1. Podcasts
  2. The Infinite Monkey Cage
  3. The First Britons - Tim Minchin, Prof Chris Stringer and Dr Selina Brace
The Infinite Monkey Cage

15 Oct 2026 · 43m · 19 chapters

Episode artwork

The First Britons - Tim Minchin, Prof Chris Stringer and Dr Selina Brace

In short

Who were the first humans in Britain, how they arrived, and how later populations (including Neanderthals and modern humans) replaced or mixed with them; includes DNA evidence from Cheddar Gorge and the “Cheddar Man” reconstruction.

Guests (backgrounds)

Chris Stringer, researcher on human evolution at the Natural History Museum (last 1 million years; mentions Cheddar Gorge remains ~15,000 years old). Selina Brace, NHM specialist in extracting DNA from very old bones and animals (e.g., Gough’s Cave DNA). Tim Minchin, comedian/songwriter/performer (adds humor; not a scientist).

Key claims

Britain was connected to Europe by a land bridge for much of the last million years; earliest evidence of people is ~900,000-year-old stone tools and footprints at Happisburgh, with possible Homo antecessor from Atapuerca (~850,000 years). Multiple human species occupied Britain in waves, likely disappearing with climate shifts. Neanderthals and modern humans interbred elsewhere, but Britain likely saw limited/no introgression. Cheddar Gorge DNA shows two different modern-human cultures around 15,000 years ago and the world’s oldest genetically proven domesticated dog from Gough’s Cave.

Notable examples

hippos in the Thames; systematic butchery at Boxgrove (including rhino); Cheddar Man (10,000 years old) DNA from the petrous bone, reconstructed as dark-skinned with blue eyes; Cheddar Gorge dog remains (domesticated canine).

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

1:34

Exploring the First Britons

The hosts introduce the scientists discussing the first inhabitants of Britain.

“And I'm Jess Fosterkew, and this is the Infinite Monkey Cage.”
5:30

The Landscape of Ancient Britain

Chris describes Britain's climate and environment a million years ago.

“So we're talking about Britain, we're talking about the peopling of these sceptred isles many moons ago.”
7:50

Evidence of Early Humans

Discussion on the oldest evidence of human presence in Britain.

“The sort of area of the British Isles was doubled by this huge area that was open land.”
12:15

Human Species and Migration

Selina and Chris discuss the different human species that inhabited Britain and their migrations.

“Mostly, we assume, because of the climate getting too bad for them to survive here.”
14:01

Neanderthal Remains: A Forensic Journey

Explore the complexities of interpreting Neanderthal remains and their implications.

“But Chris has already mentioned this site in Spain, Atapuerca, where a lot of remains have come up from this site.”
16:51

Understanding Homo Heidelbergensis

Learn about the lifestyle and characteristics of Homo heidelbergensis.

“Do we know anything about their lifestyle?”
19:20

Evolutionary Relationships in Human History

Delve into the evolutionary connections between Homo species.

“So I used to think that Heidelbergensis was the common ancestor of us and Neanderthals.”
21:11

Debunking Neanderthal Myths

Challenge the stereotypes surrounding Neanderthals and their capabilities.

“about these sort of grunting cavemen that, Chris, you've already alluded to, would just walk into a rugby team, but I think we can make them more sophisticated than that.”
23:23

The Significance of Gough's Cave

Discover the archaeological and genetic findings from Gough's Cave.

“No added growth hormones or antibiotics in their meat department means slow-braised short ribs are even more satisfying.”
28:00

The Origins of Dogs: From Wolves to Companions

Discover the process of canine domestication and its benefits to humans.

“It means I get my golden retriever but don't get the sneezes.”
Show all 19 chapters
30:02

Cheddar Man: The Oldest Complete Skeleton in Britain

Learn about Cheddar Man, his discovery, and his significance as a hunter-gatherer.

“But agriculture is beginning at this point, so the hunter-gatherer lifestyle is on the way out in Western Europe?”
31:38

Diet and Lifestyle of Cheddar Man

Explore what Cheddar Man ate and how his diet reflects hunter-gatherer life.

“Yeah, which changes when you get agriculture coming in.”
34:35

The Reconstruction Controversy: Cheddar Man's Appearance

Uncover the debates surrounding Cheddar Man's appearance based on DNA analysis.

“hair colour and so we were able to actually do a reconstruction of what Cheddar Man looked like this iconic individual.”
36:08

The First Britons: Who Were They?

Investigate the identity of the first Britons and the evidence surrounding them.

“It even feels intriguing to me that we so specifically looked for lactose intolerance.”
37:58

The Mystery of Neanderthal Extinction

Delve into theories about why Neanderthals disappeared and the role of modern humans.

“And as Selina said, us and Neanderthals, we know they may have overlapped in Britain.”
39:44

Cultural Reflections on Ancestry and Identity

Discuss the implications of ancestry research on modern identity and perceptions.

“Obviously, they're going to want to hunt the same animals, collect the same plant resources, wanting to live in the best places.”
42:01

Genetic Replacement in Britain

Learn about the historical population replacements in Britain and their implications.

“Genetically, he didn't really make much of an impact.”
43:01

Audience Interaction on Archaeological Objects

Discover what quirky objects listeners would leave for future archaeologists.

“If you were going to leave an object behind for archaeologists to find in 100 ,000 years into the future to inform or confuse them, what would it be and why?”
45:30

Global Story Podcast Teaser

Learn about the 'cockroach movement' and its impact on India's youth.

