1. Podcasts
  2. This Is Why
  3. Why do we need new North Sea gas?
This Is Why

21 Oct 2026 · 19m · 9 chapters

Episode artwork

Why do we need new North Sea gas?

In short

The UK Labour government has approved drilling in the Jackdaw North Sea gas field, overturning a 2022 legal challenge by climate campaigners. The episode argues about why new North Sea gas is needed for energy security and grid balancing, while weighing climate and cost-of-living impacts.

Guests

Tom Clark, Sky News science and technology editor; Paul Kelso, Sky News business correspondent in Aberdeen.

Guest backgrounds

Tom covers science/technology policy and climate/energy tech; Paul reports business and energy economics from Aberdeen, a North Sea hub.

Key claims

Jackdaw is a mature, connected gas field that can come online quickly, supplying gas-fired power when wind/solar are unavailable. It won’t significantly lower bills; it mainly displaces imports. The field is about 6% of UK gas needs and would last roughly six months if used alone. Fossil fuels drive price volatility; transition costs are real but unavoidable.

Notable examples

Jackdaw (discovered 2005) and Rosebank (discovered ~2001); war in Ukraine and LNG/Norwegian import dependence; UNEP forecast of 1.7–1.8°C warming within 25 years; Strait of Hormuz and Iran volatility; offshore wind timeline (first offshore 2000).

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

0:30

The Controversial Jackdaw Gas Field

Discussion about the Jackdaw gas field and its implications for UK energy security.

“When you face a problem, the answer is rarely found at the bottom of the deep blue sea.”
2:36

Economic Arguments for Domestic Gas Production

Exploration of economic arguments for producing gas locally rather than relying on imports.

“It's what you might term the common sense argument.”
4:44

The North Sea's Decline and Future

Analysis of the North Sea's maturity and the reality of gas production limits.

“Yes, there's more oil and gas that could be found if you can make the investment case to spend the money and go and look for it.”
6:40

Challenges in Transitioning to Renewables

Discussion on the difficulties and costs associated with transitioning from fossil fuels to renewable energy.

“transitioning from fossil fuels to renewables.”
8:25

Energy Security vs. Volatility

Examination of energy security in the context of recent market volatility and the UK's options for independence.

“is that we've also ended up with the most expensive energy practically in the developed world, the most expensive for industry, almost the most expensive domestically.”
11:47

The Path Forward for Energy in the UK

Discussion of the potential for renewable energy development and the choices facing the UK.

“One of the big topics in this conversation is security.”
14:00

The Cost of Energy Transition

Discussing the challenges and costs associated with transitioning to sustainable energy.

“We're a democracy with good relations with our neighbours that have got the gas, frankly, that we're going to need, even if we can't produce it ourselves.”
16:04

Impact of Jackdaw on Everyday Life

Explaining what the Jackdaw gas project means for consumers and the environment.

“I want to take it back to the very beginning.”
18:28

Future of Energy and Society

Exploring the long-term implications of current energy choices on society and climate.

“If you're worried about conflict changing the cost of things that home.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On This Is Why, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:02Sky News, the full story first.

0:11Tom Clarke: Andy Burnham's decision to approve drilling in the Jackdaw gas field is controversial and his problems have just begun. This is why.

0:30Tom Clarke: When you face a problem, the answer is rarely found at the bottom of the deep blue sea. But that's exactly where Andy Burnham's been forced to look to boost the UK's energy security. The Labour government has just approved drilling in the enormous jackdaw gas field. The controversial North Sea project has been a burning issue for climate campaigners, who threw it into limbo with a successful legal challenge in 2022, after it was given the green light by the previous Tory government. Now the gas will soon be on its way to British homes. Not that you'll really notice any difference to your energy bills.

1:02Tom Clarke: The red tape may have been cut, but Andy Burnham is left walking a tightrope as he tries to balance the UK's energy security with reaching its net zero targets. I'm Gareth Barlow. Today we're joined by our science and technology editor, Tom Clark, and our business correspondent, Paul Kelso, who's in Aberdeen. And Tom, we'll start with you first. Just talk to us about what exactly Jackdaw is and what we're going to take out of it. So yeah, Jackdaw is a natural gas field in the North Sea. It's already effectively connected to the network of pipes that bring gas in from the North Sea. One of the big advantages for government, giving it the go-ahead, the gas from that field will come online very, very quickly.

1:41Tom Clarke: So they can honestly say, you know, this is going to get to people's homes this winter. from a climate point of view, there's an aspect to that as well. The gas that it will produce, we would need it to have had anyway. We're going to need, however rapid and hell for leather, our transition to a net zero, low carbon electricity grid, we're going to need some gas-fired power stations online to come on when the wind isn't blowing, the sun isn't shining, and to balance that grid power out. And we're going to need that for a while. So we needed that gas anyway, surely better to get it locally produced from a secure supply that isn't going to get disrupted by wars in Iran or conflicts with Russia, given we were going to burn it anyway.

