1. Podcasts
  2. Creative Capes
  3. Pentagram's Paula Scher on luck, power, partners, criticism
Creative Capes

12 Nov 2026 · 1h 27m · 31 chapters

Episode artwork

Pentagram's Paula Scher on luck, power, partners, criticism

In short

Paula Scher (Pentagram partner) discusses luck vs effort in creative careers, how designers build power through access to “work,” why growth requires failure, and how criticism can be either useful or negative. She also explains branding/graphic design differences, her approach to typography, and the long life of identities.

Guest backgrounds

Paula Scher is an influential graphic designer and partner at Pentagram. She previously worked in advertising and record-industry promotion/art direction, designing record covers and promotional materials, and later co-founded/led major identity work including the Public Theater program. She’s known for typography-driven identities and for work that becomes recognizable over decades.

Key claims

“Work makes work” when clients trust and like you; success requires applying talent to the right opportunities. Designers must grow by failing and keep doing their work despite negativity. Confidence comes from persistence and having at least one supporter, plus experience working in high-pressure industries. Communities matter, but modern competition and fewer physical gatherings have weakened them.

Notable examples

Public Theater identity system (annual “manual” poster), the Citibank logo story (lowercase “t” umbrella metaphor), her early Pentagram backlash over typographic weights, and career pivots from a children’s book (“The Brownstone”) to Random House, then CBS Records, then freelancing and her firm with Terry Coppell.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

0:00

The Nature of Work and Trust

Learn about the significance of trust in professional relationships and success.

“If you work for people and they like you and they trust you, you will get more of it.”
1:16

Exploring the Pentagram Workspace

Discover the creative atmosphere and structure of the Pentagram office.

“Where guests arrive, the elevator comes up to the top floor.”
3:08

Food and Creativity Connection

Learn how the Pentagram office promotes creativity through shared meals.

“So they'd be traveling around and then, you know, they'd come back late and they didn't start the work.”
3:56

The Importance of Branding in Design

Explore the distinctions between branding in advertising and graphic design.

“There's a different meal, Monday through Thursday, generally.”
9:26

Personal Experiences and Networking

Hear a story about the serendipitous networking that can shape a design career.

“It's been mostly like seven is the biggest.”
11:14

Paula's Interview Journey with Seymour

Listen to Paula's early career challenges and a pivotal interview with Seymour.

“So you also have lots of stories of how you met people.”
14:04

Meeting Seymour Quast

Paula shares her experience of meeting her design hero and the impact it had on her career.

“a big portfolio i said yeah he says well what were you doing and i told him that i was going to meet my hero, and I missed the meeting because the train was late.”
18:11

The Accidental Children's Book

Paula narrates how she accidentally wrote and published her only children's book, highlighting unexpected career turns.

“It's not, I mean, some of it is your, I hate to say the word talent, you know, because what is talent?”
22:30

From Children's Books to CBS

Paula discusses her transition from children's book design to the record industry, emphasizing the role of chance in her career.

“His name was Herb Levitt, and he was getting a big job at Ogilvy, which is a big agency in New York, and he was taking it, but he said that there wasn't a position for me.”
24:29

Developing the Public Theater Identity

Paula elaborates on creating the Public Theater identity and its evolution over time, showcasing her creative process.

“And I'm actually still in touch with them, which is nice.”
Show all 31 chapters
27:49

Overcoming Criticism at Pentagram

Paula recounts the initial backlash she faced from partners at Pentagram regarding her design choices for the Public Theater.

“And they disliked the public logo because I made everything a different weight, you know, like a different thick and thin thing.”
28:08

Facing Criticism and Finding Confidence

Paula Scher reflects on early criticism in her career and her confidence in defending her work.

“And they thought I created typographic blasphemy.”
29:18

Childhood Challenges and Toughness

Scher discusses her turbulent childhood and its influence on her confidence and resilience.

“and actually defend, like, obviously you knew it's a great piece of work, but it's sometimes very hard where people who may be more influential or have more weight than you suddenly say that.”
31:26

The Importance of Support

Exploring the role of supportive figures in Scher's life and how they shaped her journey.

“right and i don't know if that is true for everyone but i personally find that you need to have at least one person who believes in you there might be the rest of the world that says you're nothing.”
34:00

Luck vs. Hard Work in Career Success

Scher shares her views on the interplay between luck and effort in achieving career milestones.

“You know, like you can't be heard by somebody's negativity.”
36:58

Building a Design Career from Scratch

Paula Scher recounts her transition from the music industry to establishing her own design business.

“You know, like I just don't think about them.”
38:47

Networking and Community in Design

Scher highlights the importance of networking and community engagement in building her design reputation.

“and power to be able to get it through, and that those were always the ingredients.”
42:00

The Evolution of Design Communities

Explore how design communities have changed over the years and the impact on relationships.

“The Swatch Watch poster came that way, you know, because they were appealing to, like, what they thought was a hipster audience when we were doing those things.”
45:33

The Importance of Local Communities

Discuss the significance of local connections in the design industry and the shift in culture.

“That's definitely our mission as Futureland Academy is to connect creative communities around the world and give them knowledge and inspiration to make the world better.”
47:40

Changing Dynamics in the Design Industry

Understand the competition and challenges within the modern design landscape.

“And I remember a much more open series of conversations with people who I didn't even think of as competitors.”
51:51

The Longevity of Visual Identities

Learn what contributes to the durability of visual identities in branding.

“What's the average time one of your visual identities last?”
56:00

Controversy Over Plagiarism and Creative Integrity

Explore Paula Scher's experience with accusations of plagiarism and her reflections on artistic integrity.

“And she says, since we got Swatch, the kids are never late for school and their grades are better too.”
1:01:02

Maintaining Creative Motivation in Design

Paula Scher discusses her ongoing motivation for hands-on work in design and the balance between different types of projects.

“So how did you find that motivation and curiosity throughout decades of your career?”
1:06:40

The Role of Side Projects in Creativity

Scher emphasizes the importance of side projects for maintaining creativity and finding personal fulfillment beyond commercial work.

“And my paintings I sell, and sometimes they actually do well when I have shows.”
1:10:03

Creative Flow and Painting

Learn how bad weather and boredom can fuel creativity and productivity.

“You know, it was the same thing over and over and over again.”
1:12:21

Fashion as a Creative Outlet

Understand the impact of fashion on self-presentation and creativity.

“It's really, totally, that'll push you forward.”
1:14:23

Navigating Midlife Creativity

Explore strategies to maintain creativity and passion at midlife.

“of your career and future and what you're excited about.”
1:18:22

The Importance of Proactivity in Design

Discover how taking initiative can lead to memorable design work.

“And the writing stuff is very funny, very personal, and very terse.”
1:22:05

Final Thoughts and Political Views

Reflect on a creative career and the need for political change.

“I feel like this is a lovely way to wrap up our conversation about definitely not sitting and waiting for opportunities to happen, but actually being proactive.”
1:24:00

Reflecting on Paula Scher's Impact

Learn about the profound influence Paula Scher has had on design and creativity.

“I don't care where he lands, just not in the United States.”
1:25:14

Listener Engagement and Feedback

Discover the importance of listener feedback and community interaction.

“Anything you want to say, last words, anything people should check out, go see?”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On Creative Capes, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:01Work makes work. If you work for people and they like you and they trust you, you will get more of it. If they don't like you and they don't trust you, you won't get more of it. I worked with Mick Jagger. I worked with Billy Joel. I worked with Bruce Springsteen. I worked with people who were tougher than these guys. These were just like a bunch of graphic designers, you know. Success comes from the ability to apply the talent. And to be able to apply the talent, you have to have the thing to apply the talent on.

0:27Paula Scher: What would you advise anyone in their 40s or 50s to keep doing or stop doing, to keep going? So many designers are performing their things without growth, and that to grow you have to fail. If you want to do something, you just do it. You can't be heard by somebody's negativity. Hi, I'm E. Katerina from Future London Academy, me. And today I'm taking you all the way to New York to meet another iconic person, Paula Scherr. Paula probably does not need an introduction. She is one of the most influential designers in the world. She's partner at Pentagram. And there is even an episode on Netflix in the series called Abstracts About Her.

1:12Paula Scher: This will be a very special and personal conversation for me. I hope you enjoy it.

1:35Where guests arrive, the elevator comes up to the top floor. There's a reception desk, as you can see, in the front. And sometimes it's clients who are coming to meet us. Sometimes it's people trying to sell us something. Sometimes it's students dropping off portfolios. It can be all of those things. And these rooms are conference and meeting rooms. The conference rooms are named for the original partners. So this is Colin Forbes. This is Alan Fletcher. This is Mervyn Kerlansky's over here. That was, I think, Theo Crosby and Kenneth Grange. So those were the founding partners of Pentagram that we all joined.

