1. Podcasts
  2. Great Chat
  3. The launch industrial complex
Great Chat

7 Oct 2026 · 39m · 13 chapters

Episode artwork

The launch industrial complex

In short

The episode argues that tech startups are hitting diminishing returns from “launch industrial complex” tactics: attention-seeking, manufactured hype (especially AI “slop” launch videos) that may maximize engagement but not conversions. Guests Helen and Ashley discuss whether the market’s “top of attention” is already past and what comes next for young startups.

Guest backgrounds

Helen and Ashley are startup/VC-adjacent commentators and former comms/PR practitioners; they reference prior work in communications and investing/portfolio contexts.

Key claims

A16Z/New Media can “manufacture moments” via partner networks and social proof, but most pre-seed founders can’t replicate this; “attention is not the moat.” Success depends on matching goals to the right audience (e.g., Twitter/VCs/developer communities) and creating authentic delight/surprise rather than formulaic, stock-footage montage videos.

Notable examples

A16Z Horowitz Andreessen Academy launch; a founder’s 1.5M-view launch with near-zero conversions; Hugging Face “micro duck” launch; AMD/World Labs acquisition understated photo; ChatGPT “research project” anti-launch; Instinct’s “anti-launch” driven by investor/VC chatter.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

0:46

Debate on AI Terminology

Discussion on the rebranding of AI as Super Intelligence and its implications.

“Yeah, there are comments on our podcast reviews page.”
2:47

Reflections on AI Safety

Thoughts on AI safety concerns and comparisons to climate change.

“And then instead of us changing all references to artificial intelligence, to super intelligence, because super intelligence does have a specific meaning.”
6:31

Papal Authority in Tech

Exploration of the Pope's perspective on AI and its cultural intersection.

“So we'll just, we'll do our part on the pod.”
8:16

Anthropic's Image Challenges

Analysis of how public perception affects Anthropic amidst controversies.

“So you were nice to validate my earlier word vomit.”
13:24

Sam Altman's Media Coverage

Discussion on the media portrayal of Sam Altman and AI narratives.

“And it's like, his like hands are on his hips, which I thought was like a really interesting, interesting decision.”
14:00

Analyzing Sam's Interview Controversy

A discussion on Sam's interview and the unexpected interruption from the comms person.

“I haven't read the article, but I saw your tweet on the clip and the BTS of like the comms person interjecting.”
17:44

The Evolution of Launch Strategies

Exploring how launch strategies in tech have evolved and their current effectiveness.

“watching extremely technical founders take the launch moment so seriously is new.”
23:00

The Challenge of Effective Engagement

Debating the importance of genuine engagement over mere attention in tech launches.

“I think the worst move you can make is to try to play the default game and play it poorly.”
28:01

Understanding Audience and Storytelling

Learn how to identify your audience and craft compelling stories to engage them.

“And I think it always starts with your audience, right?”
29:50

The Challenge of Distinct Founder Brands

Explore the current challenges in creating a unique founder brand in a crowded market.

“I mean, I think we are both huge believers in founder brand, right?”
Show all 13 chapters
31:26

Creativity in Launch Strategies

Discover the importance of creativity and authenticity in product launches.

“And like the thing that feels really scarce right now is like genuine delight and surprise.”
33:53

Examples of Successful Launches

Review notable examples of successful product launches and what made them stand out.

“a pre-seed startup to manufacture these conditions.”
36:40

The Evolution of Brand and Influence

Discuss the changing landscape of brand influence and the role of VCs in this dynamic.

“And that part is not accessible to everybody because I think that within the venture landscape, right?”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On Great Chat, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:04Today on Great Chat, we discuss whether we're at the top, no, not of the market yet, top of the attention-seeking launch content and manufactured hype of this AI slop era when pre-seed startups are spending money on launch videos and prioritizing attention over substance. If we're at the top, what comes next and how can a young startup stand out? I'm Helen and you have Ashley and I on the pod this week. But first, Great Chat is brought to you by Mercury, radically different banking, loved by over 300 ,000 entrepreneurs. We use Mercury to run this podcast and love recommending it to other founders and fund managers.

