1. Podcasts
  2. Broadcasting House
  3. 25/10/2026
Broadcasting House

25 Oct 2026 · 52m · 25 chapters

In short

This episode of BBC Radio 4 (Sunday 25 Oct 2026) mixes politics, preparedness, and culture. It opens with a discussion of UK-EU relations: Prime Minister Andy Burnham says “free movement” should be openly debated, not treated as a red line, arguing post-Brexit migration is harder to manage and that free movement would create a “revolving door” (people work then often return). Ben Riley-Smith (Sunday Times political editor) and David Gork (former Conservative Cabinet minister, lost the Tory whip over Boris Johnson’s Brexit plans) debate whether closer EU ties would require signing up to freedom of movement, and whether the current relationship is failing economically and on immigration.

Next, the show covers the wind-up radio boom after resilience advice: guests include Trevor Bayliss (inventor, via interview), Pav (Ranger military surplus shop), and Mark Steele (Archiva operations chief). They claim FM radio and wind-up power can work during blackouts; examples include sold-out stock and advice to stock basics for 72 hours (torches, snacks, water, first aid; avoid candles).

It also reports on French protests over cost of living and public-service cuts, featuring Nathalie Oziol (La France Insoumise MP) and later guests Guto Harry (ex-Downing Street comms director), Sir Howard Davies (Sciences Po; ex-BoE/NatWest), and comedian Cariad Lloyd (Griefcast).

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

1:38

Podcast Opening

Overview of current events including wind-up radios and their popularity.

“Hello, it's a podcast of BH from Sunday the 25th of October.”
1:50

Brexit and Free Movement Discussion

Exploring the political implications of free movement in the UK-EU relationship.

“The Prime Minister has raised the issue of free movement between the UK and the EU as part of his planned reboot of relations with the European Union.”
2:52

Interview with Ben Riley-Smith

Ben discusses Andy Burnham's openness to rejoining free movement with the EU.

“Ben Riley-Smith is the political editor of the Sunday Times and he has interviewed the Prime Minister several times for today's newspaper.”
3:21

Analyzing the Upcoming Budget

Discussion on the implications of the forthcoming budget and its impact on politics.

“Well, he has said that he is open to possibly Britain rejoining free movement, which is fascinating because no prime minister in the decades since Brexit has openly leaned into that argument.”
7:48

Reflections on Past Budgets

Guests reflect on significant past budgets and their implications for the present.

“It's slightly a sort of muddling through budget, which at one level maybe makes sense.”
9:11

Listener Feedback and Slow Radio

Listener shares thoughts on a unique sound experience from a pumping station.

“It's now anticipating how you present it.”
10:39

The Popularity of Wind-Up Radios

Exploring the surge in demand for wind-up radios amidst societal concerns.

“Our listener Andy Higgins has been in touch because he's been to the Papalwick pumping station near Nottingham.”
14:00

Fear and Preparation in Emergencies

Discusses the anxiety around emergency purchases and the importance of thoughtful preparation.

“there's a bit of anxiety about this purchase?”
15:10

The Strength of FM Radio

Explores the reliability and resilience of FM radio during crises, featuring insights from Archiva's operations chief.

“So says Mark Steele, the chief of operations for Archiva, which runs the network of around 1 ,500 broadcast transmission sites.”
17:05

Stockpiling Essentials for Emergencies

Advises on essential items to stockpile for emergencies and shares personal anecdotes about preparedness.

“already have plenty of stocks and supplies at home and are quite surprised at the urban people saying, oh, I haven't got any batteries.”
Show all 25 chapters
19:54

Government Response to Emergencies

Analyzes the UK's delayed emergency preparedness campaign and compares it with practices in other countries.

“interested in how people are expressing how afraid or fearful they are.”
22:41

Sponsor: Schwab

Promotes Schwab's investment services, highlighting their flexible options and support.

“We're back on Greenwich Mean Time, which is where we belong.”
23:21

Protests Across Europe

Reports on protests in various European countries, focusing on the unrest in France and its context.

“Protesters clashed with police in cities across France.”
26:35

Voices from the French Protests

Features an interview with a French deputy discussing the ongoing protests and demands for educational reforms.

“More people will be going through the courts this week.”
28:00

Protests in France: A Political Analysis

Learn about the current protests in France, their motivations, and political implications.

“And yes, I would like to insist on the fact that they are mainly peaceful, massive, joyful demonstrations.”
30:21

Toad Hall and Community Ownership

Discover the historical and cultural significance of Toad Hall and its transition to community ownership.

“Thank you so much for joining us and speaking to us in English live on Sunday morning about something you care so much about and your country.”
33:28

Vision for Hardwick Estate

Explore the plans for community-led management of Hardwick Estate and its cultural heritage.

“And I've been given permission to walk up these steps to what was the inspiration for Toad Hall.”
35:57

The Legacy of Toad and Community Engagement

Understand the impact of Toad's character on community initiatives and land management.

“and is part of the plans for a community-led future.”
37:42

Political Insights and Current Events

Gain insights into current political events, including Liz Truss's controversial decisions.

“It's 9.42, and here are three of the very best guests anywhere on Sunday.”
42:00

Economic Insights on Liz Truss's Approach

Discussion on the economic implications of Liz Truss's tax cuts and spending strategy.

“I think that the problem with the Liz Truss approach was that you cut taxes first and then you hope maybe you can find some way of cutting spending later.”
42:36

AI Influencers and Their Impact

Exploration of AI influencers on social media and their effect on consumer behavior.

“Yes, thank you very much for getting us going.”
44:40

Cultural Change Through AI in Learning

Discussion about the use of AI in learning languages and its societal implications.

“Why do we need to go for these made up sort of non-existent, you know, shiny looking women in front of Carriott here to sort of give us fashion advice that we shouldn't take seriously at all?”
47:10

Thomas Markle's Allegations and Family Dynamics

Insights into the allegations against Thomas Markle and their impact on Meghan Markle's narrative.

“Carriott's raising it with concern and we've heard how it can be used to learn Italian in a very beautiful demonstration.”
49:28

Political Landscape in France and Its UK Implications

Analysis of the political situation in France and its potential effects on UK policies.

“I mentioned your professor at Sciences Po and you're going to tell us about the Mail's coverage of France's new revolution.”
51:10

Cultural Reflections on the National Theatre

Celebration of the National Theatre's 50 years and its significance in the arts.

