1. Podcasts
  2. The United Stand
  3. 260: Amorim's NEW Clear Out! INEOS Refuse to SPEND!
The United Stand

3 Dec 2025 · 55m · 18 chapters

Episode artwork

260: Amorim's NEW Clear Out! INEOS Refuse to SPEND!

In short

Manchester United’s January transfer window and Ruben Amorim’s need to “clear out” players to fund new signings; criticism of Ineos/ownership for refusing to spend early, plus wage-bill contradictions and squad planning for possible Europe.

Guest backgrounds

No named guests appear in the transcript. The episode is hosted by Mark Goldbridge, with audience comments/superchats and references to journalists (e.g., Laurie Whitwell, Sam, Andy Mitten) rather than studio guests.

Key claims

United won’t spend in the first three weeks of January and may only act late; this “kicks the problem down the road” and risks missing Europe readiness. United’s wage spending is high (cited via Capology): Man United pay about £3.1m/week, similar to Chelsea, yet aren’t matching results. Amorim is portrayed as inheriting big earners and needing sales to buy. The club is described as asset-stripping potential players (e.g., Mainoo, Zirkzee, Agate, Malacia).

Notable examples

Laurie Whitwell/The Athletic loan-in/loan-out suggestion; comparisons to Chelsea/Man City aggressive January spending (Enzo Fernandez, Mamouche). Reported Barcelona interest in Marcus Rashford and potential return. Luke Shaw’s 300th appearance used as an example of “spin.”

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

1:28

Ruben Amorim's Challenges

Discussion on Ruben Amorim's need to clear out players to strengthen the team.

“For a limited time, get an extra$250 off when you sign up.”
2:14

Ruben Amorim's Challenges

Discussion on Ruben Amorim's need to clear out players to strengthen the team.

“Also, Ahmad speaking about a weak mentality last season when Amrind was here that isn't there anymore.”
2:56

The January Transfer Window Dilemma

Analysis of Manchester United's approach to the January transfer window and its implications.

“So essentially where we're at, again, is that Ruben Amrim is going to have to clear out if he wants to bring in.”
6:38

Critique of Club Management

Mark expresses frustration over Manchester United's management and decision-making.

“They're in the top three, they're in the Champions League and they're good footballing sides.”
13:32

Potential Player Sales

Discussion on which players Manchester United may sell in the upcoming transfer window.

“Bournemouth are probably the worst team in the Premier League at the moment with Wolves and West Ham aren't that great.”
14:01

Analyzing Ruben Amorim's Position at Manchester United

Discussion on Ruben Amorim's management and the challenges he faces with player transfers.

“So all these big earners he's inherited, he has to use.”
19:36

Critique of Manchester United's Management Strategy

A critical examination of Manchester United's management strategy and its impact on team performance.

“Maybe they didn't see it three months ago.”
28:54

Fans' Love for Manchester United

A discussion on the relationship between Manchester United, its fans, and the current ownership.

“that doesn't love its fans back, says Alan Miller.”
30:13

Financial Sustainability vs. Spending

Debate over the financial decisions of Manchester United and their impact on club performance.

“make that decision because you're making me comply with an ownership model that's got nothing to do with me.”
33:46

January Transfer Strategies

Exploring potential transfer strategies for Manchester United in the upcoming window.

“You'd hope the club realise that, says Sam.”
Show all 18 chapters
35:06

Luke Shaw's Contributions and Critique

Analyzing Luke Shaw's performance and the club's perception of him amidst fan opinions.

“Loads of you tuned in last night because we've got the Premier League.”
38:14

Managerial Authority and Club Dynamics

Discussion on the need for strong managerial authority at Manchester United and its implications.

“Um, but he did play well at the weekend and I had a big chat with Ricky the other night and, um, he absolutely loves him.”
42:04

Manager Profiles and Authority at Manchester United

Discussion on the types of managers needed at Manchester United and their authority to make changes.

“Sir Alex Ferguson would clear a player out, no problem, because he had the authority and aura to do it.”
43:21

Injuries and Team Performance

Exploration of player fitness, injuries, and the impact on team performance if competing in Europe.

“That's why you're not getting a midfielder.”
45:46

Transfer Window Strategies

Discussion on the importance of the January transfer window for squad improvement.

“The hilarious thing is, and I'll go back to this again, right?”
47:55

Rashford's Future and Transfer Market Dynamics

Analysis of Marcus Rashford's situation and the challenges of the January transfer market.

“summer, in a World Cup summer, that gives us six or seven players to go into next season and be prepared.”
52:28

Ownership Issues and Manager Support

Critique of Manchester United's ownership and the lack of support for the current manager.

“And they're now putting stuff out there that they might not do anything in January and he might need to sell to buy.”
56:03

January Signings: Strategic Advantages

Learn why bringing in players during January can be beneficial for teams.

“Man City did it with Mamouche and Ganchalves.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On The United Stand, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:0010 hours on my feet, traffic, noise, everybody needing something from me. My head is spinning, I just need the world to stop for one second. But then I get home, shoes off, phone out, and I open Modo Casino. Hundreds of slots, classic table games. It's my instant reset. The variety I want, and the quiet I need. Modo Casino, the social casino. We're prohibited. No purchase necessary. Visit Modo.us for more details. Download the Modo Casino app today. Must be 21+. Modo Casino. America's social casino. 102 miles ago, the oil light came on. 100 miles ago, you noticed. Now, it's time to head to Take 5.

0:38This oil change, fall in love with your car all over again. In just 10 minutes, your dream technician will check your tire pressure, top off fluids, change your oil, and verify with Carfax exactly what your car really needs. All while keeping you in the driver's seat. Take 5, the Stay in Your Car 10-minute oil change. Save up to 30 % on your next oil change to Take 5. $15 value. Valid to participating locations. Terms and conditions apply. Every dating app swipe is another loss. Jim bros, fake CEOs, straight up losers. So now the only app I open is Moto Casino. Because at least there, I'm surrounded by winners.

1:09Real winners. Thousands of them. While everyone else is in the single swamp, I'm at home relaxing while stacking bonuses, hitting wins, and playing all my favorite Vegas-style games. Moto Casino. The only app worth your time. Moto Casino. The social casino. We're prohibited. No purchase necessary. Visit moto.us for more details. Download the Moto Casino app today. Must be 21+. Moto Casino. America's Central Casino Celebrate America's 250th with DISH. For a limited time, get an extra$250 off when you sign up. Call 888-ADDISH or visit dish.com today and use code DISH250 to claim your$250 savings.

