1. Podcasts
  2. The Rest Is Science
  3. How Fluoride Saved Our Teeth
The Rest Is Science

21 Nov 2026 · 46m · 14 chapters

Episode artwork

How Fluoride Saved Our Teeth

In short

The episode traces how people historically misunderstood toothache and tooth decay (the “toothworm” idea, tooth-cleaning myths, and harmful early tooth powders) and explains the modern bacterial/acid model. It then shows how fluoride prevents decay by strengthening enamel via fluorapatite, using the Colorado Brown Stain mystery and later water-fluoridation studies. It also covers saliva’s protective role (pH buffering, calcium/phosphate) and why mouth-breathing can worsen acidity.

Guests

No guests are interviewed; it’s hosted by Michael Stevens and Hannah Fry.

Key claims

Tooth decay is driven by bacteria (not worms) that convert sugar/starch into acid, dissolving enamel; saliva buffers pH (danger below ~5.5). Fluoride helps remineralize damaged enamel and makes it more acid-resistant.

Notable examples

Frederick McKay’s 1901 Colorado Springs findings; Hans Sloan and Antoni van Leeuwenhoek’s microscope work disproving toothworms; Colorado Brown Stain; 1940s water-fluoridation trial (~60% fewer cavities).

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

0:05

The Mystery of Pitted Teeth

Exploration of a dentist's discovery of unhealthy yet intact teeth in Colorado.

“All right, I'm going to start with a bit of a crazy weird story, okay?”
2:00

Cultural Perceptions of Teeth

Discussion on British perceptions of dental aesthetics compared to Americans.

“Do you know, I don't think lots of Brits know, by the way, that the thing that Americans think about us is that we've all got horrible teeth.”
5:07

Tooth Decay and Historical Practices

Discussion on historical misconceptions regarding tooth decay and treatments.

“because she also doesn't seem to understand it.”
8:39

The Cosmic Tooth Worm Legend

Exploration of the ancient belief in a worm causing toothache and its origins.

“So this is what I want to talk to you about today.”
13:20

Scientific Advances in Dental Health

How scientific understanding evolved regarding tooth decay and treatment.

14:00

The Wormy Origins of Tooth Decay

Explore the historical perspective on tooth worms and early observations of dental issues.

“He's got some, he's got some worms in his mouth.”
14:40

Antoni van Leeuwenhoek's Discoveries

Learn about Leeuwenhoek's experiments with teeth and his findings on bacteria.

“This Dutch scientist called Antoni van Wevenhoek.”
18:00

Historical Dental Hygiene Practices

Discover the various methods people used for dental hygiene throughout history.

“I was going to say, yeah, the fact that three days is what he thought, oh, it's going to help them grow.”
23:00

The Urine Toothpaste Controversy

Examine the bizarre use of urine in dental care and its effectiveness.

“It's making me feel slightly wretchy just thinking about it, let alone imagine that.”
28:52

Understanding Tooth Decay

Dive into the science behind tooth decay and the role of bacteria.

“Okay, so all of these different tooth brushing options.”
Show all 14 chapters
36:29

The Role of Fluoride

Explore how fluoride helps prevent tooth decay and its historical significance.

“rotten tooth tooth extraction kind of things i know that you uh because i know you like stories about teeth i i know you know what's going on already do you want to do on go on give us your guess.”
41:18

Toothpaste and Its Design

Learn about the science and design behind toothpaste and its effectiveness.

“The fact that under pressure, it becomes more flowy.”
42:01

Cultural Associations of Toothpaste Flavors

Explore how different flavors, including mint, influence perceptions of cleanliness.

“And, you know, then there's the whole kind of cultural association of minty flavors with cleanliness.”
44:35

Future of Dental Solutions: Lab-Grown Teeth

Discussion about advancements in dental technology, including lab-grown teeth.

“And animators and producers we have on this show to spread knowledge about hygiene and health to improve people's lives.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On The Rest Is Science, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00Michael Stevens: Hello and welcome to The Rest is Science. I'm Michael Stevens. And I'm Hannah Fry.

0:05Hannah Fry: All right, I'm going to start with a bit of a crazy weird story, okay? Because, Michael, I want you to take a little look at this picture of some teeth. They don't look like they're in great condition. They don't look like they're in great condition, do they? Do you want to describe them for us?

0:20Michael Stevens: Yeah. So the gums are not looking too pulled back from the teeth, but the teeth are very brown and covered in pit marks and stains. And they're all there, but they don't look very happy.

0:37Hannah Fry: They're very mottled, aren't they? I would say.

0:40Michael Stevens: Yes. Yes.

0:42Hannah Fry: This actually is a story that starts in 1901. There was this dentist called Frederick McKay, who went away from the East Coast, traveled over to Colorado Springs, and found that all of these people who were living there had these horrible teeth, like the one in the picture, like brown mottled marks, sort of the color of like chocolate almost, but it's just, it really doesn't look very good and there's no answers in any of the textbooks and the locals are like maybe we're eating a bit too much pork like not really sure why have we got such horrible teeth anyway the really strange thing about these horrible teeth as you pointed out michael so correctly is that they are nonetheless completely intact yeah they don't have any holes in them they don't have any breakages there they are every single one of them in full working order even if they look absolutely horrendous.

1:40Hannah Fry: Anyway, this mystery I'm going to come back to in a minute because I want to do this episode about teeth and horrible teeth and what makes your teeth horrible and how to stop your teeth from getting horrible, which I think is a great irony that there's an English person. I wasn't going to say anything. Doing this episode to an American.

2:00Michael Stevens: But yeah.

2:00Hannah Fry: Do you know, I don't think lots of Brits know, by the way, that the thing that Americans think about us is that we've all got horrible teeth. I don't think that, like, do you remember in In Austin Powers, how Mike Myers wears these really horrible fake teeth. I don't think British people realize that that was a joke that you were making about us.

