1. Podcasts
  2. The United Stand
  3. 185: AMORIM SACKING HIMSELF!
The United Stand

14 Sep 2025 · 43m · 15 chapters

Episode artwork

185: AMORIM SACKING HIMSELF!

In short

A Manchester United watch-along/live review of the 3-0 Manchester derby loss to Manchester City, arguing Ruben Amorim is “sacking himself” due to stubborn tactical/selection decisions—especially playing Bruno Fernandes in midfield—plus criticism of substitutions, leadership, goalkeeper quality, and the summer transfer window.

Guest backgrounds

No named guests appear; it’s a solo host (“Lady Luck”) with audience superchats and mentions of other shows/figures (e.g., Gary Neville) rather than guests.

Key claims

Amorim’s insistence on Bruno as a midfield “number eight” is “sackable” and causes defensive failures (e.g., not tracking runners like Foden). Formations aren’t the issue; player roles and squad weaknesses are. United’s goalkeeper is “crap,” and the board failed to address midfield and goalkeeper needs. Players collectively failed to reach even an “average six” in the derby.

Notable examples

Goals tied to Bruno/Shaw (first), defensive positioning (second), and a third-goal breakdown involving Luke Shaw and Harry Maguire; substitution at 2-0 removing Leny Yoro for Maguire (and moving De Ligt) is called among the worst. Transfer-window example: “Mbermo shot saved by Donnarumma” contrasted with United’s goalkeeper/midfield recruitment failures.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

1:02

Ruben Amorim's Dilemma

Discussion on Amorim's decisions and their impact.

“There can be Amrim in, there can be Amrim out.”
1:16

Performance Analysis of the Derby

Evaluation of Manchester United's performance against City.

“I will say straight from the start, I am Amrim in.”
2:56

The Problems with the Current Squad

Identifying issues within Manchester United's squad.

“I can already see we're going to lose to Palace.”
4:11

Tactical Missteps and Managerial Decisions

Critique of tactical decisions and player roles in the match.

“So I also don't want to sack another manager.”
7:16

Summer Transfer Window Failures

Criticism of the summer transfer strategy and its effects.

“And every single Man United fan needs to scream and shout about it because our season is going to go down the toilet.”
9:49

Goalkeeper Issues and Conceding Goals

Discussing goalkeeper performance and missed opportunities.

“I mean, I actually questioned on the watch along whether Harry Maguire substitution was actually a metaphor for a resignation.”
14:02

Goalkeeper Calamities and Team Performance

Analyzing the goalkeeper's mistakes and the overall team performance in a crucial match.

“I mean, look, I don't really want to talk about the goalkeeper massively, but he was a calamity.”
18:38

Player Ratings and Manager Critique

Discussing player ratings, managerial decisions, and expectations for upcoming matches.

“Create your own AI agent today on Monday.com.”
28:00

Analyzing the Manchester Derby Performance

The discussion focuses on the team's poor performance against Manchester City and the implications of key players' roles.

“You know, when we finished 15th last year, we're absolutely shit.”
29:30

Fan Reactions and Managerial Decisions

The hosts discuss fan comments regarding the manager's decisions and the potential for resignation.

“Let's get into some of your comments because you've been very, very patient.”
Show all 15 chapters
31:20

Debating the Squad and Tactics

A deep dive into the current squad's capabilities, tactical choices, and necessary changes moving forward.

“They play forward through the middle anyway.”
36:10

Continuing the Analysis of Team Issues

Discussion on the lack of accountability from players, managerial strategies, and the overall state of the team.

“The agents wrote the copy and managed the timelines, while our human creative director made sure it all made sense.”
42:00

Identifying Key Problems in Football

Learn about the critical issues in the team and the roles of players.

“And what Amirim's problem is, is that he's putting a player in a position they can't play.”
45:06

Formation Debate and Player Performance

Explore the ongoing debate on formations and their impact on team performance.

“Oh, the defence, the goalkeeper was shit again.”
47:46

Closing Thoughts on Season Prospects

Discuss the team's future and expectations for the season.

“But ultimately, well done to Manchester City.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On The United Stand, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00Hey everybody, Lady Luck here, and we're celebrating America's 250th birthday. Now all summer long, I'm going to be celebrating by playing on SpinQuest.com, which is an American-owned social casino. It obviously features over a thousand slot games and live blackjack, live craps, live bubble craps. Head on over to SpinQuest.com. Get yourself a$30 coin pack for just$10. SpinQuest is a free-to-play social casino. Void where prohibited. Visit SpinQuest.com for more details. This Monday.com ad was created by a team of people and AI agents. The agents wrote the copy and managed the timelines, while our human creative director made sure it all made sense.

0:40Easy. Create your own AI agent today on Monday.com. Hello, everybody. Welcome to the United Stand. Manchester United lose 3-0 to Manchester City in the Manchester derby. Let's download and assess all your thoughts. We've got player ratings, mark every player out of 10, 6 being the average. Link is in the description for that. But ultimately, the first thing that needs to be said is that Ruben Amrim is sacking himself. You can be really angry. We can all fall out. There can be Amrim in, there can be Amrim out. But ultimately, he is sacking himself. And it matters not whether you scream Amrim out or Amrim in.

1:18I will say straight from the start, I am Amrim in. You know, 100 % Amrim in. but that doesn't mean I can't be absolutely fuming with some of the illogical decisions he keeps making. The stubbornness will ultimately do him in and we can digest that. I don't think Manchester City got out of third gear, which is ultimately very embarrassing. And I think that was, you know, like a floater in a toilet. It's shit. It's just shit. It was absolutely shit. And I think the frustrating thing is we absolutely deserve to lose that game. And Man City weren't even that good. So as I said before the game, Burnley will be in a relegation battle and we needed a last minute penalty.

