

Whether tech’s “right/MAGA” era is ending after the U.S. midterms, and what that means for AI, data centers, venture communications, and public discourse. They also discuss major tech IPO and corporate news (Anthropic, OpenAI funding rumors, Claude product launches, Adobe Max, Siri beta) and the Jensen Huang affair/spying scandal.
Ashley (host) and Helen (co-host). No other guests are interviewed.
Both are tech/venture-focused commentators and founders/fund managers; they reference experience in social platforms (Ashley mentions Facebook and Quora) and venture comms/VC strategy (Helen responds to venture-fund right-sizing and Sequoia/HF Zero moves).
Midterms signaled a “vibe shift” away from extremism; tech messaging should become more inclusive and user-focused. Venture firms must “right-size” intentionally to stay strong. Data centers need a national, bipartisan case. Early online defenses of Jensen looked premature.
Anthropic IPO demand vs SpaceX; OpenAI rumored $11B private raise; Sequoia program cuts; HF Zero downsizing; Sequoia reorg; NVIDIA/Alice Wong alleged $7.5B chip diversion; Texas turning blue; 40/41 data-center ballot measures opposed; ChatGPT disability ad; Claude Sheets; Adobe’s agentic design/MCP push.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Discussion on the upcoming Anthropic IPO and market sentiment.
“I guess like the Anthropic IPO is still on.”
Exploration of ongoing competition among AI labs and tech companies.
“and just being like, when exactly will the housing market supply demand sort of like really start to change based on this schedule because it sounds like employees can sell up to 10 % like right at the beginning, right?”
Analysis of right-sizing in venture capital firms and industry trends.
“And I feel like the 30 minutes a day or so that I use to give feedback on Gemini of how it messed up and what it should do next time is charity work.”
Conversation about Jensen's scandal and its implications for NVIDIA.
“and you're winning either in particular categories or just before everyone else, or brand.”
Discussion on initial public reactions to Jensen's email apology and its implications.
“one of which is way to beat before jumping to someone's defense.”
Analysis of Jensen's personal statement and its broader implications for NVIDIA.
“There had been sort of like rumors around this and like questions that reporters were starting to ask about Alice Wong.”
Evaluation of recent midterm elections and surprising political outcomes.
“I remember everyone losing their minds over his quote in the acquired interview around how like, you know, his honesty around if he knew how hard it was going to be to build NVIDIA, he wouldn't have done it.”
Exploration of the changing dynamics in tech culture and political sentiment post-elections.
“And now there are all these memes about like, how did the opposition like not research all of her incredible videos from 2024 that are servicing on Twitter now that are really funny?”
Explore how social media responses have changed post-election.
“Tuesday night and then especially Wednesday, like the tone and the jokes and the memes, like, had completely turned over.”
Discussion on the emergence of the 'silent woke' and introspection in response to political events.
“And I'm very, very optimistic, especially with this interesting things, and this was in the group chat, was like, oh, there was a silent woke that emerged.”
Analyzing the lack of leadership in tech and its implications post-election.
“There really isn't anyone who's super well-positioned to chart the course forward for tech with the broader populace, right?”
Examining the public's view on tech and data centers after recent elections.
“Like I've been saying too long in order for that to have been a correct point that like we're hitting these sort of upper bounds of like, how online can VCs be?”
Discussing the need for more inclusive narratives in tech communications.
“I was listening to some like podcast analysis and I'm like, yeah, people hate these for very obvious reasons.”
A call to shift the narrative focus in tech from CEOs to users.
“It's just like, I don't know, but this is part of my optimism of like the vibe shift and the very real impact it might have on tech.”
Explore the concept of users as heroes in technological storytelling.
“And I think we need to go back to making the users, the end users of the technology that these brilliant CEOs are enabling and building, the hero.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On Great Chat, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:04Is tech experiencing a post midterms five shift? Early data suggests that yes, indeed we are. I'm Ashley and I'm joined by Helen. Great chat is brought to you by Mercury, radically different banking loved by over 300 ,000 entrepreneurs. We use Mercury to run this podcast and love recommending it to other founders and fund managers. It's free to get started. Try it for yourself and visit mercury.com to learn more and apply online in minutes. Hello, hello. Hello. Okay. All right. Where to start? I guess like the Anthropic IPO is still on. Yeah. I was at a happy hour last night and an investor, I think in a later round of Anthropic, was just so confident.
