

22 Nov 2026 · 50m · 22 chapters

The episode’s main topic is Brexit and the UK-EU relationship, sparked by claims that Prime Minister Andy Burnham is being warned by two former leaders. Guests discuss whether the EU needs reform and outline trade-offs among four options: full rejoin, rejoin the single market, rejoin the customs union, or the current “deals” approach. Key claims include that the EU must be reformed (especially for enlargement), that the Friday deal will help jobs, household bills, border security, and reduce paperwork for exporters (example: a London business needing 56 export health certificate stamps on 22 papers). They also argue tuition fees for EU nationals will be negotiated during a transition, with implementation of three agreements up to 2028/2030.
Nick Thomas-Symonds, former EU negotiation minister in Keir Starmer’s government; and Sanjo Gotzi, French MEP (Italian), chairing the EU-UK Parliamentary Assembly delegation.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Discussion on Brexit warnings from former leaders Blair and May.
“And we talked about the joy of joining a choir.”
Exploration of historical perspectives on UK-EU relations.
“sure that the United Kingdom is as strong economically in security terms and in terms of opportunities for people as it can be.”
Discussion on the current state of negotiations and relationships.
“Harold Macmillan urged closer relations in 1961, which the French rebuffed twice.”
Exploring the idea of the UK rejoining the EU and its implications.
“We can speak to two men who know each other and have dealt with the current relationship between us all.”
Addressing challenges faced in current EU agreements and negotiations.
“And what I want to do is to have an honest debate about it.”
Discussion about the goodwill and personal relationships in negotiations.
“But we have to get a better, closer relationship.”
Listeners enjoy a performance of 'I Saw The Lord' by the choir.
“I lift thee up, I lift thee up And strength in the temple, strength in the temple.”
Discussion on the significance of remembering war dead and their names.
“I'm a believer by the Monkees, thanks to the Asher Glasgow Rock Choir, performing Kill Winning Abbey.”
A deep dive into the history and service of W.J. Snelling, a local war hero.
“He is buried in Hill Cemetery in Horsham and he actually has the Commonwealth war dead grave reference, H.326.”
Sharing the experiences of Sergeant Leonard Gomm during WWI.
“With thanks to Janet, who we've nicknamed Miss Marple here, Sergeant Leonard Gomm of the 10th Battalion London Regiment survived the First World War.”
Listeners share personal impacts of researching historical figures from the war.
“He's quite bitter, quite bitter about a lot of things.”
A discussion about the struggles of young people in the job market.
“which include the fabulous podcast series Voices of the First World War.”
Sir Charlie Mayfield discusses various reviews and their implications for the job market.
“10 ,000, up to 10 ,000 job applications and nothing except AI.”
The discussion focuses on the contrasting recommendations from the Milburn and Tim's reviews.
“And that is the job of leaders and government and others to figure out how they're going to balance all of those things and ultimately how they do that determines whether we actually achieve the changes that we can.”
Catherine Jenkins highlights the emotional and social benefits of participating in choirs.
“The Spalding Community Choir in South Lincolnshire were rehearsing yesterday afternoon as we continue our enjoyment of listeners and they sent us their rendition of the Game of Thrones theme tune.”
The conversation reflects on the legacy of the show Spitting Image and its impact on political satire.
“It's like the ultimate social cohesion tool.”
Discussion on the impact of political satire and nostalgia on public perception.
“and the nostalgia, you should refresh your view, what some of our reviews say.”
Examination of media coverage regarding Burnham's deal with the EU and its implications.
“Puppet master and great tributes paid to Peter Fluck.”
A touching story about Anna Hall who learned to read at 82, inspiring others.
“OK, so just to say that there's coverage everywhere of this, and Dom, I'm not going to ask you to come in, only because we did lead the programme on it.”
Insightful talk about a documentary exploring the Theranos scandal and its implications.
“And my favourite bit of this story is when she completed this course called the Read Easy programme, her kids, who didn't know she was illiterate, by the way, took her out for a meal where she wore a mortarboard.”
Discussion on utilizing retirees' skills during potential cyber attacks on organizations.
“I think it's the best thing I've seen in about 10 years.”
Final thoughts and highlights from the week's news across various topics.
“and pay suppliers without their usual software.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On Broadcasting House, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00Gareth Malone: This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK.
0:05Katherine Jenkins: Decisions made in Washington can affect your portfolio every day, but what policy changes should investors be watching?
0:14Gareth Malone: Washington Wise is an original podcast from Charles Schwab that unpacks the stories making news in Washington right now and how they may affect your finances and portfolio.
0:25Katherine Jenkins: Listen at schwab.com slash Washington Wise. That's schwab.com slash Washington Wise.
0:55Katherine Jenkins: is brought to you by Crown Royal. Please drink responsibly.
1:05Gareth Malone: Hello, here's the podcast of BH from Sunday the 22nd of November. Brexit's back, can you believe? And we talked about the joy of joining a choir. But first, the ghosts of Downing Street are haunting Andy Burnham over Brussels this weekend. Sir Tony Blair, a Leave opponent, told the Sunday Times the UK could only ever return to a reformed EU, while Baroness May, who quit as PM in anguish over Brexit, told Laura Koonsberg she was aghast at the new PM opening up any talk of rejoin.
1:36Sir Charlie Mayfield: I almost think this is what Andy Burnham is saying to the British people, sort of patting them on the head, he wants to pat them on the head and say, you know what, remember that vote? Well, you got it wrong, didn't you? So have another go and come out with the right answer or what he thinks is the right answer. But as I say, let's just get on with making sure that the United Kingdom is as strong economically in security terms and in terms of opportunities for people as it can be.
2:05Katherine Jenkins: I was painted as saying the British should just go back and rejoin. I'm not saying that. It's heavily conditioned because, and we have to be prepared to walk away from that negotiation, which is another reason why domestically we should be taking the reforms necessary to make our own economy strong and our own technology sector strong, so that when we have that negotiation with Europe, they're thinking we really don't want these guys outside Europe.
