1. Podcasts
  2. The Infinite Monkey Cage
  3. Leaf it to Nature
The Infinite Monkey Cage

5 Nov 2026 · 42m · 12 chapters

In short

Leaves—what defines them, how stomata work, how leaves evolved, why leaf shapes vary, how leaves change color and die back in autumn, and how leaf physiology (especially stomata) affects climate and future crop breeding.

Guests (backgrounds)

Jonathan Silvertown, professor at the University of Edinburgh and author of Nature’s Magicians: The Hidden Powers of Leaves; Tracy Lawson, plant physiologist professor at the University of Essex and University of Illinois; Alex Keeley, stand-up comedian.

Key claims

Leaves are flat laminar structures with pores (stomata) on upper/lower surfaces; stomata open/close to balance CO2 uptake with water loss. Leaves appeared ~50 million years after early land plants (~430 million-year-old Rhine chert fossils show stems/no leaves). Leaf efficiency is ~1% (vs ~40–50% solar panels). Stomata counts in fossils can indicate past CO2; rising CO2 can reduce stomata number, affecting transpiration and rainfall patterns.

Notable examples

ginkgo biloba (“living fossil”); rattan/palm leaves used for cane furniture; cheese plant leaves with large holes for ventilation; tropical rainforest “drip tips”; Venus flytrap jaws; Chinese nettle diversifolia (varied leaf shapes); New Zealand pseudopanax ferrox “hacksaw” leaves linked to moa predation; red/orange pigments (anthocyanins, beta-carotene) and senescence.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

1:41

Exploring the Magic of Leaves

Discussion on the origin and significance of leaves in nature.

“Those lovely flappy horizontal bits of plants that do all of the work for making sure that the planet functions.”
3:03

Guest Introductions and Favorite Leaves

Introduction of guests and their favorite types of leaves.

“I'm a professor in plant physiology at the University of Essex here in the UK, but also at the University of Illinois in the States.”
4:57

Defining Characteristics of Leaves

Discussion about the structure and features that define leaves.

“characteristics the features that make a leaf a leaf and not a step i mean basically what's a leaf So a laminar structure, flat and flappy on a stalk.”
7:31

Evolution and History of Leaves

Exploration of how leaves evolved and their historical significance.

“I remember looking at stomata at school.”
11:02

How Leaves Adapt and Function

Insights into how leaves adapt for photosynthesis and their environmental role.

“And there are lots of animals in there too, actually.”
12:21

Fossilization of Plants and Leaves

Discussion on the fossilization process of plants and the significance of plant fossils.

“I wish the listeners could have seen the mime you did for chit-chatting.”
14:00

Understanding Leaf Mechanics

Explore the functions of stomata and the balance of gas exchange in leaves.

“and preserved in extraordinary detail, in microscopic detail, so you could actually see inside the cells of these plants and other organisms living in the hot springs.”
21:41

Leaf Shapes and Adaptations

Learn about leaf shapes and their evolutionary adaptations for survival.

“Alex, what type of leaf do you think you would be?”
28:01

The Mystery of Leaf Coloration

Explore the reasons behind the changing colors of leaves in autumn.

“So the plant doesn't want to waste any of that energy.”
32:51

The Role of Leaves in Climate and Ecology

Understand how leaves interact with the climate and their ecological importance.

“So that process of photosynthesis gave us oxygen that we can breathe, but also it's the foundation for all of our food supply.”
Show all 12 chapters
37:45

Future of Crop Science and Genetic Engineering

Delve into how genetic engineering is applied to improve crops for a changing environment.

“This is mustard and cress world you're suggesting here.”
42:01

Imagining Sunlight Conversion

The hosts discuss what useful substances they would produce if their bodies could convert sunlight.

“I mean, it looks from the way she's written that that she might have sampled all of those.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On The Infinite Monkey Cage, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00Adam Rutherford: This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK. Host Thanksgiving with industry-leading quality standards from Whole Foods Market. There are no antibiotics in their meat department ever, so carve up turkey and spiral-cut ham with peace of mind. Shop organic sides like stuffing mix and cranberry sauce from 365 brand. And guess what? All their delectable pies are made with no high-fructose corn syrup. Gourmet Thanksgiving flavors with the quality you want. Only at Whole Foods Market. It was the first dinosaur ever to be scientifically named. And he came up with an animal that was about 40 foot long.

0:41A profound discovery that led to paleontology as we know it today.

0:46Adam Rutherford: Impossible monsters. These giant, weird reptilian creatures. This was like a thunderbolt. Join me, Misha Glennie, and my three guests for In Our Time. on this episode, Megalosaurus. Listen on BBC.com or wherever you get your podcasts.