0:38It's free to get started. Try it for yourself. Visit mercury.com to learn more and apply online in minutes. Hi. Hello. Okay, so I still call it Twitter. I feel like there are comments. Yeah, we'll forever call it Twitter. Yeah, there are comments on our podcast reviews page. Oh, really? Where people are calling out, like, why do you still call it Twitter? One star. I'm not calling it SI. I mean, to your point, it is a better name. Oh, yes. Well, so there's the SpaceX SI rebrand that I guess Elon has committed to. I think he just said that. I've seen no follow through on it. I think he just said it.

1:24And Trump loved it and everyone moved on with their lives. Okay. I hope that's the case because that is a mouthful. And then, yeah, so the rebranding, we talked a little bit last week about this, like convening of AI leaders at the White House, but we mostly focused on Dario's on-video presence. But maybe the more lasting thing to come out of that is that AI is supposedly now SI, which is, you know, we're going from artificial intelligence to super intelligence. And my husband and I were chatting the other day and I have to give him credit for this. He's like the worst, the worst part of this is like, he's right.

2:02There's like a better name. Artificial just feels kind of like weird and gross and maybe scary to some people. And like super intelligence just sounds like great. Sign me up. It feels too late for me. I've been talking about AI for too long. I think this is just another distraction. Like Gulf of America or like the renaming of one of the Great Lakes. But like it was a thing for a day. And then you saw all of the sycophants who hold very, very powerful positions in government say this is, you know, just like sort of roll with it. But I haven't really, I feel like maybe it's starting to die down.

2:41So we're going to have to go longer that one. I mean, the big thing will be, do people buy the.SI domain? And then instead of us changing all references to artificial intelligence, to super intelligence, because super intelligence does have a specific meaning. Do people just start using that like new companies, new products, like new ideas, you could decide to adopt that lingo? Yes, super intelligence. Yes. Worth mentioning, they do also want to expand the meaning or evolve the meaning. The narrative was that these AI companies, these labs, were getting us to AGI. Getting us to AGI was the goal.

3:21And now it almost feels like we've moved on from that because maybe there were these questions around whether AGI was safe, whether it was good. So they're just like, reset, reset. And what's in a name? Well, a name allows you to do this. And it's like, oh, we're really focused on super intelligence right now. Totally. And previously it was like there was AGI and there was ASI and now it's just SI. It's like the new drop the the from Facebook. So thank you, Trump. Branding genius for the tech industry. And we'll see where that goes. I don't know if it's a function of like age or just like jadedness, but I'm like, yeah, this seems really important and really big.

4:05but I'm also just like really tired. And I don't know. I'm going to trust. I'm going to trust somebody else is figuring this out. And I feel bad. I've been reflecting on that. I think you and I are in a group chat where we're talking about this, but it's just like, do you remember people freaking out about net neutrality? No. Like, oh, you don't? Okay, well that, okay. I saw that. And I was like, yeah, that seems pretty bad, but it kind of like never materialized or like maybe it did, but we just accepted it and moved on. This feels like that, of course, on a much consequential vector, but I don't know.

4:46Do you characterize yourself as an AI safety person? It's a little, to me, the comp that feels a little bit more relevant is climate change, where it feels like a real thing to be worried about. You get examples of how things are worsening. Your ability to make an impact as an individual is the tiniest, tiniest dent. And you can either decide to go all in on climate psychosis. And every now and then I open threads and it's just all people saying they'll never have children because the world is so fucked and people make this their entire personality. And again, like it is valid that this is a big problem, but it kind of feels like one where throwing yourself on that fire is like not actually that helpful.

5:38And so with climate change and with AI, I'm like, I am going to trust that some really smart people are going to come up with some really creative solutions. And if I get a chance to back some of them, like amazing, but I'm not under any illusion that this is my heroic role to play in the history of humanity. And listen, if not, if we all perish, then we may as well just enjoy life until then. So I think, yeah, I think I'm in the same boat as you, Helen. I think this is very real. I believe that there are valid reasons why people are pretty freaked out about AI safety, but I also don't think it's valuable to like spin myself up about it.