1:51That's 888-ADDISH. Offer ends August 12th. Terms apply.

2:02Hello everybody, good morning. Welcome to the United Stands. I'm Mark Goldbridge and this is your latest Manchester United news. As Ruben Amrim faces a familiar problem, a clear out if he is to bring players in. Celta Bay is back on the agenda as Ineos refused to spend in January. We've got the latest on that. Also, Ahmad speaking about a weak mentality last season when Amrind was here that isn't there anymore. Also, is Barcelona going to send Rashford back? Is that a good thing or a bad thing? And we'll be talking about what this means for Manchester United and why the constant talk of Manchester United needing to suffer is actually a bit of a joke when we spend more money on our midfield than any other club in the Premier League apart from Man City.

2:48So interestingly stuff on that. But how are we all doing this morning? Lots to get into. And we're going to start off with some stuff coming out of the Athletic this morning. So essentially where we're at, again, is that Ruben Amrim is going to have to clear out if he wants to bring in. This job that Ruben Amrim has been given at Manchester United does become harder and harder by the week, it feels. because obviously this is a guy that's very reluctant to speak positively about any positive result because he's always trying to say, look, you know, who knows what's around the corner. The enormity of the job he spoke about that pre-Crystal Palace.

3:24And it goes back to everything we've ever said before. Are Ineos just the Glazers a wolf in sheep's clothing? Because everything just seems to follow the same pattern. We're already getting things like this coming out from the Athletic. From a Manchester United point of view, they could do with strengthening, but they don't see January as the ideal opportunity to do that. I mean, you know what? This is Manchester United, the great institution, you know, the biggest football brand in the world with Real Madrid, Barcelona and maybe Bayern Munich. And they don't see January as an opportunity to improve a broken squad.

4:03I mean, at what point did we cease becoming a football club and become idiots? 2005? Maybe. So from a Man United point of view, they could do with strengthening, but they don't see January as the ideal opportunity to do that. If something came onto the landscape, they could act quickly. But from my understanding, it would be a loan in and a loan out kind of thing. That's from Laurie Whitwell in The Athletic. And this is why the thumbnail says not again, because we sort of alluded to this on the show last night. Remember Mark Ogden said Man United, if they can offload some players in January, may be tempted to go and spend big on an Elliot Anderson or an Adam Wharton, etc.

4:47But I did say when you read the detail of that story, what it's actually saying is Man United, if they're going to spend big, won't do anything until the last week of January, until everybody's back from the AFCON and then they can look at it. And all that is, is we're definitely not spending money in the first three weeks of the January transfer window, which basically shuts you all up for three quarters of it. And then with only a week, we'll ride the storm out and then it will be shut and then we can't do anything. A la last year, where last year we did exactly the same. All right, we brought Dorgue in, but it wasn't exciting.

5:23It was a 20-year-old from a lower relegation threatened and Serie A side. And then when the window closed, they told some bullshit story about Kenda, who a month later signed for Chelsea. At some point, well, it doesn't have to change, does it? Because we're run by mercenaries. But this constant insistence that January is not a time to improve the Manchester United squad is painstakingly irritating. It really is. It's so frustrating. And to read that and try and compute it in your head as a purist football fan who just wants the team you love to be successful. I am so tired. It's so draining to be run by these people who just do not have the interests of this football club at heart.

6:10They are business people running the club like an Excel spreadsheet. And to read that from a Man United point of view, they could do with strengthening, but they don't see January as an opportunity to do that. So why, again, did Manchester City last year see January as an opportunity to buy three players and bed them in for this season? Why the previous year did Chelsea see the opportunity to buy three expensive players and bed them in for their future? And look at where Chelsea and Man City are now. They're in the top three, they're in the Champions League and they're good footballing sides. So I'm sorry, I don't know why any ex-player, any media outlet, I don't know why they're so terrified of saying what I'm about to say and what many of you say all the time.

6:53Why are Manchester United such a badly run football club and why do they ignore something that would actually improve them? This team is very far from the finished article. The January transfer window, you could bring two players in that improve us instantly and then in the summer, you bring a different three or four players in that improve you. So why is Manchester United run as a football club that ignores something where you can get better to make our job harder for our manager, our fans and everybody else because it's money. They don't have it, do they? They're just so bad. They're so bad.

7:29And we sort of get ground down by it. I was thinking about this this morning. The symptoms that they give off almost make you want to give them a cuddle and go, let's get them some medicine. It's almost like the way the Glazers and Ineos behave, I'm surprised there's not a GoFundMe that you lot aren't funding for because you feel sorry for them. Because that's, you know, I listen to Amrim. I listen to Sir Jim. And it's like this sympathy, sympathy vote is just incredible. And I don't actually get it. You know, I listen to Amrim coming out and I have sympathy for Amrim because he's dealing with the situation.

8:08But I look at United and it's like, you know, we believe we're a top four team. Well, we're not. We believe that it's going to take three or four years. And look, this is from Capology, right? Listen to this. This is probably the most interesting thing you're going to hear today. And it's not from The Athletic and it's not from any news outlet. It would be coming in at, you know, it's coming in from as the United stands. So the current wage bill. So let me just I mean, I'm sort of riffing here because there is a lot to get through and I want to get your points. But am I wrong in saying that all we ever hear about Man United from the manager, from the owners, from the players, is that this is a hard project.

8:54It's a long project. It's a long road. We're going to have to suffer. You know, it's going to take time. If we get fifth place, it will be a miracle. You know, all this stuff, which we end up repeating. I've repeated it, right? I have said if Amram gets top four, he deserves a statue. If he gets fifth place, it's a really good season, right? We fall for... I'm not calling any of you out for falling for this because we are fed this on a daily basis. We're a long way off. We're going to suffer. We're still not good enough. You know, it's going to take years. Okay. Capology website lists wages paid by Premier League clubs.

9:36Number one, Manchester City,£4.3 million a year in wages. OK? Sorry, a week in wages. OK? £222 million a year. So let's do it by the week. £4.2 million a week, Manchester City. So you'd expect them to be up there, wouldn't you? In second place, Arsenal,£3.6 million a week. You'd expect them to be up there, wouldn't you? Yeah. Liverpool,£3.3 million a week. Well, they've just won the league. I know they're having a bad time, but you'd expect that. Chelsea,£3.1 million. There's a theme here, isn't there? The top four wage payers finished in the top four last year and will probably finish in the top four this year.