2:15So if you book the room, you say you're booking Fletcher. And that's, but most of the people who work here don't have any idea. They have no clue who these guys are, don't know what they look like.

2:25Paula Scher: I love that you have kitchens and canteen, same in pentagram in London. And I felt like food and creativity are very much connected. And having food together is a big deal. Actually, food and creativity had nothing to do with each other when this was devised. This was created because somewhere before I joined, maybe eight years before they bought the really big building that they had in Notting Hill, they had moved to a place outside the city to save money. And what they found, because the area was not densely populated, the staff would take an hour and a half for lunch because there weren't any good restaurants around.

3:08So they'd be traveling around and then, you know, they'd come back late and they didn't start the work. So Colin Forbes actually calculated the cost differential between having the staff go out to lunch and what you're paying in terms of the hourly rate against the cost of everybody eating if you hire a cook and pay for the food. And it turned out that hiring the cook and paying for the food was cheaper, which is why that's it. We love this. It's actually a true story, but it worked. Hey, Amy, what's for lunch? This is Amy. She's the cook today. Hi, Amy. Hi. So today we're serving cream of mushroom soup and potato croquettes.

3:50Oh, nice. Okay. Okay. Awesome. I'll see you at lunch. Thank you. So it's every day. There's a different meal, Monday through Thursday, generally. Friday, nobody comes in. This is the new business area, and they help us out, take phone calls, and check us here and come. I'll show you some more work over here. I think these are mostly logos.

4:13Paula Scher: Iconic, iconic logos. Yep, you make a lot of them. City? Yep, still there. Still there, still iconic. I actually love how you talk about the difference between branding coming from advertising and branding coming from graphic design. Yeah, they are different. If you go back to the early days, the talent would either be a very, very strong idea copy person or a very, very strong design person. And when they paired up and there was the strong idea person and the strong copy person, that would be great. Like, for example, Herb Lou Allen would have been the ultimate visual designer, and he was making fonts and things.

4:53And so within, if he was doing identity, the notion was it was so recognizable because it had specific characters that you could identify the product or the service based on the drawing. And if it was somebody like Michael Wolff, sometimes it's just the words. So having worked with him, it was great for me because he did really all the narrative about how there was this 12-year-old girl who was going to be in her 20s and she didn't understand banking and they had to do the thing and they had to do a whole line of bullshit. It was wonderful bullshit. And then I could just design a logo because we had done all that work It had nothing to do with anything he said.

5:31It just had to do with the fact that Citibank initially was a merger between the Citicorp and Travelers Insurance. Travelers Insurance had an umbrella. So I had discovered that if I used the lowercase t, I could put an arc over it, and it would be a metaphorical umbrella. And everybody liked it, and everybody bought it based on that. The fact of the matter is that Travelers split up in about two years after this thing was done, and it's 30 years later. And then I had to speak to the people at Citi. I did it like a building-wide Zoom call because it was their anniversary at the logo, and they wanted me to tell the story of it.

6:13And none of them knew that's why it was like that. And I said, well, what do you think it was? And he said, we thought it meant optimism.

6:20Paula Scher: Yeah, we just said, okay, that's good. I heard a different version, but it means connection. Oh, well, that makes sense. somebody has to make up something. But it's great when everyone can find their own meaning in the work, and I think that's beauty of design. Well, the whole point is I think that things become recognizable as time goes by, and they're either connected to a product or a service and recognized on that basis just because they're so connected, or they're just things that you remember because the form is memorable, you know, and you don't really control which way it lands. Okay, so we're going downstairs?

6:56Yes. My team sits right up in the front. They're right up, the first computers up front. And they're all not really related. It's wherever there was a spot, based on whoever came.

7:10Paula Scher: So this is where you spend most of your day? No, I walk around most of the day. I'm back between the team, or I might be talking to a partner, or I might be having a meeting in a bigger room if I need it. I do most of my meetings on Zoom, though and this has been great because i just sort of sit here and and you know i don't have to move around that much which is nice and this is my book collections here and i can put up my own posters and you see them on the screen any book that is the dearest to your heart oh i love them all i'll tell you i think tash and is does an amazing job this is um this is one of their books they're these huge design books and they're just loaded with great things.

7:54This is my book. And mostly these books are on typography. You know, the thing I'm most interested in because I draw a lot of my own type and it becomes, you know, a really important part. See, I love things like the two and the five.

8:14Paula Scher: Oh, yeah, they're beautiful. Well, the thing is, they're the same thing. One's just upside down. But it's still, you know, like, it's just a funny coincidence. I think that kind of work is great. I love doing that stuff. Futurism. That's a fabulous book. It's, you know, Italian futurism. And the work is amazing, really inspiring. I got a lot out of that. What's your favorite period in the design history? Well, futurism is one of them. I would say constructivism and futurism are the most influential. But I like, I don't really respond well to florid work. Pretty work with like zigzags and doodads and flowers sort of.

8:56No interest. I like loud, loud, simple, bold. My team's work is all done here. And we're doing lots of different things now. We have a big presentation this afternoon at 2.30. and it started working hard.

9:16Paula Scher: Yeah. And that's Bruno. He's on my team. It works well with virtually every form of contemporary technology, because I don't. How big is your team? It's five people. There's an architect, I see. And has it always been five? It's been mostly like seven is the biggest. You feel like the best size to do work. Well, I forget their names after that. You know, I know it's the best. I really control my work. I mean, I don't, like, give out projects. It's like I sort of figured it out to a degree before I do it. And then they collaborate against an idea. So it's very good. And it is, they've been with me a long time.

10:05The Woman in the Corner was my student years ago, about 2010. and then she was an intern and I sent her to the public theater to do work in-house because I knew she could do it because she was doing it with me and then I hired her back.

10:22Paula Scher: I have a personal story of how I met you for the first time. So you were launching your book in London and I was working with Michael Wolff so we were spending the whole morning in an B studio where we were working together and I asked him what he's doing in the evening He's like, I'm going for this dinner for the launch of Paula's book. And there was probably something on my face or maybe teary eyes that kind of showed how much I wish I was there. And then he said, you should come with me. You would love Paula. I mean, I obviously loved you already. So he brought me as his plus one to this wonderful dinner.

11:02Paula Scher: And I was sitting between Neville Brody and Michael Wolff. and then he introduced us and you were super sweet. And obviously you had so many people you had to say hello to. And literally, that was one of the best nights of my life. Really? So you also have lots of stories of how you met people. So I would love you to tell a story of the first time you went for an interview with Simo. And how did it go? Well, my teacher at Tyler, Stanislaw Sigorski, had a friend who was in the book business and was an editorial art director and designer. And he knew Seymour. And I went to show the editor my portfolio, and the editor was very nice.

11:51Maybe he was being kind, but he seemed impressed with it. And he asked me if I wanted to meet Seymour Quast. And I thought, oh, my God, the guy's my hero. And it was in January. It was a semester break. And I took a train from Philadelphia to New York with a very big portfolio, which is what you had in those days because there was no nothing was digital. You know, like you actually schlepped these things around. And I was, there were about, I don't know, four or five major stops between Philadelphia and New York City. So the train broke down at the first stop, and we had to get out and change trains.

12:32And I thought, okay, well, the next train, you know, I was so conscious about when I was going to get there to be on time for the meeting that I left super early, and I figured I'll just walk around New York until it's time for the meeting. Well, the train broke down, so I had lost about a half an hour there, but it was okay. I had all this other time. And then I got back on the train again, and the train broke down in a later stop. And then another train came, and that took, I think, about 20 or 30 minutes, so that I was already starting to be at the edge of it. And the last train that I got on just inched, because there was snow and ice.

13:12So it was like inching along into New York, and then it sped up when you got through the tunnel. So I got out, and I think my appointment was something like 3.30, and I'd gotten there at about 5. So I went to Pushpin, and for some reason the place was closed up, which is really odd because they don't close up then. There was some reason that they had done, and I think they were having some work done inside the studio. and i didn't know anything about it and i thought i missed my appointment i'm never going to get another appointment my career is over before it's even started you know like i was really grim and i was sort of sniveling and i got back on the train with a big portfolio i was sniveling and sat next to some guy with a beard and he said uh you look like you're a designer because i had a big portfolio i said yeah he says well what were you doing and i told him that i was going to meet my hero, and I missed the meeting because the train was late.

