1. Podcasts
  2. Broadcasting House
  3. King to address slavery during Commonwealth speech
Broadcasting House

1 Nov 2026 · 52m · 22 chapters

Episode artwork

King to address slavery during Commonwealth speech

In short

The episode centers on King Charles’s Commonwealth speech addressing Britain’s role in the transatlantic slave trade, amid political debate over apologies and reparations. Guests and contributors include: Sir Hilary Beckles (history professor; chairs the Caribbean Reparations Commission); Robert Hardman (biographer of Elizabeth II and King Charles III; BBC guest); Stephanie Flanders (Bloomberg economics and politics head); Matt Chorley (BBC Five Live presenter); Ian Hislop (Private Eye co-editor; co-wrote The Wipers’ Times); Guy Emanuel (squirrel contraceptive reporter); Heather Harris (Lancashire Trust Red Squirrel Recovery Network); Sir Charles Walker (former Tory MP; Sky Foundation chair); Yotam Ottolenghi (chef/restaurateur; 15m cookbooks); Kate Moss (novelist); plus BBC’s Justin Webb (Maine politics correspondent) and Jim Nocteer (studio contributor).

Key claims

Burnham’s openness to apologies pressures the King; CARICOM links apology to legal and then financial redress; grey squirrels spread squirrel pox, and Formby trials use weight-focused contraceptive feeders to avoid culling.

Notable examples

a “chocolate soldier” World War I Sergeant McKenzie research project; The Wipers’ Times’ satirical wartime magazine; a Formby grey-squirrel-only bait feeder; emergency sardines-and-beans stockpile recipe.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

1:52

The King's Caribbean Speech

Discussion on King Charles' upcoming speech on slavery during Commonwealth meeting.

“We spoke about the king in the Caribbean and red squirrels on the mainland of the UK.”
3:56

Political Implications of Apology

Exploring the pressures the King faces regarding apologies for slavery.

“History professor Sir Hilary Beckles chairs the Caribbean Reparations Commission.”
6:10

Debate on Reparations and Apologies

Analysis of the arguments for and against reparations and formal apologies from the UK.

“But as we've seen this week on this trip, yes, there is a big political debate about this, but on the ground, as he's been going around the Caribbean, there's been almost zero protest about reparations.”
8:06

Labour Party's Financial Challenges

Discussion on Labour's financial strategies and challenges ahead of the election.

“and then financial redress, this could make the Chagos dispute look very small indeed.”
14:00

Labour's Defence Spending Dilemma

Explore Labour's challenges and strategies regarding defence funding.

“Let's look at Labour's can kicking as the item limps on.”
16:56

Social Care and Welfare Bills

Discussion on the complexities of social care funding and welfare cuts.

“He wants to sort of slightly change that formula to a sort of two and a half lock.”
19:44

Remembering Sergeant McKenzie

A poignant reflection on Sergeant McKenzie and the impact of war.

“Ian co-wrote the play The Wipers' Times about a satirical magazine printed by men fighting World War I.”
21:57

The Wipers' Times and Satire in War

Exploration of the play 'The Wipers' Times' and its historical significance.

“Well, we want to know more about Sergeant McKenzie.”
28:00

Midterm Elections Overview

An analysis of the upcoming US midterm elections and key figures involved.

“Presidents Obama and Trump have traded blows in the fight for the US midterm elections.”
29:52

Obama's Campaign Strategy

Discussion on Barack Obama's renewed involvement in midterm campaigning.

“And it really does matter because it could be that one state is the difference between the Democrats winning control of the Senate or not.”
Show all 22 chapters
31:26

Polls and Their Reliability

A critical look at the reliability of polls leading up to the elections.

“Even as I said that, Paddy, I was right up your street, actually.”
32:57

Maine's Autumn and Politics

A picturesque description of Maine's autumn while discussing local politics.

“And in those circumstances, who are you missing?”
34:28

Squirrels and Conservation Efforts

Exploration of efforts to control grey squirrel populations to protect red squirrels.

“This is Justin on the banjo, as a matter of fact.”
36:14

Searching for Red Squirrels

A reporter's quest to find red squirrels in Formby, alongside public responses.

“A special feeder is being developed to bait greys with contraceptives to help save the reds.”
37:28

Contraceptive Trials for Squirrels

Details about the trial of a contraceptive feeder aimed at grey squirrels.

“They make nice noise as they chase each other.”
40:00

Cooking with Yotam Ottolenghi

Yotam Ottolenghi shares emergency stockpile recipes using pantry staples.

“It's kind of a moment where you'll walk with your family and everyone is still and just captivated by such a magical and such a sadly now rare sight to see.”
42:00

Culinary Exploration and Guest Introductions

An engaging discussion about cooking and the introduction of guests with impressive backgrounds.

“and then I'll be able to mush it into a kind of a creamy consistency and that oil with the herbs, with the beans, with the garlic will be a wonderful pasta sauce.”
44:26

Discussing Film and Characters

A lively conversation about the portrayal of characters in film and literature.

“Slow Horses Jack bounces back, but isn't he the new 007?”
45:26

Human Stories Amidst Conflict

A poignant discussion about a powerful photograph from Ukraine and its emotional impact.

“I love Mick Herron's writing and I love the books.”
47:55

Cultural Integration and Media Critique

An exploration of cultural integration efforts in the UK and a critique of media representation.

“Kate Moss, we have not had one of your personal selections.”
49:58

Art, History, and Remembrance

A discussion on a recently discovered portrait and its significance in art history.

“So you don't like the cut of the jib of the story, but you give credit to The Sun on Sunday for its headlines and also to the council, Lewisham, for what it's doing and the debate will continue endlessly, I know.”
53:59

Baked Potatoes and British Cuisine

A light-hearted conclusion discussing the resurgence of baked potatoes in British culture.

“It sounds, you're creating a beautiful picture of it for us.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On Broadcasting House, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK.