10:17But the interesting thing is, in fifth place, Manchester United pay nearly£3.1 million a year, just behind Chelsea in wages. So why aren't we comfortably the fifth best team in England competing with Chelsea? We basically pay the same in wages as Chelsea do, and yet our manager and our club are constantly talking about three-year projects. It's very, very difficult. We've got to suffer. And we're paying£3.1 million a week in wages. The sixth place club is Tottenham on 2.5. The seventh place club is Aston Villa on 2.2. And Newcastle are then Forrester 1.8 million. So I can't understand how we are suffering and struggling to get in the top five when we're comfortably in the top five for wages.

11:10We've got two of the top five best paid players in the league, in Bruno Fernandes and Casemiro. When you look at our midfield, Man City spend£51 million a year in wages on their midfield. Manchester United are second with 26. We pay more money on our midfield than Chelsea, Liverpool and Arsenal.

11:39Something just doesn't add up at this football club because where's the clear out? Maynou isn't on good wages. It's bonkers. It's absolutely bonkers, Mr Miracle. I don't know what the message is from Manchester United because all I see, and the Athletic have done an article today, Man United can't stop doing it. All we see at the moment is how amazing Luke Shaw is. Oh, Luke Shaw's an incredible footballer. Why is he not being called up for England? He's one of the best players in the world in a one-on-one situation. So we've got all this glaze for these players that have been here for years on massive wages.

12:16But on the other hand, these experienced players that have been here for years on massive wages that make up a large portion of this wage bill. But we're going to suffer. If we get fifth place, it's incredible. I mean, come on. It's mixed messages. That's what I'm trying to say. I'm so confused about what... We can't play good football. The football we play is shit. We've got the fifth best wage bill in the country. We've got the most expensive midfield in the country on wages, apart from Man City. We can't play good football. We're going to suffer. We can't spend money in January. I don't, I don't, you know what?

12:56I never thought I'd say this, but I wish Todd Bowley was in charge because he might be chaotic, but he does just go out there and go after what they need and spend money. Whereas this Ineos Glazer shagfest or whatever it is, is just incredibly confusing. It really is. And it goes back to fundamentally what I was saying at the start of the show, how Manchester United can put it out there to their little allies in the Athletic saying, yeah, we could do with strengthening, but we don't see January as an opportunity. I mean, this is why we're going to fail. And look, we've got a great opportunity over the next three games, but let's get real.

13:32It's West Ham, Wolves and Bournemouth. Bournemouth are probably the worst team in the Premier League at the moment with Wolves and West Ham aren't that great. So you can almost see nine points hopefully coming our way and this continued mantra of, well, we don't need to spend in January. And what will happen is we'll hit January, we'll play some more difficult games, we'll start losing again, the window will shut and then we'll mess up Europe. So look, I am confused, but look, Manchester United are a very, very confusing club. But I just feel like I almost want to exclude Ruben Amrim from this because if he's got to sell to buy, how much of that wage bill has he implemented really?

14:12You know, he didn't sign Casemiro. He didn't sign Bruno. He didn't sign Luke Shaw. He didn't sign Harry Maguire. So all these big earners he's inherited, he has to use. And if he wants to buy his own players, he's got to sell them. And yet he plays a completely different system to what most of these players can play. it's arse about face really he's the manager that needs the backing he's not the manager that needs to sell to buy and it just kicks the problem down the road and makes it harder and harder and harder in my opinion but look that's my thoughts on that also Manchester United will reportedly listen to offers in January for a number of players including Maynou, Xerxi, Agate and Malassia two of which we shouldn't be selling You know, I really don't think Zerksi and Mainu should be gone.

15:01And again, they'll almost become the bomb squad that aren't the bomb squad, because I genuinely just think that Mainu and Zerksi are not, you know, they're both young. They've both got potential and we're selling them because they have a value and other clubs want them, whilst retaining bags of shit on big money who aren't going to be part of our future plans as well. So, I mean, I just, it's the desperation in what we're trying to do. It's this asset stripping, which we've done in the rest of the club to try and get money in to buy. What I'm trying to say is a worrying theme that a football club that pays huge wages to shit that they want to glaze and keep is wanting to sell potential to bring money in to buy players that we desperately need.

15:45It's just not the behaviour of a football club that's heading in the right direction, in my opinion. As I said, I use Chelsea a lot because they're just so ridiculously intelligently aggressive. like they sell hotels and the women's team to get money in that they can then invest in players that they desperately need now it is chaotic it is risky but that's football and Chelsea are actually a good team to watch you know I don't want them to do well because they've got Ganacho playing for them but what Todd Bowley's done everybody's gone very very quiet now about they are one of the best teams in England they're one of the best teams in Europe they've got a ridiculously young squad that's getting stronger and stronger by the week and they've aggressively gone after it.

16:26And I look at United and I go, it's not like there aren't teams out there that we could copy their blueprint, but we won't do it. It's almost like you're trying to get across

16:42a massive river that's full of crocodiles, right? And on the other side, there's two or three people who've done it saying this is how we did it. And you go, no, we're not going to do it that way. We're going to go our own way. And that's what I feel Sir Jim Radcliffe is doing. There is a lot of people... Man City copied Man United, Liverpool copied Man United under Sir Alex. You can see what they've done. You can see. They've tweaked it, but they followed what United did for 20 years. Very, very clearly. You can see it. I've always said that about Jurgen Klopp and you can see it from Pep. We have an opportunity ourselves now to look at what other clubs are doing and we're deciding to do it our own way.

17:22You know, whilst Chelsea and Man City, maybe even Arsenal have this strategic plan to get to the top and you could take little bits from it. We've gone, no, we'll ignore that. What we're going to do is we're going to bring a manager in that doesn't suit the whole ethos of this football club. We're then going to get him to use previous failed managers players. We're then going to get him to sell assets that could be good players in the future. and then we're not going to get him players into his system straight away. We're going to take a long time to do it. We're going to allow him to get to the brink of the sack and frustrate the media and the fans so that morale's on the floor and excitement isn't really there.