0:47They're like, yeah, 1.75. Oh, okay. It's been like eight hours since he said that. And yeah, a little lower, a little lower, but still happening. I think still happening is the of the headline. Totally. And you always price lower than you think you will land, right? So they price their shares or their target price is$70 to$78, which implies like a$1.2 to$1.4 trillion market cap fully diluted. And so like$1.75 doesn't seem crazy from there. So, and apparently there's more demand at this point in the process than there was for the SpaceX IPO at the same point in the process. Oh, that's so interesting.
1:31I think I shared in the group chat that I have this friend who works at a big wealth management provider or firm. When I spoke with him, the one month mark before the IPO, if you compare that point to SpaceX, the demand was like 10 to 1. Like the phones were ringing off the hook for SpaceX. Oh, interesting. And so, you know, it just could be like totally not apples to apples. Like I think Elon Musk has been through this a couple times and he does a great job marketing. And he's been trying to get, you know, from the very beginning, SpaceX included in the index funds. And I think Main Street has been part of his strategy, whereas Anthropic is very inside the bubble.
2:15Yeah. So maybe there's just like, it's just not really an apples to apples here. and now this sort of catch-up demand is to be expected. I also think that there was a big will-they-won't-they question around Anthropik that didn't seem as relevant with SpaceX. I think once Elon called a shot, everyone's like, okay, cool, SpaceX is going public. And I think with Anthropik, it's been more of an open question. And so maybe a lot of people were sort of in limbo alongside the IPO. And I saw a tweet from CNBC's Leslie Picker that based on institutional investors, they're already oversubscribed. So it's happening.
2:54It's on. Congratulations on already owning your house in San Francisco. Here we go. On a to-do today is like feeding the schedule, the lockup schedule into a lot or whatever and just being like, when exactly will the housing market supply demand sort of like really start to change based on this schedule because it sounds like employees can sell up to 10 % like right at the beginning, right? Yeah. Yeah. I remember the day after the election that people were like, well, whoever made the decision to not go public before election day, you know, has blood on their hands or whatever. There was a lot of commentary about how like everything's over now, right?
3:41And so I think actually, no, this is great in terms of like the vibe shift. It's like, hey, look, everybody who's been like kind of doomer-y around like the, oh, okay, everything flipped to Democrats and now we will get data centers. AI's over. AI's been canceled. And it's like, no, you still get this great Anthropic IPO. So I think mood is good. Also, out of all of the labs, I feel like Anthropic is the most woke. So they're the right next entrant. And then speaking of labs, it seems like OpenAI has raised another$11 billion privately. I think that's a rumor versus confirmed. So AI is not over.
4:30And then we even saw some rumors that Harvey is considering a smaller IPO. It's funny. The comment in the group chat was like, bring back small IPOs. And like Harby actually like has pretty substantial revenue compared to what a small IPO was like 10 years ago. But I think we would all be thrilled to see a company be able to get out without having to have a trillion dollar market cap. I mean, I think it's more speaking about the timeline, right? Yeah. It's the ARR, but it's also like these companies that were founded, post-COVID, being able to go out before the Canvas and the Databricks of the world.
5:11Oh, poor Canva. Databricks, I think, could go out if it wanted to. It just wants to raise, it wants to get all the way through the alphabet with its fundraising. After it raises its series B. You can double, I think you can do AA, like BB. There we go. All the bra sizes. But Canva seems like it's in a really tricky spot. And maybe Figma was in hindsight quite brilliant to go out when it did and at least capture that value. I know another narrative violation. So there were Adobe Max, it's this week, it's in Miami. And one thing that I keep thinking about is I think that the incumbent software companies, I think it's a very Silicon Valley startup thing to dismiss incumbent software companies every Every time there's a new wave.
5:59I mean, Salesforce has never been hotter. And there's just a lot of companies where you're like, you know what? Actually, one experience that startups do not have is having the intense pressure of shareholders. And so I just feel like if you are faced with an existential risk, you're probably going to do whatever it takes. And maybe that's exactly the fire under the butt that a lot of these big public companies need. And so anyways, like Adobe came out on the announcement this morning. That was pretty exciting. Like basically it's like, okay, they're trying to figure out how do you like two steps ahead of like where Figma is going with regard to like MCPs and the agentic design layer.