0:30No bouncing between tabs. And best of all, no spreadsheets. Stop managing software and start managing your business with one unified system. Try for free today at odoo.com. That's O-D-O-O dot com. Decisions made in Washington can affect your portfolio every day. But what policy changes should investors be watching? Listen to Washington Wise, an original podcast for investors from Charles Schwab, to hear the stories making news in Washington right now. Host Mike Townsend, Charles Schwab's Managing Director for Legislative and Regulatory Affairs, takes a non-partisan look at the stories that matter most to investors, including policy initiatives for retirement savings, taxes and trade, inflation concerns, the Federal Reserve, and how regulatory developments can affect companies, sectors, and even the entire market.

1:22Mike and his guests offer their perspective on how policy changes could affect what you do with your portfolio. Download the latest episode and follow at schwab.com slash Washington Wise or wherever you listen. Hello, here's the podcast of Broadcasting House. There was a confusion about how far south on the mainland red squirrels can be found in the UK, but we began with a conference speech. Hello, here's the podcast of Broadcasting House from Sunday 1st November. We spoke about the king in the Caribbean and red squirrels on the mainland of the UK. Coming up, a tale of two Heelys, Dennis and John.

2:02It's been a tough, rough budget this time and I don't expect any of you to thank me for it. We're ready to take some pretty tough decisions on priorities and I've had to ask other Cabinet colleagues to make savings. Labour Defence secretaries turned chancellors. Are they more than just namesakes? Ahead of Remembrance Sunday, an appeal to help us find a missing World War I soldier, can you flesh out this man's backstory? Sergeant McKenzie, he really was an awfully nice man. And he had such an aptitude and a penchant for chocolate that we called him a chocolate soldier, although he was a most efficient man.

2:44Ian Hislop talks to us about his inspiration from learning of the power of individuals among the war dead. as we launch a new BH research project, Just One Name. We visit Formby to learn of contraception for grey squirrels. That's contraception for grey squirrels to preserve the reds. I think they're just absolutely charming and it's a really magical experience walking through the woodlands in Formby and spotting that flash of russet fur through the treetops. And super chef Jotam Ottolenghi is here to give us emergency stockpile recipes, joining Sir Charles Walker and bestseller Kate Moss as our headliners.

3:24The King's speech is global news again, after the Prime Minister's latest musings on slavery. King Charles is on the last leg of his Caribbean tour and will, on Tuesday, at a meeting of Commonwealth leaders, express sincere sorrow for the lasting pain of the transatlantic trade in human beings. The British government has never formally apologised for slavery or offered reparations. But in the last few days, Andy Burnham appeared to signal a shift in the government's stance, saying he was open to the possibility of formally apologising. History professor Sir Hilary Beckles chairs the Caribbean Reparations Commission.

4:05He told Saturday PM here on Radio 4, Mr Burnham was right to open the door to the conversation. This was about Atkins, Britain, or all of those countries that ravish these islands with slavery and colonization to come and sit with the governments and say, listen, we know that we have contributed to this situation that you are dealing with. You should not have to deal with it on your own because most of these countries in the Caribbean have had to borrow enormous amount of money just to build roads and schools and all the things that people take for granted in the developed world. As a result of that, they have now become the most indebted countries in the world.

4:46The question is, is that fair, is that reasonable? Live to the Daily Mail's Robert Hardman, who is the biographer of Elizabeth II and the biographer of King Charles. Charles III, new king, new court, the inside story. Robert, welcome back to BH. Good morning, Paddy. Does the Prime Minister's latest musings put pressure on the King's speech? um well it it actually means that the king is now find would find it even harder to to get into any um question of an apology because it's now become um a party political matter back here in britain i mean as you pointed out the um long-standing position of the british government has been um the you know apologies and reparations are just not going to happen um now that annie burnham has said there is going to be an apology.

5:38Kemi Baden-Ock has come out and said this is navel-gazing and there shouldn't be, and that it's not the business of the Commonwealth to be in the business of bashing Britain at these summits. So it's become now a party political issue here. The king's already in a very difficult position because on the one hand he's king of Britain, but he's king of eight Caribbean nations who form more than half of CARICOM, which is the body that is calling for reparations. So he is stuck in the middle. But as we've seen this week on this trip, yes, there is a big political debate about this, but on the ground, as he's been going around the Caribbean, there's been almost zero protest about reparations.

6:24I think in the Bahamas there was a demonstration of a total of three people. So it's a political issue, but he will be very much looking to the present and the future. I did see a campaigner say that the king was walking in a crime scene. But I mean, putting aside the rhetoric, what should Britain do? Should it apologise formally short of reparations? Well, it's in a very difficult position if you do that, because, I mean, there are essentially three strands of the argument. There's the emotional argument, which, I mean, nobody could possibly disagree with. I mean, the most cursory look at the slave trade is absolutely appalling.

7:01However, it was committed by people long dead to people long dead. And you look at the immediate announcement from another of the King's Labour prime ministers yesterday, within 24 hours of Andy Burnham's piece in The Guardian saying that he was open to apologies. There was the prime minister, leader of the Labour Party in St Lucia, Philip Peir, saying that actually, okay, that's fine, we'll take that, but we can't really have any discussion without you accepting our 10-point plan, and that 10-point plan includes debt cancellation and, crucially, financial redress. And it also mentions Britain's obligation to other parts of the Commonwealth, and I think people will rightly think, well, if Britain's going to apologise to the Caribbean and all that comes with that, then, I mean, the Commonwealth straddles a third of the world's population.

7:59And, I mean, you could have other parts of the Commonwealth saying, well, we'd like an apology too. And as the CARICOM's position is that the apology is first step to legal redress and then financial redress, this could make the Chagos dispute look very small indeed. Okay. It's the latest briefing from Robert Hardman given to BH, for which, thank you very much indeed, there's plenty of commentary on this, in the newspapers, which we will review, and also this was covered at full length on Saturday PM, which you can hear on BBC Sounds. The Chancellor, John Healy, has suggested that younger workers might not receive the same minimum wage as others before the next election, potentially breaking a Labour manifesto promise.

8:47It's all further evidence of the tug-of-war within Labour on its priorities on the big financial questions. Here he is talking to the BBC's Laura Koonsberg. There's no question about whether or if. It's a question of when. So it might not be. And it's a question of how fast. And I want to make sure that we can look hard at those trade-offs that inevitably are there between jobs and wages. I want to take business, I want to take trade unions with me and with the government, because together we have to get into what at the moment is a moral shame on this nation, a million youngsters written off without any prospect of being helped into work and making a contribution to this country for the future.