2:19Michael Stevens: Oh, I didn't think it was a joke. I thought it was just a good part of the costume. It was like the only part that wasn't a joke that made him look like a true British person.

2:33Hannah Fry: This episode is brought to you by Cancer Research UK.

2:35Michael Stevens: We know that DNA holds a lot of information, but here's a way to visualize it. If we encoded all the movies ever made in all of history into DNA, that clump of DNA would be smaller than a sugar cube.

2:51Hannah Fry: It is packed with data. And so Cancer Research UK scientists are analyzing cancer DNA to understand what makes every cancer different. They're even searching through what was once considered genetic junk.

3:04Michael Stevens: That's because uncovering these differences could lead to more personalized and precise ways to prevent, detect, and treat the disease.

3:12Hannah Fry: Over the last 50 years, Cancer Research UK's work has helped to double cancer survival in the UK. And today, it's continuing to save and improve lives around the world.

3:22Michael Stevens: For more information about Cancer Research UK, their research, breakthroughs, and how you can support them, visit cancerresearchuk.org slash restisscience.

3:33Hannah Fry: Hi, this is Gary Lineker from Goalhangers. The rest is football. This episode is brought to you by WISE. It's only when you start moving money between currencies that you really think about the exchange rate, the fee, and what might be hidden away in the small print. Whether you're living abroad, paying someone overseas, or just trying to manage your money across borders, you want a fair exchange rate, an easy transfer, and no surprises along the way. WISE keeps things simple. Wise is a smart way to move the currencies you need around the globe. It works in more than

4:06Michael Stevens: 160 countries and with over 40 currencies. Most transfers arrive instantly. Wise uses the mid-market exchange rate, like the one you see on Google, with no markups or hidden fees. So when money needs to move, you can see the rate, know the fee and get on with it. Join millions saving billions

4:25Hannah Fry: on hidden fees by downloading the Wise app today. Be smart, get wise, T's and C's apply. This episode is brought to you by Indeed. You're ready to level up your business, but the pressure to find the right person to make that happen is intense. Indeed Sponsored Jobs can help carry the load. It boosts your job post to help it reach quality talent fast. Cut through the chaos with Indeed Sponsored Jobs. Get a$75 sponsored job credit at indeed.com slash podcast. Terms and conditions apply. Hiring now? Then this is a job for Indeed Sponsored Jobs.

5:06Michael Stevens: No, I mean, I've talked to my wife about this a bunch because she also doesn't seem to understand it. And I'm like, look, their dental hygiene is good, but orthodontia is just such a meme in America. I'm not sure the dental hygiene is that great. Well, I can't speak to that. I don't actually know, but there's a difference between clean teeth and teeth that are all lined up.

5:29Hannah Fry: Right. I mean, that is definitely true.

5:31Michael Stevens: It's definitely true that in America, there's a much larger social pressure to straighten your teeth out. And it's like a thing that all kids go through. It's extremely common to go and get braces and get, you know, your tooth positions all checked. Go on, let me see your teeth. I never had any orthodontia done. Did you not? They're good teeth. No, I went to a doctor and they had me like do all the tests and I don't know. Oh, they're good teeth.

6:00Hannah Fry: They're good. They're super straight.

6:02Michael Stevens: Yeah, but they did recommend a few things that they could do. And my mom and I were like, I don't know. I mean, it's not affecting my ability to chew. I think they look fine. But I mean, there are gaps down below.

6:17Hannah Fry: I like a little gap. I've got to be honest with you. I've got a bit of a thing about teeth. I've got a bit of a thing about mouths in general. actually. When people have like slightly unusual mouths, I just really like it. I mean, look, there's some unusual mouths that are very unappealing. And then there's some, I think, as long as dental hygiene is really good, the odd gap in a tooth or like the odd little snaggle teeth, I think can be really delightful.

6:37Michael Stevens: I think, yeah, it provides a lot of character. And when everyone's teeth look the same, they're all veneered up and they all have the same smile, you start to lose that sense of uniqueness and the character of it all. Like, I'm a real, They're like, let's bring in some more Carl Maldons. I want some big weird noses. I just want people that you see them and you go, oh, I know that person.

7:00Hannah Fry: I should tell you, actually, just in exchange. I mean, I've had all of the braces. So my teeth are naturally, they're like this. I'm quite like, I'm quite toothy. I had like train tracks and things. And then I had like a little problem with one of these teeth that we had to like get rid of a little bit of it. So my front four are veneers. Okay. Now I really like them. I think they're very good.

7:27Michael Stevens: Yeah, yeah, yeah. I don't mean to say don't get veneers. I'm just saying that like do what you want and embrace who you are, you know? Like, yeah.

7:36Hannah Fry: Yeah. Well, I'll tell you one thing though. So in Ireland where my mom grew up, they were, this is around the 1940s, 1950s. I don't know whether this was uniform across Ireland or just in the particular town where she was. There was this idea that actually children's teeth would rot, adults teeth would rot. And so the best thing to do would be to drill out all of them when you were children, fill them, and then you would prevent further tooth decay later in life. Of course, the inevitable result is that a whole generation of kids, certainly from where my mum lived, basically don't have any teeth.

8:14Hannah Fry: My granny in particular, so my granny, actually, sorry, my great granny in Ireland, she only had one tooth in her mouth. One of the front ones remained. And my mom described how when she would eat a grape, she would have to chase it around her mouth with that one tooth.

8:31Michael Stevens: With the one natural tooth.

8:34Hannah Fry: Wow. So look, British people might have a bad reputation for bad teeth, but I would say we're not alone. Okay. I would say we're not alone. Okay. So this is what I want to talk to you about today. I want to talk to you about the crazy ways that we got teeth so wrong for so long, how we completely misunderstood what causes toothache and tooth decay and how hard it was for us to get to a point where we can actually have healthy, happy, clean, white teeth as sort of standard in a population. Okay. Do you know what the ancients thought caused toothache, Michael?

