


Interview with John Sutherland about his thriller The Castle and his transition from Metropolitan Police crisis negotiator to novelist, plus his views on UK policing, officer morale, resourcing, and youth violence/knife crime.
Police negotiators succeed first through listening and empathy; policing’s self-inflicted damage and “betrayal of the few” demoralize good officers; policing has become more thankless due to under-resourcing and loss of neighbourhood relationships (2010–2018 cuts of 44,000 officers/staff in England and Wales); youth violence is driven by poverty and trauma, and policing is not the solution—society must address root causes via a long-term (e.g., 20-year) prevention plan.
Sarah Everard’s murder; “basket of 10” politically imposed targets excluding domestic violence/sexual offences/explicit knife crime; Billy Smith as an archetype for young people dealing drugs due to poverty/trauma.
John Sutherland (author; former Met crisis negotiator/hostage negotiation unit head; wrote bestselling thrillers including The Castle). Host: Nihal Arthanaika.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Discussing the inspiration and story behind Sutherland's new book.
“I've got a couple of my favourite pictures on the wall behind me.”
Explaining the main characters Alex Lewis and Pip Williams in the story.
“before you thought this is a great place to set a thriller?”
Insights on the critical skills of a police negotiator.
“Well, this is probably where you and I meet more than anywhere else.”
Discussing the writing process and character creation for 'The Castle'.
“How different is The Siege to The Fallen, your second book with Alex and Pip, to The Castle?”
Learn how to develop engaging and colorful characters in storytelling.
“What did you need to understand about the role of a gamekeeper?”
Discover the importance of authenticity versus technicality in writing.
“Not too much, to be honest, because I didn't have to get into too much technical detail in the story.”
Understand how collaboration with editors enhances the quality of your work.
“So there was my editor and then it goes off to someone who I never meet.”
Explore the stages and timeline of transforming a draft into a published book.
“And as you say, you know, it goes through two or three editing stages at least before you get anywhere close to a sort of final copy.”
Learn how to build tension and keep readers engaged through challenges.
“Yeah, I mean, that's where you can begin to have a bit of fun with it.”
Discover how writing reveals creativity and opens up new possibilities.
Explore John Sutherland's unexpected transition from police officer to writer.
“All I ever wanted to be was a police officer.”
Discuss the financial and emotional challenges faced by writers and police officers.
“And if it wasn't for my, I was medically retired from policing, so I have a medical pension and that and my wife's salary is what we live off.”
Delve into the frustrations experienced by police officers and the public's expectations.
“And so that, gosh, we could spend hours talking about just this.”
Examine how political decisions affect policing priorities and effectiveness.
“And their first reaction is always one of surprise, because that almost never happens to them.”
Assess the improvements and ongoing issues in mental health support for police officers.
“Can you see a link between then, what happened between 2010 and 2018, and the kind of violence that we've seen specifically affecting young men with knives?”
Discuss the complexities of youth involvement in crime and societal factors.
“police officers during their working lives will be exposed to extreme trauma on four to six hundred occasions.”
Explore the tough circumstances faced by youth in poverty and their choices.
“Someone was telling me a story about a clever young man, a teenager, a child really, who's a drug dealer.”
Understand the limitations of policing in addressing youth violence.
“And we need to understand the root causes.”
Discuss the societal objections to long-term solutions for crime.
“But it's easy enough to say they're not our children because they'll live in a place.”
Reflect on the author's pride in his writing and his latest book, The Castle.
“if these victims of knife crime were children of the establishment, the response of society would be worlds apart from one that we see now.”
Learn about the Facebook whistleblower and the new movie inspired by her story.
“The Facebook whistleblower who leaked the documents that changed how the world saw social media.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On Headliners with Nihal Arthanayake, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK. Fall tastes better with better ingredients from Whole Foods Market. No added growth hormones or antibiotics in their meat department means slow-braised short ribs are even more satisfying. All seafood is wild-caught, like their vibrant sockeye salmon or verified responsibly farmed. And all sweets, including fall-themed cookies, are made without high fructose corn syrup. Spice up fall at Whole Foods Market. Hey, Chicagoland. Wayfair's long weekend sale is on at the Wayfair store from October 10th through October 12th. You can score up to 60 % off on everything home in person, like up to 60 % off area rugs, up to 30 % off mattresses and major appliances, and up to 50 % off kitchen and dining furniture.
0:51Plus, you can take home the small stuff that day and get the big stuff shipped fast and free. Shop Wayfair's long weekend sale October 10th through October 12th at the Wayfair store at Edens Plaza in Wilmette.