“And thank you very much indeed for bringing your take there.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On Broadcasting House, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00Paddy O'Connell: This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK.

0:30We do the things we do and how to make better choices to help avoid costly mistakes. Each episode covers the latest research in behavioral science and dives into themes like the power of self-control, shaping your mindset for success, navigating new beginnings and why starting over can feel so hard. Listen to choiceology at schwab.com slash podcast or wherever you listen. Running a business shouldn't feel like surviving a software group project. One app for accounting, another for inventory, another for sales. And somehow, none of them talk to each other. That's where Odoo comes in. An all-in-one business management software that brings every part of your business together.

1:15From sales and accounting to inventory and marketing, all in one powerful platform. No messy integrations. No bouncing between tabs. And best of all, no spreadsheets. Stop managing software and start managing your business with one unified system. Try for free today at odoo.com. That's O-D-O-O dot com.

1:38Paddy O'Connell: Hello, it's a podcast of BH from Sunday the 25th of October. You're listening sometime in the future, but we spoke about Analog FM and the wind-up radios, which are selling fast. Good morning. The Prime Minister has raised the issue of free movement between the UK and the EU as part of his planned reboot of relations with the European Union. Under Keir Starmer, Labour was said to treat Brexit as the third rail of British politics. But Keir Starmer has been dumped. Now Andy Burnham, who campaigned behind the scenes to get his job, is flexing his muscles on Brussels. A few weeks ago, he said all options, including rejoining the bloc, should be considered, just as voters in many of its member states are on the streets, protesting at their own living standards and smashing shops.

2:24Paddy O'Connell: Now the PM's told the Sunday Times he wants an honest discussion about free movement between the UK and the EU. It's ten years since Brexit, and the issue is not known for its honest discussions. All right, Steve! Steve! Be a few, mate! Shut up, I'm not crazy! Yeah? Shut up, I'm Annie! Nobody wants away from you! Be quiet about Brexit! You know, I'm going to stop it! That's one of the honest discussions. I can't remember which one. So what's changing? Ben Riley-Smith is the political editor of the Sunday Times and he has interviewed the Prime Minister several times for today's newspaper. Hello, Ben.

3:02Paddy O'Connell: Hello. It wasn't quite that shouty when we checked. I'm sure that wasn't you. And David Gork, it could have been him because he's the former Conservative Cabinet Minister who lost the Tory whip for rebelling on Boris Johnson's Brexit plans. Hello, David. Hello, Paddy. Welcome to B &J. And it wasn't me. It wasn't you, OK. Ben, what has Andy Burnham told you in a nutshell? Well, he has said that he is open to possibly Britain rejoining free movement, which is fascinating because no prime minister in the decades since Brexit has openly leaned into that argument. I put it to him that was he going to make it a red line staying out of free movement as he has these discussions with the EU about closer ties.

3:43And he made clear that he isn't going to make it a red line. His argument was basically that post-Brexit migration has become more difficult to use his word and that people often move here and stay here. And he claimed under free movement rules, there was a revolving door. So often people would come here, work for a few years and then go back. He actually cited his father, Roy, who was a telephone engineer, went to Germany in the 1990s and then came back. He's not saying he definitely wants to re-adopt it. But in this big open discussion about Brexit, he's saying we do need to think about whether it's beneficial.

4:19Paddy O'Connell: David Gort, what do you make of it? Because the shadow Home Secretary, Chris Philp, says it can be no return to free movement. Reforms, Nigel Farage, said it's a betrayal of voters who supported Brexit. What do you think of the prime minister raising it in this way? I think he's right to raise it. First of all, if we are serious about a closer relationship with the European Union, whatever your perspective on that, you do have to face up to the fact that if you want better trade access, you are ultimately going to have to sign up to freedom of movement. And it would be wrong for those who argue for a closer relationship and say it would make a really big difference without facing up to that reality.

5:01That is part of the reality. I also think that Andy Burnham makes a good point that the type of immigration that we had under the single market with freedom of movement was that you had generally, typically sort of young people coming here, no dependents, working here for a period. sometimes they stayed, more often than not they moved back. Whereas what we've seen with immigration in recent years is people coming from other parts of the world, bringing their families with them, and with very little prospect of them ever returning. And I think his characterisation is spot on.

5:37Paddy O'Connell: And what about the angry tone of Brexit every time it's raised and your own career crashed to a halt because of it? Are you sure Britain's ready for this? Polling's still only sort of 55-45, Chris. David, do you want this all over again? I think the fact is that the current relationship isn't working. It isn't working for the people of the United Kingdom. It has had a substantial economic cost. It hasn't addressed people's concerns about immigration for the reasons others just talking about. And if we are serious about economic growth, we can't ignore the European issue. And I know it can be divisive, but it's always going to be with us.

6:18It's always going to be with us as an issue.

6:19Paddy O'Connell: Just for listeners waking up, blinking with the extra hour, Ben, we should say that the Prime Minister told you it's a fundamental change which would require a mandate at a general election. So he's not proposing a referendum at this point. He's saying a general election would have to decide if this was on the cards. Well, he said if we want to go back as full with EU members, he did feel there would need to be a referendum specifically. But when I asked him about option short of that, rejoining single market, rejoining the customs union, he didn't say that. So the assumption about any of these big changes is that at the very least, they would have to be in the next election manifesto and be voted for.

6:54Paddy O'Connell: That's a big style of Andy Burnham, isn't it? To say we must do this, for instance, the triple lock after the general election. We must do this after the general election. So we're seeing we've got his form now. Let's move on to the budget. To you first, David Gawke, as a as a blood conservative. This is when we're going to find out what the colour of Andy Burnham's eyes are, aren't they? this budget's going to decide whether or not he's a tax and spend prime minister? Well, perhaps we're not, because what we're hearing in the run up to this budget, it's all going to be very low key. The point you were just making to Ben a moment ago that a lot of this, all the exciting stuff seems to be after the general election.

7:36If this really is a low key budget, it sounds as if there's not going to be that many big tax increases. There's not going to be that much said about spending. that's sort of kicked into the next year. It's slightly a sort of muddling through budget, which at one level maybe makes sense. He needs time to work out precisely what he wants to do. But at another level, this is where his political capital is at the highest. So you might have expected this to be quite a radical budget. Your first budget tends to be quite a radical one. It doesn't appear to be the case this year.