“I'm Tristan Redmond, co-host of the BBC's Global Story podcast.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On The Infinite Monkey Cage, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK.

0:30Spice up fall at Whole Foods Market. O, O, O, O 'Reilly. Check engine, ABS, or maintenance light on. Take the guesswork out of your warning lights with O 'Reilly Veriscan. The service is free and provides a report with solutions verified by ASE certified master technicians. And if you need help, we could recommend a shop for you. Ask for O 'Reilly Veriscan today. O, O, O, O 'Reilly.

1:28Auto Parts

1:34Hello, I'm Adam Rutherford. And I'm Jess Fosterkew, and this is the Infinite Monkey Cage. Same cage, different monkeys. If I was a monkey, I'd be a mandrill, I reckon, because they can climb, but they prefer not to, and I've got a lot of time for that attitude. Also, I think facially they look a bit like a clown, and I'm a comedian. Yes, but as a biologist, I have to point out that it's only the males that have blue faces and the females actually have bright red arses. All right, well, you're a biologist, so what monkey does that make you? A lab monkey? Or actually, are we both apes? Now, I want to take this opportunity as a biologist to clear this issue up once and for all.

2:14Apes are types of monkeys. Please don't write in. Old world monkeys, which are called Sercopythacidae, including the red-arsed banderill, are more closely related to the great apes, which are called the hominidae, than they are to the New World monkeys, which are called the Platorini, and all three belong to the infra-order Simiformes, which is the monkeys. So we are all monkeys. Good audience. That was quite long, though. Is it too late to get the physicist back? We're talking about first Britons. We're asking the question, who was actually on Britain first? Like, who got here first? Yeah, that's a great question to ask our scientists.

3:00But for God's sake, don't ask it on Facebook or Twitter or at Uncle Ian's birthday lunch. No, best avoided. Definitely not a political question, this one. It's the science of the first hominids to ever live on these islands. Even though Britain wasn't always an island. So, we're not being political, but we are talking about rejoining Europe. Yes, but a million years ago. And to help us dig up the bones and the history of the first Britons, we are joined by a geneticist, a paleoanthropologist... ..and a living international treasure. They are... I'm Chris Stringer and I'm a researcher on human evolution at the Natural History Museum in London.

3:43And I mainly work on the last one million years of the story, which does include the whole of the British story, and us and Neanderthals and weird creatures like hobbits that lived way over near Australia. I think, you know, one of the most interesting things I've ever dug up, I think would be the most interesting, some human remains in Cheddar Gorge. They're about 15 ,000 years old and they were cannibalised. So not a very nice story, but they were very thoroughly done over, beheaded and scalped, eyes cut out, tongues cut out. Selina. OK, yeah, different story. I'm Selina Brace. I'm at the Natural History Museum in London and I specialise in getting DNA from very dead people and animals.

4:30I feel like dead is a binary category and it doesn't really need the very. True. But if you died right now, I probably shouldn't take your DNA. That's not... It's rude. It's rude to do it. They've been dead for long enough that it's OK that you muck around with them. Yeah, I think so. I feel vaguely threatened. Yeah, so I'm not an archaeologist. I work in a lab. so the most interesting thing that I've dug up was actually half a human mannequin from a skip outside a football club.

5:05I did ask permission, by the way. I'm Tim Minchin. I write songs and act and make things and the most interesting thing I've ever dug up was a tweet that Adam wrote in 2012 that was really racist. No, it's a joke. LAUGHTER LAUGHTER That would be an amazing revelation. Thank you, Tim. And this is our panel. APPLAUSE

5:35Chris, let's start with you. So we're talking about Britain, we're talking about the peopling of these sceptred isles many moons ago. What did Britain look like a million years ago? Yeah, as you've already said, it was pretty firmly joined onto the rest of Europe. So there was a wide land bridge, and that was there most of the last million years. And it was a different place in terms of the vegetation, in terms of the animals. So at times there were very cold periods, so could ice ages, and other times it was as warm or even warmer than the present day. So a million years ago, the climate was pretty good.

6:09There were giant carnivores around, saber-toothed cats. In some of the warm periods, we had hippos swimming. So there were hippos swimming in the River Thames 120 ,000 years ago. At times it would have looked like the Serengeti Plains in Britain. At other times it would have looked like the wastes of Siberia with some woolly rhinos and some woolly mammoths and reindeer. Hippos in the Thames? Yeah, hippos in the Thames. Oh, my God. It's one of my favourite bands. Their bones are underneath Trafalgar Square. When they dig in the foundations of buildings in Trafalgar Square, you find hippos, lions, hyenas.

6:44Are you sure that just wasn't the remnants of one of the things that's been on the fourth plinth? Yeah, yeah. Can I ask about, so the climate's changing and I know the timescales are huge, but not enough for these animals to evolve. So they're coming up from Africa when it's warm enough? So the hippos could have swum around from the Mediterranean along the coasts, of course, and then gone across following the south side of that land bridge before there was an island. I'm not saying I've watched too much AI slop, but could smaller animals have ridden on the hippo's back? Elephants as well, yeah, they could have been on the elephants.