6:23And I'm just default optimistic. Yeah. Which is like a luxurious place to be, right? Maybe if I worked at Anthropic, I too would be freaking out or tweeting my resignation, but I'm not. So here we are. So we'll just, we'll do our part on the pod. I love that. Did you catch the weekend sort of Catholic Church AI safety, I guess, coverage? Nobody really said anything, but I think this started with, or at least the conversation I caught first was this sort of debate on whether AI has feelings or capable of feeling pain. Consciousness, I think. Consciousness. Yes, yes. I think then I put in the group chat like the Sam Altman sort of comment on like the, hey, just FYI, I don't think that they have consciousness or what did he say?

7:21A soul, I think. Like I think that - A soul, yes. The most direct attack to date. Big word. Yeah, it's, first off, I went to a Jesuit college, Georgetown. So like anytime like the Pope intersects with like tech news, I'm like, this is awesome. And it is kind of funny that like there is like a, like an authority of the Catholic church who also in some ways speaks for, maybe this is controversial, but like Christianity and then maybe religion more broadly, like in terms of how he's weighing in on these topics. I think that Tech has such a hero worship culture. He's like Pope is founder mode. Okay, good angle, good angle.

8:00But also just like Pope is kind of one of the only like parallels to that where like they really take a central figure and I mean, for biblical reasons, I mean, or whatever, like it makes sense. We love like benevolent dictator in tech, right? Like, yes, yes. Actually, and Pope is manager mode. So you were nice to validate my earlier word vomit. Yeah, that's funny. Like we want like one person with a vision. Yes, Pope is manager mode. Yes, because God is founder mode and then Pope is manager mode. Yeah, okay. um just just in case anyone you know that it was funny I asked I hadn't gone like super down this rabbit hole and um I asked Claude uh to summarize summarize it for me and it did it gave like the play-by-play of like the you know the sort of like that event at the Vatican that Anthropic co-founder Chris Ola was at.

9:00And then the New York Times investigation that sort of exposed that there was some tension between the Vatican and what Chris wanted and sort of the Anthropic perspective. And then Claude gave me some talking points. And one of the, on this topic, which I love, it was like, here's what you could say for your podcast. And it was, the lazy take is anthropic is a weird cult the better one is institutional this is a frontier lab trying to move doctrine not regulation anyways i just thought it was like the funniest thing that anthropic was like your take is that we're not weird and that that's lazy oh claude claude pushed this claude claude was and they were proactive you weren't even like give me a i didn't ask for a take i just was like give me i just want the facts so um so interesting anyways uh claude wants me to be his little messenger yeah a little propaganda machine that's super cute maybe that's like the plan that you're on and if you go on a higher tier you don't get like little nudges to be a propaganda machine i'm paying like 200 a month i i feel like i'm pretty pretty elite for like one person this is such good fodder for open ai and any other competitors because like you can see increasingly that anyone who is anti-anthropic can just like paint them as this weird cult between like the religious stuff between the EA and like you know all the like sex cult stuff like there's just a lot of material that is probably being like unfairly framed but to the person who doesn't already have a formed opinion of anthropic and isn't in the details.

10:44Like weird, weird cult is like a very effective messaging. And so it was interesting to your point to see Sam and he did it in this like very like a light touch way. Like I'm not super comfortable with the idea that AI has a soul, but like he's just feeding that positioning around anthropic. Something I've said before is like weird is such a conversation stopper. if that makes sense when you paint someone as weird it's like okay like it's like I don't have to explain myself I just I just think they're weird I don't want anything to do with it I mean JD Vance learned this the hard way and so I kind of feel like athropic is swimming towards that and yes there are like you said so many openings for counter positioning against that why it's such a tee up is that it requires little explanation, right?