2:05If you can't dominate teams like that because you're going to give them chances to get back in the game, you're definitely going to lose games like this. And that was what I was hoping to see. Every goal is just so basic. So basic. I mean, we can break it down, but every goal is preventable. And you can't give leads to any team in the Premier League. Because, all right, Bruno loses Foden. But if Bruno loses a Brentford midfielder in a couple of weeks, they'll score. You know, we're going to concede goals because we did it against Fulham. It doesn't matter. And as I said, look, Newcastle lost 12 games and finished fifth.

2:45We've lost two to Arsenal and Man City. If you're picking 10 games to lose, you're probably going to say Man City at the Etihad, Arsenal at home. They're acceptable losses if you're going to lose 10 games. But we ain't going to just lose to them. I can already see we're going to lose to Palace. We're going to lose to Bournemouth. I can see these losses. So as much as some people might spin a positive and say, well, we've had a hard start. We've had to play Chelsea, Man City and Arsenal in the first three and we might lose all three. That's fine if you're playing well and losing to very good teams.

3:15We're playing badly and we're going to lose to teams in the mid table. We're going to lose to teams in the bottom half of the table because that team is in disarray. You can already see it. So what's the big problem here? I think there's multiple problems. I mean, let's just start off with Amrim. Why am I not saying Amrim out? Because it's preposterous. And I will read all your super chats, by the way. We'll probably just do it towards the end of the show. I will read them. There's a lot to unpack and we'll do the player ratings, of course. But I'm not Amram out for this reason. Stubbornness or not, sacking a manager in season never goes well.

3:51Stubbornness or what or not, we are a club that can't afford to buy a midfielder and a goalkeeper. And you want us pay to sack another manager and then try and fund another manager when we couldn't fund this one. Financially, it will ruin us to sack the manager. We couldn't even pay for this project. How are we going to pay for another project? So look, maybe Aram's not going to be the guy. But sacking a manager to me is suicidal for this football club. So I also don't want to sack another manager. So that's my explanation. But that's my explanation. I honestly say this with total sincerity. He's going to sack himself.

4:26He is going to sack himself. Clip it, whatever you want to do. He will sack himself. I've watched football for too many years. So have you. I've seen the movie. I know what's going to happen. You cannot put square pegs in a round hole. Consistency is all that matters in the Premier League and you will get exposed for mistakes. We have played four Premier League games and we have lost two games because of mistakes. Biinder Arsenal, Man City today. But against Fulham, we didn't get three points because Bruno lost Smith Rowe. And today we're losing because Bruno doesn't track Foden. People will talk about formations and systems.

5:06Please stop watching this show. Ring up talk shit. That's your level. If you're going to ring up and say he's got to change the formation, you're a moron. The formation is not the problem. The system is not the problem. Conte won a Premier League with a 3-4-3. Eric Ten Hag and Oli got sacked with a 4-3-3. Anybody who says we need to go to a 4-3-3 or it's a 3-4-3, you're wrong. You're really wrong. The problem is the people he's using in the system. So when you put a number 10 as a number eight in a midfield two, forget it. You are going to get demolished. Fulham said at the end of the game, we swamped the midfield because they're weak.

5:49Man City today let us have the ball and then swamped the midfield and broke on us. Man City played counterattacking football against Man United at the Etihad. What death trap are we walking into? It's like a mouse seeing a big lump of cheese on a mousetrap and saying, I'll get the knife and fork. I mean, it's crazy. Absolutely crazy. If you can't control the midfield, do not bloody let team counter-attack you. And that's exactly what we did. Bruno Fernandes, as a number 10, may or may not still be a very, very good player. Bruno Fernandes, as a midfielder, is like putting Van Dijk in midfield.

6:27Very good player for Liverpool. Captain for Liverpool. World-class player for Liverpool. Put him in the midfield, he'll be shit. Bruno Fernandes is a number 10. We are asking a 31-year-old who is a specialist number 10 to play as a number eight, and then we're moaning at him for not picking up the runners. You are asking him to do a job he can't do. So obviously I blame Bruno. Maybe he should be putting his hand up and saying, I can't do this. Maybe he's stupid for not doing that, but ultimately the manager picks the team. He is sacking himself doing this. And I have to say, this is not a niche argument.

7:02I've heard Gary Neville talk about it. I've heard all of you talk about it. I've spoken about it. You can't go into the Premier League and play Bruno Fernandes as a midfielder in a midfield two. It's sackable. You are going to lose your job. And every single Man United fan needs to scream and shout about it because our season is going to go down the toilet. Like, just play Agathe and Mainu. They might not be good enough, but it's better than putting Bruno there. He is costing us goals. He has got no idea of the role and what you need to do. And it's going to keep costing us games. And people can talk about the lack of service to Seshko.

7:40Good point. People can talk about you don't like a 3-4-3. Fair point. But ultimately, putting Bruno Fernandes in that midfield every week gives everybody a chance. Somebody said it. It's like a bloody festival. It's like a bloody, you know, what are you going to win this week? Three points, three points, three points. It's madness. Second to that, I've got to say, this goes down as one of the worst substitutions I've ever seen. At 2-0, you never know. The biggest cliche in football is 2-0 is a, you know, it's a dangerous scoreline because if you concede one, you lose the momentum, it can go to 2-2.

