1. Podcasts
  2. Headliners with Nihal Arthanayake
  3. Megan Jayne Crabbe
Headliners with Nihal Arthanayake

11 Jun 2025 · 55m · 20 chapters

In short

Headliners with Nihal Arthanaike interviews Megan Jayne Crabbe about her book We Don’t Make Ourselves Smaller Here, focusing on authenticity, “likability” pressures, fat acceptance/body positivity, dating, sexuality, productivity, motherhood expectations, and reclaiming joyful movement.

Guest background

Megan Jayne Crabbe is an author and long-time content creator (about 10 years). She was diagnosed with anorexia nervosa at 14 and later recovered. She says she came out as queer later (initially thought she was straight) and now has a girlfriend. She describes herself as having “various privileges” in relation to body norms.

Key claims

Shrinking oneself is usually taught, not chosen. Health is holistic and not determined by size/weight alone. Fat positivity should include personal and political dismantling of fatphobia, racism, ableism, and ageism. “Health concern” objections are often “health policing” used to silence body-positive conversations. Productivity culture and capitalism devalue rest and human worth.

Notable examples

“Date one” behavior—hollowing needs, performing desirability, restricting food, managing how she’s perceived; “date two”—showing up fully, eating what she wants, leaving without needing approval. Reclaiming movement: walking mindfully, then returning to dance/running despite being the “fattest” in class; she fractured an ankle while dancing joyfully.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

1:14

Embracing Authenticity

Discussion on Megan's book and the importance of authenticity and body image.

“Welcome to Headliners with Nihal Arthanaike.”
2:18

The Challenge of Likability

Megan explores the societal pressures of likability and its impact on self-identity.

“headliners with nihil afamayaka megan we don't make ourselves smaller here reclaiming all that's rightfully ours and The first question I thought about was, do you 100 % believe in that title?”
5:04

Reframing Fatness

Megan shares her journey of reinterpreting the concept of fatness and body positivity.

“For me personally, the challenge has been figuring out which parts of me are really me and which are parts that I have grown and adapted in order to fulfill this idea of likability.”
10:00

The Evolution of Body Positivity

A discussion on the current state of body positivity and its challenges.

“and making more peace with fatness as a concept, I think would make the world a much kinder and more equitable place, especially for people who exist in larger bodies.”
13:00

Critiques and Accessibility in Activism

Megan discusses critiques within social movements and the need for inclusivity.

“to ally build, it was designed to wag fingers at people.”
14:03

The Need for Community and Acceptance

Exploring the importance of community and gradual acceptance in movements.

“And at the end of the day, you know, as humans, we want that community.”
16:46

Navigating Personal Experiences in Dating

Megan shares her past dating experiences and the pressures of societal expectations.

“biggest self this is a journey this is me inviting the readers to come with me and just just investigate.”
19:50

The Exhaustion of Performance in Dating

Discussion on the exhausting performance expectations in dating scenarios.

“and I show up as my full self and I ask myself, do I like this person?”
22:26

Understanding Gender Expectations in Relationships

Examining gender expectations and their impact on dating and self-expression.

“You know, society will look down on us in some way.”
24:41

Evolving Perspectives on Sexuality and Self

Megan discusses her journey toward understanding her sexuality and self-acceptance.

“We're seeing a lot of like deeply ingrained disdain for women, for femininity, for girlhood.”
Show all 20 chapters
28:46

Self-Reflection and Body Image

Megan discusses her journey in body image and self-acceptance over the past ten years.

29:58

Dating Dynamics and Misogyny

Exploring the differences in dating experiences between queer women and straight women amidst societal misogyny.

“So I would just zoom in stomach, zoom in thighs, zoom in arms, you know, and make this mental checklist of, okay, must lose this, must change this, must get surgery on this.”
33:55

The Productivity Trap

Megan discusses the societal pressure to be constantly productive and its impact on mental health.

“It's deeply sad because I think it is robbing so many people of genuine connection.”
37:44

Motherhood and Societal Expectations

Megan shares her thoughts on motherhood and the societal pressures surrounding women's roles.

“Again, because so much of this book is about societal expectations placed upon women.”
41:48

Fears of Parenting in a Complex World

Megan expresses her fears and considerations about raising children in today's society.

“Well, I think there's undeniably a possibility of that.”
42:04

The Complexities of Parenthood

Explore the fears and challenges of parenting in today's world.

“I think if I'm being completely honest, I would definitely have deep fears about bringing a child of any gender into this world.”
46:08

Aspirations for the New Book

Megan discusses her goals for her new book and its impact.

“and you want as many people, especially middle-aged men, to read this book.”
47:30

Health Policing in Body Positivity

Megan reflects on societal reactions to body positivity and health policing.

“But at the end of the day, if people read it and just feel seen, that's enough.”
51:32

Reclaiming Movement and Joy

Megan shares her journey of reclaiming movement and joy in dancing.

“Because size has an effect on how the freedom to move that we have as kids somehow becomes an image of just self-awareness, like hyper self-aware of every bit of your body and how it moves.”
56:00

Intriguing Tales in Sports

Explore shocking stories from the world of sports, including crime and betrayal.

