1. Podcasts
  2. The United Stand
  3. 366: Bruno EXIT Fear! INEOS Biggest MISTAKE!
The United Stand

5 Apr 2026 · 46m · 15 chapters

Episode artwork

366: Bruno EXIT Fear! INEOS Biggest MISTAKE!

In short

Manchester United fan commentary on (1) INEOS/ownership “biggest mistake” of ignoring the January transfer window, (2) why Man United may struggle next season due to squad depth, injuries, and financial rules, and (3) Bruno Fernandes’ future amid a rumored exit and a possible recommendation of Matias Fernandes from West Ham.

Guest backgrounds

No named guests appear; the episode is a solo host (Mark Goldbridge) with audience/superchat comments.

Key claims

United need “volume” (about 8 signings) and should have acted in January like Man City; four/six signings won’t be enough for Europe + cups. Bruno has a £55m release clause, is feared to be leaving for PSG/Bayern/Real, and United must provide a “platform” to keep him. United should not celebrate wage savings without reinvesting.

Notable examples

Man City spending in January (and finishing strongly); Arsenal losing to Southampton in the FA Cup; comparisons to Newcastle/Liverpool/Chelsea “running on empty”; Rashford linked to Barcelona; Matias Fernandes stats vs Tonali/Anderson/Casemiro/Balaba.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

0:36

Manchester United's Transfer Dilemma

Discussion on the challenges facing Manchester United, focusing on transfer strategies and the need for new signings.

“Bruno makes a demand on a player that might make him stay.”
2:42

The Impact of January Transfers

Analysis of the importance of making strategic transfers during the January window and the consequences of ignoring it.

“Because looking at Arsenal last night, losing to Southampton in the quarterfinal of the FA Cup, very happy about it because it means no treble.”
6:16

Financial Fair Play Challenges

Exploration of the financial fair play rules and their implications for clubs like Manchester United.

“I can already envision the future of next March where we're in a reasonably good position.”
9:08

Bruno Fernandes Transfer Rumors

Discussion on Bruno Fernandes's potential exit, his release clause, and his value to Manchester United.

“But look, let me get into some of the main stuff I wanted to talk about this morning.”
14:00

Bruno Fernandes' Future with Manchester United

Explore the implications of Bruno Fernandes' age and performance on his future at United.

“Because I have a fear, and I think United have that fear now, that 55 million pounds for Bruno Fernandes, although he's going to be 31 or 32, I think he's going to be 32 soon, it might, might, might put people off.”
16:44

Debate on Bruno's Legacy and Potential Transfers

Discuss the likelihood of Bruno Fernandes winning titles and the impact on his career.

“because of the era he played in and that's probably a fair argument there is also this debate that he will retire as a player that didn't win anywhere near as much as he should have done.”
17:59

United's Strategy to Retain Key Players

Analyze Manchester United's need to support players like Bruno Fernandes to keep them.

“So even the 55 million might be negotiable.”
19:50

Critique of Player Breaks and Club Decisions

Discuss the scrutiny of players' off-time and how it reflects on club decisions.

“But you can't just be sat there going, we're going to get one decent midfielder in, a kid in the midfield and a couple of other backups.”
22:59

Rumors and Future Moves for Rashford and Others

Examine the future of Marcus Rashford and potential transfers affecting the team.

“I think the club are walking into a silly trap, but that's up to themselves.”
24:58

Analysis of Matias Fernandes as a Transfer Target

Evaluate Matias Fernandes and the importance of suitable signings for the team.

“This is a story coming out this morning.”
Show all 15 chapters
28:00

Analyzing Player Performance Metrics

A deep dive into the statistical performance of various football players, comparing their defensive and attacking outputs.

“Tonali 25, Anderson 23, Casemiro 34, Balaba 22.”
31:33

Concerns About Squad Depth and Injuries

Discussion on the squad's physicality, injury concerns, and the need for more midfielders in light of potential departures.

“Again, this is the incredible naivety of only signing two midfielders.”
39:58

Future Challenges for Manchester United

Explores the challenges Manchester United will face with squad changes and the need for effective management moving forward.

“Right here, right now, this squad next season capitulates.”
42:10

Preparing for Player Departures

Discussing the implications of player sales and necessary squad changes for Manchester United.

“We have to prepare for the inevitability of what is to come.”
47:02

Preparing for Player Departures

Discussing the implications of player sales and necessary squad changes for Manchester United.

“It's Bluff here and you know what's more American than America's 250th birthday?”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On The United Stand, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00Hey everybody, Lady Luck here, and we're celebrating America's 250th birthday. Now all summer long, I'm going to be celebrating by playing on SpinQuest.com, which is an American-owned social casino. It obviously features over a thousand slot games and live blackjack, live craps, live bubble craps. Head on over to SpinQuest.com. Get yourself a$30 coin pack for just$10. SpinQuest is a free-to-play social casino. Void where prohibited. Visit SpinQuest.com for more details. Hello everybody, good morning and welcome to the United Stands. I'm Mark Goldbridge and this is your latest Manchester United news as United face uncertainty around Bruno Fernandes again.