1:14Hello and welcome to Headliners with Nihal Arthanaika. It is your favourite interview show. I know you're thinking, Nihal, that's a bit presumptuous. You don't know everything about me. My gosh, if you found an interview show that is better than this one, I would question your taste. In today's episode, I'm speaking to John Sutherland. Now, these days, he's the author of bestselling thrillers, including his new book, The Castle. But for many years, he worked for the Metropolitan Police and as a crisis negotiator. In fact, the top crisis negotiator in the Met. we had as i always say but i mean a fascinating conversation about the transition to life as an author the incredible inspiration behind his new book and also about the state of policing in the uk how good police officers feel about bad police officers how public perception impacts the life of a police officer and what the murder of sarah everard meant so here it is my conversation with John Sutherland.
2:18Headliners with Nihal Arthamataka. BBC Radio 5 Live. Hey, nice to see you, man. Is that your home office? Is it you at home? This is actually the kitchen table. I've got a couple of my favourite pictures on the wall behind me. So nice. I love that. It's nice to see you, John. Let's start with a castle, because I know you well enough to know, and people always say, write what you know. and I know you well enough to know that you and your wonderful wife do from time to time get to spend time in the Scottish castle, don't you? Well, yes, we do. And as I'm always keen to point out, everything classy in my life begins and ends with my wife.
3:04She brings all of the class to our relationship and I bring whatever's left over. And one of her best friends from university who she then lived with in London and was living with when we first met 25 years ago. This friend of hers married the heir to Ballendalloc Castle in the Scottish Islands. As you do. It's about an hour west of Aberdeen, and it's the most magnificent place in the most magnificent setting. and over the years of course Vicks, his wife, I already knew but Guy, the laird of the castle Guy McPherson Grant has become a wonderful, wonderful friend and he's just as kind and down to earth and generous as you could ever hope for in a friend and the story of the castle was inspired by a story he told me over a beer in London a few years back and the castle that you see on the cover of the book is the real one that is Ballendallet Castle in Banffshire up on the whiskey trail in Scotland but it was about an incident uh on the river um so they the the river spay runs through uh the castle estate uh but but yeah he he told me what was in effect a little story but it sparked a big idea in my head and I hasten to add that the whole of the content of the book is made up, but it's very much inspired by the real place.
4:43And so in a sense, the book is a product of a wonderful friendship. So when you visited there, how long did it take you before you thought this is a great place to set a thriller? or was it that chat in London with the Laird that made you say, actually, do you know what? Yeah, I'm going to do it there. It's probably a combination of the two. I mean, I'm a Sutherland, so somewhere in my heritage, there's a proud Scotsman, although you have to go back a few generations to find the proper ones. And certainly come Calcutta Cup Day, I'm an Englishman, not a Scotsman. But there's a bit of the Scott in me and I've always loved the landscape and I've always loved the people.
5:38So I kind of, it's been there in my heart and mind for a while, but it was definitely this little story about an incident on the water that he told me that then just sparked a whole tumble of ideas that eventually became the book. so when you are in the castle itself and exploring the real castle are you because you're a novelist now you're no longer and haven't been for some years a member of the metropolitan police force as you're walking through each room are you thinking to yourself almost like a kind of form of augmented reality you're imposing these scenarios as you walk through it um i've certainly done that done that a little bit more retrospectively since writing the book because i i am i i wrote the book during a period where actually i wasn't in the best of health and and wasn't able to travel up there so at the time of writing i was writing from recollection with a very kindly sent me down a copy of the castle guidebook so i was sort of writing from memory and from pictures and of course since realized that one or two of my recollections aren't quite aren't quite the same as the reality but but they work in the story is that hopefully not whiskey related the whiskey is magnificent yeah so i i guess as i can't call myself a novelist that sounds far too grown up, but I guess I am a writer now.
7:14And as a writer, I guess you've always got half an eye open for a little detail or a little description or a turn of phrase. I don't know. I remember once walking past a line of trees and I was so struck by them that they became a line in the book. It's that sort of thing. I guess there's a little bit of the magpie and you just collect as you go. So tell us about your two main characters, Alex Lewis and Pip Williams, John. Well, this is their third story. So the castle is the third in a series. They're standalone tales, so they can be read in any order. But these are the two characters that come back each time.
7:58Pip Williams is inspired by a real-life character. She's a woman, but he's a bloke. he's an old friend of mine who's the former head of the hostage and crisis negotiation unit in the met his name's phil williams and and he's a good friend of mine and uh and when i was writing the first book siege i said look i'm thinking of putting you in the book would that be all right and and he said yeah of course and i said but i'm thinking of putting you in a dress and how do you feel about that and he was entirely on for it then and has been ever since So Pip Williams is based on Phil Williams, who's the former head of the hostage unit.