“An ill-advised errand changing F1 forever.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On Headliners with Nihal Arthanayake, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK. Fall tastes better with better ingredients from Whole Foods Market. No added growth hormones or antibiotics in their meat department means slow-braised short ribs are even more satisfying. All seafood is wild-caught, like their vibrant sockeye salmon or verified responsibly farmed. and all sweets, including fall-themed cookies, are made without high-fructose corn syrup. Spice up fall at Whole Foods Market. Is World War II back up for debate? I'm Tristan Redman, host of the Global Story podcast from the BBC. If you live in Europe or the US, the chances are you thought the rights and wrongs of World War II were mostly settled, which is why some of us were surprised to find out that the podcaster Tucker Carlson not only disagreed, but he's been podcasting about it with a British politician.

0:55Today on the show, we explore why. Listen to The Global Story on bbc.com or wherever you listen.

1:14Welcome to Headliners with Nihal Arthanaike. Today's guest is Megan Jane Crabb. Her book entitled We Don't Make Ourselves Smaller Here is described as a powerful rallying cry for embracing authenticity in all areas of our lives. And Megan certainly brought that energy to our conversation. We spoke about the importance of taking up space, modern dating, coming out and as ever, so much more. but in the question of of health and body image and fat acceptance there is so much evidence that health is far far more complicated than size and weight and that alone health is holistic health includes mental health emotional health spiritual health and it has so many factors that go into it even someone's body size has so many factors of genetic even if someone is fat and unhealthy are they not deserving of being treated with respect um because this is what fat acceptance and you know body positivity should also be aiming for

2:18headliners with nihil afamayaka megan we don't make ourselves smaller here reclaiming all that's rightfully ours and The first question I thought about was, do you 100 % believe in that title? Or could I slightly edit it to say, I hope we won't make ourselves smaller here? Oh, what an insightful observation and first question. You are spot on. I love the title as a phrase. I think in itself, it can be quite an affirmation, quite empowering in a way. But there's layers to it, right? I think, first of all, it's important to know that it makes it sound like a completely individual choice. We don't make ourselves smaller here.

3:04Whereas in reality, for most women, this is not something that we choose to do. It's something we've been taught. It's something we've been conditioned to do. You know, we live within a culture that convinces us that we should make ourselves small, that it will be conducive to our success or our likability. So there's that element. And then I think you are spot on in saying that. I hope that we will fight back against that narrative of having to shrink ourselves and refuse to. But it is absolutely, for me especially, a lifelong challenge and a process. Have you managed to disconnect a sense, a need to be liked with the fact that shrinking yourself means that for so much of your life, you will be liked more?

3:58I actually wrote a whole chapter in the book about likability and the idea that for women especially likability is a bit of a rigged concept because we are taught so many different things throughout our lives as to what would make us the most likable you know don't be too loud don't be too confident uh be be funny but don't make yourself the center of attention be conventionally attractive, but not so conventionally attractive that you're then threatening to other women. So many conflicting messages as to how to be likable. And I would say that I practiced them all really thoroughly and effectively throughout my teenage years and into my early twenties.

4:41But it leaves you kind of hollow. It leaves you with this sense of, you know, I'm not being my full self. Yes, I have this kind of this, this likability that I can't even quite, you know, I put my finger on, but it's this feeling that I'm in control of other people's perceptions of me, which can be a very comforting feeling. But ultimately, if it comes at the expense of being your whole self, it is hollow. It is an empty win. For me personally, the challenge has been figuring out which parts of me are really me and which are parts that I have grown and adapted in order to fulfill this idea of likability.

5:16And genuinely, I believe that the satisfaction that comes from being disliked for being yourself is much it's just much more powerful it's it's it's it's a much more fulfilling thing it's you know it's that that you know the courage to be disliked and the confidence to say no I would rather show up as me and accept that I'm not going to be for everyone and that's okay because everyone's not for me either true but how difficult has that been for you to realise that, especially in a social media age, when this isn't just about kids that you see every day in the playground, this is about complete strangers somehow having some power over you?

5:57Oh, massively difficult. It's incredibly hard to detach the need to be liked when you exist within a career where your success is literally measured in likes. So that has been a journey in itself. Again, a willingness to piss some people off or lose followers, you know, not, not look in the comment sections when you know there are people in there who are, who are saying really damning things about you. And I will say that I have developed much, much, much thicker skin than I used to have. You know, I've been a content creator for 10 years. And back then when people would kind of turn on me or have an inaccurate impression of me, it would absolutely destroy me and I would carry it around for days and days and be broken by it.

6:44And now I am much more resilient and I know that if someone doesn't really like me, it probably says more about them than it does about me. Because, you know, people come into interactions with preconceptions. They project whatever they're going through onto you. Sometimes you're just a scapegoat for other people's insecurities. And it's often not about you at all. How has your attitude changed over time to the word fat? How many different meanings does it have for you? Well, I learned very early on in life that fat was a horrible insult and the worst thing that I could possibly be. My own body image issues started when I was at primary school and I was in the classroom and I perceived that I was a bit different to everyone around me.

7:34I was a bit bigger. I had brown skin. No one else did in the class. And I latched onto the narrative that different was bad and I must change myself. and it was my body size in particular but I thought yes I can control this I can make myself thinner and you know everything around me was corroborating this idea that thinner is better we we exist in an extremely fat phobic society where thinness is held up as desirable as the ultimate achievement as the only way to be a main character to be seen to be respected in some instances. So I had a really fear-based relationship with the word fat for a long time.

