from. And then I would have said C also, and I would have included citations that included dangerous and, and dangerous, or in the C also. And I would, if I was going to do, okay, I would be along with you, but I would have a paren that would have quotes, dangerous and, dangerous or. Okay. But I would never, if it's quotes.
30:57Sarah Isgur: Our non-legal listeners are like, OMG. I know. No, honestly, like this is 90 % of our listeners are like, this is, can you move on? And 10 % of our listeners are like, I am so here for this. Guys, when it comes to citations and exactly what you put, whether it's C versus C also, you can read hundreds, maybe thousands of pages about the difference between C and C also. And we haven't even got to C-E-G and C-F. Oh, but C and C-F. Oh my God. Like we're off to the races. All right, David, I want to get to this other descent from the denial of certiorari. Justice Gorsuch said he would grant the petition, but did not join this dissent.
31:43Justice Thomas and Justice Alito are joining what I'm going to read. In 2022, California began requiring private instructors in privately run and privately accredited continuing medical education courses to discuss how so-called implicit bias affects health care outcomes. The Ninth Circuit held that First Amendment scrutiny did not apply to this compelled speech requirement because the breadth of California's CME regulation renders the content of any CME course government speech, not private speech. That logic fundamentally misunderstands its court's precedence and the Constitution. First Amendment protections do not give way simply because a state heavily regulates speech.
32:26And David, the rest of this dissent from the denial of cert is all about, I mean, basically not overturning the outcome of shirtlift, one of my favorite cases, but of overturning the reasoning underpinning shirtlift. And so to remind everyone about the shirtlift case, this is the flag flying over Boston City Hall. And the city would fly all sorts of flags. If you just asked to fly a flag, they'd be like, sure, whatever. the flagpole's over there. And then someone asked to fly the Christian flag. And they were like, ooh, we think if we do this, it would violate the establishment clause. So we're going to say no to you.
33:07And the Supreme Court was like, this is not government speech if you're letting everyone else do it. And these are the one people that you don't let do it. That's just called viewpoint discrimination. And of course, the city then changed their policy to have nobody flying flags. This is my this is why we can't have nice things poster child of a case. Yeah. Although funny enough, David, to follow up, they did, in fact, before shutting down the whole thing, let that guy fly his flag. Well, good. Which I actually thought was gracious of them. Yes. They could have just said no. And there's nothing he could have done about it.
33:42However, David, when we talked about Shurtleff, I don't know that we spent enough time on Justice Alito's concurrence in that case, which, by the way, was Alito, Thomas and Gorsuch. Interesting. And they were like, hey, guys, I think we might have a problem here. The factors that you laid out about whether something is government speech or not is going to be a hot mess. And it's going to under protect regular speech if the government involves itself at all. So Shurtleff says here are the factors. One, the history of the expression at issue. Two, the public's likely perception as to who the government or a private person is speaking.
34:23And three, the extent to which the government has actively shaped or controlled the expression. And the three of them in that concurrence and shirtlift are like, no, it should just be the person. Is it the government speaking or is it a private person speaking? And if it's a private person, we're done. Yeah. And so here in this statement about California's CMEs, you have the three of them together again, though, again, only Thomas and Alito write about it, saying like, yep, we told you. This is a hot mess. The Ninth Circuit is somehow applying those three factors and saying that this is government speech because the government basically regulates that there is continuing medical education, regulates that it has to be about the practice of medicine.
35:10It's like pretty broad regulation. And all of a sudden that transforms all continuing medical education into government speech, which, by the way, would obviously apply to continuing legal education. Yes, it would. And that means the government in, well, I was going to say Texas, but let's move to Tennessee or Florida. You mean purple Tennessee and purple Florida? You know, they could mandate that you say that gender identity isn't real as part of your continuing legal education because it's government speech after all. This is insane, David. And there were three votes to grant cert. And clearly there was no courtesy forth.
