In short
Debate over whether ClassPass/Playlist (Mindbody + ClassPass) helps or hurts boutique studio owners, including pricing pressure, capacity allocation, and “vicious cycle” discounting; also discussion of women’s underrepresentation in fitness leadership.
Guests (backgrounds)
- Jack Thomas: Co-founder of The Fit Guide; co-host; founder of Base in Bangkok; runs Fitness Business Asia; studies studio markets globally.
- Rachel Hirsch: Managing partner at Wellness Growth Ventures; host of the 2% Club; invests/advises wellness brands.
- Jeff Blatt: Shaped ClassPass/Playlist operations (pricing models, marketplace dynamics); Mindbody ClassPass integration context.
Key claims
- Jeff: ClassPass evolved from an “unlimited $99” model that competed on price to a credit-based marketplace; it fills unused spots and brings new audiences; data shows ~29% increase in total revenue after joining and minimal cannibalization.
- Rachel: Studios can become dependent; users use ClassPass as an “arbitrage” opportunity, perceiving $12/class as the true value; free trials (e.g., September) can devalue studios.
Notable examples
September free-month/trial rules; Netflix analogy; “Gym Loyalty Month” campaign urging members to skip ClassPass; Jack notes ClassPass booking UX vs studios’ hard-to-book schedules; Rachel’s LA yoga example of prior ClassPass users buying a non-ClassPass package only when ClassPass pricing wasn’t available.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.
Chapters
Tap a time to open that second in VOIntroduction to ClassPass Debate
0:00 to 0:37
The hosts set the stage for the discussion on ClassPass and its impact on studios.
“Adding another person on a mat where you're mat to mat or slightly on top of each other is commonplace.”
Exploring ClassPass's Impact
0:37 to 4:53
A deep dive into the various perspectives on ClassPass, its history, and its evolution.
“I'm joined with Jack Thomas, all the way from Bangkok, and Mo Iqbal from, I don't know where.”
ClassPass's Business Model Evolution
4:53 to 5:56
Discussion of how ClassPass transformed its business model over the years.
“With that, Jack, I will pass it off to you.”
Insights from Jeff Bladt on ClassPass
5:56 to 10:44
Jeff Bladt discusses the origins of ClassPass and its journey to becoming a major player.
“I don't own a software company and I don't want a studio.”
Rachel Hirsch's Perspective on ClassPass
10:44 to 12:22
Rachel shares her views on ClassPass's effects on the fitness ecosystem as a consumer and studio owner.
“You mentioned our partnership with WeWork.”
Rachel's Studio Experience with ClassPass
12:22 to 14:00
Discussion on the relationship between ClassPass and yoga studios from Rachel's viewpoint.
“I think overall, though, there is massive benefit of growing the ecosystem.”
The Impact of Free ClassPass Month
14:00 to 14:36
Discussion on how ClassPass's free month affects studio owners and their revenue.
“It's a free month basically for ClassPass.”
Challenges and Solutions for Studios
14:36 to 16:37
Exploration of studio owners’ concerns about ClassPass and potential solutions.
“For me, I feel, from a studio owner's perspective, the first free class seems kind of fair.”
ClassPass as a Two-Sided Marketplace
16:37 to 18:51
Understanding ClassPass's role as a marketplace benefiting both consumers and studios.
“So we've invested heavily in making it truly what it's been designed to do, bring new people into the studios.”
Industry Comparisons and Dependency
18:51 to 22:48
Comparison of ClassPass dynamics with challenges faced by other industries.
“I'm in constant conversations with dozens of partners every month.”
Show all 22 chapters
The Vicious Cycle of Pricing and ClassPass
22:48 to 25:18
Discussion about the pricing issues related to ClassPass and studio perceptions.
“I viewed it as a symbolic pushback to what many saw as almost an unhealthy dependency on third-party platforms.”
ClassPass's Role in Market Access
25:18 to 28:00
Debate on ClassPass's potential to expand access to fitness and its implications.
“And just to add some perspective, when I look at ClassPass, SilverSneakers, Medicare Advantage have been heavily involved in advocacy to get the FID Act passed through.”
ClassPass Utilization and Perception
28:00 to 28:50
Discussing the impact of ClassPass on studio utilization and competition.
“Do you think ClassPass should do more to helping govern utilization and usage?”
Revenue Impact of ClassPass
28:50 to 30:50
Exploring how ClassPass affects studio revenue and business growth.
“So the misconception is ClassPass is sending would-be full paid riders or attendees for less money.”
Personal Anecdotes on ClassPass
30:50 to 33:00
Sharing personal experiences and potential cannibalization of studio revenue.
“And for every user that we find that fits that pattern, we find two that start on ClassPass and BookDirect.”
Consumer Perspective on ClassPass
33:00 to 35:30
Debating whether consumers benefit from ClassPass offerings.
“We've had over 20 in two days buy this package who were previous ClassPass users.”
Challenges and Misuse of ClassPass
35:30 to 36:40
Discussing the potential misuse of ClassPass by studios and its implications.
“And I don't think this is ClassPass's fault, but I think you need to talk to, or we need to address sort of how many studios end up using it, which is they end up releasing too many slots.”
ClassPass's Role in Studio Success
36:40 to 38:40
Analyzing the factors that lead to success or failure for studios using ClassPass.
“Like I can count on one hand the number of times you've ever paid a studio out and said, yep, you're the edge case.”
Women in Fitness Leadership
38:40 to 41:20
Addressing the underrepresentation of women in fitness leadership roles.
“business, they're putting on a great class, they're investing in growing, that are building a great community, a welcoming place.”
Elevating Women's Voices in Fitness
41:20 to 44:20
Discussing strategies to enhance women's representation in fitness leadership.
“of saying part of the reason I would call it ringing the bell or however you want to describe, you know, the conversations that I've been having around ClassPass is because of exactly what you're saying.”
The Role of the 2% Club
44:20 to 48:03
The benefits and collaborative efforts of the 2% Club, a group focused on empowering women in wellness.
“Yeah, I actually really value and appreciate you saying that and really hearing because the 2 % Club is a group of a couple hundred wellness leaders, operators, founders that are 99 % female in our group.”
Final Thoughts on ClassPass and Studio Strategies
48:03 to 52:10
Panelists share insights on how studios can effectively balance their relationship with ClassPass to enhance their business.
“We love having even men come to the table.”
Transcript
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.0:00Adding another person on a mat where you're mat to mat or slightly on top of each other is commonplace. You can't do that in a reformer studio. You make no money off the trials. As do we. We don't make any money off of the trial participants either. But that's a choice that you're making on our behalf. We offer a few classes up on ClassPass. Students then think that$12 a class is actually what the class should be valued at instead of$36. They will never come back to pay at the studio. We as studio owners become more and more reliant, and it just becomes this sort of vicious circle.
