

Post–midterms analysis of what happened to Trumpism/MAGA, why it faltered, and what right populism might look like next.
Sagar Anjeti, described as a right-populism advocate and co-host of a left-right show; he says his political evolution was shaped by opposition to the Iraq War while growing up in Bush/neo-conservative Texas (College Station). Camille Foster hosts; Anna Martin is NYT branding.
MAGA’s first-term failure came from hiring staff who pushed Romney-style policies and from loyalty to Trump replacing loyalty to an agenda. Voters’ affordability/anti-foreign-entanglement priorities were undermined by “betrayals” like new foreign wars and mishandled immigration enforcement. Tariffs are defended in principle but criticized for chaotic implementation. Corruption is framed as voters’ “spiritual/ethical” sense of leaders getting richer, even if not always legally corrupt. Right populism is said to be “nation-first,” unlike left populism.
Iraq War; Ukraine/anti-neocon stance; Iran war; border “mass deportation” messaging; AI-meme glee in enforcement; reciprocal tariffs; Kirsten Noem replaced by Mark Wayne Mullen; Texas shifting Democrats; El-Sayed “America first” ads; claims about Trump vs. JD Vance on Iran.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Discussion on the Republican Party's recent electoral challenges.
“A total wipeout of the Republican Party as we know it.”
Exploration of MAGA's origins and Sagar Anjeti's views on Trumpism.
“And I knew that you might be able to give us some unique perspective on what's going on here.”
Insights into the challenges faced during Trump's first term and its aftermath.
“And I think what it required was taking Trump seriously.”
Analysis of Trump's tariffs and immigration policies and their effectiveness.
“But let's talk about how it's going, because after these most recent midterms, the Trump coalition and MAGA broadly don't really seemed to be on the best footing.”
Discussion on corruption as a major voter concern and its implications.
“Again, all of this, to be very fair, again, to many of the critics who are tearing their hair out, listening, yes, much of this was evident from 2016.”
Explore how voters perceive corruption and its implications for political figures.
“So that could contribute to some disillusionment during the midterms.”
Discuss the philosophical questions surrounding limited government and effective governance.
“Although, obviously, this takes all of that times by a thousand.”
Examine the relationship between corporate power and government and its effects on liberty.
“me, we're both hoping that the right kinds of people get elected.”
Analyze the differences between left populism and right populism in American politics.
“Can we talk a little bit more about the current circumstance?”
Exploring the contrasting political philosophies of Ted Cruz and James Tallarico.
“It is a laughable concept to me from the paradigm that I grew up in.”
Discussing the cultural issues affecting conservatism, including immigration and identity politics.
“Because as I hear you talk about it, there are some social issues that you're concerned about, the culture war stuff.”
Examining the implications of identity politics and how it affects public perception.
“I don't believe in many of these post civil rights kind of extra constitutional creations that maybe have been necessary.”
Analyzing the impact of race in political discussions and its implications for policy.
“I hate the phrase, but I use it to try to illustrate things in a way that's understandable.”
Discussing the complexities of the U.S.-Israel relationship and its portrayal in media.
“I can't I actually can't overstate how important it was, at least to the small demographic of people that I can at least claim to be an expert in podcasting.”
Exploring the future trajectory of the Republican Party and the influence of Trump.
“and Israel that place a particular emphasis on Israel having this kind of control over the United States.”
Analyzing the challenges for Republicans in aligning with Trump’s legacy.
“What could they possibly do at this point to compete?”
Explore how Trump's influence shapes Republican loyalty and electoral dynamics.
“I'm reading a story this morning about Vance 2028, the same exact position.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On Interesting Times, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00Hey, it's Anna Martin from The New York Times. What if I told you you'll never have to hear this line again? Wherever you get your podcasts. Yeah, no, I actually can't tell you that. But you know what I can tell you? A place I think you might want to go. It's the Shows tab in The New York Times app. The place to listen to and now watch full episodes of New York Times shows. The Shows tab. Find it in The New York Times app. Explore the Shows tab and follow a show today. For New York Times Opinion, I am Camille Foster, guest hosting for Interesting Times. What happens to Republicans now? A total wipeout of the Republican Party as we know it.
0:38Democrats are now going to control both the Senate and the House. This was an absolute asteroid that smacked into Trump. After a crushing electoral defeat, every political party spends a little bit of time in the wilderness. But what reemerges may be something that is almost unrecognizable. That is how we got the MAGA coalition in the first place. Now, I'm very much an old school libertarian who still values limited government and free markets. And I've always been a little uncomfortable with this whole MAGA thing. My guest today is Sagar Anjeti. Sagar is one of the clearest and most articulate advocates for the brand of right populism that has come to define the modern conservative movement.
1:16Trump era is over. MAGA in and of itself is dead. My suspicion is that he'll have some unique insights into what has gone wrong, whether or not the president failed that movement, and what the Republican Party is likely to do next.
1:35Sagar Anjeti, welcome to Interesting Times. Thanks for having me. Yeah, absolutely. I'm thrilled to be able to talk to you post midterms. There is a great deal that has unfolded. And I knew that you might be able to give us some unique perspective on what's going on here. But I want to talk about your personal evolution, like how you kind of arrived at these views. And I'd also like you to talk about just Trump and Trumpism in general. What is it about the movement, if not the man that attracted you to it? Well, I mean, look, let's be honest here. You know, Trump is one of the most extraordinary figures in American politics, in modern American history.
