

Yes Apples builds a consumer-facing apple brand from a 100+ year parent company that serves 50+ multi-generational New York family farms; it focuses on variety-driven “rolling harvest,” vertical integration, and marketing apples as a “super fruit” with health and orchard-story benefits. It also covers go-to-market challenges in a saturated, low-brand apple category and how e-commerce/subscriptions help create new buying behavior.
Tenley Fitzgerald, Head of Marketing at Yes Apples. Background: previously worked in consumer/e-commerce marketing at FreshDirect (6+ years) and Blue Apron (nearly 2 years); started at Yes Apples as a freelance social media marketer ~7 years ago.
apples can be branded like modern CPG (lesson from lettuce innovation); controlled-atmosphere storage preserves taste from June to October; e-commerce enables full brand control and “orchard aroma” unboxing; subscription is the biggest driver of repeat purchase.
varieties spanning August to mid/late November (e.g., Sweet Tango, Evercrisp, Snapdragon); retailers including Costco, Walmart, Whole Foods, Sprouts, Wegmans; Food Lion and Sprouts carrying branded apples; Walmart.com launch planned; customer feedback about childhood memories after buying via private-label bag tags.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Kelly welcomes Tenley Fitzgerald to discuss Yes Apples and its unique brand story.
“Welcome back to a new episode of Emerging Brands Podcast with Kelly Bennett.”
Tenley shares the history of Yes Apples and the significance of New York farms.
“First, can you give us an overview of Yes Apples?”
Exploration of challenges and strategies in establishing a brand for apples.
“So after a few months of convincing, was able to launch Yes Apples, I worked with a brand consultant, worked on some naming, worked on some logos and colors, and then have been at the helm of the effort ever since.”
Discussion on educating consumers about apple varieties and health benefits.
“Because the example you shared of lettuce like Gotham Greens, I personally love shopping Gotham Greens.”
Tenley explains how e-commerce has become vital for Yes Apples’ success.
“I think it is, but by creating the skin super facing brand, we're trying to use these brand principles to say like, here's who's growing your food.”
Learn how Yes Apples leverages e-commerce to connect with consumers.
“So another sort of like thing that I didn't know was going to be an opportunity for us was actually e-commerce was D2C.”
Understand the challenges of competing with private label brands and marketing strategies.
“really cute thank you tote bag that said yes apples yeah I'm into this I love that this is like a whole feeling and a whole experience around eating apples, which I personally love apples.”
Discover key advice for emerging brands regarding team building and collaboration.
“Is there one thing you would just tell them to think about while going about it?”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On Emerging Brands Podcast, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00Tenley Fitzgerald: Welcome to the Emerging Brands Podcast with Kelly Bennett. This is the podcast to discover stories behind your new favorite CPG brands. Each episode brings you behind the scenes of the brand and founder story, learn what sets them apart in the marketplace, and their strategy going to market. We talk about plans for growth, practical advice for an emerging brand founder, and where to shop products that are making waves in food, beverage, wellness, beauty, and beyond. You'll also hear from industry experts, brand builders, investors, and operators you should absolutely have on your radar if you're building a CPG brand today.
0:44Tenley Fitzgerald: I'm your host, Kelly Bennett, a Brooklyn-based brand strategist with a front row seat of what makes an emerging CPG brand stand out. Whether you're building a brand of your own or love supporting what's next, you're in the right place. This episode was made possible by our sponsor, Hummingbirds. Hummingbirds is a platform that connects everyday small creators with brands that drive user-generated content, build buzz at specific retailers, and captures competitive market share. It's a tool that I recommend to all of my clients that you should absolutely check out. Head to hummingbirds.com for all the details.