11:36And what I say is like, you know, people, very, very smart people, they can only really remember one thing, maybe two, but really one. And you don't want to spend all of the oxygen in the room explaining, explaining, explaining. So weird is like this label where it's like, they're weird. It's like, end. So I don't know. You don't want to back yourself into that corner. Totally. And like anthropic is weird, but in ways that like in a more sort of insular insider community can be very interesting. But I think like as tech is increasingly being exposed to like the outside world, like we are going beyond our bubble, things that maybe were like celebrated or at least tolerated within tech are finding a less receptive audience.

12:26And so like it's it's tricky. Like the weirdness that's part of your early mythology can actually backfire as you have like an expanded audience. So, you know, all the obsession with, with safety and, you know, it's interesting too, like an example of this is I feel like Dario's essay, Machines of Love and Grace from a couple of years ago was like very warmly received at the time. It was very thoughtful. It was like mind expanding. And now in light of this like Pope news cycle is being used against anthropic and used to paint this like cultish kind of picture. And so as like things shift and the audience grows, the messaging that was working a couple of years ago is not so much anymore.

13:16Well, you shared the Sam Altman Vanity Fair cover and I thought it was AI generated because I was like, is this the first cover ever where it's the back of someone? I know. And it's like, his like hands are on his hips, which I thought was like a really interesting, interesting decision. Yeah. It was so interesting. I mean, listen, there have been worse covers for sure. So, you know, this is, this is always one of the, like your job as a comms person is to make sure during like the photo shoot that they don't convince the CEO or the founder to do anything like really weird. This isn't bad. It's just odd.

13:56He's like looking off into the distance and there's like a beautiful landscape. I haven't actually read the article. I don't know if you have. I haven't read the article, but I saw your tweet on the clip and the BTS of like the comms person interjecting. Yeah. So for context, for anyone who is living their life instead of being extremely online. There was an interview that, a video interview that Sam did and Vanity Fair chopped it into these little clips, you know, for our short attention spans. And one of them is the reporter asking Sam a question that starts off sounding like it's going to be like a gotcha, right?

14:38So we asked him if he's familiar with someone's name and sam says no and he's like oh okay this person is a journalist and she wrote a piece a year ago about how her daughter committed suicide and chad gpt didn't tell her to but it like you know helped her draft her suicide note or something like that and so the comms person. This probably was not in the list of like... Questions to expect. You hear this voice off camera and she's like, hey, so, you know, not to be rude, but I want to make sure we have a chance to talk about the other topics we discussed. And then Sam, like, I think to his credit, the journalist sort of keeps going with the question and Sam is receptive to that.

15:27And then the way the journalist actually asks the question, I think is like very fair, which is just how do you think about the way that this product can be used for people who are in crisis, etc. And Sam has a good answer. And I weighed in as like a former comms person because a lot of people were like, it's like crazy that she interrupted and blah, blah, blah. And part of it was, we just don't get to see this kind of like, usually these moments are not caught on camera. Usually they are not clicked for broader consumption. and I felt a lot of empathy for the comms person because one, like, you know, you're exactly being asked a question about an incident that they supposedly know nothing about.

16:11That's a really tricky place to be. And two, like probably they did set guardrails for like where the conversation would go. But I think the more nuanced thing that I appreciated and point I wanted, also wanted to make twofold. One, I think Sam actually looks better for like overriding her and being like, I'm going to take on this tough question. And his answer was thoughtful and good. And then two, being a comms person is often incredibly cringe. Sometimes when things are awkward, you have to self-sacrifice. She was trying to give Sam an off-ramp by being the one who needed to object. And he could have taken it.

16:53Not that that wouldn't have had consequences, but like, you know, sometimes you're the one who has to play dumb or not be helpful or just, you know, there's, even if you don't go into like dark arts PR where people are like willfully deceptive, there are a lot of awkward moments when you're sort of like negotiating these conversations. And it was just so interesting to see one live and then see how strongly people reacted to it as if this was like a crazy thing. And I was like, oh no, this is, this is the job. Yes. It really does seem like we, and it's something we've brought up on the pod several times, like we are in this era of, you know, hype.