1:08Adam Rutherford: Hello, I'm Adam Rutherford. Hello, I'm Jess Fosterkew and this is the Infinite Monkey Cage. We meet here this evening as the nights start to draw in. Summer has faded and autumn is upon us. Now, autumn is named after autumnus, a folk deity or personification of the season. It embodies abundance, thankfulness and the Earth's transition via the bounty of the harvest. And in America, it's called fall because the leaves go wee! Yes, so leaves are the subject of today's monkey cage. Those lovely flappy horizontal bits of plants that do all of the work for making sure that the planet functions. So, you know, no biggie.

1:51Where did they come from? Where are they going? And are they actually magic? Yes, they are. What, you're saying yes? You are letting me suggest on this massive science show that leaves might be proof of magic.

2:02Adam Rutherford: I will allow it. They are probably magic. But to explain why, please welcome our guests. And they are... Hello, I'm Jonathan Silvertown. I'm a professor at the University of Edinburgh and author of a new book called Nature's Magicians. There you go. The Hidden Powers of Leaves. And my favourite leaves belong to palms. In particular, the leaves of ratans. Ratans are amazing things that climb into the canopy of tropical rainforest and their stems, the stems of the leaves, are so pliant that when they are cut down and stripped up into long pieces, they're used to make cane furniture. So if you enjoy a little lie down in a piece of cane furniture because it's nice and bouncy, that's because it comes from leaves that are adapted to survive the vicissitudes of living in the canopy of tropical rainforest.

3:01Adam Rutherford: Also good use bonus points for using the word, what was it? Vicissitude. Hi, I'm Tracy Lawson. I'm a professor in plant physiology at the University of Essex here in the UK, but also at the University of Illinois in the States. And my favourite leaf is ginkgo biloba. say that again ginkgo biloba I mean that's a cute name why is it your favourite leaf? so it's like a living fossil it's the only one that's left now from 290 million years ago and it's a cute pale colour and it's just a beautiful leaf my favourite tree Hi I'm Alex Keeley I'm a stand-up comedian and my favourite leaf is more to do with the tree that the leaf is the leaf from the dragon's blood tree, or Dracaena...

3:54Let's get this right.

4:00Dracaena cinnab... Cinnabarina, maybe. Cinnabarina, there we go. And that is the national tree of Yemen, which I first saw in Tunisia, and the leaves are only kind of on the outer edge, and the tree looks like a sort of top slice of a sphere shoved quite starkly onto a tree trunk and below is sort of a network of branches which looks like spaghetti or human lung and it's called dragon's blood because it's the red sap that comes out of the tree trunk which is extremely cool.

4:32Adam Rutherford: I've got a question. You compared it to spaghetti or human lung? Yes. Those are two different things. I've not often looked at a bowl of spaghetti and thought, lungy, that's lungy. Yeah, yeah. Long-time smoker, I guess, is the issue. and this is our panel

4:56Adam Rutherford: all right i think we better get started with the basics here so what are the defining characteristics the features that make a leaf a leaf and not a step i mean basically what's a leaf So a laminar structure, flat and flappy on a stalk. That's a technical term. It's a technical term. Yeah, look it up. And as you told. It really was. B minus for Rutherford. And has a top surface and a lower surface. And they're both perforated by pores. Over to Tracy. We'll tell you what they do. So you've got these little pores that's mostly on the undersurface of the leaf, and they allow gases in and out of the leaf, which allows them to photosynthesise.

5:41So they're not just flappy structures. They're really doing some really cool things all the time through the day. And all leaves have that. That's what defines it as a leaf, as opposed to being another bit of a plant. Yes, the cells that make it up, the multistructural cells that's in a leaf.

5:56Adam Rutherford: We know what leaves are on trees, right? Nice leaves from trees. but is a cactus spine a leaf? Actually it is. It's a modified leaf and pine needles are leaves as well. Well what about a spider plant? Is that just all leaves and no stem? Spider plants I'm fairly sure are monocots with these sword shaped leaves. Grasses are also monocots, bamboos and they often have long leaves and rather short stems. Alex, I thought it would have been funny to ask you the difference of a leaf and a stem. Did you already know all that? Are you into, like, growing plants? Yeah, I knew all that, obviously. I just thought all leaves and no stems sounded like something that Jack Nickerson would type in The Shining, and I was sort of thinking about that.

6:42Adam Rutherford: But wait, if a pine needle and or a spike on a cactus is a modified leaf, do they have... The holes you're talking about are the stomata, right? Yep. Do pine needles have stomata? Yep. they have to have them to be leaves yeah if it hasn't got it the little latin mouth it's not a leaf Adam and I think they're in a little trough a little groove underneath the leaf why is that so they're sunken down a little bit because then it protects them from the atmosphere so if you're in a little pit it just helps protect you from well insects but also it gives you a buffer between the dry air because that's what smart are trying to do is hold the water in the leaf but at the same time they have to open to allow carbon dioxide in for photosynthesis.

7:27So they're balancing that the whole time, all through the day, doing this juggling act of opening and closing, responding to different stimuli.