35:55And for the first time, our three conservative honey badgers are the ones that are more protective of speech. Gorsuch doesn't surprise me at all. With Thomas and Alito, there's some surprise. And it's such a funny irony, Sarah, because we just had a really fun conversation at UVA where we talked about how Alito wasn't necessarily the biggest speech guy on the court. and we heard him give a speech at AEI where he talked about the importance of free speech. And then here he comes out with a dissent from denial that is a free speech. You know, he's like the signal beacons of Gondor are lit on free speech.
36:36And I'm with him, I'm with him. And let me put it like this. I can imagine, if there's a situation, there are situations in which private individuals could give a government message. Think about it like imagine if the state of California said as part of our CME curriculum, we have a diversity curriculum. Here's the diversity curriculum that has to be like one hour. Here's the whole thing. Here's the PowerPoint. And we don't have enough state officials who can go out and teach this. So we're going to hire on a 1099 basis or whatever it is. We're going to have independent contractors who we will hire to span out across whatever.
37:16I mean, I'm just creating a hypo to deliver the state approved curriculum. But in that circumstance, by taking money from the state to deliver the state approved curriculum, you I think that's much more of a government speech situation as opposed to these kinds of situations where if it's anything like the CLE world, it would be about like saying you and I doing CLE being paid as our private business, being paid by a private entity that we're going to have to include content regarding race that we don't agree with. So let me give you the example in this case. To satisfy the requirement that California passed by its legislature, CME courses must contain, quote, examples of how implicit bias affects perceptions and treatment decisions of physicians and surgeons, leading to disparities in health outcomes and strategies to address how unintended biases and decision making may contribute to healthcare disparities.
38:15The doctor in question who was presenting a CME said she disagrees that implicit bias is the primary factor driving disparities in healthcare and does not want to devote time to the subject. The other group that was part of the lawsuit said that they just don't believe that implicit bias training actually helps. Right. And there's a lot of data to back them up, by the way. That's right. This isn't crankery here. It seems crazy to me, David. Like we do CLEs. If in every CLE we did, the government forced us to say something that we don't agree with. I wouldn't do CLEs anymore. Like how is that not so clearly a strict scrutiny land issue and not government speech?
39:04You're at you're demanding you're requiring that private individuals who are being paid by other private individuals to do that they must deliver a state compelled message. If the state wants to send a message to create a message that it's going to send, which it can do, it can, it can create a implicit bias curriculum. It can do that, hire people to do that under the banner of the state. That, but this is, I think the identity, the speaker test, which Alito is urging, I think is the much better default standard. Who are you? Who's paying you? You're a private citizen being paid by more private citizens.
39:42You know, there is state mandated training. We that is acceptable. That is that's been upheld for good reasons. But that's not the mouse hole into which you can shoehorn the elephant of state mandated ideological indoctrination. All right, David, when we get back, I've got another First Amendment case for you and an interesting suggestion from a listener. We'll be right back.
40:08Sarah Isgur: When our first was about a year old, I thought it'd be really funny to put him in a large shopping bag. The picture we got is of a very confused little baby looking really adorable in this huge bag. And it's those little moments that tend to disappear into a camera roll, even when they're the ones we most want to remember. Aura Frames can bring those everyday photos out of your phone and into your home, where the whole family can actually enjoy them. Aura Frames can bring those everyday photos out of your phone and into your home. The little moments in life are worth remembering. You can do that with Aura Frames.
40:41Sarah Isgur: Aura is the number one digital frame loved by millions of families, and their Black Friday Cyber Monday deal is the best of the year. For a limited time, visit AuraFrames.com and get up to$50 off select frames, plus an additional$5 off your order with the promo code ADVISORY. That's A-U-R-A-Frames.com promo code ADVISORY. Support the show by mentioning us at checkout. Terms and conditions apply. All right, David. Judge Harvey Wilkinson, the one, the only, has another barn burner out. So this is in-ray application of the United States of America for an order pursuant to 18 U.S.C. Section 273D. That is actually the name of the case, for those who are curious.