2:33Gareth Malone: We've listened to 65 years of British Prime Ministers tackling and gripping the European question. We'd like to see if you agree that the language is strikingly similar over the decades to today. Harold Macmillan urged closer relations in 1961, which the French rebuffed twice. Edward Heath said on joining the EEC in 1973, it would remove obstacles, and then he played Beethoven. Harold Wilson claimed the 1975 referendum ended years of argument. John Major urged the Tory party to stop squabbling. I could go on, and you know I have done. But instead, step with us into the circus tent of UK-EU relations.
3:28Sir Tony Blair: Think of the peoples of Europe. We already have close ties,
3:31Katherine Jenkins: and I firmly believe that it is our destiny to work more and more closely with them. There's no future for our continent, and that includes us,
3:42Sir Tony Blair: unless we get rid of all these obstructions.
3:47Katherine Jenkins: 14 years of national argument are over.
3:52Sir Charlie Mayfield: No, no, no.
3:55Gareth Malone: Parliament must put this stalemate over Europe behind it.
4:00Katherine Jenkins: We're not fighting each other anymore. These are our partners, they're our colleagues, and our future lies in Europe. Our plan for Europe gives us the best of both worlds. The choice is in your hands.
4:14Sir Charlie Mayfield: No deal is better than a bad deal.
4:18Sir Tony Blair: We will be an independent coastal state with full control of our waters. Today we do draw a line on a decade of drift and division by reconnecting with old friends.
4:35Gareth Malone: We can speak to two men who know each other and have dealt with the current relationship between us all. Nick Thomas-Simmons led negotiations with the EU as Minister for European Relations in Keir Starmer's government. Hello, Nick. Hello, good morning. Good to join you. And Sanjo Gotzi is the French MEP who's Italian, so he's really two guests in one. He chairs the European delegation to the EU-UK Parliamentary Assembly. Sanjo, welcome. Good morning and thanks for inviting me. When you hear that 65 years, do you know why listeners can be accused of feeling exhausted by it all, Sanjo?
5:14Baroness Theresa May: It is unavoidable because, I mean, you don't choose geography and you don't choose interest after all. And geography and interest push you UK to be together in a way or another. So, I mean, I understand 65 years of debate. Then if you could make your mind once for all, it would be better for everybody.
5:35Gareth Malone: Yes. OK, well, here's another way. We agree the UK can't settle. Do you agree the UK won't reform?
5:44Baroness Theresa May: The EU or UK won't reform?
5:46Gareth Malone: Sorry, the EU won't reform.
5:49Baroness Theresa May: I strongly think that the EU needs badly to be reformed. We are talking about enlarging the EU. We are talking about newcomers from the Western Balkans. We even talk in the long run of Ukraine, in the EU, and I do not think that this would be possible without an important reform of the EU. Then I don't know if I was listening to Tony Blair. I don't know if the reform of the EU is thinking in the same reform that we are thinking, but certainly it must be reformed. But how can it be a matter for discussion?
6:24Gareth Malone: And should we rejoin, Nick?
6:27Sir Tony Blair: well i think that the eu and the uk will certainly be closer together if you're asking me in 10 years time precisely what form that takes i think this is the moment to have a clear debate as to what the trade-offs are of the different options i want to see those uh trade-offs uh set out now broadly speaking we have four options don't we there's to rejoin there is to rejoin the single market, there is to rejoin the customs union and there is something along the position we have at the moment which is that we are looking at different areas and having deals. I think by the way the deal that was struck on Friday that will be good for jobs, I think it will be done on household bills, will be good for securing our borders.
7:14Sir Tony Blair: So that's what I think we need to see in this national conversation we're going to have.
7:18Gareth Malone: Nick, was that an answer to the question do you want to rejoin? Nick, do you?
7:24Sir Tony Blair: Well, look, I was... Try an answer.
7:27Gareth Malone: Just try an answer.
7:28Sir Tony Blair: Well, the answer to your question is, in each of these cases, it depends on the terms. It depends. And what I want to do is to have an honest debate about it. Because the problem with the rejoin question, let me just say why it is. At the moment, it's a bit of a fantasy debate because people are having a debate about, well, what would the EU want in return? You know, you just heard there a clip from Tony Blair who's talking about rejoin but saying, hang on, we want to deal with AI in a different way. So what we have to do is see what the terms are on rejoin, what the terms are on the customs union single market, and make a choice that is in our national interest.
8:04Gareth Malone: OK, because Theresa May has said she's aghast. That's the warning to Andy Burnham. And she left the job in tears. So she's warning him. What do you make of Theresa May's warning? I've always got great respect for what Theresa May says.
8:20Sir Tony Blair: She has a lot of experience in terms of negotiating with the EU. However, I do think this is a necessary debate. And I think it's a necessary debate because the current status quo is not working for businesses and households. Let me just give you an example. I was passed a document by my team from a business in London that wants to export out into the EU. And they has to get an export health certificate, 56 wet stamps on 22 pieces of paper. Now, that is the kind of thing that the deal was struck on Friday will take away. But we have to get a better, closer relationship. And it's also, by the way, for geopolitical reasons, because of the war in Ukraine, Putin's illegal war.
9:00Sir Tony Blair: We need to come together on security and defence. And also the fact the Americans' permanent shift, it seems to me, of lowering defence spending in Europe as well. So we need to come close together.
9:12Gareth Malone: Sandro, the Sundays are full of detail about the agreement architecture. that says the Commission had a draft agreement which member states then ambushed over tuition fees. Can you clarify for us if you think the deal Andy Burnham signed will last if we do not compromise on tuition fees for EU nationals?
9:33Baroness Theresa May: Well, for the fall, to be very precise in every single detail, I should read the legal text. The legal text will be published next week, I believe. I think that it is pretty clear, however, how it will work from the operational point of view. We have now, until 2028, to implement the three important agreements. I agree with Nick. Important agreements will bring a concrete result, make life easier for business and increase opportunities for youth. And it will take time. In the meantime, and within six months, so I mean, well before the implementation of the three deals, we will continue discussion with the commitment to find a solution on tuition fees.
