1. Podcasts
  2. Great Chat
  3. The case for AI optimism
Great Chat

29 Oct 2026 · 41m · 17 chapters

Episode artwork

The case for AI optimism

In short

The hosts argue for AI optimism as a counterpoint to “doomer” headlines, using examples from AI creativity, shifting job value, and real-world productivity/health use cases. They also discuss recent AI industry news, including Anthropic’s S1/IPO chatter and new agent apps (Instinct, Muse, Boba).

Guests (hosts)

Ashley (co-host; former comms/marketing background), Helen (co-host; former comms/marketing background; uses an agent via Sejal’s agent), Angela (co-host; emphasizes business opportunities and “hope-core”), Mac (co-host; jokes about being both Gen Z/boomer; skeptical of group-chat AI agents; discusses housing/using Helen’s agent).

Key claims

AI automates disliked “little tasks,” making human craft more valuable; AI lowers barriers to entry and can be more meritocratic; productivity gains don’t necessarily mean fewer workers (example: 10x sales effectiveness implies hiring fewer salespeople is not the only outcome); time/capital may flow to undervalued care work; AI can support health research (e.g., ferritin/iron).

Notable examples

Marissa Mayer’s NYT “Dazzle” anecdote about describing her daughter; Anthropic S1 reception and IPO strategy speculation; Instinct’s intrusive group-chat behavior; Human-and-Boba agent launch; Nathan Fielder doc and Seinfeld podcast as “deep human craft” examples; ChatGPT used for pregnancy questions and iron/ferritin research.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

0:30

Celebrating Achievements

The hosts celebrate their award for best co-host team.

“And we couldn't have done it without you because it was best co-host team.”
1:40

Pottery and Candle Making

Discussing pottery and plans to create candles for the podcast.

“I recently posted that I've been getting really into pottery, so maybe I just make us a statue.”
4:00

Marissa Mayer Discussion

Analyzing the controversy around Marissa Mayer's AI app and parenting.

“I would import koalas just to import koalas, but I don't want any of the spiders or snakes from Australia.”
6:40

AI and Parenting Dilemmas

Exploring the challenges of modern parenting with AI technologies.

“And so everyone's tweeting this and like just completely dunking.”
8:30

Anthropic IPO Discussion

Analyzing the recent Anthropic S1 filing and its implications.

“two weeks after having a baby but has the luxury of working from home and like kind of having my cake and eating it too and figuring it out, I'm like, you know what?”
11:00

Predictions and Market Insights

Discussing market predictions and investor reactions to the IPO news.

“Yeah, just like get it out of our – okay, fine.”
14:01

Investors and IPOs

Discussion on investor sentiments towards recent IPOs and investments in AI.

“We've talked many times about how he's a true believer.”
16:41

AI Chatbots in Group Chats

Discussion on the use and frustrations with AI chatbots in group settings.

“Rohit, I didn't say your name until you brought yourself up.”
19:22

Trends in AI and User Experiences

Exploration of user experiences with AI tools and the changing landscape.

“Well, I was going to say, yeah, like my instinct usage is declining and it's not nudging me as much to use it, which means they're probably running into compute capacity.”
23:02

Optimism About AI Development

A shift towards positive perspectives on AI and its potential benefits.

“Like the clock is just moving so quickly.”
Show all 17 chapters
25:41

Creativity and AI

Discussion on how AI influences creativity and the balance with human artistry.

“I saw this really dumb AI-generated video on the timeline the other day.”
28:00

The Intersection of AI and Human Craft

Exploring how AI can enhance human creativity and appreciation for craft.

“is bending art forms and created something totally new.”
29:11

Redefining Marketing and Communication Roles

Discussing how AI is reshaping and elevating traditional marketing and communication roles.

“So I'll just go right after you, which is just, you know, I love when people think that they gotcha.”
30:37

AI's Impact on Opportunities and Workforce

Highlighting how AI democratizes access and creates meritocratic environments.

“Mine is, I have so many things I'm optimistic about right now, especially because like there's an absurd amount of good stuff happening.”
33:17

Valuing Undervalued Jobs in the AI Era

Examining how AI can shift value towards traditionally undervalued jobs.

“It's like one of the few things that's bringing me a huge amount of hope.”
35:35

The Narrative of AI: Beyond Major Milestones

Discussing the need for narratives about AI's everyday positive impacts.

“But also looks maxing and health maxing for all.”
36:57

Choosing Optimism in an AI-Driven World

Advocating for an optimistic perspective on AI and its potential benefits.