8:40And then Alex, I suppose, is a loose version of me. But he's infinitely more interesting than I am. When I first wrote the first book, I gave a very early draft of it to a friend of mine who is an extraordinary storyteller, works in Hollywood, in the movies, big time. and uh he he i and i said to him i'm giving you this on the basis that you give me some honest feedback and he came back he said yeah i love you love your villain he's really interesting love your victim he's really interesting but alex your negotiator he's just a bit vanilla was what he said to me and i said to him eddie you do know that's the one who's loosely based on me don't you he said yes i know but you asked me to be honest um so to write a character too like me was just too boring um but alex has bits of me in him he's a man who cares about the job he's a man who's a little bit haunted by some of the things he's seen along the way he's a man who wants to make a difference in the world what differentiates their skill set as being police negotiators as opposed to being any other aspect of the police?
10:03Well, this is probably where you and I meet more than anywhere else. In the end, it all comes down to listening. I think people would be forgiven for thinking that police negotiators are selected on the basis of their ability to talk. And that's important, of course. It's important to know how to say the right thing, how to avoid saying the wrong thing. Talking is important, but it's not the first thing. The first thing is listening. and the thing that marks out all of the best negotiators I ever worked with was a deep sense of human compassion, of empathy and more than anything else that ability to listen.
10:52Phil Williams, the guy I mentioned earlier, whenever he used to call you out on the job, so you perform the role of hostage negotiator in addition to your day job. So my day job was as a uniform superintendent in North London, much like Alex in the books. And then I took my turn on the call rotor. And when the phone goes, and it might be in the middle of the night, you look at the call display and you can see that it's Phil calling. So you can guess what's coming. But when you connect the call there's no hello no how are you no hope I didn't disturb you no small talk of any description there's just a voice at the other end of the phone saying are you ready to save a life and it's in a way a little bit of an affectation I suppose but it it focused the mind in the most extraordinary way on the one thing, the only thing in that moment that mattered, that there was someone out there in some kind of trouble and you were being given the responsibility of doing something about it.
12:05I've always said that the greatest privilege, but also the greatest responsibility that any police officer could ever have is to save the life of another human being. And that's the role of a negotiator. How different is The Siege to The Fallen, your second book with Alex and Pip, to The Castle? Is there any difference? Do you start with the scenarios that Alex and Pip will face in the same way that you receive that phone call saying, are you ready to save a life? Or do you start somewhere else? It's a really good question. I mean, I'm still fairly early in my writing life. This is my third fiction book, my fifth book of all.
12:55So I still regard myself very much as a novice in my trade. I tend to come up with an idea and I tend to come up with, I don't know, three, four, five set pieces within the story. But much of the rest of it, I let it come to me as I write. I once heard Jeffrey Archer say, you know, if I'm not capable of surprising myself, then I'm not capable of surprising my readers. And so I like to have an idea of where I am and where I'm heading and perhaps one or two of the stops along the way. But much of what happens between times, I like to find it when I get there. And that's particularly true of the dialogue.
13:38I mean, the stories themselves are completely made up, but sort of emotionally, they're very real. I feel them as I write them. obviously Alex and Pip come first in terms of characters but you of course need to invent new characters with each new novel so who came first in the castle after Alex and Pip I think probably Tom the gamekeeper he was far and away the most fun to write and people tell me that he's fun to read so Tom Jameson is the gamekeeper he once upon a time was in special forces then he had a long career in the Met and when Alex was a young constable Tom was his sergeant so that's the connection between them and now in retirement he's gone to be the head gamekeeper on the, well it's Ballandalic in reality but I've called it Blaine Castle in the book and so he's a wonderfully colourful character who knows how to swear in Scottish and takes no nonsense but is also brave as a lion and and the man you'd want to be alongside you in in a crisis so he apart from Alex and Pip he probably came first but then I needed a villain and I needed some protagonists And that's so much of the fun of writing a book, is finding those people and their characters and their personalities, and then trying to make them live and breathe on the page.
15:26What did you need to understand about the role of a gamekeeper? Not too much, to be honest, because I didn't have to get into too much technical detail in the story. the technical details such as it is it comes more from the policing side than the gamekeeping side and of course I've got a shortcut on that in terms of my own experience but I did ask a friend of mine who owns a shotgun lawfully I hasten to add to take it out of the safe and dismantle it and show it to me and just show me how it works and how it's put together and what's the difference between an over and under barrel and a side by side barrel.
16:11And so it's just, you don't want to put so much technical detail in the book that it becomes distracting, but you want enough in there for it to be authentic, for it to sound at least half like you know what you're talking about. So how do you get that right with the police procedural then? because of your intimate knowledge of police procedural, but also not getting bogged down in a list of acronyms and initialism and terminology that distracts from the story. Yeah, well, that's where a brilliant editor comes in as much as anything else. You know, writing in many ways is quite a solitary journey, but it takes a village to raise a book.