10:17Baroness Theresa May: That is, so I mean, basically tuition fees will be discussed in the next semester and all the rest will be implemented by 2028 with producing effect at the latest by 2030. This is my understanding, but to be very precise, I should read legal text.
10:31Gareth Malone: Yes, and Sandra, that doesn't sound to me like a very clear answer to the question. It's a bit like Nick tackling the rejoin question. It's so complicated, it gives us the whole relationship in two answers, which is why we're very lucky to have you. Can I ask you both, what's it like when you talk to each other face to face in the room? Can you tell us if you've enjoyed when you negotiate together? Do you love it? Is there a lot of goodwill which we don't report on the radio, Sandra?
10:59Baroness Theresa May: I think Thomas Simons did a great job and I think that he should he deserved to get at least part of the merit of the deal on Friday because these are things that we have been discussing together for a long time and also he is a very great professional, I enjoy very much I'm also a good friend of Britain in general as many politicians in your country, from the left from the right, from the centre knows So, I mean, for me, the more we discuss and the closer we come together, the better. So, I mean, this is my personal attitude, which is always constructive towards London.
11:37Sir Tony Blair: And Nick? Yes, is the answer to your question. There were huge amounts of goodwill in the room, whether, you know, I've spoken to Sandra many, many times over the past two years, but also the relationship that I had with Commissioner Sefcovic, with whom I negotiated. And there's nothing inconsistent between the two of us negotiating very robustly. he in the interest of the EU, me in the interests of the United Kingdom, but also having a very close friendship. And there was a real sense of goodwill. And I sensed it when I was doing the job in opposition and building the contacts around Europe. But also when I came into government, there was a real sense of relief, I found, that here was the UK wanting to come back into a close relationship with the EU.
12:21Sir Tony Blair: And I think both sides felt it was a mutual benefit. Well, it's been a mutual benefit to have you two talking to us.
12:26Gareth Malone: Thank you very much. indeed do come back together, separately and constantly, maybe, in the next few years. It's 20 past nine, nearly. Philippa and Louis are our listeners who've been on holiday in Switzerland. They went to Grier to see the cheesemaking factory. They wandered around the village, up to the castle, and were treated to the gentle tinkling of bells of the sheep grazing in the fields below. It was one of those lovely, unhurried moments they've written to us that seemed to capture the very essence of Switzerland, shared only now on Radio 4 as Sunday's Slow Radio.
13:31Gareth Malone: TINA RITCHIE, DO YOU WANT A TINKLING BELL?
13:33Sir Charlie Mayfield: I love a bell. In fact, Paddy, as I was reading the cue material to Bells on Sunday this morning, I think we should have more bells on Radio 4.
13:42Gareth Malone: More bells, you've heard it here first. The mezzo-soprano Catherine Jenkins is singing the praises of joining a choir. We'll hear from her later. First, let's enjoy listeners in two vibrant active groups. Harrow Philharmonic Choir, performed alongside the Harrow String Collective at Pinner Paris Church last night and sent us this. I saw the Lord sitting upon a throne I lift thee up, I lift thee up And strength in the temple, strength in the temple. I saw the Lord, sitting on a throne, riding their eyes. Fabulous. Thanks to the choir there, I Saw The Lord by John Stainer, and Ayrshire and Glasgow Rock Choir were performing in Kill Winning Abbey.
15:43Gareth Malone: I'm a believer by the Monkees, thanks to the Asher Glasgow Rock Choir, performing Kill Winning Abbey. Our listeners just won't stop singing and Tina Rich is dancing. I must warn you. Listeners have also been sharing with us the power of just one name to honour the war dead. 500 ,000 British and Commonwealth men went missing on land, sea and in the air in the First World War. They have no known grave. India raised history's largest volunteer army in World War II. 255 service personnel died in the Falklands War. 457 in the recent Afghan conflict. Faced with it all, we the public have been left proud, grieving, awestruck or furious.
16:24Gareth Malone: So what then could be the impact of just one name heard on Radio 4? We're after your new research. Janet is our listener in Horsham. She's walked past its war memorial for 30 years and only this week has she decided to learn about one of its hundreds of names, which we say now, W.J. Snelling.
16:46Sir Charlie Mayfield: He died in 1919 and he's buried locally. He is buried in Hill Cemetery in Horsham and he actually has the Commonwealth war dead grave reference, H.326.
17:00Gareth Malone: And how did he look? What are the details?
17:03Sir Charlie Mayfield: So he was 5 '6 when he was 18. He had blue eyes and light brown hair.
17:09Gareth Malone: So already when you walk past in Horsham, you know W.J. Snelling, you can picture him as being a sort of slim young man.
17:19Sir Charlie Mayfield: Yes, yes.
17:20Gareth Malone: He progressed through the Navy and he was promoted a lot.
17:23Sir Charlie Mayfield: Yes, he joined as a boy. And when you joined as a boy, you joined up long term. so a lot of his work was training obviously and then went through a boy first class and ordinary seaman and ended up as a naval seaman.
17:42Gareth Malone: And did his ships see battle?
17:44Sir Charlie Mayfield: Well one of them HMS Albemarle spent time in the Channel Fleet as part of the blockade of Germany but it was damaged in very heavy weather on the way to the Dardanelles so it had to return and didn't actually take part in that campaign. But most of his time on ships was actually spent guarding the southern parts of England.
18:13Gareth Malone: And then do we know from the work you did if he was considered a good character? Was there notes about how he served and what kind of shipmate he was?
18:24Sir Charlie Mayfield: Yes, he was always recorded as very good and his ability was never less than satisfactory. So, yes, he was obviously a very good sailor, yes.
18:35Gareth Malone: And then he had an illness, which is how he died. What happened?
18:40Sir Charlie Mayfield: Well, he was invalided out of the Navy in October 1917 because he had diabetes. And this was something I hadn't realised. In days pre-insulin, diabetes was virtually a death sentence. And he actually died in 1919 when he was 22. But because this was within the war dead criteria, he still classed as war dead.
19:09Gareth Malone: And what impact has it had on you as a local of finding out just one name?