“And yeah, Helen, I would say like similarly, the small things just on like a personal health level, right?”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On Great Chat, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:05Today on Great Chat, amidst all the Doomer AI headlines, we talk about our reasons for optimism. How contrarian. I'm Ashley and I'm joined by Helen, Angela, and Mac. Great chat is brought to you by Mercury, radically different banking loved by over 300 ,000 entrepreneurs. We use Mercury to run this podcast and love recommending it to other founders and fund managers. It's free to get started. Try it for yourself and visit mercury.com to learn more and apply online in this. Damn, I miss you guys so much. This is awesome. We won an award. I know. Woo! A round of applause. A signal award. And we couldn't have done it without you because it was best co-host team.

0:46And that's everyone. It's my favorite thing when people I love get recognized for doing badass shit. I'm just like, yes. Yes. Mar. Mac, whether you want to or not, you are part of this. Yeah. I want to. I am part of this. No Mac erasure, even if she is a very occasional guest. But when you're here, you bring the energy. I have pitched Gabe on going to the awards show, so I will keep you guys posted. I mean, for the content. A trophy? So there's nothing I hate more than like being in a crowd of people I don't – I'm just not good at talking to strangers, and I don't think I will know anyone at this party.

1:22Oh, I mean, I don't think mingling is like a requirement. Why don't you just go bring the baby? Bring the baby. I'm not bringing my two-month-old and peak flu and COVID season to a podcast party. Somebody just needs to retrieve the award. I don't know if you've been following me on my Instagram. Not to plug. Everybody follow Max. She's a great follow. I recently posted that I've been getting really into pottery, so maybe I just make us a statue. Oh, yes. I did see that. Or what if I make us another big-ass candle? Your emblem. It's very Loewe, however you pronounce that brand. You nailed it. you absolutely pronounced Loewe correctly.

2:00Was that what you were intending, the little emblem? Oh, you mean the little – so I'm messing around with – dear, great chat listeners, we will throw a couple options for signatures in the chat, and I would really appreciate if the group would opine because I feel like it looks a little bit like a butterfly and not like in a cute Zara Larson way and like it's kind of distracting. Can you tell that that's an M and a situation. I have a few other options. I want the group's take on this because you guys have good taste. This is great. Chat Enterprises, like consumer products additions. Yeah. We're going to make ceramic candles.

2:36My favorite thing is that Angela is never going to, never going to forget that there's always a business opportunity and we must absolutely capitalize on it. And like, that is why we are all going to retire early and go be talking mad shit from our houses in Napa. Like I love this. Angela, never letting you go, babe. This podcast will get so much spicier when we're post-economic. Like I can't wait. Post-economic? God, I forgot about that chapter of this year. You guys, I feel like 2026 has been 18 years long. It is really long. This guy would be your energy. But I was on a – if banks sponsored a women in tech, like I guess diversity is still alive and well.

3:14They just must have slipped that under the budget and I was just a boondoggle to Napa for two days. But we went on this hike and this guy who was our guy from Napa was like, I come up here and I take the eucalyptus leaves and then I dry it down and take the oils and make my own candle. So it's free. Like we could literally make great chat enterprise candles for free with eucalyptus oil in Napa. Well, she just gave the keys to the supply chain. I know. Angela, what is your problem? Why are you out here spoiling our secrets? There is an exploitable resource available. How dare you? It's not like it grows back.

3:52It's, you know. You know what? We do need to get rid of eucalyptus trees in California too, because they are like one of the most flammable things. Why don't we import koalas? Koalas? Don't koalas eat eucalyptus? I would import koalas just to import koalas, but I don't want any of the spiders or snakes from Australia. Thank you. Did you guys read the Marissa Mayer New York Times article? I only read the excerpt that everyone was sharing, the lead. Did you read the whole thing? No, I didn't. I was hoping one of you did so that you could be like, actually, it was just very unfair that the screenshot went viral because the whole piece was extremely thoughtful.

4:30The whole piece was not extremely thoughtful. The whole piece, the whole piece, like, don't get me wrong. Like, Marissa, Deepa, like, oh, you've done so many good things. Why? Genuine question. Like, do you think once you hit billionaire status, you're like, you know what I need? A little bit more exposure. Like, I feel like what people want, they're asking for more of me. No, no. Specifically, they're like, let me take this thing that I am very clearly out of touch with, but I've lost any ability to sense whether or not I'm out of touch and then amplify it. No, here's the thing. I know better than everyone else around me.

5:07But like, don't these people employ other people who are in touch to stop this? Like I – No, because I know best. I actually – like I understand life a little bit more than you. That's why I have a billion of those things in the bank. And I just think it's like really important that like everyone understand what I understand, which is that I don't understand my kids. Are you guys ready for me to be a Marissa Mayer apologist? And it's not just because of the last name. Yes. I'm so here for it. I saw that you saw the – Yeah. Defend your cousin, Ashley. I am on board. You know, I used to – Yes, the rebuttal was good.