0:41Bruno makes a demand on a player that might make him stay. Also Sir Jim Radcliffe is looking to raise£100 million in sales this summer. Is that realistic? And I want to start off with Ineos' biggest mistake which has been exposed again. Happy Easter to everybody who is celebrating it. But look, Arsenal got knocked out last night in the FA Cup. There's a bit of a meltdown. I've just about, I just recorded a video on that's football. It'll go out after this. But you know what? This exposes Man United's biggest issue. And I am so tired of this fan base arguing over irrelevant points between each other instead of actually looking at what is happening at the football club on a regular basis.

1:24So you'll get, you know, you're not a real fan if you don't want Carrick. Oh, if you want to sell Bruno, you're not a real fan. You know, all this, you know, top red nonsense about what makes you a real fan. And nobody actually ever discusses the big things like knocking Old Trafford down, you lot paying your increased ticket prices to help the bloody debt. But the biggest thing that probably resonates in relation to football is United's continued ignorance of the January transfer window. And it has been exposed again in what happened last night with Arsenal. And it is something that some intelligent people in our fan base are starting to figure out very, very quickly that this summer transfer window is not going to be sufficient.

2:05You've got people like Rio Fairyland saying stuff like four transfers will be realistic. Four transfers won't touch the sides, mate. I'd challenge Rio and say, how are four transfers going to make us get back into the Premier League's top five next season and compete in the Champions League. It's not going to work. It's just not going to work, mate. It really isn't going to work. We need about eight signings to give ourselves a fair chance of competing on all levels next season. Otherwise, this time next year, we're going to find ourselves somewhere around where Newcastle are very, very, very, very quickly.

2:42Because looking at Arsenal last night, losing to Southampton in the quarterfinal of the FA Cup, very happy about it because it means no treble. So we maintain that. But the big thing for me is this just shows how stupid, I underline the word stupid, this football club is to continually ignore the January transfer window. And I'll tell you why. Arsenal have a very good squad, but they're running on empty in April. Liverpool and Chelsea have been running on empty for weeks. Newcastle have been running on empty for weeks. There's only one club that's actually not running on empty, and that's Manchester City.

3:20Now, what did Manchester City do last season to end the season well? Oh, they went and bought three or four players in January, didn't they? And what have Man City gone and done to end the season well again? Oh, they went and spent over£100 million on two top class players, didn't they? There is a running theme here that people criticise Man City and their 1-1-5 charges. But, you know, the irony is for all that money that they spend that apparently they're not allowed to spend, they're the only club in the modern game that can actually end the season well. They're the only club that actually goes and spends money in January every season now.

3:57And they're the only club that actually looks like they've got momentum when it hits April. And isn't that such an irony to the Premier League and their rules that they don't want clubs to spend beyond their means, but the one that apparently has is the only one that actually makes a fist of it in the last few weeks of the season because they've actually got a squad. Even Arsenal, which has an incredible squad, they're running on empty because it's a long, hard season. So, look, you can moan about who the manager can be. You can moan about who the midfield is going to be. And they're very, very relevant points.

4:28But this football club has and will continue to make extraordinarily stupid mistakes because it will not look at the January transfer window in the way that we're going to need to. Or the summer transfer window. It's never about volume. It's never about quantity. It's always about the Excel spreadsheet. And we didn't necessarily need to spend this January. I'll take that on board, but we should have done. We should have done. And, you know, somebody in the chat said we didn't need anyone. Look, we're third in the league. It was never about that. If we'd have bought a midfielder or a winger or a left back in January, you don't need to buy them in the summer.

5:10You actually make your life better. You bring a player in in January who gets used to the team and then you don't have to do that deal in the summer, which gives you more time to do other deals. And we ignore it every year. And I'm telling you now, look, Man City are not in the Champions League because Real Madrid were better than them. That's fair enough. But when you look at Manchester City in the Cups and in the Premier League at the moment, they're the only team that looks revved up, motivated and like they're going to finish the season strong. Arsenal, Liverpool, Chelsea, they're all they're all struggling.

5:41Even Arsenal with that squad, they're starting to struggle. So what we have to do this summer transfer window is get volume as well as quality in. And, you know, I just I don't know why this isn't, you know, numero one when it comes to United conversation in our fan base, because we've moan about the wrong things. And the reality is we have an ownership that refuses to use one of the two transfer windows that we get every year and refuses to acknowledge that they need volume and not just quantity. And if we do not buy more than six players this summer, I think we are going to struggle massively next year.

6:19I can already envision the future of next March where we're in a reasonably good position. But you've got whoever the manager is coming out saying this player's out, this player's out, this player's tired, this player's out, this player's out. I think it's going to be a massive, massive issue. EJ says, do you think the season's too long? I genuinely cannot believe I'm going to say this, but I've thought it for a few weeks. I actually think that what Man City are getting charged with actually is probably wrong in the modern game. What they did 10 years ago, and let's not forget, they did it between 2008 and 2018.

