1. Podcasts
  2. Problem Solvers
  3. The Man Behind Madden on Building Another Hit
Problem Solvers

9 Nov 2026 · 26m · 8 chapters

Episode artwork

The Man Behind Madden on Building Another Hit

In short

How to build products people love and keep users coming back, using lessons from video games; includes why “one-hit wonders” happen, how to motivate creative teams, and how to design for retention (“does the app love you?”).

Guests

Bing Gordon, co-founder and former chief creative officer of Electronic Arts; later chief product officer/advisor at Kleiner Perkins; author of Everybody Wins: What Games Teach Us About Making Products People Love. Host: Jason Pfeiffer, Editor-in-Chief of Entrepreneur Magazine.

Key claims

Creative boredom and rising stakes cause follow-on failures; teams need mixed tenure and cofounder partnership. Gamer retention follows Maslow-like needs: social meaning, self-improvement/mastery (e.g., leveling in ~8 minutes), and productivity. Use “session economics” to keep value-per-time constant.

Notable examples

Madden sequel skepticism by retailers; EA’s team-motivation model; MyFitnessPal session value; Duolingo/Peloton badges; Zynga “active social loops” (magic number ~5); Roblox agency/hangout; Nintendo lab disproving “great graphics” as the main driver.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

2:15

Exploring the Challenge of Sustained Success

Discussion on the difficulty of consistently creating hit products in gaming.

“You know, salespeople all know that if you want to get somebody to buy something from you, you have to say their name and you have to get them smiling.”
4:56

Understanding Creator Persistence

Insights into why some creators succeed while others become one-hit wonders.

“And because there's something about why creators don't succeed.”
8:00

Motivation and Engagement in Gaming

Discussion on what motivates gamers and how these principles apply to product design.

“and that's different than how do you keep people continuing to come back.”
10:58

Lessons from Gaming for Product Development

Connecting gaming engagement strategies to creating beloved products in other industries.

“So if you think about everything you do, there's a cost and there's a benefit.”
14:00

Creating Products That Users Love

Learn how to develop products that foster user loyalty and emotional connection.

“and how we should be thinking about those lessons as applied to other products that are not games.”
17:42

Observing User Behavior for Product Development

Understand the importance of observing user behavior to enhance product features.

“My recollection on the retweet button, by the way, is that retweet came out of the team at Twitter observing organic user behavior.”
19:24

The Evolution of Video Games and User Interests

Explore how video game design has shifted to meet the evolving interests of younger users.

“And a lot of creators, I said with one-hit wonders, their first creation is for themselves.”
22:36

Engaging with Kids' Interests in Gaming

Discover strategies for parents to understand and engage with their children's gaming interests.

“Well, I got a first thought for you is the most interesting game that you're not playing there is finding out from your son kind of the meta of what's interesting to him.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On Problem Solvers, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00I'm a writer and entrepreneur, so I know better than anyone. Small business is storytelling. You're not just selling a product, you're selling a story. But it can be hard to get that product and that story in front of the right buyers. If you're a small business owner, how do you get your product onto shelves? And if you're a small retailer, how do you stock the right products? FAIR has figured out the solution. It's an online wholesale marketplace that connects independent retailers with more than 100 ,000 unique small brands worldwide. Fair gives small businesses a chance to scale, and it gives independent retailers access to interesting new products, and it's perfect for planning inventory for the holiday season.

0:45By connecting retailers with over 100 ,000 unique brands, Fair gives small and local businesses a platform to thrive. Retailers get a boost because FAIR reduces the risk while testing new products with analytics and free returns on first orders with every brand. So far, FAIR has given more than 700 ,000 retailers access to over 100 ,000 brands. Sign up today and get 50 % off your first wholesale order up to$100 at FAIR, that's F-A-I-R-E, FAIR.com slash entrepreneur. That's FAIR, F-A-I-R-E.com slash entrepreneur. Terms may apply. On this show, we know that teamwork makes the dream work, and our friends over at U.S.

1:28Bank believe the same. That's why they offer the U.S. Bank Business Essentials Visa Card. Not only does it get you unlimited 2 % cash back on every purchase, you can also pair it with a business checking account to earn even more cash back. And it's easy. All you have to do is open the U.S. Bank Business Essentials Visa Card and pair it with qualifying balances in a qualified business checking account. That bumps your earnings up to 2.5 % just by letting the accounts work together. Go team. Visit usbank.com slash BECard, that is B-E like business essentials, to learn more. The creditor and issuer of this card is U.S.