8:17So at 2-0, very disappointing. The game's probably over, but there's half an hour to go. What does he do? He takes Lenny Yorov off. We don't play for a week. Why are you taking Lenny Yorov off? You take Lenny Yorov off and you put Harry Maguire on. But even better than that, you move De Ligt. So De Ligt's the central centre-back. You move him to right side and you put Harry Maguire as the last man against the quickest and best striker in Europe. And lo and behold, two times. Forget whatever plans you have this weekend because you're staying at home and playing on SpinQuest. And there's never been a better time to sign up than right now.

8:57New users get$30 coin packs for just$10. All the table games you love with hundreds of slot games and real cash prizes. That's at SpinQuest.com. S-P-I-N-Q-U-E-S-T dot com. SpinQuest is a free-to-play social casino. Void where prohibited. Visit SpinQuest.com for more details. This Monday.com ad was created by a team of people and AI agents. Reese, our content agent, wrote the copy based on our best practices, like mentioning Monday.com three times. That was the second. Johnny, our coordination agent, built the timeline and kept everyone aligned. Olivia, our human creative director, stayed in the loop.

9:37Because agents are great, but they don't always know when a joke lands. She had one note. Tell listeners it only takes minutes to build an agent. So, minutes. Create your own AI agent today on Monday.com. They need a score to go. I mean, I actually questioned on the watch along whether Harry Maguire substitution was actually a metaphor for a resignation. Because that was basically like, let's get stuffed. It's like a turkey sitting there on your bloody kitchen table with a packet of Paxo saying, stuff me. It was mad. I don't even know what that was all about. Now, I mean, poor old Harry Maguire is stood there on the halfway line with Erling Haaland in a foot race.

10:21It's the equivalent of a Ferrari taking on a brick. It was just ridiculous. I don't understand what that was all about. That was a shocking substitution at 2-0 in a Manchester derby. And I tell you what, it might be a joke to some people. It might be a joke to the manager. It might be a joke to the players and it might be a joke to Sir Jim. But to some of us, the Manchester derby actually dictates our mood. It actually matters when you support this football club. And you might be 2-0 down and go, oh, fuck it. Doesn't matter. But to us, it's all we've got. You know, it ruins our day. It ruins the week.

10:57You know, actually supporting Manchester United actually does matter to us. It actually does. So when you 2-0 up and you make a fucking idiotic substitution like that and players are fucking around, it does boil the blood. It is frustrating. And I am frustrated. I don't even feel bad towards Man. You know, sometimes you want to blame a referee or you want to go and look at Haaland with his ponytail. I don't even care about Man City because they're not even very good. I think Arsenal will beat them next season, next week. They're not even very good. They're a team in crisis who've just had three points.

11:38They never even got out of third gear. I don't think that was vintage Man City at all. I've seen United play Man City and I've gone, bloody hell, they're a good side. They weren't even that good. We have been battered. Battered. It should have been 5-0. We have been battered by a Manchester City side that isn't even that good. You know? So, yeah, I'm sort of like, I'm sort of in a position where I'm like, well, I need to get into your comments. Of course I do. And also as well, like this needs to be said. This has to be said. Why and who is responsible for our summer transfer window? Because watching that game, watching the Fulham game, watching the Burnley game, I'm sort of looking at it and going, we spent£200 million on an attack that doesn't get any service.

12:31at what point did people sit in the boardroom over the summer and go, you know, we've just finished 15th and been shit. The problem is the attack. That's the problem. If we buy the attack, we'll be fine. You don't buy goals. Like, Mbermo didn't score those goals for Brentford just because he's Mbermo. And Kunja didn't score the goals just because he's Kunja. Like, there was actually a team feeding them. Sheshko won't pull goals out of his arse. Like, there has to be, you know, a system, a rhythm, a cohesion, a chemistry to build up to the final third. Why did we spend£200 million on the front three?

13:11Like, to ignore the midfield and the goalkeeper is hilarious. And you know what? I think you can, I think when it comes to transfers, if you want a visual to sum up how we fucked up the summer transfer window, I would say, watch the Mbermo shot saved by Donnarumma. That really should be played on loop to Ruben Amirim, Jason Wilcox, Omar Barada, Sir Jim Radcliffe and Joel Glazer. That is where we fucked up. Because Man City lose Edison and buy an experienced goalkeeper. We get rid of Inanna and we're still playing Beindering goal. Like, top-class goalkeepers win your games. If that Mbermo shot goes in, And I think it was 2-0 at that point.

13:592-1, maybe you scrap an equaliser and we're all sat here very happy. I mean, look, I don't really want to talk about the goalkeeper massively, but he was a calamity. He was crap. He was crap. He's not at fault for the Foden goal. He's not at fault for the third goal. He's definitely at fault for the second goal. Like if that's David Rea, if that's Donnarumma, if that's Alisson, they're anticipating the danger, which gets them a yard further forward and they don't stop halfway. They take the ball, they take Haaland. And, you know, it's just, I was stunned where he was. You know, when you watch a lot of football and you go, the goalkeeper's coming for that.

14:37And I'm like, where's the fucking goalkeeper? Like, you know, when you watch loads of football and you get used to different things. And as that ball goes through, I'm like, that's a heavy touch. Where's the goalkeeper? No, no. And then he stops and sort of, yeah, just fuck off. Just not good enough. But that's that again is sort of like I don't I'm not going to say. Le Mans should have played. I don't maybe he's not good enough. I don't know. He's from the Belgian League. Maybe he's not good enough. But we should have bought Emi Martinez. You know, we should have bought Emi Martinez and we should have bought a midfielder.

