

Suzanne Somers’ career comeback in 1991 and her rise as a direct-to-consumer “fitness/weight loss” celebrity, centered on the Thighmaster, followed by her later shift into diet books and cancer/“toxins” claims, including hormone-replacement commentary.
Michael Hobbs (podcaster/health commentator; discusses exercise marketing and fact-checking medical claims). Aubrey Gordon (podcast cohost; focuses on cultural/marketing angles and critiques of health misinformation).
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
A brief overview of Suzanne Somers' early career and challenges in Hollywood.
“As a little refresher, can you remind the people where we left off with Suzanne Somers?”
Discussion of Somers' return to television with the sitcom 'Step by Step'.
“Which is the year of her triumphant return to primetime television.”
Analyzing the cultural footprint of 'Step by Step' compared to other shows.
“And another is arguably the biggest impact that Suzanne Somers made on sort of cultural memory, which is the Thighmaster.”
Exploration of Somers' various projects including her memoir and business ventures in 1991.
“And it says, squeeze, squeeze your way to a shapely figure.”
Introduction to the Thighmaster and its significance in Suzanne Somers' career.
“So there's sort of a hinge in the middle and those two wings that when you press them together give you some resistance.”
Discussion about the marketing strategies used for the Thighmaster and its reception.
“I thought I'd never fit into these jeans again.”
Hosts react to the Thighmaster ad and discuss its implications in pop culture.
“The chief marketer of the Thighmaster wrote a book about the marketing of the Thighmaster.”
Explore how infomercials target feelings of isolation and impulsive buying.
“people always think that infomercials are about selling to people who are gullible that's not what it is it's about selling to people who are isolated god he like admits this yes he says it out loud.”
Discuss the emergence of body image concerns related to thighs and fitness marketing.
“any of this stuff at this point thighs in particular were increasingly an area of concern for a few reasons.”
Learn about the marketing strategies focused on 'problem areas' in fitness.
“It wasn't just that this machine or this workout would make you thin.”
Detail the Thighmaster's rise in popularity and its marketing success.
“Well, and a bunch of them were Thighmaster spinoff products.”
Investigate the true inventor of the Thighmaster and her story.
“Of course, Suzanne Summers was the face of the product and she and her husband, Alan, bought out the other business partners.”
Learn about Anne-Marie Benstrom, the physical therapist behind the Thighmaster.
“At the time, she was treating 10 skiers who all had leg fractures.”
Explore Suzanne Somers' journey into fitness and diet marketing.
“And this woman was straightforwardly the inventor.”
Explore Suzanne Somers' dietary approach and her various diet books.
“She's not a huge on calorie counting, nor even on super restrictive portions.”
Discussing the motivations behind Somers' diet books and her business ventures.
“Suzanne Somers' Fast and Easy Cookbook for Summer-Sized Recipes.”
Analyzing the reviews and reception of Suzanne Somers' one-woman show on Broadway.
“She's like way into her sort of diet book writing world.”
How increased paparazzi attention affected Suzanne Somers' public image.
“This is Spider-Man turn off the dark levels of like, oh, nobody wants it.”
Discussing Suzanne Somers' controversial health claims and misdiagnosis.
“The combination of a correct diagnosis, like having cancer once, and then later thinking she has cancer again, but not actually having it seems to be sort of like the radioactive spider that bit her.”
Examining the backlash against Somers for promoting alternative cancer treatments.
“She also interviews a doctor named Stanislaw Brzezinski, a Houston physician who treated well over 10 ,000 cancer patients before being disciplined by the Texas Medical Board for misinforming those cancer patients.”
Exploring the media's role in amplifying Suzanne Somers' cancer claims.
“If it sounds wrong to you, that's because it is wrong.”
Exploration of how diet, stress, and lifestyle impact cancer risk.
“In your research, is there any correlation, environment, weather kind of thing as far as these illnesses go?”
Discussion of Suzanne Somers' controversial remarks about cancer and chemotherapy.
“the corners of her mouth oh my god so after this she just starts talking about cancer in general as if she is a cancer expert.”
Insights into Somers' advocacy for bioidentical HRT and its implications.
“It's impossible to say the name of the book.”
Critique of the Wiley Protocol and the implications of its promotion by Somers.
“Like, this is the information environment in which Suzanne Summers is like, hold tight, everybody.”
Learn about Suzanne Somers' promotion of bioidentical hormone therapy and the controversy surrounding it.
“And then like sweet potato for every meal.”
Explore Somers' unconventional views on the Sandy Hook shooting and her critiques of the Affordable Care Act.
“Do you have any guesses, by the way, 2013?”
Examine Somers' political statements and the inaccuracies in her quotes regarding healthcare.
“I did track down the origin of the fake Lennon quote because that will pop up from time to time.”
Discussion on the societal expectations and pressures individuals face, particularly regarding personal struggles and resilience.
“And my class was one of the last years that you had to write an entire epic poem using all the rules of epic poems.”
Analysis of Suzanne Somers' legacy, focusing on her health and wellness claims compared to her acting career.
“So why don't you want to get paid that little?”
Discussion about the potential dangers of spreading misinformation in health and wellness, and its impact on public perception.
“significantly longer than she was an actress, right?”
Examination of the connection between health narratives, conservative politics, and the implications for public policy.
“At the very least, even if they didn't die, right?”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On Maintenance Phase, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:11Welcome to Main's Phase, the podcast that wants you to squeeze and release. Squeeze and release. That sounds like we're doing Kegels. Is that the Phi Master though? That is kind of, yeah, absolutely. Kind of. Absolutely. I am very surprised that you didn't just go with Suzanne Tuzan. Oh. which is how I've been thinking about it in my own brain. Two Su's, two's Anne, no. I'm Michael Humps. I'm Aubrey Gordon. If you would like to support the show, you can do that at patreon.com slash maintenance phase. You can also subscribe on Apple Podcasts. It is the same audio content. Michael. Aubrey. As a little refresher, can you remind the people where we left off with Suzanne Somers?
0:55What did we sort of broadly learn last time? Suzanne Somers, beautiful woman, grew up in a terrible home environment, eventually moved to LA, and then went on a sitcom and became like America's sweetheart quite rapidly. And then they fired her because she wanted to be paid currency for goods and services. And then I think when we left off, she's like late stage. She's kind of like gone through the Hollywood ringer. Yep. And she's sort of looking for a new chapter. Yes, all of that is correct. After Three's Company, she's sort of down and out in Hollywood. She's still working, definitely, but it's a far cry from, you know, being on the cover of like so many magazines and being in like one of the biggest TV shows every week.
1:40She spends several years performing in Las Vegas, doing USO tour shows and writing her second book, which is a very popular memoir about being the adult child of an alcoholic. So we are picking back up with Suzanne Somers in 1991. Okay. Which is the year of her triumphant return to primetime television. first she gets a starring role in step by step which was a family sitcom that was part of abc's tgif the year that step by step premiered they premiered at 8 30 on fridays for tgif their lead in was family matters and they were followed up by dinosaurs oh yeah i'm the baby that show is like such a cult classic the only thing i love more than step by step was dinosaurs yeah and it was only after like one season or something, but like everyone our age remembers it extremely vividly.
2:36So on Step by Step, she played opposite Patrick Duffy from Dallas. So this was like a couple of real 80s TV blockbuster stars sort of at their height. What was the premise of Step by Step again? That Suzanne Somers and Patrick Duffy both had children from previous relationships. I believe Patrick Duffy was a widower. Suzanne Somers might also have been a widow. You weren't having divorced leads on a TV show. Yeah, we realized we're not compatible, and that can't see the light of day. Yeah. Step by Step ran from 1991 to 1998 and made 160 episodes. It was a huge hit by any measure and at a real high point in network primetime TV.
3:27What is funny, though, is it's kind of a forgot buster in that that show has like 10 times the success of dinosaurs and like one tenth the cultural footprint. That's right. I have not heard someone mention Step by Step since it went off the air. Like, oh, that reminds me of that episode of Step by Step. Like, it just disappeared from the zeitgeist completely. Didn't make the cut in the cultural memory. Yes, completely. So Step by Step premiered in 1991. And that is the same year that ABC aired Keeping Secrets, a two hour made for TV movie based on Suzanne's memoir. Oh, wow. 1991 is also a big year for her because you sort of like get the sense that she has been through this three's company ringer and she's like, never again.