19:15Sir Charlie Mayfield: Well, it's interesting because I hadn't even realised that we had war graves in Horsham and I actually saw something that goes on over Christmas where you can go and put a candle on people's war graves so that they're all remembered over Christmas. So I think that's a lovely idea. I think I may well be doing that.
19:38Gareth Malone: With thanks to Janet, who we've nicknamed Miss Marple here, Sergeant Leonard Gomm of the 10th Battalion London Regiment survived the First World War. He fought on the first day of the Battle of the Somme. July 1st, 1916, was the bloodiest in British history, and he was there. He became angry at the losses whilst proud of the bravery of his comrades. We know this because he was recorded speaking for the Imperial War Museum by the BBC. We broadcast his voice to you a couple of weeks ago to ask if anyone knew more about him or the comrade he buried, Sergeant McKenzie.
20:12Katherine Jenkins: Even if we were up to our neck in mud, somehow old Mac always looked as though he'd just stepped out of a band box. And here again, sad to relate, he was killed. And before we put him in a winding sheet and I buried him personally, I parted his hair and straightened him up. And but for a bullet wound in the back, you wouldn't have known that he was even dead. I shall never forget him. He was one of my best pals. And when these things happen, it's just another notch of bitterness that remains.
20:49Gareth Malone: Listening to that on BH was Lindsay, who felt compelled to research that man, just one name, Leonard Gomm. I asked her what she'd found out. What were his views of the war?
21:02Sir Charlie Mayfield: He's quite bitter, quite bitter about a lot of things. and he was very concerned about things like army morale and the way that the men, the fighting men, were treated. It's another case of, you know, keeping them in the dark and they didn't know what was going on. They just got moved from place to place. I just wonder what you think about him
21:30Gareth Malone: and whether his voice sounds very ancient to you. What kind of impression?
21:35Sir Charlie Mayfield: No, no, not at all. Absolutely contemporary and with very contemporary views. I mean, contemporary to us now, never mind in 1976. Lots of stuff on what he thought the mistakes were regarding the economy, his views on anti-Semitism. He spoke very well of every Jewish person he had ever encountered. Very, I mean, startlingly contemporary.
22:06Gareth Malone: What's been the effect on you of going this extra mile to do this work? What kind of impact has it had on you?
22:14Sir Charlie Mayfield: Oh, I love research. I've spent my retirement on the internet. It's like a vast library. You can find out so much, you can learn so much. and it's quite extraordinary when you come across audio like this and it's now made me think, well, next time I take time off from all the tedious things we have to do online, I might have a look and see what else I can find.
22:45Gareth Malone: With thanks to Lindsay, she's talking about the IWM Collections Online which include the fabulous podcast series Voices of the First World War. We plan to end the series Just One Name next Sunday. Thank you for sending messages. Every single one is read by human beings. Next, a 19-year-old woman advises the government what to do about neats and pips. More younger Britons are out of work and more reclaiming disability payments with a report into that due in days. Standing by is Sir Charlie Mayfield, who headed John Lewis and then became a government jobs advisor. First, two people you haven't heard of, Elizabeth, who's 19, and Amari, who's 22.
23:23Katherine Jenkins: You're going from company to company, just sending your CV through, and all you're getting back is an automated AI response. It's very miserable because all of us generally do want to go into work and help out the community, but nobody wants to hire young people anymore.
23:38Gareth Malone: And Elizabeth, when you hear Amari's story, what do you think?
23:42Sir Charlie Mayfield: I think it's very applicable to so many young people. So, for example, I have a network called the Hire Estate Network, which is a community to support young women to get into industries. and there's so many of them that just talk about how jobs are like jobs want young people to apply but then when they're applying they ask for experience and it's like how are you supposed to come with something you don't have for example internships they ask for experience but you're doing the internship for the experience so it's kind of like you can't give what you don't have and it just makes you feel like you're going around in a circle over and over again and do you feel angry for Amari 110 percent like every day we see young talent that just gets wasted and And it's not that young people are lazy or they don't have the ambition or the talent.
24:22Sir Charlie Mayfield: It's just that there's not enough opportunity. And what do you expect them to do? Like every day you turn on the news and you hear the government talking about how there's up to one million young people who are classified as needs. And it's like, what are they supposed to do? So, of course, that brings up some anger and a lot of frustration.
24:36Gareth Malone: Amari, how many jobs do you think you've applied for? At least over a thousand, maybe under 10 ,000. Maybe 10 ,000 jobs? Yes. Elizabeth, what do you think of that?
24:48Sir Charlie Mayfield: I think it's rather shameful and very embarrassing. 10 ,000 people to just either not respond or throw AI in a young person's way, it's not acceptable at all.
24:58Gareth Malone: And Amari, do you claim any benefits? Yes, yes I do. I'm currently on Universal Credit and I'll be real,
25:05Katherine Jenkins: yeah, it's money at the end of the month, but it's not really pushing me or motivating me to move forward within my job search because most of the time they'll just give you your money, check up on you and call it a day. they will like push you to be further
25:19Gareth Malone: go further within your search Has anything changed in your outlook Elizabeth having heard of Mari?
25:24Sir Charlie Mayfield: It's just made me realise that there's so like for one young person to apply for 10 ,000 roles and not even hear back it's just made me really have a passion to push for more companies to actually open up programmes for young people because the issue is no longer a talent gap it's an opportunity gap What belongs to you will actually come to you eventually and you may not understand why but something will definitely open up in the long term
25:45Gareth Malone: Alright, thank you Well, thanks to them too, Elizabeth and Omari. Sir Charlie Mayfield is author of the Keep Britain Working Review. It was published in November last year. He was also on the advisory panel for the Milburn Review, launched last week, calling for a complete system reset. There's a lot of reviews. We'll talk about that. Sir Charlie, welcome to BH. Good morning, Paddy. 10 ,000, up to 10 ,000 job applications and nothing except AI. What do you make of it?
26:13Sir Tony Blair: It's terrible. And I think you hear young people saying, I mean, Alan described it as a rejection economy. And, you know, a lot of people talk about young people lacking resilience. But honestly, if you think about this from your own point of view, if you applied for a thousand jobs and you didn't hear anything back, you'd probably find your confidence got knocked. So I think it is a real problem.
