1. Podcasts
  2. Great Chat
  3. What happened to tech’s backbone?
Great Chat

16 Oct 2026 · 46m · 20 chapters

Episode artwork

What happened to tech’s backbone?

In short

Tech’s “narrative problem” and why AI-era messaging fails the public; includes a comms breakdown of VC/online drama and the “clock” framework for startup reputation cycles.

Guests

Aaron Zamost, former comms leader at Square and Google; later ran people/HR alongside comms at Square; now runs consultancy Background Partners and lectures at Berkeley Law School; writes op-eds for The New York Times.

Key claims

Tech leaders optimize for investor/insider audiences (often on X) rather than normal consumers; AI is “shoved down people’s throats” with fear/job-loss messaging, so adoption and goodwill lag. The reputation “clock” still works, but cycles are faster and fragmented into multiple audiences. Tech’s public stances are often performative business strategy, not values.

Notable examples

Valor Atomics vs Day One Ventures/Sequoia pro rata dispute; Huberman-style “don’t defend, advance” comms; Benioff rebranding “AI Force” to “SI Force”; Anthropic’s “safety” positioning vs broader AI backlash; AI suggested-reply/consumer UX as a first-impression failure.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

0:37

The Importance of Appearance in Podcasting

Hosts discuss the impact of visual presence in podcasting.

“No, no, no, the pink shirt, it's going to be iconic now.”
1:40

Discussion on Social Media Platforms

Aaron shares his experiences and preferences regarding various social media platforms.

“You missed a lot of drama over the past week or so.”
3:05

Venture Capital Drama: Valor and Day One

A deep dive into the recent public dispute involving Valor and Day One Ventures.

“I think my comment was like, oh, my gosh, this is going to be reputationally worse for Masha than the Epstein file inclusion.”
4:33

The Role of Communication in Business Conflicts

Analysis of strategic communication in the context of business disputes.

“yes, it seems like she was an early believer in the company.”
7:57

Observations on Online Outrage and Public Drama

Discussion on the nature of online outrage and its entertainment value.

“Like it's so, people are just putting it all out there all the time, every day.”
10:34

First Mover Advantage in Public Discourse

The significance of being the first to speak in public controversies.

“who who opens this type of shop that why is that shocking to anybody but all i'm saying is that There is enough nonsense in the world.”
12:18

Rebranding AI and Tech Discourse

Discussion on recent changes in the narrative around AI technology.

“How much of the first mover advantage is exactly what you described where people see it the first time and then they just drop off and they don't follow the back and forth?”
14:00

Reflections on Tech Leaders' Narratives

Discussing the portrayal and rebranding of AI by tech leaders like Benioff.

“Or else he wouldn't prevent people from coming onto his beach.”
15:06

The Narrative Clock Framework

Exploring the framework of time in startup narratives and how it reflects media attention.

“How much do we think that Trump didn't want anyone larger than him there?”
18:49

The Evolution of Perception in Tech

Analyzing how the perception of tech companies has changed over time, particularly in relation to media influence.

“probably tired of talking about that you published in 2015 called What's Your Hour in Silicon Valley time.”
Show all 20 chapters
22:43

The Complexities of Public Sentiment

Discussing the split between insider perceptions and public sentiment in the tech industry.

“I mean, there are pockets of the public use Anthropic because they feel its brand is safety, right?”
28:00

The Shift in Tech's Narrative

Discussing the current perception of big tech and the narrative around AI.

“So where you are on the clock on X to your point, Ashley, is to speak to a certain, very specific audience to accomplish a very specific goal.”
29:42

Consumer Sentiment Towards AI

Exploring why consumers feel negatively about AI and technology.

“I wrote that piece when I was a very young person in his mid thirties, right?”
31:38

The Speed and Complexity of Tech Changes

Examining how rapid changes in tech affect public perception and understanding.

“And there's a reason that Amazon, yes, people like there's a lot of anti-Amazon sentiment out in the world on workers' rights and all sorts of stuff.”
33:42

The Quality of AI Interactions

Critiquing the current state of AI interactions and their impact on users.

“So I think that there's that layer that it's super fast, but then it's also really fragmented.”
35:46

The Need for a New Tech Spokesperson

Discussing the lack of relatable leadership in tech and the need for a spokesperson.

“We need like a Steve Jobs of this era or someone who actually is good at talking about technology to consumers and making that feel tangible and exciting.”
39:48

Long-Term Thinking in Tech

Debating the importance of long-term thinking versus short-term gains in tech.

“but he's also saying SI and talking about how Trump is the smartest person he's ever met.”
42:03

The Illusion of Tech's Values

Explore how tech companies prioritize business over genuine values.

“And in areas where the power structures are different.”
43:38

Looking Forward: New Founders and Opportunities

Discuss the potential for new founders to create positive narratives in tech.

“And the central pillar of business has now maximized shareholder value, which is why Tim Cook gives Trump a glass award, right?”
44:31

Navigating the Current Tech Landscape

Analyze the current state of tech leadership and the potential for change.