2:18I mean, he redefined not only American conservatism, He realigned many of the parties. And I think, you know, more than anything, he was an Overton window shatterer. I mean, he broke open the possibility for a new way of doing business. I think that's very attractive, regardless of whether you're left, right. You know, obviously, I co-host a left-right show. And even the leftists will acknowledge that Trump's victory, you know, broke open their own capacity, potentially not only to win, but to move things in a new direction. And so when he won in 2016, I mean, it really just proved to me that many of the people that I had looked up to genuinely had no idea what they were talking about.
2:52And I think what it required was taking Trump seriously. And ultimately, you know, one of the great failings, I think, of the American left or at least the American Democratic Party at that time was to cast his election as illegitimate and stolen by Russia, as opposed to taking seriously why many of these voters who previously voted for Barack Obama ultimately crossed over to Donald Trump. And so ultimately for me, it was exciting in terms of a new paradigm. You know, I would say the number one reason that I'm involved in politics, period, whatsoever is the Iraq War. I came up against the Iraq War.
3:24I lived in Bush country. I was raised in College Station, Texas, actually. And so I grew up really in the beating heart of American Bible Belt, conservatism, neoconservatism, pro-war. And I found it repulsive at that time. And so when Trump is able to take the stage and tell Jeb Bush that his father or his brother was a failure, is that he led us into the most disastrous war. I mean, you know, even Howard Stern liberals were barely capable at that time of even articulating such an incisive position. George Bush made a mistake. We can make mistakes. But that one was a beauty. We should have never been in Iraq.
4:00We have destabilized the Middle East. But so you so I mean, so you still think he should be impeached? it's my turn. And you do whatever you want. You call it whatever you want. I want to tell you they lied. And I also was, you know, raised in a country which I saw my parents prosper. I saw their S &P 500 portfolios and all that go up. They were able to buy a house to raise a family, many other people, middle class. And ultimately, after 2008, what happened is that our living standards went down. And I don't care how many neoliberals are out there to tell me that it hasn't. That has unfortunately accelerated over the last 10 years.
4:33But you can understand how in 2016, how refreshing it is, again, to me and to millennial generation and others who are raised with a lot of these promises, but very quickly learning that those promises were not coming true as to why that is an attractive vision, I think, for the nation. So that's that accounts for the how it started. But let's talk about how it's going, because after these most recent midterms, the Trump coalition and MAGA broadly don't really seemed to be on the best footing. What was supposed to happen and what actually transpired? Yeah, it's a fascinating story. I actually think the first term is incredibly instructive.
5:14And so one of the problems, you know, I got a lot of books behind me. Many of them are on populism as well. And unfortunately, one of the common themes of populism is that you catch the office before you're ready for it. And that's basically kind of the idea of what I think went wrong in the first term is that they hired many of these people who not only just disagreed with Trump entirely, but would often push policies that were very much reminiscent of Mitt Romney. Right. And so that was a great struggle, I think, in the first term. Now, this is where it comes to 2020. And this is a very important part of the story.
5:46There are two kind of wings of their theories of what went wrong under the first Trump administration. And remember, this is also in the wake of January 6th, when Trump is historically unpopular and obviously, you know, literally denies the election results. And so what happens is that Trump undergoes kind of a theory of his first term as a betrayal, but he doesn't look at it as a betrayal of policy. He looks at it as a betrayal of himself. And so loyalty to Trump in and of itself becomes the only true virtue of what it means to be MAGA. And so ultimately, what I had wanted to believe and what I did believe to be very transparent was that, yes, there was a lot of nonsense that came along with the Trump movement An incredible amount of nonsense.
6:28However, there was an ideological struggle within that in which the staffers believe that we're not going to do things the way that we did in the first term. We're going to be loyal to the agenda with the assumption that Trump is loyal to that agenda as well. Right. And in particular, this really comes to head with the Ukraine war with being against neoconservatism and also an antiwar principle. Immigration obviously aligns with cost of living and in particular, the general feeling of chaos is I can't afford a home. The border is wide open. Tens of millions of people have come to our country illegally.
7:01And within that chaos, we need something that's a little bit crazy, perhaps. But I remember 2019. My life wasn't so bad back then. That's ultimately the reason why Trump wins the election. What ends up happening, of course, is a multifaceted story where that policy struggle I talked about becomes completely subordinated really to Trump himself and kind of the whims of the personalities around him, their willingness to be obsequious to Trump. And that is how we get the greatest betrayal, perhaps greatest campaign betrayal of all time. No new foreign wars. Then I go and get involved in a foreign war, a foreign quagmire like Iran on the backs of a coalition which rejected the Iraq war to then pursue a strategic defeat, which we have now suffered in Iran and will continue to suffer until Trump eventually just admits it.
7:49that really becomes the story. That's why you have the midterm election results that you have, is that you had voters who were on board with an agenda, but you have a White House which is on board solely with the man himself who can do no wrong, and only we can admit that wrong if he admits that wrong himself. Again, all of this, to be very fair, again, to many of the critics who are tearing their hair out, listening, yes, much of this was evident from 2016. Some of it was on on display. Yeah. And I've read I've read some of your work from 2020, 2021. And I know you were critical of the president at that time as well and seem to reach a lot of the right conclusions about what kind of person he was, but obviously reached the point where you thought that you could make a different sort of bet in 2024.