18:03And then we're just going to tell everyone that we're going to stick with it. And you sort of like go, so you're going to take ages to give him what he wants. You're going to take him to the brink of the sack so some people don't trust him. And then you're going to tell everyone that you're just going to stick with it as well. wow this sounds absolutely scintillating i'm convinced it's going to work as opposed to getting your hand in your pocket finding ways to back him from the start to keep the enthusiasm and excitement going and the trust it's a crazy way to try and run a football club absolutely crazy and and tell me that's wrong you know i i look at i look at like the buzz around other clubs and the relentlessness and the aggression to compete and i look at united with this slowly slowly dead snail shit approach and a manager that already is splitting the fan base who is on a hiding to nothing and that's the inios approach you know we're going to take a long time but we're going to stick with you don't don't worry about the media don't worry about the ex-players don't worry about the fans they're irrelevant i'm in charge here i'm going to back you um and we're going to do it and then amram goes they actually do matter though because i speak to them on a regular basis they are the people that matter well don't worry about them peasants you know don't worry about them and and and i think that's sort of where sort of where we are you know we can't be sacking another manager absolutely not but um it it concerns me the strategy not i'm not even talking about style of play or long throwings i'm talking about the strategy um just a bit of breaking news coming out barcelona are trying to sign manchester united teenage sensation jj gabriel sources say united director of football jason wilcox was in key in convincing him to stay at the club united insiders believe the involvement of wilcox demonstrated to gabriel's family how much they value the forward and there is confidence i mean this is coming in from pratturst from the sun i mean this is about three months old um i actually thought this was something relevant i mean that's just basically like going through somebody's bins and then putting it on your dinner plate i mean that is about three months old i mean i don't know whether this is about glazing jason wilcox or something or luckhurst is desperate to try and get more stuff out of the thing since he's been demoted to the sun but i don't know i don't know what that story is breaking about um it's breaking bad that is i mean we know that he's i mean barcelona real madrid psg arsenal they all want him he's um he's basically a generational talent at his age but man united have got him to stay for now it's difficult because he's under 16 those clubs will still be there however at the moment his commitment is to manchester united so i mean i don't know why That's breaking news, but some people are posting it out there.

20:36Maybe they didn't see it three months ago. Football changed when City were bought, says Sam. United are still playing catch-up with regards to structure, personnel, stadium and squad. Chelsea twigged early. And this is a great point, Sam. And you can have this conversation or you can't. But I saw a lot of people taking the piss out of Todd Bowley at the start. You know, he wanted to do that North versus South game, which is very American. You know, they have the All-Stars game. And, you know, at the time, a lot of people took the piss out of him, thought he was ruining Chelsea. But I think a lot of his fans looked at it and went, hold on a minute, we can all join in with the pile on and laugh along with the ex-players at something that they're scared about.

21:18or we can look at it as fans and go if I was a Man United fan and Todd Boley owned the football club and he was finding creative ways to spend money on the first team day in day out and he spent somewhere between one and two billion in two years I don't think I'd be taking the piss out of him of a north versus south game I think I'd be looking at him and going well nothing else matters really you know we're not a very good football club and we want to be good at football you know you can talk about FFP you can talk about building stadiums you can talk about infrastructure you can talk about longevity but at the end of the day the most important thing is your team winning on a Saturday afternoon and beating your rivals and competing for major trophies and Chelsea are doing that Man United on so you know I would take that ownership every single day of the week and people took the piss out of it and look I don't know what the answer is, but that's the answer.

22:15The answer is to have an owner that's in tune with the fans that doesn't sit there telling you, please keep buying these shirts. Please keep paying for these corporate tickets. Please keep pumping your money into the football club while we don't pump money back. Please keep making us relevant and rich whilst paying for it yourself. And United are stagnant. We're stagnant at the moment. And I think Amrim hopefully is going to keep winning games and providing us with some solace, but I still don't look at that United side and go, it's going anywhere. Even if this team finishes fifth, there's no longevity in it.

22:49Harry Maguire, Luke Shaw, Mason Mount, Bruno Fernandes, Casemiro, they're not the future. You know they're not the future. Might be unfair to say that about Mason Mount. We can hope for miracles, but I mean, his body looks broken and can he play the football we need? Sacking a manager is what the Glazers used to escape judgment. And now with Sir Jim Radcliffe, we're doomed. How do we move forward? When will We fed up 16th, says Old Trafford. I think, look, I think the issue I have here is that when I hear that United know they need to strengthen, but they don't see January as an opportunity, I feel that sacked the board.

23:23I think that is a level of incompetence that should be screamed and shouted about. But you won't get it. The media are too, you know, it's too niche for them. They'd rather shout sack the manager. and fans have just become intolerant to the truth and we've started to swallow the shit. And that's why I bring in the wages because we're told that fifth place would be a miracle. We're told that we're going to suffer. We're told that it's a long road. And then I go, we've got two of the top five earners in the league, two of the top five earners in the league. We pay the fifth best wages in the league by a very long way and we're very close to the fourth team in Chelsea and we pay more on our midfield than anybody in the league apart from Man City.

24:10Our midfield, we pay more in wages than Chelsea do, Newcastle do, and any other midfield that shits all over ours apart from Man City. And yet we're being told we've got to suffer. It's going to take time. And you go, hold on, there's a contradiction here. There's a massive contradiction. You're saying we've got to suffer. You're saying it's going to take time. You're saying we've got to cut our cloth accordingly. and yet our midfield is the second best paid midfield in the league. We've got two of the top five best paid players in the league and we've got the fifth best wage bill in the league and yet fifth place is like the Holy Grail.

24:49Something doesn't add up here. Maybe, maybe you need to get rid of some of those wages and spend it or maybe you're talking shit to pull the blinkers on a fan base that needs to wake up. it's not acceptable to say that we're not buying players in January because we don't see the opportunity when other rivals have gone out there because there'll be somebody in the chat that goes yeah but what do you want them to do? They can't sign Anderson in January well how did Chelsea sign Enzo Fernandes in January? How did Manchester City take Mamouche from Eintracht Frankfurt in January when Eintracht Frankfurt were trying to win the Europa League why can't we do that to Stille and Stuttgart?