8:14It was the last thing I ever wanted to be. And I had an eating disorder when I was a teenager, was diagnosed with anorexia nervosa at 14. And with anorexia, fat was the absolute enemy. The last thing I could consider, I wanted to get rid of every single bit of it on my entire body. after going through recovery kind of coming back into this world that's still filled with diet culture where weight loss is sold at every turn and this this thin ideal is everywhere I still had an awful relationship with the idea of fatness with the idea of my body being anything other than the smallest it could be and it was when I stumbled across the body positive community online when I was about 21, that for the first time I saw people saying the word fat and reclaiming it as a neutral descriptor, just as someone would say, I'm tall or I'm brunette.

9:09Some people are fat, some people are thin, some people are somewhere in between. And that is a statement of fact. And, you know, body diversity has existed across all cultures, everywhere, forever. There have always been people who are bigger than others. And so it was a real challenge to reframe my idea of fatness, to make it a neutral thing. And it was it was exposure therapy. You know, it was exposing myself to all these people in all these different types of bodies who were reclaiming this word and reclaiming the meaning. And I think, you know, there is so much damage done within society because we are deeply fat phobic.

9:50We are encouraged to be deeply fat phobic from media, from health professionals, everywhere we turn. and really interrogating that internalised fatphobia and making more peace with fatness as a concept, I think would make the world a much kinder and more equitable place, especially for people who exist in larger bodies. How do you relate still to the term body positive? Do you think that it has been hijacked or commodified or undermined in any way, or do you still believe it to have the power that it had when the movement started? listen I think um whoever you ask they're gonna have a different opinion on first of all what that term even means you know because it was never set in stone it was this kind of organic mainly online movement and people had different definitions of it so you know lots of people now say body positivity was co-opted it became you know all about the wrong things it doesn't have meaning anymore it still has meaning to me it still for me is the thing that I genuinely credit with saving my life.

10:58And for me, the definition of body positivity has always included the personal and the political. It's always included the personal body image, how I feel about myself in my body, and also the political of let's recognize that bodies are put into hierarchies within our culture. And things like fat phobia and racism and ableism and ageism, these all exist. And this is something that we're also trying to dismantle. And I think when you put those two things together that is really body positivity that's the true meaning but yes a lot of what we see online especially these days um does not recognize the second part of that and i think that's the real issue but the attack on anything woke largely from an old generation who my analysis of largely is that they see a relinquishing of their power the pushback is full on isn't it and it's terrifying i don't really know what to make of the world we're living in megan i hear you i am with you i think um for me personally i i have to believe that the good people fighting the good fight are here they're they exist they're everywhere they're not necessarily always the loudest voices even these days on social media you know we're all getting a warped perception really because it's all so extreme um and so clickbaity i have i have to believe i have to believe that the good people are still there doing the work well we don't have another option do we we're certainly not going to give up and we're certainly not going to let the bigots and the idiots and the small-minded people win But I wonder whether being so deeply embedded in the messaging, if you feel that the messaging at times was too strong, it wasn't designed to ally build, it was designed to wag fingers at people.

13:07How do you feel about that? I think there is absolutely some truth to what you've just said. And I think it's a critique that can be applied to most movements on the left, most kind of social justice movements, in that sometimes, especially online, we seem to be far more interested in reprimanding anyone who makes a slight mistake or gatekeeping who's allowed to be part of the movement. You have to, you know, you have to be perfect. We are much better at doing that sometimes than we are, as you say, ally building, bringing people in. And I do understand that, you know, people who do the kind of left to right swing, I get it because they'll accept anyone.

13:57You can be trash and they're like, come in, you're welcome here. We accept you. And at the end of the day, you know, as humans, we want that community. We want that acceptance. And, you know, at the left, we can alienate people. And I 100 % recognize that. And I've also always believed that there has to be stepping stones in any movement when you're coming in. And in the past, people have criticized me for not being radical enough in my messaging, you know, not putting out the most extreme kind of political viewpoints. And I've kind of seen myself as a bit of a stepping stone, especially into body positivity, because I do exist in a body that doesn't fall too far out of what society sees as an acceptable body.

14:44I have various privileges. And that means that for a lot of people, I'm a very accessible entry point into this movement. And I have been criticised for that. But ultimately, I think that that is necessary because people are not going to jump from the right straight to the left, or they're not going to go from hating their body to suddenly being radical fat activists. You need the stepping stones. And that's interesting in itself, because if we want the word fat to be neutral, then being a radical fat activist almost doesn't make any sense. I see what you mean. Like a radical brunette activist or radical tall activist.

15:22Right. Like you use those examples before, didn't you? Tall. Just make it neutral. Right. But interesting to be a radical fat activist when actually what you're trying to achieve is neutrality doesn't seem to make any sense. well i think it's that thing of um well we don't currently need radical tall activists or radical activists uh because culturally those things are accepted they don't come with prejudice and and judgment so you have to sometimes swing to that way in order to end up somewhere in the middle because we have a lot of damage to undo right we have a lot of unlearning to do so to be radical is to, I guess, make up for or try and level out where we're currently at so that we can land at neutrality in the end.