7:20So you describe it as a land bridge, which makes it sound like a bridge, but it's just land, isn't it? Yeah, it's just land, yeah. Think about the shape of the UK today. Where is it connected? Yeah, so you think of the white cliffs of Dover, all that chalk there. So there's similar chalk on the other side of the channel, in Belgium or France, so that was continuous. There was this big ridge of chalk, and at times it was really wide. So there's this thing called Doggerland, of course, so where the Dogger Bank is in the North Sea. 50 ,000 years ago, that was all dry land. The sort of area of the British Isles was doubled by this huge area that was open land.

7:55Is that why in the shipping forecast they said Dogger? Yeah, Dogger, that's right. So Dogger Bank is just part of this much wider expanse and fishermen trawling find artefacts, they find woolly mammoth bones and bring them up in their nets sometimes. Whoa. What's the earliest evidence, please, of there being people then in Britain? And how did they get there? Not on a hippo's back. Yeah, well, they would have walked across. And the oldest we know of are about 900 ,000 years old. We don't actually have their fossil remains, but what we have is stone tools they're left behind and their footprints.

8:31So we've actually got some footprints that are 900 ,000 years old. So the River Thames then was flowing much further north, across East Anglia into the North Sea. and these people were walking alongside the banks of the Proto-River Thames. How do you know that someone who was like 880 ,000 years old didn't have some leftover 20 ,000-year-old feet and faked the foot? Yeah, it's a good question. You should have checked that first. I mean, these were discovered right where the tide was washing over the beach and there were these clays there. He's answering it seriously. I know, you've just upturned the whole of the field with your comedy clown feet.

9:11Frank's shoes. Have you considered this, Chris? When we heard of these footprints, that was my reaction too, to be honest. So some of my colleagues were up there sampling these clays where we had found the stone tools, and they phoned back to us and said, we think we've found some footprints. We said, you idiots. We thought they were probably made a few days earlier. But they were barefoot for a start, and it was not good weather, so it wasn't even likely to be. They were in a clay that we could date to 900 ,000 because the pollen in that clay was matching the ones we had. And these impressions, the sea was going over them twice a day and within two weeks they'd all been washed away.

9:46So we couldn't even preserve them. And that's in North Norfolk? That's, yeah, Haysborough. Yeah, yeah. It's one of the worst places for coastal erosion and it's constantly exposing things. So more footprints have turned up briefly. Stone tools are found on the beach and we've got a network of collectors now who go over the beaches when they're walking their dogs. So you've got some evidence of culture, so tools and things like that, and you've got these footprints as well. So who did walk on those muddy fields? Well, without the fossils, of course, we don't know for sure, but there is a species in Spain at Atapuerca.

10:22So there are about 850 ,000-year-old fossils. About 200 fossils have been found there of people, and they've been put in a species called Homo antecessor, or Pioneer Man, thought to be one of the earliest humans in Europe. They're only known from that site, but given the 850 ,000-year date, they could well be the people that were up in Britain, and they were cannibals as well. I'm sure the ones in Britain weren't, but the ones in Spain were eating each other, it seems. Wow. What we don't know, of course, in the early cases is, was it what's called crisis cannibalism, where it's a bad winter, people are dying, starving to death, and they're having to eat...

10:59That's the type we'd do. Yeah. Like, this got shut down, like, if we couldn't get out. Yeah. I mean... And I was like, it was almost 11pm. And I hadn't had my snack. That's right. This whole conversation is focusing much more on cannibalism than I thought it was going to be. But there is a phrase in evolutionary biology which is sexual cannibalism, possibly the least sexy phrase that's ever existed. Tim looks dubious about my judgement on that. I'm not shaming anyone else's kink. Come on.

11:31I think that one's OK. We evolved shame for a reason, and that's probably it. It's spiders I'm talking about. Anyway, I don't know why he went straight to humans, you weirdo. Did these original visitors in Britain settle permanently, or am I right in the thing it's happened over hundreds of thousands of years? So how did that develop into the British people of today? So these people, we don't know how long they were there for. We've just got a little episode when we got the footprints, and we've got their stone tools. It was the end of a warm period when it actually was getting colder. And then we lose sight of them for 200 ,000 years.

12:07We pick up the next record. And so we're able to map at least 12 occupations of Britain by early humans and 11 of them disappeared. Mostly, we assume, because of the climate getting too bad for them to survive here. So people came across. They were here maybe 10 ,000, 20 ,000 years. Then they disappeared again. And Britain had to be recolonised all over again. and we think there probably were four species of humans in that story. So maybe Homo antecessor at the beginning, then Homo heidaburgensis, and then Neanderthals, and then finally us. I was going to say, because if they're all pioneering, man, that's pretty persistent.

12:43I think if I'd been extinction evented ten times, I'd get the hint. Yeah, yeah. I mean, yeah, why were they coming here? Just coming over here. It was the edge of... Exactly. Leaving their foot, the same story. Selina, you're a geneticist, right? Your expertise is extracting DNA from people who, as you say, have been very dead for a long time. Yes. We can't get DNA from this far back, right? No, not this far back, no. I think the oldest DNA that we've got from any human remains, not modern human, but ancient humans, is about 400 ,000 years old, so from Neanderthals itself, yeah. So you've got no interest in anything that Chris has ever done or studied?

13:24No, it's fascinating and I love all of it. I just can't work on it. That's still pretty long ago, right? And they were skeletal remains? Yes, so this would have been skeletal remains. The first skeletal remains in Britain are around 500 ,000 years ago. And these are from Boxgrove in West Sussex. And this was actually, I think it was a leg bone and a couple of teeth that have been found there in Britain. Just that. That's enough to get a new species out of it? Yeah, so that they think is, well, there is quite a debate, isn't there, Chris, about what this actual species is. They thought it was Hyderbergensis, because it's around the right time for Hyderbergensis, right place, all good.

