

Broadcasting House (BBC Radio 4) episode covering (1) Labour’s U-turn on using judge-only trials instead of juries to reduce criminal court backlogs; (2) the evacuation and security confusion around RAF Fairford after US bombers struck Iran; (3) why people are nostalgic for the 1990s, ahead of a Tate Britain exhibition; plus a news review and cultural segments.
Sir Robert Buckland (former Conservative Lord Chancellor/Justice Secretary, 2019–2021; expert witness on jury trials). Geoffrey Archer (novelist; final novel Adam and Eve). Anne Cleaves (novelist; Vera Stanhope series; ITV adaptations). Simeon Brown (Channel 4 News Home Affairs Correspondent; author of The Good, The Black and The Boogey). Isabel Hardman (The Spectator assistant editor; Sunday Times/press panel).
Norris/Alex Norris says judge-only “bit” was new/slow to set up and can be removed while still cutting backlog; juries are “intangible” and “democratic” and eroding them risks public confidence. RAF Fairford villagers report conflicting information, delayed local communication, and evacuation of 80+ homes. 1990s nostalgia is tied to analog culture, collective music experiences, optimism, and less pressure to “be a brand.”
Leaked press release/hurried statement; 25,000 cases to magistrates; concerns about expanding magistrates’ sentencing powers; RAF Fairford B-1 bombers; seal yodel sound on Slow Radio; Tate Britain 90s exhibition; ticket-price comparisons (e.g., Glastonbury £1 in 1970); Real McCoy comedy’s 35th anniversary.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Exploring the reasons behind the public's nostalgia for the 1990s.
“Back in the 90s, there was less pressure to turn yourself into a brand.”
Discussion on Labour's decision to maintain jury trials amid court backlogs.
“Faced with record backlogs in the courts, Keir Starmer's government planned the greater use of a judge-only process to speed up criminal justice.”
Sir Robert Buckland discusses the implications of changes to jury trials.
“And also, you were presiding over the backlog building, so we don't need to make a political point.”
Listener shares a unique sound from grey seals on Sable Island.
“Damien Lidyard is our listener in Halifax, Nova Scotia, and he has recorded for us a very rare sound for slow radio.”
Discussion on the 90s cultural revival and its significance today.
“TINA RITCHIE Tina Ritchie, what do you make of males yodelling?”
Explore the carefree fashion choices and cultural optimism of the 1990s.
“It felt incredibly, in retrospect, innocent.”
Discuss the political optimism during the 90s with figures like Clinton and Blair.
“I mean, it looked completely ridiculous.”
Examine how women's fashion and representation evolved in the 90s amidst societal changes.
“Do you think, Terry, we had a better sense of who we were in the 90s?”
Reflect on the cultural excesses and behaviors of the 90s including the drinking culture.
“of a night out and bring it into your dressing room.”
Consider how elements of the 90s can influence modern life, especially in music consumption.
“outlandish behavior of her life I wish I'd spent less time drinking and smoking and partying and wish I'd painted more.”
Debate the enduring influence of 90s music and culture on current generations.
“That's what makes the 90s look so fantastic in retrospect.”
Explore how local communities react to security threats and emergency situations near RAF Fairford.
“And a play out will give you a choice between two tracks famous from the 90s.”
Listen to personal narratives about the sudden evacuations caused by security incidents near RAF Fairford.
“And Geoffrey Archer is in our corridor looking at our stale pastries.”
Residents express their fears and experiences related to local disturbances.
“but there was such politicking and holding things back, it did feel that we were the last people to know.”
Geoffrey Archer discusses his writing journey and his last novel, 'Adam and Eve'.
“With more news to come, I'm quite sure, on that.”
Simeon Brown discusses the insights from his research on Britain's black middle class.
“Very nice to meet you, and we hope to see you again.”
Discussion on childcare policy and its implications for the creative sector.
“So she's going to scrap that cliff edge.”
Guests share their favorite beautiful locations in Northumberland and Shetland.
“Don't spoil it, but what's the appeal of a beautiful place?”
Reflection on the significance of the BBC show 'The Real McCoy' and its impact on black British comedy.
“Of course, it's the real McCoy celebrating its 35th anniversary this year.”
Discussion on the annoyance of loud music on public transport and a potential ban.
“it was playing, or rather it was you doing that thing that only comedy can really do.”
Guests discuss changes in shared culture and ticket prices for concerts over the years.
“And I opened my newspaper up and started reading about David Cameron's Europe policy.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On Broadcasting House, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00Paddy O'Connell: This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK.
0:30Paddy O'Connell: goals or appetite for investing, Schwab has everything you need all in one place. Visit schwab.com to learn more. How many streaming subscriptions do you have? Is it the same for your business? Avoid it by having all your business on one platform. Try Odoo for free at odoo.com. That's O-D-O-O dot com. Hello, it's the podcast of Broadcasting House from Sunday, the 4th of October. We spoke about jury trials and the 1990s, what did they all mean? Ahead, the verdict's in for Labour's previous plans to scrap some jury trials. Guilty. I've made the assessment that I can take that out of the legislation, which helps to keep public confidence, helps the passage of the bill, but that I can get the backlog savings from that by bringing forward other provisions.
1:17Paddy O'Connell: We'll have a reaction from a former Justice Secretary. Also on BH, I've been to investigate the mysterious case of RAF Fairford. what on earth is going on? Villagers tell us about the evacuation one week on. They said you've got to get out now, as soon as possible. So we did. We fed the chickens, we fed the cat, picked up the dog, and that was it. And she's a BH listener. Geoffrey Archer's in the studio shortly, talking politics, prisons and pulling the plug on novel writing. And...
1:56Back in the 90s, there was less pressure to turn yourself into a brand. There was more space to find yourself through other people.