6:54So those charges are relevant. But in 2026, I actually think most teams, if they want to be successful in all the competitions they've got to enter, you need a squad of 20 good players, like 20 good players you need now. And to carry that, you need money. And these financial fair play bollocks and PSR is just a load of rubbish. They're trying to make a fair level playing field. But if you're Brentford and you're Manchester City, Manchester City could be playing another 20 games more than you. You're going to need more money. You're going to need more of a budget. I mean, look, I've not changed the game.

7:35You've not changed the game. The reality is the Champions League is heading towards 15 to 20 games more a season if you're successful. And yet the Premier League again, well, you've got to be fair. We don't want your budgets running away too far from Burnley. Well, hold on a minute. I'm playing nearly 20 games extra and I can't carry that squad. I can't carry Burnley's squad. I need two first teams. And to do that, I need massive money. And then you're restricting me on what I can spend. So I'm not making excuses yet at United Red Devil 7 because you're a bit of a moron, to be honest, because you didn't listen to what I said.

8:13What Man City did between 2008 and 2018 is what they're actually being investigated for. And if you're not intelligent enough to actually know what they're being investigated for, that's fine. But I did say that. But eight years on from that investigation period in 2026, tell me you don't need two teams now to be successful in all the tournaments you have to enter. and then the Premier League and FIFA and UEFA have got these limitations on what you can spend, yet they want you to play more and more games. Something's got to give. You cannot compete in the Premier League and the Champions League under the current financial rules because they're too limiting.

8:51But what they're doing is they're going, well, we don't want you to run away from Brentford and Everton. Why are you giving us so many more games than them then? Like, you need a big squad these days, not just a good first XI. and United are going to find that out big time next season if we don't put our hand in our pocket and start spending money. But look, let me get into some of the main stuff I wanted to talk about this morning. I suppose that's just, you are a moron, United Red Devil. You are a moron. You didn't listen and you don't understand. So you are a moron, I'm sorry. Brett Dowell, thanks for being a member for 41 months.

9:25Appreciate you. United is the most short-term, long-term project I've ever seen, says Emily Derry. They are unable to truly think strategically because they can't or don't see the forest from the trees. Well, Emily, look, I don't know whether the ownership are just thick or manipulative, but they certainly do not have a clue when it comes to how to making this football club successful at all. And that's the sort of comment we want, United's Red Devil. the sort of stuff you get from Emily which is absolutely spot on I'm excited about the summer I'm excited to see what we're going to do with the manager situation but they are short term views the long term is there staring us in the face look at Liverpool look at Chelsea look at Arsenal last night look at Newcastle varying levels of teams that are running out of juice at the most important stage of the season and look at Man City spend in January for the second year in a row and for the second year in a row, they're finishing the season stronger than everybody else.

10:31I know they got knocked out of the Champions League, but they've just won the Carabao Cup. They're going to win the FA Cup and they're going to push Arsenal for the league because they've got momentum, energy, because they spent in January and everybody who didn't is now struggling. And that is abundantly clear. And if you want to defend the Glazers and Ineos this morning because you think that not spending in January is not moronic, then that's up to you. But I'm going to stick with the word moron. If you don't think that we need to buy players more than we are and you don't think we need to spend money in January, I think that's the definition of a moron.

11:06Sorry, but sometimes you've got to say what you think and that's what this community should be about. Instead of Carrick, we should go for Fabregas since Ineos are not looking for world class, says Aiken. But look, you know what? Let me start off. Well, not start off. Let me move on. Bruno Fernandes. Now, apparently, Bruno Fernandes wants Manchester United to sign another Fernandes from West Ham. We'll talk about him in a moment. But more and more, the rumour mill is turning around a Bruno Fernandes exit from Manchester United. So where are we at with that this morning? Well, it's interesting.

11:42I was looking at a poll yesterday. I forget where it was. It was online. It was some, I don't know, let's pretend it was like some mainstream outlet. And it was, but it was who should win player of the year. And Bruno Fernandes won by a long way on percentage. I don't know who else wins player of the year other than Declan Rice. And he might get it because Arsenal might win the league, but Arsenal are wobbling at the moment. I think Bruno Fernandes is in the ascendancy. He's just won Premier League player of the month. He's up for player of the year. He's had a fantastic season. He has a release clause of£55 million.

12:22He will not make a decision on his future until after the World Cup, which is mid-July. And there are now rumours that big European clubs might take a punt on him at that price. United are in a bit of a difficult situation now because Bruno Fernandes is not just this niche Man United player that does brilliant for us and no one else has realised it. Bruno Fernandes is now probably the best number 10 in Europe. name a better one he probably is the best number 10 in Europe and his numbers and output are incredible but also his availability as well and he's not a player that is dependent on pace so you could look at Bruno Fernandes if you're PSG or Bayern Munich or even Real Madrid and go he will give us three maybe four really good seasons at the highest level in the Champions League and our domestic league and his release clause is 55 million pounds.

13:20In the modern game, I fear, and I think United are starting to fear, it's not just Saudi now. This could well be a problem. And I don't know why Man United stuck a bloody release clause in it anyway. I mean, you know, talk about morons. I still do not know why we gave him a pay rise from 250 grand a week to 300 grand a week and also stuck a release clause in there. Considering his previous contract did not run out for another two years on 250 grand a week and didn't have a release clause in it, why did we give him a pay rise and a bloody release clause? I just do not know what that's all about.