0:36Matthew Januszek:Welcome to this week's episode of Lifts. And today, we've got two co-hosts. I'm joined with Jack Thomas, all the way from Bangkok, and Mo Iqbal from, I don't know where. Where are you today? Are you back home? I'm back home. I'm in Arlington, Virginia. back home. But we do have a special episode of Lifts today. And Matthew, as you mentioned, really privileged to be doing this in partnership with the Fit Guide podcast and also talking about what has been, I think, an often talked about topic. It kind of ebbs and flows at times controversial topic, which is ClassPass. And ClassPass has been through many iterations.
1:18And over the past decade, ClassPass has been celebrated in a lot of cases as a powerful customer acquisition tool. It has also been criticized as a race to the bottom. But ultimately, it's been adopted by some of the biggest names in the industry, including brands like SoulCycle, which initially were actually not supportive of ClassPass. As Matt, as you know, I started working with SoulCycle all the way back in 2015. And at the time, as we were working through strategy and digital, we never even considered ClassPass to be something that we would ever consider implementing, but here we are. I think, love it or hate it, ClassPass has truly reshaped how consumers discover, book, and experience boutique fitness.
2:05And now, under MindBody, recently rebranded it as Playlist. Its influence has only continued to grow. And I'm also just for the audience. I am also the chief strategy officer at ABC Fitness. And in that, we are actively working on a ClassPass partnership as well. So I just want to put that out there for this group and for the audience. The reality, as at least I've seen it, is that class pass is just really one factor in what is a much larger story. Batiks truthfully have faced headwinds, largely leading from shifting consumer preferences. We saw the pandemic pull forward a lot of the changes in preferences.
2:45Some of the ones that I'm calling attention to are the decline of hit that we've seen and the decline of cycling. These are some of the obvious ones, the rise of Pilates, the rise of strength training. At the same time, you're dealing with rises in rents and wages and insurance costs and all the non-tangibles that might always not be obvious. And candidly, I have the privilege of speaking to a lot of small business owners and running a small business has never been easy. The question has really been is what role have aggregators contributed to in either playing or hurting the journey? And in that, we can include aggregators such as WellPaths and WellHub and ClassPass.
3:25So this is a topic that we could talk about for hours. We've only got about 40 minutes here. But to unpack this, we brought together a powerhouse. It's the first time we've had as many guests on Lyfts in our history. And we're excited to have you all on. But kicking things off with Jack Thomas, who's a co-founder of The Fit Guide and also co-host in this podcast. He's also the founder of Base in Bangkok, host of Fitness Business Asia, and also Five Star Fitness. He brings a global view of what's happening inside studios and across markets worldwide. And if you don't follow him, I encourage you to follow him and take a look at his research reports.
3:59And we've covered Jack as a guest on this podcast many times. Next, we have Rachel Hirsch, who is the managing partner at Wellness Growth Ventures and host of the 2 % Club. Well, Rachel sits at the intersection of capital and culture and is investing in wellness brands and advising founders on how to scale and survive in a very competitive landscape. And finally, Jeff Blatt, I've met many people at MindBody ClassPass Playlist over the years, but Jeff, you and I have not had the pleasure of making our acquaintance. Playlist is the combined platform of MindBody and ClassPass. and Jeff, you've been there and been central in shaping how Claspers operates from pricing models to marketplace dynamics.
4:39So we're excited to get your perspective on how aggregators are evolving. Today, we're going to explore the positives, the negatives, and more importantly, how boutique owners can make smart choices in a world where aggregators are really becoming the norm and not the exception. With that, Jack, I will pass it off to you. Yeah, well, we've been talking about this topic, Mo, privately, and I've done some LinkedIn posts about it. And it's really sparked some very interesting conversation. People definitely feel very passionate about it. I mean, ClassPass has been around for a long time, I think probably over a decade, and it's been for a few evolutions in that time.
5:15I know Matthew, before we went live, said he wanted to kind of dig into that a little bit more, kind of its journey and how it's become what it has today. You know, it has a big influence on boutique fitness, for sure. They now go into other areas. They have a new partnership with WeWork. They do work with big box gyms as well. So I think it's something that really can't be ignored. I think it's an incredibly important conversation to have. And I think every single, especially boutique fitness junior, and it really needs to understand exactly how ClassPass works, how can it make the most of it, and hopefully use it to its advantage rather than have it negatively affect the business.
5:47Unfortunately, it does seem like there's a lot of people at the moment that really feel like it's not a positive influence on the market. So yeah, really important topic, really excited to dig into it.
5:55Matthew Januszek:I feel as I'm a little bit of an outsider. I don't own a software company and I don't want a studio. But I am aware of the brand ClassPass. I think we've had people from ClassPass on over the years. And probably first question to you, Jeff, which, you know, just to provide a little context for people that are not, you know, superly in touch with the business, is tell us a little bit about, you know, when ClassPass started, what was the real problem that they aimed to solve then? And how would you probably describe the evolution as to where they are today? Sure. And thanks for having me on. So ClassPass started, I think, under like a classivity name 10 years ago in New York City.
6:36And sort of Pyle Kadacki founded the company on a basic insight that it was really hard, especially 10 years ago, to discover a place to work out at a time that was convenient. She was working in Manhattan, tons of studios, probably the densest studio footprint. in the United States, and she still struggled to find what she wanted when she wanted. And she thought there must be sort of a platform that could help with this. Her initial sort of insight was that discovery was hard, and you could work with studios, and she thought they would be a great lead generation for those studio partners. So started in Manhattan, and what she discovered is people would sign up, and then you could go to one visit to all these studios at a negotiated rate, and then she thought she'd be able to pass them off as leads, and that would be the business.
7:21But that last part never really took off in that burst. You saw that users really liked the variety, and they really liked making it easier to discover things, and that was really motivating. But they weren't sticky after that. They were sort of a different type of user. And sort of during this early part of ClassPass, they sort of iterated on how users engaged, and they hit upon then the unlimited model. I think it was$99, and you could go to all the classes you want. It was sort of a magic product. It sold itself. and the product really took off at this one. So the initial sort of, you know, go to one studio, try them all, that thing had very low user adoption and sent very little sort of booking behavior to our studio partners.
8:04But the unlimited model sort of marketed itself and, you know, truth be told, when you're selling dollars for pennies, that's a really easy business model. You don't have to do a lot of marketing. It's magic. And that was the business model for maybe only two years. I think a lot of people think it lasted much longer, sort of was what brought us into the ecosystem. I mean, I joined sort of right at the tail end of that eight years ago to ClassPass, so 2017, 2018. And at that moment, internally, we knew it was just a flawed business model. It didn't work for our studio partners at that point. I think it would be fair to characterize ClassPass with its unlimited model as being directly competitive.