2:05Paddy O'Connell: That kind of sense of inclusivity and fun. Why are people so nostalgic for the 90s? Were you there? Do you remember it? We'll discuss as the decade gets its own Tate exhibition. Our press panel is gathering the novelist Anne Cleaves and journalists Simeon Brown and Isabel Hardman. Labour's U-turned-on-jury trials. Faced with record backlogs in the courts, Keir Starmer's government planned the greater use of a judge-only process to speed up criminal justice. But now, Andy Burnham's Justice Secretary, Alex Norris, says more serious cases will continue to be heard by the panel of peers known to us all as The Jury.
2:43Paddy O'Connell: Here he was moments ago on Sky News. I know one of the central premises of this legislation is that the delay of justice is the denial of justice. but also it's very clear from the public too they don't want to see justice diminished and there was concerns particularly about this proposal around creating that sort of extra, a different way of having a judge-only trial. So we looked at it again and I've made the assessment that I can take that out of the legislation which helps me keep public confidence, helps the passage of the bill but that I can get the backlog savings from that by bringing forward other provisions because actually the judge-only bit was new and novel would have taken time to set up so I can bring forward the provisions and we can get that backlog coming down.
3:24Paddy O'Connell: Sir Robert Buckland was the Conservative Lord Chancellor and Secretary of State for Justice from 2019 to 2021 and he is our expert witness. Sir Robert, hello. Hello, good morning. Can we start with victims? Do they wait just much too long in the UK? Yes, they do. The answer was never to strip back jury trials. You know, we've had juries for many generations and no backlog. The reason why we've had a backlog, I think everybody knows there was a combination of too few court days being allocated some years ago. I tried to increase that, but then we were hit with Covid. We lost a couple of months of jury trials because of social distancing.
4:04And the system's never really recovered since. And the way in which this proposal emerged late last year through a leaked press release and then a hurried statement by David Lammy, I think, illustrated the fact that this was a rushed policy. it was the wrong prescription for the problem. And now the new Justice Secretary, I think, has rightly U-turned. There are still some provisions within the government's proposals that I think are matters of concern, though, which we can look at.
4:34Paddy O'Connell: OK, but I don't think everyone would agree that it was rushed. They had a senior judge look at their plans. And also, you were presiding over the backlog building, so we don't need to make a political point. If I could just ask you about the courts, though. But to be fair to Sir Brian Leveson, Lord Leveson, who did the review, the government did rush this because they announced their proposals before Sir Brian had reported fully. OK, that point's been made. And they ignored a lot of those recommendations. All right, Sir Robert, it's just that with time being tight, if we just say what will happen in the courts, do you think there'll be more work for magistrates?
5:08Paddy O'Connell: If you are going to stop this system, does it mean more work for the mag? Yeah, it does, because the impact assessment says about 25 ,000 cases will go to the magistrate's court. They want to increase the maximum powers for magistrates from one year to two years of imprisonment. That, I think, will have a whole host of problems of their own. And I also think that removing the defendant's choice of going to the Crown Court as well, actually doesn't deal with the problem in the sense that the magistrate's courts themselves need resources. now, if they're going to do more complex cases, are they going to be able to cope?
5:45And the real fear is that they're not. So, you know, we've still got big questions here about really how to deal with the backlog. One way in which Brian Leveson recommended, which is being seemingly ignored by the government, is actually to allow more discretion for courts to give greater credit for guilty pleas. That may mean that some defendants who are currently holding out and hoping that their case will disappear somehow because of the backlog, might well plead guilty. So I think that needs to be looked at urgently. There's still more options for the government to consider. I don't like the idea of removing juries in fraud.
6:20I think, again, that is an old idea that's come back. I think it's a mistaken premise. So there's still some details here to be ironed out. But broadly, I think the government's done the right thing. New Lord Chancellors moved well on this, but the devil's in the detail.
6:34Paddy O'Connell: And can I ask a Sunday morning question, which isn't political and it's not really philosophical, it's cultural. Do you just think there's something mysterious and magical about a jury? Is it to be judged by one's peers? Is that something that you feel is totally and utterly correct and the only way sometimes in life? Well, having conducted many jury trials myself, prosecutor, defender and indeed as a judge, I can tell you there is something really intangible, indefinable, but ultimately rather democratic about having non-lawyers who've perhaps never been in a court before, determining the facts and the faith, the liberty of the individual.
7:15I think it's a deep-seated part of our system. I think those who play with it tend to be those who perhaps have never experienced it or understand it. I think it's the best possible system we could have, and we erode it at our peril.
7:32Paddy O'Connell: Our expert witness, Sir Robert Buckland. Thank you very much. Come back soon. Damien Lidyard is our listener in Halifax, Nova Scotia, and he has recorded for us a very rare sound for slow radio. I work on Sable Island, NS, that's Nova Scotia, where there is a large breeding colony of grey seals, the same species found around the UK, but the male has a unique yodel. That is a unique yodel. Listen out for it now for Slow Radio.
8:44Paddy O'Connell: TINA RITCHIE Tina Ritchie, what do you make of males yodelling? It was a unique yodel, wasn't it? Males in the UK apparently did not yodel. Really? I'm talking about seals, not humans. Ah, interesting, Paddy. Always learn something listening to you. The sound of the pups and females. The pups call for the mum to be fed. The females are calling to warn off the males that they're too close to the pups. Have another listen.
9:12Go you girls. That's what I say.
9:15Paddy O'Connell: Political and cultural figures are excavating the 90s. There's a new exhibition looming at Tate Britain and the Chancellor used his conference speech in the last few days to say he was enjoying his own nostalgic return to the decade. But he said there was just one difference. Now, I know the 90s is having a bit of a revival. To Angela's excitement, Oasis are going back on tour. To Angela's joy, Gladiators back on Saturday night TV. But I have to level with you, conference. the money New Labour had in the 90s is simply not there now. Were you there in the 90s? What on earth did it all mean? You could get a mortgage for three times your salary, the USSR broke up, Nelson Mandela became the first black president of South Africa, the Belfast or Good Friday Agreement was struck in Northern Ireland and the Republic.