14:02Because I have a fear, and I think United have that fear now, that 55 million pounds for Bruno Fernandes, although he's going to be 31 or 32, I think he's going to be 32 soon, it might, might, might put people off. But you look at people like Modric, who are still playing at a high level in their late 30s. Bruno Fernandes, okay, he's going to be 32 in September, but I still think you can get three decent seasons out of him. And I say decent, I'm talking like top level. And, you know,£55 million for a PSG is not that much. And he wouldn't be playing as much because he'd be playing in a bloody domestic league that's not the same as the Prem.

14:47It's a problem. It's a problem. And it's one that United fear. I mean, United fear the Saudis, but I'm not convinced Bruno wants to go to Saudi. But if these rumours start, he's such... I don't think people realise that Bruno Fernandes could well be in the top five players in Europe at the moment. and people are going to laugh at that but status wise he might well be in the top five players in the Premier League in the world at the moment because obviously on ability you're going to talk about people like Jamal and Vinicius Junior but the numbers he's putting in I just think that a club can just come in and do it and I don't think Bayern Munich will do it I don't think Bayern Munich could spend that amount of money on wages.

15:36And I don't think they'd spend that much on the transfer fee either. But it's a risk. It's a risk for United. And we cannot afford to lose Bruno Fernandes. I know some people think that we have got to at some point, but we can't afford for this to happen. And also going into a World Cup as well, does that put him on a platform where people will look at him even more. I think the most important thing with Bruno, and I've said it before, is it just depends what he wants. Now, if he wants to finish his... Look. Hanging out at the pool is great. Relaxing and playing Vegas-style games on my phone at the same time.

16:19Drinking one hand and a blackjack in the other. It's all at SpinQuest. Over a thousand and games including your favorite slots and table games be cool with this summer special new players get 30 coin packs for 10 at spinquest.com spinquest is a free-to-play social casino void where prohibited visit spinquest.com for more details there is this debate around bruno fernandez at manchester united that he will never go down on the level he should go down because of the era he played in and that's probably a fair argument there is also this debate that he will retire as a player that didn't win anywhere near as much as he should have done.

16:59And if he's aware of those things, they might play on his mind if the right offer comes up. For example, Bruno Fernandes will retire without a Champions League and a major domestic title. He'll never win the league and he'll never win a Champions League. That is something that might be in Bruno Fernandes' ear. You will retire as a player that never won the league and never won the Champions League? Or will he? Will an option come in from a PSG or somewhere where he can go and win a domestic league and he could go and win a Champions League? Because I don't think he's going to do it at Manchester United.

17:33Even if by some miracle, Man United get back on top, I don't think we're going to win a Premier League or a Champions League in Bruno Fernandes' career at Man United. So those things might be of interest to him. What I was also told as well is there is a release clause for Bruno Fernandes and it is£55 million. But if a PSG come forward and say we'll give you£45 and Bruno wants to go, would United force him to stay? and nobody's ever mentioned that before and yes United can say you're not going but if PSG come forward and say we can't pay 55 million pounds for a 32 year old but we will pay 45 million and we will pay your wage and Bruno knocks on the door of United and goes I want to go to PSG and United go yeah but your release scores is 55 million and Bruno goes they're never going to give me that but I've been a loyal servant I want to go for 45 what happens then Do United force him to stay?

18:31So even the 55 million might be negotiable. Release clauses aren't always adhered to. The solution is that United need to provide a platform here. I mean, that update sounds a bit negative. That's a reality. There is a positive reality. United need to provide the platform to make him stay. You need to turn the fear and uncertainty into an opportunity. So you need to be going, look, we've qualified for the Champions League. There's an opportunity for us to be in the Champions League for the next two or three years with you here. Obviously, we know that it's not going to be easy to do that. But look at the players we're bringing in in the summer.

19:16Look at the ambition we're showing with the manager. And you are the key player in this. That's how you do it. that's how you make him stay. You know, your family's settled here. You're loved at this football club. Look at the manager we're bringing in. Look at the players we're bringing in. You know, we think that we can be competitive in the Champions League, get higher up in the league and make sure we're back in the Champions League and let's go, you know, we want to win the league in the next two or three years with you as the captain. We want to try and win the Champions League with you.

19:45It sounds preposterous, but that's the project they've got to sell. And that goes back to what I was saying at the start. But you can't just be sat there going, we're going to get one decent midfielder in, a kid in the midfield and a couple of other backups. And we'll see how it goes. You've got to go and deliver the project. That's what you've got to do. And that's why it's interesting, because something came out this morning in relation to Bruno and it was about the other Fernandes at West Ham. I need hold on with it. Let me just say this. Right. OK, I'm going to call this out. Right. There are people in our fan base that have put pictures out of Maynu in New York in an inflammatory way.