8:43We were putting pricing pressure on the market. We were competing directly on price. And we're forcing studios potentially to lower their prices because we have this$99 price point that we're out there banning the drum on. And studios were hesitant to put all their inventory on ClassPass, so it was limiting their monetization. Users would flood to our most popular studios because there was no prices on anything. There were no marketplace dynamics. And so that ended up being bad for users as well. The most popular classes were impossible to get into. They were frustrated and rightly so. Popular times, their instructors wouldn't get listed.
9:15It just didn't work for a lot of studios, so we didn't have enough partners. And then obviously as a business selling dollars for pennies, you only can do that for so long. So we moved away from the unlimited model and sort of transitioned first to sort of you get 10 classes for$99, eventually where we are today, which is a marketplace model, which is users get credits. And then the classes inside the model have various credit prices that sort of correspond to the negotiated rate with our partners. So we moved away from this sort of let's compete on price. And we sort of dialed in on that initial insight, which was there's a different audience out there interested in fitness.
9:52And when we're at our best to our studio partners, we're filling spots they weren't going to sell. I think across the industry, 60 plus percent of spots go unfilled in fitness. And that's still the stat today when we look at it across our ecosystem. So it's spots they weren't going to sell. And there's a lot of those to users they weren't going to reach. And so we look at who does ClassPass bring in, roughly half of the users that ClassPass brings in have never been to a group class before. So we really tailor our marketing to bring in a new audience. And then we look at even the ones that have been before, are they discovering new things or are we just sending back the same user for less?
10:26And 94 % of the users that ClassPass brings in are going to new studios. And so there's only a very small amount of that behavior, which is a user using ClassPass to basically do what they were doing before, but for less. And so today that sort of, you know, class passes sort of where we are in that evolution journey. And then I think if you look ahead, we've moved into spa and salon services. You mentioned our partnership with WeWork. We have a partnership with AMC Theaters in a few states. We have smoothie restaurants to go. And we're looking at ways to sort of keep users engaged, especially during those oscillating moments of motivation with fitness.
11:02How do we pull them into the next cycle so they can continue booking and continue sending revenue?
11:08Matthew Januszek:So next question to Rachel then. What was it, how would you describe the landscape pre-ClassPass when they came onto the market? And then maybe where you think that the area is, the space is today.
11:25Well, transparently, I'm not old enough to really tell you much before. But I will tell you that I was a consumer when ClassPass came onto the market. And that$99 in Manhattan was the best thing that ever happened to me as a consumer for so many reasons. Where I see it now is really, I guess, where I'll tell you my perspective, because I think that's where I can add, contribute the most. ClassPass is a two-sided marketplace that has helped the fitness space and the wellness space broadly grow, undoubtedly. I am a proponent of ClassPass, albeit my LinkedIn post may say something slightly different.
12:07Overall, I think ClassPass has a brilliant effect on the overall ecosystem. I think that it has pivoted and adjusted in a variety of ways, which have in turn negatively impacted certain players in the market. I think overall, though, there is massive benefit of growing the ecosystem. And I think that's, as Jeff alluded to, really the crux of what ClassPass is. It grows the ecosystem. It brings in players who wouldn't be signing up to go to Barry's Bootcamp or wherever it may be. I guess the more pointed piece of my opinion and my data is really just a two-sided marketplace needs to be supportive of both sides of said ecosystem.
12:50And there are times, not at all times, that there are regulations in place which prevent those benefits to both sides. Interesting, Rachel. Good to hear your thoughts. Am I correct in saying that you have a yoga studio in LA? Is that right? On top of being a managing partner of Wellness Growth Ventures, I also co-own two yoga studios in Los Angeles. Okay, cool. So can you tell us a bit more about your relationship with ClassPass now through that yoga studio? How, from a studio perspective, do you feel like ClassPass serves you? And overall, I guess, would you say it's a net positive or a net negative?
13:23My relationship with ClassPass from a B2B side began when I spent time in Exponential Fitness. And I have dealt with various partners from that side beginning then. There are points in time, like I said, where I think it's incredibly advantageous. A yoga studio is vastly different than a reformer studio. I always say there's always room in yoga. And so adding another person on a mat where you're mat to mat or slightly on top of each other is commonplace. You can't do that in a reformer studio. So my perspective is even more niche. Do I think that there are pieces? It's September. Perfect example.
14:09It is September. It's a free month basically for ClassPass. Studios don't get paid on those members. But I will give you in recent years you have changed it that is really only for free members or for new members. It used to be September was such a hard month because everyone and their mother was signing up for the month free of ClassPass. But they have, again, put in more rules in place to make it less challenging for studios that are then filling their spots with all free spots. I can back up a little bit if there might be listeners who are unfamiliar with what I'm saying, if that's helpful.
14:41For me, I feel, from a studio owner's perspective, the first free class seems kind of fair. I mean, when it was introduced to me, when it was explained to me, it was basically saying, look, ClassPass is in trouble. It's before the mind-body acquisition, you know, difficult time. It was something that they basically needed to do. And I was like, look, fair enough. And what they said as well is that, you know, studios often give a free trial anyway. So it's kind of what most studios do, which I don't think is really true anymore. I think most boutique studio owners feel that a free trial is kind of devaluing what they do.
15:12So that for me, from a studio owner perspective, kind of put me at odds with this whole sort of quote unquote partnership with ClassPass. I mean, Jeff, has that been sort of a common concern with studio partners? Yeah, I can maybe talk through the program here and then happy to field any specific questions. So I think you have the timing roughly correct. During the pandemic, sort of coming off of that deep trough, we pivot our business to really focus on how do we bring new people in and bring people back to studio fitness? You know, ClassPass, like the whole category, I think we saw like 90, 95 % of our reservation volume disappear overnight.
15:50And so you have a very scarce resource. How do you bring people back? And like so many industries, especially when you're trying to bring new people in, the best way to do it, we discovered at scale, is to give them a free visit. Netflix gives you a free week. You see this across platforms. Let someone try it. And this is how we discovered we could be not competing against our studio partners, but working with them. And so it's a free visit. The trials are typically two weeks. September is four weeks. The drum up interest is sort of the end of summer. But you can only go one time to any studio.
16:21So it's not as if it's a free pass to go to a studio unlimited times. It's once per studio. We put tremendous number of fraud protections in place. We're not perfect. We hate fraud as much as any studio does. We try to prevent studio users from creating multiple accounts, all of that behavior we hate. So we've invested heavily in making it truly what it's been designed to do, bring new people into the studios. Rachel, you have a question. Well, I guess I do have a question, if that's okay. You referenced Netflix. Netflix isn't a two-sided marketplace. And I think transparently where the most conversation when I've engaged with other studio owners really is, is the lack of ownership that then we have.
17:01You're making the choice for us. And that was a recent change. So if as a platform, it's challenging that you just decide processing fees, you decide that we have to offer up, we have to give up capacity for free.