4:13Yeah, I will never be sort of hung out to dry in this particular way ever again. So she is like sending out little runners in a bunch of different directions for her career. One is step by step. Another is writing these books. Another is this made for TV movie. And another is arguably the biggest impact that Suzanne Somers made on sort of cultural memory, which is the Thighmaster. I think that it is true what you said. And it's also very funny that she has this like two decades long career in hollywood and like what she is remembered for is this like goofy exercise product yes that is like extremely basic extremely sort of silly in a funny way yeah michael what do you know about the thigh master oh aubrey oh aubrey what don't i know about the thigh master good it was a staple of like late night tv advertisements It was a weird little kind of paperclip shaped object with like foam on it that you put between your legs and you squeeze it to strengthen your like inner thighs or something.
5:21It reminds me of like how Alton Brown says you shouldn't buy kitchen gadgets with only like one purpose. It only does one thing. Thighmaster always struck me as the weirdest fucking thing. It's like it's one exercise. Like you sit in front of the TV or whatever and you squeeze your legs shut and like I guess this will help you lose weight or something. but it's like it's one exercise i don't know the funny thing is you're saying that this is a single tasker and they pretty aggressively advertised it as a multitasker okay it's a two task thing you put it under your arm you put it between your arms you put it behind your knee no one is doing the chicken wing as they're sitting there watching tv no way that's right well and it's called the thigh master you know what i mean so you're like buddies what so i just sent you a picture of the original Thighmaster in its box.
6:09Yes. Oh, yeah, it's her. You know, like a 80s leotard lying down, saucily. And then, yeah, there's this goofy object, which is just like, yeah, it's got blue wings and like a little red ball in the middle. And it says, squeeze, squeeze your way to a shapely figure. And there's a quote on the front with Suzanne Sommer's signature that says, you won't believe how fast you'll see results with the amazing Thighmaster system. I love that it's a system. Suzanne, it's a system. How dare you? The system is this one thing that you do sometimes. Squeeze your legs together. Squeeze your way to a shapely figure, Michael!
6:47I will say, graphic design-wise, a Nobel Prize for the person who came up with the font of the word Thighmaster. Like, the first letter of it is very thick, like extra bold, and then the letters get skinnier and skinnier as the word goes on. So by the time it gets to the final R, it's like really skinny. It's like a sans serif, like contemporary font. It's the font from Thinner, from the movie Thinner. It's so good. The letters start out fat and then they get thin, Michael. Yeah, and then they get thin, just like the system. Which is also wild because it is sold as a toner. It's not a weight loss device in any meaningful way.
7:27What's the difference though? What's a toner mean? What does that mean? That it's giving you muscle tone, but it's not necessarily like claiming to cause fat loss, right? That would have to be like some level of like aerobic exercise or whatever. This is doing resistance training. Right, but muscle tone only on your inner thighs. Yep, classic. I have like the most ripped inner thighs imaginable. Yeah, idiot. That's how it works.
7:53So you're exactly right. Like it's a very simple device. It's a spring-based resistance training tool, right? So there's sort of a hinge in the middle and those two wings that when you press them together give you some resistance. It's a very straightforward device. It's easy to manufacture. It's easy to ship. It's easy to store, right? What was the original price? I'm so glad you asked, Michael. It sold for$19.95 plus$4.50 shipping. So is that like$50 or something in today's money? It's like$25 in 1991. So it's about$60. Okay, 60 bucks. So the Thighmaster was a direct to consumer product that was advertised primarily on TV.
8:35Today, we have like, whatever, Helix mattresses and MeUndies and a bajillion direct to consumer products. In the 90s, there were plenty of direct to consumer products. They were advertised through TV. And I think they were broadly seen as like a little bit schlocky. I mean, I don't know that there was a period where Thighmasters were like cool and then people started making fun of them. I think people started making fun of them immediately. Yes. A little bit shake weight style. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yes. We'll get there. But like, there was a bunch of like jokes about it on like Murphy Brown and on late night shows and on blah, blah, blah.
9:10And people would ask Suzanne Summers how she felt about how much people were making fun of it. And she was like, it's great. People learn about it. But yeah, cash those checks, Suzanne. Yeah. There was one ad in particular for the Thighmaster. It was their first ad. It was absolutely everywhere on TV for years and years and years. Michael, would you like to watch the ad? Yes, yes, yes. I'm so excited, Mike. This is where we get to watch all the fun, schlocky TV shit. Hell yes. I'm so stoked about the amount of TV you and I are about to watch. Great legs. Thank you. How do you get them? I used to do aerobics till I dropped.
9:49Then I found Thighmaster. Every single time you squeeze Thighmaster, you strengthen and tone right where you need it. So it's easy to squeeze, squeeze your way to shape the hips and thighs. I thought I'd never fit into these jeans again. Thank you, Thighmaster. Hell yeah. I recommend it and use it. The piece with the shape of the thighs is exercising these muscles. Just the right resistance. This balance resistance coil is designed to give you results quickly and comfortably. Want to tone your upper chest and arms? No one is doing this. A thigh master will give you excellent results. No one is doing curls.
10:20Thigh master, we may not have been born with great legs, but now we can look like we were. To order your thigh master, call 1-800-421-2000. Have your credit card ready or send check a money order for$19.95 plus$4.50 for shipping and handling to this address. No CODs, please. No CODs. It's like a prescription drug ad now. Call right now. We'll also send you Suzanne Slender. If I like, plan absolutely free. So call now for a quick delivery. slender for life plan it's a system aubrey it's not a diet it's a lifestyle tell me what you think about this ad michael so the best thing about it i mean it's kind of a classic 80s like exercise gadget ad whatever but like it opens with susan sommer's looking great and then it cuts to her sitting on the couch in like an exercise leotard but still sitting and doing like the thigh master leg squeezes squeeze squeezing isn't the whole point of these kinds of things is like you could be wearing like jeans and a t-shirt at home and doing you're putting on exercise gear to then sit on the couch and do it it's a workout michael and then it cut to some like buff people like you can use it for all kinds of exercises and it was a man trying to do bicep curls with it yeah but in like this unbelievably weird goofy way where you can just tell like it does not work for bicep curls the thigh master was inexpensive you know what's less expensive than a thigh master free weights No, dude, totally.
11:39I'll tell you the thing that caught my eye about this commercial is at the end, she says, we may not have been born with great legs, but now we can look like we were. And I'm like, Suzanne, Suzanne. Suzanne, you were born with great legs. You were born with these legs. These are not, you did not have a thigh master on Three's Company. No. working out and being at the gym has been zero part of her story up until this point. I was just going to ask you about this. Was exercise like a big part of her life? No. We haven't like mentioned it at all. Nope. Not that she wrote about in her memoirs. Not that I have like heard discussed in media.
12:20Okay. She is just a famously hot lady. Yeah. She's like a naturally thin person who's kind of been thin her whole life and never really thought that much about it. Yes. That's my impression. So it sounds like the most plausible scenario for this is this company just came to her and was like, we will pay you many, many millions of dollars to endorse this product. Will you do that? Even though you've never used it, you don't care about it, it's not part of your life at all. You're just like, slap my name on it. Yeah, economic opportunity is what drew her to it. Because this is less like Richard Simmons making exercise videos and more like Pokemane selling macadamia nut cookies.
12:51I will say in addition to these like one minute spots that aired throughout the day for the Thighmaster, there were also full on like 30 minute infomercials for the Thighmaster. But those aired at weird dead airtimes like 3 a.m. on a Wednesday or whatever. So most people would have seen this one minute spot. God, what was the ROI for those fucking three in the morning infomercials? Michael, I read an entire fucking book about it for this goddamn episode. Wait, did you really? Yes. The chief marketer of the Thighmaster wrote a book about the marketing of the Thighmaster. And the book is called This Business Has Legs.