16:07But I don't, while reading We Don't Make Ourselves Smaller Here, feel that you are a radical. I feel that you are someone trying to explain a very human story to people who just might not understand. And as a man and a father of a daughter, nothing that you seem to be saying is radical in tone or indeed in language no i agree with you and also i think something that i've tried to be very clear with in this this book is i don't have all the answers this is not a quick fix how to guide to being your biggest self this is a journey this is me inviting the readers to come with me and just just investigate.

16:53Let's just look at these places in our lives where we shrink ourselves, where we've been taught to make ourselves smaller and unpack why do we feel this way? Where are these narratives coming from? Is there anything that we ourselves can do? So I agree with you. This should not be in any way a radical message. I don't think that, you know, feminism and equality should be in any way a radical message. But I guess it will be to some people. Sadly, yes. Those who are paranoid enough to feel that they somehow lose out due to equality happening. I want you to describe two different romantic dates to me, right?

17:33Megan goes out on a date with a dude and Megan doesn't like herself very much, but she is desperate to be liked. She looks in the mirror and she doesn't like what she sees so she goes on a date walk me through the behaviors of that megan that megan existed 15 years ago and first of all she would um i've described in the book a sense of hollowing myself out to arrive to this date. So essentially my needs, my wants, my concerns, or anything about my personality that might not be 100 % likable, that gets shelved, right? That gets left at home. And all I'm doing in this state of not liking myself, not liking my body, is I'm trying to secure the validation of being wanted and liked by someone else.

18:32And for a long in my life, I sought that through the male gaze and through securing attraction from men as a way to validate my worth. So on that date, you know, I wouldn't show up as my whole self. I wouldn't be present. I would be constantly in my head thinking, how do I look to him? How is he perceiving me? Am I being likeful enough? Oh, I can't eat anything on this date because that might be unattractive. you know am I performing and I think when um when we don't think very much of ourselves it's easy to believe this idea that dating is a performance and it doesn't matter how we feel it doesn't even matter if we like the other person all that matters is whether we have secured their attraction to us and that's how I dated for a long time um and that didn't change until I did a hell of a lot of unlearning of these very patriarchal expectations and this idea of you know perfect womanhood this idea that a perfect woman has no needs um has doesn't disagree with anything it's never rude um doesn't want too much you know isn't isn't abrasive or loud or angry or all of this um and through unlearning that narrative the second date that you mentioned um is a very different date you know it happens years and years in the future and I show up as my full self and I ask myself, do I like this person?

19:59And I eat a meal and I check in with my needs and I leave the date and the guy doesn't like me and it's okay because I don't like him either. And again, it's that feeling of I have validated myself and I do not need to shrink myself in order to secure the validation from someone else. And you know what, that feels better than the first date. And the details around that I found fascinating. So you You order a chicken wrap on date one. You only eat half of it. On date two, you order whatever you want with two sides. Don't care. You don't wear a coat. You'd rather be cold on date one. On date two, you wear a coat, big coat, so you don't have to be shivering in a corner of a bus on the way home.

20:44All of these things that you have to navigate in order to be liked. I mean, I'm reading it. I'm like, this is bloody exhausting. Not that, like, I mean, everyone's performing on a date, right? Especially a first date, everyone is. But there's no way I've ever been to a date ever. Well, I've been married for 20 years, so that's been a long time. But a date night, actually, I have date nights with my wife, but that's different. A kind of first date, and ever have I had to think, well, I'm not going to order, just in case. Or, as you say in the book, position my body in a certain way so I don't look, like, there's not something there that physically you might find unattractive.

21:24I'm going to have to do any of those things. Of course I'm going to wear a coat if it's cold. Yeah, welcome to womanhood. Yeah, yeah. But that's the important thing about books like this and why it's so bloody important. No disrespect to teenage girls. I've got one in my home. But middle-aged men read these books. Just to get a sense of it. Just to idea, oh gosh. Wow, is that what my sister had to go through? Is that what my daughter would have to go through? Is that what my mum had to go through? yeah yeah it's it it is exhausting it is all all the very all the very detailed rules and expectations and you know these things that we didn't ask for you know that are put onto us in this culture but just diminish us just make us small and and sell us the narrative that we have to do these things.

22:19And if we don't, we are undesirable and no one will want to date us and we won't be successful. You know, society will look down on us in some way. And I guess that's why I do what I do and why I talk about the things I talk about, because I am frankly saying, hey, I exist and I'm not playing by these rules anymore. I'm not doing these things. And look, You know, I'm here. I'm happier than I was back then. And this is an option. It is possible to say, no, I'm not playing by these rules. Do you think that part of what you describe about wanting to be that person in that first date, Megan, is about society or men themselves still want that?

23:07They want that woman to turn up, eat three salad leaves with maybe a chopped radish on top of it and some kind of sauce. but make sure it's okay let's not go crazy okay all right low calorie dressing right yeah yeah all right make sure she's well dressed don't wear a big coat is it still that because i've also got a 17 year old son so it'd be interesting to know whether you think that the next generation coming through gen z and beyond are still going to have those expectations and women like you who would spend two hours getting ready before you went to school. Two hours, Megan. Yep. My son flies out the house barely, like still putting a sock on when he's in the car, right?