8:09Paddy O'Connell: Absolutely, Ben, because I thought we were all about ending 40 years of neoliberalism. now it's being briefed it's a steady as we go budget well there is this gap between the prime minister's rhetoric that he gave on the steps of down street when he got the job and the realities of the budget coming it seems to me partly that's due to the public finances they've deteriorated significantly but he hasn't got any money he hasn't got exactly you've got to raise money not give away money and what to you um david you worked on several budgets what's it like at this moment to be in the treasury to to be in john healy's flat well at least i would hope most of the work has been done yeah all the decisions have been taken it's all been sort of signed off uh by the obr at this point i would have thought john healy is working on his speech so the decisions are done it's now about the presentation it's being making sure that you understand all the details making sure that you're what they call the narrative is clear.

9:08What's the big message that they're trying to deliver on Wednesday? What's the big argument? How are they presenting it? So the hard work at one level is done. It's now anticipating how you present it.

9:20Paddy O'Connell: And finally, these interviews are never rehearsed, so you may not have an answer for this. Tell us Ben first and then David, if you had to think of one budget measure that stands out in your mind, not saying whether you liked it or not, from all the budgets of your career, which would come first to mind ben and then david what the biggest budget move that springs to mind yes well the the one i can think of is probably the biggest tax raise i've covered which was rachel reeves weeks after taking office uh saying she was a pro-business chancellor increasing national insurance on employers and raising from memory something like 26 billion the relationship between labor and business has never recovered from that point david so i go back to the 2010 budget.

10:02I was in the Treasury team for that and essentially setting out the spending plans that were described as the whole spending package which was described as austerity, but it did ensure that we had the confidence of the markets and that was really important for the following years.

10:22Paddy O'Connell: Okay, I mean it is hard to get a budget in the centre. So thank you very much indeed, David Gork, the former Conservative Cabinet Minister, Ben Riley-Smith, the current political editor at the Sunday Times, who's reporting with the Prime Minister, leads the paper and has led our headlines here on Radio 4. It's quarter past nine. Our listener Andy Higgins has been in touch because he's been to the Papalwick pumping station near Nottingham. He says the steam engine valve gear becomes hypnotic and he's sent it to us for some slow radio. Prepare to be hypnotised.

11:24MUSIC PLAYS

11:24Paddy O'Connell: Lisa Costello, are you hypnotised? I'm kind of speechless. Well, we don't want that enough. It's sort of hypnotic, but gave visions of galley slaves for some reason. It was designed in the early 1880s, Lisa, to pump millions of gallons of clean, fresh water every day to the rapidly increasing population of industrial Nottingham. A modern marvel. Thank you to Andy Higgins. Sales of wind-up FM radios have cranked up after the government's latest resilience advice. So says the owner of one store we spoke to with at least one giant online retailer sold out this weekend, several newspapers report sales are jumping.

12:06Paddy O'Connell: Hand and solar-powered receivers now double up as power banks and torches. The Defence Secretary, Wes Streeting, says owning one would keep important information flowing in the event of blackouts. The wind-up radio was invented by the late Trevor Bayliss, a lovely man who appeared on BH Often. Here he was, telling me how he came up with the idea. Well, it was pure chance. You know, there's an expression, chance papers that prepared mind. I happened to be in the lounge watching telly. I could have been watching Come Dancing or The Golden Shop, but there was a programme about the spread of HIV AIDS in Africa.

12:40And they said the only way they could stop this dreadful disease cutting its way through all those people was with the power of information, which could be best brought to people using radio. But there was a problem. Most of Africa didn't have electricity, and the only other form of electricity was in the form of batteries and batteries were horrendously expensive. People were bartering their maize and their rice in order to obtain batteries and where do you get batteries? Up the Wadi Thartha and that's how it came about.

13:09Paddy O'Connell: We spoke to a man whose first name is Pav. He runs Ranger, a military surplus shop in Greater London where he's seen massive demand for the wind-up contraption. The recent sales of wind-up radios have been very popular. I think we started this week with about 10. We have now completely sold out of this store. And when did you start selling them and why? We first saw them come out of our supplier at the beginning of this year. We just saw it as, oh, it's a great, you know, prepper's item. Let's have two or three. Then they sold through. Then we got another five. And then our supplier was completely out of stock.

13:44And now they've just been sitting there on the shelves for a long time with not much attention. and all of a sudden out of nowhere just all of them sold out.

13:52Paddy O'Connell: When people are buying these particular wind-up radios, have they expressed fear at why they're buying them? Have they told you why they're and do you get the impression there's a bit of anxiety about this purchase? Yeah, for sure. I mean, prepping kind of starts with a bit of a fear of, you know, oh, something's going to happen. We do our best in the store to obviously make sure that people stay calm they don't overbuy they buy only the stuff that is needed um ultimately if i have now an old lady come in and she's worried about uh the floods or whatever's going to happen i'm not going to sell her absolutely everything that's in my store uh like you know she doesn't need 10 packs of military rations that would be ridiculous but we'll make sure that we sell them items that they can still use just in their day-to-day lives this is stuff this is the reason why these wind-up radios are so popular, because you don't need to only use them in a prepper scenario, they are just a useful day-to-day item to have.

14:50Paddy O'Connell: Also, I hear a lot from old ladies who write to us, and they're often the most prepared. We hear a lot about streaming audio. You can't move for being told to stream your audio by the BBC. We are delighted if that's how you listen to us, but this is a rare moment to sing up for Fabulous FM. So says Mark Steele, the chief of operations for Archiva, which runs the network of around 1 ,500 broadcast transmission sites. FM radio doesn't rely upon internet in terms of broadband, power or mobile connectivity. Its simplicity in itself provides a lot of strength and it's very mature and it's widely available and it's easy to broadcast to many at the same time.

15:38We have our own means of providing power through our own generation of power and resilience within that infrastructure. So we are able to run even during a power cut.

15:49Paddy O'Connell: Now, I've got Wind Up Radio here. And because this studio is a sealed box and covered in kiln and the editor's leopard print carpet, there is no reception in this room. So I tested it out a little earlier in the corridor of Glee.

16:23Jagged flagged doesn't erre Tiago is behind that Sheath classic XpeSamx

16:31and certain bedding down to live during Winter However, we're now going to anticipate their return and rejuvenation in spring with the violin sonata by Beethoven with that nickname. Thanks in part to the...

