1. Podcasts
  2. Headliners with Nihal Arthanayake
  3. James Jones
Headliners with Nihal Arthanayake

29 Jun 2025 · 59m · 16 chapters

In short

Conversation about documentary filmmaker James Jones’s two-part Putin assassination investigation, focused on Christo Grozev’s reporting and the OSINT collective Bellingcat, and how their work exposed Kremlin-linked poisoning and assassination plots, including a plan to kill Grozev.

Guest backgrounds

James Jones is a documentary filmmaker/director of Kill List (Hunted by Putin Spies). He studied Russian, lived in Russia in 2003 working for a Russian advertising company, and later became a BBC translator on a series about Russian oligarchs.

Key claims

Putin’s regime dismantled democratic norms while improving living standards via oil and gas; “deniability” was undermined by the Salisbury poisoning and later Navalny’s investigation. Grozev’s methods (including buying stolen dark-web data) unmasked hundreds of spies and forced Russia to adapt by using local freelancers for surveillance and arson. Grozev is now a target and lives in exile/hiding.

Notable examples

Salisbury Skripal case; Navalny’s poisoning and confession call; Bellingcat’s identification of two Salisbury suspects via open-source/digital traces; the “Berlin bicycle killer” Vadim Krasikov; Wirecard executive Jan Marsalek; the Old Bailey trial messages about killing Grozev; six Bulgarian spies arrested in London.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

2:19

James Jones on His Journey and Documentary

James shares his background and the motivations behind his documentary, Kill List.

“Yeah, so when I was a teenage boy, I was really into history.”
4:24

Understanding Putin's Grip on Power

A discussion on Putin's early popularity and the erosion of democratic norms in Russia.

“Who was in charge of Russia when you were there for a year?”
6:17

The Lawlessness of Early 2000s Russia

James recounts his experiences in Russia, highlighting its chaotic atmosphere.

“I mean, you could hardly say that Yeltsin was a paragon of democratic norms.”
8:48

From Antidote to Kill List: Documentary Title Changes

Exploration of the title change of the documentary and its implications.

“You know, Russia and the Soviet Union has a long track record of developing these poisons that are kind of brutal, but to some extent undetectable.”
12:20

Bellingcat and Investigative Journalism

An overview of Bellingcat's role in exposing Putin's actions and its investigative techniques.

“And there's one thing that Putin can't stand and that's being laughed at.”
14:00

The Investigative Genius of Christo Grozev

Explore how Christo Grozev uses data to identify Russian spies and the ethical implications of his methods.

“And so Christo mastered the skill of collating passport data, travel data, phone records.”
28:00

Surveillance and Threats

Discussion about surveillance and the dangers posed by untrained spies.

“They, you know, had done surveillance on his father's home.”
28:57

Introduction to Facebook's Decline

Introduction to a podcast discussing the decline of Facebook and its cultural impact.

“I'm Tristan Redmond, host of the Global Story podcast from the BBC.”
29:31

Putin's Assassination Tactics

In-depth discussion on Putin's tactics regarding political assassinations and the implications.

“Let's return to Vadim Krasikov, Putin's, by all accounts, number one assassin.”
36:21

The State of Russian Opposition

Exploration of the current state of Russian opposition and the risks faced by dissidents.

“And then I guess Kill List, Hunted by Putin Spies, it's a bit more obvious.”
Show all 16 chapters
42:01

The Risks of Journalism in Authoritarian Regimes

Explore the dangers faced by journalists in oppressive regimes and the importance of truth-telling.

“But on another level, you know, you look at Christo and others and like their work is heroic and more important than ever.”
46:26

Personal Experiences with Surveillance and Danger

Hear firsthand accounts of the risks and surveillance faced while documenting sensitive topics.

“And similarly with how Krzysztof Grozov started and where he's at now, you're going again for Putin.”
51:23

Documentary Success and Societal Impact

Discuss the challenges and metrics of success for impactful documentaries in today's world.

“What do you use as a measurement of success for a documentary like Kill List, Hunted by Putin Spies?”
55:16

Conversations on Hope and Optimism

Delve into conversations about hope amid adversity and the differing views on the future of Russia.

56:00

Discussion on Christo Groza and Optimism in Russia

Explore the contrasting views on Russia's future and the impact of optimism amid adversity.

“My position is more that there's something very rotten about Russia, not just at the top, but, you know, down through the courts, the prison guards, all these people.”
59:06

Reflections on Documentary Filmmaking

A discussion on the importance and impact of documentary filmmaking in today's media landscape.

“Well, listen, thank you so much for having me on.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On Headliners with Nihal Arthanayake, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK. Fall flavours are waiting for you at Whole Foods Market. Cozy picks all through the store, like maple leaf cookies from 365 brand. Swing by the bakery for pumpkin cheesecake, here for a limited time, and pumpkin turmeric bread freshly baked every single day. Sip the season with 365 brand cinnamon spice coffee and pumpkin spice creamer. While you still can, spice up fall at Whole Foods Market. Is Facebook dying? I'm Tristan Redman, host of the Global Story podcast from the BBC. More than 15 years after The Social Network, a new movie on the inner workings of Facebook hit cinemas in October.

0:47The journalist who's reporting inspired the film tells us why Facebook stopped being cool and whether Meta, its parent company, can reinvent itself. For more, listen to The Global Story on bbc.com or wherever you get your pods.