24:03Like the idea that he would get up two hours before to get ready to make sure his face is on. It's just absurd. And to be fair, my daughter's the same. She doesn't bother with any of that nonsense. She sometimes likes to get her hair plaited. Great. Love that. Whether it's, you know, society, whether it's, you know, these things are inseparable. I think it's impossible to say this is exactly where this is coming from, this is the issue, because it's all so intertwined and it's all so deeply conditioned. And, you know, we are seeing, I think people are seeing more clearly, especially now, the prevalence of misogyny online and for the younger generation.

24:53We're seeing a lot of like deeply ingrained disdain for women, for femininity, for girlhood. And, you know, these boys, they're not born with this. This is not an innate thing. this is something that they are being conditioned with at kind of every stage throughout their lives, it's really difficult to untangle and begin that unlearning process. What is dating like now? Well, here's the thing, Nahal. I'm a lot gayer than the first time we met. I thought I was straight for the majority of my life. And I had to really question the thing that we've spoken about a lot which is this idea of uh perfect womanhood um and how to how to do womanhood right how to you know live life correctly and you know along with the beauty standards and these other expectations we also have a hell of a lot of compulsive heterosexuality so you know this this um suppression of anything queer this time of um i grew up in school at the time of like section 28 Section 28, 21.

26:06The criminalisation of the promotion of homosexuality. Of homosexuality, yeah. As if you can catch it. So there was absolutely no queer representation for me growing up. I did not see that as an option. I just thought, you know, you be thin, you be beautiful, you be successful, you get a husband, you settle down, you've done life right. Unpacking all of that, that deep patriarchal conditioning, kind of left me realising, oh, no, wait, maybe it doesn't have to be meet a man and then my life is valid and actually I have always had an attraction to women that I have suppressed or that I have you know caveated with oh but you know I can kiss a woman if there's a man there and that makes it okay um and actually accepting that about myself and exploring that massively changed um everything about my dating life um and how I present myself and you know I have a beautiful incredible girlfriend now and at the beginning of our relationship she actually would kind of gently call me out when she sensed I was still doing a bit of the performance that I had learned from dating men and she would say you don't need to do that here you can just be yourself you don't have to perform desirability or try to be this you know perfect version of of womanhood but the whole of you is welcome so i've had a 180 in that

27:40fall tastes better with better ingredients from whole foods market no added growth hormones or antibiotics in their meat department means slow braised short ribs are even more satisfying All seafood is wild caught, like their vibrant sockeye salmon or verified responsibly farmed. And all sweets, including fall-themed cookies, are made without high-fructose corn syrup. Spice up fall at Whole Foods Market. Is World War II back up for debate? I'm Tristan Redman, host of the Global Story podcast from the BBC. If you live in Europe or the US, the chances are you thought the rights and wrongs of World War II were mostly settled, which is why some of us were surprised to find out that the podcaster Tucker Carlson not only disagreed, but he's been podcasting about it with a British politician.

28:30Today on the show, we explore why. Listen to The Global Story on bbc.com or wherever you listen.

28:45what were those performance aspects then that your girlfriend pointed out i think they were mainly the the things that i wrote about from you know that date number one all those years ago um that was still clinging on a little bit so just being a bit too aware of how she saw me you know managing my like how I looked to her too much or not expressing when I had a need or a want not asking anything of her to not you know put her out because I can handle everything myself and and I don't you know I don't need to show an emotion that's difficult or you know those just just making myself emotionally smaller still now that you look in the mirror now it's been 10 years really as you write in the book of you absolving yourself of these pressures when you look in the mirror and listen let's face it not everyone looks in the mirror most people don't look in the mirror and go I love what I see right most people don't um you'd have to be a next level narcissist I think for you not to to do that but what is the what is the difference now than Megan 10 years ago when you look in the mirror?

29:59There are so many differences. I think primarily the way I look is different because 10 years ago, I would look in the mirror and I would automatically just zoom in on these supposed problem areas that I've been convinced to see as flaws and think I had to fix. So I would just zoom in stomach, zoom in thighs, zoom in arms, you know, and make this mental checklist of, okay, must lose this, must change this, must get surgery on this. Every time I looked in the mirror, which again is exhausting. And today I don't do the zoom in. I see myself more as a whole and regardless of how I feel on any given day about the way that I look.

30:48And as you said, it's not, you know, it's not everyday look and love what you see. I get on with my day regardless. Because 10 years ago, if I'd have woken up in the morning, looked in the mirror and listed all those disgusting flaws, the day was ruined. That's all I'm thinking about for the entire day. I'm not really present anywhere that I'm going. I'm dressing in a way to try and disguise things. I'm starving myself to try and fix things. And now I can look in the mirror and just, yeah, get on with the day and understand that this is not the be all and end all. This is not my ultimate worth and I don't have to I don't have to make it my life work to mold and change how my body looks I can actually do other things yes um for your heterosexual friends who are still dating do you still see vast differences between you know your experience now as a gay woman and their experiences such as sexual women oh massively there's a there's i feel like it's um a bit of a running joke especially online now as to the the state of dating for straight women these days it is um it's hard out there on those streets it's they're really they're really going through it it's a bit of a battlefield so yeah yeah i do i do see massive differences and and And that's not to say that, you know, queer dating is always unproblematic.