16:54Paddy O'Connell: I always find Westlife needs a bit of a crank. The storm has left thousands without power, which is the point of this item when it began a long time ago. And our many BH listeners in isolated rural parts already have plenty of stocks and supplies at home and are quite surprised at the urban people saying, oh, I haven't got any batteries. Politicians have been asked what they'd include in their stockpile. The Prime Minister was on Five Live, where Matt Chorley asked him about his cabinet colleague Angela Rayner and her idea to include a bottle of Sauvignon Blanc in her stockpile. well I'm not sure a bottle of wine is your best first port of call if you're in a slightly crisis situation but it probably helps when you've done the hard work but I just will I'll stick to the basics I think Matt I do like my beans so there are plenty of those in the cupboard and soup I think those are the kind of things that I would recommend people to have as well as Twiglets I'm not sure I can get by for too long without those.

18:00Paddy O'Connell: And the whole interview is on BBC Sounds, which of course is a streaming service which relies on power. Lucy Easthope is an advisor on emergency planning and disaster recovery. I'm generally supportive of the campaign at the moment. It's very much based on existing disaster science and it's what many other countries do. It's just landed a bit clunkily, I would say, this week. But the idea of people having a way to perhaps stay in place for 72 hours until responders can get to you, which allows them to focus on the most vulnerable, is a very sensible practice. And what kind of simple goods, simple power banks, simple measures?

18:39So for me, the place I always started with light, so the idea of a lamp or a torch, I tend to dissuade against candles. It's a couple of days of snacks. One of the things I love about the socials at the moment, people are coming over to sort of talk about things that they've found working in power and water outages, So maybe filling your bath. I do have at home about 10 litres of water per person. So for our household, that's 40 litres plus my mum. I have a camping stove, which I only use outside. So it's just thinking about, okay, power's down. We had a power outage for nine hours last year. What have I got?

19:15Power banks are great. I'm also seeing people putting power banks in their sort of go bags or rucksacks when they go out to work in case they're kept away from home and need to send a message.

19:25Paddy O'Connell: And interesting there that you remind us that if you're not used to using camping gas, use it outside if you can rather than in. Yeah, yeah. And one of the difficulties I think here is, you know, the very experienced survivalists and the people who camp all the time have a different level of acceptance and awareness of other people. So some people say, well, I do this and that. Just, you know, we go for these kind of more stark general rules for people who perhaps aren't camping all the time. So that's why I say no candles, for example. I'm really interested in how people are expressing how afraid or fearful they are.

19:58This is what other countries have been doing for about 20 years. Successive British governments have kicked it down the road as I can. And now they really have to rush it out in the middle of a storm. It's quite unfortunate comms, really, but it's nothing to be frightened about. Which is a go to country

20:15Paddy O'Connell: for you? Lots of places have been doing this, as I say, as just as just part of cultural behaviour. So the US, Australia, New Zealand, lots of places in Europe. And there's been some great articles the last 24 hours about how places have been doing it, as I say, for decades. I thought we were going to roll it out in the UK in 2010. Various imagery and assets and writing and websites have been in draft for years. It's a little bit late, but I do support it. and in the house what's your go-to can well i'm i'm actually i don't particularly like the legumes which has been the big debate over the last over the last 24 hours so i i have to probably admit it's not the healthiest of of snack drawers for me it's probably the cereal bars and the and the cups of tea one reason we got the stamp the camping stove was to be able to make a cup tea which for me is an emergency staple and some kind of dehydrated soup or noodle is always very good if you can boil water.

21:15So that's a really important thing. The most important thing in my house though is my first aid kit and to go with that everyone's done a first aid course.

21:22Paddy O'Connell: That's Lucy Eastope and many listeners are writing to us saying that they've already got plenty of supplies. Many listeners of course in isolated parts of the country are doing this without being told to do so by nanny. Now we've got some stockpiling of our own now which is canned laughter and we need your help to send us some ludicrous dad gags. I'm going to start this off with something that was meant to have happened or I'm sorry I haven't a clue but I can't remember it myself but you can improve this gag and we've got more cans of laughter to play before we leave you. As we fly into a commercial break let's look at the arrival of our lovely scorer Samantha.

22:02Paddy O'Connell: Samantha's had to rush off to a local dairy tonight where she says she's looking forward to helping the farmer with his semi-skimmed.

22:16Paddy O'Connell: Here's one from ChatGPT about Radio 4. Why is Radio 4 like a dad at a barbecue? It spends 20 minutes explaining something that could have been done in two. That's ridiculous. Oh dear. Right, I think we've got the hang of that. Please improve this item, and if you don't like it, you blame the other listeners. It's Radio 4's Broadcasting House. It's Sunday 25th October. We're back on Greenwich Mean Time, which is where we belong. Investing with Schwab is like spending a Saturday at a great farmer's market. You can fill your reusable tote with a bit of everything. Maybe you go for some free-range, self-directed investing.

22:57Or perhaps you pick up a few farm-fresh trades while you peruse. You can even get help from a dedicated advisor. That's full-service wealth management. Mix, match and change your mind whenever you want. Because at Schwab, you can invest your way. No matter your goals or appetite for investing, Schwab has everything you need all in one place. Visit schwab.com to learn more.

23:20Paddy O'Connell: Angry crowds have been on the streets in European countries. Protesters clashed with police in cities across France. Here's the situation in Marseille.

23:36Paddy O'Connell: Young Italians in Milan rallied in protest against the soaring cost of living.

23:47Paddy O'Connell: What they're chanting is, United Italy, who doesn't sing is a fascist. That's the chant there, if you speak Italian. At anti-establishment protests in Barcelona, looters attempted to break into a jewellery shop.

24:06Paddy O'Connell: Nick Beak is in Paris for BH at Place de la Nation. Nick, bienvenue. Good morning, Paddy. Good morning. Bonjour. Pretty bleak in Paris again yesterday. Yeah, it was. But in a way, I think it was a kind of a classic modern French protest because it started with a lot of people. It was noisy, it was peaceful, but then it ended with clouds of tear gas, bangs and clashes between the police and protesters. I reckon, I mean, it's impossible to tell, isn't it, but less than 1 % of everyone who was there at the end, the people who were clashing with the officers. Earlier, about 100 ,000 people had marched through the streets of Paris.