“with like a positive story for the future, if they can be normal enough, or even if they can just care beyond a sort of more insider class when they're thinking about their audience.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On Great Chat, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:04Aaron Zamost: Today on Great Chat, we talk about tech's narrative problem and why what the world actually needs is a spokesperson from this industry who is, well, normal. We're joined by Aaron Zamost, former comms leader at Square and Google. I'm Ashley and Helen is here too. Great Chat is brought to you by Mercury, radically different banking led by over 300 ,000 entrepreneurs. We use Mercury to run this podcast and love recommending it to other founders and fund managers. It's free to get started. Try it for yourself and visit mercury.com to learn more and apply online in minutes. Hey guys, Aaron. Welcome.

0:39Hello.

0:40Aaron Zamost: It's so good to have you here. I'm so excited. This is being videotaped too. So everybody sees the pink shirt. I would have dressed up. Everyone, yeah, everyone sees. No, no, no, the pink shirt, it's going to be iconic now. This will go down in great chat lore. It's almost our brand color. Just like a few shades off. I probably would have put on a color shirt if I realized that people were going to be watching us, but okay. Yeah, unfortunately, like podcasting is video these days. There's no getting around it. So we are in that era. But you should be comforted that I think like over 90 % of our subscribers, they listen audio only.

1:21So you're good. Well, I don't have the fake food of Amy Poehler and her podcast. There's no fancy good hang memorabilia, but at least it looks like I have some professional background.

1:31Aaron Zamost: No, no, no. You look like you've read a book or two. So that's good. That's really instant credibility. Aaron, you're not on Twitter anymore, right? Is that correct? I am not on Twitter anymore. You missed a lot of drama over the past week or so. Years. I've missed a lot of drama over the last several years. Are you on Blue Sky? Are you on Threads? I am on Blue Sky because it satisfies the need I have for - Short form written content. Yes. A scrollable feeds. A scrollable feed of dunks and things that make me feel righteous about my opinions. and I get that without the Nazi slop and anti-Semitic AI generated child pornography.

2:21So for me, Blue Sky satisfies my every need without feeling like a moral failure.

2:26Aaron Zamost: For what it's worth, my feed has none of the things you just mentioned on Twitter, but it has a lot of people in our industry seeking attention, which was kind of the topic of our last episode. So maybe you completely missed some of the drama. One was the Valor Atomics and Day One beef, which was, I think, maybe hell and especially fun for those of us in venture because a topic that no one ever talks about, pro rata, so your right to participate in future rounds as an investor and to sort of defend your ownership, became like an industry-wide debate. It's really a comms story, first and foremost, because Isaiah, the founder of Valor, went on the offense against one of his first investors, Masha Boucher, who might be a familiar name from the Epstein files and is the founder of Day One Ventures.

3:21Aaron Zamost: We were in the group chat. Isaiah dropped his blog post. I think my comment was like, oh, my gosh, this is going to be reputationally worse for Masha than the Epstein file inclusion. and then because it was like she's not founder friendly everyone was bending over backwards she almost blew up my run with sequoia etc and then i feel like i don't know helen like masha's response was so good i feel like all the favor tips uh tip towards her it was written by a law firm so yes i do think that they're wooden it wasn't like legalese she's she's a comms person originally oh for sure but there was like also i'm married to a litigator so you know i just like everything you look at through these special special uh colored glasses but um yes it did get it got more interesting the more that we learned and like any great beef there were sides right and there were points and it was really interesting kind of how how things shook out and TBD, because I think what Isaiah was saying is like, I want a judge to decide or an arbitrator to decide or someone to decide, right?

4:30And he will follow whatever their decision is. But essentially, yes, it seems like she was an early believer in the company. She may have even bailed them out when they needed an extension. And later, Sequoia wanted to preempt their B. And large firms, when they come in, they flex their brand and they say, we're going to cram down all of your existing investors. And he was able to get approval from the other investors because I think maybe they felt pressure or who knows why they were like okay with that. I mean, it's good for them to say, hey, actually, Sequoia is going to mark up our deal that we got in much earlier.

5:07So there's benefit there, but she was not. So he painted this picture like she was being unfriendly, she's not founder friendly. And then I think him going directly to Twitter, to me, the medium is the message in this one where it's like him going directly to Twitter. He knew exactly what he was doing. He knew that people would bring up the Epstein files stuff, the Putin's kiss stuff, right? Like her connection to like all of that. And it was just like theater doing its thing. So then when she clapped back with a very thoughtful, you know, what I think was written through a lawyer, but she's also a very talented comms person.

5:42You realize, oh, there are actually layers to this and she's punching back. Ah, first mover advantage is a really important thing. Not to jump way ahead on the discussion of communications, but if you can set the table first, everybody is reacting to your framing of it, right? So having no idea what you are talking about at all and not living in VC drama at all, the person who went first on X 100 % knew exactly what they were doing. Yes, absolutely. So through to the wolves, but I don't think that it settled as cleanly as the founder thought that it would.

6:17Aaron Zamost: I don't think it was a decisive blow. Yeah. Yes. Yes. So, so very interesting. Still TBD. I think she had a couple of jabs in there. Like, I bailed you out when, you know, you were about to totally fold as a business and you took out secondary at the last round without even telling us, you know, like, so there were all of these little jabs to make this some more multifaceted picture. And then it's sparked an interesting debate, I think, on the internet about like, what is prorata? I think a take I agree with is if you need a legal, like venture and early stage, it's such a handshaky sort of relationship based business that like, if you need a legal document to protect your rights on something, or, you know, basically referred to, it's like the relationship is already soured, or, you know, People aren't playing by these rules.