9:08Michael Stevens: Oh, probably some spirits or humors out of line.

9:11Hannah Fry: Not far off. It was a cosmic worm.

9:14Michael Stevens: Oh yeah, the old cosmic worm.

9:18Hannah Fry: Sent down by the gods, of course, to live in your mouth and to drink your blood. That was the big idea. This sort of legend of the toothworm comes from around 1200 BC in Egypt, this is. and there's like a papyrus that talks about the pain uh that that you get in your teeth and says that it's because there is a worm that's north at at your teeth right so they actually think there's a little worm there in the fifth century bc you've got more evidence of this in babylon people talking about this tooth worm that's like really problematic there's even in In Babylon, in Babylonian, there's this amazing incantation that you're supposed to sing to the toothworm to make it go away.

10:07Michael Stevens: Did they think of the toothworm as a real worm that was maybe was too small to see? Or was it like a ghost worm, like a spirit, a god?

10:17Hannah Fry: No, as a real worm.

10:19Michael Stevens: A real thing. So it was almost, they were almost right when they were thinking of like microscopic bacteria type stuff.

10:28Hannah Fry: Yeah. The problem is, is that I think the main thing that they got wrong was that they thought the worm was inside getting out rather than outside getting in. How did it get in in the first place? Well, it was sent by the gods, of course, Michael. How else would it get there? And now it's trying to get out. Right. But I think perhaps one of the reasons, so let me tell you this incantation, okay? So this is like, this is how you treat toothache. This is incantation. It says, after the sky God created the heavens, the heavens created the earth, the earth created the rivers, the rivers created the canals, the canals created the mud, the mud created the worm.

11:03Hannah Fry: And then the worm went crying before the sun and its tears flowed before the gods. What have you given me to eat? What have you given me to suck? And the God replies, I've given you the right fig and the apricot. What good is that to me? The right fig and the apricot. place me and let me dwell between tooth and gum so i can suck the tooth's blood and mince up the gum um right that's like sort of this is not a good cosmic worm but one of the one one of the ways that you would treat this is that you drive in a peg into the tooth and then try and seize the foot which historians now think was you actually grabbing the nerve right from the tooth and that's what the worm was.

11:46Michael Stevens: Yeah. So they saw it as a real physical thing, a creature, a nerve, that was the worm created by the mud. Is it in all of our mouths? I think only when you've got

11:58Hannah Fry: toothache.

11:59Michael Stevens: Right. So what was this worm's deal? Why was it not happy with the ripe apricot? Why was it like, no, no, no. I've got a very specific palate. I want to literally be in the palate i want to be between the gum and tooth then i want to suck on teeth from the inside

12:16Hannah Fry: i i think i think the worm is a dickhead michael i think that's the only thing that we've got but in a weird way i mean this sort of idea okay it's a worm you got to pull the worm's foot out kind of works right if you remove the nerve couldn't feel anything pretty grim idea to imagine that without any any anesthetic at all like horrendously grim But at the same time, I don't know if you've had toothache before. I mean, you've got this very big nerve in your face that can get triggered by teethache. It can be excruciatingly painful, excruciatingly painful. You would try anything to try and relieve that pain.

12:52Hannah Fry: Yep. So the thing is, this idea of this worm living in your mouth, I mean, it just persists. Everyone believed it. You've got, you know, you've got the Egyptians believing it, the Babylonians believing it. In Vietnamese, the word for tooth decay still literally translates to worm tooth. Wow, this is really widespread. Really widespread. Shakespeare, in Much Ado About Nothing, calls toothache a humor or a worm, right? So they still think it's a worm back then. once you get to the era that the enlightenment this then is the point where people start to try and think more scientifically about where this worm is and where this is coming from so in 1700 there's a guy called han sloan who's a physician he's also the secretary of the royal society by the way and uh he's right square uh gosh quite possibly yeah no we talked about him

13:48Michael Stevens: in the live show he was the guy who came after newton yes after newton you're right and i made some joke like oh and name a square after me and i think seven people laughed i think i think i'll

14:03Hannah Fry: be honest with you i was so petrified to be in front of a thousand people and not knowing what i was going to say next i wasn't listening properly to your jokes i apologize they were very supportive though it was it was very nice okay so mr sloan of sloan square yeah he's chatting about tooth worms. Good. Good for him. Okay. So where does he take us? Okay. So, so he's got this friend called Mr. Chamberlain. He's got some, he's got some worms in his mouth. So I found some actual worms. So he takes them out and he pops them in some silk and he sends them over to his friend at the Royal Society, Mr.

14:32Hannah Fry: Sloan of Sloan Square fame. Hans Sloan is like, I know what to do with these. I'm going to send them over to my mate in Holland. This Dutch scientist called Antoni van Wevenhoek. Do you remember about the Wevenhoek? Yeah. this guy is a big deal. This guy has got the best microscopes in Europe. That's what this guy is. So, I mean, this is actually, I think this is pretty disgusting. Someone's like, is that a worm? Ew. Puts in a bit of silk, sends it to the Royal Society, then it gets sent over to Holland. And then Lou Evan Hook's looking at them under his microscope. By the way, it's not even in the top five most disgusting things that Lou Evan Hook looked at under his

15:13Michael Stevens: microscope no it isn't but i know the name he gave to what he saw i think we've talked about that

15:20Hannah Fry: before on the pond animal cubicles he did to little wriggly things you're right anything that's like wriggly you're right so he is he's like looking at these wriggly things and he's like hang on a second by the way by the time the parcel arrives one of the little worms is still alive oh good for that guy. So what he does, he's like, I don't know if these are, I don't know if these are teeth worms. So he goes and he buys some rotten cheese. This is so gross. I'm sorry. I really hope no one's eating their lunch while they're listening to this episode. Put away your rotten cheese.