5:42We were related. Well, I just thought like she – You said that you were related like in an Elizabeth Holmes way or just like for shits and giggles? I don't know. Oh, I mean for shits and giggles. And it was back when her star was like at its peak, right? Like the moment when she went from Google to Yahoo and, you know, everyone thought she was the person. Okay. So, yes. First of all, I thought – so if anyone hasn't read the excerpt, maybe we should explain that. She's like talking about a use case for her AI app Dazzle. And the New York Times story opens with her daughter is turning 10. And I guess the teacher prompted her to send like three words that describe her daughter.

6:29And the way the writer portrays it is that Marissa was like stuck and she turned to Dazzle. And Dazzle said, your daughter is creative, empathetic, and an animal lover or something. And she thought that was great. And so everyone's tweeting this and like just completely dunking. Like you don't even know your daughter. You're turning to AI to describe her, whatever. So – and I get why that was fodder. I mean, we were saying in the group chat, this is like Sam Altman's, how did people raise babies before chat GPT? Like, and she's like, oh, no. So anyways, terrible anecdote to share. Um, Marissa was very classy in her response and like thanked the New York times for the piece and just gave more context around, around that use case and like why she thought it was impressive that the AI like landed on those things.

7:21So anyways, I just liked that she didn't get furious, like talk about fake news, like try to blow. I mean, she already got a ton of attention from that moment, so she didn't need to do anything more. but I have to respect Marissa's hustle. I mean, talk about being post-economic. She could just chill and she keeps launching these apps. But maybe it's better to just chill in this case. I don't know. I mean, genuinely, I don't know. Angela, you're like – Does the world need more – I'm rooting her on. I'm trying. Here's what I will give her. It probably means that she's talking about her kid a lot to her AI.

7:55No, it's – do you know what the app is? It's like a muse based on your camera roll instead of back and forth in language or something. And so when she asked Dazzle to describe her daughter, it's like looking at all these photos and I guess surmising things. So it did kind of make sense. I also want to be a Marissa Mayer apologist. Maybe this will get me canceled a little bit. Remember when she got in so much trouble for like two weeks after having twins? She went back to the office and she like had a little nursery built in her office. this. And as someone who is not taking a traditional parental leave and started working two weeks after having a baby but has the luxury of working from home and like kind of having my cake and eating it too and figuring it out, I'm like, you know what?

8:39Good for her. Good for her. I get all the reasons that it's complicated because of the standard it sets for other women. Like I understand why she specifically has a deeper responsibility to like set an example and that's kind of an impossible example to set for most people. But on an individual level, I was like, Marissa, I get you. I get why you did that and I'm happy your babies were near. So there's my mayor to mayor apology. I'm so glad you and your cousin are so close. We're so close. We're so alike. Who has a favorite Anthropic S1 take? No. You know what I have is a job. You know what I haven't done?

9:18Read the Anthropic S1 yet. But it dropped yesterday. I'm so employed that I have been working all day. I told my husband this at dinner. I'm like, honestly, the pervasive thought I've had all day, anytime the Anthropic S1 came was, I'm so glad we own our home. Like truly, because – Fuck you, Ellen. Yeah, I know. Sorry. I know you're in the market. But like I think the numbers that people have been projecting like, oh, when these IPOs hit, San Francisco is going to have a tidal wave of bazillionaires and they're going to buy up all the – I'm like, yeah, you know, that's never going to happen. You know, yeah, I don't know.

9:58I don't know if that's really – and then this pretty clearly spelled out exactly how many people would come into extreme wealth and on what dates, you know. And you're like, oh, oh, okay. Mac, buy your home before that. Yeah, Mac, you literally were just shown a schedule. If you best believe Helen, Sejal is seeing a place today. Yes. Like it is. For great chat listeners, I am using Helen's agent and she is amazing. So anyone want a pro tip, Sejal Binnings. But fuck off until I've got my place. Thank you. I have a hot take, which is that I thought the reception to the S1 was generally very positive.

10:37So positive. This is an incredible business. And now I'm like, oh, the negative news cycle we had like a week ago that inspired our last pod, like is AI over and anthropic soft Q3. I think that was quite strategic. The thing you don't want to do is disappoint people in the S1. And like they had kind of their course correction ahead of it where people got to like digest and process that. Let it all out. Yeah, just like get it out of our – okay, fine. And I'm so angry that this giant company didn't keep up like the Q2 growth rate. And we all came to terms with that and grieved it. And so when the S1 hit, like there's the stats of like the number of businesses who spend more than 10 million a year on Claude, the number of businesses that spend more than a million.

11:23Like it's just like an insane business that was started in what, 2021. And so I feel like we all got, you know, sort of the negative news cycle out of the way and were able to approach this S1 with like the reverence it deserved. And so kudos to the Anthropic Coms team. I wonder if that's a new playbook and like you'll see anybody else like take away the very insightful, you know, sort of take away that you had. I mean, I'm sitting here taking notes. You're like, guys, what about – I was paying attention. I saw that and I was like, oh, okay, noted. What about the day before we just, you know, sort of shake it all out?