14:06But Chris has already mentioned this site in Spain, Atapuerca, where a lot of remains have come up from this site. And they had a huge amount of remains of Hyderbergensis that they thought were from this site. There's 29 individuals. but then when pesky people with their DNA looked at this and they said actually they're not hideable against this they're more likely to be very old Neanderthals. So then when the samples that we have from Boxgrove were then compared to these Atapuerca samples they found that the teeth look really similar to them. So actually they're possibly probably Neanderthals but the leg didn't actually look anything like that so it's still highly likely that the leg bone is different and is actually high up against it.

14:48Is it possible that the remains was like someone had bitten someone else's leg?

14:57And then, I don't know, a tiger came and tore everything away and was just left with the teeth of one dude from one species in the leg of a dude from another species? Or could they be wearing the teeth of a former victim as a necklet? As an anklet? Yeah. A beautiful anklet. and then they perished and animals feasted... Or friends, in this time, feasted on them, took it away for picnics and left just the leg bone and the remnants of the anklet. Or could someone have used a leg bone to smash out someone else's teeth? The leg bone actually was chewed on one end, probably by a wolf. Oh, OK. So, yeah, not a human as far as we know.

15:42And the teeth were in pretty bad shape. These people used to hold stuff in their jaws, maybe chewing skins, meat, whatever, and they've actually got cut marks on them where they've been cutting stuff while in their mouths. So these teeth probably may even have just fallen out of the jaw. So you're saying that British people have bad teeth even then? Yeah. It was true then, and it's maybe unfortunately true today. Yeah. So tell me, what do we know then about Homo heidelbergensis? What were they up to? Yeah, so the first remains were found near Heidelberg in Germany. So they lived in Africa and Europe, pretty certainly in Asia as well.

16:21Some of them were really big. The Boxgrove guy was huge. He would have walked into a rugby team here with no trouble. We assume male. Obviously, it's only a leg bone. But this guy was 80 or 90 kilograms and close to six foot tall. Very powerfully built. An early gym. Looking at him there, yeah. He's about six foot tall and very nicely built. Yeah. Yeah, and angry and don't look after my teeth. And weirdly interested in cannibalism. Yeah. But they had big brains. How were they living? Big brains? Yeah, big brains. Do we know anything about their lifestyle? Very little about exactly where they lived.

16:58We know some of them were in caves, but these ones at Bottsgrove, with the evidence we've got is that they're out on this open landscape near the sea, coastal plain with some nice chalk cliffs behind them. They're making these beautiful hand axe tools to do butchery, and they're butchering horse and deer and even a couple of rhinoceroses were being butchered. And that's pretty amazing because rhinos are pretty bad-tempered beasts and to actually think of capturing, killing a rhino to butcher it. So we don't actually know, did they scavenge this rhino? Maybe something else killed the rhino but then they drove it away because they got primary access.

17:34All the butchery marks, they really systematically went over the carcass. They got the brains out. They broke open the bones to get the marrow. and they probably ate the meat raw on the spot. I think we call it whole carcass butchery. I'm just wondering whether Tim's werewolf theory might have something to say about the rhino. Yeah, totally. Could a werewolf take out a rhino? Definitely. Do we know? Chris, have you ever considered the... No, let's not do that at all. So you're saying they might have eaten this rhino raw. What about fires? Were Neanderthals able to light fires, do we think? There's evidence people were using fire probably much earlier than they were able to make it.

18:08so they probably captured natural fires so if there was a forest fire if there was fire from a volcano or something like that people early on probably learned to capture it and keep it going at least for a period of time and use it then for cooking and warmth and so on but actually making fire the really good evidence comes much later and we've got evidence from britain at 400 000 years from a site in Suffolk where they've got two little pieces of an iron mineral that can be used to make a spark, and this actually has been brought into the site. It's not natural to the site. So we think they at least started to have the capability to make fire at will 400 ,000 years ago.

18:49That's like hundreds of years where they were having to wander around with a candle going, don't go out, don't go out, don't go out, don't go out. Like just a burning leaf. That's a lot of pressure. It is, yeah. They might have been able to make it early, we just don't have the evidence of it. So I want you to do some of the evolutionary tree here because we've talked about Heidelbergensis and we've talked about Homo antecessor and these are the first people that we've got physical remains for in Britain. How do they relate to subsequent species, Neanderthals and us? Yeah, so there's a lot of dispute about how they relate to us.

19:20So I used to think that Heidelbergensis was the common ancestor of us and Neanderthals. So the Heidelbergensis is in Africa, went on to evolve into us, Homo sapiens in Africa, and the Hyderbergensis in Europe and Asia went on to evolve into Neanderthals. Now that doesn't look so likely because we've got evidence, and Selina's mentioned earlier, the Neanderthal lineage is going back deep in time. We can tell that from DNA and from fossils. And the Sapiens lineage is going back. And Hyderbergensis, some of the fossils are actually younger. So there's a fossil from Africa of Hyderbergensis from Zambia, and we've dated it to about 300 ,000 years.