8:35But I want to talk specifically about some of the values that brought that coalition together, because it's one thing to talk about the war in the abstract, about affordability in the abstract, as folks have continued to do in the most recent election. But the specific policies that were supposed to achieve these better outcomes, some of these things the president was actually able to do, certainly in terms of closing the border, constraining immigration in a very dramatic way. He seemed to do those things successfully. And then another cornerstone policy of his was the tariffs. Could you talk a little bit about the economic theory there?
9:10Because I think a lot of the conversations about populism, right populism, tend to be pretty abstract. And I get that populism is something of a vibe, a sensibility. But when the rubber hits the road from a policy standpoint, this is where I begin to get a little bit confused. My orientation to conservative politics is I come from a much more personally a libertarian frame of reference. So I am thinking about the kind of Paul Ryan establishment view that is seemingly completely outdated. So help me understand what was supposed to happen with the tariffs because he got those and it doesn't seem to have delivered the goods.
9:49Well, so this is where principle and practice matter quite a great deal. So am I a supporter of tariffs? Absolutely. Will it drive up prices in some limited respects? Yes, that's true. I don't believe that GDP is the only thing to worship at the altar of like Paul Ryan does. I believe that the nation of itself and its strength is ultimately what matters and what should be put forward by its government. Thus, tariffs, let's say, either on China for a targeted and specific way, not just China, many any other country and a way to build up your industrial base. Yes, incurring some inflation in the interim along the way.
10:23I think it's worth it. I challenge you to find somebody who disagrees. Now, when you say he got the tariffs, do you think that the average farmer in Kansas or in Iowa, which, by the way, just voted Democrat, thought that that entailed coming before the Rose Garden with a chart based on what various trade deficits were with no policy process whatsoever that would be announced and which would sink the S &P 500 only to then be renounced on a case by case basis that would be on and off, which effectively froze U.S. imports for over a month. In a few moments, I will sign a historic executive order instituting reciprocal tariffs tariffs on countries throughout the world, reciprocal.
11:09That means they do it to us and we do it to them. Very simple. So this is where you could say, Sagar, you supported tariffs. And I said, yeah, I do support tariffs. Does that mean that I support the way that the Trump administration did tariffs? Absolutely not. And by the way, no serious person does outside of Donald Trump and maybe Peter Navarro. Although I'll be honest, if I actually got to talk to him privately, I doubt even he would defend what ended up happening there. OK, let's talk about immigration. So you're exactly right. And I did say immigration is such an important part of the story.
11:38Obviously, Trump closing the border, I think, is one of the best things that he's done. He has reduced the amount of immigration in this country. Many people, including me, I thought was good for the nation. Now, let's talk about how the way that that went down. So how did the administration handle mass deportation? And let's be clear, we did vote for mass deportation. The sign said mass deportation. So anybody second guessing that the joke is on you, but because clearly you didn't read it whenever it was there at the RNC. Many, many voters, what I've been stunned by is apparently just literally did not read or listen to many of these speeches and just heard whatever they wanted to hear.
12:14And I heard, I think, in the newspaper of this podcast, The New York Times read a story of some woman whose brother was here illegally and was shocked that he was deported, despite the fact that she voted for Donald Trump. However, there's multiple ways in which you can pursue a deportation strategy. One is the Trump administration's way, which was not only to flood blue cities predominantly and to grab people up, but also to express an extraordinary amount of glee in the way that that is done, including posting AI memes and videos and others in the way that they did it. There's a lot of ways actually to pursue self-deportation.
12:47It's very easy. You could easily pass remittance taxes and make sure that you crack down on remittance transfers of a vast number of illegal aliens currently present in our country. You could pass a mandatory e-verify program. You could go after the banks and big business and people who are here illegally with no ICE agent in their face or at their door will just leave because it becomes impossible to conduct business. You could do that. They didn't do that. Right. Because they're ultimately loyal to big business. And I think that gets to the problem here ultimately and how they turned the American people, I think, against the immigration agenda where they made it actually appear the agent of chaos, where the argument in 2024 was that illegal immigration itself is the agent of chaos.
13:27And honestly, that takes an extraordinary amount of, you know, screw ups from the Trump administration. And it's part of why they ultimately fire Kirstie Noem and they bring in Mark Wayne Mullen. And you haven't read many stories like you used to in the initial period. So they agree with me whether they like it or not. And even the vice president does, where he says we can target big business and some of the other agents and others that facilitate illegal immigration. Got it. So there is an element of people just not understanding the policies that were actually on offer in terms of voters who were actually a part of this coalition.
14:01So that could contribute to some disillusionment during the midterms. But there was also just ineptitude, it sounds like you're describing here, that they miscrafted the actual policies that they went ahead and tried to institute. And they had the wrong people instituting these policies. So they were instituted in ways that got people killed, that raised the negative perception of things. And that, as you mentioned, made them seem almost gleeful when executing these policies, even if they happen to hurt people. But beyond tariffs, beyond immigration, there is another issue, corruption, that rated very highly amongst voters.