13:29Hell yes. OK, I'm in. And it's like the dumbest shit. Like there's like a full passage that's just on the difference between like utility patents and design patents. You're like, and now we're doing an hour of our podcast about it. Here it is. it's easy to forget that like prior to this era that airtime that like 2 a.m airtime would have just been a test pattern right yeah so they're selling that airtime for a song right one of the things that the marketer says in his book about the sales of the thigh masters he's like look man people always think that infomercials are about selling to people who are gullible that's not what it is it's about selling to people who are isolated god he like admits this yes he says it out loud.
14:13And so like, if you are airing things at two or three in the morning, even if that's not a person who's structurally like isolated in their life in that moment, they are probably feeling the isolation. Also, I wonder just logistically how many people who are up at that hour are like drunk or high or something that would affect their judgment basically. And you're like, yeah, fuck it. 20 bucks. I'll call in for 20 bucks. Yeah. And then you kind of wake up the next morning and you're like, wait, what did I buy? Or like you had a fight with your partner and they left the house and stayed with a friend or you don't know where somebody is or whatever you know what i mean like the reasons that people would be awake at like three in the morning at this point and watching tv are like not great or you are 13 years old and you are smoking weed which is why i was up at that interesting that's why i was watching like the oxyclean commercials and shit but luckily i didn't have a credit card so i couldn't order any of this stuff at this point thighs in particular were increasingly an area of concern for a few reasons.
15:10Wait, we're actually doing a thighs digression? We're just doing a little thighs digression because it was sort of a newer thing to be worried about at this point. And here is a specialized product that's like, it's mostly for your thighs, right? Young people do not know, but there was a time when like people didn't talk about washboard abs. That was like a 1990s thing. I think it was like Thelma and Louise that like invented the concept of washboard abs for people. Another thing to be mad at Brad Pitt about. This is why we get stuff like buckle fat and stuff. We're literally making up new body parts to feel weird about because like we've done all the major ones by now.
15:46So there are a few reasons that people are particularly concerned about thighs in this moment. One is that mini skirts and short shorts had now been mainstream popular for about 20 years, right? The 60s is when those really, really sort of took off. They certainly existed prior to that, but that's when they became like really, really mainstream. So people were seeing their upper thighs in public more often. And the very generation that had popularized those looks was now in early middle age. But folks are having a hard time adjusting to that. And there is now this huge marketing apparatus bearing down on them saying, you actually need to keep looking like you did in your teens and 20s.
16:32And if you don't, that's like a failure of your body, right? Right. So as workout videos and exercise equipment became more popular, targeting specific quote unquote problem areas became like one of the leading marketing techniques to differentiate products. Right. Right. It wasn't just that this machine or this workout would make you thin. It would make you toned in specific areas. This is the buns of steel era. Also, not that people are like super literate about this stuff now, but this was also a time when there was less exercise literacy. Yes. And so people did actually think like if you're doing thigh exercises, you will have less body fat on your thighs.
17:11Yes, correct. People just didn't know. They're like, that's not the way that body fat works. And the argument here wasn't just that you would be absent fat in that specific area, but also that that body part would have like a particular shape, a particular level of firmness, right? Like all of this sort of stuff comes wrapped up in like buy this one product and you will have thighs that look like Suzanne Somers thighs, right? But it just shows that like these people want to sell you something. They don't actually want to get you healthier. It's just an excuse to sell you something. Right. I think people misinterpret this era as like an explosion of interest in fitness and not an explosion of marketing of fitness products.
17:49Aubrey, while we're recording this, I'm watching as a visual background noise. I found a 10-minute long Thighmaster official exercise video. Oh, yeah. And like they're trying to pretend that it's like a full body exercise system and it's the funniest shit. There's like a woman with the Thighmaster on her stomach, like lying on her back, and she's pretending to do crunches. Yeah. Like with the resistance of the Thighmaster. It's like so obviously fake. I wouldn't be – is someone laying the Thighmaster down on the ground and then doing push-ups on top of it? That makes it too easy. Like jumping into the air, like popcorn.
18:23Oh, yeah. I guess it's going the wrong way, huh? So the Thighmaster sales took off immediately. It again starts to like pop up in sitcoms like Murphy Brown and Designing Women. And Suzanne really did a full court press of promotion for it. As of 2023, the company told the New York Times that it had sold more than 10 million Thighmasters. Okay. Six million of those Thighmasters were sold in the first 18 months of sales. Yeah, that makes sense. That was also part of that sort of nationwide boom in exercise equipment. According to the National Sporting Goods Association in a 1995 New York Times piece, the overall sales of exercise equipment increased 20 % from 1992 to 1993 alone.
19:22Which means everyone's closet filled up with these gadgets they never used. Well, and a bunch of them were Thighmaster spinoff products. Right. Like the Thighmaster vibrato. What? Which is just a vibrating Thighmaster, Michael. Why? They also made the face master. Oh my God. Is that like the mewing one where you like open and shut your jaw? No, this one was a battery powered device that sent electrical currents into the skin. One of those spinoff products got the most airtime on TV. And that was the butt master. Okay. They ran a very classic infomercial style commercial where the voiceover says something like, it's impossible to figure out how to work out this stubborn area.
20:16Oh, come on. And then it shows a person in like washed out footage dressed terribly, like falling off a treadmill or whatever. Are you tired of exercises that don't work your butt? My very favorite part of the butt master is the jingle for the butt master. I know you're going to send it. Just cut to the point where you send it. Send it to me. I'm so excited right now. Suzanne Somers on the butt master dancers
21:03Mike are you tired of feeling like a big old tub of lard use your butt master you'll get nice and hard but they weren't showing me how to use the butt master how does the what even is the butt master how does it work the butt master is the thigh master going the opposite direction oh so it goes in between your butt cheeks no it doesn't go in between and then you squeeze the butt cheeks together no the thigh master you put it between your thighs and you squeeze in on it the butt master you put it on the outside of your legs and move your legs out and open it's a reverse thigh master all it is the reverse Thighmaster?
21:39Reverse Thighmaster, baby. They could just have the ordinary Thighmaster, like, be reversible. I have to buy another thing for 60 fucking dollars. So behind all of this success, all of these devices, all of these infomercials, and all of this money, these hundreds of millions of dollars of money, there is a core question here, which is who gets credit for the Thighmaster? Oh, yeah. Of course, Suzanne Summers was the face of the product and she and her husband, Alan, bought out the other business partners. So the profits of the Thighmaster largely flowed to Suzanne over time. She was like, this is making money.
22:15We're going to buy it up so that we make all the money eventually. Eventually. Yeah. That's interesting. Okay. But you were right. She was approached to endorse the Thighmaster and she was approached by a marketer named Peter Beeler. Beeler is the one who wrote the book called This Business Has legs. Okay. About the Thighmaster. The full title, by the way, is this business has legs, colon, how I used infomercial marketing to create the$100 million Thighmaster craze, colon, an entrepreneurial adventure story. I kind of like this guy. I'm sorry. He had recently started an infomercial company called Ovation, and he was the one who reportedly approached Suzanne Somers, although he had also apparently considered several other spokespeople, including Caitlyn Jenner and Suzanne's former Three's Company co-star, Joyce DeWitt.
23:12Oh, okay. So Peter Beeler was the marketer, but he still wasn't like the inventor. He was hired by someone. Someone had to fashion a giant paperclip into wings. The person he was hired by was an investor named Joshua Reynolds. Joshua Reynolds claims to be the inventor of mood rings. Oh, okay. Not where I thought you were going with that. He is also the son of R.J. Reynolds. Okay. Do you want to tell the kids who R.J. Reynolds is? It's a tobacco company. famed tobacco air really cares about your health everyone he redesigned the device to give it like a little bit of curb appeal he covered the spring he gave it like a color scheme but who did it before so this is the question right yeah you can look up the actual patent for the thigh master okay it was originally patented as the v toner okay well yep you needed the marketers on board It lists four inventors, the first of whom appears to be the original inventor, named Anne-Marie Benstrom.