7:10And so there's a larger problem there, which I do generally agree with. This isn't typically an industry where there's a lot of at least legal battles because people think of the long game of like, well, I want to work here for a long time. I don't want to be known as the guy that sued the Portco or sued my co-founder or anything. So I think that's the part where we're just sort of watching. And frankly, to me, her engaging a law firm and sort of, you know, in my eyes, like taking the first blow that way was, I read that as pretty aggressive. But now it seems like, oh, well, maybe she engaged them just for the negotiation.

7:51There wasn't actually a suit filed. He's the one filing the suit now. So it's a mess. We look at it through a comms lens. But that's what you missed on Twitter.

8:02Aaron Zamost: You really are missing out on. Like Twitter is reality TV in tech. Like it's so, people are just putting it all out there all the time, every day. It's, you know, just for the entertainment value, Erin. Like, come on back, Casey Newton's back. Like I'm just, I am, I'm working on all my friends who left me alone. I have so much rage in me on a daily basis. I am not looking to - Well, this won't help with that. I am not looking to mainline the purest form of online outrage anymore. Oh my God. I think I, like, somehow it's like soothing, soothing to me to just see everyone else so angry. I'm like, I am at peace.

8:46Aaron Zamost: I am at peace by comparison. I still take great joy in watching people fall apart publicly. Like, I don't, but it's totally random stuff that probably, although the one that I was going to use as an example is I've been fascinated by the good people. good golf collapse there was a video a golf company made of the ceo pushing a woman to the ground who tried to use his driver and then callaway dropped them and then the pga tour dropped them and the ceo went on x to say that callaway had violated some so i get it i get the big stuff that breaks through but i think the advantage of actually not being on x is i only get the stuff that breaks beyond it so like kelly clarkson and a mechanical bird oh yeah everything going on with that.

9:28Just watch the video. But I can't tell you anything that never leaves the little microclimate of like VC drama.

9:34Aaron Zamost: Wait, where do you stand on Kelly versus the like the game store or the magic store or whatever it was? I mean, don't you always want to be anti-celebrity? But I think actually from what I've from what I've read of this really important situation, my interpretation is that I saw an interview with the store owner in which they asked him the price of the bird multiple times and he declined to answer the question multiple times and i just thought what does this guy have to hide that he won't share what the price of the bird was and seems to be not fully transparent about what happened and so that made me a kelly stan i guess every now and then i go on threads which like really breaks my brain but someone was like you know i was on the side of the shop owner but then i found out that he's rich so then it was like rich on rich violence and they were like i'm out i don't care anymore so it was like a nice narrative when it was like kelly this wealthy celeb is like bullying this like small business but i guess like the business owners are wealthy themselves and so now now i mean who who opens this type of shop that why is that shocking to anybody but all i'm saying is that There is enough nonsense in the world.

10:52And not being on X creates at least some importance hurdle that the nonsense has to get over in order to get to me. So like Ed Sheeran in Free Palestine, I followed that. I've got the bird thing. But like I say this with great love and respect for you two VC friends. But like I got other things to do.

11:12Aaron Zamost: Oh my gosh, Aaron, then you probably also missed. I think this was a week ago. time is time is strange on the internet someone who was the advisor to a company called factory i did this one did get in company okay and you saw the node say that like factory was a shitty company and cognition was a great company and then someone pointed out that kosala is a big investor in both that was that was great so that made its way that made its way to me because people sent it to me and said, would you like to see the VC drama of the day? And I said, sure. So they at least thought that it met that level.

11:50But that was another example of the person who went first having an advantage, right? Whoever, I don't even remember. I couldn't tell you who was first, but having read the first one, I was like, oh, geez, this advisor is a real, real asshole. And what was he doing advising this other company while he was working for them? And then I was like gone for a couple hours. I never saw the response, which was actually perhaps I had resigned. And so anyways, first mover advantage, man, it's such a good, it's such a good strategy. How much of the first mover advantage is exactly what you described where people see it the first time and then they just drop off and they don't follow the back and forth?

12:27Yeah. I mean, in this new cycle, it's probably a lot, but I've never thought about it that way. I think about it as if you're defending, you're losing. Any second that you're spending responding to someone else's frame is a wasted second of your opportunity to be on offense advancing your frame. Ashley coined Huberman-ing it, right? So like when that whole thing was happening, how he just was not responding at all. And then he just moved on.

12:53Aaron Zamost: With all the women who came forward and accused him of being like a really shitty boyfriend. Partner. He just kept posting about, you know, like, go look at the sunlight, take these peptides. Exactly. He refused to get into a defensive position. And it was like, that was effective. And then we've seen basically every company copy that strategy and it be really effective. You know what's funny? I thought Vinod had stepped in it with his crazy bashing of his own portfolio company in favor of another portfolio company. But maybe it was incredibly strategic. Like the only way to distract from this mess was to create a bigger mess.