17:19as a two-sided marketplace the other sides are users and so we're trying to also give a consistent user experience and for us at scale that means if a user is interested in class pass they're interested in trying boutique fitness for the first time they need to understand that during that trial the studios that are on class pass are going to be available if they have remnant spots they're taking a lot of trade-offs to come through class pass even to sign up for a free trial. They have to put down a credit card. It automatically rolls into a paid month. So there's a lot of things. And they have, you know, ClassPass has less generous late in this policy.
17:51So there's a lot of trade-offs they're accepting. But part of that for us is they need to be able to try the product as it would be once they're paying for it. So we make no money off the trials. We don't make any money off of the trial participants either. But that's a choice that you're making on our behalf. And that is not common with two-sided marketplaces. Yes, it's common for a Netflix or whomever, but again, you are taking away the ownership. And that was a change. And I think that's just the piece, that it was a change that you all made in your rules and regulations, really without any sort of advisory board or common conversation with us as the boutique studio owners.
18:29So even Lululemon, they have an ambassador management team where we have conversations with them all the time about how they can engage with us and how we can better engage with them. That is really the crux of sort of my kerfuffle with you all right now, that I think a much more open conversation can be had so that it can be truly beneficial for everyone at hand. Correct. And we worked very closely with studios when we made this transition. It wasn't made in a vacuum. I'm in constant conversations with dozens of partners every month. We have tons of studios that were very open and bounce ideas off.
19:00So this wasn't sort of arrived at in a vacuum. We looked very closely at the data. We had piloted it actually pre-pandemic as a more effective marketing technique for all parties on the marketplace. So it wasn't just sort of arrived at out of haste or sort of out of fiat. There's a difference between the various boot camps of the world and sub-five studio location owners. And I think the majority of the LA market that is participating in this September collaboration, let's call it, are sub-five location studio owners. and I think that's just, and primarily women. And I mean, even if we look at the demographics of this podcast, these are different types of conversations being had in rooms where we're, whether intentionally or not excluded from.
19:47I just want to provide a bit more context here on everything we're talking about. This is great discussion. Rachel, to your point, ClassPass is really a classic example of a two-sided marketplace. And just for the listeners to understand what that means is, as Jeff pointed out, on one side, you've got consumers, You've got people who want variety, flexibility, and price options. The same reason, Rachel, why you had loved it. I lived in New York as well and was a class-class consumer. On the other side, you've got boutique studios, businesses that want visibility, new clients, and incremental revenue, right?
20:21You just pointed out filling up the unused capacity. The interesting thing here, though, is that we're talking like this is a unique problem to fitness. The reality is that it's not unique to fitness. We've seen the same dynamic played in other industries. And I want to talk through that. As an example, I just have some notes that I pulled up here. In travel, you've got online agencies like Expedia and booking.com. Do you know they drive about 40 % of all U.S. hotel bookings and take 15 % to 25 % of commissions on each reservation? And that's why hotels then have rewards programs and other benefits to book directly with them.
20:55Restaurants, open table charges$1 to$2 plus monthly fees, again, to help fill empty spots, but they can limit that. Margins are thin. I go to a restaurant, they want you to book there directly. Food delivery, you've got Uber Eats and DoorDash can charge 20 % to 30 % per order. And typically, that is the restaurant's entire margin in that meal. But the idea is that it's going to open up visibility. So in fitness, we've seen a bit of a similar story. I understand that studios make 30 to 50 % less than typically normal class rate. It's been used as a way to fill unused spots. In fact, I think it's two episodes ago, Matthew, we had Michael Ramsey, who is a co-founder of Strong Pilates, who actually shifted his view from being kind of not pro-class pass when he was at 45 to not being pro-class pass.
21:47And we asked him the question about how did he change that? And he said, it's all about controlling it as a tool. Rachel, to your point, not one to five studio location, right? I want to unpack the woman owned here in a minute. So how do we all come together? The frustration, what I've noticed, really boiled over when Tonehouse launched this campaign in August. I think it was August, not September, called the Gym Loyalty Month. The Chief Innovation Officer, James McMillan. And I don't have a relationship with Tonehouse. I've been there a few times for Workout, but that was it. But they urged members to skip ClassPass, and not just ClassPass, to be fair, all aggregators for a whole month and book directly with the studio.
22:29So the message was pretty simple. It was, if you don't value your GM, go ahead and book direct. And this campaign resonated. And I know you talked about it being only women's only, but a good friend of mine is Akin, who's the founder of Army. He supported it. Even Barry's Voice supports. It wasn't just like the small brands. You had big brands. push and support. I viewed it as a symbolic pushback to what many saw as almost an unhealthy dependency on third-party platforms. I think it was more of a call to action to say, you've got to get your act together because you can't just constantly rely on this because it's going to hurt you.
23:06At the same time, the question that I had, which is why I'm so excited to talk to all of you is, is the problem really ClassPass? Is it other issues that are happening and we're trying to point it to ClassPass and other aggregators. So Rachel, I want to bring you in here and say, from your perspective, you're an investor, you're an advisor. Do you think that the boutique studios that you're referencing and you're close to have an unhealthy dependency on ClassPass? It's almost like once you get so far in, you can't get out. And it kind of resonates with how some hotels and restaurants feel about Expedia and OpenTable and Resi and others.
Read the full transcript
23:42Listen, I think there's blame, if that's what you want to call it, plenty to go around and an education piece and so much. Like, I'm not pointing to ClassPass as really the problem here. And this is part of the advisory board that I keep pushing for that I think is incredibly important that can make us all better collaborators. But it is a little bit of a vicious cycle. When we started sending out consumer surveys, I have a newsletter that goes out to a couple thousand people. So, again, it's very niche, very biased sample size. But we sent out a survey asking for feedback on ClassPass and why people were using it.
24:15I posted on Instagram, so another 40 plus thousand people. And we got a lot of feedback. And the data most importantly showed that now people use ClassPass not because it's an aggregator and they want flexibility, but actually because it's an arbitration opportunity. They're able to arbitrage. They're able to price, get it for cheaper. and that's discounting on the value of our classes. And so in turn, we offer a few classes up on ClassPass. Students then think that$12 a class is actually what the class should be valued at instead of 36. They will never come back to pay at the studio, but we as studio owners become more and more reliant and it just becomes this sort of vicious circle.
24:59Is that ClassPass's fault? Partially for underpricing. Is it also the studio owner's fault for not managing it properly? Yes, partially. And so there's plenty of ownership to go around. But again, if we start to reframe this as a community and really collaborate and have open conversations, it's an easy fix. I really appreciate that. And just to add some perspective, when I look at ClassPass, SilverSneakers, Medicare Advantage have been heavily involved in advocacy to get the FID Act passed through. Think about all the things that we're doing here, right? The FIT Act, which unfortunately did not get pulled through.