2:08Bank National Association, pursuant to a license from Visa USA, Inc. Some restrictions may apply. So I ask product people in all walks of life, do your customers think your app likes them? And they go, what do you mean? And I go, well, just ask them. And they go, I never thought about it. You know, salespeople all know that if you want to get somebody to buy something from you, you have to say their name and you have to get them smiling. Running a business means solving problems. I tell you how the smartest entrepreneurs do it. Hi, I'm Jason Pfeiffer, Editor-in-Chief of Entrepreneur Magazine, and this is Problem Solvers.

2:49I was a magazine writer and editor at the dawn of video game apps, as we know it, right? Like the things that just really took off. Candy Crush, Angry Birds. And this really interesting thing happened at the very beginning of covering that stuff as a journalist, which was that the media would all kind of stampede to crown the next genius in the video game space. And there would be all this coverage about how smart they were for creating this one game or something. And then years would go by and a lot of those companies that were really hot never made another hit product. And then the narrative changed and it felt kind of revelatory to me when it happened.

3:33I was a young magazine editor at the time. And the answer was, it's actually incredibly hard to build a video game that people love. And so just because you made one doesn't necessarily mean that you know how to make others. Maybe you just lucked out on that one and then the company never makes another hit again. And I have thought about that quite a lot. What is the difference between really understanding how to create something that people love and will come back to. And if you could really understand that, understand the psychology of what it is that drives people to engage and to return, well, boy, you would have something.

4:14And today on this show, I would say I've got the guy who has the answer because Bing Gordon is the co-founder and former chief creative officer of Electronic Arts. Electronic Arts, they made some stuff you've heard about. John Madden football, The Sims, SimCity, Need for Speed, Tiger Woods Golf, he could tell you more. He is now with Kleiner Perkins, serves as the chief product officer and an advisor for the firm and author of this new book, which is absolutely fascinating, Everybody Wins, What Games Teach Us About Making Products People Love, which is to say a book full of the answers to the questions that I've always had.

4:52Bing Gordon, welcome to Problem Solvers. Thanks, Jason. So I love the question that you asked, and I think it's a two-part question. And because there's something about why creators don't succeed. And there's another about why people don't persist. And the creators don't succeed. I tried acting a little bit in my 20s in New York. And there was a concept that I heard then that's very familiar in the music business, which is one hit wonders. And I started wondering, why do so many people have one hit, never have another hit because one hit wonders it and in theater at the time it was thought that about 50 percent of theatrical successes in new york at the time uh never had a follow-on and they might keep writing but never had another one and over over the years i've seen it with game teams because later on we got into doing sequels of madden and sequels and oddly enough when the The first time we tried to sequel Madden, the retailers all said, don't you dare sequels never sell.

6:01And, you know, it turned out the same thing happens in TV shows, how they all kind of jump the shark sooner or later. You know, I think the first thing is creative boredom that, you know, Happy Days had the Fonzie jumping the shark, which has become the idiom for when you can't keep being creative, just mail it in and do something as lame as jumping a shark. So the one-hit wonder aspect. Which is also, it is the inevitable product of consistently having to raise the stakes. So if you've got something that is a hit and you want to build upon it, at some point it has to become so big that it becomes ridiculous and detached from whatever originally made it great yeah well we found in um a guy named john shappard who ran the studio that did madden football for years we just found that you build a team with one third of nfl lifers they would they would want to work on the nfl games for 20 years their season ticket holders about one third want to do it for a couple of years and one third one year only.

7:13And so you can build a team of longevity, medium term and short term. But with so you could engineer a team for, you know, constant motivation. Another way to motivate creative people is in partnership. So it looks like you're a one man banana stand. Sometimes if you have partnership, John Shepard had a guy named Steve Chang, who was kind of as Robin to as Batman. And one of them would show up at work and kind of be out of it. And the other would say, hey, get it together. And so they would motivate each other. I think this maybe happens in good marriages as well. You don't let, if somebody lies slack, you pick up the kids, you do something.

7:54And so the machine of a couple, the machine of co-founders stays motivated. and that's different than how do you keep people continuing to come back. And I would say what we discovered in games is the motivation of gamers, the hierarchy of Maslow's hierarchy of needs for gamers, number one is social meaning. Where you build social capital, that turns out to be the stickiest way to get people to come back tomorrow. The second thing is self-improvement and mastery. And so almost all games, we learn in games that in the first experience, you level up, you win something. We found in mobile games that the sweet spot was in the first session, about eight minutes, get the level three or four, and that'll get you to come back tomorrow if you feel like you earned it.