20:29And if they haven't got the balls to admit it, then that's up to them. But when I see people posting on Instagram and stuff, I hope Maynu's enjoying his break in New York City. I don't think they're genuinely saying, I hope Maynu enjoys his break in New York City. I think they just don't have the balls to say what is Maynou doing in New York City because this happened with Rashford as well. There is a picture of Maynou at Madison Square Gardens in New York watching the basketball and some people are trying to stir this up, right? Where's Agate? Cunha's in Brazil, isn't he? Where is everybody else?

21:10Why are we doing this again? Why do we care about Maynou being in New York? Most of you I don't think do, but some people are trying to stir it up again. We are never going to succeed as a football club if we keep going down that route. We're not playing this weekend. We're off to Dublin next week for a training camp. The Premier League, in its infinite stupidity, decided that 15 Premier League clubs were going to end up not playing the Premier League game for three and a half weeks. idiots, right? So you've got players who, because of that, effectively end up with a mid-season break. And yes, getting on a plane to New York is a bit extensive and a bit tiring, but Man United have clearly given players their time off again.

22:03Why is Manu in New York, on the other side of the world, having time off? Why is such and such in Brazil? Why is such and such at centre parks? That's not the players issue. That's Man United again. And I don't have a problem with it at all. But we've got to stop scrutinising individual players and what they're doing with their time off. Because ultimately, this is not Rashford, you know, missing training to go out on the piss in Belfast. This is players doing things that the club have signed off. And it's just not a story. But look, we are a community and I think we do need to hold ourselves accountable to protecting our players for having some time off.

22:51Manu's not gone on a plane. Another player's not gone on a plane and said, yours are not turning up to train and I'm off to watch the basketball. They've been given that time off. Whether you agree with that time off, that's about the club. I think the club are walking into a silly trap, but that's up to themselves. I think the intensity and the training has dropped off over the last few weeks because we've got so much time off and they don't know what to do with it. Oh, we've only got one game a week. This won't happen next season. So, you know, some people say, let's start preparing them for next season.

23:23Other people think, give them a break while they can. You know, I don't think it's that deep, but I certainly don't think there should be an angle of what's mainly doing in New York. I think that's incredible to me and we need to be very careful about that sort of rhetoric. Talking about Rashford, by the way, scored a goal for Barcelona last night. Hansi Flick after the game says, I'm very happy with Marcus. He's shown his quality and he scored an important goal. I can't say anything about his future. We have to focus in the matches until the end of the season. I think this is really good, positive news for us that Manchester United do want to move Rashford on.

23:58Rashford does want to go to Barcelona and Rafinha is injured at the moment so if Rashford can take those opportunities and do well I think this is really good for United because the sooner Barcelona make that decision the better and if he's playing well it makes that decision better and quicker On Schlotterbeck I think Schlotterbeck would be a very interesting signing for Manchester United but he had an interview after the game yesterday and he's basically indicated that he's having talks with Dortmund this week and it shouldn't take much longer before he can make a decision. He said all along, I can imagine staying, but he's got to get those discussions right and we'll see how they develop.

24:42So it looks like Schlotterbeck's actually going to extend at Dortmund anyway. But even if he didn't, United wouldn't be going for Schlotterbeck. I think we need to be very, very clear about that, that they wouldn't. But where I was going to go is Bruno Fernandes is set to recommend Matias Fernandes to Manchester United as a midfield target this summer. This is a story coming out this morning. And I think, look, you've got, you can't, Bruno Fernandes, I mean, I would trust Bruno Fernandes as our director of football over Jason Wilcox. There's no doubt about that. But obviously Bruno Fernandes can't dictate who we sign at Manchester United this summer.

25:17but he is a player that you've got to factor in into like is it are these signings going to be agreeable to him um in the sense that like if you buy the labor he might say i'm going if you buy ellie anderson he might say i'm saying stay and say i'm staying and i think if you it goes back to that whole thing does it if you buy potential and bruno looks at it and goes this is another project that's going to take years and fail he might go if you buy players that are going to improve that team straight away, he might look at it and go, I might stay. I think, as I said last night, one of the biggest things that Man United need to get right is the replacement for Casemiro.

25:54Bruno Fernandes, when he walks onto that pitch or he's in that dressing room and he sees Casemiro, will see somebody that he sees as his equal or is maybe superior to him because of what he's achieved in his career. Next season, Bruno doesn't walk out onto that pitch with Casemiro. He probably walks onto that pitch with a kid who has a very difficult season ahead of him and Bruno's got to help him. I think Bruno Fernandes would like to be walking on that pitch with somebody that he feels is ready to go. And I think that's a very important point. And if United aren't going to provide that, then they can't moan if Bruno decides to go.

26:26If Bruno decides to go, let me just say this very, very clearly. If Bruno Fernandes leaves Manchester United this summer, that's on Jason Wilcox and the board. That's not on Bruno Fernandes. And I think people need to get that round their head very, very quickly. If Bruno goes, it will be because Man United have failed him. And if Bruno stays, it's because Man United have provided him with a platform that he thinks is worth staying for. So don't get it twisted. If United don't provide the project and Bruno goes, that's not Bruno's fault. That's the club's fault. And if Bruno stays, the club have done the job of providing Bruno with the platform to stay.