24:27Benstrom was a Swedish physical therapist who had come up with the device over 20 years earlier and had been using it in her practice since then. At the time, she was treating 10 skiers who all had leg fractures. So she developed this device to help them fight muscle atrophy while they were recovering. Right. There's probably specific motions you need to do to rehabilitate specific muscles. So she's like, oh, I'm going to make this custom built thing for these people. And then she's like, wait a minute, this could help other people. She called it the V-toner. She used it herself in PT contexts and other physical therapists used it as well.
25:11It wasn't until 1989 that Reynolds approached her about making a home version. So Benstrom is without question the inventor of the Thighmaster. Right. I'm going to send you a passage from an interview that she did at the time with the Orlando Sentinel. Two years in, the inventor hadn't been paid. Actually, I haven't seen anything yet, she says. My hand comes after the net. Anyway, she's not waiting around. She has something new. The Body Ball, 1995. And this time, I'm taking 50 cents each right off the top. It's a spiny but friendly-looking ball, and she seems quite giddy about its promise as she sits on it and starts bouncing around the lobby of the Miami Hotel where she's staying during a visit to South Florida.
25:57You can hardly see the ball as she rides around on the floor, someplace between levitation and ecstasy. We can't wait to see Suzanne Somers do this. We went to Suzanne Somers first, but they didn't want to do it, Benstrom says. Said it wasn't sexy enough for her. That's hard to believe. So this woman is like writhing around on the floor in front of a journalist in like the lobby of a Miami hotel to show off this also quite goofy sounding exercise product. Yes, correct. So this is exercise product, parentheses, and version. Yeah, that's right. That's right. That's right. She's doing a Taylor Swift.
26:29This is her Cleveland. Yes. But like, I think more to the point, this is a product that is invented by a woman who is getting a raw deal for the thing that she helped create. Yeah. And then when she comes up with another product and asks for a better deal, Suzanne Summers turned her down. Although I do have a little trouble feeling that. Sorry for this. The spiny ball is like, whatever. Yes. Well, she's clearly like also wants to like sell these like grifty health products to people. I get that business is business, but this is part of Suzanne's triumphant return after being famously underpaid as a woman.
27:06And it's just a real bummer that she turned right around and as part of her comeback underpaid the one other woman involved. Yeah, no, it's insane that she got nothing. And this woman was straightforwardly the inventor. Like she didn't put the bright colors on it or whatever, but she invented it. She's not only the inventor, she's a physical therapist. Right, yeah. She is the one person in this array of people who could be considered an expert. Right. And all of the non-experts are getting paid for a thing that she invented. Yeah, the tobacco air is getting the money. Yes! The fucking mood rings tobacco air.
27:42Never has there been more of a character on succession. so the thigh master ushered in kind of a new era for suzanne summers and a new career track and that is fitness and weight loss magnate it's so funny a woman who like doesn't exercise doesn't give a shit about exercise becomes like essentially an exercise influencer in 1997 she releases her first diet book eat great lose weight okay as ever the first chapter is just called diets don't work yes i was just gonna ask you about this i was like does she start by saying diets don't work okay perfection chapter one diets don't work and then includes like a cute little non-diet name for what is 1000 you know what i mean she's doing like it's not a diet it's a lifestyle it's a system it's a yeah in this case she does say that it's a quote-unquote lifestyle that she calls and i quote summer sizing okay this is not a hall of fame terrible diet it's got a leg up on a lot of other diet books.
28:48She's not a huge on calorie counting, nor even on super restrictive portions. The recipes look like regular 90s recipes, sort of for better and for worse. They don't look extra diet-y, right? It does, however, cut out whole food groups and still insists it's a plan where you can eat whatever you want and still lose weight, which is like, no. That's another hallmark of the first chapter of these diet books. You don't have to like do any complicated stuff it's not boring you can live your life and then once you get to chapter three it's like meticulously write down every single thing that you have and you can't eat anything that starts with a vowel like oh that's like super complicated stuff it's not the worst of the worst but it is something that i realized we haven't really talked about on this show before which is a sort of strain of diets which is a food combining diet oh god it's like a roguelike for each meal you can either have vegetables and carbs or you can have vegetables fats and proteins it's like the materia system from final fantasy 7 it's exactly like that thing that i definitely know that's what you were gonna say after that she wrote several more diet books get skinny on fabulous food okay eat cheat and melt the fat away summer size desserts summer-sized chocolate, summer-sized cocktails.
30:10These are all books? These are all books. Suzanne Somers' Fast and Easy Cookbook for Summer-Sized Recipes. Okay. And Sexy Forever, How to Fight Fat After 40. Man, all this without Chachi BT. It's kind of impressive. I do think it is worth noting that aside from occasional weight gain of like 10 or 15 pounds, this is not a person who has done any meaningful amount of weight loss. No, yeah. She is someone who's been thin her whole life. She is someone who signed with a modeling agency before she could legally drink at a bar. Yeah. And this is a profitable business for her. Right. Right. Like the point of this for her is not making people thin.
30:54It is making her money. Yeah. Yeah. And like a very straight ahead kind of way. Right. Right. And while she was writing those diet books she also launched a number of summer size branded products okay and a partnership with the home shopping network so she's in she's in baby she's on tv selling shit on hsn she became so influential in this kind of tv-based direct-to-consumer marketing that in 2014 she is inducted into the direct response hall of fame aka the infomercial hall of fame that's like her brag about like winning the grifties one year just her and ron popeel hanging out i get an award from the most hated group of people in the fucking country just like scam and spam like phone call and mailers yes in the 2000s however this starts to sort of wear thin a little bit she's had a solid 10 years top of the pops but in the 2000s things really do sort of seem to take a downturn step by step is off the air at this point.
32:02She's like way into her sort of diet book writing world. And she's trying to find a way to be on stage and on camera again. So she premieres a one woman show called The Blonde in the Thunderbird. Okay. It is an autobiographical show based on her two memoirs. This show does make its way to Broadway. Is she starring in it? Starring Suzanne Somers, was written by Suzanne Somers the whole bit. It is actually pretty impressive that she had control of her career for this entire time. It's interesting. The downside here is that the reviews of her one-woman show are uniquely terrible. Okay. I just sent you a quote from, this is from a review from the New York Times.
32:49Miss Somers and her collaborators have packaged her journey from damaged child to healthy woman in glib, shrink-wrapped vignettes that have all the emotional grit of an infomercial. Liberally laced with the bland jargon of self-help books, her story proves the peculiar truth that a victory over low self-esteem often comes at the price of a swan dive into narcissism. That same review called it, quote, a drab and embarrassing display of emotional exhibitionism masquerading as entertainment. Oh. They talk about the costumes being, like, unfortunately spandex. That's kind of mean, though. The New York Times review was, I think, famously sort of the worst one.
33:30But the reviews across the board were really bad. And ticket sales came up short in a pretty major way. So the Broadway production was canceled after 15 performances. Wow. This is Spider-Man turn off the dark levels of like, oh, nobody wants it. Yeah, the weirdest thing about Suzanne's show is all the wire work. So in 2001, Suzanne Somers remains sort of in her diet book bag. But things get tricky for her when the paparazzi presence really starts ramping up in Southern California in the 90s and 2000s. It's like going to the next level. People would hide in the bushes outside of your house and try to get pictures of you.
34:13I forget what year it was, but there was an incident where Jude Law was at his mom's house and he like went into the backyard to change into his swim trunks. so he was naked for like a brief period and someone with a telephoto lens from like hundreds of feet away like zoomed in and got nude photos of jude law i love that your one example of the paparazzi being terrible is like this is about morality aubrey this isn't about me remembering the peen of a handsome actor how dare you but it is weird that they're taking pictures of suzanne because isn't she in her 40s at this point she's in her 40s here's why they took a picture of her they got a picture of Suzanne Somers exercise and diet diva going into a plastic surgeons practice and she has been very upfront about like I don't do it I'm all natural I don't do anything but Suzanne Somers famously natty the photos are widely publicized and the implication is that this lady who has been selling you exercise equipment and diet books is actually getting plastic surgery.