25:27You can do these deals because other clubs are doing them you can Patrick Lynch says unfortunately and that's the truth like people say you can't get Wharton out of Crystal Palace well Chelsea got Enzo Fernandes out of Benfica they didn't want to do that deal Mamouche Frankfurt they didn't want to do that deal you can do these deals you've just got to have the right ownership to do it who are focused on football and not bloody spreadsheets Patrick Lynch thanks for your super chat he says unfortunately other teams don't have the debt we have it's tying our hands and it will always be used as an excuse for not doing more.

26:02Glazers needed to go, but instead, Ineos propped them up. Yeah. And absolutely, Patrick, the debt should never be used by anybody as an excuse because the people who put us in debt are the people who own this football club and they are wholly responsible for that. It is not an excuse. So utilize the word debt. My thing is we're getting details on the lack of moves. Loose lips run the club. That's why club taxes the fuck out of us. They know all our moves. It says Law of the Dingle. Look, mate, my opinion of the media around Manchester United is their lapdogs. They're client journalists. They're not proper journalists.

26:37I can't remember the last time, and I'm talking years, I can't remember the last time I read an exclusive piece of news on Man United that Man United wouldn't want to be out there. That's journalism. You might not like it, but over the years, some of the best pieces of journalism are scoops that people don't want to be out there and they're well-researched and they're true. I can't remember the last time we had one article at a Man United that was a good piece of journalism. And yet the club, I know for a fact, and you know for a fact, has never been so bad. There are so many stories about Man United that could come out over the last 18 months.

27:17Even Ruben Amrim has alluded to them, but they never come out because the media around United are just lapdogs. They're client journalists. They don't dare say anything bad because they'll be cut off. So what they do is they use that media to feed stuff out like this. The Athletic, Laurie Whitwell saying, Man United probably won't spend in January because they're doing the drip drip effect work for them. Let's start putting it out there now. It's tough. It's a challenging market, etc. So, So, you know, it's...

27:51My opinion is we have to do something in January. My opinion is don't hold your breath. Now it's time for a little word from today's podcast sponsor. And as a preview, they have a great discount for you. It's been a long season so far. And after a year of grinding, you've earned a little something special for yourself. This upcoming festive season is all about taking a break, recharging and actually enjoying the things you want. and that's where Air Up comes in. Air Up lets you drink plain water that tastes full of flavour through scents alone. No sugar, no additives, just simple hydration made better.

28:27And for someone who spends as much time talking football as I do, it's been a great addition to the routine. If you want to try it for yourself, hit the link in the show notes or visit airup.link slash the United Stand and of course you can use the code GOLD and you get an amazing 10 % off at checkout. So what are you waiting for? Smash the link in the show notes or visit airup.link slash the United Stand and elevate your hydration game today. It's hard to love a club that doesn't love its fans back, says Alan Miller. I love that. I think that is my comment of the day from Alan. I absolutely love that.

29:04It's hard to love a club that doesn't love its fans back. But I disagree with the first bit because I'll never stop loving this football club. You know, all I need to do is get a DVD out and watch a Sir Alex Ferguson season from start to finish for two hours. And I'm loving it. Or, you know, read a book on the Busby Babes. That's what Manchester United is to me. Manchester United is not the Glazers. It's not these players. It's not even a manager. Manchester United, I will always love. But they don't love the fans. They don't. What is... Hi, Mark. What if the club is cash poor? If the club borrows to buy, we criticise the club for more debt.

29:39As a fan base, we have to decide between financial sustainability and erratic spending. Do you agree, says Ryle. No, I don't. No, I don't. And you can shove your accountancy, book up your arse. I don't agree with that. I don't have to do that at all. I don't have to make a decision between financial stability and erratic spending at all. No, I don't. I don't have to do that. Because why did Chelsea not do that. Chelsea had debt. I don't have to make that decision. I have to make a decision about what I think is best for my football club. And I don't think the Glazers are. So I don't have to make that decision because you're making me comply with an ownership model that's got nothing to do with me.

30:19I didn't choose the Glazers to put my football club in debt, their debt. I didn't choose for my football club to spend tens of millions of pounds a year serviting debt interest. What cripples this football club is the Glazers. But also I would say, Ryle as well, why is the club cash poor then? Because we had£60 million to pay for Belaber that we didn't use. Where's that£60 million gone now then? Has it disappeared? It's still there. That was there three weeks before the transfer window closed and we didn't buy anybody. So we know there is a capability to spend£60 million. And we also know that we turned down£90 million for Bruno Fernandes.

31:01so the cash rich bollocks which I'm sure is going to come out in the next few weeks is bollocks we've had opportunities to raise money that would buy quality players and we've decided not to do it what does it take to get the Glazers out of the clubs says Liam a miracle we need a non-bias Ariel for a football journalist says Ryan I mean we also signed Bruno in January as well says Raz yeah and he's our best signing since Sir Alex since Sir Alex Ferguson retired Garfield says if you were manager Mark what would you be doing in January well I know what I'd do in January I'd be buying the best midfielder I can get and I need two anyway so if it's absolutely impossible to get Elliot Anderson, Adam Wharton, Carlos Baleba or Angelo Stiller and I don't think it is I don't think it's impossible it might be difficult but I don't think it's impossible then I then would be looking at somebody like Edison or a Conor Gallagher or a Manu Kone because there are options Nobody can tell me out of seven options you can't get any of them because you can.

32:06Everybody's got a price. And as I said to you last night, we don't know the complexities of the situation at Nottingham Forest, Crystal Palace, Atalanta. We don't know what their personal situations are. They can put it out there that they want 100 million. However, it might be a very different story. There could be release clauses. There could be all sorts of stuff that makes them decide. And you know what? What if Forrest already have a replacement for Elliot Anderson that they can get in January as well? So a lot of the time, United use difficult as a reason not to do something. We tend to just do easy and what we want, whereas difficult is why big clubs succeed.

32:53difficult deals are what separate you from the rest. And I look at United over the last sort of 10 years, how many difficult deals have we done? I think Lenny Yorreau was a difficult deal. I'm not going to pretend we haven't done any. I thought Lenny Yorreau was a very difficult deal because it looked like he was going to go to Real Madrid. We spent the money. We got the player. Well done. But the more deals like that you do, the better you get as a football club. And we need to do difficult deals. And it looks to me at the moment we're going, I don't really want to do any business in January because the spreadsheet's not quite right.