6:41And people are innovating. I think that's great. I mean, we underestimate the big guys, but I think in general, we celebrate competition because it pushes everyone to be better and innovate. And then, of course, the labs are doing this too. I haven't had a chance to poke around, but I saw a tweet, and this is Tuesday that we're recording, that Claude has launched Sheets and a bunch of other stuff. And of course, there was already Claude slides. And so there's so much competition coming from so many different vectors. It's very exciting as a user of these products, but also just generally, I think, for the tech industry.
7:19Yeah, no, I agree. Meanwhile, as a family, we have a Gemini Pro account. And I feel like the 30 minutes a day or so that I use to give feedback on Gemini of how it messed up and what it should do next time is charity work. But anyways, it's like, okay, I did my public service for the day. It's really crazy. And I just updated my iOS. And there's a new version of Siri that they're trialing on phones. And it's, oh, it's rough. So the counterpoint of everything I just said about the incumbents, it's like... Whenever I accidentally talk to A-L-E-X-A, I don't want to wake her up right now. The level of like comprehension and dialogue feels so amateur now that, you know, we're used to these like frontier models and including like the voice versions of that.
8:16And so, yes, the incumbents are pushing ahead in some areas and lagging woefully behind in others. But even the venture firms, the incumbent venture firms are shaking things up. Helen, I'm going to give you a shout out because I saw you respond or play off a tweet about HF Zero's decision to thoughtfully downsize and have fewer startups, fewer founders be part of its program. And I think their communications around that was very intentional. Anyways, you made a broader point around right-sizing and that the firms that do this proactively and from a position of strength are going to be in a much better place.
9:02And then literally the next day, Sequoia announces it's a pretty big reorg. I mean, they like chopped a bunch of programs like their scout program, their art program. They shut out their London office. They tightened their team. I think they combined growth and early stage and also announced another 10 billion in new funds. So, you know, it was anchored to a flex, to a big moment. But I feel you were like the most prescient person on the internet. Well, I think right-sizing, as we heard last week with Jameson, is like such a, I just love that phrase, right? It's like right-sizing, it's the most clever way of positioning like smaller or downsizing or, you know, getting rid of a bunch of programs and all these things.
9:56But here's the thing, not everybody is going to be able to right-size. And so my thing was being first and early to this is going to put you in a position of strength and make it seem very intentional and part of your strategy. And I think the majority of venture funds next year, maybe even the year after, I think that the success of the Anthropoc IPO, frankly, will make the music play on a little bit longer in terms of good times. whenever they do downsize, they're not going to have the benefit of being able to position it that way. That's really, really good on them. I also think that given Sequoia did this in this first wave, it also might give a lot of other firms permission to make changes, if that makes sense.
10:43At least with their LPs, right? If Sequoia is doing it, then... I mean, I already have seen a bunch of commentary around scout programs and how they actually don't fulfill their intended purpose of making sure firms don't miss great deals. And I didn't know this, but someone said, oh, Kleiner actually already canceled their scout program. Now Sequoia is doing it. Who's going to be next? And so already you're starting to see some of the ripple effects of that move for better or for worse. But yeah, I mean, to your point, there's always a lag. But as you and I both know, and anyone who works in venture knows, this is already in progress with a lot of firms, not intentionally.
11:29A lot of folks are being forced to... It's kind of like the biggest multi-stage platform firms getting so big. The middle has been in a tough spot for a while. And so you either are playing the AUM game or you're having to get tighter with your strategy. And so, yeah, we're going to see a lot more of these announcements in the coming year. I agree. I think it's like you're either a mega firm, AOM game, really small craft, and you're winning either in particular categories or just before everyone else, or brand. That, to me, surpassed. The ones in the middle that I think survive are the ones that have a very elite brand and don't have to play the size game.
12:13But I don't know. We'll see. Yeah, you know, it's funny. Last week, another announcement that was made was the discontinuation of the Cybertruck. And when I read that, I mean, so many funny takes on it. But I wish that that announcement was made like right before we had Jameson on and we could have talked about right sizing. Oh my gosh. Oh, that would have been perfect. Being in the Cybertruck era for like, you know, venture and everything being mega. We were too early, which is a problem in venture sometimes. Exactly. Last week we had the midterms and then this was going to be like a super chill week where we processed everything.