10:06Paddy O'Connell: I could go on, and you know I can. So here instead are the 90s in 90 seconds.
10:16I believe very firmly in the 1990s that we will have a decade of the most remarkable opportunities. Wake up, Cass. Come on, darling. Choose life. Choose a job. Choose a career. Because I know we're the best band on the planet. This is about girl power. This is not about picking up guys. Hello and welcome to Top of the Pubs on BBC One and Radio One.
10:56An online network called Internet. No one told you that was gonna be this way. How do you spell bouquet? B-U-C-K-E-T.
11:12The world is back again after eight months off the air. It's quintessentially British as getting dumped out of the World Cup.
11:24This new Labour government will govern in the interests of all our people, the whole of this nation. I feel the hand of history upon our shoulder.
11:33Paddy O'Connell: The two governments and the political parties of Northern Ireland have reached agreement. I did not have sexual relations with that woman. I'm Keith Townsend forever, mate. Well, at least I remember where I put my car. Hadley Freeman is an author, Sunday Times columnist and new film critic on the title. And Terry Christian is the broadcaster and DJ who hosted the late-night entertainment show The Word from 1990 to 1995. I asked him first, does the 90s need an exhibition? From my point of view, really the 90s to me started with the Manchester explosion in 88, 89. Although, you know, the name Manchester came later.
12:19That wasn't created by a marketing department. And I actually kind of resent the idea that they're doing it. For young people today, the 90s does need an exhibition. There is just such a fascination with that era, which was really the last analog era. It's when young people could go out. We got our music news from people like Terry on TV. We were all watching The Word then. We weren't all listening to different podcasts. Things weren't as atomised. People weren't all standing around staring at their phones in the club. They were all listening to the music. So it felt like a real collective experience every time you went out.
12:55And also when you went out, you could be private, which is something that young kids don't have today. I mean, I certainly look back on it as a golden era.
13:02Paddy O'Connell: Terry painting in cultural primary colours. There was Friends was on the screen, Seinfeld, Twin Peaks, Titanic came out. Hadley's saying that your show, the word, people were watching it in mass numbers. Do you remember feeling that you were part of a moment? I could see it and I felt it. And it kind of made me wish I was like 18 instead of 28. And it was nice to feel at the centre of stuff. But, you know, I'd always had very diverse tastes. You know, I basically grew up in inner city, Manchester, in an area where you're either basically Irish or Jamaican, you know. So we loved reggae, but we had Catholic guilt.
13:41And there was always that sort of feeling in Manchester that it was something a bit different there. That was part of what the 90s was. It was very inclusive.
13:49Paddy O'Connell: Whisper it, Terry, for Hadley and me, the 90s was about more than Manchester. Hadley, what was it like living in the moment? What was it like not having your phone, not having your photograph taken, not having to pay£9 for a pint? It felt incredibly, in retrospect, innocent. And I remember my weekends as a school kid would be about going to Tower Records, going to Our Price, going to HMV, just going down the high street, Kukai, River Island, and everyone just trying on clothes. And there was a lack of self-consciousness. You know, obviously girls were interested in clothes. We all shopped at these shops, but we weren't all taking photos of ourselves all the time.
14:27We had no real sense of what we looked like, which is why when I look back on 90s clothes, we all looked kind of a mess. You know, we were wearing dresses over jeans, slip dresses that didn't really fit right, over plucking our eyebrows. I mean, it looked completely ridiculous. We were just throwing things on because that's what we saw someone on top of the pops wearing that week and went out.
14:48Paddy O'Connell: Did you feel optimistic? Yeah, it was a time of enormous optimism politically, definitely. You know, I look back and think, OK, so I'm American-British. There was Clinton in the White House. Now, of course, Clinton had his scandals, but he was someone who seemed exciting and young, interested in music. And then in the latter half of the decade, you get Tony Blair, who also seems interesting, young, exciting. And of course, there were things like the Northern Irish Peace Agreement, attempts between Yitzhak Rabin and Arafat. There was a sense that maybe peace could come to the world. It was supposed to be the end of history, as they famously said at the time.
15:20You know, the 90s was also before housing became out of reach for most young people in this country. So there was the sense that your adulthood was waiting for you. We didn't have 26-year-olds still living with their parents back then.
15:33Paddy O'Connell: Do you think, Terry, we had a better sense of who we were in the 90s? It's very polarised now, very angry. I can live in a silo. Absolutely. There was less pressure to turn yourself into a brand. there was more space to find yourself through other people, that kind of sense of inclusivity and fun. I suppose it was optimism, it was more possibilities, because once upon a time, I would have had no chance of getting on national radio, never mind national TV back then, but suddenly that whole 90s thing switched up a gear. The idea of the word is to create the madness and the chaos of a night out and bring it into your dressing room.
16:14Paddy O'Connell: And Hadley, what about women in the 90s? It was said by the Times reviewing this exhibition at the Tate Britain, the women were allowed in if they behaved more outrageously than the men. There was a sort of, it was very looks driven, there was heroin chic, there was ladette culture. Do you remember this being a great high mark for equality in the 90s? I don't know if that's fair to say. I felt that there were a lot more very cool, outspoken women singers around then. But yes, there was definitely this return to heroin chic. Kate Moss was the big model instead of the supermodels from the era before.
16:50so suddenly skinniness was a thing again for women and my theory is that whenever feminism is on the ascent or women's equality is on the ascent suddenly the fashion industry or some industry will start endorsing extreme skinniness in a way to kind of push women back down so that in the 1920s and the same in the 1990s.