8:55Gamers value what they feel they've earned. Gamers don't value stuff for free. And then the third is productivity. And this is playing a game to win a sword. But it's also playing a game to make money. And so if you think about creators, when you're broke, you're doing it to make money. But in the end, it's even better if I can make a game that my kids want to play with me. So my most meaningful moments in games are in my game history. You know, making hits is kind of cool, but the meaningful exact instances is when I have a mental image of me and another person. So my favorite game moments in my mind is a screenshot and a picture with kind of a voiceover of another person.

9:53I've got another concept in engagement called session economics. So I learned this in a diet thing called MyFitnessPal. But in general, in mobile games, when somebody installs a game, very rarely do 50 % come back tomorrow. It's more like 35 % come back tomorrow. Maybe it works that way in dating. You know, if you go to a dating app and you have a date, maybe you only get 35 % follow on and probably you don't get 35 % who have one date and then go out again the next day. That would be, that would be a vast minority. But so in mobile games, 35%. Which is to say somebody downloads the game, tries it out.

10:39They play it today. They play it today. They get the level four. They kind of like it. Only a third, 35 % of those people are going to come back tomorrow. The best way to keep somebody forever is to get them to come back tomorrow. And so we really focus on getting to come back tomorrow. And so there's, I would say there's another aspect of retention hacking, which I call session economics. And I learned this in MyFitnessPal. So if you think about everything you do, there's a cost and there's a benefit. So by the way, doing this podcast with you, you know, the cost is you're spending a half hour.

11:16and you're getting something for it. And maybe you're getting a little money. Yeah, whatever. Better yet, you're getting some kind of mastery or some kind of self-improvement. I figured this out with MyFitnessPal, and that was an app that you input your meals every day. It would tell you what your calories were. You'd weigh yourself, and you'd tell it what your goals were to lose weight. And guess what? But if you've ever been on a diet, in the first week of a diet, everybody loses two pounds. You've got the business idea. We've got the framework. Move from idea to investor-ready business plan with Babson's Master's of Science in Management and Business Creation, or MSBC.

11:59A fully online, part-time graduate degree designed for founders. Build your venture in real time as you learn from experienced faculty. receive mentorship from alumni and access the resources to validate, iterate, and develop your idea. This is your opportunity to build your business while earning your master's degree from the leading college for entrepreneurship. Learn more at babson.edu slash business creation. At CLA, we're in your corner and on it. We coach tax strategies and little league first base. we help you adopt ai data tools and we adopt rescues named buddy we walked your factory floor and jog the local 5k though sometimes we walk that too wherever you're coming from we're right there with you wherever you're going we'll get you there cla cpas consultants and advisors Learn more at claconnect.com slash with you.

12:58And you spend about an hour in the app in that first week because you've got to input everything and all that. So now you're losing two pounds per hour of time in the app. So your app session is two pounds per hour. And then the next week, in MyFitnessPal, people would lose one pound. And they'd spend one hour in the app. And they'd go, hey, what happened to my two pounds per hour? And so what do they do? They don't lose two pounds in the third week. They use the app for only a half hour. And so now they might lose one pound again, only half hour. I'm back to two. My session economics is two pounds per hour.

13:38And then they go to the third week or the fourth week. And by the fourth week, most people don't lose weight anymore. We've got to figure out how the value per time stays the same. Here's what it makes me think about is, the premise of your book here is what games can teach us about making products people love. I'd love for you to draw some lines between that structure that you just laid out about what engages people and has them coming back for games, and how we should be thinking about those lessons as applied to other products that are not games. But I'd love for you to draw some of those lines that people in different industries might want to be thinking about as they evaluate how to drive repeat purchases or how to just make sure that people are using their thing longer and not becoming the two -thirds that just kind of forget about it instantly.

14:32I think in general, I start with, does the app love you? and it's not, you know, make apps that people love. If, uh, if you think the other party in a relationship holds you in high esteem, it's easier to like them. And so I asked product people in all walks of life, do your customers think the, your app likes them? And they go, what do you mean? And I go, well, just ask them. And they go, I'd have never thought about it. so Amazon do you think do you think your customers love your app and you know sales people all know that if you want to get somebody to buy something from you you have to say their name and you have to get them smiling and you want to make them think that the sales person admires you and so that's kind of thought number one how do you make how do you wait, wait, wait.