35:13So you're being duped. On some level, that's fair enough because it's a hypocrisy about her public profile. But on the other hand, it's like it's her doing a medical appointment. Also, you don't know why she was there. You're getting close to it. Okay. The press frenzy is great enough that she winds up going on Larry King Live to clear it up. Okay. And she tells Larry King that she was there for liposuction as part of it. Okay. But also for breast reconstruction because she had been diagnosed with breast cancer and was trying to keep it like didn't want to tell people that she had cancer this is yet another reason why you just you shouldn't like take out of context photos of people and like build whole narratives around them she says on larry king that she had a lumpectomy and radiation but that she had declined chemo for treatment of her cancer in this time in 2000 2001 chemotherapy was an even gnarlier experience than it is today with way fewer supports to help people with the symptoms so like i can understand being like no thanks to that era of chemo so it wasn't because she was into like weird woo health practices it's like an actual like cost benefit thing that she made yeah but she also turns it into weird woo woo health okay all right so in 2008 she announced that she was diagnosed with cancer once again, but later found out that she had been misdiagnosed.
36:35Oh, okay. So she didn't actually have cancer. The combination of a correct diagnosis, like having cancer once, and then later thinking she has cancer again, but not actually having it seems to be sort of like the radioactive spider that bit her. Okay. Like any number of people who get diagnosed with cancer, She tried to learn everything she could about it. She read books. She interviewed doctors. But unlike other people who get diagnosed with cancer, she wrote books about it. Uh-oh. Right. So she wrote a book called Knockout, Interviews with Doctors Who Are Curing Cancer. Oh, no. Suzanne. Which was all about alternative cancer treatments and featured interviews with a number of doctors.
37:24That's it. Once you reach a certain net worth, you can't write health books. One of the doctors that she interviews for Knockout is Dr. Nicholas Gonzalez, who offers coffee enemas. Oh, great. A famously ineffective treatment for almost anything. Certainly not fucking cancer. She also interviews a doctor named Stanislaw Brzezinski, a Houston physician who treated well over 10 ,000 cancer patients before being disciplined by the Texas Medical Board for misinforming those cancer patients. What was he treating them with? He was using proteins called anti-neoplastons, a treatment that was not FDA approved at the time but was being funded for research.
38:08He wasn't upfront with those patients about how not approved it was and how experimental it was. How do celebrities find these fucking people? The quackiest fucking quacks. Yes. Because like any journalist who wanted like, I want to interview some cancer doctors, you'd like open the yellow pages at the time and just sort of like start calling cancer doctors, you wouldn't be like, who's this guy who's been disbarred? Famous, I hate a doctor who can't pass the bar. Well, whatever. You know what I mean. I know what you mean. I know what you mean. So needless to say, the American Cancer Society was not a fan of Suzanne Somers at this point.
38:45Yeah. Because she was straight up decontextualizing information about life or death medical treatment, right? I love how many whiplashes we've had between like, she's great, she sucks, she's great, she sucks. in this one episode. It's really remarkable, right? Yeah. So the American Cancer Society starts like doing press enough that when Suzanne Somers makes a cancer claim, reporters just start calling the American Cancer Society and being like, do you want to respond to what Suzanne Somers said? Okay, good. That only really seems to make her go harder on her wild claims. Oh no. Oh, I'm being suppressed.
39:19You can't even ask the questions. She says that the reason that she was in that plastic surgeon's office was to quote unquote regrow her breast after surgery. Okay. Through something called cell assisted lipo transfer. Oh no. Was it like a grifty plastic surgeon? I got to tell you the fact checking that I found on this. Can you regrow a breast thing? If it sounds wrong to you, that's because it is wrong. I feel like I would know if you could regrow breasts. If anyone would know, it would be Michael Hobbs. A health podcaster, excuse you, a health podcaster. Okay, sorry, sorry, sorry, sorry. I passed the medical bar exam.
40:01I know what I'm doing. Excuse you. I'm actually very qualified. The fact checking that I found from this, I regret to inform you, I'm sending you a quote from the fucking New York Post. Can cell-assisted lipotransfer actually regrow a missing breast? No. According to Dr. Rod Rorick, professor and past chairman of the Department of Plastic Surgery at the University of Texas the Southwestern Medical Center at Dallas. He cites a 2016 meta-review which found that studies of the technique were largely ill-designed, with few control groups to benchmark for safety or efficacy. The doctor, who also edits the journal Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery and works at Dallas Plastic Surgery Institute, additionally questions claims that these stem cells can help transplanted fat take to its new home.
40:39Despite Summer's tingly feelings of new growth, Rorick says the procedure is basically just a breast augmentation, only riskier. Not only is this like a guy who edits this journal and is the head of the plastic surgery institute. Yes. Not only is he saying this isn't likely, he's also saying you might be increasing your chance for malignant cell growth. Right. Despite all of this blowback and honestly, likely because of it. I knew you were going to say, despite all this, I knew, I knew that's the next thing you were going to say. No one is ever like, oh, yeah, I appreciate the correction by actual experts.
41:20Well, despite all the blowback, she gets way more media coverage for her cancer takes. That's the despite. It's not nevertheless she persisted, although nevertheless she persisted. Media starts going om nom nom, give me more. Yeah, yeah. She gets a full hour on Dateline. What? This gets written up in the New York Times with the headline, Suzanne Somers, cancer expert. Even if you're fact checking her, there is a Streisand effect happening, right? And a lot of them are just not fact checking her. So as a, for example, she gets interviewed by Al Roker. Okay. We're going to watch a little clip. In your research, is there any correlation, environment, weather kind of thing as far as these illnesses go?
42:14You bet. Every doctor. There's a whole second half on how to prevent getting in the first place. Here's what's real interesting. I asked Dr. Brzezinski, how do we get cancer? He said it's really quite simple. He said we all have cancer in us. We all have cancer-protective genes. They're like light switches that are turned on. He said they get turned off by diet and lifestyle habits. I said, like what? He said, well, toxicity and chemicals, you turn off a switch. A poor diet, so you turn off a switch. No sleep, you turn off a switch. Stress, you turn off a switch. And imbalanced hormones, you turn off a switch.
42:47So if you got all five switches off, you're a likely candidate. I said, can you turn them back on? Yeah, you can balance your hormones, you can manage your stress, you can learn to sleep without drugs, you can eat organic food and clean out your house and your food of chemicals because they all are making the link with chemicals. Every single doctor I interviewed. We live in hell. We live in hell. It's the same thing. I mean, this is like from a million years ago, but it's like precisely the same shit we get now. We live in hell. And here she is with Al fucking Roker, just saying this, like, for people outside the US and for people who are younger than us, Al Roker, famed weatherman.
43:23Yeah. Like, that is genuinely, that's his whole thing is the weather. Although still closer to a cancer doctor than Suzanne Somers is probably. At least he's a STEM guy. Honest to God. But then what she's saying here, I mean, you can't say it's like completely fake, right? Like there's risk factors for cancer that can be reduced by like lifestyle, whatever. But she's explaining it here like it's like so easy. Like if you have a great diet and you sleep enough, you won't get cancer. And like this whole idea of like chemicals as like a broad category of thing. Part of the implication of what she's saying here is if you get cancer, it is your fault and it could be prevented.
44:01Yeah. She's not saying that outright. Nobody ever does, but that is the obvious implication. Yeah. That is the underpinning of what she's saying here, which is, again, like a gnarly way to talk about human beings. Even with her own experience, just like the Thighmaster thing is obviously not how she has thighs like that, she got cancer while she was a health influencer. Also, okay, Aubrey, this is mean. But is she still saying she's not getting plastic surgery? Uh, yes. she's obviously had plastic surgery i'm sorry she's obviously had lip fillers the lip fillers like she looks like mickey roark what is she talking about she's doing elisa rinna yeah with the lip fillers no question i don't care if you get lip fillers but it's like just admit that you're getting lip fillers it's fine years later in the 2010s she's like oops i've been getting botox which is wild because she has a whole all-natural thing that she does for a long time and i'm like but you're having botulism injected into your face like don't get me wrong like everybody go do what you want yeah but there is some real friction between everything i do is all natural and botulism to the forehead i'm not gonna wait outside of a doctor's office to accuse her of hypocrisy but i'm gonna look at her face no she says all she uses is the face master how dare you she's she's pursing her lips she's a little tiny thymaster that she puts in between the corners of her mouth oh my god so after this she just starts talking about cancer in general as if she is a cancer expert.