15:54Michael Stevens: Save it for after the show.

15:55Hannah Fry: Put away your rotten cheese. He goes and buys some rotten cheese and he raises his own set of maggots next to this, this one that, that Sloan of Sloan Square fame has sent him. And he realizes is they're the same and he's like well hang on a second this isn't teethworms this is just it's a cheese fly maggot so so his conclusion was that what happened was mr chamberlain had obviously eaten some maggoty cheese and then and then be like oh why are all these maggots in my

16:25Michael Stevens: mouth it's because you put them there by eating the maggot cheese dude disgusting goodness me

16:32Hannah Fry: different times anyway lou evanhoek is really fascinated by this though what he does is i mean this is sort of over the course of his career um and maybe jumping backwards and forwards in time ever so slightly but but what he does in 1683 is he's like what is going on with your teeth so he deliberately doesn't clean his teeth for three days and then he like scrapes off all the stuff and this is when he sees all those swimming creatures as you described the the way he calls

17:00Michael Stevens: again animalcules which is a great word which we should still use for microbes i think maybe i mean they're not animals they don't belong to the animal kingdom but yet they are tiny living things like molecules but alive animal he got he got i mean he was basically there right he basically got

17:18Hannah Fry: it and then he's like how how do you how do you get rid of them so he tries killing them with vinegar and he finds out that when he kills them with vinegar in the petri dish they're dead but when he tries to rinse with vinegar in his mouth they're still there they're absolutely fine and then he tried scalding hot coffee kills them in the dish in his mouth it kills all the ones at the front but doesn't kill the ones at the back so he's like okay i mean he essentially disproved the toothworm and he found the real culprit bacteria but he didn't manage to connect it with decay and that that like final connection that actually toothache was from the outside in that didn't happen for another couple of hundred years oh wow okay i'm gonna pause on the pause on the idea of like what is going on with tooth decay how do you get it because uh that story about leuvenhuk i mean i just told you that he didn't clean his teeth for three days and so what that heavily implies is that people were cleaning their teeth you know even in the 1600s.

18:23Michael Stevens: I was going to say, yeah, the fact that three days is what he thought, oh, it's going to help them grow. That meant that he was doing some pretty good teeth cleaning. Pretty good teeth

18:31Hannah Fry: cleaning. And actually people have, you know, for as long as the history books have existed, people have really wanted to clean their teeth. All of these different methods that have existed, people would use a sort of ox hoof ashes, eggshells, pumice, oyster shells, sort of anything that's like a little bit grainy just to sort of like scrape them down a bit. But I think the most interesting version of toothpaste that people created, or at least allegedly, is urine. Ooh, I haven't tried that one. No, me neither. Frankly, I'm much happier with minty toothpaste. Yeah, yeah. I was born at the right time, I think.

19:15Hannah Fry: The idea here is that it was the Spanish, right? The Romans were writing about it, The Greeks were writing about it, but it was the Spanish who apparently were all up in there with the urine. That's the story that they would say.

19:30Michael Stevens: And is urine an effective mouth cleaner or not? Oh, good. Okay.

19:35Hannah Fry: It actually would be, especially aged urine. The reason is because of ammonia. So if you leave urine to age, fresh urine is mostly just water, but the dissolved substance in it is urea. And when you leave it out for days to sit, you get bacteria from the air that breaks down the urea into ammonia and carbon dioxide. And ammonia is a really amazing solvent and degreaser. So it would have got rid of at least some of the stains. It would have made your teeth whiter. Although it wouldn't do very much with tooth decay. So there's one document, a guy called Strabo, who writes that the people of Iberia bathe with urine, which they have aged in cisterns and wash their teeth with it, both they and their wives.

20:17Hannah Fry: as the Cantabrians and the neighbouring peoples are said to do. And then another person, this is Didiorus Siculius, he wrote that the people of Iberia consistently use urine to bathe the body and wash their teeth with it, thinking that this in practice constituted the care and healing of the body. Bit judgy, bit judgy, don't you think? It's a bit judgy, yeah. Bit judgy. Anyway, my favourite bit is that there was one poet, this is a Roman poet who used the urine thing to mock one of his rivals. So he's writing about Ignatius, who's this Roman citizen of Spanish origin, where they all use the urine.

21:00Hannah Fry: And he says that, let me give you this poem, okay? It's sort of going on. Ignatius, because he has snow white teeth, smiles all the time. If you're a defendant in court, when the council draws tears, he smiles. If you're in grief at the pyre of pious sons, the lone lawn mother is weeping. He smiles. Whatever it is, whenever it is, whatever he's doing, he smiles. He's got a disease, neither polite, I would say, nor charming. Now, you're Spanish in the country of Spain. What each man pisses, he's used to brushing his teeth and red gums with every morning. So the fact that your teeth are so polished just shows you're the more full of piss.

21:40Yeah, I like that.

21:42Michael Stevens: So, you know, you're full of piss. You're a piss swisher, but it does make your teeth nice and white.

21:49Hannah Fry: It does make your teeth nice and white. And this actually maybe is what we should say to the Americans, what the British should say to the Americans. Well done you with your spangly white teeth, but it shows you're full of piss.

21:59Michael Stevens: Or does it? I think it advances in dental hygiene since toilet mouth technique.

22:07Hannah Fry: Allegedly. Yeah. Wow.

22:12Michael Stevens: You know, funny enough, this gives a positive spin to the phrase potty mouth.

22:17Hannah Fry: At last. At last. Sparkly potty mouth. Yeah, absolutely. I should tell you, by the way, the Iberians themselves never said they were doing this. It was always an outsider saying those guys. Oh, wait. So were they or weren't they?