25:32We're trying to provide access. We're trying to provide a tax-free benefit to enjoying fitness. That could be viewed as a discount. Silver sneakers, my parents leveraged their silver sneakers benefit to go to LA Fitness. They don't pay anything for LA Fitness, but they leveraged a Medicare Advantage benefit via silver sneakers to go and leverage a benefit. So they're getting the gym for free. You could view that as pushing the price down. I think at the same time, it comes down, think about my ABC fitness hat on, you know, we are excited to be working with ClassPass. And again, we gave it a lot of thought because Rachel, everything that you've said resonates 100 % with me.
26:13The way we were looking at it was, could we expand access such as that? If you want to use your ClassPass credits to maybe go join a crunch, maybe you are just going to boutiques, but you want to understand what is it like to go to a Crunch Fitness or an EOS or a Planet Fitness, along with boutiques. Could we afford someone that? At the end of the day, at least my vision and the vision of, I would say, a lot of my peers in the industry is focused on one thing. We are heavily focused on moving, improving health outcomes. Can we get more people under our tent? Can we be more inclusive, not exclusive?
26:47How do we do that? And in large ways, ClassPass, I think, has opened up a market for a lot of brands, candidly, that in the boutiques that I never would have heard of if it wasn't for ClassPass. I would not even have walked in a particular studio if it wasn't for ClassPass. And I'm in the industry, right? I'm not as tenured as Matthew or Jack, but I've been in the industry for about 15 years. I lead a couple of executive positions. I'm on advisory boards, yet I'm still coming across incredibly new creative brands that I would not have otherwise found without aggregators. And Jeff, I want to, you know, as you said on the other side of this marketplace and kind of really shaping how it works, you've heard both sides of it.
27:32Why should studios, and everything Rachel says, by the way, I've also validated, and that is a true sentiment. But why should studios not view ClassPass as a threat? How can they think about it as a growth partner? And I think the thing that I always think about is you don't want to get too dependent on it, but it's so hard, right? Once a consumer gets conditioned, the studio gets conditioned, you're looking at five empty beds in a Pilates, well, I could fill that up with ClassPass. Do you think ClassPass should do more to helping govern utilization and usage? And honestly, almost like turning it off to say, hey, you know what?
28:12At this point, you are over leveraging the benefit. We're going to pull it back. I want to maybe back up a little bit. You sort of were comparing ClassPass to the travel aggregators and you have delivery aggregation, you know, the booking platforms for restaurants. I think there's something that's sort of different about ClassPass. And sort of the frame with the travel has always been that the travel aggregators are in direct competition with Booking Direct, and they're in price competition with Booking Direct. And that's not something that ClassPass is designed to do. ClassPass isn't trying to front run the direct demand and send you the same person but for less.
28:51So the misconception is ClassPass is sending would-be full paid riders or attendees for less money. ClassPass is taking empty spots and filling up with someone new for some revenue. Now it's less. That's how we built a new audience. But there's not this direct competition. We've done a lot to protect direct pricing power. We put things in credits to allow studios not to have to do this pricing comparison. We don't take out billboards across the street from studios saying go for less. We don't market on those terms at all. We market on variety and bringing new people in. So there's a little bit of difference there.
29:22And I think the broad thing I want to - Just real quick, just to be fair though, consumers are doing the calculation in their head. consumers are doing that math and they'll do a lot of it's price discrimination sure but studios don't get to decide their floor you do your own math based on our 10 packs so like that is an important indicator but we're not trying to direct price compute we're doing as much as we can and it shows up in the data so one of the great things that happened when mind body and class pass came together is we could actually look at a decade of data across thousands of shared businesses businesses that were on ClassPass and left that were on MindBody, then joined ClassPass, every permutation you can imagine across the United States and in a lot of other countries as well.
30:04So huge robust data set going back years and years and years, pre-pandemic, post-pandemic. It allowed us to ask a lot of these questions, you know, how incremental is that ClassPass revenue? And the typical studio that we can look at in the MindBody data, and we've done ad hoc looks at studios not using MindBody, and we think it's representative, is that they see a 29 % increase in all-up revenue after joining ClassPass. And so that is additional revenue that they can use to make their studio better. And then we can look and say, are these studios doing better off ClassPass with their non-ClassPass revenue?
30:36So after you join ClassPass, what happens to your direct business? Are we cannibalizing users and it grows because we're sending you more people, but for less? We don't see that. The number of users that start on a direct relationship and move to ClassPass is the minimus. And for every user that we find that fits that pattern, we find two that start on ClassPass and BookDirect. But both of that is a small part of the overall economic relationship. So ClassPass is almost never taking someone who's going direct and turning them into a discount user. To the extent it happens, there's twice as many that start on ClassPass and fall in love with the brand.
31:09But overall, it's a 29 % increase in revenue. And then we can look at how those businesses perform. When we look at the businesses on MindBody that were on ClassPass this year and not, and what happened in Q1. And the businesses on ClassPass grew 10 % faster in their direct business. And so ClassPass use actually helps a business be better. Now, why do we think that happens? It gives them more money to invest. It allows them to support more class times, which benefits the whole community, not just ClassPass users. And it gives them great word of mouth when ClassPass users talk about the great workout they just had.
31:41They're primarily telling people that don't use ClassPass the book. And so the use of ClassPass doesn't just send incremental revenue from the ClassPass subscription. Time and time again in the data when we look, it actually makes the businesses stronger in their own direct business. And that's what we want. We want strong partners. We want growing businesses. Those are our best partners. I'm with you because I will back you 10 out of 10 times given during COVID, you guys gave those incredible, I'll call them grants slash loans to a lot of businesses in the LA region, at least I can vouch for.
32:10So again, like super here for what you're saying. I were not on MindBody, and I am a yoga studio in LA. So I am probably the end of one very specific spectrum and not indicative of states or globally in its entirety. So I totally appreciate that I come from a niche bias perspective. But I will tell you two anecdotes from the data set that I have, which again, vastly smaller and more niche. This month, we are off class pass, for lack of a
32:45ClassPass pricing comparative package just for the month. And so it would basically mean that the people that come to us or that via ClassPass would come only because of pricing, then they're able to come this month on this package without any sort of dollar financial change. We've had over 20 in two days buy this package who were previous ClassPass users. and so they're just basically indicating to us that they were only on class pass because it was cheaper and so it actually indeed was cannibalizing our business and again i'm that we that is two studios in yoga so specific i'm not saying it's indicative but that's the data set that i am
33:28Matthew Januszek:looking at i've got a quick question to jump in again i'm i'm a little bit of an outsider on this i'm probably more the consumer um question to rachel and jack that they both use it's like Like, who's winning or does the consumer win? So me, Matthew Januzek, I like to use boutique studios. I like to travel quite a bit. I'm in Europe and in the US. Am I winning as a consumer because I've got broad access to lots of different classes I didn't know about that Mo referenced? Am I getting better deals than I could probably do on my own? Am I saving time because somebody's brought this together for me?