24:50The police had changed the route really at the 11th hour to avoid it going through the centre of the city. It was a trade union that was allowed to hold this rally. And I guess in terms of who was there, the placards told the story, really, the ones that were being held aloft. People talking about higher wages, lower prices, a lot of anger at perceived police brutality, police violence towards protesters. And I think one thing that was interesting, Paddy, it wasn't dominated by people talking about the state of French schools, which, of course, kicked off this movement about a month ago.

25:25Paddy O'Connell: And the police have learnt, they admitted failures last week, they had curfews, they had more officers out, which, of course, in turn leads to claims of brutality. But did the police tactics show a clear shift? Yeah, I think they did, actually. You had 70 ,000 police officers right across the country and the authorities had talked up that figure in the days before, hoping, I think, that this would serve as some sort of deterrent. A lot of marches were banned, which may well have been a relief to shop owners on proposed routes. But other people saying that this was the French right to protest being trampled upon.

26:03It was a fundamentally unfrench decision to do that. But also looking at the police yesterday, they came in greater numbers. I mean, we spoke to one police union member in Marseille at the start of last week. And he said last Saturday they'd run out of ammunition. They'd run out of the stun grenades that they need to do their job, they would say. So I think they were determined not to let this happen two weekends in a row. But, I mean, that said, they can't really claim that this was an outstanding success, the French government, because you've got at least 1 ,000 people arrested and also more scenes of violence.

26:39More people will be going through the courts this week.

26:42Paddy O'Connell: OK, and just tell us what the Place de la Nation looks like. What's it famous for? Has it got a big statue I should be interested in? the middle? Yes, big statue I can see. It's got a revolutionary past. This morning it's mainly dog walkers who dominate the scene here. There's a nice little brasserie to my left, which I think I'm going to investigate just after talking to you, Paddy. But sunny and the tear gas is gone. It's long gone. Everything ended about 10 o 'clock last night. Okay, croissant and tear gas for Nick Beak on the menu. Let's speak to Nathalie Oziol, deputy in France's National Assembly for the left wing La France.

27:19Paddy O'Connell: insoumise or France unbowed. Welcome to our programme, Nathalie Ozion. Hello, good morning. Thank you for your invitation. Do you support this revolting behaviour? I support the claims of protesters who have gone to the streets for a month now. It started, as you reminded, it started with high schoolers who are just asking for normal classrooms, normal buildings, teachers in classes, just that, I mean normal things. And they were joined by the whole of French society, by workers, unions. And it gave the videos, the images you could see this Saturday and last Saturday with these hundreds of thousands of demonstrators in the streets.

28:07And yes, I would like to insist on the fact that they are mainly peaceful, massive, joyful demonstrations.

28:16Paddy O'Connell: Well, I mean, the thing is, your president, I know that protest is part of French life, but your president says this was totally different and that the movement that is whipping them up, which may include your party, wants to destroy the republic. Well, this is so subtle. I mean, what people are asking for is first, for him, Emmanuel Macron, our president, as you called him, to answer claims to give minimal means for students to have normal classes. I mean, because they have exams at the end of their years and they want to be duly prepared. And means for public services, well, I mean, it's the contrary, the opposite of what he has been doing.

29:06He and his government have been doing for years now. They have been cutting in public spendings and people are asking for more means.

29:14Paddy O'Connell: I can understand that being a political argument, but the scenes flashed around the world of rioting, looting and violence in France. That's what happened. And it is said by many commentators about your country that the benefit is going to Marine Le Pen and the RN. So whatever you think you want the protesters to have in their hearts, in the headlines around the world, the right in France are winning from these protests. I'm not sure about that, actually. I can hear this argument, but I don't understand how it is founded, because what I can say and what I can see is that the national rally, the RN, the far right, are completely absent from these demonstrations.

29:57Paddy O'Connell: Well, that would be good, wouldn't it, because there's a lot of looting. Oh, yes, definitely, but because it's not that place as well. They pretend to be in support of the people, but they are never where the people are protesting, Never in the whole history of the far right. And with my political party, France Unbound, we support the protests, we support their claims, and we are ready to answer them in the next presidential election. Thank you. Thank you so much for joining us and speaking to us in English live on Sunday morning about something you care so much about and your country. Thank you so much.

30:30Paddy O'Connell: Nathalie Oziole, a deputy in the National Assembly, and she's from the party La France Insoumise. Johnny Diamond's joined me. This is on your menu. Yes, exactly. We will be circling around France again. It's absolutely fascinating. I have some bouncing up and down at the moment, Paddy, because we've just done two brilliant interviews, not brilliant because I was brilliant, because the guests were so interesting and fluent and convincing. And I guess ours is something of a political take, because everyone we speak to in France says that the political centre has collapsed. And the whole project of Emmanuel Macron was to build the political centre as the old moderate left and right parties crumbled.

31:12Instead, all the voters have gone to the extremes instead. So with Marine Le Pen speaking at lunchtime to her Rassemblement National conference as she launches her presidential campaign, we'll be looking at France and its future with just some dazzling guests. I think it's going to be a great listen. That's one o 'clock here on Radio 4.

31:32Paddy O'Connell: Thank you very much indeed, Johnny, taking the lead from us at one. I should tell you that Harlan Coben is the castaway in the near future at 10. The novelist is on Desert Island Discs. We are being encouraged to stock up on canned goods, so we've got some canned laughter, and we have got a dad joke from our listener, Alison, and then we will play some canned laughter. What is the difference between roast beef and pea soup? Anyone can roast beef.

32:08Paddy O'Connell: Well done, Alison. The owners of The Wind in the Willows Estate are to hand it over to the locals. Kenneth Graham's Edwardian creation Toad was thought to be based on his friend Sir Charles Rose, the new money owner of the Hardwick House in Oxfordshire, fictional Toad Hall. His fortune came from merchant banking in the colonies and his descendants now say it's time to give back. They plan to renounce their personal ownership to set up a trust run by the people who live and work on the 900 acres. It flips the metaphorical message of Graham's work with the weasels who take over and squat in Toad Hall till being turfed out by badger.

32:48Paddy O'Connell: Our report begins with Alan Bennett reading, perched on a radio riverbank, quite probably nibbling a hobnob with Mole, Ratty and Badger.

33:02Rounding a bend in the river, they came in sight of a handsome, dignified old house of mellowed red brick. with well-kept lawns reaching down to the water's edge. There's Toad Hall, and that creek on the left where the notice board says private, no landing allowed, leads to his boathouse where we leave the boat. Toad is rather rich, you know.