14:42and I've heard you speak to this issue, but I'm curious exactly what you mean when you say corruption or what you hear when you hear voters talk about corruption. What I hear from the voters is the same thing that you or I understand of what it means to be corrupt. And that's what the previous host of this podcast asked the president in his recent sit down. There's a Forbes story that said that your net worth, maybe it's changed with the stock market recently, but your net worth went up by$3 billion. Well, since you returned to - Okay, you ready? So everyone's my net worth did not go up by three billion dollars.
15:15You should have had stock. I should have. I should have had stock. I should have had stock. Excuse me. So how did I vote? How did it go up? Well, let me explain. I understand that to be spiritually, ethically and potentially legally wrong. Well, now our Supreme Court has defined corruption very narrowly. And so, you know, there's a legal definition here, but it wrestles with the popular populist definition, perhaps, if you will. You're getting rich and I'm getting poor. And at the end of the day, I can't stand that. And, you know, this gets to the cult, the personality issue as well, and perhaps the immense difficulty the vice president faces in the future.
15:50I mean, in a Mark Halperin sit down before the midterms, he is unable to say I believe he said I have seen no evidence of Donald Trump being personally corrupt. There's a separate concern that I sometimes think gets muddled with the first concern, which is that is D.C. just too corrupt of a town? Do people get too rich for knowing the right people? Do they sell access to the president? Now, I've never seen any evidence that anybody's selling access to the president or certainly selling access to me. But like if there's a credible accusation there, I guarantee you the president of the United States is going to be the first person in line to say that's ridiculous and despicable.
16:23And I am, too. That's what he said. OK, good luck with that in 2028, because, again, that's a legalistic answer. That is not a spiritual answer. It's the same spiritual answer that we all say whenever we see congressmen enter with nothing and become multimillionaires. Just doesn't sit right with me. No self-respecting American should be able to stand that, especially when their real wages, their personal life situation, their housing and all of that, their business, any of that could have been negatively affected by the Trump administration. And yet he is getting fantastically wealthy. I mean, it shocks the conscience.
16:57It's the same reason the Hunter Biden scandal did and many of the presidential familial scandals over the last several decades. Although, obviously, this takes all of that times by a thousand. If you look at it, then you've got the individual actions of people like Kimberly Guilfoyle. of Alina Habba, of his son, who's sitting on the boards of these companies and pursuing all of these deals with the Pentagon. And, you know, to cover my own situation here, I am not alleging that that is legal corruption. I'm speaking to the way that the voters understand it as an issue. Certainly. At a moment, there's a stench of corruption, an appearance of corruption that I think is kind of easy to identify.
17:34And it's something that voters definitely notice. I wonder, though, beyond the corruption, this right populism seems very much at odds with a president who gets elected and begins using the levers of power to enrich himself. And I wonder if this isn't a potential blind spot for the right populist movement and the new right that I've seen kind of emerge, which generally seems much more interested in how to wield power and how to accrue as much power as possible, but has very little interest in what might go wrong once that power has accrued, both with respect to your own party and betraying your values, but also once you're in the political wilderness, they may come after you.
18:18They may use those same tools and they themselves might be abusive and corrupt in different ways. Absolutely. I mean, look, this is a philosophical question we've debated since Trump came on the scene in 2015. I had this argument, I think, with Ben Shapiro once. He said, ask me what the limiting principle was. The limiting principle is democracy. Okay. And I actually think you just saw it at the ballot box where Trump suffers a historic midterm defeat. I don't worship limited government. And it's specifically because I think that this philosophical question undermines the ability to deliver as a government for the people.
18:51And obviously, I'm not a Reaganite conservative, period. And this is part of the reason why. By the way, you know, every single one of those people who talks about limited government would max out the Pentagon budget to two trillion. So spare me a little bit of your discussion. Well, not me. Sure, but let's talk about the political reality of how that governs in practice. This is about libertarianism in the tax code and about basically big government whenever it comes to defense contractors. So they believe in plenty of big government on their side. I think all I do is want a little bit of a reallocation of said government.
19:25If I can put a pause on you for a moment, there's a sense in which we're both kind of advocating for these aspirational kinds of politics. We have to elect the right people who aren't going to overinvest in the Pentagon, who aren't going to regulate the markets in ways that would perhaps benefit themselves more than the broader economy. me, we're both hoping that the right kinds of people get elected. I think that the reality is, however, if I'm aiming for that kind of limited government thing and providing a lot of space for the kind of competitive landscape to emerge, that I'm going to err in a different sort of way than someone who is advocating for a much more muscular executive branch that has the power to do all manner of things potentially, but only ever gets around to doing things incompetently in the one case and in another case corruptly.
20:17Right. See, Camille, this is where what I would challenge you with is like you said, you talked about the downsides because what you're looking at are the downsides of a muscular government. I would point to the downsides of basically neoliberal capitalist agenda, which this country has suffered under from the 1990s onward. And so you may point to the fact that the television I'm looking for at right now costs, I think,$150,$200. And yet, You know, our mortgage rates are seven point two percent. Our homes are dramatically more expensive than ever compared to the median. The S &P 500, by the way, in the time that I laid out, there is up.
20:52I don't even know the number well over a thousand percent. And let's get to my Democratic, you know, limiting principle argument. Well, I think that that's been explicitly rejected at the ballot box. I mean, Biden was one of the most unpopular presidents before Donald Trump. The S &P 500 was great. If you own stock to borrow Trump's to borrow Trump's phrase, you should have owned stock. I own stock under Biden, did phenomenally well. Did that mean that I thought that the country did well under him? Absolutely not. So that's what the market, I think, delivered. The market delivers. It certainly does.