33:30We'll wait until the summer and then the difficult deals will be there and we won't get them done. I don't think we'll get Elliot Anderson. I don't think we've got a bloody chance. I honestly do not think we'll get Elliot Anderson. Football is transitional. Owners, managers, players, stadiums, success, even, come and go. The only constant is the fans. You'd hope the club realise that, says Sam. Yeah, but the thing is, Sam, if you buy a business and you treat it as a business and you know in five years time that business is going to be worth double what you paid for it now. Do you need to be emotionally invested?

34:05Do you really need to care about the customers? Man United. I mean, somebody said to me about six months ago, people say, why did Ineos get into bed with the Glazers? They've paid one point something billion for something that in five years is going to be worth double simply because a stadium is going to get built. In a business sense, it's the easiest money you can earn because United are going to go from five billion to ten billion overnight as soon as that stadium gets built. So that's why they got into bed with the Glazers. A lifelong Man United fan would never get into bed with the Glazers.

34:45But a lifelong Man United fan that loves business. That's what that was always, always going to be about. Until we get proved wrong. That's what that always is going to be about. Right. Let me carry on anyway, because a few bits to get into this morning. Thank you very much for that. OK, where are we? Where are we? Where are we? Where are we? Remember, it's a 6.45 show tonight. Loads of you tuned in last night because we've got the Premier League. obviously Man United playing tomorrow I think there is a um I think there is a press conference this afternoon as well correct me if I'm wrong I haven't heard 100 % but I presume we're going to do a press conference it's a Premier League game so I think we will be doing one um Luke Shaw's 300th game for Manchester United comes amid good form and health I mean this this you know what i'm gonna play devil's advocate here right i have to man united are so easy to read like yesterday there were two tweets of compilations of luke shaw there was two last week as well it's like they're ramming it down our throat it's like somebody works at man united and says, you know, with Luke Shaw, we're clearly going to have him for a few years.

36:01He costs us a lot of money and the fan base, I'd say 50 % of them don't really like him. We need to get that. We need to change that. We need more tweets of positivity around Luke Shaw because it's just being rammed down our throat at the moment, right? So Manchester United signed Luke Shaw in 2014, June 2014. So 11 and a half years ago, we signed Luke Shaw. And he's played 300 games, right? And United have given him a placard of 300 games, right? In 11 and a half years. Somebody please do the maths, because that's definitely less than 30 games a season.

36:54oh but he had a bad injury mark yeah maybe we should have got rid of him then you know 11 and a half years 300 games and they're they're putting it out there like it's some massive achievement just do the maths 27 games a season I mean for a club like Man United that's you'd expect to be playing 50 games a season so 300 games in an 11 in 11 and a half years and United are out there going, oh yeah, 300 games. And then this from Andy Mitten, Manchester United consider Luke Shaw a top player who understands the game and is very difficult to beat in 1v1 situations. Look, I get it. This is the purpose of communities like this and I think some people don't understand it.

37:42I've read United fan forums for years. Some of them are very, very, very, very confrontational and I like that. Some of them are very tame. The United stand is a community for all and we're never going to skirt around difficult conversations. But United, for some reason at the moment, are desperate to push a positive Luke Shaw story every opportunity they can. and it's strange. I find it strange because whilst he is a good player when he's fit, he's nearly 30 now and I just don't think that's going to continue and I'm a bit worried that it's almost like while he's playing and while he's doing well, let's spin every positive we can because we know at some point he's going to go back to being injured and we're going to be stuck with him.

38:38That's my take on it. Um, but he did play well at the weekend and I had a big chat with Ricky the other night and, um, he absolutely loves him. So it's not anti Luke Shaw. I'm anti Luke Shaw, but Ricky isn't. And a lot of people on the channel aren't, and a lot of you are, but I'm anti Luke Shaw. And you know what? Sometimes life is simple as explaining it. I used to back Luke Shaw. I used to like Luke Shaw. I got accused of being a racist for liking Luke Shaw, which I'll never understand, but there we go. But effectively, the reason I've gone off Luke Shaw is because of the TikTok on New Year's.

39:15No, it's not. The reason I went off Luke Shaw is because he was injured for six months. He wasn't fit. He went to the World Cup. He went to the Euros. He wasn't fit. He played in the final and then he was injured for another six months. And I don't like players that prioritise country over Manchester United. And it's as simple as that. And he did it. And he did that, I went, right, okay, I've invested a lot in you and you basically went England are more important. So you know what? If you play for Man United and you play well, I'll give you a good score, but I ain't investing any more time in you being part of our future.

39:49I think you're a stopgap, simple as that. What happens to Bruno if we get two midfielders over the next two windows, says Michael? Well, one of the midfielders sits on the bench and one of them starts and Bruno starts every week probably uh bruno has 304 appearances and he joined in 2020 says patrick lynch so bruno's played 304 times in five and a half years and luke shaw's played 300 times in 11 and a half years well done patrick um if if inios don't know we need to invest to succeed then that's an issue inios sold their soul to the devil and inios have no control like they say says Ray. Tech says you missed my super chat.

40:29I'll go back from that, Tech. We need a... I mean we also signed that. Garfield, Old Trafford, Malik, did we read that? Thank you very much. Man United need a board like Barcelona and Madrid. Well, Barcelona and Real Madrid, aren't they a little bit like democracy, memberships, things like that? So, you know, I think that's it. Tech Empire says might be off Top topic. All the managers that came post Sir Alex Ferguson never did slash wanted reset bar Jose. Ten Hag, Oli, Ruben ignored it. Certain players always got away, says Tech. I don't think now's the time to analyse that, but I think it's interesting what Ahmad said about how last year the dressing room was really toxic.

41:18I don't think that was the word, but something like that. And this year it's a lot better. And it got me thinking, well Amrim was the manager last year was he talking about before Amrim came in he can't be because Amrim came in November and we were shit so what is it that changed the dressing room from toxic or you know not very good to positive this year even though the manager's the same is it simply a pre-season is it the changing of a few players um it's hard to tell is it in Burmo you know I don't know I thought I thought it was quite an interesting topic because we haven't changed the manager.

41:52And we haven't changed a lot of the key leadership team either. But going back to what you were saying there, Tech Empire, I think there's a theme in what Man United would like to recruit. And I think you've identified it there. Sir Alex Ferguson would clear a player out, no problem, because he had the authority and aura to do it. Jose Mourinho had the aura and authority to do it. Eric Ten Hag, Ole Gunnar Solskjaer, Ruben Amirim, they're all what I call debtors. They're all good managers who would be in debt for being given the opportunity at Manchester United. They're in awe of it. So is that the right type of manager profile for Man United?