15:13And we are basically, you know, a lucky dip at the moment. You don't know what you're going to get. We could beat Chelsea next week. we could lose to Brentford the week after. I don't know what's going to happen. But when you look at the league table, we are already, I was looking at it there, we are already 14th and we are already five points off fourth. So, you know, that gap is there already. I said by game 10, we want to be in touching distance of fifth. We're not even in touching distance after game four. It's shocking. And also, can I just say, we get very locked in on transfer activity, tactics, the manager.

15:57Let's just put a shine on the players before we do the player ratings here as well. Forget me, correct me if I'm wrong, but there are 11 players on that pitch. And correct me if I'm wrong, when we do the player ratings next, every player starts off with an average six. Now, manager makes decisions, yes. Transfers are on the board, yes Explain to me why legitimately There won't be any player above a six In a Manchester derby Again, why is it the players get off the hook all the time? This is a Manchester derby We're playing one game a week We're meant to be intense and focused for one game a week now Because they're not good enough to be in Europe we ask for one game a week of intensity and not one of them can put a 6 out of 10 in explain that against the Man City side that didn't get out of third gear not one player can put a 6 out of 10 in that's a disgrace that is a disgrace and every player I mean this is just falling on deaf ears but you are an absolute disgrace in a Manchester derby in the city where you play where we're playing our city rivals where, you know, Everton will be up for it against Liverpool next week.

17:16You can't even put in an average performance. Shame on you. Do you not understand what that badge is? So yeah, Amerim is sacking himself. The board, what were they doing in the summer? I don't know. But the players, this ain't Brentford or Sunderland. It's a Manchester derby. And you're putting in a performance like that. It's shameful. And I'm looking at the camera after the game And they're all walking around shaking hands. And I'm like. Hey, everybody. Lady Luck here. And we're celebrating America's 250th birthday. Now, all summer long, I'm going to be celebrating by playing on SpinQuest.com, which is an American-owned social casino.

17:56It obviously features over a thousand slot games and live blackjack, live craps, live bubble craps. Head on over to SpinQuest.com. Get yourself a$30 coin pack for just$10. SpendQuest is a free-to-play social casino. Avoid where prohibited. Visit SpendQuest.com for more details.

18:37Tell listeners it only takes minutes to build an agent. So, minutes. Create your own AI agent today on Monday.com. Forget shaking hands. You'd be getting punched. You'd be getting punched by Roy Keane for that performance. You'd be getting kicked off the pitch. Where's the passion for this shirt? Like, where's the... And again, I think that ultimately, sadly, does fall on Bruno. He's an awful captain. And I don't blame him, because who would you give it to? But that team has been bereft of leadership for a very long time. It's a shocking, shocking, shocking, shocking leadership group. Really bad.

19:18I mean, Luke Shaw's in the leadership group. He couldn't lead a bloody wasp to an open can of Red Bull. It's rubbish. Rubbish. They don't care. They don't care. They just do not care. They don't. Let's do the player ratings because then I want to get into some of your comments. Make sure you subscribe to the channel, by the way. Bottom right-hand corner. Give us your thoughts. We're going to be live in the studio with Ricky and co and Beth and everybody very shortly after this. But player ratings are incoming. Let me just make sure. Okay. I mean, look, I don't know what you're going to give. Beinder a three for me.

19:57Can't do anything on the first goal, but he was a nervous wreck. You know, there's no confidence there. I know Inanna was, but you can tell. You can tell the defenders don't rate him. He's too slow on the second goal. He ain't good enough. He ain't good enough. He's going to cost us goals. He's going to cost us goals. I don't think he cost us the game today, to be fair, but he ain't good enough. Yaro, I'd probably say, you know, five. Yeah, probably a five. I'd say De Ligt was a five as well. I don't think they were shocking as a pair, and they have been our best two players this season so far, but they were both below average.

20:35I mean, you know, the first goal was on Bruno and Shaw. The second goal, I think De Ligt gets caught in a bad position, but Luke Shaw should cover it. Yoro, they just didn't look as good. They looked nervous. They didn't look as good as they did before the international break. Luke Shaw, two. I thought he was abysmal. I don't know how he stayed on the pitch. I mean, that attempt at a tackle on the first goal, all right, it's Bruno's fault, but it's weak. I'm looking at this one here. He's trying to pull the hit-hal and back. He should sprint. He's got no pace. I thought he was absolute dog shit, to be honest with you.

21:19I don't know why he stayed on the pitch. He was abysmal, absolutely abysmal. And that's on the manager. I mean, why you take Yorro on, off, and keep Luke Shaw on, I'll never know. And I don't think he's been good all season. I mean, fair play, he's stayed fit. But if he thinks he's getting back in the England squad, he's got absolutely no chance. I'd rather play Aidan Heaven. I really would. I know he's going to make mistakes, but I would rather play him because he's got no pace anymore. He's tackling is weak. Experience? I don't know. I don't know. It's weak. I mean, they're showing it here and it's weak.