21:21Delivers for, I think, a smaller slice of people. I don't think it is in any way shaped or created a system which has delivered genuine prosperity, I think, for the median American. Again, many of the neoliberals and others will be furious for me saying that I don't accept that an iPhone and a MacBook and a television being cheaper is better when high health care premiums are dramatically going up the home prices. I think the entire system is stacked against people who are my age and in particular, even younger. I really, really feel for them. And so that's where, you know, I had this big grand debate at that time in 2016, 2017.
21:57Kind of the line that I came up with is that I think a corporation can be just as much, if not more so, of a threat to your liberty as the government itself. And whenever it comes to checking the power of that corporation, then the government is the only democratic answer that we have. You are not a shareholder in every company, but you are a shareholder in this country if you're a citizen and if you can vote. And that is how you can exercise ultimately the small amount of power that you have left in an era where you are governed by these dramatically rich and powerful people.
22:38Hey, I'm Robert Vinlo and I'm from New York Times Games and I'm here talking to people about Wordle and the Wordle Archive. You all play Wordle? Yeah. I have something exciting to show you. Oh, okay. It's the Wordle Archive. Oh! Oh! And you keep your... So if I miss it, I can go back. 100%. Oh, that's sick. So now you can play every Wordle that has ever existed. There's like a thousand puzzles. Oh my god, I love it! Amazing. New York Times Games subscribers can now access the entire Wordle Archive. Find out more at nytimes.com slash games. Can we talk a little bit more about the current circumstance?
23:12At the moment, we have a left populism and a right populism, and the energetic, electorally successful party seems to be the kind of left populist vision. I'm curious if you could maybe define what those two things are and help me understand how the right populist vision is different. Are you concerned about the fact that, say, El-Sayed, for example, is the standard bearer, perhaps, for that left populist vision and may become a very prominent force in our politics? Is that a good thing for your vision of the world or a bad thing? Are you competing directly with him or are you potentially allies?
23:52I think if I had to really come up with a difference between the two is that leftists, left populism is fundamentally, I guess the way I would describe it is it doesn't prioritize the nation as the primary. Right. And so with right populism, it's about the nation. Now, I think what's made things a little bit different is that this current iteration of some of these left populists have adopted what used to be seen as a right wing framework of the nation as the preeminent and the most important thing to ascribe to. So Abdul El-Sayed, for example, literally put me in an ad describing him as America first.
24:32Don't want to take my word for it. How about some folks you know a little bit better? It's campaign now. It's America first. And there's a reason that he did not only that, but he also stood in front of the American flag. And when he spoke about issues of foreign aid or other, he spoke about the direct expense of our taxpayer. So things are changing dramatically. And like I said, I mean, it's issue by issue basis. By the way, I interviewed Abdul the couple of days before his election. The question is, are you a woke 1.0 guy or are you a guy who actually cares about affordability? The big question really is, what is government for?
25:05What is our politics really about? And I think there are a lot of people who want to distract us from the fact that our politics have not addressed the material needs of our lives by trying to make politics about cultural war. We actually sparred on cultural issues. So if you really want to know the biggest difference separating somebody between me or Abdul or Zoran, a lot of it comes down to the culture war. But really what I would describe in your question when you're talking about right populism, I mean, right populism as an agenda based movement is dead under Donald Trump. And the reason why is that it was subsumed and perhaps always was effectively just a cult of personality around Trump himself.
25:41And that's a complete loss, obviously, for any political project that I believed in. And also, I think a huge problem facing the Republican Party really going forward is that because Trump aligns everything around himself as the sun and the moon and the stars, it creates the ideological space for people like Abdul El-Sayed or Zoran Mamdani or others to come in and to fill that gap. I would really point you to the work that Abdul and Zoran did, where they spent significant and inordinate amounts of time speaking to people who voted for Donald Trump. Did you get a chance to vote on Tuesday? Yes.
26:15And who did you vote for? Trump. Ah, the million dollar question. Trump. Trump. Donald Trump. A lot of it was affordability. And from that point is the affordability really as a moniker born, I think. But also is about, you know, the critique of foreign entanglements, in particular, when we get into this war in Iran and so much of kind of the Israel worship that dominates so much of the GOP. And so that gives them the ability to connect the cost of living issue to the foreign entanglements that we now face ahead of us. And because Trump has cast such a different version of himself personally, it creates this opportunity for the left to really fill in that negative vacuum.
26:54American politics of recent has largely been negative elections. And what I mean by that is that they are negative responses to the people in power. You have Bush, then you have Obama, then you have Trump, then you have Biden, then you have Trump. Like, what's the story that people are trying to tell us? How exactly does a Latino population of South Texas swing over 70 points in a two year period? You can only describe that as a rejection of the status quo. And then similarly, right, similarly before that is that these people voted for Hillary Clinton and then they voted for Donald Trump eight years later.
27:28This is about swinging back and forth and waiting for somebody to seize the mantle and to deliver because this is still where we are. Like what we've just seen happen in the most recent election. These are not durable gains for Democrats. This could absolutely evaporate. Of course it could. How can you have looked at an election in 2024 where Trump wins a popular vote and then loses the state of time? I'm from Texas. I'm still grappling with what happened in my home state. How did the James Tallarico win by 12? I can't even talk about it without almost laughing. It is a laughable concept to me from the paradigm that I grew up in.