27:04And that's really important in this decision and United have to provide that platform but a lot of people doing a lot of talking about Mateus Fernandes from West Ham in relation to his suitability for Manchester United so I've just chucked him into our Wise Scout comparison tool and I've put him ahead against Tonali, Anderson, Casemiro and Balaba so first things foremost let's start off with a bit of a negative. Passes per 90 from those five players, he is only doing 38 passes per 90, which is only one more than Balaba. Casemiro is 51, Anderson is 60, and Tonali is 48. So his passes per 90 is very, very low, as low as Balaba.

27:57Now, the only thing I would say is Balaba plays for Brighton who are actually a possession-based side and therefore 37 passes per 90 is abysmal Fernandes does play for West Ham under Nuno and they do not play a possession-based football they play counter-attack so it's it there may be a little bit of context there that he is obviously playing in a team that's not very possession-based so Balaba is and still has low numbers also I think age has to be an impact here. Tonali 25, Anderson 23, Casemiro 34, Balaba 22. Fernandez is the youngest at 21. What about his defensive output? Well, successful defensive actions per 90.

28:46Tonali is in last place with seven. Balaba is in second to last place with eight. Fernandez would be third place with 8.3. Anderson would be nine successful defensive actions per 90. And then Casemiro is 12. Um, aerially he's the worst of the lot, um, with Tonali is only one aerial jewel per 90, uh, which is the same as Tonali and, um, interceptions per 90, 3.8, which is the same as Belaba. So his defensive output is reasonable. Um, his passing output but leaves a little bit to be desired. And look, to be fair, successful attacking actions per 90, he's second place. You've got Balaba with 0.8, successful attacking actions per 90.

29:40You've got Casemiro in fourth with 1.1, successful attacking actions per 90. You've then got Tonali in third with 1.7, Fernandez with 1.8, and Anderson with 2.1. and I think that with regards to

30:00progressive runs per 90 he's actually number one out of all of them with 1.5 so he's an interesting profile of player Fernandes and I said this yesterday last night I actually said it that you the community deserve some credit because you've been talking about him for a long time the only downside to Fernandes from West Ham at the moment is his passing game but is that because West Ham are not a possession based team His defensive output is good. His attacking output is good. It's just his passing. But that could be an issue because he's playing in the West Ham side. It's low. His passes per 90 is very low, like the Labour, but everything else, he's very good.

30:38So, yeah. But yeah, I mean, Samurai says the whole section makes me really want Anderson. I don't know. I don't know why some people are sleeping on Anderson. I mean, he's head and shoulders, everybody else on everything. Definitely. If we miss out on Anderson, says Vipul, we need Tonali with Gomez's backup and Wharton competing with Maynou as Maynou cannot handle two games a week. What do you think, Mark? Says Vipul. Whether it's slots or live dealers, SpinQuest.com has the fun and action you're looking for with SpinQuest exclusives, blackjack, roulette, baccarat, and even live dice with craps and bubble craps.

31:17The games never stop, so you don't have to. And right now, new users get$30 coin packs for just$10. Play now at SpinQuest.com. SpinQuest is a free-to-play social casino. Avoid where prohibited. Visit SpinQuest.com for more details. I think I think the I'm a big fan of Maynou um the only thing I'm I I tentatively agree with the critics on Maynou is that um his physicality and speed are an issue and can he deal with the Champions League on a Wednesday night and the Premier League on a Saturday every week for a season um he is only 20 and he has had a couple of injuries himself so I think the only the only the only thing I would agree I think technically mainly is a very good player I still think he's got gears to go through but physically and speed wise can he deal with two games a week in the Premier League and the Champions League and and that is a fair question of any 20 year old that's a fair question of a 20 year old Steven Gerrard that's that's a fair question of a 20 year old Paul Scholes so I do agree with you on that I mean this is why for me signing two two midfielders isn't enough because you've got two midfielders in Manu for two spots, one injury, you've got no subs.

32:38Again, this is the incredible naivety of only signing two midfielders. You sign two midfielders, you pick two midfielders, you've got one on the bench. If one gets injured, you've got none on the bench. Josh, we haven't missed any Super Chats, we just haven't read them yet, which we are doing now. Who do you think we would replace Bruno with, says Joey. Well, he's irreplaceable. Factually, he's irreplaceable. I personally think United would not replace him. I think they would move Kunya to 10 and that would be it. I don't think we would replace him. Liao isn't happy at Milan, says Josh. Don't feel like Liao is the right player for Man United.

33:19Don't see the queue for Liao that we used to, to be honest. Andy Atherton with a very generous super chat this morning, probably the biggest of the day. He says, hi, Mark. There are too many if, buts and maybes in our squad. Injury prone players like Martinez, De Litt, Maguire, Mount, crap players like Shaw, Deleu, Agate, still developing players like Le Mans, Hevin, Joré, Maynou, Sesko. That leaves Bruno, Mbuermo and Cunha. Andy, look, I think we are working towards a very exciting summer transfer window, but exciting doesn't mean great. You know, you might wake up this morning if you're celebrating Easter excited about the Easter eggs you're going to get.