15:30How do you make a product that people feel like likes them? You recognize their accomplishments. So I think that very quickly you have a profile page of the person, which shows them in a way that they want to be seen, that they kind of can't help but think that other people are going to want to see. And we use badges, you know, and Peloton, they keep track of all your history. You know, in Duolingo, you see, you know, welcome back, Bing, and then you see what you've accomplished. So the app seems to admire and collect the things you've done. The user kind of feels that other people are going to want to see it.

16:20And in all social media, being noticed once versus zero times is a step function. Going from one to two is not a zero to one is huge. And then we found in games at Zynga, we call that an active social network, active social loop. And we would see that if somebody touched, they sent out a request for help, they got a response. It's a compliment. They get something back. There was a magic number of about five. If you could complete five social loops in a session, you're coming back tomorrow. And I liken that. We were talking about cheers the bar. If you go to a bar and a couple of people recognize you, you're coming back.

17:07And in different walks of life, there's a different critical number. I think Facebook in the early days found if you had like 15 friends, you were coming back. And Twitter, if you followed 11 people or something like that, you were coming back. So there's this magic social meaning that based on whatever kind of product you're trying to build, there is a secret number you're trying to get to. but you always want to go bigger than zero. My recollection on the retweet button, by the way, is that retweet came out of the team at Twitter observing organic user behavior. So people were essentially, and I remember the early days of this, where you would manually almost copy and paste what somebody else had tweeted and then write.

18:06People came up with their own thing. It They came up with their own thing. It was RT colon and then somebody's handle and then what they had to do. And that was a user behavior that the team noticed and then built into the product itself. And that's maybe, I don't know how much of that exists inside of video games, but I would love to hear your thoughts on how founders of products should be watching what people do with the product and then responding accordingly. Similarly, the Facebook photo app came because somebody noticed that some users were changing their profile picture. And when they changed their profile picture, then they started sending out a note.

18:49Jason changes profile picture and people go look at it. And so it became self-expression. In games, we started out in game. Most game designers start out designing something for themselves. You know, a guy named Peter Molyneux built a magic carpet game, among others, because when he was 12 years old, he fantasized about flying a magic carpet. And some of the things that happened in Madden football is going back to, you know, what we did as 10-year-olds, you know, fantasizing, living inside a trading card. So for creators, usually the initial idea comes from a self-fantasy. And a lot of creators, I said with one-hit wonders, their first creation is for themselves.

19:41And then after that, stage two is you have to start paying attention to others. what David Kelly of IDEO and design thinking calls discovering the latent customer need. So you go watch them. And in fact, he teaches watching with a camera because in person, you're so much trying to build an affiliative relationship that you don't notice everything. And if you can dispassionately look with a camera lady, you'll start noticing cues of what they're trying to do. We learned early on at Electronic Arts that if we asked people what they wanted, they would mislead us. And the key example in games is people said, I buy games with great graphics.

20:26And then Nintendo showed us in a lab that when people said great graphics, that correlated with when you click, something happened on the screen right away. And we thought it meant painterly. so right you know really beautiful graphics yeah yeah we thought we and um i think that because we were talking about roblox and roblox is one of those where it does you know it doesn't look great but it turns out there's a generation that wants highly interactive more than they want um painterly what what do you this will circle back to something we you and i were talking about before we started recording and could be an interesting place to land because of how much the video game industry and even thinking of what a product is has evolved, which is, as I told you before, but just to repeat for everybody, my oldest son is 11.

21:26He loves Roblox. That is where he spends his time with his friends. And he has invited me many times to play some of these Roblox games with him. And I will tell you, I struggle. because they're so boring. They're so boring. It's just walking around this little world collecting stuff or whatever. And I keep thinking, this is fascinating because millions and millions and millions of kids are playing these games that to me seem incredibly dumb and boring. And I can't imagine that a bunch of sophisticated video game makers at EA in a world before Roblox would have ever come up with some of these games because they're just too simple.

22:08They don't seem to have a purpose or a point. And yet, now that we're in an open platform world where anyone can make a game about anything and just post it, we almost get to see in a free market kind of way what form of entertainment and product kids gravitate towards. And they're often very different from the kinds of things that were made for kids before, which were more sophisticated. And it makes me wonder what you make of that shift. And if we're witnessing a tapping into a kind of interest in simplicity that was always there but never served, or if just the needs and interests of the young video game consumer have radically changed beyond when I was playing video games as a kid.