2:27Tom Clarke: So I think that's how the government can sort of argue, despite its climate targets, we can go ahead with this. And Paul, that's a point that the government was keen to make, wasn't it? It's like, on the economics of this, a bit like the environmental argument, if we're going to be using gas, then why not produce it closer to home and kind of utilised our own homegrown products and our homegrown industry in an industry that's been going for 30, 40 years. It's what you might term the common sense argument. We are going to be burning this gas anyway. Why import it? We may as well use what's here.

3:00I've compared it to not picking up a fiver on your doorstep because you're on the way to the cash point. You're still going to need the money. Why would you leave it there? What was really striking to me talking to of the Energy Secretary, Mata Fambula, here in Aberdeen today, is how much she leaned in to that argument. She didn't try and wiggle round the climate consequences of this. She didn't try and make a cost of living bills argument for this, because it's very, very marginal. This will not substantially or even significantly bring down the cost of gas. There might be some impact at the margins because we will be displacing imports, particularly LNG imports coming in on boats, or perhaps just as likely Norwegian gas will be piped in from the other side of the North Sea.

3:46But she made a practical argument and she made an energy security argument.

3:50Tom Clarke: Just sticking with the economics of it for a second, the North Sea is often referred to as kind of a mature area for oil and gas. I think mature is code word for running out slash not much there anymore. And it's said that Jackdaw will produce about 6 % of our gas needs. If we were to only use jackdaw, I think it would only get us through about six months of our needs before it itself ran out. Is there a sense that it's being ever so slightly oversold? I think it's really striking as this debate has got much more polarised and the political consensus around energy policy, which held for knocking 20 years, has gone, frankly, because of the cost of living.

4:26The way the North Sea has become sort of proxy for the whole net zero debate. And you will, on one side, it's the answer to all our energy problems. The other, it's the source of all our climate ills. And actually, it's neither. You wouldn't say this to someone whose job depended on here in Aberdeen. It's almost something of a distraction for the bigger picture. The North Sea is a declining basin. Yes, there's more oil and gas that could be found if you can make the investment case to spend the money and go and look for it. And many companies will say that the UK simply does not currently provide that investment case.

5:01It's taxed too highly, these insufficient tax incentives to do the work. And frankly, as we've seen with this, the consenting and the regulation takes an enormously long time. But it doesn't matter how many new licenses you grant or tried to grant or encourage people to, we're never going to be self-sufficient for gas again. It is a relatively small gas field in the scheme of things. It's the largest that's been consented for a long time. But it's not game-changing.

5:29Tom Clarke: I'm just picking up something Paul was mentioning there. And I think it's important to remember, while people might get annoyed with the vegan road-blocking climate protesters who are pressuring the government to make these crazy expensive commitments to net zero, let's not forget where the oil industry has been through all of this. And they are a powerful, very, very powerful, very wealthy lobbying effort. It's worth remembering that the Rosebank oil field was discovered, I think back in 2001, Jackdaw, 2005. The reasons they were not exploited was because it wasn't profitable to do so. The price of oil at the time was low.

6:07Tom Clarke: There were other factors in the industry that meant it stayed that way. They only applied to the government to drill these fields after the war in Ukraine began and panic over energy security in Europe ramped up. There's a lot of spin being applied to these things. There's a lot of politics. There's a lot of big business involved here that I don't think we should take our eye off when it comes to those kinds of arguments about making the most of the fossil fuels on our doorstep. There's also this whole conversation about this is all part of the green transition, transitioning from fossil fuels to renewables.

6:45Tom Clarke: I did some very simple digging to find out that the first onshore commercial wind farm in this country was 1991, the first offshore 2000. It's 2026, like how long do we need? That's a really important point here. We've had this technology for a while. We've also known about the climate warming for a while. What I think people should be reminded of is all the projections and forecasts climate scientists have made. We've thing that's happening now is they seem to be getting slightly more concerning than they were previously. We are now, according to the latest UNEP report, looking at 1.7 to 1.8 degrees of warming within the next 25 years.

7:24Tom Clarke: That's nearly two degrees of global warming in our lifetimes. It's a problem we can't ignore. Coming back to the moral arguments about what to do about this, if we don't tackle it now, And there's another case where people quite understandably and correctly point out, emissions from Jackdall, Rosebank combined, in fact, even the UK's entire industrial emissions are small compared to global emissions when you factor in China and the US and people like that. So why should we do anything about it? It's a weak moral argument though, given that we are going to have to do something about this. You need to show that a mature economy can afford to do it.