7:34Adam Rutherford: Oh, God, it's so clever, isn't it? I remember looking at stomata at school. We'd take leaves and look at them under the microscope. And they do... I mean, they're called stomata because they look like mouths. And they've got sort of lips on either side and go... Great radio, this. Less sound. They don't make a sound. Not that popular. Wow, you weren't listening close enough. They do make a sound, but it's not that poppy, did you say? It's definitely not his pop. Do they look like Han Solo trapped in carbonite? I'm trying to sort of get a visual on what the kind of... Is it sort of a horrified scream or sort of...

8:09It's just a gentle breath. A gentle breath. Just a gentle breath. That's adorable. I would love to know about how leaves evolved. Did they evolve at the same time as the first plants? What came first, the stem or the leaf? The stem. the stem that was definitive tell us about it it's 500 million years ago so nobody can say no can they plants colonized land probably somewhere around 500 million years ago maybe slightly more recently than that and the fossils of the first plants have no leaves and for 50 million years plants were little short things mainly stem roots and there was stomata on the stems themselves i believe wait how do you know this we know there's some fossils and in particular there's a wonderful deposit of fossils at a little village called rhine just south of aberdeen and in the ground and sometimes in the field walls of this village is a rock called rhine chert which is a bit like a flint and it turns out that this contains fossils of some of the earliest known plants 430 million years old and they include these tiny little things that have stems and no leaves they have roots they're even fungi visible inside the roots but no leaves and it was 50 million years or so later that leaves appeared in the fossil record and then six different lineages of plants evolved leaves at around the same time so it's the whole bus thing about you You wait ages for one, nothing turns up, and then six come at once.

9:50And this is the history of leaves. When you said that plants colonise land,

9:54Adam Rutherford: plant life starts in the sea where there are no leaves. Well, all life started in the sea. Yes, agreed. Yes. So the plants are in the sea and they don't have leaves, and then they're on the land and they still don't have leaves. They're just stems. So can I just really clear up for me, how do they get out of the sea? I know I can picture the stem. Yeah. But I don't... Is it slithering? Is it just the algae that's sort of on rocks and then it's grown? But if this is pre-animal or beast to move that algae from one spot to another, how is it getting further out on the land? They would be beast in the ocean, I guess.

10:38So green plants, the things that we call plants on land, evolved, we think, from a group of algae called the streptophyte algae, whose ancestors lived in the sea. And their first stop on land was actually puddles and things like the habitat of the Rhine-e-chert plants. Those were actually fossilised in hot springs. And there are lots of animals in there too, actually. It's fascinating stuff, all tiny, really small. So in answer to your question, Jess, The first stop to land was a puddle, a hot puddle. A hot puddle was actually the sea trying to emigrate.

11:17Adam Rutherford: So how do we get from stems in hot puddles to leaves? Where do the leaves come from? There's no stems in the puddles. Algae don't need stems because they just float around and don't need to have any structure. So then they evolved leaves to actually start photosynthesising and the more plants that came onto land, they start shading out your neighbours, etc. So you need to evolve leaves and start growing and then millions of years later we ended up with trees. You jumped a bit. I feel like you skipped over a couple of... Just a few million years. I'm interested in the how and the why. I thought there was something to do with an abundance of carbon in the atmosphere so they didn't need leaves.

11:53Or is this just completely enough? No, no. Have I accidentally got this off Reddit? No, you're right. You're right. It is right. Yeah, so there was huge amounts of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere. As plants evolved, of course, they started taking that carbon dioxide up and then they got less and less. carbon dioxide in the atmosphere, and that allowed them to evolve the leaf to actually be able to take up more of that carbon dioxide. Bigger surface area, more stomata, doing more chit-chatting and pulling that carbon dioxide into it. I wish the listeners could have seen the mime you did for chit-chatting.

12:25Adam Rutherford: Yeah, lovely, OK, that makes sense. So when I think about leaves, I've got a lot of pot plants at home which don't have leaves on them.

12:35Adam Rutherford: So just pots? They're mostly just pots, to be perfectly honest. Alex, how are you with your pot plants? What are they like at home? I can take real good care of the plastic ones, for sure. Those do fine. I'm very bad with them. They die quite quickly. And giving the neighbour a spare key has not necessarily helped when I'm away on tour for a week. Just some dead plants litter my house. It's quite bleak for Radio 4, I'd say. They're all dead. Our two plant scientists look horrified. You presumably are very green-fingered. Well, your plants have been dead for 400 million years. Yeah, you don't have to water fossils.

13:12That's one of the good things. I've killed a few plants in my time. I don't mind admitting that on live radio. Accidentally, I should say. Well, some of them deliberately. I wonder about these fossils just beneath Aberdeen because I didn't necessarily think of plants as being possible to have left a fossil because it's so porous and fragile compared to other things like bones, which we've discovered so much about from fossils. So was there anything particular about where you got these plant fossils from that meant that the plants were able to be fossilised? Yes, indeed. So it's probably significant that these were hot springs and there were probably silicates dissolved in the water.