14:14And he said, well, who are you meeting with? And I said, I was supposed to meet with Seymour Quast. And he said, I know Seymour. I can call him and tell him that you missed the appointment and you're crying and you need to get another appointment. And he did. What's the odds of that happening? So I got another appointment and I met Seymour and he was really, really nice. And I, you know, he was going to help me get some freelance work and he thought maybe I could do a drawing for some little job they had. And then I left and, you know, went back to school. The break was over. I went back to school and about, I don't know, five days after I got back to Philadelphia, I got a children's book in the mail from him, and it said, For Paula from Seymour Quast.

15:06And I went, Wow! And then I took it to school to show to my teachers. And I said, Look, when you go to Pushpin, you get a book. And they said, No, you don't.

15:20Paula Scher: There you have it. Well, clearly, you stunned Seymour when he saw you and saw your work and that professional and personal relationship developed. Totally. It was very magnetic. You know, I mean, I was really a fan of the work. You know, and I also, one of my favorite fonts was the one he did for Artone ink, you know, that looks like an ink drop. And that's when I sort of understood that typography had feeling and could be recognizable separate from, you know, the image. You know, there's usually an illustration and then there's copy, and that's just sort of like typography. You know, it's like, oh, yeah, this letter is A, B, C, D, E, big deal.

16:07And that seeing that R-tone font, you know, is just maybe the most influential thing of the 60s for me in terms of what was going on in design.

16:17Paula Scher: I think it is so important to find inspiration, especially when you're young, of someone you truly admire. And it could be super subjective. And especially if you have, I suppose, a personal connection to that person, then you want to impress them, so you would try to do extra bit of work. And I feel like that's what makes someone, I suppose, succeed, because they have this original passion and they want to do more than everyone else. You have to have it, or you don't really do very much, and you don't get to grow, you know, because I think being a designer for a long period of time is a learning experience all the way, because at the beginning, you're just discovering how things could and do work.

17:02Then you're beginning to push them and discover and explore more, and you'll see more opportunities for how to solve problems by doing that. And then And then pretty soon you develop a vocabulary. And then sometimes you find, oh, the vocabulary got dated. I need a new vocabulary. So you move around and you take things that you know how to work with and you manipulate them so they become contemporary. And that's what most designers are doing.

17:30Paula Scher: So what do you think makes some designers successful and some not? You're an example of incredible success. and obviously you're very influential, not just in design circles, but in the world, your work is everywhere. And when I was reading some of your earlier interviews, you were not necessarily talking about your early work in the highest regard. So therefore you didn't feel like you were the most talented designer when you were growing up. So what do you think that makes certain designers as a creative succeed compared to others? Well, it's luck, I have to say that. It's not, I mean, some of it is your, I hate to say the word talent, you know, because what is talent?

18:20Talent is some proclivity, something that you can do and understand how to work with it. But I think success comes from the ability to apply the talent and to be able to apply the talent, You have to have the thing to apply the talent on. So it means that you have to have access to wonderful things to work on to prove your mettle. And I was lucky because, I mean, I had a sort of a strange beginning. I went to work at an advertising agency. And because I was a fan of Seymour and Pushpin, I wanted to do children's books. I wanted to be an illustrator. I wanted to be creating children's books. And so I was working at this stupid advertising agency for about a week and a half.

19:16And then I asked somebody, how do I get to do children's books? And they said, well, we don't do them here. You're going to have to see a children's book editor. So I met a children's book editor. And the children's book editor said that the best way to get a children's book to do the illustrations floor is to write the book. So I said, oh, okay. And I went home and I wrote a children's book. And I wrote the only children's book I ever wrote. And it was a hit. It was called The Brownstone. And it was about these animals that lived in a brownstone building. And the whole thing was done as a cutaway of the floors.

19:56And there was a bear who came home and wanted to go to sleep for the winter. But there was a cat that lived next door. And she was practicing to be an opera singer and keeping him up all night. And the whole thing was a series of cutaways of the buildings where these animals moved all around until they solved their problem. Then what happened was that I wrote the book and I went back to that children's book editor. It was at Doubleday. And I gave it to him and he said, OK, he'll look at it. And I had done illustrations for it. And then I came back three weeks later and he said he didn't have it, he lost it.

20:31and they were all illustrate you know they were like illustrations that are the originals like there isn't a computer where this stuff is all kept so that I had lost the comp and the writing the whole thing for the book and I didn't know what to do and I walked out and I was pretty upset and then um I got a job doing designing the insides of children's books at random house which was a real dumb dumb job all I was doing this was pasting a line of top in the bottom of somebody else's illustrations. So this American illustrator who was terrific named Stan Mack used to come down the hall and bum cigarettes for me because I smoked.

21:08And I was in this whole room and there was all the smoke coming out of the room. And Stan came in and he'd like mooch cigarettes. And he was there to see a children's book editor who was very good. Her name was Jane Fader. And I started telling him about my story of my children's book. And he wanted to see the story and how it played out, and I made like a little diagram of the cutaways of the apartments, and the bear goes here, and then the owl moves up here, and blah, blah, blah. So he said to me, I'll get it published for you if you let me illustrate it. So it is the one and only children's book I've ever done.

21:47It won some kind of, I can't remember what the prize was, but it's now collected in the Historical Society about stories about New York, because it was, you know, a brownstone in New York, and that's where the animals were moving around. And it was reprinted about three or four times. And now it's printed by Scholastic.

22:09Paula Scher: Wow. So it's sort of a, it was like an accident, you know, and I really didn't want, after I got into design, there was no way I wanted to do another children's book. I just didn't see, I didn't have any ideas. I never had another idea for a second one. Seymour has done 46 children's books, and I never had another idea. Anyway, then after that, after the book came out, I had a very nice boss at Random House. His name was Herb Levitt, and he was getting a big job at Ogilvy, which is a big agency in New York, and he was taking it, but he said that there wasn't a position for me. So he called up a friend of his named Teddy Bernstein and got me a job in the promotion department of CBS records, which is how I got into the record industry.

22:57All of this stuff was happenstance. I mean, like there was no grand design or there wasn't any planning for it. It's just that first I was here, then I did something and somebody lost it. And then I met another person who could use it. You know, I mean, it's like sort of the strange, and these things were happening within weeks and months of each other. So, I mean, I think I wrote the book when I was 22. It was published when I was 23, and I started working in the record industry in the advertising department. And I get a call from a guy named Bob Deferin, who worked at Atlantic Records, and wanted to know if I would come and work with him because he needed somebody to work on his promotional materials.

23:41So I came and I did that, but I didn't really want to do that. But they did promotion and record covers in the same department so i got to do record covers and then i did i think 25 covers at atlantic and they some of them won awards so then cbs records hired me back to be east coast art director so i took this giant jump from being sort of really low level low pay to actually having you know my own american express card and full office and and that sort of thing and i i was responsible for about i I don't know, I'm going to do something like 100 covers a year or something like that. And so that's how I met the Pink Floyd guys, which was nice.

24:22I used to handle doing the liner notes and the crap for their covers, and they would come to town, and they were really sweet. And I'm actually still in touch with them, which is nice. And then there were the big recording artists, and that was actually very hard to do good things for because the whole company was breathing down your neck. And then I left to start my own business. But I already at that point had a fairly serious reputation.

24:46Paula Scher: If you had to pick any of the projects that you're personally very proud of, would it be public or anything else? I mean, there's individual pieces of work that I'm very proud of. The public theater is a really unusual body of work because it's been going on. It's now in its 32nd year. the way I set it up was smart because we do one poster each year that serves as a manual for all the other things that are done at the public theater, meaning the way the type is handled, the way the photograph may be handled, or whether it's photography or not, or how the type is positioned or what little conceits are in there.

25:33And then you'll see around town, these things. There may be three or four different ones that become active in the subway, and now they're digital, so they're on the streets. And so they become the theme of the year, and they're recognized. And I wrote a book about it, which sort of talks about how it's made. And it's really the poster. The first poster is the manual. And the manual is the poster itself, because you take the elements from the poster, you look at the poster is designed, and I see them all, and they all go out and it's great.

26:05Paula Scher: That's a brilliant way to do identity, have a source that inspires everything else, but it's not constrained. It's not like a style guide. It is very much a piece of creativity that everyone can then develop on and interpret in, but it still has all those elements, as you said, typography, layout, colors. Well, you should see what we did this year. I mean, last year we had, it was the, I think it was the 30th anniversary of my work. So there was like sort of an honor, and then there was a big thing with circles, and it was beautiful color, really nice series. And then I got sick of it. And what I did is I did handwriting this year, and I got five kids, two kids, they work at the public, to emulate it.

26:51It's online. If you go to the Pentagram website, I mean, it really looks terrific because it's so anti-tech. You know, it's like scribbly handwriting all over the thing. but when you look at them, it looks like any other identity in that it's completely consistent.