13:31Aaron Zamost: Like suddenly everyone was talking about Vinod and investing in competitive companies. And it just sort of took the, no one cares about the CRO anymore and where he used to advise. That's true. So maybe that was, yeah, maybe actually it helped both companies. He just absorbed all of the attention. That is a very fresh take. I did not think of that. Thank you. That's like easy as a service. Vinod famously is happy to have horrible news cycles about himself. Or else he wouldn't prevent people from coming onto his beach. Don't those feel like such quaint days when like that was like the evil billionaire discourse, like beach access?

14:12Aaron Zamost: And now we're somewhere. I mean, that leads us to our good friend Benioff, who boldly declared the rebranding of AI force to SI force. A couple pods ago, we talked about Trump's mandate that artificial intelligence is now super intelligence. And I think there was a follow-up post on Truth Social that anyone who still says AI is the enemy in all caps. Oh, Aaron, you got off Twitter because you're just full-timing it on Truth Social, right? Exactly. Totally. Exactly. I think it hurts Mark in his soul that the event at the White House did not include him. That there was this big summit of all the most, I'm putting it in quotes, important people in tech attended the president's premier discussion of the future of AI.

15:06And that Mark Benioff wasn't there makes him want to die.

15:09Aaron Zamost: How much do we think that Trump didn't want anyone larger than him there? Yeah, Trump doesn't want to get frame-mogged. He's like, come stand next to me, Sam Altman. That's going to be it. Sure, and irrelevant because his not being there was, okay, how do I show the cool people that I'm cool like them? It's such high school thirst. And so he puts up a post that calls it S.I. Force, the way you roll into school with your backpack on two shoulders pretending you're just as cool as everybody else. And then go to their website. This is my plug for the podcast. This might be like reading an app. Go to www.salesforce.com slash artificial dash intelligence and see how they're branding it for their customers, which is AI force.

15:54It's not SI force. So it's just a showy, nonsensical thing to do. So pick me, pick me, as my kids say. Mark Benioff is a thirsty pick me. There you go. For all Gen Z listening to your call. There you go. Well, he's not alone. He is not alone. It sounds like XAI is now XSI, right? Yes, XSI. Very easy to see. It rolls off the tongue. It's just one step closer to getting to SX, what did I say? S-I, yes. Sexy. And like Elon has done this before. Remember when he wanted to name the Tesla models to spell sexy? The S, the three, the X, and the Y.

16:40Aaron Zamost: A high school like lunchroom metaphor is holding up really well. Yes, this is boobless and turn the calculator upside down. There's a theory I saw. I can't even know who to attribute it to. I have no memory of it. The theory is everyone is 12. And if you just accept that we're living in a time where everyone is 12. Trump only letting people come to his thing and letting and not letting everybody in. And then saying now we're all calling it. It's like don't say fetch anymore. Fetch is so over. So now we're all saying super intelligence and I'm going to make all the people in my circle also call it super intelligence.

17:17And then Benioff's like, oh, I wasn't there. But like SI, I mean, it's just everyone is 12.

17:22Aaron Zamost: On Wednesdays, we wear pink. And Erin, that is literally what you're doing right now. So one of the common themes of this podcast, maybe because Helen has a marketing background, I have a comms background, we've been in tech for a while, is like the tech industry's narrative and why it's so bad, especially outside of tech. And why do so many of our most visible leaders keep making it worse? And Aaron, you are, I was going to say equally, but you are like the perfect person to weigh in on this. You have a storied tech comms career. You started in Google. You were at Square, now Block. I don't know if you feel the same way about calling it Block as I feel about calling Twitter X.

18:04I left before it became Block, and so I call it Square.

18:07Aaron Zamost: Oh, we can call it Square. Good. I can't say block. I can't. Okay. So Square, you were at Square for almost a decade, running comms and then also running the people team, which is like a fascinating dual role. You now run your own consultancy called Background Partners, where I think you advise founders on both of those organizations and how to scale them. You lecture at Berkeley Law School. You have always been my favorite writer on all things comms, which actually used to be a very low bar. I think there's more out there now, but you are still at the top. You are now actually penning op-eds for the New York Times, calling out some of the bad behavior from the most powerful in tech, and we'll definitely get into that.

18:48Aaron Zamost: But before we get into today's mess, Helen and I are both obsessed with a particular piece that you're probably tired of talking about that you published in 2015 called What's Your Hour in Silicon Valley time. But essentially, you put forth a framework of sorts. The framework is a clock. And each of the hours represents a moment in a startup's narrative. So at midnight, you're just getting started. This is your launch moment that no one's even paying attention to. By 3 p.m., I might butcher this. By 3 p.m., you're kind of getting hot. People are like, ooh, who's this? By 6 p.m., you're the hottest company in the world.

19:29Aaron Zamost: And then you tip over into skepticism because nothing stays up forever. And I think this has had a ripple effect within the tech ecosystem, sort of a different way of thinking about hype curve or something like that. I went back and read this essay. Maybe the biggest thing that really struck me 11 years later is it was very focused on the media and when reporters are paying attention you know when business reporters start to take note not just the tech insiders and how like you know how they're receiving the story like it just reminded me of how influential media was in the prior era maybe maybe still is but just everyone on on twitter were were in la la land but yeah okay first off does the clock still work in 2026 so yes i mean obviously i think a couple of things have changed, but the impetus of the clock was a very rough patch that Square was going through based on broad and wrong, if I may say so, wrong media speculation about the health of the business.