19:56So Hydebergensis was actually living alongside the evolving Neanderthal and Sapiens lineages. So it looks like it's a related form, but deeper in time, not our ancestor, and not the ancestor of Neanderthals. So it could be a side branch, and that's what we see in human evil. So a lot of diversity, and a lot of these other lineages die out along the way, and of course we're the last ones left of all these experiments in how to be human. For now. Selina, what does the DNA say to us about how they related to each other and can we tell if they were getting off with each other ever? There's a lot of what we call introgression.

20:34Right. Yeah. Which is getting off with each other. So there's been some new studies recently that are looking at modern DNA and trying to find things like ghost lineages. So trying to understand where different people came from and so some of these ideas, as then with Hodderbergensis as well, is that this might be one of these ghost lineages that has input their DNA in the past and been an ancestor and then introgressed again, possibly, around 50 ,000 years ago as well. Well, ghost lineages sounds really cool. It's all a bit detective mystery stuff. Can we just dispel some of the ideas that we have about these sort of grunting cavemen that, Chris, you've already alluded to, would just walk into a rugby team, but I think we can make them more sophisticated than that.

21:23Neanderthals have got an image problem and it goes right back to their first discoveries. People who believed in evolution thought there should be the so-called missing link, something halfway between an ape and a human. And because there weren't any really early fossils from Africa, Neanderthals got pushed into that place of being a sort of missing link. So they were often portrayed as ape men, shambling, long arms and bent forward, very hairy. And most of what we know about them now is that they were very human, their brains were as large as ours, they had a lot of complex behaviour. We mentioned the fire-making for a start.

21:55I remember a few years ago there was some suggestion that Neanderthals might have had ginger hair.

22:05Yep. I think I've seen a reproduction of a Neanderthal that was a bit ginger. Very good-looking. So that's ancient DNA analysis. Where do we stand on that? It's not true, is it? I think there were some ginger genes there. Yeah, but the most important ones were the Fox P2 genes to do with language genes, so that they have very similar voice boxes, and the anatomy is the same, so, yeah, they would likely have had communication. And there's an ear bone as well. They would have had a similar hearing, is my understanding, Neanderthals. And now, you know, this is 15 years old now, but it's still quite shocking, Selina, that now that we've got DNA out of Neanderthal bones, we've got a much clearer evidence base for the relationship, the introgression, what we were up to with them.

22:53I'm going to start calling it introgression. Yes, although we don't think that in Britain, Neanderthals and modern humans probably overlapped or introgressed. Talking about shagging, aren't we? Yeah, we are. Jess is going to go home and put down to introgress on her Tinder profile. It's also called gene flow events as well. Oh, yes, yes. And they say romantic. Fall tastes better with better ingredients from Whole Foods Market. No added growth hormones or antibiotics in their meat department means slow-braised short ribs are even more satisfying. All seafood is wild-caught, like their vibrant sockeye salmon or verified responsibly farmed.

23:36And all sweets, including fall-themed cookies, are made without high-fructose corn syrup. Spice Up Fall at Whole Foods Market.

24:18So the gene flow events between homo sapiens and Neanderthals? Yeah, limited to none in Britain, but in the continent, oh yes. There's a lot going on there. Don't tell me they were already having more sex in France. They were more DTI. For about 6 ,000 to 7 ,000 years, there is an awful lot of integration going on between them. It's a particular bugbear of mine that when we refer to Neanderthals as our evolutionary cousins, they're not. They're our evolutionary ancestors because your great-great-great-great-great times 40 grandmother jagged a Neanderthal. What is actually quite interesting is that there's been some recent studies that it was actually sex-biased, though.

25:01Oh. So this interactions was actually a lot more with Neanderthal males and anatomically modern females. It was definitely shifted in that direction. Maybe. You said about the ear bones, maybe they were good listeners. I did a DNA test and found I had no Neanderthal DNA and felt quite bereft. I'm sorry. You know, I've got a bit of a prehensile jaw and I'm ginger. I thought, surely I'm a bit Neanderthal, but no. You need a second opinion. Yeah. LAUGHTER

25:38Well, look, let's skip forward a few tens of thousands of years into the era when DNA is really informative for Britain's inhabitants, and so we can move a bit west now. So Cheddar Gorge is where some of the action happens, Selina. Absolutely. Cheddar Gorge is a wonderful, amazing place, particularly for DNA. It's incredibly well-preserved there. So some of the oldest DNA that we've recovered from Britain from people is from 15 ,000 years ago from Goss Cave, but also from a second cave, so from Kendrick's Caves in Wales, and they died about 13 ,500 years ago. But what's quite weird is you've got the two oldest people through the DNA at this time point, but they come from two very different cultures.

26:21So you have a Magdalenian culture who are very arty. They're good at their cave art. They're good with figurines and needles and... Bishwinks. Yes, good. And harpoons. Yeah, really detailed harpoon. Yeah, it's really beautiful. And so you get these people coming in to Gough's Cave, and then you also have these Western hunter-gatherers, who are not quite as creative, but still very culturally adept, coming in and going into Wales. So two different groups coming into Britain at the same time, around 15 ,000 years ago. They're coming from the continent, from Europe, so the Magdalenians probably from France, Spain, they would have moved up into Britain as the glaciers were retreating.

27:00And these are all sapiens? Yes, modern humans. And there's another bit to the story recently, the dogs. Oh, yeah, no. Goff's cave is just a treasure trove of goodies. So we also found from this same period canard remains from the same cave. And people looked at this canard and were like, ooh, morphologically, this is actually quite small. Maybe this is a dog rather than a wolf. So up until this point, all the canard remains that had been found, is this right? Even if they'd been small and there'd been excitement about it being a dog, it had all turned out to be a wolf. Yeah, a wolf. Yeah, they were all wolves.