1:14Hello and welcome to Headliners with Nihal Arthanaika. Here we go, in deep, another conversation that I know you are going to be fascinated by. Today's episode is with the documentary filmmaker James Jones, the director of the chilling documentary Kill List. Now, it follows a journalist, Christo Grozov, who's investigating the Kremlin's assassination plots and ultimately discovers a plot for his own assassination. Yeah, I don't think Christo, when he began his route into journalism, I don't think he thought he'd be this successful and this prominent to even get the Kremlin's attention in this way.

1:54In terms of the risk, I think it just happened so gradually. And he's so obsessive. I had dinner with him the other night after a screening. And he basically said the only way he can relax is by catching another Russian spy. So it is an addiction. It's an incredible documentary. And this is not a conversation that you want to miss.

2:19Headliners with Nihal Afamayake. Yeah, so when I was a teenage boy, I was really into history. You know, Russian history is just more exciting, more extreme than any other country's history. So it seemed at the age of 15, you know, revolutions and, you know, just like huge characters. And compared to British history, that was all about kind of Tudor kings and queens and all kind of felt quite moderate. and and same as you actually going to Russia for the first time to Moscow and St Petersburg in the late 90s and I just remember being in Moscow and like packs of wild dogs roaming the streets at night and then I had a gun pulled at me in St Petersburg and it was just like it felt like so far from where I lived in London in Chiswick and like you know it was just kind of extreme and thrilling and different and then yeah just I studied at the university so sorry studied Russian university uh spent a year living out there 2003 for working for a Russian advertising company um in the end quit because we're advertising cigarettes and I felt like they were um gearing their advertising campaigns towards uh underage smokers let's say um and you know and And then just like I started, my first job was as a translator on a BBC series about Russian oligarchs.

3:49Just that's how I fell in love with making documentaries. Just like when you're a translator, you're involved in every stage of the process. And then after a while, actually just fell out of love with it because of Putin. You know, it just felt like such a harsh place with something like fundamentally wrong and dark. and so just didn't work on anything Russia-related for about 10 years until the revolution in 2014 in Ukraine and that kind of got me back into this whole world. Who was in charge of Russia when you were there for a year? Putin. So it was still at the time when we thought this could go either way.

4:33You know, he wasn't. And the West was courting him at that point. they thought that he was potentially a different type of Russian leader? Yeah, he was a breath of fresh air after the chaos of Yeltsin. He seemed, you know, they knew his FSB background, but he seemed open to cooperation. He was saying all the right things about NATO, even about Ukraine. You know, you look back and he jokes like, oh, we would never take back Crimea. You know, we're not an empire anymore. And then you look at the things he says now, and it's completely, you know, the opposite. So there were, you know, there were some signs that some people were getting arrested, you know, businessmen getting too big for their boots and that kind of thing.

5:16But it was it was easy still for the West to ignore. Did you get a sense that he was a Democrat? I think pretty quickly it became clear that he promised Russians stability, prosperity, you know, the latest fridges, the latest, you know, mod cons that they couldn't have dreamed of 20 years earlier or 10 years earlier. and the payoff for that was you're going to give up the idea of democracy because democracy in many people's minds equated to the chaos of the 90s you know so okay we can vote but there's no food you know the businessmen are ripping us off it's all it's all just very uncertain and frightening and so I think the deal he did was look largely based on like oil and gas and all the rest of it but he your standard of living willing would carry on improving but pretty methodically he dismantled the apparatus of democracy and just took a tighter and tighter grip and whilst you were in your own moral conundrum over the marketing of cigarettes to children, did you also notice a subtle dismantling of, I would say, democratic norms, but there weren't any democratic norms as we understand them in Russia, even at that point, was there?

6:46I mean, you could hardly say that Yeltsin was a paragon of democratic norms. Yeah. I mean, it's interesting, actually, at the end of our film, one of our central characters who manages to leave Russia and is told by his FSB handler, you know, you look out the window, this is the last time you'll see your homeland. And he replies in a great line, you know, I'm a historian, I know I'll be back and it'll be sooner than you think. And a bit of me thinks it's quite something to be an optimist if you are a kind of student of Russian history, because very rarely does it end in anything better than what came before.

7:25You know, there aren't glorious chapters of freedom of speech and democratic norms it's you know that maybe there will be revolution and upheaval but it um rarely has a positive outcome so yeah i mean i think what i witnessed in the late 90s and then early 2000s was just a place that was in massive flux you know some people were getting rich very quickly it was open opening up to western influences western businesses it was still the early 2000s the rich people still look like gangsters you know i think a few years later they were more westernized it was people in suits and it was a bit more respectable but back then it was like men in tracksuits were becoming insanely wealthy very quickly and there were you know i remember even like for half the year i studied before i I went and worked in advertising.

8:20I was studying Russian at a school in a provincial town. And I remember there was like a biker bar kind of attached on the land owned by the guy who ran the school. And he wanted to get rid of them, basically, and they didn't want to leave. And we came in one morning, it had just been burned to the ground. I was like, OK, I wonder how that happened. And it was just like, it was kind of lawless, but people were, yeah, taking the law into their own hands, making lots of money and like it's terrible to say but that made it again that idea of it being this wild unpredictable place that played into it you know it's like felt like an exciting crazy place to be what are the distinctions between the two different titles antidote and kill list for this documentary that you've made this extraordinary two-part documentary series that you made yeah so the original title was antidote which i guess has a more hopeful tone to it without being you know overly optimistic as we've just been discussing but you know the film really started as an expose of putin's poison program and how he used poisons and his um kind of team of assassins to target opponents and they were largely like russian domestic political opponents that they would target within Russia and poison them.