20:37So the focus of the Post at the time was media because the media thought Square was going to zero. And since engaging with the media was my job, and as you know, it's relevance as a function of the time, but other public groups do this too, right? I mean, it happens to celebrities all the time. We already talked about where on the clock is Ed Sheeran, right? And so, you know, the it girl, whoever the it girl is, is the time goes through the clock, right? Everybody loves this person, then everyone hates her. And then there's a big comeback.

21:06Aaron Zamost: And Hathaway, she was like reviled and now she's revered. Yeah. The Anne Hathaway renaissance is real. She basically circled the clock, right? And you could say that's media or you could say it's fans or people who follow celebrity content, right? I think the one major change since I wrote that post, though, is the speed with which the clock operates. Open AI, sped run. Speed ran? Sped run. Speed ran. Speed ran. Speed ran, yeah. It's like attorneys general. Speed ran the clock. And news cycles, let alone social media cycles, happen so fast now. But the up and down nature of perception reputation hasn't changed at all.

21:44I totally agree. I was thinking of Anthropic though, because I felt like even just, you know, we were reminiscing about when Anthropic did that like little coffee shop pop-up thing in the West Village and like airmail. And, you know, I happened to be in the West Village that weekend and the line was like wrapped around the block and we just thought like, oh, infinite aura, you know, Anthropic and everyone wanted to work there. And it's like, wow, you really can have it all. It's like this mission driven company that's making so much money and they're so smart and blah, blah, blah. And then it was like, holy crap, this summer, they just got raked through the coals.

22:20And I thought of the clock, right? And I'm like, you know what? Anthropic is still such a young company. We forget about this. So like the clock to me just got like crazy condensed. And people need to go read that blog post because I'm like, I don't think the clock is outdated. I think just exactly what you said, which is like the timeline just has condensed so much. Yeah, I mean, like, we forget, it's easy to forget now, but Twitter went around the clock like nine times. It is faster now, I think. And a lot of companies just blew through it, which is a moment and I think is reflection of the time we're living in more than the media, like social media news cycles today are no different than they were five years ago, but the environment is different.

23:02But I think Anthropics a hard one. I mean, there are pockets of the public use Anthropic because they feel its brand is safety, right? and hats off to the Anthropic comms team that has a very clear message and hits it as much as they possibly can. I think Dario comes off much better than Sam and they did such a good job, in my opinion, dealing with like the Pentagon and their very public argument over security and contracts. But people still hate AI broadly. Anthropic is probably not in the good part of the clock, I think. But I don't think they're deep into it.

23:35Aaron Zamost: Which is so interesting because like if they really want to be at a good part of the clock timed with their IPO if that is still happening it's really hard it's really hard the public hates AI and they hate open AI and so Anthropic can position itself against open AI come out looking good but they're still in the AI AI tech, you know, taking our jobs, AI slop stuff. But I think Anthropic is doing as good a job as it possibly can, given the circumstances. My reaction to that comment is, wow, that is a very different take than I think. It's because he's on Blue Sky, Helen, and not on Twitter. No.

24:17Twitter is not real life, and neither is Blue Sky. Totally agreed. But the premise, and I think maybe, Ashley, somebody said this on the pod. We definitely talked about it in the group chat, but it was like the safety message. And maybe the, sometimes it feels like it's overdone. Sometimes it feels really extreme, but it's like they're being really consistent, right? And the whole game of, well, I called it out first. And because I'm acknowledging it, because I'm acknowledging and recognizing its dangers, limitations to progress, all of these things, it's almost like I'm going on the offense. so that I don't have to be on the defense for the public to point out all of its potential dangers and yada, yada, yada.

25:05Well, two things. First of all, I think Anthropic compared to Open Eye is what makes Anthropic look so good. They have smartly embraced every opportunity to be the thoughtful adults in the conversation. Whether you buy it or not, that is the strategy. The second story is a story I'll tell. I was at lunch about a week ago. I was in the South Bay having lunch outside and with a friend of mine and next door, the table next to us were two elderly women. They had to be in their 70s, maybe even early 80s. And you're not listening to what the people next to you are saying. And then suddenly, anthropic.

25:41And so the tech person I was with and I start laughing. And we, you know, let's listen to it. And these two older women started talking. And this woman says, well, I like anthropic because I think they care about safety. It's a thing she literally said out loud. Wow. And that is as close to a normal person.

26:01Aaron Zamost: We're going to clip this for the Anthropic Con. And I was just like, you know, why do politicians stand up on stage with giant signs behind them that say freedom? Right? There is a simple, single message that they are driving nonstop and they're not overcomplicating it. And that is the only way to break through when you're underwater and under the attack that they are in. So I mean, we joke that I'm on Blue Sky and you guys are on X, but like neither of those places matter. Like the perspective of the people in either of those places are irrelevant. Yes and no. Like my push on the clock, I think the clock still holds up.

26:36Aaron Zamost: I just think we have multiple clocks now. Like I think we used to have a more unified and this was a big role that the media played, right? Like the reason you cared so much about the coverage on Square was because that sort of dictated how other people felt about the company, whether it was like, you know, industry people or like, you know, merchants or developers or, you know, whatever audiences mattered most. And now I think we have like a bunch of clocks and like, you know, the clock you're describing that, you know, the, you know, sort of the more like mainstream perception clock feels like very disconnected from the insider Twitter clock.