17:09Paddy O'Connell: Tracey Emin for instance has said she regrets the outlandish behavior of her life I wish I'd spent less time drinking and smoking and partying and wish I'd painted more. Was the 90s just also people, a lot of people behaving very badly, Terry? Yeah, I mean, obviously, I was always a drinker. That was my thing. And maybe it's that cultural thing, you know, and I sometimes go, oh, my God, where did I put it all? And yes, there was that part of it, you know, the inappropriateness of the drinking. But I never got into that whole loaded culture, which I thought was very odd. You know, being a working class kid, they were always asking me to go in it.
17:47I never even did an interview with Loaded. I actually said to James Brown, you know, the editor at the time, I said, instead of your logo being for men who should know better, it should be for men who should get a girlfriend
17:59Paddy O'Connell: and stop living at home with their mums. So what do we take from the 90s and give to ourselves now? A return as much as possible to the analogue era. That's what makes the 90s look so fantastic in retrospect. I mean, just look at how we consume music now. We only listen to the single that's released. Back then, you would just buy the whole album. You would put up with the rubbish songs on it. Now it's just, it's the greatest hits culture is what we do. And we're all told what to do. You know, this is the cool thing to do. Everyone has to go to Glastonbury. Everyone has to see this movie. Everyone has to do this.
18:33There's none of that kind of spontaneity, just finding things, wandering around, because everything costs so much. So you don't want to, you know, risk spending 100 quid to see something that's rubbish.
18:43Paddy O'Connell: So the 60s means something to everyone. It's a shorthand, the 70s also. Is the 90s yet a shorthand? Is this exhibition going to educate people about the 90s or reinforce things that we already think, Terry? I'm very cynical about exhibitions. I'm cynical about London trying to sequestrate all the culture. Well, I think the 90s, obviously, kids are still listening to a lot of the bands from there, whether it's Nirvana, whether it's Oasis. There's an excitement about that stuff. it now gets referenced a lot and I suppose that's how culture works and I think now, you know, with the 90s it's people don't just miss being young they miss that feeling that the future might be better it felt like the door was being pushed open a bit it felt like everything was still ahead of us Terry Christian and Hadley Freeman we'd like to know from you you've heard Hadley say things cost a lot more do you have a concert ticket price for us from the 90s?
19:42Paddy O'Connell: do send it. And a play out will give you a choice between two tracks famous from the 90s. Will it be the Spice Girls with their debut single?
20:05Paddy O'Connell: Released on the 26th of June 1996, Wannabe is the best selling debut single by a girl group in history? That's the Spice Girls. Or will it be Common People, released in May 1995? She came from Greece, she had a thirst for knowledge. She studied sculpture at St Martin's College. That's where I, got her eye. Pulp's single, it was the lead single from the fifth studio album, it reached number two in the singles charts, but later Radio 6 music listeners and Rolling Stone readers voted it their favourite and the greatest Brit pop song ever. And on ticket prices, Glastonbury 2027 tickets are on sale for the first time they've breached the 400 mark and it cost just£1 back in 1970.
20:56Paddy O'Connell: Johnny Darm, do you remember the 90s? I do. Well, if you can remember them, you weren't there or something like that. No, I do. Yeah, I do. And I was grinning through your fabulous montage and I'm sapping my foot to pulp. I'm always aware of this risk that, oh, it's the best decade ever, say people who were young during that decade. Other decades are available. Because Tina Ritchie, who was also there in the 90s, was saying, is it old people wanging on, carving on? Yes, it is. Is it? Could it be? Although, I mean, it's 90s stuff, happy to my bones listening to that montage. Happy to my bones. If we have made Tina Ritchie happy, we can all retire.
21:34Paddy O'Connell: Absolutely. No, no, job done, job done. Gentlemen, thank you. In the nearer future, we ask what on earth has been going on near the US base known as RAF Fairford? And Geoffrey Archer is in our corridor looking at our stale pastries. He's here because he's going to give up being a novelist. And our reviewers include the very much productive novelist Anne Cleaves, Simeon Brown and Isabel Hardman, the journalists. It's Sunday 4th October. It's BBC Radio 4's Broadcasting House. Villagers living near RAFF say they've been left shaken by conflicting information surrounding the security swoop last weekend.
22:14Paddy O'Connell: The base has been used by US bombers striking Iran and a sudden series of events unfolded last weekend as more than 80 homes were evacuated. It's seven short days since police investigated vans arriving in the middle of the night and checked for explosives. Here's a reminder. Hello, at nine o 'clock, this is BH Broadcasting House. Several men have been arrested on suspicion of explosives offences near an RAF base in Gloucestershire, which is used by the US Air Force. Five people have been arrested on suspicion of terrorism offences. We had them under view for a long time and we got them. Thank you.
22:48I am absolutely staggered that it was left to me, as a member of the public, to see and report this. I would also just say respectfully that she has a partial picture. Counter-terrorism policing say the five men arrested are all UK nationals. All five men who were arrested have now been allowed to walk free. There are strong indications that Iran played a part in what happened over the weekend.
23:15Paddy O'Connell: One of the five men arrested had called the police himself. Tristan Wilkinson represents the area on Cotswold District Council and drove me around the base. I'm looking straight down the runway and it is about yards from someone's front garden it's a very unusual perspective especially for the householder going past a police vehicle there that's parked with its lights on and as we drive now past the nearest point of the road bends there are three people dressed in hoodies and jeans and backpacks 200 yards from three of the aircraft they're there with binoculars, they're there with cameras they are presumably innocent plane spotters but now I suppose everyone looks at everyone in a different way.