32:14I think there's, you know, there's its own stuff. I know enough gay people who have mad, mad experiences in that world. Yeah. But for women, for women dating men, it is a deeply difficult and actually sometimes quite scary time out there where, you know, this this extreme misogyny is going unchecked. you know, flourishing quietly. I have a hell of a lot of friends who have been deep in relationships with men and have not realised the amount of misogyny lurking underneath that's been disguised and, you know, just pushed back and they're pretending to be someone that they aren't. That seems to be especially prevalent these days.

33:06It's scary times out there. And that was what adolescence was talking about, wasn't it? It wasn't about the kind of poster boys, if that's not a weird term, the Tates, etc. It was about this kind of creeping misogyny. This thing that exists just by feeding these messages that somehow, especially through dating apps, that you're never, ever going to get a woman because you're not six foot tall. You don't earn£100 ,000. so the only way you're going to do this is through subterfuge, through coercion, through tricking them. And that is just so terrifying. Truly. I feel like you've summed that up very well.

33:53It is terrifying and it's sad. It's deeply sad because I think it is robbing so many people of genuine connection. but the issue is that a lot of healing would have to happen in order for you know these genuine connections in order for these young men to find those connections which yes are out there and you don't have to be six foot or earning this much money but you do have to be you do have to have started the work of healing you do have to be willing to look at yourself honestly and self reflect and recognize your flaws and recognize you know a little bit of the system that we exist in and do the work.

34:33And it is work. It is work to go against the grain of what you're being taught to be and conditioned to be. Let's talk about life. Talked about sexuality, talked about body. Let's talk about life and the productivity trap. Tell me about the productivity trap. The productivity trap is a chapter in which I write about this never-ending pressure to squeeze productivity out every minute of every day and I would say about five years ago I was the epitome of this and I from waking until going to bed would have to be using every moment in order to feel like I'd done the day right in order to feel validated and ultimately in order to feel like I had earned my right to be here just you know existing because I had been productive and I'd done my to-do list and I'd smashed work and it's it's it's it's again it's another kind of creeping feeling and I think it's a product of capitalism absolutely and that we have been conditioned to think that if we are not contributing to to capitalist society in some way we're getting it right um and it's this also this you know protestant work ethic thing of keep working smash it out and productivity productivity productivity yes that's the mantra also from the government right well yeah and it is massively detrimental it is first of all we we are human beings we're not machinery uh we require rest we deserve rest and something else that I wrote about in the book that has altered my relationship with productivity is my sister so my sister is older than me she has cerebral palsy I have been one of her carers for a very long time now and when I think about Gemma she is never going to be productive according to the standards set for us societally you know she's never going to produce a piece of work or something of value for someone else.

36:42And to say that she then has less worth is, first of all, deeply ableist. And secondly, just incorrect. And I can see that she has so much worth simply because she exists. And she also has a right to a happy and peaceful and fulfilling life. And if I can see that for her, why can I not see that for myself or for everyone else? You know, I have friends who almost brag about burning themselves out and how much they've done and how much it's affected them. But it's like a badge of honor, this burnout from productivity. And I say to my friends, you know, if you never produce a single thing more, you still have value and you still deserve to be here and, you know, have a nice life where your needs are met.

37:33And it's transferring that empathy and acceptance onto myself, which has been a challenge and is something that I'm still working on, but I'm getting there. What about children? Again, because so much of this book is about societal expectations placed upon women. And one of those is you are not really a woman. Like, what is your purpose if you haven't had a child? And that's not just from men. That can be from other women as well. Especially when you're in a social group where suddenly women start having babies. Yeah, I'm in that group now. It is jarring. I definitely grew up seeing the, you know, the lifeline checklist, tick, tick, tick, university, job, married, babies, etc.

38:24And I find myself now at 32 being still deeply unsure of whether I want to have children or even what I see life looking like. And I write in the book, I kind of go through my fools and against and why I feel so conflicted about this. And there are a lot of incredibly valid reasons why women are unsure or don't want children. And as you said previously, this wasn't a decision we were really allowed to make. It was just an expectation. Feminist leaders have fought for us to have the choice to not have children. And I very much don't take that for granted. And I think there are so many layers when it comes to motherhood and what's expected of us, the double standards for men and women when it comes to parenting, how much onus and responsibility is still placed more so on mothers, the lack of support within our culture that mothers have um sorry can you hear that in the background yeah what is that that someone gardening oh wow i love it i asked them to stop it's all right it's nice life continues you're right you're right continues through conversations yeah yes so yeah the lack of support that mothers have culturally how bloody expensive it is to be apparent that it's you know not even an accessible option for a lot of people anymore and also this this question of identity because I think I can't imagine how difficult it is to be a mother and not have that become the whole of your being and the whole of your identity and I think from my own perspective, I write about my mother who was just an absolute superhuman mum, just mothered on a level that was unbelievable, but that I recognize now having grown up looking back at her life, gave up just about everything else.