16:56And, you know, as you know from your own experience of writing, that actually it's the input of others that can be the difference between something that's bang average and something that sings on the page. I mean, I think I've got better at it over time, but I'm still capable of putting in jargon ease that just doesn't need to be there. And that's when your editor steps in and says, hang on, that's nonsense. Give it to me again in plain English. Yeah, I had two layers of editor. So there was my editor and then it goes off to someone who I never meet. I think I knew their first name only. Yeah.
17:37And that was brutal. That process. I mean, mine was nonfiction, but where they're just giving you questions going, well, that doesn't make any sense. Well, it's, do you know, as you may have noticed, and I'm all too aware, the male ego is a fragile thing. and um i am when i wrote my very first book blue what i wanted to be told what my ego needed to be told was that i'd written the first great masterpiece of the 21st century what was actually required though was for someone gently to point out here's some good stuff but here's where you need to do some work. And what I've learned over time is actually that editorial process becomes an essential part of the creative process.
18:34But you're right, at times it can be brutal. My most brutal experience was when Laura, my agent, and she does an edit before she lets it anywhere near a publisher. She writes digital notes in the margin of my electronic manuscript. And at one point she just wrote, you can do better than this. Wow. I'm not angry. I'm disappointed. Yes, exactly. But what made it so much worse was that she was right. And in fact, what I've learned is that Laura is always right. And so that fragile male ego just needs to get back in its box. And I need to get on and do the work. And that's the thing, isn't it, is that people always see the author being interviewed, talking about his or her book, and it's all good.
19:31But what perhaps a lot of people don't realise is the process that it goes through and how many brilliant minds kind of help us really condense it down into that piece of work that ultimately we're most proud of. it very it's much more collaborative in some ways as well after you've written it than uh than perhaps people think yeah no absolutely and i guess that's the point about taking a village to raise a book i mean there is a period that is very solitary yes that's when you just got to get the words down on the page and you've just got to discipline yourself to do it yeah but from that point on you know the first person i always show it to is my wife the second person i show it to is Laura, my agent, and they've always got notes for me.
20:18And they're both always right. And from there, it goes to a publisher. And as you say, you know, it goes through two or three editing stages at least before you get anywhere close to a sort of final copy. So it's quite a journey. I mean, I've recently handed in to my editor the sequel to The Castle. and that first draft, and it's only the first draft, it took me about three months to write, which I was pretty pleased with, but it'll be another 12 months at least to knock it into shape. It's a journey. It always is. How about the thrills in the castle, as in with the siege and the fallen, about that tempo, about surprising yourself, about scaring me as the reader as I place myself into a situation where my daughter's in danger, for instance, and you have daughters, I have a daughter, those kinds of things that you do.
21:26Yeah, I mean, that's where you can begin to have a bit of fun with it. Weirdly, considering what we're talking about. I spent so much of my real life doing stuff that was altogether too serious and too troubling. This is a little bit different. But I learned a really important lesson. The first two books I wrote were nonfiction. It's like switching codes in rugby. It's the best analogy I can come up with. On the surface, there are lots of similarities. it's played with an oval ball and you've got to score tries and kick penalties and you've got to pass the ball backwards you know there are lots of similarities but actually when you get into the detail there are huge numbers of really profound differences and the most obvious one for me is when I when I was writing fiction I'm sorry non-fiction the idea is you get to the end of a chapter and you reach a point of resolution.
22:30So if I'm writing a chapter about what policing has to teach us about male violence, by the end of that chapter I need to have reached a conclusion that I can share with the reader before I move on to the next chapter that might be about gangs or about drugs. Writing fiction is completely the opposite. So non-fiction, end of a chapter resolution fiction end of a chapter anything but resolution you need to try and leave well at the end of the day it's the magic is if the reader wants to turn the page if the if the reader can't wait to turn the page so so so there's that it's the art of leaving a person hanging but I guess the other lesson I was taught was that as the author you want to make it as difficult as you possibly can for your characters in the book without making it impossible so there was there's a point fairly early in the book and this isn't a spoiler because it's on the blurb at the back there's a point fairly early in the book where Pip gets injured and uh in the first draft it was you know that the story was there but it was not much more than a scratch she was able to carry on uh and my editor came back to me and said no she needs to be much more seriously injured than that um you need to put her in jeopardy and and you need to put your readers through the ringer and from a story failing point of view she was and is absolutely right but that that stuff doesn't come naturally to me.
24:12What comes naturally to me is, is wanting all to be well and, uh, and wanting everyone to get home safely. So when you put the reader through the ringer, which ultimately you have to put yourself through the ringer first as the author to come up with this scenario and then work out how Alex is going to get out of it. Do you know how they're going to get out of it?