27:14Aaron Zamost: And I would argue that the Twitter clock matters insofar as the venture dollars matter, right? Like I think a lot of the reason that, that, you know, GoDirect has been like, you know, so successful in terms of being adopted as a strategy is because we're in this era where like capital accumulation matters so much and so many investors are hanging in on Twitter. And so it just, it's like, if Anthropik raises more money and then has more revenue and then raises more money and has more revenue, that's like, that's dictating a big part of the, their position on the clock for like that set of people.

27:51If you are a startup, you want people excited about you to give you money. And by the way, half the reason that startups want coverage is to help them raise money and to recruit. And those people are all on X. So where you are on the clock on X to your point, Ashley, is to speak to a certain, very specific audience to accomplish a very specific goal. And that goal is raise money, hire people, right? But when I think about perception of big tech or a company like Anthropic that I think has graduated beyond those being the most important objectives, if everybody on X loves them, but the country hates them, I mean, look at data center polling right now.

28:32People hate data centers. So if the pocket on there trying to reach on X has them in a more positive part of the clock, I guess good for them, but it's not going to help them in reality.

28:44Aaron Zamost: Is that why the broader tech narrative sucks so much that everyone's over-indexed on a very specific audience and maybe lost sight? I mean, I think obviously the AI labs are now very aware of public sentiment, but it kind of feels like it was an afterthought for a really long time. And now heading into the midterms, heading into maybe public offerings, everyone has to really care. And it feels like there's all this baggage from telling a story to an audience. Like my perspective is the reason that Dario included a lot of these AI leaders were saying, oh, AI is going to take all the jobs. It's going to automate all white collar work is because they were selling a story to investors so they could raise more money, so they could have more.

29:35Aaron Zamost: Like that was the game for so long. And now they're dealing with the baggage of those stories in an audience where that doesn't land at all. I mean, I'm an old person now, right? I am the wrong. I wrote that piece when I was a very young person in his mid thirties, right? So I'm going to sound like such a Pollyanna, right? But I look back and I think, okay, people used to love tech. And all tech grew out of people recommending it to others, right? Like say what you will about Foursquare, which no one remembers anymore. But Foursquare was people saying, Oh, my God, it's so fun. You should do this thing with me, right?

30:16Uber was, you'll never believe how I got here. I pushed a button and a black car picked me up and took me Google, which had, I mean, I was at Google from 2007 to 2011, and we were under privacy PR siege then, but people loved Street View because they thought Google turn-by-turn navigation was so amazing and useful to them, right? And so the things that were being given to people were exciting and useful and spread because people saw value in it and shared that value and excitement with others. Did you try this thing? And so now, in particular, AI, unfortunately, is being shoved down people's throats, and there's no sense of choice by consumers.

30:59Now, I am not an AI hater. I use Claude. I find real value in AI tools. I don't use it to write, but I see that there is things that I can do. I'm a runner. I use it for helping me like plan workouts. Like there's value in it. But the problem if you're a regular person is all the messages you're getting are, you have to use this. By the way, it's bad for the environment. Oh, and it also might result in a data center next to your house and you'll lose your job and you can't do anything about it. What is there to root for in that? And so big tech and tech's narrative problem is that nobody's being given a thing that they love anymore.

31:37There's a reason Apple sort of survives. People still love their iPhones, right? And there's a reason that Amazon, yes, people like there's a lot of anti-Amazon sentiment out in the world on workers' rights and all sorts of stuff. But like if I push a button, I can have paper towels outside my door in an hour. And people find value in that. And also that's why I think people hate meta in Facebook because Facebook for 10 years has never shown any value to anyone. on the level that Google or Uber or anyone else has. And so the divergence in perception of tech was usually like, well, we like Google and we like Amazon and we like Apple, but we don't like Facebook.

32:12And for a period, we don't like Uber. Now they all get blended together because AI is basically the only thing tech is thinking about.

32:22Aaron Zamost: I feel like people would be more excited about AI in the workplace if it weren't paired with this message around and this is going to take your job. And all these layoffs. I mean, you wrote, one of your pieces that you wrote for the New York Times was about the, we'll call it blocks for the purpose of this story. The block layoffs. The block layoffs. Not the square layoffs, the block layoffs. And how so much of that is actually more messaging than reality when these leaders are coming out and they're like, oh yeah, we're slashing our workforce because we're just, we're going all in on AI and AI is replacing all these jobs.

32:57Aaron Zamost: using AI is actually quite magical. But, you know, before mentioned threads conversations that find their way to me, I will see people post things like, you know, my boss just said, I have to use AI or else I'll be fired. Like, what should I do? And so it's just like the delivery, the speed at which things are happening. I was at Box for six years and we told like the same story for all six years. We're like, guys, the cloud, the cloud is changing. And now things are so fast. If you're in tech, they feel fast. But if you're outside of tech, I think it feels like this is all happening very quickly and no one has any say in it.

33:41Aaron Zamost: But also more fragmented than ever. So I think that there's that layer that it's super fast, but then it's also really fragmented. So So if it were just the speed, I think that would be one thing. But it's both speed and complexity of like, you know, people live in completely separate realities. And so you almost have to adjust your message and fine tune and figure out like, well, what is this cohort influenced by? I am on my phone right now because I wanted to find the Google AI summary of my emails back at work with Ashley about this pod. The tip of the spear for consumer engagement with AI right now is the worst shit in the world.