27:05Paula Scher: Perfect. But it's such a beautiful piece of work. And I felt like it required so much confidence from your side. I also read a story that when you originally designed, it wasn't very well received by other partners at Pentagram. Was that true? At the very beginning, yeah. Yeah, I had a, it was actually horrible. I was, it was my first year at Pentagram and I had, I don't know that it was my first year. I think it was the second year. It doesn't really matter. It's the same story. I had done the public theater identity and I was really excited because I was going to be able to show this, you know, a very significant identity that a lot of people in New York saw and, you know, had a lot of following.

27:53And, you know, I brought it to London. Nobody knew about it in London. And they disliked the public logo because I made everything a different weight, you know, like a different thick and thin thing. And they thought I created typographic blasphemy. And it wasn't Helvetica. And it didn't, you know, it didn't have all that stuff. And in the middle of showing it, David Hillman was just outraged by it. And so was John McConnell. and they got up and they walked out of the room. And I was a new partner. I was really rattled by that. And John Rushworth sat there and he said, well, I rather liked some of the posters, but I don't understand why you made those different weights in the type.

28:38Why don't you just make it one weight and be done with it? And I thought, because you wouldn't recognize it. It would look special that way. I mean, he sort of didn't get it. And then it was years later and he actually did a public apology for being that stupid. Oh, wow. That was really, it's really, but it's now a joke. And David Hillman started knocking this stuff off, particularly my environmental work, the 3D stuff. At first, he thought that was blasphemy. The type was too big on the building. It was too showy, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. And then all of a sudden, he started doing it.

29:10Paula Scher: How did you have that confidence, especially, as you said, very early as a partner in pentagram? Other partners don't like something. How did you have the confidence to stand your ground and actually defend, like, obviously you knew it's a great piece of work, but it's sometimes very hard where people who may be more influential or have more weight than you suddenly say that. I was in the music business for 10 years. I worked with people who were tougher than these guys. These were just like a bunch of graphic designers, you know. I mean, I worked with Mick Jagger. I worked with Billy Joel. I worked with Bruce Springsteen.

29:46I worked with a bunch of bands who were assholes. You know, I mean, like it was the music business. You know, nobody stood in a ceremony. They were like, why are you doing that? I don't like that yellow. Can you give me that yellow? I don't like that yellow.

30:00Paula Scher: What's this thing over here? Where do you think your confidence comes from? Were you always confident as a child, or you actually developed this toughness while you were working in the industry? Probably before. My brother was the darling son. who was five years older than me, and he was a really, really good student. He was a straight-A student, and he got a scholarship to Johns Hopkins, full scholarship, and a scholarship to Stanford, and I was a shitty student. I misbehaved, and my mother, who was a school teacher, just didn't know what to do with me and really thought I was either dumb or just not trying, and my father was sort of the same way.

30:43They didn't want me to go to art school. My father thought that stupid people who can't do anything else go to art school. That's how his brain worked. And, you know, you get a little toughened by that kind of thing. It was rough. It was adolescence, mostly childhood, besides I was a little kid. But I think my high school years were really painful.

31:12Paula Scher: in those situations i suppose people go either way so either they toughen up and learn how to defend yourself be confident and survive in this world those circumstances can break someone that's right and i don't know if that is true for everyone but i personally find that you need to have at least one person who believes in you there might be the rest of the world that says you're nothing. That's true. But there needs to be at least someone who supports you, believes in you. Was that that person when you were growing up or through your... Well, I had two teachers at Tyler School of Art because I thought I was going to be thrown out.

31:51As a matter of fact, the first day I'll tell you was about the teacher I had for basic design. And in those days, you know, there were no computers. And the way you learn to understand spacing was sort of the Swiss way where you cut out a black square and you moved it around a white page to see how it separated and broke up space. So that's how you learn scale, which is important. The problem was I could have done that and really learned a lot if there were computables, but you had to actually cut out the black square and move it with rubber cement. And I was sloppy. So my black square was never perfectly square and the paper was always somewhat wrinkled.

32:31I had a teacher named Bob Stein who just thought I was hopeless. As a matter of fact, when the class was over at the end of freshman year and he was giving me my grade, which was a C, he said, why are you here? And I said, well, I want to be an artist. And he said, cooking is an art. You know, that's what he said to me. Wow. And then I graduated, you know, and I had two terrific teachers who really, Stanislaus Zagorski, a Polish illustrator, really, it was completely inspiring and very supportive and actually drove me to New York to introduce me to people who were art directors who could give me work and stuff like that.

33:13That was amazing. But in the middle of it, I get a call from Bob Stein, the nasty guy. And he said, I'd like you to come and speak to my class and show your work. You know, because I was doing record covers then, and they were winning awards. And he just called me up out of the blue, and he remembered me. And I was just shocked. And I thought, I think I just want to go and see what this is going to be about. And so I went back to Philadelphia, where he was still teaching. And he introduced me to the class, and he said, this is Paula Sher. She was one of my students, and I cannot take a single moment of credit for anything she's done.

33:53Paula Scher: And then that was sort of like the end of that horrible thing turned into a nice thing. But, you know, if you want to do something, I think, and most of the people I know who are like that, especially my husband, is you just do it. You know, like you can't be heard by somebody's negativity. Sometimes somebody can make a point that's good. It's not like that you can't listen to criticism. But you can tell when there's a kind of negativity that wants to drive you away from the thing you're doing. Yeah, I kind of like me just driving. That is such a beautiful story. Thank you for sharing. I want to go back to what you talked as elements of luck in your life.

34:40Paula Scher: because, I mean, I also believe in luck, but I feel like there needs to be some work done for luck to happen. And from what I'm hearing from your story, and correct me if I'm wrong, I'm trying to see what is the pattern for what you've done differently compared to someone else who was at the same companies, maybe was doing even similar quality work, but still didn't get those pivots and opportunities that you got. And it sounds like there were these people that you built relationships with that would think about you as the first person they would call. That was later, not early. In the early days, I'm telling you, it was really timing.

35:22You know, like you... The first thing when I wrote the children's book, I'd go to see a guy who's a children's book art director and designer. How did you decide to go to see a guy?

35:33Paula Scher: Like, there's still an action from your side. Well, that is an action from my side. I mean, I wanted to do children's books. I thought, you know, I was a fan of Seymour's children's books, and I thought, I want to do a children's book. And so I go to, and I want to illustrate it. I didn't think about writing it. And then I go, I got the appointment I got. I called about probably five publishing houses because, you know, I went in the phone book and got the names of them and found out where the guys were, which is, you know, like doing your homework. And then I called him up and I got this interview with Doubleday, which was a good children's book publisher.

36:07And then he said the best way to get one is to write one. And I thought, oh, I better write one. So I went and I wrote one. And I've never written one since, but that one is still in print after 50 years. I mean, it's sort of like, how does that happen? And that to me is luck. Yes, the children's book, it's a good story. I admit that. But it's not. It's one.

36:32Paula Scher: You know, I mean, it's not. I agree. I feel like there are lots of elements of luck, but I feel like there are so many things probably that didn't lead to anything that you don't remember anymore. But they were same process of you really wanted to do something, putting some actions, going to try, do your homework, do the work, and then maybe it doesn't work out. And the ones that did work out. I remember those. I just don't. That's probably true because I have a tendency to wipe out things that are not successful. You know, like I just don't think about them. Because if you do, if you sit around and you think about them, I mean, they can be helpful if you want to improve, I guess.

37:10But they're mostly depressing. You know, like, oh, I really screwed that up. That's terrible. But the thing was that this is really about getting your foot in the door, as they say. You know, that you—everything was temporary. And the thing that wasn't luck was when Bob Deferin hired me to go to Atlantic. He had seen something I'd done. You know, it wasn't like Teddy Bernstein was a friend of blah, blah. He had seen something I'd done. He didn't know me from a hole in the wall. He called me up from a piece of work I did. And then I went in to interview with him, and the interview was very good, and I started doing promotional work there.

37:57And it was a much smaller company, so it was easier to be known. And I started doing jazz albums there because the person who approved the work was Nessui Erdogan, who was Ahmet and Nessui. We were brothers, and they ran the whole company. So I could make things actually quite easily because I didn't have a lot of criticism or interference from higher-ups, simply because the company was small. So I think I did 25 covers there. You know, seven got into shows, and I think three won awards or something like that. And that's why I got hired back to CBS Records. That wasn't luck. That was from the output at Atlantic.

38:41I was already a pro. The main thing to make a designer successful, which is good work to be able to work with and power to be able to get it through, and that those were always the ingredients. And if you're in that position and you're not doing good work, then there's something wrong with you, because that is the ultimate situation. If I had gotten a position, say, in an advertising agency with the same kind of power and salary, et cetera, but I had to work on crappy ads, it wouldn't go the right way. I mean, so that there's still luck in it.