45:27Also, she's basically a retired actress at this point. This is what's crazy. Like, she wasn't even all that famous at this point. Her sort of main career was kind of over at this point. She was, like, just doing this health stuff. So why do they keep having her on? In part because she keeps saying shit that becomes newsworthy. So here is a quote from some coverage of Suzanne Somers' cancer expert era. This is from coverage from the San Diego Union Tribune. The actress had to apologize recently when her offhand comment that chemo had likely killed actor Patrick Swayze rather than his pancreatic cancer made tabloid headlines.
46:01I shouldn't have said anything, Summer says now. I apologize to his family. But, she adds, we all know that chemotherapy does nothing for pancreatic cancer. But also I was right. Sorry about that, but also I was correct when I said that horrible thing. Why in the fuck would you say and do this? This literally isn't an apology. This is the opposite of an apology. It's a doubling down. Yeah. She's like, I'm sorry I said that, but I said it because it's true. It's not a fucking apology. And the quote was like very shortly after his death where you're like, ma 'am. This is also, it's such a perfect example of what you were saying, right?
46:37It's like you have this general worldview of like diet and exercise can help prevent cancer, which at the most super duper abstract level is fine. But it's clear that she's taking it to this like it will prevent cancer. Everyone who gets cancer did something fucked up. And then she starts commenting on like actual people, like a specific case of someone she does not know, has not examined, knows nothing about, and then just makes up this thing that fucking chemo doesn't work for pancreatic cancer. I think you're right. I think the worst part is that she didn't examine Patrick.
47:11If only she had put her hands on him, then I'd be fine with it. Then I have no criticism whatsoever. From there, she just kind of starts freestyling about health and wellness in general. What? Who is this woman at this point? It's just like an actress from the 90s. She, from the 80s, how dare you. She speaks out against water fluoridation, calling fluoride, quote, a toxic waste byproduct. Yeah. She writes a book about, quote unquote, toxins. And Michael, I'm sending you the book cover now. this is the worst this i'm sure it wasn't but this has such a like self-publish on amazon vibe so the cover of it the title of the book is tox sick tox dash sick and the subtitle is from toxic to not sick i lost like four iq points reading that that's so fucking good and then the tagline is the toxins in your body the diseases they cause the doctors who can help 100 chance every single doctor is i'm like crank also by the way did you notice in that al roker interview that she's like yes according to dr brzezinski and you're like the fucking guy you're still talking the disbarred guy the guy who was removed from the bar association he's been disbarred when it's b-a-r-r-e
48:39so toxic is structured around an enumerated list did you read the whole fucking thing michael i told you i read 10 books for this fucking episode michael talks dash sick i read talks dash sick why are you making fun of me haven't i already made fun of myself it must have been miserable aubrey it's structured around this list of quote-unquote toxic threats would you like to know what the toxic threats are it's got to be oh it's vaccines plastics and chemicals okay low fat and ultra processed foods oh my god mold new one new one a category that she just calls overuse of pills okay of course god gmos oh yeah and emfs and cell phones baby Oh, yes.
49:31We're at the 5G shit. Electromagnetic frequencies. Let's go. What year is this? What year did Toxic come out? It's impossible to say the name of the book. Toxic. It's only to be looked at and not to be said. I know. 2015. Okay, so it's late. As all of this is happening and she's talking more and more about toxins, about cancer risk, about all of this sort of stuff. And she has really segued herself into sort of like a broad health and wellness voice in the media. Her wellness content is also shifting away from weight loss and into perimenopause and menopause content. Oh, good. This is also happening.
50:22Suzanne Somers sort of pivot into perimenopause and menopause content is also happening at the same time that the NIH caused a big splash by claiming that hormone replacement therapy for menopause caused more risks than benefits. Right. We are now almost 25 years in the future and we know considerably more about that increased cancer risk. And while HRT can increase the risk of certain cancers, even on HRT, your total risk remains quite low. So essentially people in perimenopause are being asked to choose between a slight increase in cancer risk versus years or even a decade of symptoms that for many people can be overwhelming.
51:11Where are the woo-woo people on this? So is Suzanne against? Well, Michael. Because it seems like she would be against HRT because it's like a pill. But then she's also against like cancer. But then also she hates research and knowledge. So I don't know where she falls on this. So, yeah, I think you're exactly right. Like, this is the information environment in which Suzanne Summers is like, hold tight, everybody. I cracked the code. I was on two sitcoms that no one remembers. I'd like to weigh in now. She advocates for something called bioidentical hormone replacement therapy. Oh, no. OK. The primary appeal of bioidentical HRT is that it is claimed to be, quote unquote, all natural and plant based.
51:53OK. Okay. Implying that HRT from pharmacies, things like estradiol and progesterone are synthetic, unnatural, and the sort of implication is that they're unsafe, right? Chemicals. Yeah. Hormone replacement therapy is the primary treatment for perimenopause. It uses synthetic versions of hormones like estrogen and progesterone. Bioidentical HRT is the same thing, but its claim to fame is instead of having a molecular structure that is very similar to the estrogen and progesterone that your body naturally produces, bioidentical HRT has a molecular structure that is supposedly identical to the kind that your body produces.
52:37Bioidentical HRT at this point is not FDA approved because it simply hasn't been studied at a scale. Again, regular ass HRT hasn't even been studied at a scale. So the idea that like some offshoot would be safer and that we would know that it is safer is cuckoo fucking bananas, right? Right. She winds up writing several books relating to menopause and perimenopause. Okay. Slim and Sexy Forever, The Hormone Solution for Permanent Weight Loss and Optimal Living. Okay. Ageless, The Naked Truth About Bioidentical hormones oh man she really goes down the rabbit hole huh stay young and sexy with bioidentical hormone replacement the science explained a book called sexy forever and another book called i'm too young for this the natural hormone solution to enjoy perimenopause are you about to tell me you read all five books i did not read all these books i'm worried about you no her books again specifically focus on bioidentical HRT, but there are different approaches to bioidentical HRT.
53:45And hers focuses on one approach called the Wiley Protocol. Okay. The Wiley Protocol was developed by T.S. Wiley, who wrote a book called Sex, Lies, and Menopause. In it, Wiley claims that most of women's health conditions as they age can be attributed to hormone imbalances. Okay. Her solution is bioidentical HRT to return your hormone levels to what they were when you were 20. Okay, that doesn't sound plausible. As a 42-year-old woman, the thought of having the same hormone levels that I had when I was like 19 or 20 sounds nightmarish. That sounds terrible. And again, as with Suzanne Somers, T.S.
54:34Wiley is not a clinician. She does not have any medical training. She is a former actor. Of course. Oh my God. What is it with these fucking people and finding grifters? It's so bizarre. Just talk to like a normal doctor. So that's$1 ,500 for providers to get certified in the Wiley Protocol. Oh, perfection. It's a seminar grift. Great. $500 for pharmacies to get certified. Is Susan Summer selling hormones or products on the back of this? or she's just writing the books, promoting them? She's just writing the book. She's still selling her summer size stuff and she's still at Home Shopping Network and all of that.
55:13She's just like helping another grifter sell theirs for some reason. One gynecologist who is quoted in Suzanne's book about the Wiley Protocol told the New York Times, quote, I truly don't understand how she can certify anyone to do anything. Everyone is entitled to their own opinion, but for a non-physician layperson to have her own hormone protocol for prescription medication is a bit of a question. She's just some lady. She's just some lady. This is like us certifying people. Like we're not also not medical professionals. Right. We shouldn't. Anyone can just announce like the Hobbs protocol certification, but like that doesn't mean it's real.