22:31Michael Stevens: We don't know. I mean, there's definitely loads of rumors. Loads of rumors. But we do know that scientifically, there is some reason to believe that the ammonia in aged urine would be good for the teeth, not for decay, not for antiseptic reasons, but for appearance.

22:45Hannah Fry: Yeah.

22:45Michael Stevens: For appearance.

22:46Hannah Fry: Huh. Okay. Yeah. So, you know, if you can stomach it, because the problem is, is that the other options... You don't have to stomach it.

22:53Michael Stevens: You have to mouth it. They don't say you have to swallow it. No. Look at me. I'm the big like pee defender over here.

23:00Hannah Fry: I'll be honest with you. It's making me feel slightly wretchy just thinking about it, let alone imagine that. I think I'd rather just have shit teeth.

23:07Michael Stevens: Oh, no, I would rather use number one than number two.

23:12Hannah Fry: Okay, bad choice of words.

23:14Michael Stevens: Good choice of words for the show. But yeah, I think toothache is so bad. I would rather have a daily oral urine regimen than toothache.

23:27Hannah Fry: I don't think it would help with that.

23:29Michael Stevens: I've never had a toothache. But from my father did. And from what I've heard from people who have had it, As you've mentioned just a few minutes ago, it's excruciating and distracting and really affects your quality of life. I think I could put up with, you know, two minutes of, you know, mouthwash.

23:47Hannah Fry: Of urine.

23:49Michael Stevens: Of the number one variety. Yeah.

23:52Hannah Fry: I don't know, man. I don't know. The only time I've had it really bad was actually after I had a baby. Oh. My first daughter. I mean she was like less than a month old And then it was like oh my god I had to have two thousand Okay so if you're not using urine All of the other ideas that people had You know brick dust Crush china Earthenware Cuttlefish Anything that's sort of like a bit grippy The problem is Is that what it does Is it ends up wearing down your enamel over time Yeah So you might look good for a short period of time But then Then you're really in trouble Because then you've like got rid of it Worn them down.

24:31Hannah Fry: Yeah. And this was even true in the late 19th and early 20th centuries. There was this great medicine era, particularly in the United States, where suddenly sort of the combination of like industrial growth. And there were no federal laws that required drug companies to test their products safely. And the rise of mass advertising. There were all of these brands that were suddenly flooding the market saying, look, we can sell you the secret to perfectly white tea. So this is when you saw commercial toothpaste, well, not a paste, more a powder, just really exploding. It almost across the board, all of these adverts, I found a few of them from America and they're targeted at appearance, right?

25:15Hannah Fry: Like improving your own appearance. This is looks maxing 1900 style. So there's one of them called Sozodont. The tagline is Sozodont for the teeth in breath. One ad promised that men go wild for splendid teeth. Okay.

25:32Michael Stevens: We do.

25:34Hannah Fry: Oh, absolutely. Absolutely. The thing about this stuff is it's basically just alcohol. So it had like 37 % alcohol in it. Okay. So they ended up having to testify in front of Congress that customers were using it to clean their teeth and not as a tax-free form of liquor.

25:50Michael Stevens: Yeah. Right. Right.

25:51Hannah Fry: It also, by the way, would destroy your teeth. So it had all of these abrasives. Anyway, there's like a few of these. There's another one called Dr. Lion's Tooth Powder, which is essentially chalk and soap that you would brush onto your teeth. But all of these are like essentially, they're essentially destroying your teeth slowly. Yeah, right.

26:11Michael Stevens: The whole like having to testify that you are using, you're selling it as a hygiene product, not as a spirit, reminds me of the bricks of concentrated grape juice that were sold during prohibition in America. And you could break off pieces of this like concentrated dried grape brick and then mix it with water and get grape juice. And it came with a warning that said, warning, do not put in water and store covered in a dark place for this long at this temperature and blah, blah, blah, because then it would become the one thing you don't want, which is wine. Don't let it ferment. And of course, people were like, oh, cool.

26:53Michael Stevens: Thanks for telling me what not to do so specifically that I can do it and make some wine.

26:58Hannah Fry: That, although that slightly reminds me of the label on OxyContin. You know that? No, what does it say? Because OxyContin had this very particular coating, which was one of the reasons why it got FDA approval because it was supposedly slow release. And on the label, it ended up getting this very controversial particular label that had never existed on other drugs before that essentially said it was safe, but added under no circumstances, I'm paraphrasing, obviously, under no circumstances should you crush or break this capsule. Because if you do that, then you'll end up getting really high really quickly.

27:34Hannah Fry: And you won't have the slow release thing. So people are like, thank you very much for giving me the instructions.

27:39Michael Stevens: There's got to be a word for when a warning backfires. Because what it warns you about is what you want.

27:45Hannah Fry: I'll tell you what, hold that thought for a second, because I think we should go for a break and we're back very shortly.

28:09Hannah Fry: reach quality talent fast. Cut through the chaos with Indeed Sponsored Jobs. Get a$75 sponsored job credit at Indeed.com slash podcast. Terms and conditions apply. Hiring now? Then this is a job for Indeed Sponsored Jobs.

28:27Michael Stevens: You know what they say. Good things come to those who shop early, especially when we're talking early Black Friday deals and lows. Get up to 50 % off select major appliances. Plus, get free delivery, haul away, installation and parts on purchases of$896 or more. Black Friday deals are on now at Lowe's, in-store and online. Valid through 12-2 while supplies last. Selection varies by location.

29:00Hannah Fry: Okay, so all of these different tooth brushing options. They're all well and good, but they are missing the key thing that actually causes tooth decay and actually causes toothache.

29:13Michael Stevens: Yeah. What are they missing?

29:14Hannah Fry: Well, they're missing the fact that it's bacteria, basically. They're missing the fact that what ends up happening with cavities is when you have so many of a particular type of bacteria in your mouth. Now, I know you know precisely what causes tooth decay because you have told me this in the past and I love your description of it.