1:27Tenley Fitzgerald: Now let's dive into the new episode. Hi everyone. Welcome back to a new episode of Emerging Brands Podcast with Kelly Bennett. You've probably seen on my Instagram stories me posting a lot of pictures of me eating apples and dipping it into Wintrick Pony peanut butter because I got this really gorgeous delivery of Yes Apples. And Tenley Fitzgerald, head of marketing of Yes Apples, is on the podcast today. And I'm so excited to talk apples and building a consumer-facing brand around apples. What a cool concept. Thank you, Kelly. Great to be here. You're so welcome. First, can you give us an overview of Yes Apples?
2:12Tenley Fitzgerald: I know that the growing behind the apples has been around for a hundred years to my understanding, but also creating the Yes Apples brand is still relatively new. So could you give us a background of how this all came to be? Yes. It's a very interesting spot. I recently learned a couple of years ago about the term intrapreneur, which is sort of somebody who works within the confines of an existing business and then creates new elements of the business. And when I learned of this, it felt like it unlocked my identity because I've sort of done this at several businesses today, but certainly the biggest at Yes Apples.
2:55The parent company has been around for over a hundred years. It's taken sort of many forms over that time, but for more than 20, 25 years, it's really been this sort of behind the scenes entity where we're sort of the central hub to 50 plus multi-generational family farms in New York. Our apples are exclusively grown in New York state. And we work with these multi-generational farms that are anywhere from three to eight generations. These are families who literally live within the confines of their orchards. They walk out of their front door and they're surrounded by apple orchards. Their packing houses is, you know, just adjacent to their homes.
3:34They truly like eat, breathe and sleep their business and their product. And so our company sort of sits in the middle of that whole group. And we help with sales and marketing, logistics, packing. We're really working closely with growers on what they forecast, what they're planting, what are, you know, consumer trends. Should they stop planting, you know, bread delicious and plant more sweet tango, that type of thing. And so they've been doing this work excellently in partnership with each other for years. I came on board about seven years ago and was just a freelance social media gal. I had a full-time job otherwise, was asked to start social media and very quickly realized I didn't have something to market.
4:20I had always been in consumer marketing from Fresh Tract and Blue Apron and a chocolate company, and that was my sort of bread and butter. So I went to Kari, the CEO and owner, and said, I really think that we have an opportunity here to provide connection to consumers with these apples. I mean, you don't really meet too many people that don't love apples. So let's give them something to love about apples even more. Let's also give some credit to the growers behind the scenes. There was no vehicle to show their faces, to tell their stories, to talk about their growing processes. And particularly with local produce being sort of the big win that it is, I felt like there was a really untapped opportunity to really highlight New York and what these growers were doing.
5:04And they're so, you know, deep rooted in New York state agriculture to really lean into that aspect as well. So after a few months of convincing, was able to launch Yes Apples, I worked with a brand consultant, worked on some naming, worked on some logos and colors, and then have been at the helm of the effort ever since. And it's been a very interesting road, much more so than I ever could have imagined. If you're familiar with the produce category, there are brands now. There were not many brands five to seven years ago. And even still, there were not many, there still are not many brands in apples.
5:42One category that I always like to highlight is the lettuce category. When I was first starting out in my career about 15 years ago, the lettuce category was like heads of iceberg lettuce and maybe some bagged lettuce from Dole. Now you look at that category and it's completely blown out. There's Bowery Farms, there's Gotham Greens, there's Brightlands, there's so many, there's so much innovation, there's so many new different types of lettuces. And so that category literally went from no brand and no diversity or innovation to what it is today. So that's sort of been my North Star in a way is if lettuce can do it, soak in apples.
6:22And so, you know, a lot of people, a lot of brands rather in the produce industry have really popped into the scene over the past few years. And then you sort of have your legacy brands like Driscoll or Sunkissed or Chiquita that have been around forever, but there is sort of emergence of newer brands. There is some emulation of what you're seeing in center store and dairy. And so I've really been trying to wear a CPG hat in a sort of non-CPG category and really leverage the tools and strategy of those other areas of store and apply them to apples.