41:27This is a 24-page opinion coming out of the Fourth Circuit, unanimous. I'll just read you from the top here. It is part of the audacity of the American project to believe that collective security can coexist with individual freedom. In striking that balance, an intermediate appellate body can do no more than follow the instructions laid down by Congress and the constitutional wisdom imparted by the founders and our nation's highest court. So David, there was a leak of classified information that was published by a news organization. The federal government then, I'm not going to say it's like clever, but smartly, correctly, I suppose, if you were going to investigate a leak investigation, went to LinkedIn and was like, yeah, we'd like to see that reporter's metadata on LinkedIn for the last 18 months.
42:21Because as we know, David, a lot of this happens on LinkedIn for journalists, not necessarily the exchange of the information, but the initial touch, you know, where they're like, hey, can we hop on the phone? Hey, can we meet up? Because LinkedIn allows journalists to search by where you work and all sorts of other things. So in short, the government sent LinkedIn this request, demand, and told LinkedIn that they could not tell anyone about it for a year. So LinkedIn objected. And it's sort of interesting. In the end, Judge Wilkinson's opinion, and by the way, as Adam Lipdak of the New York Times noted, Judge Wilkinson is a former journalist.
43:11He was three years at the as the editorial page editor of the Norfolk, Virginia pilot, which back in the day, by the way, was a big deal newspaper. That was one of the major regional newspapers of the United States. But when he comes to the like solution part of it, David, I mean, this is like Judge Wilkinson, maybe at his best. And what judges I think used to do more of. And this is sort of how the conservative legal movement takes off is that you end up with these balancing tests because this is what judgment is. We've got these two competing interests. There's no obvious like right answer. There's no math formula that you can put in.
43:46And so in the end, he just sends it back to the district court and is like, consider this, consider this. Here, I'll read you what his factors are. On remand, the district court's analysis should thus consider the following. One, the government's need for the disclosure order. Two, the breadth of the records sought and whether any subdivisions might feasibly be drawn. One, three, that the government cannot know precisely what is relevant at early stages of an investigation. And four, any First Amendment and legislative standards implicated by the disclosure order. We have confidence that the statutory discretion conferred upon the district court will be soundly exercised upon remand.
44:27Sarah Isgur: Dude, if I'm the district court judge, I'm like, no, thank you. What? I don't know what you want me to do here. Just tell me. I love the opening paragraph that you read, the Audacity of the American Project opening paragraph. I was I was thinking into my veins, as the kids would say. But I think when you're when you're talking about this case, the next paragraph to me is really the most important. So it says in that and it's understandably vigorous investigation of that leak. which to be very clear, as much as we are First Amendment absolutists, as much as we appreciate freedom of the press, if I'm a member of the government, if I have sworn an oath to uphold, protect, and defend the Constitution, I'm bound by laws and rules regarding disclosure of classified information.
45:13I cannot, I cannot in my own judgment decide, you know what, this is, I don't like what's happening here, so I'm going to violate my agreements, I'm going to violate the law, and I'm going to send this to a journalist. The government can, in fact, investigate that and it can find me and prosecute me. So when he says understandably vigorous investigation of that leak, but it's also at the same time, the journalist who receives the information has a right to publish the information. This is the Pentagon Papers case. So, and so there's a person under, who has a legal obligation not to disclose And then on the other end is a person who has a legal right to disclose if he or she obtains the information.
45:59So it's a complex situation. So we get to the next part. He says, it's understandably a vigorous investigation of that leak. The government sought two court orders pursuant to the Stored Communications Act. Those orders obligated appellant LinkedIn to produce the records of many journalists and prohibited from divulging the existence of the orders to anyone. The requested records seemingly identify a vast number of confidential sources who have no conceivable relationship to the matter under investigation. While we respect the government's interest in gathering information potentially relevant to the leak, neither the Stored Communications Act nor the Constitution permit the district court to approve orders that by all apparent indications are substantially overbroad.
46:43And so this, Sarah, I think is interesting because that phrasing, that term substantially overbroad is going to be super familiar to litigants in civil cases. That is something that district tort judges do all the time as they narrow discovery requests. They do it constantly. And I think this situation is just a little bit more difficult because how much can you narrow it when the government has the understandable right to investigate? And so but I think it's very clear. It's one of those cases where and this happens quite a bit in the law where essentially they say wherever the line is, this is over the line.