17:33Launch videos, sort of very well-produced launch moments. You know, I think a part of me and maybe you too is just like, wow, watching extremely technical founders take the launch moment so seriously is new. Oh, what if back in my days, this were going on then? However, now our debate is whether we've sort of reached the maximum point and whether we're kind of moving back and whether it really works at all anymore. Or maybe did it ever work? I think I'm increasingly hearing founders say that all you need is attention, right? Or that attention is the moat. Ooh, attention is not the moat. I have heard that exact phrase several times.

18:21We're seeing it too. That's what we're going to talk about today. But it's interesting, Ashley, I remember you had this tweet where you were sort of calling out like, does this stuff work anymore? You know, is this effective? And everyone assumed that you were talking about the A16Z announcement that day. The Horowitz Andreessen Academy. Yeah, that's right. That's right. And that was not a subtweet. It was just like, we were building to this moment, right? Totally. I think my question, which is a genuine one and one I've been thinking about for a while, is like, have we gotten too good at launches in tech?

19:00Because the main thing I mean by that is, it's so funny. I spent my entire career trying to convince founders how powerful it is to create a moment, right? Don't miss the chance to create a moment. You might only have one or two a year and you can really like, yeah, you can sort of galvanize attention and enthusiasm and tell your story. It's gotten really, really good at creating moments. But in doing so, when they like feel and look coordinated, we've like decoupled engagement from like enthusiasm. Like these launches have less signal now. If something is taking over your feed, it used to mean that people were really excited about something that was happening.

19:39and now something is taking over your feed. You're like, oh, well, you paid for a bunch of video engagement and you have a bunch of group chats where you got people to boost your thing. And it's still impressive, but does it work is the question. Are you converting it? Are you winning any hearts and minds with those launches? And I think it's an interesting topic for us to get into. So let's talk about what you've talked about, A16Z and New Media a couple times on the pod, but they have fully fleshed out their vision or what I assume was their vision of what they intended to create and the extremely valuable service, if we're being honest, that they provide their portfolio companies.

20:28If that gives you the edge in winning, then it's worth it. And I think that what they've done is they've operationalized the idea of a launch announcement. First of all, they have more partners than any other firm. I think that's undisputed. And all of those partners, I think over the past year or two, and some of them have been on X from the beginning, but they have big followings, right? So they can absolutely manufacture a moment. And so that is really valuable because in the earliest stages, we talk about velocity, We talk about like, how do you get people to care when you're just starting out, when you don't have all of that?

21:10And so. Totally. They've solved the cold start problem for founders. Yeah. And social proof, like built in to their term sheet. And I think that that is super valuable. It's very hard, you know, to guarantee it, but they pretty much do. And frankly, like, I think they're doing an excellent job delivering on that. I think the question that we're asking now is like, should everyone else play that game? But if everyone else plays that game, right? Like, let's go back to the comment that I just made that you disputed, which I agree with you, which is like, if attention is the moat, right? Like, isn't a moat by definition something that like, you know, others cannot access?

21:53And it's literally like not only A16Z, New Media, but also like there are agencies out there. I mean, the perfect irony of like, I started my career in the agency world before going into tech. And like, it's never been more attractive in my mind when I like see what these agencies are making and what they're doing. And it's just a really interesting work. I'm like, am I going to go through this full arc and end up there? But like, agencies are also promising like, hey, we're going to like hire us and we'll be the differentiator on whether, you know, your company gets attention at that early of a phase.

22:28So you're hearing founders spend money, invest in this earlier than ever, like pre-seed. There's budget to spend money on agencies and sort of amplification. That's totally new. So our question is like, well, now that everybody's doing it, how does the algorithm even handle that? Is it effective? And then what's the next thing? If everyone's doing it, then how do you differentiate yourself? Being silent seems not like the answer. To vastly oversimplify it, I think the worst move you can make is to try to play the default game and play it poorly. You either need to play the default game and win.