39:21Paula Scher: Well, let's talk about your fabulous career going forward from the world of music industry into your own business. You left that to start your own company with a partner. And obviously you had experience, you had reputation, you had connections to clients, but still it was a new business, a new name that you had to start from scratch. So how did you go about finding those clients and what did you do to actually establish some sort of foundation for the business to start growing? Well, at the end of the time, I think it was maybe two or three years before I left CBS, book publishers who had book jackets started to call me to see if I would do freelance work, which I did.

40:07So I had a bunch of clients already from the book jacket business. But I was working alone then, and I didn't like it. I wanted a partner. And I met up with a friend of mine from college named Terry Coppell, who was a magazine designer, and he worked on the Boston Globe in Boston. And I was offered a gig to go up to Time, Inc., and work on a new magazine and do a format for it. I had no experience, and I needed Terry. So we got into this room upstairs for a year, developing these, really there were two magazines. And he is very funny, and we had a great time. After we did that, they tested the magazines, and the magazines didn't test well, and they didn't come out.

40:56So we decided we'd just open our own business because we had such a good time working together. So we found a space in actually in this neighborhood pretty much. It was years ago, and there were prostitutes that were on every corner. It was really, really kind of messy. And we got—the first thing we got was something called Manhattan Records, which was the former president of CBS Records who had gone to another company and gave me a whole series of record covers to do. So, like, you know, you get work. Work makes work. If you work for people who control work, meaning that they have access to it, and they work with you and they like you and they trust you, you will get more of it.

41:40If you work with them and they don't like you and they don't trust you, you won't get more of it. It's like not that complicated. But that's where the work came from. And Terry was a magazine designer, which was great because he was attracting other kinds of business. So I would get things that were packaging-related, music business-related. The Swatch Watch poster came that way, you know, because they were appealing to, like, what they thought was a hipster audience when we were doing those things. And so work just materialized because the reputation was growing. And I became an activist. Like, I got on the board of AIGA, and I started to know the whole design community around the United States.

42:23That's when I met Colin Forbes. He was president of the board when I was on it, you know, so that he knew me before I joined Pentagram. I didn't even think at that point in time I never thought I'd be joining Pentagram. But there were the key American designers, Woody Pertle, Michael Vanderbile, and really the whole community of people who I would say from the 1980s all the way through 2000s were sort of the lead of the design community of the United States. And so that all of those kinds of friendships and connections and socialization that wasn't even work, you know, like it was fun, you know, that's how things materialize.

43:08That's how I know my partners, you know, in that you meet them through the American Institute of Graphic Arts. You know, you go to an opening and you start meeting people who are your age and peers and you make relationships with them, and then all of a sudden you become a community.

43:23Paula Scher: Do you think that changed now because people stop gathering as much in physical places and spaces, and in general it feels like there are less of these kind of communities? I agree. I think that there is less of it. And I was trying to figure out why. I mean, part of it was for AIGA, which was such a strong thing, you know, we bought a building, And Colin led that. And we were already in the pentagram building on Fifth Avenue. And Colin wanted to buy another building. He said, hey, we can organize the community and buy this building. It can be the headquarters for the AIGA. And it was. It had a mortgage on it, but it was.

44:02And then we got this horrible director. I'm blanking on his name. He was just, he shouldn't have been director. He had ambitions that didn't have anything to do with the community. And he wanted to make AIGA chapters in China. and sort of began spending money in very strange ways. And he bankrupted the company, and we were forced to sell the building. So when we sold the building to get rid of the debt, it sort of ruined the connection that was New York City, because people would come to New York, and we'd be having shows in the building, and that's where we had our openings and parties and things like that.

44:38Then there was a new director who wanted to try to bring that back together, and she spent a huge amount of money renting some space downtown, and there just wasn't that kind of money in the chapter anymore. And then the relationships started to fall apart. You know, the newer members weren't actually getting into the group because there wasn't enough events for them to go to where you actually made the positive interaction. I mean, it takes time to make friends. And all that seemed to have gone away. And then, you know, I had joined Pentagram, I mean, I had such a strong social group in our own building that I had lost interest in it anyway.

45:18It just didn't make sense to try to be an activist and keep up with it anymore because we were sort of doing our own community there.

45:27Paula Scher: Well, I hope that still will be a new wave of communities and people coming together. That's definitely our mission as Futureland Academy is to connect creative communities around the world and give them knowledge and inspiration to make the world better. So hopefully, through different things that we do, we'll try to bring it. At least in London, we do have things that we do in the U.S. as well. But I agree, a community is so important. The community is important. And the local community is, I think, the most important because you don't belong to the international community unless you've gotten through to the local community because that's how you broaden.

46:03I belong to AGI. I don't know if you know what that is. is alliance graphic international and it's a it's completely global you know so that there are you know and all i think almost every pentagram partner is a member so it's like a very big group activity and it's fun and all of that but i i do think that something really changed in new york

46:26Paula Scher: with that when we lost that building i actually heard a i don't know if it's a rumor or theory that companies who made it till now in terms of design or creative industry are those who bought their own building because the property was affordable or cheap. Sure. And they're still here. Would you agree with that? Well, I think that there's something, I don't know, I don't know the totality of the belief, but I think there's something in the confidence of having your own space. I mean, we moved into here, into this space because we outgrew the other space. You know, we had a building, and they've built on top of it, damn them.

47:07It was three floors, and, I mean, we all loved it. You know, it was home, and we used to have parties on the roof, and the parties were just sort of sloppy burger places, and the community came, and it was just wonderful. And that doesn't really exist now, and we have a very fancy roof garden, and nobody's on it. You know, I mean... Why do you think people don't want to come together? I think they're too competitive. I think everybody's very protective about their work and what they've got and who they know and who they're working for and what they'll share about it. And I remember a much more open series of conversations with people who I didn't even think of as competitors.

47:52I just thought of them as friends who were also really good designers. You know, and that somewhere that attitude changed, the community got nastier. Do you think it's in New York or globally? I don't know.

48:02Paula Scher: I can't answer for globally. It's definitely in New York. Interesting. I always thought that London is a great place for community because we are so tiny as a country and as a city. And agencies in London and studios in London tend to be smaller than in the rest of the world. So you don't have any other option to succeed rather than collaborate. because you might have the most brilliant motion design studio collaborate with the most brilliant whatever architecture studio. Like it could, it makes sense to collaborate. So therefore, by nature of it, you always will have lots of friends and connections.

48:39Paula Scher: And yes, there is competition, but kind of in a healthy way when you lose a pitch to someone, you know, you meet for a beer and say, well, well done to you, we'll get the next one. And I hope, I really hope that we'll stay in London as well. I think you're probably right about the scale. You know, like it seems that

49:02the technology has, I think, kind of murdered the business in a way, because you're making things with machines that don't involve secondary people, you know, so that you're right away, if you're not teaching, you're losing connections to young designers who start to help build a community because they have the energy to do it. And they come in particularly, you know, I, from my point of view, I would not have the energy to do what I did in the, you know, 20 and 30 years ago. I can't, I can't be that person. I mean, I can go and speak to a group publicly, but I'm not going to organize them to do something.

49:42Where back then we were actually doing that through AIGA, you know, setting up programs. We made AIGA a national organizations. So there were chapters all over the United States and they'd have an annual conference that Michael Beirut and I chaired. It was just a hoot. I mean, that these things really brought a broad American community as one and it's all gone now. What can we do to change that? I don't know. I really don't know. The industry isn't the same. I think that, And when I think about our competition now, everything is for these jobs of enormous scale and enormous fees. And I don't know, I think that kind of broke the industry a little bit.

50:27Because you have to compete with them in very specific ways. And you have to be able to show your capability to be able to handle the scale or the money or the other organizations you're going to have to communicate with. and it becomes a competition that doesn't really have anything to do with what anybody does well. You know, you're talking about being organized as big business in this way that most of the people who are makers don't really want to be doing. So then you bring in other people into the organization or you bring in, you know, advisors or people who are supposed to help you do that and then you find they don't know what they're doing either.

51:11You know, it's just sort of that problem of it. And I don't know how to fix that. I think there has to be a group of young—I thought, you know, the most interesting communities right now are in Brooklyn. And there is a hot spot for a lot of young design firms. The problem is they get to a point where they're successful, but they don't seem to go into the same kind of leadership of trying to organize it bigger. You know, they have reputations, but even the design organizations don't have the power they used to, like the AIGA or the Art Directors Club or the Type Directors Club. I mean, they seem much more marginal than they were back maybe 20 years ago.