55:57It just means they're charging you money for it. Wait, Michael, what is the Hobbs protocol. Viking, Tums, and Wilbutrin. And then like sweet potato for every meal. They're actually bioidentical sweet potatoes that you have to get at the pharmacy for some reason. So Suzanne Summers really spends a solid decade plus shouting from the rooftops about bioidentical HRT and about the Wiley protocol in particular. And she starts describing the protocol that she uses and like what her daily routine is around her bioidentical HRT. Okay. She actually describes it on Oprah's show. Of course Oprah has her on, of course.
56:36This is a quote about that Oprah appearance from the San Diego Tribune. Summers, whose hormone regimen involves creams, injections, and some 60 supplements daily, got a huge boost earlier this year from Oprah. Many people write Suzanne off as a quackadoo, Winfrey said when Summers appeared on her show. But she just might be a pioneer. Yet Winfrey's tacit support of Summers gave her some of the worst press of her career. Crazy Talk Newsweek headlined an article on the talk show host earlier this year. Another headline on Salon.com, Oprah's Bad Medicine. Winfrey responded in a statement that her viewers know that the medical information presented on the show is just that, information, not an endorsement or prescription.
57:18But many doctors feel Winfrey has more of a responsibility to her viewers. Dude, it's crazy to say the medical information is merely information. It's not information. Because usually people say like, oh, it's only entertainment. But she's like, oh, it's only information. We're not endorsing it. But like the information you're presenting here is that there is a pill available that will make me feel good and not get cancer. But I'm not supposed to do anything with that information, I guess. Dr. Jen Gunter, who's a public figure and an OBGYN who does a lot of sort of like women's health fact checking, wrote that, quote, Summers almost single handedly vaulted a fringe untested hypothesis into the mainstream.
57:58Right. When she's on Oprah, she says that she is taking 60 pills a day. No, I know this whole thing of like, oh, it's all about like the natural lifestyle. And like once you're in harmony with nature, 60 fucking pills a day. You think that's natural? I would also argue it's not natural for a 40-year-old to have the hormone levels of a 20-year-old. Thank God I'm not falling for this artificial stuff as I gulp like a giant handful of pellets. Like I'm like feeding an elephant at the zoo. I have like a giant paw full of fucking pills in the morning. Mine come from a different pharmacy. Mine are unregulated.
58:37That's how you know they work. So there was significant blowback to Suzanne Somers' promotion of bioidentical hormones, both in media, as we heard, but also from not just doctors, but the very doctors she quoted in her book. Oh, interesting. Okay. Many of whom administer bioidentical hormone therapy themselves. So even like the grifters are like, let's just dial it back a notch. So much so that they wrote an open letter to her publisher, objecting to the publication of the book that they are all quoted in. Whoa. The New York Times wrote a piece on Suzanne Somers' claims and the backlash to the Wiley protocol.
59:23And they asked T.S. Wiley, Teresa Wiley, whether or not her advice was coming from a credentialed source. So I am going to send you that quote. Well, of course she's credentialed. She has a certification. She has credentials. She offers credentials to other people. She's an actor. Of course it's credentialed. Miss Wiley shrugged this off. Does it have to come from a pedigreed source? Instead, she maintains that the debate is really a fight over women's bodies and how much money those women are worth to doctors. Who gets to prescribe and sell hormones to these women, she said. Suzanne is giving women enough ammunition and information to ask the right questions when they go to the doctors.
1:00:07They're not happy she's thinking on their own, and they don't want women to do that either. Ms. Summer said the Wiley Protocol is just one of many options she advocates. She also takes vitamins, does yoga, and has sworn off sugar. I'm not selling anything, she said. I don't have an agenda. I give every doctor equal time. I spent two years interviewing 16 doctors. It was like getting a PhD. Okay, not what a PhD is, but still. Also, you are absolutely selling something. No, she's like lying through her teeth. You're on the home shopping network. I know. You absolutely cannot credibly claim that you're not selling anything, ma 'am.
1:00:42She's like, I don't give any preferential treatment to one protocol. It's just the one named after me. Doesn't mean I like it more than the other protocols. Also, if two years and interviewing 16 doctors is like getting a PhD, A, no, it's fucking not. and B, if that's true, then you and I each have like three PhDs by this point. I'm going to start saying that. Don't tempt me. I have talked to so many doctors that I basically am a doctor now. It's the transitive property. I also hate the way that people take like genuine concerns about women not being addressed by the medical system and then use that to sell women garbage that does not help their health.
1:01:19So by the 2010s, Suzanne has kind of transitioned into like a professional marketer slash yapper. This is what I mean when I say the word influencer. Marketer slash yapper. She starts to wade into more explicitly political topics. Here it comes. And in 2013, we get two of Suzanne Somers' wildest takes. Do you have any guesses, by the way, 2013? Do you have any guesses about what she might have wild takes about in 2013? Did she think the artist deserved to win Best Picture? No, it's not that bad. No, it's not that bad. It's about Sandy Hook. Oh, what? Yep. Not where I thought you were going with this.
1:01:57Holy shit. The Sandy Hook shooting was a particularly brutal school shooting of very young children by an older teenager named Adam Lanza. Suzanne Somers was publicly speculating about the underlying causes for the shooting. Oh my God. Was it gun control? No, dummy. It's GMOs. I am going to send you a quote from your former employer. She was on HuffPost Live when she said this one. It was me interviewing her. I do remember this now. I could not find the video clip of this. HuffPost has very smartly scrubbed it. Summers told HuffPost Live that she feels diet and household toxins may have electrified Adam Lanza's brain.
1:02:42Everybody's looking at guns. I look at it and go, what is the diet of that guy who went nuts? What toxins was he exposed to? What kind of household cleaners are they using? She reflected on a conversation she had with a neuroscientist following the shooting at Columbine High School. He at that time said to me, around the time of Columbine, you're going to see a lot more shoot-'em-ups, Summers said. He said brains of young people have been over-electrified. Most young people have been exposed to chemicals, for the most part starting in the womb, by well-meaning mothers drinking diet sodas thinking they were doing something good for their babies.
1:03:13Oh, this is grisly. When I was pulling this episode together, I really thought that the Patrick Swayze thing was going to be the big gremlin mic drop. But I'm so fascinated by this thing where like something just takes over your brain and then it just becomes your explanation of literally everything. Right. Every single person who fucking dies has to have been using like the wrong toilet cleaner. Because also what's funny about it is even if it is the household cleaner, it's still the guns. People, many people use household cleaners and don't fucking shoot up a school. so it's still ultimately the guns.
1:03:44That is only one of her bad takes in 2013. Later that year, she publishes an op-ed in the Wall Street Journal. She has given her hot take on Sandy Hook. So why not weigh in on the Affordable Care Act? Hell yes. This woman is like 15 years away from an actual career as like doing anything in Hollywood. Why are people still listening to her? It's insane. Because she keeps having knowledge to drop, Michael. So I read this Wall Street Journal op-ed, and I don't really know where to start with this one. I did toy with the idea of making you read the entire thing into a microphone. Also, I'm assuming it's just boring.
1:04:27It doesn't cover like preventative medicine. We need to prevent diseases. It's not boring, Michael. If there's one thing, it's not boring. This is an op-ed not just for the opinion page of the Wall Street Journal. It's for a standing feature in the Wall Street Journal at the time called The Experts. I think it's going to be called The Craziest Person at Your Family Gathering. The Experts was a regular space for op-eds from issue experts. Oh my God. So they would bring in someone who was like an economist to talk about tax policy. Suzanne Somers is one of the experts for the Wall Street Journal.
1:05:10Well, she is a thigh master. Yeah. It's actually a formal title. It is also like a very scattershot piece that talks through a few different things. One, she talks about a story of a family member who needed health care in Canada and had to wait. Oh, for fuck's sake. It is boring. She referenced a Canadian magazine cover that said, quote, your dog can get better health care than you. That's probably true because they don't have socialized medicine for dogs. It's probably if you pay money, your dog can probably get amazing health care. That's exactly the point. Yeah. And she's a lady who has money.