9:49You know, Russia and the Soviet Union has a long track record of developing these poisons that are kind of brutal, but to some extent undetectable. And so it fits Putin's worldview perfectly because he can make his enemies suffer quite brutal, painful deaths. But there's also that element of deniability, which, you know, given that Putin is the world's kind of king of disinformation suits him quite well so he can always say oh nivalney collapsed on a plane but actually you know it was he took an overdose of antidepressants or he you know you can always all all people just drop dead of heart attacks or have a stroke or whatever so it it's part of him so in chaos as well because lots of people think if you want to kill your enemies why not just shoot them or run them over in the street was this idea of deniability though completely destroyed by Salisbury and what happened to the Skripals and the fact that the arguments from the Kremlin were so absurd, so comically absurd, that these two men from military intelligence would just be wandering down to Salisbury as tourists.

11:05And then how lauded these two men were when they got back to Russia. Didn't that destroy any semblance of wishing to deny what was happening yeah i think salisbury was a key turning point and it was you know in large part thanks to bellingcat and krista grozev who you know because i'd wanted to make a film about putin being a killer for years but it was always hard journalistically to stand up exactly what had happened you know even though you knew the pattern that everything suggested it was a targeted assassination it was very hard to pinpoint it and then bellingcat turned up and as if by magic could say well it was these two guys they traveled here at this time they downloaded 2.8 megabytes of data on their phone at this minute and it was like honestly like lifting the lid and exposing it yeah as you say in quite a kind of humiliating way And then that was followed up by the Navalny poisoning when Christo figured out the team that had followed him and poisoned him.

12:08And Navalny ended up calling one of them, pretending to be his boss at the FSB and getting the guy to confess to putting the poison in his underpants in his hotel room. And I think for Putin, that not only removed the kind of veil of deniability, but was also humiliating. And there's one thing that Putin can't stand and that's being laughed at. And I think that was the moment that Christo, you know, the central character in our film, got a target on his back because Putin can stand for some things, but being mocked around the world and not just him, but his beloved FSB security services were seen as clowns, really.

12:54And so that was the moment when Christo became a target himself. You mentioned Bellingcat there, James. Can you explain what Bellingcat is, what it does? So Bellingcat was founded by a guy called Elliot Higgins, who is kind of brilliant, nerdy guy who, you know, was kind of into computer gaming and lots of nerdy things. And then 10 years ago, got interested in, you know, what was happening in Syria and kind of realized he had this amazing skill to use open source data. So whether it's YouTube videos or posts on social media to search for like visual clues to basically solve crimes and figure or like identify war crimes.

13:41And then Christo came in and expanded that by using basically data that you could find on the dark web relating to Russia. So in Russia, they accumulate data on everything, on all their citizens. But because it's so corrupt, a lot of that data is sold and bought on the black market. And so Christo mastered the skill of collating passport data, travel data, phone records. And using that could identify who the spies were. You know, in one instance, he figured out basically that there was a sequence of numbers on people's passports that all related to one unit of kind of Russian spies. And if you were in that sequence, you would, you know, the passport had been printed for you by the Russian government as a spy under a fake identity.

14:35it's quite amazing it means that when someone commits a war crime in ukraine they can identify who it is which bit of forest they are you know who the victim is and the idea is that that would lead to accountability in the long term but also in the short term people thinking twice before they commit these acts i mean obviously we're seeing a lot part of the world that it isn't stopping people um but uh yeah bellingcat is quite they kind of revolutionized journalism really um and particularly with christo's work uh with russia why do you think it was that huge news organizations couldn't do what bellingcat did so i think in terms of the kind of open source investigations, a lot of them have borrowed the techniques.

15:34So the New York Times, the BBC got, they call it OSINT, like open source investigation. But they, so they borrowed some of that. Where I think it's tricky for them is Christo operates more in a kind of gray area where he, you know, he does pay for stolen data on the dark web, which, you know, you work for the BBC, the BBC would never let you do that. And, you know, I have colleagues who work at the Financial Times or BBC or wherever who are incredibly envious that Christo can access this data. And I think, you know, in Christo's mind, the end justifies the means. So if you're going after killers on behalf of the Russian state, paying middlemen for data is worth it i think it you know and i think that there is a debate about that like i saw the new york times yesterday ran a piece where they had got a data set from hackers um really and it was basically like leaked hacked russian intelligence documents and they said well obviously we don't pay for stolen data but they offered us a freebie so we use that and a bit of me is like that's a that's quite a small distinction like if if you think it's wrong to deal with criminals and take their data even if you cross-check it and all the rest of it paying for it or not paying for it to me is a kind of minor distinction so i think it's a kind of interesting ethical area like do we think the end justifies the means or you know do you end up on a spectrum where suddenly you think that hacking people's phones and emails is okay as well because you know there's a public interest argument so it's it is a thorny issue and it's controversial um what i would say is even now more more people particularly russian journalists use the same techniques as christo no one has mastered it like he has you know his brain is just like one big spreadsheet constantly wearing so he can see these connections to he can like reel off the name names of like hundreds of russian spies and you know no one else has that knowledge or capability so i think chrystal's results speak for themselves and i think i'm definitely happy he's doing what he's doing well i mean the numbers are quite extraordinary i mean he unmasked 300 agents and exposed 5 ,000 names of people who are spies.