29:32Michael Stevens: Yeah. I've been following really deeply these kind of new, these new bacteria you can put in your mouth and I haven't tried them yet, but did we talk about them before?

29:43Hannah Fry: No, we've never talked about them on the, on the show.

29:46Michael Stevens: Not on the show. Okay. Cause, cause teeth decay itself is essentially caused by bacteria that you have in your mouth.

29:53Hannah Fry: The bacteria themselves are fine, but what they do is they sort of eat up sugar and starches that are left in your teeth and then they they they poop our acid basically and it's the acid that is the problem the acid strips the enamel of your teeth and we're just talking chemistry here you know this is just straight up chemistry but you've got these materials like calcium and phosphate it's it's actually not dissimilar to to what's going on in your kettle if you live in a heart i mean look i'm sorry americans you're gonna have to imagine what kettles are like for a second because I know you don't have them in your homes.

30:29Hannah Fry: Some do. Some do. But if you have a kettle and you, you know, you have water going through it over and over again, you end up with this buildup of limescale. And if you throw in something like lemon juice, it will strip away the buildup of that limescale. And you essentially, you know, look, I'm giving you this as an analogy here, But it's a really similar idea with your teeth that you've got this like layer of calcium and phosphate that is protecting your teeth from the outside. And if you have too much acid in your mouth, which is what happens when you have these bacteria, you strip away those minerals.

31:09Hannah Fry: And then you end up with these kind of holes, these patches in your enamel, which is when a cavity forms.

31:14Michael Stevens: And that acid comes from the bacteria in all of our mouths. What was it called? Here we go.

31:21Hannah Fry: Mutants, streptococcus, mutants and streptococcus, so rhinus.

31:26Michael Stevens: Sound tasty.

31:28Hannah Fry: Don't they? There they are, happily living in my mouth. Okay, so your body does have a way to combat this. Your saliva plays this massive role in keeping your teeth safe. So what happens in your saliva is you've got all of these ions, these calcium and phosphate ions are dissolved into your saliva. so actually it's kind of okay that like you have a bit of bacteria there's a little bit of acid that gets on the outside of your enamel it dissolves some of the ions because it doesn't matter because there's more like being washed through with your with your saliva it's a bit like you know you're putting more water into the kettle over and over again your saliva also by the way keeps your mouth's ph levels balanced it keeps kind of your the acidity to a minimum it's only when your mouth becomes really acidic that you really start to be in danger.

32:16Hannah Fry: So your normal pH levels are between 6.2 and 7.6. And that will counteract the acid that gets left behind by this pooping bacteria. But it's when you drop below 5.5, that's when you're really in trouble. That's when you start to see problems. Oh, interesting.

32:35Michael Stevens: I've heard that's also why it's so good to breathe through your nose at night because your teeth will get all dry and then the bacteria aren't getting Like beaten off by your spit Exactly

32:46Hannah Fry: So if you breathe through your mouth at night The pH in your mouth can drop to 3.6 Whoa Acid mouth alert If you swill a mouthful of orange juice And you go to sleep with the orange juice sitting in your mouth That's the sort of level of acidity that you're talking about What a great comparison Wow Also really bad for your gums I mean try not to I have actually Since reading this I have started considering

33:11Michael Stevens: Mouth tape? mm-hmm yeah i i um am i too hairy for mouth tape we should get some mouth tape company to sponsor this show also for like a decade i have used toothpaste companies as like the idea the ideal brand i'm like i want to do the science chemistry biology of dental hygiene and like a brand should produce like really informative content as their ads not just like ours is great but like show me

33:39Hannah Fry: why it works because it's fascinating it's so fascinating in line with science i quite right seriously why are you not doing adverts like this which is like let me talk to you about these ions that dissolved in your saliva that continue i know every time a brand reached out they were like we

33:56Michael Stevens: just want you to say that it's like nice white teeth these these pitch these ad pitches and i'm like i would like to describe the science behind why this works and like you you you're using science here that does give you an advantage over your competitors and they'd be like nah it's too smart people won't want it and so i just wouldn't do them devastating devastating i totally agree

34:16Hannah Fry: completely complete missed opportunity okay so so right it took you know from from lewevenhuk really getting super close with his animal anicules and how wait how do you say it

34:31Michael Stevens: animalcules.

34:33Hannah Fry: Animalcules. Really, really close to working out that it was that bacteria, Streptococcus mutans and Streptococcus sobrinus, that were causing all of the problems. It took another, to the 1800s basically, to the late 1800s, another couple of hundred years, for people to really work out that it's this acidity that is causing the problem from the outside in, stripping away these ions, creating these holes that end up turning into cavities. And one of the guys who works it out is someone called Dr. G.V. Black. He writes this paper called The Formation of Poisons by Microorganisms. Okay, so it's like you're being poisoned.

35:11Hannah Fry: And when did he write this? This is 1884.

35:14Michael Stevens: Oh, wow.

35:15Hannah Fry: Yeah. Anyway, he has this really big contribution to make to this whole story. Because remember those chocolate teeth that I told you right at the very beginning?

35:26Michael Stevens: Yeah.

35:27Hannah Fry: The chocolate stains on those. I mean, they're not chocolate. They just look... They're chocolate colored. Chocolate colored, thank you. That became known, that sort of strange phenomenon that all the people in this town had this same pattern. It became known as Colorado Brown Stain. And in 1909, Dr. G.V. Black, the person who understands what happens with teeth, he agrees to come to Colorado Springs and to collaborate with Mackay, who's the doctor, the dentist who saw this. and when he arrives Dr. Black is like wow these people's teeth are hella brown like this is really strange going on and so he spends six years of his life trying to work out what is going on and during that time they make this really important discovery that the teeth that had Colorado brown stain were inexplicably resistant to decay something was happening to these teeth that was turning them brown but also meant that there was no teeth decay and no major issues with like having to sort of destroyed teeth ache that kind

36:35Michael Stevens: rotten tooth tooth extraction kind of things i know that you uh because i know you like stories

36:42Hannah Fry: about teeth i i know you know what's going on already do you want to do on go on give us your guess.