1:05:44So she's like, it's getting worse. American health care, if you're rich as fuck, American health care is incredible. That's never been the problem. In the piece, she also includes two quotes. One from Lennon. Nice. And one from Churchill. She quotes Lennon in the piece as saying, quote, socialized medicine is the keystone to the arch of the socialist state. OK. And she quotes Churchill as saying, control your citizens' health care and you control your citizens. Which is a weird quote for a guy who explicitly supported public health care, but OK. That's from like brainyquote.com and like she didn't like double check it.
1:06:25Well, Michael, if you look up the Wall Street Journal op-ed today, you will see that a correction has been added. Hell yes. Okay. Both quotes are fully fake. Okay. I did track down the origin of the fake Lennon quote because that will pop up from time to time. To find the origin of it, I went back to a New Yorker piece from 1966. Okay. The fake Lennon quote traces back to a GR firm, a government relations firm, hired by the American Medical Association during the Truman administration. OK. That fabricated quote was deployed in lobbying efforts to undercut nationalized health care by the American Medical Association.
1:07:15It was made as anti-universal health care propaganda, basically. Yes, and pushed by the AMA, the Professional Association for Doctors. Yeah, yeah. Those attacks from the AMA were extremely effective and were built in part on false information. Here is that same quote some 65 years later. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Being used to do an extremely watered down stopgap measure because we don't have nationalized health care, right? I wonder how she even found it. I think it was getting passed around on the far right, as it very often does, right? Yeah, like an email forward or some shit. So from there, from those two sort of pretty atrocious takes, she goes pretty mask off with her politics.
1:08:07She tells Huffington Post at one point that she's, quote, an independent and she votes the candidate, never the party. It just happens to be Republicans every time. But like, that's just like a coincidence because like, I'm so independent. In 2014, she told Fox Business that the Obama administration was, quote, the most divisive of all the administrations that I've ever experienced in my lifetime. I hate divisions. I hate it when people divide us. In 2018, she told a paparazzo on camera that she was very happy with Trump as president. Great. In 2019, she went on Dr. Oz to talk about her cancer bullshit.
1:08:43Dude, I'm so proud of myself for not knowing this. I honestly did not know this episode ended in this place because I just like hadn't heard of her in decades. When you were like, I had to Google to see what show she was on. I was like, fucking dope. Everything is going to be new to you. In 2020, following sort of the crest of Me Too, she talked about sexual politics and sexual harassment. I wonder what she said. I wonder, God, let me just, give me a second to wonder what she would have said about Me Too. Do you want to try to guess? This is fucked up. But like a lot of older women at the time were like, well, in my era, we just called it joking around.
1:09:19These young people today, there was like a weird kids these days thing among like older conservative women. Michael, it's as if you're reading the quote. I just sent it to you. This is from a New York Times piece in 2020. Ms. Summers is notably lacking in Me Too era outrage. I'm not wearing pink pussy hats and I never will. She said she never experienced advances that she considered threatening. It was a different era, she said. then you used to come on to women and either you liked it or you didn't. She said, you go to a bar, you might get picked up and it's up to you. It's not like you want me to sleep with you, you pig.
1:09:52We saw her getting hit on like on TV with like Johnny Carson. Right. Absolutely. I mean, I think it is sort of the version of like when I was in high school, we had a big paper to, we had a couple of big papers to write. And my class was one of the last years that you had to write an entire epic poem using all the rules of epic poems. And a bunch of people in my class had a bunch of resentment for younger kids despite the fact that they were like it was useless i don't know why we did it i didn't want to do it blah blah blah and then they were like but you should also have to do it and i think that's like kind of what's happening here right she's like hey man if i have to fucking figure out how to be a single mom without a bank account yeah and if i have to get sexually harassed by all these dudes and like publicly shamed for getting asked to be paid and all of this shit, then like you can at least do some fucking fraction of that.
1:10:46I love this argument because it's an argument against any form of social progress whatsoever. I mean, it really, really is. I got paid so little that I had to sleep under a bridge. So why don't you want to get paid that little? Like literally anything that improves in society. Rather than going, it shouldn't be that way for anybody. And I want to make sure that nobody has to go through what I went through. Yeah. folks move into this headspace of like, I can do it. And if you can't, you're a pussy is sort of the thinking, right? Yeah. Yeah. So that is sort of how Suzanne Somers spends the final years of her life.
1:11:20Trying to make it worse for people younger than her. Great. In 2023, she gets the news that her cancer has actually come back this time. And within just a few months, Her cancer is detected late and is very fast moving. So within a few months of getting the news that her cancer was back, she did pass away at her home in Palm Springs. She was 76 years old. So we get all of these public tributes about her work on Three's Company and Step by Step. and they sort of skate right past or gloss right over her really complicated and lengthy legacy in health and wellness territory and to a degree in politics, right?
1:12:07Yeah, because she was a sort of health and wellness wrong in public person significantly longer than she was an actress, right? Absolutely. It was like 20 to 30 years, depending on how you measure it, of these like bad health takes. Just to put this in context, this would be like memorializing Gwyneth Paltrow and not really discussing goop. Right. Some tabloid coverage reported that many of her friends and family urged her to engage with conventional treatment and she decided not to. One source told the Daily Mail, which like a source close to the family told the Daily Mail usually means a publicist wanted to leak a thing.
1:12:43Right. Right. Yeah. Quote, she never regretted her decisions and she was prepared to go. She believed that she lived a life beyond her wildest dreams and truly made a dent in the world. And she did. Yeah, yeah. Coming from the start that she had, I absolutely believe that her life was beyond her wildest dreams. And then... She did make several dents in the world. Yeah, yeah. Some of them positive and a lot of them really complicated and bad. Because a Thighmaster, you can say like, whatever, it's a grifty health product, but the stakes are relatively low. You wasted$60 on a product you never used.
1:13:18There are worse things in the world, right? But then the stuff after that, like there's literally a body count associated with this probably, right? Somebody probably read this book, one of her like 10 books about hormones or cancer or something, and then didn't get treatment for some condition for which there is treatment and probably died. I think that's like worth noting as like, yes, that is a huge part of her legacy in public life. Yes, that's right. At the very least, even if they didn't die, right? We don't have evidence or reporting about anyone specifically following this and then dying.
1:13:47Right. And she's not the only person saying this. And she's not the only person saying this. Even if she didn't get that far, I do think giving cancer patients wrong information is a bad thing to do, even if no one dies. Yeah. I think there's a few things in the researching of this episode that really stood out to me as sort of through lines of the show that seemed like worth pulling out. One is that Susan Summer's story sort of maps out this pipeline that starts with weight loss and fitness content and ends with explicit political conservatism arguing against other people having health care. That is because the belief is that health is a meritocracy and that would be aiding people who are delinquent in their own health.
1:14:41That's the underlying sort of rhetoric here. It's also so interesting because this always leads people to a conservative place. And yet the actual argument that like the environment is full of toxins and we should get rid of chemicals is actually an argument for like better government regulation of business. It's not necessarily conservative, but it's all conservatives who put this out. And conservatives only put this out so that they can guide you away from actual structural solutions to problems. Well, and each of her sort of turns in her career paves the way for the next, right? Yeah. First, it's bodies are a meritocracy.
1:15:16And because I am thin, I have therefore put work into it. So I'm an expert in thinness. Next is thinness is health. So I'm also an expert in health and wellness because I am thin. And because I am able to sell my weight loss and wellness products successfully, the invisible hand of the free market has validated that my ideas are both correct and beneficial. Right. And like all of that is inherently deeply, deeply conservative. And it all starts from let's learn from thin people about how to be thin. I love that you're drawing like the tiny domino is like, I'm going to try to lose 10 pounds. And then it's like the big domino.
1:16:00Like it really is. Like that is how she gets to the point that she's at. Yeah. If she doesn't take this pivot into Thighmaster and diet book world, none of the rest of this follows. Aside from just like a kooky old actress shows up on TV and decides to talk about her political views, which doesn't get the same kind of attention. Right. as it does if she's like guys i figured out menopause and cancer you're welcome and school shootings like fucking jesus god
1:16:54Thank you.
Suzanne drops her sitcom persona, picks up the ThighMaster and emerges as an early 2000's proto-Gwyneth.
Support us:
Links!
Video clips:
Thanks to Doctor Dreamchip for our lovely theme song!