40:26And I do not want that for myself. I don't want that for other women. I want us to still be able to have identities and passions and projects and, you know, And so that, I think, is probably the main thing that still holds this question over my head of, do I want to be a mother? And I'm still not sure. And I don't land an answer either. I just kind of land a, I don't know, and maybe I will know soon. Yeah, but you asked your friend, your first, one of your school friends, didn't you? When she had her first child and she had that high flying job and she had a mortgage and a house in the suburbs.

41:10and what was her answer to the question you know why she said well it's just something to do isn't it for the next 20 years yeah I mean that's not a great sell is it and I get you know I I think that's essentially her saying this is the next stepping stone in the traditional life path um so that's why we're doing it but for me I need more than that I think, you know, it's maybe the biggest decision that a person ever makes. And I want to feel sure. And because of what you've been through, is there an innate fear that a child with two mums is going to face discrimination, that a child with a mum and dad isn't?

41:58Well, I think there's undeniably a possibility of that. And I think even just the process of having a child, obviously, is going to be far more complicated now with me being with a woman. It's not going to happen accidentally. I think if I'm being completely honest, I would definitely have deep fears about bringing a child of any gender into this world. For a girl, I would fear all the things that I personally have been through and written about in this book. and for a boy I would fear being able to raise a good boy and a good man I think that is a that is an incredible challenge in this day and age and you know if I had a child that was non-binary that's its whole own um thing like level of prejudice to deal with and so difficult in this culture and yeah I um that's adding to the hesitance hesitancy for sure do you know what I think that

42:59someone once said to me it's like watching your heart walking around in front of you about being a parent and it is an extraordinary type of love you know if you think about relationship to that word love being a parent is something else but my gosh it's infuriating but not in a kind of socio-political or value sense that just can be like not doing chores and not doing all that stuff. And the only thing is, is that, and I've got lots of it wrong, Megan, but you're just trying to be the least worst influence on them. Inevitably, things that are rubbish about you, they will pick up on because you can't hide it from them.

43:46You know, you just are what you are. But it is, I am, I insisted on a 30-second hug from my daughter the other day because I wanted the hug to be meaningful. And it got awkward for after about 15 seconds. But it was just the best hug in the world. Yeah, it's powerful. I mean, it is powerful without doubt. But it shouldn't be that a woman's worth or meaning is based on it. You know, my wife gave up 15 years of work, 15 years of career progression. to be a full-time mother. And that is not to devalue the worth of being a full-time mother and what she could give my children and the foundation and all that with them.

44:35And financially it would work better for me to work than her. Yeah, but that's difficult, you know, that sense that you're not... You can't be defined by it. And with you and your partner, if you do decide to become parents, it's so important to not lose yourselves in that. So what inevitably can happen is that you end up having a transactional relationship with your partner because it's based around essentially micromanaging two little people all the time. So you're just divvying up responsibilities. And at the end of each week, you're so exhausted. You haven't found any time for each other when ultimately it was your love for each other that created these two or one human in the first place by whatever means.

45:26Well, yeah, and that makes complete sense when you consider the idea that the nuclear family is quite a modern invention and we are meant to be raising kids in communities. And if we still did that, you know, you and your partner would have plenty more capacity and time for each other. To be fair, coming from Sri Lankan communities, if we were in Sri Lanka, it would have been done. Like there would have been uncles and aunties and even not related, everyone's called an uncle or an auntie, right? So there'd be all manner of people to do that. So look, what's next for you, Megan? Because this book you obviously want to do very well and you want as many people, especially middle-aged men, to read this book.

46:13I'm putting it out there, that that should be the main driver of sales, middle-aged men. around the world, this book. But what do you want for it? I think the answer to that is quite similar to what I wanted for my first book, which was, I want as many people as possible to read this so that they can feel seen and it can maybe help their healing along in some way. And I'm incredibly grateful that people tell me that the first book did that for them. And I think this second book, it is a continuation. I've gone from book number one, all about the body to book number two, beyond and expanding into all these other areas of life where we shrink ourselves.

46:51And I just, I want for people and yes, primarily women to read it and see themselves and see their experience and feel galvanized. I think at this point in time, that is what we desperately need. We need, we need to feel a sense of empowerment and a sense of resilience because we're up against it. And that goes not just for women, but for people of any marginalized group. We still need that hope and that reassurance that people get it and things can change and we are not powerless. So it's a lot of things that I want people to feel. But at the end of the day, if people read it and just feel seen, that's enough.

47:40I interviewed a man recently, Megan, called Omar El Akkad, who's written a book called One Day Everyone Will Have Always Been Against This. And I asked him about whenever he mentions Gaza and the atrocities that are taking place in Gaza, the tens of thousands of civilians who've died. that people will immediately say, well, what about the hostages? Or what about this? Or what about that? And he said to me, I've learned to understand that when someone says that to me, it's not because they want me to say, because he said it's a given that I want the hostages returned. It's a given that I want Israelis and Palestinians to live side by side.

48:28It's a given. They're not really asking about that. What they're trying to do is silence me. Similarly, I wonder, whenever there is someone who is advocating for body positivity, you will always hear a, what about obesity? What about health? Always. How do you react? And is there a similar kind of parallel between what Omar al-Aqad said and how you would react to those questions?