24:03That's one of the consequences of this is do you know who's around? We do get a lot of plane spotters here. When this particular conflict started we were inundated because there's some quite rare aircraft taking off from here. We don't want to deter visitors. This is a holiday destination after all but we also need to make sure that people feel safe.
24:26Paddy O'Connell: I'm just going through the hedge to stand at the perimeter fence. Ministry of Defence, this is a prohibited place within the meaning of the Official Secrets Act. Unauthorised persons entering the area may be arrested and prosecuted. Well, I haven't entered the area, but I'm standing at the seven-foot-high, eight-foot-high barbed wire-topped fence, and there is a B-1 bomber 200 yards away from me. Can I ask, what's your dog's name, most importantly? That's Buster. I mean, it's very rural. Do you love it here? I do. It's beautiful, nice and quiet, yes, normally. We've only personally moved in a year ago, and it was very quiet at that time, and then when it was March time or something, when all this happened, it suddenly started getting very busy.
25:11Personally, we didn't mind it. We quite enjoy the planes. We often go to the air show every year.
25:16Paddy O'Connell: What kind of noise do the big American bombers make? Very noisy. As you can see, they've got four jet engines, so the sound, you can hear them a few minutes before they take off, you know, it's horrendous. RAF Fairford has a long tradition and a crucial role in aviation. It was a D-Day post, also it's used as the test flights for Concorde and I've learnt today that it was also a potential emergency runway at one of the longest in Europe for any emergencies on the space shuttle. So the American presence has been very well known in peacetime, but now these bombers that are based here have been used to bomb Iran.
25:56Paddy O'Connell: And as we were driving to the base, we passed a petrol station showing diesel at£2.02. And around the country, people know that's an Iran impact. But here, in these quiet streets, they've had another potential impact from the Iran war, which is what is the motive for people pulling up in vans and what is the response of the authorities. So we are just driving into the outskirts of Welford and on Sunday this is where the cordon started. So it started on the day of the arrest. Everything was moving very quickly then? It was. I think we literally went from some people being woken up to the rest of us kind of waking up to the news of what was happening and by the end of the day the world's media had descended.
26:37I do think that one of the lessons to be learnt from this is that we need a clear, authoritative voice that is able to communicate particularly to the local community, many of whom are kind of digitally excluded and maybe don't have access to some of the digital channels and are getting their news from kind of friends, family and the broadcast media. So I think that clarity of an authoritative voice is something that we need more of. We've been a little bit on edge since the war started in March because there's been threats towards the base since then and there's been really heightened, noisy activity.
27:12I've got my head in the sand. I don't want to think about it. I'm back to normal. I'm going back to yoga. I'm back to walking the dog. There's nothing really I can do. I can't suddenly move house for six months. I haven't got bulletproof glass or anything like that. What will be will be. But it is unsettling when you think about it, and I think a lot of people have concerns. I think quite a few people are in a worse position than me. Those with young children who got very upset by it are still having to settle them down.
27:35Paddy O'Connell: And if we imagine that there are multiple agencies all working as hard as they can, and the local councillor saying he thinks there could be better coordination. We're not being critical, but is that something you would recognise? That would be very, very helpful, because one of the things that we heard was that we were finding stuff out from the press two hours before we could go home, so there was no central communication. Obviously, people wanted to keep speculation to a minimum, so couldn't give out an awful lot of information, but there was such politicking and holding things back, it did feel that we were the last people to know.
28:10Paddy O'Connell: now there goes a agricultural land rover just past the spot where the vans that we've all seen and read about and heard about have been uh stopped that's the white vans i'm just going to see the gentleman leaning on his gate i thought it was quite amazing how quickly it all swung into place and the rugby club or the football club up at fairford it has got ambulances and fire engines there's a unit somewhere close that will come and sort this sort of thing out. We woke up at six o 'clock, lights everywhere, police everywhere, hammering on the door, came downstairs, opened the door in my nightdress.
28:50They said, you've got to get out now, as soon as possible. So we did. We fed the chickens, we fed the cat, picked up the dog, got as far as Fairford, forgot my insulin, and they let us back. And that was it.
29:08Paddy O'Connell: You've lived here for nearly 50 years, you told me. Yes. And do you love it? Do you feel that things are safe here? There's a bit of a bump in the road and all will be well in the end. Well, we're pretty ancient, so it doesn't really matter, you know, to us. I feel sorry for the young people and people who've just bought houses here. We've never had anything like this before. And, you know... Hopefully we won't have another one. We won't have another one. No. Basically, if you had a message to tell the world about what you'd like to happen, because you've kindly spoken to me, what would that be?
29:43It'd be nice if the bombers weren't here, because we'd probably be able to sell our house and downsize, which we ought to do. They've got to be somewhere. We've got to have a defence in some form, whether it's our own or Americans. They don't disturb us too much. We get a couple of flights a day, which are very noisy. Very noisy and very smelly. Well, they can be, yes. But we put up with that because we live here.
30:05Paddy O'Connell: I'm about to leave and I've come back to the spot where those vans were pictured. And you do have to ask yourself, what were they doing in this location opposite the village hall? Do we know? No. Is that part of the problem here? Yes. with thanks to the villagers and the councillor around RAF Fairford. With more news to come, I'm quite sure, on that. The novelist Geoffrey Archer is hanging up his pen, publishing his final novel. Lord Archer sold 300 million books in more than 100 countries. He's achieved bestsellers in fiction, short stories and non-fiction. Knowing when to stop is a plot line for all of us.
30:52Paddy O'Connell: Recently, Peter Hennessy told us he'd stop broadcasting. Rod Stewart said he'd stop touring. and now Geoffrey Archer is going to make this new title, Adam and Eve, his last. And here he is. Good morning, Paddy. Is it sad? Well, I'm 86 years old. Are you? And I feel, in all truth, I think it's the best book I've ever, Adam and Eve is the best book I've ever written. But you will be told that every author believes their last book is the best book they've ever written. But then the crits have been very kind as well. But what does it mean to you as someone who's enjoyed writing to decide to stop publishing?