11:58Day before. Girl, week and a half. Yeah, I think Angela's about to disagree with me. No, I feel like it was kind of like already expected. Like, weren't there so many reports pre the negative cycle about here's, we saw the draft S1, here are all the stats. Like, weren't all the stats already disclosed? I almost felt like the S1 dropped and it was like everybody knew already what was in it. So it was kind of like, okay, like, it's just now confirmed. There were all those like leaks of the S1 like weeks before. And I feel like they like preempted all of this. They had all the good stuff come out.

12:32Also a power comms move. Like that is also a genius strategy of like, fine, we'll put it and we'll put it in a shinier package later. I know. Not to take away from the business, but I was like, oh, like there's nothing new in here. I think it was the combination of like the numbers are amazing. And yes, we kind of like knew the numbers, but also they're doing it, right? Like the conversation a week ago, even in our group chat was like, is Anthropic actually going to go out before the end of the year given these numbers, given like, you know, are they pacing for a good Q4 because you don't want to miss your first quarter out of the gate and they're doing it and it's kind of a power move or at least that's what it feels like.

13:09Although Helen had like a conspiratorial hot take in the group chat. Which one? No, you said they were going to intentionally like have a shitty IPO to slow down. I was kidding. I know. Okay. My joke was. Helen's like, do not hold me to my words. Yeah, that I repeated over and over again. No, I believe the exact words were, is Dario the real AI doomer doing the IPO in the pit of pessimism? No, no, no, no, no, no. I said maybe Dario's real power move, if he truly is a believer, is he's going to purposely go out in front and do this massive IPO and have it be such a bomb that that will literally pace the frontier.

13:55It will force a pacing of the frontier. But guys, I joke. It's a joke. I loved it. I was cackling. It was good. It was a good joke. I don't know. We've talked many times about how he's a true believer. This is not just like a shtick, right? How pissed would his investors be if he was like, I'm going to architect the worst? Very, very pissed all the way to the bank when they cash out before any of that really comes to. I mean, like, even a soft anthropic IPO would still make most of his investors an obscene amount of money. So, like, I don't feel too bad for them. Like, congrats on, like, making one of these smartest investments of your life.

14:35The triple-layered SPVs into the latest rounds might feel the crunch. But everyone else, they're doing okay. Tiny violin. I don't know. I do know some of those people, and they seem pretty happy. I think they're going to be really happy. I think the – I mean, you know, famous last words. I don't know shit about the IPOs, but. At the very least, they can tweet. Like when I invested in Anthropic, like everyone was doubting. Oh, God. A whole new class of insufferable people. Oh, my gosh. Oh, my God. We get Uber 2.0. Oh, can't wait. Who's the new Jason Calcanis? Who's the new Jason Calcanis? Jason Calcanis has said nice things about it.

15:12Great chat. We love you, Jason. I have not seen many people like do that on the timeline just yet, at least. They've learned from Aura. I think that like for instance, I saw content around like Spark Capitals investing in the series. And I wonder if people are being really strategic and like seeding it with others to share it versus like chest thumping themselves because that's what I would do. Or just waiting until the actual IPO. Yeah. If Coalition were like an early investor in Anthropik, I'd be like, hey, Helen, can you like screenshot this part of the S1? and like, you know, because I think, I do think it's like a little much.

15:51And also there are so many folks involved, but I mean, truly like Anthropic was a contrarian bet in the earlier rounds. And so this is fun. This is what like venture is for. And its earliest investors were all high net worth individuals. So we're like no VC firms. Right. I love that all of these charts, like the, who, you know, what, what funds get the biggest windfall, yada, yada, yada, to start at series c it was just like eric schmidt yeah our boy eric schmidt in the earliest rounds and our girl caroline ellison i read somewhere that her stake is now worth 5.4 billion dollars which is crazy that's so impressive is anyone still using like a ai chat pod if anybody doesn't have a strong opinion on this can i bitch for like 10 minutes please 10 minutes you can have I'm in it.

16:40Okay. Jesus Christ. Somebody added... Rohit, I didn't say your name until you brought yourself up. I've been following this Mac Twitter drama. Somebody added fucking instinct to one of our group chats. Rohit. Not ours. No, but if you do, I will leave the group chat and then I will come find you. You guys were very specific. If you want to try adding one, start another one. No, I don't want another one. Do not add me to the other one. Why the fuck? Like genuinely, only what is the use case for adding an AI agent to a fucking group chat? Like, don't get me wrong. I love AI. It's great. I'm rooting for Anthropics IPO.