18:13Yeah. I mean, that is extraordinarily embarrassing for the Russian state and definitely puts a target on his back. For sure. I mean, he's seen as now an operative rather than just a journalist. Like it's that that's kind of their what their propaganda says. But I think they partly believe it because they think like a journalist couldn't be this effective and this damaging. and what he's done he's changed the way they operate you know it's harder all these russian spies and their passports have been burned so it's much harder for them to travel around europe and target people so as you know as you see in the film and we're seeing in various court cases at the moment the russian state has started to hire local freelancers who are just kind of low-level criminals who do a job for you for 10 grand whether it's like setting fire to a car or a house or a warehouse or doing surveillance on someone for three years, which is what they did with Christo.

19:12These six Bulgarians followed him around the world for three years. Until, of course, they were arrested in London. Do you think that Christo Grozov, when he began doing this, was entirely aware of the potential ramifications of what he was doing. I say that because at one point his wife, Steph, says to him, look at the mess you created. And his own son says that he's resourceful, yet a silly man. yeah i don't think chris though when he began his route into journalism ever thought it would end up like this um i don't think he thought he'd be this successful and this prominent to even you know get the kremlin's attention in this way in terms of the risk i think it just happened so gradually and he's so obsessive and involved in his work you know i was i had dinner with him the other night after a screening and he basically said the only way he can relax is by catching another russian spy so it is an addiction you know and i think wow that's that's his dopamine i mean if we were having dinner he's still doing it someone will mention someone and he'll get on his phone and do a you know a face check on the internet to see if they can track him down and check some database or other it is it's a compulsion um and so you can see how you would end up in a in a dangerous place by being kind of oblivious to what's happening around you but also you know you reach a certain point as i think he says in the film it's like he could stop doing it now but it's kind of too late like he is a target all he can hope for is that putin's regime falls so i think and you know i've had a tiny insight into that working on this film because it's like if someone said to me are you at risk from the kremlin i'd say well no not really like if i am i'm like at the very very bottom of a long list but even that risk like i don't want to bring any risk on myself or my family or my colleagues.

21:36But equally, when you're committed to doing something and you're invested in it, it's very hard to pull yourself away from that because the threat is quite abstract. I guess what's shocking with Christo is it suddenly became very tangible and very real. And to be clear, Putin has a legal mandate to hunt down and kill enemies of Russia. Is that right? Well, he has, he basically, there are kind of different levels and you can be like an undesirable person. You can be on the criminal wanted list and then there is a kind of unofficial kill list, I guess. But like once you're on the criminal wanted list, it's a pretty good sign that they're going to come for you in a kind of extrajudicial way.

22:28I think his ideal with Christo would have been not to kill him, but to abduct him when he was traveling in Eastern Europe and bring him to Moscow and put him on trial and have him in prison, which in some ways is probably a fate worse than death. So, but I think he, depending on who the target is, sometimes he denies it, but there was a guy they shot in broad daylight in Berlin. Who was a Chechen. Who was a Chechen who'd fought in the Chechen War of Independence against Russia, who Putin saw as a terrorist. And, you know, you see in the film the guy who shot him, who Christo exposed as an FSB agent.

23:15Vadim Krasikov. Vadim Krasikov, the Berlin bicycle killer. He's got a special technique of killing people from a moving bicycle. He is terrifying. Terrifying. Like if you wanted to imagine in your mind what a hired killer looks like, go and search up a picture of Vadim Krasikov. But before I get to Vadim Krasikov, return to him. Tell me about Jan Marsalek. So Jan Marsalek ran one of Germany's most successful companies, kind of their version of PayPal. Wirecard. Wirecard. Yeah. And they made billions. And then at some point, it turned out that almost two billion euros was missing. And effectively, he'd put the books and he'd been living this lifestyle, you know, playboy, but also had been kind of getting in with Russian spies.

24:10You know, there's various theories about how it happened, but there was a Russian honey trap that he fell in love with. I think he also just quite enjoyed feeling like a bad boy, you know, being taken to Syria to shoot guns and just showing a life that, you know, if you're into that kind of thing, suddenly seemed very seductive and exciting. And he then disappeared after the fraud was exposed. and Christo and Bellingcat showed that he basically traveled to Russia and he was hiding out in Russia, even though he made it look like he'd gone to the Philippines. Jan Mosalek is now living in Moscow as a wanted, you know, Germany's kind of most wanted man.

24:55And when Christo discovered that there was this plot to kill or abduct him, someone hinted to him that it was a plot orchestrated by the target of one of his previous investigations. So he was racking his brains. Who could it be? And then when it turned out that it was Jan Marsalek, we thought this can't be true. It's like too crazy a detail. There's this like Bond villain living in Moscow. And as time went by, it became more and more clear to the point where in the trial at the Old Bailey of these six spies, I mean, they're so stupid, these spies, they didn't delete the head, the guy, the ringleader in Great Yarmouth.

25:37hadn't deleted any of his messages. So there were like 80 ,000 text messages between him and the other spies and him and Jan Marsalek basically plotting how to get Christo. In graphic detail. In quite chilling detail, yeah. And like, you know, it's interesting, there's a scene in the film, and Christo obviously had an idea of the outline of what they'd been up to, that they'd hired an apartment opposite his home in Vienna. They'd been on flights with him, all this kind of stuff. But they hadn't shared all the detail, I think partly because they thought they might call him as a witness in the trial.