6:55Tenley Fitzgerald: So cool. I love everything you just said. So as far as building a brand around apples, what was the strategy around getting people excited to shop a certain brand of apples, right? Because the example you shared of lettuce like Gotham Greens, I personally love shopping Gotham Greens. Like I feel like I understand what makes them different. I like the packaging. I like the quality. What was that thought process? Because you're also using products, what it sounds like from multiple different farms. So like, what was the thought process of building a brand that people would trust of like, they know the best of the best and how to explain that to people because probably they're not thinking about where exactly their apples were grown.
7:43I would love to hear your point of view. Yeah, it's been interesting from everything that you just described because it was putting a brand in a place where brands had never existed. And that was challenging from both the consumer and the retail side. The retail side, I'll just say quickly first, was that was really tough because a lot of the Apple buyers have tenure in this category. They've been selling, buying and selling apples for 20, 30 years. It was, it was definitely like a role where the person had been in it for a long time and it's what they knew. And that was it. And coming into that space and saying like, here's a whole new thing that you've never experienced or dealt with before.
8:25It was, it was, and has been challenging to get them to sort of shift their operation and to want to sell something more, which was sort of actually an error on our part in the beginning. We didn't do a great job to start with explaining that Yes Apples was actually in service to the category and in service to the buyer in addition to the consumer, of course. But sort of the idea there, the strategy there was that there's actually a ton of saturation in the apple category. There are so many different varieties and a lot of people know what they know and they stick with it. So if you're a Fuji eater, you stick with Fuji.
9:04If you're a Honeycrisp feeder, you just like go to the category and you find your Honeycrisp. But there are so many new apple varieties like Sweet Tango, Evercrisp, Snapdragon, Rape. Like there's so many. And so when we initially went to the buyer, they felt like, yes, apples was one more thing they had to sell in an already saturated category. And so what we've really tried to do in learning from that was streamline that messaging and say, actually, we're here to help you. We're here to help you and the consumer cut through the noise. and by telling our consumer facing story, which I'll get to in a minute, that's really creating this loyalty and this tie to the consumers so that they know that yes, apples is quality consistently.
9:45It is from New York. It is a woman owned business and it is coming from family firms that they can feel good about supporting. And so we sort of did a misstep in the beginning. We worked really hard to like, you know, correct that. And then from the consumer side, it's a lot of what I just said. It's like apples traditionally, we're just like, I'm just picking up an apple. It doesn't have any sort of emotional connection to me, but it's yummy. Like it fulfills my snack itch. Maybe it's good for me. I don't really know. I think it is, but by creating the skin super facing brand, we're trying to use these brand principles to say like, here's who's growing your food.
10:20It's in your backyard. If you're sort of in the Northeast or East coast, um, and using sort of like all the brand principles that your typical CBG brand would use to connect, to connect to this piece of fruit. Sort of layered on top of that is also highlighting the health benefits and having a vehicle to do that. Again, a lot of people from our consumer research, they know that apples are good for them, but they don't know exactly why. And they're actually very good for you. And so they're packed with, you know, antioxidants, they have kercetin, they're really, they provide a lot of hydration.
10:56They're almost 85 % water. So you can almost swap eating an apple for drinking a glass of water to get your hydration. So there's a lot of, there's a lot packed into this sort of super fruit that that name sort of became ubiquitous and sort of overused, but it truly does apply to apples. So again, using the vehicle of a consumer facing brand to talk about what the benefits of this fruit are as well.
11:18Tenley Fitzgerald: Something I found really interesting when I unboxed my beautiful delivery of apples was that I had apples in, you know, late May, early June because of the different types of varieties and when they're grown. I thought that was really interesting. That really blew my mind. Can you give me more of like educating consumers on that as well? Yeah, it's both that, Kelly. It's both that we have, you know, we grow over 10 to 15 varieties depending on the grower. And by the way, Kari, the owner of the company, she's a part owner in one of our farms and two of our packing facilities. So in a small margin of our operations, we are completely vertically integrated.