17:16But what the shit is that? Like, it is so bad. Oh my God. It is like, I just got ad after ad after ad. It's so responsive and it's such a sycophant and it's the worst. And oh my God, it's so annoying. Wait, how does that, how does that work? Does it text in a group chat or like, what is it? What would you like to see? Because they just kept texting me back lots of links it says oh by the way do you want to download it oh my god by the way do you want to download it and i'm like no i didn't want to download it the first 18 times bitch like go away i thought it would just sit there and like add reactions i don't like that either that'd be no but that'd be like a way to ease reactions i only want earned laughter if i'm being stupid i need to know i feel like instincts reactions in in the i messages are like pretty good.

18:00It was a good, thoughtful thing that they did. It's just doing like thumbs up or check boxes for me pretty much. No, they'll get more – Yes, they get creative. I asked for a restaurant recommendations in Japan and there was like a sushi emoticon or like toy trains and it was a train emoticon. So I kind of stepped in it. I was at an event last week and I was talking to two guys. One is an investor, one is a founder, and we were talking about instinct and muse and all this stuff and like how like he's good at some use cases, but, you know, usage is dropping off. And I went on a little rant about how I think couples using it to coordinate with each other is like very sad.

18:43Like I don't know if you've seen these screenshots of like the husband's instinct is talking to the wife's instinct and it's just like going back and forth. And then anyways, I did my whole thing and both of them were like, oh, we love that. And I was like, is this a gendered thing? Is this how men want to not talk to their wives? Anyways. Maybe. Maybe. Do either of you use it in that way to like coordinate with your – yeah. Okay. No. I'm glad. I'm the bigger instinct and muse user than my husband. So there's no risk yet of that in my household. But yeah. Okay. Well, I was going to say, yeah, like my instinct usage is declining and it's not nudging me as much to use it, which means they're probably running into compute capacity.

19:35It's because it only wants Mac. It's like we have our eye on the prize. It only wants to serve ads. Its entire like product and marketing budgets are aligned around like how do we get Mac? I think I'm literally never going to use it now because that was such a terrible first experience. I'm just sort of like, wow, fuck this noise. It's good hearing that you guys are having good experiences with it. Like I said, I'm such a fucking boomer when it comes to AI stuff. So I love learning through you guys what actual useful use cases for this stuff is. But it's bad in group chats. Okay. Well, Mac, have you tried Boba?

20:09Girl, I have not tried any of these things. We don't have time. I have no agents. But there was a big reveal. No, there was a new – there's a new one. Oh, is that the humans and one? Yes. That's – it dropped last week and literally nobody gave a shit. Helen, I only saw about it from – because of your post in our group chat. Like nowhere in my feed, no one talking about – it's like the opposite of instinct. My joke was this company – yes, this company raised, what was it, 500 million on 5 billion like a year ago. And I think the clever thing that they did was, it was technically a seed. It was like a first round outside capital.

20:47And they would take a one-hour walk or a one-hour meeting with every investor and answer whatever questions you wanted. But then at the end of the meeting, you had to say you're in or you're out. I'm like, okay. And then you saw people kind of flexing on Twitter that they were in that round. And I'm like, I think you're kind of an idiot. But anyways, it was innovative. It was an interesting way to fundraise. So Helen in the same podcast, people who were early on anthropic, that was a contrarian bet at the time. Also, Helen, people who invested in human and, bro. Yeah, I don't know. It's all of them.

21:20Timing. Timing is really important. But they finally did their big like – But my favorite part of the humans and is like, look, they're all like 24 years old and like super idealistic and it's wonderful and they're going to change the world and they all left anthropic. And the funniest thing, they were like, Anthropic is too commercial. Like, they don't care about the frontier. They don't care about research. Like, we left to go pursue the truest form of, like, building for AI. And it was like – I was like, it's like Anthropic left of an AI, and now all these factions are leaving Anthropic. It's like, yes, you don't care – Russian nesting dolls.

21:53You don't care about commercialization, but you're raising at a$4 billion valuation, right? It's like, oh, we're curious, but we care about the$4 billion valuation. Yes, but, okay, so the launch was last week. and their product is called Boba, which from what I can see is probably like an instinct. It's like a thing that you chat with. My joke was, wow, this post is a day old and it has as many likes as like Ashley's average tweet on a daily basis. Like - Thanks, guys. Like 364 likes or something. And I was like, this truly shows like we just, there's no space. There's no space in the algorithm.

22:27There's no space on Mac's phone. There's just no space. Like there are so many agents now. That's also why, I mean, not to go back to our doomerism, but after like a big run met us back down this week, you know, people have sort of like come off of the Muse high and started to ask the questions of you have to raise a ton of money and is Muse ever going to make money? Well, that's, I mean, the stock has been down, right? And so I feel like it sort of like reach the peak of like Muse mania and like personal app mania. And then it's, it's like a hangover. This is like our conversation with Aaron Zamos.