9:32It's 50 years since another Healy, Dennis, told Labour that the party needed to show discipline over public finances. He had increased tax on investment to 98 % and eventually went to the IMF for a bailout. Here he was at the party conference defending spending cuts, he said, were dictated by the harsh reality of the world we live in. It means sticking to a pay policy which enables us, as the TUC resolved a week or two ago, to continue the attack on inflation. It means seeing that the increase in our output, which has now begun, goes not into public or private spending, but into exports or investment.

10:16That's what it means and that's what I'm asking for. That's what I'm going to negotiate for. And I ask that content to support me in that time. There was applause, but I heard Korver resign in there. Stephanie Flanders is head of economics and politics at Bloomberg News. I asked if John Healy and Dennis Healy-Thread was another BH example of stretching things too far or if there were relevant comparisons. I think you can go a bit further than the surnames. If you look at their careers, certainly their immediate political career, they'd both been defence secretaries committed to maintaining or, in John Healy's case, increasing defence spending, who then become chancellor and face a need to walk back some of that ambition and generally tell some pretty hard truths to their party in straightened financial circumstances.

11:09Do you think that both Dennis and John Healy have got to look the Labour Party in the eye and say the state has got to be smaller if my sums are going to add up? I mean, you could argue actually in this budget that John Healey sort of ducked some of those choices. But you are right that they're both having to make an argument which is uncomfortable for their party. I would say in the case of Dennis Healey, it was an era in which actually he was having to persuade the party in the country that Britain needed to scale back its global role. It didn't have the money. You know, we were just coming out of Suez crisis and things like that.

11:44It just couldn't have the ambition and the defence spending that it had before. and it was facing these tough conditions. Of course, John Healy is in a way the opposite situation. He's having to persuade the Labour Party that they need more defence spending in this environment, but they still don't have any money. It's the same financial constraints, the same constraints of the markets, of people buying bonds in the market. So, you know, although the environment is pretty different, I would say that the peculiar challenge of trying to persuade the Labour Party in particular to make the agenda sort of fit the times, I think is similar.

12:20Let's go all out on the differences. You've already said to us in private that the BH ability to spin an item out of one surname needs to be challenged. So he had a top rate of tax, Dennis, of 98%. He had inflation at 25%. He had a huge union pay round, which they rejected some pay deals. So is John Healy's job easier? He is in an environment where we are used to hearing that the world has got tougher and it's a more hostile place, that we can't spend our way out of recession, all of these lines. But a lot of those lines were born in the 1970s and early 80s. And Healy was the one who was absolutely in the thick of that first round of sort of post-Keynesian policies that you could no longer throw money at a problem and you really did have a serious inflation problem.

13:14And I would say, I mean, the other big difference is all these politicians were still very much living in the shadow of World War II. I mean, like many major politicians of that time, Dennis Healy had been a major in the war. He had a very distinguished war record. I mean, the politicians of today have just, you know, sound different talking about defence and have a very different kind of hinterland. There's a fabulous archive of Delis singing the D-Day Dodgers song, isn't there, mocking those who'd served in Italy, not in Normandy. Stephanie Flanders, head of economics and politics at Bloomberg News.

13:52The government has denied it's been kicking the can down the road on big spending plans. I met Five Lives Matt Chorley to see why they're accused of putting things off. You're going to kick it too, mate? I'm going to kick it too, yeah. That's the item. Let's look at Labour's can kicking as the item limps on. Yes, probably the biggest can is the well-armoured can of defence spending. John Healy resigned in July, and he accused the government of being unable and unwilling to find the money. But we're still not very clear as to where the money comes from to hit 3 % of GDP on defence by 2030. Right, I'll give the can a kick.

14:30Hold on. However, Labour say it's not fair because they have got 1 % departmental cuts already agreeing this budget, which is more than was going to be the case. Yes, and although the can has been kicked, they are scurrying along behind it. Spending review. Yeah, so the spending review is laying out exactly what each department is going to get. And we now... I'm just going to catch the can. The can's gone. The can's moving itself. The can's been blown by the wind. We need to be careful because there's a bin lobby there. They might come and take our can away. The item's collapsing because the can's moving itself.

15:03So, yes, the spending review, which would normally come alongside a budget, there's now some reporting not completely knocked down by Number 10. It might not come to the later part of next year, which is where we would get how you're going to pay for defence spending. There's also the question of welfare. John Healy said last week that they were going to cut the welfare bill in this Parliament, and then the Treasury went around trying to hose that down and said, no, we haven't committed to that. and then you've got the question, well, aren't you going to do anything on the welfare bill in this Parliament?

15:27A couple of small cans which have been kicked down the road a little bit. The Milburn review into NEATS, the young people who are in education, employment or training, and the Timms review into PIP, the personal independence payment. We were expecting them before the budget. They've been kicked a little bit further down the road. Very nice, gentle kick. We're still expecting that before Christmas, but there's a lot of talk that actually, far from just lopping money off of welfare, it might even mean spending money up front to get people back in the work, Hopefully the bill will come down later.

15:55Now, here's an easy one, I think. Relations with the EU await a general election. At the Labour Party conference, Andy Burnham made a big play for let's have a big national conversation about Europe. You know, he's bringing the can a bit closer. He's having this big summit at the end of November, the EU-UK summit in Brussels. Whenever anyone's asked him a question about it, he's ramping it up. So it does feel like something... Certainly there's an ambition or a hope, though, in Number 10. there might be something come the end of November. Hang on, I'll get my cam back. When do we get a National Care Service?

16:30I mean, that is a big cam which has been kicked. Shall I kick it again? Yeah, go on. Oh, it's gone over there. If you kick it as far as the Prime Minister has kicked it, it will be in a different postcode. So, again, in his party conference speech, Andy Burnham says he is going to be the one that grasps this nettle, but at the moment he's sort of still in the garden shed looking for his gloves. He says something must be done. it will be funded in part from changes to the pension triple lock. He wants to sort of slightly change that formula to a sort of two and a half lock. But all of that is right after the election.