13:58And so the fossils are almost like glass. In fact, they are glass. They're silicate fossils. and preserved in extraordinary detail, in microscopic detail, so you could actually see inside the cells of these plants and other organisms living in the hot springs. I'm not sure about the exact chemistry. Possibly, no, she's shaking her head. Yeah, not this end of the table. I think this is where the jokes are required. Yeah. But, yeah, anyone know any silicate jokes? Even on this show, that's too niche. Okay.

14:32Adam Rutherford: So in the prep for this, Jess nerded out at levels I've never seen before and has told me leaf facts all day. It's been quite a long day, to be honest. You're welcome. She is really interested in the sort of mechanics. So those little stomata, they're opening and closing. What's going on? So the stomata on the leaves open and close to light CO2 concentrations, humidity. So they're continually adjusting through the day. And there's two specialized cells that surround the pore, the mouth, like lips, and they're different shapes, and there's lots of different complexity to them, and they're open, and that allows the carbon dioxide to diffuse from the atmosphere into the leaf, where it's used in the process of photosynthesis, which is the basis of all life on this planet.

15:19And then as a consequence of that, of course, water travels out of the plant. And that water traveling out travels out much, much faster than the CO2 going in. and so they're trying to continually balance that how much should i be open to let co2 in

15:35Adam Rutherford: and not let too much water out what's a leaf doing during the course of of a normal day after loose women it's done on that done some sleep it's not to open in the mornings so they try to open sort of quite quickly in the mornings there's some mechanisms that allow that to happen so they can start taking in that co2 water then starts being lost and we think of that as a wasteful process but it's really important to bring nutrients up from the soil and it also helps the leaf keep cool and so through the day it's just trying to balance that all the time trying to balance how much co2 how much water depending on how much light how much carbon dioxide how much you water your plants or didn't water your plants and that'll make a big difference to what the stomata are doing and they're closed during the night because there's no sunlight yes apart from can plants.

16:24From what? Your cactus. Oh, yes. Yeah, it opens to monitor at night.

16:28Adam Rutherford: Oh, why are they doing that? They're the comedians of the plant world. Because they live in a hot desert. Oh, no. We just work at night. I'm seeing some parallels between being a plant and being a comedian, Alex, in that you have to breathe at night. Alex is also a new dad. Are you finding you're having to adapt to that with different patterns? Yeah, I'm sort of up at the same time as those plants opening their leaves, I suppose. Sweating a lot? Sweating a lot. Trying to move to the desert, I suppose. I don't know what's involved. Yeah. Okay, so what are some of the bigger problems that a leaf might have to solve?

17:09So the key one is it's got to do that gaseous exchange, get that right. But the other thing is that, of course, light changes. you've got dynamic light environment. Some days are really sunny, other days are really dull. So plants just need loads and loads of light. But if it's too much, it damages them. So they've got some really cool mechanisms where they actually sort of dissipate this light and get rid of it.

17:30Adam Rutherford: We so casually talk about photosynthesis and we learn about photosynthesis and it being the lungs of the planet. But what is actually going on there? It doesn't seem like a very efficient way of processing energy, staring at the sun for 12 hours and then sweating a lot. No, it's not the most efficient process. There's a lot of losses of that light energy. But we see that, and yet it's fueled the entire planet to where we've got to, even if it's inefficient. What would it look like if leaves were like 99 % efficient? So would that be like a problem for leaves or trees if they were like that? Would it be taking on too much energy?

18:09So leaves are about 1 % efficient. So if you compare that with a solar panel, the best ones, I'm told, are about 40 % to 50 % efficient. So 40 % to 50 % of the light energy landing on your solar panel ends up as electricity. The equivalent in leaves, they're not producing electricity, but they're producing glucose, is about 1%. So what happens to the other 99 % of the energy, which is perhaps what Alex is asking? It's dangerous. It's dangerous because it's heat. So some gets reflected, some fluoresces, so the wavelength is changed and re-emitted. Some go straight through. Typically plants live surrounded by each other, by other plants.

18:51There are layers. Up to about six layers of leaf is sort of the maximum that works. And the upper leaves filter out the red, but by the time you get down to sort of layer five or six, there's only green light left. and green light works in photosynthesis. They can use green light as well. So that's kind of what's going on and the heat has to be dealt with, radiated in some ways. And leaves have all sorts of ways of dealing with that. Actually, Jess is wearing a very nice example of the way in which some leaves deal with this. Thank you for mentioning that, even though it's radio. Well, I do mean your earrings.