34:05Matthew Januszek:I'm just curious, is the end user winning, which is why it's kind of driving a lot of these decisions? Or in the end, does the consumer lose? Just curious of how you guys sort of see that from a perspective. Sure. I mean, in the end, the consumer absolutely wins, no doubt about it. They have access to a whole ton of studios at reduced rates. I think that's one of the things that, as we've all sort of said, it has opened up the market, It has brought a lot of new clients to boutique fitness. I think Jeff said it, half the people that join ClassPass are new clients. So from a studio perspective, that's a good thing.
34:44It's brought, certainly in Bangkok, in my market, which is quite an immature, young industry, it's brought a whole ton of people into doing the kind of training that we do. So I think from the consumer's perspective, it's excellent. It's an excellent product. I mean, I have ClassPass and I use it when I go abroad. I think, you know, through the Fit Guide, we've seen that a lot of studios, it's quite hard to book. You go on the website, you go on their socials and there's no schedule there. And it's often not a great experience, to be honest, whereas you go on ClassPass and the technology is good.
35:12It's a smooth experience. So I think from a consumer, I haven't heard any consumers moaning, put it that way. I've heard studio owners not happy, but consumers all seem happy. I mean, just pushing back for a moment on some of the things that Jeff said there, I think, you know, you said, I think the way you described what it should be, I think is kind of the sort of ideal theory and the way that it should be used. And I don't think this is ClassPass's fault, but I think you need to talk to, or we need to address sort of how many studios end up using it, which is they end up releasing too many slots.
35:42They don't use it in the way that it's intended. And then it does certainly take the clients, I think, that otherwise would be paying more. Now, again, I don't think that's ClassPass's fault. But I think to just say, look, we're just filling those spots that otherwise wouldn't be filled, I think is not 100 % correct. And I don't really expect ClassPass to maybe get that message out. I kind of see that more as my role through Fitness Business Asia. We talk about how to make the most from the ClassPass relationship. But would you concede, Jeff, that if ClassPass isn't used smartly, as Mo said, you know, could there be some kind of checks?
36:13I don't expect or think ClassPass should do that really. But you can see that if it's not used well and not used correctly, it could certainly be cannibalized. And if they do release other slots and too many slots at a low price and their base rate is not good, the minimum rate they get from ClassPass, of course, that could take then clients that were willing to pay more, correct? We don't see that really in the data. Again, for studios that use MindBody, you will guarantee the revenue is incremental, that the flow of any small amount of cannibalization is more than outweighed. We'll pay that out 2x.
36:46And it pretty much has happened. Like I can count on one hand the number of times you've ever paid a studio out and said, yep, you're the edge case. And so, you know, 99 point whatever percent of the time, it just doesn't exist that this cannibalization fear materializes. And we built tools to solve the problem of releasing too many spots. We never want to put a ClassPass user in a spot you could sell direct. And for any partner that's using sort of software to manage their business, we will integrate with them. We're working to do that with ABC right now. And that allows us to predict that direct demand and get out of the way.
37:21And we've had really sophisticated partners turn that tool on, long time sort of skeptical of it, and actually see it reduce the number of spots on ClassPass and improve their direct business. And so we build tools to do this. I think an optimized partner should be using SmartSpot. That's the name of the automated inventory release tool. It's designed with the objective function of never put a class pass person in a spot that would go direct. But if your studio is chronically sort of has excess capacity, it varies by genre, you know, machine-based Pilates, very capacity constrained. But for other ones, we've not seen this idea of, oh, we have too many class pass people and therefore our direct business is hurting.
38:01It just doesn't really show up in the data. Now, studios that are hurting in general, class pass isn't magic it doesn't help them turn around we look at the star ratings for studios before they join class pass if we can get that off you know google or something and studios with a low star rating before they join class pass tend to get a low star rating on class pass from class pass people they're responding to the sort of same studio dynamic and those studios don't do great and when they leave class pass they don't stay in business as long so struggling studios class pass isn't going to turn that around and sort of you know back to my original point you know i know it might rain hollow, but we truly want healthy partners.
38:39We want partners that have a direct business, they're putting on a great class, they're investing in growing, that are building a great community, a welcoming place. We want to send our users into those types of studios. And so we never want a studio to fully rely on ClassPass. And if a studio can sell out all on its own, then they obviously don't need us on that extreme as well. Before we wrap up, I want to touch on an important point, which Rachel brought up earlier, which is women in leadership, and as representative in this panel, you raise an important point, Rachel, at the top of the podcast that I'd like to incorporate in this discussion, even though it wasn't the core theme.
39:14Women make up the vast majority of the boutique fitness users, yet they are very often misrepresented and underrepresented rather in leadership. And the numbers tell the story. So women account for about 70 to 80 % of boutique class participants, especially when you look at Pilates, bar, yoga, and cycling. Yet according to URSA's report, which we had URSA or HFA on, the Women Leadership Report, fewer than 30 % of executive roles across the fitness industry are held by women. And that, I think, is an issue. It's actually worse on the investment side. I'm an investor. Rachel, I know you're an investor.
39:51It's pretty gloomy. Only around 2 % of venture funding in wellness and fitness goes to woman-led companies, despite woman being the primary consumer base. And I think because of that mismatch, you've got such a gap there, you naturally have blind spots, which is to be expected because we are not driving to remove that. People shaping models in business and partnerships and a lot of other strategies don't typically reflect the demographics of actual users driving the market. Even on this podcast, you heard about me talk about my experience, Matthew talked about when he traveled internationally, where men taking boutique fitness, we do not represent the vast majority of users.
40:37And you also pointed out that smaller boutiques like yourself, many of them are founded and run by women, are often underrepresented in companies such as ClassPass that allocates visibility and pricing. So that would amplify the challenges here. So Rachel, question for you here. Just given your involvement, I'd love to know a bit more about the 2 % Club. Do you think women's underrepresentation in leadership is one reason that small boutiques, female entrepreneurs in particular, are at a disadvantage in the model that we're talking about today? It's a good question. I think it's an and, and a lot of ands at that, as to the true cause and issue at hand, but I can speak from my experience of saying part of the reason I would call it ringing the bell or however you want to describe, you know, the conversations that I've been having around ClassPass is because of exactly what you're saying.
41:31I want us to be at the table. I want to find a way that it really makes sense, that it can be collaborative, that it can be supportive because so many of these small businesses are run by young single moms or whomever it may be. Like, let's build them up and give them the chance. And maybe they need more tools than others, but let's give them that opportunity. And so I don't know, maybe I'm coming at it from an incredibly biased standpoint, probably am. But I think that that is the longevity, call it, of the fitness space is being able to support some of the people who maybe have been historically underrepresented, except not on the consumer side.