49:04there is absolutely a similarity in the intention of those responses we call it health policing or false health concern concern policing um and it does it does pop up every single time and um i don't entertain those discussions as much as i used to uh but for a long time i would come back and give these answers that as you said they don't necessarily even want they're just trying to shut down the conversation or say they disagree and that's a clickbait response that they've latched on to but in the question of of health and and body image and fat acceptance there is so much evidence that we that we don't see a lot of but it exists that the health is far far more complicated than size and weight and that alone health is holistic health includes mental health emotional health spiritual health and it has so many factors that go into it even someone's body size has so many factors uh genetic and you know and habitual um and x y and z there are so many factors that determine someone's body size and size is not an indicator of health by itself it's just not and I think another prong to that is even if someone is unhealthy even if someone is fat and unhealthy are they not deserving of being treated with respect because this is what fat acceptance and you know body positivity should also be aiming for it's treating everyone regardless of their body regardless of how they look, with respect and kindness and, you know, stopping the bullying and the shaming of people who exist in larger bodies.

50:55And health shouldn't actually be an indicator of someone's worth as a human being, because equally, the people who go around concern trolling fat people do not do the same to smokers or, you know, party animals, people who go out drinking people who have genuinely really unhealthy lifestyles they do not bring that same smoke to those people and i think that in itself is very telling but ultimately it is not concern it is simply saying i don't like the way you look i don't want to see it no you're wrong and it's dressed up as concern lastly let's talk about dancing sure let's talk about movement because Because size has an effect on how the freedom to move that we have as kids somehow becomes an image of just self-awareness, like hyper self-aware of every bit of your body and how it moves.

52:08and just tell me about reclaiming that freedom of movement and what effect that has had on you the ability to be able to dance again but i grew up incredibly active loved sports loved dancing running around all of it and as i entered the kind of pre-teen early teenage years my relationship with movement was completely tainted by diet culture and i started to believe that movement was purely about making my body smaller, sculpting, toning, burning off, you know, earning what I was going to eat. It was all a numbers game. And so I lost the joy and was so hyper aware of how I looked whenever I was doing anything.

52:54You know, I wouldn't want to do PE because what if I ran and then my stomach bounced as I ran and someone noticed? Or what if I sweat and then my makeup that I'd spent two hours putting on that morning, that's gone. So I removed myself from movement in order to protect my image and avoid that shame. And then at the same time was doing it obsessively, was obsessively exercising in order to make myself smaller, locked in a room by myself. That was my relationship with movement. There was no joy, just pressure and shame. when I started to heal from diet culture when I started to heal my relationship with my body I began to reclaim movement and I started really simply I started with going for a walk and allowing myself to be present and you know notice the beauty of my surroundings notice how it felt to breathe air into my lungs and have a rhythm with my feet on the ground and and really appreciate that and not stop to project onto you know people who walked past me not stop to think oh how do I look to them or how does my body look as I'm doing this really allow myself to be present and I built up that positive relationship to movement until I was able to reclaim things that I used to love so much as a kid like dance even like running which is wild because I never thought I would be able to reclaim running.

54:19And you're nursing a dance related injury, aren't you? I have, yes, fractured an ankle, unfortunately, through no fault of my own, because I was dancing so joyfully and enthusiastically. And that's what it is to me, it's just a pure embodied, joyful expression, get those endorphins. Also, it doesn't matter what you look like, how much you're sweating, whether you look different to everyone else in the class. You know, often I go to a dance class, I'm the fattest one there. And, you know, I've got hairy armpits and I'm wearing bright fluorescent workout gear and everyone else is dressed in black.

54:55But I'm probably having the best time because I am just embodied. I am present. I'm getting my endorphins. And that's what it should be about. Freedom. Absolutely. Hallelujah. Megan, lovely to see you. You as well. Thank you so much. Thank you so much for this conversation. Thank you for listening to today's conversation with Megan Jane Crabb. The book is out later this month. Let me know what you thought about today's show or indeed any other show in our extensive catalogue of extraordinary conversations. Nihal at bbc.co.uk if you still use email. And I'll see you soon.

55:41for support on topics covered in this program you can get details of organizations within the uk by visiting the bbc action line website bbc.co.uk slash action line on bbc sounds this is sports strangest crimes from the man who tried to buy crickets one night one game winner take all 20 US million dollars. The kidnap of a superhorse. It must have been terrifying. Of course it was. How we got through all the time. An ill-advised errand changing F1 forever. It will haunt the people involved for as long as they live. A trillion dollar takeover which never took off. Broadsters of this level, they will never stop.

56:22The mysterious death of a superstar cyclist. Entering the world of professional cycling was like joining the mafia. And teammates becoming bitter enemies at one of the biggest football clubs in the world. Betrayal. Plot. We've gone beyond women's football in France. Sports. Strangest crimes. Listen on BBC Sounds.

56:46Is World War II back up for debate? I'm Tristan Redmond, host of the Global Story podcast from the BBC. If you live in Europe or the US, the chances are you thought the rights and wrongs of World War II were mostly settled, which is why some of us were surprised to find out that the podcaster Tucker Carlson not only disagreed but he's been podcasting about it with a British politician. Today on the show we explore why. Listen to The Global Story on bbc.com or wherever you listen.

From the publisher

Writer and socal media star, Megan Jayne Crabbe, joins Nihal for an in-depth conversation.

More from Headliners with Nihal Arthanayake

All episodes