8:07Tom Clarke: somebody's got to start making those differences. We have set an example. The problem we bump into now, in large part, changing economic conditions, is that one of the lessons people might draw from what I would argue are quite bold moves towards renewable technology and replacing fossil fuels, is that we've also ended up with the most expensive energy practically in the developed world, the most expensive for industry, almost the most expensive domestically. domestically. Now, there are lots of reasons why that is. One of them absolutely is that we are extremely exposed to fossil fuels. We rely on it for home heating.

8:43We rely on it to underpin the electricity grid. And to reduce that reliance, we have to build more renewables so that gas doesn't set the price. The way the market works, it's complex, but ultimately, gas still has a really defining price setting. So I think we are exemplars, but not all the lessons are palatable and you're trying to change the way that we pay for it with all the economic pressures we have on top it's extremely difficult you can't really say to people that there's going to be a price dividend a bill dividend for a decade i think that's put us in a really difficult place and just i mean to say on that what is the alternative i mean it is being put out there but

9:29Tom Clarke: without really any numbers to back it up yeah all this green stuff's too expensive we've got to take this pressure off bills. We can't afford it right now. I've got a huge amount of sympathy for that. Those costs are real, and there are some things we've arguably got quite wrong. The cost of the recent nuclear power stations that we've consented are very expensive. We did arguably pretty bad deals to get our last couple of nuclear power plants built, and they're going to be costing bill payers for decades into the future. But what is the alternative apart from keeping to invest this money, investing in the electricity grid so we can make more use of this renewable energy.

10:05Tom Clarke: Because there is no evidence out there that I can see that sticking with fossil fuels is going to continue to bring bills down. And you've also got what we're seeing so much recently, crises like the war in Iran, the Strait of Hormuz, the invasion of Ukraine, that caused such volatility in fossil fuel markets. Those costs can spike in ways that no economy can cope with. We've got to get off this stuff, but we have to invest in order to do it. And I don't hear any arguments for how you can avoid it. And you're completely right. And we should be saying, this decision has come today. When the announcement was made, I think, within an hour, gas prices were up 3 % on the day.

10:44Now, UK gas prices are up 25 % in the last month, a really hefty increase to the domestic price cap come January. It's almost baked in almost every day since Ofgem, the regulator, began its observation window, as they call it, when they look at wholesale prices to set that cap. Almost every day since that began, getting on for a month ago, the gas price has risen. We are about to have, as they say, an energy crisis, but we are having a second really steep winter energy price spike coming, what, four years after Ukraine did so much harm right now because of the price of fossil fuels. So it is absolutely right.

11:21Fossil fuels are the primary driver. But you listen to energy bosses, they will tell you fossil fuels went down, the fixed costs that are now baked in because of the transition that are necessary to expand the grid to link up all this power, the stuff we've talked about. They are responsible for knocking on half of bill increases, and bills would go up even if fossil fuels didn't.

11:58Tom Clarke: One of the big topics in this conversation is security. We talk about energy security, massively so. As just an island nation, do we have the mosaic of opportunity to be independent, or at least to be secure? Because it feels as though, from the consumer's perspective, all we've talked about is volatility in recent years. I mean, I think if you looked maybe through slightly rose-tinted green spectacles, can you have those? Yeah, why not? Green spectacles. You know, 100 % we should be. We're an island nation. We're surrounded by ocean in which you can put wind turbines. We can have batteries to store power.

12:35Tom Clarke: So, you know, if we got that up and going, you know, invested a lot more in that, you could even completely forget about the gas. That technology is there. It's currently a bit too expensive for a meaningful transition. But, you know, we could become entirely insulated from the world in terms of our energy needs. That's with the caveat that right now, a lot of the components of those things and the steel to make them comes from China and other economies in the world. You'd have to import a lot of that stuff. But once it's built, you can maintain it. We're actually blessed to have that sort of access to those resources.

13:05Tom Clarke: So 100%, we could be insulated from the volatility and the shocks that come at us from these volatile markets. There's a word there you say, which is could. I feel as we hear this quite a lot with these kinds of projects. We could put tidal capacity across the Bristol Channel, the second highest tidal range on the planet, but then there's always the counter-argument. It feels as though there's always pulled the counter-argument to every potential project. We could do more in terms of nuclear, but it's too expensive. We could do more in terms of solar panel farms across the UK, but it takes away from arable production.

13:42Tom Clarke: Someone's got to buy a bullet, surely, and say, we will, we'll, we'll. Indeed. And I go back to my unfashionably optimistic view of that. No, I agree. We have bitten bullets. We have bitten quite a lot of bullets. And I agree with Tom. I think the UK has an enormous amount going for it in terms of a diversity of energy supply, much of it renewable. We're a democracy with good relations with our neighbours that have got the gas, frankly, that we're going to need, even if we can't produce it ourselves. We have a great legacy in nuclear. So it's all there to be one. The challenge is that switching an energy, this is expensive stuff.