51:56Paula Scher: What's the average time one of your visual identities last? Because City, again, is a great example. I have some more ones. there's City there is Public Theater there is now Shake Shack Shake Shack is 20 years old and they started with the Little Shack and now they're all over the world they're totally global so that's 20 years old what else? it's hard for me to run a Criterion I don't know if you know the movie channel it's like a Criterion is a scene that sort of turns around That's about 25 years old. A lot of my logos were done in the High Line. I did that in 1988. Wow. A lot of my New York City logos are old.

52:51I did a lot of work for city government. And I redid the Parks Department. So all those signs, and they're around.

52:59Paula Scher: What do you think makes an identity that will last for so long compared to the one that will want to be rebranded very quickly? That's a good question. It really depends upon the people who are managing that situation. Some people always want change, or usually a logo changes if something significantly changes in the company, particularly if it's an old logo. And that really can only be caused because some product really failed and was embarrassing, or the management changed and they wanted to get rid of the people that came before and sort of create some new image for whatever reason. Sometimes the reason is good and needs to be done, and sometimes it's silly and sometimes that doesn't last long.

53:46And I worked on Windows 8, and it was, I would say, a modification of a window, except for they had these sort of like goofy, they were all color, but they were like goofy sort of bending in the windows. They weren't windows. They were like waves. So I got it. I thought that in looking at it, I thought they didn't mean to make something that looked like a flag. They were really trying to show a window in perspective. So I had persuaded them that that's what that was and then did the sub-brands the same way. And it lasted about 10 years. And then they came in and they started goofing around with the perspective so that you can see 2011, 12, whatever, and you see them all slightly different, but they're still based on the same premise.

54:36Paula Scher: Still a window. For a tech company, more than 10 years for a product, that's a very long-lasting visual identity considering tech moves so fast and tries always to look futuristic and look innovative, and therefore I feel like visual identity often falls the victim of this modernization? Probably. I mean, I just think it's silly. You've got to change everything and everything. It seems like a giant waste of money. You know, and look at Apple. It's been a long, been there, I guess it's now. That was done when I had my own business with Terry Coppell, so it had to be like 1984 or something. I think it was 1984 when they launched that.

55:20I mean, that is one long logo. Wow. I mean, they change the color inside it. Sometimes they make it shiny. Sometimes it's one color. Sometimes it's a rainbow. But that's a long life.

55:32Paula Scher: I spotted one of the scandalous posters there. So I would love to ask you that. So tell us more. What happened? Well, I was doing advertisement for Swatch Watch. And I had done a couple of campaigns in front of this campaign. The campaigns were all parodies of things. Like the first campaign was a parody of 1950s advertising. And there was a mother and she held up her arms and she had all these watches on her arms. And she says, since we got Swatch, the kids are never late for school and their grades are better too. And the tagline was the family that ticks together sticks together. And that was, you know, it was funny.

56:13And there was a calendar and stuff like that. This was the second campaign, and it happened that the Swatch Watch headquarters had moved into a Swiss commercial building where there were a lot of Swiss businesses. And so I was walking around the hall, and there was the Herbert Matter poster, and she had an arm up. I thought I could get an arm in there, and that it was just crying out for a watch. And I thought, you know, it's Swiss, it's Swatch, it's appropriate. Mercedes Matter was alive. That was the wife. And she was active in AIGA. And I was on the board of AIGA at the time. And we called her up and paid for permission and used it.

56:57It came out in 19, I think it was like 1982. It didn't become a controversy until Tibor Kalman decided to make a stink about it in some design journal he wrote. And then there was this furor over it. But it was around and in the public view for like six years before it became controversial. It was very strange. And then it died. And now kids look at it and they go, what's the big deal? Nobody gets why there was any kind of controversy about it. I was accused of plagiarism. That's not plagiarism. You know, I mean, there was just a whole, you know, on the bottom of the posters, it says something like, Coppell and Cher, thanks to Herbert Matter.

57:44I mean, there was no hiding the source. Plagiarism is when you take something, you manipulate it, you make it your own and pretend like it didn't, that you invented it. That's the different part of it. And so it was very public and then it went away.

58:01Paula Scher: Was it hard when you read the article from Tibur that? Yeah, because he was a friend of mine. I mean, we were, you know, he, I helped him with his career early and I just thought it was an absolutely disgusting thing to do. Then he, then we didn't talk for about, I don't know, five or six years. He went to Europe for a long period of time and this is before he got sick and we had met again in, it wasn't Denmark, trying to remember which country. Anyway, we had met there because there was some kind of a design event we were both invited to. We made up there. And then - Did you ask him why did he do that?

58:39I knew why he did it. Press. I mean, he made press for himself. He was creating controversy. And that's what T. Bore did. He did it in his work. Some of it's terrific. And he did it in public. And he used to ridicule other designers, which really never happened in the design industry in New York until he started doing it. Then suddenly it sort of seemed like fair practice, but now nobody does it.

59:08Paula Scher: Did you feel like during that time or that article and overall that conversation, anyone questioned you or was it difficult for your work or it was just kind of personally not pleasant, but it didn't affect your work or what you did? A little of both. I mean, I think that it didn't affect my work in terms of what I put out or what I was getting, where I felt it what it did is it really lived within the design community. It wasn't like, oh, the whole world has this thing. The design community in New York is actually a small little body of people. And, you know, friends in California and people who are AIGA members.

59:50And so it became like the big controversy. And then there were a couple people who made it go away. One of them was Michael Rock, who wrote, he used to write for ID Magazine, which was a very powerful magazine back then. And he just wrote a piece that sort of lambasted, but he was equating it to another, they're made up controversies for his point of view. And he was right, actually, they are made up controversies. And little by little, people thought, eh, it doesn't matter. But what is that? And why is it? Why did that happen?

1:00:26Paula Scher: What did you learn from that period? I learned that Tibor was snarky. That was my learning curve. There wasn't anything else to learn from. And I felt like, I mean, my very own partner, Abbott Miller, wrote an article sort of defending Tibor's position. And he was in the controversy. he feels stupid about it now, but, you know, I mean, it was part of a very small group of people sort of being able to be self-important in some way. Let's talk about the world of creativity and creative work. If a great subject. And I love that about Pentagram and how you talk about your work that here everyone is a maker and Pentagram very much made a very specific effort in keeping teams small and keeping that spirit where everyone is still involved in work and therefore you still do your work, which is very rare for any senior professional to be very hands on as they progress within their career.

1:01:28Paula Scher: So I would love to talk about what motivates you still to actually be hands on, because it's very easy to get into the state of like, I've already done this, it's another visual identity for another financial institution or whatever another theater i've done plenty of those um and as you've seen your as you've said your style toolkit you kind of develop it a lot when you're young because everything seems new and everything seems so exciting and shiny and i feel like a lot of creatives lose that excitement about new things and what else can I try and what I don't know and what should I learn. So how did you find that motivation and curiosity throughout decades of your career?

1:02:20Paula Scher: I try to keep my work broad-based. In other words, that I have really three things I do, and one of them is outside Pentagram. I'm a designer of logos and identities and systems that other people work with. In other words, the identities I design are programmed into the website so that they can draw from them and get the typography right, and it's going to look like the thing that I made, which is my goal when I do those things, to make it look like what i designed as opposed to something somebody messes around with and i enjoy that i sometimes those jobs are quite lucrative uh sometimes they're not the ones that aren't usually are more creative so that you know it's a balance i'll do some where i feel like i'm sort of servicing the company and others where i feel like i'm getting to events invent stuff for them so they look more unique and it really has to do with what kind of a business it is and I like doing them but not always and I don't like it when I have sort of a rigid corporation that doesn't want to do anything that's interesting and then that's very depressing because usually there's more money attached that job and so then you start holding on to it because you don't want to lose the money and then you end up kind of depressing yourself a little bit.

1:03:54But that's one type of work I do. And I would say identity-driven work is probably, you know, it's my biggest earner in terms of the things I make. And in many ways, it's very joyful for me if the product that I'm working for is good and the potential is there to do something terrific, and then that's great. The other type of work I do is things that are not-for-profit, and sometimes things that I do for free, and I do them because I want to do the work. And it's kind of, if you're working for clients, there are expectations of what you need to do for them and their right to have those expectations.

1:04:39When you're working for free, you don't care what their expectations are, because you actually end up having control of the work, and that's where you can really invent. And if they're not paying you anyway, and you do something you love and they don't want to do it, you can save it and use it on some other place, so nothing is wasted. And I like the balance of that. I have to earn a living. You can't not get paid. But you can find situations where it becomes something that promotes you. I mean, we did this poster system that was like sort of a—there was a thing called Art House. Art House is an organization that's a government organization that promotes art film houses.