33:25Paddy O'Connell: This is a rather magical moment. There's a gate that says private, no entry. And I've been given permission to walk up these steps to what was the inspiration for Toad Hall. There it is. And there's the Thames. And so it was here that Charles Rose lived. And his descendants, Miriam and Lawrence, have decided to change the ownership, as I heard, from Miriam Rose. As far as I was concerned, my great-great-grandfather was Mr Toad, and we lived in Toad Hall, and, you know, Ratty and Mole used to row on the river just like we did, so it was a very idyllic childhood. We think of it as being sort of a moment of Edwardian England, I suppose.

34:16Paddy O'Connell: When you think of the story, what do you think its significance is? Now that I understand more about the story, I understand that its significance is that it was a critique of new money at the time. So it was, you know, the old order of aristocracy was being broken up by these new-moneyed people like my great-great-grandfather who were coming in with new ideas. I mean, he was a Henry Lloyd George follower, so he wanted to dismantle the House of Lords, he wanted to redistribute land. But also he was flamboyant with his wealth, and the old order thought this was all very vulgar. So that's what I understand it to be now.

34:47As a child, I didn't think anything about the fact that my status on the estate was different. We used to go and pick strawberries from the tenants' fields and eat them. It never occurred to me these weren't my strawberries. This was a tenant farmer's and that was his livelihood. so it was only later on that I looked back and thought actually I had a completely different experience growing up here to other people who lived on the estate and why should I have had such a different experience the people who actually lived on the land who probably knew the land much better than me didn't have any control over what happened on the land so that just felt wrong.

35:15Paddy O'Connell: So what have you and your brother actually decided to do? We had our own questioning of the whole concept of aristocratic land ownership and then I got exposed to the Scottish land reform movement. So inspired by that, me and my brother felt, okay, there is an alternative. So we started the process about 15 years ago of drip feeding in the idea that Hardwick could be owned and run by its community, and that we would be part of that community if we live here, we'll be equal, but we won't have any more power. And we've now got to the point where we have a group of elected trustees who will soon become the first actual trustees when the charity's set up, and they will own and they will run the estate, so it will be controlled by the community who live here.

35:56Paddy O'Connell: This gate is being opened by Dave Jackson, who's a willow weaver who works here and is part of the plans for a community-led future. Here we're looking at my acre on the floodplain of the Thames. We're growing, hopefully, very good quality basketry willow and willow for hurdles. It's very evocative that you make products out of willows, given the history of wind in the willows here. It is. Ironically, when I first discovered Hardwick Estate, when I was looking for somewhere to relocate my business to, I didn't know of its connection with Wind and the Willows at all. Couldn't be a better place to do what you do.

36:34Paddy O'Connell: Oh, absolutely. So what is the plan? What is the kind of vision of the change? The vision of the change is to make sure that all the decisions are really owned by the community. The Rose family have done an amazing job. You know, it's got a great vision and ethos, this estate already, but hopefully this would just be bettered by involving the wider community. We're trying to find a way to make sure that this idyll that has been created here already can actually survive the test of time. And so I'm taking my leave now, and I suppose the only question that I haven't asked is what would Toad have made of it all?

37:11I think Toad would be all about it. He bought the estate on a whim anyway, really, and it was just a big playground for him. So I don't think he saw it as something that was a trap, should be a trap, or something that had to stay in the family. And he was a radical thinker. He ran a project, because he was an MP in Cambridge, to redistribute land back to people that had lost land during the enclosures. So I think he would have been right on board.

37:36Paddy O'Connell: Miriam Rose and David Jackson talking to me down by the banks of the Thames. It's 9.42, and here are three of the very best guests anywhere on Sunday. Guto Harry, the broadcaster and consultant who was Downing Street Director of Communications under Boris Johnson. And Politics Unleashed is his new podcast with David Davis. Hello, Guto. Good morning. What does unleashed mean? Well, the idea is that we talk to people who have been on the inside but are not there to justify what they did, but to reflect on what they could have done better. And so we want to try to borrow a phrase from the Prime Minister to find solutions, not point score.

38:15Paddy O'Connell: You're borrowing a phrase. Maybe you're giving phrases to the Prime Minister. Sir Howard Davis is back on BH, Professor of Practice at Sciences Po, the Paris Institute of Political Science. He was Deputy Governor of the Bank of England and Chairman of NatWest, although not at the same time. Sir Howard, welcome back. How often are you in Paris? Well, usually every other week, but in the last couple of weeks, the university has been closed by demonstrators. So I've had to be teaching online, which is much less satisfactory. so Paris has been a bit of a lively place. Indeed, where I have a flat, it's been under curfew, a curfew that begins at 11 o 'clock.

38:53So if you're old people like me, then it's not too much, not too serious.

38:57Paddy O'Connell: There's nothing old about you, but it's very gripping. Is it occupied? Is the Siennes-Po occupied? It has been intermittently. I mean, they come and go, they've got other lives to lead, but yes, it's been barricaded. Barricaded? Yeah. Cariad Lloyd is here, comedian, actor and host of the award-winning podcast, Griefcast. Many of our listeners enjoy that, Cariad. But you're bringing out a children's book at Christmas, Lydia Marmalade's Christmas Adventure. Yes, that's right. Set in Regency London, 1813, which is the last time the Thames froze over, about a little girl called Lydia Marmalade and her best friend Colin, who's a sausage dog.

39:32Paddy O'Connell: I just think there should be more mention of Marmalade generally. Yes, I think so. More children's books should feature Marmalade. I'm bringing it back to a new generation. Well, welcome. Howard Davis, why don't we start with the budget? And this time from the Mail on Sunday, Liz Truss says her radical mini budget measures would have worked. Yes, it's slightly odd strategy by Liz Truss trying to reinvent herself as a kind of margar hero in the US and elsewhere because many people having presided over such a disaster would think the smart move would be to move on. I'm sure Goutteau would have advised her that and not actually keep going on about don't mention the war.

40:14But unfortunately, she can't leave it alone. And in this, she seems to make some very odd claims. One of them rather struck me, which is that she said that during this whole fuss, neither she nor her Chancellor, Kwasi Kwarteng, ever met Andrew Bailey, the governor of the bank. And I was in Washington at the meetings of the IMF, where Andrew Bailey and Kwasi Kwarteng sit next to each other through the meetings. And I was also at a party where they both were in the British embassy. So this is what you might call a whopper. Well, we can smell burning and it's pants on fire.