19:33They're from a cheese plant, aren't they? Precisely. And what's the thing we all know about cheese plants they have holes in their leaves yeah why well jesse's ones are about what i'd say five or six centimeters long oh sorry but real ones but real real ones are are really big they're among the biggest leaves that you're likely to grow in on your house plants and that means in terms of dissipating the heat that's the problem the 99 problem so the holes in the leaves are for ventilation they help cool the leaf and the other way leaves cool is by having serrated edges it's the edge where the the air moves across the leaf surface cooling the leaf and so one of the factors that affects the evolution of leaf shape is the effect of shape on dealing with with heat why is

20:25Adam Rutherford: there so much variation in in leaf shape that we can identify every one of tens of thousands of trees simply by the leaves why are they not all the same well actually your premise is wrong unfortunately that's another b minus for other so huge species richness in in tropical rainforest you can find hundreds of different species in a hectare and you cannot usually identify all of those hundreds by their leaves because they all look the same and the typical tropical rainforest leaf looks like a sort of shield with a pointy tip and the pointy tip is called a drip tip because what happens when it rains and in rainforests it does rain a lot the water is basically taken off the leaf by the tip the tip kind of acts as a little spigot the leaf bends under the weight of the water the water then runs off the drip tip like a like a dripping nose if you like and all these different species in many different plant families have converged on this common shape there are other leaves other leaves are available i think is the phrase but this convergent evolution is because there's something really important about what the drip tip does and what it is basically is it helps with photosynthesis because a wet leaf is very reflective and while you want to reflect some of the light so that it doesn't overheat you've got to catch some as well especially if your leaves are underneath somebody else's leaves so what the drip tip does is it drains the surface of the leaf after rainfall and then as the weight of the water on it is relieved the leaf is then able to get back into a more upright position where it can capture light and that's so important that hundreds of species essentially have identical looking leaves.

22:19Oh, this is so interesting. Alex, what type of leaf do you think you would be? One with a drip tip or not? It feels quite a low status leaf, the drip tip. What's a sort of high status leaf? High status? What's an alpha leaf? I'd like to know what the leafs drink is. This is definitely a question for Tracy here.

22:41Adam Rutherford: Wow, way to offload there. We mentioned the spider plants, that's just all leaves right surely if you're a spider flytrap a leaf it is it's modified leaf yeah alex that would be pretty sick yeah okay i'll be that one then i mean you're the kindest man i've ever met not the venus flytrap energy but fair play yeah trapper i mean are how normal the venus flytrap leaves that's pretty weird stuff isn't it well carnivorous plants are vanishingly rare right Yes. They're only found in a limited number of habitats where nitrogen is not very available. They tend to be wet bogs, things like that. And the Venus flytrap is unique.

23:21There's nothing else that has jaws and does that trick. And it's fascinating stuff. Those jaws are leaves. I loved Day of the Triffids. So that isn't a thing. There aren't like swamp lands with actual plants that could gobble up a person anywhere. not we found so far okay nice one not ruling out i love the idea that you only find those venus fly traps in those kind of remote boggy areas than also every kind of teenage boy's bedroom can i ask a specific question because about that leaf variety thing um is it sometimes to ward off predators i read about one plant that the plant itself had a variety of different leaf shapes And the theory was that butterflies in particular would lay their eggs on these plants or plants like this, and they would decide on where to lay their eggs.

24:14And obviously they're going to be laying eggs that then go on to become caterpillars that scoff that leaf right up. So the plant wants to protect itself from that. And because the butterflies decide by shape, that might be one reason why some plants have a variety of different leaf shapes. Yes, you're thinking of this nettle, this Chinese nettle, that has these vicious stinging hairs. I mean, our nettles are kind of wimps by comparison. And strangely enough, it has a variety of different leaf shapes on the same plant. And we don't honestly know why. And initially, when these plants were first described from herbarium specimens, like dried leaves pressed in newspapers, stuck away in museums, It was thought to be a number of different species because the leaves look so different.

25:03But on closer examination, it turns out that individual plants can have different leaves. And so the specific name of this plant is diversifolia, meaning variety of leaves. Host Thanksgiving with industry-leading quality standards from Whole Foods Market. There are no antibiotics in their meat department ever. So carve up turkey and spiral cut ham with peace of mind. Shop organic sides like stuffing mix and cranberry sauce from 365 brand. And guess what? All their delectable pies are made with no high fructose corn syrup. Gourmet Thanksgiving flavors with the quality you want. Only at Whole Foods Market.

25:45It was the first dinosaur ever to be scientifically named. And he came up with an animal that was about 40 foot long. A profound discovery that led to paleontology as we know it today.

25:57Adam Rutherford: Impossible monsters, these giant, weird reptilian creatures. This was like a thunderbolt. Join me, Misha Glennie, and my three guests for In Our Time on this episode, Megalosaurus. Listen on bbc.com or wherever you get your podcasts.

26:20Adam Rutherford: So, here's a question, which I probably should know the answer to. Leaves are green, right? Because they've got chlorophyll in them, which is green. Why are some leaves red? So that's another pigment. And that can change with the seasons. You often see leaves turn red with seasons. So you have, like, pigments that's not chlorophyll, anthracyanins and other types of pigments, beta-carotene, except you have the orange in your carrots. And so plants have all of those, and they change the different concentrations of them, depending on the conditions, because that helps them to either protect from too much light or absorb light.

26:58So they, again, balance what they want to achieve. And so they turn different colours.