26:33Gareth Malone: There do also seem to be thousands of reviews by the great and the good into the problem. Do you agree with that?
26:40Sir Tony Blair: So there are, you know, you're getting reviews almost every week at the moment. So there are reviews. I think basically it's a good thing that they're happening because we do face some really difficult problems. And one of the things that Alan actually said to me last week, he said that he had the time to go around the whole country, meeting people like Amari and Elizabeth and many, many others to really understand and hear what their experience has been. And then to grapple with the complexities of what you actually have to then change to impact that and find a better solution.
27:11Gareth Malone: So they are important. Politically, they seem to appear at cross purposes. The commentators have pointed out that the Tim's review was basically there to placate rebels over welfare cuts, while the Milburn review was there to make the case for the need for reform.
27:27Sir Tony Blair: Well, look, I mean, there are, these things are very connected. They are complex and they need quite a lot of unravelling. And I think one of the things, all reviews have basically three dimensions. The first is that you've got to understand and explain the problem. Secondly, you've got to set an ambition and identify how to achieve it. And then thirdly, you've got to make the changes and deliver the results. And when you get to a publication, you've only had the first two, you haven't had the third. So you have to move on to that. And of course, when you're implementing things, you will have tensions, you will have conflicts, and you've got trade-offs.
28:01Sir Tony Blair: And that is the job of leaders and government and others to figure out how they're going to balance all of those things and ultimately how they do that determines whether we actually achieve the changes that we can.
28:13Gareth Malone: The Tim's Review is due this week, I think, and the papers say that really what will happen is that the two reviews, the Milburn Review and the Tim's Review, will recommend policies which are nearly enough at odds with each other. So whether or not you agree with that, which I could read from the papers at you, but we're so pleased to have you here, do you know what the Tim's Review should say?
28:35Sir Tony Blair: So I haven't seen, I haven't seen, I haven't been involved in the Tim's review closely. So I don't know what it's going to say. I will only have read what you've read. But I think what I'd say to you is that in a lot of these issues, economists talk about stock and flow. So you have the stock of a problem, and then you have the flow. So it's a bit, if you think about a bucket, if you've got people who are in welfare or receiving welfare, they're currently in that bucket, and they're there. But you also have people who are flowing into that bucket all the time. And if you, And what you have to do, and this is the difficult thing, is you've got to tackle both.
29:07Sir Tony Blair: It's really hard to take things off people who have become entitled to them in some way. And that's what you're hearing. A lot of the debate and the discussion and the controversy revolves around that. But what you also have to do is you've got to look at where these people come from. And if you can act early, and for example, with disabled people, if you help them to get into work and stay in work successfully, that's by far the best outcome. And similarly for young people, if you can help them to get jobs, get on the ladder, you can solve some of these problems early and it's much better to do so.
29:39Gareth Malone: And so Charlie, in 30 seconds only, it's striking because I know what you've briefed our colleagues here. When Elizabeth and Omari told us that it's easier for an employer to employ an older person than a younger person, you ran John Lewis and you think the same thing.
29:58Sir Tony Blair: I think there is always the case that you're going to have, if someone's got experience, they are, you know, they've got experience. But there's also a social contract. And I think that, you know, everybody, a lot of employers really have really engaged with these reviews, because they basically understand that they were young ones too. Somebody gave them a chance. And there's a sort of understanding that we need to do that for our young people. And you've got a lot of employers who are leaning into doing exactly that. And some, there's some actually some good examples of where employers are making conscious efforts to carve out within all their recruitment specific opportunities for people who haven't got experience and who are coming from difficult backgrounds.
30:34Sir Tony Blair: And I think that's encouraging and we need to see more of it.
30:37Gareth Malone: OK, we will ring you up. We'll get a name of one or two of them that you've given us and we will ask to go and visit because this isn't going away. But I'm afraid you now are. But with many thanks, Sir Charlie.
30:50Katherine Jenkins: Self-directed investing. Trading. Full-service wealth management. automated investing, financial planning, thematic investing, retirement planning. Phew. And to think, that's just a small taste of what Schwab offers. Because Schwab knows that when it comes to your finances, choice matters. No matter your goals, investing style, life stage or experience, Schwab has everything you need, all in one place, so you can invest your way. Visit schwab.com to learn more. Imagine buying a toy for your kid, but it doesn't come with batteries. That sucks. But honestly, it's even worse when you buy business software.
31:28Katherine Jenkins: You end up with fragmented, disconnected systems that cost a fortune and don't talk to each other. Odoo completely changes that. Odoo comes fully complete, with all your business apps perfectly integrated and working together seamlessly. It's everything your business needs in one place, saving you time, headaches, and serious money. Stop paying for missing pieces. Go to odoo.com. That's O-D-O-O dot com to learn more.
32:00Gareth Malone: The Spalding Community Choir in South Lincolnshire were rehearsing yesterday afternoon as we continue our enjoyment of listeners and they sent us their rendition of the Game of Thrones theme tune. Hello, and you. It's the Spalding Community Choir.
32:46CHOIR SINGS
32:48Gareth Malone: The Spalding Community Choir, amazing. The legendary opera singer, the mezzo-soprano Catherine Jenkins, began singing in choirs as a child in the Welsh town of Neath. She told us what choirs mean to her.
33:00Sir Charlie Mayfield: I just think that it's a great way to learn life lessons as well as kind of channel emotion and brilliant for teaching musicianship at a young age. And so, yeah, I'm really thankful for those days. I think they've been really important for me.
33:14Gareth Malone: What is it about being in an ensemble rather than a soloist that is good for a person?
33:21Sir Charlie Mayfield: Well, I think when you're in a choir, you have to learn to work as a team. You know, you're purposely looking to have your voices blend together rather than be the one person that stands out. So working together to create harmony, to create a beautiful sound, I think is a really, you know, good life lesson. So I think there's that, which is, you know, musically. But I think as well, when you sing with other people, you know, you can go into a room with complete strangers. But when you've sung together for a few hours, I think you sort of leave and that's changed. You know, you have that connection.