12:52But instead we have like the craziest story of all time, which is Jensen's affair with a supposed spy. Yes. I think I'm caught up on all the takes and the memes and I'm exhausted by some of them because they do kind of bring out the worst in some people. But yeah, what is your, where are you at? I mean, it is actually amazing how many details continue to come to light in a relatively short period. I mean, so we're recording on a Tuesday. Jensen sent his sort of statement to the company yesterday. His board put out a statement. And then subsequent to that, we've gotten all this new information about just how massive the impact of this relationship was.
13:41And it seems like$7.5 billion worth of chips were funneled to Chinese companies through Alice Wong and her Shell company. and there are details around NVIDIA advocating for certain policies that now look really suspicious in hindsight. And so I have a couple of takes, one of which is way to beat before jumping to someone's defense. There were a lot of people on our favorite website, Twitter, who like as soon as Jensen's email apology hit where it was mostly, I'm so sorry for cheating. And then a little bit of like, there will, there will be an investigation. I, you know, I'm cooperating. And there were so many people who were like, you know, like Bill Ackman, you know, we should support him.
14:37Sean McGuire. Like a lot of people were like, Hey, like the joke was like, first one's free. Like how, or how could he not cheat? Like, you know, everyone makes mistakes. And then as more and more details have come out. Those early responses look increasingly silly in light of the gravity of the reporting. And so wearing my comms hat, my advice to all of us who are spending a lot of time online and feel like we need to comment on everything is way to beat sometimes and see what the story is before coming out with a really strong opinion or a defense because that can backfire. Well, actually, yes, I agree.
15:22And I thought that actually revealed where their positions were. Like the reason why these guys came out and said that wasn't because some people jumped to this conclusion that like they are womanizers who want to excuse this behavior so quickly. They too have spy relationships. Yeah, exactly. It's like, no, no, no. They are coming out so quickly with this judgment because they would do that. They would do whatever they could to preserve their portfolio or whatever their financial interests. And so to me, that was such a reveal. And then I think the comment I made in the group chat... As a spectator, I love it.
16:00Yeah, yeah, yeah. In the group chat, I think my comment was when I asked you what you thought about the statement that Jensen put out to his employees, it was way too heavy on the personal and not enough on the sort of national security, like, you know, sort of like that's - Implications for the business. Like maybe that was intentional though to make the chatter more about the person. I mean, like personally, I think it's possible or maybe likely that Jensen and his wife were in an open relationship. And like, I don't know why we're commenting on infidelity again and again and again. Like, but yes, this comes up.
16:38And yes, I do appreciate the memes about like, you know, this wouldn't happen with a female CEO. But the national security thing, yes. And then now more details coming out about like how much exactly she and her company benefited from this relationship are like very, very, you know, concerning. So in my opinion. Yeah, I definitely thought the statement to NVIDIA employees was weird because I really do think even after the blue tsunami, like if this were just a run of the mill, you know, affair, I don't think a lot of people, his family would care. maybe he'd be a little tarnished in some people's eyes but you know otherwise I don't think anyone would be doubting his ability to um to lead NVIDIA um as he has been for like over 30 years and so it was just weird to see something so crafted uh around that and not not really addressing the like massive massive elephant in the room um there was also an interesting sub conversation around, like this wasn't like a brand new news cycle.
17:52There had been sort of like rumors around this and like questions that reporters were starting to ask about Alice Wong. And one of the NVIDIA spokespeople, this guy, John Rizzo, had given a statement like something along the lines of, you know, Jensen regularly has contact with customers like this isn't unexpected or something. and a bunch of people were resurfacing those statements, which didn't look so good a couple of days later as more reporting came out and as Jensen himself admitted to the relationship. And so there was this whole debate that I appreciated around, should spokespeople have to put their names on quotes?
18:35Oh yes, that's right. Which I think is so interesting. And I was being made, I think a couple of reporters were like, this is great that there is a name attached to this. And if John Rizzo was lied to, I think what they're thinking is that this is an additional piece of accountability, right? If you're going to put your name on something, you're going to care more about what goes out there, especially if it's in any way untrue. And that if he was lied to and sort of stuck his neck out there with this quote, he should resign on principle. Anyways, I generally think that's true. I hadn't really thought about that before.