28:04OK, just to show you how long it has been since there has been Democratic statewide rule in the state. And now Ted Cruz is the only one standing by. But same thing. I think it's a very hopeful story. Actually, it shows that the American people are absolutely willing to punish the status quo rapidly if you do not deliver. So that's the story. I want to talk about philosophy a little bit more because you mentioned Texas. Very soon we'll have James Tellurico and Ted Cruz being the Senate delegation from Texas. It's hard to imagine two more different men from a philosophical and political standpoint.
28:38I'm curious which one of those men you are closer to politically at this stage. Because Ted Cruz, when I heard, I watched him give brief remarks after the midterms and he promised that Texas will be red again. We are going to turn Texas around. Texas will be red again, and we are going to turn this country around. But he also seemed to be embodying a kind of Reaganite conservatism when he was articulating this vision for Texas becoming red again. Very different from the kind of populist rhetoric you're talking about. So I'm curious which one of these men is closer to your particular worldview now.
29:19Because as I hear you talk about it, there are some social issues that you're concerned about, the culture war stuff. Is that the only thing that still makes you a conservative? So I guess the question is difficult because, I mean, ultimately what divides American politics is the culture issue, right? You know, I would agree with Ted Cruz on some things. I would agree with James Tallarico on others. I need to see Tallarico govern, first of all. I have no idea who this guy is going to end up being. He's kind of an interesting figure. He's talked a big game on some of the economic populist issues.
29:50Let's see how he votes. obviously he's now representing the eighth largest economy in the world and uh you know so he's got a lot of business interests also yeah that he has to balance i i'm i'm gonna hold my judgment before i see james tallarico and how he operates can we dig into some of those cultural issues that you have concerns about with with the left in particular it seems yeah sure could you just articulate them for me immigration is going to be the number one right because i think uh immigration in particular they are just uh yeah right obviously we did talk about that and you know they believe in amnesty.
30:21And I think that not only they believe in amnesty, they believe in higher levels of immigration going forward, somewhere around the 1 million level that we were before Donald Trump. That's going to be one of the biggest issues. But the second issue really is, you know, it's not, I think a lot of it is traditional, gender, race, kind of disagreements. Whenever we saw the left really believe that they had achieved not only electoral, but kind of a cultural victory over the Trump administration, kind of Trumpism or the right wing in the country. And that's when you actually saw the most egregious Biden policies or even Democratic policies necessarily come forward.
30:55Crime certainly would be another one, although they have changed their tune on this. I am curious to see where things go for them. I have a theory of politics where it's much easier to be an emergent left when crime is low. So, yeah, I think and I hope I'm not trying to dodge your question or any of that, but I'm trying to lay them out. So immigration and the gender fights race also. I mean, I believe really ultimately in a completely race blind society. I don't believe in affirmative action. I don't believe in many of these post civil rights kind of extra constitutional creations that maybe have been necessary.
31:31were at the time I wasn't alive and I won't be there to kind of articulate it, but I will in 2026. I think Camille, you know, you agree with me on some of these things. And so really, I think that's still what separates. And, you know, one of the big debates I've had with my co-host, Crystal, and with the left today is, you know, okay, you know, you guys said woke one was crazy. What do you actually disagree with from woke one? And that gets a little bit different. I think Like whenever you start to dig down issue by issue, I'm like, okay, do you still believe in affirmative action? Do you still believe in some of those, you know, majority black by law districts?
32:07You don't think that that violates, you know, the spirit of the constitution or race blind society? That's the policy that you are articulating and which we'll have to fight about.
32:28Yeah, there's two things at least I want to try to get to before we run out of time here. But specifically, you mentioned race and gender there. And I think we do generally agree. I'm interested in a meritocracy. I see people as individuals and not representatives of particular groups. I don't think it's best for our politics to be oriented in that way. and that that's been a concern for me and it was primarily a concern with respect to the way the left was approaching politics but there has been a kind of emergent identitarian right that has seen a renewed kind of prominence in our politics and i don't want to overstate this i don't think most conservatives um are are obsessed with this movement but it's undeniable that there is something, a very pronounced sense of perhaps it's a rejection of wokeness in response.
33:21I hate the phrase, but I use it to try to illustrate things in a way that's understandable. And I'm curious if this is something that's on your radar, if it's something that concerns you, if you think that this is likely to be a kind of persistent trend going forward, or if perhaps it's ebbing. Oh, well, I think it will be persistent because the internet and the way the algorithm works. And here's what I would say to those people. You had your shot and you called it. You called it in the state of Texas. His name was Beau French. All right. Beau French put out that picture. I'm sure he saw it. We took a picture of some Indian kids at a UT game and he was like, wow, you know, I'd heard the problem was bad at Texas.
33:59I had no idea. What happened in the state of Texas, Camille? What happened? Right. They went Democrat by over 10. Now the cope that they're going to offer is like, well, every statewide office holder was rejected. But here's what I knew that I think you know, too, is that identitarianism of any kind is repulsive to the median American. And so I don't talk in the language of groups. I don't I don't talk about the Indian community because it doesn't really exist. And if it does, I don't want to be part of it because I don't want to be a part of any race based community. What it what happened is that the median white Texan, the median Latino Texan are repulsed by that.