26:13So they didn't want it to seem like he'd been kind of coached. So near the end of the trial, I went to New York to see him and showed him the messages that we transcribed from the courtroom in London. And it was chilling. You know, it's like breaking into his home, planning to gas him and his family. all sorts of kind of pretty lurid, violent ways to kill him. Including a suicide bomber. That was one of the plans, wasn't it? To then blame it on ISIS in revenge against Bellingcat. So pretty outlandish stuff. But he included emojis. I mean, you were looking at some of this stuff and he was talking about killing someone and then there was like the kind of monkey with his hands over its eyes emoji next to it yeah it was like you know the kind of things my kids would send each other on snapchat right with all these this and you're talking about butchering another human being yeah it's quite bizarre but then yan masalik is a extraordinarily bizarre human being he is a weird guy and you know there were i think he'd had a fascination with kind of far-right politics.

27:33He's very anti-Islam, very pro-Russia. He has a family history of, I think his grandfather was secretly working for the Soviets and stuff. So I think he was just like infatuated with all this kind of Russian spy stuff. And, you know, when you read those messages, it does feel almost like a game. But the problem is it potentially has real consequences. You know, these guys were getting paid good money to follow Christ around the world. They did break into his home. They, you know, had done surveillance on his father's home. And I think, you know, just because these guys are kind of clowns on one level and they're not incredibly well-trained spies, they can still be dangerous.

28:27Fall flavors are waiting for you at Whole Foods Market. Cozy picks all through the store, like maple leaf cookies from 365 brand. Swing by the bakery for pumpkin cheesecake, here for a limited time, and pumpkin turmeric bread freshly baked every single day. Sip the season with 365 brand cinnamon spice coffee and pumpkin spice creamer. While you still can, spice up fall at Whole Foods Market. Is Facebook dying? I'm Tristan Redmond, host of the Global Story podcast from the BBC. More than 15 years after The Social Network, a new movie on the inner workings of Facebook hit cinemas in October. The journalist who's reporting inspired the film tells us why Facebook stopped being cool and whether Meta, its parent company, can reinvent itself.

29:17For more, listen to The Global Story on bbc.com or wherever you get your pods.

29:31Let's return to Vadim Krasikov, Putin's, by all accounts, number one assassin. Now, this man gets arrested shortly after killing this Chechen guy in Berlin, doesn't he? because he's seen shaving, is he, or cutting his hair off and changing out of one piece of clothing into another while still with his bike, the bike he's been on and shot this man dead. And the German police arrest him pretty quickly, don't they? Yeah, luckily, I think a couple of teenage boys, they spotted this man getting changed and shaving in a bush and thought, that's weird, and kind of pointed the police's attention to him.

30:18And so they did arrest him, found him with a tourist's passport, basically. And then it was Christo who took his photo, picture of his tattoo, and basically traced it to his real identity, which was Badim Prasikob, and then figured out that he'd been involved in previous shootings on bicycles and he had a connection to the FSB. And so it's just kind of extraordinary that Russia thought they would get away with shooting someone in broad daylight in a park in Berlin. Germany at that point was, to some extent, still an ally, like a huge business partner. So just like I guess Nord Stream 2, right?

31:03Talking about like, you know, big energy links between the two countries. So pretty mad that they would want to pull this off, but it just shows Putin's mentality. He wants to get his enemies in a way that is really bloodthirsty and ruthless. And a warning. It's not really about the veil of deniability, is it? It's about a very public execution that sends a message out to anyone who has crossed him or sin of sins is a traitor to Mother Russia. Yeah, for sure. I mean, if he can get you on the streets of Berlin or with Lipinenko and, you know. In central London. In London, then you're not safe anywhere.

31:53So, yeah, it's a kind of psychological threat as well. Do you think that at some point Christo Grozov saw this as a bit of a game? I think he does see it as a game because they burn some spies. Putin will arrest, you know, political opposition figures. And then you saw with the prisoner swap negotiations, it's almost like a race to see you can collect more goodies and baddies and then they trade them at the end. And so it is a kind of game of chess that he's involved in. I think there were just a couple of moments in the film. One, when his father was found dead. And the other, secondly, when he read those text messages about what they were going to do to him and his family, that stopped feeling like a game and just became very real.

32:46And Christo was very good friends with Alexei Navalny, wasn't he? He was, yeah. And so they worked on that investigation together, made a documentary together. Oscar nominated. Oscar winning. Oscar winning my apologies yeah Oscar winning of course yeah and when Alexei went back that you know I think everyone knew he would be arrested but probably didn't understand quite how harshly he'd be treated and then Christo put a lot of energy into trying to put together this prisoner swap to get Navalny out I always thought it seemed far-fetched that Putin would let his biggest enemy and biggest threat go free.

33:33And as turned out to be the case, they put together this prisoner swap with Navalny at the heart of it in exchange for Vadim Krasica of the Berlin killer and others. And then just before the swap was due to happen, Navalny was killed or died in a remote prison. And so again, you just see how cynical Putin is. He kind of he put the deal in place and then killed Navalny, but then still managed to get some form of the deal involving other people because America wanted American journalist Evan Gershkiewicz and other people. there was still the deal was close enough that even without Navalny enough people wanted it to happen but yeah I think for Krista that was kind of devastating because it's you know he was a friend and he was also some cause for optimism for the future of Russia and you think like oh we did this great investigation this great documentary that was you know couldn't have been more successful but they still killed him, you know.

34:40And so I think it makes you question the value of what you're doing a bit. But in the documentary, it does note that the death of Navalny perhaps gave the West more leverage in how many prisoners it could swap for Vadim Krasikov. Yeah, I think, and in the end, you know, because even for Christo, trying to put together a deal that leads to Krasikov, this horrible killer being free, is quite a morally unclear thing to pursue. But in the end, a lot of great people, including Vladimir Karamoza, who's one of the central people in our film, was released to his family back in America. And as he says on the phone to Joe Biden and his family in the Oval Office, I thought I was going to die in prison.