24:42before you come up with the, or you go, okay, so here's an end result, but I already know how they're going to get out of it. Or is it a kind of form of just sadomasochism that you say, let's go mad here, and now I've got to really work out, and you sit there staring at this blank computer screen for ages going, what have I done? Yeah. What have I done to Alex and what have I done to myself? Well, at that point, I usually take the dog for a walk in the local park. Headphones in or headphones out? No, headphones out. Right. Because I need to be clear to think. That's exactly what Anthony Horowitz does.
25:25He takes his dog for a walk. Well, that's not a bad example. And with no headphones in. Yeah, no, I find that distracting. I need to be sort of plugged into the world around me. You and Anthony Horowitz? there you go i mean if i could end up selling as many books as him indeed but yeah so it's a bit of both but but for me the bottom line is it's always it's got to remain plausible so you can't take it beyond the point of impossibility to the point where the reader's just going to look at it and say nah that's never going to happen because then you've lost them So you want to make it impossible enough that you're hanging on to the edge of the page.
26:09But when the resolution comes, you think, oh, yeah, no, I can see how that might happen or how that might work. And I guess the magic is in finding that balance, making it as difficult as possible, but making the resolution plausible.
26:32Fall tastes better with better ingredients from Whole Foods Market. No added growth hormones or antibiotics in their meat department means slow-braised short ribs are even more satisfying. All seafood is wild-caught, like their vibrant sockeye salmon or verified responsibly farmed. And all sweets, including fall-themed cookies, are made without high-fructose corn syrup. Spice up fall at Whole Foods Market. Hey, Chicagoland. Wayfair's long weekend sale is on at the Wayfair store from October 10th through October 12th. You can score up to 60 % off on everything home in person, like up to 60 % off area rugs, up to 30 % off mattresses and major appliances, and up to 50 % off kitchen and dining furniture.
27:18Plus, you can take home the small stuff that day and get the big stuff shipped fast and free. Shop Wayfair's long weekend sale October 10th through October 12th at the Wayfair store at Edens Plaza in Wilmette.
27:35what are you learning more about yourself as a writer the more you do it and as we've pointed out a number of times this is the third novel i'm learning that that i am and i suspect that we all are infinitely more creative than we might think we are i mean i honestly never imagined that i would write a book. All I ever wanted to be was a police officer. Had I not got ill, I might still be one now. I didn't have a plan B. And so writing came to me almost by accident. But having come to writing, I thought, well, I might just manage one book, but that will be it, that I'll have used up every idea I ever had.
28:22And what I realise now, sort of seven or eight years into my writing journey, is that I've got more stories in me than I ever knew were there. And actually that's true of all of us. We're all full of stories of where we came from and where we're going and how we got here. I mean, you have a police pension, so you're not entirely reliant on writing, but you are now a writer. And that's a fairly financially perilous job, isn't it? I mean, it's wracked with insecurities. How are you finding that? It's hugely perilous. And if it wasn't for my, I was medically retired from policing, so I have a medical pension and that and my wife's salary is what we live off.
29:15There are very, very few authors. I mean, Anthony Horowitz would be one, but there are very few authors who actually make a full-time living from writing. even some surprisingly big names there's not a lot of money in the printed word but a little like i did policing i do writing now for the love of it as your kind of ex-handle the police commander what is the most common source of frustration anger and sadness that you receive from current serving officers gosh, where do we begin? Because people really do see you. I've seen it. I've seen your interactions. And in fact, previously, when you and I have had conversations, they've gone viral because of how willing you are to stand up for policing while not being blinkered to the challenges of policing, but also sometimes the big mistakes that police forces make.
30:21Yeah. And so that, gosh, we could spend hours talking about just this. I think to answer your original question about the biggest frustrations, I think it probably, this is what I feel myself, but also what I pick up from serving officers. I mean, the first enormous frustration is the self-inflicted damage that policing does. You know, we've talked about this before. I'm not a blind apologist for the job that I used to do. I think everyone in society has every right to expect higher standards of police officers than they do of anyone else, without exception. And the experience, well, of my lifetime, but certainly of the last decade, is that on occasions, policing individually and collectively gets things catastrophically wrong.
31:15And the consequences of that are almost beyond comprehension. You know, I still find myself thinking all the time about Sarah Everard. I refuse to use the name of the man who killed her. So I think good police officers hate bad police officers with a fiery passion. Way more than they hate criminals, I can imagine. Well, of course, the bad police officers are criminals. You know, some of them just belong in jail and should be there for the rest of their breathing days. Because they betray the very promise that we made on the day that we joined. That's a big one. And probably bigger than anything else in the last five to ten years is just the betrayal of the few.