23:03Like the clock is just moving so quickly. Like Muse was the hottest thing. And now it's like, eh, will it ever make money? And that happened in like a couple of weeks, which is insane. Yes. The cycles are faster, but the cycles are still the cycles. Can we invite a security person on great chat? Because I have like a trillion questions. No, Mac, I am amazed at how much access people are giving apps like Instinct and use to like their bank accounts, their chats. I just feel like I keep reading all these horror stories that get like – I have so many friends who have so many – who are being helped so much by this technology.

23:41Like, again, like, God, I sound like such a fucking boomer. No, it's good. It's good. We need a boomer on this podcast. Yeah, and it could be you, the youngest person on this podcast. Congrats. I love that. I love that for me. Mac, you are both our, like, Gen Z and our boomer at the same time, and we're just hanging out millennial land. I feel solidly both, so I can get you someone who can do all three. Gen X, I'm coming for you. The headlines around AI, aside from, like, anthropic, you know, now being a positive story, like, are, like, pretty bleak, right? Like, human extinction, AI taking all the jobs, cybersecurity apocalypse from like the past week or so.

24:23And apparently that's only going to get way worse. What might happen to the economy if Helen is right and Dario is architecting this IPO to flop and like crash the whole US and maybe global economy. But even the Marissa Mayer stuff, right? Like, you know, use cases that are outsourcing like what it means to be human to AI. and I was just scrolling my favorite Happy Place Twitter last week and I saw this tweet from Joe Wiesenthal and it was basically just his bull case for AI that he's like learning so much more and reading so much more and like going down rabbit holes and he has friends who are getting like super philosophical as we grapple with all these questions around what it means to live with like abundant super intelligence.

25:07It was just like so refreshing because I think so much of the feed is so negative and certainly so many of the headlines are so negative. And so we decided that we would make this – we got all the rants out of the way and we would make this podcast like our reasons for optimism around AI and this like technology wave more broadly. And so let's do it. Let's like be contrarian and optimistic. Who wants to go first? Like why are you optimistic about – I really liked your answer, Ashley. Will you kick us off? I have been thinking a lot about like human creativity and AI, and I think it's barbelling in this really fun way.

25:44I saw this really dumb AI-generated video on the timeline the other day. I don't know if you guys saw it. Trump is like Dr. Evil from Austin Powers fame. Can you send it to me? Because as you know, I am your fellow Austin Power trilogy enthusiast. I think it's like a very millennial thing to be obsessed with Austin Powers. Wait, is this something we all have in common? Because Austin Powers can do no wrong. Thank you, Mike Myers, for your creation. It's the best trilogy of all time. Anyways, I'm going to digress. Okay, now you're a millennial again. Anyways, it's just like, you know, Dr. Evil's doing his famous like$100 million or$1 million, but instead it's like he gets a billion and a trillion wrong.

26:24And then Sam Altman is his son. And like the other AI leaders are all the evil henchmen. And you know, it's dumb, but I like – like it was so great. I need this. I need the tweet. I will throw it in the group chat. Ashley, please throw it in the group chat. And can I just say that one of my group chats has been – we have this friend, F. Miles, who is like the biggest personality. But my friends have started making campaign ads for him using AI. And I have never laughed so hard. Every time someone comes out with one, I'm like, stop, guys. My show is on. It's the best. Yes. This is exactly it. There are so many silly, fun things.

26:57It would have just been way too much work to ever – you'd be such a weirdo if you had figured out how to do anything like this pre-AI. It would have taken so much. And now it's just so easy. And so if you can dream it, you can do it. And right now everything's like pretty free. We'll see what happens when it's less subsidized. And so I just think there's going to be this explosion of creativity. And yeah, there's going to be a lot of slop and a lot of it's going to be dumb. But it's also going to be new forms of expression. And it kind of reminds me a little bit of how taking photos became so democratized with smartphones, right?

27:28Previously with the camera. And then all of a sudden, you know, people are taking billions upon billions, I don't know, maybe trillions of photos all the time. And we're just going to be able to do that in so many other formats and so much other creativity. So that's one end of the barbell. And then the other end of the barbell is like, I think that our appreciation deepens and the bar raises for like true human genius artistry. I mean, the Nathan Fielder doc is an example where it just like blew everyone's minds. And it's so because like Nathan is such a unique, like genius person who is bending art forms and created something totally new.

28:04Over the weekend, I was listening to Acquired. It did like a three-hour podcast on Seinfeld, both like the series and the business of Seinfeld. If you love Seinfeld, listen to it. It's so fun. But it was both like hearing about that and then also just Ben and David like nerding out so hard on the series, on the business, and like, you know, their personalities and their passion. And I was like, I could ask Chachi B.T. or Claude to assemble a list of all the Seinfeld facts it could find. And like, I don't know. I don't care about that. Like, I don't want to read a list of things or, you know, we could put it in a deck.