19:12I hadn't thought about that either until I saw the tweet about how, just as a reminder, Richard Nixon avoided jail time, but his chief of staff did not. And I was like... Wow. Yeah, I was like, oh, oh, interesting. But I mean, in this specific NVIDIA case, it does seem like very believable that the spokesperson was lied to the same way, right? Like, yeah, they were just doing what they thought was factually accurate. Yeah, and I don't think anyone's like coming for John Rizzo's head. But it's more just that, oh, it actually hits very differently coming from an individual versus an NVIDIA spokesperson, which is how I think most company quotes are given.
19:54And I'm like, yeah, I think I am in support of putting a name on it, with the exception of situations where that's going to make that person a target somehow. I can imagine some communications that might make it unsafe for someone to have their name attached. But yeah, just wild. And then the biggest story here is like Jensen's aura loss, right? Like I just feel like a couple years ago, you know, he was at his peak. I remember everyone losing their minds over his quote in the acquired interview around how like, you know, his honesty around if he knew how hard it was going to be to build NVIDIA, he wouldn't have done it.
20:34But here was this massive, massive company that is really underpinning this entire technology shift, the AI wave. And one man's actions have jeopardized such a massive category. It's just actually kind of mind-blowing and sad because I think he was a real candidate for a role model in the tech world. and probably could have survived infidelity, but I don't know how he recoups an affair with a spy and the implications of that. I was thinking about like, well, didn't Wormie just talking about Jensen like an episode ago or a couple episodes ago and it was the comment about how his appearance on All In was just like such a masterclass of how you handle Trump and frankly, like how you handle narcissists generally, right?
21:30You just, as the kids say, just the glazing is through the roof and you just, you know, sort of like move on and get your way as a result. And I think he's been very successful at managing that relationship. Anyways, the midterm. So last week we filmed also, recorded also on a Tuesday. And we thought, we were like, oh, thank goodness we don't have to talk about this. And it turns out, wow, kind of a fun. But here are the things that I shared in our group chat, tying it back to great chat commentary. Ashley, you have this great reminder that you give founders that you assume your audience is smart.
22:15And I thought of that over and over again because in Texas, James Tallarico defeated Ken Paxton in a highly contended race, but he defeated him quite a bit. And one thing for me, like the Paxton campaign and his supporters were quick to label him Tala Frico, right? And like, I'm not like up on Texas politics, but at some point I think I Googled like, okay, who is this James Tala Rico guy? Because Tala Frico, oh, there must be some freaky shit in his history. And it's like, oh my God, have you guys read his bio? Have you read who this person is and what they say and how they conduct themselves?
22:55And I'm like, I'm so sorry, but like Google or ChashyBT or whatever, anybody who's willing to put in 10 seconds of effort to like just check that, like you will lose credibility very fast. And so I thought that was like they assumed their audience would just blindly follow the Tala Freako thing. And honestly, a lot of people did too, right? It's like a lot of people did, but that was such like a reminder of actually something that you say a lot. Now he's being heralded as like the leader of the moral left or the Christian left. So yes, they picked the wrong nickname for him. And then I think there was, I think it was Annie Andrews, although now I need to fact check this.
23:41But like South Carolina, and she was sort of like an unexpected winner of the night. So South Carolina now has a Democratic senator. and people were a little bit like, how did that happen? We thought Lindsey Graham's sister like had it in the bag and turns out she had her team like have some polling numbers that she never released. And so now I think like generally campaigns release their numbers to the public to show like, you know, where they are in the race and it's just another piece of news that you can own the cycle. She knew she was doing really well and she held the numbers. And I was like, oh, what a move.
24:19Like, I think that that was, that was cool. Power move. Yeah, totally. And it worked. And now there are all these memes about like, how did the opposition like not research all of her incredible videos from 2024 that are servicing on Twitter now that are really funny? And, you know, I was like, well, maybe this will be like a new phase we enter into in tech where we don't announce, you know, valuations and we're not constantly releasing like big numbers. And yeah, anyways, one thing to three. We leave a little to the imagination. Exactly. Exactly. And then I just think overall, I mean, like, I think the theme of this, and this is a good segue into our main topic today, but like the vibe shift was just that, wow, like that cheesy thing we heard when we were little about killing with kindness.