33:59Sir Charlie Mayfield: I think that's really important, whatever age you are.
34:02Gareth Malone: So you've worked with a choir, in fact, a choir of schoolchildren, for a rendition of Belinda Carlyle's 1987 hit, Heaven is a Place on Earth. And we can have a little bit of a listen to that now. Oh, baby, dear, my God's word.
34:22Katherine Jenkins: Oh, heaven is a place on earth. They say in heaven that love comes first. Now in heaven, a place on earth. Oh, heaven is a place on earth. Oh, heaven is a place on earth. Oh, heaven is a place on earth.
34:51Gareth Malone: So there they are. How are they being used in this track? What kind of... Oh, I love that key change. What does it bring?
35:00Sir Charlie Mayfield: Well, we... I wanted to create a sort of festive version of this song. Trying to kind of make it a festive anthem was something that I knew all the different parts I wanted to include. and a big part of that were the choirs. So we actually have an adult choir and a children's choir and it was so lovely working with these young people and getting to work with them, seeing their excitement and it takes me back to my childhood and getting those opportunities as a young singer.
35:34Gareth Malone: And finally, I always remember in a choir, it may have been my fault, it may have been someone else's, there's always someone who's having a bad day who's a bit ropey, Catherine. And we have to be honest. What should you do if the person next to you maybe isn't as good as they could be?
35:54Sir Charlie Mayfield: Maybe pass them a throat lozenge. But I honestly believe, you know, I was a singing teacher. I believe that everybody has got the capability to sing. I've literally heard all different kinds of voices and I really think everybody can sing. and I think it's so good for your emotional, mental well-being. So I wouldn't be dissuading the person next to me. I'd be encouraging them because everybody's in a choir for a different reason and it's just a really special thing to be able to sing together.
36:25Gareth Malone: Listening to everything for us this morning, the legendary choir master Gareth Malone, who convened, among many others, the Military Wives Choir. Welcome to BH Gareth. Good morning. Jenny is our listener. She's just emailed to say that her choir has helped her health. Rochester Choral Society's performance of Britain's St. Nicholas and Rejoice in the Lamb was thrilling. Do you understand why she's thrilled?
36:48Katherine Jenkins: Absolutely. I mean, those are two fantastic pieces for any choir to sing. But I don't think the piece is what's important here. It is just fantastic for your health, for your mental well-being. And the science is there now to back it up. It lowers stress. It helps with respiratory illnesses, helps with those who have dementia, but it helps everyone. It's just a good thing to be in a room with other people doing this incredible social. It's like the ultimate social cohesion tool.
37:19Gareth Malone: Because Catherine Jenkins is saying, get into a choir if you want and if you can, although I hear there's actually a queue for some of them. What did you make of what we've heard throughout the hour with Spalding Community Choir, Harrow Philharmonic and the Ayrshire and Glasgow Rock Choir? I heard a lot of different music, but a lot of joy.
37:37Katherine Jenkins: I think that's it. That's the unifying factor. And it doesn't really matter what you sing. It's just the doing it with other people. It's not simply singing. Singing is a lovely thing to do on your own. But it's much better when you do it with other people because your heart rate, your breathing all syncs up with the other people. and you feel instantly knitted together with those people. And that's what I hear in all of those choirs. There are different qualities, there's perhaps different musical levels of complexity to it, but fundamentally they are all singing with heart and soul and, as you say, joy.
38:11Gareth Malone: And to take it back to how we got to know you, we've been doing just one name, very movingly hearing people from the war dead with the Military Wives Choir. Was there a lot unspoken? Was there a sort of electricity of understanding in that choir?
38:26Katherine Jenkins: I always believed in choirs. I've always loved it from my own experience. And I know what it did for me when I was at school and going through tough times. It was very important for me. But to see those women in that room dealing with unimaginable losses and pressures and tension, and to see them passing the tissues along the line as they as they kind of collectively cried and the way that that became normal within the choir. and you could feel this unspoken support between them. And that's available for everyone. That's available for everyone in the country. It's completely accessible. It's probably the most accessible hobby that there is.
39:04Katherine Jenkins: You just need to sort of rock up with your voice. You don't need any special equipment. Easy to do.
39:09Gareth Malone: And also you've had a big part in all of that. Gareth, thank you for listening to all of our choirs. We've enjoyed it. And also thank you to you. Thank you very much. It's quarter to ten. The broadcasting legend Angela Rippon is here. She was photographed in the weekend papers, receiving an honorary degree from Stirling University. You laughed then, you were wondering what I was going to say. Yes, I was. Congratulations, you didn't go to uni yourself.
39:33Sir Charlie Mayfield: I didn't, no. I'm from that generation where if you wanted to be a journalist, you didn't go to university to do media studies. You actually were apprenticed to a newspaper, which I was for three years, when, as well as doing an equivalent degree for the National Union of Journalists in Politics and Law to understand libel and slander, you actually were doing the job for three years and then got qualified.
39:59Gareth Malone: Thank goodness one of us understands the rules on libel and slander with this live review. Michael Simmons is economics editor of The Spectator with a background in mathematics and statistics. As a young man, he worshipped data before it was essential to contemporary journalism. Hello, Michael. Hello, thank you for having me. You're a data man?
40:15Baroness Theresa May: Yes, I am. I was briefly a government statistician before I decided that was too boring and journalism was the way to go.
40:22Gareth Malone: And the comedian and writer Dom Jolly hosts Mugwuffin Online, a weekly hidden camera show, and he's touring with Trigger Happy TV's 25th anniversary tour. Welcome back, Dom. Thank you very much, Paddy. I wonder if you could begin our review with The Sun on Sunday's coverage of puppet master Peter Fluck.