28:42It's like, I think our appreciation for deeply human craft is just going to increase. And so we have, yeah, we have like the explosion of AI-generated creativity over here and it's democratized. And then we just have like higher and higher regard for people who are pushing boundaries or just like doing things that they love and are passionate about. And I think that's like a great world to live in. So that's my optimism. Mine is so similar. So I'll just go right after you, which is just, you know, I love when people think that they gotcha. Like, it's like, oh, ha ha, marketing was the first role to get automated.

29:22ha ha, comms people, who needs them? Because I'm like, okay, so newsflash, those were all the little activities that nobody liked doing anyways. And if you would have asked me 15 years ago what I would predict that AI would replace, I would have named exactly these things that they are replacing. And so similarly, I feel like, great, cool. Nobody wants a marketing ops person on their team. Now we can focus on creative campaigns, like what is really deeply figuring out your audience. All of these things that I think that are like much more, you know, on the surface, like closer to the human experience and what make us human.

30:00And I think AI is helping make that more clear rather than like arguing and debating on like what the roles are and all of this. So similarly, I totally agree. And it's funny, Helen, because we've seen like, it's, I think it's funny for both of us as former comms and marketing people, like now those roles are being like rebranded and elevated and like comms people are like storytellers and it's just like how marketing became growth. And I think yesterday Notion announced like it's creating a new field storytelling program. I roll my eyes at this stuff, but also it is so true that automating the little things has only made like the craft piece like that much more valuable.

30:43Mine is, I have so many things I'm optimistic about right now, especially because like there's an absurd amount of good stuff happening. And specifically with AI, like this kind of dovetails nicely with Helens. I think like it has been really, really cool and really, really like aggressively hope core for me to see just how AI is able to like lower the barriers to entry and create like a more almost like truly meritocratic environment. And I think like it'll be really interesting to watch this over the next couple of years because I think the Doomer case of it is essentially like, look, you completely de-skill everything, making workers useless.

31:20But I just don't really think that that's how we as society works. I think somebody said, oh, it was Alex from Long Lake. He was saying essentially like, OK, so assume you go implement AI, making your salespeople 10x more effective, hitting 10x their quotas on a regular basis. What are you going to do? Hire fewer salespeople? And I thought that that was like a really perfectly articulated point. And I think it's been really cool. Like I'm in this like ridiculously privileged position where I get to see like impact on people every single day of like being able to enter spaces that you never thought you would actually have access to and that you didn't think.

32:00Like it's been really interesting to see how like, you know, positions at least like at Hadrian, like we have people who are coming from like super, super nontraditional backgrounds. And it's been really cool to be able to see them not only coming into the company, learning how to like operate and work in a factory, learn like all sorts of like crazy heavy machinery, but also like learn about product. Like we've had people move into like a traditional like product org from a very, very different like non-Stanford background. And I think that like what that means for the future of product development, what that means for the future of work generally is really exciting to me because it means that like you're competing on like your hunger, your raw horsepower, your work ethic.

32:47Creativity, yeah. Yeah, your creativity. And I think that's really good. Like I think that's a good thing. I think that is so much better than going and having like you or your parents spend a quarter to a half a million dollars on four years of education. Like I think that that's really exciting. And I think it's so much better for the economy. I also think like over the long term, that also makes a lot more places and a lot like it hopefully in an abundance use case, decentralizes a lot of wealth generation. And I think that's really fucking cool. And I'm really excited. It's like one of the few things that's bringing me a huge amount of hope.

33:21So I'm really excited for, I'm excited. I think this is going to be a really sick new chapter. I hope, knock wood, but I'm optimistic. Yeah, I think everybody with internet access will have access to AI, right? Like we're arguing on the margins of, you know, how much usage, how fast the model is and all this. But it's, you know, at whatever level, I mean, like people can access Google and that internet is probably slower in some parts of the world and faster in others. So I think that thinking about that is pretty cool. just the scale potential of the scale of it all. And also just like, again, like, and what that means is essentially like now that means that there's a much more even playing field.

33:58And that's, I can understand how that's scary for some people. Like if, if like you're where you are because of if you benefited from the uneven playing field. Yeah, exactly. If you benefited from the uneven playing field, but if you believe in yourself, I think like, that's actually a really, really, really good thing. Like it's exciting. It means we'll have better shit because more people will be able to participate. And I fucking love that. I think that's great. It's very American and I love it. Angela, how about you? I mean, if we don't have to work anymore, everyone can just focus on looks maxing.

34:27So all of society will be hotter. So that's definitely a reason for Oh my God. Or can we looks men? Can we looks minimize? I would like, can I start the ugly Nicole, I'm with you, Mac. I think, joking aside, though, like, I was, my grandfather is in a nursing home, this and I was visiting him this weekend. And it would struck me how many people could benefit from having more time to spend with their loved ones and, you know, healthcare workers, and there's sort of all these industries, whether it's stay at home moms, or nannies, or healthcare workers, where that work is very undervalued today.