31:31What does it mean to you? Ah, not publishing, Paddy. I will still write short stories. I hope I write a play, even a screenplay. It's the final novel. It means that the agony of, and it's wonderful at one point, fun, but I won't be doing 150 ,000 words again. Those days are over. and I'm not unhappy about that.
31:57Paddy O'Connell: And when a person decides to stop doing something, is that a sign of living or is it a sign of giving up? I am certainly not giving up. That is not my style. I shall go on working night and day. I'll do my charity auctions, I'll do lots of other things and I will write short stories and possibly a novella. Adam and Eve is about two children born on Armstice Day in 1918. Can you give me a synopsis of Adam and Eve? November the 11th, these two children are born. But the first idea came, I was reading a history book and came across the fact that on September the 15th, Hitler changed his mind three times.
32:44And I wondered what would have happened if he changed his mind twice and attempted to invade the British Isles. Then, six months later, got this idea of an earl desperate to have a son so that he could inherit the title and the estate. And a shepherd on the estate, desperate to have a daughter because he feared any boy would end up going to war. The earl gets a daughter. The shepherd gets a son, Adam and Eve. So I've got the two ideas. Then comes the problem. How do I make Adam and Eve be responsible for making Hitler change his mind a third time? And listening is Anne Cleves, who we're about to meet.
33:37Paddy O'Connell: A distinguished author. And to say the least, do you understand Geoffrey talking about giving up this thing that he loves? Well, not yet, because I love it too. And I can't imagine getting up in the morning and thinking, what am I going to do today? Because at the moment I get up very early. I listen to the shipping forecast. I drink lots of tea and I sit at my kitchen table and I make stuff up. And I can't imagine not doing that. And I'm not going to stop working. I get up at 5.30 every morning. I do six to eight. So I'm like you. I'm a lark, not an owl. My wife is an owl. So I am a lark and I will continue.
34:15I woke this morning at ten past five and that won't change. OK. We're lucky to have you here on this day with the courts in the news.
34:25Paddy O'Connell: And I wonder, you know, you've reflected on your life, but also on being in prison. And with the early release going on, we want you to listen to what some prisoners have said this week about being let out of prison. Let's just have a listen to what people have been saying. People who are dangerous, they're now trying to crumb people in with them, who should have a single cell, because they're overcrowded. They'll lock you up for 23, 22, 23 hours a day. Really? Yeah. Is it overcrowded in there? Yeah, bad. Really bad. Everyone's having to share souls. They shouldn't be sharing souls in that. They're full of cockroaches, rats.
34:58Paddy O'Connell: Yeah, it's disgusting in there. It's filthy. Do you have sympathy with prisoners? Sorry? Do you have sympathy with prisoners? Well, they fall into so many different categories. I don't have with rapists, murderers, and no, I don't. and I was shocked at the decision to let people out early. They'll either have to build more prisons or we're going to have a massive problem. What did it do to you? In what sense? Being inside. Well, it was 25 years ago, Paddy, so I can't pretend it was yesterday morning and since then I've written 20 books and done a lot of charity work, so it's a long time ago. But did it change you?
35:41Well, certainly the privilege of meeting lots of interesting people, dare I put it that way, meant that I had wonderful plots for books. Yes. What did you learn about the public, people in Britain? Oh, well, I was told that when I came out, no one would buy any of my books, and the book sales went up and up. So I learned that. Are we forgiving? Are we forgiving people? Oh, the British are, tremendously so. And the British like people to fight back. It's a very British trait.
36:16Paddy O'Connell: Geoffrey Archer, thank you very much for coming to meet us. Not at all, Paddy. Very nice to meet you, and we hope to see you again. Yes, please. Thank you very much. Well, listening very patiently along with us is Simeon Brown, Home Affairs Correspondent for Channel 4 News. He's published The Good, The Black and The Boogey, exploring Britain's black middle class. And he's asked thousands of black professionals 200 questions. Simon, that's a lot of work. It's a lot of work. You're telling me. You were asked one of the best questions I've ever heard anyone ask. I was looking at deep feedback with Elijah on YouTube.
36:52Paddy O'Connell: And he said to you, what did you find that you weren't looking for? What a great question. What's the answer? I mean, to be honest with you, I asked so many questions that there were so many things that were interesting in there. So, for example, 72 % of black professionals were considering sending their children to private schools. And one in four of those who were in the emerging black middle class, their parents had or their mother had done care work, for example. So it spoke to the extent to the mobility that they had had in their own life, their family had had. So I think that there was so much interesting findings.
37:28We think of the black experience in this country as being primarily a working class experience. but what we see through the black middle class is how class itself has changed but also how the texture of black life is far broader than the public imagination I guess expresses it to be if we think about the kind of media and films and things that we see. So the good, the black and the bougie was an attempt to really try and unpick both the black experience but also what class means today in modern Britain.
38:01Paddy O'Connell: I love a chat about class no matter what else happens on Radio 4 I'm looking forward to what your picks are today Anne Cleaves, as I've mentioned, is the author of 40 critically acclaimed novels Her Vera Stanhope books were adapted by ITV starring Brenda Blathen Her latest novel in the Matthew Venn series is The Dying Light and welcome properly welcome to you Well thanks very much Paddy, it's lovely to be here Do you know what your end will be when you pick up your pen or your typewriter key? Not at all, no. I think because for the first 20 years of being published, I had no commercial success at all.
38:36It had to be fun and writing was like reading. It was an escape. It was getting into a different world. And if I'd known how the book was going to end, there would be no fun in it at all. Wow.