23:14And crush. Or you play a different game. Because I think the thing in A16Z, to use the Horowitz Andreessen Academy. I kind of hate that name. It's like so it breaks my brain every time I switch their names. Horowitz Andreessen Academy launched as an example. Like, yeah, like when you have an army of partners and like this massive new media team and then all these new media fellows who are very A16Z friendly and sort of your, your, you know, circle of people who are just excited about everything you do, like, you should absolutely have like a big, flashy, shiny launch and execute the hell out of it, which they did.

23:59Like, the irony was like, it's like a school for like 45 people or so. I forget the details. But it's like, it was this very, very big moment that they created and created beautifully. And I think shout out to Kristen Culver, a comms person, I believe she was also like the architect behind a lot of that. Great. A16Z should keep doing that. They sort of designed the game and they're going to play it well. The question is, should the average pre-seed founder who doesn't have A16Z on their cap table, doesn't have like a big social fault, like should they try to play that game as well? And I do think the danger is like everyone trying to do this, it just becomes less and less effective, both from your ability to execute its standpoint, but also its impact.

24:47I think we keep raising the bar for what a successful launch looks like. And that is, in most cases, actually not going to translate to the results that people want if they do the work of thinking through what their announcement goals are in the first place. And maybe that's actually a good place for us to go because I think we're in this era, we've talked about this, that engagement maxing, where a successful launch is lots of engagement. But actually, that doesn't necessarily translate to the things that will help your business. Yes, yes, yes. I mean, I was telling you a couple weeks ago, there's a founder I adore, and he literally followed the launch playbook to a T, like literally no mistakes, and got 1.5 million views on a really great launch video that they spent good money on and saw basically zero conversions.

25:39I don't think that that's proof of no product market fit. I mean, none of these companies at this stage really have product market fit. I think it's an audience question. And so I think that's where you were going with this comment where it's like, well, what are your goals? Oh yeah, goals. It's not just like you got to check the box and have a really buzzy launch. It's like, one, is your core audience on Twitter? And I think that if you are fundraising, I think that in your audience is VCs who, P.S., were in this super consensus era. Or like, you know, the reason why we are having a conversation about manufacturing heat is like, I think VCs right now are very much heat seeking, right?

26:27Yes. So it's like, if your goal is to capture the attention of those folks who are very online, then I think Twitter is a great channel. I still think Twitter is a good channel for developer tools, particularly indie developers, but also developers working in AI. It really does seem like this is where the conversation is happening. This is where the announcements are happening on new model releases and all of these advancements. So I don't argue when very technical founders who are building at that infrastructure layer say X has to be a part of the launch strategy. I think if you're a startup selling to startups, it can be a good channel, especially if it's more sort of YC or YC-adjacent contingent because they tend to be more online.

27:19And then yes, if you are building in AI right now, so much of the early adopter set, a lot of that conversation is happening on Twitter. And so I get that. I guess maybe as a counter to the story, you told there is a startup in our portfolio who did the fancy launch video and got millions of views, but also got tens of thousands of signups within the first couple of days. And so that did work for them. I think that was probably video money well spent. But yeah, when I chat with founders about this, very few times is this actually the playbook that's going to work well for them. And I think it always starts with your audience, right?

28:10Who you are, what you want them to do. And then story falls out of that. What is a story that is going to get them there, that's going to get them excited, get them to sign up, whatever. And then usually, it's like, what are the channels where we can find that audience? And we're starting with the channel. But this isn't even really a critique of this batch of founders because this has always happened. It was TechCrunch back earlier in our career. Everyone needed the TechCrunch story when they were launching. And then it was like product hunt. Being number one on product hunt for a while was this really valuable thing.