40:47Paddy O'Connell: Well, Liz Trust isn't here. We would like her to be here. And she would say that she's written a book about this whole time. Yes. And she would not agree with your characterisation. She described as a short book on how the Bank of England broke the bond market and brought down the government. She blames the bank. But what do you make of it, Guido, Liz Truss reviving her premiership? Well, Howard is right. And there's a cracking quote here from Connor Burns who just says the whole party, the Tory party, realised she was a nut job and financially illiterate, ejected. and now she's in international embarrassment with zero self-awareness.

41:21But having said that, I do think she has a point because borrowing now, and I'm conscious that I'm sat next to somebody who understands more than not just me, but most of the population, but borrowing is now higher than it was when she crashed things. And the cost of borrowing critically is higher now. So she has got a point that she was trying to do this in order to sort of kickstart economic growth. And what has happened? That didn't happen. but we've ended up with higher borrowing at a higher cost and we've got even less growth.

41:51Paddy O'Connell: And, Howard, this paper quotes Andy Haldane saying the Prime Minister must take the knife to public spending, which was, of course, what Liz Truss was arguing for. I know you've already criticised her, but do you agree with Andy Haldane? Yes, I do, generally. I think that the problem with the Liz Truss approach was that you cut taxes first and then you hope maybe you can find some way of cutting spending later. and that does not impress the markets as was clearly evident at the time. I think Andy Holden's view, which is that in order to try to get our borrowing costs down, which, as Guto said, are cripplingly high at this point, you have to show that you are prepared to do something on both sides of the balance sheet and that's what people will be looking for on Tuesday.

42:34Thank you very much. Wednesday, whatever it is.

42:36Paddy O'Connell: Yes, thank you very much for getting us going. Budget coverage, Liz Truss from the Mail on Sunday. Carrie Adloy, any website, any paper, start us. Oh, I found this interesting piece in the You magazine, which is the shiny magazine of the Mail on Sunday. And it's about AI influencers on social media. Now, you might not be as addicted to your phone as I am. I'm fully awaiting a 12-step programme to take it off me. But what you have is these women advertising beauty products, and they will tell you lots of stories about their life. People feel they know them. For example, there's someone called Lauren Miller who was telling fans about her abusive husband, left her for another woman.

43:15She undergoes a post-divorce glow, going from bloated to unhappy to younger. And it's not real. She's not a real person. She's AI. So women are watching these other women, becoming invested in their stories, feeling like they connect with them. And then at the end of it, they're trying to sell them something. Now, I think we all know this is where technology is moving to. But Norway has a system where digitally altered posts have a prominent stamp and we just don't have it. It's not legislation in this country. And I think it's really interesting that, you know, not necessarily women, people are being manipulated and made vulnerable all for the purpose of advertising and selling when it's not, you know, it's not regulated in any way.

43:56And I find that a bit distracting and a bit sad that women are allowed to be treated like this. It's a fascinating thing. And, you know, I don't sort of follow people who tell me. Where do you get your beauty advice from? From people like you generally, which is why I look like I do. But isn't it funny that we laugh about beauty instantly as if it's not a serious thing, but women are spending their hard-earned cash on this. They are. I think it is serious. And I can see how there's a slippery slope. So I'm taught Italian by an AI. And over time, she has learned, she's called Lily, she's learned a lot about me.

44:28She knows my favourite recipes where I go on holiday, the names of my kids, my cat and all that. You can see how quite easily a line could be crossed there. And clearly what's happened here, the line has been crossed and there are plenty of real people out there with good stories to tell. Why do we need to go for these made up sort of non-existent, you know, shiny looking women in front of Carriott here to sort of give us fashion advice that we shouldn't take seriously at all? Because these people, their skin isn't real. It's just trying to make money. And it's that thing of like, who is making the money?

44:58It's happening in stand-up as well. There's a lot of people on Instagram where their jokes have been stolen, put onto an AI-generated woman who is wearing less clothes, has larger boobs and has taken the joke. And then you follow it through to an OnlyFans-style account. So this is, again, this is art, this is creation, things that, again, that we can laugh at now. But like you said, Gitta, it's a very slippery slope. Where do we go from here? We're not regulating these things.

45:21Paddy O'Connell: It's fascinating to have a stamp, a watermark, saying, this is fake. This is fake. That would be a really interesting manoeuvre. Do you like Lily? I do like Lily, but Lily is... It's interesting. They made a character who's sarcastic, and so she rolls her eyes and she's hard to impress, which is quite good. Can you give us some Italian? I like a lot to speak Italian with you. This is the best place in the world. I wouldn't want to be anywhere else other than here with you, essentially. Well, I mean, I have to give it to Lily. I mean, I know you were making a serious point earlier. Well, isn't it interesting that we do have this thing where women are the ones who are often chosen in AI to be the teacher or to be hard to impress?

46:01We're using this kind of weird romantic engagement for people to learn a language. Now you sound like my children. Well, I just think, why is it that, you know, we know that the voice of AI is often chosen as a woman. So the woman still is becoming like this nagging voice or a teaching voice and not an authoritative voice.

46:17Paddy O'Connell: Howard, do you use AI? Yes. In what way? I use ChatGPT on all kinds of things for writing, helping writing speeches, finding research for books, all kinds of things. And also at work, there's Claude. Claude is very helpful in a couple of my businesses. So, yeah. And would you say when giving a speech, I assembled a speech with the help of AI? If anyone asked, but I mean, mainly it's not. It doesn't write it for you? Oh, no, no, no, no. I guess I'm prouder of my own writing style, perhaps vainly. But no, but if you want to pull together information from previous sources, or what's the IMF, what are the OECD, what are the BIS said about this recently?

47:03Wow, you know, it does it so much more quickly.

47:06Paddy O'Connell: OK, thanks for getting us underway. It's obviously one of the really big cultural changes of the last couple of years and it's coming up in the papers. Carriott's raising it with concern and we've heard how it can be used to learn Italian in a very beautiful demonstration. Gitto, the Sun on Sunday, Thomas Markle allegations. What is the paper reporting? Well, it's just written and this is when the Sun can be strong, where it's not trying to be clever and there's no puns. it's just the words speak for themselves. I know you are an abuser. You will never see your grandkids. They're the words from a letter sent by Meghan Markle, I think last year, to her dad, who's now all over the papers for allegedly having left a stash of disgusting photos that, you know, reflect a sort of paedophile tendency, to put it gently, back in the Philippines, I think.