35:33And I think he really did. Like he'd been poisoned twice, really wasn't well. And so sentenced to 25 years, 25 years for giving basically giving a speech about the war. I mean, you know, just crazy, crazy times that we're living in. And so, you know, there's a happy ending to some extent. And actually going back to your question about antidote versus kill list, you know, the antidote to the poison. The film became more about the people standing up to Putin rather than just the assassination program. So I guess the idea of the title is that people like Christo and Vladimir Karamoza, who are brave enough to carry on speaking out, are some kind of antidote to the poison of Putin.

36:21And then I guess Kill List, Hunted by Putin Spies, it's a bit more obvious. why do you think it is that myself who takes an interest in this area had never heard of Vladimir Karamoza yeah it's interesting because I mean he also he's a British citizen he's got a British passport uh his family live in America I think what he's very good at and it's really interesting actually because unlike Navalny you had this big popular following and genuinely was a threat to Putin. Like in a fair election, he could beat Putin. Whereas Karim Orza doesn't have that popular following. But what he had worked so hard on was getting sanctions put on people around Putin.

37:10It's another insight into how Putin operates like a mafia boss. It's like, if you come for my money and my friend's money, I'll come after you. So he wasn't even that much of a political threat, but he had done damage to their pockets. And so that was what made him kind of persona non grata. But yeah, he's working hard now. I think there is a problem with the Russian opposition that there isn't a figurehead. You know, some people thought Navalny's wife might take over. You know, there are various people. Yulia. Yulia, yeah. who is you know really impressive but i don't think wants to be that person and so and that was why getting nivani out was so important to countries like germany just so that there was an alternative future for russia that they could try and support and now the russian opposition there's a lot of infighting you know there's not really a focus or a shared purpose so it's a bit um yeah a bit depressing it's interesting because i don't know if you've read patriot um alexei nabalny's memoir but his arguments for going back to russia seem now obviously in hindsight as being suicidal and similarly for kristo grozov He can't return to Vienna, can he?

38:39He's now in America. He's split from his family, not in any kind of divorce sense, but geographically. And it's a very real threat for him to be in pretty much any European capital or indeed perhaps anywhere in the world. Yeah, well, I mean, what's interesting is that his calculation was always that America was safer than Europe. You know, there'd been a red line that Russia wouldn't assassinate people on American soil. What happened at the end of last year has changed that calculation, I think. You know, there's someone in the White House who wants to be Vladimir Putin's best friend. And so I think there's a question about whether Putin would still feel that there were consequences for assassinating someone on American soil.

39:32I also think there's a question about whether Donald Trump would value Krzysztof Grozev enough to protect him or suddenly turn around tomorrow and say, oh, yeah, he's a Bulgarian spy and we're extraditing him to Moscow. You know, I think all the assumptions we had about America as a safe haven in that way have gone. So Christo is now even more homeless than he was before. And, you know, he can go back to Vienna, but with that very heavy police, a very heavy police presence and kind of going very much under the radar. But by their own admission, James, the Austrian police don't believe that they could protect him.

40:15do they no they don't and i and you know there are various cases um even connected to yan marsalek where the austrian security forces have been infiltrated by russia so i don't think you can trust them at all krista now is kind of permanently on the move really and you know maybe he'll settle somewhere like canada which feels um like a more stable place but um yeah what what a crazy world we live in that um a journalist can't feel safe from the kremlin in america well this is the question isn't it is about the price that you pay for holding power to account and of course in Alexei Navalny's case that was his life with Krzysztof Grozev he's essentially in hiding thousands of miles away from his family constantly now in fear living in paranoia that just around the corner there will be a group of people because you've shown him the messages who will kidnap him, torture him.

41:27I think one of the messages said, I've got someone that will kill him slowly, painfully. It won't be quick. So it doesn't really send a message out to people to say, hold these gangsters, these criminals, these dictators to account. Yeah, I know. And actually, yeah, we did a Q &A the other night in Eastern Europe and someone said, oh, this isn't a very inspiring account of journalism, which on some level I understand. But on another level, you know, you look at Christo and others and like their work is heroic and more important than ever. And it's working. Otherwise, he wouldn't be on a kill list.

42:12And he's doing proper damage to the bad guys. you know there are um upsides to taking these risks but i can also understand that it seems pretty unappealing to put yourself in the firing line like that but i think you know our film is about vladimir putin and um telling the truth about him but it's also a film about the threats to truth the threats to journalism and journalists and that is that goes for a lot of parts of the world right now and i think i i guess what the the example of russia shows what can happen like how bad it can get um when a strongman dictator just kind of takes over all the different parts of the state from tv channels to you know the courts and democratic processes and i think you know i don't want to be alarmist but you look at the way already trump is threatening the media in america and they're bending over backwards for him in a way that like i don't think we would have predicted a year or two ago and certainly didn't happen during his first term um and that is you know that is scary people getting sacked for being critical of the administration the attack Back on universities.

43:33Back on universities. You know, these things are really unprecedented in our lifetime. You know, you just, you wonder how far that can go. So I was just listening to the Lex Friedman podcast where he was interviewing a historian who was just talking about how in 1930s Germany, James, Germany had 70 % of the population had radios, which was only surpassed by America, whose percentage of population only had slightly more people with access to radios. And what was happening was that, of course, Nazi propaganda was fed into those radios every single day. Right? And that's... And, you know, Hitler was voted in, I think, with 33 % of the vote initially.