27:36This one? No, not this one. When we did the genetic analysis on it, it actually turned out to be a domesticated dog. In fact, the world's oldest, right now, genetically proven... Oldest known. ...currently oldest known dog to have been discovered from Goff's Cave. That is really cool. What type of dog is it? Brutal. Man's best friend. So this is a canine domesticus. This is genetically more like my groodle than a wolf. A what? What's a groodle? A golden retriever poodle. Oh. They're ubiquitous in Australia. Are they? Yeah, intragression. It means I get my golden retriever but don't get the sneezes.

28:17It turns out, yeah, wolves and dogs didn't intragress. So canine domesticus, it was human selection of timid wolves. over generations? Yeah, we don't know the exact process. You can imagine maybe wolves more... Chill. Timid ones, chilled ones might come by the fire, people might start feeding them. You can see the benefits for humans to having someone to guard for them, someone to look out when they're sleeping. There's a lot of advantages. At what point does the genetic drift caused by us selecting for more and more timid, smaller, less bitey wolves mean one day... Oh, this one's not a wolf anymore.

28:56Where's that day? We reckon it happened at least 20 ,000 years ago because at 15 ,000 years ago, this dog is looking like Fido. And the diet's different, isn't it? Yeah, absolutely. So in one of the sites where we found these dogs, you look at the food that the dog's been given, you look at the isotopes. Came out of a can. Yeah, not then. We checked the label on the can, yeah. And when you say it's a small dog, what type of dog? Is it, what did you say, a Grudel? Yeah. What does it look like? It just looked more like a wolf. They thought it was a wolf bone to start with. Maybe Alsatian size, that sort of size.

29:32Yeah, so I think as the investigation process goes, yeah, the snouts change. They get smaller. Paws change as well, and they just become a bit more bog-like. You know, it's... Any sapien canine introgression? I just needed to say something. I just want to make sure something I say gets cut out of the board. Just as a matter of pride. So if they are, these are hunters, and this is 10 ,000 years ago. 15 ,000. Hunters and artists mingling together. Oh. Yeah. But agriculture is beginning at this point, so the hunter-gatherer lifestyle is on the way out in Western Europe? So the hunter-gatherers hang around for a bit longer.

30:12They hang around until about 6 ,000 years ago. And we've got Cheddar Man, haven't we? Yes. Last name Cheddar, last name Man. So did we learn loads then from this guy compared to what we knew before? Yeah, so Cheddar Man is an interesting character. He is actually the oldest, most complete skeleton ever found in Britain. All the ones we've been talking about before, I mean, a bit of jawbone, a tooth, a leg bone, whereas Cheddar Man is almost complete skeleton. He was found in 1903 by workmen digging a drainage ditch, but he actually, yeah, dated to 10 ,000 years old. So he is one of these classic hunter-gatherer individuals, again, found in Gough's Cave.

30:53And he's called Cheddar Man because they were dairy farmers? Not at that point, no. We still haven't got to the agriculture. Cheddar Man because he was found in Cheddar Gorge. Yeah, that makes my smell sound. He'd have digested cheese very well. He'd have been lactose intolerant. He would, yes. What else do we know about him if he's lactose intolerant? Do we know what he'd have been eating? So he, as a hunter-gatherer at that time, he would have been eating things like reindeer and deer, bison. Any cereals, though, and stuff? No, not a lot of cereals at that point. Plant materials, obviously. Hazelnuts.

31:26Yeah. That kind of woodland. Quite a varied diet. Yeah, quite varied. Yeah, the Mesolithic, think of sites like Starchar. You've got all the evidence of the seeds and fruits that they were eating. So a varied diet. Yeah, which changes when you get agriculture coming in. Why is he so complete? You know, these are thousands of years, tens of thousands of years old, and mostly we find teeth and bits of fragments. but Mr Man, sorry, Mr Cheddar Man, they're all called Man, aren't they? Boxgrove is also called Man. Anyway, why is he so complete? First ones with proper names. Steve. Steve. Steve Man.

32:03Why is he so complete? He might be a burial. We don't know. It could have been a burial and that will obviously preserve the bones better. Or he could have just called in there and died. He might have even washed in there because they had these floods. So we don't really know for sure how he got there. He went for a wash in a flood? washed in there in a flood. Oh, he got washed in there. Yeah, because you get the rivers... When there's a flooding event... Yeah. When there's a flooding event in Cheddar Gorge, the water surges into the cave... Yeah, no, I do know what a flood is. My bad. ..and you might have drowned.

32:33Yeah. All right, so you get DNA out of Mr Cheddar Man. Indeed. Where from, in his bones? Ooh, from his inner ear bone, actually. The petrous bone. It's actually the densest bone in the body, and so it preserves the DNA. inside skeletal remains, including animals, a lot better than any other bone. If you reach behind your ear, you can feel that really hard bit. Yeah. It's just really good for protecting DNA over tens of thousands of years. Yeah, so I literally did put a drill into Cheddar Man's ear to get his DNA out. All right, so you drill into this poor guy's long dead ear. Yes. And what do you get out?