17:01They're committed to keeping the triple lock as it is until the general election. And if there isn't a general election until 2029, that's a can which is quite a long way down the road. And if we just pass our slide rule over some other parties, Theresa May arguably said she would grip social care and was then undone, her majority was undone. Boris Johnson did pass a measure, which was then undone, so the can was removed. Plaid have said they want greater move for nationalisation, but they realise it's not right now. And the SNPs say further independence referendum is in the future. So is everyone at Cannes kicking?

17:37It's not just old Burnham? Yeah, and I think there's definitely something about, in order to balance the books, to pay for things like defence, to pay for things like getting young people into work, at a time when the tax burden is as high as it's ever been and inflation is going up because of what's happening in Ukraine. That is just where politics is right now. But there's a reason why these issues have lingered for so long, whether it's youth unemployment or social care. It's because they are really difficult. So politicians of all parties forever have been kicking it down the road. There's one other thing I should get from John Healy Inspiration, which is, do you want to come with me and sink a pint before you do Newsnight?

18:17As long as I don't have to drink it out with a pedigree chum tin, I don't mind. With thanks to Matt Chorley and to our listener Nick Salmon, who writes saying, Attached is a recording for your slow radio to calm down from the weekly news. This is goats shaking the rain off. Magical sounds in a gorge in southern Crete. Slow radio, goats in the rain.

19:15BIRDS CHIRP Steady on. They sound like they're kicking a whole load of Matt Chorley's cans down the... Hang on, let's just have a listen. Let's just have a listen again. It is the kicking cans. Well, they wouldn't be bleating if it was Matt Chorley's cans. There you go. It is very musical. Yeah, isn't it? There is a bit of a can to it, you're right. I think the kicking can's down the road there. With thanks very much indeed to Nick Salmon and his remarkable old goats. Ian Hislop is backing a BH experiment to research just one name in remembrance of the war dead. Ian co-wrote the play The Wipers' Times about a satirical magazine printed by men fighting World War I.

19:59More on that in a moment. British veterans who returned from the big global conflicts prayed never again or advised don't start another war, hopes which have obviously been constantly ignored. BH is off air next Sunday as Radio 4 falls silent, led by the King at the Cenotaph, alongside the record line-up of former Prime Ministers. This morning, and when we return during November, we hope to swap research or find family members of just one name. Here's our starter for ten. In the archive of the Imperial War Museum are interviews with World War I veterans, including Leonard Gomm of the London Regiment.

20:39Here he mentions the meticulous Sergeant McKenzie, his inspiring leader, who was always smartest on parade, despite the mud and slime of the trenches. The saddest of all, in my opinion, of those we knew so well on whom we could depend, was Sergeant McKenzie. He really was an awfully nice man, and he had such an aptitude and a penchant for chocolate that we called him a chocolate soldier although he was a most efficient man and he always looked even if we were up to our neck in mud somehow old Mac always looked as though he'd just stepped out of a band box and here again sad to relate he was killed and before we put him in a winding sheet and I buried him personally I parted his hair and straightened him up and but for a bullet wound in the back You wouldn't have known that he was even dead.

21:41I shall never forget him. He was one of my best pals. And when these things happen, it's just another notch of bitterness that remains. You can hear all of that and more on the Imperial War Museum's podcast, Voices of the First World War. Well, we want to know more about Sergeant McKenzie. From our amateur research online, We think he could be Sergeant Harold Mackenzie and that the grave Leonard buried him in is lost. Instead, he's named at the Met Saint-Couture British Extension Cemetery near Calais. But we can't be sure. We're starting an experiment, which will then be over to you. Please mark our homework.

22:25Are you related to Sergeant Mackenzie? Are you related to Leonard Gomm? You could email bh at bbc.co.uk. do you just like history research? You can research just one name, enlist a handy child who might be in your home or classroom. We ask that any name is currently unknown to you, perhaps on a local war memorial, perhaps someone listed as missing. And so to The Wipers' Times, the play written by Ian Hislop and Nick Newman, which tells the story of two officers from the Sherwood Foresters who started a satirical magazine. I met Ian for BBC Newsnight to mark 40 years as editor of Private Eye and he told me the thing he was most proud of in his life is this play and he agreed to join our fledgling BH experiment.

23:13I was very, very pleased. I wrote a play about another satirical magazine which was called The Wipers' Times, which was founded in 1916 in the middle of the First World War. It was set up by two remarkable British officers who, you know, in 1916, they found an old printer. They were looking for salvage in Ypres, which the British soldiers called wipers because they couldn't pronounce it. And instead of smashing it up and using it for pit props, they seemed to react in the archetypal British way and say, why don't we print a satirical magazine right here? Which they then did. They had, when the flamethrower was introduced on the Western Front, they ran an ad for marvellous new kids toy, the Flamenverfer.

24:03And you just thought, I mean, you are extraordinary. They had an agony column, agony art column, where one of the questions was, is it always wrong to shoot a superior officer? I mean, it's amazing stuff. I suppose the other reason I'm so proud of that project, at the end of the war, the two officers came home. their efforts were entirely unrecognised despite the huge success of this magazine during the war and the compilations of it and we ended the play originally by saying they didn't even get an obituary in the times and after we brought the play out the times ran an obituary of both of them which I was quite pleased with and you're emotional am I it's a clue yeah I just you know any satirical magazine you are standing on the shoulders of giants really I mean Britain has a tradition of doing this for hundreds of years I went to university and I studied all the people who do it well you know I did I did Pope I did Congreve I did the Restoration Pats I did Dryden I did Swift I did Wild I did Shaw and then if you had the people who drew well you know the Hogarths and the Browlansons and Gilrays.

25:26These are all the people who you say, why do you do this now? And you think, this is what we do in this country. Do you think that's what those people died for? Among the things they died for was our way of life, which includes a strong knocking of the powerful. That's something that the British have done. Yes. I mean, you know, Orwell was a great source on these things. But he said it's as important to laugh at politicians as it is to vote for them. I was going to ask you if you would help with the BH project. You did a project once before with individual names on war memorials. Yes. I think Not Forgotten was the name.