44:28of the German population. It was a democratic vote that got him in. You know, I don't think you need to caveat anything with saying, I don't wish to be alarmist. We have to be very serious about these things. And journalists have to be very, very serious about calling this stuff out and not hide behind kind of weak ideas of due impartiality in not calling something what it is. I mean, Putin, there's no semblance of trying to pretend that Putin and the Russian people are living in a democracy. Yeah. And I think the thing that I find chilling about the States is that a lot of the kind of timidness or cowardice in terms of standing up to him is driven by business interests of the big broadcasters and networks.

45:22That is really depressing. But, you know, so the 60 Minutes CBS, Trump is suing them for tens of millions for a completely legitimate interview they did with Kamala Harris. But Trump knows that the parent company, Paramount, are trying to put through a sale that's worth billions. And so he's going to get an apology and a payout of tens of millions of dollars. I think the entire staff of 60 Minutes may resign, which is admirable on some level, but that actually means that they are neutered as a voice, you know, doing proper journalism in Trump America. and like it just feels yeah it feels like a slippery slope to me and you know i'm working on a new project looking at putin and how he um manipulated media in russia and kind of became the person that he is now and in those early days you do see parallels and it's scary So you're going again for Putin, right?

46:32Yeah. And similarly with how Krzysztof Grozov started and where he's at now, you're going again for Putin. What are your thoughts then on how protected you could be in the UK? Now, he tends not to go for people who are not Russian or in the case of Chechen, for instance. I'm struggling to think of a time where he sent a kill team to take out someone who is an American. Yeah, yeah. Certainly a British person. Does that play on your mind? I mean, honestly, there was a moment when the six Bulgarian spies were arrested in February 2020. in london london and i mean these guys as i said before these guys are dumb okay so they a lot of them put google reviews up for hotels they stayed in when they were following christian vienna in valencia complaining about the lack of clean towel you know all sorts of stuff and at first i was like this is so stupid it must be a code like they must be communicating with moscow or something i think it was actually just them being so complacent and a bit bored probably A bit bored and just kind of those kind of people.

47:53They just like, they spent their lives doing Google reviews. And two days before Vanya Gaberova, who ran a beauty salon in Acton, award-winning beauty therapist, she had left a review for Beauty Salon about one minute from my house. And I'm sure it was a coincidence, but it did give me pause, thinking like these guys who, because, you know, we'd been taking like really extreme precautions because we were filming with people sometimes having to conceal their identity and the stakes were life and death. So we were very, very cautious. And every now and then we'd be like, it's a bit silly. Like no one really cares what we're doing.

48:35And then these six people arrested and you're like, oh, they were actually following our friend and colleague around the world for three years. And then when I saw that one of them had been that close to my home, like I say I'm sure it was a coincidence but it did give me but it just felt literally very close to home wait a minute you say I'm sure it's a coincidence are you saying that as some form of comfort blanket do you genuinely believe it in the sense that you've seen the lengths and I'm really not trying to freak you out here because I don't need to you've done all this work but I do have to question whether you really genuinely think it's a coincidence.

49:17Yes, these people may be stupid, but they're also thorough. Yeah, I think if I'd... So basically because all these messages, tens of thousands of messages, and we don't know that that was all of them, certainly wasn't all of them, but a good selection of the messages between the ringleader in Great Yarmouth and the others. We don't have the messages between the lower level spies, for instance. So from that, we know that the first time I met Christo in London, they knew he was coming before I did because they had a mole inside the airline booking system. So that is scary. But there is no mention of us as a documentary team making the film.

50:01And if they were maybe better at their job, they would have clocked that he was going to meet us and do filming and all the rest of it. So like had had there been a reference to me or my home or my family, then that would have freaked me out. The fact that there wasn't does give me some comfort. And also. You know, their resources are finite. you know they spent hundreds of thousands probably possibly more um on the surveillance of Christo following someone even using pretty low level people is is expensive and honestly I just think I'm so low on their list of priorities they've got a lot of stuff going on but that's not to say that I'm complacent about it and you know and also I spend a lot of time with Christo you know we do screenings around the world and you know some countries you go to he has like 24 hour armed protection from the state sometimes you go places and there isn't anything so um it's very very hard and that's the other thing about them using these freelancers is it's very hard to know the risk like it's not like you know there are x amount of russian spies and x amount of them are in this country it could be anyone you know the um the fact that people are being hired on telegram to go and set fire to cars and buildings um for probably quite a small amount of money shows that doesn't take much for them to turn you into a target james in an attention economy where we're all battling for eyes and ears and also at a time where I don't think you would describe it as a golden age of funding for documentary films, if indeed there ever was a golden age, but certainly that isn't now.

51:59What do you use as a measurement of success for a documentary like Kill List, Hunted by Putin Spies? That is a good question. I think for me, honestly, a big moment was when we sold the film in America because, you know, the man in the White House has decided to, you know, appease Vladimir Putin and vilify Vladimir Zelensky. And he's taking a lot of the American public with him in terms of the opinion about Putin. And so for me, you know, when we started making the film, I didn't think it was going to be breaking news that Putin was a bad guy and did bad things. And yet we found ourselves in a situation where the White House are treating him like he's the victim and he's in the right.