34:37Right. The median black Texan, I think I would say as well, people across all races. And that is something that I think that they will continue to learn if they want to embrace this, is that identity politics of any kind is repulsive to the median American. It's why critical race theory was so dramatically unpopular. I mean, I think they will learn the same lesson, is that algorithmically boosted race identity. Sure, it sounds fun, must be fun to post in replies. And I'm sure many will be in the comments section here. But I remain faithful in the American people who, regardless, have always, I think, in recent times rejected any true embrace of identitarism and find it repulsive.
35:20I should note, you know, I didn't even mention free speech, which is so crazy, considering how important of an issue it is to you and I, Camille, because remember how much the Trump administration used censorship, left-wing censorship and cancel culture as a dominating and animating issue. I can't I actually can't overstate how important it was, at least to the small demographic of people that I can at least claim to be an expert in podcasting. Right. Is a specific demographic that we kind of speak to in some cases. Right. And that was a major animating issue, a feeling of overwhelming political correctness in our government and in our culture.
35:57And what did the Trump administration do? The Trump administration effectively has Ibrahim X. Kendi's dream of a department of anti-racism, but renamed it the Department of Anti-Semitism in the DOJ, pursuing small-scale cases that would put Obama to shame if it happened to be some sort of anti-Black incident or something like that. And so they've embraced it too. They've also used the machinery of government to pursue their own identitarianism. And I think people find that just as disgusting as when it was done previously. I actually think your analysis there is correct in a lot of respects. I think it is the case that a lot of the pronounced concern that I've encountered recently about antisemitism has an inflection of what I was seeing in terms of the excesses of wokeness in 2020 and 2021, where pretty much anything could be called racist.
36:50but it's also the case that there has been a meaningful increase in the amount of anti-Semitism that we've seen. And there can be a lot of complicated reasons for why that's happening. But one of the reasons is because people are talking in these kind of categorical ways about Israel, about Jews in different contexts. But the specific thing that I've noticed, and it's something that I actually wanted to ask you about, because I know you have a relationship with Tucker Carlson. And I've heard Tucker talk about these things in many instances. And the thing that I think many people are uncomfortable with is when they hear descriptions of the relationship between the U.S.
37:29and Israel that place a particular emphasis on Israel having this kind of control over the United States. And it almost sounds, it has a conspiratorial edge to it. And it also doesn't really seem to comport with the facts fully in my estimation. The reality of things is not one where Israel is simply dictating terms to the United States and then the United States is carrying out attacks on behalf of Israel. There have been, even in the past 12 months or so, in the past several months, pretty serious dust-ups between the administration and their Israeli counterparts. It feels like if it's a complicated relationship where there are of these kind of mutual interests, why not acknowledge that complexity?
38:14Should we be more careful about the way that we're talking about that particular relationship and its importance on the foreign policy stage? Well, Camille, I can only speak for myself. I believe in individuals. And so I always am the first person to point out this is Trump's fault. Trump is the idiot who listened to B.B. OK. And so, yeah, I blame B.B. a lot for many of the things that he's done throughout the course of the last several years of his prime ministership. But ultimately, it's Trump who agreed with Bibi and decided to go along with him. So I don't think that he is, quote, controlled by Bibi.
38:48However, and this is where, you know, I would really point you to kind of a democratic understanding. If you have a war, which nobody wants necessarily outside of a small group of people in Washington and the Israeli government, and many of the president's own advisors, save for maybe one or two, don't want that war. And you go along with said war. Could you maybe forgive people for saying, wow, this seems really weird and strange? And then let's talk about the fact that we have multiple state laws on the books across the nation, which are against BDS. Now, I'm not going to say it is a control in terms of they are dictating every single thing that we do.
39:24But there's a level of subservience, which is voluntary, to be clear, on behalf of U.S. policymakers, which strikes many citizens as odd. And so that's really where I think the difference kind of comes down to is you're speaking and I get it, you know, to a conspiratorial understanding, which is going to enhance anti-Semitism. And that's abhorrent and it's wrong. And again, because I believe in individuals and, you know, I would even point to the fact that many Jewish Americans voted for Abdul El-Sayed. how many Jewish voters actually supported Zoran Mamdani. I believe New York City is one of the largest Jewish cities in the world, actually, by population, just again to set the table for some of the critics.
40:05And so I find the entire discussion kind of difficult because, you know, with great respect, I hear so much about that challenge. But when I just laid out all those things that has happened, you know, in our country, and you could say on behalf or voluntarily, kind of with the nation of Israel and this incredible kind of rhetorical subservience and relationship, which is pursued by many of these politicians. You know, you can forgive people, I think, for speaking the way that they have, or at least I can, as long as it is not genuinely anti-Semitic, of which is abhorrent and wrong in all cases.
40:43Yeah, I can appreciate that. I think if there was, in general, a real commitment to regarding people as individuals, evading these kind of categorical denunciations and really just avoiding the sort of vague speculation and confronting the broader kind of conspiratorial attitude that I think is precipitating so much of our politics these days, we'd probably be much better off. But I want to kind of pivot to just look forward a little bit, because I'm very curious about your perspective on what is coming for Republicans, what's likely to happen in the future. At the moment, we see J.D. Vance, by some accounts, who seems to be trying to distance himself from some of the foreign policy failures of the Trump administration, which I think is going to be a very difficult road to hoe.