27:02Adam Rutherford: And why are some leaves variegated? Is that the right word? I'm not on Gardner's Question Time. It is the right word. And what does that mean, sorry? What does variegated mean in that context? Like a spider plant that has a white stripe in it. And that white stripe still has stomata because they're uber important. Still has the stomata but doesn't have any chlorophyll. I'm not obsessed with spider plants, just for the record. It's about the only plant I can name. OK, so they're mostly green, and some of them are red. And why do they go brown? Why do they go brown? It's autumn, because they're dead, probably.

27:42Adam Rutherford: That's not enough. I don't go brown when I'm dead. I don't think so. Well, we don't really know yet, do we? That sounded like a threat to me. Sorry. But why is autumn so characterised by lovely shades of brown as the leaves fall off the trees? What's going on there? So the plant doesn't want to waste any of that energy. It's just put into those leaves. And so it starts taking it back and storing it in the trunks or the bulbs. Different plants have different storage. So they start taking back some of those key pigments and they do it in different stages. And that's how you get them colours of fall or autumn.

28:20And at the end, there's virtually nothing left there but some of the structure. But isn't there something else as well? I mean, the anthocyanin in maple leaves, for example, which typically turn red, is actually manufactured during senescence, isn't it? So that's not just that the green is disappearing, revealing what was underneath, which was red. It's actually being manufactured. And so why is that? Why is a leaf that's dying making something new? So I think they've still got to protect themselves. so anthracinins can be a protectant. So they can protect, as in, I mentioned about this, dissipating light, so the plant absorbs the light, but if it doesn't need it, it gets rid of its heat.

29:02But also they produce reactive oxygen species and things that's not good for the plant and the anthracinins can mop them up and get rid of them. Protective things. Am I right in saying there's still a little bit of mystery around why leaves turn the colours they do? Yes. In the orchid. There are so many theories. Another theory may be that you can shoot this down or say, oh my God, you nailed it. Feel free to do that one. So might that be a reason why some plants go particularly bright reds, especially as red in nature is a go away. They're nodding, listeners. It's a go away colour. Is there any weight to the theory at all that as the leaf is getting that energy in from the leaf into the plant before it knows it's going to drop that it goes red so that things stop coming to eat it an interesting question i'm rapidly trying to think if i can think of an example of a plant that has warning coloration so warning coloration is quite common in animals um i don't believe that there is an example in plants what plants tend to do is hide so for example in australia there's a whole group of mistletoe species and different species of mistletoe live on different australian trees and the shapes of the mistletoe leaves corresponds to the shapes of the leaves of the trees in which they live mistletoes live in other in trees like those parasites um why well because actually mistletoe leaves turn out to be quite tasty to a koala bear and things like that so that's hiding by mimicry um i can't think of an example where a plant actually i have just thought of an example yeah yeah go on yeah you're not gonna tell us mine so there is this is pretty this is pretty unusual this is a new zealand plant that produces the most barbarous leaves and i mean literally barbarous it's got barbs all along it The leaves are grey and they have teeth on either side, like a double-sided hacksaw blade.

31:16And some of them, not all of them, have a yellow stripe down the centre of the leaf. What is all this about? Well, it's especially interesting because once these plants get to about 12 feet high, they stop producing these hacksaw-type leaves with their warning stripes. And they produce ordinary-looking leaves. what we think of as ordinary looking leaves at 12 feet and this is really weird the theory is that this has evolved under predation from moas these giant extinct birds that went extinct about only about seven or eight hundred years ago and prior to that these huge birds could reach up into the canopy about 12 feet and beyond that the leaves would be safe so below that level the leaves of this plant are barbed and have these yellow stripes and above it not oh i love it i love it what's the name of that plant i was afraid you'd ask me that i just give me a moment only so

32:16Adam Rutherford: i can tell out alex uh his favorite alpha plant now but everything everything's weird in australia it's called it's called well there are various species but it's called pseudopanax and the one have growing in my bathroom actually is pseudopanax ferrox uh ferrox meaning so unless your bathroom's four meters tall it's just like well it's a small one it's a seedling it's a baby but it's the babies that have these vicious spines do you keep mower in your bathroom no i keep the mower in the garden shed right this is extreme exfoliation right let's move move it on because we want to we want to get into the anthropocene and what plants what have plants ever done for us which feels like a ridiculously big question but tracy how dependent are we on leaves like utterly dependent on them so we wouldn't be here without them so plants and we have to give credit to the oceans as well put the put the oxygen in our in our atmosphere that we breathe so before plants started to photosynthesize and cyanobacteria earlier on there was very little oxygen in the planet.

33:23So that process of photosynthesis gave us oxygen that we can breathe, but also it's the foundation for all of our food supply. Whether that's, whether you're eating a beef burger, the cow that ate the grass, you know, it's the foundation for all of it. And medicines, materials, plants, the basis of how we actually even settle down from those nomadic lifestyles to settling down and starting to form.