22:54Well, I got a first thought for you is the most interesting game that you're not playing there is finding out from your son kind of the meta of what's interesting to him. And I would always sit down and go, how are you getting better at this? Why are you good at it? Who's better than you? Are you better now than you were last month? and just a guy named Alfie Cohn, an educator, said to be kid-centric. You want to be kid-centric. And if you start out, you know, you want them to be fascinated, then you want to find out why. So I think the first thing is I'd encourage all parents, if your kids are fascinated by anything, whether you get it or not, as long as it's not illegal, to ask them what's in it for you and what's your path to constant improvement and you know with all parents know that there's kind of an art to getting their kids to engage one way to do it is to put them with some friends and go on a long drive in a car and be the chauffeur and suggest a topic and get them talking you know what's so cool about roblox and with with each other but that's kind of the first thing and then The next thing is the two fascinations in Roblox.

24:15One is the creators. And, you know, it's kind of by their generation for their generation. When we did SimCity and then The Sims, I built into those games this creating and sharing. before that the SimCity group had thousands of uploads sent to them with gamers saying, look at this city I built, isn't it cool? And the employees at Maxis said, our stupid customers, don't they realize all their cities look the same? And I'm going, but don't you realize that every one of them describe their cities differently. They're yearning to be different and basically they're telling you you're not given enough ways to personalize and then you're not giving them the audience that they want.

25:15So they're telling you they want more personalization and more audience and you're telling them they're stupid. So in the Roblox it's generational. operational. I think there's, especially at that age, what kids at that age is they want agency. What they say at that age is my parents tell me what to do. My teachers tell me what to do. Games don't tell me what to do. I'm my own boss. And then they look around and see some kids like them who are getting millions of plays and they're kind of fascinated. They want to know if I play their games, I'll become like them. And then the second is it becomes a hangout.

25:56You know, if you can remember playing in a playground at school recess, you do the same thing over and over again. And I'm sure the parents would go, why are they playing kick the can? That's a stupid game. It's like a stupid game. There's nothing to do it. But we're doing it together. And so I think the first thing is, as parents always pay attention to what the kids are fascinated by. And then, you know, turn it into an everybody wins conversation. and then um you know there's another concept in the book of win first win fast you know get a get a success before not a success and if they're playing something like that maybe they'll think uh my dad's gonna make me stop playing i'm out of my screen time and go well actually no i'm fascinated with you know tell me about this and now as a parent you're getting the kid to think about the meta of what they like and what they do and i'm just coming to grips with that i feel too old to understand the things that they like.

26:55Bing Gordon, author of Everybody Wins, What Games Teach Us About Making Products People Love. And you've certainly made many of them. Really appreciate your time. Thanks, Jason. Pleasure. Hope it was useful for you.

27:20at CLA we're in your corner and on it we coach tax strategies and little league first base we help you adopt AI data tools and we adopt rescues named buddy we walk your factory floor and jog the local 5K, though sometimes we walk that too. Wherever you're coming from, we're right there with you. Wherever you're going, we'll get you there. CLA, CPAs, consultants, and advisors. Learn more at claconnect.com slash with you.

From the publisher

Most hit makers never make a second hit. Bing Gordon cracked the code. As part of the founding team at Electronic Arts, he helped build Madden, The Sims, and SimCity, and learned exactly why people return to a product (or don’t). His first question for any business is a strange one: Does your app make customers feel liked?

Chapters

0:00 Does your app make customers feel liked?

0:38 Why video game companies become one-hit wonders

2:03 Bing Gordon, Electronic Arts co-founder

2:39 Why creators and musicians struggle to repeat a hit

4:35 How EA kept the Madden NFL team motivated for decades

5:56 Why gamers come back: social, mastery, and rewards

7:39 Session economics and the MyFitnessPal retention lesson

11:08 Customer retention: does your product love its users?

12:15 How Duolingo and Peloton make users feel recognized

13:15 Zynga, Facebook, and Twitter’s magic engagement numbers

14:18 How Twitter’s retweet came from watching user behavior

16:47 Why customer feedback misleads product teams

17:43 Why kids love Roblox games adults find boring

21:01 What SimCity players taught EA about personalization

22:48 How parents should talk to kids about video games
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

More from Problem Solvers

All episodes