41:29Ted Cruz has come up. What vision of the future do you suspect is likely to be successful for Republicans going forward? Should they be embracing? I know you're skeptical of the kind of Reaganite perspective, but is there perhaps an abundance bro version of conservatism that might be successful going forward? What could they possibly do at this point to compete? the problem with that question is it supposes that it's a policy question it's a trump question so let's take jd for example jd puts out his tweet he puts out the long essay the reason was the war trump kind of backs it but what does he say in his very first comments when he's asked about it well a lot of people didn't like it but i didn't care i think i've known and covered trump i was a white house correspondent i covered him down day out for years so i i know what he's trying to say when he says that.
42:21I'm reading a story this morning about Vance 2028, the same exact position. Somebody says, the question is not which Republican can win, but can any Republican win? And inside, there's a little nugget where they talk about how Trump privately has been a little upset about the vice president's comments. And actually, he even articulated that publicly because what did he say? He said the only thing he missed is he should have said is that this was an important war or one of the greatest things that I've done as president. And so what does that show? There can be no distance between Trump and you, regardless of who you are.
42:53The way I've always described it is how can J.D. answer the question that sunk Kamala in the 2024 election? She was on The View, and I forget which host asked her. She said, which, you know, do you have any policies that you disagree with? Would you have done anything different from Biden? If anything, would you have done something differently than President Biden during the past four years? there is not a thing that comes to mind and she couldn't name one and do you know how much that hurt her with the american people it was in every ad over and over again can jd say the same he can hint at it he can point to it he can try and yet at the end of the day trump will always demand absolute 100 loyalty especially on his most unpopular decisions as president because he's vain and he's narcissistic and ultimately it's about him and so that is that belies this entire policy discussion.
43:48But this is a historically unpopular president across the board. And within the Republican movement itself, he may still have some popularity, but two years removed from today. Do you suspect that will really still be the case in the same sort of way that he'll command the same sort of authority even within the party? Look, I don't see a world where remaining Republican primary voters where the median age is a 50 something year old, you know, with a non-college degree, you really think that that person is going to like leave Trump, especially, by the way, if you're all if you're still engaged in Republican politics, if you're still engaged with Trump at this point, you know, everybody else is left.
44:30So if you're still left at this point, I'm not really sure what else could kind of kick you out of the tent. And if Trump gets into a fight, not with J.D., with Ron DeSantis or some other Republican candidate who's challenging him. I just don't see any evidence yet that there's a large Republican bloc who's willing to buck. I mean, polls tell us that a large percentage of Republicans disagree with the Iran war. And yet when Thomas Massey's primary comes around, they all come and they vote and they vote out Thomas Massey, right, for standing up to him on two things, Epstein and Iran. So what does that tell you, you know, about those primary victories.
45:04Look, there will be a test as the primaries and the presidency emerges. But I think this most recent dust up between Trump and Vance, even if it is a dust up. I mean, let's look at the timeline. Vance puts out the statement. Trump is asked about it. He very clearly is personally annoyed. He's annoyed that Vance doesn't defend the Iran war. And then there's another part of the story, which I didn't even mention. He puts out an emasculating truth social posts. And he says, what? Vice President Vance is no longer on the Iran portfolio. I've told him to go in his focus on. Yeah. What does that tell you about the consequences for this?
45:39How long do Republicans stay in the wilderness then? Because what you're describing does not sound like a party that is likely to win anything. However badly Democrats may screw things up if they are simply devoted to a man who is increasingly unpopular and who, in many respects, seems very disinterested in even governing in a serious way. What does that mean for Republicans? As long as Trump is alive? Look, that's a reductive question because anything can happen. Maybe he'll end the war. Maybe it'll be over. Maybe inflation will drop as a result. Maybe JD has a shot. Maybe the Democrats nominate AOC, right?
46:14Maybe something. Who knows? I mean, he's 80 years old. Who knows what's going to happen to him? Look at the Democratic leaders. So anything can happen. So it's just not it's I can only speak from the time period of where we're at today. I see no evidence that the average Republican primary voter is going to ditch Donald Trump for an affirmative critique of that presidency. I don't see it yet. And I don't think that he will handle that and that they will vote accordingly. So in the interim, as long as he's around, they're going to have a Trump problem. Will that sink them? I have no idea. I'm wrong all the time.
46:45Sagar Anjeti, thank you so much for joining me. Thanks for having me.
46:55Thank you.
After a bruising midterm defeat, Donald Trump’s Republican Party is in shambles. Does that mean the promise of a more populist G.O.P. is dead? Or will a new anti-establishment coalition arise from the ashes of the Trump era?
Saagar Enjeti, the co-host of Breaking Points, joins guest host Kmele Foster to discuss the past, present and future of MAGA.
Note: As we work on relaunching “Interesting Times,” the show will feature a series of guest hosts in the coming months.
(A full transcript of this episode is available on the Times website.)
Thoughts? Email us at [email protected]. Please subscribe to our YouTube Channel, Interesting Times.
Subscribe today at nytimes.com/podcasts or on Apple Podcasts, Spotify and Amazon Music. You can also subscribe via your favorite podcast app here https://www.nytimes.com/activate-access/audio?source=podcatcher. For more podcasts and narrated articles, download The New York Times app at nytimes.com/app.
Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.