40:41Sir Tony Blair: Yes, so Peter Fluck, the creator of Spitting Images, died sadly at the age of 85. and I just, yeah, it's the sort of end of an era. I mean, Spitting Image was so defining a show and so incredibly powerful in its time. It's deeply, deeply sad, but I can still remember, you know, just, I can remember extraordinary moments from Spitting Image, you know, the Margaret Thatcher and the vegetables, basically asking, being asked whether she's having vegetables and she said they'll have the same as me. But what I remember from Spitting Image which is the sort of more serious, the sort of songs, really, which were actually not funny.
41:19Sir Tony Blair: They were just actually rather moving. Incredible show, so very sad to hear.
41:23Sir Charlie Mayfield: I was never a puppet. No, I know you were going to ask me that. I wasn't. But what I do know is that John Gummer and I believe also Jeffrey Archer were at least two of the people who were always being lampooned on that programme, actually bought their puppets and have them to this day because they took it as a huge compliment to be included in that kind of humour.
41:45Baroness Theresa May: It was a brilliant show, wasn't it? And I think compare it to political satire now, which I think if you watch the old stuff, maybe I'm too young to be nostalgic, but it was much better than the things we see now.
41:58Sir Charlie Mayfield: It didn't have the woke restrictions that I think are put on the humorist now.
42:02Gareth Malone: Many reviewers here do say that the UK SNL is very good and the nostalgia, you should refresh your view, what some of our reviews say. Dom, one of the papers says that this show, Spitting Image, allowed teenagers to name every member of the cabinet. Did you see that?
42:22Sir Tony Blair: I did see that. I mean, I was doing politics at university and I was a bit of a politics junkie anyway, so I probably could name them. I think it also helped that possibly we had people, I don't know if it's I'm just getting old, but that we had people of a slightly better stature in government back then. And so you kind of could name all the, I think I could have named, I could probably still name all of Thatcher's cabinet at certain times. But I think it was very odd. I think it existed in a time when there was a lot of extremism going on. And there was a lot of politics was, I don't know why we haven't had satire, I suppose, is what I'm saying in the last 20 years.
43:03Sir Tony Blair: I agree with you that SNL, British SNL is actually unexpectedly good. and I think we need to bring more of that back. I've just been watching a lot of Veep.
43:12Gareth Malone: OK, should I be asking you to name the current Cabinet? Could you go farther down the list? No. Not really. Well, look, we can't have the whole review on this, although we're all interested in it. But thank you for getting us underway. Puppet master and great tributes paid to Peter Fluck. Angela Rippon, where would you like to begin?
43:32Sir Charlie Mayfield: Well, I think both of us, Michael and I, are just overwhelmed by the amount of coverage that there is in every newspaper today about Andy Burnham's deal, can we call it that, with the EU. And I think that the Mail on Sunday, its headline is ambushed, our naive MP walks straight into an EU trap that's going to cost Britain millions. And demonstrating the way in which most of the newspapers feel that he really has been humiliated because the EU have put so many restrictions on the plan that he's come up with. And, I mean, it's very interesting that so many of them are concentrating on the way in which the universities are going to be affected.
44:17Sir Charlie Mayfield: And depending on which newspaper you read, it's either going to be the universities will lose out to the tune of 12 million every year, whereas the Sun says it's going to be 1.5 billion every year.
44:30Baroness Theresa May: And there's annoyance on that on both sides. There's quite a catty story in the Sunday Telegraph from somebody on the pro-EU side who's annoyed at these European diplomats trying to get these discounts for our universities, which they say is because all of these EU diplomats have children, have progeny in our universities. So we seem to have come up with this renegotiation that hasn't even made the sort of pro-EU, pro-rejoin side happy.
44:56Sir Charlie Mayfield: No, and I suppose if people aren't aware of it, we should say that at the moment I think the average price for going to university, if you are English, is£9 ,000 a year, whereas if we take in foreign students, it's£30 ,000 a year. And under this plan, not only are we letting in, I think it's 100 ,000 people, isn't it, for over three years to come and work here. And it is reciprocal. We can send students a year.
45:22Gareth Malone: That's the movement for Parliament. OK, so just to say that there's coverage everywhere of this, and Dom, I'm not going to ask you to come in, only because we did lead the programme on it. So there's a lot of coverage. Everyone can read constantly in all the papers, and the starting for that was the Mail on Sunday. Michael, the Sunday Times, at 82, I've learnt to read.
45:43Baroness Theresa May: Yeah, well, this is a lovely story, and this is about a lady called Anna Hall, who actually turns 82 today, so happy birthday, Anna Hall. and she, for various reasons, never learned to read when she was at school but she managed to live a life finding other ways. So she worked, she wrote children, she learned to use her phone by recognising the shapes of words. But recently she decided that she'd had enough so she walked into her local library and said, please, will you help me to read? And she was taught to read. There's 2.4 million adults in a position like hers. She can now read. She now loves reading.
46:23Baroness Theresa May: And my favourite bit of this story is when she completed this course called the Read Easy programme, her kids, who didn't know she was illiterate, by the way, took her out for a meal where she wore a mortarboard.
46:34Sir Charlie Mayfield: Oh, I think she's so inspirational because, for a start, I think it's a pity that so many people who cannot read feel ashamed and hide it for so long and don't feel that they can come out honestly and say, I need help with this. But, you know, she is a great example to people of all ages who find themselves having difficulty with reading and it closes their world if they're not able to read properly.
46:58Gareth Malone: Thank you for raising that. Her name one more time? Anna Hall. Anna Hall, happy birthday. You're listening to Radio 4's review of newspapers, online sites and, in this case, a new documentary from Dom Jolly. It's called You Can See Everything and Dom is picking from the Observer's coverage of this documentary. Dom, can you do a new listeners start here guide? What are you talking about and what does the paper say?
47:21Sir Tony Blair: So the documentary, I think it's the first time I've booked a month ahead to see a film in the cinema and it's called You Can See Everything. It's by, well, it's by two people, but essentially it's by a guy called Nathan Fielder, who is a comedian that I have absolutely worshipped for about 20 years. I think he's astonishing. And he started off making sort of slightly scammy, cringe documentary type comedy about business scams. But he's ended up making this absolutely unbelievable documentary in which he gets access to Elizabeth Holmes, who was the disgraced blood testing billionaire who I don't know if people have seen either the drama about or the documentary about.