14:26It's never been done before. And we're switching, remember, to lower carbon, less intensive forms of energy, which means we need more of it. And that all requires more of the bits that join it up so there's an expense to get there um but yeah we do have to make tough choices it's interesting you know drive around rural england farmers are making the choice the economics are pushing them towards solar it pays the challenge i see is that the world in which we are uniquely placed to have this wonderful diverse balanced sustainable stable affordable mix of energy and those are the three key bits for me, it's a decade away or more.

15:06And we're trying to do it against the backdrop of really tight public finances. There's no money. The fuels we do rely on at the moment, fossil fuels that drive our prices, are getting more expensive. And we are in a system where at the moment, bill payers are bearing the cost. It's not spread into general taxation. So individuals are being asked to bear the cost rather than it being a national project for a lot of these costs. But there's a big, big prize for the UK.

15:36Tom Clarke: I do not envy the people in government whose job is to try and fix these things. But to just flippantly say, we can't afford this transition, we can't afford to do it. It's like living in a house with broken windows and a leaky roof and chucking a log on the fire. Even though you know that's a very expensive thing to do, you can't carry on ignoring the fact you need to make the longer term investments. Just, yeah, how do you square that sort of, that bit of economics? This is a big, extensive, expansive conversation. I want to take it back to the very beginning. You've got 45 seconds to summarise for the person in the average postcode what Jackdaw means for them from the business, climate, finance, and economy kind of perspective.

16:19Tom Clarke: Paul, we'll start with you. Jackdaw means you are likely to be burning more gas when you cook your tea or turn the boiler on this winter that is produced in the North Sea. It means it might be coming at a slightly lower carbon footprint, some of the gas that you might have been burning otherwise had it been imported. But sadly, it is not going to cut the cost of your bills. is negligible in those terms. But in a world where we have a war in the Middle East that is choking off crucial energy supplies that, like it or not, we still need, we have very low reserves in the UK, there is probably a little comfort to be taken from the fact that we're getting a little more of our gas domestically than might otherwise have been the case.

17:10It's protected some jobs. There should be some tax revenue that will make its way into Treasury coffers and ultimately, hopefully benefit all of us. So it is a small win. Actually, you might almost say it's in the scheme of things, it's not the really big question we need to worry about in energy policy. And we've talked about many of those already.

17:30Tom Clarke: Tom, same question to you from the climate, the science, the tech perspective. If I'm sat at home, what's changed today? I would say not very much at all. for the reasons Paul mentioned, it's not going to reduce your bills. It's not sufficiently more locally sourced fossil fuels. It's going to bring down the carbon footprint of those things. I would say to people, what does it say to them? I think rather than see this as an extension of whether it's a romantic or a nostalgic attachment to your gas boiler or your gas stove, time to start thinking deeply about what we're actually expecting in our futures here.

18:08Tom Clarke: because if you think we can carry on down that road, I think you're deluding yourself. We've learned enough from rising energy costs. And don't forget some of those inflationary pressures that are being on cost of living, they're being driven by fossil fuel prices, which are exacerbated by things like conflict. What are the alternatives? Just carry on doing things as they are. If you're worried about small boat migrants, the cost of food that we can produce here in the UK, around the rest of the world. If you're worried about conflict changing the cost of things that home. Imagine what it's like now and then imagine it 20 years in the future when the planet's nearly two degrees warmer and the world looks a lot more like that.

18:48Tom Clarke: I know that that doesn't come for anyone who's struggling to pay their bills right now. And I can also appreciate the cost of a transition seems like something we cannot manage now, but I don't see any alternative. Ultimately, it will help reduce the cost of our bills and it will also help make the societies in which our kids and our grandchildren grow up in a lot safer and more secure as well. Tom thank you so much. Paul before that thank you so much. That's it for today. You can message the show at y at sky.uk. This is Y and I'll be back again tomorrow.

From the publisher

Winter is coming. So, a decision to finally allow drilling at the controversial Jackdaw gas field in the North Sea should be welcome.

Well, not by environmental campaigners – who've accused the government of backtracking on its net zero commitments.

And even supporters of North Sea expansion have admitted opening Jackdaw won’t reduce energy bills, even though it could start helping to supply homes within months.

Why, then, has Andy Burnham invested so much political capital in giving the go-ahead?

Gareth Barlow is joined by Sky’s science and technology editor Tom Clarke and business correspondent Paul Kelso.

Have you got a question for the show? Email us: [email protected]

More from This Is Why

All episodes