21:56De Ligt's in a bad position, but Luke Shaw has to cover that. And it's rubbish. Absolutely rubbish. Masraoui was a 4.5. I do agree with that. I mean, it's great to have him back. I put his name down before the game as being an important player for us. But yeah, he wasn't. We've got a real problem down that right-hand side. If you put Ahmad there, he can't defend. If you put Masraoui and Deleu there, they can't attack. So it doesn't work. If you're going to play that system, you need somebody who can play that position and we can't. I actually thought Agate was okay I wouldn't give him a 6 But I'd give him a 5.5 He was probably my man of the match for us I thought he played well I thought he was very impressive In the intensity of his press I think it's a very difficult job To play in the midfield as one person I mean Luke I'm just looking at the third goal That's on Luke Shaw and Maguire isn't it It's absolutely shit I didn't realise that I mean, what's Luke Shaw doing on the third goal?

23:00Hospital pass to Maguire. I mean, Luke Shaw should get an assist for that. Takes Maguire out the game. Bruno, I mean, a three. Yeah, I agree. A three. I mean, terrible captaincy performance. Costa's the first goal. Square peg in a round hole. I expect better from a player on 300 grand a week. I do I thought there was a level of resignation from him as well I think his head was down for most of the game Blaming other people I mean there's just no leadership there There's no accountability there I mean with Bruno as well We've basically created the main man syndrome Haven't we as well When somebody wants to give you£90 million For a player that's not worth£50 And then you beg them to stay you basically just make them the main man, don't they?

23:59Dorgou, probably a five. I thought he was okay, but his final ball was a bit bad. Embermo, 5.5. To be fair, you could give him man of the match, really, couldn't you? I'd probably give him man of the match. I thought he was a bit unlucky with his shot. I think he's the bright spark, really. Him and Agate are probably the bright spark. I would give Agathe another go next week, 100%. And I think Embermo is a bright spark in a team that really is, you know, in the shadows at the moment. I think he is a bright spark. I think he's one of the players that can probably walk off and say, you know, I did my part.

24:43Ahmad, I don't know, 4.5? Yeah. Too many touches. Too many touches on the ball. That's what I would say about Ahmad. He's not having... He's not had a very good start to the season. Seshko's got to be a 4.5 and that's generous. Definitely a graveyard shift. Yeah, definitely a graveyard shift. What can you say? I mean, how many times are we going to say this about a striker as well? It's just... It ain't good enough, is it? Harry Maguire I mean God 4 yeah I mean I feel like Harry Maguire as an analogy was a little bit like getting a lamb coating it in tomato ketchup and throwing it to a load of wolves you know a lamb to the slaughter really I mean it was just I know Harry go and stand on the halfway line with Harland and have a foot race three times yeah I just I don't get that substitution at all Mainu did okay probably give him a 5 5.

25:50Casimiro, 5. Zerksi, 5. I mean, they're irrelevant really. Amorim today, 2. And, you know, there's your Amorim inner. I am Amorim in. I am Amorim in, but like, if we don't say it, it feels like it just needs to be said. Like, I want him to do well. I want to back him. But it's like your mate. It's like your mate who's clearly in the wrong. and you want to back them and you do back them. But on this, it has to be said. You know, like if you've got a mate who's got a lovely wife and a lovely family and he's off doing things he shouldn't do and you don't agree with it and you say, look, you are a mate.

26:39There's loads of opportunities, but you're in the wrong. I feel like this with Amarim. I want you to stay. I want you to be the manager. I want us to build something and I believe we can. Hey everybody, Lady Luck here and we're celebrating America's 250th birthday. Now all summer long, I'm going to be celebrating by playing on spinquest.com, which is an American owned social casino. It obviously features over a thousand slot games and live blackjack, live craps, live bubble craps. Head on over to spinquest.com. Get yourself a$30 coin pack for just$10. SpendQuest is a free-to-play social casino.

27:17Void where prohibited. Visit SpendQuest.com for more details. This Monday.com ad was created by a team of people and AI agents. The agents wrote the copy and managed the timelines, while our human creative director made sure it all made sense. Easy. Create your own AI agent today on Monday.com. But the Bruno thing has to stop, mate. Like, I can't back that. I can't back that. It's idiotic. It is stupid. It is costing us games. The opposition know what to do. They basically put players on Bruno and then run off him, knowing they're going to be unmarked in the six-yard box. It is killing us. I actually think up until the goal, we were doing all right.

28:02You know, when we finished 15th last year, we're absolutely shit. First 20 minutes at the Etihad against a very good Man City team on paper. And we're holding our own. It's competitive. It's equal. We're doing OK. You know, we're not creating anything. They're not creating anything, but we're doing OK. And then one bit of bad defending by Luke Shaw. A cross comes in and Bruno's lost his man and it's 1-0. And then you've got a mountain to climb. And who's that on? Really? Who is that on? And I've got Bruno on my screen here. I don't give a shit what he says, because at the end of the day, mate, you playing as a number eight is cost us the game.

28:41What do you think about that? Well, I disagree. I'm sorry, mate. I think the vast majority of the earth know that. So look, I back the manager. We can't sack the manager, but somebody needs to be telling him, are you going to change that midfield? Because if you're not, you may as well resign. Like, I hate to say it. I back the manager. I'm not hammering him out. I'm hammering him in. But if you're going to pick Bruno, you're going to die on that hill. If you're going to put Bruno in your midfield, you're going to die on that hill. It's not going to work. It's not going to work. And we can all pinpoint the decision to keep him instead of taking 90 million.

29:20And we can, you know, we can go mad thinking what we could have done with that 90 million pounds. But if you don't stop picking him in the midfield, you will sack yourself. A hundred percent. A hundred percent. Who was your man of the match? 59 % Embermo. Thank you very much for that. Okay, right. Let's get into some of your comments because you've been very, very patient. Then we'll go over to Manchester. Thanks for all your super chats. If you want to chuck them in, I will read them. We belong in the championship, says Salim. Do you think that could be Amrim gone? Really hope it's not. No, no.