48:06Sir Tony Blair: We basically set up a company called Theranos, which was supposed to be able to diagnose every disease from a little drop of blood. And it turned out to be completely just not happening. And it's very I don't want to ruin the documentary for people because it's just such an extraordinary thing. But it's a three hour documentary. I think it's the best thing I've seen in about 10 years. It just it has so many twists and turns. It's unbelievably brilliant and fantastic. And I'm convinced it's actually going to win the best Oscar film, not just for documentary, but film overall.
48:41Gareth Malone: OK, and I've heard a lot of people in the office talking about it. You're talking about it. You can see everything is the name of the documentary. Angela Rippon, rehire retirees to run old systems during cyber attacks from the Sunday Telegraph.
48:56Sir Charlie Mayfield: I love this story because basically what it's saying, you should never, never underestimate the knowledge and the skills. that people of my generation, if you like, who've retired, still have and can be used when we suffer yet another one of the cyber attacks that we're getting.
49:13Gareth Malone: I should mention Gillian in our office, who keeps a typewriter under her desk.
49:17Sir Charlie Mayfield: Well done, Gillian, because what happens when everything stops and the computer goes dead? She can still keep writing scripts for her.
49:22Gareth Malone: Well, I know how to change the ribbon.
49:25Sir Charlie Mayfield: I'm amazed.
49:26Gareth Malone: Dom, do you have a typewriter hidden in your home?
49:29Sir Tony Blair: I do actually have a typewriter, yeah, but that's just to make anonymous threats. I normally just use computers and stuff for everything else.
49:35Gareth Malone: What do you make of it, Michael? You're an economist and data man. Keep the skills of people who knew an analogue world in case we do get hit by all this cyber horror.
49:45Baroness Theresa May: Well, I think it's worrying. And we had this just last week, didn't we? Where none of us could log into our emails. And that was perfectly good for a morning. I just went to the pub rather than doing any work. But if we get a cyber attack that the government thinks could last more than a day or two without power, then I think it's right that the younger generation do not have these skills and old systems in places like the NHS government, all our organisations.
50:10Sir Charlie Mayfield: Well, the Telegraph actually do give a lot of examples when they say finance teams, for example, must establish how to receive invoices, record them and pay suppliers without their usual software.
50:21Gareth Malone: Dom, did I hear you imminent there? Did I hear you imminent on this or not?
50:27Sir Tony Blair: Well, I mean, the idea that anyone pays you fast anyway is absolutely ridiculous. I spend the whole time chasing invoices. So if we have to go back to typewriters and stuff, then, yeah, we'll get paid for three years.
50:39Gareth Malone: So, sorry, go ahead, Mark. Go ahead, Dom.
50:41Sir Tony Blair: Yeah, I mean, it's not just that. I mean, my wife has now taken on the whole thing. We've now got a wind-up radio downstairs. I think we've got a little bit of cash in a box. Like, we've got tins of beans. I think we are waiting for the imminent breakdown of our society, so we're ready.
50:56Baroness Theresa May: Yeah, I have not been stockpiling yet, but maybe I should be.
51:00Sir Tony Blair: I think it's crucial. If we don't have a wind-up radio, how are you going to listen to Broadcasting House?
51:05Sir Charlie Mayfield: But I think it's interesting that in this article, it's the government's national cyber security centre that actually recognises that organisations have backup systems, including paper-based information.
51:18Gareth Malone: So the time is very brief. You can only give us a headline to say goodbye. So, Michael, to you first, give us a headline in a newspaper or a website.
51:26Baroness Theresa May: This is from The Sun. that the Man City probe was raised in trade talks with the government.
51:31Gareth Malone: OK, that's the Suns reporting. That's an interesting story, which you're telling us at the end. So you, Angela?
51:38Sir Charlie Mayfield: You always like us to have something light. From the front page of The Times, there's a cartoon referring back to what's happening with the EU saying, I'd like to reopen the old wound from when I shot myself in the foot. And on the sports pages, of course, wonderful news that the England rugby team beat the All Blacks 37 to 12.
51:57Sir Tony Blair: And a few seconds, Dom. Well, The Sun talking about how Tulu's Wayne Rooney has become a TikTok heartthrob has to be the story of the week for me. Thank you so much for fitting everything in
52:10Gareth Malone: in such a beautiful way. Today's producers were Harvey Stevens and Natasha Mayo. Studio direction from Graham White. The editor was Sam Mason-Jones, and you listened to it for which thank you and goodbye.
52:23Katherine Jenkins: All right, all right, turn it up. This next track by Crown Royal, it's got a way of getting everybody together. So grab your people, grab a glass, and play this one loud.
52:44Katherine Jenkins: This track is brought to you by Crown Royal. Please drink responsibly. I said you got gold. So just bring it, bring it in. Sometimes we all need an extra helping hand, especially with a tricky business problem you've been putting off. Claude is the AI for just that. It's the collaborator that understands your entire workflow and thinks with you, not for you. And Claude isn't just for quick questions. Hand it a whole task, like turning a folder of scattered notes into a report, and it does the work and hands back something finished that you can open and edit. Claude can now draft a dock or deck right in front of you, and Claude Design now lives right inside Claude.
53:25Katherine Jenkins: Describe the website or prototype you're picturing, attach your design system, and it comes back in your own design language, ready to edit right on the canvas. It works with your files and the tools you already use, like Gmail and Slack. And whether you're debugging code at midnight, building a financial model, or strategizing your next business move, Claude extends your thinking to tackle the problems that matter. For problems worth solving, Get started with Claude at claude.ai.solve. That's claude.ai.solve. And check out Claude Pro, which includes access to all of the features mentioned in today's episode.
54:01Katherine Jenkins: claude.ai.solve.
Sir Tony Blair and Baroness Theresa May express concern over the prospect of Andy Burnham reversing Brexit. We discuss the deal struck this week with negotiators either side of the Channel. Plus: Sir Charlie Mayfield on how to get young people in to work, and Katherine Jenkins and Gareth Malone discuss the joy of singing in a choir.