25:13Like, I really do feel like people are exhausted about all of the sort of negativity and, you know, the language and all of these things. It really did seem to backfire and signal that like people are tired of it. And that reminded me of if you've worked on a social media platform, so I spent five and a half years at Facebook and another year or so at Quora, and the question of why don't we have a dislike button always comes up, right? And when you start running the numbers, you see very quickly why you don't do that. It is, it truly kills discussion. It kills the conversation. and even Elon, when he took over Twitter, introduced and tested a dislike button and then we never saw it again, which means he learned that very fast as well.
26:03And so I was like, oh man, if anybody in government or in these campaigns would sort of see the long-term arc on these things, it's effective, but for a very short period of time. That broader takeaway is kind of, I think, one of the most hopeful things coming out of this. I think the novelty of extremism has like worn off and people are tired of it. On both sides of the political aisle, everyone underestimated this election, right? Like the progressives, the progressives I know were shocked and waited a long time before celebrating because I'll out myself, we've been burned before. You know, I think like the more MAGA side of things was equally shocked by how, but I think generally, you know, midterm elections don't go well for the party in the White House.
26:54But this was beyond, I think, anyone's expectations, despite there being a lot of polling showing that it might go quite well for the Democrats. So I would love if the era of extremism on both ends of the spectrum is coming to a close. And yeah, that gets us to sort of our bigger topic. Is it too soon to call it a vibe shift? And I mean in tech specifically. So not to make it all about us, but tech was very much on the ballot for the midterm elections. And our good friend Elon spent, you know, almost half a billion trying to influence outcomes. Of course, Texas turned blue in a pretty spectacular way.
27:34A lot of high profile candidates ran on platforms that were anti-tech billionaire, anti-data centers, and they won. They won with that messaging. And so I think it's worth asking if tech's MAGA era or like the tech right era might be over. I think it's too soon to call it. We'll all just sort of like jump ahead to that. But even just based on the feeds, like, you know, who's loud, who's quiet, it was striking. Tuesday night and then especially Wednesday, like the tone and the jokes and the memes, like, had completely turned over. Yes. A lot of folks are very quiet, very quiet or, like, still tweeting but about very different subjects.
28:26and yeah it's it's gonna be interesting there were a lot of really funny memes immediately after one was like oh man all those defense tech funds are gonna have to pivot the climate funds like and there were all these sort of like you know woke is back jokes that are that are quite funny but i feel like people are very light-hearted about it which is great you know what i mean like i'm hopeful that like we're all gonna you know we we tried a couple extremes and like we're finding like a middle ground and people are generally, you know, I assume people are good and people are well-intended and we're just going to kind of go back to like some semblance of that.
29:07And so, you know, maybe I'm speaking too soon and this is wishful thinking. But so far, yeah, the vibe shift feels real and I feel great. And I'm very, very optimistic, especially with this interesting things, and this was in the group chat, was like, oh, there was a silent woke that emerged. A bunch of people were celebrating the election results or even just celebrating the repudiation of Trumpism specifically, who had been pretty quiet politically, understandably. I think there were a lot of people who've been keeping their heads down because they're you know, sticking your neck out in this era has come with consequences.
29:58But yeah, the silent woke, the silent woke emerged on Wednesday and they were having a lot of fun. And that was pretty funny to see. And then I think what we don't know is how the more sort of like tech right, Trumpist contingent, how they're regrouping. I think there are probably a lot of group chats that are popping off right now and some aligning on messaging. I do not expect like a full capitulation. Well, Ashley, let me ask you this. Do you feel like there's introspection happening? I was just about to make a bow. This is a mind meld. Oh, man. I'm guessing there's like not that much introspection happening.
30:40For those who don't get the reference, Merkin Dresen of A16Z famously declared he is anti-introspection. and he did not introspect. But I think there will be some messaging tweaks and it'll be interesting to see how far they go or if the strategy is to actually just like pull back for a little while and let a couple cycles pass and then get back to it. I was thinking a lot about our episode with Aaron Zamos from a couple of weeks ago where we were talking about sort of the tech's leadership vacuum and how there really isn't, and gosh, with the Jensen news, we have an even weaker bench. There really isn't anyone who's super well-positioned to chart the course forward for tech with the broader populace, right?