36:48Michael Stevens: Well, when you mentioned the American West and certain regions having different tooth problems than others, I go right to fluoride. Oh yeah, exactly. Is that, so what's happening? Do they have fluoride in their water or not enough? They have loads of fluoride in their water. Okay. So, so the fluoride is staining their teeth, but it's preventing the decay caused by the acid, the bacteria, all of that.

37:16Hannah Fry: Exactly. And the way that it works is so fascinating.

37:19Michael Stevens: I don't know how it works. What the heck does fluoride do?

37:22Hannah Fry: Okay. So basically what happens is you've got like these little rods, these little tubes, essentially, that are all over your teeth.

37:30Michael Stevens: It's like a microtexture in the actual enamel. Okay.

37:34Hannah Fry: Exactly. Exactly. So what ends up happening is that fluoride enters into those rods. What you really want to happen when you get these little patches in the enamel where the ions have been stripped away. What you really want is all the calcium and the phosphate that's in your saliva to form these new crystals, to sort of regrow exactly like limescale in a kettle, to form this film that patches up what was there before. But when there is fluoride floating around, what happens is you're sort of artificially boosting the number of ions that could bind in this crystal and then fluoride takes this place in this crystal and creates something called fluoropapite which is an which is noticeably stronger and takes more acid to dissolve so it's like you're doing a little swapsies basically it's like but but this swap is for something strong but brown well there's a level basically there's a level where you can have all of the benefits of it but without actually turning your teeth brown oh so you end up when you've got fluoride in your mouth you end up with these patches that have been regrown essentially it's not it's not a biological process this is sort of a chemistry one yeah but they are tougher than the original patches themselves this is why fluoride works best when it's little and often you know regularly having fluoride in your toothpaste, in your water, means that your patches never get too big for you to get cavities, essentially.

39:11Hannah Fry: Right.

39:11Michael Stevens: And they resist cavities.

39:15Hannah Fry: So the way that we know this, I mean, this is all the Colorado brownstone was really the beginning of this. They thought there was something in the water and found out there was one town where they had a communal water pipeline to a spring nearby. And as soon as that pipeline was turned on people's teeth went brown they turned it off the brown teeth sort of went away right um in sort of new children as they came through but because of all of this stuff this knowledge they then did this sort of study where um they worked out they would try and put in one part per million of fluoride in drinking water and they did this in a town where there there were 30 ,000 school children that they monitored.

39:58Hannah Fry: And the finding was that children born after fluoride was added to the water, their need for cavities dropped by 60%.

40:10Michael Stevens: The occurrence of cavities in their mouth dropped 60%.

40:14Hannah Fry: 60%.

40:15Michael Stevens: This is no brushing. This is no sort of like, you know, two minutes twice a day.

40:20Hannah Fry: This is just the water that they're drinking. Nobody did anything. you know nobody no extra effort and you just suddenly improve the health of these kids teeth which i think is phenomenal i really think yeah yeah that was in the 1940s by the way so by the 1950s this is the point where crest toothpaste by procter and gamble were like okay you know what let's put some fluoride in this toothpaste yeah and you know ultimately that is the thing that makes toothpaste so amazing partly it's making sure that you have something abrasive there that's not too abrasive that it doesn't wear away your enamel there's certain things in there that sort of keep it keep your teeth whiter you're kind of dissolving the stains that appear on there but the really amazing thing about toothpaste is this fluoride that you're putting in that's the thing that actually makes a difference and stops your teeth from decaying wow i don't know man i just love the fact that it's like oh just a random rock you know oh just should we just shove a bit of a random rock in our mouths and then that'll make

41:22Michael Stevens: it all all right i would say to that what are our teeth but random rocks yeah it's true

41:30Hannah Fry: this is very true you know i realize i've gone on for 50 minutes already and i could do another 50 on how cool toothpaste is because toothpaste the design of toothpaste is so i mean the fluoride yeah great but you know you've also for toothpaste you've got to have something that is essentially a solid when it's in the tube then it becomes liquid for a brief moment when you squirt it out of the And then it's got to be solid on your toothbrush again.

41:52Michael Stevens: Yeah, right. I hadn't really thought about that. The fact that under pressure, it becomes more flowy.

41:58Hannah Fry: Yeah.

41:58Michael Stevens: But then it's got to be abrasive enough. And, you know, then there's the whole kind of cultural association of minty flavors with cleanliness. Right. Which is not an instinctive thing. Right. You can have bacon flavor if you want it. Yeah, you could.

42:15Hannah Fry: You can have urine flavor if you really want it.

42:18Michael Stevens: Oh, please. brands either sponsor us or bring back the urine flavor tooth cleaning gels because we need one of them it's a little bit boring it's a bit samey isn't it mint mint mint mint mint yawn mint mint

42:33Hannah Fry: yeah once you have lost your teeth which you know i think irish children really are very aware of um of that generation it you really can't get anything as good nothing else is ever quite as good as a natural tooth.

42:47Michael Stevens: Wait, why Irish children?

42:49Hannah Fry: Only because, you know, my mom's generation that all had their teeth drilled out and then lost them all.

42:54Michael Stevens: Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.

42:55Hannah Fry: Once you've lost your teeth, you really can't ever get anything quite as good. I think dentures are just not, maybe aesthetically they're all right, but you know, they're just not, they're not the thing.