33:45Adam Rutherford: So the evolution of life on earth is dependent on plants arriving in puddles and then colonising the entire planet and the subsequent evolution of animals including us is also utterly dependent on on that process we're really dependent on leaves aren't we absolutely we've talked about like stuff that leaves are trying to cope with problems that leaves are trying to solve and you touched on it briefly in terms of how rapidly the climate's changing now compared to the millions of years that leaves have had to adapt to climate change pre-industrialisation. Are leaves sort of effectively shaping the climate around them?

34:22So they're affected by it and they also affect the climate. It all comes back down to stomata as well, because they're super important, not just because I work on them, but...

34:29Adam Rutherford: You really love stomata, don't you? I've done them for 30 years. So actually, as the CO2 concentrations are rising in the atmosphere and have done in the past, the number of stomata changes on the leaves. And so we talked about the fossils before. People find those fossils and use those fossils as paleoindicators. So they count the stomata on the fossil leaves, and that can be a predictor of what the CO2 concentration was when that was fossilised. I'm amazed that you can see stomata in fossils, because we don't see that sort of resolution in lots of animal fossils, which tend to be more recent than this.

35:03Adam Rutherford: You can actually see individual cells. Yep, yep. Not on all of them, and not all plants are preserved as well as each other. so that's an issue for paleo indicators but yeah you can see that plants that evolved in a high CO2 environment had very few stomata. Which plants have got the most mouths then? It's like an oak got like tens, hundreds, thousands. Are there plants that have got loads more stomata than others then? Oak? Oak? You nailed it. A plus. That's the equivalent of a Paul Hollywood handshake by the way guys so I'll take that. It's oak that's got the most stomata. I don't know if it's got most, but it's got a lot.

35:42How many on one oak leaf, roughly? Like a million? A hundred thousand? Ten thousand? You have around about 800 to 1 ,000 per millimetre squared. Okay. They're not trivial. So, carry the one, and then... Do you need my pen? I'd love a pen and the rest of the episode, probably.

36:02Adam Rutherford: And in terms of adapting to climate change, what's happening in the last couple of hundred years? So there's definitely been changes in the number of stomata on the leaves. So there was a study that was done a few years ago now that looked at the northern boreal forests. And just this change in CO2 concentration in the last sort of 50, 70 years, stomata have decreased in number, which has changed the entire transpiration stream of the northern boreal forests, which has an impact on where rain falls on the rest of the planet. Whoa. So that's how important they are. Is there a chance that socialist governments around the world have sort of bribed the leaves to have fewer stomata as a sort of, you know, hoax?

36:46I don't think the plants would do without their tea plants. That's good. It is interesting. It does sound like, with changing carbon levels again, but this time man-made, I want to know a bit more about how plants are adapting to that. So I think the key thing is that virtually all of the water on our planet passes through plants at some point. so therefore they influence the climate by what they are doing physiologically so if you transpire more if you let more water out of the stomata you let more out into the atmosphere that changes the atmospheric conditions and where there was rainfall patterns might might change or where they might fall so but at the same time the amount of rain that falls influences the plants so they influence the climate and the climate influences their behavior so if pre-leaves we had just stems because there was an abundance of carbon and we're going back to having an abundance of carbon.

37:35Is there a world in which we use what space we've got more efficiently by having plants that are still very productive but that don't have leaves and go back to just having stems? This is mustard and cress world you're suggesting here. I think not because what we need to do actually is adapt crops for this new world, which is not only higher in CO2. And I mean, in terms of the climate, admit it's a very important difference but compared to how much co2 there was when plants had no leaves it's not that big a change which is not to say it isn't important it's very important to climate so we we need plants that can also resist heat that can resist uh drought salinization of soil so salt accumulating in irrigated soils pests newly emerging pests and diseases so there are all these challenges and i don't think you're going to cure them just by stripping a few leaves off

38:29Adam Rutherford: now tracy you you you're an experimental biologist what are you actually doing in your labs so we are trying to find crops or manipulate crops that will work better in future environments we know there's going to be less water on the planet you know it's the liquid gold um temperatures because of course the co2 rises we also have a rise in temperature which plants have to cope with that cause them to lose more water probably getting smaller leaves in that adaptation um and of course resistance to pests nutrients etc and try and make them more productive because there's no more land to grow food but there's more people so plants have to be able to increase yields in fact we have to double yields by the end of well some some scenarios would say by the year 2050 2060 to feed the growing population globally.

39:18Adam Rutherford: And your experiments, you say you're modifying the plants, altering the number of stomata in the size and the shape of leaves. How are you doing that alteration? Just traditional breeding? So we know there's huge amounts of natural variation, so if you can find that, you can put that into breeding lines. The development pathway for stomata is very well known, so we know what genes are involved. So there's gene editing tools that you can use. And a key part of the work that I'm doing is also trying to speed up how stomata open and close. And you can genetically modify the stomata so they are more flappy?