12:04But then we work with all these other partners as well. But there are, you know, because there are so many varieties, there are varieties that come off the trees in August. and so you're sort of able to hit that start of back to school messaging with sort of this like quintessential back to school item and then we have varieties that come off the trees as late as late November mid to late November and so that span allows us to sort of have this ongoing rolling harvest season of all these different varieties that have different taste profiles that have different eating attributes and so it's sort of like this always on always new sort of season for us, those, those kind of four months.
12:43And then beyond that, when you're eating a piece of fruit in June, it's because it's been in atmosphere, controlled atmosphere storage, which is actually perfectly set to keep the apple intact exactly as it's meant to be as soon as it comes off the tree. And so with sort of these bigger retailers that are asking for more fruit longer, we've really been able to lean into this technology and give people apples that taste exactly the same as they would in October as they do in June. And so it's been this huge technological opportunity for us to be able to provide fruit longer than outside our normal season at the same quality that it would be in peak season.
13:28Tenley Fitzgerald: And domestically, right? Because you're in upstate New York and you're able to preserve, it sounds like, or keep them fresh so that you have that consistent supply chain. That's really cool. That's really interesting. How has it been on the consumer side as far as, you know, get your apples from yes apples and this is why it's important or this is why this is a better option? Like what has been the messaging that you find is really resonating with consumers today? So another sort of like thing that I didn't know was going to be an opportunity for us was actually e-commerce was D2C. When I initially pitched this idea, it was just to cut through the noise and everything that I just said in store in brick and mortar.
14:21And then because I came from the world of e-commerce, I was at Fresh Direct for over six years and I was at Blue Apron for almost two. That was sort of my bread and butter was e-commerce. And so I quickly decided we should to unlock that opportunity for us as well. And so we've actually had a ton of success with e-commerce and there it allows us to truly directly connect to the consumer, which is something that was always so special about Fresh Direct. And so that's been a huge unlock. And what's made that even more special is that we are up against private label in a lot of our key retailers in produce where even if it's in a pre-existing relationship or it's a new relationship, if the whole category decides to go private label, we often are sort of beholden to that decision and we don't have a lot of muscle at this point.
15:13The hope, the true hope is that as we get bigger, we'll be able to like stand up against those decisions and say, no, we have this really great thing going and this is why we can, you know, bring in more traffic to your store and have more volume and velocity and all the things, but we're not there yet. But that's the hope. But anyway, so that's been a challenge for us is because if we are in a private label situation, typically in those cases, we only have the marketing real estate of the PLU sticker that's on the Apple. Or if it's in a bag, we have what's called like a, you know, like those bread tags, they look like there's like a little flag on the end of the bread tags.
15:49And those denote our, our brand to the consumer. And actually from both of those vehicles, despite what we might have thought, we've actually gotten a ton of feedback. Like I bought your, you know, apples in private label bag and Walmart, but I saw your tag. I wrote into the website. These are the best apples I've ever had. They make me think of my childhood in upstate New York. Now I live in North Carolina. We've gotten a lot of that feedback and it's been incredible. But the reason I brought up e-commerce is because there we control the brand. It's fully branded. We control that experience with our customers.
16:20And there, we've also just been able to really see what a difference this brand has made and how we can connect with consumers. And I'd be curious to know if you had this experience, Kelly, when you opened your box. But one of the biggest pieces of feedback that we get when people receive our apples is that when they open the box, they're sort of overcome with this aroma of apples because it's all been locked in this box and it kind of wafts out. and time and time again, we've had the feedback that people feel like they're walking into an orchard and it feels a little, you know, cliche and hokey, but we, we sort of love it.