43:05Michael Stevens: Yeah. And I mean, they're always getting better, but man, yeah, it's, it's, it's wild that we've got this whole set of kids teeth, you know, and then when they fall out, you kind of get the teeth you're going to be stuck with so you got to take care of them there are other options by

43:18Hannah Fry: the way so there's um there's some work at uh king's college london uh in collaboration with imperial college london where they're trying to do lab grown teeth so the idea is that they um they've created this like hydro gel that that is very similar to the embryonic environment that you get for really early tooth development and then i think the idea is that you um you sort of you can grow these little tooth buds, these toothlets, they're called. And then maybe you could implant those tooth buds into people who've lost their teeth. So I think you sort of grow them from their own cells and then let them grow naturally.

43:54Hannah Fry: Or you just grow the full tooth in the lab and you're like, I'll have, thank you. I'll have that one there. That'd be great.

43:59Michael Stevens: Oh, sure. Sure. Yeah. If you implanted it and let it grow in the mouth, it would get pushed around into the right position and everything, I would assume. But not just adult teeth, but Supra adult teeth

44:13Hannah Fry: Supra, yeah, exactly Could you be like 80 years old and be like I'll have a new set, please

44:16Michael Stevens: I'm going to grow a new set I'm done with these juvenile teeth

44:20Hannah Fry: So there we go I mean, look, if you retrospectively want to respond to us We're fine with that We're absolutely fine with that I'm very happy to I'm very happy to pay my mortgage Using toothpaste money

44:32Michael Stevens: Well, I'm very happy to pay the wonderful staff And animators and producers we have on this show to spread knowledge about hygiene and health to improve people's lives. Yeah, it's a product, but hopefully everything can kind of root together and we can, you know, get the people at the show paid and also all have much more beautiful, healthy, comfortable smiles.

44:59Hannah Fry: Did you mean to use root as a pun during that? Cause it worked quite well.

45:03Michael Stevens: No, I didn't. But I thought about the speech I gave at my wedding about how, like, I don't really know what love is, but I do know that I want my roots to grow with your roots and for us to become one tree. And maybe that's love. So there you go.

45:17Hannah Fry: That's lovely, Michael. You know, if someone started off a story by saying, I was at my wedding and I gave a speech about how I don't know what love is. I think if it was anyone else in the earth apart from you, I'd be worried.

45:31Michael Stevens: I think it worked. We're still together. We, you know, we're, we're only closer. Our roots really have grown closer and closer together. Like it really is what happens. It's what I wanted.

45:41Hannah Fry: Yeah, that's really lovely. All right. Well, I'll tell you who else we love. You, our listeners and viewers. Thank you very much for joining us. And we'll be back later in the week with the Field Notes.

45:50Michael Stevens: See you later.

45:51Hannah Fry: Bye.

46:06Michael Stevens: Come, number 10, on that flight with 350 passengers on board. The great game. Strategic struggle between Britain and Russia. We assess, Prime Minister, with high confidence it was Russian. Holding the Russians accountable is World War III.

46:29Hannah Fry: They took down a British passenger jet containing 350 people. Man in the Kremlin is playing, Alex. Got to ask yourself. Do you want to play or not? You're the Prime Minister. You've done nothing!

46:45Michael Stevens: We would need to understand the policy context.

46:48Hannah Fry: All the relevant context will be structured as a framework today. Disseminated into an operation order. Or frago. Or frago that says to kill the President of Russia. Yes. News from Goalhanger. Who is going to be able to pull this off?

47:07Michael Stevens: You're my soldier, are you? Sergeant Tom McDuff, Duffy! An audio drama journey like no other.

47:14Hannah Fry: Men like Duffy, they are our most valuable weapons.

47:18Michael Stevens: Devised as a technically rigorous geopolitical action thriller. Where Britain plays its strongest hand. He's the best. Against its strongest foe. Don't do it, Duffy! Bear Hunt. Available now wherever you get your podcasts.

From the publisher

In 1901, a dentist arrived in Colorado Springs to find locals with stained brown teeth, yet those teeth were strangely resistant to tooth decay.In this episode of The Rest Is Science, Professor Hannah Fry and Michael Stevens (Vsauce) dig into the weird history of dentistry, and how a rock changed our teeth forever.

For thousands of years, people blamed toothache on a "tooth worm", from an ancient Egyptian papyrus to a Babylonian incantation and even Shakespeare's Much Ado About Nothing.

Then microscope pioneer Antonie van Leeuwenhoek skipped cleaning his teeth for three days, scraped them, and found them teeming with tiny "animalcules".Along the way: the history of toothpaste, from aged urine (allegedly) to Sozodont, a tooth cleaner so boozy its makers had to tell Congress people weren't drinking it as tax-free liquor. Plus how Streptococcus mutans turns sugar into enamel-stripping acid, and why breathing through your mouth at night can leave it as acidic as a mouthful of orange juice.

Then it's back to Colorado, where dentists Frederick McKay and G.V. Black chased the mystery of "Colorado brown stain" – leading to fluoride in drinking water, a 60% drop in children's cavities, and fluoride toothpaste.And could lab-grown "toothlets" from King's College London and Imperial College London one day replace lost teeth?

-------------------

For more information about Cancer Research UK, their research, breakthroughs and how you can support them, visit ⁠https://cancerresearchuk.org/restisscience⁠

Cancer Research UK is a registered charity in England and Wales (1089464), Scotland (SC041666), the Isle of Man (1103) and Jersey (247). A company limited by guarantee. Registered company in England and Wales (4325234) and the Isle of Man (5713F). Registered address: 2 Redman Place, London, E20 1JQ.

-------------------

Find The Rest Is Science all over the internet by ⁠⁠clicking ⁠here⁠.⁠⁠

-------------------

Video Producer: Adam Thornton + Oli Oakley + Jack Meek

Animator: Sam Benson

Video & Social: Bex Tyrrell

Producer: Simona Rata + Lucy Lipscombe

Senior Producer: Lauren Armstrong-Carter

Chief Digital Officer: Samuel Oakley

Exec Producer: Neil Fearn
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

More from The Rest Is Science

All episodes