42:38It's certainly the type of profile manager that the Glazers want because they're manipulated, but a big personality manager is what man united need we we need um an ancelotti we need a klopp you know dare i even say a conte you need somebody that comes in and isn't in awe of manchester united in the sense of you know i know what i'm doing i know what needs doing and this is what needs to happen whereas you know ruben amram still a very young manager oligone solskjaer was a young manager eric ten haag was still an inexperienced manager because he only managed Ajax. So we do like to bring in a manager that can be sort of in debt to the club that, oh, what an opportunity we've given you.

43:21That's why you're not getting a midfielder. My thing is, why are we getting details on the lack of moves? Have I done that? Law of the... I think I did do that. Yeah, I did do that. Thank you very much. Okay. if only Shaw and Mount had Bruno's fitness record says Carlo well look hopefully both of them are going to play tomorrow which means they're going to play two games in four days and then we've got another one in three days so look hopefully they're going to keep playing you know that's the only way to defy those conversations isn't it if we qualify for European football next year says George how many more players do you think we would need at the moment the positions that we need to strengthen wouldn't be enough two midfielders wouldn't be enough says George if we were in Europe I think we'd be mid-table this season.

44:07I think we'd be in big trouble. If you think about how many games Newcastle have played this year, what are we on, game week six next week of the Champions League? So that's another five, six games. I think we'd be in big trouble with that, really big trouble. I think we'd have a lot more injuries. I saw somebody yesterday, it was on That's Football actually no it was on Terry's channel and they were trying to they were constantly spamming and they were going Mark said in the summer that this new fitness regime that Amarim had been implemented was a load of bollocks it's not bollocks now is it and I was like it's Terry's channel who never brought it up so I'll bring it up here it's not a load of bollocks a lot of people seem to think that Reuben Amarim gave them all a bloody powerpoint on how to stay fit and now everybody's staying fit.

45:02Absolutely bollocks. It is bollocks because we have had loads of injuries. Harry Maguire's had two. Cunha has been injured. Sesco's injured. We've had injuries. They're just not the players you would expect, like Mount. Mount's had two injuries, actually. He has had two injuries already this season. Luke Shaw's not been injured. Casemiro's not been injured. So we have still had injuries, but also, as Savage says, we're playing one game a week. I mean, there has to be an expectation that you're going to lower your injuries when you're lowering your load by 50%. So I think that we have had injuries.

45:40We've still picked up injuries. And if we were playing in Europe, I think we'd be really struggling. I don't think we're set up for Europe. The hilarious thing is, and I'll go back to this again, right? We pay£3.1 million a week in wages, which is basically what Chelsea pay. But they're in Europe. Tottenham pay£2.5 million a week in wages,£600 ,000 less than us. They're in Europe. Newcastle pay£2.2 million a week in wages,£900 ,000 a week less than us. and they're in Europe. So we're paying a lot of money for a squad that's not even in Europe. We're definitely paying European wages, but that squad's not ready for Europe at all.

46:31I mean, we don't need to worry about it now because we might not be in Europe, but we are not prepared for Europe at all. So I think you make a great point, George. And this is why we go back to January again. Are you telling me that if we get into Europe, we're going to buy eight players so that we're ready for Europe? We're not going to buy eight players. And this is why January is so important as well. And this is why the Glazers and Ineos are full of shit, because to say January is not an opportunity, they want Europe. If we're in Europe next year, we need seven, eight players because we are not ready for it.

47:04You're not going to buy seven or eight players in the summer. So we're going to be short and then Amrim is going to suffer. And then it's going to be Amrim out again. I can see United getting fifth place this year and next year as sacking Amarim because he struggles under the weight of a squad that's not able to do Europe. I can really see next season being more challenging than this year. I can see this season being quite positive. I can see fifth place. But next year, I think we're going to struggle. And that's why January is important because that's what Man City did. Man City brought two or three players in last January preparing for this season.

47:42And then in the summer, they brought in another three or four. So overall, they brought in six or seven players, didn't they? That's what United should be doing. We should be looking at what Man City did and going, if we can get two or three players in January, and then another three or four in the summer, in a World Cup summer, that gives us six or seven players to go into next season and be prepared. And football is about the now, but it's also about future planning. And I mean, people talk about Casemiro going Harry Maguire going Bruno Fernandes going that's three players you need to replace plus another three that we need we're not signing six players in one summer in a World Cup year so why aren't we utilising January it's very obvious Kai says considering the Gibbs White situation Anderson deal is almost impossible in January says Kai and if only I've done that one from Carlo we're run by orthodox tight-arse words by Delboy says Simon Prem teams rarely starters sell in January, says Kay.

48:44Yeah, but mate, this is what I'm talking about. You're almost swallowing the Glazer bullshit book. There are players that can be bought in January because people have been doing it for the last three years. And what you're basically saying is, well, it's too difficult, so let's don't do it. Let's take your theory, right? You can't get Anderson in January. Well, you can't get him in the summer. so maybe you go for the alternative in January that could be Angelo Stiller it could be Manu Kone it could, you know I don't we need players in January as I said to you yesterday I think this is the best analogy of all time the roof is leaking the builder we want isn't available till the summer and he might not be available then anyway but there is a builder that will come and fix that leak now do you wait till the summer for the builder that might not be available or do you get the leak fixed now it's the winter It's going to rain a lot.

49:37Fix the fucking leak, you know. Against the current bottom half teams, we have a 20 % win ratio. Against the current top half teams, it's 62.5. Why are we not beating the easier teams, says Tara. come back to me in three games time because i think that's about to change i'm not allowed to predict but i think it is about to change um elliot anderson looks like the primary focus at the moment but you've got to also look at adam wharton who's uh a different type of midfielder says laurie whitwell there well we're talking about the summer again aren't we let's kick it down the road and then in the summer they'll go somewhere else and we'll end up with a player that we could have got in january uh marcus rashford what do you think about that Mark, I was quite surprised by that story yesterday.

