1. Podcasts
  2. Interesting Times
  3. Why Are We Having Less Sex? Ask a Pornographer.
Interesting Times

29 Oct 2026 · 50m · 19 chapters

Episode artwork

Why Are We Having Less Sex? Ask a Pornographer.

In short

Whether pornography can be ethical in the digital age—covering consent and labor standards, consumer responsibility, porn literacy/sex education, and risks when fantasy meets reality. The episode argues for “ethical porn” that centers women’s pleasure, fair pay, and transparent production practices, while criticizing algorithm-driven “tube site” porn focused on clicks and phallocentric narratives.

Guest backgrounds

Erica Lust (born Erica Hallquist), Swedish political science student turned adult filmmaker. She grew up in Sweden’s feminist/sex-education environment and became an “ethical pornographer” after feeling mainstream porn didn’t reflect women’s pleasure. She directs independent, narrative “boutique” films with mostly female and queer crews and runs ericalast.com via a subscriber-supported model.

Key claims

Ethical porn includes performer “Bill of Rights,” ongoing consent talks (including pleasure preferences), and post-shoot check-ins. Porn ethics also includes marketing/distribution/consumer choices. Porn doesn’t have “magical” power over behavior; the bigger issue is lack of sex education and media literacy.

Notable examples

Linda Williams’ book Hardcore; discussions of clitoral stimulation; critiques of mainstream porn and tech-controlled sites; references to the Cornell “Seven” case; her chapter on filming a gangbang after meeting performer Katsumi; Pompeii frescoes as a historical contrast.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

1:38

From Erika Hallquist to Erica Lust

Erica Lust shares her journey into the world of ethical pornography.

“And you're a great advocate for porn and for the cultural work that it can do.”
2:15

Understanding Ethical Pornography

Erica discusses the misconceptions about porn workers and the importance of representation.

“And then somehow they kind of end up in this industry.”
4:19

Behind the Scenes of Ethical Porn

Erica describes how she directs her films while ensuring performer consent and safety.

“and about how we relate to each other sexually.”
6:42

Performers' Rights and Communication

Erica explains the protocols in place to protect performers and promote open communication.

“You have a lot of protocols to ensure safety and consent and everything for everyone involved in your shoots.”
9:29

Ethics of Production and Consumption

Erica discusses the ethical implications of producing and consuming pornography.

“What distinguishes pornography from a project like, say, Euphoria, which is an HBO drama that incorporates a lot of explicit elements, but is certainly not classified as porn in genre terms.”
12:02

Representing Realism in Porn

Erica emphasizes the importance of realism in portraying female pleasure in porn.

“But the way we make this work is through our audience.”
14:00

Feminism and Porn: A Complex Relationship

Explore the intersection of feminism and pornography, focusing on representation and agency.

“It looks and feels very fake what is happening.”
18:02

The Landscape of Non-Feminist Pornography

Discuss the characteristics and implications of mainstream pornography and its patriarchal influences.

“Because obviously, I am also a product of this world we live in.”
23:14

Cultural Conditioning of Desires

Investigate the societal constructs that shape our desires and the perceived shame around them.

“And sometimes what we see is how that conversation changes.”
28:14

The Cornell Seven and Its Implications

Discussion on the Cornell Seven case and its connection to pornographic scenarios.

“We're recording this conversation in the midst of a pretty big story here in the U.S.”
Show all 19 chapters
28:59

The Need for Comprehensive Sex Education

Exploring the gaps in U.S. sex education and advocating for broader topics.

“And obviously, some of these stories are also portrayed in porn.”
30:19

Incorporating Media Literacy in Sex Ed

The importance of teaching porn literacy and addressing gender identity.

“What do you think sex education should encompass?”
32:17

Challenging Myths about Gangbangs

Discussing the stigma around gangbangs and personal revelations about consent.

“So a sex ed curriculum for you would certainly include porn literacy and also...”
34:06

Understanding Risk and Sexual Freedom

Exploring the risks associated with sexual freedom and societal stigma.

“a closed course and do not attempt unless you really, really want to, and you're going to be really careful or something like that.”
36:48

Female Pleasure and Societal Expectations

Examining the conversation around female pleasure and societal pressures.

“I mean, I think many of the stigmas we have, they come from this kind of situations from the past where a woman feel that she's in a risky situation.”
39:38

Impact of Technology on Sexual Connections

Discussing how technology affects intimacy and sexual relationships.

“also the whole sex act is focused on pleasing their men instead of really having a life fulfilling moment.”
42:13

The Impact of Porn on Sexual Connection

Explore how anxiety and fear affect people's ability to connect sexually.

“They are scared that it's going to go wrong somehow.”
45:56

Exploring the Relationship Between Porn and Satisfaction

Discuss whether porn consumption affects sexual satisfaction and perception.

“But I guess I wonder whether too much exploration can make sex actually less enjoyable.”
48:24

Navigating Shame and Values in Porn Consumption

Address the complexities of shame, values, and personal preferences regarding porn.

“I feel that first of all, it's a question also what kind of porn are you watching?”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On Interesting Times, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00Erika Lust: You're on a job, in a meeting, slammed, and a customer calls. If nobody picks up, they go to your competitor. That's why over 90 ,000 companies choose Quo, the business phone system built for busy teams. Try it free at Quo.com slash NYT. Smart call routing sends calls to the right person. Shared numbers let your team cover for each other. And an AI agent picks up when nobody can, capturing every lead so nothing falls through the cracks. Money is on the line. Always say hello with Quo.

0:32Julia Yost: I would ask people, you know, when they consume porn, don't do it from their online free platforms.

0:41Erika Lust: Don't do it. Yeah, no, support your local pornographer, absolutely. Exactly.

0:52Erika Lust: From New York Times Opinion, I'm Julia Yost, guest hosting for Interesting Times. Pornography use has skyrocketed in the digital age. And as Americans watch sex more than ever, they're having it less. Celibacy is all the rage these days. Nearly half of young people aren't having sex. They haven't had sex in the last year. That's crazy. Because if you can click your way to sexual satisfaction, who needs other people? My guest today is Erica Lust, a self-described ethical pornographer. She makes porn that is cinematic and socially progressive and that caters to women's fantasies rather than men's.

1:28Erika Lust: Can she redeem pornography in the digital age? Is porn even worth saving? Erica Lust, welcome to Interesting Times. You're the first pornographer I've ever met. Oh. As far as I know. And you're a great advocate for porn and for the cultural work that it can do. I am not, to be clear. Nonetheless, I think we can find some common ground. So tell me, how did Erika Hallquist, a good girl from Sweden, become Erika Lust, world-renowned adult filmmaker?

2:05Julia Yost: Well, you know, it is a long story. I try to tell it in the book, obviously, that has just come out here in the U.S. And it's an expected story, I think, from many people, because I think that most of us think that people who are working in porn are doing it because they come from poor circumstances. They had no other choice. And then somehow they kind of end up in this industry. Well, I studied political science in Sweden. I grew up in Sweden, you know, one of the countries in this world with a feminist background, with sex education. So we have a tradition of being a country that is a little bit more sexual liberated.

2:51Julia Yost: When I grew up and I started to kind of get in contact with my sexuality, I wanted to figure out more about myself. I watched porn you know back then it was a whole different situation because we didn't have access to the internet that young people have access to today and then what I felt was that there was this discrepancy in my body kind of my body got turned on by looking at these images but at the same time I felt conflict. I felt that something was not working for me. It felt like the women was mostly there to please the men, but it wasn't really their stories. And I asked myself, why is it this way?

3:44Julia Yost: Can it be different? Does another kind of porn exist? And when I started to talk to people and Search for some things on that early internet. And I found a book by a wonderful film professor from Berkeley, Linda Williams, called Hardcore. And that book really changed my mind about pornography. because through that book, I realized that pornography is not just porn. It's more than that. It's a discourse about sexuality and about gender and about how we relate to each other sexually.

4:24Erika Lust: Walk me through a day on set without getting too explicit. How do you direct people to have sex?

4:31Julia Yost: What I'm doing is independent filmmaking. So I shoot with crews, mostly female and queer crews. We are sometimes 50 people behind the camera. They are films that have been developed, that have characters. They have a narrative. They have a visual style to it. But then I guess that most people, what they are curious about is how do you work with performers? How does this really, really work? Do you put them at risk? Do they have a say? And I can tell you that what we do is that we talk all the time to performers, the production team, the talent managers. They talk to performers to get to know them, to see who they are, what they like and what they don't like.

5:24Julia Yost: But then when they get casted for a film, we really talk through in detail everything about the film and about how they feel. What do they want to do with these characters? How do we develop that whole sexual tension and situation together? And we don't only talk about their boundaries and things that they don't want to do, which is obviously something we do talk about. But we also talk a lot about the pleasure side of sex. What do they like? How do they like to get touched? We get into detail here. What is the easiest way to make them come? Can we make it happen really on camera? And then when we actually shoot this, we do the sex talk again in the morning.

6:14Julia Yost: And when we arrive to the set, we look at different angles. Here we also get the technical crew involved, our DOP and the camera operators. And then we look at it from a more cinematic angle also. Where do we have the good light? What kind of positions would work in this scenario? That everything around feels great for everyone.

6:42Erika Lust: You have a lot of protocols to ensure safety and consent and everything for everyone involved in your shoots. Can you describe those?

6:51Julia Yost: Well, we have something that we call the Bill of Rights. That every performer gets to see and to read and to sign before a shoot. So we agree on how the process is going to work out. And also so we both understand our responsibilities. Because when you come in as a performer, it's also very important that you are aware that if anything doesn't feel right, you need to voice that. But to be able to voice that, I think it's important that they really feel that they are in an ambient where they can speak up and they're not going to get punished for it.

7:34Erika Lust: I wanted to ask about that because it strikes me that these are not normal labor practices. When you talk about your performers, your emphasis is always on the way in which they're expressing themselves, they're finding themselves, they're connecting with each other and then sharing that with viewers. but then you also need to follow up with them after the shoot and make sure they're okay. I wanted to ask, what do you feel that you're protecting them from?

7:59Julia Yost: It's being a support to make sure that afterwards they don't have second thoughts or other feelings Because when you are on set, that is also somehow an euphoric experience. You know, you come in, you are being taken care of, you feel like a star for that day. So many things are happening or going on. So many decisions are being made. And what I really want to do is to check in afterwards if they have any second thoughts about anything that could have happened.

8:39Erika Lust: Yeah, so if someone does have second thoughts, what does that tend to look like? I mean, what kind of ambivalence or distress are they expressing to you and how do you handle that?

8:50Julia Yost: Well, I haven't had that kind of situation where someone has said, oh, it didn't feel good at all. But I have had small comments on certain situations. There might have been someone spanking someone on an ass and then, you know, a performer saying, hey, Erica, I've been thinking and I don't want that part to be part of the film, for example. This is the kind of conversations that we are having afterwards.

9:29Erika Lust: What distinguishes pornography from a project like, say, Euphoria, which is an HBO drama that incorporates a lot of explicit elements, but is certainly not classified as porn in genre terms. And you're always emphasizing the sort of cinematic and narrative elements of your work. And you describe it as boutique, but you're not trying to shed the porn label. In fact, you embrace it. So to you, what is it that makes your work porn?

9:59Julia Yost: Because I'm interested in exciting you. That's part of the work. I'm interested in finding these erotic narratives, these stories, taking you as the audience on kind of an erotic journey. and when you talk about the series like Euphoria which I couldn't see the last season myself because I'm very sensitive to violence and from what I've seen from the trailers it felt too violent to me but the idea behind it is not to excite you.

10:38Erika Lust: So your project is not just aesthetic it's also moral or ethical. You've been called the queen of ethical porn So explain ethical porn.

10:47Julia Yost: Well, you know, always when we talk about ethical, it becomes very complicated because what I'm really talking about when we say ethical porn is about the working conditions, the working standards, the whole process. How do we put it in practice? That's the main goal of talking about ethical porn. But I also think that it extends. I think that we have also to think about how do we market it, how do we distribute it, and how do we consume it. I think the whole ethical aspect also enters for consumers. Because for me, it's essential that people understand that to make great pornography, it has a cost.

11:38Julia Yost: You have to pay people a fair salary, crew and performers and staff, obviously. And to do that, we need a budget. And to be able to have support of that budget, you need to find a system that works. I'm an independent production company owned by me and my husband. There are no big investors. There are nobody else in this. But the way we make this work is through our audience. is through our community of subscribers, our online cinema streaming platform, ericalast.com. And they are the ones that are supporting the way we can actually make these films. So I would ask people, you know, when they consume porn, don't do it from the online free platforms.

12:32Erika Lust: Don't do it. Yeah, no, support your local pornographer. Absolutely. Exactly.

12:37Julia Yost: think the same way as you're thinking about, you know, food or restaurants or fair trade or clothes or, you know, we should all be more responsible consumers here. And we need to understand that as consumers, we have a great deal of power. We do. People and big industries and businesses, they see where you click and how much time you spend on something. So you actually vote by, you know, spending your time online on certain sites. I, you know, really would like to ask people to think twice and look for independent, independent pornography.

13:25Erika Lust: Could you talk about realism as an aspect of your pornographic ethics? Realism? Yeah, it seems to me that you're very interested in being realistic about sort of the mechanics of female pleasure.

13:40Julia Yost: I am, definitely. I want it to feel real to my audience. I want my audience to feel that we are representing sex the way that they can find pleasure in real life. Because this is also something that has upset me when I, you know, have watched what we call mainstream porn, that normally women are not portrayed in a realistic sexual context. It looks and feels very fake what is happening. And here I'm especially thinking about clitoral stimulation, that most women need to be able to come. Can we say this? Can we say clitoral stimulation?

14:35Erika Lust: We may get an explicit label, but we can say it. And so you would consider your style of porn feminist? That's part of your ethics?

14:46Julia Yost: I consider myself a feminist. Okay. And I make porn. That's how I would put it.

14:54Erika Lust: And so what does feminism mean for you in the context of porn?

14:59Julia Yost: So in the context of porn, I would go to two things. Participation behind the camera. Who's making this film? Who's in the process? Who has the right to make decisions, really? And then I would talk about representation. What do we see on screen? How are not only women, obviously, how is gender portrayed? Do we see different kind of power relations that the films are helping us to understand who is who and how are they negotiating. Because I feel that many times in regular mainstream kind of pornography, that conversation is happening outside the camera. It's not happening in the film. But I know from experience and from working with many performers that this is standard in the industry, in the adult industry today.

16:06Julia Yost: it's standard to have all these negotiations. So even if you don't see it in the scene, it probably happened before. But I think it really can help the audience if they get to see it on screen.

16:21Erika Lust: Yeah, so you really emphasize character and narrative and context and all these forms of complexity. I'm listening to you talk and thinking, wow, she makes porn sound like a George Eliot novel. But your account of porn's positive work is not universally accepted by feminists. So in the 70s and 80s, Andrea Dworkin argued that pornography inherently subjugated women, like other forms of sex work. Pornography is a system of sexual exploitation in which women are devalued. Women are turned into commodities. Women are sold as meat. Women are, in fact, tortured. Pornography creates both physical aggression towards women and attitudes and behaviors of discrimination.

17:12Erika Lust: And it makes every struggle that we have towards civil equality essentially ridiculous. So why should women embrace porn and sex work broadly?

17:24Julia Yost: Well, you know, there's many types of feminism at the same time as there's many kinds of porn, obviously. And we have a part of the feminist movement that believes that there could never exist a fair feminist kind of pornography, obviously. I don't agree with them. I obviously think that we as women have the right to our pleasure, to our sexuality. And we need space to try out things and to get into our own fantasies and desire and kind of revise them. Because obviously, I am also a product of this world we live in. I'm a product of this patriarchy. And my fantasies are not only my fantasies, but they are a construct of what I have learned in this society since I was a little girl.

18:35Julia Yost: And pornography is helping us to get rid of that sexual shame that so many of us somehow feel.

18:47Erika Lust: So far, we've been focusing on your work and sort of talking around the other world of porn out there, the type that floods the Internet. What is the non-feminist pornography that you are working against?

19:02Julia Yost: It's almost everything that's out there. It's lots of people, creators who have no interest really in how to show female pleasure on screen, but are more interested in the business of pornography. They're interested not that much in the actual sex, but in the clicks and in the algorithms. And what I've seen is a business that has been taken over by many of these tech guys. If we look back at the 60s and the 70s and where, you know, we had this golden era of porn and the porn was even in the theaters. And many of the creators back then, they were filmmakers, they were artists, they were people who had a vision and who wanted, you know, who had this reaction to a conservative world that they lived in back then and wanted to show a more liberated sexuality.

20:13Julia Yost: But then as society advanced, we get into the videocassette era and then to the beginning of the Internet and this pay site that we had and the photo archives with images that you could slowly download. And then we get to the era we now live in with the tube sites taking over. And here is where really these tech guys comes in. They are not that interested in the sex anymore, but rather in the technology of it.

20:53Erika Lust: So what kind of porn do those sites tend to host? I mean, what are the sort of mechanics of it? What's the style of it? Is it kind of substantively misogynistic?

21:04Julia Yost: It's phallocentric. I would use that as the first way of describing it. It's about men and their sexuality. And women are many, many times reduced to some kind of object in that sexuality. But it's not really their stories.

21:26Erika Lust: Now, there's a big audience, Shirley, for this misogynistic porn, which you critique. Is there something wrong with the millions of men who are using it to fantasize? I mean, you say that women have a right to their desires, including desires that have been shaped by the patriarchy. Do men not?

21:50Julia Yost: No, of course, they also have a right to fantasizing and desire. But I think we have to think, how should I put it? But it's a job each of us have to kind of to understand what we are desiring and what we are fantasizing about and how it affects us in our life. But I also think it's very important that we understand that we are cultural products. We are socialized with the general ideas that we have as human beings. And if we understand those and we criticize them and we think about them, we are also able to change. So I think sometimes men haven't even realized that what they are attracted to in some sexual circumstances is this misogynistic concept.

23:03Erika Lust: What if a woman were attracted to a misogynistic concept? Well, they are.

23:08Julia Yost: Many, many, many women are. We all are. but we have to be able to explore it and to think about it and then when it comes to porn it's also interesting how we all have this kind of personal relationship to it to what we enjoy when nobody watches us and then how we talk about it when we're in front of other people, when we are in contact with other people. And sometimes what we see is how that conversation changes. How does it change as a role? It changes in the sense that we feel that what we like is shameful and is something that we shouldn't like. And then when we talk about it to other people, we don't recognize what actually turns us on.

24:16Erika Lust: Where does it come from, that idea that what we like is shameful, that our desires are shameful? What's your sense of that?

24:24Julia Yost: I mean, it has a long tradition. We can go back many, many years in history. And what we see is there is a change from Roman culture to Christian culture, where we start seeing how the church somehow is dividing all these goddesses that we had in the past that was representing so many things. Power, goddesses, women who were representing power, representing fertility, representing sexuality. And then when we get into this moment of history, they are being divided into different roles. So suddenly, we have the whore on the one side, and we have the respectable mother figure, Maria, the saint, on the other side.

25:29Erika Lust: Yeah, my understanding of the scholarship around the transition from pre-Christian to Christian Rome is that Christianity was the force that accorded rights to women in the domain of sex and marriage and also basically said, hands off the little boys. So, I mean, I was struck by that moment in your book where you described going to, I think it was Pompeii. Yes. And you saw the frescoes and there was... The erect penises.

25:56Julia Yost: Yes, exactly.

25:58Erika Lust: And, you know, I don't know, orgies or whatever just depicted on walls. And that you felt that was a very kind of liberating moment. And you thought, yes, there was a time when sex was just so elaborately incorporated into art and it was out in the open and it was it was not it was not consigned to the red light district. It's just, you know, in people's dining rooms or whatever. and I thought, yeah, but I think that was part of a sexual dispensation that was actually quite cruel to both women and children. I'm not sure you really want to live in Pompeii before the volcano.

26:32Julia Yost: I would rather live in today than in any period of the past.

27:05Erika Lust: I'm your host. learn, listen, and be inspired. Listen to new episodes Mondays through Fridays at 7 p.m. on 98.7 FM, WFMT.com, and the WFMT app.

27:20Julia Yost: 75 % of women who seek menopause care don't receive it. The lying awake at 3 a.m. wondering what's happening to your body ends now. Midi is virtual care built for women in perimenopause and menopause with clinicians who specialize in women's health. Plus, it's covered by most major insurances. Getting started is easy. You can book your first visit with a clinician right away. Midlife needs MIDI. Visit JoinMIDI.com to book your first visit today. That's JoinMIDI.com. Insurance coverage varies. Check with your plan for coverage. This podcast is supported by Sattva. Have a big day coming up? Remember, tomorrow starts tonight with the restorative sleep you need to perform at your best.

28:00Erika Lust: the kind every Satva mattress is designed for. So whether it's a new job, a marathon, or an important presentation, Satva helps you be the best version of you. Visit Satva.com. That's S-A-A-T-V-A dot com. We're recording this conversation in the midst of a pretty big story here in the U.S. I'm not sure if you've been following the story of the Cornell Seven. So seven young men are accused of sexually assaulting a young woman in the context of group sex under the influence of drugs and alcohol on a college campus. And I was thinking about this story as I read your book and wondering whether the students had drawn on some scenario they had picked up from porn, a gangbang scenario.

28:46Erika Lust: So I want to ask you, when pornographic fantasy meets reality, as it will sometimes do, is there potential for risk or danger?

28:58Julia Yost: Look, so what we see in cinema, we see it in film, we see it in video games, we heard it, we read it in books. And obviously, some of these stories are also portrayed in porn. But I don't think that porn has this kind of magical power that is so much bigger than other medias in influencing people in doing exact acts. What I see is a huge lack of sex education. I see a huge lack of conversation around sex and around consent and respecting women. And I think that those conversations and that sex education is what we really, really need now to focus on. We cannot continue censoring voices who are speaking about eroticism and who are speaking about sexuality.

30:06Julia Yost: We cannot censure books in school. We cannot cut sex education programs when it's so clearly seen that it's needed.

30:18Erika Lust: So this is interesting. What do you think sex education should encompass? Because in the United States, it tends to be, you know, how not to get pregnant, how not to get an STD. I guess we're calling them STIs now. That's the basics. That's the basics. That's the absolute basics. But you are, you come from, you had the Nordic model growing up. So, and that's much more extensive. So what would you have? What would you have children learning? And I guess from what age?

30:48Julia Yost: Right from the beginning. For me, it's not one sex conversation that you have to have when suddenly you're - So we're talking first grade. Your kid is, yes. We're talking parents who needs to be part of this from the beginning. I think we need to be more natural with conversations around sex. You know, people are discovering their bodies from a very young age. And what we are doing is giving them messages. And sometimes if we don't give them vocabulary, they don't even know how to name their sexual organs. And I think that this conversation, if we don't have it with them, what we are doing is sending them directly into trouble.

31:48Erika Lust: Yeah, they'll learn it from Pornhub or whatever.

31:51Julia Yost: Well, they learn it from all over our society. They might learn it some from Pornhub, others might learn it from euphoria. We have to be aware of the importance in today's society of being media literate, of being porn literate, of being able to think critically of anything you read or see. I mean, we all know that on socials, there are messages being passed on to our kids and teens and young adults and adults all the time.

32:32Erika Lust: So a sex ed curriculum for you would certainly include porn literacy and also... Gender identity questions. Okay, gender identity. So kids sort of being asked about their pronouns every week, because you get that in some of the kind of tonier schools.

32:49Julia Yost: It's not that they have to be asked every week about their pronouns. But what we need to be able to do is to stop this heteronormative culture that we have. We need to enter a queer perspective into all sex education. We need to make people feel that they have a right over their bodies and their identities and that they can safely express that and being respected and that they can get an inclusive, diverse sex education. education without having this very heteronormative perspective that still is the most powerful that we see in sex education in most countries.

33:45Erika Lust: To return us to the Cornell case, the question about fantasy versus reality, I think you're proposing a pretty sturdy wall. It's a pretty sturdy border between those two. So for you, it's just kind of, okay, porn is porn. And remember, these are trained professionals on a closed course and do not attempt unless you really, really want to, and you're going to be really careful or something like that. But one of the reasons I wanted to bring up the Cornell case is because gangbangs feature prominently in your new book. The first chapter is titled, Does Every Woman Deserve a Gang Bang? And in it, you write about overcoming your discomfort with gang bangs in order to film one.

34:31Erika Lust: So why was it important for you to push past that discomfort and make that film?

34:36Julia Yost: Because I had, like so many people, this idea that we are talking about that a gangbang is a situation where a group of men are preying on a woman. And then I met a performer, an actor, Katsumi, and the meeting with her, we were talking about making a potential film together in a first kind of meeting. And I had maybe more romantic ideas for this film. But then when we started to talk about what she really liked and what she wanted to do, this idea of her wanting to do a gangbang with five men came up time after time after time. So I had to challenge my own prejudices. And then when she started to explain how she felt about it, and she told me real life stories of her life outside the film, outside the adult industry, situations that she had had.

35:56Julia Yost: And she told me about all the fun and how it made her feel in the center of so much attention and so much care that suddenly it really opened up my mind.

36:14Erika Lust: You write, a woman enjoying sex with multiple men on her own terms for her own gratification is the ultimate anti-patriarchal sex fantasy. No wonder it's taboo. And so that's kind of the understanding of the gangbang that you finally reached. But I do wonder whether that taboo and perhaps also your discomfort arose in part from an intuition that was arguably vindicated by the Cornell case, namely that one woman having sex with multiple men is objectively a risky situation. And so I wonder whether some stigmas on sex may exist for good reason, because the activities that are stigmatized are intrinsically risky.

37:01Julia Yost: I mean, I think many of the stigmas we have, they come from this kind of situations from the past where a woman feel that she's in a risky situation. walking through a park during night, I would feel that that's a risky situation. It's a situation where, you know, when many women would get their keys in their hands. But also, if we don't face some of these risky situations, then we are, we don't have the same, right? The same opportunities, the same possibilities. So every woman does deserve a gangbang is what I'm getting from you. To live, to feel. I think that this was also something that was in Vigini Despont's book, The King Kong Theory, where she talks a lot about this idea of even if there's risk going out into the world and experience and take up space and learn on the way.

38:12Julia Yost: Sure.

38:13Erika Lust: Your advocacy of porn seems to presume that we live in a patriarchy in which girls and women are taught to feel shame about their bodies and desires and that demonizing pornography is an extension of that. But is this true? It seems to me that most of the messaging to girls and women is sex positive. And pornography certainly has been normalized to the extent that it's been widely adopted. So who needs to hear the good news of sexual liberation?

38:48Julia Yost: Well, I don't agree. Sex positive messages, yes, some of them we have. Empowerment messages, yes, some of them are out there. But at the same time, I still see so many women worrying about their own sexuality, about what they project to the world, how they are dressing, what kind of sex they want to have, what kind of sex they accept having. I hear still so many stories of women being in sexual relationships where they are with especially with heterosexual men where there's not only the orgasm gap really, really happening, but also the whole sex act is focused on pleasing their men instead of really having a life fulfilling moment.

39:53Julia Yost: themselves. And then when I talk to them and they describe how they are having sex by themselves, it's a whole different story.

40:03Erika Lust: So do you think there's too much reticence around the question of sort of the mechanics of female pleasure? People don't talk enough about that?

40:13Julia Yost: I mean, people talk about it but i think they could still talk lots more about it and it's also different in different generations and what i'm hearing a lot lately is people stuck on social media stuck on their cell phones connecting much less with people we hear reports about young people not having as much sex anymore. We hear reports about the AI girlfriends. That seems easier for some young men to connect to, to real people. I mean, sex involves intimacy. It involves negotiation. It involves friction. It involves difficult conversations sometimes. Yeah.

41:11Erika Lust: So we're talking about, I guess, what I'll call in-person sex. Whereas, you know, porn is other people's sex that you're watching. And so I think that for you, porn can facilitate in-person sex or can foster connections between flesh and blood human beings who watch it. But I wonder whether that's universally the case. So do you see the abundance of porn on the internet as contributing to the problem of the decline of sex?

41:45Julia Yost: I think it starts with that people have anxieties about sex, fear, shame, difficulties to connect to other people. I think that technology really have worsened this situation because we have less interaction with real people and people are afraid of getting humiliated somehow through connecting, through getting not accepted by a potential partner or not knowing how to reach out. They are scared that it's going to go wrong somehow. And I think that all this kind of anxiety has led to that many people have an easier time fulfilling their sexual needs watching porn online than connecting with other people.

42:46Erika Lust: So it's kind of old fashioned shame at Baden. That's the issue. Okay. So you don't see the availability of porn as a replacement for actual partners?