32:09The betrayal of the many by the few. because the vast majority of police officers, the vast majority of the time, are extraordinary people. And I think that brings me on to the second concern that I get most frequently at the moment is that the job has become more thankless than ever before. Police officers so much of the time at the moment just feel damned whatever they do. and in an environment where they're hopelessly under-resourced, where we as a society actually are setting them up to fail. It's still recent history. From 2010 to 2018, the government cut 44 ,000 officers and staff from policing in England and Wales.
33:00And the government since have been desperately scrabbling to repair the harm done, but haven't come anywhere close to doing so. Because in that eight-year period, it wasn't just the numbers that we lost. It wasn't just the 44 ,000. It was the experience that went with the generations of policing experience. And it's a job that you learn by doing. But it wasn't just the numbers and the experience that you lost. It was also, So perhaps this is the most important thing of all. It was the relationships with local communities. When the last government ripped the heart out of neighbourhood policing, they ripped the heart out of those relationships of trust that had been built over years between, you know, we often get some misty-eyed about the idea of the local Bobby.
33:51But that still existed up until very recently. You know, in my policing lifetime, I talk about London because that's what I know, but it was the same across the country. In every local authority ward, I had a sergeant, two constables and three community support officers who were dedicated to that small neighbourhood. And local people knew their names, knew who they were, knew where to find them. And in my experience, everything good in policing happens when it's done with the communities that we serve, not to them. Policing is collaborative. It's a partnership. It's an old colleague of mine has a phrase that I often return to, whatever the question, the answer is relationships.
34:41And so policing at the moment finds itself in a near impossible position where it's desperately under-resourced, desperately underfunded, desperately overstretched and with far too many priorities and actually as a society we need to have a proper grown-up honest conversation about what it is in 2025 that we want the police to be and what it is that we want them to do because at the moment we're asking them to be everything to everyone and then blaming them when we when they fail and I think that's what coppers find hardest of all. Do you get the sense that the police that you speak to have any confidence that there are non-police officers who are out there batting for them or even in fact in some instances their own leadership are out there batting for them?
35:42yeah two distinct and equally important questions I think I'm the thing that strikes me most when I will often just when I see police officers in the street I welcome just as a out of habit now and almost as a kind of point of stubborn principle I'll go up to them and I won't identify myself I'll just just say thank you to them for whatever it is that they happen to be doing that day. And their first reaction is always one of surprise, because that almost never happens to them. But their second reaction usually is to smile and to say, well, you know, that's the job, that's what we do. And most of them retain that kind of good-humoured sense of duty and service.
36:30And I think most of them know that there is still a silent majority out there who, when push comes to shove would support them. It's just that those don't tend to be the voices that shout loudest, that are heard clearest. I do think, if I'm honest, to your second point, that there are an awful lot of coppers at the moment, you know, ordinary street coppers, who feel let down by their leadership. Not all of them, not all of the time, because there are still some extraordinary people in positions of senior leadership in policing. On Wednesday this week, I'm going to the retirement due of the current Deputy Commissioner, Lynn Owen.
37:14She's amazing, a lifetime of dedicated service. But I think if you talk to a lot of coppers, they will feel that the leadership of policing, for example, has become far too politicised, that decisions are taken with a political audience in mind rather than with operational need at the heart of what's being said and done. And that's been a trend in policing over the course of my service and certainly over the course of the last 20 years. You know, going back to when I was borough commander at Camden in North London and subsequently at Southwark in South London, responsible for local policing in those boroughs, we had politically imposed targets that came from City Hall.
38:04It was called colloquially the basket of 10. It was 10 crime types that we were asked to focus on. But actually, with some exceptions, many of those crime types weren't the things that were actually most concerning local people, and they certainly weren't the things that were causing greatest harm. For example, none of those 10 crimes we were asked to focus on made any mention of domestic violence. None of them made any mention of sexual offences. None of them made any mention of knife crime explicitly. And those were things that, as far as I was concerned, had to matter far more than, say, breaking into a car.
38:44You know, every crime matters to every victim, understandably so, rightly so, but not all crimes are equal. And the ones that cause greatest harm are the ones that have to matter more. And sometimes, often, in my experience, politics gets in the way of that. Can you see a link between then, what happened between 2010 and 2018, and the kind of violence that we've seen specifically affecting young men with knives? Is it too crude to make a link between those two things? I don't think so at all. I think there's an absolute connection. I've borne out repeatedly in my operational experience everywhere I served.
39:39And I served in seven different London boroughs over the course of my service. There is an absolute connection between levels of intelligent policing activity and levels of crime. and some of the surges, the heartbreaking repetition of history, some of these surges of youth violence that we've seen in the last couple of years. I mean, there are many and complex causes, and I'll happily get into those if we have time. But absolutely one of them is levels of intelligent, proactive policing. And when we see less of that, we see more of the violence. Do you believe that mental health support has got way better for police officers, serving police officers, than when you were coming through the ranks?