31:33I feel like a lot of the loudest voices in tech have been very sort of Trump-aligned and more speaking to an insular audience versus a broader one. And so especially coming up like on the other side of these midterms and we knew tech was unpopular, but I think this really brought it home how like wildly unpopular tech generally and AI specifically is with a broader population. Like it's existential for our industry to navigate this, but like who are the people, who are the voices who are going to do that? That still feels like very much of an open question. Absolutely. I think some people have been quick to say, oh, this is a big win for moderates.
32:17And maybe. But I think that you're basically saying, who's going to volunteer to be that representative is going to be interesting for tech? because I think the last, you know, gosh, the last 10 years, we've been sort of barreling towards like very extreme points of view. And maybe that coincides with, you know, there just being more presence in public of VCs taking positions. And so, you know, when you do that, you're forced to kind of take an extreme, right? I mean, with these platforms, right? If you want your clip to go viral, you need to say something extreme. That's right. That's right. And so I think like, it's going to be a check on that too.
33:07So not to like do that meme of like the dominoes getting bigger where it's like this little thing happened and it leads to this gigantic thing. But it's like, I don't know, I've been saying for a long time, which means I'm wrong. Like I've been saying too long in order for that to have been a correct point that like we're hitting these sort of upper bounds of like, how online can VCs be? Like how public do they have to be? How much of a public presence do they have? Do they have to be constantly putting out, you know, blog posts, thought leadership posts, joining every podcast and sharing their perspective?
33:42Like, I'm hopeful like, oh, is this a sign? Are we kind of pulling back a little bit? Like somebody had a tweet this week about like, you know, what's changed in VC and somebody said, oh, actually the biggest change in VC in the last 10 years is the way reporters cover VC. They don't cover it. We have reporter friends and they're like, yeah, why would I ask a VC what they think? I just go to their Twitter and they're just telling me all day. And I think for previous version of comms was like, I saw companies use their investors very strategically. They were this invisible, off the record, on background relationship that reporters built so that they can turn to them for their opinions.
34:22And now, because there's so much pressure for all of them to be so public, every opinion that a VC has, you discredit or you look at... There's a grain of salt because you're like, well, what's in their portfolio and why is it in their interest? I know it's funny you say that because one of my thoughts when I saw the Sequoia reset announcement was I wonder if this will also be a tightening of their brand presence because in many ways, It has felt like, and I think we saw a tweet making this point, that A16Z has sort of like pulled them into playing their like new media game where they're just like super online all the time, lots of content.
35:08And Sequoia can do that. But Sequoia also has the brand and the track record where they don't have to. And so it'll be interesting to see that with this new sort of orientation and new org structure and new path forward, if that also includes tightening things up on the brand, thought leadership, like how online are all of its partners side. I think that is very right. I think the incentives of social media have pulled people to be more extreme in ways that make them very ill-suited to now be a credible voice for tech to a much broader population. I think the good news is there are some very obvious places that tech needs to start.
35:53And there were 41 ballot measures related to data centers in this past election. and 40 of them, people voted against data centers, sided against data centers. And there was like no correlation with how like red a county was. And so what that tells me is this is truly bipartisan, which is exciting actually. Like I'm so ready to depoliticize tech. And so it really feels that if data centers are critical to our like, you know, broader infrastructure build out and to America's competitiveness with AI, we have to make a case on a national level for like why this is the right investment, why this is important.
36:39I don't think we've done that. It's just sort of been bulldozing forward with let's get as much compute as possible, as fast as possible and on a local level. And I think understandably, I was listening to some like podcast analysis and I'm like, yeah, people hate these for very obvious reasons. Like it's incredibly noisy. Their livestock is disturbed. Like it's not even this like ideological or like philosophical debate around do we, are we worried about super intelligence? Actually, no, this has like dramatically decreased my quality of life. And it was interesting to see that OpenAI was ready with its comms around what it was doing on the data center front.
37:17And it's the measures that it's proposing and enacting around no more NDAs. And we'll audit noise levels and the impact on communities. And so you can start to see the pieces come into play. Totally. A race to inclusion. So last night I was watching Monday Night Football. There was a ChatGPT commercial I'd never seen before. And it was about, you know, how ChatGPT improves the lives of, like, you know, people with disabilities. And it was, like, somebody who either was, like, vision impaired or hearing impaired and, like, you know, basically using this thing. And I was, like, you know, there had not been much attention called to, like, new television campaigns that OpenAI was running.