42:11And that gap is something that I think is advantageous for all of us to fill in this conversation. I think one question I'd like to ask the panel here, including my co-host, is what steps do you think the industry can take to better elevate women's voices in leadership and decision-making? I can tell you that I'm involved with the HFA and advocacy. I know we proactively seek out women leaders. I think they do. That voice and perspective, to your point, Rachel, it's so important as we think about fitness and boutique, where women play such a critical role. But Jeff, would love to hand it off to you.
42:47I know of many women leaders at Playlist. But what do you think we could do as an industry to better elevate women's voices in leadership? Oh, boy. Great question. I think ClassPass was maybe privileged that we had a female founder. And so she was very attuned to sort of this from a very early age. So I joined a company. And when I joined, I think the leadership team was roughly half women. And it's remained half women, even with people turnover over the eight years. We have great female leaders on our board. So I think, you know, despite me being the face of this right here, like we actually have quite a strong sort of history with female leaders at Playlist.
43:31And I agree. I think I meet with a lot of owners and chief strategy officers of major brands. I meet with a lot of smaller brands. And it's a lot of men I meet with. And that's sort of weird. And our user base is largely female, you look at in the class. So fully agree with the problem statement that's been put out there. How do you get women elevated? I would love to have Playlist and ClassPass be part of that. But, you know, I think part of that's, you know, listening to your point, Rachel, like, it's clear, you know, just hearing you speak, and I read a lot of your posts coming into this that, you know, part of what's missing here is the communication, like I can come in with stats, and that's great.
44:07But, you know, that's not the same thing as having a dialogue. And so, and, you know, there's always this tension, we deal with 10s of 1000s of partners, how do we make each one feel treasured, but that's not an excuse. And so, you know, we're very much open to that, you know, dialogue. The stats are really part of it. It's a trust-based industry. So. Yeah, I actually really value and appreciate you saying that and really hearing because the 2 % Club is a group of a couple hundred wellness leaders, operators, founders that are 99 % female in our group. And we have these conversations all the time.
44:41And there are a few of us that are super keen to have conversations with you. And so I appreciate, as the owner of empowered, I am an absolute no one. But as the founder, co-founder of the 2 % Club and someone that is actively involved in these conversations, like we want to appoint leaders to have these conversations with you so that you don't need to have the millions of conversations. And we're raising our hands saying we want to be ambassadors to really come and collaborate with you. You can reach out to me. I'm happy to come and listen as soon as this week. So yeah. Thank you. Matthew, anything to comment on the last point?
45:18Matthew Januszek:I think a couple of things. From a class pass perspective, and I'm just sort of as an observer, but I would say it would make sense for any business to really get in touch with who their consumers are. And I probably wouldn't see any business would discriminate necessarily between male and female. And I would just say, if their audience is represented by female, it would clearly make a lot more sense to just figure out the challenges that their clients are having and really dive into that. Similar thing to our business, I work with my mother, who's sort of co-founded the business with me, my sister, who's a real leader in the business, my wife, my sister-in-law, and my daughter's coming up.
46:05Matthew Januszek:And I think, so for me, I'd rather employ females and males for so many different reasons um they're just a lot better at many things um i i think the challenge when it comes to this and again you know not not really sort of discriminating by um gender but but just i think for women um there's just a lot less out there where they can have similar people that are guiding leading that are not men and i think probably you know be good to expand a little bit racial in terms of what the two percent club is but i you know i'd love nothing more of it for my wife and and you know she's she's pretty proactive and searches out a lot of these groups and gets involved in women that are strong and powerful and smart and and that guide her and and you know it's the same thing for my sister and my daughter it's just just looking to see if I to find places where they can gravitate with people that have got similar issues you know they're they have husbands and they have children and they have jobs and that sort of stuff which is very different to all of us guys you know we we just have one thing to do and and that's it so I so I think uh you know just in terms of an industry I think it's just the more people probably like yourself Rachel that that are out there and and saying hey look I understand you I speak your language and and here's a path I think we'll probably see a lot more of that and and the only reason I don't think we've seen as much as what we could do is there's probably not as many of those places that are easy to find than what there are with some of these men's groups tell us about a 2 % club?
47:38The 2 % club is a group of a couple hundred women. I call it everything from the original CMO of Barry's Bootcamp to the founder of fitness softwares like Walla. It is an incredible group of collaborative women who help everything from fundraising to, you know, building out your second studio to it's all wellness. So it's actually not just fitness, but we definitely lean heavy in fitness. And we love having people involved. We love having even men come to the table. It's everyone coming to the table to collaborate, but it's just a safe space for us to learn, fundraise, collaborate, and really lean on each other.
48:16And it has come to be such a joy in my life. So very grateful to be a part of it. And hopefully your wife, sister, daughter, all of them will join. Jack, do you want to bring us home? Yeah, sure. I mean, yeah, just to add to that, I mean, for me, it's quite easy because Fitness Business Asia, we interview boutique fitness studio owners, majority of which are female. So I think most of our guests have been female. So it's been quite easy for me on that platform to elevate female voices. And I think if we continue to do that in the industry, then that can inspire other women and hopefully you get this positive cycle.
48:49So yeah, a little bit easier for me, I think, because there's so many fantastic female studio owners. And yeah, I interviewed one this morning, Linda Tang from WeBar that went out on Five Star Fitness Podcast today. Again, an amazing story from Singapore. I guess, yeah, final thoughts. Should we do that, boys, to wrap things up? One of the things that we love to do on Lyft, I know Rachel and Jeff, you're new to the podcast. If you'd love to wrap up with our final thoughts of the episode. So Rachel, I'd love to start with you. Do you have any final thoughts from what we discussed today? Really grateful for the conversation.
49:20I think the more we can have these types of conversation, the better the industry can become. And I'm looking forward to all the future collaboration that will inevitably happen. Jeff, how about you? Grateful to come on and be part of the conversation as well. And, you know, ClassPass is, we're not going anywhere and we want to be the best partner possible. And, you know, I said it before, I'll say it again, strong, successful businesses with their own clientele are our favorite partners, not because we want to grow against them, we want to grow with them. And so, you know, happy to keep that conversation going and really excited to see what happens next.
49:54Anything new that you picked up from the podcast this evening, your time? Yeah, I think in terms of final thoughts, as Jess said, ClassPass aren't going anywhere. And I think that's a really important thing for studio owners to recognize. So that means we need to really make the most out of the platform. And I think the best way to do that is double down on creating an incredible experience. What we've seen at the Fit Guide is we too often miss basic service standards that are very commonly done at the world's best hotels, the world's best restaurants. We're not doing them. And then some of these same studios, of course, are going to be complaining about ClassPass.