52:55I don't think that's a fair characterisation, to be honest. I don't think that is a fair characterisation. They're making out that Zelensky is as responsible as Putin for starting the war. Yes. And even now when Putin carries out these kind of huge attacks acting shocked yeah i think they recognize there are people within the administration who recognized that putin was the aggressor but compared to what the biden administration would have said or what most of nato yes it's different it's looking for excuses and kind of buying a lot of their propaganda about um you know russian speakers in ukraine being oppressed and you know a lot of their talking points end up coming out of the white house as well um so it just felt important that just to remind people and make you know because i think the film is kind of vivid but it's very human as well you know it's about it ends up not necessarily being an expose of the assassination program but a kind of human portrait of the people who sacrifice so much to to stand up to them um so you know that was a pbs frontline in america bought it and broadcast it um a month ago and that gave me some satisfaction and you know we're going to do a campaign to get it seen by the right people um but you know i'm not one of those people who thinks that documentaries can change the world because i think you're setting yourself up for failure you know we we do it because we care about the subjects and we hope we can do them justice.

54:36But, you know, with me for this one, making a film, honestly, that like Christo and the Cara Mozes felt did it justice was, you know, huge for me. So we're going to carry on hoping it gets seen in a world where people just want to watch true crime and celebrity and sports. it is hard to reach a mass mass audience i would say in a way that probably had this film gone out on channel 4 10 or 20 years ago would have been watched by five times as many people you know but then of course i guess it's it's up to you and christo to really do the marketing for it isn't it right and that is what you're doing q and a's and touring and yeah and you know without sounding kind of glib about it like the film is really exciting you know it's a wild story about heroic people going through extraordinary stuff and it feels you know lots of people have written it kind of feels like a thriller more than a documentary yeah and like that's not to say that it's not very real and the stakes aren't very high um i don't want to kind of you know be silly about it but um it's it's not like it's a kind of hard watch it's not like doing a homework it is it's an exciting film so i think when people do watch it they're very taken with it um but yeah it's just a it's a tricky time for broadcast media as well indeed it really really is um you said you were at dinner with Christo Groza very recently do you get the sense that he believes that everything that he's been through is worth it and where do you sense his idea of hope comes from he is an incredible optimist and I think that is partly what drives him um and for instance you know he and i disagree about what could happen next with russia and people were often asked about it on stage and we kind of make a joke about how much we argue about it but right what's the disagreement he basically thinks that putin will fall within the next few years the war has done the war and sanctions and all the rest of it had done enough damage that people around Putin eventually will decide enough is enough.

57:11We want our old lives back. My position is more that there's something very rotten about Russia, not just at the top, but, you know, down through the courts, the prison guards, all these people. There's something rotten in Russian society. And a lot of the kind of more liberal, progressive people have left because they couldn't speak openly in Russia, Western businesses left. So a lot of the potential opposition just isn't there anymore and is living all around the world scattered. And also, you know, the fact that the war might be coming to an end, sanctions will be lifted, just takes a lot of the pressure off.

57:57So yeah, my hopes for Russia in the medium term are not great, but I think, you know, it's part of Christo's amazing talent is that he's optimistic and he does sometimes pull off these crazy things you know so I think there's something about his mentality that is like aiming for the stars and sometimes you know he pulls it off um but yeah I think he genuinely feels that we're in the kind of end times of the Putin regime and that sustains him I think that he cannot afford to think like you do, even if he wanted to, because of how much skin he has in the game, because of his friend Alexei Navalny, because of Vladimir Karamutza.

58:42He just can't think like you do. Yeah, I think you're right. I actually don't even think that he really disagrees that much. I just think he can't kind of allow himself to say that. No. No. James, thank you so much for spending an hour with me. Thank you also for making this documentary. I'm a huge supporter of documentary filmmaking and the work that you do and others that you do. and yeah and it's a sobering watch but also I think an inspirational watch if you think about this man and you think about Bellingcat and perhaps as well of course if Bellingcat can do this thing not only does it embarrass the Russian state and the FSB etc but also to a certain extent perhaps embarrasses Western intelligence agencies that a few people dotted around the world with computers are managing to do this stuff.

59:48For sure. I think it did. Yeah. Well, listen, thank you so much for having me on. That was great talking to you. Thanks, James. And I look forward to seeing your next documentary. When do you think that will be finished? Hopefully about a year from now. All going well. Best of luck. Stay safe. thanks mate

1:00:12thank you for listening to another episode of Headliners I'd love to know what you think you can email us at nihal at bbc.co.uk and please share the Headliners love subscribe let your friends know we'll be back with more of our favourite conversations next week so I'll see you then

1:00:38Delve deep into the lives and careers of some of the biggest names in sports. And hear from those who know them best. Including Pep Guardiola. He is looking always for the profession. Andy Murray. Something that he'd worked towards all of his career. And Kean Mbappé. When I saw him the first time play, I said, we have to play here. Sporting Giants. Listen on BBC Sounds.

1:01:07Is Facebook dying? I'm Tristan Redmond, host of the Global Story podcast from the BBC. More than 15 years after The Social Network, a new movie on the inner workings of Facebook hit cinemas in October. The journalist who's reporting inspired the film tells us why Facebook stopped being cool and whether Meta, its parent company, can reinvent itself. For more, listen to The Global Story on bbc.com or wherever you get your pods.

From the publisher

Award-winning documentary film director, James Jones, joins Nihal for an in-depth conversation.

Nihal Arthanayake presents his Sunday evening show and podcast, featuring exclusive in-depth interviews with headline guests across entertainment, sport, culture and politics.

More from Headliners with Nihal Arthanayake

All episodes