40:34Yes, absolutely. But there's still a very long way to go. So I was medically retired from policing, as you know, because I had a nervous breakdown because my head broke under the strain of it all. And at that time, there was very little open conversation about mental health in policing. In the 13, 14 years since, that has improved significantly and provision and support for officers has improved significantly. but we've still got a very, very long way to go. Again, I've said this to you before, but it bears repeating. If I've learned anything in the period since my illness and my retirement, it's that it would be impossible to do the job of a police officer for any length of time and to remain unaffected by the things that you see and the things that you do.
41:31Most of us in our lifetimes will be exposed to severe trauma on three or four occasions. police officers during their working lives will be exposed to extreme trauma on four to six hundred occasions. That's three to four times in an ordinary life, four to six hundred times in a policing life. And that cannot possibly be without consequences. It's an inevitable result of the things that we as a society ask and expect them to do. And as a consequence of that, they deserve the best possible support. Someone was telling me a story about a clever young man, a teenager, a child really, who's a drug dealer.
42:21and he needs to get money for a parent because that parent isn't really functioning as you and I would regard a parent to be. But this child loves his parent and will do anything for this parent and therefore in order to have money, and this isn't money to spend on flash trainers or new phones. This is to have food. And this young person deals drugs, doesn't want to, hates the danger that comes along with it, but also has children way younger than this person's self coming to them saying, can I run drugs for you? Can I work for you? and this young person told a friend of mine, it's because we're poor.
43:24We know we're poor, but what option do we have? Now, at the end of this is a legal system that has to deal with the inherent criminality in drug dealing for children who are living in poverty, and the police are at the front line of this. And I wonder how much seething resentment there is that they are having to deal with the, and I hate this term, but essentially the collateral damage of poverty.
44:07Oh, gosh, I listen with a heavy heart because I've not met the boy you're talking about, but I've met so many like him. And that story is an immensely familiar one to me. And way more widespread than so many people who are living largely comfortable middle-class lives will be willing to admit it's taking place. It's endemic. I often refer to a young boy called Billy Smith. He's not a real person. He's sort of an archetype, an amalgam of all the young men I met over the course of my career. And I tell his story in my second book, the second nonfiction one, Crossing the Line. And this connects us back to, you know, you were asking me about the connection between levels of policing activity and levels of youth violence.
44:58And I said, absolutely, there is a connection. But policing is not the answer to youth violence. In fact, I think it's not unreasonable to say that by the time the police get involved, society has already failed. Blaming police officers for the existence of crime makes as much sense as blaming doctors for the existence of disease. and so it's vital one of the reasons why i love talking to you is because there's the time and the space to have the conversations that need to be had because most of the rest of the world is in far too much of a hurry to be having it if we want to understand why your friend my billy smith is dealing drugs carrying a knife involved in violence then we need to look a whole lot deeper.
45:55And we need to understand the root causes. And I would say that the two most significant root causes of youth violence in this country are poverty and trauma. Billy Smith grew up in a deprived neighbourhood, in a broken home, where he had experienced domestic violence almost every day of his young life. And so he set out on young adulthood almost without a hope, almost without a chance. And so if we're really serious about doing something about this, then that's what we need to understand and that's what we need to address. we need to be looking after Billy, not just from the day that he's born, but even before the day that he's born.
46:58What about their criminals, throw them in jail, throw away the key? So it's such a good question, and it requires a significant amount to stubbornness and it requires a relentless dependence on evidence and facts and that is so much more difficult in a post-truth world or whatever else we we try to come up with to make sense of the madness of the situation we live in i mean i wouldn't dismiss every objection out of hand, there are some young people out there who are at this moment in time just so dangerous that there is no alternative for society in the short term at least but to lock them up.
47:59I take no pleasure in saying that. I take no delight in saying that. In fact, I feel an enormous sense of sadness in saying that because it's another admission of our failure as a society. It's actually an admission of my failure personally as a police officer. Some of them are just so dangerous that today they need locking up. But actually, that's never going to change unless we not only understand the things that you and I are talking about, but do something about them. And the reality is, as a quote that I've misappropriated and slightly misquoted from, of all places, C.S. Lewis, the reality is that actually we know what needs to be done about youth violence and knife crime and it's not that it's it's been tried and found wanting it's been found difficult and left untried this is tough stuff this is complex stuff this is stuff that doesn't get fixed within a news cycle or within an electoral cycle.