39:47Yes. So they open and close more often? Stomata can be lazy, so depending on the species, so they're a bit slow, a bit lazy to open. So some things will open really fast. Some of the grasses, some of our key crops, rice, wheat, can be quite fast. Other things like French beans or broad beans, really slow, lazy. And so if we can speed them up, they'll be more in tune with the environment. So, you know, if you think, light comes on, plant has to open stomata, and as they slowly open to allow that CO2 in, if they're slow, the CO2 won't get in fast enough, can't use that light to make our sugars and use that as fuel.

40:25So they're limiting photosynthesis, limiting CO2 in. If they open, and then when the light goes, if something shades the plant, a cloud comes over, then they have to close again. And if they close too slowly, they're losing loads of water for not gaining any carbon dioxide. So we want speedy stomata. Speedy stomata, it's amazing. And it sounds like, I guess, when we're talking about your lab and stuff like that, by the way, if we need to kind of do some PR for this, as it does sound like quite urgent work, I think we are making these labs sound like a fun theme park if we do actually call them mustard and cress world.

40:56But equally, it's not new, is it? Because we've been doing this in agriculture forever. Like a cabbage doesn't grow like that because it wants to grow like that. We've designed it to grow in a way that's going to feed us most efficiently. Absolutely. We found the traits that we want and tried to breed them into those varieties as we've domesticated various crops.

41:13Adam Rutherford: But now you do that using genetic engineering. Alex, if you were going to genetically engineer any quality into a plant, what would it be? Timeliness, sort of good timekeeping. What was the pace that you're talking about when you say how quickly they're opening? Is it like half an hour? Yes, if you're lazy vissier. Okay. You're quite judgmental about the speed of stomata. Anyway, we asked our audience if your body was able to convert sunlight into something useful, what would it be? Alex. If your body was able to convert sunlight into something useful, what would it be? Beer. Who said that? Simon has said that.

41:56I think we might have a bit of a theme here because Katie has written red wine. No, white wine. No, rosé. No, dry rosé.

42:05Adam Rutherford: I mean, it looks from the way she's written that that she might have sampled all of those. Also, I mean, where is it coming out of? Why? What is it coming out of the nose? Licking your skin. Straight out the nose. Or into the stomata. Yeah. So Helen's continued that theme. If your body was able to convert sunlight into something useful, what would it be? Chocolate. Although, if my body had produced it, I'm not sure I'd want to eat it. Mm-hmm, she says, and then says, or cash. Good. It's the Groucho Marx approach to chocolate. I wouldn't want to eat any chocolate that my own body produced, if I'm so sad.

42:44Brian says, if your body was able to convert sunlight into something useful, what would it be? Anti-constipation treatment. Brackets, but not too fast acting.

42:57Quite a sinister backstory for that.

42:59Adam Rutherford: And that was from Brian? That was from Brian. No last name. Absolutely fair play to not last name. And finally, if your body was able to convert sunlight into something useful, what would it be? Heidi has said money, but I imagine most people will say that, so maybe cats.

43:15Can't have too many cats. I love that. Spare cats. I don't want that coming out of my stomata.

43:24Adam Rutherford: All right, well, thank you to all of our guests, Tracey Lawson, Jonathan Silvertown and Alex Keeley. We'll be back at the same time next week. Goodbye. Goodbye. In the infinite monkey cage. In the infinite monkey cage. Without your trousers. In the infinite monkey cage.

43:47Till now, nice again.

43:49Adam Rutherford: This Cultural Life from BBC Radio 4. I will never go into anything so deep like that again. The world's leading artistic figures reveal their creative influences. Disobey, disagree, disavow. I'm John Wilson and my recent guests have included the sculptor Anish Kapoor, photographer Annie Leibovitz, the actor Kristen Scott-Thomas. It has made me good at telling stories about people who have a secret suffering. And former Children's Laureate Frank Cottrell-Boys. If art's got one function, it's to point to what's wonderful and say, look, this is your world, it's insane. Listen to This Cultural Life on BBC Sounds.

44:31It was the first dinosaur ever to be scientifically named. And he came up with an animal that was about 40 foot long. A profound discovery that led to paleontology as we know it today.

44:43Adam Rutherford: Impossible monsters, these giant, weird reptilian creatures. This was like a thunderbolt. Join me, Misha Glennie, and my three guests for In Our Time on this episode, Megalosaurus. Listen on BBC.com or wherever you get your podcasts.

From the publisher

We walk on them, rake them up, often barely give them a thought, but the humble leaf is an extraordinary feat of biological engineering. Adam Rutherford and Jessica Fostekew are joined plant scientist Tracy Lawson, biologist Jonathan Silvertown, and comedian Alex Kealy to uncover the hidden ingenuity of leaves. They explore how leaves evolved, why plants face a constant battle between thirst and starvation, and whether understanding their clever adaptations could help us engineer crops for a hotter, drier future.

Producer: Mel Brown A BBC Studios Production

More from The Infinite Monkey Cage

All episodes