29:52HM. The club ain't going to sack him for losing to Man City. The club won't sack him for losing to Chelsea. He won't be sacked by the club. If you want Amrim to go, he will have to resign. But he will eventually sack himself because the scary thing is, is he stubborn and up his own ass enough to think that we're all wrong? Is he stubborn enough to think that he can play Bruno Fernandes in the Premier League? Because the thing about Amrim is we've all been watching Man United for years. More importantly, we all watch the Premier League. you cannot play with a midfield like that. The players can't play the system, but transfer window is closed.

30:32He needs to work with what he's got, says Swish. What would I do in the midfield? Just Agathe and Mainou. Agathe and Mainou every week. You've got to make it work. It's the most balanced midfield we've got until January. It's Agathe and Mainou every week. That's what I would do. No fight, no organisation, rolled over for City. Same mistake, same passengers. This isn't bad luck anymore. or its mentality, says Slow Sports News. Bring in Areola, says Maliki. You know what, Maliki, I do think there's a level of naivety to think that there's a magic manager out there. I genuinely think at this point, we need to realise that sacking a manager and bringing in the next hipster won't work because we've literally done that five times.

31:15It's not as simple as sacking a manager and bringing another manager in anymore. It has to be bigger than that. They play forward through the middle anyway. It's always from centre-back to the wide players after that. It's just stuttering, says Salim. Shame to just expect these results now, says David. Newcastle sacked Steve Bruce and got Eddie Howe. Best thing they did. Apart from maybe not getting Sheshko, Eddie would do a great job at Man United, says Nathan. He wouldn't take it. Roy Keane created Haaland, says Vanessa. Trying to blame Maguire is simply pathetic, says Red Army. You didn't listen.

31:44This season feels like it's going to be a case of same shit, different toilet from United, says Aaron. Fernandes should play number 10 only, not midfield, says Mr. and Mrs. AM. He should go back to Casemiro Agate and play Agate as a Kante-style counterpress high up the pitch the way we played in the Europa League. We have too many average players to be controlling possession-based, says Chip. I'm done with Bruno in the midfield. Amrim is going to keep costing his games with his stubbornness, says Mr. Lopez. If that was a good Agate performance, Jesus, says Matthew. Well, I didn't say it was good.

32:14I gave him 5.5. I mean, nobody hit a six for me. Mate, stop the lies. How many teams have won major titles with a 4-3-3? Says Victoria. I think your obsession with the formation is boring, Victoria, and I'm not going to talk about it. Please ring up talk shit and shout. Luke Shaw single-handedly losses that game. We needed to do a whole team cleanup, not half all the way. So Scott, it's simple. We don't... We don't... We've done player authority on the hand or subs to change this. It's the players and not the system. We need more players, says D-Budge. Mark Amram is not Conte, says Kiel. 3-0, Oli.

32:49Oli, Manchester is blue. Keep crying, says the football pulse. Only way to get payout if he gets sacked, says Jason Brown. Keeping Bruno on the centre midfield is proof. We need wins, says JB. Mark, he's as bad as Oli. You're not seeing it. He's taking the club backwards as well. It's another manager who doesn't get the midfield working when there is obvious options he won't touch, says Kreshin. Seshko was in a great position for most of the game. So many chances for a through ball, but took it wide for a cross that did absolutely nothing, says Cameron. You know what? Watch Rasmus' goal against Napoli last night and watch what Spinozola does and then watch Man United and you'll realise we never do it.

33:26We never play the ball early into the striker. He's sacking himself, says Corey. Be under bench next game, please, says 44 mad. I like Amrind, but it's the same every week. This clearly isn't working. We look slightly better than last year, but it's nowhere near good enough, says Jordan. There is no system philosophy that suits this group, says Dylan. It doesn't matter what midfielder you bring in. If Bruno stays in the midfield, nothing will change, doesn't it? And that's the thing as well. It has to be said. People will say the board didn't backhammer him and they didn't. They didn't get a midfielder in.

33:56They didn't get an experienced goalkeeper in. But even I will say if they'd got Belaiba or they'd got Conor Gallagher, he'd still be playing Bruno next to them. So, you know, as much as I agree we didn't buy a midfielder, I'm absolutely convinced if they'd bought a midfielder, he'd still pick fucking Bruno next to him. It would be Belaiba and Bruno. it would be Conor Gallagher and Bruno. And even as somebody that backs Amorim, I'll still be truthful and say it wouldn't have been Belaber and Mainu. It wouldn't have been Belaber and Ogarte. It would have been Belaber and Amorim and Bruno. Until today, I've never been Amorim out.

34:31But if we play this dead formation that couldn't beat Grimsby more tight... But Justine, you've just contradicted yourself. I mean, you don't need a formation or a system to beat Grimsby. That's clearly on the players when you're playing a League Two side with people on hundreds of thousands of pounds a week. That's players. You don't need a system to beat Grimsby. That's fucking shit players. Like, come on. I can't listen to you about systems and formations. You need to get yourself on to talk shit, Victoria, because you are talking it. I'd like to hear how you defend Ruben now, says Colin. I didn't.

35:00People are asking for Amrim's sack. New manager in, same shit players, same result. Same player will start the same cycle and will be a mid-table club. I mean, Anu, as I said, like Amrim's sacking himself, But I'm not hammering him out. But what I do find amazing is that we still have fans that want to put it all at the manager's feet. Like, these are shit players. Like, you know, they are shit. Like, they are shit with a shit mentality. I've just watched the Manchester Derby. We've just done player ratings and not one player is average. They're all below average. That's not on the manager. That's not on Sir Jim.