38:04But I was, like, oh, man. Like, the, yes, I think that. Vibeshift. Vibeshift. Vibe shift, but maybe act one was permanent underclass and oh, now people with advantages now have 10x the advantages and everyone will be left behind or we're going to wipe out all these jobs. It's like, oh, that didn't quite work. And so maybe act two is like, okay, let me figure out how to make this vision of the future inclusive and exciting for everyone. That is a very, very different muscle. And I think hopefully, I'm hopeful that the introspection that happens here is like, yeah, when does it really benefit companies to go with that act one?
38:46Like you must tell if I'm fair. You know what I mean? It's just like, I don't know, but this is part of my optimism of like the vibe shift and the very real impact it might have on tech. I'm also optimistic because I think some of these products are great and people already love them, right? Like, ChatGPT has a ton of users. It has replaced Google for, like, a non-trivial number of people. And I'm thinking back to our Taylor Lorenz episode where we were talking about the narrative that, like, young people hate AI. And it's like, young people also love AI products. And so, not to say that this is just a messaging problem, and I feel like I always have to check myself when I'm like, the calm solution to this is because if a company has evil aspirations to wipe out the human race, messaging is only going to take you so far.
39:40But I really do think that the way these products and this category has been positioned has been so counter to those company's objectives and certainly to the individual end user. And so if the goal now is to make products really popular and delightful and useful, and I think we both know how incredible they can be in our work and personal lives, but there's just been so little incentive to sort of make that the main messaging pillar. So I'm very optimistic because there's so much to work with. On a meta level, we created this podcast because we felt like there is a version of tech that is just kind of underrepresented, which is you can be extremely tech forward.
40:28And you can be like a techno optimist and not have to sell out all these other aspects of your life and your values. And still also be like pro-human. Yes, exactly. And I think that's very interesting. And to your point about like, maybe we see a new type of leadership or new faces, new voices emerge through this. That would be really exciting. And stories where the hero isn't just like the tech company, right? This is a hill I will die on again and again. Like make someone else the hero of your story. Like Nike is not the hero of its story. Like the athlete, the everyday athlete is. And so I think we just...
41:10Totally. I was just saying this. I feel like you and I grew up in this era of platforms and the people who benefited, the people who built on top of the platforms were always front and center in terms of the company narrative and the campaigns. And then we switched to making the CEOs the main character in Hero, which has been wildly backfiring and in some cases doing really well. But the second you put it all on a human, right? And humans make mistakes. It was just a very different era of tech. And I don't think the solution, I think what tech leaders pivoted to later with AI was like, oh, well, let's make the technology the hero.
41:54And it's like... Or the revenue. Exactly. Yes. I mean, seriously, like the valuation. We're trying everything. And I think we need to go back to making the users, the end users of the technology that these brilliant CEOs are enabling and building, the hero. And so maybe that is the new era we will get into, the era of one's past. I love it. The hero, Apple's hero was the creative misfit, right? And that was so inspiring. And it led to such interesting creative. And we have talked before about how repetitive of these like everyone having the same kind of launch video with the talking CEO like like let's like broaden let's have a take a more expansive and inclusive approach to uh to storytelling and and I think it'll I think it'll have some pretty good pretty positive consequences all right well what a great place to end optimism thank you for listening to great chat have questions for us make sure to submit them on another great chat.com see you next week
43:01Thank you.
The blue tsunami hit tech harder than anyone’s group chat predicted. Elon spent nearly half a billion dollars to influence election outcomes, but Texas (and a bunch of other states) turned blue and data centers lost 40 of 41 ballot measures. Ashley and Helen ask whether tech’s MAGA era is actually over and which leaders will rise to speak for an industry this unpopular. Plus: the Anthropic IPO is (still) on, Sequoia right-sizes, and Jensen suffers a historic aura loss.
Mercury is back as the headline sponsor for year two of Great Chat. Mercury is a financial technology company, not a bank. Banking services provided through Choice Financial Group, Column N.A., and Evolve Bank & Trust; Members FDIC.
This podcast is edited by Eric Johnson from LightningPod: https://lightningpod.fm