49:09You know, I am on record in print advocating that this country needs a 20-year life crime prevention plan, life crime reduction plan, which means that we need politicians who are brave enough to look beyond the lifetime of this parliament and the interests of their party, and to say, to acknowledge, to recognise that there's something that matters more than party politics, which is the very fabric of our society, of who we are, what it means to be us, because these are our children. Yes. But it's easy enough to say they're not our children because they'll live in a place. And we can wash our hands of them.
49:56Yeah, exactly. and they live in a place that we don't go to or we don't just drive through or drive past and we see segregated communities living segregated lives and as we know because you talked about data and facts rich people get richer and poor people get poorer And it's the relative gap between those two groups of people that all of the clever people will tell you is a really significant determinant of so many of the problems that we're facing in society. The gap between the richest and the poorest, which is growing exponentially, almost daily, it seems at the moment, is the source of a huge amount of society's ills.
50:47I often say there are four reasons, very briefly, why we don't do what needs to be done about things like life crime, about domestic violence, about extremism, you name the problem. Reason number one is we say it will take too long. And my point is, you know, it will probably take 20 years or more. When you're dealing with stuff that has been a generation or more in the making, it may just take a generation or more to mend. But people say that's too long. The problem is, though, that by repeatedly getting it wrong and having to put it right again, it actually ends up taking longer. So that's a nonsense objection.
51:29The second objection is that it will cost too much. We can't afford to do what you're saying needs doing. To which I have two responses. Well, number one is you can't afford not to. But equally, actually spending money on the wrong stuff and then having to spend it all over again ends up costing more. So we say it'll take too long and we end up taking longer. We say it will cost too much and we end up spending more. Number three is we just say that it's too difficult. It's like you're frying my brain. It's too difficult. And then the fourth, to your point, is because it doesn't happen to people like you and me.
52:11if these victims of knife crime were children of the establishment, the response of society would be worlds apart from one that we see now. We're rapidly running out of time. You and I, as you know, could speak for hours. And we have done, thankfully, away from microphones. Not as much as I would like, but we have done away from microphones. it's a it's a it's a weird question to ask but it i just want to ask you how proud are you of the castle it's such a incredibly immersive book it's exciting and it's thrilling violent in parts how proud are you of it i'm really proud of it i think you know we started of the conversation talk about me being a writer and I still struggle to come to terms with that in a nice way.
53:11But as a writer, it's the best book I've written. And so on that simple level, I'm really proud of it. But also what I hope lies at the heart of all of my books is I hope there's a humanity. It's the way that Alex and Pip go about things, that they try to remember, as I try to remember, that all of us have our stories and all of us have our scars. John Sutherland, we shall have a wee dram next time we meet in person. I look forward to that. Whiskey from the River Spey. And thank you for writing The Castle. Such an exciting read. Unputdownable page turner. All those fantastic cliches, but true.
54:04True with The Castle. It was meant to be a perfect escape. And my gosh, it certainly was far from perfect. Take good care. Give my love to Bear. And hopefully I'll see you very soon. Thanks so much for having me on. Thank you for listening to another episode of Headliners. I'd love to know what you thought of that one. It was, I think you'll agree, a great conversation with a man that not only have I interviewed before on the radio, but even interviewed for my book. I'd love to know what you thought of John Sutherland, but also what guests you'd like to see coming up, because we don't have that many headliners left, maybe 10 free slots left before it disappears.
54:50from the schedule. Nihal at bbc.co.uk is the email address. And please share the headliner's love because there's a whole heap of back catalogue for you to wade yourself through. We'll be back with more of our favourite conversations next week. I'll see you then.
55:15What does it take to go racing in the fastest cars in the world? Oscar Piastri. Your head's trying to get roof one way, your body's trying to go another. Lance Stroll. It's very extreme in the sense of how close you're racing wheel to wheel. We've been given unprecedented access to two of the most famous names in Formula One, McLaren and Aston Martin. I'm Landon Aris, racing driver for McLaren Formula One team. They opened the doors to their factories as the 2024 season reached its peak. They work to build a beautiful bit of machinery that I get to then go and have fun in. I'm Josh Hartnett. This is F1 Back at Base.
55:47Listen on BBC Sounds. Part of why I blew the whistle was I didn't want to lay in bed in 20 years, having seen another million people die, and know that I could have done something when I had a chance. This week on The Interface, we're talking to Frances Haugen. The Facebook whistleblower who leaked the documents that changed how the world saw social media. And now she is the subject of Aaron Sorkin's latest movie, The Social Reckoning. So join me, Thomas Germain. And me, Jess Maddox, for The Interface. Listen on BBC.com or wherever you get your podcasts. Thank you.
Author and former chief superintendent at the Met, John Sutherland, joins Nihal for an in-depth chat.
Nihal Arthanayake presents his Sunday evening show and podcast, featuring exclusive in-depth interviews with headline guests across entertainment, sport, culture and politics.