35:36That's not on you. That's on them. Hey, everybody. Lady Luck here. and we're celebrating America's 250th birthday. Now, all summer long, I'm going to be celebrating by playing on SpinQuest.com, which is an American-owned social casino. It obviously features over 1 ,000 slot games and live blackjack, live craps, live bubble craps. Head on over to SpinQuest.com. Get yourself a$30 coin pack for just$10. SpinQuest is a free-to-play social casino. Void where prohibited. Visit SpinQuest.com for more details. This Monday.com ad was created by a team of people and AI agents. The agents wrote the copy and managed the timelines, while our human creative director made sure it all made sense.

36:20Easy. Create your own AI agent today on Monday.com. You can talk about systems. You can talk about Bruno in the midfield. You can talk about the goalkeeper. You can talk about a lack of signings. This is a Manchester fucking derby, and not one Man United player has managed to play average. I don't care about arguments about formations. I don't care about arguments about the manager. And I don't care about ownership arguments either. This is a Manchester derby and you can't even play average. What the fuck? Like, why is that not at least being mentioned as well? Okay, you don't like the manager.

36:54Okay, you don't like the owners. But this is a Manchester derby and you can't even play average. That has to be in the conversation. Like, you don't get away with that. I'm sorry. As a Man United player, you do not get away with that. You can't leak to the press that you don't like the system. It's a Manchester derby and not one of you played average. Look in the fucking mirror. You know, I'm not saying they're to blame, but I'm saying that they have to take some of it. Of course they do. I don't think there is any point getting angry. We need strong players in all positions, says Rohiv. If Amorin doesn't stop nepotism managing, he must go, says Lemophilia.

37:33What have I just watched? It was a shambles, says Gavin. Embarrassing that they haven't found a way to include the striker in the attack. He's the number one priority, says Sudev. Well, remember next week, we're about to play one of the best midfielders in the league as well. James Hook, thank you very much for joining the members club. I've still got a few super chats coming in here.

37:56But, you know, I don't like losing, but I'll lose 6-3 if we give it a go and we're entertaining. But that's piss poor. You know, that's horse piss, that result. It's, you know, no goals scored, shitty goals conceded, Man City don't get out of third gear. no cohesion, no leadership, no accountability, shit substitutions. I mean, there's nothing to take out of that game, is there? Like, that's the thing. There's nothing to take out of it. I'm not Amirim out, but 100 % needs to realise that his formation might not work with these players. Jacob says, do you understand the fans can't see the progress?

38:37Amirim, we're doing better. It's just the result. Don't show it. Mate, I'll repeat again. If you want to get a mass message to Ruben Amirim, Mate, you're going to sack yourself. You can talk about us getting better, but what does that matter if you've got a guy in the midfield who doesn't mark people and cost you goals? Fulham, three points down the drain because Smith Rowe doesn't get tracked. Today, one nil down in a Manchester derby because Foden doesn't get tracked. You can talk about all the good stuff you like. You know what it is, mate? Maybe things are getting better, but it's like filling your living room with a lovely TV and loads of brilliant stuff and then leaving the patio door open for it to get nicked.

39:20It doesn't matter if it's getting better, if you're stupid and giving a big gaping hole. As I said, that midfield is as wide open as a hippo's yawn. It's massive, massive. And if he doesn't figure that out, he may as well walk. I can't get positive about this United side. I can't get optimistic about this United side, Even though I see improvement, I can't get optimistic if he's going to pick Bruno every week in the midfield. It's going to kill us. I'm sorry. It's like saying you're going on a once-in-a-lifetime holiday to Sydney, Australia. But to do it, you've got to swim up and down the coast with bloody cuts on your knee.

40:05I'm going to get eaten by a fucking shark. It doesn't matter if I'm on a holiday of a lifetime. Was it the game today? The effort I made to get there was more than the players made in the pitch, jogging around instead of sprinting. No hard tackling. Pathetic, says Amon. We need to give Bruno accountability, but sub him off. Needs manager to let him know he's underperforming. Well, we may as well build a statue of Bruno. He's on a bloody... He's untouchable, isn't he? You know, we turned down£90 million for him. Anarud says, I may be disillusional, but this loss shows that we can never get back to a team that plays for the badge.

40:37All of us need to make peace with our downfall. Well, realistically, at the moment, I think you'd pitch us in at 15th again, wouldn't you? And that's the challenge. We've got to be better. We lose 3-0 to City, but we're getting better. Standards in the mud, says Victoria. My big dilemma is I don't see it working with Amrima or a new manager. I don't see a light at the end of the tunnel. Nigel, I think you are absolutely spot on. By all means, change the manager, but I don't think it will get any better. Please bring Ten Hag back, says Amrima out. Maybe Ruud van Nistelrooy should get a chance, says Grant.

41:13I don't know why I can't get rid of you, but you're gone. Thank you very much. We actually need better wingbacks. Amrim System needs it, says Shan. We have a six-foot strike striker and we're crossing to four-foot cams, says Naveen. Baz says you've been disrespectful against Victoria. I'm not being disrespectful. You probably just knew. We've spent about nine months talking about the formation. It's a boring conversation. and if you want to talk about it, get yourself on TalkSport because I guarantee that I'll be full of low IQ idiots saying the formation's the problem. If you want me to repeat it again, I will tell you.