28:41I mean, to basically counter what I said earlier, it was always treated like a checklist, right? Okay, we need to get a TechCrunch article. And I always be like, oh, well, let me tell you how journalists are incentivized and how building a long term relationship with reporters is valuable. And it's like, we just need the TechCrunch article. And I'm like, no, I think that now, like the big viral X launch is like, I just need to check all of these boxes, right? And so this is where I think folks like Aaron Levy and people who have been investing in growing their own audience, like the founder's personal audience, over a very long period of time tend to do really well.

29:21and ones who, when you look at when they created their account, and it's more recent, and they amassed a huge following in a very short period of time, unless you're Nikesh Aurora, those folks are either paid or it was some superficial reason as to how you got those followers. So I do think that there are still some authentic pieces here that tend to outperform the more recent manufactured ones. But still. Yeah, definitely. I mean, I think we are both huge believers in founder brand, right? And I think the biggest challenge is, and it makes so much sense that you brought up that we are in this very consensus moment in venture because I think this is driving a lot of the behavior.

30:06A lot of founders sound the same right now, right? Like founder brand is powerful when it is distinct. And when people have, since you used Aaron Levy as an example, Like he has a very specific sense of humor and he's like really passionate about enterprise software. And he talks about a lot of things that aren't box. Like in fact, he mostly talks about things that aren't box. And the thing that I worry about for founders in this era is like things look very formulaic right now. Like a lot of these startup launch videos look the same. A lot of them are getting done by the same studios. The sort of go-to-market playbook is being run in the same way.

30:45And to be fair, that was happening in earlier areas of tech. there were just far fewer startups and people weren't announcing things as often. Like it was like you had like a couple of big moments, but now it's both like, there's so many startups. People are trying to create as many moments as possible to get as much attention as possible because attention is this currency we all really value right now. And they're using like the same toolkit, the same look and feel. And so I think that just inevitably has diminishing returns. And then I also think audiences are getting more skeptical. My number one rule is like people are smart.

31:21They can tell when things, when enthusiasm is like authentic versus it's manufactured. And like the thing that feels really scarce right now is like genuine delight and surprise. Well, it's almost like we're default. Well, you know, we're default conditioned to anytime something goes viral or it's like the algorithm surfaces it to your feed when you first log on in the morning or in that midday or whatever. You're like, was this well-coordinated among a bunch of group chats? Right? The fact that you're looking for proof of life as default, show me this was not a perfectly coordinated and well-produced launch.

31:59Show me that your customers, your users are so excited about this. That's a different mode of existing in these spaces that maybe we have to get used to. and then that's what will really swing things the other way. Should we make it tangible? Like, are there any launches that either like more recent or going back a bit that you thought were exceptionally done? You know, I feel like we have, you know, you see the people complaining about claw-generated slides and they're pretty specific on why. It's like, oh God, I could, you know, I see 20 of these a day. It's such a dead giveaway. There was like this, the color palette and italicized.

32:39Now I kind of feel like a lot of the launch videos look exactly the same, right? There's like this montage of stock footage and some retro, you know, throwback footage and clips and some of it. A lot of that is because Gen.A.I. can produce those things like pretty cheaply. Like that is still much cheaper than like hiring a crew and doing like a real shoot. but I think that we're just going to get a little bit numb to it. And so the advice I would have is like, gosh, and this sounds like such a creative agency person thing to say. It's like, go create something, like you said, delightful. Go create something provocative and differentiated that is on brand and does a service to the message and the tone that you want to be associated with.

33:30And so I would say like, this is still something that is unique to humans for now, before super intelligence or AGI or whatever we want to call it. But it's just like, I think creativity breaks through. I think delight breaks through. You want people to genuinely feel something. That's the part where I would push folks, if you're going to invest in this, to sort of like get to. My favorite recent example, and it's kind of an unfair example because it'd be very hard for like a pre-seed startup to manufacture these conditions. But I love the Hugging Face micro duck launch, the little like the robotic duck for a couple of reasons.