35:04So I actually think the case for optimism is value can shift where previous work that was highly valued can now be done by AI. That means that money, capital, people's time will flow into these other jobs which have been traditionally undervalued but really serve the human experience. So I'm hopeful that this means the incremental time you have, you can spend with your kids, you can spend with your grandparents, you can spend taking care of the community. So that's my reason for optimism, which is jobs that didn't get ascribed as much value as before in this new paradigm will be ascribed so much more value.

35:39And that creates net positivity. But also looks maxing and health maxing for all. Yes. Like, I know I'm jumping to it, but it's like, we keep talking about the really big, big advancements in technology, you know, that AI is accelerating and enabling, like, Like, you know, when is Claude going to cure cancer? And it's like, there are advancements in technology happening everywhere. And it's pretty cool to just think about like even the small silly things, right? And like I was thinking about how like just between kids, like I've had to take prenatal vitamins and they get smaller and smaller. But they literally started as like horse pills.

36:20And now they're like quite small. And you're like, thank you, technology. And those are just such silly things. But it's like, I don't know. it's hard not to be excited when you think about like little things that you don't always have to set the bar at like curing cancer, which is a very important bar to continue to. Totally. But AI needs like a narrative other than, I feel like curing cancer is always held up as the like, well, AI might wipe out humanity, but it could also cure cancer. And like, for curing cancer, that's like a lot of pressure to put on it. I hope AI does. But like, we need more stories about like why this technology is good.

37:00And yeah, Helen, I would say like similarly, the small things just on like a personal health level, right? Anyone who wants to go down a health rabbit hole, like I have, first of all, I was amazing when I was pregnant because I didn't have a good OB. And so like Chad GPT was kind of my supplemental doctor that I could ask a bunch of questions of and do that with like, you know, do that responsibly and fact check things. But or like I've now become, I'm either a ferritin influencer or I have ferritin psychosis. But like I am obsessed with how many women have super low iron stores and I've like posted about it and I've had so many people reach out and like everyone I know has terrible ferritin levels and it's something that you can actually fix.

37:51And I think it like addresses a lot of the things that are being grouped under perimenopause right now. And actually like, you don't have to have brain fog and you can fix your sleep and all of this stuff. Anyways, I won't go on a whole rant here about that, but like, you know, slide into my DMs if you want to hear more. But ChatGPT is like this amazing tool for going deep on things that, you know, Otherwise, we're kind of gatekept by very, very slow-moving medical establishment. There are so many big and small reasons to be optimistic right now. And I kind of feel, too, like the really doomer stuff, unless you are in a position to make a dent in that, to shape that, like devoting a lot of headspace to it is just unhealthy and not productive.

38:40And so I also think the optimistic view is the pragmatic view as well, in addition to just being like a happier place to live. Oh, yes. The best way to win arguments with people who are critical of people who are too optimistic is like actually the data shows that it's more logical to be optimistic. And that is always like a very good thing to bring up. But yes, and also it'd be such a vibe killer right now. The vibes are very, very good since Anthropic got to shake their sillies out for the last couple of months. Let's ride these good vibes into the holidays, guys. No more negative news cycles until 2027.

39:27Keep SF prices high. No, sorry, Matt. I was going to say, Angela, what the hell? Build more in us up. more abundance, Angela. That's right. Larger pie. Larger pie. Build more houses. I'm happy to live in an apartment forever. I just don't want it to be garbage. So. Hey, listeners, if you know a place that Mac should live, just sign into her DMs. Call me tomorrow. Oh yeah. She's backing me all the tips. If you have an apartment to rent me, I'm also open to that option. I just am horrified by the fact that renting a one-bedroom costs$6 ,500. Oh, that's a good deal. Fuck off. Wow. Respectfully. Thank you for listening to Great Chat.

40:10Have questions for us? Make sure to submit them at anothergreatchat.com. See you next week. Bye-bye.

From the publisher

Amidst the human-extinction headlines, cybersecurity apocalypse warnings, and billionaires going viral for outsourcing parenting to AI, we do the most contrarian thing possible: find reasons for optimism. The full crew joined the chat to make the bull case: creativity barbelling between democratized slop and true genius, the “annoying” jobs getting automated first, AI as a true meritocracy lever, and value finally flowing to the work (caregiving, parenting, nursing) that was always undervalued. Plus: we won a Signal Award, marvel at Anthropic’s S-1, and Mac goes on an epic Instinct rant.

Mercury is back as the headline sponsor for year two of Great Chat. Mercury is a financial technology company, not a bank. Banking services provided through Choice Financial Group, Column N.A., and Evolve Bank & Trust; Members FDIC.

This podcast is edited by Eric Johnson from ⁠⁠LightningPod: https://lightningpod.fm

More from Great Chat

All episodes