50:26People are going there instead. ClassPass isn't going anywhere. So create the best experience you possibly can, the best business you can, the best community you can. Treat, I would say, ClassPass clients when they come through the door exactly the same as your normal clients. Give them that same great experience. But have some other things such as community events, maybe some other little extras that your members get that ClassPass members don't. Don't release all of your slots onto ClassPass. So definitely have a few peak slots that you can keep off the platform just for your members, I think is crucial.
50:55Use ClassPass in the way it was intended. and if you do all these things you don't need class pass and then you can use class pass really in the way that i think it should be used and that jeff has said that it's been designed to be used i think if you don't do that despite what jeff is saying i think some clubs do get into a trap where all of their slots are on class pass they're losing their members and i think that's something that studios need to really make sure it doesn't happen to them final final thought from me is i think a lot of things were left unsaid today i think this is very surface level but very very important.
51:24I'll be digging into this a lot, lot deeper in terms of what studios can do, really a step by step to make the most out of the platform. I am a fan of ClassPass, it has been good for us. But I do think in the wrong hands, it can definitely be bad for studios. So I'll be doing a lot of education on Fitness Business Asia, but it will certainly be relevant to any studio owners anywhere.
51:43Matthew Januszek:I'll echo your comments. I remember being on a panel a few years ago with Anthony Geisler when he was at Expo. And I'm not sure whether this is still his opinion now, but he seemed to have a real discipline around ClassPass. I think for quite some time, I don't think they were even using it. And I'm sure that slightly changed. But there was a real, there seemed to be from the panel a discipline in terms of where they use ClassPass and where they don't. But the emphasis really was on building their own marketing strategies direct to their individual consumers. And I would guess being as class class is still relatively new and there's still a lot of people that come into the industry that's passionate about fitness but may need help and may need to be part of these groups that both of you are involved in where there's education around how to reduce the risk within your business.
52:40Matthew Januszek:I think it's the same in any business where once you have a particular client that represents two large a percentage, there's a risk there. And so it's sort of managing that risk accordingly. And I think the other thing is, as Jack said, and it was quite the focus of the conversation last week with Michael Ramsey from Strong Pilates is really just putting a lot of emphasis onto the quality of the product. And obviously that does take time. But if you've really got an exceptional product that's better than everything else out there, whether it's the whole experience, the people that greet the consumers, just really focusing on that, then I think naturally that will start to raise you from I think what's probably a lot of similar people offering a very, very similar product.
53:35Matthew Januszek:And the only key differentiation is really separating themselves on price, which probably isn't where a business wants to end up. Mo, final thoughts? As we close, and I'm just listening to all of you, so I've got the benefit of going last. I keep on coming back to moderation. And in fitness, we know that too much of anything isn't good for you. If you overdo, hit, if you outrun, if you run too much, if you lift heavy, you know, only lift heavy, don't focus on recovery. Too much of anything is just not good for you. But when you work together, so cardio, strength, recovery, stretching, all the things, you tend to make progress.
54:13And I've had the pleasure of working out with Jack and Matthew, we still got to get a work at it. We have not, I mean, this has been a couple of years we still have not worked out together. I think the same is true for ClassPass. So I think if a studio leans in too heavily, as Jack mentioned, it could be unhealthy. Compresses margins, cannibalizes memberships. If the studio ignores it entirely, like what it suggested by Tonehouse, I think they'll frankly miss out on new audiences, new trial funnels, and even missing out on corporate wellness reach if you skip even the welcomes of the world. In moderation, again, just like how I treat my fitness, use strategically with the right inventory, with the focus on converting trial users to members, I think ClassPass could be a valuable tool.
54:51If it wasn't, I wouldn't be investing and bringing ABC into it. So to wrap up, the lesson for boutique operators is not to avoid ClassPass at all costs. I think it is to treat it like a supplement, not a substitute. Just like fitness, the right balance makes all the difference. So Matthew, with that, we'll wrap it up.
55:11Matthew Januszek:Yeah, thank you very much. Jack, thanks for pulling this together. Jeff and Rachel, thank you very much for your contribution. If you enjoyed this conversation, we've got a Lifts page on LinkedIn. We'd love to hear your thoughts. If you've got any comments for anyone within the panel today, then please share it there and we'll continue the conversation afterwards. So thanks very much for listening and I hope you enjoyed this episode.
55:39Thank you.
From the publisher
In this special debate episode of the LIFTS Podcast, hosts Matthew Januszek and Mohammed Iqbal are joined by guest co-host Jack Thomas (Fitness Business Asia) to moderate a high-level discussion on the impact of ClassPass for boutique fitness owners.
Industry voices Jeff Bladt (ClassPass/Playlist) and Rachel Hirsch (Wellness Growth Ventures, The 2% Club, and studio owner) share opposing perspectives on whether ClassPass is a powerful growth partner or a dangerous dependency.
Discussion highlights include:
- The origin and evolution of ClassPass.
- How ClassPass transformed consumer behavior in fitness.
- Free trials, pricing power, and fairness for studios.
- Parallels with aggregators in travel, dining, and delivery.
- Revenue data showing both growth and risks for studio owners.
- Strategies to avoid over-reliance on ClassPass.
- How ClassPass affects women-led boutique studios.
- Industry-wide calls for better collaboration between aggregators and studios.
👉 Learn more about Jack Thomas:
https://www.linkedin.com/in/fitnessbusinessasia/
👉 Learn more about Jeff Bladt:
https://www.linkedin.com/in/bladt/
👉 Learn more about Rachel Hirsch:
https://www.linkedin.com/in/rachel-hirsch-43b31265/
👉 Learn more about ClassPass:
Support fitness industry news by sponsoring future LIFTS episodes.
Contact us at wendy@escapefitness.com for advertising opportunities.
Subscribe on YouTube and turn on notifications so you never miss a new video:
https://www.youtube.com/user/EscapeFitness
🛒 Shop gym equipment: https://escapefitness.com/shop
📘 View our full catalog:
US – https://escapefitness.com/support/catalog
UK – https://escapefitness.com/support/catalogue
Follow Escape Fitness on social media:
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/Escapefitness
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/escapefitness
Twitter: https://www.twitter.com/escapefitness
LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/company/escapefitness/
0:00 Intro & Hosts
4:21 Why ClassPass Matters
5:50 The Origin Story of ClassPass
10:30 Consumer Perspective with Rachel
12:46 Free Trials Debate
19:10 ClassPass as an Aggregator
23:05 Discounting & Devaluation Issues
27:40 Revenue Data Insights
33:44 Consumer Wins vs. Studio Risks
38:22 Women in Leadership Discussion
47:51 Final Thoughts & Takeaways
54:34 Closing Remarks