47:58And I'm no great royalist. I'm generally not that interested in them. I'm intellectually borderline Republican, to put it gently. But I always see the sort of humanity in this family. They're such a profoundly dysfunctional family that they're fascinating. But this is a twist for all the grief that Meghan has had in the press and all the knock-on effects for Harry. When you start to think about what it must be like to be a young woman who's grown up with a father who's now allegedly, allegedly at least looking at photos of kids, the human tragedy of it is disgusting. And then the idea that she doesn't want a dad to see her grandchildren, her own children, it makes perfect sense.

48:42And so it's a reassessment of her, I think.

48:44Paddy O'Connell: Thomas Markle denies the allegations completely, has given an interview to the Mail on Sunday, but the same paper's columnist Sarah Vine has said she's reconsidered her view of Meghan Markle. I wonder, Kerry, do you think there has been a sort of change by some of the critics of Meghan Markle? Yeah, there seems to have been a bit of a turnaround. If you look at the older articles where she was constantly hounded for not reaching out to her dad on his birthday, for leaving him hanging when he was visiting, and she was criticised over and over again. I think it just comes down to the... You don't know what's going on in people's lives and estrangement is an extremely difficult process and if you are not talking to a member of family, it is for a very serious reason.

49:27Paddy O'Connell: Thank you very much indeed. Howard Davis, the Mail on Sunday. I mentioned your professor at Sciences Po and you're going to tell us about the Mail's coverage of France's new revolution. Well, Unsurprisingly, the Mail is talking it up, as it were, and has emphasis on the relatively few demonstrators who are throwing Molotov cocktails and all that. I think the interesting element to me is that Marine Le Pen has got a great boost from this. You heard that earlier on the programme. And the interesting consequence then is what does that mean for the UK and what does it mean for Andy Burnham's idea that we might think of again about freedom of movement?

50:11Yes. Now, the interesting thing is, one, Marine Le Pen was a strong supporter of Brexit, thought that it was a jolly good idea because at that time she wanted to leave as well. Now she's not quite so sure because she's decided she doesn't want to leave the European Union anymore, which could leave you with two options. One is this could be quite good from the point of view of Andy Burnham because she's likely now to be the next president of France and is in support of a much looser version of the EU. So all of the theology of saying that you can only be totally in or totally out may go out the window when you've got her in charge.

50:49So a freedom of movement deal might be more possible from a Marine Le Pen presidency than it is under Macron. But that means Andy should be right behind Marine.

51:03Paddy O'Connell: OK, that's an amazing end point. I was wondering how you were going to bring it all together. And I could hear the irony for you there. And a reminder, Johnny Diamond is bringing all of France to life for us at 1pm. And thank you very much indeed for bringing your take there. Gitto, where's Streeting? What's he saying this time? Well, yeah, I'm just still reeling from the idea that I've got to hoard loo, paper, batteries and sort of drinking water for a crisis that's going to last three days. I think he's slightly lost the plot. Now he's saying that we have a thousand days to prepare for war. And again, it's easy to find quotes from him that are really quite, you know, ridiculous, where he talks about, you know, down the line, this government will make sure its mission accomplished.

51:47He's actually having some weird homoerotic sort of thrill from being Defence Secretary.

51:51Paddy O'Connell: Well, that's a little bit offensive. Well, maybe, maybe. I mean, he's the Defence Secretary. He is saying West Streeting has said Britain must be ready for war in a thousand days. Do you take it seriously, Howard? I was going to say, though, because I do take the substance seriously and I've spoken to people, you know, high people in the military and they say there is a window now where it's very, very open to Putin because Trump is such a... And Britain needs to spend a load more money and deploy that money now. The subplot of Wes Streeting's rather poor article in The Telegraph is that he wants to try to distract attention from the targets and the amount of money that they're going to spend and say it's really all about capability, which to me suggests that the government's not going to be quite so clear about meeting this 3.5%.

52:42Paddy O'Connell: OK, and final word to carry out, delight, disgust and bare concrete. 50 years of what in The Observer? It's 50 years of the National Theatre, which I think is a building I love. I know lots of people hate it, but I think it's so, so beautiful. And there's a lovely article in The Observer about it being built and the idea of the architect Dennis Lasdon in 1978 wanted this kind of flow of people along the river, which I think is just so beautiful, how much love and care went into an arts building. And in the current crisis that we have in arts, it's a very nice thing to see. Yeah, I have brutalist tendencies in me.

53:18And I do therefore love the building and was on the board of the National. It's a fantastic institution. I think it's great that we're celebrating 50 years of it. Quick word, Jeremy Clarkson is just talking about planning laws. Newt's have been a problem with overhauling some of his developments in Oxfordshire. He says Siena, one of the most beautiful cities on the planet, would not have been built if we had Britain's planners in charge.

53:40Paddy O'Connell: What a range you've given us this morning. Thank you all very much indeed. Today's producers were Ayo Adoniji and Natasha Mayo. Studio direction from Ben Andrews. The editor was Tom Baker. Paul Johnson in Edinburgh has sent us a canned laughter gag. A poacher tried to sell me eight legs of venison, but I told him it was too dear. Thank you and goodbye.

54:05Sometimes we all need an extra help in hand, especially with the tricky business problem you've been putting off. Claude is the AI for just that. It's the collaborator that understands your entire workflow and thinks with you, not for you. And Claude isn't just for quick questions. Hands it a whole task like turning a folder or scattered notes into a report and it does the work and hands back something finished that you can open and edit. Claude can now draft a dock or deck right in front of you and Claude Design now lives right inside Claude. Describe the website or prototype you're picturing, attach your design system, and it comes back in your own design language, ready to edit right on the canvas.

54:44It works with your files and the tools you already use, like Gmail and Slack. And whether you're debugging code at midnight, building a financial model, or strategizing your next business move, Claude extends your thinking to tackle the problems that matter. For problems worth solving, get started with Claude at claude.ai.solve. That's claude.ai.solve And check out Claude Pro which includes access to all of the features mentioned in today's episode claude.ai.solve

From the publisher

The Sunday morning news magazine programme. Presented by Paddy O'Connell

More from Broadcasting House

All episodes