33:09A lot of bone powder at that point, but then we do go through chemical processes and then retrieve his DNA. So from his DNA, we were actually really interested in looking at this change from hunter-gatherer to Neolithic farmer and trying to understand why people started farming in Britain. Because, like you were just saying, hunter-gatherer, very varied diet, actually doing very well, and then people start farming. And if you look at the skeletal remains for people at that time, they're not looking that good. The diet's changed, it's minimised. I think humans, modern humans, have always been happy to suffer as long as they get to be lazy.

33:48Like AI is basically, it's going to destroy us, but at least we get to not do as much work, and then we can just happily, lazily go to our demise. And that started with the dude after Cheddar Man. Yeah, exactly. Yeah, like just around. Just like, yeah, conveniencing ourselves into meaninglessness is how I phrase it. Sorry, is that a bit dire? But he's had a really, really interesting afterlife because once you get his DNA out, what everyone wants to know is what does he look like? Indeed they did, yes. That wasn't actually the purpose of what we were doing, but he had really well-preserved DNA.

34:20So one of the classic things that you do then is to look at the different genes, to look at things like lactose tolerance, but then people were interested in what he looked like. So we looked at genes associated with pigmentation. So we looked at things like eye colour, skin pigmentation, hair colour and so we were able to actually do a reconstruction of what Cheddar Man looked like this iconic individual. And was he or wasn't he fit? We've got the reconstruction in the NHM so you can come and have a look and see what you think. Okey dokey. This was not an unproblematic thing to have happened.

34:59Yeah it did ruffle some feathers. Some racist feathers. Yes it did. Because The DNA says he was quite dark-skinned. Yes, that's correct. But had blue eyes. Yes, that's correct. Now, how confident are we about that? Fairly confident, yeah. I'm going to stick by that, absolutely. Right, and then the next thing that happens is a bust is made, and that's really when the trouble began, isn't it? Because the bust of Cheddar Man, Steve, is very dark-skinned. Now, how confident are we about that? It depends on the lighting, how dark he looks. under the lighting in the museum, you'll see that he's kind of medium dark, not really dark.

35:38But, of course, yes, some of my social media feed, you could imagine that you saw some of the stuff. You probably got it yourself on social media, comments about it and how we were trying to show that, you know, the first Britons were Africans and all the rest of it, which, you know, it was really what the data suggested. It's a weird thing to worry about. Of all the things, to look at this unbelievable thing that science has helped us to create to go, he doesn't look white like me sorry I shouldn't do that accent it's like he doesn't look white like me it's the weirdest reaction what have you got at stake in someone 10 ,000 years old it could be pink or green it just doesn't it's a weird reaction it wasn't the first person who'd been shown to have that skin pigmentation but there just wasn't the publicity about wait till these guys see Jesus

36:36And here he is! It even feels intriguing to me that we so specifically looked for lactose intolerance. That's such a specific intolerance. Oh, is it because it's a gene that's easy to... Yeah. It's easier to work that out than whether they were sort of not great for peanuts. Did he like olives? Yeah. We probably could have chatted if he liked Brussels sprouts or not. Yeah, totally. Your response to that. We should go back and check that. So I think what's interesting is, just leaving aside all that cultural nonsense, it is not the first, but it's really clear evidence that people with significantly dark skin, the same skin tones as people of the recent African diaspora, sub-Saharan Africa, were present in Western Europe 10 ,000 years ago.

37:21Right? Yep. So that's just not even controversial now because of your work. Yep. Yeah. So we know so much. How much have we got left to find, potentially, in terms of artefacts and evidence of ancient peoples in Britain? Loads. That's kind of exciting, right? In the beginning of the story is still really, we've got those few footprints and a few stone tools, but what do they look like? Until we find the fossils, we won't know. And is 900 ,000 really the earliest time? Because we've got people in southern Europe well over a million years, so they could have got here even earlier. So there's a lot of the story we don't know.

37:58And as Selina said, us and Neanderthals, we know they may have overlapped in Britain. We can't prove it at the moment. 40 ,000 years ago, the Neanderthals were physically dying out across the whole world. They were still in Britain 44 ,000 years ago. And Homo sapiens was here 40 ,000 years ago. So there's that tantalising gap that we'd love to know what happened here. I want to know more about that tantalising gap. And will that help to explain why modern humans won out? Do we know that why? Yeah, that is one of the big questions, and I'm writing a book about that at the moment, actually. That should be ready next year.

38:35And, yeah, why are we the last ones left out of all of these different kinds of humans? And we don't have the right answer. One idea was we're the ones who had complex language, but that doesn't seem to be a good enough answer to me. Because it's not just Neanderthals disappearing. There were these people called the Denissimans living over in the Far East, another group of humans who were very successful for hundreds of thousands of years. they disappeared as well but also did see interbreeding so we didn't evolve from them but we've got their dna as well so these people didn't completely die out but they physically disappeared and it more or less coincided with homo sapiens spreading into their regions so you think we must be to blame but they didn't die out straight away it's nowhere near farming though right because because if it intersected with farming you can imagine the sapiens invented this thing and then protected their land and it became like sort of colonization wiping them out or whatever, but it's way before that, isn't it?

39:29The Neanderthals were gone 30 ,000 years before farming. I think there could have been competition for resources, but we're talking about really small numbers of people. At best, tens of thousands of people spread over very wide areas. So they're at low density, and yet we did end up taking over. But did we... Obviously, they're going to want to hunt the same animals, collect the same plant resources, wanting to live in the best places. So there could have been a sort of competition, but even if there was, why did we win, if you want to put it that way? Can it not just be xenophobia? I mean, is it not just that we are competitive with...