34:11One, it was like the content was just delightful. It's like this little duck robot like doing things and it was fun and lighthearted. And also like, you know, Clem just like tweeted it out and people were like, I want that. That's so cool. You could tell the responses were like, people were surprised and they wanted it. And they like, they were like, I'm ordering this. And it didn't feel like they had, that he had like emailed. And again, I tell founders to do this. And so I'm not even critiquing, but like emailed all his friends and said like, at this time, please chime in. Like people were, you can tell people were genuinely excited.

34:44But the best part was it was right after the NVIDIA acquisition of hugging face had been like reported, but not confirmed. And so he started with like, we have a huge announcement to make. And then he's like introducing micro doc. And I was like, Oh, I love this so much. That is such a good play. That is a playbook. That could be like a, yeah, best practice. Or even the, the like AMD and world labs acquisition. Like, obviously that's going to get a lot of ink no matter what, but like just how understated it was. They had that like photo of Lisa and Fei-Fei together in each other's sweatshirts, like signing the term sheet.

35:25Like I loved that they didn't make a video and like do a big thing. It was just sort of, it was sort of chill. But I think the number one flex in this moment is the anti-launch. ChatGPT, the original ChatGPT launch was like such an anti-launch. Like they called it like a research project. There was no video. There was like a blog post. And it was like the day two pop that really hit. Well, here's a question though. Like, do you think Instinct was an anti-launch? You know, that's such a good question. Instinct to me is a great example of a successful launch. And again, like this is because the product was so good where like I didn't even see the company's announcement.

36:07I just saw people tweeting about how amazing Instinct was. It was VCs. It was investors who invested super early, right? So it's like - It's funny. It's like kind of an anti-launch, but it's also kind of very of this moment. Right? Like VCs thinking that they're, yeah, going to play this outsized role in the company's trajectory. And then like when you look at the instinct thing and it's like, well, how did you first learn about instinct? It's like, Sarah Guo wouldn't stop talking about it. You see why there is this circle. And that part is not accessible to everybody because I think that within the venture landscape, right?

36:51Like, gosh, we talk about multi-layered SPVs. We talk about the Cucktron. We talk about all of these things where like, oh, is everyone finding out the power of brand? Guess what? Like in high school, the pretty girl probably also had an easier time with her homework. And I'm just sort of like, wait, is everybody sort of learning about these advantages that having a brand get you? And I feel like, yeah, we're watching people crash out in real time over it. But I think that that's what the Sequoias of the world have been building towards. And here they are reaping their benefits. I think Pat Grady shared a video that he made for Boston College this week in one of his LPs where it was a very classy way of putting it, which was like, Well, now the best founders have their company building partners, Sequoia, and then their capital partners, everyone who follows on to the much more expensive, like second tranche of that investment, right?

37:53And I was like, oh, that's such a, okay. You know what I mean? But it's like, that's brand. No, it doesn't just get you the pole position. You get a better price now. That is brands. You can actually monetize brands in a way that I don't think we've seen before. And it's funny. I remember 10 years ago, there were jokes about like, oh, do VCs need to be influencers? And influencers are becoming VCs. And now we're very much in that era. A lot of those are still around and it's like TBD. Well, good luck founders. Yeah, good luck founders. go use that time machine and go back in time. Start your Twitter following from 2008.

38:33Or just get Helen and I on your cap table or Helen and me on your cap table and we'll help you through it. Amazing. All right. See you next week.

38:57Thank you.

From the publisher

In the AI slop era, pre-seed startups are spending real money on cinematic launch videos, renting creator armies, and prioritizing attention over substance. This week on Great Chat, Ashley and Helen ask whether manufactured hype has peaked, what comes next, and how a young startup can actually stand out when everyone is shouting. Plus: what's in a name? We dig into the proposed AI-to-SI name change, discuss AI safety, and debate whether AI can feel.

Mercury is back as the headline sponsor for year two of Great Chat. Mercury is a financial technology company, not a bank. Banking services provided through Choice Financial Group, Column N.A., and Evolve Bank & Trust; Members FDIC.

This podcast is edited by Eric Johnson from ⁠⁠LightningPod: https://lightningpod.fm

More from Great Chat

All episodes