47:25Now go back and draw the line slightly more clearly so that we can have more, you know, that there can be more certainty and more guidance for the litigants. But I love this decision from the standpoint of wherever the line is, this is too much. But also at the same time, it is very difficult to draft and craft a single rule for subpoenas and other forms of investigation of these kinds of leaks. All right, David, I want to leave you with a email from a listener with an idea. Major legislation ends with a Rose Garden ceremony that effectively sends the message, this is a thing the president is doing.
48:05Some congressmen are standing near him with his other staff. There's no strong party structure to keep the presidency in check or channel public credit anywhere else or to counter the mass media effects. But there is a solution. We could remove the third house of Congress. Remove the presidential veto. The presidency retains its executive, but loses its legislative function. Congress would be vastly empowered. Midterm elections would be much more meaningful and would become occasions for regular education about what the powers of Congress are once they're unshackled from the president's chariot.
48:42David, I actually, I mean, I think the presidential veto is important and I'm not voting for this yet until I really, really give it some real thought. But it's not a crazy suggestion right now. I love that email. It's not a crazy suggestion, but can I add an addendum? A lot of states, such as Tennessee, unless it's changed of late, but a lot of states, they have a veto, but it can be overwritten by a simple majority.
49:08Sarah Isgur: You just vote again, basically. Yeah, you just pass it again. Oh, I like that. The governor is basically saying, are you sure about this? Yeah. I don't like it, and here's why I don't like it. Oh, and this fits with my Chesterton's fence, you know, preferences. We could at least start with that as the change. Let's just move it down to a simple majority to override the veto. See how that works. And then if it's still not working, then we could think about getting rid of the veto altogether. But let's do incrementalism, baby steps towards ending the veto. Yes. No, I'm so interested in that. Like I'm interested in various ideas around filibuster reform.
49:45But, you know, one of the things when we had Judge Sutton on and talking about state constitutions is, you know, there's a lot of history in the United States of weaker executives than we have in the state in the in the presidency. Texas is a very weak governor. For example, there is a lot of examples across the United States of it being easier to amend state constitutions, sometimes too easy.
50:08Sarah Isgur: Also Texas. Also Texas. So but, you know, what we've seen is in state after state after state that has these slightly different or permutations on the constitutional democracy that we have at the federal level. In some ways, some of these states maybe function better. Some of these states, you know, the ability to change the Constitution or the ability to override a veto more easily has not, in fact, led to the tyranny of the majority, particularly in environments where you have the Bill of Rights strongly protected. And so, you know, it is it is a very interesting thing if you're thinking about.
50:45And I need to think this through, because when you have a bill of rights that is universally applicable. And protects the citizen against every layer of the government, then the government gets less dangerous than it was at the founding of the republic. And so in that circumstance, you know, the the restriction on action that a president is placing on Congress may be less necessary when you have strong bedrock Bill of Rights protection. That means that whatever Congress does, their basic human rights as a citizen can't be touched. And so I do wonder about that. All right, David, that's it for AO.
51:28So don't forget, if you're going to be in the Houston or Austin area, December 5th and 6th, we will have live shows December 5th in Houston and December 6th in Austin. You can go to sarahisger.com slash events to check that out or the advisory opinions page on SCOTUS blog or The Dispatch. We'll see you there. Bye.
52:01Sarah Isgur: Hi, guys!
Sarah Isgur and David French discuss the nature of lame-duck confirmations after the showdown between Texas Senators John Cornyn and Ted Cruz, journalists’ records, and weakening the presidential veto.
The Agenda:
–A Texas showdown?
–How legitimate is it for the GOP to do anything during the lame duck?
–Denying cert on sensitive places gun ban
–’Dangerous and unusual’ and what citations actually mean
–Private speech vs. government speech
–Weakening the presidential veto
Show Notes:
–We’re hiring! Apply here.
–Come see us in Austin! Or come see us in Houston!
–Shurtleff v. Boston
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices