1. Podcasts
  2. Interesting Times
  3. That Daily Brain Rot Break Is Taking Us Back to the Dark Ages
Interesting Times

8 Oct 2026 · 49m · 19 chapters

Episode artwork

That Daily Brain Rot Break Is Taking Us Back to the Dark Ages

In short

Declining long-form reading and rising short-form video (“TikTok”) are shifting culture from text-based literacy to image-based “post-literacy,” with consequences for attention, education, and democratic politics—potentially enabling more tribal, mystical, and autocratic leadership.

Guests

James Marriott, author/scholar arguing for “New Dark Ages” and linking literacy to democracy; Mary Harrington, guest host from New York Times Opinion.

Key claims

Leisure reading fell about 40% in the US (American Time Use Survey, ~250,000 people). UK data suggests a third of adults stopped reading for pleasure. “Post-literate” doesn’t mean illiterate; text remains everywhere but long-form reading and proficiency decline. Smartphones and video reduce deep concentration (“400-word wall”). Literacy historically supported democratic, reasoned debate; image-driven politics favors charisma over evidence.

Notable examples

Walter Ong and Marshall McLuhan; Neil Postman’s “Amusing Ourselves to Death”; Bukele’s TikTok as “post-literate autocracy”; Trump, Modi, Erdogan, Putin, and (UK) Andy Burnham.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

0:38

Decline of Reading and Rise of the 'New Dark Ages'

Explore the alarming decline in reading habits and its societal implications.

“The portion of the population who read for fun every day fell about 40%.”
0:52

What Does Post-Literacy Mean?

Discuss what it means for society to become 'post-literate' in a text-heavy world.

“and he thinks that as we slip away from mass long-form literacy into a world of tick-tock and slop, that we're in danger of sacrificing the foundations of democracy itself.”
2:17

Quantifying the Decline of Reading

Examine statistics highlighting the significant drop in reading habits.

“And this is something that I think probably a lot of people have been sort of sensing atmospherically for a while.”
3:40

Impact of Technology on Reading Habits

Analyze how technology, especially smartphones, affects our reading capacity.

“the written word into one that I think is more defined by the image and especially the moving image.”
4:36

Cultural Shifts in Reading and Media Consumption

Explore the cultural implications of shifting from reading to video consumption.

“I did a thought experiment a couple of years ago.”
6:47

Oral vs. Literate Cultures

Discuss Walter Ong's insights into the differences between oral and literate cultures.

“And I imagine you were frog marched through much the same canon as I was.”
10:25

Consequences of Declining Literacy

Delve into the potential societal changes resulting from the decline of literacy.

“And if given the option, we tend to opt for the screen, not the text.”
14:00

The Impact of Literacy on Society

Explore how literacy shapes our emotional experience and societal structures.

“And some of the connections he draws between what a preliterate and a postliterate world look like are really remarkable.”
16:50

The Birth of Modernity through the Printing Press

Understand the connection between the printing press and the rise of modern democratic societies.

“But your argument is that really the modern world was born out of or inextricably from the printing press.”
21:06

The Evolution of Political Awareness through Literacy

Learn how literacy empowered individuals politically and socially over time.

“So what's the mechanism then whereby all these distinctively modern phenomena bring us to democracy?”
Show all 19 chapters
24:13

Medieval Cultural Dynamics and the Shift to Print

Examine the transition from oral traditions to print culture and its effects.

“Okay, so just to recap, if I understand you right, you're saying that broadly, from the deep distant past, culture was predominantly oral, predominantly spoken word.”
28:00

Exploring Medieval Memory Practices

Learn about the significance of memory techniques in medieval scholarship and their societal impacts.

“which is about medieval memory practices, which is to say an enormous, probably the scribal culture which involved physical texts was the tip of an iceberg, most of which existed in the minds of medieval scholars.”
30:10

The Shift from Memory to Digital Recall

Discuss the transition from memory-focused cultures to digital storage and its implications for modern society.

“I mean, I'm always a little bit sceptical about the extent of the lessons that we can learn from the past.”
32:28

Humor and Cultural References in Memory

Explore how cultural references and humor relate to memory in modern society, including a humorous take on 'The Iliad'.

“Incredible city, beautiful city, big walls, very strong walls, some of the best walls in history.”
35:28

The Impact of Post-Literate Politics

Examine the implications of post-literate politics through the lens of modern leaders and visual communication.

“Download Instacart and try Clementine today.”
40:39

Challenges of Modern Governance

Discuss the complexities of governance in the context of charismatic leaders and the challenges they pose to democracy.

“And, you know, he is, I think he's still pretty popular in El Salvador when it's polled.”
42:01

Post-Literate Politics and Global Leaders

Explores how modern leaders leverage visual media and autocracy in politics.

“So we've spoken a bit about Bukele as an example of a postmodern autocrat in this much more audiovisual key.”
45:31

The Threat of Tyranny and Cultural Shifts

Discusses the implications of a post-literate society and potential paths forward.

“You think tyranny is an inevitable end product of our current direction of travel.”
49:44

Final Thoughts and Reflections

Concludes with reflections on the future of literacy in society and its impact.

“information environments between your New York Times readers and your people who are getting their news on TikTok, increasingly newspapers are full of video.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On Interesting Times, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00If you like YouTube, you'll love YouTube Premium. Hi, Sean Evans from Hot Ones here. With YouTube Premium, I get ad-free videos, offline downloads, background play, and so much more. Try YouTube Premium for two months free at youtube.com slash premium. Trial eligibility varies, terms apply, cancel anytime. The standard meme that gets posted in response to that is, I ain't reading all of that. I'm happy for you, or sorry that happened. Yes, the modern response to an English degree. I'm reading all that. Sorry, Dickens.

0:32From New York Times Opinion, I'm Mary Harrington, guest hosting for Interesting Times. When is the last time you read a book? No comment. Oh my gosh, okay. The portion of the population who read for fun every day fell about 40%. A revolution is underway, and the enemy, it seems, is reading. James Marriott calls this the New Dark Ages, and he thinks that as we slip away from mass long-form literacy into a world of tick-tock and slop, that we're in danger of sacrificing the foundations of democracy itself. James Marion, welcome to Interesting Times. Thank you very much for having me. So you say, James, that the world is becoming post-literate.

1:11But everything is covered in text everywhere. I mean, I rode through New York City on the way to come speak to you today. As I looked out of the window, I could see shop signs, I could see street signs, I could see everybody scrolling on their phones, most of them were looking at text. Some of them were texting with their thumbs while they were walking along, trying not to bump into each other. Literally everything is covered in writing. So what exactly do you mean when you say the world is becoming post-literate? I think that's such a good point. And I think it is one of the remarkable and weird things about the modern world that we are obsessed with text.

1:41And text covers absolutely everything. And I mean more now than probably any point in history. I mean, I guess it's important to say, and this is always the confusion that sometimes needs clearing up, post-literate doesn't mean illiterate. I guess a lot of the reason we're talking about this is that there have been these big reports in the news about the decline of reading, decline of reading proficiency, and we seem to be entering a world in which long-form text, at least, is a much less important part of people's lives and something people are spending much less time with. We're reading it less, we're becoming less proficient in interpreting it, and we're becoming less at home with it.

2:20Can you give us some numbers? How bad is it? Can we quantify the decline? Yes, I think we definitely can. And this is something that I think probably a lot of people have been sort of sensing atmospherically for a while. And in recent sort of months and years, there has been some really good data on this. I guess the most sort of stark piece of data is the American time use survey of almost a quarter of a million Americans, which found that over the first two decades, leisure reading fell by 40%. Reading what? Is this specifically one or reading anything at all? This is reading quite widely defined according to this survey.

2:57So it includes not only books, but magazines. I think it also includes audiobooks. So this is quite a wide and generous interpretation of reading. And that's declined really quite starkly. There are similar figures in the UK. A report found that a third of UK adults said that they had given up reading for pleasure. I suspect that figure is probably actually worse because we know that when you ask people about a socially prestigious activity like reading, They tend to be a bit optimistic about how much time they're spending reading. So I would say that figure is probably more stark. And another thing that made headlines was the report from the OECD at the end of 2024, which found that literacy was declining or stagnating in most developed countries, which is another really stark data point that we seem to be moving out of this culture of the written word into one that I think is more defined by the image and especially the moving image.

3:49So post-literacy isn't illiteracy. I guess it's more about the dominant medium of our culture. And I guess I think the other important thing to say about these statistics is that people have been writing about this trajectory in our society for a long time. The famous one, a book that made an enormous impact on me when I first read it, was Neil Postman's Amusing Ourselves to Death about the move of America from a textual print culture to a TV culture. In that book, I don't think he cites a single statistic about the decline of literacy. And I think if you're sceptical of those statistics, all you need to be persuaded of is this idea that we are moving from a culture in which our predominant way of interpreting our politics and our reality is mediated by text to one in which our interpretation of politics and reality is mediated by the image.

4:35And that, I think, is the crucial shift that we're talking about. I did a thought experiment a couple of years ago. I was on a plane between Los Angeles and Boston, and I thought, I'm never going to get a better random organic sample of coastal Americans than this. So I thought, I need to walk to the bathroom at the front of the plane. I'm going to count how many of them are reading long form of the other passengers on the plane. So, again, I interpreted that fairly expansively. It was anybody who was looking at anything on an e-reader or even I think I counted magazines. Very generous. Yeah. So an expansive definition.

5:10definition and my by my reckoning it was roughly 10 percent um everybody else was scrolling or watching movies or just doing i mean or asleep i mean i can't really fault people for that but yeah basically everybody else was either scrolling or watching a movie yeah roughly 10 does that track with your assessment and the statistics that you totally and i i share your nosiness about the media consumption habits of my fellow transport passengers i do it in the tube all the time and it really is stark i think the other important shift that we're both noticing is that if you were to do that survey a bit longer ago, 15 years ago, 10 years ago perhaps, of the kind of surveys I'm constantly doing on the bus and on the train in my nosy way, people would have been staring at their devices but they might still have been reading.

5:52They might have been scrolling through the New York Times or the Guardian or the BBC website. And I think one of the reasons that this topic is so fervidly in the air at the moment is I think that people other than us are noticing that when you're doing that walk down the train or down the bus you're noticing that people aren't even reading on their phones anymore they're watching videos i mean frankly you don't even have to look over their shoulders because you can hear them watching videos infuriating you can see the thumb going yeah and you can hear them playing them out loud which is yeah yeah happened to me on my on my train here to to leeds this morning and i think this is really striking and i think people are really noticing that video just seems to have taken over our world.

6:31So short form video has eaten everybody's capacity to concentrate. I mean, I avoid short form video for much that reason. I find it does something very brain rotting. I was just actually, you and I both studied English, English literature at Oxford, I believe. I think I was, I'm a little older than you, but not much. And I imagine you were frog marched through much the same canon as I was. And I was, I recounted an anecdote to somebody the other day about how, because like everybody else, I hadn't finished the reading list over the summer because nobody ever really does. I had to speed read Bleak House and Middlemarch in a week to write an essay in my first week of the first year.

7:09And the person I told this story to said, that's a thing, people, yeah. And seemed flabbergasted that that was even possible. But is that just something which people are losing the ability to do? Yes, I think it is. I mean, I think I am, to be honest. I'm not sure I could do it now. One of my great hubristic moments at university was trying to speed read Paradise Lost, which is an even more mad thing to try to do. How long did you give yourself to do it? Not long enough. I have since read it properly. That was even more hubristic than trying to speed read Bleak House or Middlemarch, I think. Yes, I think academics are finding that, for instance, they've spent their whole career assigning books like Middlemarch and Ulysses, and they're having to stop because the kids just can't get through them anymore.

7:50There's something that you increasingly hear in these educational circles, a phrase, I think it's the 400 word wall, which seems to be that 400 words is often the limit that students struggle to get past. That's apparently how long it takes to read for 90 seconds. You get through about 400 words. And that seems to be the point at which people begin to feel fidgety or need distraction or need to look at something else. i i know all this stuff and whenever i say i know all this stuff about how university students can't read sounds so old man shouts at cloud so like the kind of thing people have been complaining about forever but i think it is a really serious i think it's a serious thing and i think it's happening and i think it is i think it is pretty unprecedented and i think the statistics that we're talking about bear that out it would be ironic um but maybe appropriate to cite a meme here um which is one that gets posted online in response to a wall of what what people greet as a wall of text which they're just do not refuse to engage with and the standard meme that gets posted in response to that is i ain't reading all that um i'm happy for you or sorry that happened yes the modern response to an english degree i'm reading all that i'm sorry that happened whatever um so if literacy is declining in this radical way what does that do um what is the what is the impact of that and how and why perhaps before we get to that how am i is it happening now i think well i think it's happening now because of the phenomenon we're talking about about smartphones and short video i think it's also part of a longer-term story when you get when When you get into this, the declines in reading that are measured and that people begin to talk about are in the 1950s and 60s and 70s with the arrival of television.

9:37Television just swallows up human free time. There's a remarkable statistic quoted by Robert Putnam in his book Bowling Alone about how I think it's between the 60s and the 90s the average American gained hours of free time. And they spent virtually all of it watching television. when you when you measure how people are using their free time after the arrival of television reading just drops off a cliff and people and the screen just swallows things up i think there's a fundamental and you know quite comprehensible cognitive mechanism there which is that reading is hard work it's not it's a cognitively taxing activity it requires a bit of brain effort and watching a screen is passive it's easy to do it comes much more naturally to us absorbing images through our eyes is something we've evolved to do.

10:22Absorbing language through our eyes via text is a weird and difficult thing to do. And if given the option, we tend to opt for the screen, not the text. I think the decline of deep reading is really accelerated by the arrival of the smartphone in the early 2000s. That's a major revolution and so much has been said about that. I guess the point we're at now is almost a revolution within a revolution. It's become impossible to watch video everywhere. And I think that has really, for a lot of people, meant that long-form text, or I increasingly think if you're young, kind of any text, any real reading is just beginning to drain out your life.

11:00So James, in your work, you cite the influential Jesuit literary scholar Walter Ong, who wrote a book really that impacted me enormously when I was an undergraduate, about the difference between oral and literate cultures, which is to say cultures that run on the spoken word and cultures which turn on literacy. I wonder, can you tell us a little bit more about the difference between oral and literate cultures and how that can help us make sense of what's happening today? Yes, totally. That book, Orality and Literacy, is brilliant. And I think it blows the mind of almost everybody who reads it.

11:37I guess the exciting and fundamental thing that Walter Ong says, which is that we forget to realise how unusual, and this is the same point made by Marshall McLuhan, how unusual our literate world is. All our ways of thinking and understanding the world, which we view as natural aspects of being human beings, are very often the artificial creations of our interactions with text. Walter Ong says there are whole spheres of human knowledge that can't exist without text. Things like philosophy, history as we know it, certainly logic and mathematics. These things don't spring naturally out of human minds, They're the product of the human mind's interaction with the page.

12:12We move from an oral world in which people are communicating face-to-face, in which information isn't stored in words and on paper or on papyrus or on shards of pottery. But all information in oral pre-literate societies is stored in our minds. And for Walter Ong, this is not just about the way we store information, the way we communicate. It shapes the entire society and culture and politics of a pre-literate society. literacy comes along and in Walter Ong's account transforms our world intellectually, politically, and socially. And as literacy declines, or as the written word declines in importance in our culture, I guess his argument, and certainly my argument would be, we're not returning to a time before mass literacy.

12:57It's not like we're going to go back to oral poems and Beowulf and the Iliad and strumming our lives and singing our epic songs and all those things that were such important features of oral culture, we're going to go into a hybrid culture, where the written word exists, and it's not like people are going to stop reading. I mean, it's simply difficult to make an iPhone without text. Emails must be sent, instruction manuals must be read. Text underpins our world, but for a lot of people, it becomes radically less important. And some of the conclusions that Walter Ong drew, and I think people have gone further looking at that book in hindsight, is that this post-literate or secondary oral world may in some ways have some of the characteristics of the pre-literate world that existed before text.

13:46I mean, this idea of a reversal that post-literacy looks like pre-literacy is sort of threaded all the way through these media theorists we're talking about. Marshall McLuhan. It's very Marshall McLuhan, yes. I mean, Marshall McLuhan in some ways, in my view, a bit bonkers, but in other ways, just astonishingly prescient. And some of the connections he draws between what a preliterate and a postliterate world look like are really remarkable. When you put a new medium into a play in a given population, all their sensory life shifts a bit, sometimes shifts a lot. This changes their outlook, their attitudes, changes their feelings about studies, about school, about politics.

14:22And I think the idea can certainly be taken too far. And I think online people, you know, get carried away and do get very excited about the idea that we're going to have the Homer of TikTok, which I'm sceptical about. But I think looking at the world before literacy can be a way to understand what the world after sort of peak literacy might look like. So you've suggested that this is a world that will be more mystical, more tribal, and more autocratic. Why? Well, I think for a number of reasons. I guess there are a few things that literacy does in organizing our minds and organizing our politics.

15:01I think almost the most important, or to me, the most striking thing about these media theoretical arguments about what literacy does to us is, again, to do with that unnaturalness of the written word and how strange it is to live in a literate culture, something that fails to strike us all the time. Marshall McLuhan talks about how eerie life in a literate culture in which all our information comes via text might it seemed to someone from a pre-literate tribe. If you live in a pre-literate world, every single piece of information, your whole experience of the world is mediated through other people.

15:35It's face-to-face, it's emotional, you're talking, you're grabbing each other by the shoulder. Every piece of information is mediated via a human being, and that makes communication more emotional, perhaps more angry, more raucous, more warm. It has this very warm emotional atmosphere. A world in which all information is mediated via print and text, I think, feels emotionally desaturated and would feel weirdly cold and alien to those people, McLuhan argues. When all your political information comes not from your friend or your chief telling you what's going on in your world, but via a newspaper on a blank page covered in text, it's a much less emotional experience.

16:15You know, I can hear this sort of, I can hear this seeping back into me, to my great irritation on the train down here to come to this studio. the raucousness of a TikTok feed. You're back in this emotional world where all information is mediated via a human being, but it has refilled our world with feelings and passions and anger and rage and sort of, I think also one of the roots of this more tribal feeling that our world has now. And I think although that literate world was in many ways kind of weird in its emotional desaturation, that emotional desaturation was very useful for democratic politics, which relies on people being able to have not perfectly rational arguments, but arguments that are informed more by logic and reason and evidenced argument than by the kinds of forms of emotional persuasion that come more naturally when you can persuade someone not with evidence or with an argument, but by charming them around your point of view or crying at them or shouting at them.

17:16All these kind of irrational modes of persuasion that were very common in preliterate political cultures were sort of banished by print because you can't you can't shout at someone through print you can't charm someone through print and this stuff I think is rushing back into our world these passions that were banished by print are returning to us let's let's go back a little bit further to the beginning of the print story you know we've talked we've explored some of the implications of the transition away from

17:47era. But your argument is that really the modern world was born out of or inextricably from the printing press. As I understand you, you're speaking specifically about the end of mass long-form print culture as bringing about all of these, in your view, very undesirable transitions. But I want to hear a little bit more about your story of how it all began. What does the other end of the story look like? Why the printing press? What does that do? I guess, you know, there are various places at which you could begin the story of the spread of literacy. One, obviously, is with the invention of the Gutenberg Press.

18:27That multiplies the production of books and that lays the groundwork for mass literacy. The story as I tell it in my book, I think, you know, all starting places are somewhat arbitrary. It's attractive to me, this phenomenon in the middle and the end of the 18th century that is sometimes known to historians as the reading revolution. And this isn't the arrival of mass literacy as we know it today and as we experienced it in the late 19th and early 20th centuries. And it's not, you know, the very beginning of the story of Gutenberg. But there does seem to have been an acceleration of literacy and book reading in the middle of the 18th century.

19:02A few factors combined. You had the printing press, you had the increasing production of cheaper books, circulating libraries, the important pressure of Protestantism, a version of Christianity very strongly based on reading texts, was an important force in driving literacy beyond social elites. And there was this point in the middle and the end of the 18th century when journalists and authors begin to look around at the world around them and say, oh my God, it looks like everybody is reading. And allowing for journalistic exaggeration, which has always existed in history, the accounts are very attractive.

19:34A gentleman saying, I wondered where my serving girl was and I went to the kitchen and she was in there reading the newspaper rather than paying attention to me. People saying that they're walking down the street and a guy will be walking past them reading a novel. This strikes them as deeply weird because literacy has been, for pretty much all of human history up until this point, a minority habit of social and clerical elites and not spread through the population. The appearance of the written word in ordinary life causes a flurry of comment and excitement and curiosity. And it's this phenomenon in hindsight we call the reading revolution.

20:07And I think, you know, to sort of be very broad brush about it, I think there are a number of, from the perspective of the modernity I cherish, beneficial results from this. I think the spread of literacy is inextricably tied up with enlightenment as knowledge proliferates, as more people get access, not only to the information that's stored in books, but to the critical, analytic, and abstract forms of thinking that we know are associated with literacy. And you get this swell of natural philosophy, people questioning the world and how it works in the natural world. And it would be too simplistic to say that, you know, press the literacy button, get the enlightenment.

20:49But I think these phenomena are very connected. And this, I think, creates this culture of more complex and more cumulative thought. As people can correspond more in print, they can talk to each other more, they can build on each other's ideas. And I think, you know, it's not just me arguing this, it's the argument famously made by the economist Joel Mocke, who won a Nobel Prize for his work on this, that the Republic of Letters and the exchange of information through this network of journals and letters in Europe in the 18th century was the major cause behind the scientific revolution, the industrial revolution, and the beginnings of, I mean, really the whole of modernity as we know it.

21:29So what's the mechanism then whereby all these distinctively modern phenomena bring us to democracy? I mean, this has been a central theme in your thesis, that there's this incredibly central link between democracy and long-form literacy. So really, can you talk me through what is that link? I think there's a link. Again, I think the directness of the link can be overemphasized. I think there's a quote from, or maybe a misquotation from the Victorian historian Thomas Carlyle, who said, invent the printing press and democracy is inevitable. I wouldn't go quite that far. I think as literacy spread down through society, people began to access information about their political leaders and their laws.

22:08And I think it's worth emphasizing how, again, how strange this was. Most people, for most of history, had lived far from urban centers and had very little idea about what was going on in the politics above them. And if they tried to comment on it or if they found out about it, they were often punished. But as people began to find out more about their leaders and as they began to think critically about them, because I think critical thinking is associated with literacy, they began to be able to understand and advocate for their own political rights. And I'm not saying this situation is by any means a straightforward connection, but you begin to get the spread of literacy gives a voice to people who would not have been able to influence politics at all in the age before mass literacy.

22:55So people who are advocating more democratic or republican forms of politics, like the examples in my book, Russo or Thomas Paine, come from backgrounds in which a hundred years before they would not have been literate and their voices and their political ideas would have had absolutely no influence because they would have had no way of getting their ideas out. Nobody could have listened to Thomas Paine's great-great-great-grandfather because he wouldn't have been able to write his ideas down and nobody would have heard them. So when you spread literacy through society, you also get more people joining the conversation.

23:26So it's not just more people having more information, more different kinds of people from different social backgrounds can join that great democratic conversation, advocate for their rights. And, you know, all this, I think, is building up through history until the beginning of the 20th century. And I think it's no accident that the great age of mass literacy in the early 20th century is also the great age of mass democracy. This is when you get votes for women. And I think these things are completely tied up with the spread of information, criticism and debate all the way through society. So political information and argument is not just the privilege of a small elite around a royal court or around an aristocratic court.

24:06It is something that everybody has access to. And that isn't, I think, just a fundamental force for democracy in history. Okay, so just to recap, if I understand you right, you're saying that broadly, from the deep distant past, culture was predominantly oral, predominantly spoken word. The vast majority of people didn't read because they didn't need to. And these cultures were more agonistic, more participatory, more religious faith and magic and eeriness and uncanniness was much more prevalent and treated as a normal feature of reality. and then then the printing press came along and then some stuff happened and then we got to the 18th century and we get to the enlightenment and um and and everything suddenly starts getting better in a distinctively modern way i want to go back a little bit before the 18th century um because it seems to me as though you're skipping over some some your you know didn't didn't quite Quite a lot happened between Beowulf and the 18th century.

25:09But you've treated the middle bit, the medieval era, the era really before the Enlightenment, briefly. And really only in terms of how scarcity oppressed people. And then the much greater prevalence of printed materials with following the printing press had a liberatory and a rationalizing effect. how how did how did scarcity um affect the culture and can you say a little bit more about about these changes yes absolutely i i guess you know i i mean part of the reason i don't write about the middle ages is that i you know i don't profess to be an expert in them i think the scarcity of books is is interesting and certainly one of the other features of this so-called reading revolution at the end of the 18th century wasn't just the growth of literacy it was the proliferation of texts.

25:59And I think one of the important things that was happening to people in that world was not just that they were able to read, it was that they had a huge wealth of things to read. But the case that people like Elizabeth Eisenstein would make is that in a world in which there are very few texts, you are much more respectful of the authority of texts. So if you have access to only a couple of books, and that was probably the case for most people in this world that you're describing, unless you had access to a great monastic or royal library. If you wanted to find out about the natural world or theology or science or law or medicine, you might have only one book you could go to on that subject.

26:37And your respect for that book is hugely increased. And it's, again, I think another thing that is hard for us to get our heads around as people who live in this incredibly rich, incredibly diverse information environment is, what is it like to have a single source of authority? But this scribal culture that you that you talk about, this medieval culture, was inheriting a few texts passed down from antiquity. It wasn't possible to produce lots of copies of them. Each one had to be copied out by hand. And they were treated with great reverence. And this was quite a hierarchical knowledge environment.

27:08There were few texts and they were reverenced. And, you know, not to caricature the Middle Ages, but we know that people picked up strange ideas from Aristotle. What are the good Aristotle things? There's a great thing that I always love about how beavers castrate themselves and discard their testicles when pursued. I can't remember if there's Aristotle who says that or another classical thinker. What happens when texts begin to proliferate? And I think this probably does to some degree precede the printing press, is that you begin to be able to look at two different texts and say, hang on, these things contradict each other.

27:37And I think it's this environment that allows you to begin to ask questions about what you know. Well, while we're on the subject of the Middle Ages, my big aha moment in trying to understand the other end of the shift, really at the beginning of the print revolution, was learning a little bit more about how the practice of medieval scholarship and discovering that a missing piece, which I hadn't been aware of really when I read Walter Ong, which is about medieval memory practices, which is to say an enormous, probably the scribal culture which involved physical texts was the tip of an iceberg, most of which existed in the minds of medieval scholars.

28:16The practice of medieval scholarship required deep study of a much smaller corpus of literature and the storage of the ideas of that through the practice of trained memory, which is very difficult to get your head around now because we just don't do it. We have bookshelves. But it functions like a practice of meditation, really, highly visual meditation. And all of those little illustrations and ornate marginalia you see in a medieval text are aids to memory. They're not just there because people like doodling in the margins. They're actually at their components of a memory technology. And they're there as visual cues to help somebody remember the passage next to them in this very meditative, very visualizing practice of study.

29:03So memorizing the Book of Psalms was kids' stuff, which just seems unfathomable to people now. I mean, this is like learning your times tables. Yes, I know. And I mean, and I guess this is this whole, one of the phenomenons of literate modernity is a tendency to see the entire past in terms of literacy, because it's what comes down to us from the past. We see the literate half of the past, we see the literate top percentage of the past, and we miss, as you say, this whole world of memory and songs that are passed on and gossip and rumour. And 90 % of the information environment of the past is lost to us.

29:36It's the point that Robert Danton makes about the French Revolution. We can view that moment in history too easily as an entirely literate one because what survives for us is the text. We don't see the gossip and the songs and the memory. So this is something that I found myself mulling over. Do you think there's anything that we can draw on from this missing medieval world and particularly from their practices of trained memory in order to help us reassemble some kind of a functioning hybrid culture in the aftermath of mass long-form literacy as we transition, or so it would seem, to a more post-literate culture?

30:09That's such an interesting thought. I wonder. I mean, I'm always a little bit sceptical about the extent of the lessons that we can learn from the past. Post-industrial modernity is incredibly weird in the context of the whole of human history. And the lessons that we can take away from, I think, the pre-industrial past can be interesting, but are sort of limited. I guess the crucial difference that we're talking about here is this difference between a world in which you can remember nothing and the art of memory is an obsession for society and shapes a society in ways that are enormous but now invisible to us.

30:43In the 21st century, we remember everything. We don't have to, even in our post-literate age, everything is recorded. Videos are stored. Texts are stored. The internet is basically a huge archive. But this is a really interesting, just to nuance that point a minute, we don't remember this, the computers do. Yes. So there's this enormous, just overwhelming, kind of we're drowning in memory, but none of it's in our heads. No, and it's so hard to imagine what that will do to us in the way we interact. The writer Catherine D made this point. I think I saw her writing that in Substack, was that in some ways, the state of remembering everything and remembering nothing are more similar than we imagine.

31:23one of the features of um oral discourse that walter ong points out is that it has to everything you say has to be intensely memorable otherwise it will be lost so when you're talking the thing everybody cites now and this is almost turned into a meme is that oral poetry for instance is full of epithets the swift footed achilles shining helm shining helmeted athena and you have these little verbal tags that tag people in your memory so that you can come back to them and think about of them. And if you're a speaker, you have to make your speech memorable, otherwise it will be lost. There's a preference in oral poetry, according to Walter Ong and Eric Havelock, I think also Eric Havelock says this, for heavy characters.

31:59Highly memorable, distinctive characters stand out. So the Iliad, for instance, is full of larger-than-life heroes, and Greek myths are full of monsters, things that stand out in our minds, because in a world in which everything can so easily be forgotten the memorable is incredibly important and i guess the analogy is sometimes i think there's an analogy to be made with the world in which you remember everything which is that because we remember literally everything it's just as important to try and seize things and make them stand out so the analogy that people have made you know trump is a heavy character in the same way that cerberus you know the kind of monster of antiquity is highly memorable because he's so absurd or Achilles is highly memorable because he has these extraordinary superhuman faculties and is a natural character in epic poetry which requires memorable characters to work modern culture in which remember everything requires highly memorable things to stick in our minds because we're so unused to remembering things I remember a brilliant impressionist once do it reading out the beginning of the the Iliad um in the voice of Donald Trump today we are reading about Troy.

33:03Incredible city, beautiful city, big walls, very strong walls, some of the best walls in history. And I know walls, nobody knows walls like me. And it was, I was listening to it thinking, that's it. That's exactly it. That's amazing. I mean, you're not making me think I would listen to this too. Where can I get it? I wish I could tell you where I found it. An unexpected retirement project. I wonder, I doubt he could be persuaded to do the whole thing. I think it might be, it'll be a bit much. I mean, you know, it was a great joke, but I'm not sure I'd want to listen to the whole thing.

34:01There's like a ton more in there. You should try it. If you like YouTube, you'll love YouTube Premium. Try it now for two months free at youtube.com slash premium. If you like YouTube, you'll love YouTube Premium. Hi, I'm Sean Evans from Hot Ones, and I want to tell you about YouTube Premium. It has offline downloads, so you can watch without Wi-Fi. Background play, so you can lock your phone, and it still plays, baby. Oh, and it is completely ad-free. Yes, I said it, ad-free. Try YouTube Premium for two months free at youtube.com slash premium. Trial eligibility varies, terms apply, cancel anytime.

34:43This podcast is supported by Viking, committed to exploring the world in comfort. Journey through the heart of Europe on an elegant Viking longship, with thoughtful service, destination-focused dining, and cultural enrichment, on board and on shore. And every Viking voyage is all-inclusive with no children and no casinos. Discover more at Viking.com. Whether you meal prep or meal panic, Instacart's new shopping assistant Clementine is here to help. Now you can generate a recipe in seconds, add everything you need to make it to your cart, and have it delivered in as fast as 30 minutes. Plus, you can plan a menu for any occasion, get meal ideas for the week, and reorder your faves with just a few taps.

35:23That way you can spend less time figuring out what to make and more time enjoying it. Download Instacart and try Clementine today. So if your thesis is right, and I find it persuasive, the end of mass long-form literacy is going to make us less rational, more visually oriented, perhaps more participatory, more enchanted, if you like, in our relation to each other and to the world and also to politics. And you've cited, I think very persuasively, Nayib Bukele, the president of El Salvador, as perhaps a sign of things to come. A postmodern autocrat in the sense of operating in a much more visual register, very skillfully through social media, whilst also doing a fairly unembarrassed end run around some of the more sort of textual and deliberative aspects, I think you might say, of democracy as we consider it today.

36:32And I actually, I found that persuasive because I remember being really struck a year or so ago. I came across a post by Bukele on his social media feed, which is, I mean, it's just an extraordinary artifact. His social media game is off the charts. It's incredibly good. And he posted a photo of himself in a crowd and facing, surrounded by his heavies, but surrounded by clearly adoring supporters. and he's facing a man who's got his little, I assume his little son on his shoulder, a little boy, maybe seven or eight, five, six years old, who's reaching down towards Bukele, who's reaching up to sort of high five him.

37:08And there's a light shining just behind where the two hands are touching. And the whole visual image is incredibly painterly. And I looked at it and I thought, that's the visual register of the pre-modern world. That's the iconography of kingship redone in photography in a postmodern key. And I was thinking, this is an astonishing artifact. and I think it really speaks to the the kind of phenomena that you're describing here wouldn't you say yes totally you make me think of that sort of online phenomenon of you know modern paint modern photo on instagram versus renaissance painting those two visual worlds have more in common than we sometimes remember that's right that's right isn't there somebody there's somebody whose bit is um football football players as yes as classic works of art yes exactly and they're always really good yeah and it's always persuasive and i think partly because the point that you make exactly there is that this visual language of power was understood and comprehended in a in a in europe before mass literacy changed our politics and was used effectively by kings and people are rediscovering the same you know the same incredibly persuasive aspects this visual language of power almost down to the hand gestures and to the and to the and the aspect of light as as you mentioned.

38:21I think, I mean, Bukhali, I guess, is an often cited example of what a post-literate politics might look like, because he is famously the most followed world leader on TikTok. And as you say, his TikTok feed to a sort of woolly liberal is quite terrifying. This, I think, to me at least, is a really dramatic way of bringing home the difference between literate and a post-literate politics. If, as I have in my book, one of the distinctive features of illiterate politics is long-form argument, reasoned debate, evidence, a sort of cooler and more rational environment in which politics can take place.

38:58The Bukaili TikTok feed almost seems to provide the kind of night to me, the sort of nightmare counterpoint to what a visual politics looks like. So there's something to, I just want to push you on a little bit there. So, so in, I mean, you, you write in the context of Bukaili and sort of postmodern autocracy in a visual culture, you say there are political systems that prefer their citizens not to think, and they're called dictatorships. But I just wanted to submit to you that there's a difference in kind between political systems where their leaders prefer them not to think or actively obstruct their efforts to think.

39:33You know, you write very movingly about slave owners preventing their, punishing their slaves physically for trying to learn to read, which is a clear illustration of this sort of tyrannical authority. But surely there's something different in kind between that and and under polity where citizens are not prevented from thinking but they just they just don't want to um isn't there something if you have a situation where people just it's not that they can't that they're being stopped from thinking they just don't want to because they're too busy scrolling you know what if under those circumstances actually the the least worst option is some kind of a monarch who at least has the best interests of his subjects at heart to me that that that's very hard to that's very hard to swallow i'm very pessimistic about the future of democracy.

40:16I am also... I share your pessimism, but I suppose I'm, yeah, what if the least worst option under those circumstances is in fact a king? You know, I don't know that I'd want a Bukele in England, but, you know, in the context of El Salvador, where the whole country was run by gangs until he came along and shut them all away, I'd see Bukele, you know, if I was a Salvadoran granny, I'd probably see him as on my side. Yes. And, you know, he is, I think he's still pretty popular in El Salvador when it's polled. I guess the important transformation here is that this visual culture is much more receptive to personality than print culture It's hard to be an influencer via a newspaper When you are communicating visually and through tiktok and through images People have much more access to your personality and I think it supercharges the ability of Charismatic personalities and charismatic autocrats to dominate politics and I would say this is the fundamental theme of Democratic decline around the world.

41:07The great threat to democracy in the 21st century is not an ideology. I think ideologies are perhaps rather kind of print and text-based, but the threat from charismatic personalities. I guess I am much more pessimistic about autocracy, perhaps. I think all political systems have their problems. Democracy certainly has its problems. I don't deny that. I think autocracies are full of even worse problems. And I think if you can't remove someone from power, if there are no checks and balances on that power, if you create all kinds of difficulties that are vastly worse than the ones you'd encounter in a democracy.

41:41I also think the idea of a monarch in a modern state is just unworkable. We live in these unimaginably complex societies, more bigger than any of us could get our heads around. And for that whole system to depend on one charismatic leader who is running things in this monarchical fashion, as people often say, people refer to repatrimonialization, this idea that modern leaders are behaving like monarchs and everything is based not on an impersonal civil service and appointing people on merit, but through networks of loyalty and kinship and appointing your friends and your family to diplomatic postings and all these themes of autocracy around the world, that is no way to run a complex modern state.

42:17And I think it will fail. So we've spoken a bit about Bukele as an example of a postmodern autocrat in this much more audiovisual key. Who else? Who else is doing this? Can you give me other examples of leaders who are embracing the new post-literate political register. I mean, I think that, you know, I wouldn't quite say ten a penny, but I think this is the main threat to democracy. And I think you can find them anywhere in the world. The really obvious example, which one almost shies away from mentioning because it's so obvious, is Donald Trump. Donald Trump is, I think, basically owes his presidency to his complete mastery of television and social media.

42:55And talking about someone who can participate with brilliant effectiveness in a visual environment. Trump is just the undisputed master of this. Other people you could look at, Modi in India. He's suffered a setback recently, obviously, but he had a real personality cult. And that was really supercharged by social media. I think Modi has his own app through which communicates with his followers. Erdogan in Turkey, Orban obviously now voted out in Hungary, which shows that this trend isn't completely linear everywhere. All of these people, I think were drawing on social media and this culture of the image to impose their charisma and authority on a country's politics and dominate it that way.

43:37I guess one other obvious example would be Putin, who is kind of the pioneer of this, who used TV and photography to... So you're making it sound as though this is just a right-wing phenomenon. Is that right? Or can you think of anybody on the left who expresses this trend? I mean, the one that springs to mind for me is the current mayor of New York City, who seems to have a very competent social media game. I think that's a really good point. And one of the things that I mildly regretted looking back on the book, having finished it, was that a lot of the people I'm bashing in the book are 20th and 21st century right-wing populists.

44:08I have a go at Newt Gingrich. I obviously have a go at Donald Trump. The argument is not that post-literacy is a political phenomenon. It's not that it only belongs in the right. I think it's probably been pioneered on the right. And I think there are more right-wing examples of this because we know looking around the world that one of the major divisions in I think almost every western country in its democratic politics is education and the conservative part of the political spectrum has increasingly become the party of the less well educated and the liberal party will be the party of the more well educated and I think it's kind of for that reason that because liberals have been historically more tied to literate institutions like universities and newspapers they have slightly lagged conservatives in moving into this post-literate form of politics, which was pioneered by, you might say, Fox News, Conservative Talk Radio, Twitter, as we know it today.

44:56That said, I do not think that this is a taller partisan phenomenon. And I think the example you cited of Mamdani is very relevant. There's one obviously going on in the United Kingdom. We have a Prime Minister, Andy Burnham, who is, I mean, really quite astonishingly good, as everybody says at TikTok. We're putting the cowboys out of business. a first for a Labour leader. And I think post-literate politics is coming for the left and is coming for the liberal left. And I think, although it's probably pioneered on the right, I think we're going to see more and more examples. And I think everybody will be doing politics this way in 20 years' time.

45:32This is sounding pretty bleak. You think tyranny is an inevitable end product of our current direction of travel. And it sounds as though your fear is that with an increasingly post-literate population, this may be difficult. We may not be able to avert this. So, I mean, what do you think we can do? What's the best case scenario for the future that we're looking at? Is there a best case scenario? And what do you think we can do, either individually or collectively, to avert some of these nightmare scenarios? Good question. Like you, I'm pessimistic about it. And I think, you know, like you, I've looked, you know, I've read this media history and I've thought about the history of where we are through this media theoretical lens.

46:13And I think one of the great and perhaps alarming lessons is that I don't think communications revolutions get reversed. I don't think there was any point in history in which you could uninvent the printing press. There may have been Catholic priests in the midst of the Reformation thinking, let's just uninvent the printing press and go back to a world in which the Catholic Church and the Catholic hierarchy is undisturbed. That's simply not plausible. And I think it's not plausible to un-invent the iPhone. It's not plausible to un-invent TV. I think that can't happen, and I think it won't happen.

46:42And I think a lot of the political trends, away from a literate, deliberative, argumentative, evidenced political discourse towards one that is dominated by charismatic personalities, I think is baked into our culture now. And we're going to see that. I mean, I think we're pretty far into that story now across the world. I think it's going to continue to play out. As to what we can do, I mean, I'm interested in your view on this. The The thing that I think can be done is probably individual, which is that I think people are waking up to the dangers of this post-literate society. I think people are worried about the effects of excessive screen time on their cognitive health.

47:17Individually, I think probably some people will look at all this and look at this, our slop-ridden, brain-rotting environment and think, I'm going to make a conscious effort to read more. I'm going to sit down and make a really tough effort, which it is hard when you've got a smartphone, to spend an hour reading in the evening. And the analogy that's often made is the flooding of our nutritional environment in the 60s and 70s, the junk food. It made lots of people very fat. It also gave us marathon runners, gym bunnies, and a culture of people who are actively resisting it. And I think there probably will be a culture of active cognitive resistance.

47:51It strikes me that, again, the picture that you're painting here is not dissimilar in some ways to the medieval one, in as much as if you have a small height, It's the equivalent of intellectually super fit scholars and then a very much larger cohort of people who are mostly scrolling. That perhaps replicates something not unlike the pre-Gutenberg world, where you had a small, small elite of highly literate scholars and then the vast majority who lived in a much more oral world. Absolutely, definitely. And I guess, you know, if people are going to make this effort to enrich their cognitive environments, I think that's going to be basically a middle class phenomenon.

48:31I think it's going to be relatively well off, relatively well educated people who are doing that. So you think we just need to build an arc and save as many people as we can? Well, I mean, I guess perhaps, you know, if you're looking for points of, well, I mean, if you're looking for points of optimism, you know, history takes a long time to unfold. Stagnation is always a possibility. If you're looking at a point of pessimism, I almost wonder if the scenario we're outlining in which we return to this bifurcated information environment in which you have middle class people subscribing to newspapers and participating in this more literate culture and most other people who lack the financial and educational resources to participate in literate culture.

49:11Part of me increasingly wonders, as I get even more pessimistic, how true that's even going to be. I think when you look at what's going on at universities, universities are rapidly becoming post-literate. We know that with the advent of generative AI, you can pretty much get through a degree without writing an essay. We've been talking about how you can seem to get through a degree without reading a book. And I wonder if these literate institutions will decay as well and actually will all be post-literate. I mean, these things that we mentioned when we talk about what this sort of literate culture might look like that outlasts this supposed bifurcation of information environments between your New York Times readers and your people who are getting their news on TikTok, increasingly newspapers are full of video.

49:50You open the homepage of a newspaper and that's right you're looking at video not at text and i wonder if perhaps it's not the case there'll be a bifurcation but the educated well-off people have just simply been lagging a trend and we might be looking at we might be we might see the same story unfold for those for those people as well i think that maybe to me feels more likely now the tide the flood of slop is coming and very few will make it onto the ark save yourself if you can and james is here to warn you. James Marriott, thank you so much for joining us today. This has been fascinating and daunting and concerning.

50:25I've enjoyed it. Thank you very much for having me.

50:50This podcast is supported by Viking, committed to exploring the world in comfort. Journey through the heart of Europe on an elegant Viking longship, with thoughtful service, destination-focused dining, and cultural enrichment, on board and on shore. And every Viking voyage is all-inclusive, with no children and no casinos. Discover more at viking.com.

From the publisher

Literacy is declining sharply across the West. In the era of vertical video, who has the time or concentration to read a long article — let alone a whole book?

As we lose the ability to read long-form text, we might also be losing the capacity for democratic deliberation and self-governance. That’s the argument this week’s guest, the Times of London columnist James Marriott, makes in his recent book, “The New Dark Ages.” He sits down with guest host Mary Harrington to discuss our return to oral culture, the political consequences and what we can learn from the medieval era about storing information in a digital world.

Note: As we work on relaunching “Interesting Times,” the show will feature a series of guest hosts in the coming months.

  • 00:00 Intro
  • 00:52 Post-Literacy
  • 02:05 The Data Behind the Decline
  • 05:13 The Shift Toward Video
  • 08:48 Why Reading Is Hard
  • 10:45 Walter Ong on Orality and Literacy
  • 14:27 Tribal Politics and Emotion
  • 17:16 The Reading Revolution
  • 21:14 Literacy as an Engine for Democracy
  • 25:15 Scarcity and Authority
  • 27:27 Lessons from Medieval Times
  • 30:13 Remembering Everything and Nothing
  • 33:29 How Bukele Commands the Attention Economy
  • 37:04 Monarchy vs. Democracy
  • 40:16 Other Postliterate Leaders
  • 43:29 Can We Resist the Slide?
  • 46:33 Closing

(A full transcript of this episode is available on the Times website.)

Thoughts? Email us at [email protected]. Please subscribe to our YouTube Channel, Interesting Times.


 

Subscribe today at nytimes.com/podcasts or on Apple Podcasts, Spotify and Amazon Music. You can also subscribe via your favorite podcast app here https://www.nytimes.com/activate-access/audio?source=podcatcher. For more podcasts and narrated articles, download The New York Times app at nytimes.com/app.


Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.

More from Interesting Times

All episodes