50:21And I was watching the show with Terry and I was like, so a report in Barcelona is that the most likely outcome is that they are going to send him back, even though he's done quite well. I have a different opinion on this. Look, we can't just take news reports as read. Otherwise, what are we as a community? We're here to question we're here to debate um i my personal take on the the rashford thing gav says is he homesick i don't think he's homesick i think it might just be bartering early bartering from barcelona i mean they're a football club that doesn't piss about and doesn't get taken for a ride and i think that essentially um they are he is doing well there he's a massive brand player, which helps Barcelona.

51:16If you've got a good player and they're a brand, happy days. So that's what they've got with Rashford. He's cheap. He probably would take a bit of a wage reduction as well. So why would they not want to do that deal? Maybe because they want to get the price down even lower. So I don't see Barcelona wanting to send him back unless they've got somebody better lined up um but i don't buy into it i think rashford's got a really good opportunity of going to barcelona and if he doesn't go to barcelona i still think that the bayern munich's the psgs of this world would look at it and go in our league he would do quite well i don't think there'd be many premier league clubs looking at him i don't think they would because i think in the Premier League it's very you know looking at Rashford over the last three years I think he struggles a bit in the Premier League but I think in in the European scene we saw it last year with Ten Hag he was brilliant in Portugal in that first half so I think he suits the European scene and I think there'd be a lot of clubs interested in him so I'm quite relaxed about it really I mean look there's always the scenario that Amrim gets sacked we go back to a 4-3-3 and he's starting for United next season I don't think that's good for anybody by the way but you never know so I'm very relaxed about the Rashford situation but I think I think Barcelona is still a very likely outcome to be honest when was the last time we bought a premiership player in January says average well I think it was a fair point what somebody said before it's difficult to get premier league players in january but do we need does every player we need to buy do they have to be a premier league player um i don't think they do i really don't think they do i think there's some good options out there connor gallagher's a premier league player playing in the liga as well so it doesn't always have to be like that um so yeah i think it's um the reality is we have to do something in the january transfer window and it feels a little bit like, and I want to say this again, I do feel sorry for the manager because he didn't get a midfielder in the summer.

53:36That's on the ownership. And they're now putting stuff out there that they might not do anything in January and he might need to sell to buy. And that's not how a Man United manager should be working. Not in the first formulative months of your career. You need support. like this is where you borrow money this is where you find the money you don't bring a manager in who's under huge pressure to succeed and then go we're going to make your job harder by not supporting you i mean he's basically using ten hogs midfield well there's no basically about it he's using a midfield that failed ten hog that is what amram has not been given one midfield signing the most important area in a football team and they've given him no midfielders they're basically saying work a miracle with 10 hogs midfield that got him sacked that's incredible to me that is absolutely incredible to me and then they're saying you need to sell to buy um if that's the state of manchester united then this ownership should not be in charge you know it's not going to make it work is it in my opinion um okay we um we'll leave it there because i'm desperate for a coffee although i've got my hair up

54:50thank you very much um chapman you blocked see you later um an honor is coming back no he's not i would take rafinha as a swap for rashford says john um just like the first time if you take did it take shots you won't score says vincent and would you take rashford back says jayden no no i don't think we should be going back um It doesn't mean it won't happen, but I don't think we should be going back. I think there's too many people who've given up on Rashford in a Man United shirt. And I think he's said too many things that would sort of make it difficult for him to come back and pretend that, you know, everything is good.

55:29I think I think it's time to move on. Yeah, I think it's time to move on. And also, we shouldn't be taking steps back. We need to take steps forward. Gomez or Gallagher would not get any minutes anyway, says Melch. well they would if they're players that Amarin want if you bring players in that Amarin wants then they will get picked certainly okay thanks everyone for watching stay safe take care and I'll speak to you all on the next one I'm live with you at 6 45 and we have got a press conference reaction I'm told as well at about half past one so lots to get involved in and it's Premier League night on that's football at half seven can you see my stiller super chats as Raphael let me just quickly check that for you sometime no i've got it i look at vert and his adaption to the league stiller should be done in january if we go that way while we have casemiro avoid the flop talk with uh time i think this is a great comment i really do um we did it with everett and vidic ourselves we brought them in in january um liverpool did it with gacpo chelsea did it with Enzo.

56:34Liverpool did it with Gakpo. Man City did it with Mamouche and Ganchalves. It really helps to bring them in in January because there's less expectation on a player that comes in January. It's almost psychologically fans go, well, it's the middle of the season. It's difficult to come in in the middle of the season. And you get that extra six months that they don't get when they come in the summer. It should be the same, but people don't get the patience in the summer as a new signing. While they've had a pre-season, they should be good. You bring them in in January, they get six months to adjust and then they hit the ground running in the next season.

57:09It's an intelligent time to buy as well. Very good comment, Raphael. Take care, everyone. Stay safe. I'll speak to you on the next one.

57:20Here's golf legend John Daly. Hell yeah, these wins are piling up faster than my divorces. I only spent on Moto, America's social casino. You know I've won a couple of majors. And on Moto, I've won majors, grands and epic jackpots on their classic Vegas slots with huge, huge bonus rounds. Moto Casino adds new games and awards players free coins every single day. Grip it and spend it on Moto Casino. Download the Moto Casino app today. Moto Casino is a social casino. We're prohibited. No purchase necessary. Visit Moto.us for more details. Moto Casino. America's social casino. This is the story of the one.

57:54The one who keeps multiple buildings running smoothly day after day. Plumbing that flows. HVAC that hums. cleaning supplies that keep surfaces sparkling. That's why she counts on Grainger. With easy reordering online and 24-7 support, Grainger helps her keep the product she needs on hand. So shelves stay stocked and buildings stay ready. Call 1-800-GRAINGER, click grainger.com, or just stop by. Grainger, for the ones who get it done. Treat Dad this Father's Day with great gifts from an art. From levels, nailers, and drills to complete any project to tool chests, recliners, and grills. We've got the perfect gifts to make this Father's Day one to remember.

58:36Stop by your local Menards today and save big money on gifts for Dad. Plus, check out our weekly flyer on Menards.com for all the great deals happening now. Save big money at Menards.

From the publisher
Treat yourself or those around you and get 10% off your airup bottle today with the code GOLD - http://airup.link/theunitedstand #AD

Mark Goldbridge has the latest Man Utd Transfer News as INEOS look to ignore the January transfer window and force Amorim to sell to buy. Plus why are United so intent on spreading the message of not being good enough when they pay more for players than most of their rivals? Get the latest Man Utd Transfer News on The United Stand. 

More from The United Stand

All episodes