40:01It's a tribalism. They just hated each other. Could sapiens have just killed... I mean, mention the cannibalism, and there's even a few claims of violence on Neanderthals, which might have been done by Homo sapiens, and obviously it could have even gone the other way, but there's no good evidence of that. There's obviously evidence of them coming together from the interbreeding, and that happened quite a bit, it seems, in that short-time zone, but they were small in number and they were low in diversity. They could have been an endangered species near the end of their time. So maybe we just absorbed the last remnants of them and that's how they disappeared.

40:36But the Denisovans were much more widespread and that's more of a problem explaining why they disappeared. It's a Doctor Who episode waiting to be made, isn't it? A long way away from Britain now, though, with Denisovans. All right, let's bring it back to Britain because the premise was who were the first Britons and I don't feel like we've got to the bottom of that. So I want to ask all of our guests, Come on, we need an answer. Who were the first Britons, Chris Stringer? If we mean the first human inhabitants, then it's Homo antecessor at my best guess. But in terms of Homo sapiens, the oldest fossils are in Devon and Wales.

41:08Selina, you going with that? I am going with that, but if we're going to say continuous occupation, then I've got to stick with my cheddar man, man. OK, well, I'm not a scientist, so I'm just going to go with the naming pattern and say Swindon woman. Very good Yeah and she actually rode in on the back of a hippo All the way from Greece I have no idea, I'm an interloper It's a scientifically intriguing, beautiful puzzle But the sort of idea that one conclusion or the other Will say something about me is so far outside my comprehension And just one thing to add is because Cheddar Man isn't even much of an ancestor of the Britons of today, is he?

41:52Most of his DNA didn't come through to us today. No, those Neolithic farmers came in. So how much of a Briton is he in modern terms? He's hardly a Briton at all, is he? No, not at all, actually. Genetically, he didn't really make much of an impact. That politics question that Tim's talking about is really interesting because a few thousand years later, and we know this from the DNA, we get a complete population replacement where the entire population of these islands is replaced in the period of about, well, it's about 200 years or something crazy short. By whom? Spanish people. Ugh, Spanish people.

42:23As an Australian, of course, this is all intriguing. In Australia, it's unbelievably clear who the first Australians were and their extant. And there's one little group who spread out and became numerous, but not particularly, who lived as hunter-gatherers forever and only yesterday got trampled on. And so it's really clear in Britain it's been a shemuzzle for so long that it seems sort of obtuse. If you can get the word shemuzzle into your book and your next scientific book, full credit goes... Don't mind if you quote me. I'll try it. To Tim Minchin. Shemuzzle man. OK, we asked our audience a question.

43:03If you were going to leave an object behind for archaeologists to find in 100 ,000 years into the future to inform or confuse them, what would it be and why? Jeremy says, a Tesco meal deal. And an Argos catalogue circa 1998. Horace says, my Tamagotchi, it will be hungry. Colin says, a Nokia 3310 mobile phone. It's the only thing from the 21st century that would survive for 100 ,000 years. And the battery would still be at 80%. Thank you to all of our guests Chris Stringer, Selena Brace and Tim Minchin Join us next week and we'll be talking about Absolutely Nothing As in nothing The theme is nothing The science of nothing The science of what?

43:54The science of Goodbye Bye

44:11Until now, nice again. Boo, how are you? It is Danny here, just dropping into your feed to let you know that something very exciting is coming your way. There is a chill in the air, the evenings are drawing in, it can only mean one thing. It is time to get ready for the spookiest night of the year, Paranormal Christmas, with our annual Halloween countdown. Every day in October, we are going to be releasing a brand new tiny tale of terror, a mini uncanny case sent in by you, the uncanny community. I'm going to be reading your emails out and sharing some truly spooky stuff that will scare the living shizzle out of you, trust me.

44:56There'll be hauntings, time slips, apparitions, and some truly weird and wonderful real-life witness accounts of poltergeists, ghost dogs and even some phantom false teeth. So that is the uncanny Halloween countdown, dropping every day right through to Halloween itself. Will you be there? I hope so. Until then, stay spooky.

45:29How's a movement that started off as a meme taking on India's Prime Minister? I'm Tristan Redmond, co-host of the BBC's Global Story podcast. On today's show, we hear how the so-called cockroach movement has motivated young people across the world's biggest democracy to protest for their rights. How could they reshape the country? For more, listen to The Global Story on bbc.com or wherever you get your pods.

From the publisher

The Infinite Monkey Cage returns for a brand-new series, with Professor Adam Rutherford and comedian Jessica Fostekew swinging into the cage as guest presenters. In this first episode, they find out who were the very first people to land on the British Isles… if they even were Isles at all.

Joined by anthropologist Professor Chris Stringer, geneticist Dr Selina Brace and comedian Tim Minchin, they learn that our British ancestors got to hang out with hippopotamuses, uncover what ancient DNA can tell us about man’s earliest best friends, and discover that some Homo sapiens became more than just friends with our Neanderthal cousins... The panel also gets to the bottom of some of the most pressing scientific debates: like if Cheddar Man was really a looker and whether the Brits have always had bad teeth.

Producer: Mel Brown A BBC Studios Production

More from The Infinite Monkey Cage

All episodes