26:02Not Forgotten. Channel 4. Yes, that's fine. That's allowed. But if you might contribute one in the coming weeks for BH, because I know there was one family lost four brothers, for instance, features. Yeah, yeah. They were called The Souls. The Souls, amazingly. Perhaps you'd tell us about one name on a war memorial. Well, not today, but for the future. Yeah, yeah, sure. Ian, with thanks to Ian Hislop, the officers who found the printing press were Captain Fred Roberts and Lieutenant Jack Pearson. You can email bh at bbc.co.uk to help join in with this. And I think I heard this morning that there's a new programme with Ian Hislop on Radio 4 celebrating 300 years of Gulliver's travels coming up soon.

26:43Yes, everyone in the studio is nodding or nodding off.

26:49Sometimes we all need an extra helping hand, especially with a tricky business problem you've been putting off. Claude is the AI for just that. It's the collaborator that understands your entire workflow and thinks with you, not for you. And Claude isn't just for quick questions. Hand it a whole task, like turning a folder of scattered notes into a report, and it does the work and hands back something finished that you can open and edit. Claude can now draft a dock or deck right in front of you, and Claude Design now lives right inside Claude. Describe the website or prototype you're picturing, attach your design system, and it comes back in your own design language, ready to edit right on the canvas.

27:30It works with your files and the tools you already use, like Gmail and Slack. And whether you're debugging code at midnight, building a financial model, or strategizing your next business move, Claude extends your thinking to tackle the problems that matter. for problems worth solving. Get started with Claude at claude.ai.solve. That's claude.ai.solve. And check out Claude Pro, which includes access to all of the features mentioned in today's episode. Claude.ai.solve.

28:03Presidents Obama and Trump have traded blows in the fight for the US midterm elections. The US goes to the polls again on Tuesday with high cost of living prices and a toxic public debate. Presidents of both parties often face an upset halfway through as both houses of Congress could flip to their rivals. The Republican president Donald Trump enjoys a House and a Senate controlled by the same party. But I heard from the BBC's Justin Webb in Maine in the northeastern United States to remember the first rule. All politics is local. So it's basically a Democratic Party state when it comes to presidential elections, but with this incredible, long-standing Republican senator, Susan Collins, who's been here since, I think, the 19th century.

28:51Don't fact-check that. But she's been here a long time, and it feels to people in the state as if she's been here since the 19th century. That's certainly true. And they feel she's done an awful lot for the state. Also, she's not a friend of Donald Trump in any way, shape or form. So although she's a Republican, she voted for the second impeachment. You remember there were two of them. The second one, she actually voted to convict him. In other words, she is a particular enemy of Donald Trump, and there's no love lost between them. But the Democrats have had the most appalling task in trying to get rid of her down the years.

29:24And this time they thought, and I put that slightly in the past tense, they thought they had a real chance of doing it because they'd come up with a really good candidate. He's an oyster fisherman, salt of the earth kind of guy. But then that completely blew up. There were all sorts of allegations about the way he treated women. And eventually he had to pull out. And they found another guy, Troy Jackson, who is a local politician, who they hope can still do the job. But it's incredibly close. And frankly, nobody knows what is going to happen. And it really does matter because it could be that one state is the difference between the Democrats winning control of the Senate or not.

30:00Yeah. And it's also schooling us on the fact that these are midterm elections with local reasons why people vote. There are two House districts. The governor is up in Maine. But on the national stage, is it fair to say that Barack Obama has been unleashed for the Democrats in a way he has not been during this second Trump term? Yes and no. Generally, in the latter stages of a campaign, he does get involved. But I think it is fair to say that this time round, it is a bit different. It's very, very pointed. It's very much needling Trump in a way that he, Obama, knows upsets him. And there's this rally where he made a load of jokes, actually, at the expense of the president.

30:45But there was one that really hit her. It's paved over the Rose Garden, put a helicopter pad on the south lawn, and there's gold everywhere. What's up with the gold? Everything, more gold. He's got the white ass looking like Saddam Hussein opened a Cheesecake Factory.

31:08OK, for those who don't know America well, the Cheesecake Factory is one of these fast food outlets, a hugely successful one, actually. It's the place you take your kids. I saw it described recently as if ancient Egypt had gone to Las Vegas in decor style. I want to go. I want to go. Even as I said that, Paddy, I was right up your street, actually. But they're great places, isn't it? Relatively cheap. You can take all the kids, etc., etc. So what the Republicans have said is, oh, he's anti-cheesecake factory. And that has then become the Republican pushback against Obama, that somehow it's a class thing.

31:47And because he was likening the White House to a cheesecake factory, somehow he's saying cheesecake factories aren't good enough. And the president himself, as I think Obama intended, got involved. Guys like Obama, he doesn't notice dirt and film that hadn't been cleaned for years. He doesn't notice areas that haven't been painted. for you to say it's a cheesecake factory. That just shows why you were a lousy president. Right, thank you. OK, so it obviously needled him. It's the first rule, isn't it, of political debate. Don't get needled. But these are difficult times for the president because the House is predicted by the same polls that were pretty disastrous last time.

32:25But anyway, they're predicting that the House could go and you've reminded us that the Senate is tight. But do you accept yourself the polls that say the House will swing to the Democrats, Justin? uh no i don't think the polls tell us anything very useful so i was talking to someone the other day a friend of mine actually who is a pollster here who was saying that to get about 800 which sort of decent number of people to take part in a poll they are having to poll at his company anything up to 800 000 people to get just the 800 to say yes to actually answer the phone and say okay, I'll do the poll.

33:02And in those circumstances, who are you missing? What the Trump people say, I mean, they say, you're missing Trump people, because Trump people don't trust pollsters, because they don't trust authority. Lots of them don't have mobile phones, quite a few of them have several jobs. So, you know, you've got this whole idea that actually, the Democrats are ahead. And it looks as if they are for all sorts of reasons of enthusiasm on their side, etc, etc. But you cannot know with any certainty from the polls. And I think I was reading there's only just over one million registered voters in Maine where you are, which is a reminder how that sample is extraordinary.

33:40And I can't let you go without just describing the beautiful geography of the United States. Where are you? What are the colours like on the trees? How is the sea and the lobster? Yeah, it's imagine the best autumn day in, I don't know, the lowlands of Scotland and the whole of Maine is like it and Maine is the size of all of Scotland with those million people and it is a sort of sea of russets and reds and golden colors on the trees actually just just beginning to end now but also the amazing coastline has got a kind of massive coastline sort of Cornish style coastline all the way up to Canada here in Maine you know they are really interested in Maine things which is blueberries, which is logging, which is lobster fishing.