16:55And we've tried to lean into that because we feel like it's a way for us to bring the orchard to you. And particularly with a lot of specialty varieties that don't have the widespread distribution that a gala or a honey crisp has, having the e-commerce opportunity, sorry, option really allows for this sort of mass always on distribution. So if you're in the center of the country and you can't reach a sweet tango from your local grocer, you can get it from Yes Apples and that can be a really nice opportunity for them. So it's been interesting, the sort of dual nature of the business, whether brick and mortar or e-commerce, there's benefits to both, there's challenges to both, but having sort of this 360 awareness and play and opportunity has been been helpful in the overall goal of
17:42Tenley Fitzgerald: achieving this I definitely had a cool experience unboxing these gorgeous apples it came with a really cute thank you tote bag that said yes apples yeah I'm into this I love that this is like a whole feeling and a whole experience around eating apples, which I personally love apples. And they were really, really great apples. As far as getting the word out for people to not just grab the apples they find in their local grocery store, that's probably subpar for being honest. Yeah. Yeah. What was the thing that really helped them create this new behavior of going out of their way and buying this type of apples and like getting, okay, I'm going to be loyal to my apples, right?
18:35Tenley Fitzgerald: And kind of like removing it from their regular grocery list to buy yes apples. I'm just so curious because it's really cool how you did it. I feel like that behavior is what we're seeing more on the e-commerce side. I feel like because of the private label barrier, it's been harder to train and to really leverage that behavior in store. I will say that there are some retailers like Food Lion, which is sort of like southeast coast of the U.S., excuse me, or Sprouts, excuse me, that have a wide array of our branded apples. People are going into those stores and they are buying Yes Apples. We're doing sharper marketing with those retailers to highlight Yes Apples.
19:19And so it's sort of boots on the ground sort of strategy that you would be applying to any launching brand in-store. But the e-commerce space, that's where I feel like we've really changed the behavior of people who are buying apples because they're making a cognitive decision to come to an online source that is outside of their typical shopping habit to buy these apples. And we have subscription. We have a subscription model on our site where you can buy apples and get them delivered two, three or four weeks. And we have, that's the most success that we see is all the people that are signed up for our subscription.
19:57You get a slight discount, but it's also something that's recurring and you don't even have to worry about it. And that was a huge unlock for us as well. Because it just allowed this, allowed Yes Apples to very seamlessly just like integrate into these people's shopping habits and eating habits. So that's where, yeah, that's where it's been the biggest opportunity, the brick and mortar. I mean, truly everything that we're doing and actually I don't want to speak. I'm not going to share exactly what these two things are, but we just had two very big opportunities come to us for, yes, Apple's branded product in private label stores.
20:36but it's because we're partnering with those retailers in a way that we're bringing innovation and new items to the category that they don't have in their private label. And so that's also something where it's like, how can I be a solution to a problem that you have so that, yes, Apples is the vehicle for that solution and that you wouldn't go to somebody else or you wouldn't go to private label because it's something outside of that space. And so that's been a really strategic part of what I'm trying to do, particularly in the brick and mortar space, so that they can't say no to us. Yes, they have to say yes.
21:12They have to say yes.
21:13Tenley Fitzgerald: Before I let you go, I would love to hear, like, what is a quick piece of advice for someone who's building a consumer facing brand and maybe is doing it in a category that is maybe a new behavior that people would go out of their way to purchase this particular brand or this particular item? Is there one thing you would just tell them to think about while going about it? Yeah. For a long time, technically, I'm the only person on the marketing team in my organization. I have a right-hand gal that I hired four years ago when I went out on my first maternity leave, And she was brought on to like keep things afloat while I was out.
21:59And then I never let her go, but she's still like a part-time freelance sort of figure. So I'm the only marketing person on the payroll at my company. And for a long time, I sort of thought, and I think that that could be the case in a lot of like small startup businesses where you have to wear a lot of hats. Like, and so for a long time, I sort of like wrote high on that and was a little bit like, I'm doing this thing all by myself. And it felt good to like be this like lone soldier. and then I like quickly realized that that was not correct and that you do need a team and that you can very quickly be in an echo chamber you can very quickly not have somebody to bounce ideas off of like it gets very lonely and very challenging very quickly and so then I just started hiring friends peers people that I had worked with before and I surrounded myself with people that could actually help me execute and get to the goal I needed.