41:49If you think the formation's the problem, fine, but 4-3-3 got three managers sacked. 3-4-3, 4-3-3, 5-3-2, 2-2-4. It won't, it doesn't matter. The formation doesn't matter. It's the players. And what Amirim's problem is, is that he's putting a player in a position they can't play. So the players are 100 % always going to be a problem. But Amirim is compounding that by putting a player in a position that he shouldn't play. The problem with the modern football fan who doesn't know what they're talking about is they try and list loads of problems because they don't feel one problem is big enough. Trust me, we've got two major problems.

42:37The goalkeeper is shit and the midfield is shit. That's enough. That's simply enough. You don't need to start listing more like wingbacks or strikers or systems or formations. Those two problems, they're going to screw you over in the Premier League. The midfield is where games are won and lost and we are losing it. And our goalkeeper ain't good enough either. So those two problems are absolutely spot on. Gary Neville said it three weeks ago. We need a goalkeeper And we need a midfielder And we haven't solved the problem You lot have been saying it for a year We need a goalkeeper and a midfielder And we haven't solved the problem If we had Let's say Conor Gallagher Next to Agate today And Emi Martinez in goal I don't think we'd lose the game I really don't Because we don't concede the first goal Maybe we get a draw But To me Football is very very simple And the problems are very very easy to see And the problem is we've got an attacker playing in the midfield and we've got a crap goalkeeper in goal.

43:40And that feeds into the whole team. And when you've got a weakness in a team, everybody else is weakened by it. So Agarte or Casemiro or Mainu's game is always going to be shit because they've got a shit player next to them. And the defence is going to be impacted by the goalkeeper. So, you know, formation to me screams if we change the formation next week, we will win.

44:27for just$10. SpendQuest is a free-to-play social casino. Void where prohibited. Visit SpendQuest.com for more details. This Monday.com ad was created by a team of people and AI agents. Reese, our content agent, wrote the copy based on our best practices, like mentioning Monday.com three times. That was the second. Johnny, our coordination agent, built the timeline and kept everyone aligned. Olivia, our human creative director, stayed in the loop because agents are great, but they don't always know when a joke lands. She had one note. Tell listeners it only takes minutes to build an agent. So minutes.

45:01Create your own AI agent today on Monday.com. And then next week you'll be going, Bruno was shit again. Oh, the defence, the goalkeeper was shit again. I don't think it's a formational problem at all. I don't think we've got the players. He ain't changing anything, says Robert McCormack, and therefore he will get the sack because he will be sacking himself, which I said at the start. Absolutely. Absolutely agree with that. 100%. And Arna's made a blunder against Fenerbahce, apparently.

45:34Anwar says the formation works for Glasner because his midfield is press resistant. I mean, this is a great point. A great point. Crystal Palace play a 3-4-3. They play it very, very well. Conte plays a 3-4-3. They play it very, very well. We can't do it because he's putting a player in the midfield that doesn't have the profile to do it. And that's on the manager. So, you know, that is sacking himself. 100%. 100%. I don't want him to do it. I don't want him to do it. I want him to do well. But is it stubbornness? Yes. Will it sack him if he keeps doing it? Yes. 100%. Let me have a quick look at your comments.

46:16They're ready to go in the studio. I feel I'm hogging the limelight here. I'm sure you'll get completely different opinions over there.

46:32Justin says... No, no, Justin, you don't understand what you're talking about. Sorry, I'm not being baited into an argument about that. We've been doing this for 10 years. We disagree. That's the way it works. But I will repeat it again. If you think of formation as the problem at Manchester United, I think you have got low IQ and I'm entitled to say it. You can argue back. You bloody well do. Well done. It's called an opinion. But I'm telling you now, there's nothing wrong with a 4-3-3, a 3-4-3, a 5-3-2. Formations are never the problem. And this is what I mean about low IQ. Formations aren't the problem.

47:07If Crystal Palace can win an FA Cup playing a 3-4-3 and Conte can win a Premier League winning a 3-4-3, it ain't the formation, is it? It's the players you're using in it. that's the conversation we're having. It's not that people go, change the formation, change the formation. It's not the formation, it's the players in it. And what I'm saying is Amram's insistence on using Bruno in this formation is going to sack him. Simple. Hopefully. I think most people can understand that. Well done. Let's get over to Manchester. I'm interested to see what they say. I need to take a deep breath and calm down.

47:46But ultimately, well done to Manchester City. They thoroughly deserved it. We can have no complaints apart from the ones that we've raised. Where are we going to finish this season? Mid-table. Get it in the live chat. Spam them. Mid-table FC. Thanks for watching.

48:15Now, new users get$30 coin packs for just$10. All the table games you love with hundreds of slot games and real cash prizes. That's at spinquest.com. S-P-I-N-Q-U-E-S-T dot com. SpinQuest is a free-to-play social casino. Void where prohibited. Visit spinquest.com for more details.

48:37Kitchen and bathroom professionals know. What goes behind the tile matters. That's why trade pros trust fiber cement Hardy Backer Board to keep tile firmly in place, resist cracking, and help block moisture. Chosen in over 40 million kitchens and bathrooms, Hardy Backer Board. What the best build on. Shop now at participating Home Depot, Lowe's, and Floor & Decor stores. For more information, visit jameshardy.com slash hardybacker.

From the publisher
14/09/2025 - Match Review! Mark dissects Man United's horrific 3-0 defeat to Man City in the derby! 

More from The United Stand

All episodes