38:49Paddy O'Connell: And Isabel Hardman is assistant editor of The Spectator. And where are you, Isabel? Where in the world are you? I'm in Glasgow. Ah, good. Well, we need to start with you then, out of politeness. You're the one who's not here. Tell us where to start from the news agenda today. Well, I'm on page six of the Sunday Times. It's Ben Reilly-Smith writing about Kemi Baden-Ock's blueprint for Britain. He writes that the party has prepared a manifesto in the case of an early election. This is setting out Baden-Ock's views on the economy, energy, government. it's called The Right Way and is an echo of Margaret Thatcher's 1976 The Right Approach and he asks her is this Baden-Ockism which is quite a clunky term and she replies saying chemistry is what I call it With a K Chemistry, yes So government, she quoted as saying that since Brexit and Covid the size of the civil service has swollen by over a third is government working a third better for you?
39:53Paddy O'Connell: I don't think so Is that a good place to understand chemistry? Yeah, I think that probably is. And the idea of the quite weak institutions but a bloated state at the same time is something she refers to a lot. They're obviously going into their conference today. I'm not going actually because I'm finishing a book at the moment. But I think the state of the country that she's looking at and having to respond to is in part, and we've been talking about prisons, it's in part a response to things that the Tories didn't get done during their time in government. So it's very difficult for the Conservatives to move forward.
40:36Paddy O'Connell: Exactly. Simeon Brown, Kemi Badenoch, a big figure in British public life and getting stronger? Yeah, I mean, I certainly thought that whoever coined chemistry might deserve a pay rise. I thought that was cool. I mean, I look at the black political class and in the good, the black and the bougie. And Kemi Baden-Ock obviously has become a huge figure, although obviously, of course, she transcends black politics. But I think that she has managed to create a great deal of conversation. I think that she seems to be performing well at the dispatch box. and if you put her politics to the side, I think that she seems more confident.
41:20I think that people have a lot of goodwill towards her in the parts of the press that she's speaking to and yeah, I mean, she certainly seems to have moved her party away from some of the existential challenges that were dominating.
41:35Paddy O'Connell: I mean, when she started, people thought she was so bad. She was working for the Labour Party, I seem to remember. Anne Cleaves, that can be very not... Let's move on from her to a policy from her, which is in the Sunday Telegraph. What is the planned policy announcement? Yeah, I was interested in this because she's decided that if you earn over£100 ,000, you can't afford to pay for childcare. So she's going to scrap that cliff edge. So even if two of you earn£100 ,000, you still won't. You still will have to pay for childcare. You won't have to pay for childcare. I was interested in that, but more interested, I think, in the fact that she said she would pay for that by sacking staff in Arts Council England and in English Nature.
42:25I'm obviously biased, but I think that the creative industries bring so much money into this country that she hasn't actually thought that policy through very clearly. For instance, you mentioned Vera. that show sold to more than 200 territories around the world and that's brought in income but it's also brought in tourism the show Vera, and I wrote the books for that has increased tourism in Shetland by 46 % and at a time of climate emergency to think it's a good plan to get rid of the people the skilled experts in English nature who are helping farmers, helping the rest of us to look at how to build sustainable environment and landscape.
43:10That is important.
43:11Paddy O'Connell: Can I break apart some of what you're telling us and go back to the starting point, which is the cliff edge of childcare? And Simeon and Isabel, this business of some people put off a promotion and earning more money because they're going to lose free childcare, it's a very big political issue, Simeon. Can you see what the underlying trigger is for the Conservatives in announcing a policy change? Yeah, I mean, I'm interested in the moment more broadly around ultimately some of the big challenges around earnings and around what you are able to do as a young worker in this country. So at that end, right, what we're seeing is that it is very expensive now to buy property.
43:57It's very expensive to do childcare. There is a huge delay of adulthood that is taking place. And so I think that the policy that I was more interested in, actually, was the response to the fact that if you look at professional work that has been eaten up at the entry level, AI is eating up those jobs. And yet the response that I had seen in the papers from the Conservative Party, they were talking about the increase in welfare being claimed by young people. And I thought that there was a very much a kind of tension in which we see young people who are struggling to get their first foot on the job ladder.
44:39They are facing existential threat from artificial intelligence. And there doesn't seem to be a actual strong policy response from the major parties.
44:48Paddy O'Connell: And Isabel, this juggling of resources, is it how much of a political win is it to address the cliff edge at 100 ,000? And where is the money, which is what Siemens asking? Well, I don't know where the money is and I suspect Kemi Badenot doesn't either. But yeah, I mean, I think it is important to look at things in the round. My sort of concern about when you're targeting higher earners is you end up in quite a sort of transactional politics where you want to be offering them something for free that they could probably still afford themselves. I think with Cliff Edge on childcare, I think that is important because you do, you know, you want women to be able to return to senior positions and for childcare not to be a barrier to that.
45:29Because otherwise you end up with a workforce where women are ahead until they have a child and then they start to disappear from the workplace. And that's not desirable.
45:38Paddy O'Connell: So there's a lot going on here, many issues that we hear from listeners about all the time. But if I go back to where you started about how your books have increased tourism in Northumberland and Shetland, can you tell me a beautiful place in Northumberland or Shetland? Don't spoil it, but what's the appeal of a beautiful place? Name one. Fair Isle in Shetland. Fair Isle is the island that I first went to. I dropped out of university and I went there to be. And it was interesting hearing what Simeon said. It was you could drop out of university and know that you would get a job when I left. and I could have worked in a bar or I could have worked actually in childcare but in fact I decided that this was an adventure and I was offered a job as assistant cook in the bird observatory in Fair Isle.
46:24Couldn't cook, didn't know anything about birds but went and loved it and it's still one of my favourite places and I go back. Northumberland there are so many beautiful places and I'm going to say one of the coastal towns just because I want everyone to go to the coast and leave the inland free for me to walk and not meet anybody.