22:52So I think that there, for me, at least there was sort of this like misperception of what it meant to be the only person on the marketing team. At first it felt like sexy and cool. Like I was doing this like crazy pioneering, you know, Joan Arbor type of thing. And then I was like, actually it's better when you have a team. And even if I can't have that full time, full staff internally, I can make that team become, you know, my, my counsel and my, my partners in crime. And so that's my, that's been my biggest takeaway is hire people that, you know, that can do the work. I've also have several people in my circle right now that I just like cold called on Instagram and LinkedIn that I was like, I see what you're doing.
23:33I really appreciate it. How can I leverage what you're doing for this place with me? And I mean, I have a 10 out of 10 success rate so far. Everybody's like, yes, I'd love to do that. Especially when you're doing something sort of new and different, like trying to brand apples. I think there's an allure there as well. But just reach out, ask questions, ask for help. People are typically always willing to help. And don't try to do it alone. That's a great piece of advice. That's a great piece of advice.
24:03Tenley Fitzgerald: Well, I know you have to get back to work. And thank you so much for your time and energy. Thank you, Kelly. One last question. Can people just go to your website to start trying the apples? Yeah, please, please. Yes. Yes. Apples dot com. We're also in Costco, Walmart, Whole Foods, Sprouts, Wegmans with certain varieties in the fall. We're launching something special on Walmart dot com this fall. So be sure to check that out. But yes. Yes. Apples dot com will always be on. Thank you so much. All right, everyone, go stock up on your apples and I'll see you on the next episode. Bye.
25:06Tenley Fitzgerald: and one you should absolutely check out. Head to hummingbirds.com for all the details. If you're new here, hi, I'm Kelly Bennett, a Brooklyn-based brand strategist working with first-time CPG food and beverage founders. I have a front row seat of what makes an emerging CPG brand stand out because you're not just building a product, you are building a brand. And you wanna make sure that is one that consumers love and retailers remember. That's where I come in. I've recently advised brands like Frankly Good Coffee, She's the Sauce, a new non-alcoholic cocktail line that's coming to market soon, and a hormone-conscious deodorant because food-adjacent brands count too.
25:53Tenley Fitzgerald: If you are bringing a new product to market, please reach out at withkellybennett.com. Thank you so much for listening and sharing. You can follow me on Instagram at withkellybennett, and you can follow the show at Emerging Brands Podcast. Thank you again, and I'll see you on the next episode.
In this episode, I'm joined by Tenley Fitzgerald, Vice President of Marketing at Yes! Apples—a bold, modern apple brand with deep roots in New York agriculture. With over 100 years in the apple business, Yes! Apples is a network of 50+ family farms growing more than 10 high-quality varieties—and stands out as the only female-run apple organization in the country.
Tenley began working with the team as a freelancer in 2017 and ultimately led the charge to take the Yes! Apples brand from concept to consumer launch. Since then, she's built a powerhouse in-house marketing team and brought apples into the lifestyle and CPG conversation—partnering with brands like Martinelli's and Ithaca Hummus, and showcasing the brand at Pop Up Grocer and Cherry Bombe Jubilee. With past experience at FreshDirect, Blue Apron, and Beyond Good, Tenley brings a deep understanding of integrated marketing, storytelling, and brand building in food.
How Tenley transformed Yes! Apples from a traditional grower network into a national lifestyle apple brand
The strategy behind turning apples into an experience
Advice for brand marketers looking to evolve heritage categories with a fresh, modern voice
Hummingbirds is a platform that connects everyday, smaller creators with brands to share in-store user-generated content, drive brand awareness in specific retailers, and capture competitive market share. They're an awesome platform that I recommend to all my clients that you should absolutely check out. Go to hummingbirds.com for all the details.