1:05:27and we did a logo that I drew in five minutes because it was a funny sketch of a house that got made from the A of art and house. The H is underneath it, so it makes a house and blah, blah. It took about 10 minutes to make. Then they determined what movie theaters were going to be part of this exercise and that took forever to make because nobody can make up their mind about these pieces of information. It takes nothing to design something. It's really like getting other people to behave. So we did it, and it's out, and it was all over Manhattan, or was all over Manhattan, and now there's events and things, and it's like sort of you've invented a little organization that's going to have a life out there that you didn't get paid for, but everybody knows what it is.

1:06:10So to me, that's valuable as a career opportunity. I would not have done it if I didn't have time, but I did have time to do that, and I knew it was going to take a minute. So these are things in balance so that corporate work pays more than work that's based around arts. That's the way it goes. You have to determine if you want to do it or you don't want to do it. And I like to do it. And the third thing I do is my paintings. And my paintings I sell, and sometimes they actually do well when I have shows. and I also have prints that my dealer sells without me being involved in it and it's like found money, you know, so that these things work in tandem in different ways.

1:06:58But I find that the painting is good for me because if I'm having a frustrating period as a designer, I sort of escape into that.

1:07:08Paula Scher: Do you think it's important for creatives or designers to have that side project or, I don't want to call it a hobby, but side passion that is completely outside of your commercial role, but potentially can be commercialized, but there is no pressure to make it commercial, and kind of entertains different parts of your brain, I suppose, or different skill. A lot of people do. I mean, it's all over the map. Not everybody, but some of my partners have things that they're passionate about that have nothing to do with their work and sometimes they don't even have anything to do with making art it's it's it may be uh some interest in something that's scientific or i mean eddie o 'pero is always inventing things he's like a guy who wants to redesign lighting in general or something like that you know i mean they they they do things you know where where is your passion what do you love to do i think as kids we have so much more of that because at that point we don't have a job so it's normal for us to have I don't know like one thing that we do with friends one thing we do at school one other thing we do after after school and we love all of them and have challenges and all of them but it's kind of normal for us to have this balanced or diverse life and I think when we become grown-ups we need to pick one thing that we do and do it well and perfect it and and build a career and and if by any chance we decide to change the career is obviously a failure of everything you've done in the past but also if you decide to dedicate half of your time to something else it's a waste of time because you're not dedicating it your everything to your main thing and i feel like there is too much pressure almost to that stops a lot of people from maybe exploring things that will be bad at initially they will not succeed for many years, but they might just enjoy them and just have fun with it.

1:09:10Paula Scher: That might fuel everything else that they do in life. I can't answer for individuals. I can tell you when I started painting, it was, we had a big house in the country. We still do. The first house we just bought that way. The second house we built ourselves and it's got all this workspace. But, you know, we're up there on long weekends in the winter, and it's snowing. And I started doing watercolors up there, you know, just because I didn't have anything else to do. You know, I can only watch somebody. No social media back then. No computers. No, there was, you know, so I just started goofing around.

1:09:45And I had a little painting show of my flowers in the country. And it was in, like, a little railroad house in a little town in Connecticut. it and and you know I liked it I like it was it was relaxing and I I started doing this I think when I was working on Citibank and it was it was fantastic because Citibank was after you know the Michael Wolff part where he had he'd sort of come up with what the general thinking was with it and the logo was already accepted there were these sort of things I had to prove out with the logo and then they were like all the sub branding I had to do and it was really boring.

1:10:26You know, it was the same thing over and over and over again. And, you know, I couldn't, it was really hard even to keep interns to do that. You know, like, I mean, it just was, you know, boring and I can go up and like paint.

1:10:39Paula Scher: How do you get into your creative flow for work or for painting? Do you have a ritual or something that you practice every day or before a big project to make sure you get into this state of creativity? The best way to get me there is bad weather you know you can't go outside just you know you're not gonna not gonna play a sport you're not gonna you know it's bad weather you're trapped and you should have seen covid when i painted the porsche in the basement i don't know if you ever saw them film of me painting the porsche no i haven't seen there was a guy who commissioned uh me to paint a map of the united states on a porsche and it took it took a year and a half and it was perfect timing because because i did it during COVID.

1:11:23And it was a project. So we had in the basement, we had a garage door, and there was a Sharon Motors, who fixes my car, got the Porsche from the guy who commissioned me. He was German. He lives in Munich. So this car rose with no—you know, the inside was gutted, and it was like rolled into my basement and it was put on I don't know what you call those things that go up you know the car can be raised and down so I the car was painted flat black with acrylic so I could paint on top of it and I painted the United States all over the car and underneath it and we and we we did a webcam of it so I have a film of the whole thing which is sort of amazing and it's because This was bad weather, you know?

1:12:14If it had been nice out, it would have taken me three times as long to paint that thing. Boredom, boredom is the secret.

1:12:22Paula Scher: It's really, totally, that'll push you forward. Love it. Let's talk about fashion as an outlet for creativity. It's New York Fashion Week, so very appropriate conversation. And I love that you're wearing heels today. I rarely meet designers or creative people who wear heels. I obviously love wearing heels, and I was judged for it, surprisingly, because all designers were wearing trainers, jeans and checkered shirts. And I love that you have so many details. You have beautiful rings, you have a necklace. There is so much thought that goes into what you dress. Well, I'm sure I need the heels. Well, I feel like it's still a choice to look certain ways.

1:13:04Paula Scher: So how do you think about fashion and what role it plays in the way you show up? Have you ever thought of what you need to wear to appear more present and confident or more creative or maybe more serious in front of certain clients? Or does fashion play? Absolutely. I mean, if I'm going to a straight corporate meeting, I'll put on some kind of suit of sorts. or I have a fashion designer I love, and I wear a lot of her clothes, whose name is Maria Carneo. And she is an American fashion designer who's top tier, and she cuts things that look nice on me. And they're good business clothes. So I have a certain amount of those things.

1:13:50Mostly, if I'm here, I'm wearing pants. And I have a million pairs of these. These are Manolo Blahn. I love the way the shoes are cut. I thought it was a girl. I thought it was Manola. It's Manolo. And, you know, they come in all different colors, and they're very nice. And I like the way they look at my feet. And I wear sneakers because I walk to work. I don't walk to work in these because the heels get caught in the sidewalk.

1:14:16Paula Scher: That's the most annoying thing. I've ruined lots of heels in New York, unfortunately. Yep. Let's talk a little bit more about the kind of reflection of your career and future and what you're excited about. So I, as I mentioned, I love that you lived through so many different decades of design and still have the passion and curiosity for everything you do and keep producing some of the most exciting and fresh work. I am somewhere midway through this journey. And a lot of our listeners and viewers, maybe in their 40s or 50s right now, and are thinking about how do I keep doing this and what maybe I should be focusing on in my 40s and 50s to make sure that at any age, whether we are 70, 80, 90 or 100 years old, we still keep that freshness and that perspective and that passion for what we do.

1:15:14Paula Scher: do. So what would you advise anyone in their 40s or 50s to keep doing or stop doing to maybe keep going? I think the hardest thing is to find some success with something that you've done that people come to you for, and then the expectation is that you're going to do that over and over again. And that can become very trust, you know, can become frustrating because you find yourself trapped in some kind of silo. And it might not even be that they're relying on you to do that. They may be relying on you to do something that they're comfortable paying for because they've already had that experience.

1:15:56It's a trap. That is a very big trap. And it usually comes at the period of time you're describing because you've made some form of reputation that's bringing you that work or you're in a job that is repetitive, you know, and so that's where you sort of have to experiment. Travel, go to museums, look at stuff you never looked at before, buy some books, go to Rizzoli, hang out for a couple hours. You know, I mean, it's like you sort of have to feed your head. So many designers are performing the things without growth and that to grow you have to fail you know like you have to try something and fail and learn from it you know you need to you need to have another experience that's going to push you up a notch it's you know you and you don't you don't really control when that can happen that at least from my point of view i mean i find that i i'll know when i need to do something like that like i gotta pay attention you know all the books in my room i'll sit down and look at every book and see what i'm missing what i'm not doing what I don't, what I have ignored.

1:17:05Paula Scher: MARGARET WARNER, Ph.D.: Did you have some sort of crisis in the 40s or 50s, whether it is midlife crisis, creative crisis, identity crisis, or where do you go from there? ANNE HENRY, Ph.D.: It was earlier than that. I mean, it was when I left the record industry. When Terry and I had the business at the beginning, it was really great. At the end, it wasn't. We hit a bad economy. And he left and left me with debt. You know, and it was a mess. And I had rented out, we had a big space, and I'd rented out parts of the space to make the overhead. I kept most of the team. And I was still working, and Woody Pirtle came over and asked me if I would be interested in joining Pentagram.