46:46Paddy O'Connell: I think the question of Northumberland's beautiful beaches deserves its own radio programme. Absolutely. So that's a conversation linked really from the Sunday Telegraph's coverage of what happens to childcare benefits when Bonnerno reaches£100 ,000 and we also talked about tourism and politics. Simien, move us along, if you will, celebrating the BBC show that changed black British comedy. Which was that? Of course, it's the real McCoy celebrating its 35th anniversary this year. And the reason why there was a piece in Black Current News, which is founded by the Dean White, Big Up the Dean White, and the reason why I liked the piece was that it really highlighted how much black British history is in the archives of public service broadcasters like the BBC.
47:37ITV, Channel 4 and how entwined black British history is into this country obviously as somebody who's written a book on it it was something that I was deeply connected and invested in and it would just be so brilliant if those archives could just be mined so that we can bring some of these things out. The Real McCoy is actually on iPlayer at the moment but there are so many others that have almost been lost and I think we need to is just kind of re-engage with the work that is being produced that shows you a different side to our kind of national story.
48:12Paddy O'Connell: And it sort of mocked stereotypes, but also it mocked generations within black culture, didn't it? It was kind of, I suppose it could be seen as colourless in a way because it was also about generations. Yeah, yeah, yeah, of course, of course. So I suppose that's the sort of liberating part of it. It's got to be seen as funny and in-round, hasn't it? Yeah, the Royal McCoy was funny. It was ahead of its time. it was playing, or rather it was you doing that thing that only comedy can really do. It was kind of scrutinising and bringing truth to all kinds of relations, both racial, both related to generations, to gender, to what it is to be in a city.
48:46And I like that it kind of, it would, today something like that might be seen as woke just because it happens to be different, when in reality we're just bringing a new lens and new flavour to Britain.
48:57Paddy O'Connell: And you've mentioned a title that's new to me. Where does this come from, this celebration of this? What's the name of the site? Oh, what the... Where did the story come from? Oh, from Black Current News. So Black Current News is a publication set up by a very well-known journalist called Nadine White. And it's the first mention of it here. Really? You win a prize. What do I win? You win this teacup. You're listening to the news review of Simien Brown, Anne Cleaves, and in Glasgow, Isabel Hardman, who's got the Herald. Edinburgh's banned loud music on its buses, Isabel. Oh, this is so great. This is fantastic.
49:33It's a column by Derek MacArthur looking at whether this should be a nationwide ban. And it is, I mean, it is really annoying. It's one of those things that, you know, if I was prime minister for a day, I'd probably want to ban first before getting onto the great matters of state. Because you sit on a train and somebody thinks that their music is better than anything else anyone else could possibly be consuming. It also reminded me of one of the few quick thinking moments in my entire life where I was on. This is when I lived in England. There was a fellow next to me playing some very loud music from his phone and I asked him to turn it off.
50:07And he said no. And I said, well, in that case, I'm going to read from my newspaper. And I opened my newspaper up and started reading about David Cameron's Europe policy. He turned it off pretty quickly at that point. And it was a very satisfying moment. but you can't do that to everyone and I think there's a certain type of person he definitely wouldn't want to do it to. Yeah, and nobody seems to wear headphones anymore. No. Wherever you go, there are people playing videos or they're playing music and you just, I do want to just wander around with a bag full of headphones and tell them to put them in.
50:43That's very giving of you. Yeah, you know what, I mean, I'm someone who does wear headphones. Good. But you could say on the other side of it, one of the big things that we've lost is a sharing of popular culture. So because everyone has their own algorithm and they have their own kind of content, we no longer all watch the same thing on the BBC unless it's traitors. So maybe we need to be all leaning in when someone's playing some weird video. We need to say, oh, what are you watching? And I'm afraid Anne is shaking her head. No, because everybody is playing things. No, I know, I know. You get hit from all sides.
51:16So maybe you just want to read a book. Bring back dignity.
51:18Paddy O'Connell: We need that back. Listeners have been writing to us this morning about ticket prices. I suppose it's linked to what you're saying about a shared culture. Joe saw Radiohead for £12.50. Andy saw Oasis for£7.50 in 1994. Rupert saw them for £3 in Bristol. In 1997, Ashley spent £27.50 to see them in Exeter. Rich saw Green Day, the Red Hot Chili Peppers, Foo Fighters and Rage Against the Machine for less than £13. Will saw Tina Turner in Birmingham for£30. Hannah went for a post-A-level Glastonbury trip for£40 in 1992. But Isabel and Simeon, both of you, was it easier in the 90s to share the same culture than it is now?
51:58I wasn't very cool in the 90s, so I have absolutely no idea. But I'm not going to disclose how much I recently spent on Harry Styles tickets because it definitely wasn't£13. I mean, I would say I remember more the early 2000s. And I think that certainly I recall popular culture was way more of a thing. People were all consuming the same ideas and it felt that there was way more of a connection. Now we're way more fragmented.
52:23Paddy O'Connell: Thank you very much indeed all for telling us the papers. And this is the winner of today's play out. Today's producers were Isabel Gough and Natasha Mayo. Studio direction for Gabriel O 'Regan. The editor was Louisa Service. BH listeners voted for Pulp.
52:55Is Facebook dying? I'm Tristan Redmond, host of the Global Story podcast from the BBC. More than 15 years after The Social Network, a new movie on the inner workings of Facebook hit cinemas in October. The journalist who's reporting inspired the film tells us why Facebook stopped being cool and whether Meta, its parent company, can reinvent itself. For more, listen to The Global Story on bbc.com or wherever you get your pods.
The Sunday morning news magazine programme. Presented by Paddy O'Connell