33:58You know, your auntie might turn up and instead of a big Malteser Easter egg that she normally gets, she might say, I thought you're too old for it. Here's a couple of quid instead. You never know whether excitement is going to turn to, you know, happiness or disappointment in many areas. So look, I'm very excited about what's to come but I'm also very realistic that this club is very capable of turning that excitement into disappointment but even if we make some exciting decisions this summer I still don't think it takes away from the vulnerability that everybody can see in the next season

34:34there's there's less and less people in our fan base now that are just going if we get the Champions League that's it we're all right we're not we're not Spurs are in the Champions League a year ago. Newcastle are in the Champions League a year ago. Look at them now. It's papering the cracks. It's an opportunity where you have to take it. And if Man United don't take this opportunity, they will be out of it very, very quickly. And there is, you're right, Andy, a lot of issues in that squad. There are crap players that have probably overachieved. I mean, will Luke Shaw be available for every game next season?

35:10Will Harry Maguire be as fit as he has been this season? Will Martinez and De Ligt be able to be playing regularly next season? Will Yarrow and Heaven develop more next season? We've spoken about the midfield. Like, there's a lot of if, buts and maybes, like you say. Plus, we weren't playing one game a week. And as I said to you last night, under Amorim, the results weren't good enough. But when you look at the results, there were one goal off. There was lots of draws. If we lost the game, it was by one goal. If we won a game, it was by one goal. With Amorim, it was close, but not close enough.

35:44With Carrick, it's not like we're smashing teams. It's still one goal. If we win a game, it's by one goal. If we draw a game, obviously, it's a draw. If we lose a game, it tends to be by one goal. The margins are fine. There's not a lot of leeway for United to get it wrong this summer. We've done really well over the last few weeks, but the results are tending to be by one goal. there's a massive increase in our load next year. How are we going to deal with that? And as I've said, I can see a situation in October, December, January, March next year, where we're going, Manu's injured, Maguire's injured, Shaw's injured, De Litt's injured, the new signing's injured, Ahmad's picked up a knock.

36:31I mean, we've been there. We know this can happen. I don't think our fitness department's very good, by the way. Breaking news. I don't think our fitness department's very good. And I don't think that that problem's gone away. I just think even playing one game a week, we've had a lot of injuries. I don't think anybody's studied that. We've been playing one game a week and we've still had loads of injuries. Dorgoo's been out for three months. Martinez has been out. De Litt's been out for ages. Maguire's had injuries. Manu was out for a month over Christmas. Even Bruno was out with an injury. We've had a lot of injuries this season, considering we're only playing one game a week.

37:1038 games in the Premier League and two cup games. We've played 40 games this season. Our lowest load of games since 19, we're saying over 100 years. And we've still picked up injuries. So the challenges of next year are there, definitely. And this is why you need volume, definitely. Don't think PSG buy older players anymore either, says Robert McCormack. Well, I hope you're right, Robert. Martinez replace Casemiro by Schlotterbeck and move him up, says Jack.

37:42No, I don't think I don't think Sandro Martinez's body can deal with playing centre midfielder after the injuries he's had at 28. Is he 28? Yeah. I mean, look, I think Martinez can do a job there. We saw it against Villa at Christmas, but I don't think he's going to become a holding midfielder at 28 with the injuries that he's got. I just don't see it. I think with Martinez, I don't even know if he's our long term centre back. I think we've just got to get him back fit. Nick Ass says, Nicholas says, I've been away for a week, haven't been able to tune in. Would be a car crash losing Bruno. Good to be back and chat.

38:18Happy Easter. Welcome back, mate. And thank you for being a member. um uh also emily's given us another super chat here and says that um the results margins may have shifted under carrick but performances haven't improved much except for arsenal and man city but the issues and problems areas in the team have not really changed as emily derry uh thank you very much for that um appreciate it and yeah look i look i think the results have been fantastic over the last few weeks, definitely. I think it's well known that we played brilliantly against Arsenal and Man City, and we haven't played that well since.

38:59And the margins in a lot of the games that we're playing have been quite fine. So I think that it doesn't matter who you think the manager should be. It doesn't really matter who you think the signing should be. There is one certainty I can give you About the future of Manchester United And I can't tell you who the manager is going to be And I can't tell you who the transfers are going to be But I can tell you Next season is going to be A bloody nightmare To go from no European football And cups To European football And cup competitions And trying to navigate That with a squad that's not used to it and also isn't big enough.

39:44And that's where we are at the moment. That can change. That's not a prophecy of doom. That can change, but it has to change. And there's only one set of people who can change that. And that is the owners. Right here, right now, this squad next season capitulates. Anyone going to disagree with that? Right here, right now, this season with this team, in Europe next year, it falls apart. So four signings is not going to be enough when Casemiro is definitely leaving because that only gives you three signings. And somebody else might leave like Agate. So that's two signings. And Xerxes is going to leave.

40:28So that's one signing. So you know what I mean? When you listen to Ferdinand saying four signings, you go, but that's not four on top of what we've got that's four take away casimiro xerxi agate that's that's one signing um we need to add four to the number that we've got at the moment so if if xerxi casimiro and agate go you need seven that that's what you need um because we need volume we definitely need volume and um If you did watch that Arsenal game yesterday, look, it's embarrassing for them to lose to Southampton. But you look at their squad and you look at their bench, there's a hell of a lot of players missing.