34:24It's like I get to my thing and the opening email is like, Ashley asked if you would join the podcast. You said da-da-da-da-da. She said, great, and you will be – like it's just such – and that's what people are seeing every single day as the main interaction. I agree. There's some incredible stuff and I use it, but you have to go passively what you're receiving is shit. and so if once you you know what is it you only have one chance to make a good first impression right and so people see ai is not useful to them in its first iteration and that you're just like i don't i don't want to use this right and so the justification for the amount of money that these companies are spending they need to find a way to get it to be used so that way they can come out with the kind of vanity metrics that the three of us used to come up with uh to show how many people love using a 10 million bajillion people are using ai and google gmail for creating whatever like it's just such nonsense and like my parents who are generally tech tech savvy they like they don't use ai because these things are being fed they're like this what what was this the google gmail uh suggested replies are the fucking worst suggested replies they're hilarious They were so bad.

35:39Ashley, comma, I would be so happy to – I'm like, Ashley will read this and know I didn't say this. This is such shit. And I worry that AI companies in particular and tech broadly are trying to dig themselves out of a hole they created in the past year or two.

35:53Aaron Zamost: Are there any reasons for optimism? We've talked about before. We need like a Steve Jobs of this era or someone who actually is good at talking about technology to consumers and making that feel tangible and exciting. And I think a big part of this is it feels like there's a bit of a leadership vacuum where there's no one who is the voice of this. I mean, I think Sam Altman would like to be. I think Dario is a little bit too. Academic. The word you're looking for is academic. We've seen the videos. And then like people like, you know, Satya Nantala have actually taken a little bit of a backseat.

36:33Aaron Zamost: There's just an Apple change in leadership. It feels like there's no one to be the voice. I guess Zuck is trying, right? He's now written multiple essays talking about how great AI is going to be for consumers. But I don't think anyone's buying that. He can't be the voice. His voice isn't normal, right? Most people are normal. I mean, it's debatable. But the broad, silent majority of the public look at Mark Zuckerberg and go, that guy is not human. He just is incapable of demonstrating any indication that he is a normal person. I totally agree. I think the one recent pushback I got on that sort of thinking is that he has been CEO of this company for so long.

37:25He can't get fired. There are now people in tech who are entering this chapter and missed completely every chapter before him. And so now that he's literally got a crew of 20 people managing his social media, his image, like all this stuff. No one believes that Mark Zuckerberg in his fancy T-shirt, wearing his newly acquired$500 ,000 watch and best friends with the CEO of MMA. No one is buying that. With him walking with his gold chain, like no one sees him and hears him talk and thinks, now there's a normal cool guy. And I think Sam, you're right, Ashley, has tried to also grab that mantle. And then he went on The Tonight Show and said, I can't imagine anybody raising a baby without Chats GPT, even though every human in the history of human civilization has.

38:16It's just like these people cannot, they're not the right spokespeople. Well, so who would be? Who would you cast? Who would you bring in? What would you do? This is not an original idea, but I heard somebody speaking on in a video about how companies used to have corporate spokespeople, right? Do you remember I'm a Mac, I'm a PC? The guy who was a Mac made Mac look super cool. And the guy who was a PC was what, John Hodgman, right? Justin Long, that was the name of the guy. Justin Long. And that was an ad that made Macs look cool. It wasn't Steve Jobs on TV telling you to use a Mac. And so Mark Zuckerberg telling you to use a muse or the way he was like trying to get you to use the metaverse.

38:56Are you kidding? I want to be in the metaverse with that guy. That's crazy. I mean, that's what corporate spokespeople are for. So that's not an original idea. But it's, it's, I think I'm really sure you say Satya, Ashley, and I agree. I think there is what I've been calling a reputational arbitrage opportunity for any normal leader in tech to suddenly become the most beloved leader in corporate America. and Tim Cook, I thought, would have been that guy. And he completely decided not to.

39:24Aaron Zamost: I think it was political, right? It was like, why put yourself out there as a target? He was already dealing with the tariff stuff. I mean, I'm not saying, I mean, I think there could have been a ton of upside, but I think it was like downside mitigation. Yes. So I don't know. I mean, look at the leaders of all these companies, right? So like, Satya seems more normal. Jensen Wang, I thought, might be. but he's also saying SI and talking about how Trump is the smartest person he's ever met. None of these things are authentic at all. If you're just a Mark Benioff, does anyone believe Mark Benioff?

40:01Well, maybe we have to wait for midterms. Maybe we have to wait for some sort of tide to change because I do agree. Everyone is bending their knee. It's going to be very hard to come back and present yourself as somebody who stood on principle. I cannot picture who in current business life in tech has that elder statesman adult thing. I think Jamie Dimon in finance has a level of credibility from – and look, America hates Wall Street and finance. But Jamie Dimon comes out and he says a thing. We're like, all right, that guy's an adult. I mean, I think Dario has a chance, but you're right. He's really academic.

40:40Sam cannot. Mark constitutionally cannot. Elon is the villain of our age.