43:00Julia Yost: I don't think it is. I honestly don't think it is. But it's, I mean, you want to connect with someone. No, I agree. You want to be in the same room.

43:09Erika Lust: I'm with you.

43:10Julia Yost: You want the bodies to be active in this.

43:13Erika Lust: I'm completely with you, but not everybody's with us on that.

43:17Julia Yost: But I think they are fearing it. I don't know if it's that they don't want it or that the fear is so big and they have so little knowledge in how to connect to others.

43:34Erika Lust: Oh, I think the revealed preferences are that people, a lot of people do actually prefer to have perfect control over their sexual experiences, which they can get with whatever, a vibrator and a porn hub, whatever. I don't know.

43:51Julia Yost: it's hard it's hard to ask another person right it's hard to ask it for what you want and here we get to the point again where so many people they don't even know what they want they don't know what they want sex education here we go sex education we need sex education

44:21Erika Lust: This message comes from Betterment. Betterment's Dan Egan talks about tax loss harvesting. Tax loss harvesting is a tax management strategy. When you have a position that's gone down over time, we intentionally sell out of it to realize a loss,

44:36Julia Yost: which we then say to the IRS, hey, we lost money. You get to use that to offset your ordinary income every year, decreasing your tax burden.

44:43Erika Lust: Investing involves risk. Performance not guaranteed. Betterment does not offer tax advice. TLH may not be suitable for all customers. Learn more at betterment.com slash TLH-terms. AI isn't just opening new business opportunities. It's changing the way businesses get work done. The questions they ask, the decisions they make, and the routine tasks they can hand off. And nobody understands that better than NetSuite. That's why they put together a free expert guide you need to grab today. Aligning for the agentic era, how AI is changing everyday work. Download it and you'll see exactly how AI is reshaping work across every part of your organization.

45:16Erika Lust: And how to make sure you come out ahead. Get your free guide at netsuite.com slash NYT. netsuite.com slash NYT. 33 presidents. I called the president at 430 in the morning and he answered. Seven decades in space. We want to see what's beyond the next star. 60 super sundaes. They were probably the best team in the league every single year. 53 ,500 puzzles.

45:38Julia Yost: I use a different starting word every day.

45:40Erika Lust: 25 ,000 recipes.

45:42Julia Yost: And I love a one pan recipe because I don't love washing pans.

45:45Erika Lust: The New York Times, celebrating 175 years of helping you understand the world. Subscribe now for a special offer at nytimes.com slash subscribe. But I guess I wonder whether too much exploration can make sex actually less enjoyable. So there's a recent survey that was written up in The Atlantic that found that married, church-going Americans have the most sex of any demographic group in the country. So it would seem that the most vanilla people have the hottest sex lives. Explain that to me. Maybe it's the connection after church on Sunday. Maybe. But I just wonder about the relation of porn to satisfaction.

46:29Erika Lust: Is it possible that people who spend a lot of time watching other people have sex and thinking about the kinds of sex they could be having but probably aren't, could they be more prone to sexual dissatisfaction?

46:48Julia Yost: I mean, here it's also a question, how much porn are we really watching? Because this is also an interesting subject, because many people who consider themselves being porn addicts, actually, when they look at the numbers, how much porn they're watching, they watch much less porn than people who don't consider themselves being porn. addicts. And there's this idea, the moral incongruence idea.

47:19Erika Lust: So, yeah, the funny thing about that, though, is that, I don't know, to me, that doesn't undermine their position. It's just a description of their struggle, right? Because if you're a person who doesn't want to be using porn, you have some kind of objection to it. Maybe it's religious. Maybe it's not religious. Maybe you just want to practice more kind of temperance in your life or discipline or whatever, or you find it's getting in the way of your finding other people to connect with, whatever. But you don't want to be using porn. You're going to try not to use it. You will probably use less of it.

47:51Erika Lust: But to the extent that you do use it, it's because you feel compelled. You feel like you have a compulsion. I think that's where the language of compulsion and addiction comes from, the sense that people, they feel sort of captured by porn. They feel that they cannot quit it, even though they want to. And I did want to ask you about people like that. What would you say to them? Is their job simply to put away their shame? Or could there be a way in which their desire to be rid of porn is valid?

48:23Julia Yost: I think you have to find a balance that works for you in your own life. I feel that first of all, it's a question also what kind of porn are you watching? I mean, I would like to watch porn that I feel represents my value and I would not connect to a kind of pornography that I feel is not representing me. For me, it's important to use this moment as a connection with my own erotic self. It's almost kind of a moment of erotic mindfulness somehow. You're a virtuoso of porn. I think that for most people, it's not a mindfulness moment, probably. The porn that I watch, the porn I make, the porn that I'm in contact with.

49:27Julia Yost: Sure. It's so great. It's so beautiful. So it's true that I live in a bubble of sex positivity and people who are wanting to explore their identity through this kind of pornography.