34:27I'm moving. I'm moving to Maine. Come. I'm not leaving. Hang on. Where's the banjo? I was promised banjo. Ah, there we are. There we are. This is Justin on the banjo, as a matter of fact. Jim Nocteer's here, looking like his life's briefly come to an end. I wish I was there. I know. We all wish we were there. Never forget the beauty of the US. When people go on about the US, I never hear enough about the beauty of the place. Everyone's wanging on about the politics. It's wonderful. Are you going to wang on about the politics, Jim? Well, to an extent, but Justin's right. Forget polls with two days to go.

35:05Be as leery as an innocent abroad and Halloween, Paddy, it's a pretty dark business. So you and your listener will be delighted to hear that. We're not going to spend the whole of the world this weekend trying to predict the result. Just wait for those results on Tuesday. But we will hear, among other things, a powerful creed occur from a conservative, lifelong Republican lawyer who worked on Capitol Hill for many years about why he wants Democrats to take over Congress. It's worth hearing, I can tell you. And among others, from one of the veteran Democrats, she's actually 83, a veteran Congresswoman, who are preparing their all-out assault on Trump.

35:39if they do take the House. By the way, she'll be in charge of a committee that dispenses$1.7 trillion a year and we'll hear from one of Trump's strongest supporters in Capitol Hill too, of course. Come along, I promise you'll feel as if you're there. But no predictions. The world this weekend at one. Thank you, Jim. In the nearer future, the founder of Parkrun, Paul Sinton Hewitt, is Lauren's castaway at 10. And in the nearer future, we've the review of Yota Motolenghi, Sir Charles Walker and Kate Moss. But now, contraception for squirrels. A special feeder is being developed to bait greys with contraceptives to help save the reds.

36:21Greys were introduced by the Victorians, who, to be fair to them, also gave us steam, sewers and the penny black. Greys carry squirrel pox, but they're not harmed by it. They simply spread it to the much-loved reds. Their most southerly mainland community is in Formby, where they're trialling a new feeding device, which will allow only the grey to eat the bait. BH squirrel contraceptive reporter Guy Emanuel has been there. I'm in the Formby National Trust Reserve. It's a lovely day. And I'm surrounded by tall pine trees just a stone's throw away from the beach and the sea. I've been here many times over the years and normally I manage to spot at least one red squirrel.

37:08They're much more discreet than their grey cousins, so hopefully, fingers crossed, I can find one today. Excuse me, have you seen any red squirrels at all? No, sadly. Better luck next time.

37:23I'm looking for red squirrels. Have you seen any today, sir? No, I haven't today, no. I see them regularly, so yeah, I like to see them. They make nice noise as they chase each other. There's a chance I'll find one then. If you're in the right places, yes. OK, there's something rustling over there in the leaves. Is that a...

37:48Is that a red squirrel? That's a grey squirrel. That's a grey squirrel. The search continues. And Guy is still walking around the woods looking for one. So we couldn't find a red in the flesh. So here is one from the BBC Natural History Unit. This is two red squirrels chasing each other up a tree.

38:23Heather Harris is from Lancashire Trust's Red Squirrel Recovery Network and she hopes one day reds will be more numerous that even our team can spot them She explained a trial that's happening in Formby to control the greys and promote the reds So this study is for fertility control for grey squirrels. So that would offer a non-lethal option to reduce grey squirrel numbers. So contraception for greys. Yes, yeah. So not culling. No. So they were in the process of developing a feeder and a contraceptive. So that feeder would allow only grey squirrels to get the bait and then that would cause infertility in the grey squirrels.

39:06The feeder mechanism will be trialled here, so we'll have the help of our wonderful volunteers who will monitor the mechanism and make sure that it's only grey squirrels that get into the bait and that any other wildlife would not take any effects. How do you check for one species entry only? What is the trick of the feeder? They are making it weight-focused, so it will be specifically designed to take the grey squirrels' weight. It will please some who don't want culling, because there's also been a suggestion over the years to cull the greys. Yes, absolutely. And the sad truth is that without undertaking any grey squirrel control, red squirrels would be extinct in the UK in under 10 years.

39:49And what do you love about the red? I think they're just absolutely charming. And it's a really magical experience walking through the woodlands in Thornby and spotting that flash of russet fur through the treetops. It's kind of a moment where you'll walk with your family and everyone is still and just captivated by such a magical and such a sadly now rare sight to see. With thanks to Heather Harris. Our guests in the studio are Sir Charles Walker. You've eaten a squirrel. I have in America. Very tasty. And that's not illegal? No, no. In fact, during the war, they were sold to the American GIs stationed in the country.

40:25Kate Moss is not in the studio. Kate, have you eaten a squirrel? I don't eat any things, let alone squirrels. OK, good. Just checking. Just toast. It's toast. Well, now here is Yotam Otolenghi. Welcome back. Yotam, you're going to go first because we've asked you to help us out with emergency stockpile recipes. The government says we should stockpile. In our imaginary BH larder, we've got sardines. Yes. Canned tomatoes. Uh-huh. Half a bag of pasta, half a bag of rice, some olive oil and some mixed herbs. Okay. Do you have garlic? It's very old and it's gone very soggy. It's gone soggy? Well, you know, it goes soft.

41:05Oh. But yes, I have got, secretly I've got some for you. Secretly, okay, secretly for me. What I would try to do, and I love sardines from a can, and I would maybe take some, drain those sardines if they're in oil and use that oil plus some extra olive oil to take your beans. What beans are they? Is it like a jar of beans, like white beans, like cannellini beans or something? That's exactly what they are. It's uncanny. Yeah. Okay, amazing. You've obviously seen my pantry. I have not seen your pantry. So beans, I would take those. I'll steep those beans in oil from the can and from some olive oil.