41:20And when it gets to this time of the season, we've seen it over the last few years. How many times have we been in March and April and May over the last seven years and had loads of injuries? I mean, can you remember that Rangyuk interim? Can I remember when Rangyuk was interim? The amount of injuries we had, it was incredible. Can you remember the season when we won the Europa League with Mourinho? The amount of injuries we had in April was incredible. I mean, we literally in the final had Eric Bailly, Zlatan and Luke Shaw on crutches. Learn from your fucking history, for God's sake. Like, learn from your fucking history.

41:59Like, over the last few years, we've had injury crises in March, April and May, numerous years. We have to prepare for that for next season. We have to prepare for the inevitability of what is to come. But I think United will go like this. They'll go and hide under the desk and say, let's hope it's going to be OK. Finally I did see something this morning that Sir Jim Madcliffe is targeting at least 100 million in player sales As he looks to offload surplus talent at Manchester United A minimum of eight senior players are expected to depart the club at the end of the season Now this is the sort of stuff that certain people in our fanbase run for the tissues because they get excited But does that not go hand in hand with what I've just said?

42:49If you raise£100 million by removing eight players, how many of those eight players are part of the first team squad today? Obviously Rashford's not, Rasmus isn't, but£100 million and you remove eight players, are they all being replaced? This is not now about money, this is about volume. If you get rid of eight players and you bring in two£50 million players, how does that help me with the squad? we have to have a squad as much as we have to have quantity we we absolutely have to and i saw something the other day about the money we're going to save from from wages from people leaving and it's laughable that people you know get excited about that we're going to save 350 grand a week by casemiro going what are we going to do with it what are we going to do with that money because in my mind that 350 grand a week losing casemiro a vast amount of it should be going on a replacement So if Casemiro's going on 350 grand a week, Tonali should be coming in on 250.

43:52But no, pass me the tissues, we're going to save 350 grand a week. And I'm like, no. Why are some of our fans so obsessed with accountancy? We should never be celebrating saving money. We should be reinvesting that money. If you save 350 grand a week on Casemiro, then spend a massive amount of it on somebody that's better than him. Don't go, I've saved 350 grand a week and I bought the labour and he's only on 100. That's a quarter of a million a week saved. This is football. This is football. You've got to go and get the best. Last time we really re-rotated, we lost to Grimsby, says Joey. And your point is, are you competing for more on of the day?

44:38Because I thought I'd already given that out. I don't even know what you're talking about. Joey last time we rotated we lost to Grimsby um so what you're saying we should never rotate I don't even know what I don't know I don't know what to do with that Joey uh we used to have likes of uh O'Shea Brown May Neville Blomqvist quality squad players so Steve I think that we need to bring in players now that are first team players I've said this before and I don't know whether people agree with me, but I do not want Manchester United to sign bench players. I don't see the point. When Manchester City buy Semenyu and Gehi, they're first team players.

45:22So somebody goes to the bench. I do not want to buy understudies. I do not want to buy backups. I want to buy first team players. So every player I buy, in my mind, is challenging for a first team spot. I don't see the point in backup players. Backup players leads to low performance. The two midfielders or the three midfielders we should sign should be capable of starting. If you buy Jao Gomez as your third midfielder, he's still capable of starting. If you buy Anderson and Waterden, they're capable of starting. If you buy Diamonde, they're capable of starting. If you buy Trufford, they're capable of signing.

46:03That's five signings there that are capable of starting. if you buy Schlotterbeck he's capable of starting um we need we need to buy we need to buy that's how we'll get better too many people want to buy bench players because they go oh what will happen to Manu if we buy Anderson and Wharton I don't care maybe Wharton will go on the bench and Manu will start but we need competition for places absolutely um okay thanks everyone for watching we have got a Sunday night live show tonight at eight o 'clock looking forward to that I have just put up an Arsenal in crisis video, by the way. I didn't do a video last night on Arsenal.

46:38I've done it now. So if you want to check that, the link is in the live chat or just get yourself over to That's Football. Thank you, everybody, for watching this morning. Stay safe. Take care. Happy Easter. I'm off to do an Easter egg hunt now and I'll speak to you all in a bit. Take care.

47:01What's going on, everyone? It's Bluff here and you know what's more American than America's 250th birthday? Supporting American-owned companies like SpinQuest, America's number one social casino with over 1 ,000 games like Live Dealer Blackjack and Craps. They're offering new users a$30 coin package for just$10. Go to SpinQuest.com and sign up today. SpinQuest is a free-to-play social casino. Void where prohibited. Visit SpinQuest.com for more details.

From the publisher

Mark Goldbridge reacts to the latest reports suggesting a poor summer transfer window is on the horizon. With rival clubs already making moves, the lack of activity and mounting rumors are starting to ring alarm bells.

Are the owners failing the manager again? Is the recruitment structure already falling apart? Mark doesn’t hold back as he breaks down the targets we're missing out on and why this summer could set the club back years if things don't change, and fast.

More from The United Stand

All episodes