49:54Erika Lust: But I just repeatedly hear you describing the psychology of that, that refusal, as arising from shame, that everybody has shame over their bodies, shame over their desires. They think sex is dirty and we have to use sex education and whatnot to kind of train people out of that. I have to say that that does not ring true to me. um my social and professional networks are very conservative on sex and the idea of shame about desire and um sex being dirty those are not sentiments that i would attribute to anyone i

50:34Julia Yost: know seriously oh no no you don't feel that people are are are thinking i think that they

50:42Erika Lust: agree with you that sex is extremely important and meaningful. Yes. And they take that insight in a different direction. They say because of that, you know, we honor it by putting certain parameters on it, which not everybody needs to accept, obviously. It's a free society. But that I think that is the logic. I would say that is my logic. That's the logic of pretty much everyone I know. If they do think that sex is shameful, they're not saying it out loud. so they're ashamed of the idea that they think sex is shameful but i think that that is happening

51:16Julia Yost: i think that that is also happening that's what is that some people uh think that they don't want to say that they think that sex is shameful they want openly in a conversation they want to be open and liberal and make other people feel that they are not judging anyone?

51:43Erika Lust: Yeah. Sure. I mean, I'm talking about people who tend to have, you know, five or more kids. So they're definitely having sex. Right. So they're definitely not inhibited from it in their own lives. Yeah. I mean, I think one thing I would suggest is that America's favorite ice cream flavor is vanilla. And so you could say it's a good flavor.

52:05Julia Yost: It's a great flavor. Why not?

52:06Erika Lust: Why not? You could one could say that in a patriarchy, death by chocolate is taboo because people think that cocoa powder is dirty. But then you would just get a lot of American women saying, no, thank you. I'm just a vanilla gal. It's not that there's a, you know, a fear of porn. There's often just a kind of thing like it's private like my finances are private um sex is private for reasons that don't have to do with um it's intrinsically shameful nature which i just don't think that all that many people believe in anymore um and so it just comes down to you know how you how you want to play it and that often implicates um values but i don't think that the values are this kind of patriarchal, misogynistic thing that I feel like it is your mission to oppose.

53:01Julia Yost: I don't want to push porn on anyone. Oh, no. Agreed. Agreed. If you don't want to watch it, I think that's fantastic. No, certainly. I don't take you to be saying that. What I do want is to offer an alternative for people who felt that we couldn't find the kind of pornography that we wanted to watch. And I think that we are quite many people feeling that way.

53:28Erika Lust: Well, this has been fascinating. Erika Lust, it's been a pleasure. Thank you very much.

53:40Thank you.

54:07Erika Lust: the agentic era, how AI is changing everyday work. Download it and you'll see exactly how AI is reshaping work across every part of your organization and how to make sure you come out ahead. Get your free guide at netsuite.com slash NYT netsuite.com slash NYT.

From the publisher

Pornography gets the blame for a lot of societal problems, including the so-called “sex recession.” Can porn ever really be ethical? Erika Lust thinks so. The adult filmmaker sees porn as an art form. She’s a self-described feminist who centers women’s desires and fantasies in her work. But how different is the product she’s making?

Lust sits down with Julia Yost, senior editor at “First Things,” to make the case for porn. Together, they discuss the adult film industry, stigmas around sex and translating fantasy into reality.

Note: As we work on relaunching “Interesting Times,” the show will feature a series of guest hosts in the coming months.

  • 00:00 - Intro
  • 01:22 - How Erika Became a Pornographer
  • 03:51 - Behind the Scenes of an Adult Film
  • 08:07 - The Relationship With Performers
  • 08:55 - Porn vs. “Euphoria”
  • 10:16 - Ethical Porn
  • 13:00 - Accurately Depicting Female Pleasure
  • 14:22 - Making Porn as a Feminist
  • 16:03 - Andrea Dworkin and the Anti-Porn Feminist Movement
  • 19:06 - “The Golden Era of Porn”
  • 20:55 - Fantasizing Under The Patriarchy
  • 24:01 - Sexuality In Ancient Rome
  • 26:15 - The Cornell Seven and Sexual Risk
  • 34:30 - Why We Need Stigmas
  • 40:55 - Is Porn Causing the Sex Recession?
  • 42:23 - “The Most Vanilla People Have the Hottest Sex Lives”
  • 43:23 - Porn Addiction and Compulsive Behavior
  • 46:44 - Religious Conservatives Aren’t Ashamed of Sex

(A full transcript of this episode is available on the Times website.)

Thoughts? Email us at [email protected]. Please subscribe to our YouTube Channel, Interesting Times.

Subscribe today at nytimes.com/podcasts or on Apple Podcasts, Spotify and Amazon Music. You can also subscribe via your favorite podcast app here https://www.nytimes.com/activate-access/audio?source=podcatcher. For more podcasts and narrated articles, download The New York Times app at nytimes.com/app.


Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.

More from Interesting Times

All episodes