41:42And you said you had some dried mixed herbs. I'll add those. And if I'm giving the garlic, I'll take like, I don't know, five or six garlic cloves and add them there. And then just cook it slowly like a confit. so the beans will go softer and a little bit mushy in a good way and then the garlic will cook slowly and then I'll be able to mush it into a kind of a creamy consistency and that oil with the herbs, with the beans, with the garlic will be a wonderful pasta sauce. You'd add the sardines back to it, warm it up and put it over on your pasta. Fantastic, eh? I mean, that's only my stock. Better than squirrel.

42:21Kate, do you eat any sardines? No, I don't eat meat or fish at all, I'm afraid, not since I was a very little girl. No, but we know many listeners are in the same camp. So do you like everything else that was in that recipe except the sardines? Yes, I love the sound of even the soggy garlic and the beans. Absolutely, that sounds brilliant. Well, look, thank you for playing along with us. Let me introduce our guests by their correct monikers. We've the king of the kitchen, the queen of fiction and a knight of the realm. Yotam is the chef and restaurateur who's sold 15 million cookbooks. His latest is Simple 2, Dishes in Under 30 Minutes.

42:57That should be one of them. That could be one of them. And it's a kind of a take on things that do happen in the book. Confying beans and garlic for a long time in oil is a wonderful way to put a meal on the table with very little effort. Sir Charles Walker is the former Tory MP who lost patience with the angry tone of politics. He is on the Independent Parliamentary Standards Authority and he's also chair of the Sky Foundation, a new charitable trust. Sir Charles, who do you give money to? Right now we're supporting young dancers through scholarships but we're hoping to be supporting many more parts of the arts and promoting women in sport.

43:37Welcome back. And Kate Moss is the novelist who burst into worldwide best-selling fame 21 years ago. Can you believe it, Kate? Labyrinth. No, no. She's had a string of bestsellers since. Her current title is Return to Nonfiction, Autumn, the Story of a Season. That follows Michael Morpurgo on Spring in Devon and Val McDermott on Winter in Scotland. Do you think you've got the best season to talk about, Kate? Well, what's so wonderful is that all four of us, Bernardine Evaristo, who's writing Summer, we all thought we'd been given first choice. So autumn is the best season. We all know that. It's got the best colours.

44:13It's about new beginnings. It's about hope of a new school year. So, yes, I got the best one, but they all think they got the best one. Yeah, well, we're very pleased to have you back. And autumn is such a lovely time of year. Thank you for coming. OK, Yotam, no time to die from the Mail on Sunday. Slow Horses Jack bounces back, but isn't he the new 007? Yes, this is a piece in the Mail on Sunday. and so the Slow Horses star, River Cartwright, well, that's the character, but actually it's Jack and he has been spotted filming season eight of Slow Horses. I love Slow Horses and I think it would be amazing if he does become the new, I vote for him as the next James Bond.

45:04I like the fact that he is both, you know, a hero, but he's vulnerable and fallible and sensitive. So a perfect hero for the 21st century as the new James Bond, that's Jack Loudoun. Kate, as someone who's created many characters yourself, what do you think of River Cartwright as a character? Well, I mean, I don't really know the series at all. I love Mick Herron's writing and I love the books. But the entire television series has passed me by because I'm writing. And when I am writing, I find it impossible to have other stories in my head. I can only reread Agatha Christie on a loop. So I've been in Perdo, really, writing Perdo for some time.

45:48What makes a good 007? What are the right qualities? I think, well, what Yotam just said, I think is absolutely right. And, of course, this kind of more modern 007, that they're kind of masculine but soft, they're gentle, they're thoughtful. They're in the tradition of the great Alan Quartermain from Ryder Haggard's books, you know, King Solomon's Minds and She, which is a man who can be all things, is in touch with his feminine side, but can do the business when he needs to. So I think Jack Loudoun would be a great choice. Lovely. Well, we're underway. Thank you very much indeed. We turn to some of the most serious news this weekend with Charles, the Sunday Telegraph, a photo reunited in Ukraine.

46:26It is. It's a Ukrainian soldier greeting his long-separated partner. Dimitro is the soldier and Larissa is his partner. And it is quite the most beautiful photograph I've ever seen. It sums up the human capacity for love and devotion. And I would really recommend all your listeners to try and find a copy of it. It is utterly beautiful. It tells a human story and it is deeply, deeply moving. Without being more than unusually pompous, this is how journalists get paid when people buy newspapers. And I'm looking at it now. It was taken by Diego Fidele. And this tells us about how the Russian-occupied Oleschke, these people have been living in the most vicious circumstances.

47:17Kate, did you follow the story that apparently Melania Trump is responsible for the temporary ceasefire? I did follow the story. And I think the piece, firstly, I agree with Charles that the photograph is absolutely beautiful. And it reminds us that the heart of every single statistic is a real person. You know, it's just not the numbers game. I followed it and I think the piece is very accurate and that it makes the point that this is just a one off. It has no effect on the broader ceasefire or the pattern of the war between Russia and Ukraine. but the fact that any people have been saved from what is clearly an appalling situation is wonderful we must celebrate every tiny victory even if actually it doesn't have a bigger effect overall i i agree i i just i i go back just the the human capacity for love and devotion is is something that we we should celebrate and this photograph celebrates it thank you very much indeed.

48:16Kate Moss, we have not had one of your personal selections. You can begin anywhere you like. Well, I'm afraid I'm going to begin with one from The Sun, on page 8 of The Sun. And it's partly because whatever one thinks about The Sun or not, they are the best headline writers. And this particular one is Lefty Wasters. And it's a very misleading article about how a so-called lefty council, it's actually a Labour and now a Green Council in Lewisham, so read into that what you will, has spent£50 ,000 on what they've described as tea drinking lessons. And they have obviously done freedom of information and the article is taking great exception to the idea of the waste of taxpayers' money.

49:03I chose it for the headline because I think, and later on it goes, you know, what are PG tips? So the sun keeps this going. But I also, I think it's a serious point, is that because the discussions around immigration, legal and illegal, have become so unpleasant and so toxic, everything that anybody is trying to do to make our country a happier, better place to live in is derided. And what is at the bottom of this is, do we want people who legally have come here to be helped to integrate? If you go and live in France or Greece or wherever, you will be able to go and find lessons. you will be able to do things about the culture that you're moving into.