1:17:51You know, and that was like out of the blue. I didn't think that was a possibility. I mean, I wasn't thinking, maybe I should do this or that. I was sort of in this kind of a trap of just trying to support the place and make interesting work. But it wasn't to the level of, I thought, my best work. I thought everything was a little bit compromised. But I did start doing more writing. And I started inventing this thing I do where the writing becomes the design. And I'm having an exhibit in Zurich in February, and I'm putting it together, and it's very different from the exhibit I had at the Pina Kotec, because this one has actually earlier work and the work through the periods and the writing stuff.

1:18:38And the writing stuff is very funny, very personal, and very terse. It's like sort of nasty, but that was something I was doing for myself to get out of the situation I was in.

1:18:50Paula Scher: kind of writing, like a diary? Oh, I wrote, I made, I would be asked, sometimes I did a lot of it for the New York Times. They were political. You know, like I wrote a whole big visual diary in what was going on in the Gulf War week by week by week, you know, and it was, you know, like blowing things up and I don't know, that stuff is actually around. You can see that. That was highly published and it was a whole print magazine issue, you know, And then I wrote, my favorite one is, it makes a heart, and it's on a red background, and it is a diary of a menstrual cycle. Nothing. It's like, you'll live it.

1:19:32Everybody's had them. That's great. It was funny. But I do stuff like that. I wrote a lot of, I did a lot of things for the New York Times that were mostly political and written, it's written design. I wrote a whole thing on the Palm Beach County ballot. I don't know if you know what that was, but that was the ballot that threw the election to George Bush instead of Al Gore in the 70s.

1:19:55Paula Scher: So would usually the topics come to you or you would feel passionate about something and you would want to write about it and therefore you pitch? What happened is I started doing this. It's crazy because it was a whole way of working that I invented because of an AIGA competition. There was a competition to do something for graphic design in New York, and you had to do something about New York City. And Michael Beirut and I always competed, and he did the New York Times, and he drew it in pencil, like the whole front page. It was sort of great. So I did a thing on cardboard. I painted on cardboard, and it was called New York, New York, Actual Size.

1:20:43And it was like a map of New York and all the people that were in it and stupid places and places to go. And it sold for the most money from the AIGA thing. So I got really encouraged from that. And then I started doing these sort of fractured maps that were hand-painted. And there was one for the AIGA cover. And they had said, we'd like you to do the cover of the AIGA annual this year. And we have$1 ,000. for expenses. And I said, what if you don't have any expenses? And they said, I guess you get to keep$1 ,000. So I painted the whole cover by hand. There was no expenses. Stuff like that. I mean, they were all sort of goofy things that I did.

1:21:26And then all of a sudden, it was a thing I did. You know, like, I mean, you don't kind of just change. You just start doing something, I think, because it's situational. You know, like you find yourself in some situation, or there's some opportunity, and you think about it, and then something happens as a result of it. I mean, if you just sort of sit around going, I don't know what to do, you better talk to somebody because other people have things that maybe there's something that you can do with, or there just may be a dumb opportunity that you can take that is going to create memorable work.

1:22:06Paula Scher: I feel like this is a lovely way to wrap up our conversation about definitely not sitting and waiting for opportunities to happen, but actually being proactive. I have last two questions that we ask everyone who comes in our podcast. And the first one is about the next guest we should have. You met so many incredible people throughout your career. But who do you think creative need to learn from, creative audience who wants new inspiration? Who do you think we should invite? Oh, God, there are so many. I mean, every single one. my partners I think you should talk to. I mean, I think Abbott Miller just is an amazing creator for a long period of time with a bounty of interesting work in a lot of different areas.

1:22:57And I think he'd be good to talk to. And that's a pentagram one. Outside of pentagram, Tony Brooke. Tony Brooke's painting now. I don't know if you've seen them. They're great. I mean, He was always a spectacular designer. The business with Adrian is really over. He's still doing books on his own, but the painting is just a whole breakthrough. And he's got, he also does very community active things, you know, like he'll host evening discussions about another artist. And I just think he's amazing.

1:23:33Paula Scher: So there's your London guy. You don't have to travel for that one. Definitely, that's a good recommendation. And the last question we have is, Paula, if you could change one thing in the world, what would it be? I'd like to get rid of Donald Trump. That's what I'd change. We tried to stay out of politics, but it's impossible. I can't. I'm sorry. That has to be—you know, just get him out of here. Throw him out of power. I don't care where he lands, just not in the United States. oh wow thank you Paula this was such a joy to talk to you and obviously I feel like I've known you my whole life because I've been following your career my whole life and I admire you so much that for me this conversation is dream come true and I'm sure for many listeners and viewers this shows a different side of everything they've seen visually but gives a bit more of a backstory and the thinking behind it.

1:24:32Paula Scher: And just thank you so much for being you and being the inspiration for all of us. I remember when I was growing up and someone was saying, you want to do design, you want to be like Paula Sher. And at that point, I didn't know who Paula Sher was because I didn't know what design was. But the fact that you existed meant that I could exist. And I think that is so special. That's a lot of pressure. But I felt like you definitely created a path forward but for so many creatives, designers, and people in the industry. And seriously, thank you for all the work that you've done. And thank you for still finding time to share your wisdom and connect with the community and keep building this incredible ecosystem that we have.

1:25:13So thank you.

1:25:16Paula Scher: You're welcome. It's a pleasure. Anything you want to say, last words, anything people should check out, go see? What did I see that was terrific? I don't know. Virtually anything can be terrific. I love being in New York because I always see something I haven't seen before without trying. And that's what's great about city living. But the country is beautiful, too. That's beautiful. Well, thank you, Paula. And thank you, everyone, for listening. If you found this conversation interesting, please share anything that specifically you found insightful, provocative, inspiring. We always love hearing that feedback that helps us to create more interesting content and stories that you will all enjoy.

1:26:07Paula Scher: Feel free to tag Future London Academy so we can actually see what you liked. And as always, thank you for listening and until next time.

1:26:27immobilco.com

From the publisher

We visited Paula Scher at Pentagram’s New York office and talked about luck, power, partners, criticism and why so many designers stop growing. 


In the episode, you’ll hear:

🟡 How a stranger on a train helped her meet her design hero Seymour Chwast

🟡 What she’d advise designers in their 40s and 50s

🟡 What’s the secret to her best work


Ready to create a bigger impact with design? Learn more about our Executive Programme for Design Leaders at Future London Academy: https://fla.wiki/4BWUKU5

00:00 Meet Paula Scher, Pentagram Partner and One of the World's Most Influential Designers

01:34 Inside Pentagram's New York Studio

02:36 Story Behind Pentagram's In-House Kitchen

04:23 How Branding From Graphic Design Differs From Advertising

05:27 The Hidden Story Behind the Citi Logo

07:37 Inside Paula Scher's Typography Book Collection

09:24 Why Paula Scher Leads a Small Design Team

11:13 How Paula Met Her Hero Seymour Chwast

15:30 Typography Has Feeling

17:29 What Makes Some Designers More Successful Than Others

18:52 How a Lost Manuscript Became Paula Scher's Only Children's Book

22:25 How Paula Scher Broke Into the Record Industry

24:48 How One Poster Became the Brand Manual for The Public Theatre

29:10 Where a Creative Leader's Confidence Really Comes From

31:25 Cooking Is an Art

34:31 Is Design Career Success Luck or Hard Work

39:15 How to Win Clients When You Start Your Own Design Studio

43:16 Why Design Communities Are Weaker Than They Used to Be

46:28 Why Owning Your Own Studio Space Builds Confidence

50:04 How Big-Scale Pitches Changed the Design Industry

51:55 What Makes a Visual Identity Last for Decades

53:42 Designing the Iconic Windows Logo

55:31 The Swatch Poster Controversy

58:02 How Paula Scher Handled Public Criticism From Tibor Kalman

01:00:57 How Paula Scher Stays Hands-On as a Senior Creative Leader

01:02:19 The Three Types of Work That Keep Paula Scher Creative

01:04:17 Why Unpaid Projects Give Designers More Creative Control

01:07:04 Why Creative Leaders Need a Passion Outside Work

01:12:21 How Fashion Shapes the Way a Creative Leader Shows Up

01:14:21 Career Advice for Designers in Their 40s and 50s

01:18:11 How Paula Scher Turned Writing Into Design

01:22:05 The Designers You Should Learn From

01:23:34 The One Change Paula Scher Would Make to the World 

More from Creative Capes

All episodes