40:47Aaron Zamost: Maybe John Ternus is our dark horse. Sounds great. I was just thinking that too. How do we get to him? Sounds great. It's a great idea. This is your opportunity. You're like kind of the only one who has, doesn't have the baggage, but has the platform and the credibility just by virtue of being Apple CEO. Yeah, maybe not being in the AI race, right? Being completely absent in the AI race for the last few years will end up being Apple's like - Apple hasn't said any terrible things about what's going to happen to the human race. So that is an advantage on day one. The American public, if you look at the polls, desperately wants someone normal.

41:26And no one has decided to go, you know what? I'll be that person. It's October, 2026. Polls on AI, Trump, and data centers are in the toilet. And every single one of these leaders goes to the White House and stands next to him. I'm like, that is negligence. That is like such a bad idea. And I get politically, it might make sense. But from a reputational perspective, could you think of a dumber thing to do than go to an AI summit at the White House in October, 2026? That's crazy.

41:54Aaron Zamost: I think this is like back to the speed of the clock. I think everyone has very short-term thinking and we've lost the ability to think on longer time horizons. Yes, that's 100%. And in areas where the power structures are different. Like, it's just like, we're all, I think a lot of it is belief that massive liquidity and massive wealth and power accumulation are right around the corner. And so why would you think three steps ahead? A thousand percent. I totally agree. And the idea that you can message your way through it by being like, oh, don't worry. AI is going to create a three-day work week, says Jeff Bezos.

42:27While last year, he forced all Amazon employees to be back in the office. Well, not him. Amazon forced all Amazon employees to be back in the office five days a week. So yeah, right. I'm supposed to believe that AI is going to create a three-day work week. The second AI makes a three-day work week, they're just going to make you work the extra two days on something else. And there's just like, nobody has decided to just be normal and honest about this stuff. I think it's so weird. Anybody could stand up and be a fucking hero right now. You said, did tech lose its spine, right? And I have to be the cynical person who says that like, I don't think that they lost their spine.

43:04I think they never had one, which is super depressing for a person who used to be idealistic and work in these companies, right? Like everything leaders have ever done publicly has apparently or has been performative in service of like whatever reputational strategy was necessary to grow their business, right? When it was smart branding to be pro-environment, they were. And it was smart politics to avoid regulation by sucking up to Trump. They did that too, right? That is not about values. That is about business, right? Companies used to try to balance the benefits to shareholders against the benefits to workers, the benefits to consumers, the benefits of their community.

43:36But that all went out the window in the 70s and 80s. And the central pillar of business has now maximized shareholder value, which is why Tim Cook gives Trump a glass award, right? So did Tim Cook lose his spine? I mean, maybe yes. But I could just be naive because if Tim Cook had told Trump to fuck off and Apple stock had collapsed, they'd question, the public would have questioned whether he was the right person to be the CEO during this time, right? So it's all business. So the fact that after the midterms or any other administration, people will have to go back. And that's why I think it will be harder for the people who've been way out on a ledge, right?

44:10Like if you're the CEO of Palantir, you ain't coming back to moderation.

44:14Aaron Zamost: Just to be optimistic for a second, this is as an early stage investor, this is why I'm so excited for like a new wave of founders who don't have this baggage from this era. If they actually can come to the table with like a positive story for the future, if they can be normal enough, or even if they can just care beyond a sort of more insider class when they're thinking about their audience. I think that that is a massive opportunity. To your point, I try to, I think of it like what is abundant and what is scarce. There's so much that's scarce right now, even though it's this insanely noisy time and everyone's vying for attention, like both in terms of story content, but also how people are telling them.

45:01Aaron Zamost: there's just so much space to go after. And a lot of it is just having, yeah, like speaking to people who aren't investors or other tech people, having a version of the future that you believe deeply in that is not dystopian. Like those are all up for grabs right now. And so I don't know, I think like if you are a founder building today and you have like the appetite and the aptitude to go for that. It could be massive. Yeah. I mean, it's not hard to look like you are not evil during a time of great public awfulness. I mean, your point about Satya is like, he's going to win by default. In the land of the blind, the one-eyed man is king, right?

45:44And so

45:44Aaron Zamost: Satya, he's looking pretty good. This was so fun. Thank you, Aaron. No, thank you for having me. I am super happy to come to a place where two people want to hear me rant. Thank you for listening to Great Chat. Have questions for us? Make sure to submit them at anothergreatchat.com. See you next week.

From the publisher

People beyond Silicon Valley used to love the products tech companies made. Now, they feel like AI tools (and data centers) are being shoved down their throats. This week, comms pro Aaron Zamost joins the chat to rant about tech’s reputational decline and leadership vacuum. Maybe what we really need is a spokesperson who is, well…normal (it's a lot to ask). Plus: we debate what has and hasn’t changed since Aaron’s famous “startup clock” essay from 2015, lament the AI to SI rebrands, and dissect Twitter beefs spanning Vinod Khosla and Kelly Clarkson.

Mercury is back as the headline sponsor for year two of Great Chat. Mercury is a financial technology company, not a bank. Banking services provided through Choice Financial Group, Column N.A., and Evolve Bank & Trust; Members FDIC.

This podcast is edited by Eric Johnson from ⁠⁠LightningPod: https://lightningpod.fm

More from Great Chat

All episodes