49:45Whereas this is presented as it's a terrible thing to explain to people that the culture that they're moving to has certain traditions that they might not know about. Whereas I would suggest it's a really good thing because that is how integration works. Thank you. So you don't like the cut of the jib of the story, but you give credit to The Sun on Sunday for its headlines and also to the council, Lewisham, for what it's doing and the debate will continue endlessly, I know. Yotam, strenuous Cotswold Way proves a slog for who from the Observer? Well, for American tourists, they found it on TikTok.

50:18So you've got this viral route of hiking going all the way from Chipping Camden to Bath over 100 miles. And it looks idyllic to me. It looks beautiful. But I think as often happens on TikTok, things are overhyped. So the expectations never live up to the promise. So someone wrote that they've taken the trip. It's a lower expectation. They write, it is a slog. It was made hard by being long, occasionally technical, and sometimes steep as hell. Charles, are you a walker in the country? I am. Yeah, no, I love walking in the country. I'm greatly sad that most people walk around in the country now with their mobile phones in front of their faces, filming everything.

51:07I mean, I went to the Alps this summer to walk with my kids, and I also failed miserably to... So we went walking in Austria, you know, something that was supposed to be three hours ended up being seven hours. Well, that's good for children. It is very good for children. They just really wanted to kill me. And my youngest one said how... He was outraged, and he says, how is this a holiday? And I had to explain to him that this will be good memories for the future. Yes, it's a point of a childhood holiday. You must hate it. Yeah, but the thing you must... You should have told him that. That is not how I solved it.

51:39Daddy's not stopping the car. We've got to drive to Salzburg. Charles Walker, your turn now. Where next? Alan Milburn, who is doing some great thinking on how to get youngsters back into work. It's the challenge of our age. We have a million, well over a million young people who are looking for work, want to work, and we can't find them work. And I don't think you can separate this from the rise in AI. and it is going to be a huge societal challenge. It already is. And we better sort it out pretty quickly before it gets much worse. We need to make it better. And you left politics in part because you're fed up of tribalism and shoutiness.

52:17Do you support Alan Milburn, the Labour grandee? Alan Milburn is a Labour grandee and a great brain and a serious thinker. So I'm really pleased he's on it. He feels passionate about it. I hope that when he does report back, the political parties across the House, take his work seriously and take his recommendations seriously. Kate Moss, deathbed portrait of artist Vanessa Bell discovered from The Observer. Yes, this is a beautiful story of an anonymous donor who was given what now appears to be the very last portrait of Vanessa Bell by Duncan Grant. He was her partner and was in a relationship with another man.

52:56She was married. But they worked together and loved one another for a very, very, very long time. Belle died when she was 81 in April in 1961. And before that, there was a charcoal painting, a sketch that he'd done. But this is a beautiful piece of work of an amazing woman, very close to the end of her life when she was dying from Boncarte. She knew she was. And we forget, I think, sometimes in these days, I completely agree with Charles. Put your phones down if you're going. Don't photograph everything. Live it. But this is a memory, a reminder that firstly, beautiful things survive. We didn't know this existed and it's been given to Charleston now to be on display.

53:41But secondly, that people have always recorded the people that matter to them in the ways that they can. It might be in print, it might be in music, it might be in painting, it might be in pencil, whatever it is. And so I just always celebrate in these very hectic times the fact that something so beautiful has somehow survived and now it's been found. Thank you. and given to Charleston. It sounds, you're creating a beautiful picture of it for us. And 20 seconds for you, Yotam, from the day, the star on Sunday, the Queen is a spuddy marvel. Yes, so the Queen Camilla is a big fan of the old jacket potato, which is having a massive comeback.

54:16And there's Ben Newman, who's got this pink mohawk, and in Staffordshire, making these amazing toppings for baked potatoes. He's also got a baked potato cookbook that he's selling. But it's this idea that a baked potato is quintessentially British, but you can put whatever you want on it, even pizza topping. But not pineapple. Not pineapple, peas and beans. Thank you very much indeed. We did say mainland red squirrels. If you've been writing to us about the Isle of Wight squirrels, we did make it plain that we were mainland reds. Today's producers were Hattie Nash and Rose Nugy. Studio direction from Antonio Fernandez.

54:54The editor was Mark Faulkner. Thanks to Yotam, Kate and Charles and to you for listening. Goodbye. Sometimes we all need an extra help in hand, especially with a tricky business problem you've been putting off. Claude is an AI for just that. It's the collaborator that understands your entire workflow and thinks with you, not for you. And Claude isn't just for quick questions. Handed a whole task like turning a folder of scattered notes into a report and it does the work and hands back something finished that you can open and edit. Claude can now draft a doc or deck right in front of you. and Claude Design now lives right inside Claude.

55:32Describe the website or prototype you're picturing, attach your design system and it comes back in your own design language ready to edit right on the canvas. It works with your files and the tools you already use like Gmail and Slack and whether you're debugging code at midnight, building a financial model or strategizing your next business move, Claude extends your thinking to tackle the problems that matter. For problems worth solving, get started with Claude at claude.ai slash solve. That's claude.ai slash solve. And check out Claude Pro, which includes access to all of the features mentioned in today's episode.

56:08Claude.ai slash solve. Investing with Schwab is like spending a Saturday at a great farmer's market. You can fill your reusable tote with a bit of everything. Maybe you go for some free range, self-directed investing, or perhaps you pick up a few farm fresh trades while you peruse. You can even get help from a dedicated advisor. That's full service wealth management. Mix, match and change your mind whenever you want. Because at Schwab, you can invest your way. No matter your goals or appetite for investing, Schwab has everything you need all in one place. Visit schwab.com to learn more.

From the publisher

King Charles to address slavery during Commonwealth speech in Antigua on final leg of Caribbean tour, Royal biographer Robert Hardman says PM intervention unhelpful. Also on BH a tale of two Healeys Bloomberg's Stephanie Flanders on the parallels between two Labour Chancellors Denis and John. Justin Webb on the upcoming US midterm elections. Ian Hislop on a BH project 'Just One Name' aiming to remember soldiers killed in the two World Wars. A new project to save the red squirrel in the UK. On the news review former Conservative MP Sir Charles Walker, super chef Yotam Ottolenghi and bestselling author Kate Mosse.

More from Broadcasting House

All episodes